Конрад Лоренц. Человек находит друга

реклама
DhgjZ^ Ehj_gpQ_eh\_d gZoh^bl ^Sm]Z
Fhkd\Z
K H > ? J @ : G B ?
<\_^_gb_Q_eh\_d b^hfZrgb_ `b\hlgu_
DZd\_jhylgh\k_ wlh gZqZehkv
>\Z bklhqgbdZij_^Zgghklb
Kh[Zqvb ebqghklb
H[mq_gb_
Kh[Zqvb h[uqZb
Ohaybg bkh[ZdZ
Kh[Zdb b^_lb
DZd \u[jZlvkh[Zdm
Ijbau\ dl_fdlh jZa\h^blkh[Zd
I_j_fbjb_
AZ[hj
Fgh]h rmfZbaaZ fZe_gvdh]h^bg]h
DZdZy `Zehklvqlh hgZg_ ]h\hjbl\_^v hgZ
ihgbfZ_l dZ`^h_keh\h
IjZ\Z ij_^Zgghklb
Kh[Zqv_ gZkljh_gb_
H dhrZqvbob]jZo
Q_eh\_d bdhrdZ
@b\hlgu_dhlhju_ e]ml
DhrZqvy gZlmjZ
@b\hlgu_gZ^_e_ggu_ kh\_klvx
<_jghklv bkf_jlv
<<?>?GB?Q?EH<?D B>HF:RGB? @B<HLGU?
G_h[oh^bfhklv
h[j_dZ_l
bo
@blv kq_eh\_dhf gZ _]h em]Zo
< _]h ^\hj_bev mg_]h \^hfm
B qZklh gZf y\ey_l boijbf_j
Kdhev ^hjh]mx
p_gm hg
[_j_l
AZ ihdjh\bl_evkl\h
Dmi_jIjh]medZ \abfgbc ihe^_gv
K_]h^gy yihaZ\ljZdZe ih^`Zj_ggufoe_[hf k dhe[ZkdhcB
dhe[Zkhc b`bjhfgZ dhlhjhfih^`Zjb\Zeky oe_[y [ue h[yaZg
k\bgv_dhlhjmx agZ\Ze hqZjh\Zl_evguf xjdbf
ihjhk_gdhf
H^gZdh_^\Z hgZ \ureZ
ba wlh]h g_`gh]h \hajZklZy
ij_djZlbe k g_c \kydh_ agZdhfkl\h^Z[u ba[Z\blv
k\hx
kh\_klv hlm]jua_gbcdh]^Z ijb^_lg_ba[_`guc qZkY m\_j_g
qlh_keb [ufg_ ijbrehkvkZfhfm m[b\Zlv`b\hlguodhlhjuo y
_fgZ fhc klhe gbdh]^Z g_ ihiZ^Zeb [u kms_kl\Zih
bgl_ee_dlmZevghfm mjh\gx\ur_ ju[u beb\ djZcg_f kemqZ_
ey]mrdbJZamf__lkykgbfZlv
k
k_[y
lZdbf kihkh[hf
hl\_lkl\_gghklv qbkl_cr_c \h^u ebp_f_jb_Gh \ ex[hf
kemqZ_ hlghr_gb_ q_eh\_dZd `b\hlgufdhlhjuo hg\ujZsb\Ze
^ey _^ughkbl ijhlb\hj_qb\uc oZjZdl_jM n_jf_jh\ hgh
hij_^_ey_lky \_dh\ufb ljZ^bpbyfb b ^Z\gh m`_ \uebehkv\
kljh]h hij_^_e_ggmxihqlb jblmZevgmx nhjfmih\_^_gbyqlh
iheghklvx
hk\h[h`^Z_l
bo
hl
hsms_gby
fhjZevghc
hl\_lkl\_gghklb b \bgu>ey q_eh\_dZ `_ijhn_kkbhgZevgh
aZgbfZxs_]hky bamq_gb_f mfkl\_gguo kihkh[ghkl_c `b\hlguo
wlZ ijh[e_fZijbh[j_lZ_l kh\k_f bgh_hk\_s_gb_K _]h lhqdb
aj_gbyg_h[oh^bfhklv m[b\Zlv^hfZrgbo `b\hlguodm^Z [he__
ly]hklgZq_f hlklj_e ^bqbHohlgbd g_agZdhf kh
k\h_c
^h[uq_c ebqgh\h \kydhf kemqZ_hg kZf__ g_ \ujZsb\Ze:
]eZ\gh_^bdb_ a\_jbagZxlqlh bfihklhyggh ]jhabl ]b[_ev
< fhjZevghf
Zki_dl_ k\_jgmlv
]heh\m ^hfZrg_fm
]mkx
^h\_jqb\h lygms_fmky d \Zf aZ dhjfhfdm^Z ljm^g__q_f
aZljZlb\ g_fZeh l_ji_gby b nbabq_kdbomkbebcih^klj_eblv
_]h ^bdh]hkh[jZlZdhlhjuc g_lhevdh agZ_lh ih^kl_j_]Zxs_c
_]h hiZkghklbgh b bf__l\hafh`ghklv ba[_`Zlv__H^gZdh
ihabpby q_eh\_dZ ih hlghr_gbx d l_f ^hfZrgbf `b\hlguf
dhlhjuo hgg_ _klZ bkihevam_l ^ey^jm]bo p_e_cih`Zemc
_s_ [he__khfgbl_evgZq_f _]hihabpby ihhlghr_gbx d l_f
dhlhjuo hg ihlj_[ey_l \ ibsm b dhlhju_ ^hk\h_c h[uqgh
[ukljhc b [_a[he_ag_gghckf_jlb \_^mle_]dmx b[_aaZ[hlgmx
`bagvKm^v[Z ehrZ^bqv_ kms_kl\h\Zgb_ih f_j_ijb[eb`_gby
klZjhklb klZgh\blky \k_ [he__ ly`dbfkebrdhf ljZ]bqgZ
qlh[u gZ g_cohl_ehkv hklZgZ\eb\ZlvkyD gZbf_g__ijbylguf
q_jlZf
\aZbfhhlghr_gbc
q_eh\_dZ
b
^hfZrgbo
`b\hlguo
hlghkblky oeZ^ghdjh\b_k dhlhjuf hgaZ[b\Z_l l_eylb ^Z`_
kZfbo dhjh\dh]^Z\u^h_ggu_
^hkmoZhgb
i_j_klZxl
hijZ\^u\Zlv k_[y
Lhevdh k kZfhc rbjhdhc [bheh]bq_kdhc lhqdb
aj_gby
jZkkfZljb\Zy g_ bg^b\b^mZevgu_ hkh[bZ \b^ \p_ehffu
fh`_f kqblZlv k\yav f_`^m q_eh\_dhfb ^hfZrgbfb`b\hlgufb
\aZbfh\u]h^guf kbf[bhahf<_^v dZd behrZ^vb dhjh\Zb
h\pZb
ijhqb_ ^hfZrgb_
`b\hlgu_ ihemqbeb
hl k\h_]h
h^hfZrgb\Zgby [_kkihjgmx\u]h^mihkdhevdm bo^bdb_ ij_^db
g_ kihkh[gu_ kms_kl\h\Zlv \ pb\bebah\ZgguokljZgZo^Z\gh
m`_ \uf_jeb
D lhfm`_ q_eh\_dgbdh]^Z g_ [jZegZ k_[y ihhlghr_gbx
d gbfgbdZdbo fhjZevguoh[yaZl_evkl\bkh[kl\_ggh ]h\hjy
hg
h[jZsZ_lky
k
gbfb
lZddZd
\
^j_\ghklb ^Z`_
\ukhdhpb\bebah\Zggu_
gZjh^u
h[jZsZebkv
k
ie_ggbdZfb
aZo\Zq_ggufb gZ \hcg_:
\ i_j\h[ulgu_ \j_f_gZ
lZdbo
ie_ggbdh\ g_j_^dh
ijhklh _ebB ih[_^bl_eb
ijb wlhf
bkiulu\Zeb dm^Zf_gvr_ gjZ\kl\_gguokhfg_gbcq_f bkiulu\Ze
bo k_]h^gymljhf yaZ\ljZdZy dhe[Zkhc
Lhevdh ^\Z \b^Z`b\hlguo klZebqe_gZfb ^hfZrg_]hdjm]Z
q_eh\_dZ g_ dZd ie_ggbdb b [ueb ijbjmq_gu g_k ihfhsvx
ijbgm`^_gbyY bf_x\ \b^mkh[Zdm bdhrdmBo h[t_^bgyxl ^\Z
fhf_glZ h[Z hgb obsgbdbb mh[hbo q_eh\_dbkihevam_l bo
hohlgbqvb kihkh[ghklb: \h\k_f hklZevghfb ]eZ\gh_ih
oZjZdl_jm k\hbo hlghr_gbc k q_eh\_dhfhgb jZagylkyf_`^m
kh[hcdZd ^_gv bghqvG_l ^jm]h]h`b\hlgh]hdhlhjh_ lZd
dZj^bgZevgh baf_gbeh [u\_kv h[jZa`bagb\kx kn_jm k\hbo
bgl_j_kh\klZeh [u^h lZdhckl_i_gb ^hfZrgbodZd kh[ZdZb
g_l ^jm]h]h`b\hlgh]hdhlhjh_ aZ^he]b_ \_dZk\h_c k\yabk
q_eh\_dhf baf_gbehkv [u lZd fZehdZd dhrdZMl\_j`^_gb_
qlh dhrdb_keb bkdexqblv g_kdhevdh ^_dhjZlb\guo ihjh^
\jh^_ Zg]hjkdhcbeb kbZfkdhc\ kmsghklb\h\k_ g_ ^hfZrgb_
`b\hlgu_Z
ih^ebggh
^bdb_
kms_kl\Z\h fgh]hf
kijZ\_^eb\hDhrdZkhojZgyy
ihegmx
g_aZ\bkbfhklv
ij_^ihqblZ_l k_eblvky \ ^hfZo b ohayckl\_gguoihkljhcdZo
q_eh\_dZ ih lhcijhklhc ijbqbg_qlh gb]^_[hevr_ furbg_
\h^ylky \lZdhf dhebq_kl\_KbeZ h[Zygbykh[Zdb aZdexq_gZ \
]em[bg_ ^jm`[ub dj_ihklb ^moh\guomadhlhju_ k\yau\Zxl __
k q_eh\_dhfZ hqZjh\Zgb_ dhrdb
h[tykgy_lkydZd jZal_f
qlh hgZg_ \klmibeZk gbf\ l_kgucdhglZdlqlh hgZ hohlblky
\ _]hdhgxrgyo bZf[ZjZo k lZbgkl\_gghcb g_^hklmighc ^Z`_
lh]^Zdh]^Z g_`ghlj_lky hgh]b ohaycdbbeb m[eZ]hl\hj_gh
fmjeuq_l m h]gy>ey f_gy fmjeudZxsZydhrdZ wlh kbf\he
^hfZrg_]h hqZ]Zmxlgh]h ihdhyFg_ [ueh [ulZd `_ljm^gh
h[hclbkv [_a dhrdb\ fh_f^hf_dZd b [_akh[ZdbdhlhjZy
ljmkbl kh fghc ih mebp_ beb ih em]mK kZfh]hjZgg_]h
^_lkl\Z y \k_]^Z[ue hdjm`_gkh[ZdZfb bdhrdZfbb \wlhc
dgb]_ y jZkkdZ`m h gbo>_eh\blu_ ^jmavykh\_lh\Zeb fg_
gZibkZlv hl^_evgmx dgb]m ijh kh[Zd bhl^_evgmx dgb]mijh
dhr_dihlhfm qlh ex^bex[ysb_ dhr_dqZklh g_\ughkyl
kh[ZdGZ fhc\a]ey^bklbggZy ex[h\vd `b\hlgufb ihgbfZgb_
bo ^hdZau\Z_lky dZd jZa l_fqlh h^bg blhl `_q_eh\_d
bkiulu\Z_l kbfiZlbx b d kh[ZdZf b ddhrdZfmf_y p_gblv
hkh[u_ dZq_kl\Z dZd l_olZd b ^jm]bo: ihlhfm
wlm
fZe_gvdmx dgb]my ihk\ysZx\k_f l_fdlh ex[blb ihgbfZ_l b
kh[Zdb dhr_d
D:D<?JHYLGH<K? WLH G:QBG:EHKV
>ZgZ bf fm^jhklv lhgdZyqmlvy
B ih ebpmih \b^m
q_eh\_dZ
P_ev lZcgmx _]hijhq_klv mf_xl
G_ jZa
kiZk_gv_ h[j_lZeb
fu
< lhf k\hckl\_qlh
g_^hklmigh
kZfbfgZf
Dmi_j
Kd\hav ]mklu_ aZjhkeb\ukhdbo kl_iguoljZ\ ijh[bjZ_lky
dmqdZ gZ]bo ex^_ci_j\h[ulgZy hj^Z>Zwlhg_khfg_ggh
ex^b lZdb_ `_dZd fu k \Zfbbo keh`_gb_ gbq_f
g_
hlebqZ_lky hl keh`_gby kh\j_f_ggh]h q_eh\_dZ< jmdZohgb
^_j`Zl dhivy k dhklygufb gZdhg_qgbdZfbZ g_dhlhju_^Z`_
\hhjm`_gu mdZfb b klj_eZfbh^gZdh \ bo ih\_^_gbb_klv
qlhlhq_]h \ gZr_ \j_fy g_evay gZclb ^Z`_ mie_f_g
klhysbo gZ kZfhf gbadhf mjh\g_ jZa\blbyqlhlhqlh fu
ijb\udeb aZf_qZlvlhevdh m `b\hlguoWlb ex^b_s_ ^Ze_dhg_
\eZ^udb A_feb[_kkljZrgh \abjZxsb_
gZ \k_qlh
bo
hdjm`Z_lG_lgb lhb ^_ehbkim]Zggh h]ey^u\Zxlkyq_j_a
ie_qhb bol_fgu_ ]eZaZ\k_ \j_fy[_kihdhcgh [_]ZxlHgb
\_^ml k_[ydZd he_gbdZd ]hgbfu_`b\hlgu_dhlhju_ ^he`gu
[ulv \k_ \j_fygZklhjh`_Hgb klZjZxlky ih^Zevr_h[oh^blv
dmklu b dmiu ^_j_\v_\]^_\hafh`ghijyq_lky obsgbdZ
dh]^Z gZ\klj_qm bfaZrmjrZ\ \_ldZfb\g_aZigh \ukdZdb\Z_l
djmigZy ZglbehiZg_j\gh \a^jZ]b\Zxl b ih^gbfZxl dhivy
]hlh\ykv
h[hjhgylvkyGh
lml
hgb
magZxl [_ah[b^gh_
ljZ\hy^gh_b kljZo kf_gy_lky h[e_]q_gb_fhgb gZqbgZxl
\ha[m`^_gh
i_j_]h\Zjb\ZlvkyZ
ihlhf
jZa^jZ`Zxlky
jZ^hklguf kf_ohf
H^gZdh \_k_ev_[ukljh m]ZkZ_lhj^Z ho\Zq_gZ mgugb_fb
qlh \iheg_
ihgylghG_^Z\gh
^jm]h_[he__
kbevgh_ b
fgh]hqbke_ggh ie_fy \ul_kgbeh bo ba ijb\uqguohohlgbqvbo
m]h^bcb \hl hgb\ugm`^_gu moh^blv \k_^Zevr_ gZ aZiZ^Z
wlb f_klZ
bf kh\k_f
g_agZdhfub
d lhfm
`_ a^_kv
\klj_qZ_lky [hevr_ hiZkguo obsgbdh\q_f lZf]^_
hgb
h[blZeb jZgvr_Bo ij_`gbc ij_^\h^bl_evhiulguc klZjuc
hohlgbdih]b[ g_kdhevdh g_^_ev gZaZ^ _]h
jZkl_jaZe
kZ[e_am[uc lb]jdhlhjuc ghqvx ih^djZeky d
klhc[bsm b
ko\Zlbe ^_\hqdm<k_ fm`qbgu dbgmebkvgZ lb]jZk dhivyfb
Ij_^\h^bl_ev [ue \i_j_^bb m^Zj h]jhfghceZiu h[jmrbeky
bf_ggh gZg_]h>_\hqdZ [ueZm`_ f_jl\ZZ klZjuc hohlgbd
mf_j hl jZg gZ ^jm]hc ^_gvIjZ\^Zb lb]jihjZ`_gguc
dhiv_f \ [jxohg_^_ex kimkly k^hogh wlhgbkdhevdh g_
h[e_]qZeh iheh`_gb_ hj^uL_i_jv \ g_c hklZehkv lhevdh
iylv fm`qbgZ iyl_juf fm`qbgZfg_ ih^kbem aZsblblv`_gsbg
b ^_l_chl djmigh]h obsgbdZ>Z bgh\uc ij_^\h^bl_ev^Ze_dh
g_ lZdhiul_g bkbe_gdZd ih]b[rbcAZlh eh[m g_]h\ur_ b
\uimde__Z ]eZaZ [he__ `b\u_ b kf_leb\u_;hevr_ \k_]h
hj^Z kljZ^Z_l hl g_^hkuiZgby< k\hbojh^guo f_klZoex^b
kiZeb \hdjm] [hevrh]h dhkljZZ djhf_ lh]hm gbo[ueZ
kljZ`Zohly hkhagZeb hgb wlh lhevdhl_i_jvIh ghqZfbo
klhygdm l_kguf dhevphf hdjm`Zeb rZdZeudhlhju_ ke_^h\Zeb
aZ hj^hcih^[bjZy h[t_^dbEx^_c bbo gZahceb\uo kimlgbdh\
g_
k\yau\ZeZ
gbdZdZy
^jm`[Z<
rZdZeZiulZ\r_]hky
ih^h[jZlvky ih[eb`_ d dhkljme_l_eb dZfgbZ bgh]^Zb
klj_eZohly hohlgbdb ij_^ihqblZebg_ jZkoh^h\Zlv klj_eugZ
lZdbo fZehkt_^h[guoa\_j_c
<_^v ^Z`_ b \ gZrb
^gb m fgh]bo gZjh^h\
kh[ZdZ
kqblZ_lky
g_qbkluf
`b\hlguf
baaZ
k\hbo
ij_^dh\
fmkhjsbdh\L_f g_ f_g__rZdZeu ijbghkbeb i_j\h[ulgufex^yf
g_khfg_ggmx ihevamke_^my aZ gbfbhgb \dZdhclh f_j_
ba[Z\eyeb bo hl g_h[oh^bfhklb \uklZ\eylvqZkh\uolZd dZd
gZqbgZeb ly\dZlv b aZ\u\Zlv_^\Z g_ih^Ze_dm
ihy\eyeky
hiZkguc obsgbdEx^b_s_ g_mf_\rb_ fukeblvZ[kljZdlgh b
`b\msb_ lhevdh gZklhys_cfbgmlhcg_ aZf_qZeb ihfhsbk\h_c
q_l\_jhgh]hc k\bluGh k_cqZk hgbebrbebkv wlhcihfhsbb
ih ghqZf \hdjm] bo klhygdb \hpZjyeZkv lZdZy `mldZy
b
aeh\_sZy lbrbgZqlh ^Z`_ l_dlh g_^he`_g [ueklhjh`blv
khg hklZevguog_ j_rZebkv khfdgmlv ]eZa<hl ihq_fm\k_
hgb [ueb bklhfe_gub hkh[_ggh iyl_jh fm`qbgdhlhjuf
l_i_jvdh]^Z bo hklZehkv lZdfZehihklhyggh ijboh^behkv
i_j_gZijy]Zlv \gbfZgb_LZd qe_gu wlhc fZe_gvdhc
hj^u
mklZeu_bafmq_ggu_ bl_ehf b^mohfijh^he`Zeb ie_klbkv ih
kl_ib\a^jZ]b\Zy ijbdZ`^hf g_h`b^Zgghfrhjho_ bo\ZlZykv
aZ dhivy b emdbgh l_i_jv hgb \k_j_`_ jZajZ`Zebkv
ohohlhfdh]^Z
lj_\h]Z
hdZau\ZeZkv
eh`ghcGZqbgZeh
kf_jdZlvkyb \ gbo ijh[m`^Zeky m`Zk i_j_^ gZklmiZxs_c
ghqvxbfb \eZ^_elhl kljZoi_j_^ g_\_^hfufdhlhjuc ^Z\gh
ijhr_^rb_ wihob lZd kbevgh aZi_qZle_eky\ fha]mq_eh\_dZ
qlh ^Z`_ \gZrb ^gbghqgZy l_fghlZim]Z_l j_[_gdZZ ^ey
\ajhkeuo kem`bl kbf\hehf aeZWlh ^j_\gb_\hkihfbgZgby h
l_o
\j_f_gZodh]^Z
kbeu
fjZdZ\hiehs_ggu_
\
obsgbdZoex^h_^Zodb^Zebkv ba g_ijhgbpZ_fhc lvfugZ k\hx
^\mgh]mx ^h[uqm>ey gZrbo
i_j\h[ulguo ij_^dh\
ghqv
g_khfg_gghlZbeZ \k_[_ g_bkqbkebfu_m`Zku
Ex^b k[b\Zxlky \ l_kgmx dmqmgZqbgZxl h]ey^u\Zlvky\
ihbkdZo m^h[gh]h f_klZ ^ey ghqe_]Z ih^Zevr_ hl ]mklh]h
dmklZjgbdZ]jhays_]h \g_aZiguf gZiZ^_gb_fDh]^Z
lZdh_
f_klh [m^_l
gZc^_ghhgb
ihke_ ^ebl_evghc
b keh`ghc
ijhp_^mju ^h[u\Zgby h]gyjZah`]ml gZdhg_pdhkl_jih^`Zjyl
b jZa^_eyl kdm^gmx _^mK_]h^gy bfm^Zehkv jZa^h[ulvm`_
kbevgh ljhgmlu_hklZgdb \_ijyg_ ^h_^_ggu_kZ[e_am[uf
lb]jhfhl dhlhjuofm`qbgu g_[_a ljm^Zhlh]gZeb ]b_gh\uo
kh[ZdGZf wlb dhklb k ehofhlvyfb ]gbxs_]hfykZ \jy^eb
ihdZaZebkv [uZii_lblgufbgh qe_guhj^u ih]ey^u\ZxlgZ gbo
k ]heh^ghc `Z^ghklvxG_k_l ^h[uqmkZf ij_^\h^bl_evqlh[u
g_
ih^\_j]Zlv
kh[eZagm
[he__
[_ahl\_lkl\_gguo
k\hbo
kh[jZlv_\<g_aZigh
]jmiiZ
hklZgZ\eb\Z_lkylhqgh ih
dhfZg^_<k_
]heh\u
ih\hjZqb\Zxlkybih^h[gh
\klj_\h`_gguf he_gyfex^b khkj_^hlhqb\Zxl aj_gb_kemo b
h[hgygb_ gZh^ghf gZ lhfqlh gZklb]Z_lbo kaZ^bhllm^Z
hldm^Z hgb ijbrebHgb mkeurZeb a\mdkb]gZeih^Zgguc
`b\hlgufbGh hg\ hlebqb_hl [hevrbgkl\Zih^h[guo a\mdh\
dZd gb kljZgghg_ hagZqZ_l hiZkghklbohly ih^ZxllZdb_
kb]gZeu lhevdhij_ke_^h\Zl_ebZ `_jl\u^Z\gh m`_gZmqbebkv
ojZgblv ihegh_[_afhe\b_B wlhla\md gZihfbgZ_lkdblZevpZf
h[ bo jh^guof_klZoh ^gyodh]^Z bo ih^kl_j_]Zehf_gvr_
hiZkghkl_cdh]^Z hgb[ueb kqZkleb\u=^_lh ^Ze_dhihaZ^b
aZ\ue
rZdZeB
hj^Z
k
^_lkdhcihqlb h[_avygv_c
bfimevkb\ghklvx m`_ ]hlh\Zdbgmlvky h[jZlghlm^Zhldm^Z
^hghkblky \hcB lml fheh^hc ij_^\h^bl_evk \ukhdbfe[hf
kh\_jrZ_l aZf_qZl_evgucohly b g_ihgylguc ^eyhklZevguo
ihklmihdhg [jhkZ_lhklZgdb \_ijygZ a_fexb ijbgbfZ_lky
hl^bjZlv [hevrhcehkdml dh`b k[Zojhfdhc fykZ>_lbj_rb\
qlh k_cqZk
[m^ml jZkij_^_eylv
m`bgih^oh^yl
d g_fm
ih[eb`_gh hg hl]hgy_l bo k_j^bluf [mjqZgb_fdeZ^_l
hlhj\Zgguc dmkhd gZ a_fex\a\Zeb\Z_l \_ijy gZ ie_qbb
^_eZ_l agZd
hj^_ ijh^he`Zlv
imlv?^\Z
hgb ijhoh^yl
g_kdhevdh
rZ]h\dZd
fm`qbgZklhysbc
gZ ke_^mxs_c
b_jZjobq_kdhc klmi_gb hg ^Z`_ kbevg__ij_^\h^bl_eygh
^Ze_dh g_lZd khh[jZabl_e_gh[hjZqb\Z_lky bk \uau\Zxsbf
\b^hf mdZau\Z_l ]eZaZfbb ^\b`_gb_f]heh\u g_ jmdZfbdZd
k^_eZeb [u wlhfugZ [jhr_gguc ehkdmldh`bIj_^\h^bl_ev
ofmjblky
b
b^_l
^Zevr_<kdhj_
\lhjhc
fm`qbgZ
ih\hjZqb\Z_lky d hklZ\e_gghfm fykmIj_^\h^bl_ev
deZ^_l
k\hx ghrm[_`bl aZgbf b \lm k_dmg^mdh]^Z lhlih^ghkbl
lmoeh_ eZdhfkl\hdh jlmlhedZ_l _]hie_qhf lZdqlh hg qmlv
g_ iZ^Z_lHgb klhyl^jm] ijhlb\ ^jm]Zk m]jh`Zxsbf \b^hf
gZfhjsb\ e[u b hkdZeb\ am[ugh ihlhf \lhjhc
fm`qbgZ
himkdZ_l ]eZaZbqlhlh [hjfhqZ^h]hgy_l hj^m
B gbdlh ba gbo g_ khagZ_lqlh hgblhevdh qlh[ueb
k\b^_l_eyfb
kh[ulbydeZ^ms_]h
gZqZeh
gh\hc
wiho_
k\b^_l_eyfb
]_gbZevgh]h
ijhaj_gbybklhjbq_kdZy
jhev
dhlhjh]h
g_baf_jbfh
ij_\hkoh^bl
jZajmr_gb_
Ljhb
beb
bah[j_l_gb_ ihjhoZWlh g_ ihgbfZ_l ^Z`_kZf \ukhdheh[uc
ij_^\h^bl_evHg ihklmibelZd bfimevkb\ghg_ hl^Z\Zyk_[_
hlq_lZ \ lhfqlh bfjmdh\h^bl `_eZgb_ih^fZgblv rZdZeh\
aZklZ\blv boij_ke_^h\Zlv aZ hj^hcHg bgklbgdlb\ghb \_jgh
jZkkqblZeqlh \_l_jdhlhjuc ^m_l bfgZ\klj_qm^hg_k_l
aZiZo fykZ^h gha^j_c \hxsborZdZeh\Hj^Z ijh^he`Z_l b^lb
gh ihij_`g_fm gb]^_ g_ \b^gh ^hklZlhqghhldjulh]h f_klZ
^ey
[_ahiZkgh]h
ghqe_]Zb
g_kdhevdh
fbgml
kimkly
ij_^\h^bl_ev ih\lhjy_l k\hckljZgguc ihklmihdZ hklZevgu_
fm`qbgu k_j^blh \hjqZlijhl_klmyDh]^Z `_ hghlju\Z_l
lj_lbc ehkdml dh`bhgb ihqlb \uoh^yl baih\bgh\_gbyb
ij_^\h^bl_ex m^Z_lkygZklhylv gZk\h_f lhevdhihke_ [_r_gghc
\kiurdb i_j\h[ulghc yjhklbGh \kdhj_ aZjhkeb j_^_xl b
gZqbgZ_lky hldjulZy kl_ivIj_^\h^bl_ev k[jZku\Z_lhklZgdb
\_ijy gZ a_fexd gbf ih^oh^yl
hklZevgu_ fm`qbgu
b
gZqbgZxl\hjqZ b m]jh`Zy ^jm] ^jm]m^_eblv ZjhfZlguc
^_ebdZl_k gZdmqdbZ `_gsbgub ^_lbl_f \j_f_g_f kh[bjZxl
lhieb\h ^eydhkljZdhlhjuc ^he`_g]hj_lv \kxghqv
<_l_j klboZ_lb \ gZklmib\r_f [_afhe\bbqmldbo kemo
i_j\h[ulguo ex^_c meZ\eb\Z_lhq_gv ^Ze_db_a\mdb<g_aZigh
ij_^\h^bl_ev ih^Z_l g_]jhfdbc
kb]gZe \k_
aZfhedZxl
gZklhjZ`b\Zxlky b aZklu\Zxl \ g_ih^\b`ghklb>h gbo\gh\v
^hghkblky \hcgh [he__ ]jhfdbcq_f jZgvr_rZdZeu gZreb
i_j\uc ehkdmldh`bbkm^y ih juqZgbxb \ba]mf_`^m gbfb
aZ\yau\Z_lky ^jZdZIj_^\h^bl_ev meu[Z_lky b ^_eZ_lagZd
hklZevguf ijh^he`ZlvjZ[hlmG_dhlhjh_ \j_fykimkly juqZgb_
b s_edZgv_ am[h\
jZa^Zxlky _s_ [eb`_B \gh\v
ex^b
\gbfZl_evgh
ijbkemrb\Zxlky<g_aZigh
fm`qbgZdhlhjuc
i_j\uf ohl_e\_jgmlvky dhklZ\e_gghfm fykmh[hjZqb\Z_lky b
gZijy`_ggh
\]ey^u\Z_lky
\
ebph
ij_^\h^bl_eyLhl k
m^h\e_l\hj_gghc mofuedhc kemrZ_ljuqZgb_ ^_jmsbokyrZdZeh\
L_i_jvgZdhg_p\lhjhc fm`qbgZ ihgbfZ_l _]h gZf_j_gb_
Ko\Zlb\ iZjm ihqlb^hqbklZ h[]eh^Zgguoj_[_jhg kmeu[dhc
ih^oh^bl d\h`ZdmlhedZ_l _]hehdl_fba^Z_l eZxsb_ a\mdb
ih^jZ`Zy rZdZeZfZ aZl_f b^_lk dhklyfb\ lhfgZijZ\e_gbb
hldm^Z hgb lhevdhqlh ijbreb< rZ]Zoljb^pZlb hlklhygdb
hg gZ]b[Z_lkydeZ^_l dhklb gZa_fexihlhf \uijyfey_lkyb
\hijhkbl_evgh kfhljbl gZij_^\h^bl_eydhlhjuc k bgl_j_khf
ke_^bl aZ _]h ^_ckl\byfbHgb mofueyxlky ^jm] ^jm]m b
g_h`b^Zggh jZajZ`Zxlky ]jhfdbf [_aaZ[hlguf ohohlhflhqgh
^\h_ kh\j_f_gguofZevqbr_d ihke_m^Zqghc rZehklb
M`_ gZklmibeZ
l_fghlZgZ
klhygd_ iueZ_l
dhkl_j
Ij_^\h^bl_ev kgh\Z ^_eZ_l hklZevguf agZd aZfheqZlvBa
fjZdZ ^hghkblky ojmkl
jZa]juaZ_fuo dhkl_cb
\g_aZigh
hl[e_kd dhkljZ hk\_sZ_l rZdZeZmih_ggh ih`bjZxs_]hk\hx
^hex m`bgZRZdZe ih^gbfZ_l ]heh\mb hiZkeb\hih]ey^u\Z_l
gZ gbogh \k_ kb^yl g_ih^\b`ghb hg\gh\v ijbgbfZ_lky
]jualvZ
hgb ijh^he`Zxl
lbohgvdh gZ[ex^Zlv
aZ gbf
Ihbklbg_ wihoZevgh_ kh[ulb_ \i_j\u_ q_eh\_d
ihdhjfbe
ihe_agh_ `b\hlgh_B dh]^Z ex^bmdeZ^u\Zxlky kiZlvbo \k_o
ho\Zlu\Z_l lZdh_ hsms_gb_ [_ahiZkghklbdZdh]h hgb^Z\gh
m`_ g_bkiulu\Zeb
Ijhoh^yl
\_dZKf_gy_lky
fgh]h
ihdhe_gbcRZdZeu
klZgh\ylky \k_ [he__ jmqgufb b kf_eufbHgb kh[bjZxlky
\hdjm]
klhc[bs
[hevrbfb
klZyfbEx^b
l_f
\j_f_g_f
gZmqbebkv hohlblvky gZ ^bdbo ehrZ^_c b he_g_cZ rZdZeu
baf_gbeb g_dhlhju_ k\hb ijb\uqdb?keb ij_`^_ hgb ^g_f
ijylZebkv blhevdh k l_fghlhcjbkdh\Zeb \uoh^blvba ]mklh]h
dmklZjgbdZlh
l_i_jv kZfu_
mfgu_ b
kf_eu_ ba
gbo
ij_\jZsZxlky \ ^g_\guo`b\hlguo bke_^mxl aZex^vfbdh]^Z
l_ hlijZ\eyxlky gZhohlmB \iheg_ \hafh`ghqlh h^gZ`^u
dh]^Z hohlgbdb ]gZebkv aZ `_j_[hc dh[uehcdhlhjmx hgb
jZgbeb dhiv_fijhbahreh qlhgb[m^v \jh^_gb`_ke_^mxs_]h
Ex^b jZ^hklgh \ha[m`^_gulZd
dZd m`_ ^h\hevgh
^he]h
]heh^Zebb rZdZeudhlhjuf \k_wlh \j_fyhl gbogbq_]h beb ihqlbgbq_]h g_ i_j_iZ^Zehkhijh\h`^Zxl bok hkh[uf
mk_j^b_fHkeZ[_\rZy hl ihl_jb djh\b dh[ueZ ijb[_]Z_ld
h[uqghc obljhklb aZljZ\e_gghc ^bqb b kdjZ^u\Z_lke_^lh
_klv \ha\jZsZ_lky gZ dZdh_lh jZkklhygb_ gZaZ^Z aZl_f
kdju\Z_lky \ dmklZjgbd_jZkiheh`_gghf \ klhjhg_ hl __
ij_`g_]h ke_^ZWlhl ijb_f qZklh kiZkZeihqlb h[j_q_ggmx
`_jl\m^Z b l_i_jv hohlgbdb\ g_^hmf_gb_hklZgZ\eb\Zxlky
lZf]^_ ke_^u\g_aZigh h[ju\Zxlky
RZdZeu khijh\h`^Zxl ex^_c gZ ihqlbl_evghfjZkklhygbb
\k_ _s_ hiZkZykvijb[ebablvky drmfguf hohlgbdZfB^ml hgb
ih ke_^m ex^_cZ g_ dh[ueuihkdhevdm bfg_l gbdZdh]h
kfukeu ]gZlvky aZ lZdhc djmighc ^bqvx \_^v hgbkZfb
kijZ\blky k g_c g_ fh]mlH^gZdh mwlbo rZdZeh\g_j_^dh
ihemqZ\rbo hlex^_c dmkhqdb^h[uqb\ujZ[Zlu\Zehkv daZiZom
fykZ hkh[h_ hlghr_gb_b \lh `_\j_fy lZdhc\hl djh\Z\uc
ke_^ ihkl_i_ggh klZe k\yau\Zlvky \ bo fha]m k [ebadhc
dhjf_`dhcK_]h^gy h]heh^Z\rb_ rZdZeuhkh[_ggh \ha[m`^_gu
aZiZohf djh\bb \hl ijhbkoh^bl g_qlhdeZ^ms__ gZqZeh
gh\uf hlghr_gbyf f_`^m q_eh\_dhf b _]h rZdZev_ck\blhc
\_^msZy klZx klZjZykZfdZ kihk_^_ehc fhj^hcaZf_qZ_l lh
q_]h g_ aZf_lbeb ex^bjZa\_l\e_gb_ djh\Z\h]h ke_^Z
RZdZeu k\hjZqb\Zxlb b^mlih ke_^m kZfhklhyl_evghhohlgbdb
khh[jZab\ gZdhg_pqlh
ijhbahrehlZd `_
\ha\jZsZxlky
gZaZ^M lh]hf_klZ]^_ ke_^jZa^\Zb\Z_lkyhgb keurZl\
klhjhg_ aZ\u\Zgb_ rZdZeh\ki_rZl gZa\md b\b^yl djh\Z\u_
iylgZ lZf]^_ rZdZevy klZymlhilZeZ ljZ\mB lml\i_j\u_
kdeZ^u\Z_lky [m^ms_c ihjy^hd ij_ke_^h\Zgby ^bqb\i_j_^b
kh[ZdaZ g_c q_eh\_dRZdZeu [uklj__ ex^_c
gZklb]Zxl
`_jl\m b\ugm`^Zxl __hklZgh\blky
Dh]^Z kh[Zdb aZ]hgyxl djmigmx ^bqv\ ^_eh\klmiZ_l
hkh[uc
ikboheh]bq_kdbc
f_oZgbafaZljZ\e_gguc
he_gv
f_^\_^v beb dZ[Zg[_]msbc hlq_eh\_dZgh ]hlh\uc^jZlvky
k kh[ZdZfbijboh^bl \ yjhklvbaaZ gZahceb\hklbwlbo [he__
keZ[uo ij_ke_^h\Zl_e_c b
aZ[u\Z_l ijh ]eZ\gh]h
\jZ]Z
MklZeZy dh[ueZdhlhjZy \b^bl
\ rZdZeZo
lhevdh klZx
ly\dZxsbo ljmkh\ijbgbfZ_l h[hjhgbl_evgmx ihamb yjhklgh
[v_l i_j_^gbf dhiulhf lh]h ba gbodlh jbkdgmeih^hclb
kebrdhf [ebadhLy`_eh ^urZdh[ueZ hibku\Z_l djm]\f_klh
lh]h qlh[u [_`Zlv^Zevr_L_f \j_f_g_f
hohlgbdbdhlhju_
keurZlqlh rZdZeu l_i_jv khkj_^hlhqbebkv \h^ghf f_kl_
\kdhj_ ^h[bjZxlky lm^Z b [_krmfghhdjm`Zxl ^h[uqmRZdZeu
[ukljh hl[_]Zxlgh lZd dZd bf gbdlh g_ m]jh`Z_lhgb
hklZxlkyBo
ij_^\h^bl_evgbpZm`_
gbq_]h g_
[hykv
db^Z_lky gZ dh[uem k yjhklguf eZ_fZ dh]^Z lZiZ^Z_l
ihjZ`_ggZy dhiv_fk\bj_ih \p_iey_lky
_c \
]hjeh
b
hl[_]Z_llhevdh dh]^Z d lmr_ ih^oh^bl \h`^vhohlgbdh\
Wlhl q_eh\_d\hafh`ghijZijZ\gmd lh]hdlh i_j\uf [jhkbe
rZdZeZf dmkhd fykZjZkiZju\Z_l [jxoh dh[ueub \uju\Z_l
dbrdbG_
]ey^y
gZ
rZdZeh\
wlh
ih^kdZau\Z_l _fm
bglmblb\guc lZdlhg [jhkZ_l dbrdbg_ ijyfhbfZ qmlv\
klhjhgmK_^Zy kZfdZ bkim]ZggZ iylblkyghaZf_lb\qlh
q_eh\_d g_ ^_eZ_l gbdZdbo m]jh`Zxsbo `_klh\Z
lhevdh
ba^Z_l
^jm`_ex[gu_
a\mdb\jh^_
l_odhlhju_ qZklh
^hghkbebkv ^h bo mr_c hl dhkljZ\p_iey_lky \
l_ieu_
\gmlj_gghklbAZ`Z\ bo \ am[Zo b lhjhieb\h ijh]eZlu\Zy
dmkhqdbhgZ gZklhjh`_ggh h]ey^u\Z_lky gZ q_eh\_dZZ __
o\hkl \^jm] gZqbgZ_l ^\b]Zlvky
ba klhjhgu \
klhjhgm
<i_j\u_ rZdZe aZ\beye o\hklhf ijb \b^_ q_eh\_dZ_s_ gZ
h^bg rZ] ijb[ebab\aZdexq_gb_ \_qghc^jm`[u f_`^mex^vfb b
kh[ZdZfb>Z`_ lZdb_ mfgu_`b\hlgu_dZd obsgbdb k_f_ckl\Z
kh[Zqvbog_ kjZamh[j_lZxl Z[khexlghgh\uc lbiih\_^_gby
dZdbf [u [eZ]hl\hjguf gb
[ue i_j\uc hiul>ey
wlh]h
lj_[m_lkyqlh[u
\
ikbobd_
`b\hlgh]h
h[jZah\Zebkv
hij_^_e_ggu_ k\yab \ j_amevlZl_ fgh]hdjZlgh]h ih\lhj_gby
h^ghc b lhc `_
kblmZpbb<hafh`ghijhreh
g_kdhevdh
f_kyp_\ij_`^_ q_fwlZ klZjZykZfdZ kgh\Zih[_`ZeZ \i_j_^b
hohlgbdZ aZ `b\hlgufijheh`b\rbf eh`gucke_^B ih`Zemc
lhevdh
__
hl^Ze_gguc
ihlhfhd
gZmqbeky
ihklhyggh
b
p_e_mklj_fe_ggh \_klb aZ kh[hc hohlgbdh\ d aZljZ\e_gghc
^h[uq_
< jZgg_f g_hebl_ q_eh\_dih\b^bfhfmi_j_oh^bl
d
hk_^ehfm
h[jZam
`bagbI_j\u_
ba\_klgu_
gZf `bebsZ
\ha^\b]Zebkv gZ k\Zyo hgb ijbgZ^e_`Zeb ex^yfdhlhju_
jZ^b [_ahiZkghklb kljhbeb bo gZ hlf_eyoha_jj_d b^Z`_
;Zelbckdh]h fhjyFu agZ_fqlh d wlhfm\j_f_gb kh[ZdZ m`_
ij_\jZlbeZkv \^hfZrg__ `b\hlgh_Q_j_iZ g_[hevrhcihoh`_c
gZ
ribpZ
lhjnyghc
kh[Zdb\i_j\u_
h[gZjm`_ggu_ ijb
jZkdhidZo k\Zcguoihk_e_gbc m[Zelbckdh]h ih[_j_`vyohly b
g_hijh\_j`bfh k\b^_l_evkl\mxlh __ijhbkoh`^_gbb hl rZdZeZ
l_f g_f_g__ ihdZau\ZxlijbagZdb h^hfZrgb\Zgby
H^gZdh \Z`gh \hl qlhohly \ lm wihom rZdZeu[ueb
jZkijhkljZg_gu ]hjZa^h [he__ rbjhdhq_f \ gZrb^gbih
[_j_]Zf
;Zelbckdh]h
fhjy
hgb
lh]^Z
g_
\h^bebkv
Ke_^h\Zl_evghfh`gh ij_^iheh`blvqlh q_eh\_dijh^\b]Zykv
gZ
k_\_j
b
aZiZ^ijb\_e
k
kh[hc
b kh[Zdbeb
ihemijbjmq_gguo rZdZeh\dhlhju_ ke_^h\Zeb aZ gbf \_]h
kljZgkl\byoDh]^Z `_ hggZqZe kljhblv `bebsZgZ k\Zyo gZ^
\h^hc b
bah[j_e ibjh]m
^\Z gh\h\\_^_gbyg_khfg_ggh
agZf_gh\Z\rb_
agZqbl_evguc
dmevlmjguc
ijh]j_kk_]h
\aZbfhhlghr_gby k q_l\_jhgh]bfbkimlgbdZfb g_fbgm_fh^he`gu
[ueb ij_l_ji_lv
dZj^bgZevgu_ baf_g_gby<h^Z m`_
g_
iha\heyeZ rZdZeZf `blv\hdjm] _]hklhc[bsZdZd ij_`^_G_
fh]eb hgb bhojZgylv `bebsZk\hbo ohay_\hl ^jm]boex^_c
gZiZ^Z\rbo k \h^uIj_^klZ\ey_lky eh]bqgufqlh q_eh\_d
dh]^Z hg
\i_j\u_ kf_gbe
ij_`g__ klhc[bs_
gZ k\Zcguc
ihk_ehdaZo\Zlbe k kh[hc b g_kdhevdh gZb[he__
jmqguo
rZdZeh\ l_ogZijbf_jdhlhju_ hkh[_ggh hlebqZebkvgZ
hohl_ b
[ueb ihdeZ^bkl__
[hevrbgkl\Z k\hbo
ihem^bdbo
kh[jZlv_\b lZdbf h[jZahfkha^Ze bagbo ^hfZrgbokh[Zd
\ [md\Zevghfkfuke_ keh\Z
>Z`_ \gZrb ^gb jZagu_gZjh^u kh^_j`Zlkh[Zd ihjZaghfm
\iehlv ^hkZfh]h ijbfblb\gh]hkihkh[Zdh]^Z kh[Zdb `b\ml
klZyfb \hdjm] k_e_gby b bo k\yav k ex^vfbghkbl \_kvfZ
g_ijhqguc oZjZdl_j>jm]hc lbi kh^_j`Zgbykh[Zd fugZoh^bf
\ ex[hc _\jhi_ckdhc^_j_\g_]^_ g_kdhevdh kh[Zdk\yaZgu k
h^gbf ^hfhc b
ijbgZ^e_`Zl h^ghfm dhgdj_lghfm
ohaybgm
<iheg_ \_jhylghqlh lZdhc lbi\aZbfhhlghr_gbc \ujZ[hlZeky
\ ijhp_kk_ jZa\blby k\Zcguo ihk_e_gbcFgh]h kh[Zd lZf
^_j`Zlv [ueh g_evayb
wlh_kl_kl\_ggh^he`gh
[ueh
ijb\_klb d
bg[jb^bg]m kdj_sb\Zgb_
f_`^m kh[hc
^\mo
[ebadhjh^kl\_gguo
hj]Zgbafh\Ihklhyggh
ijbf_gy_lky
k_e_dpbhg_jZfbijZdlbdZfb
^ey
memqr_gby
ebgbc
k_evkdhohayckl\_gguo `b\hlguo b jZkl_gbcqlh\
k\hx
hq_j_^vkihkh[kl\h\Zeh
i_j_^Zq_
ih
gZke_^kl\m
q_jl
ih^ebggh]h h^hfZrgb\Zgby>\Z nZdlZ
k\b^_l_evkl\mxl
\
ihevam wlh]h ij_^iheh`_gby\hi_j\uolhjnygZy
kh[ZdZ
h[eZ^Z\rZy [he__ dhjhldhcfhj^hc b[he__ \uimdeufq_j_ihf
g_khfg_gghij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc h^hfZrg_ggmx jZagh\b^ghklv
rZdZeZZ
\h\lhjuodhklb
wlbo
`b\hlguo m^Z\Zehkv
hlukdZlv
ihqlb
bkdexqbl_evgh
kj_^b
hklZldh\
k\Zcguo
ihk_e_gbc
Wlb kh[Zdb^he`gh [ulvm`_ [ueb gZklhevdhijbjmq_gu
qlh \oh^beb\ ibjh]mb kihdhcgh kb^_eb\ g_cihdZ hohlgbd
]j_[ d[_j_]mZ ih\ha\jZs_gbb ^hfhc\a[bjZebkv gZihfhkl
Ihemijbjmq_ggZy kh[ZdZiZjby gbaZ qlhg_ k^_eZ_lwlh]hb
^Z`_ \ujhkrb_m f_gy\ ^hf_ s_gdbkh]eZrZxlky \ i_j\ucjZa
kimklblvky \ fhx eh^dm beb \hclb\ `_e_agh^hjh`guc\Z]hg
lhevdh ihke_fhbo ^he]bob l_ji_eb\uom\_s_\Zgbc
<hafh`ghijbjmq_gb_ kh[Zdb m`_ aZ\_jrbehkv d
lhfm
fhf_glmdh]^Z ex^b gZqZeb\ha\h^blv k\Zcgu_ ihkljhcdbbeb
`_ hgh ijhbkoh^beh iZjZee_evgh k wlbf ijhp_kkhf<iheg_
\_jhylghqlh dZdZylh `_gsbgZZ lh bfZe_gvdZy ^_\hqdZ
b]jZy \ ^hqdbfZl_jbih^h[jZeZ hkbjhl_\r_]h s_gdZ
b
\ujZklbeZ _]h\ k\h_f^hf_;ulv fh`_ljh^bl_e_cZ lZd`_
[jZlv_\ b k_kl_j wlh]h s_gdZ kh`jZekZ[e_am[uc lb]jlZd
qlh \ `b\uo hklZeky hg h^bg;_^gy`dZgZ\_jghkdmebe b
ieZdZegh gbdlh g_ h[jZsZe gZ g_]h\gbfZgby \ l_^gb
qm\kl\bl_evghklv [ueZex^yf g_k\hckl\_ggZ
g
Gh \hl fm`qbgu mieueb gZ hohlmZ `_gsbguaZgyebkv
ju[ghc eh\e_cb ihq_fm
[u gZf
g_ \hh[jZablvqlh
fZe_gvdZy ^_\hqdZ h[blZl_e_c ha_jghc ob`bgu
hlijZ\beZkv
lm^Zhldm^Z ^hghkbehkv `Zeh[gh_ ih\ba]b\Zgb_b \dhgp_
dhgph\ h[gZjm`beZ \ a_feyghc i_s_jd_ djhohlgh]h
s_gdZ
dhlhjuc [_kkljZrgh aZdh\ueye d g_c gZ\klj_qm bijbgyeky
ebaZlv __
ijhlygmlu_ jmdbFy]dh_djm]eh_imrbklh_
kms_kl\h[_a khfg_gbyijh[m^beh \wlhc fZe_gvdhc^_\hqd_
dZf_ggh]h \_dZ
lZdh_`_ klj_fe_gb_ lZkdZlv_]h gZ jmdZob
gygqblvdZdh_ fu gZ[ex^Z_f m fZe_gvdbo ^_\hq_d
gZr_c
kh[kl\_gghc wihobb[h ihjh`^Zxsbc_]h bgklbgdl fZl_jbgkl\Z
g_ f_g__^j_\_gq_f kZfq_eh\_dB \hl^_\qmrdZ dZf_ggh]h
\_dZih^jZ`Zy \ajhkeuf `_gsbgZf^ZeZ s_gdm ih_klv b
ke_^y aZl_fk dZdhc`Z^ghklvx hggZ[jhkbeky gZ m]hs_gb_
bkiulZeZ g_ f_gvrmx jZ^hklvq_f bkiulu\Z_loe_[hkhevgZy
ohaycdZ
gZrbo
^g_cdh]^Z
]hklv
hl^Z_l
^he`gh_
dZdhfmgb[m^v bkdmkgh
ijb]hlh\e_gghfm [ex^m<_jgm\rbkv
^hfhcjh^bl_eb ^_\hqdbk m^b\e_gb_b [_ahkh[h]h \hklhj]Z
h[gZjm`b\Zxl lZf
khggh]h h[t_\r_]hky
rZdZe_gdZHl_p
dhg_qghgZf_j_\Z_lky lml `_ _]h mlhiblvgh ^_\hqdZkh
ke_aZfb \p_iey_lky\ dhe_gbhlpZlZd qlhhg kihludZ_lky b
jhgy_l s_gdZ: dh]^Z hg \uijyfey_lky bohq_l hiylv_]h
ko\Zlblvlh h[gZjm`b\Z_lqlh ^hqdZ aZ[beZkv \
kZfuc
^Zevgbc m]hebh[eb\Zykv ke_aZfbijb`bfZ_l s_gdZd ]jm^b
Jh^bl_evkdh_ k_j^p_ ^Z`_\ dZf_gghf\_d_ \k_lZdb g_fh]eh
[ulv gZklhevdh m` dZf_ggufb s_gdmjZaj_rZxl hklZlvky\
^hf_;eZ]h^Zjy kulghfmb h[bevghfmdhjfm hg[ukljh jZkl_l
klZgh\ykv [hevrbf b kbevgufLml _]h iuedZy ex[h\v
d
^_\hqd_ gZqbgZ_lij_l_ji_\Zlv baf_g_gbyb ohly hl_p]eZ\Z
k_f_ckl\Zg_ h[jZsZ_l gZ kh[Zdm\gbfZgbyhgZ ihkl_i_ggh
hl^Z_l k\hx ijb\yaZgghklv m`_ g_ j_[_gdmZ \ajhkehfm
>jm]bfb keh\ZfbgZklmiZ_l fhf_gldh]^Z s_ghd[m^v hggZ
\he_mr_e [uhl fZl_jb
>h kbo ihj \ `bagb gZr_]h s_gdZ^_\hqdZ b]jZeZjhev
fZl_jbgh l_i_jvhl_p aZgbfZ_l^ey g_]hf_klh \h`ZdZklZb
dhlhjhfm jy^h\hc qe_g klZb h[yaZg g_ihdhe_[bfh kem`blv
<gZqZe_ fm`qbg_ wlZijb\yaZgghklv lhevdh^hkZ`^Z_lh^gZdh
\kdhj_ hg hkhagZ_lqlh gZhohl_ lZdZyijbjmq_ggZy kh[ZdZ
[m^_l
]hjZa^h
ihe_ag__
ihem^bdbo
rZdZeh\dhlhju_
^_j`Zlvky gZ [_j_]m \hae_ ihk_edZghihij_`g_fm [hykv
q_eh\_dZg_j_^dh m[_]Zxl bf_ggh \ lhl fhf_gldh]^Z bf
ke_^h\Zeh [u aZ^_j`Zlv aZljZ\e_ggmx ^bqv>Z b d ^bqb
ijbjmq_ggZy kh[ZdZhlghkblky dm^Z[_kkljZrg__q_f __^bdb_
kh[jZlvylZd
dZd
__
xghklv
ijhreZ \ [_ahiZkghklb
q_eh\_q_kdh]h `bevy b_c g_ijbrehkv gZhiul_ ihagZdhfblky
k deudZfbb dh]lyfb djmiguoobsgbdh\<hl lZd kh[ZdZ\kdhj_
klZgh\blky
ihklhygguf
kimlgbdhf
fm`qbgud
g_fZehfm
h]hjq_gbx ^_\hqdbdhlhjZy \b^bl l_i_jv k\h_]h
[u\r_]h
iblhfpZlhevdh dh]^Z __ hl_p \ha\jZsZ_lky ^hfhcZ \
dZf_gghf \_d_hlpu hlemqZebkvba ^hfmhq_gv gZ^he]h
H^gZdh \_kghc\ lm ihjmdh]^Z rZdZeus_gylkyhl_p
dZdlh \_q_jhf \oh^bl \ ^hflZsZ gZ ie_q_ f_rhd
ba
g_\u^_eZgghc
rdmju\
dhlhjhf
dlhdlh
dhihrblky
b
ih\ba]b\Z_lHg jZkdju\Z_l f_rhdb ^_\hqdZih^iju]b\Z_l
hl jZ^hklbihlhfm qlh gZihe \udZlu\Zxlkyq_luj_ f_oh\uo
rZjbdZLhevdh fZlv
g_^h\hevgh fhjsblkykqblZyqlh
o\Zlbeh [ub ^\mo
>_ckl\bl_evgh eb wlhkemqbehkv bf_gghlZd"GmgZk lZf
g_ [uehh^gZdh_keb bkoh^blvba \k_]hqlh gZf ba\_klgh
fu fh`_fkihdhcgh ijbgylvb ih^h[gmx \_jkbx< lh `_\j_fy
g_evay aZdju\Zlv ]eZaZ gZ lhl nZdlqlh fu g_ agZ_f
^_ckl\bl_evgh eb lhevdh h[udgh\_gguc rZdZe &DQLVDXUHXV
k\yaZe ih^h[guf h[jZahf k\hx km^v[m kq_eh\_dhf<_kvfZ
\_jhylghqlh
\
jZaebqguo
h[eZklyo
a_fgh]h
rZjZ
ijbjmqZebkvZ \ihke_^kl\bb kdj_sb\Zebkv jZaebqgu_
\b^u
rZdZeZ [he__ djmigu_ b [he__ koh^gu_ k \hedhf<_^v
fgh]b_ ^hfZrgb_ `b\hlgu_ bf_xl g_ h^gh]hZ g_kdhevdbo
^bdbo ij_^dh\< ihevamwlh]h ij_^iheh`_gby k\b^_l_evkl\m_l
lh h[klhyl_evkl\Zqlh kh[ZdbiZjbb gb]^_ b gbdh]^Z g_
h[sZxlky k rZdZeZfb b g_ kdj_sb\Zxlky k gbfb=hkih^bg
R_[[_j ex[_agh h[jZlbe fh_ \gbfZgb_ gZ lhlnZdlqlh gZ
;eb`g_f <hklhd_ fgh]b_ f_klghklb bah[bemxl dZdh^bqZeufb
kh[ZdZfblZd b rZdZeZfbh^gZdh kf_r_gby f_`^mgbfb g_
gZ[ex^Z_lky gbdZdh]hGh\h \kydhf kemqZ_fu
l\_j^h
agZ_fqlh
lmg^jh\uc \hed
\h\k_ g_
y\ey_lky ij_^dhf
[hevrbgkl\Z gZrbo ^hfZrgbo kh[ZddZd kqblZehkv ij_`^_
Ebrv g_kdhevdh kh[Zqvbo ihjh^ \_^mlk\h_ ijhbkoh`^_gb_hl
\hedh\ b lh \ g_ qbklhf \b^_b bohkh[_gghklb kem`Zl
ebrgbf ^hdZaZl_evkl\hf lh]hqlh hgb ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc
bkdexq_gb_ ba h[s_]h ijZ\beZWlb ihjh^uh[eZ^Zxsb_ g_
lhevdh \g_rgbf koh^kl\hf k \hedhfwkdbfhkkdZy kh[ZdZ
_a^h\u_ eZcdbqZmqZm b _s_ g_dhlhju_ keh`bebkv gZ
DjZcg_f K_\_j_Qbklhc \heqv_cdjh\vx g_ fh`_liho\ZklZlvky
gb
h^gZ
ba
gbo<iheg_
ijZ\^hih^h[guf
y\ey_lky
ij_^iheh`_gb_qlh q_eh\_dijh^\b]Zykv \k_^Zevr_ b^Zevr_
gZ k_\_j\_e k kh[hc m`_ h^hfZrg_gguokh[Zd krZdZev_c
djh\vxdhlhju_ ihke_ g_h^ghdjZlguo kdj_sb\Zgbck \hedZfb
b
ihlhfdZfb
\hedh\
\
dhgp_
dhgph\
klZeb ij_^dZfb
\ur_i_j_qbke_gguo
ihjh^H[
hkh[_gghklyo
ikbobq_kdh]h
kdeZ^Z kh[Zdk \heqv_cdjh\vx y_s_ [m^m]h\hjblv
< hlebqb_hl kh[Zdb dhrdZkh\k_f g_^Z\ghklZeZ ^hfZrgbf
`b\hlguf^Z b lh ebrv gZklhevdhgZkdhevdh hgZ\hh[s_
kihkh[gZ d
h^hfZrgb\ZgbxG_^Z\ghdhg_qghebrv
ih
kjZ\g_gbx k kh[Zdhcbklhjby dhlhjhcih fg_gbxagZxsbo
ex^_cgZkqblu\Z_l khjhdr_klv^_kyl lukyqe_lY ^mfZxqlh
q_eh\_d \i_j\u_ ihdhjfbe rZdZeZ ijbf_jgh iylv^_kyllukyq
e_l gZaZ^Z \i_j\u_ ihk_ebe_]h mk_[y \ha_jghf `bebs_
ijb[ebabl_evgh aZ^\Z^pZlv lukyqe_l ^h gZqZeZbklhjbq_kdhc
wjuJy^hf k lZdbfb pbnjZfb khxadhrdb kq_eh\_dhf fh`gh
kqblZlv kh[ulb_f \q_jZrg_]h^gyL_ `_ kZfu_ex^bdhlhju_
\ ke_^mxs_f lukyq_e_lbb ihkljhbeb ibjZfb^m O_hikZm`_
kha^Zeb [he__ \ukhdmxnhjfm dmevlmjudhjh\uh\puehrZ^b
[ueb m gbo lZdbfb `_ ^hfZrgbfb `b\hlgufbdZdbfb fubo
agZ_f k_cqZkq_eh\_d `be \ dZf_gguo^hfZo bh[jZ[Zlu\Ze
k\hb iheyaZijy]Ze \iem] \heh\bgZq_ ]h\hjyjZaebqby
f_`^m l_f \j_f_g_f b gZrbf g_ lZd m` \_ebdb<_kvfZ
\_jhylghqlh bf_ggh \ ?]bil_i_j\hc \bklhjbb Z]jZjghc
kljZg_dhrdb bijbkh_^bgbeZkv dq_eh\_dm \_^v h]jhfgu_
oe_[gu_ `blgbpu?]bilZ mihfbgZxlky _s_\ ;b[ebb: ]^__klv
[hevrb_ a_jghojZgbebsZlZd
\k_]^Z aZ\h^blky
fgh`_kl\h
fur_c b djukb _keb
\ <_lohf aZ\_l_ kj_^b
dZag_c
_]bi_lkdbofurb g_ mihfygmlulhgZ\_jgh_ebrv ihlhfm
qlh bo b lZd m`_ [ueh qj_a\uqZcghfgh]h bm\_ebq_gb_ bo
qbkeZ g_fh]eh ijhba\_klbaZf_lgh]h \i_qZle_gby
>j_\gb_ _]bilyg_ mf_eb \gbfZl_evgh gZ[ex^Zlv blhgdh
qm\kl\h\Zlv
ijbjh^mh
q_f
k\b^_l_evkl\mxl
ohly [u
m^b\bl_evgu_ jbkmgdb `b\hlguokhojZgb\rb_ky gZ
kl_gZo
]jh[gbp b ojZfh\bdhg_qghhgb kh\_jr_gghlhqgh agZeb
dZdb_ ba f_klguof_edbo obsgbdh\hiZkgu ^eyfur_c bdjuk
=_jh^hl khh[sZ_lqlh bog_\fhgdhlhjh]h gZau\Zeb lZd`_
nZjZhgh\hc furvx[ue k\ys_gguf `b\hlgufZ \]jh[gbpZo
Kj_^g_]h pZjkl\Z h[gZjm`_gh fgh]h lsZl_evghba]hlh\e_gguo
fmfbc kl_ighc dhrdb )HOLVRFUHDWDmjh`_gdb :njbdb b
Kbjbb^bdh]h
ij_^dZ
gZr_c
^hfZrg_c
dhrdbH^gZdh
bkke_^h\Zgby ihdZaZebqlh dhrdZ ihqblZeZkv g_ kZfZ ih
k_[_gh dZd kbf\heev\bpu`b\hlgh]h wlhc[h]bgbqlh ^ey
k\hbo
[h]hkem`_gbc
hgb
ba[jZeb
`b\hlgh_
ihf_gvr_ b
ihihdeZ^bkl_c ev\bpuohly [u
^Z`_ b
kh\k_f jmqghc
<hafh`ghdZdZygb[m^v ev\bpZ hkjZfbeZkv kZfufg_ijbylguf
h[jZahfkdmrZ\ \h \j_fy [h]hkem`_gby hkh[_ggh^hjh^gh]h
`j_pZ [h]bgb ;ZklGh_keb ]h\hjblvk_jv_aghfg_ hq_gv
ijbylgh ij_^klZ\e_gb_ h dhrd_ dZd h kbf\he_ev\ZdZd h
fbgbZlxjghc dhibb pZjya\_j_cDhrdZ gjZ\blky fg_ bf_ggh
ihlhfmqlh hgZijbghkbl \fhc ^hfg_mdjhs_ggmx ^bdhklvb
]b[dh_ bays_kl\hdhlhju_ jh^gyl __k iZgl_jhcy]mZjhf b
lb]jhf b dhlhjufb hgZ gZ^_e_gZ \ jZ\ghckl_i_gb kgbfb
<kydbcdhfm ^h\_ehkv ih[eb`_ magZlv kl_iguo dhr_d[_a
khfg_gbykh]eZkblkyqlh hgb hq_gv e_]dhijbjmqZxlky<
dZdhclh f_j_ wlh ijbjh`^_ggu_ ^hfZrgb_ `b\hlgu_?keb
^bdb_ _\jhi_ckdb_ dhrdb )HOLVVLOYHVWULVijbjmq_gbx g_
ih^^Zxlkyohly [u hgbb ihiZeb \g_\hex kh\k_f fZe_gvdbfb
dhlylZfblh ^Z`_ \ajhkeZy kl_igZydhrdZ gZklhevdh[ukljh
klZgh\blky jmqghc [_a \kydbo d lhfm klZjZgbckh klhjhgu
ijbkfZljb\Zxsbo aZ g_c ex^_cqlh \kdhj_kh^_j`Zgb_ __\
de_ld_ ij_\jZsZ_lky \ [_kkfuke_ggmx `_klhdhklv<h fgh]bo
ahhiZjdZo dhrdbijb[u\ lm^Z ie_ggbpZfbiha`_ klZgh\bebkv
ex[bfpZfb k\hbo klhjh`_cb gZgbo \haeZ]Zebkvh[yaZgghklb
^hfZrg_c dhrdbKj_^b
fhbo fgh]hqbke_gguo
q_l\_jhgh]bo
agZdhfp_\ y g_fh]m gZa\Zlvgb _^bghcihgZklhys_fm ^bdhc
beb im]eb\hc kl_ighc dhrdb
b g_ _^bghc
^_ckl\bl_evgh
ijbjmqb\r_cky _\jhi_ckdhc^bdhc dhrdb
Dh]^Z ^j_\gb_ _]bilyg_khagZ\ZygZkdhevdh ihe_agu bf
wlb `b\hlgu_[eZ]hjZamfgh
ihf_klbeb dhr_d ih^
aZsblm
aZdhgZ aZ m[bckl\hdhrdb iheZ]ZeZkvkf_jlgZy dZagvwlh
bklhjbq_kdbc
nZdlk\ys_ggu_
dhrdb
q_j_a
g_kdhevdh
ihdhe_gbc_kl_kl\_gghmljZlbeb
\kydbc
kljZo
i_j_^
q_eh\_dhf
b
klZeb
klhev
`_
gZahceb\h jmqgufbdZd
kh\j_f_ggu_ k\ys_ggu_ dhjh\u \ Bg^bb: m` _keb
wlhl
]hj[Zluc kdhllZd m\_j_g \k\h_c [_ahiZkghklbqlh kihdhcgh
aZoh^bl \ h\hsgu_ eZ\hqdb bd m`Zkmlhj]h\p_\ih`bjZ_l
kZfu_ khqgu_njmdlu b h\hsblh gZkdhevdhemqr_ ^he`gu[ueb
hkhagZlv ij_bfms_kl\Z k\h_]h iheh`_gby b \hkihevah\Zlvky
bfb
g_kjZ\g_ggh
[he__
mfgu_
k\ys_ggu_
dhrdb;m^_f
gZ^_ylvkyqlh hgb ijb wlhf g_ aZ[u\Zebh k\h_f^he]_ b
ijh^he`Zeb mk_j^gheh\blv fur_c
G_ljm^gh
ij_^klZ\blv
k_[_k
dZdhc ij_ajbl_evghc
g_[j_`ghklvx lh]^Zrgb_ dhrdb hlghkbebkv dk\hbf ohay_\Zf
jZa m`^Z`_ gZrb kZfu_h[udgh\_ggu_ dhrdbj_^dh m^_eyxlgZf
\gbfZgb_ijZ\h `_qm\kl\m_rv k_[y ihevs_ggufdh]^Z
fZe_gvdbc
lb]j
baj_^dZ
ih[Zem_l
l_[y
dZdbfgb[m^v
baty\e_gb_f
\_`eb\hklb
beb
ijb\yaZgghklbKms_kl\m_l
g_khfg_ggZy
k\yav
f_`^m
g_aZ\bkbfuf
gjZ\hf
dhr_d b
f_^e_gghklvx
ihy\e_gby
m
gbo
nbabq_kdbo
ijbagZdh\
h^hfZrgb\ZgbyOhly dhrdZ [ueZh[ty\e_gZ k\ys_gguf ojZfh\uf
`b\hlguf \h \j_f_gy iylhc beb r_klhc ^bgZklbbe_]db_
ijbagZdb fmlZpbb\ klhjhgmh^hfZrgb\Zgb_ m^Z_lky h[gZjm`blv
m dhrZqvbo fmfbclhevdh ^\_gZ^pZlhcb ljbgZ^pZlhc^bgZklbc
gZijbf_jaZf_lgu_ baf_g_gby \kljh_gbb moZb \ZjbZpbyo
hdjZkdbdhlhjZy
d lhfm
\j_f_gb klZgh\blky
^h\hevgh
jZaghh[jZaghcohly
q_jgu_[_eu
b djZiqZlu_
rdmjdb
hklZxlky _s_ ^_ehf[m^ms_]hLh]^Z `_ q_j_idhrdb gZqbgZ_l
h[gZjm`b\Zlv
g_dhlhjmx
\uimdehklv
\bkhqguo
dhkl_c
b
mdhjZqb\Zgb_
fhj^ulh
_klv
l_
q_jludhlhju_ m`_
oZjZdl_jbah\Zeb lhjnygmx kh[Zdm dZd ^hfZrg__ `b\hlgh_aZ
g_kdhevdh ^_kyldh\lukyq_e_lbc ^hwlh]h>Z`_ \gZrb ^gb m
dhr_ddhlhjuo g_ \u\h^beb ki_pbZevgh kaZjZg__ aZ^Zgghc
p_evxnbabq_kdb_ b ikbobq_kdb_ baf_g_gbyk\yaZggu_
k
h^hfZrgb\Zgb_faZf_lgu hq_gv fZehb om^u_^ebgghgh]b_
dhjhldhr_jklgu_ dhrdb k lb]jh\hc hdjZkdhcdZdbo g_fZeh\
P_gljZevghc ?\jhi_khojZgyxl m^b\bl_evgh_
koh^kl\h
k
^j_\gbfb dhrdZfb
Ohly dhrdZ dZd ^hfZrg__ `b\hlgh_ [ueZ k ^Z\gboihj
rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_ggZ
ih \k_fm
?]bilmihlj_[h\Zehkv
g_\_jhylgh ^he]h_ \j_fyqlh[u
hgZ ijhgbdeZ \
^jm]b_
kljZgu:glbqgu_ ibkZl_ebih\b^bfhfmg_ bf_eb hg_c
ijZdlbq_kdb gbdZdh]h ij_^klZ\e_gbyb i_j\uf hihy\e_gbb
dhr_d \ ?\jhi_ jZkkdZau\Z_l gZf IemlZjo ebrv \ i_j\hf
klhe_lbb gZr_c
wjuEx[hiulghqlh
h^gh\j_f_ggh
hg
mihfbgZ_l h eZkd_dZd hihe_aghf `b\hlghfdhlhjh_ ^_j`Zl
\ ^hf_ lhevdh jZ^b mgbqlh`_gby fur_cIh\b^bfhfmeZkdZ
lh]^Z _s_ g_ [ueZ \ul_kg_gZ ^hfZrg_c dhrdhc\h
\k_o
hlghr_gbyo [he__ m^h[ghc^ey kh^_j`Zgby\ ^hf_>Zevg_cr__
jZkijhkljZg_gb_ ^hfZrg_c dhrdb ih ?\jhi_ ijhbkoh^beh gZ
m^b\e_gb_ f_^e_ggh \ MwevkdboaZdhgZo GhmweeZ>vx lhqgh
mdZau\Z_lkydZdmx p_gmfh`gh aZijhkblvaZ dhrdmb dZdbo__
dZq_kl\ bf__l ijZ\h lj_[h\Zlv ihdmiZl_ev< wlm wihom
ijbf_jgh \lukyqghf ]h^m gZr_cwjuq_eh\_dm[b\rbc dhrdm
h[yaZg [ue ieZlblv
rljZn h\pmy]g_gdZ beb
lZdh_
dhebq_kl\h ir_gbpudZdh]h o\Zlbeh [u ^ey lh]hqlh[u
iheghklvx aZkuiZlv m[blmxdhrdmih^\_r_ggmx gZ^ a_fe_caZ
o\hklIhkdhevdm
\
lZdhf
iheh`_gbb
l_eh
kbevgh
\uly]b\Z_lkya_jgZ ijboh^behkvhl^Z\Zlv g_fZeh
< 9,,,\_d_ \=_jfZgbb dhr_dih\b^bfhfmg_ [ueh\h
\kydhf kemqZ_\ KZebq_kdbo ijZ\beZohgb g_mihfbgZxlky
< wlhc kljZg_ _s_ \ ;,9\_d_ dhrdb p_gbebkvgZklhevdh
\ukhdhqlh \ g_dhlhjuo dmiqbo hgb mdZau\Zebkv\ kibkd_
^\b`bfhklbdhlhjmx ijh^Zxsbc mklmiZe \f_kl_ kn_jfhcY
ijb\_e a^_kv
\k_ wlb
k\_^_gbydhlhju_jZamf__lky
ihq_jigme ba ;j_fZg_ [_a aZ^g_c fukeb\b^u ^hfZrgbo
`b\hlguoki_pbZevgh \u\h^bfu_ q_eh\_dhfjZkijhkljZgyebkv
]hjZa^h [uklj__q_f wlh ijhbahrehk dhrdZfb>Z`_ bl_i_jv
g_ lZdlh ijhklh ijh^Zlv dhrdm gZklhjhgmhkh[_ggh _keb
hgZ h[eZ^Z_l l_f g_aZ\bkbfuf hohlgbqvbf ^mohfdhlhju_
ih\urZ_l __ p_gghklv dZd djukheh\ZJmdh\h^kl\mykv k\hbf
bamfbl_evgh
ohjhrh
khojZgb\rbfky
qm\kl\hf gZijZ\e_gby
dhrdb mijyfh
\ha\jZsZxlky \
ij_`gb_ `bebsZihdju\Zy
g_fukebfu_ jZkklhygb_B gZclb ^hjh]m^hfhcwlh \h\k_ g_
hagZqZ_lqlh hgZ ijb`b\_lky lZflZdZy dhrdZ\iheg_
kihkh[gZ ijhy\blvihegmx g_aZ\bkbfhklvb \_jgmlvky d^bdhfm
h[jZam
`bagbIhwlhfm
kgZqZeZ
dhrdZ\_jhylgh
jZkijhkljZgyeZkv \h\k_ g_ ihlhfmqlh ihdhjgh iha\heyeZ
ex^yf ijh^Z\Zlvk_[yg_lhgZ i_j_[bjZeZkvba ^hfZ\ ^hf
b ba ^_j_\gb\ ^_j_\gxihdZ g_aZ\eZ^_eZ ihkl_i_ggh\k_f
dhglbg_glhf
><: BKLHQGBD:IJ?>:GGHKLB
<k_dhfm ijboh^behkv bf_lv[hevr_ h^ghc kh[ZdbagZxl
gZkdhevdh jZaebqgufb [u\Zxl kh[Zqvb bg^b\b^mZevghklbG_l
^\mo Z[khexlghihoh`bo ^jm]gZ ^jm]Z kh[ZddZd g_l b^\mo
Z[khexlgh h^bgZdh\uo ex^_c ^Z`_ kj_^b [ebag_ph\Gh
\uy\eyy dhgdj_lgu_ q_jlu
dZ`^h]h ^Zggh]h
q_eh\_q_kdh]h
oZjZdl_jZ b h[t_^bgyy bo \ dZl_]hjbbfh`gh ^hba\_klghc
kl_i_gb h[tykgblv jZaebqgu_ l_fi_jZf_gluohly
ih^h[guc
ZgZeba baaZ [_kdhg_qgh]hjZaghh[jZaby bamqZ_fh]hfZl_jbZeZ
gbdh]^Z
g_
^hklb]g_l
klZlmkZ
lhqghc
gZmdbKh[Zqvy
bg^b\b^mZevghklv fgh]h ijhs_Z ihlhfm gZf]hjZa^h e_]q_
h[tykgblv hkh[_gghklb jZaebqguo oZjZdl_jhfjZkkfZljb\Zy
jZa\blb_ hij_^_e_gguo
oZjZdl_jheh]bq_kdboq_jl
b
bo
khq_lZgby m^Zggh]h bg^b\b^Z
Dhg_qghy g_kh[bjZxkv ijh\h^blv\ wlhcdgb]_ gZmqgh_
bkke_^h\Zgb_ oZjZdl_jheh]bq_kdbo q_jl ^hfZrg_c kh[Zdbgh
l_f
g_
f_g__
ihijh[mx
ihdZaZlvdZd \aZbfh^_ckl\b_
g_dhlhjuo \jh`^_gguo hkh[_gghkl_cih\_^_gbyb \ qZklghklb
^\mo ba gbokha^Z_l qj_a\uqZcgh rbjhdmx ]Zffmkh[Zqvbo
oZjZdl_jh\gZ i_j\uc
\a]ey^ dZj^bgZevgh
jZaebqZxsboky
f_`^m kh[hcBf_ggh wlb ^\Z \u^_e_gguo fghxk\hckl\Z \
i_j\mx hq_j_^v hij_^_eyxlhlghr_gb_ kh[Zdbd __ohaybgmZ
ihlhfm hgb ij_^klZ\eyxl
[hevrhc bgl_j_k ^ey
ex[bl_e_c
kh[ZdIj_^Zgghklv
kh[Zdb ohaybgm
\hagbdZ_l ba
^\mo
kh\_jr_ggh jZaguo bklhqgbdh\<h fgh]hf hgZ h[tykgy_lky
l_fb maZfbdhlhju_ k\yau\Zxl ^bdmxkh[Zdm kfZl_jvx lhevdh
\ ^_lkdhf\hajZkl_Z m^hfZrg_c kh[ZdbkhojZgy_lky gZ \kx
`bagv b \f_kl_k jy^hf^jm]bo fhf_glh\kihkh[kl\m_l lhfm
qlh g_dhlhju_ ^_lkdb_q_jlu oZjZdl_jZg_ bkq_aZ_lb dh]^Z
`b\hlgh_ klZgh\blky \ajhkeuf>jm]hc dhj_gv
ij_^Zgghklb
aZeh`_g \ lhc\_jghklbdhlhjZy k\yau\Z_l jy^h\mxkh[Zdm k
\h`Zdhf klZb beb `_ \hagbdZ_l baijb\yaZgghklbiblZ_fhc
hl^_evgufb qe_gZfb k_fvb ^jm] d ^jm]mM kh[Zdk \heqv_c
djh\vx wlhl dhj_gv moh^bl ]hjZa^h ]em[`_q_f mihlhfdh\
rZdZeZb ih hq_\b^ghc ijbqbg_khojZg_gb_ klZb b]jZ_l
]hjZa^h [hevrmxjhev \`bagb \hedZq_f \`bagb rZdZeZ
?keb \aylv \ ^hf s_gdZ g_h^hfZrg_ggh]hij_^klZ\bl_ey
k_f_ckl\Z kh[Zqvbo b jZklblv _]h dZdkh[Zdme_]dh fh`gh
\hh[jZablv[m^lh ihlj_[ghklv ^bdh]h ^_l_gurZ \aZ[hl_ b
moh^_ jZ\ghagZqgZlhc ih`bag_gghck\yabdhlhjZy kms_kl\m_l
f_`^m [hevrbgkl\hf gZrbo ^hfZrgbo kh[Zd b boohay_\Zfb
Ie_gguc \heqhghd h[uqgh[u\Z_l jh[dbfij_^ihqblZ_l l_fgu_
m]eu b y\gh[hblky i_j_k_dZlvhldjulu_ ijhkljZgkl\ZHg \
\ukr_c kl_i_gb g_^h\_jqb\d g_agZdhfufex^yf b_keb lZdhc
q_eh\_d ihijh[m_l _]h ih]eZ^blvfh`_l yjhklgh b
[_a
ij_^mij_`^_gby \p_iblvky
\ eZkdZxsmx
jmdmHg
m`_ k
jh`^_gby \_kvfZ kdehg_g dmkZlvky hl kljZoZ
ihg_f_pdb
lZdbo `b\hlguo
gZau\Zxl Zg]kl[Zck_jgh d
ohaybgm
\heqhghd ijb\yau\Z_lky biheZ]Z_lky gZg_]h lhqghlZd `_
dZd s_ghd?keb j_qvb^_l hkZfd_dhlhjZy ijbghjfZevghf
oh^_ kh[ulbc\ujZklZygZqbgZ_l \hkijbgbfZlvkZfpZ\h`ZdZ
dZd ohaybgZhiulguf ^j_kkbjh\sbdZfbgh]^Z m^Z_lky aZgylv
f_klh
lZdh]h
\h`ZdZ
\
lhl
i_jbh^dh]^Z
^_lkdZy
aZ\bkbfhklv
kZfdb
koh^bl
gZ
g_lb
lZdbf h[jZahf
h[_ki_qblv k_[_ __ ijb\yaZgghklv b \ ^Zevg_cr_fH^bg
\_gkdbc ihebp_ckdbc kmf_e ^h[blvky lZdhc ij_^Zgghklb hl
k\h_c agZf_gblhc \heqbpu Ihev^bGh lh]hdlh \hkiblu\Z_l
\hedZkZfpZ`^_l g_fbgm_fh_ jZahqZjh\Zgb_ dZd lhevdh
\hed klZgh\blky\ajhkeufhg \g_aZighi_j_klZ_l ih^qbgylvky
ohaybgm b^_j`blky Z[khexlgh g_aZ\bkbfh< _]hih\_^_gbb ih
hlghr_gbx d [u\r_fm ohaybgm g_ ijhy\ey_lky gbaeh[ugb
k\bj_ihklb hg ihij_`g_fm h[oh^blkyk gbfdZd k^jm]hf
gh _fm [hevr_ b \ ]heh\m g_ ijb^_l ke_ihih\bgh\Zlvky
ohaybgmb\hafh`ghhg ^Z`_ihiulZ_lky ih^qbgblv_]h k_[_
b klZlv\h`ZdhfMqblu\Zy kbem\heqvbo am[h\g_ ijboh^blky
m^b\eylvkyqlh wlZ ijhp_^mjZ bgh]^Zijbh[j_lZ_l ^h\hevgh
djh\Z\uc oZjZdl_j
Lh `_ijhbahreh k^bg]hdhlhjh]h y\aye gZ iyluc^_gv
_]h `bagbih^eh`be d dhjfys_c kh[Zd_ b \hkiblu\Zeg_
`Ze_y \j_f_gbb kbeWlZ ^bdZykh[ZdZ g_ iulZeZkvih^qbgblv
f_gy k_[_ bebbkdmkZlvghklZ\ \ajhkehchgZ ihkl_i_ggh
mljZlbeZ ij_`gxxihkemrghklvijbq_f ijhbkoh^behwlh \_kvfZ
ex[hiulguf h[jZahfIhdZ fhc^bg]h [ues_gdhf_]h ih\_^_gb_
gbq_f g_hlebqZehkv hlih\_^_gby h[udgh\_gghc kh[ZdbDh]^Z
y gZdZau\Ze_]h aZdZdmxgb[m^v ijh\bgghklvhg \ujZ`Ze k\h_
jZkdZygb_ gZ
h[uqguc kh[Zqbc
fZg_jlh
_klv iulZeky
mfbjhl\hjblv jZa]g_\Zggh]h ohaybgZ\ujZ`_gbyfb ihdhjghklbb
fhev[uijbq_f mkihdZb\Zekylhevdh dh]^Z^h[b\Zeky eZkdb
hagZqZxs_c ijhs_gb_H^gZdhdh]^Z _fmbkihegbehkv ihelhjZ
]h^Z_]h ih\_^_gb_dhj_gguf h[jZahfbaf_gbehkv hg \k_ _s_
[_a khijhlb\e_gby ijbgbfZe gZdZaZgb_^Z`_ ih[hbgh _^\Z
\k_ dhgqZehkvdZd hg \kljyob\Zeky^jm`_kdb \beye fg_
o\hklhf b m[_]Zeijb]eZrZy f_gyih]hgylvky aZgbfBgufb
keh\ZfbgZdZaZgb_ gbdZdg_ \ebyehgZ _]hgZkljh_gb_ bg_
ijhba\h^beh gZ g_]hgb fZe_cr_]h^_ckl\by\iehlv ^hlh]h
qlh hgfh] lml `_ih\lhjblv ij_klmie_gb_aZ dhlhjh_lhevdh
qlh ihg_k kijZ\_^eb\mxdZjmgZijbf_j\gh\v ihdmkblvkygZ
`bagv h^ghcba kZfuop_gguo fhbomlhd< lhf`_ \hajZkl_hg
mljZlbe \kydh_ `_eZgb_khijh\h`^Zlv f_gy\h \j_fyijh]mehd
b ijhklh m[_]Zedm^Z ohl_eg_ h[jZsZygbdZdh]h \gbfZgby
gZ fhb dhfZg^uL_f g_ f_g__ y ^he`_gih^q_jdgmlvqlh
ihevah\Zeky kZfuf l_ieu__]h jZkiheh`_gb_fbdh]^Z [ufu
gb \klj_qZebkvhg ijb\_lkl\h\Zef_gy k kh[ex^_gb_fihegh]h
kh[Zqv_]h p_j_fhgbZeZG_ ke_^m_l`^Zlvqlh ^bdh_`b\hlgh_
[m^_l h[oh^blvky k q_eh\_dhf bgZq_q_f khkh[yfb k\h_]h
\b^ZFu _s_
\_jg_fky d wlhfm
\hijhkmdh]^Z
[m^_f
jZkkfZljb\Zlv hlghr_gby f_`^mex^vfb bdhrdZfbFhc ^bg]h
kh\_jr_ggh g_khfg_gghiblZe dh fg_kZfu_ ]hjyqb_qm\kl\Z
gh ihdhjghklvb ihkemrZgb_lml ijhklhgb ijbq_f
H^hfZrg_ggu_ kh[Zdb\
dhlhjuo ij_h[eZ^Z_l
rZdZevy
djh\v\kx `bagv hklZxlky \ lhc`_ aZ\bkbfhklbhl k\h_]h
ohaybgZ\
dZdhc gZoh^ylky
fheh^u_ ^bdb_
kh[Zdb
hl
\ajhkeuoB wlh g__^bgkl\_ggZy ^_lkdZyq_jlZdhlhjmx \
hlebqb_ hl ^bdhc kh[Zdb hgb khojZgyxl ^h dhgpZ `bagb
DhjhldZ r_jklvo\hkl dhevphf b\bkyqb_ mrbk\hckl\_ggu_
fgh]bf ihjh^ZfZ ]eZ\gh_mdhjhq_ggZy fhj^Zb \uimdehklv
q_j_iZdhlhju_ fu m`_ \b^_eb m lhjnyghc kh[Zdb&DQLV
IDPLOLDULVSDOXVWULVwlb q_jlu oZjZdl_jbam_lm ^bdbo
nhjf lhevdh
fheh^uo `b\hlguogh m
^hfZrg_c
kh[Zdb
khojZgyxlky gZijhly`_gbb \k_c__ `bagb
DZd
b
[hevrbgkl\h
oZjZdl_jheh]bq_kdbo
q_jl
bgnZglbevghklv fh`_l [ulv b ^hklhbgkl\hf bg_^hklZldhf \k_ aZ\bkblhl kl_i_gbKh[Zdbiheghklvx __ebr_ggu_ohly
b bgl_j_kguk\h_c g_aZ\bkbfhklvxohaybgm hkh[hc jZ^hklbg_
^hklZ\eyxllZd dZdhgb g_bkijZ\bfu_[jh^y]b bebrv \j_fy
hl \j_f_gb kgbkoh^yl ^h ihk_s_gby ^hfZ k\h_]h\eZ^_evpZ
keh\h ohaybglml y\gh g_ ih^oh^blK \hajZklhflZdb_
kh[Zdb qZklh
klZgh\ylky hiZkgufblZd dZdebr_ggu_
lbibqghc kh[Zqv_cihdhjghklbhgb fh]mlbkdmkZlv beb k[blv
k gh] q_eh\_dZkeh\gh ^jm]mxkh[ZdmH^gZdhhkm`^Zy ^mo
[jh^y`gbq_kl\Z b khimlkl\mxs__
_fm hlkmlkl\b_
\_jghklb
ohaybgm bebf_klmy ^he`_g^h[Z\blvqlh ba[ulhd xghr_kdhc
aZ\bkbfhklb fh`_ldZd gbkljZgghijb\_klb ihqlbd l_f `_
j_amevlZlZfd dZdbfijb\h^bl ihegh___ hlkmlkl\b_
Ohly m [hevrbgkl\Z gZrbo ^hfZrgbo kh[Zd bklhdb
bo
ij_^Zgghklb e_`Zl bf_ggh \ wlhc^h ba\_klghc
kl_i_gb
khojZgyxs_cky
bgnZglbevghklbba[ulhd
__
^Z_l
ijhlb\hiheh`gmx dZjlbgmLZdb_ kh[Zdb qj_a\uqZcgheZkdh\u
kh k\hbfbohay_\Zfb Z aZh^ghb kh\k_fb ^jm]bfb ex^vfb<
Dhevp_ pZjy KhehfhgZy m`_kjZ\gb\Ze wlhllbi kh[Zd
k
ba[Zeh\Zggufb ^_lvfbdhlhju_
dZ`^h]h fm`qbgm
gZau\Zxl
^y^_cb ex[hfm
g_agZdhfhfm q_eh\_dm gZ\yau\Zxl
k\hx
g_ijhr_gmx ^jm`[mB ^_eh g_\ lhf[m^lh lZdZykh[ZdZ g_
agZ_l k\h_]h ohaybgZgZh[hjhlhgZ jZ^m_lky_]h ijboh^m
b ijb\_lkl\m_l _]h [he__ \hklhj`_gghq_f ^jm]boihke_
q_]h
hohlgh
m[_]Z_l
k
i_j\uf
\klj_qgufIh^h[gZy
g_jZa[hjqb\Zy ^jm`_ex[ghklv dh \k_fm jh^m q_eh\_q_kdhfm
g_khfg_gghihjh`^Z_lky kbevg_cr_c bgnZglbevghklvx wlh
^hdZau\Z_lky \k_f kljh_f ih\_^_gby ih^h[guo kh[ZdHgb
\k_]^Z baebrg_kdehggu d b]j_b fgh]h\j_f_gb kimklyihke_
lh]hdZd bfbkihegblky ]h^b \k_bo ghjfZevgu_jh\_kgbdb
mki_xl ^Z\gh hkl_i_gblvkyhgb \k_ _s_ ]juamlohayckdb_
re_iZgpu bgZghkyl kf_jl_evgu_ jZguaZgZ\_kdZfZ ]eZ\gh_ khojZgyxl jZ[kdmx ihdhjghklvdhlhjZy m ^jm]bokh[Zd ijb
\ajhke_gbb [ukljh kf_gy_lky a^hjh\hc m\_j_gghklvx\ k_[_
IheZy\ ba qm\kl\Z ^he]h gZ g_agZdhfh]h q_eh\_dZlZdZy
kh[ZdZ m]h^eb\h \Zeblky i_j_^ gbf gZ kibgmklhbl _fm
kljh]h aZ]h\hjblvk g_cB lhldlh ^_j`bl__ ih\h^hd^ey
g__ m`_]jhaguc b\k_fh]msbc ohaybg
KqZkleb\Zy k_j_^bgZ f_`^m kebrdhf aZ\bkbfhcb kebrdhf
g_aZ\bkbfhc kh[Zdhc wlh b _klvb^_Ze bklbgghij_^Zgghc
kh[ZdbWlhl b^_Ze\klj_qZ_lky ^Ze_dh g_lZd qZklhb m`\h
\kydhf kemqZ_]hjZa^h j_`_q_f dZ`_lky kj_^g_fm\eZ^_evpm
kh[Zdb
Hij_^_e_ggZy
kl_i_gv
g_ij_oh^ys_c
bgnZglbevghklb
g_h[oh^bfZqlh[u kh[ZdZiblZeZ dk\h_fm ohaybgmex[h\v b
ij_^Zgghklvgh __ba[ulhd aZklZ\ey_lkh[Zdm lZd`_ ihdhjgh
h[h`Zlv \k_o ex^_c [_a jZa[hjZIhwlhfm ebrvhlghkbl_evgh
g_fgh]b_ kh[Zdb[m^ml ^_ckl\bl_evghaZsbsZlv k\h_]h ohaybgZ
hl omeb]ZgZohly hgb\h\k_ g_hklZxlky jZ\gh^mrgufbd lhfm
qlh gZ ohaybgZdlhlh gZiZeh^gZdh q_eh\_d\hh[s_ \gmrZ_l
bf [eZ]h\_cgh_ ihql_gb_b hgb
g_\ khklhygbbijbqbgblv
_fm \j_^
Ij_^Zgghklv kh[ZdijbgZ^e_`Zsbo dl_f ihjh^Zf\ `beZo
dhlhjuo l_q_l dZdZylh ^ey \heqv_c djh\bijbgpbibZevgh
hlebqgZ hl ij_^Zgghklb gZrbop_gljZevgh_\jhi_ckdbo ihjh^
\_^msboih\b^bfhfmk\h_ ijhbkoh`^_gb_ g_ihkj_^kl\_gghhl
rZdZeh\<jy^ eb kms_kl\mxl ihjh^u\hkoh^ysb_ ijyfh d
\hedZf_klv \k_ hkgh\Zgby kqblZlvqlh q_eh\_dZ \ lh
\j_fydh]^Z hggZqZe k_eblvky\ Zjdlbq_kdboh[eZklyo]^_
\hr_e
\
khijbdhkgh\_gb_
k
lmg^jh\uf
\hedhfm`_
khijh\h`^Zeb kh[Zdb rZdZev_c djh\bKdj_sb\Zgb_ \hedh\k
^hfZrgbfb kh[ZdZfb k_\_jguo gZjh^h\ ijhbahrehhq_\b^gh
kjZ\gbl_evgh iha^gh
b m`\h \kydhf
kemqZ_]hjZa^h
iha^g__q_f i_j\h_
ijbjmq_gb_ rZdZeZIhkdhevdm
\hed
kbevg__ b
\ughkeb\__fh]eZ
\hagbdgmlv ihlj_[ghklv
\
ihjh^Zo kh agZqbl_evguf ij_h[eZ^Zgb_f \heqv_c djh\bZ
k\bj_ihklv bg_mdjhlbfhklv\_jhylghg_ kebrdhf [_kihdhbeb
h[blZl_e_c DjZcg_]h K_\_jZ ijbjh`^_gguo ^j_kkbjh\sbdh\
mf_xsbo
kijZ\eylvky
k
kZfufb
g_aZ\bkbfufb
ikZfb
G_ihkj_^kl\_gguf j_amevlZlhf wlh]h [hevrh]hb kjZ\gbl_evgh
g_^Z\g_]h
ijbeb\Z
\heqv_c
djh\b
y\behkv
agZqbl_evgh
hkeZ[e_gb_ \ \heqvboihjh^Zo q_jl h^hfZrg_gghklbb \
qZklghklbg_ij_oh^ys_c
bgnZglbevghklbHgZ
aZf_gy_lky
aZ\bkbfhklvx kh\k_f bgh]h
lbiZdhlhjZy h[yaZgZ
k\hbf
ijhbkoh`^_gb_f
ki_pbnbq_kdb
\heqvbf
hkh[_gghklyf?keb
rZdZe \ hkgh\ghf_kl iZ^Zevlh \hedgZklhysbc obsgbdb
abfhc gm`^Z_lky \ ihfhsb
k\hbo kh[jZlv_\hohlykv
gZ
djmiguo ljZ\hy^guo_]h _^bgkl\_ggucdhjf \wlm ihjm]h^Z
Qlh[u h[_ki_qblv k_[y ^hklZlhqguf dhebq_kl\hf
ibsb
\heqvy klZy \ugm`^_gZ
ihdju\Zlv [hevrb_ jZkklhygbyZ
j_amevlZlu hohluaZ\bkyl hl \aZbfghcih^^_j`db \l_ fbgmlu
dh]^Z __qe_gZf m^Z_lkyaZljZ\blv ^bqvKljh]Zy hj]ZgbaZpby
klZb[_aaZ\_lgZy
ij_^Zgghklv \h`Zdm
b
[_ah]h\hjhqgZy
\aZbfgZy \ujmqdZ
\hl
g_h[oh^bfu_ mkeh\by
mki_rgh]h
\u`b\Zgby wlh]h \b^Z \ ly`_ehc [hjv[_ aZkms_kl\h\Zgb_
LZdb_ \heqvb k\hckl\Ziheghklvx h[tykgyxlkmsghklv
\_kvfZ
aZf_lguo jZaebqbc \oZjZdl_j_ rZdZevbob \heqvbokh[Zd
jZaebqbchq_\b^guo ^ey \k_odlh ihgZklhys_fm ihgbfZ_l
kh[ZdI_j\u_
hlghkylky
d
k\hbf
ohay_\Zf
dZd
d
kh[ZdZfjh^bl_eyf\lhju_ \b^yl\ gbokdhj__ \h`Zdh\klZb b
\_^ml k_[yk gbfbkhhl\_lkl\_ggh
Ihdhjghklb bgnZglbevghc
rZdZev_c kh[Zdb
m
\heqv_c
kh[Zdb khhl\_lkl\m_l]hj^Zy fm`kdZyehyevghklv\ dhlhjhc
ih^qbg_gb_ b]jZ_l \_kvfZ fZemx jhevZ jZ[kdZyihdhjghklv
gbdZdhc<heqvy kh[ZdZ \ hlebqb_ hlrZdZev_c \h\k_g_
\b^bl \ ohaybg_q_]hlh \jh^_ihf_kb hlpZb [h]Z^ey g__
hg kdhj__ lh\Zjbsohly __ ijb\yaZgghklv dg_fm ]hjZa^h
ijhqg__ b g_ i_j_ghkblvky
k e_]dhklvx gZ
dh]hgb[m^v
^jm]h]hWlh h^ghex[b_jZa\b\Z_lky \ fheh^uo
\heqvbo
kh[ZdZo \_kvfZ k\h_h[jZagh\ hij_^_e_gguc fhf_gl^_lkdZy
aZ\bkbfhklv
hl
jh^bl_e_c
q_ldh
kf_gy_lky
\ajhkehc
ij_^Zgghklvx \h`ZdmklZbijbq_f wlhijhbkoh^bl^Z`_ dh]^Z
s_ghd
jZkl_l
\
baheypbb
hl
k_[_
ih^h[guoZ
kh[ZdZjh^bl_evb \h`Zd klZb\hiehs_gu \h^ghf q_eh\_d_
KH;:QVB EBQGHKLB
< wlhc
]eZ\_ y
ihiulZxkv gZ
dhgdj_lguo ijbf_jZo
ijhbeexkljbjh\ZlvdZdbf
h[jZahf
mihfbgZ\rb_ky
\ur_
oZjZdl_jheh]bq_kdb_
q_jlu
ijhy\eyxlky
\ bg^b\b^mZevguo
hkh[_gghklyo hl^_evguo kh[ZdIjb wlhfy [m^mbkoh^blv ba
h[s_]h ^_e_gby kh[Zd gZ ^\_ ijhlb\hiheh`gu_ ]jmiiu
ih
ijbagZdm eb[h ihegh]hkhojZg_gby ^_lkdhcaZ\bkbfhklbeb[h
klhev
`_
ihegh]h
__
hlkmlkl\by
\
khq_lZgbb
k
khhl\_lkl\mxs_c
kl_i_gvx
ij_^Zgghklb
\h`Zdm
kh \k_fb
\ul_dZxsbfb hlkx^Zihke_^kl\byfb
Y gZqgm k jZkkdZaZ h kh[Zd_qvy gZ i_j\uc\a]ey^
ljh]Zl_evgZy ^_lkdZy ijb\yaZgghklv
d ohaybgm
ijbgbfZeZ
gZklhevdh ij_m\_ebq_ggu_ nhjfuqlh wlh[ue m`_g_ i_kZ
dZdZylh iZjh^byJ_qv ihc^_l h lZdk_ ih debqd_Djhdb
dhlhjmx ih^Zjbe fg_ ^h[juc ^y^xrdZiehoh jZa[bjZ\rbcky\
`b\hlguoY [ue lh]^Z _s_ kh\k_ffZe_gvdbf fZevqbdhfgh
m`_ aZy^euf
gZlmjZebklhfDebqdm
Djhdb i_kbd
ihemqbe
ihlhfmqlh
fhc
^h[juc
jh^kl\_ggbd
kgZqZeZ
h[eZ]h^_l_evkl\h\Ze f_gy djhdh^bevqbdhfgh lhl
gZhlj_a
hldZau\Zeky _klv fg_ g_ m^Z\ZehkvgZ]j_\Zlv fhcl_jjZjbmf
^h gm`ghc l_fi_jZlmjub fuh[f_gyeb _]h\ ahheh]bq_kdhf
fZ]Zabg_ gZ `b\hlgh_gZb[he__ gZihfbgZ\r___]h \g_rg_
gZ ZjbklhdjZlbq_kdmx lZdkm k hq_gv ^ebgguf lmeh\bs_f b
hq_gv dhjhldbfb eZiZfbWlhl dh[_e_d ^_ckl\bl_evgh [ue
ihoh` gZ djhdh^beZ_]h hl\bkeu_ mrb ih^f_lZeb ihe
\
[md\Zevghf kfuke_keh\Z
?]h hlebqZeh eZkdh\h_ ^jm`_ex[b_b ijb i_j\hc
`_
\klj_q_ hg
ijb\_lkl\h\Ze f_gy
dZd ^Z\gh
ihl_jyggh]h
ohaybgZDhg_qghwlh fg_ hq_gvevklbehihdZ y g_aZf_lbe
qlh Djhdblhqgh lZd`_ \klj_qZ_l\k_o bdZ`^h]h?]h lhfbeZ
[mjgZy ex[h\v dh \k_fm
jh^m q_eh\_q_kdhfm [_a
\kydbo
bkdexq_gbcHg gbdh]^Z gb gZ
dh]h g_ eZye bohly
\hafh`ghy b fhb [ebadb_ gjZ\bebkv_fm [hevr_hklZevguo
ex^_c[_a dhe_[Zgbc ke_^h\Ze aZ i_j\uf iha\Z\rbf
_]h
q_eh\_dhf_keb gZkg_ hdZau\Zehkvih[ebahklbK \hajZklhf
Djhdb g_ ba[Z\beky hl k\h_c kljZklbb gZf
ihklhyggh
ijboh^behkv m\h^blv _]h ba khk_^gbo bg_ khk_^gbo^hfh\
dm^Z
hg
hlijZ\eyeky
ih]hklblv<
dhgp_ dhgph\ fhy
^\hxjh^gZy k_kljZiblZ\rZy keZ[hklvd wlhc djZkb\hclZdk_
\ayeZ __ d k_[_b Djhdb h[hkgh\Zeky dg__ \=jbgpbg]_
ijb]hjh^_ <_gu]^_ ijh^he`Ze \_klb lhl `_jZkk_ygguc
h[jZa `bagbHg gZkZfu_ jZagu_kjhdb ihk_eyekylh m h^gbo
lh m^jm]bo agZdhfuob g_kdhevdhjZa _]hdjZeb b ijh^Z\Zeb
ijhklh^mrguf ex^yfdhlhjuo
ie_gyeZ _]h
ij_^Zgghklv
<hafh`ghdjZe
Djhdb h^bg
b lhl
`_ \hjdhlhjuc
hagZdhfb\rbkv k _]h ijb\uqdZfbk^_eZe ba g_]h
klZlvx
ihklhyggh]h b^h\hevgh ijbebqgh]h^hoh^Z
>bZf_ljZevghc ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvxwlhc lZdl_y gZa\Ze [u
<hedZh^gm ba ^\mo kh[Zddhlhju_ `b\ml mgZk k_cqZk
<ijhq_f\jy^ ebfh`gh kdZaZlvqlh hg`b\_l mgZkWlh
lbibqgZy g_aZ\bkbfZy \heqvy kh[ZdZ\ oZjZdl_j_ dhlhjhc
g_l gb dZieb bgnZglbevghklbb hgZ gbdhfmg_ ih^qbg_gZ
kh[kl\_ggh ]h\hjy<hed y\gh kqblZ_l k_[y \h`ZdhfgZr_c
klZbH[tykg_gb_ _]h oZjZdl_jZ djh_lky \ bklhjbb _]h
`bagb
I_jbh^dh]^Z
\heqvy
kh[ZdZ
gZ\_db
hl^Z_l k\hx
ijb\yaZgghklv
h^ghfm
dZdhfmlh
q_eh\_dm
i_jbh^
aZi_qZle_gbygZklmiZ_l
m g__
kjZ\gbl_evgh jZgh
ijbf_jgh gZiylhf f_kyp_ `bagbFg_ dZdlh ijbrehkv^hjh]h
aZieZlblv aZ k\hxg_hk\_^hfe_gghklv \wlhf \hijhk_I_j\mx
gZrm kmdmqZmqZm ydmibe \ih^Zjhd `_g_dh ^gx jh`^_gbyb
`_eZy k^_eZlv _c kxjijbaihijhkbe fhx^\hxjh^gmx k_kljm
ih^_j`Zlv s_gdZ
dhlhjhfm [ueh
hdheh r_klb
f_kyp_\
hklZ\rmxky g_^_ex m k_[yOhlbl_ \_jvl_ohlbl_ g_lgh
wlbo k_fb
^g_c hdZaZehkv
^hklZlhqghqlh[u
fZe_gvdZy
qZmqZm jZab gZ\k_]^Zhl^ZeZ k\hx ex[h\vfh_c dmabg_qlh
g_kdhevdh kgbabeh __
ih^Zjhqgmx p_gghklvOhly
dmabgZ
[u\ZeZ m gZk j_^dhmijyfZy qZmqZm y\gh kqblZeZk\h_c
aZdhgghc \eZ^_ebp_c __Z
g_ fhx `_gmIjZ\^ZhgZ
ihkl_i_ggh
ijb\yaZeZkv
d
`_g_ghg_khfg_gghwlZ
ijb\yaZgghklv [ueZ[u dm^Z[he__ ]hjyq_c_keb [uy ijbg_k
__ ba iblhfgbdZ ijyfh ^hfhc>Z`_ fgh]h e_lkimkly hgZ
hohlgh mreZ[u hlgZk dk\h_c i_j\hcohaycd_
I_jbh^\h \j_fy dhlhjh]h lZdZy kh[ZdZ\u[bjZ_l k_[_
ohaybgZfh`_l fbgh\Zlv[_kieh^gh_keb hgZ[m^_l hklZ\Zlvky
\ iblhfgbd_ kebrdhf^he]h eb[hih dZdhclh ^jm]hc ijbqbg_
^ey g__g_ gZc^_lkyih^oh^ys_]h ohaybgZB \lhf b \^jm]hf
kemqZ_ kdeZ^u\Z_lky
k\h_h[jZagucZ[khexlgh
g_aZ\bkbfuc
kh[Zqbc oZjZdl_jhebp_l\hj_gguc\ qZklghklb\ <hed_Hg
jh^beky \kdhj_ ihke_hdhgqZgby \lhjhcfbjh\hc \hcgudh]^Z
hkljh hsmsZeZkv
g_o\ZldZ ijh^h\hevkl\bygh fhy
`_gZ
khojZgbeZ _]hqlh[u k^_eZlv fg_ih^ZjhdlZd dZd ^mfZeZ
qlh y\hl\hl \_jgmkv ^hfhcD g_kqZklvx\_jgmeky y^Ze_dh
g_ lZdkdhjhb <hedm\ i_jbh^aZi_qZle_gby g_ ddhfm [ueh
ijb\yaZlvky?]h fZe_gvdZyk_kljZ `beZb ^hkbo ihj`b\_l
\ khk_^g_c ^_j_\g_
m ljZdlbjsbdZkljZklgh]h
ex[bl_ey
kh[Zdhkh[_ggh qZmqZm<hed ^h\hevghkdhjh hlukdZek\hx
k_kljm \ jhkdhrghf gh\hf ^hf_ b \\hajZkl_ k_fbf_kyp_\
i_j_k_ebeky lm^ZH^gh\j_f_gghbkihevamy k\hckl\_ggh__fm
gZ^f_ggh_ h[Zygb_hg \l_jky fbgbfmf\ ^\Z^jm]bo ^hfZb
[ueh \j_fydh]^Z q_luj_
k_fvb gZb\gh
kqblZeb
k_[y
_^bgkl\_ggufb ohay_\Zfb wlh]h \_ebdhe_igh]h ikZDh]^Z y
gZdhg_p \_jgmeky^hfhc<hedm bkihegbehkvm`_ ihelhjZ]h^Z
>_j`Zkv kgbf lZdlbqgh bg_gZ\yaqb\hy kmf_e aZ\h_\Zlv_]h
^h\_jb_ gZklhevdhqlh hg ih^h[jhc \he_khijh\h`^Ze f_gy\
^Ze_dbo
ijh]medZoohly
y[_amkeh\ghg_
fh]
]ZjZglbjh\Zlvqlh
_fm
\^jm]
g_
\a[j_^_l \ ]heh\m
jZkklZlvky kh fghc b hlijZ\blvky ihdZdbflh ^jm]bfk\hb
^_eZfHg ihkemrgh[_`Ze aZfhbf \_ehkbi_^hflhevdh _keb
fg_ m^Z\Zehkv aZfZgblv _]h ih^Zevr_<
g_bkke_^h\Zgguo
f_klZodm^Z
kh[ZdZ
g_
aZ[j_^Z_l
\h
\j_fy
k\hbo
kZfhklhyl_evguo
wdkdmjkbc
b
]^_
hgZ
qm\kl\m_l k_[y
m\_j_gghc lhevdh jy^hf kh agZdhfuf q_eh\_dhfhlghr_gby
kh[Zdb d ohaybgm mih^h[ey_lky hlghr_gbx \hedZ d \h`Zdm
klZb\_^ms_fm __ q_j_a qm`mx l_jjblhjbx< j_amevlZl_
q_eh\_d h[j_lZ_l \]eZaZo kh[ZdbklZlmk \hedZ\h`ZdZb y
g_ agZx emqr_]h kihkh[Z aZklZ\blv kh[Zdm ijbagZlv\ \Zk
ohaybgZQ_f f_g__ ijb\uqgZ hdjm`ZxsZy h[klZgh\dZl_f
[he__ l_kguf klZgh\blky dhglZdl f_`^m kh[Zdhc b\ZfbZ
ihlhfm gZb[he__ wnn_dlb\gu
kblmZpbb\ dhlhjuo
kh[ZdZ
hsmsZ_l ihegmx jZkk_ygghklv<havfbl_ \ujhkrmx\ ^_j_\g_
kh[Zdm \ ]hjh^]^_ __m\_j_gghklv \k_[_ [m^_lih^hj\ZgZ
\ha^_ckl\b_f
fgh`_kl\Z
g_agZdhfuo
jZa^jZ`bl_e_c
ljZf\ZyfbZ\lhfh[beyfbg_\_^hfufb
aZiZoZfbqm`bfb
ex^vfbb kZfZy g_ihdhjgZy kh[ZdZ ba kljZoZebrblvky
_^bgkl\_ggh]h ^jm]Z ihc^_ljy^hf k\Zfb dZd\ufmrljh\Zgguc
ihebp_ckdbc i_kDhg_qghg_ ke_^m_l ijb\h^blv
kh[Zdm
lm^Z]^_ hgZ [m^_l bkiulu\Zlv iZgbq_kdbcm`ZklZd dZd
ohly \i_j\uc jZahgZ b ijhy\bl[_amij_qgh_ ihkemrZgb_\h
\lhjhc jZa \u__ lm^Zm`_ g_aZfZgbl_Z ihiuldZgZkbevgh
lZsblv gZ ih\h^d_ kh[Zdm k kbevgufoZjZdl_jhf ijb\_^_ld
j_amevlZlZf ijhlb\hiheh`guf lhfmdhlhjh]h \u^h[b\Z_l_kv
Fg_ m^Zehkv gZklhevdh aZkem`blv m\Z`_gb_ <hedZqlh hg
i_j_[jZeky ba ljZdlbjZd gZfb ijbagZef_gy ohaybghf\
lhf kfuke_qlh khijh\h`^Ze f_gyih\kx^m^Z`_ \ f_klZ_fm
g_ijbylgu_Gh wlbf \k_ b bkq_jiu\ZehkvIhkemrZgb_ [ueh
_fm Z[khexlgh qm`^hb hg ihij_`g_fm qZklhijhiZ^Ze ba
^hfm>h
kZfh]h
ihke_^g_]h
\j_f_gb
hg
j_]meyjgh
hlkmlkl\h\Ze ih km[[hlZf b \hkdj_k_gvyfY aZf_lbe wlh
ihlhfmqlh _]hgbdh]^Z g_hdZau\Zehkv ih^jmdhcdh]^Z fg_
ohl_ehkv ihdZaZlv _]h^jmavyfijb_a`Z\rbf ih]hklblv dgZf
gZ wlb ^gbLZcgZ jZkdjueZkv[ukljh \_q_j km[[hlub \k_
\hkdj_k_gv_ <hed ijh\h^be\ ljZdlbj_Ih\b^bfhfmhg
h[gZjm`beqlh bf_ggh \ wlh \j_fy fh`_ljZkkqblu\Zlv gZ
gZb[he__ eZdhfh_ m]hs_gb_^Z bijbkmlkl\b_ ^\modjZkZ\bp
qZmqZm lh`_\_jhylghjZkiheZ]Zeh _]h qm\kl\h\Zlvk_[y
lZf dZd^hfZ
>h\hevgh ih\_joghklgZy
^jm`[Zk\yau\ZxsZy
f_gy
k
<hedhfkem`bl fg_ g_bklhsbfufbklhqgbdhf ihe_aguo k\_^_gbc
b jZa\e_q_gbyBkke_^h\Zl_ex ikboheh]bb `b\hlguo
djZcg_
bgl_j_kgh bamqZlv kh[Zdmg_ qm\kl\mxsmx k_[y h[yaZgghc
\_jghklvx gbh^ghfm q_eh\_dmZ <hed i_j\Zy kh[ZdZ wlh]h
lbiZk dhlhjhcfg_ ^h\_ehkv[ebadh ihagZdhfblkyB hq_gv
kf_rghdZd \k_ \dexqZy bf_gy kZfh]hdlh agZdhf kwlbf
]hj^uf\eZklguf ikhfqm\kl\mxl k_[yihevs_ggufb_keb hg
\_ebq_kl\_ggh ihqlblbo agZdhfk\h_]h jZkiheh`_gby
HibkZ\ lZdkm
Djhdb b
qZmqZm <hedZdhlhju_
ih
^bZf_ljZevgh ijhlb\hiheh`guf ijbqbgZf g_h[j_eb gZklhys_]h
dhglZdlZ k ohaybghfy i_j_c^md lj_lv_ckh[Zqv_c ebqghklb
b jZkkdZ`mh oZjZdl_j_fh_c h\qZjdbKlZkb< __hlghr_gbb d
ohaybgm kqZkleb\h khq_lZebkv kbevgZy ^_lkdZyaZ\bkbfhklv
ihemq_ggZy hl [Z[mrdb Lblub bkdexqbl_evgZyij_^Zgghklv
\h`ZdmmgZke_^h\ZggZy hlij_^dh\ k\heqv_c djh\vx
KlZkb jh^beZkvm gZk\ ^hf_ jZgg_c\_kghc ]h^Zb
_c [ueh k_fv f_kyp_\dh]^Z y h[ty\be __ k\h_cebqghc
kh[Zdhc b aZgyeky__ \hkiblZgb_f< __\g_rghklbdZd b\
__
l_fi_jZf_gl_g_h[udgh\_ggh
m^Zqgh
khq_lZebkv
hkh[_gghklb g_f_pdbo h\qZjhd
b qZmqZmHkljZy
\heqvy
fhj^Zrbjhdb_ kdmeujZkdhku_ ]eZaZdhjhldb_ imrbklu_
mrbdhjhldbc fhogZluo o\hklZ ]eZ\gh_ m^b\bl_evgh
ieZklbqgu_ b
baysgu_ ^\b`_gby
^_eZeb __
ihoh`_c
gZ
fbgbZlxjgmx \heqbpmLhevdh
h]g_ggZyahehlbklhju`Zy
r_jklv \u^Z\ZeZ \ g_c djh\v rZdZeh\Gh
ihgZklhys_fm
ahehluf m g__ [ue oZjZdl_jHgZ km^b\bl_evghc [ukljhlhc
ihklb]eZ Zau kh[Zqv_]h\hkiblZgby ihkemrgh oh^beZjy^hf
dZd k ih\h^dhflZd b[_a g_]hkZ^beZkv beh`beZkvHgZ
kZfZ gZmqbeZkv kh[ex^Zlv qbklhlm \ ^hf_ b g_
ljh]Zlv
^hfZrgxx ilbpmlZd qlhwlbo ijZ\be_c \gmrZlvg_ ijbrehkv
Ihke_ ^\mo djZldbo f_kyp_\ km^v[Z jZaemqbeZ gZk
k_gly[jy ]h^Z y
m_oZe qblZlv dmjk ikboheh]bb
\
D_gb]k[_j]kdhf mgb\_jkbl_l_jZkklZ\rbkv k k_fv_c^hfhf b
kh[ZdZfbDh]^Z y \_jgmeky gZ jh`^_kl\_gkdb_
dZgbdmeu
KlZkb h[_amf_eZ hl jZ^hklb^hdZau\Zyqlh __
\_ebdZy
ex[h\v dh
fg_ g_
baf_gbeZkvHgZ
ihij_`g_fm
q_ldh
\uihegyeZ dhfZg^udhlhjuf y
__ gZmqbeb \h
\k_o
hlghr_gbyo [ueZlhc `_ kZfhckh[Zdhck dhlhjhc yjZkklZeky
q_luj_ f_kypZgZaZ^Gh dh]^Zy gZqZekh[bjZlvky \ ^hjh]m
jZau]jZehkv g_kdhevdh ljZ]bq_kdbo kp_gFgh]bf ex[bl_eyf
kh[Zdg_khfg_gghkZfbf ijboh^behkv
i_j_`b\Zlv
g_qlh
ih^h[gh_?s_ ^hlh]hdZd y ijbgyekymiZdh\u\Zlv q_fh^Zgu
\b^bfuc agZd
hlt_a^ZKlZkb
aZf_lgh ijbmgueZ
b
hldZau\ZeZkv hlhclbhl f_gyohly [ugZ rZ]Dh]^Z y \uoh^be
ba dhfgZluhgZ k g_j\ghcihki_rghklvx \kdZdb\ZeZb [_`ZeZ
aZ fghckhijh\h`^Zy f_gy ^Z`_ \ \ZggmxdhfgZlmDh]^Z
\_sb [uebmeh`_gu b fhchlt_a^ klZeg_fbgm_fhc j_Zevghklvx
lhkdZ [_^gy`db KlZkb kf_gbeZkv hlqZygb_fihqlb g_\jhahf
HgZ hldZau\ZeZkv _klv__ ^uoZgb_ klZeh g_ghjfZevguf hq_gv g_]em[hdbfi_j_f_`Zxsbfky km^hjh`gufb \a^hoZfbFu
j_rbeb aZi_j_lv__ i_j_^ fhbmoh^hfqlh[u hgZ g_[jhkbeZkv
aZ fghcGhdZd gbkljZgghKlZkbdhlhjZy ihke_^gb_^gb
g_ hklZ\eyeZ f_gygb gZfbgmlmlml \^jm] m[_`ZeZ\ kZ^b
g_ \uoh^beZ gZ fhc ah\Ihkemrg_crZy bakh[Zd \g_aZigh
klZeZ k\h_\hevghcZ ihcfZlv __ fu g_ kmf_ebDh]^Z
gZdhg_p \ khijh\h`^_gbb h[uqghc
k\blu ^_l_c b
jmqghc
l_e_`db k
[Z]Z`hf y
hlijZ\beky gZ
\hdaZerZ]Zo
\
iylb^_kylb aZ gZfb ke_^h\ZeZ kh[ZdZ kZfh]h^bdh]h \b^Z
o\hkl m g__ [ue hims_gr_jklv gZaZ]jb\d_ klhyeZ^u[hf
]eZa k\_jdZeb [_amfb_fY k^_eZe_s_ h^gmihiuldm ihcfZlv
KlZkbgh mf_gy gbq_]h g_ihemqbehkv>Z`_ dh]^Zy \hr_e\
\Z]hghgZ
ijh^he`ZeZ
khojZgylv
\uau\Zxsmx
iham
\a[mglh\Z\r_cky kh[Zdbbijb`Z\ mrbih^hajbl_evgh ke_^beZ
aZ fghck [_ahiZkgh]hjZkklhygbyIh_a^ ljhgmekyZ KlZkb
\k_ _s_ klhyeZ g_ih^\b`ghH^gZdhdh]^Z ih_a^
gZ[jZe
kdhjhklvhgZ \g_aZigh f_lgmeZkv\i_j_^klj_ehc ijhfqZeZkv
\^hev khklZ\Zb \kdhqbeZ\ g_]hgZ ljb\Z]hgZ \i_j_^b lh]h
gZ iehsZ^d_dhlhjh]h y ijh^he`Zeklhylvqlh[u kh]gZlv __\
kemqZ_ g_h[oh^bfhklb< :g]ebb \Z]hgu ih_a^h\ f_klgh]h
ke_^h\Zgby
kgZ[`_gu
k
h[hbo
dhgph\
hq_gv
rbjhdbfb
iehsZ^dZfbY dbgmekyih \Z]hgZf\i_j_^ bko\Zlb\ __aZ
aZ]jb\hd b hkgh\Zgb_ o\hklZk[jhkbe kih_a^Zdhlhjuc d
wlhfm
\j_f_gb
r_e
m`_
hq_gv
[ukljhKlZkb
eh\dh
ijba_febeZkv gZ \k_q_luj_ eZiuGZklhjh`b\ mrbb gZdehgb\
]heh\m\ iha_\ dhlhjhcm`_ g_[ueh gbq_]h\uau\Zxs_]h
hgZ kfhlj_eZ\ke_^ ih_a^mihdZ hgg_ kdjuekyba \b^m
<kdhj_ ihke_ fh_]h\ha\jZs_gby \mgb\_jkbl_l yihemqbe
lj_\h`gu_ ba\_klbyh KlZkbhgZ i_j_^mrbeZ fgh]bokhk_^kdbo
dmjaZ\_eZ ijb\uqdm [_kp_evgh [jh^blv ih hdj_klghklyf
jZamqbeZkv
\_klb
k_[y
\
^hf_
b
g_ `_eZeZ gbdhfm
ih^qbgylvkyHgZ khojZgyeZ p_gghklvlhevdh dZdklhjh`_\Zy
kh[ZdZihlhfm qlh kh ^gy gZ ^_gvklZgh\beZkv \k_[he__
k\bj_ihcIhke_
lh]h dZd
KlZkb kh\_jrbeZ
p_euc
jy^
ij_klmie_gbc\dexqZy g_kdhevdh fZkkh\uo bklj_[e_gbcdmj
djh\hijheblguc gZe_lgZ djhevqZlgbdbgZdhg_pij_\jZs_gb_
\ ehofhlvy[jxd ihqlZevhgZhgZ [ueZgba\_^_gZ ^h iheh`_gby
^\hjh\hc kh[Zdbb \mguehf h^bghq_kl\_ kb^_eZgZ \_jZg^_ m
aZiZ^ghc kl_gu ^hfZLh _klv h^bghdhc hgZ[ueZ lhevdh\
kfuke_ q_eh\_q_kdh]h h[s_kl\ZlZd dZd ^_eZeb [hevrmxb
m^h[gmx dhgmjm
k djZkZ\p_f
^bg]hh
dhlhjhf y
m`_
jZkkdZau\Ze \h \lhjhc ]eZ\_LZdbf h[jZahfk yg\Zjyih
bxgv hgZ ijhkb^_eZ\aZi_jlblhqgh ie_gguc ^bdbca\_jvb
\f_kl_ k^bdbf a\_j_f
<_jgm\rbkv \ :evl_g[_j]\ dhgp_bxgyy kjZam ihr_e\
kZ^ ih\b^Zlvky kh KlZkb?^\Z y gZqZe ih^gbfZlvky
gZ
\_jZg^mdZd KlZkb b ^bg]h [jhkbebkvfg_ gZ\klj_qmk lhc
k\bj_ihklvxgZ dhlhjmx kihkh[gu lhevdh kh[Zdbebr_ggu_
k\h[h^uY
hklZgh\beky gZ
\_jog_c klmi_gvd_Z
hgb
ijb[eb`Zebkv k juqZgb_fb eZ_flZd dZd\_l_j hlghkbefhc
aZiZo \klhjhgmY j_rbeijh\_jblvdh]^Z hgbmagZxl f_gy
ajbl_evghgh ^hwlh]h ^_ehg_ ^hreh<g_aZigh KlZkbmqmyeZ
f_gyb ^Zevg_cr_]h
y gbdh]^Z g_
aZ[m^mhgZ
j_adh
hklZgh\beZkv b aZf_jeZdZd klZlmyR_jklv m g__
gZ
aZ]jb\d_ _s_ klhyeZ ^u[hfmrb _s_[ueb ijb`ZluZ o\hkl
hims_ggh __ gha^jb m`_ rbjhdhjZa^m\Zebkveh\y \_klv
dhlhjmx g_k _c
\_l_jAZl_f
r_jklv e_]eZih
l_em
ijh[_`ZeZ ^jh`vb hgZihklZ\beZ mrb lhjqdhfY ^mfZeqlh
hgZ dbg_lky dh fg_ \g_ k_[y hl \hklhj]Zgh wlh]hg_
ijhbahreh>mr_\gu_
kljZ^Zgbydhlhju_
[ueb
gZklhevdh
bgl_gkb\guqlh baf_gbeb\kx __ebqghklv baZklZ\beb lZdh_
\hkijbbfqb\h_ kms_kl\h gZfgh]h f_kyp_\aZ[ulv \k_ijZ\beZ
ih\_^_gbyg_ fh]eb bkq_agmlv [_a ke_^Z \h^gm k_dmg^m
AZ^gb_ gh]b KlZkb
ih^h]gmebkvfhj^Z aZ^jZeZkv]hjeh
aZ^_j]Zehkvb fgh]hf_kyqgu_fmdb gZrebmoh^ \`mldbo bl_f
g_ f_g__ ij_djZkguoa\mdZo \heqv_]h\hyHgZ \ueZ ^he]h
g_ f_gvr_ ihefbgmluZ ihlhf fhegb_cdbgmeZkv gZf_gyY
hdZaZeky \p_glj_ lZcnmgZ kh[Zqv_cjZ^hklbHgZ iju]ZeZ fg_
gZ ie_qbqmlv g_ khj\ZeZ k f_gy ib^`Zd hgZKlZkb
k^_j`ZggZydhjj_dlgZyh[uqgh
h]jZgbqb\ZxsZyky
k\h_
ijb\_lkl\b_ e_]dbf ihfZob\Zgb_f o\hklZZ ^ey \ujZ`_gby
ex[\b deZ\rZy ]heh\m fg_
gZ dhe_gbg_ [hevr_hgZ
fheqZeb\Zy KlZkbl_i_jv k\bkl_eZdZd iZjh\hab \ba`ZeZ
^Z`_ _s_ [he__ijhgabl_evghq_f fbgmlm gZaZ^\ueZIhlhf
hgZ hliju]gmeZ \klhjhgmih^[_`ZeZ d dZebld_b h]eygmeZkv
gZ f_gy q_j_aie_qhmfheyyqlh[u y__ \uimklbe>ey g__
kZfh kh[hc jZamf_ehkvqlh
k fhbf ijb_a^hf __
Zj_kl
dhgqbeky b hgZ hiylv fh`_l \_klb ij_`gxx `bagvDZd g_
ihaZ\b^h\Zlv
dj_ihklb
wlhc
g_j\ghc
kbkl_fu>mr_\gZy
ljZ\fZ_^\Z __ ijbqbgZ
bkq_aeZg_ hklZ\beZ
gbdZdbo
ke_^h\djhf_ l_o^ey mgbqlh`_gbydhlhjuo ^hklZlhqgh[ueh
ih\ulv
ihefbgmlu
b
ihelhju
fbgmlu
bkihegylv ieykdm
\hklhj]Zihke_ q_]h kh[ZdZ m`_ ]hlh\Z [ueZ\_jgmlvky d
ghjfZevghfm kms_kl\h\Zgbx
Dh]^Z y gZijZ\beky \ ^hf`_gZm\b^_\qlh jy^hfkh
fghc [_`bl KlZkb\kdjbdgmeZ;h`_ fhcDmjuGh KlZkb
^Z`_ g_ \a]eygmeZ gZ dmj<_q_jhfdh]^Z y \aye __\
dhfgZlu`_gZ ij_^mij_^beZ f_gyqlh KlZkb l_i_jv
g_
ke_^bl aZ qbklhlhcH^gZdh fZg_ju KlZkb \gh\v
klZeb
[_amij_qgufbHgZ ihij_`g_fm ihfgbeZ b bkihegyeZ \k_
q_fm y__ h[mqbelh _klv [ueZlhqgh lhc `_kh[ZdhcdZdhc
__ k^_eZeb g_iheguo^\Z f_kypZaZgylbc khfghc< l_q_gb_
^_\ylb f_kyp_\ ]em[hqZcr_c kh[Zqv_c lhkdb hgZ
ij_^Zggh
khojZgyeZ \k_qlh ihemqbeZ hl f_gyB l_i_jv^ey KlZkb
gZqZebkv g_^_eb gbq_f g_ hfjZq_ggh]h[eZ`_gkl\Z<h \j_fy
e_lgbo dZgbdme hgZ [ueZ fh_c g_jZaemqghckimlgbp_cb fu
ihqlb _`_^g_\ghkh\_jrZeb ^ebggu_ijh]medb ih [_j_]m>mgZy
b bgh]^Z b dmiZebkvGh \k_fm gZklmiZ_ldhg_pbdh]^Z
ijbreZ ihjZ miZdh\u\Zlv q_fh^Zgu\hagbdeZ hiZkghklvqlh
m`_ hibkZggZy ljZ]_^by ih\lhjblky \gh\vKlZkb ijblboeZb
mgueh oh^beZ aZfghc ihiylZfGZ k_c jZalhl [_kkihjguc
nZdlqlh kh[ZdZ g_ ihgbfZ_l kfukeZ q_eh\_q_kdbo keh\
klhbe [_^gy`d_ KlZkb g_fZeh fmq_gbcY j_rbe\aylv __k
kh[hcgh g_ fh]h[tykgblv _c wlh]hKdhevdh gb ih\lhjyey
_cqlh g_ [jhrm __hgZ \k_ \j_fyhklZ\ZeZkv \djZcg_
g_j\ghf gZijy`_gbbb g_hloh^beZ hl f_gygb gZ rZ]H^gZdh
ih^ dhg_pfg_ \k_`_ m^Zehkv\u\_klb __ba wlh]h khklhygby
G_aZ^he]h ^h
hlt_a^Z
KlZkb kgh\Z m_^bgbeZkv \
kZ^m
ih\b^bfhfmk l_fb `_gZf_j_gbyfbqlh b\ ijhreuc jZaY
hklZ\be __ \ ihdh_ ^h kZfhc ihke_^g_c fbgmluZ aZl_f
iha\Ze lZdbf ]hehkhfdZdbf h[uqgh a\ZegZ ijh]medmLml
hgZ \k_ihgyeZ b\ \hklhj]_aZiju]ZeZ \hdjm]f_gy
H^gZdh ih[ulv k ohaybghf
KlZkb [ueh km`^_gh
ebrv
g_kdhevdh f_kyp_\ihlhfm qlh \ hdly[j_f_gy ijba\ZebgZ
\h_ggmx kem`[mIjb jZkklZ\Zgbb ih\lhjbeZkv[ueZy ljZ]_^by
k lhclhevdh jZagbp_cqlh KlZkb k[_`ZeZb ^\Z f_kypZ\_eZ
^bdmx `bagv \ ij_^f_klvyokh\_jrZy h^ghij_klmie_gb_ aZ
^jm]bfY l\_j^hm\_j_gqlh bf_ggh hgZ[ueZ lZbgkl\_gghc
ebkbp_chimklhrb\r_c djhevqZlgbd gZ aZ]hjh^ghc
\bee_
h^gh]h fmgbpbiZevgh]h kh\_lgbdZ< dhgp_ ^_dZ[jy KlZkb
om^Zy dZd kd_e_lkh ke_aysbfbky ]eZaZfb b \hkiZe_gguf
ghkhf\_jgmeZkv ^hfhcb fhy`_gZ hdjm`beZ__ aZ[hleb\uf
moh^hfH^gZdh ^_j`Zlv KlZkb\ ^hf_ihke_ lh]hdZd hgZ
ihijZ\beZkvhdZaZehkv
g_\hafh`gufb
__ hlhkeZeb
\
ahhiZjd]^_ hgZ^_ebeZ de_ldmk h]jhfguflZ_`guf \hedhf
dhlhjuc klZe __ kmijm]hfD kh`Ze_gbxwlhl [jZqguckhxa
hdZaZeky [_kieh^gufIha`_dh]^Z yjZ[hlZe g_\jhiZlheh]hf
\ lueh\hf ]hkiblZe_fg_ m^Zehkv \aylv __d k_[_Ihlhf
f_gy hlijZ\beb gZ njhglZ KlZkb b __r_kl_juo s_gyly
hlhkeZe \ <_gm\ R_g[jmggkdbcahhiZjd]^_ \ kZfhfdhgp_
\hcgu hgZ ih]b[eZ \h \j_fy \ha^mrgh]hgZe_lZGh h^bgba
gZrbo Zevl_g[_j]kdbo khk_^_c dmibe __ kugZb \k_gZrb
gug_rgb_ kh[Zdbwlh _]hihlhfkl\hOhly KlZkbijh\_eb kh
k\hbf ohaybghff_gvr_ iheh\bguk\h_c r_klbe_lg_c `bagbhgZ
[ueZ kZfhc
\_jghc kh[Zdhc
ba \k_ok dhlhjufb
fg_
ijboh^behkv bf_lv ^_ehZ fg_ijboh^behkv bf_lv^_eh k
hq_gv [hevrbfqbkehf kh[Zd
H;MQ?GB?
Kms_kl\m_l fgh`_kl\hdgb] h[h[mq_gbb kh[ZdgZibkZgguo
ex^vfb ]hjZa^h [he__ dhfi_l_glgufbq_f yb mf_gy g_l
gZf_j_gby ij_\jZsZlv
wlm ]eZ\m
\ ljZdlZl
h kh[Zqv_f
\hkiblZgbbY ohqm lhevdh ih]h\hjblv h g_kdhevdboe_]dh
ijb\b\Z_fuo
gZ\udZodhlhju_
h[e_]qZxl \aZbfhhlghr_gby
ex[h]h \eZ^_evpZ k _]h ih^hi_qghcH[uqghfm kh\j_f_gghfm
\eZ^_evpm kh[Zdb \jy^eb hdZ`_lkyihe_aguf i_kijbmq_gguc
ih dhfZg^_ [jZlv \hjZbeb ijbghkblvly`_eu_ ij_^f_lu
beb jZaukdb\Zlvihl_jyggu_ \_sbfg_ ohl_ehkv[u kijhkblv
m kqZkleb\h]h ohaybgZ lZdhc mfghc kh[Zdbkdhevdh jZa\
]h^m _]h \_jghfm kimlgbdm ijboh^blky bkihevah\Zlv
k\h_
mf_gb_ gZ ijZdlbd_KZfh]h f_gykh[Zdb gbdh]^Zg_ kiZkZeb
hl ]jZ[bl_e_cb _^bgkl\_gghc fh_ckh[ZdhcdhlhjZy ih^ZeZ
fg_ ij_^f_lh[jhg_gguc gZ mebp_[ueZ fheh^_gvdZykmdZ
\h\k_
g_
h[mq_ggZy
ijbghkblv
ij_^f_luWlh
[ue
bgl_j_kg_crbc kemqZcIb]b ,,^hqv KlZkbljmkb\rZy ihaZ^b
f_gy ih ]hjh^kdhc mebp_\g_aZigh ldgmeZkv ghkhf fg_\
gh]mZ dh]^Zy ih]ey^_egZ g__hgZ ihlygmeZkvfhj^hc d
fh_c jmd_k`bfZy \ am[Zo dh`Zgmx i_jqZldmdhlhjmx y
h[jhgbeG_ agZxqlh hgZ
^mfZeZ \
lm fbgmlm
b
^_ckl\bl_evgh eb khh[jZabeZqlh ij_^f_lmiZ\rbc ihaZ^b
f_gy
b
ijhiblZgguc
fhbf
aZiZohfijbgZ^e_`bl
fg_
JZamf__lkyihke_ wlh]hy gZqZeqZklh l_jylvi_jqZldbgh
Ib]b gb jZam ^Z`_ g_ \a]eygmeZ gZ gboB\h \kydhf
kemqZ_fg_ [ueh [u
bgl_j_kgh magZlvkdhevdh
kh[Zd
h[mq_gguo bkdZlv ihl_jyggh_ohly [ujZa ijbg_kebohaybgm
\_svihl_jyggmx ihgZklhys_fm
< Dhevp_ pZjy KhehfhgZy m`_bkq_jiu\Zxsbf h[jZahf
baeh`be k\hc \a]ey^ gZ ex^_chl^Zxsbo kh[ZdgZ h[mq_gb_
ijhn_kkbhgZevghfm ^j_kkbjh\sbdmLjb mjhdZh dhlhjuo j_qv
ihc^_l gb`_qj_a\uqZcgh ijhklub fh`gh lhevdhm^b\eylvky
lhfmdZd j_^dh \eZ^_evpukh[Zd [_jml gZk_[y ljm^ h[mqblv
k\hbo ikh\wlbf dhfZg^ZfE_`ZlvF_klhb Jy^hf
Gh ij_`^_ yohl_e [uk^_eZlv g_kdhevdhh[sbo aZf_qZgbc
h[ h[mq_gbb kh[Zd
b gZqgm k
\hijhkZ h ihhsj_gbb
b
gZdZaZgbbKqblZlvqlh ihke_^g__ ^_ckl\_gg__i_j\h]h
wlh
]em[hdh_
aZ[em`^_gb_Fgh]b_
we_f_glu
kh[Zqv_]h
\hkiblZgby\ qZklghklb mf_gb_ kh[ex^Zlv qbklhlm\ ^hf_
]hjZa^h emqr_ ihklb]Zxlky [_a ihfhsb gZdZaZgbc>ey lh]h
qlh[u ijbmqblv lhevdh
qlh ijbh[j_l_ggh]h
lj_of_kyqgh]h
s_gdZ d kh[ex^_gbxqbklhluke_^m_l \ l_q_gb_i_j\uo qZkh\
_]h ij_[u\Zgby \\Zr_f ^hf_ihklhyggh ke_^blvaZ gbfb \
lhl fhf_gldh]^Z hgih\b^bfhfm[m^_l ]hlh\aZiylgZlv
ihelhlqZk \ughkblv_]h gZjm`m bklZ\blv gZa_fex \k_]^Z \
h^ghf b lhf `_ f_kl_Dh]^Z hg k^_eZ_llhqlh hlg_]h
lj_[m_lkyiho\Zebl_ _]h b ih]eZ^vl_keh\gh hgkh\_jrbe
]_jhbq_kdbc ihklmihdS_ghdk dhlhjufh[oh^ylky ih^h[guf
h[jZahf\kdhj_ khh[jZ`Z_lqlh
d q_fmb_keb
_]h
j_]meyjgh \u\h^blvm[bjZlv aZgbf [hevr_g_ ihlj_[m_lky
Hq_gv \Z`ghqlh[u gZdZaZgb_ ke_^h\Zeh aZijhklmidhf
g_f_^e_gghG_l gbdZdh]h kfukeZ [blv kh[Zdm ^Z`_ q_j_a
g_kdhevdh fbgmlihke_ lh]hdZd hgZ k^_eZ_lqlhlh g_ lZd
ihkdhevdm hgZ
g_ \
khklhygbb ihgylv
k\yav
kh[ulbc
Hlkjhq_ggh_ gZdZaZgb_
fh`_l [ulv
ihe_aguf lhevdh
^ey
kh[ZdbdhlhjZy ihklhyggh kh\_jrZ_l qlhlh g_^ha\he_gghb
agZ_l wlhDhg_qghba wlh]h ijZ\beZ _klvbkdexq_gby dZdlhdh]^Z h^gZba fhbokh[Zd ihqbklhfm g_\_^_gbxm[beZ
gh\h_ `b\hlgh_ \fh_c dhee_dpbby kimklyg_dhlhjh_ \j_fy
^Ze _c
ihgylvgZkdhevdh
qm^h\bsgh_ ij_klmie_gb_
hgZ
kh\_jrbeZjZaZ ^\Z kbevgh m^Zjb\ __ ljmihfaehihemqghc
`_jl\uGh y hlgx^v g_ klZ\be k_[_p_evx \gmrblvkh[Zd_
ihgylb_ h ij_klmighklb^Zggh]h ^_ygbyb jZkkqblu\Zelhevdh
\ha[m^blv m g__hl\jZs_gb_ dhij_^_e_gghfm h[t_dlmGb`_ y
jZkkdZ`mdZd
fg_ bghc
jZa ijboh^behkv
ijb[_]Zlv
d
ijhnbeZdlbq_kdhfmgZdZaZgbxqlh[u
ijb\blv
kh[ZdZf
m\Z`_gb_ d g_ijbdhkgh\_gghklb
gh\uo qe_gh\ fh_c
`b\hc
dhee_dpbb
Ijbmqblv kh[Zdmd ihkemrZgbxk ihfhsvx gZdZaZgbcg_evay
b klhev`_ [_kkfuke_ggh [blv___kebkh[eZag_ggZy aZiZohf
^bqbhgZ \h\j_fy ijh]medb m[_`blhl \ZkIh[hb g_ hlmqZ_l
__ m[_]Zlvwlh ijhbkr_kl\b_m`_ ^Ze_dhhlh^\bgmehkv \ __
iZfylbZ kdhj__ hlmqZl \ha\jZsZlvkylZd dZd \ __
ij_^klZ\e_gbb hgb [m^ml k\yaZgu bf_ggh k
\ha\jZs_gb_f
?^bgkl\_gguc kihkh[hlmqblv __hl wlhc fZg_juklj_eylv \
g__ ba jh]Zldbdh]^Z hgZaZ^mfZ_l m^jZlv<uklj_e ^he`_g
[ulv ijhba\_^_gg_h`b^Zggh ^ey g__b [m^_lemqr__keb hgZ
g_ aZf_lblqlh dZf_r_dk\Zeb\rbcky gZ g__
g_\_^hfh
hldm^Z[ue ihkeZg jmdhc ohaybgZIhegZy
[_aaZsblghklv
i_j_^ wlhc [hevx ihfh`_l kh[Zd_ ohjhrh__ aZihfgblvb d
lhfm `_wlhl kihkh[g_ \gmrbl_c kljZoZd jmdZf
GZdZau\Zlv kh[ZddZd b ^_l_cfh`gh lhevdhex[ylZd
qlh[u gZdZau\Zxsbc kZf kljZ^Ze hl wlh]hgbqmlv g_f_gvr_
\bgh\gh]h^ey hij_^_e_gby
`_ kl_i_gb gZdZaZgby
gm`gh
ohjhrh agZlv bihgbfZlv kh[ZdmJZagu_ kh[Zdb\hkijbgbfZxl
gZdZaZgb_ ihjZaghfmb ^ey g_j\gh]h\i_qZlebl_evgh]h ikZ
e_]dbc re_ihd fh`_l agZqblv ]hjZa^h[hevr_q_f gZklhysZy
ihjdZ ^ey _]h[he__ mjZ\gh\_r_ggh]hb ne_]fZlbqgh]h[jZlZ
A^hjh\Zy kh[ZdZ gZ j_^dhklv g_qm\kl\bl_evgZd nbabq_kdhfm
\ha^_ckl\bxb
jmdhc
_c
ihqlb
g_\hafh`gh ijbqbgblv
gZklhysmx [hev_keb lhevdhg_ [blv__ ihghkmFhy h\qZjdZ
LblZ hlebqZeZkv [hevrhckbehcb ihke_ \hagbk g_cydZd
ijZ\beh[u\Ze \_kv \kbgydZo<h \j_fyb]ju y fh]m^Zjblv
__ dmeZdhfigmlvj_adh kljyogmlv gZ a_fexdh]^Z hgZ
ih\bkZeZ m f_gy
gZ jmdZ\_gh
hgZ kqblZeZ \k_
wlh
m\e_dZl_evghc aZ[Z\hc^Z\Z\r_c _c ijZ\h hlieZqb\Zlvfg_
klhjbp_cH^gZdh_keb y m^Zjye__ g_\ rmldmZ \k_jv_a
imklv
kh\k_f
e_]hgvdhhgZ
\a\ba]b\ZeZ
b
lhkdeb\h
aZfudZeZkv \k_[_
Dh]^Z \ h^ghckh[Zd_ kh_^bgyxlkynbabq_kdZy b^mr_\gZy
qm\kl\bl_evghklvdZdgZijbf_jm kiZgb_e_ck_ll_jh\ b
koh^guo k gbfbihjh^l_e_kgu_ gZdZaZgby gZ^hijbf_gylv k
\_ebqZcr_c hkfhljbl_evghklvxbgZq_ kh[Zdm e_]dh
kh\k_f
aZim]ZlvlZd qlh hgZ klZg_l jh[dhcg_m\_j_gghc \k_[_
kdmqghc b \ dhgp_ dhgph\ gZ\k_]^Z ijhgbdg_lkykljZohf d
jmdZf<h \j_fyfhbo wdki_jbf_glh\ih kdj_sb\Zgbxg_f_pdbo
h\qZjhd kqZmqZm \uykgbehkvqlh hkh[_ggh \gZqZe_dh]^Z
djh\v h\qZjdb _s_ ij_h[eZ^Z_ldjZcghklb oZjZdl_jZhl
fy]dh]hb \i_qZlebl_evgh]h^h kh\_jr_ggh[_kqm\kl\_ggh]h
qZklh jZkij_^_eyxlkykj_^b ihlhfkl\Z[_a \kydhckbkl_fu
KlZkb [ueZ g_h[uqZcgh^mr_\gh dj_idhckh[Zdhcgh __
^hqv Ib]b hdZaZeZkviheghc __ijhlb\hiheh`ghklvxB \ l_o
kemqZyodh]^Z hgb h[_ koh^beb kmadhc ljhiu^h[jh^_l_eb
gZijbf_jqmlv g_ jZahj\ZebihiheZf fZevlbckdh]h l_jv_jZ
ijhoh`b_
g_]h^h\Zeb
gZ
fhx
y\gmx
ijbkljZklghklv
b
g_kijZ\_^eb\hklvlZd dZd y kmjh\h oe_klZe fZlvZ ^hqv
hlimkdZeh]jZgbqb\rbkv re_idhf bkljh]bf \u]h\hjhfL_f g_
f_g__ h[_kh[Zdb ihemqZebjZ\gh_ gZdZaZgb_
Ex[h_ gZdZaZgb_ kh[Zdb^_ckl\_ggh g_klhevdh [eZ]h^Zjy
k\yaZgghc kgbf [hebkdhevdh ihlhfmqlh hgh ^_fhgkljbjm_l
\eZklv b kbem gZdZau\Zxs_]hB ^ey lh]hqlh[u gZdZaZgb_
ijbg_keh ihevamkh[ZdZ ^he`gZ \hkijbgylv _]hbf_ggh dZd
ijhy\e_gb_ \eZklbIhkdhevdm kh[ZdbdZd bh[_avyguijb
mklZgh\e_gbb b_jZjobq_kdh]h ihjy^dZg_ [vxlZ dmkZxl^jm]
^jm]Z[blv_\
kmsghklbhdZau\Z_lky
g_
kebrdhf
wnn_dlb\ghc bg_ kebrdhfihgylhc dZjhc
H^bg bafhbo klZjuo agZdhfuoh[gZjm`beqlh e_]dbc mdmk
\ ij_^ie_qv_^Z`_ g_
hklZ\eyxsbc jZgijhba\h^bl
gZ
h[_avygm dm^Z[hevr__ \i_qZle_gb_q_f kZfu_`_klhdb_ ih[hb
>jm]h_ ^_ehdhg_qghqlh g_ \kydhfm ihgjZ\blvkydmkZlv
h[_avygmH^gZdh \ hlghr_gbb kh[Zd dZjZl_evgu_
f_lh^u
\h`ZdZ ^hklmigu dZ`^hfmq_eh\_dm b\ hlebqb_hl ih[h_\g_
lj_[mxl gZkbebygZ^ kh[hckh[Zdm gZ^hih^gylv aZ rb\hjhlb
ohjhr_gvdh \kljyogmlv;he__ kmjh\h]h gZdZaZgby^ey kh[Zdb
y g_agZxb hghg_baf_ggh ijhba\h^blgZ gZjmrbl_ey aZdhgZ
b
ihjy^dZ
kZfh_
kbevgh_
\i_qZle_gb_<
j_Zevghc
^_ckl\bl_evghklb \h`Zdkihkh[guc
ih^gylv b
\kljyogmlv
kh[Zdm
jhklhf
k
h\qZjdm^he`_g
[ulv
\_ebdZghf
k\_jo\h`Zdhfb bf_ggh
lZd \hkijbgbfZ_l kh[ZdZ
k\h_]h
ohaybgZ \ fhf_glgZdZaZgbyOhlygZ gZr\a]ey^ih^h[gZy
dZjZ dZ`_lky f_g__ kljh]hcq_f ih[hbgZghkbfu_ oeuklhf
beb ljhklvx__ ^Z`_ kh\ajhkeufb kh[ZdZfbke_^m_l imkdZlv
\ oh^ hq_gvhklhjh`gh_keb fu g_ohlbf kh\k_fkehfblv bo
^mo
AZgbfZykv ex[uf \b^hf h[mq_gbylj_[mxsbf hl kh[Zdb
Zdlb\gh]h mqZklbydZdgZijbf_jiju`dbih^ZqZ ij_^f_lZb
lhfm ih^h[gh_gZ^h ihfgblvqlh b kZfZyemqrZy kh[ZdZ g_
h[eZ^Z_l q_eh\_q_kdbf khagZgb_f ^he]ZZ ihlhfm\ hlebqb_
^Z`_ hl fZe_gvdbo^_l_c [m^_lkhljm^gbqZlv k\Zfb ebrv^h
l_o ihjihdZ jZ[hlZ_c gjZ\blkyIhwlhfm gZdZaZgb_lml g_
lhevdh g_e_ihgh ^Z`_ \j_^ghlZd dZdhgh fh`_l\gmrblv
kh[Zd_
g_ij_oh^ys__
hl\jZs_gb_
bf_ggh
d
wlhfm \b^m
^_yl_evghklbLhevdh ijb\uqdZ aZklZ\ey_l ohjhrhh[mq_ggmx
kh[Zdm ijbghkblv aZcpZb^lb
ih mdZaZgghfm ke_^m
beb
iju]Zlv q_j_a ij_iylkl\b_dh]^Z hgZ g_ \gZkljh_gbb
IhwlhfmihdZ kh[ZdZ _s_ g_ ijbh[j_eZijb\uqdb \uihegylv
hij_^_e_ggmx
dhfZg^mg_h[oh^bfhhkh[_ggh
\
gZqZe_
h[mq_gbyh]jZgbqb\Zlv
mjhd
g_kdhevdbfb
fbgmlZfb
b
g_f_^e_ggh ij_djZsZlv _]h_keb bgl_j_k kh[Zdb gZqbgZ_l
m]ZkZlvH[mqZ_fhfm
`b\hlghfm
g_h[oh^bfh
ex[hc p_ghc
\gmrblvqlh _]hg_ lhevdhg_ aZklZ\eyxlqlheb[h ^_eZlv
ZgZh[hjhliha\heyxl _fm\uihegblv ^Zggh_mijZ`g_gb_
<djZlp_ h[km^b\ h[sb_ ijbgpbiu h[mq_gby\_jg_fky d
lj_f dhgdj_lguf gZ\udZfdhlhju_ g_h[oh^bfhijb\blv ex[hc
kh[Zd_=eZ\guc ba gbogZ fhc \a]ey^[_kij_dhkeh\gh_
\uiheg_gb_ dhfZg^u E_`Zlv[eZ]h^Zjy wlhfmgZ\udm ex[Zy
kh[ZdZ klZgh\blky
ijbylg__ b
ihe_ag__Kh[ZdZ
^he`gZ
gZmqblvky eh`blvky ihdhfZg^_ bg_ \klZ\Zlv[_a jZaj_r_gby
lZdh_ mf_gb_h[_ki_qb\Z_l _cfgh]h ij_bfms_kl\\eZ^_e_p
fh`_l kihdhcgh ihdbgmlv__ \ex[hf f_kl_gZijbf_ji_j_^
^\_jvx fZ]ZabgZ beb mqj_`^_gbylZd qlh hgZ
ihemqZ_l
\hafh`ghklv khijh\h`^Zlv _]h ihqlb ih\kx^mb __
ebrv
baj_^dZ
ijboh^blky
hklZ\eylv
^hfZqlh
^ey bklbggh
ij_^Zgghc kh[Zdb y\ey_lky om^rbf bag_kqZklbc?s_ \Z`g__
\hkiblZl_evgZy p_gghklvwlhc dhfZg^ulZd dZd __\uiheg_gby
hagZqZ_l kms_kl\_ggh_ jZa\blb_ ijb\uqdb dihkemrZgbx>ey
kh[Zdb g_lZd ijhklh ih^Z\blv`_eZgb_ ke_^h\ZlvaZ ohaybghf
b hklZlvky
h^ghc \
dZdhfgb[m^v g_ijb\uqghf
f_kl_ \uiheg_gb_ wlhc dhfZg^u jZ\ghkbevgh\uiheg_gbx g_ijbylgh]h
^he]ZIhwlhfm dhfZg^u <klZlvb Dh fg_\hkijbgbfZxlky
dZd kqZkleb\h_ ba[Z\e_gb_b \j_amevlZl_ ijboh^ gZ ah\
ij_\jZsZxlky
ba
jZ[hlu
\
m^h\hevkl\b_Hq_gv qZklh
aZklZ\blv iehoh ih^^Zxsmxky kh[Zdm b^lb gZ ah\ m^Z_lky
lhevdh q_j_a ijhf_`mlhqgmx klZ^bx h[mq_gby e_`ZlvW]hg
;hcg_[mj]h^bg ba emqrbo ^j_kkbjh\sbdh\ kh[ZddZdbo y
lhevdh agZxijb h[mq_gbb hohlgbqvbokh[Zd khkj_^hlhqb\Ze
mkbeby bf_ggh gZdhfZg^_ E_`ZlvZ g_gZ Dh fg_Hg
jZajZ[hlZe f_lh^ hklZgh\d_\ jZa]ZjljZ\eb ^eyl_o kh[Zd
dhlhju_ \ h[uqguo mkeh\byo [ueb ihkemrgugh hdZau\Zebkv
klhev ZaZjlgufb
hohlgbdZfbqlh]hgyykv aZ
^h[uq_c
ih\bgh\Zebkv k\h_ckljZklbZ g_k\bkldm ohaybgZ>h[b\Zeky
hg wlh]hijbmqZy kh[Zd ih dhfZg^_ E_`Zlvij_ju\Zlv
ex[mx ^_yl_evghklv b ^Z`_
]hghgb eh`bebkv b
`^Zeb
jZkihjy`_gby Dh fg_Dh]^Z kh[ZdZ[jhkZeZkv ij_ke_^h\Zlv
^bqv;hcg_[mj] g_ ijh[h\Ze __ hlha\ZlvZ ijhklhdjbqZe
]jhfdhE_`Zlv<af_lu\Zehkv h[eZdhiuebih^gylhc j_adh
aZlhjfhab\rbfb eZiZfbZ dh]^Z hgh jZkk_b\Zehkvajbl_eb
\b^_eb ihkemrghme_]rmxky kh[Zdm
H[mq_gb_
dhfZg^_
E_`ZlvgZklhevdh
ijhklhqlh
^hklmigh
^Z`_
ex^yf\hh[s_
ebr_gguf
kihkh[ghklb
^j_kkbjh\sbdZGZqbgZlv
_]h ke_^m_l
f_`^m k_^vfuf
b
h^bggZ^pZluf f_kypZfb `bagb kh[Zdb\ aZ\bkbfhklb hl__
ihjh^uKebrdhf jZgg__ gZqZeh
gb d q_fm ohjhr_fm
g_
ijb\_^_llZd dZd g_evay lj_[h\Zlvhl ih^\b`gh]h\_k_eh]h
s_gdZqlh[u hg ih dhfZg^_ eh`bekyb khojZgyeZ[khexlgmx
g_ih^\b`ghklvDh]^Z `_
hg ih^jZklZ_l b
hkl_i_gy_lky
h[mqZxsbc klZedb\Z_lky k ]hjZa^h f_gvrbf khijhlb\e_gb_f
Mjhdb ke_^m_l gZqbgZlvgZ fy]dhckmohc a_fe_gZijbf_j aZ
r_x b dj_kl_p b e_]hgvdh ijb`bfZlv d a_fe_ih\lhjyy
E_`ZlvE_`Zlvbeb dZdh_gb[m^v ^jm]h_
ih^oh^ys__
keh\h< i_j\ucjZa\hafh`ghijb^_lky ijbf_gblvb kbem
H^gb kh[Zdb hq_gv [ukljh ihgbfZxlqlh hlgbo lj_[m_lky
^jm]b_ g_ kjZamlj_lvb `_ [m^ml klhylv hdhkl_g_\b
gZqgml jZa[bjZlvky\ kblmZpbblhevdh dh]^Zbf kbehc kh]gml
aZ^gb_Z ihlhfi_j_^gb_ gh]b
WlZ
ij_^\Zjbl_evgZy
ih^]hlh\dZ
fh`_l
ihdZaZlvky
ihklhjhgg_fm
gZ[ex^Zl_ex
g_kdhevdh
dhfbqghcgh
ihjZabl_evghdZd fZeh ih\lhj_gbclj_[m_lky ^ey lh]hqlh[u
kh[ZdZ ihgyeZq_]h hl g__ ohlylb gZqZeZeh`blvky ih
dhfZg^_ kZfZB kjZam `_ ke_^m_l ij_iylkl\h\Zlv kh[Zd_
\klZ\Zlv_keb
_c \a^mfZ_lky
k^_eZlv wlh
^h
ih^Zqb
khhl\_lkl\mxs_c dhfZg^uJZa^_eylv wlb ^\Z fhf_glZf_`^m
jZagufb mjhdZfbg_ijZ\bevghGm`gh klhylv\iehlgmx dkh[Zd_
b qmlvqmlv ihdZqb\Zlv iZevp_fi_j_^ __ ghkhfqlh[u m g__
g_ [ueh \hafh`ghklb \kdhqblv gZ gh]bAZl_f \u\g_aZigh
ah\_l_Dh fg_hl[_]Z_l_ gZg_kdhevdh rZ]h\b eZkdZ_l_
kh[Zdm beb
b]jZ_l_ k
g_c \
gZ]jZ^m aZ
lhevdh qlh
i_j_g_k_ggh_
bkiulZgb_?keb
kh[ZdZ
ijhy\bl ijbagZdb
mklZehklb b gZqg_l klhjhgblvky ohaybgZklZjZykv ba[_`Zlv
ih\lhj_gbc mijZ`g_gbcmjhd ke_^m_l ij_j\Zlvb hleh`blv^h
ke_^mxs_]h ^gy<j_fy ij_[u\Zgby \ e_`Zq_c iha_ke_^m_l
m\_ebqb\Zlv
hq_gv
ihkl_i_gghb
h[mqZxs_fm lj_[m_lky
g_fZeuc lZdlqlh[u gZclb
kqZkleb\mx k_j_^bgm
f_`^m
baebrg_c kljh]hklvxb qj_af_jghceZkdh\hklvx
Mjhd gbdh]^Zg_ ke_^m_l ij_\jZsZlv\ b]jmb]jZ ^he`gZ
hklZ\Zlvky gZ]jZ^hc aZmki_ob gb\ dh_fkemqZ_ g_evay
iha\heylv s_gdm \ hl\_l gZ dhfZg^mrZeh\eb\h \ZeblvkygZ
kibgmK ^jm]hc klhjhgugm`gh \gbfZl_evghke_^blvqlh[u
kh[ZdZ g_ ijhgbdeZkv hl\jZs_gb_f dh\k_c ijhp_^mj_Dh]^Z
kh[ZdZ gZmqblky ihkemrgh e_`Zlv g_kdhevdhfbgmlgZ^h jZa
hl jZamihkl_i_ggh hloh^blvhl g__\gZqZe_ lZdqlh[u hgZ
ijh^he`ZeZ \Zk\b^_lvZ dh]^ZhgZ hk\hblkyk wlbffZg_\jhf
gZklhevdhqlh [m^_lkhojZgylv k\hxiham bg_kdhevdh fbgml
kimkly ihke_lh]hdh]^Z ohaybghlhc^_lfh`gh mclb kh\k_f
Wlh bkiulZgb_ _c [m^_l e_]q_ i_j_g_klb_keb \uhklZ\bl_
\hae_ g__ dZdmxgb[m^v k\hx \_svb ^Z`_ g_ h^gmQ_f
[hevr_ bo [m^_l b q_f hgb [m^ml djmig__l_f kihdhcg__
kh[ZdZ [m^_l
k_[y qm\kl\h\Zlv?keb \aylv
kh[Zdm
\
lmjbklkdbc ihoh^ bhklZ\blv __\hae_ iZeZldbkh kiZevgufb
f_rdZfbhgZ ^Z`_\ kZfhfgZqZe_ h[mq_gbyhklZg_lky \hae_
gbo gZ dZdh_ m]h^gh \j_fyl_ji_eb\h h`b^Zy\ha\jZs_gby
ohaybgZIjb
ihiuld_
qm`h]h
q_eh\_dZ
ihky]gmlv
gZ
dZdmxgb[m^v \_svkh[ZdZ ijb^_l \yjhklvgh g_ ihlhfmqlh
qm\kl\m_l k_[y h[yaZgghc aZsbsZlv ohayckdh_ bfms_kl\hZ
ihlhfm
qlh
wlb
\_sbijhiblZggu_
aZiZohf
ohaybgZ
kbf\hebabjmxl ^ey
g__ ^hf
b ]ZjZglbjmxl
\ha\jZs_gb_
ohaybgZ<hl ihq_fm hgZk_j^blky_keb dlhlh ihiulZ_lky
bo mg_klbG_j_^dh fh`gh m\b^_lv
kh[ZdmdZd
[m^lh
hojZgyxsmx ihjln_ev k\h_]h ohaybgZh^gZdh ikboheh]bq_kdh_
h[tykg_gb_ wlhc kblmZpbb kh\k_f
g_ lZdh\hdZd
fh`_l
ihdZaZlvky gZ i_j\uc \a]ey^Ihjln_ev \ khagZgbbkh[Zdb
y\ey_lky dZd [u kbf\hehf ^hfZZ ohaybghklZ\be a^_kvg_
kh[Zdm klhjh`blv ihjln_evZ gZh[hjhl ihjln_evqlh[u
ihf_rZlv kh[Zd_mclb
Ijb lZdhf h[mq_gbbhkh[_ggh
_keb hgh ijhoh^bl
\
f_klghklbdhlhjZy kh[Zd_ g_agZdhfZhq_gv \Z`gh ohjhr_gvdh
h[^mfZlv]^_ bf_ggh ijbdZaZlv kh[Zd_ e_qvB ij_`^_q_f
hl^Zlv dhfZg^mke_^m_l ijbdbgmlvdZdh_ f_klhba[jZeZ [u
kZfZ kh[ZdZ_keb [uhgZ ohl_eZ ijbe_qvhl^hogmlv;ueh [u
`_klhdh mdeZ^u\Zlv kh[ZdmgZ kh\_jr_gghhldjulhc ljhi_ih
dhlhjhc
qZklh
ijhoh^yl
ex^b\
__
]eZaZo
[he__
g_ih^oh^ys_]h f_klZ ^ey hl^uoZ gZclb g_\hafh`ghb hgZ
[m^_l bkiulu\ZlvlZdb_ ^mr_\gu_fmq_gbygh \lh `_\j_fy k
m^h\hevkl\b_f
ey`_l
\
dZdhfgb[m^v
lbohf
m]hed_
ij_^ihqlbl_evgh
ohjhrh
mdjulhfgZijbf_j
ih^ kZ^h\hc
kdZf_cdhcWlh ijZ\beh lj_[m_lkljh]h]h kh[ex^_gbylZd dZd
e_`ZlvaZ^ZqZ hq_gv g_e_]dZyb ^ey __ \uiheg_gby
kh[Zd_
lj_[m_lky
k^_eZlv
gZ^
kh[hc
[hevrh_ mkbeb_
JZamf__lkymf_eh_ b \f_jm kljh]h_ h[mq_gb_lZdh]h jh^Z hlgx^v g_ `_klhdhklvih hlghr_gbxd kh[Zd_gZh[hjhlhgh
ijb\h^bl d h[h]Zs_gbx __ `bagblZd dZdohjhrh h[mq_ggZy
kh[ZdZ ihemqZ_l \hafh`ghklv khijh\h`^Zlv k\h_]h
ohaybgZ
ihqlb \kx^m?keb kh[ZdZ
bkdexqbl_evgh mfgZkljh]b_
ijZ\beZ h[mq_gby fh`gh kh \j_f_g_f g_kdhevdh
kfy]qblv
KlZkbij_\hkoh^gh \eZ^_\rZybkdmkkl\hf e_`Zlvij_djZkgh
agZeZqlh y \h\k_ g_
ohqmqlh[u hgZklhjh`Z
fhc
\_ehkbi_^b \ kZfhf^_e_ khojZgyeZ dZf_ggmxg_ih^\b`ghklv
dZd lh]h lj_[m_l [md\Z aZdhgZIh dhfZg^_hgZ eh`beZkvb
g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy hklZ\ZeZkv \ wlhciha_h^gZdhg_aZf_lgh
ih]ey^u\Zy aZg_c \hdghy \b^_eqlh ihlhfhgZ \klZ\ZeZb
gZqbgZeZ ijhoZ`b\ZlvkyijZ\^Z g_ hl^Zeyykvhl \_ehkbi_^Z
[hevr_ q_f gZf_lj^\Z?keb `_ fureb kg_c \]hklb by
ijbdZau\Ze _ce_qv \ m]emdhfgZluhgZ gbdh]^Z g_\klZ\ZeZ
>jm]bfb keh\ZfbhgZ ij_djZkgh ihgbfZeZk dZdhcdhgdj_lgh
p_evx hl^Z\ZeZkv_c wlZdhfZg^Z b \lhf b \^jm]hf kemqZ_
<
dhgp_
dhgph\
fu
kh\k_f
g_ijhba\hevgh
\ujZ[hlZeb
ke_^mxsbc dhfijhfbkkihemqb\ ijbdZae_`Zlvdh]^Z jy^hfg_
[ueh fh_]h \_ehkbi_^Zbeb ihjln_eyKlZkb `^ZeZf_gy hdheh
^_kylb fbgmlZ ihlhf_keb y g_ ihy\eyeky\klZ\ZeZ b
hlijZ\eyeZkv ^hfhc kZfhklhyl_evghgh jy^hfk fhbfb\_sZfb
hgZ_keb [uihgZ^h[behkvijh^h`^ZeZ [u f_gy^h kdhgqZgby
\_dZ
KlZkb ^hklb]eZ lZdh]hkh\_jr_gkl\Z \bkdmkkl\_ e_`Zlv
b hojZgylvqlhdZd wlhgb g_\_jhylghkZfZ j_rZeZdh]^Z
_c ke_^m_l aZgylv klhjh`_\hc ihkl< ^gb fh_cjZ[hlu \
]hkiblZe_ hgZ ijbg_keZ s_gylhlphf dhlhjuo [ue
^bg]h
ihke_ lh]h
dZd __
khxa k
lZ_`guf \hedhf
hdZaZeky
[_kieh^guf_c ij_^eh`beb \ kmijm]b ^bg]hFhc agZdhfuc
^hdlhj h^he`be fg_Z \_jg__ _cdhgmjm k\h_ch\qZjdb
dhlhjmxd g_kqZklvxmdjZebLjb ^gy KlZkb ijh\_eZ \
dhgmj_ kh s_gylZfbGZ q_l\_jluc^_gv\uc^y ba]hkiblZey
y h[gZjm`beqlh hgZ e_`bl \hae_ fh_]h \_ehkbi_^Z<k_
ihiuldb hlijZ\blv__ gZaZ^d ^_lyf l_ji_ebg_m^ZqmhgZ \h
qlh [u lh gb klZeh `_eZeZ \_jgmlvky gZ ^_ckl\bl_evgmx
kem`[m>\Z`^u \ ^_gv hgZ m[_]ZeZ ihdhjfblv s_gylgh
q_j_a iheqZkZ \gh\v aZgbfZeZ
k\hc ihkl jy^hf k
fhbf
\_ehkbi_^hf
<lhjZy dhfZg^ZF_klhkhhl\_lkl\m_l ihk\h_c kmlb
dhfZg^_ E_`Zlvgh ijbf_gy_lky ^hfZZ g_ gZmebp_
G_j_^dh kemqZ_lkyqlh h[s_kl\h kh[Zdb \Zf f_rZ_l b\u
ohlbl_ gZ \j_fyba[Z\blvky hlg__IjbdZa IhreZ \hgg_
kihkh[gZ ihgylv gbh^gZ ^Z`_kZfZy mfgZykh[ZdZihkdhevdm
\hgihgylb_ Z[kljZdlgh_ b^ey g__g_ihklb`bfh_Kh[Zd_
g_h[oh^bfh
dhgdj_lgh
h[tykgblvdm^Z
bf_ggh
\u
__
hlkueZ_l_B f_klhwlh q_ldhhij_^_e_ggh_ f_klhdm^Z
kh[ZdZ ^he`gZ
moh^blv ih
dhfZg^_ b
]^_ hgZ
^he`gZ
hklZ\Zlvky ^h l_o ihjihdZ _cg_ jZaj_rZl_]h ihdbgmlv
Emqr_ hklZgh\blv k\hc\u[hj gZlhf m]hed_dhlhjuc kh[ZdZ
ij_^ihqblZ_llm^Z hgZ \k_]^Z ihc^_l hohlg__>_lb b
kh[Zdbbf_xsb_ ijb\uqdm \f_rb\Zlvky \jZa]h\hju \ajhkeuo
ex^_cfZeh dhfm gjZ\ylkyb kh[ZdZmf_xsZy hklZ\eylv
ex^_c \
ihdh_g_khfg_ggh
[m^_l ihevah\Zlvky
h[sbfb
kbfiZlbyfbLh `_hlghkblky bd ^_lyf
Lj_lbc gZ\udkihkh[kl\mxsbc ij_\jZs_gbx
kh[Zdb
\
ijbylgh]h kimlgbdZg_ ijbqbgyxs_]h hkh[uo oehihlwlh
mf_gb_ b^lb jy^hfD g_kqZklvxwlh mf_gb_^_eZxs__
baebrgbf
ih\h^hd
^ey
ohjhrh
\hkiblZgghc
kh[Zdb
ijbh[j_lZ_lky k aZf_lgh [hevrbf ljm^hfq_f ^\ZgZ\udZ
hibkZgguo \ur_b ijb hlkmlkl\bbqZkluo ih\lhj_gbc\kdhj_
fh`_l [ulvaZ[ulhH[mq_gb_ kh[Zdbb^lb jy^hfk\h^blky d
lhfmqlh[u aZklZ\blv__ b^lb\hae_ ijZ\hcbeb e_\hcgh]b
ohaybgZ gh]Z ^he`gZ[ulv \k_]^Z h^ghcb lhc`_ijb wlhf
__ fhj^Z g_^he`gZ \u^\b]Zlvky\i_j_^Z kdhjhklv^\b`_gby
\k_
\j_fy
^he`gZ
khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv
kdhjhklb
^\b`_gby
ohaybgZ<uihegyy wlh mijZ`g_gb_kh[Zdb j_^dhiulZxlky
hklZ\blvbgZh[hjhl[hevrbgkl\h ba gbodZd ijZ\beh
\uju\Zxlky \i_j_^
hrb[dZdhlhjmx gZ^h
bkijZ\eylv
g_f_^e_gghkbevgh ^_jgm\ ih\h^hd beb oehigm\ kh[Zdmih
ghkmDZ`^uc jZadh]^Z ohaybgih\hjZqb\Z_lkh[ZdZ ^he`gZ
lZd`_ ih\_jgmlvemqr_ \k_]h wlh ^hklb]Z_lky
ke_^mxsbf
h[jZahfgZ^h ke_]dZ gZdehgblvkyb ih\_jgmlv]heh\m kh[Zdb
\ gm`gmxklhjhgm jmdhck\h[h^ghc hlih\h^dZ
JZ[hlZ lj_[m_ll_ji_gvy G_ lhevdhagZgvy bmf_gvy
Ij_`^_ q_f kh[ZdZgZmqblky b^lbjy^hf__ ijboh^blky
hq_gv ^he]h lj_gbjh\ZlvgZ ih\h^d_Lml ke_^m_lhljZ[hlZlv
^\_ dhfZg^u ijbdZaZgb_ b^lbjy^hfb jZaj_r_gb_hlhclb
bgZ fhc \a]ey^\lhjh_ agZqbl_evghljm^g__DhgljijbdZa
e_`Zs_c kh[Zd_ Dh fg__c ohjhrhihgyl_gb hgZ\kdhj_
\umqb\Z_lky g_ ^\b]ZlvkyihdZ _]hg_ mkeurblGh dhfZg^Z
<i_j_^jZaj_rZxsZy
kh[Zd_
hlhclb
hl
ohaybgZ
_kl_kl\_gghg_ lZdihgylgZ< gZqZe_ h[mq_gbyemqr_ \k_]h
hklZgh\blvkykdZaZlv <i_j_^b ih^h`^ZlvihdZ kh[ZdZg_
^\bg_lky \i_j_^Kh[Zd_ gb\ dh_fkemqZ_ g_evay jZaj_rZlv
hloh^blv \ klhjhgm ih kh[kl\_gghc bgbpbZlb\_bgZq_ hgZ
j_rblqlh _c wlh ^ha\he_ghb l_fkZfuf \agZqbl_evghc
kl_i_gb [m^mlk\_^_gu gZg_l m`_^hklb]gmlu_ j_amevlZlu
?s_ h^gZ ljm^ghklvaZdexqZ_lky \lhfqlh mfgZykh[ZdZ
hq_gv kdhjh gZqbgZ_ljZa[bjZlvkygZ^_l gZ g__ih\h^hd beb
g_lb qZklh b]ghjbjm_l dhfZg^udh]^Z _]hk g__\i_j\u_
kgbfZxlIhwlhfm k kZfh]hgZqZeZ kh[Zdmke_^m_l ijbmqblv
d madhfm e_]dhfm ih\h^dmdhlhjuc hgZijZdlbq_kdb hsmsZ_l
lhevdh \ lhl fhf_glZdh]^Z _]h j_adh ^_j]ZxlKh[ZdZ
ih\b^bfhfmg_ \khklhygbb ihgylvlml ijbqbggmxk\yav \h
\kydhf kemqZ_\ gZqZe_ h[mq_gby KlZkb\uihegyeZ dhfZg^m
Jy^hf\k_]^Zdh]^Z gZ g_c [ueih\h^hdg_aZ\bkbfh hl
lh]h^_j`Ze y
_]h beb g_l
b dZdh_ jZkklhygb_
gZk
jZa^_eyeh;_a ih\h^dZ hgZqm\kl\h\ZeZ k_[yk\h[h^ghcb
g_ \uihegyeZdhfZg^u>Z`_ ohjhrhh[mq_ggmx kh[Zdm ke_^m_l
\j_fy hl \j_f_gb\h^blv gZih\h^d_ ^ey hk\_`_gbyiZfylb
< p_ehfh^gZdhdZd k dhfZg^hc E_`Zlvg_ ke_^m_l\
dZ`^hf kemqZ_ lj_[h\Zlv
h[yaZl_evgh]h \uiheg_gby
[md\u
aZdhgZ ijbmkeh\bbqlh kh[ZdZ\h \k_fohjhrh jZah[jZeZkvb
\uihegy_l dhfZg^m
[_amij_qghKlZkb
_s_ s_gdhf
qZklh
aZ[u\ZeZ kfuke dhfZg^uJy^hfgh \ wlhfg_ [uehgbq_]h
kljZrgh]hlZd dZd g_h[oh^bfhklv \ dhfZg^_\kdhj_ \hh[s_
hliZeZ\ khhl\_lkl\mxsbo kblmZpbyo KlZkb reZ
jy^hf
kh[ex^Zy \k_ ijZ\beZg_ f_g__kljh]hq_f ijbah\hc i_kgZ
bkiulZgbbDh]^ZgZijbf_j^\b`_gb_ ih mebp_mkbeb\Zehkv
hgZ ihkh[kl\_gghfm ihqbgmijbkljZb\ZeZkv d fh_cgh]_b y
g_ hiZkZeky ihl_jylv __ ^Z`_ \ ]mkluolheiZog_baf_ggh
aZihegy\rbo \hdaZeu \ ]h^u \hcguHgZ lhqghke_^h\ZeZ aZ
dZ`^uf fhbf rZ]hflZd qlh__ r_y\k_ \j_fy[ueZ mfh_]h
e_\h]h dhe_gZ
K [hevrhc
ljh]Zl_evghklvx hgZ
ijb[_]ZeZ d
lZdhfm
^h[jh\hevghfm kZfhh]jZgbq_gbx b
lh]^Zdh]^Z hgZ
[ueZ
\ugm`^_gZ [hjhlvky k bkdmr_gb_f gZijbf_jdh]^Z fureb
q_j_a kdhlguc ^\hj]^_ bkim]Zggu_ihy\e_gb_ ju`_]h\hedZ
dmju gZqbgZeb dm^ZolZlv b f_lZlvkyg_fZeh mkbebcqlh[u
h[ma^Zlv _kl_kl\_ggh_ `_eZgb_ jZkijZ\blvky kgbfb< wlbo
kemqZyo KlZkbqlh[u mklhylvi_j_^ kh[eZaghfijb`bfZeZkv d
fh_fm e_\hfm dhe_gmHgZ ^jh`ZeZhl \ha[m`^_gbygha^jb __
jZa^m\Zebkvmrb klhyeblhjqdhfb y [md\Zevgh\b^_edZd
gZly]b\Z_l g_\b^bfuc ih\h^hddhlhjuc hgZgZ k_[ygZ^_eZ
Dhg_qghKlZkb gbdh]^Z g_ bkihevah\ZeZ [u k\h_]hmf_gby
oh^blv jy^hf_keb [u\ xghklb g_hljZ[hlZeb \k_ ]eZ\gu_
_]h ijZ\beZb \k_lZdb fg_ ijbylgh ^mfZlvqlh kh[ZdZ
\umqb\ wlhlmjhdg_ ijhklhjZ[kdb _]hih\lhjy_lgh fh`_l
ijbf_gylv _]hk \u[hjhfqlh[u g_kdZaZlv l\hjq_kdb
KH;:QVB H;UQ:B
B ghkhf^jm`_kdbf
B gxoZeb lhedZe
;_jbk>\_ kh[Zdb
Kihkh[u h[f_gZ bgnhjfZpb_cf_`^m `b\hlgufb`b\msbfb \
khh[s_kl\Zob
f_oZgbafuh[_ki_qb\Zxsb_ [_ki_j_[hcgmx
kh\f_klgmx ^_yl_evghklv bg^b\b^h\ \ klZ^_ beb klZ_g_
bf_xl
gbq_]h
h[s_]h
k
j_qvxgZ
dhlhjhc kljhblky
hkms_kl\e_gb_ wlbo \Z`g_crbonmgdpbc mq_eh\_dZ< Dhevp_
pZjy KhehfhgZy ih^jh[gh jZkkfhlj_e wlhl\hijhk \]eZ\_
Yaud `b\hlguoKfuke dhgdj_lguo kb]gZeh\ b jZaebqguo
\ujZabl_evguo ^\b`_gbc ba\mdh\ m`b\hlguo g_mkeh\_gdZd
kfuke
keh\
\
q_eh\_q_kdhf
yaud_gh
hij_^_ey_lky
\jh`^_ggufb bgklbgdlb\gufb^_ckl\byfb bhl\_lgufb j_Zdpbyfb
LZdbf h[jZahfyauddZ`^h]h ^Zggh]h\b^Z `b\hlguo]hjZa^h
[he__ dhgk_j\Zlb\_gZ bo h[uqZb bijb\uqdbg_kjZ\g_ggh
[he__ mklhcqb\u b h[yaZl_evguq_f m q_eh\_dZFh`gh
gZibkZlv p_emxdgb]m hg_jmrbfuo aZdhgZodhlhju_ mijZ\eyxl
p_j_fhgbZehfhij_^_eyxsbf ih\_^_gb_[he__ kbevguob [he__
keZ[uodh[_e_c b kmdJZkkfZljb\Z_fh_ \ p_ehf^_ckl\b_
wlbo aZdhgh\hibjZxsboky m
kh[Zd gZ
gZke_^kl\_ggu_
ih\_^_gq_kdb_
kl_j_hlbiugZihfbgZ_l
ijhy\e_gb_
gZrbo
kh[kl\_gguo q_eh\_q_kdbo
h[uqZ_\Wlh
hlghkblky b
d
\ha^_ckl\bx mihfygmluo aZdhgh\
gZ `bagv khh[s_kl\Zb
bf_ggh \ lZdhf kfuke_ ke_^m_l ihgbfZlv gZa\Zgb_ ^Zgghc
]eZ\u
G_l gbq_]hkdmqg__ kmoh]hbaeh`_gby aZdhgh\imklv ^Z`_
b g_h[udgh\_ggh bgl_j_kguob y ihijh[mx h[hclbkv
[_a
hl\e_q_gguo jZkkm`^_gbc ijhklh ihklZjZxkvk ihfhsvxjy^Z
[m^gbqguo ijbf_jh\ gZjbkh\Zlv
^hklZlhqgh `b\mx
dZjlbgm
h[s_gby kh[Zd f_`^mkh[hcqlh[u qblZl_ev kZffh] \u\_klb
l_hjbxh[tykgyxsmx wlb aZdhguY gZqgm k
ih\_^_gby
k\yaZggh]h
k
b_jZjobq_kdbf
ihjy^dhf^j_\gb_
h[uqZb
dhlhjh]h g_ lhevdh \ujZ`Zxlgh b\ agZqbl_evghckl_i_gb
hij_^_eyxl iheh`_gb_ kh[Zdb\ wlhckbkl_f_ ^hfbgbjh\Zgbyb
ih^qbg_gbyJZkkfhljbf
g_kdhevdh \klj_q g_khfg_ggh
qblZl_ev kZfg_ jZa[u\Ze k\b^_l_e_fq_]heb[h ih^h[gh]h
Fu k <hedhf b^_l ih ijhmedmh]b[Z_f \h^hjZa[hjgmx
dhehgdm b\uc^y gZ ]eZ\gmx mebpm ^_j_\gb\b^bfqlh
f_ljZo \ ^\moklZo \i_j_^b klhbl JhevnklZjuc \jZ]
b
khi_jgbd
<hedZGZf
gm`gh
ijhclb
fbfh
g_]hb
ke_^h\Zl_evgh\klj_qZ g_ba[_`gZWlb ^\_ kh[ZdbkZfu_
kbevgu_ \^_j_\g_ b\gmrZxsb_ gZb[hevrbckljZo hklZevguflh
_klv aZgbfZxsb_ \_jogxx klmi_gv b_jZjobq_kdhc
e_klgbpu
l_ji_lv ^jm] ^jm]Z g_ fh]mlgh \lh `_\j_fy bkiheg_gu
lZdh]h \aZbfgh]hm\Z`_gbyqlh _s_gb jZamg_ ih^jZebkv
B <hedb Jhevn h[Zih\b^bfhfmh^bgZdh\h g_ jZ^uwlhc
\klj_q_DZ`^uc bagbo khlgbjZa yjhklghh[eZb\Z_l ^jm]h]h
ba k\h_]h kZ^Z \ l\_j^hc m\_j_gghklbqlh lhevdhaZ[hj
f_rZ_l _fm \p_iblvky \ g_gZ\bklgmx ]ehldmGh l_i_jvhgb
bkiulu\Zxl bo
lZddZ`^uc
i_k qm\kl\m_lqlh h[yaZg
ih^^_j`Zlv k\hcij_klb`ijb\_^y \bkiheg_gb_ [ueu_m]jhau
b hiZkZ_lky \ ijhlb\ghf
kemqZ_ mljZlblv ebphHgb
jZamf__lkykjZam
`_ aZf_lbeb
^jm] ^jm]Z
b
ijbgyeb
^_fhgkljZlb\gu_ ihaulh _klv gZijy]ebkvb aZ^jZebo\hklu
\_jlbdZevghL_i_jvk[eb`Zykvhgb ihkl_i_ggh aZf_^eyxl
rZ]Dh]^Z f_`^mgbfb hklZ_lkyg_ [he__iylgZ^pZlb f_ljh\
Jhevn \g_aZigh ijbiZ^Z_l d a_fe_lhqgh ]hlh\ucd iju`dm
lb]jFhj^u h[hbog_ \ujZ`Zxlgb dhe_[Zgbcgb m]jhauE[u b
ghku g_gZfhjs_gumrb klhyllhjqdhf]eZaZ rbjhdh jZkdjulu
<hed gbdZd g_j_Z]bjm_l gZiham JhevnZohly q_eh\_q_kdhfm
]eZam hgZ ij_^klZ\ey_lky \_kvfZ aeh\_s_cZ
ijh^he`Z_l
jh\guf rZ]hfijb[eb`Zlvky d khi_jgbdmb aZfbjZ_l\hae_ g_]h
\ g_ih^\b`ghklbJhevn f]gh\_ggh \kdZdb\Z_lb l_i_jvh[Z
ikZ klhyl[hd h[hd]heh\Z do\hklmb h[gxob\Zxl\aZbfgh
ih^klZ\e_ggu_ aZ^gb_
qZklb lmeh\bsZWlh
^h[jh\hevgh_
ij_^ty\e_gb_
ZgZevghc
h[eZklb
_klv
\ujZ`_gb_
iheghc
m\_j_gghklb \ k_[_b _keb kh[ZdZ __ \^jm]mljZqb\Z_l
o\hkl g_f_^e_ggh himkdZ_lkyO\hkl \lZdbo kemqZyokem`bl
lhqguf bg^bdZlhjhfojZ[jhklb
G_dhlhjh_
\j_fy
iku
ijh^he`Zxl
khojZgylv
wlm
gZijy`_ggmx ihamZ aZl_f ihkl_i_ggh fhj^u bo gZqbgZxl
fhjsblkye[u ijhj_aZxlky ]hjbahglZevgufb b\_jlbdZevgufb
[hjha^Zfbdh`Z
gZ ghkm
kh[bjZ_lky ]Zjfhrdhcdeudb
hkdZeb\ZxlkyLZdh_
\ujZ`_gb_ fhj^u
fh`gh
bklhedh\Zlv
lhevdh dZd m]jh`Zxs__gh hgh [u\Z_l b m i_j_im]Zgguo
kh[Zddhlhju_ m]jh`ZxljZ^b kZfhaZsbludh]^Z boaZ]hgyxl
\ m]he>mr_\gh_ khklhygb_
kh[Zd b bo dhgljhev
gZ^
kblmZpb_c hljZ`Zxlky ebrv \ ^\mo f_klZomrZo bm]hedZo
jlZ?keb mrb gZdehg_gu \i_j_^Z m]hedb jlZkh\k_f g_
hllygmluagZqblkh[ZdZ g_ bkiulu\Z_l kljZoZ b
fh`_l
gZiZklv \
ex[hc fhf_gl<hajZklZgb_
[hyagb
gZoh^bl
\ujZ`_gb_ \ khhl\_lkl\mxs_f^\b`_gbb mr_cb m]hedh\jlZ keh\gh g_\b^bfu_ kbeu lygml kh[Zdm gZaZ^ih[m`^Zy __d
[_]kl\mM]jh`ZxsZy ihaZ khijh\h`^Z_lky juqZgb_fb q_f
[he__ hgh [Zkbkl__l_f [he__ m\_j_gZ \ k_[_
kh[ZdZ
jZamf__lkyk ihijZ\dhc gZ _kl_kl\_gguc lhg __ ]hehkZ
kZfhm\_j_gguc nhdkl_jv_jdhg_qgh[m^_l juqZlv gZ[he__
\ukhdhc ghl_q_f kljmkb\rbck_g[_jgZj
<k_ _s_^_j`Zkv [hdh [hdJhevn b<hed gZqbgZxl l_i_jv
h[oh^blv h^bg^jm]h]h ih ^m]_Y `^mqlh \hl\hl aZ\y`_lky
^jZdZh^gZdh ihegh_ jZ\gh\_kb_kbe ij_iylkl\m_l h[ty\e_gbx
\hcguJuqZgb_ klZgh\blky\k_ [he__aeh\_sbfghgbq_]h
g_ ijhbkoh^blM f_gy
\hagbdZ_l kfmlgh_
ih^haj_gb_
ih^dj_iey_fh_ dhkufb \a]ey^Zfbdhlhju_ [jhkZ_l gZ f_gy
<hedZ ihlhf
Jhevnqlh hgb
g_ ijhklh `^ml
fh_]h
\f_rZl_evkl\Zgh bhq_gv ohlylqlh[u yjZagye bob l_f
kZfuf hk\h[h^be hlfhjZevghc h[yaZgghklb\klmiblv \^jZdm
Klj_fe_gb_ khojZgblvk\hc ij_klb`b ^hklhbgkl\h k\hckl\_ggh
g_ lhevdh q_eh\_dmhgh aZeh`_gh]em[hdh \bklbgguo kehyo
ikbobdbdhlhju_
m
\ukrbo
`b\hlguo
[ebadb d gZrbf
kh[kl\_gguf
Y g_ \f_rb\Zxkvij_^hklZ\eyy kh[ZdZf kZfbfgZclb g_
mgbabl_evguc \uoh^
ba iheh`_gbyHgb hq_gv
f_^e_ggh
jZkoh^ylky brZ] aZ rZ]hfgZqbgZxl m^Zeylvky^jm] hl^jm]Z
<
aZdexq_gb_\k_
_s_
dhkykv
gZ
khi_jgbdZhgb
h^gh\j_f_gghkeh\gh ih dhfZg^_aZ^bjZxl aZ^gxx gh]m
<hed m l_e_]jZngh]hklhe[ZJhevn m aZ[hjZAZl_fijbgy\
^_fhgkljZlb\gmx ihamdZ`^uc b^_l k\h_c ^hjh]hc]hj^ykv
h^_j`Zgghc fhjZevghcih[_^hc bihkjZfe_gb_f ijhlb\gbdZ
Kmdbijbkmlkl\mxsb_ ijb \klj_q_ dh[_e_cjZ\guo ih
kbe_ b jZg]m\_^ml k_[y hkh[ufh[jZahf< lZdbokemqZyo
Kxabkmijm]Z <hedZkh\_jr_ggh y\ghohq_lqlh[u gZqZeZkv
^jZdZZdlb\gh hgZ kmijm]m g_ ihfh]Z_lgh _cgjZ\blky
kfhlj_lvdZd hg [_j_l \_jo gZ^ ^jm]bf ikhfY ^\Z`^u
gZ[ex^ZedZd hgZ ijb[_]ZeZ d dh\Zjghc obljhklbqlh[u
^hklbqv k\h_c p_eb<hed klhye ]heh\hcd o\hklmjy^hf k
^jm]bf ikhf h[Z jZaZwlh [ueqm`Zde_lgbc ]hklvZ
Kxab hklhjh`ghgh k [hevrbfex[hiulkl\hf djmlbeZkv\hae_
gbohgb `_g_ h[jZsZebgZ g__gbdZdh]h \gbfZgbyihkdhevdm
hgZ [ueZ kmdhc<^jm] hgZ [_afhe\ghgh wg_j]bqghdmkZeZ
kmijm]Z aZ aZ^gxx qZklvih^klZ\e_ggmx ijhlb\gbdm<hed
kqblZyqlh
lhl
\
gZjmr_gb_
\k_o ^j_\gbo kh[Zqvbo
h[uqZ_\ gZ]eh mdmkbe _]h aZ aZ^ \h \j_fy h[gxob\Zgby
lhlqZk gZ[jZku\ZekygZ k\ylhlZlpZ<lhjhc i_k_kl_kl\_ggh
jZkp_gb\Ze wlh gZiZ^_gb_
dZd klhev `_
g_ijhklbl_evgh_
gZjmr_gb_ jblmZeZb aZ\yau\ZeZkv gZ j_^dhklv
k\bj_iZy
^jZdZ
<hed \klj_qZ_l
klZjmx ^\hjgy]m`b\rmx \
^hf_ m
^Zevg_]h dhgpZgZr_c ^_j_\gb< ^gb k\h_cxghklb hg kbevgh
ih[Zb\Zeky klZjbdZL_ \j_f_gZ
^Z\gh fbgh\Zebgh
hg
g_gZ\b^bl ^jyoeh]h ikZ [hevr_ \k_o ^jm]bo kh[Zd b
g_
mimkdZ_l kemqZy ihdZaZlv _fm wlhDh]^Z <hedb ^\hjgy]Z
aZf_qZxl
^jm]
^jm]ZklZjbd
g_f_^e_ggh
ijbgbfZ_l
gZijy`_ggmx ihamgh <hed [jhkZ_lkygZ g_]hkbevgh m^Zjy_l
_]h ie_qhfbah]gm\rbkvlhedZ_l aZ^hfb \klZ_ljy^hf k gbf
KlZjbd ihiulZeky [ueh \klj_lblv \jZ]Zk\bj_iuf mdmkhfgh
baaZ lheqdZ_]h am[u khfdgmebkv\ \ha^mo_L_i_jv hgklhbl
g_ih^\b`gh\uijyfb\rbkv \h\_kv jhklgh o\hklhims_glZd
dZd
m
g_]h
g_
o\ZlZ_l
m\_j_gghklb
ih^klZ\blv ^ey
h[gxob\Zgby k\hc aZ^?]h ghk b eh[m]jh`Zxs_ kfhjs_gu
]heh\Z
hims_gZ
b
\uklZ\e_gZ
\i_j_^WlZ
ihaZ
khijh\h`^Z_fZy k_j^bluf juqZgb_fijhba\h^bl kZfh_aeh\_s__
\i_qZle_gb_b dh]^Z <hed kgh\Z ^_eZ_l ^\b`_gb_\i_j_^
klZjbd hlqZyggheya]Z_l am[Zfbb <hed qmlvqmlv hlklmiZ_l
G_ k]b[Zy
gh]ij_m\_ebq_ggh
gZ^f_gghc ihoh^dhc
<hed
h[oh^bl k\h_]h \jZ]ZaZl_f aZ^bjZ_l gh]m b [eb`Zcr_]h
ih^oh^ys_]h ij_^f_lZ bm^Zey_lkyQm\kl\Z klZjhc ^\hjgy]b
_keb h[e_qvbo \keh\Zk\h^ylky ijbf_jghd ke_^mxs_fmY
l_[_ g_khi_jgbd bg_ ij_l_g^mxgb gZjZ\_gkl\h k lh[hcgb
gZ ij_\hkoh^kl\hy g_ihky]gm gZ l\hxl_jjblhjbxB ijhrm
l_[y lhevdh h[h^ghf qlh[u luhklZ\be f_gy\ ihdh_Gh
_keb lu wlh]h g_ k^_eZ_rvy [m^m^jZlvkydZd fh]mg_
[j_a]my bg_q_klgufb ijb_fZfbGh qlhqm\kl\m_l <hed"
M
\h^hjZa[hjghc
dhehgdb
<hed
\klj_qZ_l fZe_gvdmx
k\_lehju`mx ^\hjgy`dmdhlhjZy \kf_jl_evghf m`Zk_ ijh[m_l
mkdhevagmlv hlg_]h \ hldjulmx^\_jv [ZdZe_cghceZ\db<hed
klj_fbl_evgh [jhkZ_lky gZi_j_j_aaZ]hjZ`b\Z_l ^\_jvb l_f
`_ [hdh\uf ^\b`_gb_fh dhlhjhfy m`_]h\hjbehl[jZku\Z_l
kh[Zqhgdm gZfhklh\mxlml `_gZklb]Z_l __b kgh\ZlhedZ_l
Ijb dZ`^hf m^Zj_ kh[ZqhgdZ \a\ba]b\Z_ldZd hl kbevghc
[hebb \dhgp_ dhgph\ \hlqZygbb dmkZ_lk\h_]h \jZ]Z<hed
g_ juqblg_ fhjsbl
m]jh`Zxs_]h ghkZZg_
h[jZsZy
\gbfZgby gZ mdmkuijh^he`Z_l __ lhedZlvHg gZklhevdh
ij_abjZ_l k\h_]h ijhlb\gbdZqlh g_ kqblZ_l ^Z`_gm`guf
ijbhldjulv iZklvGh \f_kl_ k l_f hg g_gZ\b^bl ju`_]h
ihemdjh\dmdhlhjuc lh b^_eh aZe_aZe dgZf \ kZ^dh]^Z m
Kxab [ueZ l_qdZb l_i_jvk\h^bl kgbf kq_luklhev ihreuf
h[jZahfLbi kljZoZdhlhjuc gZoh^bl \ujZ`_gb_ \ \hie_
[hebba^Z\Z_fhf _s_ ^h lh]hdZd kh[ZdZmki__l hsmlblv
j_Zevgmx [hevoZjZdl_jbam_lky hkh[uf iheh`_gb_f m]hedh\
jlZ hgb gZklhevdh hlly]b\Zxlky gZaZ^qlh klZgh\blky
\b^bfhc
kebabklZy
h[hehqdZh[jZfeyxsZy
]m[u
l_fghc
dZ_fhqdhc>Z`_ gZ q_eh\_q_kdbc \a]ey^ kh[Zqvyfhj^Z ijb
wlhf
ijbh[j_lZ_l
hkh[h_
kdmeys__
\ujZ`_gb_\iheg_
khhl\_lkl\mxs__ a\mdZfdhlhjufb hghkhijh\h`^Z_lky
<hed ,gZ\_sZ_l k\hxih^jm]m K_glm b\ajhkeuo ^_l_c gZ
i_j_^g_c \_jZg^_ gZr_]h^hfZHg a^hjh\Z_lky kK_glhch[Z
\beyxl o\hklZfbZ hgZ g_`gh h[ebau\Z_lm]hedb _]hjlZ b
eZkdh\h ljh]Z_l _]h ghkhfAZl_f <hed,ih\hjZqb\Z_lky d
h^ghfm ba k\hbo kugh\_cb lhljZ^hklgh ih^oh^bld hlpm
lhedZ_l _]h ghkhfgh g_ ^Z_lh[gxoZlv k\hcaZ^himkdZy
g_ij_ju\gh \beyxsbc o\hkl
f_`^m aZ^gbfb gh]ZfbKibgZ
fheh^h]h ikZ \u]gmlZih\_^_gb_ _]hih^h[hkljZklghh^gZdh
hg g_ ijhy\ey_lgbdZdh]h kljZoZi_j_^ hlphfZgZh[hjhl
lh b^_eh luq_lky\ g_]hghkhf biulZ_lky ebaZlv m]hedb_]h
jlZ<hed ijbwlhf ^_j`blkyk lZdbfqhihjguf ^hklhbgkl\hf
qlh dZ`_lky ihqlb kfms_ggufhg hl\hjZqb\Z_l]heh\m hl
eb`ms_]hky s_gdZ b\ukhdh aZ^bjZ_lghkDh]^Z fheh^hci_k
h[h^j_gguc wlbf hlklmie_gb_fklZgh\blky [he__gZahceb\uf
gZ fhj^_ hlpZ ihy\ey_lky g_h[h^jbl_evgZy kdeZ^dZEh[ `_
s_gdZ g_ ijhklh ]eZ^hddh`Z gZg_f gZklhevdhjZklygmlZ
qlh \g_rgb_ m]hedb]eZa dZ`mlkyijbsmj_ggufbFZg_jZ K_glu
a^hjh\Zlvky k <hedhf ,b ^\b`_gby s_gdZ\ujZ`Zxsb_ _]h
qm\kl\Zlhqgh kh\iZ^Zxl
k ^\b`_gbyfbdhlhjufb
hq_gv
ihkemrgZy
kh[ZdZ
a^hjh\Z_lky
kh
k\hbf
ohaybghf
Hq_eh\_qb\Zy kblmZpbxfh`gh kdZaZlvqlh fheh^hc i_kgZr_e
kqZkleb\uc dhfijhfbkk f_`^mhij_^_e_gghc kl_i_gvxkljZoZ b
ex[h\vxdhlhjZy aZklZ\ey_l_]h ih^hclbd lhfmdlh klhbl
gZfgh]h \ur__]h gZb_jZjobq_kdhc e_klgbp_
< ^_j_\g_ Kxab\klj_qZ_l djmigh]hikZihf_kv dheeb b
g_f_pdhc h\qZjdbkugZ m`_
mihfbgZ\r_]hky JhevnZGZ
f]gh\_gb_ijbgy\ __ aZ <hedZdhlhjh]h hg
kf_jl_evgh
[hblkyi_k im]Z_lky
Aj_gb_ m kh[Zd iehoh_b gZjZkklhygbb hgbjZaebqZxl
lhevdh h[sb_ hq_jlZgby
ij_^f_lh\Z lZd
dZd <hed
_^bgkl\_gguc qZmqZmdhlhjh]h f_klgu_ kh[Zdbijb\udeb lml
\klj_qZlvKxab g_j_^dh imlZxlk __ \gmrbl_evgufkhjh^bq_f
GZoZevkl\hhq_gv jZgh jZa\b\Zxs__ky mfheh^_gvdhc kmqdb
g_khfg_gghh[tykgy_lky
h[sbf
ihql_gb_fdhlhjh_ hgZ
\klj_qZ_l m
\k_o baaZ
wlhc hrb[db
bdhg_qgh
`_
ijbibku\Z_lky
kh[kl\_gghc
k\bj_ihklb<_kvfZ ex[hiulgh
gZ[ex^Zlv lZdh_^hdZaZl_evkl\h kd\_jgh]hp\_lh\h]h aj_gby m
kh[Zd<hedZ bKxab bokhjh^bqb qZklhimlZxlg_kfhljy gZ
lhqlh m<hedZ r_jklvju`ZyZ mKxab ]hem[h\Zlhk_jZy
Gh
\_jg_fky
d
hibku\Z_fhfm
kemqZxFheh^hc i_k
h[jZsZ_lky \ [_]kl\hh^gZdh Kxab [ukljh_]h gZklb]Z_lb
hklZgZ\eb\Z_lHg kfbj_gghklhbl i_j_^ g_chimklb\ mrb b
jZklygm\ dh`m gZe[mZ wlZ \hkvfbf_kyqgZykmqdZ gZqbgZ_l
ij_ajbl_evgh ihfZob\Zlv o\hklhfHgZ iulZ_lkyh[gxoZlv _]h
aZ^gh hg kfms_ggh himkdZ_l o\hkl f_`^m gh] b[ukljh
ih\hjZqb\Z_lkyih^klZ\eyy _c ]jm^v b ]heh\mB lhevdh
l_i_jv hgih\b^bfhfmaZf_qZ_lqlh i_j_^ gbfg_ ]jhaguc
kZf_pZ fbe_gvdZy kZfhqdZI_k \uly]b\Z_l r_x
\\_jo
\a^_j]b\Z_l o\hkl b b^_l gZ g__ijblZgph\u\Zy i_j_^gbfb
eZiZfbG_kfhljy gZ wlbagZdb kZfhml\_j`^_gby_]h fhj^Zb
mrb \k_ _s_ \ujZ`Zxl
b_jZjobq_kdh_ ihql_gb_gh
hgh
ihkl_i_ggh
kf_gy_lky
\ujZ`_gb_fdhlhjh_
y
gZah\m
]ZeZglghc fbghcb dhlhjh_ hlebqZ_lky hl ihqlbl_evghc
fbgulhevdh iheh`_gb_f mr_c
b m]hedh\ jlZmrb
_s_
ijb`Zlu d
]heh\_gh
k\_^_gu lZdqlh bo
dhgqbdb
khijbdZkZxlkyZ
m]hedb
jlZ
hllygmludZd
b
ijb
ihqlbl_evghc fbg_gh g_ hims_gu `Zeh[ghZgZh[hjhl
\a^_jgmlu \\_jokeh\gh hl kf_oZDh]^Z wlh \ujZ`_gb_
klZgh\blky q_ldbfaZ gbfh[yaZl_evgh ke_^m_l ijb]eZr_gb_d
b]j_Ijb wlhf iZklv ijbhldjulZ lZdqlh \b^_gyaudb
\a^_jgmlu_ m]hedb jlZjZklygmlh]h ^hmr_cijb^Zxl kh[Zd_
_s_ [he__
kf_xsbcky \b^LZdhc
kf_oqZs_
\k_]h
gZ[ex^Z_lky m kh[Zd \h \j_fy b]ju kh[h`Z_fuf ohaybghf
dh]^Z hgZ ijboh^yl \
lZdh_ \ha[m`^_gb_qlh
gZqbgZxl
iuol_lv<hafh`ghwlb
^\b`_gby
furp fhj^u
y\eyxlky
ij_^\_klgbdhf iuol_gbydhlhjh_ gZqbgZ_lkydh]^Z `_eZgb_
b]jZlv [_j_l \_jo gZ^ \k_f hklZevgufLZdh_ ij_^eh`_gb_
ih^dj_iey_lky l_f nZdlhfqlh \k_dkmZevgh hdjZr_gghcb]j_
kh[Zdb qZklh kf_xlkyb
gZqbgZxl iuol_lv ^Z`_
ihke_
g_agZqbl_evguo mkbebcI_kdhlhjuc k_cqZk klhbl
i_j_^
Kxabkf__lky \k_ [hevr_ b \k_ wg_j]bqg__
i_j_klmiZ_l
i_j_^gbfb eZiZfb<g_aZigh hg iju]Z_l gZ xgmxqZmqZm b
lhedZ_l __ i_j_^gbfb eZiZfb \ ]jm^vAZl_f klj_fbl_evgh
ih\hjZqb\Z_lky b db^Z_lky ijhqv^_j`Z l_eh ihhkh[hfm
kibgZ \k_ _s_ ihqlbl_evgh \u]gmlZaZ^ ih^`ZlZ o\hkl
ijhims_g f_`^maZ^gbfb eZiZfbGh ohly\_kv _]h \b^]h\hjbl
h kfbj_gbbhg ijh^_eu\Z_l kZfu_ ^jm`_ex[gu_ iju`dbZ
o\hkl \bey_l gZklhevdh kbevghgZkdhevdh iha\heyxlaZ^gb_
gh]bQ_j_a g_kdhevdh f_ljh\ hg hklZgZ\eb\Z_lkykgh\Z
fhegb_ghkgh ih\hjZqb\Z_lky b ih^[_]Z_l d Kxab krbjhdhc
mofuedhc gZ fhj^_Hg ijbih^gbfZ_lo\hkl lZdqlh[u ]he_gb
g_ f_rZeb _fm \beylvijbq_f l_i_jv hg\bey_l g_lhevdh
o\hklhfgh b\k_c aZ^g_cqZklvx lmeh\bsZHg kgh\Ziju]Z_l
gZ Kxabb _]h aZb]ju\Zgbyijbh[j_lZxl ke_]dZk_dkmZevguc
oZjZdl_jgh ebrvkbf\hebq_kdbihkdhevdm i_jbh^ l_qdb^ey
Kxab _s_g_ gZklmibe
< aZfd_:evl_g[_j]]^_ h[blZ_lh]jhfguc m]hevghq_jguc
gvxnZmg^e_g^ ih debqd_Ehj^fZe_gvdZy ^hqv ohaybgZ\ ^_gv
jh`^_gby ihemqbeZ \ ih^Zjhd hqZjh\Zl_evgh]h
dZjebdh\h]h
ibgq_jZdhlhjhfm lhevdhlhevdh bkihegbehkv ^\Zf_kypZY
[ue k\b^_l_e_f i_j\hc \klj_qb
wlbo kh[ZdOhly
D\bd
ibgq_j[ue xguf aZagZcdhchg ^h kf_jlb
i_j_im]Zeky
m\b^_\qlh gZ g_]h gZ^\b]Z_lky ]hjZ q_jgh]h f_oZb
ih^h[gh \k_f s_gdZf
ijb klhev `mldbo
h[klhyl_evkl\Zo
i_j_\_jgmeky gZ kibgmZ dh]^Z [hevrhc i_k h[gxoZe_]h
[jxrdhimklbe \\_jodjhohlguc `_elucnhglZgqbdIhgxoZ\ b
wlh
wfhpbhgZevgh_
baebygb_Ehj^
g_lhjhieb\h
b
\_ebq_kl\_ggh hl\_jgmeky hl ihljyk_ggh]h s_gdZH^gZdh \
ke_^mxsmx fbgmlm D\bd \kdhqbe b gZqZedZd aZ\_^_gguc
hibku\Zlv klj_fbl_evgu_ \hkvf_jdb f_`^mgh] gvxnZmg^e_g^Z
AZl_f hg ^jm`_kdbiju]gme gZg_]hijb]eZrZy Ehj^Z [_`Zlv
aZ gbfJu^ZxsZy fZe_gvdZy ohaycdZ ibgq_jZdhlhjZy g_
\f_rb\ZeZkv
lhevdh
ihlhfmqlh
__
m^_j`b\Zeb
`_kldhk_j^_qgu_ klZjrb_ [jZlvy\a^hogmeZ k h[e_]q_gb_f
lZd
dZd
agZdhfkl\h
aZ\_jrbehkv
bklbggh
ljh]Zl_evguf
aj_ebs_fhq_gv [hevrZy kh[ZdZ ^h[jh^mrgh b]jZeZk hq_gv
fZe_gvdhc
Wlb r_klv kh[Zqvbo\klj_q y\u[jZe \dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jh\
ihlhfmqlh booZjZdl_j [ue\ujZ`_g hq_gvhlq_leb\hGh \
^_ckl\bl_evghklb_kl_kl\_gghkms_kl\mxl
[_kqbke_ggu_
i_j_oh^gu_ b mkeh`g_ggu_nhjfu wfhpbcb khhl\_lkl\mxsb_bf
\ujZabl_evgu_ ^\b`_gby m\_j_gghklb \ k_[_ b
kljZoZ
\uah\Z
b
kfbj_gbygZiZ^_gby
b
aZsbluWlh djZcg_
aZljm^gy_l ZgZebanhjf ih\_^_gbyb gZ^hhq_gv ohjhrh agZlv
lbiu \ujZ`_gbcdhlhju_ y hibkZeb fgh]b_ bgu_qlh[u
meh\blv bo gZ kh[Zqv_c
fhj^_]^_ hgb bgh]^Z
kbevgh
kfZaZguZ bgh]^Zkh\f_sZxlky k^jm]bfb
Kms_kl\m_l h^gZ qj_a\uqZcgh fbeZy q_jlZ \ ih\_^_gbb
kh[ZddhlhjZy y\gh jZgh aZnbdkbjh\ZeZkv\ bop_gljZevghc
g_j\ghc kbkl_f_dZd k\hckl\hi_j_^Zxs__ky ih gZke_^kl\mY
bf_x \ \b^mjupZjkl\_ggh_ h[oh`^_gb_k kZfdZfbb s_gylZfb
Gb h^bg ghjfZevguc kZf_p gb ijbdZdbo h[klhyl_evkl\Zog_
mdmkbl kZfdmkmdm hojZgy_l Z[khexlgh_ lZ[mb hgZfh`_l
\_klb k_[yk dh[_e_fdZd ih`_eZ_l bihdmku\Zlv _]hijbq_f
^Z`_ \k_jv_a< jZkihjy`_gbb dh[_ey g_l gbdZdbokj_^kl\
aZsbludjhf_ ihqlbl_evguo ^\b`_gbc b]ZeZglghc fbguk
ihfhsvx dhlhjuo hg fh`_l ihiulZlvky ij_\jZlblv
gZkdhdb
jZatyj_gghc kmdb \b]jmFm`kdZy ]hj^hklv g_iha\hey_l _fm
ijb[_]gmlv d ^jm]hfm kihkh[m d ^jZd_lZd dZddh[_eb
\k_]^Z ijbeZ]Zxl fZdkbfmfmkbebcqlh[u \ ijbkmlkl\bbkmdb
khojZgblv ebphM \hedh\b ]j_geZg^kdbo_a^h\uo kh[Zd k
ij_h[eZ^Zxs_c
\heqv_c
djh\vx
wlhl
jupZjkl\_gguc
kZfhdhgljhev jZkijhkljZgy_lky gZ kZfhd lhevdhkh[kl\_gghc
klZbgh m kh[Zd
k ij_h[eZ^Zxs_c rZdZev_c djh\vx
hg
^_ckl\m_l \
ijbkmlkl\bb ex[hc
kZfdb^Z`_
kh\_jr_ggh
g_agZdhfhcDh[_ev
qZmqZm
aZgbfZ_l
ijhf_`mlhqgh_
iheh`_gb__keb hg \k_]^Z gZoh^blky \ h[s_kl\_
k\hbo
jh^kl\_ggbpk kmdhc rZdZev_c djh\b hg fh`_l
h[hclbkv
^h\hevgh ]jm[hohly y g_agZx kemqZyqlh[u hgmdmkbe __
ihgZklhys_fm
?keb [u
fg_ gm`gh
[ueh _s_
h^gh
^hdZaZl_evkl\h
dhj_ggh]h ahheh]bq_kdh]h jZaebqbyf_`^m kh[ZdZfbk kbevghc
ijbf_kvx \heqv_c djh\bb h[uqgufb_\jhi_ckdbfb ihjh^Zfby
mdZaZe
[u
gZ
\jZ`^mijhy\e_gby
dhlhjhc
ihklhyggh
gZ[ex^Zxlky f_`^m
wlbfb ^\mfy
lbiZfb\_^msbfb
k\h_
ijhbkoh`^_gb_
hl
jZaguo
^bdbo
ij_^dh\KihglZggZy
g_gZ\bklvdhlhjmx bkiulu\Zxl dqZmqZm ^_j_\_gkdb_ kh[Zdb
gbdh]^Z ij_`^_ bog_ \b^Z\rb_bgZh[hjhl]hlh\ghklvk
dZdhc ex[Zy^\hjgy`dZ ijbgbfZ_l rZdZeZbeb ^bg]h\ dZq_kl\_
k\h_]hij_^klZ\eyxlky
fg_
dm^Z
[he__ m[_^bl_evguf
^hdZaZl_evkl\Zfb
\
ihevam
lZdh]h
jZaebqbyq_f \k_
baf_j_gby b jZkq_lu ijhihjpbc
q_j_iZ b kd_e_lZ b
bo
klZlbklbq_kdZy h[jZ[hldZiheh`_ggu_ \ hkgh\m
h[jZlgh]h
fg_gbyFh_ m[_`^_gb_ ih^dj_iey_lkyb g_dhlhjufb ZghfZebyfb
\ ]jmiih\hfih\_^_gbb ij_^klZ\bl_eb ijhlb\hiheh`guo lbih\
qZklh gZklhevdh g_ khagZxl k_[y qe_gZfbh^gh]h \b^Zqlh
dh[_eb g_ m\Z`ZxlkZfuo we_f_glZjguokh[Zqvbo ijZ\kmd b
s_gylBkke_^h\Zl_ev ih\_^_gbyahheh]lhgdh
hsmsZxsbc
]_g_Zeh]bq_kdb_ bkbkl_fZlbq_kdb_ khhl\_lkl\byg_ fh`_l g_
aZf_lblvqlh \heqvykh[ZdZ ijbgZ^e_`bld bghc\_l\bq_f
rZdZevy: ihkdhevdmkZfb kh[ZdbgZ dhlhjuogZmqgu_ kihju
jZamf__lkygbdZd g_\ebyxlg_khfg_gghlZd`_ wlh\b^yly
^h\_jyx bf[hevr_q_f ex[ufklZlbklbq_kdbf ^Zgguf
M ij_^klZ\bl_e_c k_f_ckl\Z kh[ZqvboijbgZ^e_`Zsbo d
h^ghfm \b^m b d h^ghfm khh[s_kl\ms_ghd fheh`_ r_klb
f_kyp_\
ihevam_lky
Z[khexlghc
g_ijbdhkgh\_gghklvx
>_ckl\by\ujZ`Zxsb_ kfbj_gb_ i_j_\_jlu\Zgb_ gZkibgm b
fhq_bkimkdZgb_g_h[oh^bfu lhevdh
\ i_j\mx
fbgmlm
ih\b^bfhfmhgb ^he`gubgnhjfbjh\Zlv \ajhkemxkh[Zdmqlh
hgZ bf__l^_eh khs_gdhfY g_\_e ki_pbZevguogZ[ex^_gbc b
g_ klZ\bewdki_jbf_glh\Z ihlhfmg_ [_jmkvml\_j`^Zlvwlb
eb ^_ckl\by ihdZau\Zxl \ajhkehc kh[Zd_qlh i_j_^
g_c
[_kihfhsguc xg_pbeb aZiZo
s_gdZ lZd`_
ihfh]Zxl _c
jZkihagZlv _]h g_`guc
\hajZkl;_amkeh\ghjZaebqby
\
\_ebqbg_ f_`^m fheh^hc b \ajhkehc hkh[vxg_ b]jZx\ wlhf
magZ\Zgbb gbdZdhc jhebK_j^bluc nhdkl_jv_j h[oh^blky k
fheh^uf k_g[_jgZjhf dZdk [_kihfhsguffeZ^_gp_f^Z`_ _keb
lhl \^\h_ [hevr_ _]hBgZh[hjhldh[_eb djmiguoihjh^
ij_kihdhcgh aZl_\Zxl ^jZdb kh \ajhkeufb dh[_eyfb f_edbo
ihjh^ohly
k
q_eh\_q_kdhc
lhqdb
aj_gby
wlh
b
ij_^klZ\ey_lky fZeh[eZ]hjh^gufY g_jbkdmx iheghklvx \aylv
ih^ khfg_gb_
jupZjkl\_ggh_ ih\_^_gb_
ih hlghr_gbx
d
fZe_gvdbf
kh[ZdZfdhlhjh_
lZd
qZklh
ijbibku\Zxl
k_g[_jgZjZfgvxnZmg^e_g^Zf b ^h]Zfgh kZf y \\_kvfZ
rbjhdhf djm]m fhbo kh[Zqvbo agZdhfkl\ _s_ gb jZam
g_
\klj_lbe lZdh]h\_ebdh^mrgh]h \_ebdZgZ
Dh]^Z
\ukhdhf_jghfm
dh[_exk\ylh
[ex^ms_fm k\h_
^hklhbgkl\h[_kk_j^_qgh ij_^eZ]Zxl
ihb]jZlvk
xgufb
s_gylZfbwlh \k_]^Z h[_sZ_l fgh]h aZ[Z\guoZ g_j_^dhb
ljh]Zl_evguo
kp_gY
ki_pbZevgh
ijh^_eu\Ze
lZdb_
wdki_jbf_glu k gZrbf klZjbdhf <hedhfHg [ueqj_a\uqZcgh
k_jv_a_g b \h\k_ g_ ex[be b]jZlvZ ihlhfm
bkiulu\Ze
g_\_jhylgh_ kfms_gb_ b
g_eh\dhklvdh]^Z \ugm`^_g
[ue
gZ\_sZlv gZ \_jZg^_ k\hbo ^\mof_kyqguo ^_l_cb ^bg]hbo
k\h[h^gh]h [jZlpZS_gylZ \ iylv f_kyp_\ b klZjr_ m`_
iblZxl hij_^_e_ggh_
m\Z`_gb_ d
ijhn_kkhjkdhc
\Z`ghklb
klZjuo dh[_e_cgh s_gdb ihfheh`_ gbq_]h ih^h[gh]h
g_
bkiulu\ZxlHgb gZdb^u\Zxlky gZhlpZpZiZxl _]h aZgh]b
[_kihsZ^gufbhkljufbdZd b]euam[ZfbZ hglhevdh ih
hq_j_^b
\a^_j]b\Z_l
eZiukeh\gh
h[`b]Zykv;_^ghfm
fmq_gbdm g_ iheh`_gh ^Z`_ juqZlvb m` l_f[he__ hgg_
kf__l aZ^Zlv lj_idm k\hbf gZahceb\uf hlijukdZfG_fgh]h
ih]h^y gZr\hjqeb\uc <hediha\heye \h\e_qv k_[y\ \hagx kh
s_gylZfbgh l_f g_ f_g__ihdZ hgb[ueb fZe_gvdbfbhg
gbdh]^Z ^h[jh\hevghgZ \_jZg^mg_ aZoh^be
Dh[_ev hdZau\Z_lky \koh^ghc kblmZpbbb dh]^ZgZ g_]h
gZiZ^Z_l kmdZHg g_ fh`_l gb dmkZlvkygb ^Z`_juqZlv
h^gZdh ijb[ebablvky
d Z]j_kkb\ghc
kZfd_ _]h
lhedZ_l
g_kjZ\g_ggh [he__kbevguc bfimevkb dhgnebdl f_`^mfm`kdbf
^hklhbgkl\hfkljZohf i_j_^ hkljufb am[Zfb ijhlb\gbpu b
kbehc _]h
k_dkmZevguo ih[m`^_gbc
ihjh`^Z_l
ih\_^_gb_
dhlhjh_
bgh]^Z
ij_\jZsZ_lky
\
gZklhysmx
iZjh^bx gZ
q_eh\_q_kdmxKf_rguf klZjh]h ikZ ^_eZ_l ]eZ\gufh[jZahf
b]jb\hklv]ZeZglghklvdhlhjmx y hibku\Ze \ur_Dh]^Z
lZdhc kmjh\uc a\_jv^Z\gh
m`_ \ur_^rbc ba
s_gyqv_]h
\hajZklZgZqbgZ_l batykgylvky\ ex[\bjblfbqgh i_j_[bjZy
i_j_^gbfb eZiZfb b iju]Zy \aZ^ b \i_j_^^Z`_ gZbf_g__
kdehgguc d Zgljhihfhjnbafm gZ[ex^Zl_ev g_\hevgh gZqbgZ_l
ijh\h^blv hij_^_e_ggu_
kjZ\g_gbyq_fm
kihkh[kl\m_l
b
ih\_^_gb_ kmdbdhlhjZyagZyqlh __ moZ`_j\k_ kl_jibl
\_^_l k_[y\_kvfZ \ukhdhf_jgh
H^gZ`^u fg_ ^h\_ehkv gZ[ex^Zlv hq_gv q_ldbc
ijbf_j
lZdh]h ih\_^_gbyWlh ijhbahrehdh]^Z y\f_kl_ khKlZkb
ihk_lbe \hedZ \ _]h de_ld_;he__ ih^jh[gh y hibrmbo
\klj_qm
iha`_>h\hevgh
kdhjh
\hed
ijb]eZkbe f_gy
ihb]jZlvb y\_kvfZ ihevs_gguckh]eZkbekyH^gZdh KlZkb
h[b^_eZkvqlh y m^_eyx \hedm [hevr_\gbfZgbyq_f _cb
\g_aZigh gZ[jhkbeZkv
gZ fh_]h
gh\h]h ijbyl_eyGZ^h
kdZaZlvqlh kmdbqZmqZmklZ\y gZ f_klhg_ m]h^b\rbobf
kZfph\imkdZxl \oh^ m^b\bl_evghijhlb\guc k\Zjeb\uceZc b
hkh[mx fZg_jm dmkZlvky g_ k\bj_ih\ ihegmxkbemdZd
^_jmsb_ky ikuZ g_]em[hdhaZo\Zlu\Zy dZd [m^lhlhevdh
dh`mh^gZdh bo ijhlb\gbd ijb wlhf \ba`blhl [heb<hed
lh`_ aZ\ba`Zeh^gh\j_f_ggh iulZykv
h[_ahjm`blv
KlZkb
ihqlbl_evgufb ihaZfb b ]ZeZglgufh[oh`^_gb_f?kl_kl\_ggh
fg_ g_ ohl_ehkv ih^\_j]Zlv _]h jupZjkl\_gghklv
kebrdhf
ly`_ehfm bkiulZgbxihkdhevdm y hiZkZekydZd [uwlh g_
h[hrehkv
^hjh]h
fg_
kZfhfmb
y
kljh]h
ijbdZaZe
jZkk_j`_gghc KlZkb aZfheqZlvlh _klvfg_ ijbrehkvk^_eZlv
_c \u]h\hjqlh[u hgZ g_h[b`ZeZ ihdeZ^bklh]h\hedZZ \_^v
\k_]h ebrv^_kylv fbgmlgZaZ^ y ihklZ\bei_j_^ de_ldhc ^\Z
\_^jZ k \h^hcb `_e_agucehfqlh[u [ueh q_fkiZkZlv fhx
[_kp_ggmx KlZkb_keb e_kghc obsgbdgZdbg_lky gZg__6LF
WUDQVLFJORULDOXjLLZd ijhoh^blkeZ\Z\hedZ eZl
OHAYBG BKH;:D:
Ex^b aZ\h^yl kh[Zdb dhr_dba kZfuojZaguo ih[m`^_gbc
ijbq_f ^Ze_dhg_ \k_]^Zba ^h[juoKj_^b kljZklguo ex[bl_e_c
`b\hlguob \ qZklghklb kj_^bex[bl_e_c kh[Zdkms_kl\m_l
hkh[Zy dZl_]hjby g_kqZklguoex^_cdhlhju_ h lhcbeb bghc
]hjvdhc ijbqbg_ mljZlbeb \_jm \ k_[_ ih^h[guo b
bsml
wfhpbhgZevghc
ihfhsb
m
`b\hlguoBa\_klgh_ ijbkeh\v_
`b\hlgu_ gZklhevdh emqr_ ex^_c\k_]^Z gZ\h^blf_gy gZ
]jmklgu_ jZafure_gby<_^v wlh
g_ lZd;_kkihjgh\
hlghr_gbyo f_`^m
ex^vfb g_
kms_kl\m_l lhqgh
ih^h[by
ij_^ZgghklbgZ dhlhjmxkihkh[gZ kh[ZdZGh \_^vkh[ZdZ g_
iemlZ_l
ih
eZ[bjbglm
fhjZevguo
h[yaZl_evkl\qZklh
ijhlb\hj_qZsbo ^jm] ^jm]m?c ba\_kl_g lhevdhijhkl_crbc
dhgnebdl f_`^m`_eZgbyfb bh[yaZgghklyfb ^jm]bfb keh\Zfb
gZ^ g_cg_ ly]hl__l\k_ lhqlh gZk[_^guo ex^_cbghc jZa
k\h^bl k imlb bklbggh]hK lhqdb aj_gby
q_eh\_q_kdhc
hl\_lkl\_gghklb ^Z`_
kZfZy \_jgZy
kh[ZdZ \u]ey^bl
\
agZqbl_evghc kl_i_gb ZfhjZevghcBamq_gb_ ih\_^_gby\ukrbo
`b\hlguo\hij_db fg_gbx g_dhlhjuo\h\k_ g_ ijb\h^bld
lhfmqlh lugZqbgZ_rv g_^hhp_gb\ZlvjZaebqby f_`^mgbfb b
q_eh\_dhfGZh[hjhly ml\_j`^Zxqlh lhevdh l_dlh
ihgZklhys_fm jZa[bjZ_lky \ih\_^_gbb `b\hlguokihkh[gu \
iheghc f_j_ hp_gblvlh hkh[h_\ha\ur_ggh_ f_klhdhlhjh_ \
fbj_ `b\uokms_kl\ aZgbfZ_lq_eh\_d
KjZ\g_gb_ q_eh\_dZ b `b\hlguodhlhjh_ b]jZ_l lZdmx
agZqbl_evgmx jhev\ gZrbobkke_^h\Zl_evkdbo f_lh^Zomgb`Z_l
_]h g_[he__q_f ijbgylb_l_hjbb ijhbkoh`^_gby\b^h\Kmlv
w\hexpbb hj]Zgbq_kdh]h fbjZ \ lhf baZdexqZ_lkyqlh hgZ
kha^Z_l Z[khexlghgh\u_ b[he__ \ukhdb_ijbagZdbdhlhju_ gZ
ij_^u^ms_c klZ^bbg_ kms_kl\h\Zeb^Z`_ \aZqZld_Dhg_qgh
b \gZrb ^gb \q_eh\_d_ _klv_s_ qlhlh hl`b\hlgh]hgh \
`b\hlghf hl q_eh\_dZ gbq_]h=_g_Zeh]bq_kdb_ bkke_^h\Zgby
ih g_h[oh^bfhklb
\_^msb_ky hl
gbar_]hhl
`b\hlguo
iha\heyxl gZf hkh[_gghykgh m\b^_lvq_eh\_q_kdmx kmsghklv
\_ebdb_ ^hklb`_gbyq_eh\_q_kdh]h jZamfZb wlbdbdhlhjuo fbj
`b\hlguo \hh[s_ g_agZ_lHgb y\kl\_ggh \uklmiZxlgZ nhg_
l_o [he__ ^j_\gbo k\hckl\ bkihkh[ghkl_cdhlhju_ q_eh\_d
_s_ b l_i_jv ^_ebl k \ukrbfb `b\hlgufbMl\_j`^Zlvqlh
`b\hlgu_ emqr_
q_eh\_dZagZqbl dhsmgkl\h\Zlv^ey
djblbq_kdb fukeys_]h [bheh]Z\ ih^h[ghfaZy\e_gbb ijyq_lky
k\ylhlZlkl\_ggh_ hljbpZgb_
ih^ebggh]h jZa\blby
\
fbj_
`b\h]h
D g_kqZklvxkebrdhf fgh]b_ex[bl_eb `b\hlguohkh[_ggh
qe_gu
h[s_kl\Z
aZsblu
ihke_^gbomihjgh
hlklZb\Zxl
\ur_mdZaZggmx wlbq_kdb \j_^gmx lhqdm aj_gbyIj_djZkgZ b
ihmqbl_evgZ
lhevdh
lZ
ex[h\v
d
`b\hlgufdhlhjZy
ihjh`^Z_lky ex[h\vx dh \kydhc `bagb b \ hkgh\_dhlhjhc
^he`gZ e_`Zlv ex[h\v d ex^yfLhevdh l_dlh kihkh[_g
qm\kl\h\Zlv bf_ggh lZdfh]ml ^Zjblv k\hx ijb\yaZgghklv
`b\hlguf [_a gjZ\kl\_ggh]hms_j[Z ^eyk_[yJZahqZjh\Zgguc
b h`_klhq_ggucq_eh\_ddhlhjuc baaZ ij_]j_r_gbc hl^_evguo
bg^b\b^h\ \hkklZ_l ijhlb\\k_]h q_eh\_q_kl\Zb hl^Z_lk\hx
ex[h\v lhevdh
kh[ZdZf b
dhrdZfkh\_jrZ_l
jhdh\mx b
hl\jZlbl_evgmx hrb[dmG_gZ\bklv dex^yf bex[h\v d `b\hlguf
aeh\_sZy
b hiZkgZy
dhf[bgZpbyJZamf__lkywlh g_
hlghkblky d l_fdlh ih lhc bebbghc ijbqbg_h[j_q_g gZ
h^bghq_kl\h bh[aZ\h^blky kh[Zdhcqlh[u m^h\e_l\hjblv k\hx
ihlj_[ghklv ex[blv b [ulv ex[bfufb@_eZgb_ wlh \iheg_
aZdhggh b [_ah[b^ghZ h^bghq_kl\m[_kkihjghg_l f_klZ
_keb gZk\_l_ _klvohly [u h^ghkms_kl\hdhlhjh_ jZ^m_lky
\Zr_fm \ha\jZs_gbx^hfhc
Bamq_gb_
]Zjfhgbq_kdh]h
kh]eZkbypZjys_]h
f_`^m
ohaybghf b kh[Zdhc^Z_l qj_a\uqZcgh fgh]h^ey ihgbfZgby
ikboheh]bb dZd ex^_clZd b `b\hlguoZ bgh]^Z[u\Z_l b
hq_gv m\e_dZl_evguf<u[hj kh[Zdb m`_]h\hjbl hfgh]hfZ
_s_ [hevr_ fh`ghmagZlv bahlghr_gbckdeZ^u\Zxsboky aZl_f
f_`^m wlbfq_eh\_dhf b_]h ih^hi_qguf
DZd b m ex^_cihegZy ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv
oZjZdl_jh\
kmijm]h\dZd b ihegh_ bo koh^kl\hqZklh
]ZjZglbjm_l
[_ah[eZqgh_ kqZklv_
h[_bo klhjhgFm` b
`_gZ^he]h
khklhysb_ \ [jZd_g_j_^dh klZgh\ylky ihoh`bfb ^jm] gZ
^jm]ZdZd [jZlb k_kljZb lhqghlZd `_m ohaybgZb kh[Zdb
\ujZ[Zlu\Z_lky h[sghklv fZg_j
b ijb\uq_dijhba\h^ysZy
ih^qZk dhfbq_kdh_b \ lh`_ \j_fyljh]Zl_evgh_ \i_qZle_gb_
M hiulguo \eZ^_evp_\ lZdh_ koh^kl\hmkbeb\Z_lky [eZ]h^Zjy
\u[hjm hij_^_e_gghc ihjh^u beb dhgdj_lghckh[ZdblZd dZd
wlhl \u[hj h[uqgh ih^kdZau\Z_l kbfiZlb_c b jh^kl\_ggufb
q_jlZfb
oZjZdl_jZKmdb
qZmqZmdhlhjuo ihhq_j_^gh
\u[bjZeZ k_[_ fhy `_gZfh]ml kem`blv lbibqgufijbf_jhf
lZdbo
kbfiZlbqguob
]Zjfhgbjmxsbokh[ZdLh `_
hlghkblky dhfg_ kZfhfmb gZrb ^jmavyohjhrh agZxsb_ gZk
b gZrbo kh[Zdg_j_^dh jZa\e_dZxlky l_fqlh \ubkdb\Zxl
q_jlu koh^kl\Z f_`^mgZfb bgbfbKh[Zdb fh_c `_gu\k_]^Z
hkh[_ggh qbklhiehlgu b\ ba\_klghcf_j_ ex[ylihjy^hdHgb
gbdh]^Z g_ ih[_]ml gZijyfbd q_j_a em`mZ ijhoh^yf_`^m
demf[Zfb beb ]jy^dZfbg_ gZklmiylgZ \ajuoe_ggmxa_fex b
g_ aZ^_gmlgb _^bgh]h jZkl_gbyohly boki_pbZevgh wlhfmg_
h[mqZebFhb `_kh[Zdbm\u]hlh\u \Zeylvky\ ex[hffmkhj_
b gZlZkdb\Zxl \ ^hf qm^h\bsgh_ dhebq_kl\h ]jyabDhjhq_
]h\hjyjZaebqby f_`^m gZrbfbkh[ZdZfb ZgZeh]bqgu jZaebqbyf
fh_]h oZjZdl_jZ
b oZjZdl_jZ
fh_c `_guHlqZklb
wlh
h[tykgy_lky l_fqlh `_gZ \k_]^Z\u[bjZ_l bagh\h]h ihf_lZ
l_o s_gdh\\ dhlhjuo ij_h[eZ^Z_l gZke_^kl\_gghklv[he__
[eZ]hjh^guok^_j`Zgguoihqlb dZd
dhrdbqbklhiehlguo
qZmqZmlh]^Z dZd y ij_^ihqblZx ihlhfkl\h l_o\ dhf
ijhy\ey_lky [he__ `b\Zyb [hcdZyohly b[_amkeh\gh [he__
ie_[_ckdZygZlmjZ bo ijZjh^bl_evgbpufh_c h\qZjdbLblu
?s_ h^gZ ZgZeh]by h[gZjm`b\Z_lky \ lhfqlh kh[Zdbfh_c
`_gu _^yl mf_j_ggh b baysghZ bodjh\gu_ jh^kl\_ggbdb
ijbgZ^e_`Zsb_ fg_ij_^Zxlky ]gmkghfm h[`hjkl\mGh ihq_fm
lZd ihemqZ_lkyijZ\hkdZaZlv g_fh]m
GZ fhc \a]ey^iZjZee_evgZybeb
]ZjfhgbjmxsZy
kh[ZdZ ijbghkbl q_eh\_dm hsms_gb_ ^mr_\gh]h jZ\gh\_kbyb
^Z`_ m^h\e_l\hj_gby kh[hcGh \k_kdeZ^u\Z_lky ihbghfm k
lbihf kh[Zdh[jZlguf ]Zjfhgbjmxs_fm lbimKh\k_f g_^Z\gh
fg_ ^h\_ehkvgZ[ex^Zlv gZmebp_ beexkljZpbx \ur_kdZaZggh]h
;e_^guc madh]jm^ucq_eh\_d kofmjuf lj_\h`guf ebphfh^_luc
[_^ghgh j_ki_dlZ[_evghdZd h^_\Zxlkyf_edb_ qbgh\gbdbb
^Z`_ \ i_gkg_r_e \khijh\h`^_gbb lhs_ch\qZjdbdhlhjZy
mgueh [j_eZjy^hf kgbf< jmd_m g_]h[ue ly`_eucoeuklb
dh]^Z hg
\g_aZigh hklZgh\beky
b kh[ZdZ
gZ g_kdhevdh
kZglbf_ljh\ i_j_klmibeZ aZij_lgmx q_jlmjmdhyldZ
wlh]h
oeuklZ kkbehc himklbeZkvgZ __ghkZ gZebp_ g_ba\_klgh]h
hljZabeZkv lZdZyq_jgZy g_gZ\bklvb g_j\gh_jZa^jZ`_gb_qlh
y k ljm^hf m^_j`Zekyqlh[u
g_ \f_rZlvkyb g_mkljhblv
im[ebqguc kdZg^Ze>_j`m iZjbgZ qlhm]h^ghqlh aehihemqgZy
kh[ZdZ b]jZeZ\ `bagb k\h_]h_s_ [he__aehihemqgh]h ohaybgZ
lm `_ jhevdZdmx hgkZf b]jZe\ `bagbk\h_]h\_jhylgh
klhev `_`Zedh]h gZqZevgbdZ
KH;:DB B>?LB
>jm]bo gbkdhevdhg_ fZgbeh
Ihf_jblvky klh[hx kbehc
Bgh_ ^_ehqlhex[y
Lj_iZe f_gyluy l_[y
ME_g^hj
Fg_ g_ hq_gvih\_aeh \lhf kfuke_qlh yijh\_e k\h_
jZgg__ ^_lkl\h
[_a kh[ZdbFhy fZlv
ijbgZ^e_`ZeZ
d
ihdhe_gbxdhlhjh_ lhevdh qlh hldjueh ^eyk_[y fbdjh[h\
Lh]^Z \aZ`blhqguo k_fvyo[hevrbgkl\h ^_l_c [he_ehjZoblhf
ihlhfm qlh fhehdh kl_jbebah\Zehkv ^h l_o ihjihdZ \k_
\blZfbgu g_ jZajmrZebkv iheghklvxLhevdh dh]^Zy ^hklb]
fukeys_]h \hajZklZ b k f_gy fh`gh [ueh\aylv ^hklZlhqgh
gZ^_`gh_ q_klgh_ keh\hqlh y g_ ^Zf kh[Zd_h[ebau\Zlv
k_[yfg_ gZdhg_p[ueh ^ha\he_ghh[aZ\_klbkv i_j\hc\ fh_c
`bagb kh[ZdhcD g_kqZklvxwlhl i_kbdhdZaZeky gZklhysbf
^mjZdhf bgZ^he]h hl[be mf_gy \kydh_`_eZgb_ bf_lvkh[Zdm
Y m`_jZkkdZau\Ze \Zfh[ wlhf [_koj_[_lghfkms_kl\ lZdk_
Djhdb
Fhb `_ ^_lbjhkeb \l_kg_cr_f h[s_gbbk kh[ZdZfb\
]h^u ba jZgg_]h ^_lkl\Z m gZk [uehiylv kh[ZdY keh\gh
k_cqZk \b`mdZd wlb djhrdbd g_hibkm_fhfm m`Zkmfh_c
[_^ghc fZfuijhiheaZeb gZ
q_l\_j_gvdZo ih^
`b\hlhf
h]jhfghc h\qZjdbDh]^Z fhc kug mqbeky oh^blvhg bf_e
h[udgh\_gb_ \p_ieylvky \^ebgguc o\hklLbluqlh[u ijbgylv
\_jlbdZevgmx ihabpbxg_h[oh^bfmx ^ey oh`^_gbygZ ^\moZ
g_ gZ q_luj_odhg_qghklyoLblZ i_j_ghkbeZ wlmhi_jZpbx k
Zg]_evkdbf l_ji_gb_fgh _^\Z fZeur\uijyfeyeky bhlimkdZe
__ bkl_jaZgguc o\hkldZd hgZ ijbgbfZeZkv
\beylv wlbf
o\hklhf k lZdbf h[e_]q_gb_fqlhdZd ijZ\behaZ^_\ZeZ
k\h_]h fZe_gvdh]hfmqbl_eyb hgkgh\Z \ZebekygZ ihe
Qmldb_ kh[Zdb
hkh[_ggh eZkdh\u
k ^_lvfb
ex[bfh]h
ohaybgZkeh\gh hgbihgbfZxldZd ^hjh]b_fm wlbkms_kl\ZB
[hylvkyqlh
kh[ZdZ
ijbqbgbl
\j_^
j_[_gdmg_e_ih
gZh[hjhlkms_kl\m_l hiZkghklvqlh kh[ZdZkimkdZy ^_lyf
kebrdhf fgh]h_fh`_l ijbmqblv bo d ]jm[hklbb g_mf_gbx
aZf_qZlv qm`mx [hevWlh]h ke_^m_lhkl_j_]Zlvkyhkh[_ggh
dh]^Z j_qv b^_l
h djmiguo b
^h[jh^mrguo ikZo
\jh^_
k_g[_jgZjh\ b gvxnZmg^e_g^h\Gh h[uqgh kh[Zdbij_djZkgh
mf_xl mdehgylvkyhl kebrdhf m`gZahceb\h]h \gbfZgby^_l_c nZdlh[eZ^Zxsbc
agZqbl_evghc \hkiblZl_evghc
p_gghklvx
ihkdhevdm ghjfZevgu_ ^_lbihemqZxl [hevrh_m^h\hevkl\b_ hl
h[s_kl\Z kh[Zd bh]hjqZxlkydh]^Z l_ hlgbo m[_]Zxlhgb
\kdhj_ gZqbgZxl khh[jZ`ZlvdZd ke_^m_lk_[y \_klbqlh[u
kh[Zdb \b^_eb \gbo ohjhrbolh\Zjbs_c< j_amevlZl_ ^_lb
ohly [u g_fgh]h lZdlbqgu_ hl ijbjh^u_s_ \hq_gv jZgg_f
\hajZkl_ ijb\udZxlkqblZlvky k^jm]bfb
Dh]^Zijb^y \]hklby aZf_qZxqlh kh[ZdZ g_ba[_]Z_l
iylbr_klbe_lg_]h j_[_gdZZ kihdhcgh dg_fm ih^oh^blfh_
m\Z`_gb_ bd j_[_gdm bdh \k_ck_fv_ g_f_^e_ggh\hajZklZ_l
D g_kqZklvx^_lb gZrbo
khk_^_c ebr_gu lhc
fy]dhklb
dhlhjZy g_h[oh^bfZ ^ey h[s_gby k kh[Zdhc< hdj_klghklyo
gZr_c ^_j_\gb \u g_ \klj_lbl_ ]jmiiu fZevqbr_ddhlhjuo
khijh\h`^Ze [u kh[ZdZ b l_f [he__ g_kdhevdh
kh[Zd
Dhg_qghy agZx g_fZeh j_[ylbr_ddhlhju_ m k_[y ^hfZ
eZkdh\u
k
kh[ZdZfbgh
klhbl
bf kh[jZlvky [hevrhc
dhfiZgb_cdZd \ g_c g_ij_f_ggh hlus_lky ohly [u h^bg
ex[bl_ev fmqblv`b\hlguob hgih^qbgbl k\h_fm\ebygbx \k_o
hklZevguoDZd [ulh gb[uehgh kj_^gyy gb`g_Z\kljbckdZy
kh[ZdZaZ\b^_\
kj_^g_]h
gb`g_Z\kljbckdh]h
fZevqbdZ
imkdZ_lky gZml_dH^gZdh lZdh_ iheh`_gb_\_s_c hlgx^v g_
h[yaZl_evghb kms_kl\m_lhgh ^Ze_dhg_ \_a^_GZijbf_j\
;_ehjmkkbb ihqlb \ex[hc ^_j_\g_\u h[yaZl_evghm\b^bl_ gZ
mebp_ kf_rZggmx dhfiZgbx
fZevqbr_db kh[Zd[_eh]heh\uo
dZjZimah\ iylbk_fb e_l b jZaghh[jZaguo^\hjgy`_dKh[Zdb
gbkdhevdh g_ [hylkyfZevqm]Zgh\ZgZh[hjhliblZxl dgbf
]em[hqZcr__ ^h\_jb_qlh iha\hey_lfgh]h_ magZlvh oZjZdl_j_
b gZdehgghklyowlbo fZeur_c
KZfuc m^b\bl_evguc ba ba\_klguo fg_ ijbf_jh\ ^jm`[u
f_`^m
kh[Zdhc
b
j_[_gdhf
hlghkblky
d
^gyf
fh_]h
kh[kl\_ggh]h ^_lkl\ZJ_[_gdhf
[ue fhc [m^msbc
rmjbg
I_l_j IneZmfkug \eZ^_evpZ aZfdZ:evl_g[_j]Z kh[Zdhc h]jhfguc m]hevghq_jguc
gvxnZmg^e_g^Ehj^dZd
a\Zeb
gvxnZmg^e_g^Zh[eZ^Ze ihbklbg_ b^_Zevguf oZjZdl_jhfhg
[ue ojZ[j ^h [_ajZkkm^kl\Zij_^Zgmf_g b [eZ]hjh^_g
I_l_j `_dZd hg ex[beiho\ZklZlv bl_i_jvaZkem`_ggh keue
hli_luf
rZemghf
b
ijhdZagbdhfB
\hl
wlh]h
h^bggZ^pZlbe_lg_]h fZevqbdZ h]jhfguc gvxnZmg^e_g^
\u[jZe
k\hbf ohaybghfdh]^Z _]h
m`_\ajhkeufihemlhjZ]h^h\Zeuf
ikhf ijb\_aeb\ :evl_g[_j]Fg_ ^hkbo ihj g_ihgylghq_f
h[tykgyeky _]h \u[hjihkdhevdm Ehj^ ijbgZ^e_`Ze dlhfm
lbim kh[Zddhlhju_ h[uqgh ly]hl_xld \ajhkeuffm`qbgZf qZs_ \k_]h d]eZ\_ k_f_ckl\Z<hafh`ghlml dZdmxlh jhev
ku]jZeb jupZjkl\_ggu_ ih[m`^_gbylZd dZdI_l_j [uekZfuf
fZe_gvdbf b keZ[ufg_ lhevdhih kjZ\g_gbxkh k\hbfblj_fy
[jZlvyfbgh b kh \k_c [mcghc dhfiZgb_c ba
fgh`_kl\Z
fZevqbr_d b ^\molj_o ^_\hq_d ]jhahc
Zevl_g[_j]kdh]h
e_kZ]^_ gb b]jZeb \ bg^_cp_\b mkljZb\Zeb\aju\u hq_gv
j_Zebklbq_kdb_Z aZqZklmxb \iheg_j_Zevgu_Gh ohl_e [uy
ihkfhlj_lvdZdhc
fZevqbrdZ
jbkdg_l
m^Zjblv
^jm]h]h
fZevqbrdm_keb kh[ZdZfh]mqZydZd e_\b q_jgZydZd
ghqvlml `_iheh`bl _fm gZie_qb ^\_ly`_eu_ eZiuh[gZ`bl
m kZfh]h _]h ghkZ h]jhfgu_ [_ehkg_`gu_ am[ub m]jh`Zxs_
aZ\hjqbl \ lhg_kZfhc gbadhchj]Zgghc ljm[uI_l_j ieZlbe
aZ wlm ij_^Zgghklv ]hjyq_c ex[h\vxb hgbk Ehj^hf[ueb
g_jZaemqgu< j_amevlZl_ _]hh[jZah\Zgb_ g_kdhevdh kljZ^Ze
lZd dZd ^Z`_ kZf ]hkih^bg Gb^_jf_c_jkljh]bc ]m\_jg_j
fZevqbdZjZgh ebrb\r_]hky hlpZg_ hkf_eb\Zeky ih^gylv
]hehk gZ I_l_jZ \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ ba m]eZ dhfgZlu
^hg_kehkv
[u
aeh\_s__
jhdhqms__
juqZgb_
b
d
gbf
\_ebq_kl\_ggh ijb[ebabeky
[u q_jguc
e_\ihke_
q_]h
]hkih^bgm Gb^_jf_c_jm hklZehkv[u lhevdh[_kihfhsgh ih`Zlv
ie_qZfb bhl\_jgmlvky
Fhy fZlv jZkkdZau\ZeZfg_ hlZdhf `_kemqZ_ \^hf_ __
jh^bl_e_c]^_
fh]mqbc e_hg[_j]_j
wlZ ihjh^Z
lZd`_
ijbgZ^e_`bl d djmig_crbfba[jZe k\h_cohaycdhc feZ^rmxba
k_kl_jdhlhjmxdZd bI_l_jZ[_a`Zehklgh lbjZgbebklZjrb_
^_lb
Y iblZx ij_^m[_`^_gb_ ijhlb\ ex^_c b ^Z`_ hq_gv
fZe_gvdbo ^_l_cdhlhju_ [hylkykh[ZdIj_^m[_`^_gb_ wlh
Z[khexlgh g_hijZ\^Zggh \iheg_ _kl_kl\_gghqlh fZe_gvdh_
kms_kl\h ijb i_j\hfagZdhfkl\_ im]Z_lky[hevrbo g_agZdhfuo
kh[Zd bmf_xl h[oh^blvkyk gbfb\iheg_ hijZ\^ZghlZd dZd
gZ wlhkihkh[gu ebrvl_dlh qm\kl\m_lijbjh^m b `b\hlguo
Fhb kh[kl\_ggu_^_lb klZgh\bebkvaZy^eufb kh[ZqZlgbdZfb _s_
aZ^he]h ^hlh]hdZd bf bkihegyeky]h^b hgb^Z`_ ih^mfZlv
g_ fh]ebqlh kh[ZdZ kihkh[gZ ijbqbgblv bfaehIh wlhc
ijbqbg_ fhy ^hqv :]g_kkZdh]^Z _c[ueh hdhehr_klb e_l
gZim]ZeZ f_gy ^h ihemkf_jlbKemqbehkv wlhijb ke_^mxsbo
h[klhyl_evkl\ZoH^gZ`^u :]g_kkZ b __ [jZl \_jgmebkv k
ijh]medb \ khijh\h`^_gbb[hevrhc djZkb\hch\qZjdbdhlhjZy
ijbklZeZ dgbf ih^hjh]_Y j_rbeqlh kh[Zd_e_l r_klvk_fv
\ ^Zevg_cr_fhdZaZehkvqlh y g_hrb[kyH\qZjdZ reZaZ
^_lvfb ^h kZfh]h ^hfZ^_j`ZeZkv jy^hfHgZ dZaZeZkv
ijbrb[e_gghc b ^ZeZfg_ ih]eZ^blvk_[y k[hevrhc g_hohlhc
gZfhjsb\ ]m[uGh d^_lyf hgZevgmeZ kg_ihgylguf mihjkl\hf
Y
gbq_]h
g_
fh]
ihgylvKh[ZdZ
dZaZeZkv
^mr_\gh
g_mjZ\gh\_r_gghcZ ]eZ\gh_k dZdhc klZlb hgZ\g_aZigh
ijhgbdeZkv ex[h\vxd fhbf^_lyf"Iha`_ \k_h[tykgbehkv kZfuf
_kl_kl\_gguf h[jZahfH\qZjdZ [ueZ hq_gvg_j\ghc b[hyeZkv
jm`_cguo \uklj_eh\HgZ `beZ \^_j_\g_dbehf_ljZo \ ^_\ylb
\ur_ ihj_d_b \h \j_fyf_klgh]h ijZa^gbdZklj_ev[Z \ lbj_
ijb\_eZ __\ lZdhcm`Zkqlh hgZm[_`ZeZ dm^Z]eZaZ ]ey^yl b
g_ kmf_eZ hlukdZlv^hjh]m ^hfhcM __\eZ^_evpZ [ueh^\h_
^_l_cdhlhjuo h\qZjdZ h[h`ZeZ b dhlhju_ [ueb ijbf_jgh
jh\_kgbdZfb fhbf<hl ihq_fmhgZ b ijbklZeZd :]g_kk_ b__
[jZlmdh]^Z ih\klj_qZeZboGh lh]^Zy gbq_]hwlh]h g_ agZe
b g_
kebrdhf hohlgh
mklmibe fhev[Zf
^_l_cdhlhju_
mijZrb\Zeb hklZ\blv h\qZjdm m gZk_keb __ ohaybg
g_
hlus_lkyDhg_qghbf hq_gv gjZ\behkvqlh lZdZy[hevrZy b
djZkb\Zy kh[ZdZk lZdbfmihjkl\hf bs_lbo h[s_kl\Z
KblmZpbyihfbfh \k_]hijhq_]hhkeh`gyeZkv _s_ bl_f
qlh gZr kh[kl\_gguc i_k <hed ,lZd`_ [ue
qj_a\uqZcgh
ijb\yaZg d ^_lyf gZ hkh[ucg_aZ\bkbfuc bk^_j`Zgguc eZ^
\heqv_c kh[ZdbkZfpZG_ljm^gh ihgylvqlh ihy\e_gb_ wlh]h
m]h^eb\h]h
jZ[Zwlh]h
gZ]heh
kZfha\ZgpZdhlhjuc
mamjibjh\Ze _]h f_klh \ k_j^p_ ^_l_ckf_jl_evgh mya\beh
]hj^hklv
<hedZKgZqZeZ
fhbo
fgh]hqbke_gguo
m]jha
h[jZs_gguo dh[hbf ikZfb jh[dh]h\b^Z ijbr_evpZ hdZaZehkv
^hklZlhqghqlh[u ij_^hl\jZlblv^jZdm
Gh \aju\ [ueg_ba[_`_gFg_ ijbrehkv m^Zeblvky\ g_dh_
g_[hevrh_ ihf_s_gb_ aZ \Zgghc gZ \_jg_fwlZ`_dZd \^jm]
fhb fbjgu_ jZafure_gby [ueb ij_j\Zgu rmfhf h`_klhq_gghc
kh[Zqv_c ^jZdbd dhlhjhfm h m`Zklml `_ijbf_rZebkv
\hieb fh_c fZe_gvdhc:]g_kkua\Z\r_c gZ ihfhsvY dbgmeky
\gba ih e_klgbp_h^ghc jmdhc ijb^_j`b\Zy[jxdbb \b^_e
i_j_^ djuehf m`ZkZxs__ aj_ebs_ ^\mo kh[Zdkp_ib\rboky
\ [_kihsZ^ghc ko\Zld_b lhjqZsb_ baih^ gbogh`db fh_c
^hq_jbH[_amf_\y dbgmeky
d gbfko\Zlbe kh[Zd
aZ
aZ]jb\dbk g_q_eh\_q_kdhc kbehc jZagye bob m\b^_eqlh
:]g_kkZ e_`bl gZ kibg_ b lh`_ dj_idh ^_j`bl <hedZ
b
g_agZdhfpZ aZ
r_bklZjZykv
bo jZklZsblvIhlhf hgZ
h[tykgbeZ fg_qlh ijhbahrehmk_\rbkv gZa_fex f_`^m ^\mfy
ikZfbhgZ
ijbgyeZkv ]eZ^blv
h[hboqlh[u
ihfbjblv
Dhg_qghwlh kj_^kl\h\hauf_eh ijhlb\hiheh`gh_^_ckl\b_b
iku [jhkbebkv^jm] gZ^jm]Z:]g_kkZ ohl_eZbo jZagylvb g_
\uimklbeZ^Z`_ dh]^Z
hgb hijhdbgmeb __
gZ kibgm
b
ijh^he`Zeb ^jZlvkygZ^ g_cB \k_lZdb hgZgb gZk_dmg^m g_
ih^mfZeZqlh lhlbeb ^jm]hcfh`_l mdmkblvb __
D:D <U;J:LVKH;:DM
DZd ymagZx\_j_g ebfhc \u[hj"
<R_dkibj<_g_pbZgkdbc dmi_p
<u[hj \k_]^Z ^_eh aZljm^gbl_evgh_b hkh[_gghdh]^Z
j_qv b^_l h \u[hj_ kh[Zdihkdhevdm kms_kl\m_lfgh`_kl\h
kZfuo jZaghh[jZaguo ihjh^agZlhd `_fh`_l ^ZlvijZ\bevguc
kh\_llhevdh _keb hg
agZdhf k [m^msbf \eZ^_evp_f
b
ihgbfZ_lq_]h
lhl ohq_l
hl k\h_c
kh[ZdbGZijbf_j
k_glbf_glZevgZy b h^bghdZy klZjZy ^_\ZbsmsZy ih^oh^ysbc
ij_^f_l ^ey ex[\bb aZ[hlg_ h[j_l_lbkdhfh]h ml_r_gby\
k^_j`Zgghc b \ukhdhf_jghcqZmqZmdhlhjZy ij_abjZ_l eZkdb
b \klj_qZ_l \_jgm\rmxkyohaycdm lhevdhe_]dbf ihfZob\Zgb_f
o\hklZ\f_klh lh]hqlh[u aZiju]Zlvhl jZ^hklbdZd ^jm]b_
kh[ZdbL_fdhfm gm`gZ g_`gZy b ijb\yaqb\Zy
kh[ZdZ
dhlhjZy iheh`bl]heh\m gZdhe_gh ohaybgZih^gbf_l yglZjgu_
]eZaZ b [m^_lqZkZfb \abjZlvgZ g_]hk g_fufh[h`Zgb_fy
ihj_dhf_g^mx
bjeZg^kdh]h
k_ll_jZ
beb
ij_^klZ\bl_ey
dZdhcgb[m^v koh^ghc^ebgghmohc b^ebgghr_jklghc ihjh^uGZ
fhc `_ \dmkwlb kh[Zdb kebrdhf k_glbf_glZevgu< gZrb
[_kihdhcgu_ b lj_\h`gu_\j_f_gZ o\ZlZ_lijbqbg ^ey]jmklb
bih`Zemc^ey [hevrbgkl\Z ba gZk g_ lZd m` ihe_agh
ihklhyggh_ khijbdhkgh\_gb_ k kms_kl\hfdhlhjh_ \j_fyhl
\j_f_gb gZihfbgZ_l h k\h_f ijbkmlkl\bb imklvdjhldbfgh
]em[hdbf \a^hohf<_k_eh_ b i_qZevgh_ gZkljh_gb_
jZ\gh
aZjZabl_evgub q_eh\_d k `b\uf b kheg_qgufoZjZdl_jghf
ih\kx^m g_k_lk kh[hc[h^jhklv bjZ^hklvLh `_hlghkblky b
d \_k_ehc kh[Zd_b fg_ dZ`_lkyqlh ihimeyjghklvfgh]bo
kf_rguo ihjh^ h[tykgy_lky
bf_ggh gZr_c ihlj_[ghklvx
\
\_k_ev_RZeh\eb\hklv k_evyfl_jv_jZ b _]h
ij_^Zgghklv
ohaybgm fh]ml
ihkem`blv g_iehohc
fhjZevghc
ih^^_j`dhc
q_eh\_dm f_eZgohebq_kdh]h kdeZ^ZDlh g_meu[g_lkydh]^Z
aZ[Z\gh_ fZe_gvdh_ kms_kl\hij_bkiheg_ggh_ jZ^hklb`bagb
ih^[_`blih^iju]b\Zy gZ k\hbodhjhl_gvdbo eZidZo h^bg fhc
agZdhfuc hdj_klbe bo
oh^bevgufb khkhqdZfbgZdehgbl
]heh\m b
k g_\bgguf
emdZ\kl\hf ih]ey^bl
gZ ohaybgZ
ijb]eZrZy _]hihb]jZlv"
Lhfmdlh bs_l g_ ijhklh ^jm]Zgh b g_bkdZ`_gguc
oZjZdl_jy ihkh\_lmx h[aZ\_klbkv kh[Zdhc kh\k_f
bgh]h
lbiZKZf
y ij_^ihqblZx
kh[Zdhlghkbl_evgh
g_^Ze_dh
mr_^rbo hl ^bdbo nhjfFhb ]b[jb^u qZmqZm b g_f_pdbo
h\qZjhd b \g_rg_ b \gmlj_gg_ hq_gv [ebadbd k\hbf^bdbf
ij_^dZfQ_f f_gvr_ h^hfZrgb\Zgb_ baf_gbeh ihjh^mq_f
[hevr_ k\hckl\\hevgh]h obsgbdZkhojZgy_l kh[ZdZl_f \ur_ y
p_gx __^jm`[mIh lhc`_ ijbqbg_fg_ g_ gjZ\blkybaebrg__
bkdZ`_gb_ bklbghcijbjh^u kh[Zdbd dhlhjhfm fh`_lijb\_klb
h[mq_gb_b y g_ohqm ^Z`_qlh[u fhbkh[Zdb mljZlbebk\hc
i_j\h[ulguc hohlgbqbcbgklbgdldhlhjuc ijbqbgy_lfg_ g_fZeh
oehihl b h[oh^blky ^h\hevgh ^hjh]h;m^v hgb
djhldbfb
y]gylZfbg_ kihkh[gufbh[b^_lv b
fmobfg_ g_dZaZehkv [u
lZdbf qm^hfqlh y kihdhcgh fh]m\\_jblv bffhbo ^jma_c
<i_j\u_ yihgye wlh ihke_h^gh]h ^h\hevghkljZrgh]h kemqZy
DZdlh \`_klhdb_ abfgb_ fhjhau\ gZraZg_k_gguc kg_]hfkZ^
aZ[_`Ze he_gvb ljb fhb kh[Zdb_]h jZkl_jaZebY klhye
ihjZ`_gguc m`Zkhf\hae_
hdjh\Z\e_ggh]h ljmiZ b
\^jm]
hkhagZedZdh_ [_amkeh\gh_ ^h\_jb_ \gmrZ_l fg_
kbkl_fZ
aZij_lh\mijZ\eyxsbo ^_ckl\byfbwlbo k\bj_iuoobsgbdh\
\_^v \lh \j_fyfhb ^_lb [ueb]hjZa^h f_gvr_ b[_aaZsblg__
he_gyqvb bkl_jaZggu_hklZgdb e_`Zebi_j_^h fghcY ^Z`_
m^b\beky Z[khexlghfm[_kkljZrbxk dZdbfy _`_^g_\gh hl^Z\Ze
ojmidb_ l_evpZ fhbo ^_l_c \h \eZklvwlbo q_exkl_cklhev
ihoh`bo gZ\heqvb
>_ckl\bl_evgh^ey kh[Zdb gZiZklv gZ ^_l_cohaybgZ \_sv g_keuoZggZyb y m[_`^_gqlh ikbobq_kdb a^hjh\Zy
kh[ZdZ
\hh[s_
gZ
wlh
g_
kihkh[gZH^gZdh g_j\gmx
\ukhdhihjh^bklmx kh[ZdmZ bgh]^Z
^Z`_ b
ihemdjh\dm
j_\ghklvd dhlhjhc\k_ kh[Zdbhq_gv kdehggufh`_l ^h\_klb
^h m`Zkguo ihklmidh\G_^Z\gh y magZe h ^_ckl\bl_evgh
`mldhf ijhbkr_kl\bbdh]^Z g_qbklhihjh^guc l_jv_jij_`^_
[Zeh\_gv k_fvb[ue ihke_ jh`^_gbyj_[_gdZ ihkZ`_ggZ p_iv
b ijb i_j\hf m^h[ghf kemqZ_ iju]gme \ dheykdmb aZ]jua
fZeurZD kqZklvxwlh j_^qZcrbc kemqZcb j_\ghklvdZd
ijZ\behg_
^hklb]Z_l klhev
hiZkgh]h gZdZeZijbq_f
gZkdhevdh fh`gh km^blv\
lZdhc kl_i_gb ih^^Zlvky
_c
kihkh[gu lhevdh kh[Zdb gZb[he__ bgnZglbevgh]h lbiZFhb
\heqvb kh[Zdb gbdh]^Z g_ j_\gh\Zeb dfZe_gvdbf ^_lyfZ
gZh[hjhlkZfb
hlghkbebkv
d
gbf
[he__
beb
f_g__
ihjh^bl_evkdbB\hafh`ghlml djh_lky h^gZba ijbqbg
ihq_fm ylZd ex[exwlhl lbikh[Zd
<ijhq_fa^_kv fu i_j_oh^bf \ h[eZklv \dmkZb
y
ij_djZkgh ihgbfZxqlh fhy ^bdZyobsgZy kh[ZdZ^Ze_dh
g_
h[yaZl_evgh ^he`gZ\gmrZlv kbfiZlbb \k_fb dZ`^hfm<heqvb
kh[ZdZ baaZ qm\kl\bl_evghklbk^_j`Zgghklb bg_aZ\bkbfhklb
oZjZdl_jZ ^h\hevgh lm]hih^^Zxlky h[mq_gbxb bkihevah\Zlv
ijbkmsb_ bfihbklbg_ g_\_jhylgu_ikbobq_kdb_ j_kmjku m^Z_lky
lhevdh lhfmdlh agZ_l bo b ihgbfZ_l ihgZklhys_fmb
lhevdh ^ey lZdh]h q_eh\_dZ hgb fh]ml klZlv
bklhqgbdhf
jZ^hklb b m^h\e_l\hj_gby>jm]b_ h[j_lml lh`_ \q_klghf
^h[jhf [hdk_j_beb wj^_evl_jv_j_\_^v gZqbgZxsbcnhlh]jZn
^h[b\Z_lky agZqbl_evgh [hevrbo mki_oh\dh]^Z jZ[hlZ_lk
ijhklhc a_jdZedhcZ g_ khkeh`ghckgZ[`_gghc fgh`_kl\hf
ijbkihkh[e_gbc dZf_jhc
Wlh \h\k_ g_ agZqblqlh y ohqm hihjhqblv kh[Zdk
g_keh`ghc bijyfhebg_cghc ikbobdhcGZh[hjhly hq_gvex[ex
[hdk_jh\ b[hevrbo l_jv_jh\qvx fm`_kl\_ggmx bijb\yaqb\mx
gZlmjm
g_
m^Z_lky
bkihjlblv
^Z`_
hq_gv
g_mf_euf
\hkiblZl_eyfD lhfm `_ y ohl_e [uih^q_jdgmlvqlh fhb
\ukdZau\Zgby
h
dZq_kl\Zo
hl^_evguo
kh[Zqvbo ihjh^Zo
_kl_kl\_gghghkyl hq_gv
h[h[s_gguc oZjZdl_jlZd
dZd
kms_kl\m_l
[_a]jZgbqgh_
fgh`_kl\h
bg^b\b^mZevguo
bkdexq_gbc< kmsghklblZdh_ h[h[s_gb_ g_f_g__ mya\bfh
q_f ihiuldZ ih^\_klb ih^ h^gh bkq_jiu\Zxs__ hij_^_e_gb_
\k_o Zg]ebqZgnjZgpmah\ beb g_fp_\Y agZxqj_a\uqZcgh
qm\kl\bl_evguo [hdk_jh\ b [_koZjZdl_jguo qZmqZmy ^Z`_
[ue agZdhf k \_kvfZ j_rbl_evguf bg_aZ\bkbfuf kiZgb_e_f
Fhy k_j_[jbklhk_jZy KxabgZ q_c oZjZdl_j[_kkihjgh
agZqbl_evgh_ \ebygb_ hdZaZeZ
djh\v __
ij_^dh\h\qZjhd
[u\Z_l h[Zyl_evgh^jm`_ex[ghc k gZrbfb ]hklyfb b
ihqlb
kh\k_f ebr_gZ]hj^hklb \ukhdhf_jby^jm]bo qZmqZm
Ih`Zemc\f_klh lh]h qlh[u ^Z\Zlv dhgdj_lgu_kh\_lu
ihe_ag_c
[m^_l
ij_^hkl_j_qv
gZqbgZxsbodZdbo
kh[Zd
ijbh[j_lZlv g_ ke_^m_l b dZdbo gZdehgghkl_c \gbo gm`gh
ba[_]ZlvGh ij_`^_q_f ijh^he`Zlvy ohl_e[u mdZaZlvqlh
ij_^hkl_j_]Zy\h\k_
g_ klZ\ex
k_[_ p_evx
hl]h\hjblv
dh]hgb[m^v hlijbh[j_l_gby kh[ZdbEx[Zy kh[ZdZ emqr_q_f
gbq_]hb ^Z`__keb gZqbgZxsbc\eZ^_e_p kh[Zdbij_g_[j_`_l
fhbfb baeh`_ggufb a^_kv ijZ\beZfbhg \k_lZdb ihemqblhl
k\h_c kh[Zdb fgh]h m^h\hevkl\byH^gZdh m^h\hevkl\b_wlh
[m^_l _s_ [hevrbf_keb hg mql_l fhb aZ\_lui_j\uc ba
dhlhjuo ]eZkblihdmiZcl_ kh[Zdma^hjh\mx bl_ehf b ^mohf
?keb m \Zkg_l dZdboeb[h \_kdbo ijbqbg^ey bgh]h\u[hjZ
[_jbl_ kZfh]h kbevgh]hlheklh]h b[hcdh]h s_gdZ\ ihf_l_
wlb ljb k\hckl\Z khimlkl\mxl ^jm] ^jm]m km^b\bl_evguf
ihklhygkl\hfG_h[oh^bfh mqblu\Zlvqlh kmqdb\k_]^Z [u\Zxl
f_evq_ dh[_e_c?keb m jh^bl_e_c beb s_gyl ijhy\eyxlky
dZdb_eb[h ijbagZdb \ujh`^_gbyemqr_ \h\k_hldZaZlvky hl
s_gdZHkh[_ggh hklhjh`guf ke_^m_l
[ulvbf_y ^_eh
k
bghkljZggufb ihjh^ZfblZd dZd lml baaZ fZeh]h
qbkeZ
ohjhrbo wda_fieyjh\\hafh`_g l_kgucbg[jb^bg]Emqr_ kh[ZdZ
k jh^hkeh\ghc ih[_^g__ ebklhnbpbZevgh __aZ\_jyxsbc
dZd ijZ\beh\kdhj_
bkq_aZ_lih]j_[_gguc ih^
^jm]bfb
[mfZ]Zfb \ dZdhfgb[m^v ysbd_ ibkvf_ggh]hklheZgh aZlh
[he__ `bag_kihkh[gZf_g__ g_j\gZyDZd klZg_lykgh ba ]eZ\u
Ijbau\ d l_fdlh jZa\h^blkh[Zdy ijb^_j`b\Zxkv\_kvfZ
gbadh]h fg_gby h kh\j_f_gguo ijbgpbiZo jZa\_^_gbykh[Zd
ijbgpbiZodhlhju_
kebrdhf
[hevrh_
agZq_gb_
ijb^Zxl
djZkhl_kh[Zdij_g_[j_]Zy bomfkl\_ggufb kihkh[ghklyfb
Z ihlhfm bkdj_gg_kh\_lmx gZqbgZxsbfg_ ijbh[j_lZlvkh[Zdm
kh kebrdhf m`ohjhr_cjh^hkeh\ghcIjbh[j_lZy ihf_kv\u
bf__l_ ]hjZa^hf_gvr_ rZgkh\hdZaZlvky \eZ^_evp_f g_j\gh]h
mfkl\_ggh ms_j[gh]h `b\hlgh]hq_f dmib\kh[Zdm k\hk_fvx
q_fibhgZfb \ jh^hkeh\ghcG_f_pdmx h\qZjdm\k_]^Z ke_^m_l
[jZlv hl jh^bl_e_cijbgZ^e_`Zsbo d kem`_[ghcebgbbb \
wlhf kemqZ_ m^hklh\_j_gb_ __ ijhbkoh`^_gby hl q_fibhgh\
bf__l \iheg_j_Zevgmx ijZdlbq_kdmxp_gghklv
Ij_`^_ q_f h[aZ\_klbkv kh[Zdhcke_^m_l \a\_kblvg_
hdZ`_lky eb wlh^ey \Zkkebrdhf [hevrhcg_j\ghc gZ]jmadhc
Hq_gv ih^\b`gu_ kh[Zdb\jh^_ nhdkl_jv_jh\e_]dh fh]ml
\u\_klb bak_[y g_mjZ\gh\_r_ggh]hq_eh\_dZhkh[_ggh _keb bo
g_ihk_^eb\hklv
ihjh`^Z_lky
g_
klhev `bag_jZ^hklghklvx
kdhevdh qj_af_jgh \ha[m^bfhc g_j\ghc kbkl_fhcIjbdb^u\Zy
jZaf_ju kh[Zdb k mq_lhf jZaf_jh\ \Zr_]h `bebsZke_^m_l
ijbgbfZlv \h \gbfZgb_ b __ l_fi_jZf_glK_glbf_glZevguc
k_ll_j^ey dhlhjh]h ]eZ\gh_m^h\hevkl\b_ mfbevgh \abjZlv
gZ ohaybgZ[m^_l f_gvr_ kljZ^Zlv hl l_kghlu ]hjh^kdhc
d\Zjlbjuq_f rZeh\eb\uc fZe_gvdbo l_jv_j<ijhq_fb \
kZfhc fZe_gvdhcd\Zjlbj_ lj_[m_lkyg_ [hevr_q_f ^ey \Zr_]h
kh[kl\_ggh]h a^hjh\vy\iheg_ ^hklZlhqgh^\mo ihemqZkh\uo
ijh]mehd ihk\_`_fm \ha^mom
Fgh]b_ g_hiulgu_ ex[bl_eb kh[Zd qZklh ^_eZxlhrb[dm
\u[bjZy lh]h s_gdZdhlhjuc \i_j\u_ `_fbgmlu agZdhfkl\Z
gZqbgZ_l ^_eZlvbf ^jm`_kdb_ Z\ZgkuKe_^m_l ihfgblvqlh \
wlhf
kemqZ_
\ug_khfg_ggh\u[bjZ_l_
gZb[hevr_]h
ih^oZebfZb \jy^ eb \ ^Zevg_cr_f \Zf
[m^_l
ijbylgh
gZ[ex^ZlvdZd \ZrZkh[ZdZ lhqghlZd `_ijb\_lkl\m_l \k_o
qm`bo ih^jy^<u[jZ\ ba^_\ylb ly\dZxsbof_oh\uo dem[hqdh\
bf_ggh Kxaby ij_^ihq_e __hklZevguf hlqZklbihlhfmqlh
bf_ggh hgZ
ijhy\beZ gZb[hevr__
g_]h^h\Zgb_dh]^Z
__
dhkgmebkv fhbjmdblh _klvjmdb ihklhjhgg_]h
Ij_kfudZl_evkl\h wlh h^bgba om^rbo kh[Zqvboihjhdh\
bdZd y m`_
mihfbgZehgh jZa\b\Z_lky \
j_amevlZl_
khojZg_gby g_jZa[hjqb\h]h^jm`_ex[bydhlhjh_ fheh^u_ s_gylZ
ijhy\eyxlky ih hlghr_gbx dh \k_f ex^yf b dh
\ajhkeuf
kh[ZdZfIhjhdhf wlhklZgh\blky lhevdhm \ajhkeuokh[Zd^ey
fheh^uo `_ lZdh_ ih\_^_gb_ \iheg_ ghjfZevghb
gbq_]h
^mjgh]h \ g_f g_lD g_kqZklvxg_\hafh`gh ij_^kdZaZlv
\ujZkl_l ebba eZkdh\h]hs_gdZ ih^oZebf bebk \hajZklhf hg
ijbh[j_l_l g_h[oh^bfmx k^_j`Zgghklv ih hlghr_gbxd qm`bf
Ihwlhfmbf_y ^_ehk ihjh^Zfbm dhlhjuowlZ k^_j`Zgghklv
jZa\b\Z_lky iha^g__emqr_ ih^h`^Zlvk ihdmidhc s_gdZihdZ
_fm gZbkihegblky iylvr_klv f_kyp_\<ur_kdZaZggh_ hkh[_ggh
hlghkblky d
kiZgb_eyf b
^jm]bf ^ebgghmobf
hohlgbqvbf
kh[ZdZfm qZmqZm wlZ q_jlZjZa\b\Z_lky jZgvr_b ^Z`_\
^\Z ^\Z kiheh\bghc f_kypZm gbom`_ fh`gh aZf_lblvq_jlu
bg^b\b^mZevgh]h
oZjZdl_jZ?keb
hiZkghklv
aZihemqblv
ih^oZebfZ hlkmlkl\m_llh _klv ^_eh dZkZ_lky ihjh^^ey
dhlhjuo lZdZy kdehgghklv qm`^Zbeb _kebihdmiZl_ev agZ_l
h[hbo jh^bl_e_c k\h_c[m^ms_c kh[Zdby ihkh\_lh\Ze[u _fm
aZ[jZlv s_gdZ dZdfh`gh jZgvr__^\Z _]hfh`gh [m^_l [_a
\j_^Z ^eyg_]h jZaemqblvk fZl_jvxJZamf__lkylZdh]h s_gdZ
gm`gh [m^_l hq_gv ohjhrh dhjfblvij_bfms_kl\_ggh fykhfb
fhehdhfq_j_a ^h\hevgh dhjhldb ijhf_`mldbg_
aZ[u\Zy
^h[Z\eylv d _]h jZpbhgm kj_^kl\Z ijhlb\jZoblZgZijbf_j
ju[bc `bj
Q_f [he__fheh^hc \aylZkh[ZdZl_fdZd ijZ\behdj_iq_
klZgh\blky __ ijb\yaZgghklv d ohaybgm \ihke_^kl\bbb l_f
[hevr_ m^h\hevkl\by[m^_l hgZ_fm ^hklZ\eylvhkh[_ggh dh]^Z
hg [m^_l \kihfbgZlvq_]h
wlh _fm klhbeJZ^b
lZdbo
\hkihfbgZgbc fh`gh
kfbjblky k
ba]jua_ggufb lmneyfb
b
[hlbgdZfb bebk ^\mfylj_fy iylgZfbgZ dh\j_
B ihke_^gbc
kh\_lHg
ijh^bdlh\Zg fhbfb
ebqgufb
ijbkljZklbyfbZ ihlhfmqblZl_ev fh`_lkjZam `_ijhimklblv
_]h fbfh mr_c_keb \hafh`gh\u[bjZcl_ kmdmg_kfhljy gZ
lhqlh ^\_ __ l_qdm \ ]h^m b ijbqbgyl \Zfg_dhlhju_
g_m^h[kl\Z>mfZx\k_ hiulgu_\eZ^_evpu kh[Zdkh]eZkylky kh
fghcqlh
k
lhqdb
aj_gby
oZjZdl_jZ
kmdZ
\k_]^Z
ij_^ihqlbl_evg__q_f
dh[_evH^gh
\j_fy m
gZk
\
:evl_g[_j]_
`bebq_luj_ kmdbfhy g_f_pdZyh\qZjdZ LblZ
Ib]b qZmqZm fh_c`_guDZlb lZdkZ fh_]h[jZlZ b [mev^h]
fh_c k\hyq_gbpuLhevdh kh[ZdZ fh_]hhlpZ [ueZdh[_e_fb
_fm [ueh
g_e_]dh hl]hgylv
hl gZr_]h
^hfZ g_ijhr_guo
moZ`_jh\DZdlh l_qdZm Ib]bb DZlbgZqZeZkv h^gh\j_f_ggh
gh fuijh^he`Zeb [jZlvbo kkh[hc gZ>mgZcihkdhevdm fh]eb
hiZkZlvky f_aZevygkZ Ib]b ojZgbeZ Z[khexlgmx \_jghklv
gZr_fm ikm ;m[bZ ^ey fbgbZlxjghc lZdku\ hdj_klghklyo
ijhklh g_ gZrehkv[u ih^oh^ys_]hiZjlg_jZY ^Z\ghijb\ud
qlh gZkkhijh\h`^Zxl bqm`b_ kh[Zdbgh ihke_lh]hdZd fu
\ureb ba ^_j_\gb gZ wlhl jZajZaf_ju gZr_ck\blu f_gy
ihjZabebb ygZqZe kq_lhdZaZehkvqlhdjhf_ gZrbo iylb
aZ gZfb [_`Zeh _s_ r_klgZ^pZlv ikh\Ke_^h\Zl_evghgZr
wkdhjl khklhye ba^\Z^pZlv h^ghckh[ZdbB l_f g_f_g__ y
ih\lhjyx k\hc kh\_lkmdZ [he__ij_^ZggZyq_f dh[_ev__
ikbobdZ lhgvr_[h]Zq_ b keh`g__q_f m dh[_eybdZd
ijZ\behhgZ mfg__q_f dh[_evFg_ ^h\_ehkv[ebadh magZlv
hq_gv fgh]bo
`b\hlguob
y ml\_j`^Zxqlh ba
\k_o
q_l\_jhgh]bo kha^Zgbc [eb`_ \k_]h d q_eh\_dmih lhgdhklb
\hkijbylby b ihkihkh[ghklb dbklbgghc ^jm`[_klhbl bf_ggh
kmdZB
kljZgghqlh
__
gZa\Zgb_
ij_\jZlbehkv
\
jm]Zl_evkl\h
IJBAU< DL?FDLH J:A<H>BLKH;:D
M pbjdh\uo kh[Zdbkihegyxsbo keh`gu_ ljxdbdhlhju_
lj_[mxl
[hevrhc
khh[jZabl_evghklbj_^dh
bf_xlky
jh^hkeh\gu_B ^_eh g_\ lhfqlh [_^guf^j_kkbjh\sbdZf g_
ih dZjfZgm ihjh^bklu_kh[Zdb lZeZgleb\u_ pbjdh\u_kh[Zdb
klhyl [_r_gguo ^_g_]Z \ lhfqlh `b\hlgufZjlbklZf
lj_[mxlky g_ nbabq_kdb_Z ikbobq_kdb_ dZq_kl\ZIhf_kb
ih^oh^yl ^ey wlhcjZ[hlu g_lhevdh ihlhfmqlh hgbmfg__
gh ]eZ\guf h[jZahf ihlhfmqlh hgb dm^Zf_g__ g_j\gu
ihkdhevdm bo[he__ dj_idbchj]Zgbaf iha\hey_lbf \u^_j`b\Zlv
agZqbl_evgh_ g_j\gh_ gZijy`_gb_Ba \k_ofhbo kh[Zdlhevdh
h^gZ [ueZ qbklhihjh^ghcb fh]eZ[u mqZkl\h\Zlv\ \uklZ\dZo
g_f_pdZy h\qZjdZ ;bg]hWlh [uehq_gv [eZ]hjh^guci_k
jupZjv [_a kljZoZ b mij_dZgh ihlhgdhklb \hkijbylbyb
keh`ghklb ikbobdb hgg_ r_egb \dZdh_ kjZ\g_gb_k Lblhc
\_kvfZ ie_[_ckdhch\qZjdhc\hh[s_ g_bf_\r_c jh^hkeh\ghcM
fh_]h njZgpmakdh]h [mev^h]Z jh^hkeh\gZyijZ\^Z[ueZgh
hg g_ ihr_e \ k\hbo ZjbklhdjZlbq_kdbo ij_^dh\b g_klZe
\hiehs_gb_f ihjh^bklhklb wlhfm ij_iylkl\h\Zeh
djmigh_
keh`_gb_kebrdhf \ulygmlZy]heh\Zkebrdhf ^ebggu_gh]b b
kebrdhf ijyfZy kibgZDhjhq_ ]h\hjy^ey
njZgpmakdh]h
[mev^h]Z hg kebrdhf m` ihoh^be gZ ghjfZevgmxkh[ZdmGh
h^gh y agZe
l\_j^hgb h^bg
q_fibhg _]h ihjh^u
ih
mfkl\_gguf dZq_kl\Zfg_ ]h^bekyfh_fm ;meebb \ih^f_ldb
DZd gb ]jmklghgh klj_fe_gb_ ih^^_j`b\Zlv \ihjh^_
kljh`Zcrb_
klZg^Zjlu
hij_^_e_gguo
nbabq_kdbo
^Zgguo
g_kh\f_klbfh k jZa\blb_f
mfkl\_gguo dZq_kl\Bg^b\b^u
hl\_qZxsb_ bl_f b ^jm]bflj_[h\ZgbyfgZklhevdh j_^dbqlh
g_ \ khklhygbb ihkem`blv hkgh\hc^ey ^Zevg_cr_]hjZa\blby
k\h_c ihjh^uIjb \k_f`_eZgbb yg_ fh]m\kihfgblv gb h^gh]h
\_ebdh]h fukebl_eydhlhjuc nbabq_kdb [ue [u kjZ\gbf k
:iheehghfb gb h^ghc gZklhys_c djZkZ\bpu ohly [u
kh
kj_^gbfb mfkl\_ggufb kihkh[ghklyfbb lhqghlZd `_fg_ g_
ba\_kl_g gb h^bg kh[Zqbc q_fibhgdhlhjh]h y ohl_e [u
ihemqblv \ k\hxkh[kl\_gghklvG_evay kdZaZlvqlh wlb^\Z
jZaghgZijZ\e_gguo b^_ZeZ h[yaZl_evgh ^he`gubkdexqZlv ^jm]
^jm]Zb
ljm^gh ihgylvihq_fm kh[ZdZ
k [_amij_qguf
nbabq_kdbf keh`_gb_f g_ fh`_l [ulv b mfkl\_gghklhev `_
h^Zj_gghch^gZdh b ih hl^_evghklb wlb b^_ZeugZklhevdh
j_^dbqlh boh[t_^bg_gb_ \h^ghc hkh[bdjZcg_ fZeh\_jhylgh
?keb ^Z`_ dlhgb[m^v ihklZ\bl k_[_ p_evx \u\_klb lZdh_
kh\_jr_gkl\hhg
m[_^blkyqlh
^hklb]gmlv
_]h
[_a
dZdh]heb[h dhfijhfbkkZ g_\hafh`gh>ey kh[ZddZd b^ey
]hem[_c\uoh^ bo wlhc ^be_ffu [ue gZc^_g\ hj]ZgbaZpbb
^\mo \uklZ\hd jZagh]hlbiZgZ dhlhjuo `b\hlguokm^yl eb[h
ih wdkl_jv_jmeb[h ih mf_gbx jZ[hlZlvM ]hem[_c^_eh
aZreh m`_ lZd^Ze_dhqlh nmgdpbb ^_dhjZlb\guob ihqlh\uo
ihjh^
jZa]jZgbq_gu
iheghklvxL_g^_gpby
d
ih^h[ghfm
jZa^_e_gbxgZ
fhc \a]ey^gZf_qZ_lky b
\ hlghr_gbb
g_f_pdbo h\qZjhdG_khfg_gghg_dhlhju_ g_j\gu_b aeh[gu_
h[eZ^Zl_eb f_^Ze_c aZ
wdkl_jv_j hlebqZxlky
oZjZdl_jhf
gZklhevdh ^Ze_dbf hl b^_ZeZqlh bo ke_^m_l hlg_klb d
kh\k_f bghcdZl_]hjbbq_f gZklhysbojZ[hqboh\qZjhdqvb
bkdexqbl_evgu_ dZq_kl\Z iha\heyxl q_eh\_dmbkihevah\Zlv bo
^ey kZfuo jZaebqguop_e_c< ijhrehfdh]^Z kh[Zdb [hevr_
bkihevah\Zebkv ^ey ^_eZZ g_ ^ey aZ[Z\uijb
\u[hj_
ijhba\h^bl_ey
\jy^
eb
ij_g_[j_]Zeb
_]h
ikbobq_kdbfb
kihkh[ghklyfbK
^jm]hc
klhjhgu^_n_dlu
oZjZdl_jZ
ijhy\eyxlky bm hl^_evguolbih\ kh[Zddhlhju_ bkihevamxlky
lhevdh ^ey
jZ[hqbo p_e_cIh fg_gbx
\_kvfZ
\b^gh]h
Z\lhjbl_lZ \ wlhf \hijhk_hlkmlkl\b_ ij_^Zgghklbh^ghfm
ohaybgm m g_dhlhjuo hohlgbqvbo kh[Zdh[tykgylky bf_gghbo
ki_pbZebaZpb_cIjb \u\_^_gbbwlbo ihjh^hkgh\gh_ \gbfZgb_
h[jZsZehkv gZ
hkljhlm qmlvyb \iheg_
\hafh`ghqlh
ij_^ihql_gb_ hl^Z\Zehkv `b\hlgufdhlhju_ g_
hlebqZebkv
ij_^Zgghklv
h^ghfm
ohaybgmihkdhevdm
[h]Zlu_
hohlgbdbex[bl_eb g_j_^dh ihjmqZxl ihbkdb jZg_gghc
^bqb
gZ_fguf kem`bl_eyfb ohjhrZyhohlgbqvy kh[ZdZ ^he`gZmf_lv
jZ[hlZlv kgbfb g_om`_q_f khk\hbf \eZ^_evp_f
Gh ijh[e_fZklZgh\blky hq_gvk_jv_aghcdh]^Z fh^ZwlZ
]emi_crZy ba
]emi_crbo hkh[
`_gkdh]h iheZgZqbgZ_l
^bdlh\Zlv [_^ghc kh[Zd_dZdhc ^he`gZ[ulv __\g_rghklvb
ba \k_o \hr_^rbo\ fh^mihjh^ g_gZc^_lky gb_^bghcqvb
i_j\hgZqZevgh ij_djZkgu_ikbobq_kdb_ kihkh[ghklbg_ [ueb [u
\ j_amevlZl_
ih]m[e_guLhevdh
lZf]^_
wlm
ihjh^m
ijh^he`Zeb dmevlb\bjh\Zlv jZ^b
^_eZ[_a j_\_jZgkh\
\
klhjhgm fh^uhgZ khojZgyeZ k\hbi_j\ha^Zggu_ ^hklhbgkl\Z
GZ jh^bg_ rhleZg^kdhc h\qZjdb \k_ _s_ bf_xlky ebgbb\
dhlhjuo mp_e_eb bagZqZevgu_
kihkh[ghklbgh
ihjh^bklu_
wda_fieyju[u\rb_ \i_j\u_ ]h^u\_dZ ihke_^gbf djbdhfih
\k_c
?\jhi_ih^\_j]ebkv
ihqlb
g_\_jhylghfm ijhp_kkm
mfkl\_gghc ^_]jZ^ZpbbLhqgh lZd `_ ihdZ _s_kms_kl\mxl
gZklhysb_ k_g[_jgZju \ fhgZkluj_ K\ylh]h ;_jgZjZ b
gZ
Lb[_l_gh \ P_gljZevghc ?\jhi_ fg_ ijboh^behkv \b^_lv
lhevdh mfkl\_gguo g_^hghkdh\Dh]^Z ijZdlbq_kdZy
ihevaZ
i_j_klZ_l [ulvp_evx fh^_jgbaZpbbdZdhcgb[m^v ihjh^u__
fh`gh kqblZlvh[j_q_gghc>Z`_ s_i_lbevghq_klgu_ \eZ^_evpu
iblhfgbdh\dhlhju_ kdhj__ mfjmlq_f bkihevamxl kh[Zdmg_
hl\_qZxsmx \k_f g_h[oh^bfuf lj_[h\ZgbyfkqblZxl
\iheg_
wlbqguf ihemqZlv
ihlhfkl\h hl
nbabq_kdb djZkb\uogh
mfkl\_ggh hlklZeuo kh[ZdZ aZl_fb ijh^Z\Zlvwlbo s_gyl
Ex[ysbc `b\hlguoqblZl_ev^ey dhlhjh]hy bibrm wlmdgb]m
ih\_jv fg_lu ^h\hevghkdhjh i_j_klZg_rv]hj^blvky l_fqlh
l\hy
kh[ZdZ
ihqlb
lhqgh
khhl\_lkl\m_l
b^_Zevghfm
nbabq_kdhfm klZg^Zjlm k\h_cihjh^uZ lZdb_ __ikbobq_kdb_
g_^hklZldbdZd g_j\ghklvaeh[ghklv
bebljmkhklv[m^ml
jZa^jZ`Zlv l_[y \k_kbevg__ bkbevg__LZd qlh \dhg_qghf
kq_l_ lug_khfg_gghba\e_d [u[hevr_ jZ^hklbba h[s_kl\Z
mfghc\_jghc b ojZ[jhc kh[Zdbg_ [e_sms_cjh^hkeh\ghc
q_f ba
h[s_kl\_ k\h_]h
q_fibhgZdhlhjuc\hafh`gh
h[hr_eky l_[_\ p_eh_khklhygb_
DZd ym`_ mihfygmeijb hl[hj_nbabq_kdbo b ikbobq_kdbo
q_jl \hafh`guhij_^_e_ggu_ dhfijhfbkkuwlh ih^l\_j`^Z_lky
l_f nZdlhjhfqlh jZaebqgu_ qbklu_ ihjh^u kh[Zd ^he]h_
\j_fy khojZgyeb emqrb_ q_jlu oZjZdl_jZihdZ g_
klZeb
`_jl\hc fh^uB \k_lZdb kh[Zqvb\uklZ\db hiZkgum`_ kZfb
ih
k_[_lZd
dZd
kjZ\g_gb_
qbklhihjh^guo kh[Zd ih
wdkl_jv_jm
g_fbgm_fh
ijb\h^bl
d
dmevlb\bjh\Zgbx
b
]bi_j[hebaZpbb l_o q_jldhlhju_kh[kl\_gghb hij_^_eyxl
dZ`^mx ^Zggmx ihjh^m?keb ijhkfhlj_lv klZjbggu_jbkmgdb
dhlhju_ \ :g]ebbgZijbf_j\hkoh^yl d kj_^gbf\_dZfb
kjZ\gblv wlbbah[jZ`_gby kkh\j_f_ggufb ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb l_o
`_ ihjh^ihke_^gb_ gZqbgZxldZaZlvky aeufb dZjbdZlmjZfbgZ
k\hbo hl^Ze_gguo ij_^dh\Hkh[_ggh wlhaZf_lgh gZqZmqZm
\hr_^rbo \fh^m lhevdh \ihke_^gb_ ^_kylbe_lby< ^\Z^pZluo
]h^Zo qZmqZm \k__s_ hklZ\ZeZkvkh[Zdhcl_kgh k\yaZgghc k
^bdbfb nhjfZfb__ aZhklj_ggZy fhj^ZjZkdhku_ ]eZaZ b
hklju_ mrb ijb^Z\Zeb _c lh qm^_kgh_ \ujZ`_gb_dhlhjh_
hlebqZ_l ]j_geZg^kdbo _a^h\uokh[Zd b^jm]bo eZ_ddhjhq_
]h\hjy\k_o kh[Zd k
kbevghc ijbf_kvx \heqv_c
djh\b
Kh\j_f_ggh_ jZa\_^_gb_ qZmqZm ijb\_eh dih^q_jdb\Zgbx l_o
q_jldhlhju_ ijb^Zxlbf koh^kl\hk lhekluff_^\_^_ffhj^Z
klZeZ dhjhldhc b rbjhdhcihqlb dZd m fZklbnZ]eZaZ
mljZlbeb jZkdhkhklvZ mrb ihqlbbkq_aeb \]mklhc b^ebgghc
r_jklb
RhleZg^kdb_ l_jv_ju \hl _s_ h^gZihjh^Zdhlhjmx y
hq_gv ex[beb ikbobq_kdmx^_]jZ^Zpbx dhlhjhc hieZdb\ZxE_l
ljb^pZlv iylv gZaZ^dh]^Z fhc rhleZg^kdbc l_jv_jkmdZ
WebHgZ ke_^h\ZeZ aZ fghc ih iylZfkh[Zdb wlhcihjh^u
\k_
[_a
bkdexq_gby
h[eZ^Zeb
h[jZaph\uf
fm`_kl\hf b
ij_^ZgghklvxGbdZdZy ^jm]Zy kh[ZdZg_ aZsbsZeZf_gy lZd
^h[e_klghdZd Webgb h^gmba gbofg_ g_ijboh^behkv lZd
qZklh \ujmqZlv
ba ko\Zlhd
k gZfgh]h
[he__
kbevgufb
ijhlb\gbdZfbgb hlh^ghc yg_ ^he`_g[ue kiZkZlvklhevdh
dhr_db gbh^gZ bagbodjhf_ Webg_ aZe_aZeZaZ dhrdhc gZ
^_j_\hDZdlh hgZaZ]gZeZ dhrdmgZ gb`gxxjZa\bedm keb\u
dhlhjZy jhkeZ qmlv gZdehgghJZa\bedZ wlZgZoh^beZkv gZ
\ukhl_ ie_q \ajhkeh]h q_eh\_dZgh Web h^gbf
iju`dhf
\ae_l_eZ gZ ^_j_\hAZl_f Web\kdhqbeZ gZ^h\hevgh lheklmx
\_ldmgZ dhlhjhc[ueh jZkiheh`beZkvdhrdZ baZ]gZeZ ___s_
\ur_gh kZfZ g_ m^_j`ZeZkv b k\ZebeZkv gZgb`gbc kmd
aZp_ib\rbkv __ aZ^gxx eZim b ihf_rZ\rbc miZklvijyfh gZ
a_fexK_dmg^m Webijh\bk_eZ \gba]heh\hcihlhf k[hevrbf
ljm^hf dh_dZd hiylv \ah[jZeZkv gZ jZa\bedm bijbgyeZkv
yjhklgh eZylvgZ dhrdmdhlhjZy ijbfklbeZkvgZ ]b[dhc \_ld_
\k_]h \ f_j_ gZ^ g_cB \hllml ijhbahrehg_\_jhylgh_ Web hlqZyggh gZijy]eZ \k_
furpu b \af_lgmeZkv
\\_jo
Lhgdb_ \_ldbdhg_qghg_ fh]eb\u^_j`Zlv __\_kZgh aZlh
hgZ mki_eZ mo\Zlblv dhrdmdhlhjZy _s_ g_kdhevdhk_dmg^
\bk_eZ gZ ^_j_\_bah \k_o kbe p_ieyykv aZk\hc kmqhd
AZl_f hgb\f_kl_ ijhe_l_eb ^h[juoljb f_ljZb re_igmebkvgZ
ljZ\mZ y [jhkbeky gZ ihfhsv dhrdmdhlhjmx Web
g_
\uimklbeZohly iZ^_gb_ b h]emrbeh __DhrdZ
hklZeZkv
p_eZ b g_\j_^bfZgh Web g_kdhevdh g_^_evojhfZeZ baaZ
jZaju\Z furpu ie_qZdhlhjuf hgZ klmdgmeZkvh[ a_fex<
hlebqb_ hl dhr_dkh[Zdb hlgx^vg_ \k_]^ZiZ^Zxl gZq_luj_
eZiu
LZdbfb [uebrhleZg^kdb_ l_jv_juljb^pZlv iylv e_lgZaZ^
\_^v Web \h\k_ g_ \u^_eyeZkv kj_^bijhqbo: l_i_jvy
bkiulu\Zx
]g_lmsmx
i_qZevdh]^Z
gZ[ex^Zx
ih\_^_gb_
gug_rgbo baysguokeh\gh \uj_aZgguo ba q_jgh]h
^_j_\Z
ij_^klZ\bl_e_c wlhc ihjh^u gZ mebpZo gZr_c<_guba^Z\gZ
ex[b\r_c kh[ZdY agZxqlh fhydhkfZlZy Webk djb\uf mohf
dhlhjh_ i_j_k_dZerjZfg_ fh]eZ[u khi_jgbqZlvgZ \uklZ\d_
k wlbfbohe_gufb djZkZ\bpZfb
Gh aZlh hgblj_i_sml i_j_^kh[ZdZfbdhlhju_ k \ba]hf
imklbebkv [ugZml_dih\klj_qZc hgbWeb
?s_ g_iha^gh?s_ gZc^mlkyrhleZg^kdb_ l_jv_judhlhju_
g_ hlklmiyl i_j_^ k_g[_jgZjhf b \p_iylky \ gh]mex[h]h
q_eh\_dZihkf_\r_]h ohly[u
ih\ukblv]hehk gZbo ohaybgZ
Gh bo hklZehkv hq_gv fZehb kj_^b f_^Zebklh\kh[Zqvbo
\uklZ\hd \u bo g_ gZc^_l_: ihlhfm y ohl_e[u aZ^Zlv
ke_^mxsbc \hijhk l_fdlh aZgbfZ_lky jZa\_^_gb_fkh[Zd b
bkdj_gg_ bgl_j_km_lkybo [m^msbfjZa\_ g_klhbeh [u \\b^_
bkdexq_gby ihemqblvihlhfkl\h hllZdhc \_jghcb fm`_kl\_gghc
kh[Zdb^Z`_
_keb
[u
__
wdkl_jv_j aZf_lgh mklmiZe
]Zjfhgbqgh keh`_gguf r_^_\jZf kh\j_f_ggh]hiZjbdfZo_jkdh]h
bkdmkkl\Z"
I?J?FBJB?
Kh[Zdb^Z`_
aZy^eu_
hohlgbdbm^b\bl_evgh e_]dh
mk\Zb\Zxlqlh hgb g_ ^he`gu ljh]Zlv ^jm]bo
`b\hlguo
h[blZxsbo \ lhf `_ ^hf_KZfu_ hli_lu_dhr_g_gZ\bklgbdb
dhlhju_g_kfhljy
gb gZ
dZdb_ gZdZaZgbyijh^he`Zxl
]hgylky aZ dhrdZfb \ kZ^mg_ ]h\hjy m`_h[ mebp_[_a
ljm^Z \umqb\Zxlky g_ihdmrZlvky \^hf_ gbgZ dhr_dgb gZ
^jm]bo `b\hlguoIhwlhfm y\k_]^Z agZdhfexkh[Zd k lhevdh
qlh dmie_ggufb`b\hlgufb m k_[y\ dZ[bg_l_Ihq_fm kh[ZdZ\
kl_gZo ^hfZ klZgh\blky f_g__ djh\h`Z^ghcy g_agZxgh
h^gh g_khfg_ggh\gmljb ^hfZ m]ZkZ_llhevdh __kljZklv d
hohl_gh g_ d ^jZdZf<k_ fhb kh[Zdb \_ebk_[y hq_gv
Z]j_kkb\gh k ex[hc qm`hc kh[ZdhcdhlhjZy
hkf_eb\ZeZkv
\hclb \ gZrbdhfgZluM f_gy g_[ueh kemqZyijh\_jblv wlb
gZ[ex^_gby gZ ^jm]bo kh[ZdZolZd dZdy ijbgpbibZevghg_
[_jm k\hboikh\ kkh[hcdh]^Z b^mld ^jmavyfm dhlhjuo\
^hf_ _klvkh[ZdZFghc jmdh\h^blijhklZy ^_ebdZlghklvb g_
lhevdh ihlhfmqlh kh[Zqvb^jZdb g_j\bjmxl[hevrbgkl\h ex^_c
kZf y hlghrmkv d gbf kihdhcghlZd dZdfhb ikuh[uqgh
[_jml \_jogh bihlhfmqlh mkj_^g_]h dh[_eyihy\e_gb_ \
_]h \eZ^_gbyo
qm`h]h ij_^klZ\bl_ey
_]h \b^Z
\uau\Z_l
j_ZdpbxfZehijbylgmx ^ey ohaycdb ^hfZM kh[ZdaZ^bjZgb_
gh]b bf__l kh\_jr_gghq_ldbc kfukedZd gbiZjZ^hdkZevgh
lhqgh lhl
`_qlh
b kheh\vbgZy
i_kgyWlh
kihkh[
h[hagZq_gby ]jZgbp
k\h_]h mqZkldZij_^mij_`^_gb_
\k_
qm`ZdZfqlh hgb \lhj]Zxlky gZ l_jjblhjbxdhlhjZy m`_
dhfmlh ijbgZ^e_`blIhqlb \k_fe_dhiblZxsb_ klZ\ylgZ k\hbo
mqZkldZo iZomqb_ f_ldblZd dZd
\ha^mo lZf b[_a lh]h
ijhiblZg b__ kh[kl\_gguf aZiZohfb aZiZohf__ \eZ^_evp_\
Gh _keb qm`hc i_k beb qlh _s_om`_ ^Z\gh ba\_klguc
aZdeyluc \jZ]ohly [u gZg_kdhevdh k_dmg^i_j_klmibl ihjh]
lhjfhays__ \ebygb_ \k_o wlbo fhf_glh\ lhlqZkbkq_aZ_l<
wlhf kemqZ_ ex[Zy g_ kh\k_f [_koZjZdl_jgZykh[ZdZ khql_l
k\hbf k\yluf ^he]hf mgbqlh`blv aZiZo \jZ]ZhklZ\b\ k\hc
[he__ iZomqbcagZdD g_]h^h\Zgbxk\h_]h ohaybgZb hkh[_ggh
ohaycdbwlhl qbklhiehlgucdhfgZlguc i_khlijZ\blky \ h[oh^
^hfZ[_kklu^gh aZ^bjZy gh]m m dZ`^h]h lheZklmeZ beb
rdZnZIh^mfZcl_ h[ wlhfij_`^_ q_f\u j_rbl_gZ\_klblv
\eZ^_evpZ kh[Zdb\ khijh\h`^_gbbk\h_]h ikZ
LZdbf h[jZahffbjhex[b_ kh[Zdb \__ kh[kl\_gghf^hf_
h[_ki_qb\Z_l [_ahiZkghklvlhevdh ihl_gpbZevghc^h[uq_gh g_
^jm]bf kh[ZdZf<hafh`ghlml fuklZedb\Z_lky kba\_qghc b
rbjhdh
jZkijhkljZg_gghc
\
fbj_
`b\hlguo hkh[_gghklvx
ih\_^_gbyZ lhqg__kdZaZlvaZij_lhfBa\_klghqlh yklj_[u
b ^jm]b_
obsgu_ilbpu g_hohlylky \hae_k\h_]h ]g_a^Z<
g_ihkj_^kl\_gghc [ebahklb hl bo ]g_a^g_ jZah[gZjm`b\Zeb
]g_a^Z \yobj_ck iheghklvxhi_jb\rbfbky il_gpZfbkms_kl\mxl
ih^l\_j`^_ggu_ k\_^_gbyqlh i_]Zgdb
\u\h^beb mlyl
\
h[blZ_fuo ebkvbo ghjZoH \hedZo khh[sZehkvqlh hgbg_
ljh]Zxl
eZg_c\ujZsb\Zxsbo
k\h_
ihlhfkl\h
\
g_ihkj_^kl\_gghc [ebahklb hlbo eh]h\ZFg_ ij_^klZ\ey_lky
\iheg_ \hafh`gufqlh bf_gghwlhl \_dh\hc aZdhgi_j_fbjby
b h[tykgy_lihq_fm gZrZ^hfZrgyy kh[ZdZ mk_[y ^hfZ \_^_l
k_[y lZdk^_j`Zggh kkZfufb jZagufb`b\hlgufb
H^gZdh aZij_l wlhlg_ y\ey_lkyZ[khexlgufb lj_[mxlky
kbevgu_ f_ju \ha^_ckl\byqlh[u fheh^Zykh[ZdZihegZy kbe
b d lhfm `_ ZaZjlguc hohlgbdihgyeZqlh dhrdZ[Zjkmd
^bdb_ djhebdbfurb b ^jm]b_ `b\hlgu_k dhlhjufb hgZ
hlgug_ ^he`gZ ^_eblv\gbfZgb_ k\h_]hohaybgZg_ lhevdhg_
ij_^gZagZqZxlky ^ey_^ugh g_ijbdZkZ_fuk\ys_ggu b\hh[s_
lZ[m< fhx iZfylvgZ\k_]^Z \j_aZehkvdZd fgh]he_l gZaZ^
y ijbg_k ^hfhcgZr_]h i_j\h]hdhl_gdZ wlh [ue LhfZk,b
ihiulZeky \gmrblv fh_fm ikm ;meebaZy^ehfm hohlgbdmgZ
dhr_dqlh hg^he`_g hklZ\blv fZeurZ\ ihdh_Dh]^Z y \ugme
dhl_gdZ ba dhjabgdb;meeb [jhkbeky dh fg_bkiheg_gguc
jZ^hklgh]h ij_^\dmr_gbyhg
ihhkh[hfm [Zkbklhk
ih^\u\Zgb_f ih\ba]b\Zeqlh ^_eZe ebrv\ j_^dbokemqZyoZ
klj_fbl_evgh \beyxsbc h[jm[hd_]h o\hklZihqlb ij_\jZlbeky
\ kfmlgmx ihehkdmDhg_qgh;meeb g_ khfg_\Zekyqlh
dhl_gdZ y ijbg_kki_pbZevgh ^eyg_]hqlh[u hgjZkijZ\beky
k gbfihk\hckdb?]h m\_j_gghklvbf_eZ ih^kh[hc g_dhlhju_
hkgh\ZgbylZd dZd\ ijhrehfy g_jZa ij_a_glh\Ze_fm ^ey
jZkijZ\u klZjuoiexr_\uo fbr_dbeb ljyibqguokh[Zq_dihlhfm
qlh hg hq_gv kf_rgh l_jaZe k\hx ^h[uqmGh l_i_jvd
[hevrhfm jZahqZjh\Zgbx ;meeby kh\_jr_ggh ykgh ^Ze_fm
ihgylvqlh dhl_gdZ hgljh]Zlv gb \dh_f kemqZ_ g_^he`_g
;meeb [ue gZ j_^dhklv ^h[juf b ihkemrguf ikhfb yg_
hiZkZekyqlh hg ij_g_[j_`_l fhbf ijbdZahf b
\k_lZdb
gZ[jhkblky gZ dhl_gdZIhwlhfm y g_ \f_rZekydh]^Z hg
ih^hr_e dfZeurm blsZl_evgh _]hh[gxoZeohly i_k [md\Zevgh
^jh`Ze hl \ha[m`^_gbyZ ]eZ^dZy ]eygp_\b^gZy r_jklvgZ
ie_qZo b r__lZf]^_ ^he`gZ[ueZ [u^u[blvky ]jb\Z
aeh\_s_ ihl_fg_eZb ihlmkdg_eZ
;meeb g_ ljhgmedhl_gdZgh ijh^he`Ze \j_fyhl \j_f_gb
h]ey^u\Zlvky gZf_gy k[Zkbkluf \ba]hfdjmlblv o\hklhfdZd
ehiZklvx we_dljbq_kdh]h \_glbeylhjZb ijblZgph\u\Zlv gZ
\k_o q_luj_o eZiZoLZdbf
kihkh[hf hg mijZrb\Ze
f_gy
ihkdhj__ iha\heblv_fm gZqZlv `_eZggmxb]jm ih]hgylvky aZ
wlhc qm^_kghcb]jmrdhcko\Zlblv __b \kljyogmlvlZdqlh[u
hgZ m`_ [hevr_ g_ r_\_ebeZkvGh y ijh^he`Ze\k_ [he__
dZl_]hjbq_kdb hl\_qZlv G_l]jhay mdZaZl_evgufiZevp_f
b \ dhgp_
dhgph\ hg ihkfhlj_e
gZ f_gy lZdkeh\gh
khfg_\Zeky \a^jZ\hklb fh_]hjZkkm^dZhimklbe mrbbkimklbe
kZfuc ]em[hdbc \a^hogZ dZdhclhevdh kihkh[_gnjZgpmakdbc
[mev^h]\kiju]gme gZ^b\Zg bk\_jgmeky dZeZqbdhfK wlhc
fbgmlu hgijhklh i_j_klZeaZf_qZlv dhl_gdZb \lhl `_ ^_gv
y hklZ\be bo
gZ_^bg_ hq_gv gZ^he]hagZyqlh
fh]m
iheh`blvky gZ k\hxkh[ZdmH^gZdhwlh \h\k_g_ hagZqZeh
qlh `_eZgb_ jZkijZ\blvky k dhl_gdhf m ;meeb
iheghklvx
m]ZkehGZh[hjhldZ`^uc jZadh]^Z yaZgbfZeky dhl_gdhfb
hkh[_ggh dh]^Z [jZe _]h gZ jmdb[_ajZaebqb_ ;meblhlqZk
bkq_aZeh bhg db^Zekydh fg_hlqZyggh \_jlyo\hklhf blZd
klmqZ eZiZfbqlh ihe kh^jh]ZekyIjb wlhfhg kfhlj_egZ
f_gy kl_f `_\ujZ`_gb_f gZijy`_ggh[eZ`_ggh]h ij_^\dmr_gby
dhlhjh_ haZjyeh_]h fhj^mdh]^Z hg bagu\Zehl ]heh^Zb y
\ghkbe \dhfgZlm fbkdmk _s_g_ hklu\r_c_^hc
< lh\j_fy y [ue_s_ hq_gvfheh^gh l_fg_ f_g__ f_gy
ihjZabeh ijhklh^mrgh\_k_eh_ \ujZ`_gb_fhj^u kh[ZdbdhlhjZy
\k_f k\hbfkms_kl\hf `Z`^ZeZjZahj\Zlv b\ dehqvydjhohlgh]h
dhl_gdZY m`_ ohjhrhagZe ijb\uqdb kh[Zqv_caehklbb fg_
[ueb hlebqgh agZdhfu l_ \ujZabl_evguc ^\b`_gbydZdbfb
kh[ZdZ ^_fhgkljbjm_lg_gZ\bklvh^gZdh lmly \i_j\u_ihklb]
bklbgmdhlhjZy bh]hjqbeZ bml_rbeZ f_gyZ bf_gghobsgbd
m[b\Z_l [_a \kydhcg_gZ\bklbKh\_jr_ggh ykgh ohly \wlhc
_klv dZdhclh iZjZ^hdkqlh obsgbdbkiulu\Z_l d`b\hlghfm
dhlhjh_ hg gZf_j_gm[blvijbf_jgh l_ `_qm\kl\ZdZdb_ m
f_gy \uau\Z_l ij_^gZagZq_ggZy gZ m`bg \_lqbgZdh]^Z y
\^uoZx __ ^hghkysbckyba dmogbie_gbl_evguc ZjhfZlaZeh]
ijbylgh]h \_q_jZ<_^v ^eyobsgbdh\ _]h`_jl\u aZeh] \h\k_
g_ [eb`gb_Mfm^jbkv \u \lhedh\Zlvev\mqlh ZglbehiZgZ
dhlhjmx hohlblky_]h k_kljZZ ebk_qlh djhebd__ [jZl
hgb[_a khfg_gbym^b\bebkv [ug_ f_gvr_q_f fu_keb [u
gZf aZy\bebqlh gZr kZfuc aZdeyluc \jZ]wlh q_eh\_d
Lhevdh l_ kms_kl\Zdhlhju_ g_ khagZxlqlh bo ^h[uqZ
ih^h[gZ bfkZfbffh]ml m[b\Zlvg_ \uau\Zyhkm`^_gbyb \hl
wlhclh [_a]j_rghklbls_lgh bs_lq_eh\_ddh]^Z hgiulZ_lky
aZ[ulvqlh _]h `_jl\ZlZdh_ `_`b\h_ kms_kl\hdZd bhg
kZfbeb \gmrZ_lk_[_qlh _]h \jZ]gZklhysbc ^vy\he b
aZkem`b\Z_l khkljZ^Zgby^Z`_ f_gvr_q_f [_r_ggZykh[ZdZ
< h^ghcba k\hbo k_\_jguoih\_kl_c >`_dEhg^hg k`mldhc
j_Zebklbqghklvx
hibku\Z_l
ijhklh^mrgmx
djh\h`Z^ghklv
obsgbdh\;hevrZy
klZy
\hedh\
hdjm`beZ
klhygdm
iml_r_kl\_ggbdZm dhlhjh]h g_hklZehkv [hevr_ iZljhgh\Ih
f_j_ lh]h dZdkbeu q_eh\_dZbkkydZxl\hedb klZgh\ylky\k_
[he__ ^_jadbfb b k\bj_iufb< dhgp_ dhgph\g_ \u^_j`Z\
mklZehklb b ^he]hc [_kkhggbpuhg g_gZ^he]h aZkuiZ_l m
k\h_]h ^h]hjZxs_]h dhkljZD kqZklvxhg mki_\Z_l\h\j_fy
ijhkgmlvky b \b^blqlh dhevph\hedh\ ijb^\bgmehkv[eb`_
L_i_jv _fmohjhrh \b^gubo fhj^ub hg\^jm] aZf_qZ_lqlh
bo ij_`g__ aeh[gh_m]jh`Zxs__ \ujZ`_gb_bkq_aeh ghku g_
gZfhjs_gu]eZaZ g_ ijbsmj_gu `_klhdhdeudb g_h[gZ`_gu
mrb g_ ijb`Zlu d
]heh\_JuqZgb_ kfhedeh\hpZjbeZkv
lbrbgZb ih\kx^m\hdjm] k_[yhg \b^bl^jm`_ex[gu_ kh[Zqvb
fhj^u k lhjqZsbfb mrZfb b rbjhdh jZkdjulufb ]eZaZfbB
lhevdh dh]^Z h^bgba \hedh\g_l_ji_eb\h i_j_klmiZ_lk gh]b
gZ gh]m b h[ebau\Z_lkyiml_r_kl\_ggbd \ m`Zk_hkhagZ_l
`mldh_ agZq_gb_ wlhc ^jm`_kl\_gghc mkihdh_gghklb\hedb
gZklhevdh mljZlbebkljZo i_j_^gbfqlh \b^yl\ g_f m`_g_
hiZkgh]h \jZ]ZZ eZdhfuc h[_^Y g_ khfg_\Zxkvqlh
knhlh]jZnbjmc
f_gy
dlhgb[m^v
k
lhqdb
aj_gby
\ur_mihfygmlhc \_lqbgufh_ ebph gZkgbfd_ lh`_bklhqZeh [u
h^gh [eZ]h^mrb_
>Z`_ fgh]h g_^_ev kimkly kZfh]h e_]dh]hagZdZ kfh_c
klhjhgu [ueh [u ^hklZlhqghqlh[u ;meebm[be xgmxdhrdm
H^gZdhg_ ihemqZylZdh]h jZaj_r_gbyhg g_lhevdh gZg__
g_ gZiZ^ZeghgZh[hjhlfm`_kl\_ggh aZsbsZe __hl ^jm]bo
kh[ZdH[tykgyehkv wlh hlgx^vg_ l_fqlh hgiblZe dg_c
kbfiZlbxZ\_jhylg__ \k_]hke_^mxsbf \a]ey^hf
gZ
kblmZpbxM` _keb fg_ g_ iha\heyxl jZa^_eZlvky kwlhc
f_jadhc dhrdhc\ fh_fkh[kl\_gghf ^hf_lZd imklv`_ hgZb
^jm]hc kh[Zd_g_ ^hklZg_lky
K kZfh]h gZqZeZ dhl_ghd g_ ijhy\eye \
ijbkmlkl\bb
;meeb gb fZe_crbo ijbagZdh\ kljZoZ\_jgh_ k\b^_l_evkl\h
lh]hqlh m dhr_d g_l bgklbgdlZdhlhjuc ihfh]Ze[u bf
ihgylv \ujZ`_gb_kh[Zqv_c fhj^uY [ub \kydbcdlh \gbo
jZa[bjZ_lkygZkf_jlv
i_j_im]Zeky
wlbo
\a]ey^h\
bkiheg_gguo iehoh k^_j`b\Z_fh]hg_l_ji_gbyGh dhl_ghd b\
mk g_ ^meG_ ih^haj_\ZydZd hgjbkdm_lfZeur ihklhyggh
iulZeky aZl_ylvb]jmlh \u^Z\Zy[mev^h]m ^jm`_kdb_Z\Zgku
lh qlh [ueh ]hjZa^h hiZkg__ijb]eZrZy _]hih[_]Zlv aZ
kh[hcHg ijb[eb`Zeky d ikm k \djZ^qb\hcfbghc blml `_
imkdZeky gZml_d \gZ^_`^_qlh lhl [jhkblky_]h ^h]hgylv
<
ih^h[gu_
fbgmlu
fh_fm
[jZ\hfm
fZe_gvdhfm
;meeb
lj_[h\Zehkv \k_ _]h kZfhh[eZ^Zgb_b ih_]h gZijy`_gghfm
l_em ijh[_]ZeZ ^jh`v
ih^Z\e_gghc kljZklbY
Z[khexlgh
m[_`^_gqlh dhrdb_keb lhevdhm gbog_l ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]h
bg^b\b^mZevgh]h hiulZg_ ihgbfZxl
^\b`_gbcdhlhjufb
kh[Zdb \ujZ`Zxl k\hb qm\kl\Zohly wlb ^\b`_gby
hq_gv
koh^gu k bo kh[kl\_ggufbDhrdbgZoh^ysb_ky \^jm`_kdbo
hlghr_gbyo k kh[ZdZfbqlh fh`_l ijb\_klb Z qZklhb
ijb\h^bl d bo ]b[_ebY fgh]hjZa gZ[ex^ZedZd lZdZy
dhrdZ k [_kkljZrguf ijhklh^mrb_f kfhljbl ijyfh \ ]eZaZ
g_agZdhfhc kh[Zd_ohly lZ y\gh \hl\hl gZg__ [jhkblky
Klhev `_j_^dh bkh[ZdZdhlhjZy ^jm`blk dhrdhcihgbfZ_l
kfuke ihauijbgylhc jZkk_j`_gghc dhrdhcjZa\_ qlhhgZ
agZ_l _]h ih ij_`g_fm ]hjvdhfm hiulmM^b\bl_evgh<_^v
dZaZehkv [ukh[ZdZ fh`_l
ihgylv \hjqZgb_ dhrdblZd
ihoh`__ gZ__ kh[kl\_ggh_
DZdlh fuk Kxab_c lh]^Z [uehk_fv f_kyp_\ijbreb \
]hklb d
\eZ^_evpZf [hevrhc
Zg]hjkdhc dhrdbdhlhjZy
\klj_qZeZ fhx xgmx qZmqZm \u]gmlhc kibghc b
aeh\_sbf
mjqZgb_fKxab bmohf g_ih\_eZZ gZijZ\beZkvijyfh d dhrd_
bih\beb\Zy
o\hklhf
b
k
ex[hiulkl\hf ih^gy\ mrb
ihlygmeZkv d g_c ghkhflhqgh d ^jm`_kdb
gZkljh_gghc
kh[Zd_>Z`_ ihemqb\ i_j\uc m^Zj dh]lbklhc eZihchgZ
ih\b^bfhfmkhqeZqlh ijhbahreZ hrb[dZb g_hklZ\beZ
ihiuldb aZ\yaZlv agZdhfkl\hKe_^mxsbc ^h\hevgh
kbevguc
m^Zjdhlhjuc h[jmrbekygZ __k_j_[jbklhk_juc ghklh`_ g_
h[b^_e __ ihgZklhys_fm hgZ lhevdh qbogmeZihl_jeZ ghk
fhogZlhc s_gyqv_c eZihc
b ij_ajbl_evgh hl\_jgmeZkv
hl
g_]hkl_ijbbfghc dbkdb
Q_j_a g_kdhevdh
g_^_ev hlghr_gb_
;meeb d
dhl_gdm
baf_gbehkvY g_ agZxijhbahreh eb wlh \g_aZigh beb
^jm`[Z f_`^m gbfb dj_ieZ ihkl_i_ggh \ fh_
hlkmlkl\b_
DZdlh y m\b^_eqlh LhfZk hiylv b]jb\h ih^h[jZeky
d
[mev^h]m b lhlqZkm^Zjbeky \[_]kl\hD fh_fm m^b\e_gbxb
m`Zkm;meeb
\kdhqbe b
dbgmeky aZ
dhl_gdhfdhlhjuc
kdjueky ih^ ^b\Zghf<lbkgm\ k\hx [hevrmx ]heh\m
ih^
^b\Zg;meeb ijh^he`Ze e_`Zlv \ wlhc iha_ bgZ \k_fhb
jZkl_jyggu_ m]h\hju lhevdh [mjgh \beye dhjhldbfh[jm[dhf
o\hklZWlh hlgx^v g_ hagZqZeh ^jm`_kdh]hjZkiheh`_gby d
dhrd_lZd dZd;meeb \beye[u kg_ f_gvrbfiuehf_keb [u
am[ZfbZ o\hklhf \ujZ`Ze [u kZfu_emqrb_ qm\kl\ZDZdhc
wlh ihjZabl_evgh keh`guc f_oZgbaf fha]<ujZabl_evgu_
^\b`_gby h[jm[dZ;meeb ke_^h\Zeh[u bklhedh\Zlv lZdFbeuc
ohaybgih`ZemcklZg_ k_j^bkvghd fh_fm
[hevrhfm
kh`Ze_gbx\
^Zggmx fbgmlm
y kh\_jr_ggh
g_ kihkh[_g
hlimklblv wlm f_jadmx l\Zjv^Z`_ _keblu khql_rvgm`guf
aZ^Zlv fg_lj_idm beb[h`_ miZkbhdZlblv f_gy oheh^ghc
\h^hcGh l_i_jv ;meeb \beye g_ kh\k_f lZd: k_dmg^m
kimklydh]^Zih^qbgyykv fh_c
dhfZg^_hg
\k_lZdb
\u[jZeky baih^
^b\ZgZLhfZk lh`_ \ue_l_e hllm^ZdZd
imr_qgh_ y^jhiju]gme gZ [mev^h]Z\p_ibeky h^ghceZihc
_fm \ r_x^jm]mx aZimklbe \
r_jklv gZ^ ]eZahf
b
g_fukebfuf h[jZahf \u\_jgm\ ]heh\_gdmihiulZeky mdmkblv
_]h aZ]hjehGZ f]gh\_gb_i_j_^h fghc aZklueZm^b\bl_evgh
ieZklbqgZy ]jmiiZlhqgh \hkijhba\h^b\rZy ba\_klgmxdZjlbgm
agZf_gblh]h om^h`gbdZZgbfZebklZ
<bev]_evfZ Dmg_jlZgZ
dhlhjhc e_\ m[b\Z_l [mc\heZ wlbf `_ kZfuf
Zjlbklbqguf
^\b`_gb_f
;meeb g_f_^e_ggh ih^u]jZe LhfZkm\_kvfZ m[_^bl_evgh
bah[jZab\ ^\b`_gby kjZ`_ggh]h [mc\heZHg ly`_ehmiZe gZ
]jm^vih^qbgyykv ju\dm djhohlguo eZihdb i_j_dZlbekygZ
kibgm k lZdbf
m[_^bl_evguf ij_^kf_jlguf ojbihfdZdhc
kihkh[_g bkimklblvlhevdh kqZkleb\uc[mev^h] beb ba^uoZxsbc
[mc\heDh]^Z ;meeb gZ^h_eh [ulv `_jl\hchg i_j_o\Zlbe
bgbpbZlb\m\kdhqbe bkljyogme kk_[y dhl_gdZLhl imklbeky
gZml_dgh
ihqlb
kjZam
`_
iha\hebe
k_[y ^h]gZlv
i_j_dm\ujdgm\rbkv \\ha^mo_ hkh[ufkihkh[hfdhlhjuc y hibrm
iha`_B y\i_j\u_ \`bagb klZek\b^_l_e_f h^ghcba gZb[he__
hqZjh\Zl_evguo b]jdZdb_ lhevdh [u\Zxl \fbj_ `b\hlguo
DhgljZkl
nhjf
b
^\b`_gbc
lheklh]h]eygp_\hq_jgh]h
fmkdmebklh]h l_eZ kh[Zdb b ]b[dhc k_jhcdhrZqv_c nb]mju
ihehkdZfb bklj_fbl_evghklvx lhqghih^h[ghc lb]jmkha^Z\Ze
bamfbl_evgh_ aj_ebs_LZdb_ b]ju dhr_dk `b\hlgufbdjmig__
bo ^ey gZmdb bgl_j_kgu l_fqlh wlZ kbkl_fZ
^\b`_gbc
imkdZ_lky \oh^ ^eymf_js\e_gby ^h[uqbb gbdh]^Z\ ^jZdZo
Fg_ ijboh^behkv \b^_lv b ijbl\hjgu_b gZklhysb_dhrZqvb
^jZdbbgZkdhevdh y fh]m km^blv^_jmsZyky dhrdZlZdbo
^\b`_gbc g_ ^_eZ_l>h[uqZ\ r_x dhlhjhc
gZiZ^Zxsbc
\hgaZ_l dh]lbklZjZykv i_j_]jualv _c]hjeh kgbam^he`gZ
[ulv djmig__obsgbdZgh gbgZrZ ^hfZrgyydhrdZgb __ ^bdbc
ij_^hd aZih^h[ghc ^h[uq_cg_ hohlbebkvKe_^h\Zl_evghwlhl
hq_gv bgl_j_kguc b[_amkeh\gh\h\k_ g_j_^dbc n_ghf_g
\_jhylghh[tykgy_lky l_fqlh kbkl_fZ^\b`_gbc\hagbdrZy \
g_aZiZfylgu_ \j_f_gZb rbjhdhjZkijhkljZg_ggZy m jh^kl\_gguo
]jmii
`b\hlguo^ey
^Zgghc
]jmiiu
mljZlbeZ
k\hx
i_j\hgZqZevgmx nmgdpbx ih^^_j`Zgby `bagb \b^ZH^gZdh hgZ
khojZgbeZ gZke_^kl\_gguc oZjZdl_johly bkihevam_lkyl_i_jv
lhevdh \b]j_
Ihke_ kf_jlbLhfZkZ ,ijhreh fgh]h e_lij_`^_ q_f fg_
\gh\v ^h\_ehkv m\b^_lvdZd b]jZxsZy dhrdZ
ijh^_eu\Z_l
^\b`_gby m[bckl\Z [mc\heZGZ
wlhl jZa ev\hf[ue
k_j_[jbkluc
ihehkZluc
dhlaZ^mr_\guc
^jm]
fh_c
ihemlhjZ]h^h\Zehc ^hqdb >Z]fZjuDhl\kiuevqb\uc bf_g__
\k_]h ^h[jh^mrguckimkdZe ^_\hqd_hq_gv fgh]h_b ihdhjgh _c
ih^qbgyekydh]^Z hgZ ijbgbfZeZkv lZkdZlv_]h ihdhfgZl_
ohly hg [ue h^gh]h k g_c jhklZb _]h ij_djZkguc\
k_j_[jbklhq_jguo dhevpZo o\hkl \k_]^Z \hehqbekyih ihem
lZd qlh jZgh
beb iha^gh >Z]fZjZ
gZ g_]h
gZklmiZeZ
kihludZeZkv biZ^ZeZ gZk\hx dhrdmDhlmg_khfg_ggh^_eZ_l
[hevrmx q_klv lhl nZdlqlh ^Z`_ \wlhf iheh`_gbbhg g_
dmkZeky b g_ pZjZiZekyH^gZdh hg hlu]jZekygZ\yau\Zy
>Z]fZj_ jhev[mc\heZ;ueh gZj_^dhklv bgl_j_kghgZ[ex^Zlv
dZd hg
ih^kl_j_]Ze ^_\hqdmZ ihlhf
iju]Zedj_idh
h[o\Zlu\Ze __eZiZfb b\ib\Zeky am[Zfb \lm beb bgmxqZklv
__ l_eZGhjZamf__lkyg_ \k_jv_aHgZ
ijbgbfZeZkv
\hiblvb lh`_[hevr_ \ rmldmFhy l_hjbyqlh wlb ^\b`_gby
ij_^klZ\eyxl
kh[hc
j_ebdl
[ueuo
hohlgbqvbo ijb\uq_d
ih^l\_j`^Z_lky l_fqlh \ b]j_ bf ij_^r_kl\m_l
\_kvfZ
j_Zebklbq_kdh_ h`b^Zgb_\ aZkZ^_b ih^djZ^u\Zgb_
>jm`[Z f_`^m ;meebb LhfZkh\\uoh^beZ ^Ze_dhaZ jZfdb
\aZbfghc l_jibfhklbdhlhjZy ih\k_f_klghgZ[ex^Z_lky m kh[Zd
b dhr_d`b\msbo \ h^ghf^hf_b ijhqghklv boijb\yaZgghklb
^hdZau\ZeZkv bo \klj_qZfb \g_ ^hfZ< wlbo kemqZyohgb
h[f_gb\Zebkv ijb\_lkl\byfb dhl ke_]dZmjqZeZ i_k\beye
o\hklhfWlh \h\k_g_ hagZqZ_lqlh kh[Zdbdhlhju_ klhev `_
l_jibfu k dhrdZfb ih^jm`_kdbh[yaZl_evgh [m^mlklhev `_
l_jibfu kgbfb bgZ mebp_M f_gy\ dZ[bg_l_gZrb gug_rgb_
kh[Zdb \iheg_fbjylky kijbkmlkl\b_f gZr_c ^h\hevghe_gb\hc
dhrdhcZ Kxab ^Z`_ g_j_^dh b]jZ_l k g_cijbq_f dhrdZ
kh\k_f g_[hblky kh[ZddjZ^_l mgbo _^mb eh\bl dhgqbdbbo
o\hklh\ hgZ kebrdhf ZiZlbqgZqlh[u b]jZlv \ev\Z b
[mc\heZH^gZdh \ ^jm]bo dhfgZlZo dhrdZ ^_j`blky[he__
gZklhjh`_ggh b lsZl_evgh ba[_]Z_l kh[Zd\ emqr_fkemqZ_
^jZagy bo ba [_ahiZkgh]h f_klZ ih^ gbadbf ^b\Zghf beb
hldm^Zgb[m^v khrdZnZIjh\hpbjh\Zlv `_ih]hgx aZkh[hc hgZ
\kyq_kdb hkl_j_]Z_lky<h ^\hj___ ih\_^_gb_ kgh\Zf_gy_lky
hgZ ijhy\ey_l y\guc kljZo i_j_^kh[ZdZfbijbq_f mg__
_klv ^ey wlh]h\k_ hkgh\ZgbylZd dZd<heqbdg_khfg_ggh
bagu\Z_l hl`_eZgby aZljZ\blvdZdmxgb[m^v dhrdm?s_ [he__
gZlygmlu_ hlghr_gby kms_kl\h\Zeb f_`^mkmjh\uf k_j_[jbkluf
ijbyl_e_f >Z]fZju bfh_c KlZkb< ^hf_KlZkb b]ghjbjh\ZeZ
dhlZgh gZ ^\hj_ gZqbgZeZ hohlblvky aZ gbf k
lZdbf
mihjkl\hfqlhijbagZxkvdh]^Z
hg h^gZ`^u
ijhiZe
\bgh\gbp_c wlh]hlZbgkl\_ggh]h bkq_agh\_gbyy kq_eKlZkb
?keb ih^ h^ghc djh\e_c
k kh[Zdhc `b\ml b
^jm]b_
q_l\_jhgh]b_ beb i_jgZlu_lhgZkdhevdh ljm^ghbeb e_]dh
[m^_l _c
kijZ\eylvky kh
k\hbf hohlgbqvbf
bgklbgdlhf
aZ\bkbl hl lh]hdlh hgb lZdb_>Z`_ kZfh]h ZaZjlgh]h
hohlgbdZ fh`gh [ukljhijbmqblv dlhfmqlh[u hg g_ljh]Ze
jmqguo ilbpdZd ke_^m_l ba hl\_lZ ikZ DjZkZ\qbdZ _]h
ohaybgm Dmi_jm
Dh]^Z l\hcqb` miZe[_a kbe
Ba de_ldbdZdlh me_l_e
?]h y^_jadh g_ko\Zlbe
>Z[u g_ijh[m^blv l\hc]g_\
K\ys_gguf [uehg ^eyf_gy GbdZd g_eZdhfuf dmkdhf
B lhevdhi_jvy g_`gh y
?fm ijb]eZ^beyaudhf
Gh \gmrblv _fm lZdh_ `_ m\Z`_gb_ djZaebqguf f_edbf
a\_jvdZf
aZ^ZqZ
qj_a\uqZcgh
keh`gZyGZb[he__
kh[eZagbl_evgufb
kh[Zd_ih\b^bfhfmij_^klZ\eyxlky
djhebdbb lml g_ ke_^m_l iheZ]Zlvky ^Z`_gZ l_okh[Zd
dhlhju_ gbdh]^Z g_ ljh]Zeb dhr_dWlh hlghkblkyb dfhbf
kh[ZdZf KxabgZijbf_jg_ihgylgh ihq_fm g_ijhy\ey_l gb
fZe_cr_]h bgl_j_kZ d ahehlbkluf
ohfyqdZfgh ^Z`_
g_
ljm^blky
kdju\ZlvdZd
_c
ohl_ehkv
[u
ijbdhgqblv
hqZjh\Zl_evgh]h lmrdZgqbdZdhlhjuc kdZq_l gZ k\h[h^_ih
fh_fm dZ[bg_lm b dhlhjh]h _c kljh]hgZkljh]h
aZij_s_gh
ljh]ZlvFgh]h e_l gZaZ^ y [ueg_kdZaZggh m^b\e_gdh]^Z
ijbg_k ^hfhc fheh^h]h jmqgh]h [ZjkmdZ bihagZdhfbe _]hk
lh]^Zrgbfb fhbfb kh[ZdZfbk\bj_iufb g_f_pdbfb h\qZjdZfb
Y iheZ]Zeqlh wlhl g_agZdhfuc^bdbc a\_jvijh[m^bl \gbo
om^rb_ hohlgbqvb bgklbgdlugh kemqbehkvh[jZlgh_[Zjkmd
dhlhjuc ij_`^_ `be m e_kgbdZ bg_khfg_gghijb\ud
d
kh[ZdZf[_kkljZrgh ihr_egZ h\qZjhdb l_ohly h[gxob\Zeb
_]h kg_ijb\uqghc hklhjh`ghklvxk kZfh]hgZqZeZ ijbagZeb \
g_f g_ ^h[uqmZ
g_kdhevdh kljZggh]h qe_gZ
kh[Zqv_]h
ie_f_gbM`_ q_j_a^\Zljb qZkZhgb m\e_q_gghb]jZeb kgbf
b ex[hiulghqlh ijb_fufhogZlh]h gh\bqdZ hdZaZebkvkebrdhf
]jm[ufb ^ey _]h lhgdhdh`bo lh\Zjbs_cdhlhju_ lhb ^_eh
\a\ba]b\Zeb hl[hebB \k_lZdb b]jZ gbjZam g_ i_j_reZ\
^jZdmKh[Zdb
kjZam `_
iheh`bebkv gZ
hk\_^hfe_gghklv
[ZjkmdZ \ khhl\_lkl\mxsbo aZij_lZo biha\heyeb _fm\Zeblv
k_[y gZkibgmo\ZlZlv aZ ]hjehb ^mrblv\ khhl\_lkl\bb k
ijZ\beZfb b]judZd iha\hebeb[u wlhijbyl_eyfkh[ZdZf
Ih\_^_gb_ \k_o fhbokh[Zd ihhlghr_gbx dijbfZlZf [ueh
\_kvfZ k\h_h[jZagufFg_ ijbrehkvdZd ke_^m_l bo\urdheblv
qlh[u k[_j_qv e_fmjh\b hkh[_gghhqZjh\Zl_evgmx kZfhqdm
FZdkbaZ dhlhjhc kh[ZdbaZklZ\ __ \ kZ^mijh^he`Zeb
hohlblvky ^Z`_ ihke_ \k_o ij_ih^Zgguomjhdh\<ijhq_f__
wlh lhevdh aZ[Z\eyeh^Z b hgb [uebg_ lZdm` \bgh\Zlu
ihlhfm qlhFZdkb h[h`ZeZih^djZ^u\Zlvky dgbfsbiZlv aZ aZ^
beb ^_j]Zlv aZ o\hklqlh[u ihlhf m^bjZlv gZ
^_j_\h
bjZkiheh`b\rbkv
gZ [_ahiZkghc
\ukhl_ijh\hdZpbhggh
[helZlv o\hklhf gZ^ ]heh\Zfb jZatyj_gguo ikh\?s_ [he__
^\mkfuke_ggufb [uebhlghr_gby FZdkbk dhrdZfbb \ qZklghklb
k Imkkbohly y^\Z`^u gZoh^be _c`_gboh\aZfm` hgZlZd b
g_ \ureZ?_ i_j\uc ihdehggbd hke_iihqlb kjZam`_ ihke_
lh]hdZd y_]h dmibe`bagv `_\lhjh]h [_a\j_f_gghh[hj\Ze
g_kqZklguc kemqZc: ihlhfm FZdkbhklZ\ZeZkv [_a^_lghcb
dZd
qZklh
[u\Z_l
\
ih^h[guo
kblmZpbyoaZ\b^h\ZeZ
kqZkleb\uf
fZl_jyfh[j_f_gguf
ihlhfkl\hfImkkb
`_
h[aZ\h^beZkv ihlhfkl\hf ^\Z`^u \ ]h^FZdkb ijhgbdeZkvd
dhlylZf lZdhc`_ g_`ghc ex[h\vxdZdmx iblZ_ld gZrbf^_lyf
fhy g_aZfm`gyy l_lmrdZgh_keb `_gZ[u\ZeZ lhevdhjZ^Z
ihjmqZlv fZeur_c aZ[hlZf l_lb =_^\b]bImkkb kfhlj_eZgZ
lZdb_ \_sb bgZq_HgZ bkiulu\ZeZ d FZdkb
]em[hqZcr__
g_^h\_jb_b lZdh]^Z __ ho\Zlu\Zeh ^_eZgb_ eZkdZlvb
[Zeh\Zlv dhl_gdZ^he`gZ [ueZ ijb[_]Zlvd hkh[hclZdlbd_
h[uqgh ijbghkb\r_c_c ih[_^mDZd [ulsZl_evgh gb ijylZeZ
Imkkb k\hbo^_l_cdZd [u[^bl_evgh gbklhjh`beZ boFZdkb
\k_lZdb bo jZaukdb\ZeZ b[_krmfgh ih^djZ\rbkv
kaZ^b
ihobsZeZ dhl_gdZ?c [ueh kh\_jr_ggh ^hklZlhqghh^gh]h ^\mo hgZ gbdh]^Z g_ [jZeZFZeurZ hgZ^_j`ZeZ lZddZd
^_j`Zl fZe_gvdboe_fmjh\ bo fZl_jbijb`bfZeZ _]h d`b\hlm
aZ^g_c eZihcLj_o k\h[h^guo eZi _c \iheg_ o\ZlZeh^ey
lh]hqlh[u m[_`Zlv hldhrdb b jZgvr_g__ \kdZjZ[dZlvky gZ
^_j_\h^Z`_ _keb lZ kjZam `_ aZf_qZeZihoblbl_evgbpm b
[jhkZeZkv
\
ih]hgx
g_f_^e_gghH[uqgh ij_ke_^h\Zgb_
aZ\_jrZehkv l_fqlh FZdkb kdhl_gdhf mkljZb\ZeZkvgZ kZfuo
\_jogbo \_ldZodm^Z dhrdZ g_ fh]eZ aZg_c ke_^h\Zlvb
ijbgbfZeZkv mih_ggh _]h gygqblvGZb[he__ \Z`gmx qZklv
p_j_fhgbb khklZ\eyeb
\jh`^_ggu_ bgklbgdlb\gu_
^\b`_gby
dhlhjufb hgZ ijb\h^beZ \ ihjy^hd r_jkldm fZeurZFZdkb
kZfhaZ[\_ggh \uebau\ZeZ dhl_gdZ _fm wlZijhp_^mjZ hq_gv
gjZ\beZkv b ]eZ\gh_ \gbfZgb_h[jZsZeZ gZl_ qZklbl_eZ
dhlhju_ m \k_o feZ^_gp_\ lj_[mxlhkh[h lsZl_evgh]hmoh^Z
Dhg_qghfu klZjZebkv dZd fh`gh kdhj__ hlh[jZlv m g__
dhl_gdZhiZkZykvdZd [u hgZg_ mjhgbeZ_]h gZa_fexgh
wlh]hih ijZ\^_]h\hjygb jZamg_ ijhbahreh
<hagbdZ_l ex[hiulguc \hijhkhl\_lZ gZdhlhjuc ylZd b
g_
gZr_edZdbf
h[jZahf
FZdkb
magZ\ZeZ
\ dhl_gd_
feZ^_gpZ">_eh [uehg_ \\_ebqbg_d klhev`_ fZe_gvdbf
gh
\ajhkeuf
a\_jvdZf
hgZ
hlghkbeZkv
k
iheg_crbf
jZ\gh^mrb_fZ
dh]^Z
iha`_
LblZ
ijbg_keZ
s_gyl
ex[\_h[bevgZy
l_lmrdZijhgbdeZkv
d
gbf
lZdhc
`_
g_`ghklvxdZdhc hgZ ij_`^_iueZeZ d dhlylZfb __ qm\kl\Z
gbkdhevdh g_ hkluebb ihke_lh]hdZd [ukljhjZa\b\Zxsb_ky
h\qZjdb i_j_jhkeb__ \^\h_Ih fh_fm gZklhygbxLblZ ohly
beb k[hevrhc g_hohlhciha\heyeZ FZdkbbaeb\Zlv gZ s_gyl
__ g_m^h\e_l\hj_ggmx
ihlj_[ghklv \
fZl_jbgkl\_DZdb_
jZau]ju\Zebkv aZ[Z\gu_ kp_gu b dZdb_ \hkoblbl_evgu_b]ju
aZ\yau\Zebkv f_`^me_fmjhf bfheh^ufb kh[ZdZfb
Dh]^Z jh^beky fhc klZjrbc kugLhfZkFZdkb \hkijbgyeZ
_]h dZdgZb[he__ ih^oh^ysbc h[t_dl^ey k\hboaZ[hl bqZkZfb
ijhkb`b\ZeZ gZ djZx dheykdbEx^bg_ ijb\udrb_ d\b^m
e_fmjh\\_jhylghbkiulu\Zeb `mldh\Zlh_ qm\kl\h\_^v g_
\kydbc kmf__l hl]Z^Zlv ih ^Ze_dh g_h[uqghfm h[ebdmwlbo
kljZgguo
kms_kl\dZd
hgb
gZ
kZfhf
^_e_
fbeu b
ijb\e_dZl_evguG_ihk\ys_ggu_ mkfZljb\Zxlqlhlh ijbajZqgh_
\ wlbo q_jguo ebqbdZo k
q_eh\_q_kdbfb mrZfbmadbf
ghkhfke_]dZ
lhjqZsbfb kh[Zqvbfb
am[Zfb b
h]jhfgufb
yglZjgh`_elufb ]eZaZfbajZqdb dhlhjuodZd m \k_oghqguo
`b\hlguo^g_f km`Zxlky \djhohlgmx q_jgbevghq_jgmx lhqdm
< ijhrehf ahheh]b h[t_^bgyeb
wlm ]jmiim `b\hlguo
ih^
gZa\Zgb_ e_fmjuijb\b^_gbyGh y
ihjmqbe [u
k\h_]h
j_[_gdZ aZ[hlZf e_fmjZlZd `_kihdhcghdZd b kh[kl\_gghc
l_l_FZdkb [ueZ kihkh[gZ ijbqbgblv _fm\j_^ g_[hevr_
q_f lZH^gZdh bf_ggh ex[h\vFZdkb dj_[_gdm bijb\_eZ d
ljZ]bq_kdhfm dhgnebdlmhgZ j_\gh\ZeZ_]h daZdhgguf gygyf
b \_eZ k_[y k gbfb gZklhevdh Z]j_kkb\ghqlh ijbrehkv
h]jZgbqblv __ k\h[h^m<_^v dh]^ZFZdkb ijbkfZljb\ZeZ aZ
j_[_gdhfhgZ g_ih^imkdZeZ dg_fm gbdh]hdjhf_ f_gy
Kh\k_f g_ lZddZd k e_fmjhf^_j`Zebkv fhbkh[Zdb b
dhrdb k
gZklhysbfb h[_avygZfb[ueZ eb
lh djhohlgZy
fZjfha_ldZ beb kZfdZdZimpbg =ehjbydhlhjZy [ueZ
qmlv
ih[hevr_ ^hfZrg_cdhrdb
Kms_kl\m_l rbjhdh jZkijhkljZg_ggh_ aZ[em`^_gb_[m^lh
q_eh\_q_kdbc \a]ey^ h[eZ^Z_l kljZgghc kbehcFZm]eb \hedb
ba]gZeb bak\h_c klZb bf_gghihlhfmqlh g_ \u^_j`b\Zeb_]h
\a]ey^Zb ^Z`_iZgl_jZ_]h emqrbc^jm]g_ fh]eZkfhlj_lv
_fm ijyfh\ ]eZaZWlh km_\_jb_dZd bfgh]h_ ^jm]h_ohly
b g_\k_kh^_j`bl a_jghbklbgu>ey ilbpb fe_dhiblZxsbo
[_amkeh\ghfh`gh kqblZlv oZjZdl_jgufqlh hgbg_ kfhljyl
ijyfh ^jm]gZ ^jm]Zbeb gZ q_eh\_dZdhlhjhfm ^h\_jyxllh
_klv g_ kfhljyl ijbklZevghEbrv hq_gvg_fgh]b_ `b\hlgu_
h[eZ^Zxl l_fb hkh[_gghklyfb
kljh_gby k_lqZldbdhlhju_
iha\heyxl q_eh\_dm \b^_lv ij_^f_lu hlq_leb\hM q_eh\_dZ
p_gljZevguc
mqZklhd
\b^_lv
k_lqZldb
^Z_l
hlq_leb\h_
bah[jZ`_gb_Z i_jbn_jbq_kdh_ jZafulh_ihlhfm lhgZrb
]eZaZ \k_ \j_fy i_j_oh^yl k h^ghc lhqdb gZ ^jm]mxih
hq_j_^b nbdkbjmy gZ
dZ`^hc p_gljZevgmx qZklv
k_lqZldb
p_gljZevgmx yfdmFu \h\k_ g_ \b^bf \kx ho\Zlu\Z_fmx
gZrbf \a]ey^hf dZjlbgmh^bgZdh\h q_ldhdZd hgZihemqZ_lky
gZ nhlh]jZnbbM ih^Z\eyxs_]h [hevrbgkl\Z`b\hlguo nmgdpbb
p_gljZevgh]h
b
i_jbn_jbq_kdbo
mqZkldh\
k_lqZldb
jZa^_eyxlky g_ lZdj_adhdZd m q_eh\_dZ>jm]bfb keh\Zfb
i_j\u_ ^Zxlf_g__Z \lhju_[he__ q_ldh_bah[jZ`_gb_
Ihwlhfm `b\hlgu_dZd ijZ\behkhkj_^hlhqb\Zxl \a]ey^
gZ h^ghc lhqd_ ]hjZa^h j_`_ b gZ]hjZa^h [he__dhjhldh_
\j_fyq_f q_eh\_dHlijZ\vl_kv \ ^ebl_evgmxijh]medm kh
k\h_c kh[Zdhc bihgZ[ex^Zcl_qZklh eb hgZkfhljbl gZ\Zk
ijyfh<u h[gZjm`bl_qlh aZ
g_kdhevdh qZkh\
wlh
ijhbahc^_l jZaZ ^\Zg_ [hevr_b ih h^ghck \Zfb^hjh]_
hgZ b^_l keh\gh [u kemqZcghGZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ kh[ZdZ
ij_djZkgh \b^blohaybgZ i_jbn_jbq_kdbfaj_gb_f
;hevrZy qZklv
`b\hlguokihkh[guo
kfhlj_lv
h[hbfb
]eZaZfb h^gh\j_f_ggh \h^gm lhqdmju[uij_kfudZxsb_ky
ilbpu bfe_dhiblZxsb_ ihevamxlky wlhc kihkh[ghklvxlhevdh
\
fhf_glu
[hevrh]h
gZijy`_gbydh]^Z
bo
\gbfZgb_
khkj_^hlhq_gh gZ dhgdj_lghf ij_^f_l_Q_eh\_d
ihklhyggh
nbdkbjm_l p_gljZevguc mqZklhd k_lqZldb lh gZ lhflh gZ
^jm]hfb fu hlf_qZ_f dZd g_dmx kljZgghklv_keb
gZr
kh[_k_^gbd \^jm]
mklj_fbl \a]ey^
\ ijhkljZgkl\hM
[hevrbgkl\Z `_`b\hlguo lZdhc\a]ey^ \ gbdm^Zwlh ghjfZ
?keb `b\hlgh_ gZ^he]hhklZgh\bl k\hc\a]ey^ gZq_flhwlh
hagZqZ_l eb[h kljZoeb[h hij_^_e_ggu_ gZf_j_gbydZd
ijZ\behg_ kmeysb_ gbq_]h ohjhr_]hh[t_dlm _]h\gbfZgby
Nbdkbjh\Zgb_ \a]ey^Z
m lZdh]h
`b\hlgh]h\
kmsghklb
jZ\ghkbevgh \aylbx gZ ijbp_e@_eZy ijb\_klb dhgdj_lgu_
ijbf_ju kemqZ_\dh]^Z fhy kh[ZdZkfhljbl gZf_gy ih^h[guf
\a]ey^hfy ihke_^he]bo jZa^mfbcfh]m ijbihfgblvebrv ljb
\hi_j\uodh]^Z y \oh`m\ dhfgZlm k__ fbkdhc\h\lhjuo
\h \j_fy rmleb\uo ^jZdb\lj_lvbodh]^Z yj_adh __
hdebdZx>jm] gZ ^jm]Z `b\hlgu_kfhljyl ijbklZevghlhevdh
i_j_^ l_fdZd ij_^ijbgylv
j_rbl_evgu_ ^_ckl\bybeb
bkiulu\Zy kljZoIhwlhfm ^he]bc \a]ey^ ^ey gbo g_qlh
\jZ`^_[gh_ b m]jh`Zxs__b mq_eh\_dZ hgb_]h jZkp_gb\Zxl
dZd ijbagZd kZfuo q_jguo gZf_j_gbc< wlhfb aZdexqZ_lky
\_kv k_dj_l kbeu q_eh\_q_kdh]h \a]ey^Z?keb y\g_aZigh
hdZ`mkv \ h[s_kl\_ djmigh]h obsgbdZijbq_f gZkg_ [m^_l
jZa^_eylv j_r_ldZb _keb_s_ g_ jZah[jZ\rbkv \
_]h
hlghr_gbb dh fg_y aZf_qmqlh hg g_ kimkdZ_lk f_gy
\a]ey^Z rbjhdh jZkdjuluo ]eZa dZd wlh ^_eZ_l \kydbc
ghjfZevguc q_eh\_dh[sZykv k [eb`gbfblh]^Zg_ kdjhx
y ki_rm j_lbjh\Zlvky_ebdh \hafh`gh[uklj_c< wlhfkemqZ_
kbeZ ev\bgh]h\a]ey^ZhdZ`_lky \_kvfZagZqbl_evghc
< khhl\_lkl\bb k jZaebqbyfb \ kljh_gbb
ajbl_evgh]h
ZiiZjZlZ ijyfhc \a]ey^ m q_eh\_dZhagZqZ_l h[jZlgh_lhfm
qlh hg
agZf_gm_l m
obsgbdh\ k_f_ckl\Z
dhrZqvbo
beb
kh[ZqvboQ_eh\_ddhlhjuc g_kfhljbl fg_\ ]eZaZb \k_
\j_fy hl\h^bl \a]ey^eb[h aZfurey_l \ hlghr_gbb
f_gy
qlhlh ^mjgh_eb[h [hblky f_gy \_^v kfms_gb_ wlh
hij_^_e_ggZy kl_i_gv kljZoZLhqgh lh `_kijZ\_^eb\h b
^ey `b\hlgh]hdhlhjh_
kqblZ_l gm`guf ijbklZevgh
f_gy
jZkkfZljb\ZlvWlb gZ[ex^_gby ih^kdZau\Zxl gZfdZd
fu
^he`gu \_klb k_[ybf_y ^_eh k`b\hlgufbLhldlh ohq_l
aZ\h_\Zlv ^h\_jb_ jh[dhc dhrdbg_j\ghc kh[Zdb beb
bf
ih^h[guo^he`_g \aylvaZ ijZ\behgbdh]^Z g_mklj_feylv gZ
gbo ijbklZevgh]h \a]ey^Z ]heh^gh]h ev\ZKfhlj_lv gm`gh
fbfhlZdqlh[u \Zrb ]eZaZhklZgZ\eb\Zebkv gZgbo dZd[u
kemqZcgh bebrv gZkZfh_ dhjhldh_\j_fy
=eZa `_ h[_avygu mkljh_g dZd q_eh\_q_kdbcM h[_avyg
]eZaZ lh`_ ihkZ`_gu \ q_j_i_ lZdqlh hgbkfhljyl ijyfh
\i_j_^ b lhqghlZdbf `_h[jZahf nhdmkbjmxlkygZ hl^_evguo
ij_^f_lZoIhkdhevdm
h[_avygu
gZ^_e_gu
g_gZkulguf
ex[hiulkl\hf b\ lh `_\j_fy gblZdlhfgb ^biehfZlbqghklvx
\ h[s_gbb k^jm]bfb kms_kl\Zfbg_ hlebqZxlkyhgb hlqZyggh
^_ckl\mxl gZ g_j\u\k_f hklZevguf\ukrbf fe_dhiblZxsbfb \
hkh[_gghklb kh[ZdZf
b dhrdZfLhdZd
wlb ihke_^gb_
j_Z]bjmxl gZ h[_avygij_djZkgh ihdZau\Z_lbo hlghr_gb_d
q_eh\_dmKh[Zdbdjhldb_
ihkemrgu_k q_eh\_dhfiha\heyxl
^Z`_ djhohlgufh[_avygZf lbjZgblvk_[y gZ \k_eZ^uFg_ gb
jZam g_ijbrehkv aZsbsZlv fhbodZimpbgh\ bhl kZfuokbevguo
b k\bj_iuo kh[ZdGZh[hjhly g_j_^dh [u\Ze
\ugm`^_g
aZklmiZlvky aZ kh[ZdmFZe_gvdbc [_eheh[uc dZimpbgWfbev
dhlhjucg_khfg_gghihk\h_fm
hq_gv
ex[be
Wfbev
bkihevah\Ze _]h ihi_j_f_gghlh dZd\_joh\mx ehrZ^vlh dZd
]j_edm?keb [mev^h]ijh[h\Ze ohlv\ q_flh \hkijhlb\blvky
`_eZgbyf wlh]h gZoZevgh]h djhrdbhg g_f_^e_ggh dZjZeky
ihs_qbgZfb beb mdmkZfb?fm g_ jZaj_rZehkv \klZ\Zlv
k
^b\ZgZihdZ Wfbev \hae_ g_]h ]j_ekyZ dh]^ZgZklmiZeh
\j_fy dhjfblv;meeby \k_]^Zij_`^_ m^ZeyeWfbeybgZq_ hg
kh\k_f aZfmqbe [u [_^gmx kh[Zdmohly _fmb \]heh\m g_
ijbreh [u \kZfhf ^_e_kt_klv g_ijbohleb\uckh[Zqbc h[_^
< p_ehf
kh[Zdb \_^ml
k_[y k
h[_avygZfbkeh\gh
k
ba[Zeh\Zggufb baeufb ^_lvfbdhlhju_dZd ohjhrhba\_klgh
fh]ml [_agZdZaZggh ^jZagblv^h[jh^mrguo kh[Zdb ihke_^gb_
g_ lhevdhbo g_mdmkyl q_]h hgb\iheg_ aZkem`b\Zxlgh ^Z`_
g_ aZjuqZlgZ gbo
<k_qlh y ]h\hjbe h ih\_^_gbb kh[Zdih hlghr_gbxd
^_lyf\ agZqbl_evghckl_i_gb hlghkblkyb ddhrdZfH^gZdh
dhrdb ^Ze_dhg_ lZdl_ji_eb\uohly bkghkyl hl^_l_c fgh]h
[hevr_q_f hl \ajhkeuoQlh `_ dZkZ_lkyh[_avyglh LhfZk
,dh]^Z FZdkblZkdZeZ _]h aZo\hkl[_a \kydbodhe_[Zgbc k
rbi_gb_f
b
\hjqZgb_f
gZ]jZ`^ZeZ
__
hie_mohc^Z b
hklZevgu_ fhb dhrdb g_ om`_ g_]hmf_eb ihklZ\blvh[_avyg
gZ f_klh<hafh`ghbf [eZ]hijbylkl\h\Ze lhl nZdlqlh
h[_avygZfkh]eZkgh fhbf gZ[ex^_gbyfk\hckl\_g g_dhlhjuc
ijbjh`^_gguc kljZo i_j_^obsgbdZfb k_f_ckl\ZdhrZqvbo>\_
fhb fZjfha_ldb [ueb iZjZebah\Zgu m`Zkhf ijb \b^_qmq_eZ
lb]jZ \ahheh]bq_kdhf fma__ohly h[_hgb jh^bebkv \g_\he_
b gbdZd g_ fh]eb bf_lv \ ijhrehf g_ijbylguo \klj_q k
ih^h[gufb `b\hlgufbB h[_ hgb hq_gvhkl_j_]Zebkv dhr_d
Fhc dZimpbg
\gZqZe_ lh`_
hlghkbeky d
dhrdZf ]hjZa^h
ihqlbl_evg__q_f d kh[ZdZfohly dhrdbdhg_qgh[ueb
aZf_lgh f_gvr_ihke_^gbo
Fg_ g_gjZ\blky k_glbf_glZevgh_hq_eh\_qb\Zgb_ `b\hlguo
F_gy
\k_]^Z
ke_]dZ
ihlZrgb\Zehdh]^Z
\
`mjgZe_
dZdh]hgb[m^v h[s_kl\Z aZsblu `b\hlguo y \b`m
gZ^ibkv
>h[ju_ ^jmavybeb _s_ qlhgb[m^v \ lhf`_ ^mo_Z gZ^
g_c nhlh]jZnbxgZ dhlhjhc dhrdZlZdkZ b aZjygdZ_^yl
\ljh_f ba h^ghcfbkdb bebwlh kh\k_f m`g_kl_jibfhgh
lZdmx nhlh]jZnbxy \b^_ekh\k_f g_^Z\gh kbZfkdZy dhrdZ b
fZe_gvdbc Zeeb]Zlhj
\hkk_^Zxl [hd
h [hdjZ\gh^mrgh
b]ghjbjmy ^jm]^jm]ZBkoh^y bak\h_]h kh[kl\_ggh]hhiulZy
kqblZxqlh gZklhysZy ^jm`[Z f_`^m`b\hlgufb jZaguo\b^h\
qj_a\uqZcgh j_^dZIh wlhcijbqbg_ yb gZa\ZegZklhysmx ]eZ\m
I_j_fbjb_Z g_>jm`[Z `b\hlguobeb dZdgb[m^v _s_\ lhf
`_ jh^_<aZbfgZy l_jibfhklv wlh[_amkeh\ghg_ kbghgbf
^jm`[ub ^Z`_ dh]^Z `b\hlguo h[t_^bgy_l h[sbc bgl_j_k
gZijbf_jdh]^Z hgb b]jZxl\f_kl_\k_lZdbdZd ijZ\beh
g_evay ]h\hjblv[m^lh
f_`^m gbfb kms_kl\m_l
bklbggh_
^h[jh`_eZl_evkl\h bm` l_f[he__ijhqgZy ^jm`[ZFhc \hjhg
JhZdhlhjuc
ijhe_lZe ih
g_kdhevdh dbehf_ljh\qlh[u
hlukdZlv f_gy gZ dZdhfgb[m^v ^mgZckdhf iey`_fhy k_jZy
]mkugy FZjlbgZdhlhjZy \klj_qZeZ
f_gy k l_f
[hevrbf
\hklhj]hfq_f ^hevr_ y hlkmlkl\h\Zefhb ^bdb_fheh^u_
]mkZdb I_l_jb <bdlhjdhlhju_ fm`_kl\_gghaZsbsZeb f_gy hl
gZkdhdh\ klZjh]h]mkZdZohly kZfbkf_jl_evgh _]h[hyebkv
\k_ wlb`b\hlgu_ ^_ckl\bl_evgh [uebfhbfb ^jmavyfblh _klv
gZrZ ijb\yaZgghklv[ueZ \aZbfghcHlkmlkl\b_ ih^h[guo qm\kl\
f_`^m `b\hlgufb
jZaguo \b^h\
\ hkgh\ghf
h[tykgy_lky
yaudh\uf [Zjv_jhfY m`_ mihfbgZe h lj_gbyodhlhju_
\hagbdZxl f_`^m kh[ZdZfb b dhrdZfb ihlhfmqlh
ebr_gu
\jh`^_ggh]h ihgbfZgby
kfukeZ ^Z`_
gZb[he__ \Z`guo
ba
^_fhgkljZpbhgguo
^\b`_gbc
^jm]h]h
\b^Z
^\b`_gbc
hkhagZxsbc m]jhambeb ]g_\?s_ f_gvr_kihkh[gu hgb ihgbfZlv
ijhy\e_gb_ [he__ lhgdbo hll_gdh\ ^jm`_kdbo wfhpbc>Z`_
hlghr_gby ;meebb LhfZkZ ,dhlhju_ [eZ]h^Zjykbe_ ijb\uqdb
b
[eZ]hijbh[j_l_gghc
kihkh[ghklb
d
hij_^_e_gghfm
\aZbfhihgbfZgbx ^hklb]ebdh_dZdhc ]em[bgu\k_lZdb _^\Z eb
aZkem`b\Zxl gZa\Zgby^jm`[udZd bijbyl_evkdb_ b]juLblb b
[ZjkmdZB l_f g_ f_g__ hlghr_gbywlbo ^\moiZj gZb[he__
ijb[eb`Zxlky d bklbgghc^jm`[_ f_`^m`b\hlgufb ^\mojZaguo
\b^h\ ba \k_]hqlh fg_^h\_ehkv gZ[ex^Zlvm k_[y\ ^hf_
]^_ gZ ijhly`_gbb^_kyldh\ e_lhq_gv fgh]h`b\hlguo kZfuo
jZaguo \b^h\ `beb \ khklhygbb ijhqgh]h i_j_fbjby b
\
mkeh\byodhlhju_ dZd [m^lh ^he`gu[ueb [ukihkh[kl\h\Zlv
\hagbdgh\_gbx ^jm`[u
IjZ\^Zfg_ h^gZ`^u ijbrehkv klZlvk\b^_l_e_f kemqZy
ihdZau\Zxs_]hqlh iylgbklmx ^\hjgy`dmb lj_op\_lgmx dhrdm
dhlhju_ h[blZeb gZ n_jf_ g_ih^Ze_dm hl gZkk\yau\Zeb
kh\_jr_ggh hkh[u_mauI_k [ueg_kbe_g bljmkh\Zl \hlebqb_
hl dhrdbdhlhjZy [ueZ gZfgh]hklZjr_ _]hbih\b^bfhfm
ijhgbdeZkv m g_fmq_flh \jh^_fZl_jbgkdh]h qm\kl\Zdh]^Z
hg [ue _s_ s_gdhfGZ wlhchkgh\_ keh`beZkvkZfZy l_kgZy
^jm`[Z f_`^m kh[Zdhcb dhrdhcdZdZy fg_ba\_klgZHgb g_
lhevdh \f_kl_ b]jZebgh b \hh[s_ ij_^ihqblZebh[s_kl\h
^jm] ^jm]Z\k_fm hklZevghfm bwlh]h y[hevr_ gbdh]^Zgb]^_
g_ gZ[ex^ZehlijZ\eyebkv \^\h_f ]meylvih kZ^mb ^Z`_ih
^_j_\_gkdhc mebp_Bo
g_h[uqZcguc khxa \u^_j`Ze
kZfh_
kmjh\h_ bkiulZgb_dZdhfm fh`_l
ih^\_j]gmlvky
^jm`[Z
>\hjgy`dZ
\oh^beZ
\
qbkeh
ijbagZgguo
\jZ]h\
fh_]h
njZgpmakdh]h [mev^h]Z]eZ\guf h[jZahf ihlhfmqlh [ueZ
f_gvr_q_f hg\ hlebqb_ hlih^Z\eyxs_]h [hevrbgkl\Z
^jm]bo kh[Zd b ih[Zb\ZeZkv_]hDZdlh jZa ;meebgZklb]
iylgbklh]h i_kbdZ gZ mebp_ b kh[jZekyaZ^Zlv _fmohjhrmx
lj_idmOhlbl_ \_jvl_ohlbl_ g_lgh lj_op\_lgZydhrdZ
ime_c \ue_l_eZ ba^hfZijhg_keZkv q_j_a kZ^\ukdhqbeZ gZ
mebpmjbgmeZkv \[hcq_j_a iZjm k_dmg^h[jZlbeZ ;meeb\
[_]kl\h b ijh_oZeZ
gZ g_flhqgh
\_^vfZ gZ
ihf_e_
^h\hevghlZdb ihjy^hqgh_ jZkklhygb_?keb \hafh`gu lZdb_
ih^\b]blh l_f [he__ g_evay ]h\hjblv h^jm`[_lhevdh
ihlhfmqlh jZkdhjfe_ggZy bne_]fZlbqgZy ]hjh^kdZy kh[ZdZb
klhev `_ jZkdhjfe_ggZyb ne_]fZlbqgZydhrdZ _^ylba h^ghc
fbkdbg_ [jhkZykv^jm] gZ^jm]Z
A:;HJ
Dhfm g_ ^h\h^behkv b^lb \^hev kZ^h\h]h aZ[hjZaZ
dhlhjuf juqbl beZ_l [hevrZykh[ZdZ"HgZ [_kgm_lky]jua_l
rlZd_lgbd hkdZe_ggufb deudZfbb dZ`_lkyqlh lhevdhhg
f_rZ_l _c\hgablv bo\ \Zr_ ]hjehGh f_gy ih^h[gu_m]jhau
g_ im]Zxlb y \k_]^Z hldju\Zxl dZebldm kihdhcghb [_a
fZe_crbo
dhe_[ZgbcKh[ZdZ
l_jy_lkyg_
agZydZd
ihklmiblv hgZ ijh^he`Z_l eZylvgh m`_ g_lZd ]jhaghb
\_kv __ \b^y\gh ihdZau\Z_lqlh hgZgbdh]^Z g_iha\hebeZ
[u
k_[_
lZd
g_bkl\h\Zlv_keb
[u ij_^\b^_eZ lZdh_
g_ihql_gb_ k fh_cklhjhgu dk\ylhklb aZ[hjZ;u\Z_l ^Z`_
qlh ijb
\b^_ hldju\Zxs_cky
dZeblky hgZ
hl[_]Z_l
gZ
g_kdhevdh rZ]h\ beZ_l m`_k [_ahiZkgh]hjZkklhygby ^jm]bf
lhghfB gZh[hjhlhq_gv jh[dZykh[ZdZ beb\heddhlhjuc aZ
ijmlvyfb de_ldb g_ijhy\eye gbdZdboijbagZdh\ \jZ`^_[ghklb
beb lj_\h]bfh`_l [jhkblky \h\iheg_ j_ZevgmxZlZdm_^\Z
dlhgb[m^v ihdZ`_lkygZ ihjh]_
Wlb gZ i_j\uc \a]ey^ ijhlb\hiheh`gu_ lbiu ih\_^_gby
hibjZxlky gZh^bg b lhl`_ ikboheh]bq_kdbcf_oZgbafDZ`^h_
`b\hlgh_b \ qZklghklb djmigh_ fe_dhiblZxs__[_`bl hl
[he__
kbevgh]h
khi_jgbdZ_^\Z
lhl
ijb[ebablky
gZ
hij_^_e_ggh_ jZkklhygb_>bklZgpby [_]kl\ZdZd gZa\Ze wlh
jZkklhygb_
ijhn_kkhj
O_^b]_jhldju\rbc
wlh y\e_gb_
m\_ebqb\Z_lky
ijhihjpbhgZevgh
kljZomdhlhjuc
\gmrZ_l
`b\hlghfm _]h ijhlb\gbdFh`gh kh\_jr_gghlhqgh hij_^_eblv
lhqdmijb ^hklb`_gbb dhlhjhc `b\hlgh_ imklblky gZml_d
_^\Z \jZ] ihky]g_l gZ ^bklZgpbx [_]kl\ZDjhf_ lh]h
kms_kl\m_l klhev `_ hij_^_e_ggZygh agZqbl_evgh
[eb`_
jZkiheh`_ggZy
lhqdZijb
^hklb`_gbb
dhlhjhc `b\hlgh_
\klmiZ_l \^jZdm k \jZ]hf< _kl_kl\_gguomkeh\byo ih^h[gh_
\lhj`_gb_
\
ij_^_eu
djblbq_kdhc
^bklZgpbbl_jfbg
O_^b]_jZijhbkoh^bl lhevdh \ ^\mo kemqZyo eb[h dh]^Z
`b\hlgh_ aZo\Zq_gh \jZkiehoeb[h dh]^Z hgh ihdZdhclh
ijbqbg_ g_ fh`_l h[jZlblvky \ [_]kl\h<ZjbZglhf i_j\hc
\hafh`ghklb y\ey_lky kemqZcdh]^Z djmigh_`b\hlgh_kZfh
kihkh[gh_ gZiZklv\b^bl
ijb[eb`Zxs_]hky \jZ]Zgh
g_
m[_]Z_lZ ijyq_lkyjZkkqblu\Zy hklZlvkyg_aZf_q_gguf?keb
\jZ] _]h\k_lZdb h[gZjm`blhgh ^Z_lhlqZygguc [hcBf_ggh
wlhl f_oZgbaf b ^_eZ_l
lZdbf jbkdh\Zgguf ij_ke_^h\Zgb_
jZg_gghc djmighc ^bqbGZiZ^_gb_ gZ Z]j_kkhjZdhlhjuc
i_j_klmibl ]jZgbpmdjblbq_kdhc ^bklZgpbbih^dj_iey_lky \k_f
fm`_kl\hf hlqZygby bihlhfm gZb[he__hiZkghLZdZy j_Zdpby
k\hckl\_ggZ hlgx^v g_lhevdh djmigufobsgbdZf hgZ hq_gv
jZa\blZ mohfydZZ aZ]gZggZy\ m]hedjukZ aZsbsZ_lky lZd
qlh \h fgh]bo yaudZo \hagbdeh \ujZ`_gb_>_j_lkydZd
aZ]gZggZy \m]he djukZ
Ihgylby ^bklZgpbb
[_]kl\Z b
djblbq_kdhc
^bklZgpbb
ihfh]Zxl h[tykgblv ih\_^_gb_
kh[Zdb aZ aZ[hjhfdh]^Z
dZebldZ aZdjulZ b dh]^Z hgZ hldjulZAZ[hj wd\b\Ze_gl_g
agZqbl_evghfm jZa^_eyxs_fm jZkklhygbxkh[ZdZ ihaZ^bg_]h
qm\kl\m_l k_[y \ [_ahiZkghklb b khhl\_lkl\_gghbkiheg_gZ
ojZ[jhklbJZkiZob\ZxsZyky
dZebldZ
kha^Z_l
m
g__
hsms_gb_qlh \jZ] \^jm] j_adh ijb[ebabekyWlh
fh`_l
ijb\_klb d
hiZkguf ihke_^kl\byf
^ey g_hiulguo
ex^_c
hkh[_ggh dh]^Z^_eh dZkZ_lky`b\hlguo \ ahheh]bq_kdhfkZ^m
dhlhju_ ^he]h ijh`beb\ g_\he_b m[_`^_gu\ g_ijbklmighklb
k\hbo
de_lhdDh]^Z
q_eh\_d
hl^_e_g
hl
`b\hlgh]h
ij_]jZ^hchgh qm\kl\m_lk_[y \[_ahiZkghklb _]h ^bklZgpby
[_]kl\Z khojZgy_lky iheghklvxHgh ^Z`_]hlh\h \klmiblv\
^jm`_kdbc dhglZdl k q_eh\_dhfklhysbf ih lm
klhjhgm
ijmlv_\Gh _kebwlhl q_eh\_dh[h^j_gguc l_fqlh `b\hlgh_
lhevdh
qlh
iha\hebeh
ih]eZ^blv
k_[y
kd\hav ijmlvy
g_h`b^Zggh \hc^_l\ de_ldm`b\hlgh_ fh`_l\ m`Zk_ dbgmlvky
\ ^Zevgbc m]heZ fh`_lb gZiZklvihlhfm qlhb ^bklZgpby
[_]kl\Zb djblbq_kdZy ^bklZgpby k bkq_agh\_gb_f[Zjv_jZ
hdZaZebkv gZjmr_ggufbB lZdh_ `b\hlgh_[m^_ljZamf__lky
h[\bg_gh \dh\Zjkl\_
Lhl nZdlqlh ijbjmq_gguc \hedgZ f_gyg_ [jhkbekyh
q_f jZkkdZau\Z_lkygb`_y h[tykgyxfh_c hk\_^hfe_gghklvx \
wlbo aZdhgZoDZd y m`_
mihfbgZeh^gZ`^u yihijh[h\Ze
k\_klb fhx qZmqZm KlZkb k lZ_`guf \hedhfohly
f_gy
hl]h\Zjb\Zeb hlwlh]h gZf_j_gbylZd dZdhg keue \ahhiZjd_
qj_a\uqZcgh k\bj_iufB \k_ `_ y j_rbe jbkdgmlvgh ba
ij_^hklhjh`ghklb ^ey gZqZeZihf_klbe bo\ ^\_khh[sZxsb_ky
de_ldbKh_^bgyxsmx bo ^\_jv y kgZqZeZ ijbhldjuejh\gh
gZklhevdhqlh[u KlZkbb \hed fh]ebijhkmgmlv \s_ev ghku b
h[gxoZlv ^jm] ^jm]ZIhke_ wlhcp_j_fhgbb hgbh[Z aZ\beyeb
o\hklZfbb g_kdhevdh fbgml kimkly y rbjhdh
jZkiZogme
^\_jv b g_ jZkdZb\ZxkvlZd dZd f_`^mgbfb \k_kjZam
ihreh dZdih fZkem
Dh]^Z ym\b^_eqlh fhyKlZkb \_k_ehb]jZ_l k ]b]Zglkdbf
\hedhf\h fg_ \g_aZighijhkgmehkv `_eZgb_ bkijh[h\Zlvk_[y
gZ ihijbs_mdjhlbl_ey ^bdboa\_j_c b lh`_\hclb \ eh]h\h
\hedZKd\hav
ijmlvy
hg
a^hjh\Zeky
kh fghc \_kvfZ
ijb\_leb\hb g_ihk\ys_gghfmfh]eh [uihdZaZlvkyqlh y fh]m
\hclb d g_fmgbq_f g_jbkdmyH^gZdh wlh [ueh[u \_kvfZ
hiZkguf ij_^ijbylb_fg_ agZc y h koh^kl\_jheb ijmlv_\
de_ldb b djblbq_kdhc^bklZgpbbY aZfZgbe KlZkbb \hedZ\
kZfmx ^Zevgxx ba jy^Z de_lhdba dhlhjuo ^eywlhc p_eb
w\Zdmbjh\Ze iZjmkh[ZdrZdZeZ b]b_gmAZl_f yhldjue \k_
kh_^bgbl_evgu_ ^\_jpuf_^e_ggh \hr_e \ i_j\mx de_ldmb
hklZgh\beky lZdqlh[u ohjhrh \b^_lv\_kv kd\haghcijhoh^
Gb KlZkbgb \hed kgZqZeZ f_gy g_aZf_lbeblZd dZdhgb
klhyeb \ klhjhg_ hl \gmlj_gg_c ^\_jpugh \kdhj_ \hed
aZ]eygme \g__ bm\b^_e f_gyB lhl`_ kZfuc\heddhlhjuc
ij_djZkgh agZe f_gydhlhjuc kd\havijmlvy ebaZefg_ jmdb
gZqbgZe jZ^hklgh iju]Zlvl_i_jv i_j_im]Zeky
gZkf_jlv
m\b^_\ f_gy \ g_kdhevdbo f_ljZog_ hl^_e_ggh]hhl g_]h
ijmlvyfb?]h mrbhimklbebkvr_jklv gZ aZ]jb\d_m]jh`Zxs_
\klZeZ ^u[hfbhimklb\ o\hklf_`^m gh]Zfbhg k[ukljhlhc
fhegbb hlkdhqbe hl ^\_jpuQ_j_a k_dmg^m hg\_jgmeky gZ
ij_`g__ f_klh<b^ mg_]h \k__s_ [uebkim]Zggucgh r_jklv
m`_ g_s_lbgbeZkvhg ijbgyekyf_gy jZa]ey^u\Zlvqmlvqmlv
dehgb\ ]heh\m gZ[hdAZl_f _]ho\hkl gZqZedhjhldh \beylv
\k_ _s_ hklZ\Zykv f_`^m gh]ZfbY lZdlbqgh kfhlj_e
\
klhjhgmlZd
dZd ijbklZevguc
\a]ey^ im]Z_l
`b\hlguo
\u\_^_gguo ba ^mr_\gh]h jZ\gh\_kby< wlhl fhf_gl f_gy
aZf_lbeZ KlZkbBkdhkZ ih]ey^u\Zy gZ ZgnbeZ^mde_lhdy
m\b^_edZd hgZ]Zehihf ihfqZeZkvdh fg_Z ke_^hfaZ g_c
\hedIjbagZxkvgZ k_dmg^m f_gyho\Zlbe `mldbckljZogh
hg lml
`_ jZkk_yekydh]^Z y
h[gZjm`beqlh
\hed
ijb[eb`Z_lky dh fg_ g_mdex`_c b]jb\hc jukphcb keh\gh[u
ihdZqb\Z_l ]heh\hc wlhdZd ba\_klgh \k_fgZ[ex^Zl_evguf
ex[bl_eyf kh[ZdhagZqZ_l
ijb]eZr_gb_ ihb]jZlv
\f_kl_
Ihwlhfm ygZijy] \k_furpuqlh[u \u^_j`Zlv^jm`_kdbc iju`hd
h]jhfgh]h a\_jyb ih\_jgmeky [hdhfjZkkqblu\Zy ba[_`Zlv
ba\_klgh]h aeh\_s_]h m^ZjZeZiZfb \`b\hlG_kfhljy gZwlb
ij_^hklhjh`ghklby hle_l_e d kl_g_ b [hevghklmdgmeky
H^gZdh \hed ^_j`Zeky ^jm`_kdb b ^h\_jqb\hQlh[u ihgylv
dZdh\h [ueh b]jZlv k
gbfij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ kh[Zdm
k
ih^\b`ghklvx nhdkl_jv_jZb kbehc^Zlkdh]h ^h]Z\h \j_fy lhc
b]ju fg_ klZeh ykghihq_fm \hedg_j_^dh [u\Z_lkihkh[_g
kijZ\blky k p_ehc k\hjhc kh[ZddZd gbijbieyku\Ze y
ih[hdk_jkdbfg_ lhb ^_ehijboh^behkv e_l_lvgZ ihe
<lhjZy bklhjby haZ[hj_ k\yagZk ;meebb _]haZdeyluf
\jZ]hf[_euf ribp_f`b\rbf \ ^hf_^ebgguc madbckZ^
dhlhjh]h lygmeky
\^hev mebpu
b [ue
h]hjh`_g a_e_guf
rlZd_lgbdhf f_ljh\ \ ljb^pZlv ^ebghc>\Z gZrbo
]_jhy
hijhf_lvx ghkbebkv \aZ^ b \i_j_^ ihh[_bf klhjhgZfwlh]h
aZ[hjZaZeb\Zykv
[_r_gguf eZ_f
b hklZgZ\eb\Zykv
gZ
f]gh\_gb_ m
ihke_^g_]h klhe[Zqlh[u i_j_^
l_fdZd
ih\_jgmlv h[jZlghh[jmrblv gZ
\jZ]Z mjZ]Zgguc
\aju\
h[fZgmlhc yjhklbAZl_f \ h^bg ij_djZkguc^_gv \hagbdeZ
\_kvfZ ^\mkfuke_ggZy kblmZpby aZ[hj gZqZeb qbgblv
b
iheh\bgm rlZd_lgbdZjZkiheh`_ggmx [eb`_d >mgZxjZah[jZeb
lZd qlh l_i_jvhg f_ljh\q_j_a iylgZ^pZlvh[ju\ZekyFu k
;meeb kimklbebkv kgZr_]h ohefZgZijZ\eyykv dj_d_Ribp
dhg_qghgZk aZf_lbe bm`_ ih^`b^Ze ;meebjuqZ b ^jh`Zhl
\heg_gby \[eb`Zcr_f d gZfm]em kZ^ZKgZqZeZ ijhlb\gbdbih
h[udgh\_gbx h[f_gyebkvm]jhaZfbklhy gZf_kl_Z aZl_f h[_
kh[ZdbdZ`^Zy gZ k\h_c klhjhg_ihfqZebkvdZd iheh`_gh
\^hev aZ[hjZB lml ijhbahreZdZlZkljhnZ hgb g_aZf_lbeb
qlh ^Zevr_ rlZd_lgbd [ue kgylb h[gZjm`bebk\hx hrb[dm
lhevdh dh]^Z ^h[jZebkv^h ^Zevg_]hm]eZ]^_ bfiheZ]Zehkv
kgh\Z h[eZylv^jm] ^jm]ZaZklu\ \ g_ih^\b`ghciha_Hgb b
\klZeb\a^u[b\ r_jklvb hkdZeb\deudbZ aZ[hjZlh f_`^m
gbfb g_ hdZaZehkvEZc kjZam
h[hj\ZekyB qlh `_hgb
k^_eZeb"Lhqgh ihdhfZg^_h[Z ih\_jgmebkvihfqZebkv [hd h
[hd d_s_ klhys_fmrlZd_lgbdm blZf \gh\vih^gyeb eZclhqgh
gbq_]h g_ijhbahreh
FGH=H RMF:BAA: F:E?GVDH=H>BG=H
DZdlh \ iZkfmjguc ^_gv ]h^Z fg_ iha\hgbefhc
[ebadbc ^jm]ijhn_kkhj :glhgbmk^bj_dlhj R_g[jmggkdh]h
ahhiZjdZ
<u ]h\hjbebqlh ohl_eb [u ^Zlv \Zr_c kh[Zd_gZ
\hkiblZgb_ fZe_gvdh]h^bg]hR_klv ^g_cgZaZ^ h^gZba gZrbo
^bg]h hs_gbeZkvijb_a`Zcl_ g_f_^e_ggh b \u[_jbl_dZdh]h
ohlbl_
MkeurZ\ wlm hr_ehfeyxsmxgh\hklvy lhlqZk `_[jhkbeky
\ ahhiZjdohly m f_gy[ueh dZdh_lh \Z`gh_ ^_ehY e_]dh
aZfZgbf kh\k_f jmqgmx b hq_gv ^h[jh^mrgmx fZlv^bg]h \
kf_`gh_ ihf_s_gb_Z kZf \u[jZe ba dhihrb\rboky\ ysbd_
ju`_\Zlhdhjbqg_\uo
f_oh\uo
dem[hqdh\
_^bgkl\_ggh]h
dh[_evdZgZ
dhlhjhf
g_
[ueh
gbdZdbo
f_lhd
k\b^_l_evkl\h\Z\rbo h lhfqlh _]h ij_^db [uebdh]^Zlh
kimlgbdZfb q_eh\_dZ
>bg]h wlh hq_gvbgl_j_kgh_ `b\hlgh_wlh _^bgkl\_ggh_
djmigh_
fe_dhiblZxs__g_
ijbgZ^e_`Zs__
d
ih^deZkkm
kmfqZluodhlhjh_
[ueh
h[gZjm`_gh
gZ
:\kljZebckdhf
dhglbg_gl_dh]^Z hg [ue hldjulIhfbfh ^bg]h\ukrb_
fe_dhiblZxsb_ [ueb ij_^klZ\e_gu
lZf lhevdh
g_kdhevdbfb
\b^Zfb e_lmqbo fur_cdZdbflh h[jZahf i_j_[jZ\rboky
\
:\kljZebxIjhqb_
`_ fe_dhiblZxsb_
h[blZl_eb
wlh]h
dhglbg_glZk hq_gv ^Z\gbo ihjij_[u\Zeb \]_h]jZnbq_kdhc
baheypbbijbgZ^e_`Zeb bkdexqbl_evghd kmfqZluf\h fgh]hf
_s_ hq_gv ijbfblb\gufDjhf_ lh]hlZf `beb_s_ bex^b l_fghdh`b_ Z[hjb]_gugZoh^b\rb_ky gZ i_j\h[ulghfmjh\g_
hgb g_ h[jZ[Zlu\Zeb a_fexg_ bf_eb^hfZrgbo `b\hlguob
\b^bfhih dmevlmjghfmb ^moh\ghfmjZa\blbx klhyebaZf_lgh
gb`_ k\hbo ij_^dh\dh]^Zlh ihk_eb\rbokylZfWlb ij_^db
[ueb lZdbfb `_ohjhrbfb fhj_oh^ZfbdZd gug_rgb_h[blZl_eb
Gh\hc =\bg_bLZdhc j_]j_kk Z[hjb]_gh\\hafh`ghk\yaZg k
l_fqlh ^h[u\Zgb_ ibsb [ueh ^eyZ[hjb]_gh\ kjZ\gbl_evgh
ijhklhc aZ^Zq_cfgh]b_ kmfqZlu_]emiub hohlZgZ gbog_
lj_[m_l [hevrhcbah[j_lZl_evghklb
<hijhky\ey_lky eb ^bg]h gZklhys_c^bdhc kh[Zdhcbeb
hg ijhbkoh^bl hl ^hfZrg_c kh[ZdbihiZ\r_c \ :\kljZebx
\f_kl_ k i_j\ufb ihk_e_gpZfb\ua\Ze fgh]hkihjh\KZf y
l\_j^h m[_`^_g \ ijZ\bevghklb \lhjhc \_jkbb<kydbcdlh
ohjhrh agZdhfk nbabq_kdbfbijbagZdZfb h^hfZrgb\Zgbygb gZ
f]gh\_gb_ g_ mkhfgblky
\ lhfqlh
^bg]h ^hfZrg__
`b\hlgh_h^bqZ\r__ \lhjbqghMl\_j`^_gb_ ;j_fZ[m^lh
ijh[_`dZ ^bg]h wlh ijh[_`dZgZklhys_c ^bdhckh[Zdbg_
gZ[ex^ZxsZyky gb
m h^ghc
^hfZrg_c kh[Zdb\
dhjg_
g_\_jghwkdbfhkkdb_ kh[Zdb ]hjZa^h [hevr_q_f
^bg]h
gZihfbgZxl k\hbfb ^\b`_gbyfb \hedh\ b rZdZeh\D lhfm`_
^ey ^bg]h oZjZdl_jgu[_eu_ qmedbbeb a\_a^hqdbZ dhgqbd
o\hklZ m gbo ihqlb \k_]^Z [_eucijbq_f mjZaguo hkh[_c
wlb f_ldb jZkij_^_eyxlkyihjZaghfm hkh[_gghklvgbdh]^Z
g_
gZ[ex^ZxsZyky
m
^bdbo
`b\hlguogh
ihklhyggh
\klj_qZxsZyky m\k_o ^hfZrgbo ihjh^Y g_khfg_\Zxkvqlh \
:\kljZebx ^bg]h ijb\_aq_eh\_d bqlh ^bg]hh[hkh[eyeky hl
g_]h ihf_j_ lh]hdZd dmevlmjZZ\kljZebcp_\ j_]j_kkbjh\ZeZ
Lhl `_
kZfuc nZdlhjdhlhjuc\hafh`gh\ua\Ze wlhl
j_]j_kkf_^ebl_evghklv [hevrbgkl\Z kmfqZluob e_]dhklv
hohlu gZ gbo\_jhylghkihkh[kl\h\Ze biheghfm h^bqZgbx
Z\kljZebckdhc kh[Zdb
Fg_ ohl_ehkv khklZ\blv kh[kl\_ggh_ fg_gb_ hkmsghklb
gZlmju ^bg]h b h _]h ih\_^_gbb k ^hfZrgbfbkh[ZdZfbZ
ihlhfm y j_rbe\ujZklblv s_gdZ^bg]h m k_[y^hfZM^h[guc
kemqZc ij_^klZ\bekydh]^Z K_glZfZlv KlZkbb kZfdZ^bg]h
\ R_g[jmggkdhfahhiZjd_ aZ[_j_f_g_ebh^gh\j_f_ggh
Y dZd jZa aZkmgme
fh_]h ^bg]h \ ihjln_evdh]^Z
:glhgbmk \g_aZigh\a]eygme gZqZku b\hkdebdgme
;h`_ fhcFg_ ihjZY ^he`_g [ulv gZ ihohjhgZo
klZjbdZ <_jg_jZ: \ujZa\_ g_b^_l_"
Dhg_qghb^mLml y\^jm] khh[jZabeqlh bf_ggh wlh
\Z`gh_ ^_eh fZyqbeh \k_ \j_fy ]^_lh m f_gy \iZfylb
Ijhn_kkhj Njbp <_jg_j[ue fhbfmqbl_e_fb y iblZed g_fm
]em[hqZcr__ m\Z`_gb_ \ gZrb ^gbljm^gh gZclbq_eh\_dZ
dhlhjuc
agZe
[u
`b\hlguo
lZddZd
hg?]h madhc
ki_pbZevghklvx [ueZ ]_ji_lheh]bylh _klv hg
aZgbfZeky
Zfnb[byfb bj_ilbebyfbgh \lh `_\j_fy hg [ue\u^Zxsbfky
ahheh]hf rbjhdh]h ijhnbeyb ijbgZ^e_`Zed lhfmgug_ ihqlb
bkq_agm\r_fm lbimmq_guodhlhju_ kihkh[guk h^gh]h\a]ey^Z
magZlv ex[h_ iheaZxs__beb e_lZxs__kms_kl\h?]h wjm^bpby
[ueZ h]jhfgZ b ho\Zlu\ZeZ [md\Zevgh \k_deZkku `b\hlgh]h
fbjZOh^blv k gbf gZ wdkdmjkbb[ueh klhev`_ bgl_j_kgh
kdhev b ihmqbl_evghihlhfm qlh hg ihqlb [_adhe_[Zgbc
kjZam `_ gZau\ZeijZdlbq_kdb ex[h_`b\h_ kms_kl\hL_dlh
[u\Ze k gbf \ _]h fgh]hqbke_gguo wdki_^bpbyo\ K_\_jghc
:njbd_ b gZ ;eb`g_f <hklhd_jZkkdZau\Zeb fg_qlh nZmgm
wlbo h[eZkl_c hg agZe g_ om^_q_f nZmgm k\h_cjh^ghc
kljZgu<^h[Z\hd
ijhn_kkhj <_jg_j
k [hevrbf
mki_ohf
jZa\h^be `b\hlguo \ g_\he_b y ihemqbe hl g_]hfZkkm
k\_^_gbc hlhfdZd gm`ghkh^_j`Zlv l_jjZjbmfu
B \hl l_i_jv y
hdZaZeky \ \_kvfZ
aZljm^gbl_evghf
iheh`_gbby ohl_e hl^Zlv ihke_^gbc ^h] fh_fm ]em[hdh
ihqblZ_fhfm mqbl_exgh \ lh`_ \j_fyfg_ gm`gh[ueh dZd
fh`gh kdhj__ ^hklZ\blv ^bg]h d _]h ijb_fghc fZl_jb
\
:evl_g[_j]H^gZdh y[ue m\_j_gqlh s_ghd[m^_l kihdhcgh
kiZlv \l_iehf ]g_a^_dhlhjh_ y mkljhbe^ey g_]h mk_[y \
ihjln_e_Z ihlhfm fu hlijZ\bebkv ba R_g[jmggZijyfh gZ
deZ^[bs_Y
gZ^_yeky
aZl_jylvky
]^_gb[m^v
\ dhgp_
ijhp_kkbbgh ijhn_kkhj <_jg_j [ue ohehklydhfb ihqlbg_
bf_e jh^kl\_ggbdh\b fu
k :glhgbmkhfdZd
mq_gbdb
ihdhcgh]hdhlhjuo hg \k_]^Z hlebqZe\ugm`^_gu [uebb^lb
aZ ]jh[hf \
i_j\uo jy^ZoB
\hldh]^Z fuihegu_
bkdj_gg_]h ]hjyklhyeb i_j_^ hldjulhc fh]behc
klZjh]h
ahheh]Zba
]em[bgu fh_]h
ihjln_ey \g_aZigh
jZa^Zeky
lhgdbcijhgabl_evguc \hiev \hiev s_gdZijbau\Zxs_]h
fZlvY jZkkl_]gme ihjln_ev b kmgme \ g_]hjmdmqlh[u
mlbohfbjblv fZe_gvdh]h ^bg]hgh hg lhevdh aZ\ba`Ze_s_
ijhgabl_evg__Fg_ hklZ\Zehkv h^ghihkdhj__ kdjulvkyY
hklhjh`gh ijh[jZeky kd\hav ]mklmx lheimZ :glhgbmkdZd
gZklhysbc ^jm]ihke_^h\Ze aZ fghcIh^Z\b\ kf_ohg
kdZaZe
Wlh hkdhj[behqm\kl\Z \k_odlh lZfijbkmlkl\h\Ze
djhf_ klZjbdZ <_jg_jZB gZ ]eZaZo mg_]h ihdZaZebkv
ke_au
B dZd agZlv"<hafh`ghba \k_odlh klhyem fh]beu
[eb`_ \k_o klZjhfmijhn_kkhjm [uebfu kfZe_gvdbf ^bg]h\
ihjln_e_
Ijb_oZ\ \ :evl_g[_j] k fhbf ihjln_e_cy kjZam `_
ijhr_e gZ
l_jjZkmdhlhjZy
gZ \j_fy
[ueZ hl^ZgZ
\
jZkihjy`_gb_
K_glub
ij_ih^g_k
_c
Z\kljZebckdh]h
dmdmrhgdZ>bg]h l_f\j_f_g_f mki_e hlqZygghijh]heh^Zlvky
b l_i_jvg_ij_ju\gh kdmebe bih\ba]b\ZeK_glZ mkeurZeZ _]h
_s_ ba^Zeb bgZijZ\beZkv fg_gZ\klj_qmlj_\h`gh gZ\hkljb\
mrbKh[Zdb \b^yl ^h\hevgh iehoh^Z K_glZ [ueZ bg_
gZklhevdh mfgZqlh[u khh[jZablvqlh __ fZeurbgZ f_kl_
@Zeh[gu_ \hieb^hghkb\rb_ky ba ihjln_eyjZa[m^beb \g_c
fZl_jbgkdb_ bgklbgdlub hgZ m`_kqblZeZ g_\b^bfh]hs_gdZ
k\hbf
Y ba\e_d ^bg]h gZ k\_l b iheh`be ihkj_^b l_jjZku
gZ^_ykvqlh hgZ kZfZ mg_k_l _]h dk_[_ \ysbd?keb \u
ohlbl_qlh[u fe_dhiblZxsZy fZlv ijbgyeZ qm`h]h fZeurZ
emqr_ \k_]h ih^eh`blv _]h _c i_j_^ eh]h\hfb \gZb[he__
[_kihfhsghf \b^_< wlhf
kemqZ_ dhihrZs__ky
kms_kl\h
klbfmebjm_l
fZl_jbgkdbc
bgklbgdl
]hjZa^h
kbevg__b
ijb_fgZy fZlv kdhj__\k_]h hklhjh`ghmg_k_l dk_[_ kbjhlm
ih^[jhr_ggh]h kgZjm`b_keb `_ hgZ h[gZjm`bl _]h kj_^b
k\hbo fZeur_clh \hkijbf_l
dZd qm`ZdZ
b kt_kl<
hij_^_e_gghc f_j_ lZdh_ih\_^_gb_ ihgylghb kq_eh\_q_kdhc
lhqdb aj_gby
Gh ohly fZeurb mg_k_g\ eh]h\hwlh _s_g_ hagZqZ_l
mkugh\e_gbyM gbarbo fe_dhiblZxsbo\jh^_ djukb fur_c
qm`hc ^_l_gure_`Zsbc m ]g_a^Zg_j_^dh \uau\Z_lj_Zdpbx
i_j_lZkdb\Zgbyih iha`_\ ]g_a^_hg hihagZ_lkydZd qm`Zd
b
[_a`Zehklgh
ih`bjZ_lky?s_
[he__
we_f_glZjgh
j_ne_dlhjghc bk lhqdb
aj_gby q_eh\_dZ_s_
f_g__
ihke_^h\Zl_evghc
ij_^klZ\ey_lky
lZ
nhjfZ
fZl_jbgkdhc
j_Zdpbb ijboh^Z gZ ihfhsvdhlhjZy kms_kl\m_l m fgh]bo
ilbpIj_^iheh`bf
^ey ijbf_jZqlh i_]ZgdZ\_^msZy
\u\h^hdm\b^bl \jmdZo wdki_jbf_glZlhjZgZ^ju\gh ibsZs_]h
ml_gdZ djyd\uI_]ZgdZ g_f_^e_ggh km^b\bl_evguf fm`_kl\hf
[jhkblky gZ q_eh\_dZ b [md\Zevgh \uj\_l ml_gdZ ba _]h
iZevp_\H^gZdh
lZdh_
ijhlb\hj_qb\h_
ih\_^_gb_ hq_gv
ijhklhijbau\guc djbd ml_gdZdjyd\u ihqlbg_ hlebqZ_lky
hl ibkdZfheh^uo i_]Zghdb hgqbklh j_ne_dlhjgh \uau\Z_lm
fZl_jbi_]Zgdb klj_fe_gb_ ijbclb ml_gdm gZihfhsvH^gZdh
imrhd il_gph\djyd\u aZf_lgh hlebqZ_lkyhl imrdZi_]ZghdZ
ihlhfm kiZk_gguc [ueh ml_ghd \hkijbgbfZ_lky jy^hf k __
kh[kl\_ggufb mlylZfb dZdqm`Zdb _]h \b^ih[m`^Z_l \g_c
j_Zdpbx aZsblu \u\h^dZ lZd`_ qbklh j_ne_dlhjgmxB
fZe_gvdZy djyd\u bail_gpZdhlhjh]h gZ^h kiZklb\g_aZigh
ij_\jZsZ_lky \h\jZ]Zdhlhjh]h g_h[oh^bfhijh]gZlv>Z`_ m
klhev
\ukhdhjZa\blh]h
\
ikbobq_kdhf
hlghr_gbb
fe_dhiblZxs_]hdZd kh[ZdZe_]dh fh`_l\hagbdgmlv lZdhc`_
\gmlj_ggbc
dhgnebdl\ua\Zgguc
ijhlb\hiheh`gufb
ih[m`^_gbyfb j_ne_dlhjgh]hihjy^dZ
FZe_gvdbc ^bg]h ihkdmeb\Zeb K_glZ dbgmeZkvd g_fm
y\gh
gZf_j_\Zykv
mg_klb
_]h
\
ysbdHgZ ^Z`_ g_
hklZgh\beZkv h[gxoZlv _]hqlh[u m[_^blvkyqlh i_j_^g_c
^_ckl\bl_evgh __ kh[kl\_ggucs_ghd<f_klh wlh]h hgZkjZam
`_ gZ]gmeZkv gZ^ieZqmsbf fZeurhfb rbjhdhhldjueZ iZklv
]hlh\ykv mo\Zlblv _]h^ey i_j_ghkZkh[Zdb \wlbo kemqZyo
aZ[bjZxl s_gdZ lZd ]em[hdh \ iZklvqlh hghdZau\Z_lky
ihaZ^b deudh\dhlhju_ fh]eb [u _]h ihjZgblvB \wlhl
fhf_gl \ gha^jb K_glu m^Zjbe qm`hc ^bdbcaZiZodhlhjuc
^bg]h ijb\_a kkh[hc baahhiZjdZHgZ \ m`Zk_hlijygmeZ b
ijb wlhf\u^hogmeZ \ha^mo kdZdbflh dhrZqvbfrbi_gb_f gb
^hgb ihke_ fg_ g_ ijboh^behkv keurZlvqlh[u kh[Zdb
bkimkdZeb
ih^h[guc
a\mdH^gZdh
aZl_f
hgZ
kgh\Z
gZijZ\beZkv d s_gdmhklhjh`gh ijbgxob\ZykvIjhreh
g_
f_gvr_ fbgmluij_`^_ q_f hgZdhkgmeZkv _]hghkhfGh ihke_
wlh]h K_glZ \g_aZigh ijbgyeZkv h`_klhq_ggh\uebau\Zlv _]h
rdmjdm fg_ [ueb
ohjhrh agZdhfu wlb
ijh^he`bl_evgu_
ih^kZku\Zxsb_
^\b`_gby
__
yaudZijb
h[uqguo
h[klhyl_evkl\Zo
kh[ZdZ
kebau\Z_l
lZdbf
h[jZahf
k
gh\hjh`^_ggh]h s_gdZh[hehqdm ieh^gh]himaujy
>ey lh]h qlh[u h[tykgblv __ ih\_^_gb_y ^he`_g[m^m
g_kdhevdh hl\e_qvky< l_o kemqZyodh]^Z fe_dhiblZxsb_
fZl_jb ih_^Zxl k\hbo gh\hjh`^_gguo ^_l_gur_cwlh y\e_gb_
gZ[ex^Z_lky m ^hfZrgbo `b\hlguogZijbf_j m k\bg_c
b
djhebdh\Z bgh]^Z b \ iblhfgbdZo]^_ jZa\h^ylimrguo
a\_j_cijbqbgZ h[uqghaZdexqZ_lky \dZdhflh ^_n_dl_l_o
j_Zdpbcdhlhju_ ijb\h^yl d m^Ze_gbx ieh^ghch[hehqdbZ
lZd`_ ieZp_glu b d i_j_]juaZgbx imih\bgu?^\Z ^_l_gur
jh^blkydZd
fZlv
gZqbgZ_l
ih^kZku\Zxsbfbeb`msbfb
^\b`_gbyfb
ih^p_ieylv
kdeZ^dm
ieh^ghc
h[hehqdb lZdbf
h[jZahfqlh[u aZo\Zlblv__ j_apZfbb ZddmjZlghijhdmkblv
Ijb wlhfghk __kfhjsb\Z_lkyZ j_apuhkdZeb\Zxlky ijbf_jgh
lZd `_dZd ijb \udmku\ZgbbgZk_dhfuodh]^Z kh[ZdZ
iulZykv ba[Z\blvky hl iZjZablh\`m_l kh[kl\_ggmxdh`m \
gZ^_`^_ ijbo\Zlblv ijb wlhf h^gh]h ba k\hbofmqbl_e_c
Ihke_ lh]h dZdieh^gZy h[hehqdZlZdbf h[jZahf\kdju\Z_lky
fZlv \k_]em[`_ b]em[`_ \kZku\Z_l __\ iZklv bihkl_i_ggh
aZ]eZlu\Z_l^Zevr_ gZklmiZ_lq_j_a ieZp_glub kh_^bg_gghc k
g_c qZklb imih\bguGZ wlhfwlZi_ ihdmku\Zgb_b \kZku\Zgb_
aZf_^eyxlky b klZgh\ylky[he__ hklhjh`gufbihdZgZdhg_p
k\h[h^guc dhg_pimih\bgu g_hldjmlblkydZd dhgqbdkhkbkdb
b g_ [m^_l \ukhkZg ^hkmoZLmldhg_qghhi_jZpby ^he`gZ
ij_djZlblkyD g_kqZklvxm ^hfZrgbo`b\hlguo ijhp_kkqZklh
gZ wlhf g_ hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky< lZdhf kemqZ_ g_
lhevdh
ijh]eZlu\Z_lky
imih\bgZgh
b
jZkiZju\Z_lky
[jxrdh
gh\hjh`^_ggh]h \h[eZklb imidZ
M f_gy [ueZ djhevqboZdhlhjZy ijh^he`ZeZ\uebau\Zgb_
^h l_oihjihdZ g_kt_^ZeZ i_q_gvk\h_]h ^_l_gurZN_jf_ju
b djhebdh\h^u agZxlqlh k\bghfZld_beb djhevqbo_dhlhjZy
bf__l h[udgh\_gb_ kt_^Zlv k\hc
ijbieh^fh`gh \
wlhf
\hkij_iylkl\h\Zlv_keb
kjZam
`_
aZ[jZlv
m
g__
gh\hjh`^_gguo ^_l_gur_c b ih^eh`blv bo _c hqbs_ggufb b
kmobfb g_kdhevdh
qZkh\ kimklydh]^Z m
g__
m]Zkg_l
ihlj_[ghklv ih_^Zlv ieh^gmxh[hehqdm bieZp_glmYkghqlh
wlb `b\hlgu_g_kfhljy gZ ih^h[gh_ hldehg_gb_h[eZ^Zxl
Z[khexlgh
ghjfZevgufb
fZl_jbgkdbfb
bgklbgdlZfb>jm]b_
kZfdb kf \iheg_ ghjfZevguf ih\_^_gb_fijbgZ^e_`Zsb_
d
kZfuf jZaghh[jZaguf \b^Zf fe_dhiblZxsboba[Z\eyxlky
hl
f_jl\uo beb [hevguo gh\hjh`^_gguoih_^Zy bo>\b`_gby
dhlhju_ hgb ijh^_eu\Zxllhqgh kh\iZ^Zxl kl_fbd dZdbf
hgb ijb[_]Zxlih_^Zy ieh^gmx
h[hehqdm b ieZp_glmb
gZqbgZxl hgb_kl_kl\_gghk imidZ
Fg_ dZdlh ^h\_ehkvgZ[ex^Zlv qj_a\uqZcghyjdbc ijbf_j
lZdh]h ih\_^_gby \ R_g[jmggkdhf ahhiZjd_]^_ `beZq_lZ
y]mZjh\ hjZg`_\h`_eluc
kZf_p b \_ebdhe_igZy
q_jgZy
kZfdZdhlhjZy qmlv eb g_ _`_]h^gh ijbghkbeZij_djZkguo
a^hjh\uo dhlyllZdbo `_q_jguodZd hgZkZfZ< lhf]h^m
h dhlhjhf b^_l j_qvm g__ jh^bekylhevdh h^bgdhl_ghd
obeuc aZfhjurL_f g_ f_g__hg ^hlygme^h ^\mo f_kyp_\
DZd jZa \ lh \j_fy y aZ]eygmed ijhn_kkhjm:glhgbmkmb
dh]^Z fuijh]meb\Zykv ih ahhiZjdmih^hreb d
de_ldZf
k djmigufb obsgbdZfbhg kdZaZe fg_qlh y]mZj_ghd
\
ihke_^g__ \j_fy gZqZe obj_lv b \jy^ eb \u`b\_l< wlm
fbgmlm fZlv dZd jZa mfu\ZeZ_]hlh _klv\uebau\ZeZ k
]heh\u ^h gh]<hae_ de_ldb klhyeZom^h`gbpZihklhyggZy
ihk_lbl_evgbpZ ahhiZjdZhq_gv ex[b\rZy
`b\hlguoHgZ
kdZaZeZqlh __ hq_gv ljh]Z_l aZ[hleb\hklvk dZdhcwlZ
[hevrZy dhrdZ moZ`b\Z_l aZ
k\hbf [hevguf fZeurhfGh
:glhgbmk i_qZevghihdZqZe ]heh\hcb ih\_jgmekydh fg_
<hijhk gZ wdaZf_g_ki_pbZebklm ih ih\_^_gbx`b\hlguo
qlh ijhbkoh^blk_cqZk kkZfdhc y]mZjZ"
Y kjZam ihgyegZ
qlh hg gZf_dZe<
\uebau\Zgbb
qm\kl\h\ZeZkv g_j\gZy lhjhieb\hklvb \g_f ijhkdZevau\ZeZ
l_g^_gpby d ih^kZku\Zgbxdjhf_ lh]hy aZf_lbedZd fZlv
^\Z`^u ih^kh\u\ZeZ ghkih^ [jxoh^_l_gurZf_lykv yaudhf\
imihdIhwlhfm yhl\_lbe
GZqbgZ_lky dhgnebdlf_`^m j_Zdpb_cmoh^Z aZihf_lhf b
klj_fe_gb_f kh`jZlvf_jl\h]h ^_l_gurZ
>h[jhk_j^_qgZy om^h`gbdZ hldZaZeZkv wlhfmih\_jblvgh
fhc ^jm]kh]eZkgh db\gmebd g_kqZklvxy hdZaZeky ijZ\
gZmljh fZe_gvdbcy]mZj bkq_a[_kke_^ghFZlv kt_eZ_]h
<hl h q_f y \kihfgbe]ey^ydZd K_glZ \uebau\Z_l
fZe_gvdh]h ^bg]hb g_ hrb[ky \ k\h_faZdexq_gbbQ_j_a
fbgmlm^jm]mx hgZ ih^kmgmeZghk ih^s_gdZ bi_j_dZlbeZ _]h
gZ kibgmAZl_f hgZ ijbgyeZkv lsZl_evgh \uebau\Zlv _]h
imihd b \kdhj_m`_ gZqZeZijbo\Zlu\Zlv am[Zfbdh`m [jxrdZ
>bg]h \a\ba]gme b ]jhfdh aZkdmebeKgh\Z K_glZ \m`Zk_
hlijygmeZkeh\gh ih^mfZ\Y k^_eZeZfZeurm [hevgh;ueh
ykghqlh j_Zdpby moh^Z aZ ihf_lhf`Zehklv\ua\ZggZy
\ba]hf\gh\v \ayeZ \_joK_glZ j_rbl_evgh ihlygmeZkvd
]heh\_ s_gdZkeh\gh gZf_j_\Zykv mg_klb _]h \ ysbdgh
dh]^Z hldjueZ iZklvqlh[u \aylv _]hhgZ \gh\vhsmlbeZ
kljZggucg_agZdhfuc aZiZob hiylvijbgyeZkv lhjhieb\hkh
\k_f [hevrbf
`Zjhf \uebau\Zlv
^bg]hihdZ
\gh\v
g_
msbigmeZ _]h aZ`b\hlHg hiylv \a\ba]gmehl [hebb hgZ
hiylv hlkdhqbeZ \ m`Zk_Ihlhf \gh\v ih^hreZd g_fmgh
^\b`_gby __
klZeb _s_
lhjhieb\__yaud
jZ[hlZe
_s_
hlqZygg__Z ijhlb\hiheh`gu_ih[m`^_gby kf_gyebkv_s_ qZs_
hgZ gbdZdg_ fh]eZj_rblvmg_klb eb_c kbjhlmd k_[_ beb
kt_klv _]hdZd
g_`_eZggh]h b g_ijZ\bevgh
iZogms_]h
ih^db^urZE_]dh [ueh aZf_lblvdZdb_ \gmlj_ggb_fmq_gby
bkiulu\Z_l K_glZb \kdhj_ hgZg_ \u^_j`ZeZijbk_\ i_j_^
^bg]h gZaZ^gb_ eZiuhgZ ih^gyeZ ghkd g_[m bbaebeZ k\h_
kfyl_gb_ \ ^he]hf \heqv_f \h_Lml y aZ[jZe g_lhevdh
^bg]hgh b\k_o s_gylK_gluihkZ^be \ dZjlhggmxdhjh[dm
\hae_ dmohgghc ieblu b hklZ\be lZf gZ ghqvqlh[u hgb
ohjhr_gvdh ihl_jebkv ^jm] h ^jm]Zi_j_f_rZ\ \k_aZiZob
Dh]^Z gZke_^mxs__ mljhy hlg_kK_gl_ s_gylhgZ ijbgyeZ bo
k g_dhlhjuf khfg_gb_f b ijbreZ \kbevgh_ \ha[m`^_gb_Gh
\kdhj_ hgZ i_j_lZkdZeZbo \dhgmjmaZo\Zlb\ b fZe_gvdh]h
^bg]hijbq_f g_ i_j\uf b g_ ihke_^gbfZ kj_^bijhqbo
H^gZdh iha`_hgZ jZkihagZeZ\ g_fqm`ZdZ bohly g_ \u]gZeZ
b ^Z`_\kdZjfeb\ZeZ \f_kl_ khk\hbfb ^_lvfbdZdlh mdmkbeZ
_]h aZ moh k lZdhc k\bj_ihklvxqlh moh wlh gZ\k_]^Z
hklZehkv bkdZe_q_ggufb `Zeh[ghk\bkZeh gZ[hd
D:D:Y @:EHKLVQLH HG:G? =H<HJBL
<?>V HG:IHGBF:?L D:@>H?KEH<H
DZd \i_qZlebl_evgZgZlmjZ dheeb
>hklZlhqgh [u\Z_lkeh\Zqlh[u
<haebdh\Ze hgbeb ijbmgue
MMhlkhg
>hfZrgb_ `b\hlgu_ hlgx^v g_ f_g__ mfguq_f bo^bdb_
ij_^dbdZd wlh bgh]^ZkqblZxl;_kkihjghm fgh]boba gbo
hj]Zgu qm\kl\ \ ba\_klghc kl_i_gb klZebjZ[hlZlv om`_Z
g_dhlhju_ bgklbgdlu ijblmibebkvGh \_^vlh `_hlghkblky b
d q_eh\_dmZ q_eh\_d \ha\ukbekygZ^ `b\hlgufbg_ \hij_db
lZdhc mljZl_Z [eZ]h^Zjy _cKgb`_gb_ jhebbgklbgdlh\
bkq_agh\_gb_ `_kldbo jZfhddhlhjufb hij_^_ey_lkyih\_^_gb_
[hevrbgkl\Z `b\hlguo[ueb g_h[oh^bfhc ij_^ihkuedhc
^ey
ihy\e_gby hkh[hcqbklh
q_eh\_q_kdhc k\h[h^u
^_ckl\bc
Ih^h[guf `_
h[jZahf b
m ^hfZrgbo
`b\hlguo
m]ZkZgb_
g_dhlhjuo \jh`^_gguo nhjfih\_^_gby hagZqZ_lg_ mf_gvr_gb_
kihkh[ghklb d jZpbhgZevguf
^_ckl\byfZ gh\mx
kl_i_gv
k\h[h^u?s_ \ ]h^m QHMZclf_g kdZaZeIh^h[gu_
^_n_dlu bgklbgdlZ kZfbih k_[__s_ g_bgl_ee_dlgh hgb
lZ jZkiZogmlZy ^\_jvq_j_a dhlhjmx fh`_l \hclb\_ebdbc
mqbl_ev Hiulijbghky kkh[hc \k_qm^_kZ bgl_ee_dlZ
<ujZabl_evgu_ ^\b`_gby b \uau\Z_fu_ bfbj_Zdpbb lZd`_
ijbgZ^e_`Zl
d
bgklbgdlb\gufgZke_^kl\_gguf
nhjfZf
ih\_^_gbyoZjZdl_jguf ^ey ^Zggh]h\b^Z<k_qlh `b\hlgu_
\_^msb_ ]jmiih\hc h[jZa `bagb\jh^_ ]Zehdk_juo ]mk_c
beb obsgbdh\
k_f_ckl\Z kh[Zqvbobf_xl kdZaZlv
^jm]
^jm]mhlghkblky
bkdexqbl_evgh
d
h[eZklb
wlbo
\aZbfhk\yaZgguo \b^hki_pbnbq_kdbo nhjf ^_ckl\bcb j_Zdpbc
JR_gd_ev
bamqbe
\ujZabl_evgu_
^\b`_gby
m
\hedh\ b
ijhZgZebabjh\Ze bo agZq_gb_?keb fu kjZ\gbf
keh\Zjv
kb]gZeh\dhlhjuf jZkiheZ]Z_l \hed ^ey h[s_gby k
k_[_
ih^h[gufbb khhl\_lkl\mxsb_
kb]gZeu m gZrbo
^hfZrgbo
kh[Zdfu h[gZjm`bf l_ `_ ijbagZdbmijhs_gby bklbjZgby
dZdb_
gZoh^bf
b
\h
fgh]bo
^jm]bo
\jh`^_gguo
\b^hki_pbnbq_kdbo
nhjfZo
ih\_^_gby<hafh`ghlZdb_
^\b`_gby f_g__ q_ldh\ujZ`_gu ihj kjZ\g_gbx k\hedhfm`_
m rZdZeh\ wlhl \hijhkihdZ hklZ_lkyhldjulufgh gbq_]h
m^b\bl_evgh]h \ wlhf g_
[ueh [uihkdhevdm m
\hedh\
kljmdlmjZ khh[s_kl\Zg_khfg_gghhlebqZ_lky ]hjZa^h[he__
\ukhdbf mjh\g_f jZa\blbyq_f m rZdZeh\M kh[Zd\heqv_c
djh\blZdbo dZd qZmqZmfh`gh h[gZjm`blv \k_
nhjfu
\ujZ`_gby wfhpbck\hckl\_ggu_ \hedZfaZ bkdexq_gb_fl_o
kb]gZeh\dhlhju_ \ujZ`Zxlky
^\b`_gbyfb beb
iheh`_gb_f
o\hklZO\hkl qZmqZm aZ\_jgml [ZjZgdhcb hgbnbabq_kdb g_
\ khklhygbbijh^_eu\Zlv wlb^\b`_gbygh l_fg_ f_g__m gbo
ba
ihdhe_gby
\
ihdhe_gb_
i_j_^Z_lky
gZke_^kl\_ggZy
l_g^_gpby ihevah\Zlvky ki_pbnbq_kdb \heqvbfb o\hklh\ufb
kb]gZeZfb<k_ fhb ihemdjh\dbdhlhju_ mgZke_^h\Zeb hl
g_f_pdbo
h\qZjhd
ghjfZevguc
aZ^
^bdh]h
h[jZapZ
ijh^_eu\Zxl \k_ lbibqgu_ \heqvb ^\b`_gby o\hklhfdZdb_
gbdh]^Z g_ gZ[ex^Zxlky m qbklhihjh^guog_f_pdbo h\qZjhdb
^jm]bo kh[Zdk [hevr_cbeb f_gvr_c^hahc rZdZev_cdjh\b
Ih
\jh`^_gguf
\ujZabl_evguf
^\b`_gbyfhkZgd_
b
ihklZgh\d_ o\hklZ g_dhlhju_ ba fhbo kh[Zd klhyld \hedm
]hjZa^h [eb`_q_f hklZevgu_ _\jhi_ckdb_ ihjh^uGh ^Z`_
fhb kh[Zdb \ wlhf hlghr_gbb ^Ze_dh mklmiZxl \hedmbo
fbfbdZ f_g__ q_ldh \ujZ`_gZq_f m \hedZohly ^jm]bf
kh[ZdZf ^h gbo ^Ze_dhHiulghfm ex[bl_exrZdZevbo kh[Zd
wlh ml\_j`^_gb_ fh`_l ihdZaZlvky iZjZ^hdkZevguflZd dZd
hg[_a khfg_gbyih^mfZ_l h[h[s_c kihkh[ghklb\ujZ`_gby
jZaebqguo wfhpbcgh ylh lml ]h\hjxlhevdh h\jh`^_gguo
^\b`_gbyoMdZaZgguc \ur_ ijbgpbik\h^ysbcky dlhfmqlh
hkeZ[e_gb_ \jh`^_gguo kl_j_hlbih\hldju\Z_l gh\u_]hjbahglu
^ey \hevgh]h bah[j_l_gbynhjf ih\_^_gbyjZkrbjyxsbo
\hafh`ghklb ijbkihkh[e_gbygb]^_ g_ ijhy\ey_lkylZd ykgh
dZd \ kihkh[ghklb \ujZ`Zlv wfhpbbQZmqZm ihqlblZd `_
dZd \hedh]jZgbq_gu ebrv fbfbdhck ihfhsvxdhlhjhc ^bdb_
`b\hlgu_ ^_fhgkljbjmxl ^jm] ^jm]m qm\kl\Z \jh^_
aeh[u
ihdhjghklb
beb
jZ^hklbZ
wlb
fur_qgu_
^\b`_gby
hlghkbl_evgh fZehaZf_lgu\_^v hgbijbkihkh[e_gu dhkljhfm
j_Z]bjh\Zgbxdhlhjh_
k\hckl\_ggh
^bdbf ij_^klZ\bl_eyf
^Zggh]h \b^ZQ_eh\_d \ agZqbl_evghckl_i_gb mljZlbe wlm
kihkh[ghklvlZd dZd jZkiheZ]Z_l ohly bf_g__ lhgdbfgh
aZlh gZfgh]h [he__ q_ldbf
kj_^kl\hf h[s_gby j_qvx
Ihkdhevdm m q_eh\_dZ_klv ^Zjkeh\Z_fm m`_ g_lj_[m_lky
qblZlv ih ]eZaZf k\hbo [eb`gbo fZe_crb_ baf_g_gby \bo
gZkljh_gbb;hevrbgkl\m ex^_cdZ`_lkyqlh fbfbdZ `b\hlguo
djZcg_ kdm^gZh^gZdh \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb^_eh h[klhbldZd
jZa gZh[hjhlL_dlh
ijb\ud d rZdZevbf kh[ZdZfg_
ihgbfZxl qZmqZmlhqgh lZd `_ebpZ `bl_e_c<hklhqghc :abb
dZ`mlky _\jhi_cpZf g_ijhgbpZ_fufbH^gZdh gZlj_gbjh\Zgguc
]eZa kihkh[_g ijhqblZlv ih fhj^_ k^_j`Zggh]h \hedZ beb
qZmqZm gbqmlvg_ f_gvr_q_f gZ[ex^Zy \ujZabl_evgmxfbfbdm
rZdZevbo kh[ZdIjZ\^Zihke_^gb_ klhylgZ [he__ \ukhdhf
bgl_ee_dlmZevghf mjh\g_
bo fbfbq_kdb_ ^\b`_gbyf_gvr_
aZ\bkyl hl \jh`^_gguo nZdlhjh\Hgb ih [hevr_c
qZklb
\umq_guZ
bgh]^Z b
aZgh\h bah[j_l_gu
dZ`^hc ^Zgghc
kh[ZdhcKh[ZdZ deZ^_l
]heh\m gZ dhe_gh ohaybgZ
^ey
\ujZ`_gby k\h_c ex[\bg_ ih\_e_gbx `_kldh]hbgklbgdlZZ
ihlhfm qlh lZdh_ ^\b`_gb_ ]hjZa^h [eb`_ d q_eh\_q_kdhc
j_qbq_f yaudijb ihfhsb dhlhjh]h h[jZsZxlky^jm] k
^jm]hf ^bdb_`b\hlgu_
?s_ [eb`_d ^Zjm j_qbklhbl bkihevah\Zgb_^ey \ujZ`_gby
qm\kl\Z
dZdh]hlh
aZmq_ggh]h
^_ckl\bygZijbf_j
ijhly]b\Zgb_ eZiuFgh]b_ kh[Zdbh[mq_ggu_ ^Z\Zlv eZim
ijhly]b\Zxl __ ohaybgm \ hij_^_e_gguokblmZpbyo kdZ`_f
`_eZy mfbehklb\blv_]h bijhky ijhs_gb_Dlh g_\b^_edZd
ijh\bgb\rbcky i_k lbohgvdh ih^iheaZ_l d ohaybgmkZ^blky
i_j_^ gbfijb`Z\ mrb d aZluedmb kqj_a\uqZcghc fbghc
g_mdex`_ iulZ_lky ih^Zlv _fm eZimM f_gy [ueagZdhfuc
im^_evdhlhjuc ih^Z\ZeeZim g_lhevdh ex^yfgh b^jm]bf
kh[ZdZfijZ\^Zwlh j_^qZcr__ bkdexq_gb_lZd dZd ijb
jZa]h\hjZok k_[_ih^h[gufb ^Z`_kh[ZdbjZkiheZ]Zxsb_ \
h[s_gbb k
ohaybghf [h]Zluf
j_i_jlmZjhf
bg^b\b^mZevguo
kj_^kl\
\ujZ`_gbyihevamxlky
bkdexqbl_evgh \jh`^_gghc
fbfbdhc k\hbo^bdbo ij_^dh\< p_ehffh`gh kdZaZlvqlh q_f
kbevg__ jZa\blZ
m kh[Zdb
kihkh[ghklv d
g_aZ\bkbfuf
[eZ]hijbh[j_l_gguf beb k\h[h^gh bah[j_lZ_fufkj_^kl\Zf
\ujZ`_gby wfhpbcl_f \ f_gvr_ckl_i_gb khojZgy_lkym g__
\b^hki_pbnbq_kdZy fbfbdZoZjZdl_jgZy ^ey ^bdbonhjfLZd
gZb[he__ h^hfZrg_ggu_ kh[Zdb\ kj_^g_fgZb[he__ k\h[h^gub
]b[db \ k\h_f ih\_^_gbbohly bg^b\b^mZevgu_kihkh[ghklb
b]jZxl lmlagZqbl_evgmx jhev
Hq_gv mfgZy kh[ZdZih lbim ijb[eb`ZxsZyky d ^bdhc
nhjf_fh`_l ijb hij_^_e_gguo h[klhyl_evkl\Zo
bah[j_klb
[he__ ^hoh^qb\uc b keh`guc kihkh[ \ujZ`_gbylh]hqlh _c
gm`gh khh[sblvq_f kh[ZdZf_g__ kdh\ZggZy
\ k\h_f
ih\_^_gbb bgklbgdlZfbgh aZlh g_lZdZy mfgZyHlkmlkl\b_
bgklbgdlZ wlh ^\_jvjZkiZogmlZy i_j_^bgl_ee_dlhfgh
hlgx^v g_kZf bgl_ee_dl
<k_qlh lml[ueh kdZaZghh kihkh[ghklbkh[Zdb \ujZ`Zlv
k\hb qm\kl\Zih hlghr_gbx dq_eh\_dm\ _s_ [hevr_ckl_i_gb
hlghkblky d __ kihkh[ghklb ihgbfZlv q_eh\_q_kdb_`_klu b
j_qvFh`gh g_ khfg_\Zlvkyqlh l_ hohlgbdbdhlhju_
i_j\ufb \ bklhjbbq_eh\_q_kl\Z mklZgh\bebdhglZdl k^bdbfb
kh[ZdZfbmf_eb ]hjZa^hlhgvr_ jZa[bjZlvky\ \ujZabl_evguo
^\b`_gbyo `b\hlgh]hq_f gug_rgb_ h[blZl_eb ]hjh^h\<
dZdhclh f_j_ wlh [ueh boijhn_kkbhgZevguf dZq_kl\hflZd
dZd hohlgbd dZf_ggh]h\_dZg_ mf_\rbc jZah[jZlvfbjgh eb
gZkljh_g i_s_jguc
f_^\_^v beb
jZa^jZ`_g_kl_kl\_ggh
gbdm^Z g_ ]h^bekyM q_eh\_dZ wlZ kihkh[ghklv g_ [ueZ
bgklbgdlb\ghcZ ij_^klZ\eyeZ
kh[hc aZf_qZl_evguc
ieh^
h[mq_gbyjZa\blb_ wlhc kihkh[ghklb[ueh ih^ebgguf ih^\b]hf
b g_f_gvr_]h ih^\b]Zfu lj_[m_fhl kh[Zdbh`b^Zyqlh
hgZ [m^_l ihgbfZlv q_eh\_q_kdmx fbfbdmb j_qv<jh`^_ggZy
kihkh[ghklv `b\hlgh]h ihgbfZlv \ujZabl_evgu_ ^\b`_gby
b
a\mdb jZkijhkljZgy_lky lhevdhgZ [ebadhjh^kl\_ggu_\b^ub
g_hiulgZy kh[ZdZ g_ ihgbfZ_l ^Z`_ fbfbdZ ij_^klZ\bl_e_c
k_f_ckl\Z dhrZqvboG_h[oh^bfh ihfgblv h[ wlhfqlh[u \
^he`ghc f_j_ hp_gblvgZkdhevdh [ebadZ dih^ebgghfm qm^m
kihkh[ghklv
kh[Zdb
jZah[jZlvky
\
q_eh\_q_kdhc fZg_j_
\ujZ`_gby wfhpbc
DZd gb ex[ex y \heqvbo kh[Zd \hh[s_ b qZmqZm
\
qZklghklby m[_`^_gqlh [he__h^hfZrg_ggu_ rZdZeu\ p_ehf
ihgbfZxl qm\kl\Z k\hboohay_\ lhgvr_b emqr_Fhy g_f_pdZy
h\qZjdZ LblZg_kjZ\g_ggh ij_\hkoh^beZ\ wlhf hlghr_gbb\k_o
k\hbo \heqvbo ihlhfdh\lZd dZd hgZ kjZamihgbfZeZdlh
fg_ gjZ\blkyZ dlhg_l
Kj_^b
fhbo
kh[Zd
kf_rZgghc
ihjh^u
y
g_baf_ggh
ij_^ihqblZe l_odhlhju_ mgZke_^h\Zeb wlmqmldhklvKlZkb
gZijbf_jj_Z]bjh\ZeZ gZex[u_ ijbagZdbfh_]h g_a^hjh\vyb
lj_\h`beZkvg_ lhevdh dh]^Z m f_gy [he_eZ]heh\Z beby
dZreyegh bdh]^Z y ijhklh[u\Ze \^mjghf gZkljh_gbbK\h_
qm\kl\h hgZ\ujZ`ZeZ l_fqlh mf_jyeZh[uqgmx [hcdmx jukpm
k ijblborbf\b^hf reZkljh]h m fh_cgh]blh b^_eh gZ f_gy
ih]ey^u\ZeZ bklhbeh fg_ hklZgh\blkyijb`bfZeZkv ie_qhf
d fh_fmdhe_gmBgl_j_kghqlh hgZ \_eZk_[y lhqgh lZd`_
dh]^Z fg_ kemqZehkv oe_[gmlv ebrg_]hb fhy
[he_agv
\uau\ZeZ m g__ lZdmx lj_\h]mqlh __lhkdeb\h_ \heg_gb_
gZ\_jgh_ihf_rZeh [ufg_ klZlvivygbp_c^Z`_ _keb [u\h
fg_
ijh[m^beZkv
lZdZy
gZdehgghklvOhly
fhb kh[Zdb
[eZ]h^Zjy ijhbkoh`^_gbx hlg_f_pdhc h\qZjdb\ agZqbl_evghc
f_j_ h[eZ^Zxl
kihkh[ghklvx ihgbfZlv
ex^_c b
\ujZ`Zlv
kh[kl\_ggu_ wfhpbbg_l gb fZe_cr_]h khfg_gbyqlh wlb
kihkh[ghklb g_kjZ\gbfh [hevr_ jZa\blu m g_dhlhjuokbevgh
h^hfZrg_gguo rZdZevbokh[ZdBkoh^y bafh_]h ebqgh]hhiulZ
iZevfm i_j\_gkl\Z \ wlhf hlghr_gbb y hl^Ze [u im^_ex
kijZ\_^eb\h keZ\ys_fmky khh[jZabl_evghklvxgZ \lhjh_f_klh
y ihklZ\be [u g_f_pdmx
h\qZjdmg_dhlhjuo ibgq_jh\
b
[hevrh]h rgZmp_jZh^gZdhgZ fhc \dmk\k_ wlbkh[Zdb
kebrdhf m` mljZlbeb k\hx i_j\h[ulgmx obsgmxijbjh^mHgb
gZklhevdh hq_eh\_q_guqlh
bf g_ o\ZlZ_l
hqZjh\Zgby
_kl_kl\_gghklbdhlhjh_ k\hckl\_gghfhbf ^bdbf\hedZf
G_\_jgh ^mfZlv[m^lh kh[Zdb ihgbfZxllhevdh bglhgZpbx
b ]emob
d a\mdh\hfm
khklZ\m keh\ZBa\_klguc agZlhd
ikbobdb `b\hlguo KZjjbk g_hkihjbfh ^hdZaZewlh^Z\ k\hbf
lj_f g_f_pdbf h\qZjdZf bf_gZ OZjjbk:jbk bIZjbkDh]^Z
ohaybg ijbdZau\ZeOZjjbk beb :jbkbeb IZjbkf_klh
\klZ\ZeZ b i_qZevgh ie_eZkv d k\h_c ih^klbed_bf_ggh lZ
kh[ZdZdhlhjmx hg gZa\ZeK lZdhc `_lhqghklvx dhfZg^Z
\uihegyeZkv b lh]^Zdh]^Z hgZ ih^Z\ZeZkv ba
khk_^g_c
dhfgZluqlh
bkdexqZeh
dZdhcgb[m^v
g_\hevguc
ih^kdZau\Zxsbc `_klFg_ bgh]^Z dZ`_lkyqlh mfgZykh[ZdZ
ijb\yaZggZy
d
ohaybgmkihkh[gZ
magZ\Zlv
g_ lhevdh
hl^_evgu_ keh\Zgh b p_eu_ njZauDh]^Z y]h\hjbeFg_
ihjZ b^lbLblZ b KlZkbg_f_^e_ggh \kdZdb\Zeb^Z`_ \l_o
kemqZyodh]^Z y klZjZl_evgh khojZgye g_cljZevguc \b^b
ijhbaghkbe wlm njZam [_a dZdhceb[h hkh[hc bglhgZpbbK
^jm]hc klhjhgugb h^ghc ba wlbo keh\ijhbag_k_gguo \
^jm]hf dhgl_dkl_g_ \uau\Zehm gbogb fZe_cr_cj_Zdpbb
Ba \k_o ba\_klguofg_ kh[Zdemqr_ \k_]hmf_e ihgbfZlv
q_eh\_q_kdb_
keh\Z
[hevrhc
rgZmp_j
:nnjb
kmdZ
ijbgZ^e_`ZsZy beexkljbjh\Z\r_ckh fghcwlm dgb]m om^h`gbp_
\ qv_c ijZ\^b\hklb y
g_ khfg_\Zxkv:nnjb
ihjZaghfm
j_Z]bjh\ZeZ gZkeh\Z dZlpmriZlpbGZpbb wcdZlpb
hagZqZxsb_ khhl\_lkl\_ggh
dhl_ghd\hjh[mr_ddebqdm
jmqgh]h _`bdZ \ l_ ^gbiheblbq_kdbc l_jfbggZpb_s_ g_
\hr_e \h[boh^b [_ehqdZ
LZdbf h[jZahf\eZ^_ebpZ :nnjbgbq_]h g_ agZy
h[
wdki_jbf_gl_
KZjjbkZijh\_eZ
ijZdlbq_kdb
lZdh_
`_
bkke_^h\Zgb_ b ihemqbeZ ZgZeh]bqguc j_amevlZlIjb keh\_
dZlpbr_jklv gZ aZ]jb\d_ :nnjb \klZ\ZeZ ^u[hf b hgZ
ijbgbfZeZkv \ha[m`^_gghh[gxob\Zlv iheykgh ihdZau\Zyqlh
h`b^Z_l \klj_qbk ijhlb\gbdhfdhlhjuc [m^_laZsbsZlvkyAZ
\hjh[vyfb hgZ]hgyeZkv lhevdh\ xghklbZ aZl_fihgyeZ \kx
[_agZ^_`ghklv wlbo ihiulhd b k l_oihj h]ey^u\ZeZbog_
^\b]Zykv k f_klZb kfhlj_eZbf \ke_^kh kdmqZxsbf\b^hf
?`bdZ GZpb:nnjb g_gZ\b^_eZ ijhklhihlhfmqlh hg [ue_`hf
mkeurZ\ _]hdebqdmhgZ klj_f]eZ\[jhkZeZkv dfmkhjghc dmq_
]^_ h[blZe^jm]hc _`jueZ eZiZfbkmob_ ebklvyb eZyeZk lhc
[_kkbevghc aeh[hcdhlhjmx \uau\Zxl \kh[ZdZo wlbdhexqb_
kha^ZgbyIjb keh\_`_ wcodZlpb:nnjb aZ^bjZeZ]heh\m b
_keb g_ \b^_eZ [_edbgZqbgZeZ i_j_[_]Zlv hl ^_j_\Z d
^_j_\mih^h[gh fgh]bfkh[ZdZf kiehobf qmlv_fhgZ h[eZ^ZeZ
ij_djZkguf aj_gb_fb \b^_eZ ^Zevr_b emqr_[hevrbgkl\Z k_[_
ih^h[guoDjhf_ lh]hhgZ ihgbfZeZ kb]gZeuih^Z\Z_fuc
jmdhcgZ qlhkihkh[gu ^Ze_dhg_ \k_kh[ZdbB _s_hgZ agZeZ
bf_gZ ih f_gvr_c f_j_ ^_\ylb ex^_c b[_`ZeZ dgbf q_j_a
dhfgZlm_keb bogZau\Zeb ih bf_gbIjb wlhfhgZ gbdh]^Z g_
hrb[ZeZkv
?keb
wlb
wdki_jbf_glu
ihdZ`mlky
g_\_jhylgufb
ahhikboheh]mjZ[hlZxs_fm
eZ[hjZlhjbb_fm
ke_^m_l
\kihfgblvqlh ih^hiulgh_ `b\hlgh_gZoh^ys__ky \k_]^Z\
ihf_s_gb_ihemqZ_l ]hjZa^h f_gvr_ dZq_kl\_ggh jZaebqguo
\i_qZle_gbcq_f kh[ZdZih\kx^m khijh\h`^ZxsZy
k\h_]h
ohaybgZKh[Zd_ ]hjZa^h ljm^g__Zkkhpbbjh\Zlv hij_^_e_ggh_
keh\h k khhl\_lkl\mxsbf^_ckl\b_fdhlhjhfm __ h[mqbebgh
dhlhjh_ _c
g_ bgl_j_kghq_f k\yaZlv
gZa\Zgb_ lZdhc
aZfZgqb\hc ^h[uqbdZd dhl_ghd\hjh[_c b l^k kZfhc
wlhc ^h[uq_c< eZ[hjZlhjbb
hl kh[Zdb
j_^dh m^Z_lky
^h[blvky \uiheg_gbyklhev ljm^ghcaZ^ZqbdZd jZkihagZ\Zgb_
dhgdj_lgh]h keh\Zihlhfm qlhm g__ hlkmlkl\m_lg_h[oh^bfuc
^ey wlh]h bgl_j_klml kebrdhf fZeh\Ze_glghkl_cdZd
]h\hjyl ahhikboheh]bEx[hc \eZ^_e_p kh[Zdb h[yaZl_evgh
klZedb\Z_lky k ih\_^_gb_fdhlhjh_ g_\hafh`gh\hkkha^Zlv \
eZ[hjZlhjguo mkeh\byoOhaybg
]h\hjbl jZ\gh^mrghg_
ijhbaghky
bfy kh[ZdbG_ agZx\_klb __ bebg_lGh
kh[ZdZ m`_
\kdZdb\Z_l\bey_l
o\hklhf b
iju]Z_l
hl
\ha[m`^_gbyihlhfm qlh
ij_^\dmrZ_l ijh]medm?keb
[u
ohaybg kdZaZeIjb^_lky __ \u\_klbkh[ZdZ ih^gyeZkv[u
ihkemrgh[_a hkh[h]h bgl_j_kZ: kdZ`b ohaybgG_ly
jZa^mfZe __ \u\h^blvb gZklhjh`_ggu_ mrb
i_qZevgh
himklylkyohly
]eZaZ
[m^ml
ihij_`g_fm
k gZ^_`^hc
mklj_fe_gu gZ
ohaybgZB
ijb hdhgqZl_evghf
j_r_gbb
HklZ\ex __ ^hfZkh[ZdZ mgueh hlhc^_lb kgh\Zey`_l
Ihijh[mcl_
ij_^klZ\blv
k_[_dZdb_
keh`gu_
wdki_jbf_glZevgu_ ijhp_^mju
ihlj_[mxlkyqlh[u
^h[blvky
ZgZeh]bqguo
j_amevlZlh\
\
bkdmkkl\_gguo
mkeh\byo
eZ[hjZlhjbbb
dZdhc
mlhfbl_evghc
[m^_l
ih^h[gZy
^j_kkbjh\dZ
D kh`Ze_gbxfg_ gb jZam g_ kemqZehkvih^jm`blvky k
dZdhcgb[m^v q_eh\_dhh[jZaghc h[_avyghcgh ]hkih`Z O_ck
^hdZaZeZqlh f_`^m q_eh\_dhf b lZdhch[_avyghc \hafh`_g
hq_gv l_kgucdhglZdlkhojZgyxsbcky gZfgh]b_ ]h^uIh^h[guc
dhglZdlhkh[_ggh f_`^m hiulgufdjblbq_kdb
gZkljh_gguf
mq_guf b `b\hlgufdhlhjh_ k\yaZgh k gbfdj_idbfb maZfb
\aZbfghc
ijb\yaZgghklby\ey_lky
emqr_c
ijh\_jdhc
bgl_ee_dlmZevguo kihkh[ghkl_c lZdh]h `b\hlgh]h;_kkihjgh
fu ihdZ _s_g_ fh`_fkhihklZ\blv kh[Zdmk q_eh\_dhh[jZaghc
h[_avyghcgh ebqgh y m[_`^_gqlh ihgbfZlvq_eh\_q_kdmx
j_qv kh[ZdZ[m^_l emqr_ohly [u h[_avygZb ij_\ahreZ __\
^jm]bo ijhy\e_gbyo bgl_ee_dlZ< hij_^_e_gghf
hlghr_gbb
kh[ZdZ ]hjZa^hq_eh\_dhih^h[g__kZfhc mfghc h[_avyguDZd
b q_eh\_dhgZ h^hfZrg_ggh_ kms_kl\hbdZd bq_eh\_dZ
h^hfZrg_gghklv h^ZjbeZ __
^\mfy k\hckl\Zfb\hi_j\uo
hk\h[h^beZ hl `_kldbo jZfhd bgklbgdlb\gh]hih\_^_gbyqlh
hldjueh i_j_^g_cdZd bi_j_^ q_eh\_dhfgh\u_ \hafh`ghklb
^_yl_evghklbb\h\lhjuoh[_ki_qbeZ _clm g_ij_oh^ysmx
^_lkdhklvdhlhjZy m kh[Zdb e_`bl \hkgh\_ __ihklhygghc
ihlj_[ghklb \ ^jm`_kdhc ijb\yaZgghklbZ q_eh\_d ^Z`_\
klZjhklb khojZgy_l ykghklv b k\_`_klv fukebh dhlhjuo
<hj^k\hjl ibkZe
LZd [uehdh]^Z y\ `bagv\klmiZe
LZd _klvdh]^Z y\ajhkeuf klZe
B imklvlZd [m^_ldh]^Z khklZjxkv
Bev imklvmfjm
IJ:<: IJ?>:GGHKLB
Dh]^Zlh
m
f_gy
[ueZ
m\e_dZl_evgZy
dgb`_qdZ
nZglZklbq_kdbo bklhjbcgZau\Z\rZyky JZkkdZau Eu`gh]hWeZ
gZ khg]jy^msbcIh^ fZkdhcaZ[Z\ghc q_imob\ gbo ijylZeZkv
`]mqZy
b
ih^qZk
`_klhdZy
kZlbjZoZjZdl_jgZy
^ey
Zf_jbdZgkdh]h xfhjZ b g_ \k_]^Z ihgylgZy _\jhi_cpZf<
h^ghc ba wlbo bklhjbc Eu`guc We kqm\kl\hf ih\_kl\m_lh
ih^\b]Zo k\h_]h ^jm]ZIjbf_ju g_\_jhylgh]h
fm`_kl\Z
hr_ehfeyxs_]h [eZ]hjh^kl\Z b [_kdhjuklgh]h
q_eh\_dhex[by
]jhfha^ylky h^bggZ ^jm]hc\_k_ehc iZjh^b_c gZZf_jbdZgkdmx
jhfZglbdm >Zevg_]h AZiZ^ZaZ\_jrZeZkv jy^hfljh]Zl_evguo
kp_gdh]^Z wlhl]_jhc kiZk_lWeZ hl\hedh\]jbaeb]heh^Z
oheh^Z b ijhqbo[_kqbke_gguo hiZkghkl_cJZkkdZa dhgqZ_lky
eZdhgbqguf khh[s_gb_fIjh^_eu\Zy \k_ wlhhg hlfhjhabe
gh]blZd qlhd kh`Ze_gbxfg_ ijbrehkv_]h ijbklj_eblv
?keb \ fh_fijbkmlkl\bb q_eh\_do\ZklZ_l ^hklhbgkl\Zfb
k\h_c kh[Zdby h[yaZl_evgh kijZrb\Zx]^_ hgZ l_i_jv
ihij_`g_fm ebk gbfB kebrdhf qZklhihemqZx hl\_l \^mo_
Eu`gh]h WeZG_lfg_ ijbrehkv hl g__hl^_eZlvkyy
i_j__oZe \^jm]hc ]hjh^beb kf_gbed\Zjlbjm gZf_gvrmxbeb
i_j_r_e gZ ^jm]mx jZ[hlmb fg_ klZeh ljm^gh ^_j`Zlv
kh[ZdmBeb _s_qlhgb[m^v \lhf `_jh^_F_gy ihjZ`Z_l
dZd
ex^b\h
\k_o
hklZevguo
hlghr_gbyo
\iheg_
^h[jhihjy^hqgu_gbkdhevdh g_
kfmsZxlkyijbagZ\Zykv
\
ih^h[ghf ihklmid_Hgb g_khagZxlqlh f_`^mbo ih\_^_gb_f b
ih\_^_gb_f w]hbklZ\ukf_yggh]h \
wlhc bklhjbbg_l
ijbgpbibZevghc jZagbpuKh[ZdZ ebr_gZ dZdbo[u lhgb [ueh
ijZ\
g_
lhevdh
kh]eZkgh
aZdhgZfgh
b
baaZ
[_kqm\kl\_gghklb fgh]boex^_c
Ij_^Zgghklv kh[Zdbwlh ^jZ]hp_gguc^ZjgZdeZ^u\Zxsbc
gZ lh]hdlh _]h ijbgbfZ_lg_ f_gvrb_h[yaZl_evkl\Zq_f
q_eh\_q_kdZy ^jm`[ZB wlh ke_^m_lbf_lv \\b^m \k_fdlh
gZf_j_\Z_lky h[aZ\_klbkv q_l\_jhgh]bf ^jm]hfKemqZ_lky
dhg_qghqlh kh[ZdZkZfZ gZ\yau\Z_l\Zf k\hxex[h\vdhlhjuc
\u g_ bkdZebdZd kemqbehkvkh fghcdh]^Z ydZlZykv gZ
eu`Zo \h \j_fyhlimkdZihagZdhfbeky k ObjrfZgm[ueh hdheh
]h^Zb hg m`_ klZe lbibqghc kh[ZdhclZd bg_ h[j_lr_c
ohaybgZklZjrbc e_kgbqbcdhlhjhfm hg ijbgZ^e_`Zeex[be
lhevdh klZjmx `_kldhr_jklgmx e_]Z\mx
b g_ h[jZsZe
gb
fZe_cr_]h \gbfZgby gZ g_kmjZagh]h s_gdZg_
h[_sZ\r_]h
klZlv ohjhr_c hohlgbqv_c kh[ZdhcObjrfZg [ue eZkdh\uf
qm\kl\bl_evguf ikhf b ih[Zb\Zeky ohaybgZqlh g_kebrdhf
j_dhf_g^m_l e_kgbq_]h dZd ohjhr_]h ^j_kkbjh\sbdZGh yg_
khklZ\be hkh[_ggh\ukhdh]h fg_gbyb hObjrfZg_dh]^Z m`_ gZ
\lhjhc ^_gvhg hlijZ\bekyk gZfbY ijbgye_]h aZ ih^oZebfZ
b hrb[kylZd dZd ihlhf\uykgbehkvqlh hgke_^h\Ze g_aZ
gZfbZ lhevdh aZ fghc h^gbfDh]^Z h^gZ`^u mljhf
y
h[gZjm`beqlh hgkibl ih^^\_jvx fh_cdhfgZluy mkhfgbeky
\ k\h_fi_j\hgZqZevghf aZdexq_gbb bih^mfZeg_ hagZqZ_l eb
wlh aZjh`^_gby \_ebdhckh[Zqv_c ex[\bY hiha^Zekh k\h_c
^h]Z^dhc deyl\Z \_jghklb m`_ [ueZ ijbg_k_gZb \^_gv
fh_]h hlt_a^Z kh[ZdZ g_
aZohl_eZ hl g__ hlj_qvkyY
ihiulZeky ihcfZlv ObjrfZgZ b aZi_j_lv _]hqlh[u hgg_
ih[_`Ze aZ gZfbgh hg klZjZl_evgh^_j`Zeky \klhjhg_ hl
f_gy>jh`Z hl lhkdbhimklb\ o\hklhg k [_ahiZkgh]h
jZkklhygby kfhlj_e gZ f_gykeh\gh ]h\hjyY k^_eZx^ey
l_[y \k_qlh lu aZohq_rvaZ bkdexq_gb_fh^gh]h y l_[y
g_ ihdbgmB y k^ZekyKdhevdh \u \havf_l_ aZ k\hx
kh[Zdm"kijhkbe y m e_kgbq_]hK _]h lhqdbaj_gby
ih\_^_gb_ ObjrfZgZ[ueh qbkl_cr_c\h^u ij_^Zl_evkl\hfb hg
hl\_lbe j_adh>_kylv
rbeebg]h\Wlh ijha\mqZeh
dZd
jm]Zl_evkl\hGhij_`^_
q_f hg gZr_e [he__
\_khfu_
keh\Z^_kylv rbeebg]h\[ueb \eh`_gu _fm\ jmdmZ ^\_ iZju
eu` b^\_ iZjukh[Zqvbo eZi m`_g_kebkv ih^ mdehgY agZe
qlh ObjrfZg ihke_^m_laZ gZfbgh hrb[hqghiheZ]Ze[m^lh
fmqbfuc m]jua_gbyfbkh\_klbhg [m^_l[_`Zlv ^Ze_dhihaZ^b
qm\kl\myqlh
gZjmrbe aZij_lH^gZdh ijhbahreh
g_qlh
kh\_jr_ggh g_h`b^Zggh_fh]mq__ kh[Zqv_l_eh m^Zjbeh f_gy\
[hddZd imr_qgh_ y^jhb y re_igmeky gZ
h[e_^_g_emx
^hjh]m>Ze_dh g_\kydbc eu`gbdkmf__l m^_j`Zlv jZ\gh\_kb_
_keb gZ g_]h\g_aZigh gZe_lblh]jhfguc i_kh[_amf_\rbc hl
\hklhj]ZY g_^hhp_gbe khh[jZabl_evghklb ObjrfZgZb hg
bkihegbe lZg_pjZ^hklb gZ^fhb jZkijhkl_jlufl_ehf
Fu hp_gb\Z_f [eZ]hjh^kl\h^\mo
dlh ba gbo kihkh[_g gZ [hevrmx
^jm]h]h
^jma_cbkoh^y balh]h
[_kdhjuklgmx`_jl\m jZ^b
< ;,;\_d_ h^bg nbehkhn kdZaZeImklv \Zr_cp_evx
[m^_l \k_]^Z ex[blv [hevr_q_f ex[yl \Zkg_ [m^vl_\
ex[\b \lhjufDh]^Z ^_eh
dZkZ_lky ex^_cfg_
bgh]^Z
m^Z_lky \uihegblv wlm aZih\_^vgh \ fhbo hlghr_gbyok
ij_^Zgghc kh[Zdhc y \k_]^Z hdZau\Zxkv \lhjufDZdb_ wlh
g_h[uqgu_ b _^bgkl\_ggu_\ k\h_fjh^_ mau<u dh]^Zgb[m^v
aZ^mfu\Zebkv gZ^ bo
g_h[uqghklvx"Q_eh\_d kms_kl\h
gZ^_e_ggh_ jZamfhf b
\ukhdhjZa\bluf qm\kl\hf
fhjZevghc
hl\_lkl\_gghklbkms_kl\h^ey
dhlhjh]h
\ukr_c
b
[eZ]hjh^g_cr_c \_jhc kZeZ\_jZ \[jZlkdmx ex[h\vbf_ggh
lml \^jm] hdZau\Z_lky f_g__ [eZ]hjh^gufq_f q_l\_jhgh]bc
obsgbd=h\hjy lZdy \h\k_ g_ iha\heyx k_[_ \iZklv\
k_glbf_glZevguc
Zgljhihfhjnbaf>Z`_
kZfZy
\ukhdZy
q_eh\_q_kdZy
ex[h\v
ihjh`^Z_lky
g_
jZkkm^dhfg_
ki_pbnbq_kdb q_eh\_q_kdbf gjZ\kl\_gguf qm\kl\hfZ [_j_l
gZqZeh
\
]hjZa^h
[he__
]em[hdbo
b
^j_\gbo
qbklh
wfhpbhgZevguoZ
agZqblbgklbgdlb\guo
kehyoKZfh_
[_amij_qgh_ b gjZ\kl\_ggh_ ih\_^_gb_ mljZqb\Z_l p_gm
\
gZrbo ]eZaZo_keb hgh^bdlm_lky lhevdh jZkkm^dhfWebaZ[_l
;jhmgbg] ibkZeZ
Ex[b f_gyex[b ebrvjZ^b
Ex[\b kZfhc
>Z`_ \ gZrb ^gb q_eh\_q_kdh_ k_j^p_\k_ _s_hklZ_lky
lZdbf `_dZd m \ukrbo `b\hlguo\_^msbc ]jmiih\hch[jZa
`bagbdZd
[u [_a\j_f_ggh
gb ij_\hkoh^be
bo q_eh\_d
[eZ]h^Zjy k\h_fm jZamfm
b gjZ\kl\_gghfm qm\kl\mNZdl
hklZ_lky nZdlhffhy kh[ZdZ ex[blf_gy [hevr_q_f y __b
wlh \k_]^Z ihjh`^Z_l \h fg_ kfmlgucklu^Kh[ZdZ \ex[hc
fhf_gl ]hlh\Zih`_jl\h\Zlv aZf_gy `bagvx?keb [ugZ f_gy
gZiZe e_\ beb lb]jW^b;meebLblZKlZkb b\k_ fhb
hklZevgu_ kh[Zdb [_a fZe_cr_]h dhe_[Zgby dbgmebkv [u \
g_jZ\gmx ko\Zldm jZ^b lh]hqlh[u gZ g_kdhevdh
k_dmg^
ijh^eblv fhx`bagv: dZdihklmibe [ugZ bof_kl_ y"
KH;:QV? G:KLJH?GB?
K\_jdZxsbc aZiZo\h^u
>h[jhlguc aZiZodZfg_c
=Q_kl_jlhgI_kgv Dm^eZ
G_ agZxhldm^Z \hagbdeh wlh\ujZ`_gb_Gh y kqblZx_]h
hq_gv m^Zqgufihlhfm qlh \k_]^ZklZjZxkv ijh\_klb^_gv kh
k\h_c kh[Zdhc_keb \klZx k mljZ \kh[Zqv_f gZkljh_gbb
Dh]^Z y lmi_x hl mfkl\_gghc jZ[hludh]^Z bgl_eeb]_glgu_
jZa]h\hju b g_h[oh^bfhklv[ulv ex[_agufk ]hklyfbgZqbgZxl
ijb\h^blv f_gy \ [_r_gkl\hZ h^bg \b^ ibrms_cfZrbgdb
gZ]hgy_l fmqbl_evgmxlhkdmdZd wlhh[uqgh kemqZ_lkyd dhgpm
\_k_gg_]h k_f_kljZlh]^Z y ijbgbfZxkv ]hgylv kh[ZdY
m^Zeyxkv hl k_[_ih^h[guo bbsm h[s_kl\Z`b\hlguo b ih
ke_^mxs_c ijbqbg_kj_^b fhbo
agZdhfuo g_l gb
h^gh]h
q_eh\_dZ^hklZlhqgh e_gb\h]h ^eylh]hqlh[u khklZ\blvfg_
dhfiZgbxdh]^Z fghc h\eZ^_\Z_l wlh gZkljh_gb_<_^v y
gZ^_e_g [_kp_gguf ^Zjhf \ fbgmlu [_afyl_`gh]h[eZ`_gkl\Z
kh\_jr_ggh hldexqZlvk\hb fukebl_evgu_kihkh[ghklb[_a q_]h
g_\hafh`gh ihegh_ ^mr_\gh_ kihdhckl\b_Dh]^Z y\ `Zjdbc
e_lgbc ^_gv i_j_ieu\Zx>mgZc blhqgh djhdh^begZ hlf_eb
g_`mkv \ lbohc aZ\h^b \_ebq_kl\_gghcj_dbkj_^b ijbjh^u
keh\gh
[u
g_
\_^Zxsbc
h
kms_kl\h\Zgbb q_eh\_q_kdhc
pb\bebaZpbblh]^Z
fg_ baj_^dZ
m^Z_lky ^hklbqv
lh]h
qm^_kgh]h khklhygbyd h[j_l_gbxdhlhjh]h klj_fbebkv fm^ju_
[m^^bckdb_ hlr_evgbdbY g_ aZkuiZxgh \k_fhb qm\kl\ZdZd
[m^lh jZkl\hjyxlky\ ]Zjfhgbqghf_^bg_gbb k ijbjh^hcfukeb
aZfbjZxl\j_fy mljZqb\Z_l kfukeb dh]^Z khegp_kdehgy_lky
d aZdZlmb \_q_jgyy ijhoeZ^ZaZklZ\ey_l f_gy\kihfgblvqlh
fg_ _s_ij_^klhbl h^he_lv \ieZ\viylv dbehf_ljh\y g_fh]m
khh[jZablvk_dmg^u beb]h^u ijhrebk lh]hf]gh\_gbydh]^Z
y \u[jZekygZ i_kqZguc[_j_]
WlZ `b\hlgZy gbj\ZgZ emqr__ kj_^kl\hhl mfkl\_ggh]h
i_j_mlhfe_gbyp_ebl_evguc [ZevaZf ^ey^mr_\gh]h khklhygby
kh\j_f_ggh]hlhjhiys_]hky\_qgh
q_flh
haZ[hq_ggh]h
q_eh\_dZ k bkl_jaZggufb g_j\ZfbFg_ g_ \k_]^Z m^Z_lky
h[j_klb lZdmx [_a^mfgmx [_afyl_`ghklv^hq_eh\_q_kdh]h jZy
gh
mki_o
[u\Z_l
\_jhylg__
\
h[s_kl\_ q_l\_jhgh]h]h
kimlgbdZ\k_ _s_ iheghijZ\gh]hh[blZl_ey wlh]h jZyLZdh\u
g_khfg_ggu_ b ]em[hdb_ ijbqbguihq_fm fg_gm`gZ kh[ZdZ
dhlhjZy \_jgh ke_^h\ZeZ[u aZfghcgh ijb wlhfkhojZgyeZ
[u ^bdmx\g_rghklvqlh[u g_ihjlblv i_caZ`ZgZihfbgZgb_f h
pb\bebaZpbb
<q_jZ m`_ gZ aZj_ [ueh lZd `Zjdhqlh h jZ[hl_
mfkl\_gghc jZ[hl_ g_q_]h [ueh b ^mfZlv>_gvkeh\gh
gZjhqgh ij_^gZagZq_gguc ^ey lh]hqlh[u ijh\_klb _]hgZ
>mgZ_Y \ur_e ba ^hfm\hhjm`_gguc kZqdhfb kl_deygghc
[Zgdhcihlhfm qlh\k_]^Z ijbghrmba lZdbowdkdmjkbc `b\hc
dhjf ^ey fhbo
ju[hdBdZd
\k_]^Zfh_
kgZjy`_gb_
ihkem`beh ^eyKxab kb]gZehfqlh y\ kh[Zqv_f gZkljh_gbb
b ij_^klhblkqZkleb\uc ^_gvHgZ m[_`^_gZqlh wlb ijh]medb
y kh\_jrZxjZ^b g__ b[ulv fh`_lhgZ g_lZd m`^Ze_dh hl
bklbguKxab agZ_lqlh yg_ ijhklhiha\heyx _c khijh\h`^Zlv
k_[ygh bhq_gv ^hjh`m__ h[s_kl\hfB \k_`_ ^h\hjhl hgZ
b^_l mkZfhc gh]bZ \^jm]y ijhg__ aZ[m^m"H^gZdh gZ mebp_
hgZ ]hj^h aZ^bjZ_l imrbkluc o\hkl b e_]dhcjukphc [_`bl
\i_j_^b f_gy __ lZgpmxsZyweZklbqgZy ijh[_`dZh[ty\ey_l
\k_ kh[ZdZfqlh Kxabgbdh]h bagbo g_[hblky^Z`_ dh]^Zk
g_c g_l<hedZ ,,K gZj_^dhklv mjh^eb\ufikhf [ZdZe_csbdZ gZ^_xkv[ZdZe_csbd wlhc dgb]b g_ ijhql_l hgZ h[uqgh
aZ\yau\Z_l dhjhldbc nebjlD \_ebqZcr_fm
g_m^h\hevkl\bx
<hedZ ,,Kxab iblZ_l g_dhlhjmxkeZ[hklv dwlhfm iylgbklhfm
mjh^pmhgZ fhjsblghk bkdZebl gZg_]h [e_klysb_am[uZ
ihlhf
[_`bl
^Zevr_ih
h[udgh\_gbx
juqZ
gZ k\hbo
fgh]hqbke_gguo \jZ]h\aZ boaZ[hjZfb
MebpZ _s_ \]em[hdhc l_gbb mlhilZggZya_fey oheh^bl
[hku_ gh]bgh aZ
`_e_agh^hjh`guf fhklhfgZ ljhi_
kimkdZxs_cky d j_d_klmigb lhgml\ l_iehceZkdh\hc iueb
dhlhjZy
fZe_gvdbfb
h[eZqdZfb
\af_lu\Z_lky
baih^ eZi
[_]ms_c \i_j_^b kh[Zdb b ih\bkZ_l \g_ih^\b`ghf \ha^mo_
<_k_eh a\_gyl dmag_qbdbb pbdZ^uZ gZ^_j_\_ m\h^u ihxl
bgh]^Z b keZ\dZq_jgh]heh\dZKeZ\Z [h]mhgb _s_ihxl
AgZqble_lh _s_ lhevdhlhevdh gZqZehkvGZr imlve_`bl
q_j_a k\_`_kdhr_gguc em]b Kxab k\hjZqb\Z_l k ljhidb
ihlhfm qlh lml \k_]^Z fh`gh kh \dmkhfihfurdh\Zlv?_
jukpZ kf_gy_lky k\h_h[jZaghc ih^iju]b\Zxs_c ihoh^dhc
gZ
g_]gmsboky eZiZo=heh\m hgZ ^_j`bl \ukhdh\_kv __\b^
\u^Z_l jZ^hklgh_ \ha[m`^_gb_b o\hklhims_g b\ulygml gZ^
kZfhc a_fe_c< wlm fbgmlm hgZ [hevr_ \k_]hgZihfbgZ_l
]hem[h]h i_kpZ \ur_ kj_^g_c miblZgghklb<g_aZigh keh\gh
\uk\h[h`^Z_lky ijm`bgZb Kxab hibku\Z_l \ \ha^mo_^m]m
\ukhlhc \ f_lj b ^ebgghc \ ^\ZDh]^Z hgZijba_fey_lky
\ulygm\
\i_j_^
b
k\_^y
\f_kl_
i_j_^gb_
eZiulh
fhegb_ghkgh dmkZ_l qlhlh \ gbadhcljZ\_=jhfdh nujdZy
hgZ \\bgqb\Z_l ghk \ a_fexZ ihlhf ih^gbfZ_l]heh\m b
\hijhkbl_evgh kfhljbl gZ f_gyihfZob\Zy o\hklhffurv
mkdhevagmeZKxabg_khfg_gghihegZ klu^Zihlhfm qlh__
\_ebdhe_iguc iju`hd gZ furv hdZaZeky [_aj_amevlZlgufgh
aZlh dZd hgZ]hj^blkydh]^Z mki_\Z_l ko\Zlblv^h[uqmGZ
wlhl jZa hgZ ijh^he`Z_l \uke_`b\Zlv k\hx ^bqvh^gZdh
q_luj_ gh\uo iju`dZhiylv hdZau\Zxlky[_kieh^gufbIhe_\db
ihjZabl_evgh [uklju b ih^\b`guGh \hlfZe_gvdZy qZmqZm
ijhe_lZ_l ih \ha^momdZd j_abgh\ucfyqbdh]^Z __eZiu
dZkZxlky a_febjZa^Z_lky ijhgabl_evguc hlqZygguc
ibkd
Kxab dmkZ_laZl_f [ukljhj_adbf ^\b`_gb_f ih^[jZku\Z_llh
qlh dmkZeZb fZe_gvdh_ k_jh_ l_evp_hibku\Z_l \\ha^mo_
^m]mKxab lh`_gh [he__ rbjhdmxHllygm\ ]m[uhgZ
g_kdhevdh jZa s_edZ_lam[ZfbZ ihlhf [_j_lh^gbfb j_apZfb
qlhlhqlh
ibsbl
b
[v_lky
\
ljZ\_AZl_f Kxab
h[hjZqb\Z_lky dh fg_ b ij_^ty\ey_l ^ey fh_]h h[haj_gby
[hevrmx`bjgmxkbevgh ihfylmx furvdhlhjmx ^_j`bl \
q_exklyoY hkuiZx__ iho\ZeZfbb ijh\ha]eZrZxqlh hgZ
fh]mqbc b]jhaguc a\_jvd dhlhjhfm \k_^he`gu hlghkblky k
\_ebqZcrbf lj_i_lhfFg_ `Zdh ihe_\dmgh \_^vk g_cy g_
[ue ebqgh agZdhfZ Kxab fhc [eb`Zcrbc ^jm]b fg_
iheh`_gh jZ^h\Zlvky __ mki_oZfL_f g_ f_g__ m
f_gy
klZgh\blky e_]q_ gZ ^mr_dh]^Z hgZkt_^Z_l ihe_\dmqlh
hijZ\^u\Z_l __ihklmihdihkdhevdm hohlZjZ^b _^uaZdhggh_
ijZ\h `b\hlgh]hKgZqZeZ hgZ ke_]dZ`m_l furvij_\jZsZy __
\ iehlguc [_knhjf_gguc dhfhq_dihlhf \[bjZ_l ]em[`_ \
iZklv bijh]eZlu\Z_l;hevr_ furdh\Zlv_c ihdZg_ ohq_lkyb
hgZ ihdZau\Z_lfg_qlh fufh`_f b^lb^Zevr_
LjhidZ ijb\h^bl gZk d j_d_]^_ yjZa^_\Zxkv bijyqm
h^_`^m \f_kl_ kkZqdhf b[ZgdhcHlkx^Z gZr imlve_`bl ih
klZjhfm [_q_\gbdm \ ij_`gb_ \j_f_gZ lmlreb ehrZ^bgu_
mijy`dblZsb\rb_ [Zj`bgh l_i_jv[_q_\gbd kh\k_faZjhkb
ma_gvdZy ljhidZ\v_lky kj_^baZjhke_c \ukhdh]h dmklZjgbd\
]ms_ dhlhjh]hm\uijyq_lky djZib\Zb dhexqZy_`_\bdZlZd
qlh ijboh^blky h[_bfb jmdZfb h[_j_]Zlv l_eh hlh`h]h\ b
pZjZibg< wlhc
ljZ\ygbklhc qZsh[_ klhbl
g_\ughkbfZy
^mohlZb Kxab k iuol_gb_f [j_^_l aZ fghcZiZlbqgh g_
aZf_qZy hohlgbqvbo kh[eZagh\lZysboky ih klhjhgZfFg_
ihgylgZ __\yehklvihlhfm qlh ykZf h[eb\Zxkvihlhfb yk
khqm\kl\b_f ih]ey^u\Zxl gZ __ ]mklmx r_jklvGZdhg_p fu
^h[bjZ_fky ^hf_klZ]^_ ygZf_lbe i_j_ieulv>mgZy<h^Z \
j_d_ klhbl gbadhb kgZqZeZ fu b^_fih ^ebgghc]Ze_qghc
dhk_Y hklhjh`ghklmiZx ihdZf_rdZfZ Kxabm[_]Z_l \i_j_^
aZ[bjZ_lky \ \h^m b eh`blkylZd qlh gZ^ ih\_joghklvx
\b^g__lky lhevdh__ ]heh\ZkljZgguc fZe_gvdbclj_m]hevgbd
gZ nhg_j_qguo ijhklhjh\
Dh]^Z y \oh`m \ \h^mKxab ih^[bjZ_lkyd kZfhcfh_c
kbg_lbohgvdh
ih\ba]b\Zy_c
_s_ g_ ^h\h^behkv
i_j_ieu\Zlv >mgZcb _]h rbjbgZ ij_bkihegy_l __^mjgufb
ij_^qm\kl\byfbY klZjZxkv mkihdhblv __b ^_eZxg_kdhevdh
rZ]h\ \i_j_^Fg_ \h^Z ihdZ ^hoh^bl lhevdh^h dhe_ggh
Kxab m`_ ijboh^blky ieulvb __ gZqbgZ_l[ukljh kghkblv
l_q_gb_fIhwlhfm y lh`_ imkdZxkv \ieZ\vohly fg_lml
f_edh\Zlhgh l_i_jvy ^\b]Zxkv gZjZ\g_k g_cb[hevr_ g_
lj_\h`ZkvhgZ ljm^hex[b\h jZ[hlZ_l eZiZfbjy^hf khfghc
Kh[ZdZdhlhjZy ieu\_ljy^hf kohaybghfijhy\ey_l g_fZeuc
mfFgh]b_ kh[ZdbgbdZd g_fh]ml khh[jZablvqlh ieu\msbc
q_eh\_d g_ khojZgy_l \_jlbdZevghc ihau\ dhlhjhc
hgb
ijb\udeb _]h \b^_lvb \ j_amevlZl_klZjZykv ^_j`Zlvky
ih[eb`_d _]h ]heh\_hgb `_klhdh pZjZiZxl _fmeZiZfb
kibgm
: \hlKxab kjZamihgyeZqlh \\h^_ q_eh\_dijbgbfZ_l
]hjbahglZevgh_ iheh`_gb_b hgZ \gbfZl_evghke_^bl aZl_f
qlh[u g_ih^ieulv dhfg_ kaZ^bkebrdhf [ebadhRbjbgZ j_db b
[ukljhlZ l_q_gby __g_j\bjmxlb hgZ ^_j`blkykh\k_f jy^hf
kh fghcIhlhf __ lj_\h]Z gZklhevdh \hajZklZ_lqlh hgZ
\ukhdh]h ih^gbfZ_lky ba \h^u b h]ey^u\Z_lky gZ
[_j_]
dhlhjuc fu lhevdhqlh ihdbgmebY hiZkZxkvqlh hgZfh`_l
ih\_jgmlv gZaZ^gh Kxab
aZgbfZ_l ij_`gxx
ihabpbx b
ijh^he`Z_l ieulv[hd h[hd kh fghc<kdhj_ \hagbdZ_l gh\Zy
ljm^ghklv\ha[m`^_gb_ b `_eZgb_dZd fh`ghkdhj__ i_j_k_qv
h]jhfgmx j_dm \ g_c lZd kbevguqlh hgZ gZqbgZ_lf_gy
h[]hgylvY bah\k_o kbe klZjZxkvg_ hlklZlvgh wlh fg_g_
m^Z_lkyb Kxab \gh\v mieu\Z_l \i_j_^lhevdh ^eylh]h
qlh[u lml `_ h]eygmlvky b ihki_rblv gZaZ^ dh fg_:
ih\_jgm\rbkv fhj^hc d jh^ghfm [_j_]mhgZ \ex[hc fhf_gl
fh`_l ihieulvlm^Z[jhkb\ f_gylZd dZd^ey \klj_\h`_ggh]h
`b\hlgh]h ^hf h[eZ^Z_l hkh[hc ijbly]Zl_evghc kbehc>Z b
\hh[s_
kh[ZdZfdh]^Z
hgb
ieu\mlljm^gh
f_gylv
gZijZ\e_gb_Z ihlhfmy bkiulu\ZxagZqbl_evgh_ h[e_]q_gb_
m]h\hjb\ __ kgh\Z ih\_jgmlv \ gm`gmxklhjhgmb ijbeZ]Zx
\k_ mkbebyqlh[u g_ hlklZlvhl g__b kjZam`_ ij_k_qv__
ihiuldm ieulvgZaZ^Lhqlh fhbkeh\Ziho\Zeu bihhsj_gby
_c ihgylgu b \ha^_ckl\mxl gZ g__ebrgbc jZa^hdZau\Z_l
fg_gZkdhevdh __ bgl_ee_dl ij_\hkoh^bl kj_^gbc kh[Zqbc
mjh\_gv
Fu ijb[eb`Z_fky d
i_kqZghfm hldhkm]hjZa^h
[he__
djmlhfmq_f gZlhf [_j_]mKxab h[h]gZeZf_gy gZg_kdhevdh
f_ljh\bdh]^Z hgZ^_eZ_l i_j\u_rZ]b ihkmr_y aZf_qZx
qlh hgZaZf_lgh ihdZqb\Z_lkyWlZ e_]dZy^eysZyky g_kdhevdh
k_dmg^ ihl_jy jZ\gh\_kbydhlhjmx y kZf bkiulu\Zeihke_
^he]h]h ij_[u\Zgby \\h^_agZdhfZ fgh]bf ieh\pZfH^gZdh
ih^oh^ys_]h nbabheh]bq_kdh]h
h[tykg_gby ^ey
g__ y
g_
gZoh`mFg_ ^h\hevgh
qZklh ijboh^behkv gZ[ex^Zlv
wlm
j_Zdpbx m kh[Zdgh gb jZam hgZ g_ [ueZ klhev
yjdh
\ujZ`_gZdZd m Kxab \ lhl ^_gv<h \kydhf kemqZ_k
mlhfe_gb_f hgZ gbdZdg_ k\yaZgZwlh Kxab g_f_^e_gghfg_
^hdZau\Z_l[mjgh jZ^mykvqlh fu h^he_eb j_dmHgZ \
\hklhj]_ hibku\Z_l \hdjm] f_gy [uklju_\hkvf_jdbZ aZl_f
ijblZkdb\Z_l fg_ iZedmb fu aZl_\Z_f b]jm y [jhkZx
iZedmZ hgZ ijbghkbl __ gZaZ^Dh]^Z _cgZ^h_^Z_l wlh
jZa\e_q_gb_hgZ hijhf_lvx db^Z_lky dljykh]mad_dhlhjZy
kb^bl gZ [_j_]mf_ljZo \iylb^_kylb hlgZkG_lKxab g_
gZklhevdh gZb\gZqlh[u
gZ^_ylvky ihcfZlv wlm
ilbqdm
gh hgZ ij_djZkgh agZ_lqlh ljykh]madbbf_xl h[udgh\_gb_
ijhe_l_\ ^_kylhd f_ljh\kgh\Z kZ^blvkyZ ihlhfmk gbfb
ijbylgh ihb]jZlv\ hohlm
F_gy
jZ^m_l
\_k_eh_
gZkljh_gb_
fh_c
fZe_gvdhc
ijbyl_evgbpulZd dZd hlkx^Z ke_^m_lqlh hgZ b\ij_^v
[m^_l khijh\h`^Zlv f_gy\ wlboieZ\Zgbyo q_j_a>mgZcB y
klZjZxkv \kyq_kdb
\hagZ]jZ^blv __
aZ i_j\h_
m^Zqgh_
nhjkbjh\Zgb_ j_dbZ ^ey wlh]h g_l kihkh[Z emqr_q_f
hlijZ\blky k g_c \ ^ebggmx ijh]medm ih \hkoblbl_evghfm
j_qghfm [_j_]mkhojZgyxs_fm dZdmxlh i_j\ha^Zggmx^bdhklv
=meyy lZf
k q_l\_jhgh]bf
^jm]hffh`gh
magZlv fgh]h
ex[hiulgh]hhkh[_ggh _keb ke_^h\Zlv
g_ k\hbfZ
_]h
\dmkZf bgZdehgghklyf
KgZqZeZ fu b^_f \\_jo ih l_q_gbxm kZfh]hdjZy \h^u
aZl_f h]b[Z_ffZe_gvdmx klZjbpmm gb`g_]hdhgpZ ]em[hdmx b
ijhajZqgmx>Zevr_ hgZij_\jZsZ_lky \p_iv djhohlguoha_j
\k_ [he__ b[he__ f_edbo< ih^h[guoklZjbpZo _klvqlhlh
ljhibq_kdh_djmlu_\
[mcguo aZjhkeyo [_j_]Zihqlb
\_jlbdZevgh
moh^ysb_
\
\h^mhdjm`_gu
gZklhysbf
[hlZgbq_kdbf kZ^hf \ukhdb_ b\ulhihey^m[u aZie_l_gu
ehaZfb ^bdh]h\bgh]jZ^ZgZihfbgZxsbfb ebZgu^Z blbibqgu_
h[blZl_eb lZdbo f_klabfhjh^db b b\he]bijbgZ^e_`Zl d
k_f_ckl\Zf ilbp[hevrbgkl\h dhlhjuo khklZ\eyxlljhibq_kdb_
\b^u<h^Z aZjhkeZ \k_\hafh`ghc [hehlghcjZklbl_evghklvx
Ljhibq_kdhc dZ`_lky b \eZ`gZy `ZjZih\bkrZy gZ^ wlbfb
^`mg]eyfb \fbgbZlxj_\ug_klb __k ^hklhbgkl\hf kihkh[_g
lhevdh gZ]hcq_eh\_ddhlhjuc lhb ^_ehhdmgZ_lky \ \h^m
B \aZdexq_gb_ ijbagZ_fkyqlh kha^Zgbx ljhibq_kdhcbeexabb
\
g_fZehc
kl_i_gb
kihkh[kl\mxl
fZeyjbcgu_
dhfZju b
fgh]hqbke_ggu_ ke_igb
GZ rbjhdhc ihehk_
beZhdZcfeyxs_c klZjbpmfh`gh
m\b^_lv ke_^ujZaguo j_qguo`bl_e_ckeh\gh aZi_qZle_ggu_\
]bik_Bo \bablgu_
dZjlhqdbhli_qZlZggu_ \
aZkhor_c
]ebg_khojZgyxlky g_ljhgmlufb ^h ke_^mxs_]heb\gy beb^h
gh\h]h ih^t_fZ \h^uDlh ]h\hjbl[m^lh \ ijb^mgZckdbo
[hehlZo
m`_
g_
hklZehkv
he_g_c"Hli_qZldb
dhiul
k\b^_l_evkl\mxl h lhfqlh lZf [jh^bl _s_g_fZeh ]hj^uo
djZkZ\p_\ohly hk_gvx m`_ g_ keurgh boljm[gh]h j_\Z
lZdbfb hklhjh`gufb hgb klZeb kh \j_f_gbihke_^g_c \hcgu
aZdexqbl_evgZy nZaZ dhlhjhc jZau]ju\ZeZkv \ wlbo
kZfuo
e_kZoEbku b he_gbhg^Zlju b [he__ f_edb_
]juamgu
[_kqbke_ggu_
dmebdbi_j_\haqbdbnbnb
b
fZeu_
amcdb
mdjZkbeb \ukhorbcbe ijbohleb\ufbp_ihqdZfb k\hbo ke_^h\:
_keb wlb ke_^u bgl_j_kgu ^ey fhbo ]eZalh
gZkdhevdh
m\e_dZl_evg__ hgb ^he`gu [ulv ^ey ghkZ fh_c
fZe_gvdhc
qZmqZmhgZ
gZkeZ`^ZeZkv ibjr_kl\hf
aZiZoh\dhlhju_
g_^hklmigu gZf [_^gy]Zfebr_gguf qmlvyKe_^u he_g_c__
g_ bgl_j_kmxlihlhfm qlh Kxabd kqZklvxg_ hohlgbpZ^h
djmighc ^bqb kljZklv d furdh\ZgbxaZkehgy_l hlg__ \k_
hklZevgh_
Gh aZiZohg^Zlju kh\k_f ^jm]h_^_eh>_j`Z ghkm kZfhc
a_feb bdhkh \ulygm\o\hklhgZ \uke_`b\Z_lwlh]h ]juamgZ ^h
kZfhc _]h ghjudhlhjZy
ihke_ ihgb`_gby mjh\gy
>mgZy
hdZaZeZkv gZ^ \h^hcKxab km_l ghk \ hl\_jklb_`Z^gh
\^uoZy mihbl_evguc aZiZo ^bqbb ^Z`_gZqbgZ_l jZaju\Zlv
ghjm aZgylb_ wlh
kh\_jr_ggh [_agZ^_`ghgh y
g_
\f_rb\Zxkvqlh[u g_ ihjlblv _c m^h\hevkl\byY
e_`m
jZkieZklZ\rbkv gZ`b\hl_ \f_edhc l_iehc\h^bqd_ih^klZ\eyy
kibgm iZeys_fm khegpmb \h\k_ g_lhjhiexkv b^lb^Zevr_
GZdhg_p Kxab ih\hjZqb\Z_l\ fhxklhjhgu h[e_ie_ggmxa_fe_c
fhj^m<beyy o\hklhf b ly`_eh ^urZhgZ b^_ldh fg_b k
]em[hdbf \a^hohf eh`blky\ \h^mjy^hfLZd fu e_`bfhdheh
qZkZZ ihlhf Kxab\klZ_l b ijhkblqlh[u fu ihreb^Zevr_
Fu ijh^he`Z_f imlv \^hev ihqlb m`_kh\k_f kmohcklZjbpu
h[oh^bf ijb]hjhd b hdZau\Z_fky m hq_j_^gh]h ha_jpZgZ^
dhlhjufg_ ih^haj_\Zyh gZr_fijb[eb`_gbb \_l_j ^m_l\
gZrm klhjhgmkb^bl h]jhfgZyhg^ZljZij_\hkoh^ysZy kZfu_
kf_eu_ f_qlu Kxab]b]ZglkdZy [h]hih^h[gZy djukZdjukZ
g_keuoZgghc \_ebqbguKxab aZklu\Z_ldZd klZlmyb ylh`_
AZl_f f_^e_gghlhqgh oZf_e_hgrZ] aZ rZ]hfhgZ gZqbgZ_l
ih^djZ^u\Zlvky dkdZahqghfm a\_jx?c m^Z_lky ih^h[jZlvkyd
djuk_
gZ
m^b\e_gb_
[ebadh
ijhc^_gZ m`_ iheh\bgZ
jZkklhygbydhlhjh_ gZkjZa^_ey_lB \_^v\k_]^Z _klv rZgk
qlh
hr_ehfe_ggZy
g_h`b^Zgghklvx
djukZ
iju]g_l
\
ihem\ukhor__ ha_jphba dhlhjh]h g_l \uoh^ZGhjZ `___
\_jhylghgZoh^blky lZfdm^Z \h^Z ^hoh^beZ ij_`^_\
g_kdhevdbo f_ljZo hl lh]h f_klZ]^_ hgZ kb^blGh y
g_^hhp_gbe
wlhc djuku<g_aZigh hgZ aZf_qZ_l kh[Zdm b
fhegb_c [jhkZ_lky \\_jo ih kdehgmZ Kxabfqblky aZg_c
HgZ gZklhevdhkhh[jZabl_evgZqlh g_ijh[m_l ^h]gZlvdjukm
Z klZjZ_lky hlj_aZlv__ hlghjuB \ wlhlfb] Kxabba^Z_l
kljZklguc \hievdZdhc ebrv hq_gv j_^dh \uju\Z_lky
ba
kh[Zqv_c ]jm^b<hafh`ghg_ jZkljZlv hgZwg_j]bb gZ wlhl
\hiev_c m^Zehkv
[u ko\Zlblv djukmihlhfm qlh
bo
jZa^_ey_l \k_]h
ihelhjZ f_ljZdh]^Z lZ
bkq_aZ_l
\
kiZkbl_evghc ghj_
IheZ]Zyqlh Kxab ijbf_lky jZaju\Zlv \oh^ \ghjmy
eh`mkv \ l_iemx ]jyavgh fZe_gvdZy qZmqZm lhevdh
k
\h`^_e_gb_f
h[gxob\Z_l
_]hZ
ihlhf
jZahqZjh\Zggh
hl\hjZqb\Z_lky b ijbkh_^bgy_lky dh fg_DZd b yhgZ
qm\kl\m_lqlh ^_gv^hklb] k\h_cdmevfbgZpbbih_l b\he]Z
d\ZdZxl ey]mrdbZ h]jhfgu_ klj_dhaukmoh lj_sZdjuevyfb
]hgyxlky aZ l_jaZxsbfb gZk ke_igyfb>h[jhc hohlubfFu
ijh^he`Z_f e_`Zlv lZd ^h \_q_jZb y ij_^Zxkv
lZdhfm
[_a^mfghfm ihdhxqlh
kh fghc g_
kjZ\gblky gb
h^gh
`b\hlgh_jZa\_ qlh djhdh^beKxab wlh gZ^h_^Z_lb aZ
g_bf_gb_f
emqr_]h
aZgylby
hgZ
gZqbgZ_l
ij_ke_^h\Zlv
ey]mr_ddhlhju_h[fZgmlu_ gZr_c ^he]hc g_ih^\b`ghklvx
\hah[gh\beb k\hc dhgp_jlKxab ih^djZ^u\Z_lkyd [eb`Zcr_c
ey]mrd_ b bkiulu\Z_l gZ wlhc gh\hc^h[uq_ k\hcfurbguc
iju`hdGh __ eZiuk ie_kdhf himkdZxlky\ \h^mZ ey]mrdZ
p_eZy b g_\j_^bfZygujy_l \ ]em[bgmKfb]b\Zy [jua]bk
]eZaKxab hkfZljb\Z_lky dm^Z `_ ^_eZkv ey]mrdZ"HgZ
\b^bl __ \h \kydhfkemqZ__c lZd dZ`_lkygZ k_j_^bg_
ha_jZ]^_ rbrdb
\h^ghc fylu g_kh\_jr_gghfm
kh[Zqv_fm
aj_gbx\hafh`ghij_^klZ\eyxlky ey]mrZqv_c ]heh\hcKxab
hkfZljb\Z_l ih^hajbl_evguc ij_^f_lgZdehgyy ]heh\mkgZqZeZ
gZe_\hihlhf
gZijZ\hZ
aZl_f f_^e_gghhq_gvhq_gv
f_^e_ggh \oh^bl \ \h^mieu\_l d jZkl_gbxb dmkZ_l_]h
H]eygm\rbkv kh kljZ^Zevq_kdbf \b^hfqlh[u ijh\_jblvg_
kf_xkv eby gZ^ __]emihc hrb[dhchgZ ih\hjZqb\Z_lieu\_l
d [_j_]m b eh`blky jy^hf kh fghcY kijZrb\ZxIhreb
^hfhc"b Kxab\kdZdb\Z_lhl\_qZy ^Z\k_fb kj_^kl\Zfb
dZdb_ lhevdh _klv\ __jZkihjy`_gbbFu ijh[bjZ_fkykd\hav
^`mg]eb ijyfhd >mgZxFu ^Ze_dh mrebhl :evl_g[_j]Z \\_jo
ih j_d_gh l_q_gb_ g_k_l gZk khkdhjhklvx ^_\ylgZ^pZlv
dbehf_ljh\ \ qZkKxab [hevr_g_ ijhy\ey_lgbdZdh]h kljZoZ
i_j_^ wlbf rbjhdbf
\h^guf ijhkljZgkl\hf b
g_lhjhieb\h
ieu\_l jy^hf kh fghciha\heyy l_q_gbx g_klb k_[yFu
\u[bjZ_fky gZ[_j_] \hae_ lh]hf_klZ]^_ y kijylZeh^_`^m
b ylhjhieb\h hjm^mxkZqdhfkh[bjZy \dmkgucm`bg ^ey fhbo
ju[hdAZl_f fu^h\hevgu_ b kqZkleb\u_\ha\jZsZ_fky \
kmf_jdZo ihlhc `_ljhi_GZ furbghfem]m Kxab gZwlhl jZa
`^_l
m^ZqZhgZ
eh\bl
ih^jy^
lj_o `bjguo ihe_\hd
dhfi_gkbjmy k\h_nbZkdh khg^Zljhc bey]mrdhc
K_]h^gy fg_ gZ^h_oZlv \<_gmohlykm^y ihijh]gham
ih]h^uij_^klhbl
kh[Zqvy `ZjZFg_ gZ^h
hl\_alb
\
ba^Zl_evkl\h wlm ]eZ\mG_lKxabl_[_ g_evayihclb kh
fghcLu `_\b^brv y \[jxdZoGh aZ\ljZKxabaZ\ljZ fu
kgh\Z i_j_ieu\_f >mgZcb _kebhq_gv ihklZjZ_fkylhfh`_l
[ulv^Z`_ ihcfZ_fhg^ZljmLm kZfmx
H DHR:QVBOB=J:O
Keh\gh [u_]h ijba\Zgv_
;ueh lhevdh\ ih^jZ`Zgv_
M<hj^k\hjl
< g_dhlhjuo l\hj_gbyo
ijbjh^u g_ihklb`bfuf
h[jZahf
kh_^bgyxlky djZkhlZ b nmgdpbhgZevghklvom^h`_kl\_ggh_ b
l_ogbq_kdh_ kh\_jr_gkl\h lZdh\u iZmlbgZ iZmdZdjueh
klj_dhau\_ebdhe_igh h[l_dZ_fh_ l_eh ^_evnbgZb ^\b`_gby
dhrdbWlb ihke_^gb_ g_fh]eb [uklZlv emqr_^Z`_ _keb
[u bojZajZ[Zlu\Ze kZfuc]_gbZevguc ohj_h]jZnb g_fh]eb [u
klZlv _s_ wnn_dlb\g__ ^Z`_ ih^jmdh\h^kl\hf kha^Z\r_]hbo
emqr_]h ba lj_g_jh\[hjv[u aZ kms_kl\h\Zgb_B dZ`_lky
[m^lh dhrdZ khagZ_ldjZkhlm k\hbo^\b`_gbcihlhfm qlhhgZ
keh\gh gZkeZ`^Z_lky bfb b ijh^_eu\Z_l bo lhevdh aZl_f
qlh[u ihdZaZlv
bo kh\_jr_gkl\hIh^h[gZy b]jZb]jZ
^\b`_gbcaZgbfZ_l hkh[h_ f_klh \ `bagb baysg_cr_]h ba
`b\hlguo
Qlh lZdh_
b]jZ"Wlh
h^bg ba
ljm^g_crbo \hijhkh\
ikboheh]bb dZd q_eh\_dZlZd b `b\hlguoFu kh\_jr_ggh
lhqgh agZ_fqlh bf__f\ \b^mdh]^Z ]h\hjbfqlh dhl_ghd
s_ghd beb j_[_ghd b]jZ_lgh ^Zlv gZklhys__hij_^_e_gb_
wlhfm djZcg_ \Z`ghfm\b^m ^_yl_evghklbqj_a\uqZcgh ljm^gh
<k_ nhjfub]ju h[eZ^Zxl h^gbfh[sbf k\hckl\hfhgb dhj_gguf
h[jZahf hlebqZxlky hlk_jv_aghc^_yl_evghklbgh \lh `_
\j_fy \ gbo ijhke_`b\Z_lky y\gh_ koh^kl\hk dhgdj_lgufb
\iheg_ k_jv_agufb kblmZpbyfb b g_ ijhklh koh^kl\hZ
bfblZpbyWlh kijZ\_^eb\h ^Z`_\ hlghr_gbbZ[kljZdlguo b]j
\ajhkeuo ex^_c \_^v ihd_jbeb rZofZluiha\heyxl bf^Zlv
\uoh^ hij_^_e_gguf bgl_ee_dlmZevguf kihkh[ghklyfH^gZdh
g_kfhljy gZe_`Zs__ \ __hkgh\_ mih^h[e_gb_b]jZ ihgylb_
qj_a\uqZcgh rbjhdh_HgZ ho\Zlu\Z_l bqhihjguc p_j_fhgbZe
klZjbggh]h f_gmwlZb qmjdb klheyjgbqZxs_]h
fZevqm]ZgZ
Dh]^Z djhevqhghd hl ba[uldZ wg_j]bbkdjZ^u\Z_l ke_^ohly
aZ gbf g_ ]hgblky gbdZdhc obsgbdwlh b]jZb j_[_ghd
dhlhjuc
bah[jZ`Z_l
fZrbgbklZlh`_
b]jZ_lQblZl_ev
\hafh`ghm`_
j_rbeqlh
_fm
ij_^klhbl
\ukemrZlv
hl\e_q_ggmx
e_dpbx
h[
h[sbo
ijbagZdZo
wlh]h
\b^Z
^_yl_evghklb m ex^_cb `b\hlguoGh y\ha\jZsZxkv dl_f_
h[hagZq_gghc gZa\Zgb_f ]eZ\ud dhrZqvbf b]jZf;ulv
fh`_lg_dhlhju_
gZ[ex^_gby gZ^
dhgdj_lgufb
ijbf_jZfb
[jhkyl k\_lgZ ijh[e_fmb]j
Dhl_ghd b]jZ_lkh k\h_cljZ^bpbhgghc b]jmrdhc dem[dhf
r_jklbHg g_baf_ggh gZqbgZ_l k lh]hqlh ljh]Z_l _]h
eZidhc kgZqZeZ hklhjh`gh b \hijhkbl_evgh\ulygm\ __b
aZ]gm\ ih^mr_qdm
\gmljvAZl_f hg
\uimkdZ_l
dh]lb
ih^ly]b\Z_l dem[hd d
k_[_ b lml
`_ hllZedb\Z_l
beb
hliju]b\Z_l gZaZ^b ijbiZ^Z_l dihem<_kv ih^h[jZ\rbkvhg
gZklhjh`_ggh ih^gbfZ_l ]heh\mb lZd\g_aZighqlh dZ`_lky
[m^lh hg g_fbgm_fh ^he`_g m^Zjblvky ih^[hjh^dhf h ihe
AZ^gb_ gh]b \uihegyxlk\h_h[jZagu_ q_j_^mxsb_ky^\b`_gby hg lhi_j_klmiZ_l bfblh kdj_[_lkeh\gh hlukdb\Zy l\_j^mx
hihjm ^ey iju`dZ<g_aZigh hghibku\Z_l \\ha^mo_ rbjhdmx
^m]m b iZ^Z_lgZ b]jmrdm\uklZ\b\ \i_j_^k\_^_ggu_ \f_kl_
i_j_^gb_ eZiu?keb b]jZ^hklb]eZ hij_^_e_gghc dmevfbgZpbb
hg ^Z`_ fh`_l gZqZlv
dmkZlvkyDhl_ghd kgh\Z
lhedZ_l
dem[hddhlhjuc l_i_jv aZdZlu\Z_lky ih^ [mn_l\ s_ev
kebrdhf madmxqlh[u dhl_ghd fh] ijhe_alv lm^ZBaysguf
hljZ[hlZgguf^\b`_gb_f dhl_ghd ih^kh\u\Z_lih^ [mn_l h^gm
eZim b \um`b\Z_lk\hx b]jmrdmgZjm`mL_dhfm ^h\h^behkv
ohlv jZa\b^_lvdZd dhrdZeh\bl furvg_f_^e_ggh aZf_qZxl
qlh gZrdhl_ghddhlhjh]h fu jZaemqbebk fZl_jvxqmlv eb g_
ke_iufijh^_eu\Z_l \k_km]m[h ki_pbZebabjh\Zggu_^\b`_gby
ihfh]Zxsb_ dhrd_\ hohl_gZ hkgh\gmx __^h[uqm gZ fur_c
<_^v ^ey^bdbo dhr_dfurb wlh booe_[ gZkmsguc
?keb fu l_i_jv mkh\_jr_gkl\m_f b]jmrdmijb\yaZ\ __d
gbld_ b
ih^\_kb\ lZdqlh[u hgZ
[helZeZkvdhl_ghd
ijh^_fhgkljbjm_l kh\k_f bgmx kbkl_fm hohlgbqvbo^\b`_gbc
Hg \ukhdh ih^iju]b\Z_l b o\ZlZ_l `_jl\m h[_bfb eZiZfb
k\h^y bo rbjhdbf aZo\Zlu\Zxsbf ^\b`_gb_f<h \j_fywlh]h
iju`dZ eZiu dZ`mlky g__kl_kl\_ggh [hevrbfblZd dZddh]lb
\uims_guiZevpu jZklhiuj_guZ iylu_jm^bf_glZjgu_ iZevpu
kh]gmlu ih^
ijyfuf m]ehf
d eZi_Wlh
o\ZlZl_evgh_
^\b`_gb_dhlhjh_ dhlylZ k \hklhj]hf ijh^_eu\Zxl\ b]j_
Z[khexlgh lhqgh^h f_evqZcrbo ^_lZe_ckh\iZ^Z_l kl_f
^\b`_gb_fdhlhjuf
ihevamxlky
dhrdbko\Zlu\Zxsb_
\ae_lZxsmx ka_feb ilbpm
;bheh]bq_kdbc
kfuke
_s_
h^gh]h
^\b`_gbyqZklh
gZ[ex^Zxs_]hky \ b]j_f_g__ hq_\b^_glZd dZdijZdlbq_kdb
dhrdb ihevamxlky bf hq_gv j_^dhDhl_ghd klj_fbl_evguf
gZijZ\e_gguf
\\_jo
m^Zjhf
\u\_jgmlhc
ih^mr_qdb
fk
\uims_ggufb dh]lyfb ih^p_iey_lb]jmrdm kgbami_j_[jZku\Z_l
__ q_j_a ie_qhlZd qlh hgZ hibku\Z_l djmlmx ^m]mb
klj_fbl_evgh iju]Z_laZ g_cBeb `_ hkh[_ggh bf_y ^_ehk
[hevrbfb ij_^f_lZfb dhl_ghd kZ^blky i_j_^
b]jmrdhc
gZijy`_ggh \uijyfey_lkyih^p_iey_l
__ eZiZfb kgbam
k
h[_bo klhjhg b r\ujy_l q_j_a ]heh\m ih_s_ [he__djmlhc
^m]_QZklh dhl_ghd ke_^bl aZ ihe_lhf b]jmrdb]eZaZfb
^_eZ_l \ukhdbc iju`hd b ijba_fey_lky lZf `_]^_ iZ^Z_l
hgZ< `bagb lZdb_^\b`_gby bkihevamxlkyijb eh\e_ju[u
i_j\Zy kbkl_fZ ^ey eh\ebf_edhc ju[_rdbZ \lhjZy^ey
djmighc
Gh _s_ [he__ bgl_j_kgu
b djZkb\u ^\b`_gby
dhlyl
b]jZxsbo eb[h ^jm]k ^jm]hfeb[h kfZl_jvx;bheh]bq_kdbc
bo kfuke g_ lZd e_]dh h[tykgblvdZd kfuke hohlgbqvbo
^\b`_gbcihkdhevdmdh]^Z
dhrdb
b]jZxl
\f_kl_
bgklbgdlb\gu_ ^\b`_gbyijZdlbq_kdh_ ijbf_g_gb_
dhlhjuo
bf__l \_kvfZ rbjhdbc^bZiZahgijh^_eu\Zxlky \ ijbohleb\hf
kf_r_gbb bgZ^ h^gbfb l_f`_ h[t_dlhf
IjblZb\rbkv aZ m]hevguf ysbdhfdhl_ghd
\uke_`b\Z_l
k\h_]h [jZlZdhlhjuc mk_eky ihkj_^bdmogb bg_ ih^haj_\Z_l
h[ wlhcaZkZ^_: i_j\ucdhl_ghd kh^jh]Z_lkyhl g_l_ji_gby
lhqgh djh\h`Z^guc lb]joe_s_l k_[y o\hklhf ih [hdZfb
ijh^_eu\Z_l ]heh\hcb o\hklhf^\b`_gbylZd`_ gZ[ex^Zxsb_ky
m \ajhkeuo dhr_d?]h \g_aZiguciju`hd hlghkblkyd kh\k_f
bghc kbkl_f_ ^\b`_gbygZagZq_gb_ dhlhjuo g_ hohlZZ
^jZdZ<f_klh lh]h qlh[uiju]gmlv gZk\h_]h [jZlZdZd gZ
^h[uqm \ijhq_fwlh lh`_ g_ bkdexqZ_lkydhl_ghd gZ
[_]m ijbgbfZ_l m]jh`Zxsmx iham\u]b[Z_l kibgm b [hdhf
ijb[eb`Z_lky d ijhlb\gbdm<lhjhc dhl_ghd lh`_ \u]b[Z_l
kibgmb h[Z g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy klhyllZd\a^u[b\ r_jklvb
bah]gm\ o\hkluGZkdhevdh fg_ ba\_klgh\ajhkeu_ dhrdb
ih^h[ghc ihabpbb ih hlghr_gbx ^jm] d ^jm]m gbdh]^Z g_
aZgbfZxlDZ`^uc dhl_ghd \_^_l k_[y kdhj__ lZdkeh\gh
i_j_^ gbf kh[ZdZb \k_lZdb bo ko\ZldZjZa\b\Z_lky dZd
ih^ebggZy ^jZdZ ^\mo \ajhkeuo djhlh\Dj_idh \p_ib\rbkv
^jm] \ ^jm]Z i_j_^gbfb
eZiZfbhgb dm\ujdZxlky
kZfuf
g_\_jhylguf h[jZahfh^gh\j_f_ggh ^_j]Zy aZ^gbfb
eZiZfb
lZdqlh[m^v gZf_kl_ \lhjh]h ijhlb\gbdZq_eh\_dm g_]h
ihke_ b]ju [ueb[u jZkpZjZiZgu\k_ jmdbK`bfZy [jZlpZ\
`_e_aghc o\Zld_ i_j_^gbo eZidhl_ghd wg_j]bqgh[v_l _]h
aZ^gbfb eZiZfb k \uims_ggufb dh]lyfb< gZklhys_c^jZd_
lZdb_ k_dmsb_j\msb_ m^Zju gZp_eb\Zxlky \ g_aZsbs_gguc
`b\hl
\jZ]Zqlh
fh`_l
ijb\_klb
d kZfuf i_qZevguf
j_amevlZlZfIh[hdkbjh\Z\ g_fgh]hdhlylZ \uimkdZxl^jm]
^jm]Zb lml h[uqgh gZqbgZ_lky m\e_dZl_evgZy ih]hgy\h
\j_fy dhlhjhc fh`gh gZ[ex^Zlv _s_h^gm kbkl_fm]jZpbhaguo
^\b`_gbcDh]^Z m[_]Zxsbc dhl_ghd \b^blqlh ^jm]hc_]h
gZklb]Z_lhg \g_aZigh ijh^_eu\Z_lkZevlhfhjlZe_fy]dbf
kh\_jr_ggh [_krmfguf ^\b`_gb_f ijhkdZevau\Z_l ih^ k\h_]h
ijhlb\gbdZ\p_iey_lky
i_j_^gbfb eZiZfb
\ _]h
g_`gh_
[jxrdhZ aZ^gbfb[v_l _]hih fhj^hqd_
Q_f `_ wlb b]jb\u_ ^\b`_gby hlebqZxlkyhl k_jv_aguo"
<g_rg__ koh^kl\h gZklhevdh iheghqlh ^Z`_kZfuc hiulguc
]eZa [u\Z_l g_kihkh[_g meh\blv jZaebqb_Gh l_fg_ f_g__
lZdh_ hlebqb_ kms_kl\m_l< wlbob]jZokh_^bgyxsbo \k_[_
^\b`_gby ihbfdb ^h[uqb^jZdb k^jm]hc dhrdhcb hljZ`_gby
gZiZ^_gby
\jZ]ZiZjlg_jmbah[jZ`Zxs_fm
^h[uqm
beb
ijhlb\gbdZgbdh]^Z g_ ijbqbgy_lky k_jv_agh]h \j_^Z<h
\j_fy b]ju klj_fe_gb_dmkZlv bj\Zlv dh]lyfbihgZklhys_fm
iheghklvx aZlhjfh`_gh< j_Zevguo `_kblmZpbyo wlhlaZij_l
mljZqb\Z_l
kbem
ih^
\ha^_ckl\b_f
wfhpbc\uau\Zxsbo
khhl\_lkl\mxsb_
^\b]Zl_evgu_
j_ZdpbbDhgdj_lgh_
ikboheh]bq_kdh_ khklhygb_ `b\hlgh]h hldju\Z_l lh]^Z imlv
^ey dhgdj_lgh]h lbiZ ih\_^_gby b lhevdh^ey g_]h>ey
b]ju oZjZdl_jghqlh \ g_ckm]m[h ki_pbnbq_kdh_ih\_^_gb_
g_ hibjZ_lky gZ khhl\_lkl\mxs__ wfhpbhgZevgh_ khklhygb_
<kydZy b]jZjh^kl\_ggZ l_ZljZevghfmbkdmkkl\m \ lhfkfuke_
qlh b]jZxs_c^_eZ_l \b^[m^lh bf\eZ^_xl wfhpbbdhlhjuo
gZ kZfhf ^_e_ hg g_ bkiulu\Z_l<h \j_fy b]ju
kZfu_
jZaebqgu_
kbkl_fu
^\b`_gbykem`Zsb_
kZfuf
jZaguf
[bheh]bq_kdbf p_eyf\uihegyxlky [_a
\kydh]h
ihjy^dZ
ihlhfm qlh dhgdj_lgh_ wfhpbhgZevgh_ khklhygb_\uau\Zxs__
dZ`^h_ ba
gbo \
^_ckl\bl_evghc `bagblml iheghklvx
hlkmlkl\m_l>\b`_gby ^jZdb\uihegyxlky [_a aeh[u[_]kl\Z
[_a kljZoZhohlu [_a `_eZgbymlheblv ]heh^B g_\_jgh
[m^lh \b]j_ j_Zevgu_wfhpbb \k_ `_ijbkmlkl\mxlohly b\
kfy]q_gghc nhjf_G_l\ b]j_hgb hlkmlkl\mxliheghklvxb
_keb dZdZygb[m^v bagbo ^_ckl\bl_evghijhkg_lky \h^ghf ba
mqZklgbdh\b]jZ g_f_^e_gghij_ju\Z_lkyIhlj_[ghklv b]jZlv
\hagbdZ_l ba ^jm]h]h bklhqgbdZ[he__ h[s_]h ih k\h_fm
oZjZdl_jmq_f l_qZklgu_ ih[m`^_gbydhlhju_ \ hij_^_e_gguo
kblmZpbyo h[_ki_qb\Zxl
g_h[oh^bfhc wg_j]b_c
dZ`^h_
ba
hibkZgguo \ur_^\b`_gbc
H^gZdh wlZ [he__h[sZy ihlj_[ghklv\ b]j_wlh `_eZgb_
kh\_jrZlv Zdlb\gu_ ^_ckl\by jZ^b gbo kZfbo ij_^klZ\eyxl
kh[hc m^b\bl_evguc n_ghf_gk\hckl\_gguc lhevdh gZb[he__
ikbobq_kdb jZa\bluf ba \k_o `b\uo kms_kl\;jb^`_k hq_gv
m^Zqgh \ujZabewlh \ihwlbq_kdhc nhjf_
Kha^Z\ZyihagZx
JZ^hklv khab^Zgby
Ohlv gZaZ\ljZhgZ
KlZg_l lhqghhla\md kgZ
L_gv \hkihfbgZgvy
B g_ kemqZcghfu [u\Z_fjZkljh]ZgugZ[ex^Zy aZ b]jhc
fheh^uo `b\hlguog_ kemqZcghb]jZ ij_^klZ\ey_lky gZf[he__
\ukhdbf
\b^hf
^_yl_evghklbq_f
khhl\_lkl\mxsb_
_c
k_jv_agu_ lbiu ih\_^_gbygZagZq_gb_ dhlhjuo khojZgylv
`bagv \b^ZB]jZ hlebqZ_lky hl k_jv_aguo ^_ckl\bc
g_
lhevdh g_]Zlb\ghgh b ihablb\gh< b]j_ hkh[_ggh m
fheh^uo `b\hlguo \k_]^Z ijbkmlkl\m_l we_f_glhldjulby
B]jZ lbibqgZ ^ey jZa\b\Zxs_]hky hj]ZgbafZM keh`b\r_]hky
`b\hlgh]h ihlj_[ghklv \g_c aZlmoZ_lY hij_^_ebeb]jm dZd
YRUDKPXQJij_^\Zjbl_evgZy
bfblZpbybkihevamy l_jfbg
DZjeZ =jhhkZqlh[u ih^q_jdgmlvqlh b]jh\u_wd\b\Ze_glu
g_dhlhjuo \jh`^_gguoihemq_gguo ih gZke_^kl\m
^\b`_gbc
ijbkmlkl\mxl \`bagb dZ`^h]h `b\hlgh]h_s_ ^hlh]hdZd hgh
gZqbgZ_l ijbf_gylv bo \ j_ZevguokblmZpbyo=jhhk ijb^Z_l
b]j_ [hevrh_ \hkiblZl_evgh_ agZq_gb_ b ml\_j`^Z_lqlh
jZaebqgu_ ^\b`_gbykh\_jr_gkl\mxlky [eZ]h^ZjyqZkluf b]jh\uf
ih\lhj_gbyfM gZk _klv hkgh\Zgby mkhfgblvky \\_jghklb
ihke_^g_]h ml\_j`^_gby
dZd h[s_]h
ijbgpbiZihkdhevdm
bgklbgdlb\gu_mgZke_^h\Zggu_ ^\b`_gby jZa\b\Zxlkyih^h[gh
hj]ZgZf b g_ lj_[mxl ki_pbZevghc ijZdlbdbqlh iheghklvx
ih^l\_j`^Z_lky
fgh]hqbke_ggufb
gZ[ex^_gbyfbKh[kl\_ggh
]h\hjykh\_jr_gkl\h b
]jZg^bhaghklv ^\b`_gbcdhlhju_
ijh^_eu\Z_l dhl_ghd ijb eh\e_ furbbeb \^jm]bo b]jZo
ihdZau\Zxlqlh wlb^\b`_gby g_gm`^Zxlky \memqr_gbb bqlh
bo \hh[s_m`_ g_\hafh`ghmemqrblv
L_f g_ f_g__b]jZ q_fmlh mqbl dhl_gdZHg magZ_lg_
dZd gm`gh
eh\blv furvgh qlh
lZdh_ furvI_j\h_
jZa\_^u\Zl_evgh_
^\b`_gb_
eZidbijhlygmlhc
d dem[dm
r_jklbi_j\Zy
_s_
k^_j`ZggZy
g_j_rbl_evgZy
ihiuldZ
aZp_iblv _]h dh]lyfbaZdexqZxl \hijhklhl ebi_j_^h fghc
ij_^f_ld dhlhjhfmqlhlh klj_fblky\h fg_dhlhjuc yfh]m
\uke_^blvaZ]gZlvihcfZlv b
\ dhgp_ dhgph\
kt_klv"
MgZke_^h\Zgguc kl_j_hlbi \hkijbylby ^h[uqblh _klv
l_
mgZke_^h\Zggu_ f_oZgbafudhlhju_ \uau\Zxlbgklbgdlb\gu_
hohlgbqvb ^\b`_gbykZf ih
k_[_ ijhkl<k_
fZe_gvdb_
djm]eu_ fy]db_ ij_^f_lu\k_qlh [ukljh^\b`_lkydZlykv
beb kdhevayb]eZ\gh_\k_qlh m[_]Z_laZklZ\eyy
dhrdm Z\lhfZlbq_kdb[_a dZdh]heb[h ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]hhiulZ
ijh^_eu\Zlv
ij_djZkgu_baysgu_baukdZggu_
^\b`_gby
ihbfdb furb
Q?EH<?D BDHRD:
KihdhcgZk^_j`ZggZ bl_ji_eb\Z
LhfgZaZ]Z^hqgh fm^jZ
@_klhdh [_kijbkljZklgZ
MMhlkhgWlx^ \dhgljZklZo
L_ dlh ex[blkh[Zdg_j_^dh l_ji_lv g_fh]ml dhr_dZ
l_dlh ex[bldhr_d hkh[_ggh `_gsbgug_ \ughkyl kh[Zd
B ml_ob m^jm]bo wlhgZ fhc \a]ey^k\b^_l_evkl\m_l h[
ba\_klghc
f_ehqghklb
oZjZdl_jZy
kqblZxqlh
ihgZklhys_fm ex[blb ihgbfZ_l`b\hlguo lhevdh lhlq_eh\_d
dhlhjhfm wlb ^\Z gZb[he__ [ebadbo gZf `b\hlguo \gmrZxl
jZ\gmx kbfiZlbxM lh]hdlh ex[bl
ijbjh^m bklbgghc
ex[h\vxgZb[hevrbc
\hklhj]
b
[eZ]h]h\_gb_
\uau\Z_l
[_kdhg_qgh_ jZaghh[jZab_
`b\uo kms_kl\
b
[_kqbke_ggu_
kihkh[udhlhjufb ijbjh^Zkha^Z_l kh\_jr_ggu_]Zjfhgbb
K lhqdb aj_gby bamq_gby q_eh\_q_kdhc ikbobdb djZcg_
bgl_j_kgh gZ[ex^ZlvgZkdhevdh ihjZaghfm \_^ml k_[y
k
`b\hlgufb jZ\gh hk\_^hfe_ggu_\ wlhch[eZklb ex^b<k_ hgb
klj_fylky magZlv `b\hlgh_dZd fh`ghemqr_ jZ^b ebg_]h
kZfh]h bebjZ^b jZa\blbygZmdbFgh]b_ gZlmjZebklukqblZxl
qlh \ebylv gZ `bagv `b\hlguo ke_^m_ldZd fh`ghf_gvr_b
lsZl_evgh ba[_]Zxl dZdboeb[h ijyfuo dhglZdlh\k gbfblZd
\_^ml k_[y hjgblheh]b b nhlh]jZnudhlhju_ gZ[ex^ZxlaZ
`b\hlgufb bamdjulbyijbq_f mki_rgufbwlb gZ[ex^_gbyfh]ml
[ulv lhevdh \ lhf kemqZ__keb `b\hlgu_g_ ih^haj_\Zxlh
ijbkmlkl\bb
gZ[ex^Zl_eyIhegmx
ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv
bf
khklZ\ey_l q_eh\_ddhlhjuc \klmiZ_l k `b\hlgufb\ kZfuc
l_kguc dhglZdllZd qlh `b\hlgh_\hkijbgbfZ_l _]hdZd hkh[v
kh[kl\_ggh]h \b^Zb wlh
iha\hey_l _fm
kh\k_f
bguf
kihkh[hf ijhgbdgmlv \ ]em[bgu ikbobdb ^Zggh]h \b^ZH[Z
f_lh^Z \iheg_hijZ\^Zguh[Z bf_xlk\hb ij_bfms_kl\Zb k\hb
g_^hklZldbh[Z ^himkdZxl \hafh`ghklv\kyq_kdbo \ZjbZglh\ b
dhf[bgZpbc<u[hj f_lh^Z aZ\bkblg_ lhevdhhl gZ[ex^Zl_ey
gh b hl \b^Zdhlhjuc
hg gZf_j_g bamqZlvQ_f
\ur_
ikbobq_kdbc mjh\_gv `b\hlgh]h b q_f hghh[sbl_evg__l_f
[he__ g_h[oh^bf
^ey ih^ebggh]h
_]h ihgbfZgby
ebqguc
dhglZdlGbdlh g_ kmf__l ijZ\bevgh hp_gblv
mfkl\_ggu_
dZq_kl\Z kh[Zdb_keb kZf ohlvjZa g_[ue h[t_dlhfkh[Zqv_c
ex[\blh `_hlghkblky dhfgh]bf ^jm]bf`b\hlguf\_^msbf
]jmiih\hc h[jZa`bagbgZijbf_jd \hjhgZf]ZedZf[hevrbf
ihim]Zyf^bdbf ]mkyfb h[_avygZf
K dhrdZfb iheh`_gb_g_kdhevdh bgh_\k_ ba\_klgu_fg_
gZklhysb_ ex[bl_eb kh[Zddjhf_ lh]hb ij_djZkgu_agZlhdb
bogh kdZaZlv lh]h `_ h ex[bl_eyo dhr_d y g_ fh]m
>moh\guc fbjdhrdb mlhgq_gb ^bdhg g_jZkdju\Z_lky i_j_^
ex^vfbgZ\yau\Zxsbfb `b\hlguf k\hx ex[h\vkh[Zdb \wlhf
hlghr_gbb [he__ ih^Zleb\u?keb \eZ^_e_p`b\hlgh]h mf__l
g_ gZ\yau\Zlv k\hx ex[h\v gZkbevghwlh fh`gh
kqblZlv
g_iehobf ^hdZaZl_evkl\hf gZklhys_]h ihgbfZgby `b\hlguo b
ijbjh^uDhrdZ g_\_^_l ]jmiih\hch[jZa `bagbhgZ hklZ_lky
g_aZ\bkbfhc^bdhc fZe_gvdhciZgl_jhcb \__ oZjZdl_j_ g_l
b ke_^Z lhc bgnZglbevghklb h^hfZrgb\ZgbydhlhjZy ^_eZ_l
kh[Zdm lZdbf[eZ]h^Zjguf h[t_dlhf^ey \gbfZgby b[Zeh\kl\Z
Gh fgh]b_
ex[bl_eb dhr_d
g_ ihgbfZxl
wlhc
dhrZqv_c
ihlj_[ghklb d g_aZ\bkbfhklbHrb[hqgh_ ml\_j`^_gb_[m^lh
^_j`Zlv [hevrmx kh[Zdm \ ]hjh^kdhc d\Zjlbj_ `_klhdhfu
keurbf ihklhygghgh
h dhrdZo fg_
wlh]h keurZlv
g_
^h\h^behkvGZ kZfhf`_ ^_e_ ^eykh[Zdb d\ZjlbjZg_ [he__
q_f \f_klbl_evgZy dhgmjZihkdhevdm ohaybg h[uqgh oh^bl
]meylv kh k\hbfikhf beb[_j_l _]hk kh[hcdh]^Z b^_lih
^_em>ey dhrdb`_ d\ZjlbjZ wlh ebrv[hevrZy de_ldZY g_
ohqm kdZaZlvqlh ^ey dhr_dhkh[_ggh ihjh^bkluolZdh_
aZdexq_gb_ fmqbl_evghgh hgbg_khfg_gghmljZqb\Zxl lm
g_h[ma^Zggmx ^bdhklvdhlhjZy ^ey f_gy ebqgh khklZ\ey_l
]eZ\gh_ bo hqZjh\Zgb_Y g_ mklZx ^b\blvky lhfmqlh
jZa^_eyx k\hc^hf kfbgbZlxjgufb lb]jZfbdhlhju_ ijboh^yl b
moh^yldh]^Z bf\a^mfZ_lkydhlhju_ hohlylky bmkljZb\Zxl
k\hb ex[h\gu_ ^_eZlZdkeh\gh \k_ _s_`b\ml i_j\ha^Zgghc
`bagvx \ ^bdbo e_kZoDh]^Z mljhf fhc[hevrhc ihehkZluc
LhfZk
,,gZiheh\bgm
Zg]hjkdbc
dhl\_ebq_kl\_ggh
\ha\jZsZ_lky ^hfhc ev\bghc ihoh^dhc\_kv \
aZi_dr_cky
djh\bk
bkpZjZiZgghc fhj^hc
b \gh\v
jZkihehkh\Zgguf
fgh]hkljZ^Zevguf mohffg_ hq_gv ohl_ehkvmagZlvdlh [ue
_]h ijhlb\gbdhf \iheghqghf ih_^bgd_b fbehklbdZdhc ^Zfu
hgb hkiZjb\ZebF_gy
\k_]^Z ihjZ`Zehqlh
^h[jh^mrgh_
eZkdh\h_ kms_kl\hdhlhjh_ [Zkbklh fmjeuq_l m f_gy
gZ
dhe_gyowlhl lhl`_ m]jxfuc jZa[hcgbdqvb `mldb_ \hieb
y keurZeg_kdhevdh qZkh\gZaZ^ gZmebp_
G_kl_kg_ggZy
k\h[h^Zdhlhjhc
ihevam_lky
ih^h[guc
h[blZl_ev \Zr_]h ^hfZgbqmlv g_mf_gvrZ_l _]haZ\bkbfhklb
hl q_eh\_dZKZfu_ ]hj^u_ bk\h_gjZ\gu_ bafhbo dhlh\ohly
hgb b `beb k\h_c hkh[hc ^bdhc `bagvx bkemqZehkvih
g_kdhevdh ^g_c
g_ \ha\jZsZebkv
^hfhcl_f
g_
f_g__
hlebqZebkv m^b\bl_evghc eZkdh\hklvx?keb `b\hlgh_eZklblky
d \Zfkb^bl m \Zk gZ dhe_gyo b l_jibldh]^Z \u_]h
]eZ^bl_wlh \h\k_ g_ ijbagZd ih^ebgghc
ijb\yaZgghklb
hkh[_ggh dh]^Z j_qvb^_l hdhrd_?klv lhevdh h^bgkihkh[
magZlvp_gbl `b\hlgh_ \Zr_h[s_kl\h \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklbbeb
g_l\havfbl_ _]h k kh[hc gZ mebpmb imklvhgh kZfh
j_rblhklZlvky ebk \Zfb bebihclb k\h_c^hjh]hcH[Z fhbo
fheh^uo dhlZLhfZk ,b LhfZk ,,dhlhjuo y
kZf\ujZklbe
magZ\Zeb f_gy gZmebp_^Z`_ dh]^Z klZebkh\k_f \ajhkeufb
H[Z ijb\_lkl\h\Zeb f_gy
hkh[uf a\_gysbf ]m[guf
djbdhf
njjdhlhjuc \ajhkeu_dhrdb \ujZ`Zxlbkdj_ggxx ex[h\vb
h[Z khijh\h`^Zeb f_gy \ ^ebl_evguoijh]medZo ihhdj_klguf
e_kZf<h \j_fy
ih^h[guo wdkdmjkbcdhg_qghke_^m_l
mqblu\ZlvdZdhc
imlv \u[jZeZ
[u kZf
dhrdZG_evay
lj_[h\Zlvqlh[u
hgZ
i_j_k_dZeZ
rbjhdb_
hldjulu_
ijhkljZgkl\Z]^_ _cg_]^_ mdjulvkyb ]^_hgZ fh`_lklZlv
`_jl\hc
i_j\hc
\klj_qghc
kh[ZdbB
\hl
ijboh^blky
ijh[bjZlvky q_j_a ]mklhcih^e_khdijbkihkZ[eb\Zy k\hc rZ]
d dhrZqv_c ihoh^d_I_j\h_ \j_fy ym^b\eyekydZd [ukljh
mlhfey_lky b gZqbgZ_l hlklZ\Zlv lZdh_dj_idh_a^hjh\h_ b
kbevgh_ `b\hlgh_Dhfm ba
fhbo qblZl_e_c
ijboh^behkv
\b^_lvqlh[u dhrdZly`_eh ^urZeZb \ukh\u\ZeZyaudlhqgh
kh[ZdZ"Aj_ebs_ ihbklbg_ j_^qZcr__Gh \ajhkeZy\iheg_
a^hjh\Zy b ihegZy kbe dhrdZ m`_q_j_a iheqZkZkh\_jr_ggh
\ufZlu\Z_lky^Z`_ _keb q_eh\_daZ dhlhjufhgZ ke_^m_l
b^_l g_lhjhieb\uf rZ]hfIhwlhfm]meyy k dhrdZfbg_
ih^\_j]Zcl_ boih^h[guf bkiulZgbyfbeb hgb kdhjhhldZ`mlky
hl wlbo ijh]mehdH^gZdh_keb \ \u[hj_imlb \umql_l_
\dmku k\h_]h ihehkZlh]h^jm]Z bijbkihkh[bl_kv d_]h rZ]m
\u kfh`_l_ m\b^_lv g_fZeh ex[hiulgh]hhkh[_ggh ijhimklb\
_]h \i_j_^b ke_^myaZ gbf[_krmfgh klmiZy[hkufb gh]Zfb
Hg \b^blkeurbl b qm_l fgh`_kl\h kZfuo jZaguo \_s_c
dhlhju_ [_a g_]h mkdhevagmeb [u hl \Zr_]h\gbfZgby>h
q_]h hklhjh`gh bhiZkeb\h ijh[bjZ_lkyhg \i_j_^]hlh\uc \
ex[hc fb] h[jZlblvky\ [_]kl\hD g_kqZklvxgZ[ex^Zlv aZ
l_fdZd hg hohlblkym^Z_lky hq_gv j_^dhihlhfm qlh
k_jv_agZy hohlZgZqbgZ_lky lhevdh\ kmf_jdZo
Fgh]b_ fhbdhlu b hkh[_ggh dhrdb^hfZ [ueb]hjZa^h
eZkdh\__ h[hbo LhfZkh\gh _keb fu\klj_qZebkv gZmebp_
gbdlh bagbo g_h[jZsZe gZ f_gygb fZe_cr_]h \gbfZgbyHgb
[_kp_j_fhggh ihdZau\Zeb
fg_ kibgmb g_
lhevdh
g_
ijb\_lkl\h\Zeb f_gy a\hgdbf njjgh \hkijbgbfZeb
dZd
gZ]emx gZahceb\hklv ex[mx ihiuldm ijbkh_^bgblvky d gbf
kdhevdh [u klZjZgbc y gb ijbeZ]Zeqlh[u ijh^_eZlvwlh
g_aZf_lgh
Y hlgx^v g_ klZ\ex k_[_ p_evx ^hdZaZlvqlh dhrdm
g_evay ^_j`Zlv\ ]hjh^kdhc d\Zjlbj_=hjh^kdb_ `bl_ebb lZd
kebrdhf
fZeh
khijbdZkZxlky
k
ijbjh^hcb djZkb\Zy
g_bkihjq_ggZy dhrdZdhg_qghijbg_k_l gZmebpu ]hjh^Z__
hl[e_kdH^gZdh y ml\_j`^Zxqlh hsmlblv \k_hqZjh\Zgb_
dhrdb fh`ghlhevdh ij_^hklZ\b\ _c ihegmxk\h[h^m: fhb
kZfu_ ijbylgu_ \hkihfbgZgby h dhrdZo k\yaZgu k
lbobfb
e_kgufb ijh]medZfb\ h[s_kl\_dhlZB _s_y ml\_j`^Zxqlh
aZ\h_\Zlv gZklhysmxZ g_ dZ`msmxky ex[h\v dhrdbfh`gh
lhevdh _keb g_ f_rZlv _c `blv gZ __ kh[kl\_gguceZ^ b
lZdlbqgh bkdZlv
__ h[s_kl\Z
\ _kl_kl\_gghc
^ey
g__
h[klZgh\d_H^gh\j_f_ggh ijboh^blky kfbjblvky kl_fqlh
hlghkykv k
lZdbf m\Z`_gb_f
d \gmlj_ggbf
ihlj_[ghklyf
dhrdb\u ih^\_j]Z_l_ __ \k_f hiZkghklyfdhlhju_ fh]ml
]jhablv wlhfmfZe_gvdhfm obsgbdmGb h^bgba fhbodhlh\ g_
mf_j _kl_kl\_gghckf_jlvxLhfZk ,m]h^be eZihc\ dZidZg b
ih]b[ hl aZjZ`_gby djh\bZ LhfZk ,,iZe `_jl\hck\hbo
hohlgbqvbo kljZkl_c hg aZ^mrbe g_kdhevdh djhebdh\ \h
^\hj_ khk_^g_]h n_jf_jZb lhlaZklb]gm\ _]h gZf_kl_
ij_klmie_gbylml `_k gbfjZa^_eZekyGh lZdh\Z m`ijbjh^Z
ev\h\lb]jh\ bhjeh\qlh hgbj_^dh h[j_lZxl fbjgucdhg_p
B lZdh\Z `_ kmsghklv dhrdbaZ dhlhjmx y __ ex[ex
aZfdgmlh]h \ k_[_g_mdjhlbfh]h
^bdh]h a\_jyDZd
gb
kljZgghbf_ggh wlbf h[tykgy_lky b ^hfZrgyy
mxlghklv
dhrdblZd dZd ihgZklhys_fm hsmsZ_l ^hflhevdh lhldlh
ijh\h^bl [hevrmx qZklv `bagb \g_ _]hkl_gB fmjeudZxsZy
dhrdZ mlhiys_cky i_qdb dZ`_lkygZf kbf\hehf^hfZrg_]h mxlZ
bf_ggh ihlhfmqlh hgZ g_ie_ggbpZZ g_aZ\bkbfh_ kms_kl\h
ihqlb jZ\gh_ fg_ b ijhklh ihk_eb\r__kyih^ h^ghckh fghc
djur_c
@B<HLGU?DHLHJU? E=ML
< ke_^mxs_c]eZ\_ y ^hdZ`mgZkdhevdh hrb[Zxlkyl_dlh
kqblZ_l dhrdmkZfh_ ]hj^h_b kZfh_q_klgh_ ba \k_ogZrbo
^hfZrgbo `b\hlguo dh\Zjghc h[fZgsbp_cH^gZdh y\h\k_ g_
kqblZxl
wlm
g_kihkh[ghklv
h[fZgu\Zlv
ijbagZdhf
ij_\hkoh^kl\Z dhrdbGZh[hjhlwlh mf_gb_k\hckl\_ggh_
kh[ZdZfgZ fhc\a]ey^^hdZau\Z_lqlh hgb\ ikbobq_kdhf
hlghr_gbb klhyl ]hjZa^h \ur_G_l gbdZdbo khfg_gbcqlh
mfgu_ kh[Zdb \dZdhclh kl_i_gbmf_xl ijbl\hjylvkyb gb`_
y ijb\_^mijbf_ju lZdh]hih\_^_gbydhlhjh_ ygZ[ex^Ze
Fhc klZjuc;meebihiZ^Zy \]emih_ iheh`_gb_ij_djZkgh
hl^Z\Ze k_[_ \ wlhl hlq_l b \ lZdbo kemqZyo ijhy\eye
g_h[uqZcgh_ b kh\_jr_ggh
g_h[tykgbfh_ ihgbfZgb_
\_kvfZ
keh`guo kblmZpbcMfgu_ kh[Zdb
y\gh agZxldh]^Z
hgb
hdZau\Zxlky kf_rgufb k lhqdb aj_gby q_eh\_dZB _kebgZ^
gbfb ijbwlhf kf_xlkyfgh]b_ ba gboijboh^yl \ yjhklvbeb
ih]jm`Zxlky \ mgugb_>`_d Ehg^hg \ k\h_c ij_\hkoh^ghc
kh[Zqv_cih\_klb ;_euc Deudhibku\Z_l lZdmxj_Zdpbx
bkihevamyhq_\b^ghkh[kl\_ggu_ gZ[ex^_gby< lh \j_fyh
dhlhjhf y ibrm;meeb [uem`_ hq_gvklZjb aj_gb_gZqZeh
baf_gylv _fmZ ihlhfm hg ^h\hevgh qZklheZye gZk\hbo
\dexqZy bf_gyY lZdlbqgh g_aZf_qZe _]hhrb[db b g_^_eZe
_fm \u]h\hjZqlh ih\_j]Zeh _]h \ ly]hklgh_
kfms_gb_
AZl_f
hg
ijh^_eZe
rlmdmdhlhjmx
y
kq_e
ijhkluf
kh\iZ^_gb_fgh ihlhf m[_^bekyqlh wlh[ueh khagZl_evgh_
bkdZ`_gb_ j_Zevguo nZdlh\lh _klv ieh^[e_klys_c jZ[hlu
mfZY hldjue dZebldm b _s_ g_mki_e __ijbl\hjblvdZd
;meeb k ]jhfdb_ eZ_f [jhkbeky dh fg_MagZ\ f_gyhg gZ
k_dmg^m aZf_j \ jZkl_jygghf kfms_gbbZ ihlhfaZ^_\ fhx
gh]mihfqZeky
^Zevr_ d
dZebld_i_j_[_`Ze
^hjh]m b
ijh^he`Ze yjhklgh eZylv m \hjhl gZr_]h khk_^Zkeh\gh k
kZfh]h gZqZeZZ^j_kh\Ze k\hbm]jhau ijh`b\Z\r_fm lZf\jZ]m
GZ wlhljZa y_fm ih\_jbej_rb\qlh djZldh_ kfms_gb_fg_
ihqm^behkv b yijhklh g_ihgye gZf_j_gbckh[ZdbM gZr_]h
khk_^Z b\ kZfhf^_e_ [uei_kk dhlhjuf;meeb \jZ`^h\ZeZ
ihlhfm hg ^_ckl\bl_evgh fh] h[eZb\Zlv wlh]h ikZZ g_
f_gyH^gZdh wlh gZqZeh ih\lhjylvky qmlv eb g_dZ`^uc
^_gvb y ijbr_e d \u\h^mqlh ;meebkhagZl_evgh bkdZe
\hafh`ghklv aZfZkdbjh\Zlv lhl]jmklguc nZdlqlh hgaZeZye
gZ ohaybgZB djZldh_ kfms_gb_dh]^Z hg\g_aZigh magZ\Ze
f_gyklZgh\behkv \k_ dhjhq_ b dhjhq_ ijhklh ohq_lky
kdZaZlvqlh hg e]Ze\k_ [he__ b [he__mf_ehL_i_jv
g_j_^dh kemqZehkvqlhmagZ\ f_gyb ijh[_`Z\fbfh[meeb
hdZau\Zeky lZf]^_ beZylvlh [ueh g_gZ qlhgZijbf_j\
imklhf m]em ^\hjZGh hghklZgZ\eb\Zeky bmk_j^gh eZyegZ
]emohc aZ[hj
Wlh ih\_^_gb_ fh`ghdhg_qghh[tykgblv k
ihfhsvx
nbabheh]bq_kdh]h klbfmeZgh[_kkihjghlml mqZkl\h\Zeb
bgl_ee_dl kh[Zdbb[h ;meeb ijb[_]Zed lhqghlZdhc `_e`b
kh\k_f ih ^jm]hfmih\h^m?fmdZd b\k_f hklZevgufgZrbf
kh[ZdZf[ueh aZij_s_gh]hgylvky aZ^hfZrg_c ilbp_cb ohly
hg kljZrghg_]h^h\Zedh]^Z dmjuijbgbfZebkv de_\Zlvba _]h
fbkdbgh
g_
hkf_eb\Zeky
bo
jZah]gZlv\_jg__g_
hkf_eb\Zeky k^_eZlv wlh hldjulhhg k \hafms_gguf eZ_f
db^Zeky \kZfmx bo]msmlZd qlhhgb [jhkZebkv \jZkkuigmx
hlqZyggh dm^ZolZy;meeb `_\f_klh lh]hqlh[u ih]gZlvky
aZ dZdhcgb[m^v dmjbp_c bihiulZlvky __ ko\Zlblvijh^he`Ze
[_`Zlv ih ijyfhcb eZylvlhqgh lZd`_dZd \l_o kemqZyo
dh]^Z hgh[eZb\Ze f_gyB lhqgh lZd`_ hg qZklhhdZau\Zeky
\ lZdhf m]em ^\hjZ]^_ eZylv [uehZ[khexlgh g_gZ qlh
<ijhq_f\ wlbokemqZyo mg_]h g_o\ZlZeh khh[jZabl_evghklb
ih^h[jZlv k_[_ dZdhcgb[m^v ^jm]hc h[t_dl ^eygZiZ^_gby
ihfbfh dmj
Kxab bah[j_eZ lhqgh lZdmx `_ obljhklvdh]^Z _c[ueh
\k_]h k_fv f_kyp_\?c m`Zkgh gjZ\blky jZkim]b\Zlv^bdh
dehoqmsbo dmj hgZ iju]Z_l\ kZfmxbo ]msmk aZeb\bkluf
eZ_fZ aZl_fgb gZk_dmg^m g_mfhedZyfqblky ^Zevr_ \
kZ^<ha\jZsZ_lky hgZ m^b\bl_evgh[ukljhk kZfuf g_\bgguf
\b^hfgh lml`_ ki_rblijbeZkdZlvky dhfg_\u^Z\Zyqlh
kh\_klv mg__ g_qbklZkh\k_f dZdfZe_gvdZy ^_\hqdZ
KlZkb ijZdlbdh\ZeZh[fZg ^jm]h]hjh^ZBa\_klghfgh]b_
kh[Zdb g_ lhevdh qm\kl\bl_evgu d nbabq_kdhc [hebgh b
ex[ylqlh[u
bo `Ze_ebb hq_gv
[ukljh
\umqb\Zxlky
aehmihlj_[eylv khqm\kl\b_f fy]dhk_j^_qguo ex^_cDZdlh
dh]^Z KlZkbkhijh\h`^ZeZ f_gy \\_ehkbi_^ghc ih_a^d_m g__
hl i_j_mlhfe_gby\hkiZebehkv kmoh`beb_e_\hc i_j_^g_c eZiu
HgZ aZojhfZeZb g_kdhevdh ^g_c y ^he`_g [ue
\oh^blv
i_rdhfIha`_ y \k_\j_fy ke_^beg_ mlhfbeZkveb hgZb
j_adh kgb`Ze kdhjhklv_^\Z hgZ gZqbgZeZ
ijbojZfu\Zlv
KlZkb hq_gv [ukljh khh[jZabeZ\ q_f ^_ehb klhbehfg_
l_i_jv k\_jgmlv gZ ^hjh]mdhlhjZy _c g_gjZ\beZkvdZd
hgZ g_f_^e_ggh gZqbgZeZ ijbiZ^Zlv gZ e_\mxeZimDh]^Z y
hlijZ\eyeky ba
^hfm \
]hkiblZev]^_
_c
ij_^klhyeh
g_kdhevdh qZkh\ klhjh`blv
fhc \_ehkbi_^hgZ
gZqbgZeZ
ojhfZlv lZd `Zehklghqlh
ijhoh`b_ g_]h^mxs_ gZ
f_gy
ih]ey^u\ZebH^gZdh klhbehgZf ih\_jgmlv\ klhjhgmfZg_`Z
qlh hagZqZehaZ]hjh^gmx ijh]medmdZd [hev\ eZi_ ijhiZ^ZeZ
[_a ke_^ZHkh[_ggh ijhajZqghcwlZ obljhklvklZgh\beZkv ih
km[[hlZfMljhf ih ^hjh]_gZ kem`_[gucihkl [_^gZykh[ZqdZ
_e_ dh\ueyeZ aZ\_ehkbi_^hf gZlj_o eZiZogh ^g_fdh]^Z
fu hlijZ\eyebkv gZ ^\Z^pZlbdbehf_ljh\mx ijh]medmb y_oZe
hq_gv [ukljhKlZkb g_ [_`ZeZihaZ^b \_ehkbi_^ZZ fqZeZkv
\i_j_^b ih ^Z\gh agZdhfuf ljhiZfH^gZdh \ ihg_^_evgbd
ojhfhlZ \ha\jZsZeZkv
< aZdexq_gb_ y jZkkdZ`m
^\_ g_[hevrb_ bklhjbb\
dhlhjuo ^_ckl\mxl g_kh[ZdbZ h[_avyguL_f g_ f_g__wlb
bklhjbb lml \iheg_ mf_klgulZd dZd hgb^hdZau\Zxlqlh
gZb[he__ mfgu_ `b\hlgu_kihkh[gu be]Zlv bihgbfZlvdh]^Z
bf e]ml
Ijhn_kkhj <hevn]Zg] D_e_jqvb bkke_^h\Zgbybgl_ee_dlZ
rbfiZga_ ijbg_keb _fmfbjh\mx ba\_klghklvdZdlh ihklZ\be
i_j_^
fheh^uf
kZfphfrbfiZga_
deZkkbq_kdmx
aZ^Zqm
k
ih^\_r_gghc d ihlhedm ]jha^v [ZgZgh\dhlhjmx
h[_avyg_
iheZ]Zehkv ^hklZlvijb^\bgm\ ih^ [ZgZgu klhysbc \m]em
ysbdRbfiZga_ hkfhlj_ekyihlhf ih\_jgmekyg_ dysbdmZ
d ijhn_kkhjm b ko\Zlbe _]h aZ jmdmGZ^h kdZaZlvqlh
fbfbdZ b `_klu rbfiZga_ gZ j_^dhklv \ujZabl_evgu@_eZy
iha\Zlv dm^Zgb[m^v ^jm]h]hrbfiZga_ bebq_eh\_dZdhlhjuc
ihevam_lky bo jZkiheh`_gb_fhgb bkimkdZxl
ijhkbl_evgu_
a\mdb b lygml _]h aZ jmdmIjb[_]gm\ d wlhfm f_lh^m
fheh^hc rbfiZga_ ih\_eijhn_kkhjZ D_e_jZ\ ijhlb\hiheh`guc
m]he dhfgZluIjhn_kkhj ih^qbgyeky gZklhygbyf `b\hlgh]h
ihlhfm qlh ohl_emagZlvq_f hgh lZdaZbgl_j_kh\ZehkvHg
g_ aZf_lbeqlh _]h \_^ml ijyfh d [ZgZgZfb jZa]Z^Ze
bklbggu_ gZf_j_gby rbfiZga_lhevdh dh]^Zlhl \kdZjZ[dZeky
ih g_fmlhqgh ih ^j_\_kghfmkl\hemwg_j]bqgh hllhedgmeky
hl _]h eukbguko\Zlbe [ZgZgub [uelZdh\RbfiZga_ j_rbe
aZ^Zqm gh\ufb [he__hkljhmfguf kihkh[hf
>hiheg_gb_f d wlhcbklhjbb hrbfiZga_dhlhjuc h[fZgme
agZf_gblh]h ikboheh]Zkem`bl bklhjby hjZg]mlZg]Zdhlhjh]h
h[fZgme
fhc
^jm]
YIhjl_ev_^bj_dlhj :fkl_j^Zfkdh]h
ahhiZjdZHjZg]mlZg] [uedjmiguf kZfphfk KmfZljuIhcfZeb
_]h m`_ \ajhkeufb l_i_jv hg `be \hq_gv ijhklhjghcb
\ukhdhc de_ld_DZd \k_ hjZg]mlZg]bhg [uee_gb\bqlh[u
mkljZb\Zlv _fm jZafbgdmIhjl_ev_ ^Ze mdZaZgb_
klhjh`m
dhjfblv _]hihg_fgh]mZ _^mklZ\blv gZ\_jo de_ldbLZdbf
h[jZahfh[_avyg_ ijboh^behkv dZjZ[dZlvky \\_jo b
\gba
\kydbc jZadh]^Z _c
ohl_ehkv kt_klv dmkhq_d
[ZgZgZ
Ih\b^bfhfmbf_y ^_eh khjZg]mlZg]Zfbg_h[oh^bfh dZdbflh
h[jZahf
bfblbjh\Zlv
ljm^ghklb
_kl_kl\_gghc
[hjv[u aZ
kms_kl\h\Zgb_qlh[u
ijbgm^blv
`b\hlgh_
ih[hevr_
^\b]Zlvky\hafh`gh ^Z`_qlh ikboheh]bq_kdh_\ha^_ckl\b_
wlhc
_kl_kl\_gghc
jZ[hlu_s_
\Z`g__
nbabq_kdh]h
Ijb\uqdm hjZg]mlZg] \e_aZlv aZ _^hc ih^ ihlhehdklhjh`Z
bkihevah\Zeb b ^ey lh]hqlh[u qbklblvde_ldmihdZ h^bg
dhjfbe gZ\_jom h[_avygm^jm]hc k ihfhsvxr\Z[ju b\_^jZ
\h^u [ukljh ijb\h^be\ ihjy^hd^_j_\ygguc iheH^gZ`^u wlZ
^h\hevgh jbkdh\ZggZy ijhp_^mjZ fh]eZ [uijb\_klb d\_kvfZ
i_qZevguf ihke_^kl\byf_keb [u g_ ijbkmlkl\b_^moZ bg_
gZoh^qb\hklv Ihjl_ev_IhdZ klhjh`ijhlbjZe ihehjZg]mlZg]
\g_aZigh kdhevagme \gba ih ijmlvyf de_ldb bij_`^_ q_f
m^Zehkv aZ^\bgmlv ^\_jvfh]mqZy h[_avygZijhkmgmeZ \s_ev
h[_ jmdbOhly Ihjl_ev_ bklhjh` gZijy]Zeb\k_ kbeuqlh[u
aZ^\bgmlv ^\_jvhjZg]mlZg] f_^e_gghgh \_jghkZglbf_lj
aZ kZglbf_ljhf hlh^\b]Ze __ gZaZ^Dh]^Z hg m`_ ihqlb
ijhlbkgmeky \hl\_jklb_Ihjl_ev_ ijbreZ\ ]heh\m[e_klysZy
fukevdhlhjZy fh]eZ hk_gblv lhevdh ih^ebggh]h
agZlhdZ
ikbobdb `b\hlguohg \g_aZigh hlimklbe^\_jv bhlkdhqbe k
]jhfdbf djbdhf\ ijbl\hjghf m`Zk_]ey^y gZqlhlh ihaZ^b
hjZg]mlZg]ZH[_avygZ
klj_fbl_evgh
h[_jgmeZkvqlh[u
ihkfhlj_lvqlh ijhbkoh^bl aZ __ kibghcb ^\_jvlml `_
aZoehigmeZkvHjZg]mlZg] lhevdh
q_j_a g_kdhevdh
k_dmg^
khh[jZabeqlh lj_\h]Z[ueZ nZevrb\hcgh dh]^Zhg ihgye
qlh _]h h[fZgmeblh ijbr_e \ gZklhys__bkklmie_gb_b
g_khfg_gghjZahj\Ze [uh[fZgsbdZ \dehqvy_keb [u ^\_jv
g_ [ueZm`_ gZ^_`ghaZi_jlZHg kh\_jr_gghykgh ihgyeqlh
klZe `_jl\hcij_^gZf_j_gghc e`b
DHR:QVY G:LMJ:
FZdZ\blbFZdZ\blbdhl ]hj^ucb
lZbgkl\_gguc
Dh\Zj_g hgb \djZ^qb\hgb \
fbj_
hg _^bgkl\_gguc
LWebhl
<ujZ`_gb_ dhrZqvy gZlmjZ\ ijbf_g_gbb d
q_eh\_dm
h[uqgh ih^jZamf_\Z_l dh\Zjkl\hb obljhklvqZs_ \k_]hwlh
hij_^_e_gb_ ^Z_lky ij_^klZ\bl_evgbpZfij_djZkgh]h iheZY
qZklh klZjZeky ihgylvihq_fm dhrdZ ijbh[j_eZ ih^jh[gmx
j_imlZpbx<h
\kydhf kemqZ___ fZg_jZ
hohlblvky
[_krmfgh_ \uke_`b\Zgb_ ^h[uqblml gb ijbq_fihkdhevdm
ba\_klghqlh ev\u b lb]ju
^h[uqb lml gb
ijbq_f
ihkdhevdm ba\_klghqlh ev\u blb]ju hohlylkylhqgh lZd`_
h^gZdh gbdhfm b \ ]heh\m g_ ijb^_lgZa\Zlv lb]jbp_cbeb
ev\bp_c e`b\mx b
aehdhag_ggmx kie_lgbpmBgZh[hjhl
h[uqguc wibl_l ev\h\ b lb]jh\ djh\h`Z^gucgbdlh g_
ijbf_gy_lky d ^hfZrgbfdhrdZfohly hgb lh`_m[b\Zxl k\hx
^h[uqm
< ]eZ\_@b\hlgu_dhlhju_ e]mly baeh`be\k_qlh fg_
ba\_klgh h gZklhysbo h[fZgZolh _klv h
khagZl_evghf
ijbl\hjkl\_Y l\_j^h
m[_`^_gqlh ih^h[gh_
ih\_^_gb_
ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ]b]Zglkdh_ihqlb g_\_jhylgh_^hklb`_gb_
`b\hlgh]h bgl_ee_dlZG_dhlhju_ ba fhbodhee_]\hafh`gh
k khfg_gb_fhlg_kmlky d ijb\_^_gguffghx ijbf_jZfb khqlml
qlh bo kebrdhf fZeh ^ey ih^l\_j`^_gby fh_]h \u\h^Z
h
khagZl_evghf `mevgbq_kl\_ khklhjhgu `b\hlguoh dhlhjuoy
jZkkdZaZeH^gZdh y gb
jZam g_ gZ[ex^Ze
ZgZeh]bqgh]h
ih\_^_gb_ mdhr_dohly kwlbfb `b\hlgufby h[sZeky lZd`_
l_kghdZd kkh[ZdZfbb ihqlb lZd`_ ^he]hB yg_ agZxgb
h^gh]h kemqZy lbibqgh]hih\_^_gby dhrdbba dhlhjh]hfh`gh
[ueh ohly [u ih hrb[d_ k^_eZlv \u\h^qlh hgbe`b\u b
dh\Zjgu: \ lh `_ \j_fy kms_kl\mxl `b\hlgu_dhlhjuf
^_ckl\bl_evgh k\hckl\_ggh ih\_^_gb_gZ\h^ys__ gZ fukev
[m^lh hgb ijb[_]Zxld khagZl_evghfmh[fZgmohly gZ kZfhf
^_e_ gbq_]hih^h[gh]h g_l
G_dhlhju_ kh[Zdb gZklhevdh im]eb\uqlh gb \
dh_f
kemqZ_ g_ iha\heyl ihklhjhgg_fm q_eh\_dm ^hljhgmlvky ^h
k_[y y [u ^Z`_ kdZaZeqlh ^ey gbo wlh
nbabq_kdb
g_\hafh`ghIh^h[gu_ kh[Zdb g_j_^dhijbgbfZxl ijbgb`_ggmx
ihamqlh bijb\h^bl d g_^hjZamf_gbyflZd dZdijb wlhf hgb
^Z`_ ihqlbl_evgh\beyxl o\hklhfLhevdh hiulguc gZ[ex^Zl_ev
aZf_lblqlh kh[ZdZ iulZ_lky ba[_`Zlvijbdhkgh\_gby b\k_
iehlg__
ijb`bfZ_lky
d
a_fe_
ih^
jmdhcdhlhjZy ih
g_ihgylghc ^ey g__ ijbqbg_ klj_fblky __ ih]eZ^blv?keb
[_klZdlguc q_eh\_d [m^_l g_hklhjh`ghijh^he`Zlv gZ\yau\Zlv
_c k\hb eZkdbi_j_im]ZggZy kh[ZdZ fh`_lmljZlblv \eZklv
gZ^ kh[hc b fhegb_ghkgh jZkihehkh\Zlv[_kp_j_fhggmx jmdm
<h fgh]bo kemqZyokh[Zqvb ihdmkuhlghkylky bf_gghd lZdh]h
jh^Z mdmkZf ba kljZoZ@_jl\u `_ ih^h[gh]h gZiZ^_gby
hkh[_ggh h[b`Zxlky gZkh[Zdmihlhfm qlh lZ\gZqZe_ \beyeZ
o\hklhf
Ih\_^_gb_
f_^\_^_c
lh`_ e_]dh ih^^Z_lky
g_\_jghfm
bklhedh\Zgbxohly b g_kdhevdh ihbghfmlZd qlh
wlbo
`b\hlguo fh`gh aZde_cfblv hij_^_e_gb_fdh\Zjgu_F_^\_^b
`b\ml \h^bghqdm\gmljbf_^\_`vbhlghr_gby jZa\blufZehZ
ihlhfm fZeh jZa\blu m gb b kj_^kl\Z \ujZ`_gby wfhpbc
LheklZy dh`Zf_^\_`vbo fhj^g_ kihkh[kl\m_ljZa\blbx fbfbdb
fZe_gvdb_ mrdbkijylZggu_ \]mklhc r_jklbg_ ih^\_j]Zxlky
hiZkghklb \h \j_fy
^jZd jZkk_j`_gguc f_^\_^v
gZghkbl
\g_aZiguc m^Zj eZihcgh g_ dmkZ_lb ihlhfm f_^\_^b
hlghkylky d \_kvfZ
fZehqbke_gghc ]jmii_
fe_dhiblZxsbo
dhlhju_\iZ^Zy \yjhklvg_ ijb`bfZxlmr_c d]heh\_>jm]b_
\ujZ`_gby bo wfhpbc lh`_ g_ kebrdhf[jhkZxlky \]eZaZZ
]eZ\gh_ g_ ihoh`bgZ kh[Zqvbb \j_amevlZl_dh]^Z ex^b
khh[jZ`Zxlqlh f_^\_^v
jZkk_j`_g[u\Z_l m`_
iha^gh
<^h[Z\hd ijbjmq_ggu_f_^\_^b kdehggu dgbq_f g_\ua\Zgguf b
g_ij_^kdZam_fuf ijbiZ^dZfyjhklbHdjm]eu_ nhjfub aZ[Z\gZy
g_mdex`_klv a^hjh\h]h f_^\_^yijb^Zxl _fm\g_rg__ koh^kl\h
k
hij_^_e_gguf
lbihf
^h[jh^mrguo
lheklydh\b
fu
ih^khagZl_evgh g_h`b^Z_f \g_aZiguo\kiur_d aeh[u hllZdh]h
\_k_eh]hlheklh]h b mxlgh]h kms_kl\ZOhjg^_c^bj_dlhj
h^gh]h ba
Zf_jbdZgkdbo ahhiZjdh\
b ijbagZgguc
agZlhd
ih\_^_gby f_^\_^_cgZau\Z_l ijbjmq_gguo f_^\_^_c kZfufb
hiZkgufb ba \k_o kh^_j`Zsboky \ g_\he_ `b\hlguo?keb
l\hc \jZ]l_[_ g_gZ\bkl_gih^Zjb _fmjmqgh]h f_^\_`hgdZ
[eZ]h`_eZl_evgh j_dhf_g^m_lhg< k\h_c ij_e_klghcdgb]_
Mf
b
ih\Z^db
^bdbo
`b\hlguoOhjg^_c
hibku\Z_l
^_ckl\bl_evgh m`Zkgu_ kemqZbdh]^Z ijbjmq_ggu_
f_^\_^b
\^jm] \uoh^beb bo ih\bgh\_gbyijbq_f g_j_^dh wlh [ueb
ihem\ajhkeu_
f_^\_`ZlZF_^\_^vdhlhjuc^_j`Z mrb
lhjqdhf b g_ kdZey am[ukihdhcgh _kl y[ehdh ba
jmd
ohaybgZZ k_dmg^m kimkly [v_l _]h `_e_agufbdh]lyfb ih
]heh\_dZ`_lky dh\Zjguf b obljuflZd qlh ml\_j`^_gb_
Ohjg^_y[m^lh f_^\_^b\k_]^Z ghkylfZkdm\iheg_ ihgylgh
L_f g_ f_g__ hgh b g_\_jghb g_kijZ\_^eb\hihkdhevdm
f_^\_^v \lZdbo kemqZyo \h\k_g_ ijbl\hjy_lkyG_ _]h\bgZ
qlhijbgZ^e_`Z d `b\hlguf`b\msbf \ h^bghq_kl\_hg
ijhklh g_ jZkiheZ]Z_l aZiZkhf \ujZabl_evguo ^\b`_gbck
ihfhsvx
dhlhjuo
^jm]b_
`b\hlgu_
k
[he__ \ujZ`_gguf
]jmiih\uf ih\_^_gb_fkhh[sZxl k_[_ih^h[guf hk\hbo wfhpbyo
M ydh[u dh\Zjghcdhrdb lZdb_\ujZabl_evgu_ ^\b`_gby
jZa\blu hkh[_ggh kbevghFZeh gZc^_lky^jm]bo `b\hlguoih
qv_c fhj^_ hiulguc gZ[ex^Zl_ev fh`_l k lZdhc lhqghklvx
hij_^_eblv bo gZkljh_gb_ b ij_^kdZaZlv\ dZdb_^_ckl\by
^jm`_kdb_ beb \jZ`^_[gu_hgh kdhj__\k_]h \uev_lkyFhj^Z
dhrdb klhev ykgh
b g_^\mkfuke_ggh hljZ`Z_l
f_evqZcrb_
hll_gdb \gmlj_gg_]h khklhygby`b\hlgh]hqlh q_eh\_dohlv
g_fgh]h agZdhfuck dhrdZfbkjZam fh`_lkdZaZlvdZd ^ZggZy
dbkdZ d g_fmhlghkblky<_^v hq_gv e_]dhihgylv \ujZ`_gb_
^h\_jqb\h]h ^jm`_ex[bydh]^ZihklZ\b\ mrblhjqdhf b rbjhdh
jZkdju\ ]eZaZdhrdZ h[jZsZ_l d \Zfkihdhcgmxgbqmlv g_
gZfhjs_ggmx fhj^hqdmb ^h q_]h y\gh fbfbq_kdb_
furpu
\hkijhba\h^yl dZ`^mxijh[m`^Zxsmxky wfhpbxgZijbf_jkljZoZ
beb
\jZ`^_[ghklbIhehkdb
gZ
fhj^_
dhrdb k ^bdhc
jZkdjZkdhcih^q_jdb\Zxl fZe_crb_ ^\b`_gbyfbfbq_kdbo furp
\hkijhba\h^yl dZ`^mxijh[m`^Zxsmxky wfhpbbgZijbf_jkljZoZ
beb
\jZ`^_[ghklbIhehkdb
gZ
fhj^_
dhrdb k ^bdhc
jZkdjZkdhcih^q_jdb\Zxl fZe_crb_^\b`_gby fbfbq_kdbofurp b
mkbeb\Zxl `b\hklv \ujZ`_gbyWlh h^gZba ijbqbgihq_fm y
ij_^ihqblZx ^hfZrgxx dhrdm^bdhclb]jh\hchdjZkdb \k_f
hklZevgufKZfuc e_]dbc aZqZlhd g_^h\_jbydhlhjh_ _s_g_
]eZaZ klZgh\ylkyfbg^Ze_\b^gufb bjZkdhkufbmrb hldehgyxlky
hl
\_jlbdZebb
gZ[ex^Zl_ev
kjZam
ihgbfZ_lqlh \
ikbobq_kdhf
khklhygbb
dhrdb
ijhbkoh^bl
hij_^_e_ggZy
i_j_f_gZ^Z`_ _keb\ __iha_ g_ijhbahreh gbdZdbobaf_g_gbc
Z dhgqbdo\hklZ g_gZqZe ke_]dZih^_j]b\Zlvky
M]jh`Zxsb_ ihau dhrdbgZ j_^dhklv\ujZabl_evgu bhq_gv
hlebqZxlky h^gZ hl^jm]hc \aZ\bkbfhklb hllh]hdhfm hgb
Z^j_kh\Zgu ^jm]mq_eh\_dmdhlhjuc iha\hebe k_[_ ebrg__
beb \gmrZxs_fm kljZo \jZ]mkh[Zd_Z fh`_l [ulv^jm]hc
dhrd_>Ze__
hgb jZaebqZxlky
\ aZ\bkbfhklb
hl lh]h
ijh^bdlh\Zgu eb hgb lhevdh klj_fe_gb_f aZsbsZlvkybeb aZ
gbfb klhbl m\_j_gghklv `b\hlgh]h \ k_[_ b
]hlh\ys__ky
gZiZ^_gb_Dhrdb \k_]^Z h[ty\eyxlh k\h_f gZf_j_gbbgZiZklv
b _keb bkdexqblvms_j[guo ikbohiZlh\dhlhju_ \klj_qZxlky
g_ lhevdhkj_^b kh[Zdgh bkj_^b dhr_dgbdh]^Z g_ dmkZxl
b
g_
pZjZiZxl
[_a
ij_^\Zjbl_evgh]h
g_^\mkfuke_ggh]h
ij_^mij_`^_gby \ Z^j_k \jZ]ZH[uqgh kl_i_gv m]jhau
\
\ujZabl_evguo ^\b`_gbyo gZjZklZ_l ihkl_i_gghihke_ q_]h
ke_^m_l
\g_aZigh_ij_m\_ebq_ggh
m]jh`Zxs__
^\b`_gb_
g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh
ij_^r_kl\mxs__
ZlZd_Wlhg_khfg_ggh
mevlbfZlmf?keb luf_gy g_hklZ\brv \ihdh_ g_f_^e_ggh
fg_d kh`Ze_gbxijb^_lky ijbgylvkhhl\_lkl\mxsb_ f_ju
DhrdZ m]jh`Z_l
kh[ZdZf b ^jm]bf hiZkguf
obsgbdZf
\u]b[Zy kibgmIjbgbfZy wlm deZkkbq_kdmxihamdhrdZ klhbl
gZ ijyfuogZijy`_ggh \ulygmluo
gh]Zo b
^_eZ_l
\k_
\hafh`gh_qlh[u dZaZlvkydZd fh`gh\ur_r_jklv gZ kibg_b
o\hkl_ m g__ lhihjsblvkyZ o\hkl hgZke_]dZ hl]b[Z_l\
klhjhgmlZdqlh[u \jZ] i_j_hp_gbe _]h jZaf_juMrb m
dhrdb ijb`Zlu d aZluedmm]hedb jlZ hllygmluZ
ghk
gZfhjs_gHgZ ba^Z_lhkh[h_ f_lZeebq_kdh_]jm^gh_ mjqZgb_
dhlhjh_ \j_fyhl \j_f_gbi_j_oh^bl \ ij_keh\mlh_rbi_gb_
lh _klv \
kbevgu_ \u^hob\
fhf_gl dhlhjuo
]hjlZgv
jZkrbjy_lkyZ am[uhkdZeb\ZxlkyWlZ ^_fhgkljZpby kZfZih
k_[_
ghkbl
h[hjhgbl_evguc
oZjZdl_j
b
qZs_
\k_]h
gZ[ex^Z_lkydh]^Z dhrdZ g_h`b^Zggh ^ey k_[yhdZau\Z_lky
fhj^Z dfhj^_ k[hevrhc kh[Zdhcb g_mki_\Z_l m[_`Zlv?keb
kh[ZdZij_g_[j_]Zy wlbf ij_^mij_`^_gb_fijb[ebablky
d
dhrd_lZ g_ ih[_`blZ [jhkblky \gZiZ^_gb__^\Z __\jZ]
i_j_klmibl hij_^_e_ggmxdjblbq_kdmx q_jlmHgZ \p_iblky \
fhj^m kh[Zd_dmkZy b pZjZiZy __ \kZfuo qm\kl\bl_evguo
f_klZop_eykv \ ]eZaZ b gha^jb?keb `_kh[ZdZ ijhy\bl
g_j_rbl_evghklvdhrdZ h[yaZl_evgh \hkihevam_lky wlbf
b
m[_`blBgZq_ ]h\hjylZdh_ djZldh_dhrZqv_ gZiZ^_gb_bf__l
p_evx \ub]jZlv
\j_fy ^ey
[_]kl\ZH^gZdh
kms_kl\m_l
kblmZpbydh]^Z gZiZ^_gb_ke_^mxs__ aZ wlhck]hj[e_gghc
ihahcfh`_l hdZaZlvky k_jv_aguf b ^ebl_evgufy bf_x\
\b^m dhrdmaZsbsZxsmx k\hbo dhlyl< wlhf kemqZ_ hgZ
[jhkZ_lky
gZ\klj_qm
\jZ]mdh]^Z
bo
_s_
jZa^_ey_l
agZqbl_evgh_
jZkklhygb_^\b]Zykv
\_kvfZ
k\h_h[jZaguf
]Zehihfqlh[u \k_\j_fy ih^klZ\eylvijhlb\gbdm ]jhaguc [hd
J_Zevgu_ kblmZpbbdh]^Z ijbf_gy_lky wlhl[hdh\hc ]Zehik
ih^\_jgmluf o\hklhfqj_a\uqZcgh j_^dbgh _]h fh`ghqZklh
gZ[ex^Zlv m b]jZxsbodhlylM dhlh\ g_ijboh^behkv \b^_lv
wlh ^\b`_gb_ lhevdh \h \j_fy b]julZd dZdg_ kms_kl\m_l
kblmZpbbijb dhlhjhchgb fh]eb[u \hkihevah\Zlvkybf ^ey
j_Zevguo p_e_cM dhjfys_c `_fZl_jbdhrdb lZdh_gZiZ^_gb_
[hdhf hagZqZ_lZ[khexlgmx ]hlh\ghklvih`_jl\h\Zlv kh[hcb \
wlbo kemqZyo dhrdZijZdlbq_kdb g_ih[_^bfZFg_ ijboh^behkv
\b^_lvdZd h]jhfgu_ikui_j_^mrb\rb_ gZk\h_f \_dm g_fZeh
dhr_di_j_^ lZdhc ZlZdhc [_`Zebih^`Z\ o\hklWjg_kl
K_lhgLhfikhg
qj_a\uqZcgh
\ujZabl_evgh
hibku\Z_l
hqZjh\Zl_evguc b[_a khfg_gby\iheg_ j_Zevguc wibah^
dh]^Z \ C_eehmklhgkdhf iZjd_ dhrdZfZlv h[jZlbeZ \[_]kl\h
f_^\_^y b ]gZeZkvaZ gbf^h l_oihjihdZ hg \m`Zk_ g_
\kdZjZ[dZeky gZ^_j_\h
M]jhaudhlhju_ ij_^r_kl\mxl ^jZd_f_`^m ^\mfy dhrdZfb
b hkh[_gghdhlZfbghkyl kh\k_fbghc oZjZdl_jgh g_ f_g__
\gmrbl_evguc b
bgl_j_kguc ^ey
gZ[ex^_gby kh
klhjhgu
@b\hlgu_ klhyl ^jm] ijhlb\ ^m]Z gZ \ulygmluo gh]Zogh
kibgm ihqlbg_ ]hj[ylb [hdhf g_ih\hjZqb\ZxlkyHgb klhyl
ghk d ghkm\hjqZ baZ\u\Zy a\mdb wlbg_khfg_ggh\k_f
agZdhfub oe_sml
o\hklZfb?keb g_ kqblZlv
wlh]h
^\b`_gby o\hklhfdhlu m^b\bl_evgh ^he]hkhojZgyxl ihegmx
g_ih^\b`ghklv bgh]^Z ihg_kdhevdh fbgmlDZ`^uc klZjZ_lky
kehfblv [h_\hc ^mo ijhlb\gbdZ^_ckl\my ihijbgpbim dlh
^hevr_
\u^_j`bl<k_
ijhqb_
^\b`_gbyb hkh[_ggh
ijh^\b`_gb_ \i_j_^ dhlZ[_jms_]h \_joijhba\h^ylky hq_gv
f_^e_ggh]hGZklmiZxsbc dhl ijh^\b]Z_lky aZh^bg ijb_fgZ
h^bg^\Z fbeebf_ljZijh^he`Zy
`mldbf ]hehkhf
\ui_\Zlv
m]jhau \kZfmx fhj^m ijhlb\gbdZb fh`_lijhclb hq_gvfgh]h
\j_f_gbij_`^_ q_f \kiuog_l fhegb_ghkgZy ^jZdZkebrdhf
klj_fbl_evgZy
^ey
q_eh\_q_kdh]h
]eZaZ<
jZkkdZa_
Dhjhe_\kdZy :gZehklZgdZK_lhgLhfikhg lZd yjdh
hibkZe
\_kv keh`gucp_j_fhgby ^jZdb^\mo dhlh\qlh ywlh]h a^_kv
^_eZlv g_[m^mqlh[u g_\iZklv \ieZ]bZl
?s_ h^bg lbi m]jh`Zxsbo
^\b`_gbck\yaZgguc g_
k
^_fhgkljZpb_c kbeuZ k
\ugm`^_gguf kfbj_gb_ffh`gh
gZ[ex^Zlvdh]^Z dhrdZg_ \kbeZo [hevr_\ughkblv eZkdh\uo
ih^^jZagb\Zgbc ohjhrh agZdhfh]h
_c q_eh\_dZWlhl
lbi
aZlhjfh`_gguo m]jhakhijh\h`^Zxsboky agZdZfb ihdhjghklb
qZs_ \k_]h fh`gh gZ[ex^Zlv gZ dhrZqvbo \uklZ\dZo]^_
`b\hlgu_ hdZau\Zxlky \ g_ijb\uqghc h[klZgh\d_b \ugm`^_gu
l_ji_lv ijbdhkgh\_gby km^_cb ^jm]bog_ agZdhfuobf ex^_c
< wlbo kemqZyo bkim]ZggZy dhrdZ ijbiZ^Z_l gZ\k_ q_luj_
eZiu b ihkl_i_ggh \`bfZ_lky \ iheMrb mg__ m]jh`Zxs_
ijb`Zlu d aZluedmZ dhgqbd o\hklZaeh[gh ih^_j]b\Z_lky
?keb _ckh\k_f g_ih k_[_hgZ bkimkdZ_lg_]jhfdh_ \hjqZgb_
< lZdhf gZkljh_gbbhgZ bs_lmdjulb_ b[jhkZ_lky ih^rdZn
aZ [ZlZj_x p_gljZevgh]hhlhie_gby bebbaex[e_ggh_ f_klh
dm^Z kiZkZxlkyiZpb_glu bak_f_ckl\Z dhrZqvbo\ \_l_jbgZjguo
e_q_[gbpZo\\_jo ih ^ufhoh^m?keb jy^hfih^oh^ys_]h
mdjulby g_ldhrdZ ijb`f_lkymd kl_g_b ey`_lgZ [hdLm `_
iham hgZ ijbf_lgZ klhe_`xjb dhrZqv_c\uklZ\dbIhaZ wlZ
hagZqZ_l ]hlh\ghklv [blv i_j_^gbfb eZiZfbQ_f
kbevg__
bkim] `b\hlgh]hl_f [hevr_ hgh eh`blky gZ [hdihdZ
gZdhg_p g_aZg_k_l eZim bg_ hkdZeblam[u]hlh\ykv i_j_clb
d ^_ckl\bx?keb kljZo _s_ [he__ mkbeblkywlZ j_Zdpby
lhedZ_l dhrdm gZ ihke_^gbc hlqZygguc kihkh[kZfhaZsblu hgZ i_j_dZlu\Z_lky gZ kibgmh[jZsZy ijhlb\ \jZ]Z
\k_
hjm`b_dZdbf jZkiheZ]Z_l
LZdhc
lbi
ih\_^_gby
qZklh
gZ[ex^Z_lky
\h \j_fy
km^_ckdh]h hkfhljZ gZ dhrZqvbo \uklZ\dZob kZfu_hiulgu_
\eZ^_evpu dhr_d m^b\eyxlkykihdhckl\bxk dZdbf bkdmr_gguf
km^vy hlghkblkyd wlbfm]jhaZf fZe_gvdhc obsgbpuijh^he`Zy
g_\hafmlbfh ljh]Zlv `b\hlgh_dhlhjh_ ih^gbfZ_l eZim^ey
m^ZjZ b aZ\h^bl yjhklgmx ]hjeh\mx i_kgxGh ohlydhrdZ
kh\_jr_ggh q_ldh aZy\ey_lG_ ljh]Zcf_gyg_ lh ygZqgm
\k_jv_a pZjZiZlvky b dmkZlvky\ djblbq_kdbc fb] hgZ
\k_lZdb g_gZiZ^Z_l beb`_ \djZcg_f kemqZ_^_ckl\m_l k\hbf
hjm`b_f ebrv\ihekbeub[h lhjfhaysb_kbkl_fuijbh[j_l_ggu_
ihkemrgufjmqguf `b\hlgufkihkh[gu \u^_j`Zlv^Z`_ lZdh_
`_klhdh_ bkiulZgb_>jm]bfb keh\ZfbdhrdZ \h\k_
g_
jZau]ju\Z_l ^jm`_ex[b_k l_f qlh[u\ m^h[gucfhf_gl gZqZlv
pZjZiZlvky b dmkZlvkyZgZh[hjhlimkdZ_l \oh^ m]jhau
qlh[u ba[Z\blvky hl g_\ughkbfuo k dhrZqv_clhqdb aj_gby
ijbklZ\Zgbc km^vbgh ijb\_klb wlbm]jhau \bkiheg_gb_ hgZ
g_ fh`_l
<hl ihq_fmy g_ \b`mdZd fh`ghijbibku\Zlv dh\Zjkl\h
dhrd_ `b\hlghfmdhlhjh_
\ujZ`Z_l k\hb
qm\kl\Z
k
ij_^_evghc ykghklvx?^bgkl\_ggh_ h[tykg_gb_dZdh_ y fh]m
gZclb wlhfm g_aZkem`_gghfm
h[\bg_gbx \ Z^j_k
^hfZrg_c
dhrdbg_ kebrdhf e_klgh_ ^ey jh^Z q_eh\_q_kdh]hbeb ih
djZcg_f f_j_ ^ey_]h ij_djZkghciheh\bgu>Z`_ g_kdehgguc
d Zgljhihfhjnbafm gZ[ex^Zl_ev\ukhdh p_gysbc [h_\hc^mo
aj_euo dhlh\g_ fh`_l g_ijbagZlvqlh fy]dh_ bays_kl\hbo
^\b`_gbcoZjZdl_jgh_ g_ lhevdh ^ey ^hfZrgbodhr_dgh b
^ey \k_o dhrZqvbo^_ckl\bl_evgh gZihfbgZ_l]jZg^bhaghklv
ijbkmsmx `_gsbgZfhij_^_e_ggh]h lbiZdhlhjuc b \wlhf b
aZdexqZ_lky kmlv fh_]h
eh]bq_kdh]hihkljh_gby Z[khexlgh
g_^hklmi_g gZr_fm ihgbfZgbxihgbfZgbx [_^guofm`qbggh \
lh `_ \j_fyhq_gv gZkijb\e_dZ_lZ ihlhfm \hkijbgbfZ_lky
gZfb dZd
hiZkgucBf_ggh
wlhl lbi
`_gsbgub^_Zevgh
\hiehs_gguc DZjf_ggZ\e_dZ_l gZk_[y khklhjhgu fm`qbgl_
h[\bg_gby \ e`b\hklb b dh\Zjkl\_dhlhjufb
i_j_iheg_gZ
fbjh\Zy ebl_jZlmjZbih fh_fm]em[hdhfm m[_`^_gbxdhr_d
gZau\Zxl dh\Zjgufb lhevdh ihlhfmqlh fgh]b_`_gsbgug_
f_g__ ]jZg^bhagu_q_f hgb^_ckl\bl_evgh
aZkem`b\Zxl
lZdh]h wibl_lZ
@B<HLGU?G:>?E?GGU? KH<?KLVX
AZ ljm^k\hc ^Zj
g_qbklhc kh\_klb\havfb
<R_dkibjJbqZj^ ,,
BklbggZy fhjZev \ \ukr_f q_eh\_q_kdhfihgbfZgbb wlh]h
keh\Z ij_^iheZ]Z_l lZdhc bgl_ee_dldhlhjh]h g_l gb
m
h^gh]h `b\hlgh]hbgZh[hjhlfhjZevgZy hl\_lkl\_gghklv
q_eh\_dZ g_ fh]eZ[u \hagbdgmlv_keb [uhgZ g_hibjZeZkv
gZ hij_^_e_ggu_ wfhpbhgZevgu_
hkgh\u>Z`_ m
q_eh\_dZ
hsms_gb_
hl\_lkl\_gghklb
moh^bl
dhjgyfb
\
]em[bggu_
bgklbgdlb\gu_ kehb _]hikbobdbb hg g_fh`_l [_agZdZaZggh
\uihegylv \k_lj_[h\Zgby oheh^gh]hjZkkm^dZOhly wlbq_kdb_
ih[m`^_gby dZd[m^lh \iheg_hijZ\^u\Zxl dZdh_lh
hl^_evgh_
^_ckl\b_\gmlj_ggb_ qm\kl\Z
\k_lZdb fh]ml
\hkklZ\Zlv
ijhlb\ g_]hb ]hj_ q_eh\_dmdhlhjuc \ih^h[ghf kemqZ_
ihkemrZ_lky ]hehkZjZkkm^dZZ g_]hehkZ qm\kl\< k\yab k
wlbf yjZkkdZ`m g_[hevrmxbklhjbx
Fgh]h e_l gZaZ^dh]^Z yjZ[hlZe \Bgklblml_ ahheh]bb
ih^ fh_chi_dhc gZoh^behkvg_kdhevdh fheh^uom^Z\h\dhlhjuo
dhjfbeb mf_js\e_ggufb furZfb
b djukZfb<ajhkeZy
furv
\iheg_ gZkusZ_lfheh^h]h iblhgZb ^\Z`^u\ g_^_ex ym[b\Ze
ih furb ^eydZ`^h]h bafhbo r_klbih^hi_qguodhlhju_ [_a
\hajZ`_gbc [jZeb k\hc h[_^ m f_gyba jmdFur_ch^gZdh
ljm^g__ jZa\h^blvq_f djukb wlboihke_^gbo \ jZkihjy`_gbb
bgklblmlZ [ueh]hjZa^h [hevr_Af_c fh`gh[ueh [u dhjfblvb
djukZfbgh \wlhf kemqZ_ fg_ijbrehkv [um[b\Zlv djukylZ
djukylZ \_ebqbghc
k furv
hqZjh\Zl_evgu_
kms_kl\Z
ih^_lkdb
g_mdex`b_djm]eh]heh\u_[hevr_]eZau_k
lheklufb eZidZfbIhwlhfm y ba[_]Zebo ljh]Zlvb lhevdh
dh]^Z aZiZkfur_c \bgklblml_ [ue fhbfklZjZgbyf k\_^_g ^h
fbgbfmfZfg_ ijbrehkv h[jZlblvky ddjukylZfY h`_klhqbe
k\h_ k_j^p_kijhkb\ k_[ydlh yahheh]wdki_jbf_glZlhj
beb k_glbf_glZevgZy klZjZy^_\Z": aZl_f m[ber_klv djukyl
b kdhjfbe bok\hbf ih^hi_qgufK lhqdbaj_gby dZglbZgkdhc
wlbdb fhc ihklmihd [ue \iheg_ hijZ\^ZglZd dZdjZkkm^hd
]h\hjbl
gZfqlh
m[bckl\h
djukyl
gbqmlv
g_ [he__
ij_^hkm^bl_evghq_f m[bckl\h\ajhkeuo fur_cGh qm\kl\Zf
kdjuluf \]em[bg_ q_eh\_q_kdhc ^mrbg_l ^_eZ^h eh]bq_kdbo
\udeZ^hdb gZ wlhl jZa y ^hjh]h aZieZlbe aZ lhqlh
ihkemrZeky
jZkkm^dZ
b
kh\_jrbe
wlh
ij_lb\r__
fg_
^_lhm[bckl\hG_ f_g__ g_^_eb fg_ dZ`^mx ghqv
kgbebkv
m[blu_ djukylZ
LZdZy nhjfZjZkdZygbymoh^ysZy k\hbfbdhjgyfb ]em[hdh \
kn_jm
wfhpbhgZevgh]hbf__l
ba\_klgmx
iZjZee_ev
\
ikbobq_kdhf kljh_g_dhlhjuo \ukhdhjZa\bluo`b\hlguo`b\msbo
\ khh[s_kl\ZogZ wlhl\u\h^ f_gygZlhedgme hij_^_e_gguc
lbi ih\_^_gbygZ[ex^Zlv dhlhjuc fg_ qZklh ^h\h^behkvm
kh[ZdY g_jZa mihfbgZefh_]h njZgpmakdh]h[mev^h]Z ;meeb
Hg [uem`_ klZjgh _s_g_ mljZlbe`b\hklb oZjZdl_jZ dlhfm
\j_f_gbdh]^ZhlijZ\b\rbkv \ ]hju dZlZlvkygZ eu`Zoy
dmibe ]Zggh\_jkdmxbs_cdm ObjrfZgZZ \_jg__ObjrfZg \aye
f_gy \ ohay_\Z[md\Zevgh m\yaZ\rbkv aZfghc \<_gm?]h
ihy\e_gb_ [uehly`_euf m^Zjhf^ey ;meebb _keb[u yagZe
dZdb_ fmdb j_\ghklb [m^_l
i_j_`b\Zlv [_^guc i_klh
ih`Zemcg_ ijb\_a[u ^hfhcdjZkZ\pZ ObjrfZgZ>_gv aZ^g_f
Zlfhkn_jZ klZgh\beZkv \k_[he__ ]g_lms_cb \dhgp_ dhgph\
gZijy`_gb_ jZaj_rbehkvh^ghc bakZfuo h`_klhq_gguokh[Zqvbo
^jZddZdb_ fg_ lhevdh ^h\h^behkv\b^_lvb _^bgkl\_gghc
aZ\yaZ\r_cky \ dhfgZl_ ohaybgZ]^_ h[uqgh ^Z`_
kZfu_
aZdeylu_ \jZ]b kh[ex^Zxl
kljh`Zcr__ i_j_fbjb_IhdZ
y
jZagbfZe ijhlb\gbdh\;meeb g_qZyggh pZigmef_gy aZijZ\uc
fbabg_pGZ
wlhf ^jZdZ
dhgqbeZkvgh
;meeb
bkiulZe
`_klhqZcrbc g_j\gucrhd b \iZe\ gZklhysmxijhkljZpbxOhly
y g_lhevdh g_\u[jZgbe _]hghgZh[hjhl\kyq_kdb eZkdZe
b ml_rZehg g_ih^\b`gh e_`Ze gZ dh\jbd_g_ \ kbeZo
ih^gylvky \hiehs_gb_ g_ba[u\gh]h]hjy;_^guc i_k^jh`Ze
dZd \ ebohjZ^d_b \j_fyhl \j_f_gbih _]hl_em ijh[_]Zeb
km^hjh]bHg
^urZe g_]em[hdhgh ihjhc
dhg\mevkb\gh
\koebiu\Zeb ba _]h ]eZa dZlbebkv djmigu_ ke_auHg
^_ckl\bl_evgh [ueg_ \ khklhygbbklZlv gZgh]bb g_kdhevdh
jZa \ ^_gv y ^he`_g [ue gZ jmdZo\ughkblv _]h\h ^\hj
Hllm^Z hgijZ\^Z\ha\jZsZeky kZfhklhyl_evghh^gZdh rhd
lZd iZjZebah\Ze _]hfurpuqlh hg g_klhevdh r_ekdhevdh
\hehqbeky iha_fe_Lhldlh g_agZe gZklhys_c ijbqbgufh]
[u ih^mfZlvqlh ;meeb k_jv_agh[he_g?klv hg gZqZeebrv
q_j_a g_kdhevdh ^g_cgh b lh]^Z kh]eZrZeky [jZlvibsm
lhevdh bafhbo jmdFgh]h g_^_evhg ih^oh^bedh fg_ kfbj_ggh
b \bgh\Zlhqlh ijhba\h^behhkh[_ggh ly]hklgh_ \i_qZle_gb_
lZd dZdh[uqgh ;meeb[ue \_kvfZkZfhklhyl_evguf ikhff_gvr_
\k_]h kdehgguf d m]h^gbq_kl\mL_jaZ\rb_ _]h
m]jua_gby
kh\_klb
ijhba\h^beb
gZ
f_gy
l_f
[he__
fmqbl_evgh_
\i_qZle_gb_qlh fhy kh[kl\_ggZy kh\_klv [ueZ hlgx^vg_
qbklZIjbh[j_l_gb_ gh\hc kh[Zdb m`_ ij_^klZ\eyehkv fg_
kh\_jr_ggh g_ijhklbl_evgufihklmidhf
H^bg
klZjuc
]mkZdlbjZgb\rbc
\k_o
hklZevguo
ih\b^bfhfmkqblZe k\hbf ijba\Zgb_f ^jZagblv kh[Zd?]h
kmijm]Z kb^_eZ gZ ycpZo \hae_g_[hevrhc e_klgbp_dhlhjZy
\_^_l ba kZ^Z \h ^\hj d dZebld_LZd dZdkh[Zdb k\ylh
kh[ex^Zeb bfb `_ kZfbfb \haeh`_ggmx gZ k_[yh[yaZgghklv
eZylv m dZebldb
\kydbc jZadh]^Z
__ hldju\Zebbf
ijboh^behkv ijh[_]Zlv ih e_klgbp_ ^h\hevgh qZklhKlZjuc
]mkZd \kdhj_ h[gZjm`beqlhjZkiheh`b\rbkv gZ
\_jog_c
klmi_gvd_hg
ihemqZ_l
\_ebdhe_ig_crmx
\hafh`ghklv
^hkZ`^Zlv kh[ZdZfsbiZy bo aZo\hkludh]^Z hgbijh[_]Zxl
fbfh;eZ]hihemqgh fbgh\Zlv wlh]h rbiys_]hP_j[_jZ fh`gh
[uehlhevdh fqZkv\h \kxijulv bklZjZl_evgh ijyqZo\hkl
f_`^m
gh]Zfb>h[jh^mrguc
b
\i_qZlebl_evguc
;m[b
ijbgZ^e_`Z\rbc fh_fm hlpmkug Lblu^_^ \ur_mihfygmlh]h
<hedZ ,b ijZijZijZ^_^ Kxabhq_gv kljZ^Ze baaZ lZdhc
Z]j_kkb\ghklb klZjh]h ]mkZdZdhlhjuc balj_o gZrbokh[Zd
h[ex[h\Ze ^ey k\hbo gZiZ^_gbc bf_ggh _]h;m[b
aZ\_e
ijb\uqdm [he_ag_ggh \a\ba]b\Zlv
\kydbc jZadh]^Z
_fm
ij_^klhyeh
\klmiblv
gZ
jhdh\mx
e_klgbpmG_\hafh`gZy
kblmZpby jZaj_rbeZkvljZ]bdhfbq_kdb< h^bgij_djZkguc ^_gv
aehc klZjuc ]mkZd [ue gZc^_g gZk\h_c klmi_gvd_f_jl\uf
;m[b `_ bkq_aHg g_ y\beky d dhjf_`d_b ihke_^he]bo
ihbkdh\ _]h m^Zehkv h[gZjm`blv \ l_fghf m]emgZ q_j^Zd_
ijZq_qghcdm^Z gZrb kh[Zdb ijb h[uqguo h[klhyl_evkl\Zo
gbdh]^Z g_aZ[bjZebkv;m[b e_`ZelZf \ iheghcijhkljZpbb
Y ij_^klZ\be k_[_qlh ijhbahrehg_ f_g__ykghq_f _keb
[u \b^_e wlhkh[kl\_ggufb ]eZaZfbKlZjuc ]mkZdlZd kbevgh
\p_ibeky \ o\hkl ijh[_]Z\r_]h
fbfh ;m[bqlh i_k
g_
m^_j`Zeky b dmkgme bklhqgbd [hebIjb wlhfd g_kqZklvx
h^bg ba _]h j_aph\ gZ`Ze gZq_j_i klZjh]h]mkZdZijbq_f
ih\j_`^_gb_ wlh hdZaZehkv
jhdh\uf kdhj__ \k_]h
lhevdh
ihlhfmqlh klZjbdm [uehm`_ ^\Z^pZlv iylve_l b dhklb_]h
klZeb ojmidbfb hl \hajZklZ;m[b g_ gZdZaZebmqblu\Zy
kfy]qZxsb_ h[klhyl_evkl\ZZ lZd`_ nbabq_kdh_
khklhygb_
`_jl\u
<?JGHKLV BKF?JLV
Ju^Zlv gZ^l_fqlh gug_gZf ^Zgh
Dhev ihl_jylv_]h gZfkm`^_gh
<R_dkibjKhg_lu
Kha^Z\Zy kh[Zdmijbjh^Zih\b^bfhfmg_ mqeZ^jm`[u
dhlhjhc ij_^klhyeh k\yaZlvwlh __l\hj_gb_ kq_eh\_dhf<h
\kydhf kemqZ_\_d kh[Zdb \iyl_jhdhjhq_ \_dZ__ ohaybgZ<
q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagb b lZd o\ZlZ_l i_qZevguojZkklZ\Zgbc k
l_fbdh]h fuex[bfjZkklZ\Zgbcij_^hij_^_e_gguo aZjZg__
lhevdh ihlhfmqlh hgb jh^bebkv gZg_kdhevdh ^_kylbe_lbc
jZgvr_ gZk<hl ihq_fm _kl_kl\_ggh aZ^Zlv k_[_ \hijhk
ijZ\bevgh eb fu ihklmiZ_fhl^Z\Zy k\h_k_j^p_ kms_kl\m
dhlhjh_ h^jyoe__lb mfj_lij_`^_ q_fq_eh\_djh^b\rbcky \
h^bg ^_gv k gbfmki__l jZkijhklblvky k ^_lkl\hf"DZd
]jmklgh \b^_lvqlh kh[ZdZdhlhjZy \k_]h g_kdhevdhe_l
gZaZ^ Z l_i_jv hgb dZ`mlky f_kypZfb[ueZ g_mdex`bf
fbeuf s_ghqdhfgZqbgZ_l klZj_lv ijyfh gZ ]eZaZob fu
ihgbfZ_fqlh `blv _c hklZ_lky ^\Zljb ]h^ZIjbagZxkv
h^jyoe_gb_ fhbo kh[Zd \k_]^Z ^_ckl\m_l gZ f_gy
djZcg_
m]g_lZxs_ b mkm]m[ey_l lm fjZqghklvdhlhjZy h\eZ^_\Z_l
\k_fb ex^vfbdh]^Z hgb ^mfZxl hg_ba[_`ghf: ly]hklguc
^mr_\guc dhgnebdlh`b^Zxsbc
dZ`^h]h \eZ^_evpZ
kh[Zdb
dh]^Z __\ klZjhklbihjZ`Z_l dZdhcgb[m^v g_bae_qbfucg_^m]
b \klZ_ljhdh\hc \hijhkg_ emqr_eb __mkuiblv"
Ih kljZgghcijbohlb km^v[u wlZqZrZ f_gyihdZ fbgh\ZeZ
lZd dZd\k_ fhbkh[ZdbaZ h^gbflhevdh bkdexq_gb_fmfbjZeb
\
klZjhklb
\g_aZighc
b
[_a[he_ag_gghc
kf_jlvx
[_a
dZdh]heb[h fh_]h \f_rZl_evkl\ZGh jZkkqblu\Zlv gZwlh
jZamf__lkyg_evayZ
ihlhfm
y
g_
hq_gv
hkm`^Zx
qm\kl\bl_evguo ex^_cdhlhju_
[hylky ijbh[j_klb
kh[Zdm
baaZ g_ba[_`ghklb jZkklZ\Zgby k g_cG_ hq_gvhkm`^Zx"
G_lgZ
kZfhf ^_e_
y hkm`^Zx
bo [_ah]h\hjhqgh<
q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagbex[Zy jZ^hklvhieZqb\Z_lky i_qZevx
B y kqblZx ljmkhf lh]hdlh hldZau\Z_lkyhl g_fgh]bo
[_ah[b^guo b
k wkl_lbq_kdhc
lhqdb aj_gby
[_amij_qguo
m^h\hevkl\bc^hklmiguo q_eh\_dmlhevdh ba kljZoZqlh
jZgh beb iha^gh km^v[Z ij_^klZ\bl _fmkq_l aZgboLhfm
dlh kdmiblky gZ fhg_lm kljZ^Zgbcemqr_ \k_]haZi_j_lvky
gZ dZdhfgb[m^v mguehf q_j^Zd_ b khogmlvlZf [_aihevau
lhqgh emdh\bpZ [_a aZjh^urZdhlhjZy g_ fh`_l ijbg_klb
\_ldZ>Zdhg_qghkh[Zdb h[eZ^Zxl
bg^b\b^mZevghklvx
dZ`^Zy ba gbo ebqghklv \ kZfhflhqghf kfuke_keh\Zy
f_gvr_ \k_]hkdehg_g wlh hkiZjb\Zlvb \k_lZdb hgb ]hjZa^h
[hevr_q_f ex^bihoh`b ^jm] gZ ^jm]ZBg^b\b^mZevgu_
jZaebqby f_`^m `b\ufb kms_kl\Zfb ijyfhijhihjpbhgZevgu bo
ikbobq_kdhfm jZa\blbx^\_ ju[u h^gh]h \b^ZijZdlbq_kdb
h^bgZdh\u \h \k_ok\hbo ^_ckl\byob j_Zdpbyogh q_eh\_d
ohjhrh agZdhfuc k
ih\_^_gb_f
ahehlbkluo ohfyqdh\
beb
]ZehdaZf_qZ_l y\gu_jZaebqby f_`^mhl^_evgufb hkh[yfb:
^\_ k_ju_ \hjhgubeb ^\Zk_juo ]mkywlh g_j_^dh kh\k_f
jZagu_ bg^b\b^u
M kh[Zd lZdb_ jZaebqby \ujZ`_gu _s_ yjq_ihkdhevdm
hgb ^hfZrgb_ `b\hlgu_ b boih\_^_gb_ ^himkdZ_l]hjZa^h
[hevr_ bg^b\b^mZevguo hldehg_gbc hl kl_j_hlbiZq_f wlh
\hafh`gh ^ey ^bdbo \b^h\L_f g_ f_g__ kmsghklv k\h_c
gZlmjul_fb ]em[hdbfb bgklbgdlb\gufb qm\kl\Zfbdhlhju_
hij_^_eyxl bo hkh[u_ hlghr_gby k q_eh\_dhf\k_ kh[Zdb
hq_gv koh`bf_`^m kh[hcZ ihlhfm_keb ihl_jy\kh[Zdm\u
g_f_^e_ggh \havf_l_ s_gdZlhc `_ihjh^ulh ijbghjfZevghf
oh^_ kh[ulbc \kdhj_ m[_^bl_kvqlh hgaZihegbl imklhlm\
\Zr_f k_j^p_ b `bagbdhlhjZy \hagbdeZ lZfihke_ kf_jlb
klZjh]h q_l\_jhgh]h]h ^jm]ZBghc jZa ih^h[gh_ ml_r_gb_
hdZau\Z_lky gZklhevdh ^_ckl\_ggufqlh gZqbgZ_rvbkiulu\Zlv
g_dhlhjuc klu^keh\gh lu \ q_flh ij_^Ze k\hxmf_jrmx
kh[ZdmB \ wlhf kh[Zdb [he__ \_jgu_ ^jmavyq_f
bo
ohay_\ZlZd dZd \ kemqZ_ kf_jlb ohaybgZkh[ZdZ \jy^eb
gZc^_l _fmaZf_gm m`_ q_j_aihe]h^ZWlb khh[jZ`_gbyfh]ml
ihdZaZlvky g_e_iufb l_fdlh g_ ijbagZ_l
gjZ\kl\_gghc
hl\_lkl\_gghklb ih hlghr_gbx d `b\hlgufgh bf_ggh hgb
aZklZ\beb f_gyijbgylv hkh[u__keb g_kdZaZlv kljZggu_ f_ju
< lhl ^_gvdh]^Z ygZr_e fh_]hklZjh]h ;meebmf_jrbf
hl djh\hbaebygby\ fha]gZ _]h h[uqghfihklmy kjZam`_ k
]hj_qvx ih^mfZeqlh hgg_ hklZ\bek_[_ ij__fgbdZFg_ lh]^Z
[ueh k_fgZ^pZlv e_lb y \i_j\u_ihl_jye kh[ZdmG_ fh]m
\ujZablvdZd ylhkdh\Ze [_ag_]hFgh]h e_l hg[ue fhbf
g_jZaemqguf kimlgbdhfb g_jh\guc lhihlhd_]h eZidh]^Z hg
[_`Ze ihaZ^bf_gy hg ijbojZfu\ZelZd dZdi_j_^gyy eZiZ m
g_]h [ueZkehfZgZ b dhklviehoh kjhkeZkvgZklhevdh kebeky
kh klmdhffhbo kh[kl\_gguo rZ]h\qlh yi_j_klZe aZf_qZlvb
lhihlhd b khi_gb_aZklZ\ey_l ijhklh^mrguo ex^_c\_jblv
[m^lh boihk_sZxl ijbajZd ^hjh]bomf_jrboFgh]h e_l ihaZ^b
f_gy keurZekyi_j_klmd kh[Zqvbo eZib wlhla\md lZdijhqgh
aZi_qZle_eky
\
fh_f
fha]m
ikboheh]b
gZau\Zxl
wlh
wc^_lbqguf n_ghf_ghfqlh i_j\u_ g_^_eb fg_ihklhyggh
dZaZehkv[m^lh ;meeb[_`bl mf_gy aZkibghc
: gZlbobo ljhiZogZ^ >mgZ_fm f_gygZqbgZebkv gZklhysb_
kemoh\u_ ]ZeexpbgZpbb?keb y ijbkemrb\Zeky khagZl_evgh
lhihlhd b
khi_gb_ kjZam
ij_djZsZebkvgh
klhbeh fg_
aZ^mfZlvkyb hgbkgh\Z a\mqZeb mf_gy \mrZoLhevdh dh]^Z
LblZ \ lh\j_fy _s_[hevr_eZiuc g_kdeZ^gucs_ghd gZqZeZ
khijh\h`^Zlv f_gy gZ ijh]medZoijbajZd ;meeb[ue gZdhg_p
aZdeyl bbkq_a gZ\k_]^Z
LblZ lh`_^Z\gh mf_jeZB dZd ^Z\ghgh __ ijbajZd\k_
_s_
ke_^m_l
aZ
fghc\ly]b\Zy
gha^jyfb
\ha^moY
ihaZ[hlbeky h[wlhfk\ylh \uihegyyg_ kh\k_fh[uqguc ieZg
Dh]^Z yebrbeky Lbluklhev `_ g_h`b^ZgghdZd b ;meebfg_
[ueh ykghqlh __f_klh aZcf_l ^jm]Zykh[ZdZdZd hgZkZfZ
aZgyeZ f_klh;meebZ ihlhfmklu^ykv k\h_]hg_ihklhygkl\Z
y ihdeyeky __iZfylvxqlh k wlboihj f_gyih `bagb[m^ml
khijh\h`^Zlv lhevdh ihlhfdb LbluQ_eh\_d ih
hq_\b^guf
[bheh]bq_kdbf ijbqbgZf
g_ fh`_l
khojZgblv
ih`bag_ggmx
\_jghklv h^ghckh[Zd_gh hgfh_l hklZlvky\_jguf __ihjh^_
Dh]^Z y ebp_f_jgh m\_jyx hlhj\Z\r_]h f_gy hljZ[hlu
]hklyqlh hq_gv jZ^ _]h
\b^_lvZ Kxabgbqmlv
g_
h[fZgmlZy fhbfb keh\Zfbk_j^blh juqbl b eZ_l gZ g_]h
dh]^Z
hgZ
klZg_l
klZjr_lh
gZqg_l
_]h e_]hgvdh
ihdmku\ZlvhgZ g_ lhevdh ^_fhgkljbjm_l
g_h[udgh\_ggh_
mf_gb_ qblZlvfhb lZcgu_fukeb gZke_^b_ Lblugh hgZb
_klv LblZ`b\h_ \hiehs_gb_
LbluDh]^Z gZ em]m
hgZ
hohlblky gZ fur_c b ijh^_eu\Z_l keh`gu_iju`db furdmxsbo
obsgbdh\^_fhgkljbjmy lm`_ kljZklvd wlhfmaZgylbxqlh b
Ib]b__ [Z[dZ qZmqZmhgZ b_klv Ib]bDh]^Zh[mqZykv
dhfZg^_ E_`ZlvhgZ ijb[_]Z_l
d l_f `_
ijhajZqguf
ij_^eh]Zfqlh[u \kdhqblvdZdb_ h^bggZ^pZlv e_l
gZaZ^
bah[j_lZeZ __ ijZ[Z[dZKlZkbb dh]^Zih^h[gh KlZkbhgZ
\hklhj`_ggh \Zey_lky\ dZ`^hcem`_Z aZl_fk gh]^h ]heh\u
\ ]jyabkihdhcg_gvdh \oh^bl\ ^hflh]^Z hgZb _klv KlZkb
\hkdj_krZy KlZkb: dh]^Z hgZ ke_^m_l aZ fghcih lbobf
ijbj_qguf ljhiZfih iuevguf ^hjh]Zfbeb ]hjh^kdbfmebpZf
gZijy]Zy \k_ k\hb qm\kl\Zqlh[u g_ihl_jylv f_gylh]^Z
hgZ klZgh\blkyhebp_l\hj_gb_f \k_okh[Zddhlhju_ kh\j_f_g
i_j\h]h ijbjmq_ggh]h rZdZeZke_^h\Zeb aZk\hbfb ohay_\Zfb
qm^_kguf blh]hfex[\b b\_jghklb
Скачать