А.П.Попов ЛЕГЕНДА ПОНТИЙСКИХ ГРЕКОВ О

advertisement
:IIhih\
E?=?G>:IHGLBCKDBO=J?DH<
HIJHBKOH@>?GBBBKLHQGBD:³K<YL:YJMD:´
K?F:GLBQ?KDBC:G:EBA
<^_gvMki_gby;h]hjh^bpuZ\]mklZihglbckdb_]j_dbijh`b\Zxsb_\
DjZkgh^ZjkdhfdjZ_ljZ^bpbhgghkh[bjZxlky\mjhqbs_=jmr_\Zy[ZedZqlh\
hdj_klghklyoklG_[_j^`Z_\kdhcDjufkdh]hjZchgZA^_kv[v_lg_kdhevdhbklhqgbdh\
\h^mdhlhjuof_klgu_`bl_ebkqblZxlp_e_[ghcH^bgbagbo²jh^gbdK\ylZyjmdZ
]j_dbgZau\Zxl_]hlZd`_³Ke_aufZl_jbΤι Παναγια τα διακρια²klZgh\blky\wlhl
^_gvp_gljhfjblmZevguo^_ckl\bc
=j_dbijb_a`ZxlgZdZgmg_ijZa^gbdZZ\]mklZk_fvyfbjZkiheZ]Zxlky\
[eb`Zcr_fe_km]^_mkljZb\ZxlijZa^gbqgmxljZi_amDmevfbgZpb_cijZa^gbdZy\ey_lky
`_jl\hijbghr_gb_γουρπαν^eydhlhjh]hk_fvyihdmiZ_l[ZjZgZh[yaZl_evghfheh^h]h
a^hjh\h]hkZfpZbebi_lmoZ@_jl\_ggh_`b\hlgh_ij_^ihqlbl_evgh[_eh]hp\_lZohly
fh]mlbkihevah\Zlv³djZkgh]h´i_lmoZ@_jl\mijbghkyl\hae_bklhqgbdZ`b\hlgh_ljb`^u
h[\h^ylijhlb\qZkh\hcklj_edb\hdjm]jh^gbdZ]^_mklZgh\e_gdj_klbbdhgZ;h]hjh^bpu
aZl_f]eZ\Zk_fvbgZ^j_aZ_lijZ\h_moh[ZjZgmbebhlk_dZ_l]heh\mi_lmomdjh\vx
`b\hlgh]hfZ`mldj_klugZe[mm\k_oqe_gh\k_fvbijhbaghkylfhebl\mh[jZs_ggmx
;h]hjh^bp_h\ua^hjh\e_gbbly`_eh[hevgh]hbebha^jZ\bb\k_ck_fvbFykh[ZjZgZ
`Zjylijb]hlh\eyxlrZreud^eyk_f_cgh]haZklhevyJZgvr_fykh`_jl\_ggh]h`b\hlgh]h
\Zjbebbh[yaZl_evghjZa^Z\Zebkhk_^yf
Kij_^klZ\e_gbyfb]j_dh\hp_ebl_evguok\hckl\Zof_klZ]^_gZoh^blkybklhqgbd
k\yaZgZljZ^bpby\_rZlvehkdmlufZl_jbbieZldbbihehl_gpZgZjZklmsb_jy^hf^_j_\vy
IhglbcpukqblZxlqlh\f_kl_kehkdmlZfbhgbhklZ\eyxlgZ^_j_\vyo[he_agbLdZgv
fh]mlih\yau\Zlvkijhkv[hchkdhj_cr_f\ua^hjh\e_gbbly`_eh[hevgh]hjh^kl\_ggbdZ
<h^ZbklhqgbdZgZMki_gb_;h]hjh^bpubhkh[_ggh\iheghqvgZ^_ey_lky
bkdexqbl_evgufbe_q_[gufbk\hckl\ZfbKqblZ_lkyqlhgZ[jZggZy\wlmghqv\h^Z^he]h
ojZgblkybe_qblex[u_[he_agbG_h[udgh\_ggu_dZq_kl\Zjh^gbdZihglbckdb_]j_db
k\yau\Zxlk_]hqm^_kgufijhbkoh`^_gb_f<nhevdehjghcljZ^bpbb]j_dh\_klv
fgh`_kl\h[uebq_dhy\e_gbb\hkg_[hevghc`_gsbg_k\ylh]hbebk\ylhcdhlhju_
mdZau\Zxl_cf_klh]^_[v_lp_ebl_evgucdexqIhy\e_gb_bklhqgbdZK\ylZyjmdZlh`_
k\yau\Zxlk^_yl_evghklvxk\yluoIhe_]_g^_bklhqgbd[uehldjulgZlhff_kl_]^_
g_dh]^ZhklZgZ\eb\ZeZkv;h]hjh^bpZMklZ\rZyhgZaZkgmeZAf_c`b\rbca^_kv
\hkihevah\Zekywlbfbih^iheaqlh[ukt_klv__<g_aZighihy\b\rbckyk\ylhc=_hj]bc
m[beAf_yblZdbfh[jZahfkiZk;h]hjh^bpmGZf_kl_qm^_kgh]hkiZk_gby;h`v_cfZl_jb
aZ[bejh^gbd
E_]_g^ZdZdnhevdehjgucl_dkl\hkoh^blk\hbfbdhjgyfbdfbnm?F
F_e_lbgkdbcZgZebabjmyjZagu_ih`Zgjmb\j_f_gbkha^Zgbyijhba\_^_gbynhevdehjZb
ebl_jZlmju\u^_ey_lgZb[he__mklhcqb\u_kx`_lgu_nhjfudhlhju_y\eyxlky
Zjo_lbiZfb^eyiha^g_crboom^h`_kl\_gguol_dklh\LZdb_³Zjo_lbibqgu_´kx`_lu
bf_xlgZb[he__p_ehklgh_baZdhgq_ggh_\ujZ`_gb_\fbn_F_e_lbgkdbc
Kx`_lgZyebgbybgl_j_kmxs_cgZke_]_g^uk\h^blkydih_^bgdmk\ylh]h=_hj]bykh
Af__f:jo_lbiaf__[hjq_kl\Zbkihevam_lky\fbnheh]bb^ey\ujZ`_gbyfhlb\Z^h[u\Zgby
dmevlmjguf]_jh_fhij_^_e_gguo[eZ]agZqbfuo^eykhpbmfZF_e_lbgkdbc
<bg^h_\jhi_ckdhcljZ^bpbbih_^bghd=jhfh\_j`pZkhAf__fy\ey_lkydmevfbgZpbhgguf
kx`_lhflZdgZau\Z_fh]hhkgh\gh]hfbnZIjbqbghc[hjv[u=jhfh\_j`pZb_]hZglbih^Z
\uklmiZ_l[h]bgybaf_gb\rZy_fmkhAf__fB\Zgh\Lhihjh\QZklh\f_kl_k
[h]bg_c\i_s_j_Af_yhdZau\ZxlkyaZdexq_gu\h^ug_kmsb_ieh^hjh^b_dhlhju_
\ha\jZsZxlkyex^yfihke_ih[_^ugZ^Af__f
Hq_\b^ghihglbckdZye_]_g^Zkx`_lgh\hkoh^bldhkgh\ghfmfbnmbg^h_\jhi_cp_\
GZk[m^_lbgl_j_kh\ZlvdZdbfh[jZahf\dhgdj_lghfl_dkl_j_rZ_lkydhgp_ipbygZr_^rZy
k\h_ihegh_\ujZ`_gb_\hkgh\ghffbn_
K_fZglbq_kdbcZgZebae_]_g^udZdfbnheh]babjh\Zgh]hih\_kl\h\Zgbyij_^klZ\ey_l
kh[hcZgZebal_dklZkfukek_fZglbdmdhlhjh]hfh`ghihgylvlhevdhihke_jZkrbnjh\db
dh^h\bebyaudh\kbf\heh\dhlhjufbhg\ujZ`_gK\yabbhlghr_gbyf_`^m
kbf\hebq_kdbfbagZq_gbyfbkhklZ\eyxlkljmdlmjme_]_g^udZdkbf\hebq_kdh]hl_dklZ
LjZ^bpbyihdehg_gbybklhqgbdZfihk\ys_gguok\yluf[ueZba\_klgZ]j_dZfFZehc
:abbbIhglZP_e_[ghckqblZeZkv\h^Zkl_dZxsZyihkl_gZfkdZevgh]hfhgZklujy
IZgZbyKmf_eZjZkiheh`_ggh]h\hdj_klghklyoFZpmdb\Ihgl_DhgklZglbghihevkdb_
]j_db\^_gvijZa^gbdZIZgZby;ZemdebhlbkkZ(Παναγια ΜπαλουκληιοτισσαmkljZb\Zeb
iZehfgbq_kl\h\ih^a_fgmxqZkh\gxd[b\r_fmlZfbklhqgbdm<bevyfkIhke_
i_j_k_e_gbygZDZ\dZaihglbcpuj_]_g_jbjh\ZebljZ^bpbx\f_klguomkeh\byo<
^h\h_ggh_\j_fy]j_dbihk_sZebg_kdhevdhbklhqgbdh\\h^mdhlhjuoihqblZebk\ylhc
G_^Ze_dhhlkl>_j[_glkdhc[uehq_luj_lZdbojh^gbdZh^bgbagboihk\ysZeb>_\_
FZjbb
Ihglbckdb_]j_dbkqblZxlqlhjh^gbdK\ylZyjmdZbf__lg_ihkj_^kl\_ggh_
hlghr_gb_d;h]hjh^bp_P_e_[gZy\h^ZbklhqgbdZ²wlhijheblu_ihke_kf_jlbkugZ
ke_au;h`v_cfZl_jbZdZf_gvkiylvx\uklmiZfbihdhlhjhfm^h_]hjZajmr_gbykl_dZeZ
\h^Z²jmdZ>_\uFZjbb<fbnheh]bq_kdboij_^klZ\e_gbyoihglbcp_\;h]hjh^bpZ
y\ey_lkyZgljhihfhjngufh[jZahf\h^ubklhqgbdZFhlb\hlh`^_kl\e_gby`_gkdh]h
[h`_kl\Zk\h^ghcklbob_cjZkijhkljZg_g\fbnheh]bbbnhevdehj_<i_kg_ihglbckdbo
]j_dh\³Khegp_fh_´fZlvKhegpZ\hki_\Z_lkydZdihdjh\bl_evgbpZijbjh^u]hjguo
iZkl[bsbbklhqgbdh\ex[hiulghqlh\jZgg_ojbklbZgkdbo]bfgZo;h]hfZl_jv²wlh
fZlvKhegpZAZcdh\kdZy<keZ\ygkdhc\_jkbbhkgh\gh]hfbnZkih^a_fgufb
\h^Zfbm\yau\Z_lkyg_\_jgZy`_gZ=jhfh\_j`pZ²[h]bgyFhdhrvqlhnbdkbjm_lky
lZd`_b\gZjh^ghchghfZklbd_²Fhdhr_\h[hehlhBfy[h]bgbbf__ldhjg_\mxhkgh\m
h[smxkhkeh\Zfb³fhdjuc´³fhdgmlv´B\Zgh\Lhihjh\
;h]hjh^bpZdZdi_jkhgbnbdZpby\h^ubklhqgbdZ\l_dkl_e_]_g^ubf__l[hevrh_
dmevlmjgh_agZq_gb_²k__kms_kl\h\Zgb_fk\yau\Z_lky^hklmighklv\h^ujh^gbdZ^ey
ex^_cIjbqbghcihdhlhjhc\h^Zfh`_lg_\uclbgZih\_joghklvy\ey_lkyAf_c<kx`_l_
hkgh\gh]hfbnZAf_c²Zglbih^=jhfh\_j`pZbihoblbl_ev[h]bgbB\Zgh\Lhihjh\
Af_cdZdolhgbq_kdh_kms_kl\hbh[blZl_evgb`g_]hfbjZk\yaZgkih^a_fgufb
\h^Zfbdhlhju_g_^hklmigu^eyex^_cb^Z`_\j_^hghkgu
Fhlb\³Af_cmbklhqgbdZ´dZdij_iylkl\b_^eyihevah\Zgby\h^hcrbjhdh
jZkijhkljZg_g\jZaguofbnheh]bq_kdbokbkl_fZo<Zjfygkdbo\her_[guokdZadZoAf_c
\brZiihf_sZ_lkymjh^gbdZ`b\hc\h^uf_rZy]_jhxgZ[jZlv__:[jZfyg<
ihglbckdhfkdZahqghfnhevdehj_Af_c:`^ZoZlj_[m_lm`bl_e_c^_j_\gbaZihevah\Zgb_
bklhqgbdhf^_\mr_dgZkt_^_gb_<hkgh\ghffbn_bg^h_\jhi_cp_\Af_cm^_j`b\Z_lm
k_[y\h^udhlhju_ihke_ih[_^ugZ^gbf=jhfh\_j`pZijheb\Zxlkyg_kmsbfieh^hjh^b_
^h`^_fB\Zgh\Lhihjh\
>\Zi_jkhgZ`Znb]mjbjmxsb_\e_]_g^_k\yaZguk\h^hc;h]hjh^bpZdZd
i_jkhgbnbdZpby³k\ylhc´\h^ubklhqgbdZbAf_c²\hafh`gZyijbqbgZ__g_^hklmighklb
^eyex^_cK_fZglbdZ\h^u\fbnheh]bbZf[b\Ze_glgZKh^ghcklhjhgu\h^Z
g_hlt_fe_fZhlieh^hl\hjguokbeijbjh^uh^ghbag_h[oh^bfuomkeh\bckms_kl\h\Zgbc
ex[h]hhj]ZgbafZ<f_kl_kl_f\h^Z²wlhklbobygb`g_]hfbjZf_klhh[blZgby
olhgbq_kdbokms_kl\<fbnheh]bq_kdhckljmdlmj_fbjZ\h^uhfu\Zxldhjgbfbjh\h]h
^j_\ZaZ]jh[gh_pZjkl\hgZoh^blkyg_lhevdhih^a_fe_cghbhl^_e_gh\h^ghcij_]jZ^hc
Ih^h[gh_ijhlb\hj_qb_\kbf\hebd_\h^ugZoh^blk\h_jZaj_r_gb_\fhlb\_³`b\hcb
f_jl\hc\h^u´:\_jbgp_\Hp_gdZ\h^uaZ\bkblhlf_klZ__ehdZebaZpbb\
fbnheh]bq_kdhfijhkljZgkl\_\lhfqbke_ihrdZe_³\_jogba´ieh^hghkysbc^h`^v\
bg^h_\jhi_ckdhfhkgh\ghffbn_ijhlb\hiheh`_gihagZdm³Fhdhr_\m[hehlm´
Khhlghr_gb_Af_yb;h]hjh^bpuk\h^hciha\hey_l]h\hjblvhbolh`^_kl\_gghklb\
hij_^_e_gghffbnheh]bq_kdhfdhgl_dkl_WlhZ[kmj^gh_khihklZ\e_gb_^\mo
ijhlb\hiheh`guoihnmgdpbhgZevghcjheb\e_]_g^_i_jkhgZ`_cdZ`_lky\iheg_
h[hkgh\ZgguflZddZdh[Zhgbk\yaZguk\h^ghcklbob_cagZdh\Zyhp_gdZdhlhjhc
g_mklhcqb\Z<b^bfhkih^\b`ghklvxk_fZglbq_kdh]hagZdZk\yaZgZjblmZevgZyljZ^bpby
\uau\Zgby^h`^y[ulmxsZymihglbckdbo]j_dh\KqblZ_lkyqlh^h`^vihev_l_keb\h
\j_fyaZkmobm[blvaf_x<f_kl_kl_fba\_kl_gb^jm]hcjblmZegZi_j\uc\a]ey^ihegZy
ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvhibkZgghfm^ey\uah\Z^h`^yihglbcpu^_eZxldmdemdhlhjmx
gZau\ZxlDmrdm^_jZΚουšκουδερα__\h^ylihmebpZf^_\hqdbbihxli_kgbkijhkv[hc
^h`^yaZl_fdmdemlhiyl\j_d_Bgl_j_kghbgl_jij_lbjmxlih^h[gucjblmZeihglbckdb_
Zjfyg_ljZi_amg^puhgblh`_\h^yl\aZkmomdmdemgZau\Z_fmxDmrdmjbdhlhjZyih
h^ghfm\ZjbZglmhebp_l\hjy_lkh[hc>_\mFZjbx:gbkbfh\ZDbk_e_\Ihih\
Hq_\b^ghh[sbfagZf_gZl_e_f\jblmZe_^eyaf_bbdmdeuy\ey_lky\h^Zijbq_fdmdeZ
bf__lh^ghagZqgh`_gkdmxfhjnheh]bxb\k_fZgbimeypbbkg_cijh\h^yl`_gsbgu
^_\hqdb
<l_dkl_e_]_g^uhlh`^_kl\e_gb_;h]hjh^bpubAf_ybeb_]h\hafh`ghklv
j_Zebam_lky\ijhkljZgkl\_gghcehdZebaZpbbhibku\Z_fuokh[ulbcb\l_o^_ckl\byo
dhlhju_ijbibku\Zxlky]_jhyf
;h]hjh^bpZhdZau\Z_lky\f_kl_]^_gZg__\hafh`ghgZiZ^_gb_Af_y<
fbnheh]bq_kdhckljmdlmj_fbjZf_klhh[blZgbyAf_y²wlhdhjgbFbjh\h]h^j_\Zj_dZ
bebfhj_i_s_jZ²ijhkljZgkl\hlbiheh]bq_kdbkhklZ\eyxs__kljmdlmjgucgba^gh
LZdbfh[jZahfex^h_^Af_cb;h]hjh^bpZgZoh^ylky\h^ghfijhkljZgkl\_gghfehdmk_
dhlhjuc\_jhylghy\ey_lkyms_j[gufld[eZ]hijbyl_g^eyZdlb\gh]hih\_^_gbyAf_y
<lh`_\j_fy;h]hjh^bpZiZkkb\gZhgZkiblKhgdZd[eZ]hijbylgh_\j_fy^ey
m[bckl\Z²we_f_gljZkijhkljZg_gguc\kdZahqghfnhevdehj_KhihklZ\e_gb_kgZb
nbabq_kdhckf_jlbq_eh\_dZhlf_qZ_lky\jmkkdhc\_j[Zevghcnhjfme_³\_qgucihdhc´
eh]bdZih^h[ghcf_lZnhju\ZkkhpbZlb\ghck\yabkiys_]hq_eh\_dZbf_jl\h]h
g_ih^\b`ghklvbaZdjulu_]eZaZIhke_^g_fmijb^Z_lkyhkh[h_agZq_gb_ld\bamZevghklv
y\ey_lkyhkgh\ghcoZjZdl_jbklbdhcq_eh\_q_kdhc`bagbfbj`b\uo²wlh³[_euck\_l´\
hlebqbbhlij_bkih^g_c]^_pZjblfjZdIhwlhfmy\e_gb_kgh\b^_gbyfbnheh]bq_kdbf
khagZgb_ffh`_lljZdlh\ZlvkydZdkha_jpZgb_ihlmklhjhgg_]hfbjZ^eydhlhjh]h
oZjZdl_jgZki_pbnbq_kdZyj_ZevghklvdZdijZ\behh[jZlgZy^_ckl\bl_evghklbn_ghf_g
\_s_]hkgZihemqZ_leh]bqgh_h[tykg_gb_²\_^vlhqlhg_ba\_klgh`b\uf
ij_^gZq_jlZghkm^v[hcdhlhjZyihf_sZ_lky\bghcj_Zevghklb<jZaguofbnheh]bq_kdbo
ljZ^bpbyo[h]b\_^Zxsb_km^v[hcq_eh\_dZh[blZxl\gb`g_ffbj_KdZg^bgZ\kdb_ghjgu
hij_^_eyxsb_km^v[mkf_jlguo`b\mlmbklhqgbdZMj^\dhjgyofbjh\h]h^j_\Z
B]]^jZkbevF_e_lbgkdbc<keZ\ygkdhcfbnheh]bbljbk_kljukm^_gbpu
ijboh^ylgZj_dZlvkm^v[mgh\hjh`^_gghfm\iheghqvh^gZbak_kl_jh[yaZl_evgh
ijbkm`^Z_lj_[_gdmkf_jlvbeb[he_agbLheklhc<iha^g_cjhfZglbq_kdhc
ljZ^bpbbkx`_lkihjZkkm^v[hcljZdlm_lkyij_`^_\k_]hdZdk^_edZkhkf_jlvxp_gZ
dhlhjhc`bagvq_eh\_dZ
Khkghfk_fZglbq_kdblh`^_kl\_ggZke_ihlZ<ZglbqghfjhfZg_:ime_y
³F_lZfhjnhau´h^bgbai_jkhgZ`_chke_iey_lky\hkg_blZdbfh[jZahfihemqZ_l
\haf_a^b_aZkh\_jr_ggh_bfij_klmie_gb_IjbwlhfhgihiZ^Z_lba³kmfjZdZkgZ´\³fjZd
\haf_a^by´<jhfZg_ke_i_pkjZ\gb\Z_lkykl_gvxdhlhjZy[em`^Z_l³f_`^mpZjkl\hf
HjdZbkhegp_f´LZdbfh[jZahfke_ihcm`_khijbdZkZ_lkykhkf_jlvxIjbf_qZl_evgh
qlhhke_ie_gguc]_jhckimkdZ_lky\kde_ibijhkblaZi_j_lv_]hlZfqlh[umfbj_lvhl
]heh^Z:ime_c
Ke_ipulZd`_gZ^_eyxlky\hafh`ghklvxij_^\b^_lv[m^ms__Ihwlubi_\pu
kdZabl_eb;hyg\jmkkdbo[uebgZob=hf_j\ZglbqghcljZ^bpbb\_^Zxlfm^jhklvx
ihemq_gghc[eZ]h^Zjybo\hafh`ghklb\b^_lvihlmklhjhggbcfbjH[jZa³ke_i_p
ijhjbpZl_ev´wnn_dlb\_gb\dhgp_^\Z^pZlh]h\_dZwlh^hdZau\Z_llZdhcdmevlmjguc
n_ghf_gdZdiZehfgbq_kl\hd[he]ZjkdhcijhjbpZl_evgbp_<Zg]_
BlZdAf_cb;h]hjh^bpZehdZebamxlky\h^ghfijhkljZgkl\_gghfehdmk_bf_xs_f
oZjZdl_jbklbdbijbkmsb_fbnheh]bq_kdbms_j[ghfmf_klm<olhgbq_kdhfihijbjh^_
fbj_^he`guh[blZlvkhhl\_lkl\mxsb__fmkms_kl\ZLZdh\uAf_cdZggb[ZebkiysZyZ
agZqblfbnheh]bq_kdbf_jl\Zy;h]hjh^bpZ<kx`_l_e_]_g^uhiZkghklvih`bjZgby
;h]hjh^bpuk\yau\Z_lkybf_gghklZdhckblmZpb_c<fbnheh]bbljZi_aZbf__lkZdjZevgh_
agZq_gb_Kh^ghcklhjhgu²wlhgZkbeb_obsgbdZgZ^`_jl\hc<kdZahqghcljZ^bpbb
dZggb[Zebaf²djZcgyynhjfZZ]j_kkbbolhgbq_kdbokbeDZggb[Zebaf\hkijbgbfZ_lky
dZd_kl_kl\_ggh_ih\_^_gb_lhevdh\ihlmklhjhgg_ffbj_b_]hlbiheh]bq_kdbo\ZjbZglZo
²^hf_dhe^mgZ\e_kmbli
K^jm]hcklhjhguibsZ\hiehsZ_lb^_xbah[bebyZjblmZevgZyljZi_aZ
\hkijbgbfZ_lkydZdgZiheg_gb_kh_^bg_gb_<_]bi_lkdhffbn_h[Hkbjbk_Ohj
kdZjfeb\Z_lHkbjbkmnZeehkK_lZdhfi_gkbjmyg_gZc^_ggmxihke_jZkqe_g_gbyl_eZ[h]Z
wlm_]hqZklv<\mev]Zjghfkl_j_hlbi_jblmZevgh]hdZggb[ZebafZih_^Zgb_iehlb\jZ]Z
ljZdlm_lkydZdijbh[s_gb_dZggb[ZeZdnbabq_kdhcb^moh\ghckbe_ijhlb\gbdZ
K_fZglbdZk\Z^_[gh]hm]hs_gby`_gboZbeb_]h^jma_c\^hf_g_\_klulh`_fh`_l[ulv
jZkdjulZbdZd^_deZjZpbygZkbebykdhlhjufZkkhpbbjm_lky^_nehjZpbyg_\_klu\i_j\mx
[jZqgmxghqvbdZdkbf\hebq_kdh_kh_^bg_gb_fm`Zb`_gu\_^bgmxk_fvxMihglbcp_\
`_gbombebdmf[ZjhkmgZk\Z^v[_ih^ZxldmjbpmdhlhjmxehfZxllhevdhjmdZfb
LZdbfh[jZahfih_^Zgb_;h]hjh^bpuAf__ffh`ghjZkp_gb\ZlvdZdijbh[s_gb_
;h]hjh^bpudgb`g_fmfbjmlh_klvihegh___hlh`^_kl\e_gb_khAf__f<dhgl_dkl_
e_]_g^uwlh^he`ghijb\_klbddZlZkljhnbqguf^eykhpbmfZihke_^kl\byf²
g_^hklmighklb\h^ubklhqgbdZ^eyex^_cLZdhfmjZa\blbxkh[ulbcf_rZ_l\g_aZigh
ihy\b\rbckyk\ylhc=_hj]bcDZdijhlb\gbdAf_yhgZjo_lbibq_kdb\hkoh^bld
=jhfh\_j`pm<e_]_g^_ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_k\ylh]hAf_xke_^m_llZd`_ba
ijhkljZgkl\_ggh]hdhgl_dklZ=_hj]bcihy\ey_lky\f_kl_]^_^he`gZijhbahclbljZ]_^by
ba\g_<fbnheh]bq_kdhfmgb\_jkmf_kljmdlmjgh\g_rgbfZagZqblijhlb\hihklZ\e_gguf
gb`g_fmfbjmAf_yy\ey_lky]hjgbcfbj=jhfh\_j`pZ;h]hjh^bpZhdZau\Z_lkyg_lhevdh
h[t_dlhfkihjZAf_yb=_hj]byghbijhlb\hihklZ\ey_lkyihke_^g_fmld\fhf_gl
ihy\e_gbyk\ylh]h[ebadZdiheghfmhlh`^_kl\e_gbxkhAf__f:glbl_ahcg_ih^\b`ghklb
kiys_c;h]hjh^bpuy\ey_lky]bi_jZdlb\gh_ih\_^_gb_=_hj]by²ih^q_jdb\Z_lky
\g_aZighklv_]hihy\e_gby<ljZ^bpbhgghfij_^klZ\e_gbbihglbcp_\hk\ylhf=_hj]bb
qj_a\uqZcgZy_]hih^\b`ghklvgZb[he__mklhcqb\ucZljb[mlk\ylh]h<kdZad_³:rbd
D_jbi´=_hj]bcihfh]Z_l]_jhx²kqm^_kghckdhjhklvxi_j_ghkbl_]hba]hjh^Z\]hjh^
AZcdh\kdZy
Ijhlb\hihklZ\e_gb_³ih^\b`gucg_ih^\b`guc´\jy^m[bgZjguohiihabpbc
dhjj_ebjm_lkykZglbl_ahc³`bagvkf_jlv´>\b]Zl_evgZyZdlb\ghklvhij_^_ey_l`b\hc
hj]Zgbaf<ljZ^bpbhgghcdmevlmj_jblmZeZfk\yaZggufkgZqZehfkZfhklhyl_evgh]h
i_j_^\b`_gbyj_[_gdZm^_ey_lkyhkh[h_\gbfZgb_<ljZ^bpbhgghcf_^bpbg_jZa\blZ
kbkl_fZ³e_dZjkl\´hl^he]h]hg_oh`^_gbyj_[_gdZ<dmevlmjZohjb_glbjh\ZgguogZ
\kZ^gbq_kl\hjblmZeu`bag_ggh]hpbdeZ\dexqZxl³ihkZ^gZdhgy´dZdke_^mxsbcwlZi
khpbZebaZpbbfZevqbdh\ij_\jZs_gbybo\gZklhysbofm`qbgIh^\b`ghklvdZdZljb[ml
fm`kdh]hdjm]Zp_gghkl_cijhlb\hiheh`gh]hihagZdm`_gkdhfmgZqZemhljZ`Z_lkyb\
dhklxfguodhfie_dkZojZaguogZjh^h\kdh\u\ZxsZyx[hqgZyh^_`^Z`_gsbgb[jxqgZy
ijhklhjgZyh^_`^Zfm`qbg<kdZahqghfnhevdehj_ebr_gb_kihkh[ghklbi_j_^\b]Zlvky
f_lZnhjbqghaZf_sZ_lkf_jlv]_jhy
Ihy\e_gb_k\ylh]h=_hj]by\e_q_laZkh[hckf_jlvAf_ydhlhjucy\eyekykbf\hehfb
iZjZ^b]fhcgb`g_]hfbjZKg_cljZebaZpb_cAf_yijhbkoh^blbaf_g_gb_hp_gdb
ijhkljZgkl\Ze_]_g^ubahljbpZl_evghaZjy`_ggh]hf_klZh[blZgbyolhgbq_kdh]h
qm^h\bsZhghklZehm\yau\Zlvkykij_^klZ\bl_e_f]hjg_]hfbjZk\yluf=_hj]b_fK
baf_g_gb_fagZdZijhkljZgkl\Zf_gy_lkyihabpby;h]hjh^bpu\__hlghr_gbyok^jm]bfb
i_jkhgZ`Zfbe_]_g^uHgZjZkp_gb\Z_lkyg_dZdihl_gpbZevgZy`_jl\ZbqZklvgb`g_]h
fbjZZdZdkiZk_ggZybijbh[s_ggZydh[blZl_eyfkljmdlmjgh]h\_joZNZdlbq_kdbg_hgZ
i_j_f_sZ_lkygZ\_joZ]hjgbcfbjjZkrbjy_lky\ke_^aZk\h_ci_jkhgbnbdZpb_cb
\dexqZ_l__L_i_jv\hiihabpbb³Af_ck\ylhc=_hj]bc´;h]hjh^bpZ\uklmiZ_lgZklhjhg_
k\ylh]h
KiZk_gb_;h]hjh^bpuijb\h^bldihy\e_gbxbklhqgbdZqlh\l_dkl_e_]_g^u
j_rZ_lkydZdkgylb_agZdZms_j[ghklbij_`^_\k_]hkf_klZ]^_hgZihf_sZ_lky
Ke_^h\Zl_evghmkeh\b_f^hklmighklb\h^ujh^gbdZ^eyex^_cy\ey_lkyhp_gdZ
ijhkljZgkl\ZZgljhihfhjngufkbf\hehfdhlhjh]h\uklmiZ_l;h]hjh^bpZWlZhp_gdZ
ih^\_j`_gZbg\_jkbyfdhlhju_k\yaZgukZdlb\ghcbebiZkkb\ghcihabpb_c^\mo^jm]bo
i_jkhgZ`_c²Af_ybk\ylh]h=_hj]byAgZdh\ZyijbgZ^e_`ghklvboihklhyggZbhgb
\ujZ`Zxlg_ijbfbjbfmxhiihabpbx\l_dkl_e_]_g^u
Kljmdlmjmhlghr_gbcf_`^mi_jkhgZ`Zfbihkx`_lme_]_g^ulZdbfh[jZahffh`gh
ihdZaZlvq_j_abaf_g_gbyhp_gdbijhkljZgkl\ZihrdZe_³\_jogba´³]hjgbcfbjgb`gbc
fbj´bihabpbc]_jh_\\ij_^_eZoZglbl_au³Zdlb\guciZkkb\guc´
Ihabpby;h]hjh^bpuaZ\bkblhlhp_gdbijhkljZgkl\Z]^_hgZgZoh^blky
ihke_^h\Zl_evghklvbaZ\bkbfhklvkx`_lguowe_f_glh\hlf_q_gZklj_edZfbBaf_g_gb_
agZdZijhkljZgkl\Zdhhj^bgZevghf_gy_lihabpbx;h]hjh^bpukiZkkb\ghcgZZdlb\gmxba
q_]hfh`ghaZdexqblvqlhkhklhygb_kgZk\ylhckf_gy_lky__[h^jkl\h\Zgb_fM`_
hlf_qZeZkvfhjnheh]bq_kdZy[ebahklvkgZbke_ihlu\ZkkhpbZlb\ghcp_ibkhg ke_ihlZ
kf_jlv<jZkkfZljb\Z_fhfl_dkl_e_]_g^uk_fZglbd_kgZ;h]hjh^bpum^_ey_lky
fZeh\gbfZgbyebrvdhgklZlbjm_lkyg_aZsbs_gghklv]_jhbgb\h\j_fykgZZk\yadZ³khg
ke_ihlZ´\hh[s_g_a\mqbl[md\Zevghb\hkklZgZ\eb\Z_lkylhevdhdhk\_gghijbZgZeba_
<hafh`ghijbqbghcwlh]hy\ey_lkyZdlmZevghklvf_^bpbgkdbok\hckl\\h^ubklhqgbdZ^ey
e_q_gbybf_gghke_ihlu<_kvfZkbfilhfZlbqghqlhbkp_e_gb_hl]eZaguoaZ[he_\Zgbc
h^gZbakn_jbkihevah\Zgbyqm^_kghc\h^ubklhqgbdZB^Z`_nbabq_kdba^hjh\u_
iZehfgbdbihemqZxlqm^_kgmxkihkh[ghklv\b^_lvbdhgmIZgZbcbgZ^g_bklhqgbdZ\^_gv
Mki_gby;h]hjh^bpu
?s_h^bgi_jkhgZ`e_]_g^ulZd`_k\yau\Z_lkyihglbcpZfbke_q_gb_f]eZaguo
aZ[he_\Zgbc²wlhk\ylhc=_hj]bcMklZgbpu>_j[_glkdhch^bgba[vxsbolZf
bklhqgbdh\[ueihk\ys_gwlhfmk\ylhfmbdg_fmoh^bebe_qblv\lhfqbke_bke_ihlm<
kdZad_³:rbdD_jbi´]_jhc\ha\jZsZ_laj_gb_k\h_cke_ihcfZl_jbijbeh`b\d__]eZaZf
]jyavbaih^dhiuldhgyk\ylh]hAZcdh\kdZy<j_]bhgZevghbdmevlmjgh[ebadhc
IhglmAZiZ^ghc=jmabb[ulm_lij_^klZ\e_gb_qlhk\ylhc=_hj]bc^Z_lijhaj_gb_GZ
ijZa^gbd³Fbkjh[Z´ihk\ys_ggucwlhfmk\ylhfmke_iu_ijhkyl\_jgmlvbfaj_gb_
ijbdeZ^u\Zye_i_rdbd]eZaZf:[Zd_eby<ihglbckdhckdZad_³KhgpZj_\bqZ´
]_jhcZljb[mlbdZdhlhjh]hkh\iZ^Z_lkkbf\heZfbk\ylh]h=_hj]by^h[u\Z_laj_gb_^ey
k\hboohay_\klZjbdh\ih^a_fe_cFboZceb^bk
<aZdexq_gbbfujbkdg_fk^_eZlvhlklmie_gb_hlZgZebaZl_dklZe_]_g^ubkdZ`_f
g_kdhevdhkeh\h[hkh[hff_kl_dmevlZk\ylh]h=_hj]by\dmevlmj_ihglbckdbo]j_dh\
G_h[oh^bfhklvlZdh]hhlklmie_gby\hagbdeZ\ijhp_kk_jZ[hlugZ^klZlv_cdh]^Z
hldjuebkvbgl_j_kgu_ijhlb\hj_qby\k_fZglbd_bnmgdpbyok\ylh]h=_hj]by\dmevlmjZo
dZ\dZakdhihglbckdh]hj_]bhgZ
Hkh[ucbgl_j_k^eybkke_^h\Zgbylbiheh]bbdmevlmjuihglbcp_\ij_^klZ\ey_l
g_khhl\_lkl\b_\ukhdh]hklZlmkZ=jhfh\_j`pZ\fbnheh]bbbk\yav_]hi_jkhgbnbdZpbb
k\ylh]h=_hj]byka_fe_cwe_f_glhfkljmdlmjgh]hgbaZ
A_fey\fbnheh]bbk\yau\Z_lkykolhgbq_kdbfehdmkhfAf_ch[blZ_l\i_s_j_ih^
a_fe_cA_fe_^_eb_dZdkn_jZ^_yl_evghklbq_eh\_dZ\fbnheh]bq_kdhfkhagZgbb
\hkijbgbfZ_lkydZdgbadhklZlmkgh_bhiZkgh_^eyex^_cldZdlmZebabjm_lky
ijhgbdgh\_gb_a_fe_^_evpZ\gb`gbcfbj\h\j_fy_]hjZ[hlugZa_fe_<^j_\g_]j_q_kdhc
fbnheh]bba_feyklZgh\blkyieh^hjh^ghcdh]^Zd>_f_lj_²[h]bg_a_fe_^_ebyijboh^bl
bafbjZkf_jlb__^hqvI_jk_nhgZLZoh=h^b<ZjoZbqguoh[s_kl\Zo
a_fe_^_eb_faZgbfZxlkyex^bbebkhpbZevgu_]jmiiudhlhju_\hkijbgbfZxlkydZd
ms_j[gu_qZklhwlh`_gsbgubebg_iheghijZ\gu_khie_f_ggbdb
Khhlg_k_gghklvk\ylh]h=_hj]byka_fe_cb\hafh`ghih^a_fguffbjhf
ijhke_`b\Z_lkyb\_]hbf_gbK]j_q_kdh]h³=_hj]bc´i_j_\h^blky³a_fe_^_e_p
\ha^_eu\Zl_eva_feb´Dhg_qghj_qvg_b^_lh[md\Zevghf\hkijbylbbihglbckdbfb
]j_dZfbbf_gbk\ylh]hGh`blb_k\ylh]hkh^_j`blmdZaZgb_gZfZehZabZlkdh_
ijhbkoh`^_gb_=_hj]bybajZchgZDZiiZ^hdbbkf_`gh]hkIhglhf<_jhylghqlh
`blbcgZyljZ^bpbyhibjZeZkvgZdmevlmjguckl_j_hlbik\yau\ZxsbcwlmqZklv:gZlhebbk
a_fe_^_evq_kdbflbihfdmevlmjubhkh[ufklZlmkhf\_joh\gh]h[h`_kl\Z
Bgl_j_kgucfZl_jbZekh^_j`blihglbckdZyZ]bh]jZnby<kj_^g_\_dh\hc
LjZi_amg^kdhcbfi_jbbl_jjblhjbydhlhjhckh\iZ^Z_lk]_h]jZnbq_kdbfb]jZgbpZfb
IhglZhkh[ufihqblZgb_fihevah\Zekyk\ylhcN_h^hj²ojbklbZgkdbc\hbgfmq_gbd
ih]b[rbc\ie_gmmlmjhdk_ev^`mdh\;bh]jZnbq_kdb_^Zggu_kh^_j`Zsb_ky\`blb_
N_h^hjZgZdeZ^u\ZxlkygZ`blbcgmxko_fmk\ylh]h=_hj]byN_h^hjdZdb=_hj]bc
ijbgZ^e_`bldZjbklhdjZlbbhgbajh^Zihglbckdboijbgp_\=Z\jh\DZjih\
N_h^hjlZd`_ijbgbfZ_lfmq_gbq_kdmxkf_jlvaZ\_jm
G_h`b^Zggu_iZjZee_eb\koh^kl\_k\yluoN_h^hjZb=_hj]by^Z_l\hklhqghb
x`ghkeZ\ygkdbcfZl_jbZeGZ;ZedZgZojZkijhkljZg_gdmevlihqblZgbyk\ylh]hN_h^hjZ
LbjhgZdhlhjucdZdb=_hj]bckqblZ_lkyihdjh\bl_e_fkdhlZbaf__[hjp_fLheklhc
131-133).
LjZ^bpbxihqblZgbyN_h^hjZ\HkfZgkdbci_jbh^bklhjbbIhglZijh^he`Zeb]j_db
djbilhojbklbZg_dhlhju_lZcghfhebebkvojbklbZgkdhfmk\ylhfm\ih^a_fguoqZkh\gyo
=hj^e_\kdbcEhdZebaZpbydmevlZk\ylh]hih^a_fe_cbf__lg_lhevdh
\ugm`^_ggu_ijbqbgu²ij_ke_^h\Zgb_ojbklbZg\HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbb²ghb
fbnheh]bq_kdh_h[tykg_gb_
<=jmabbkhklZ\eyxs_ckIhglhfh^bgdmevlmjgucZj_Zek\ylhcN_h^hjihqblZ_lky
ih^bf_g_fL_^hj_baZf_sZ_lyauq_kdh_Z]jZjgh_[h`_kl\h²ihdjh\bl_eya_fe_^_ebyb
ehrZ^_cdhgv²kbf\hebg^h_\jhi_ckdh]h=jhfh\_j`pZb]eZ\gucZljb[mlk\ylh]h
=_hj]byL_^hj_bf__l\k_agZdbgb`g_]hojhgbq_kdh]hfbjZwibl_l³l_^hj_´agZqbl
³kfm]euc´bkhhl\_lkl\m_lq_jghfmp\_lma_febKdmevlhfL_^hj_k\yaZghgZqZehk_\Z\
]jmabgkdhfa_fe_^_evq_kdhfdZe_g^Zj_;j_]Z^a_
<nhevdehj_bdZe_g^Zjghch[jy^ghklbgZjh^h\IhglZolhgbq_kdmxkbf\hebdm
ihemqZ_lbk\ylhc=_hj]bcEZauhdj_klghkl_c;Zlmfb\_jylqlhihghqZf\jZa\ZebgZo
ojbklbZgkdh]hojZfZihy\ey_lky^vy\hekh]g_ggufb]eZaZfbgZq_jghfdhg_Ebha_g
<[uebqdZof_fhjZlZoihglbckdbo]j_dh\gZjy^mkljZ^bpbhggufh[jZahf
k\ylh]hxghrZaf__[hj_pgZ[_ehfdhg_nb]mjbjm_lK\ylhc=_hj]bc²klZjbdgZ
\hjhghfdhg_\q_jghch^_`^_Ihij_^klZ\e_gbyf]j_dh\\Zij_e_bghy[j_\^gbk\ylh]h
=_hj]by^mxlkbevgu_\_ljudhlhju_fh]ml[ulvhiZkgufb^ey`bagbq_eh\_dZ
AZcdh\kdZy
LZdZyZf[b\Ze_glghklvh[jZaZk\ylh]h=_hj]bybf__lhkgh\Zgb_\fbnheh]_f_
=jhfh\_j`pZ<fbn_=jhfh\_j`_p\uihegy_lg_lhevdhdhgkljmdlb\gu_nmgdpbb²
^h[u\Z_ldmevlmjgu_p_gghklbghbh[eZ^Z_ljZajmrbl_evghcwg_j]b_c=jhfh\_j`_p
m[b\Z_lk\h_]holhgbq_kdh]hZglbih^ZkimkdZ_lky\ih^a_fgucfbjkhq_lZ_lkyk\ys_gguf
[jZdhfk[h]bg_cieh^hjh^byagZdh\Zyhp_gdZdhlhjhcg_mklhcqb\Z=jhfh\_j`_p\
ijhp_kk_k\h_c^_yl_evghklbihklhygghkhijbdZkZ_lkykfbnheh]bq_kdbms_j[ghc
j_Zevghklvxbi_jkhgZ`ZfbijbwlhfkZfihemqZ_lg_]Zlb\gmxhp_gdm<km_\_jbyo]jhf
bgl_jij_lbjm_lkydZd]g_\\_joh\gh]h[h`_kl\Zdhlhjucfh`_lbf_lvdZdihablb\gu_lZd
b\j_^hghkgu_ihke_^kl\by^eyex^_cijhev_lky^h`^vbebfhegbym^Zjbl\q_eh\_dZ
K\ylhc=_hj]bcg_lhevdhe_qblghbgZdZau\Z_lebrZyjZkkm^dZm^ZjZfbk\h_]hdhivy
:[Zd_eby
Hkh[ucbgl_j_k\uau\Z_lkf_s_gb_Zdp_glZgZagZdh\hms_j[gmxk_fZglbdm
=jhfh\_j`pZ\ljZ^bpbyogZjh^h\j_]bhgZIh^q_jdb\Z_lkyi_j_f_s_gb_g_[_kgh]h
[h`_kl\Z\gb`gbcfbjIh^h[gmxbg\_jkbx\fbnheh]_f_\_joh\gh]h[h`_kl\Zfu
gZoh^bf\^j_\g_c:gZlhebb\omjjblho_llkdhfiZgl_hg_qlhfh`_lk\b^_l_evkl\h\Zlvh[
ZjoZbaf_aZljhgmlhcgZfbijh[e_fuIhgb`_gb_klZlmkZ^j_\g_]hg_[_kgh]h[h]Z
ijbkmlkl\m_l\kx`_l_gba\_j`_gby[h]Zg_[Z:eZem<iha^gbobklhqgbdZo[h`_kl\hk
lZdbf`_bf_g_fnb]mjbjm_ldZd[h]ih^a_fgh]hpZjkl\Z<omjjblkdhcfbnheh]bb[h]bgy
k[ebadhcdhjg_\hchkgh\hc\bf_gb:eZgby\ey_lkyohaycdhcij_bkih^g_cOZqbdyg
Dhj_gv³Ze´ijbkmlkl\m_l\l_jfbg_bkihevam_fhf\k_fblkdboyaudZo^ey
h[hagZq_gby[h]Z<^_fhgheh]bbfgh]bogZjh^h\ZgZlhebckdhdZ\dZakdh]hj_]bhgZ_klv
i_jkhgZ`ihbf_gb:edZfr_gkdb_Zjfyg_gZau\ZxllZd`_gsbgm^_fhgZDmag_ph\
107).
AZljhgmlu_\wlhfdhjhldhfhlklmie_gbb\hijhkufbnheh]bq_kdhcbg\_jkbb\Z`gu
^eyihgbfZgbyk_fZglbdbh^gh]hbai_jkhgZ`_ce_]_g^uk\ylh]h=_hj]byghbf_xllZd`_
[hevrh_agZq_gb_^eylbiheh]bq_kdh]hZgZebaZdmevlmjj_]bhgZ
K_fZglbq_kdbcZgZebae_]_g^ujZkdju\Z_lf_oZgbafh^ghcbanhjffure_gby
q_eh\_dZfbnheh]bq_kdh]hkhagZgbydhlhjh_j_Zebam_lk_[y\nhevdehj_jblmZeZob
^jm]bonhjfZoljZ^bpbhgghcdmevlmju:gZebae_]_g^uihdZau\Z_lkx`_lgh_jh^kl\h
nhevdehjgh]hl_dklZbhkgh\gh]hfbnZgZZjo_lbibq_kdhfmjh\g_;_amkeh\gh^ey
ijh[e_fulbiheh]bbdmevlmjgZjh^h\ihglbckdhdZ\dZakdh]hj_]bhgZbf_xl[hevrh_
agZq_gb_k_fZglbq_kdb_iZjZ^b]fudhlhju_gZrebk\h_hljZ`_gb_\nhevdehj_
IJBF?Q:GBY
KlZlvygZibkZgZgZhkgh\_ihe_\uofZl_jbZeh\kh[jZgguo\wlgh]jZnbq_kdbo
wdki_^bpbyoijh\h^b\rboky\=_e_g^`bdkdhfDjufkdhfK_\_jkdhfjZchgZo
DjZkgh^Zjkdh]hdjZy\]]
L_jfbge_]_g^Zijbf_gy_lkydij_^eZ]Z_fhfmnhevdehjghfml_dklmk^he_c
mkeh\ghklbld_]hihgbfZgb_\kh\j_f_gghcnhevdehjbklbd_ijhlb\hj_qb\hD<Qbklh\
mdZau\Z_lqlh³\h^gbokemqZyowlhll_jfbgijbf_gy_lkybkdexqbl_evghdmklguf
jZkkdZaZfgZ[b[e_ckdb_j_eb]bhagu_bp_jdh\gu_l_fu\^jm]bo²ho\Zlu\Z_l
agZqbl_evgh[he__rbjhdmxh[eZklvmklghcgZjh^ghcijhau²qmlvebg_ex[u_mklgu_
jZkkdZaug_kdZahqgh]hoZjZdl_jZb[he__bebf_g__\ufure_ggh]hkh^_j`Zgby´Qbklh\
GZfbe_]_g^Zijhlb\hihklZ\ey_lky[uebqdZfdZdfbnheh]bq_kdb[he__
gZ]jm`_ggZynhjfZnhevdehjZ
DmjbpZfh`_l[ulvmdjZ^_gZ\^hf_g_\_klubijbg_k_gZklhjhghc`_gboZdZd
ijZ\behgZkbeb_gZ^ilbp_cbf__lyjdh\ujZ`_ggmxwjhlbq_kdmxkbf\hebdmkf
fZl_jbZeuwdki_^bpbb\i<blya_\him[ebdm_fu_\^Zgghf\uimkd_<ihglbckdhc
k\Z^_[ghcljZ^bpbbilbpZqZs_\k_]hwlhdmjbpZfZjdbjm_lg_\_klm\ibs_\hfdh^_
<Z`_giheilbpu\ihglbckdhckdZad_i_lmo^h[u\Z_lahehlu_fhg_lu^eyklZjbdZZ
dmjbpZl_jiblg_m^Zqmihfh]ZyklZjmo_FboZceb^bk
Bkke_^myijh[e_fml_dklZbyaudZXFEhlfZghlf_qZeqlhy\e_gb_dmevlmju
ij_\jZsZ_lky\yaudlhevdh³p_ghcmljZlug_ihkj_^kl\_gghcj_Zevghklbbijb\_^_gb___\
qbklhnhjfZevgmxkn_jm´EhlfZg
Kx`_l^h[u\Zgbyaj_gbybaih^a_febjZkijhkljZg_g\kdZahqghfnhevdehj_
fgh]bogZjh^h\<jmkkdhckdZad_xghrZkem`bliZklmohfmke_iuoklZjbdZbklZjmob
^hklZ_lbfaj_gb_m[b\af_x\_^vfmijbwlhfhgkimkdZ_lky\ih^a_fgh_pZjkl\hPb\vyg
IhdZaZl_evghqlhaf__[hjq_kdbcfhlb\[ehdbjm_lkykiZklmr_kdhcl_fZlbdhc
K\ylhc=_hj]bc\dZe_g^Zjghch[jy^ghklb\hklhqguokeZ\yg\uihegy_lnmgdpbx
ihdjh\bl_ey^hfZrg_]hkdhlZhghl]hgy_lhlklZ^\hedh\baf_c<u]hgkdhlZgZe_lgb_
iZkl[bsZgZqbgZekyihke_\_k_gg_]h^gyk\ylh]h:\_jbgp_\Ihglbckdb_]j_db
\\_k_ggbc^_gvk\ylh]h=_hj]byhl]hgyebkdhlgZyceZ\]hjuZgZhk_ggbcijb]hgyeb
h[jZlghAZcdh\kdZy
Download