Проблемы государственного регулирования инвестиционных

!"#$%&'( )#*+,-"*./&00#)#
"&)+%1"#/-012 10/&*.131#00(4
!"#3&**#/ / *#/"&'&00(4 +*%#/124
"#**15*6#5 76#0#'161
!"#$%&%'
()%#%*+,-
.$/'+%0
$
1%)2$20
3(2+21%('
$
2007
%
2008
4256
)"*7)2*&)"+.'&*., 7)'85' $*'42, +" %+$'*&%9%2++,' 7)29'**,. :8' 2;'$%5+2, ;&2
$,*2(2)"#$%&,' *&)"+,, (2&2),' %*&2)%;'*(% )"**1"&)%$"/% %+$'*&%9%2++,'
7)29'**, ("( 2<='(&, ;%*&2 ),+2;+242 )'46/%)2$"+%., "(&%$+2 7)%$"&%#%)6>&
%+$'*&%9%2++,' <"+(% % ()67+'0?%' %+$'*&%9%2++,' (217"+%%, &.'. "(&%$%#%)6>&
7)29'**, 42*65")*&$'++242 )'46/%)2$"+%. +" %+$'*&%9%2++,- ),+("-.
!"# $%&&'' (%)*%&+ ,-.&/'# 0%&,1.*&/(. ( ,)*.("23'' ' *20,"'*%(.3'#
'3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%42&&%( #("#2/&# 32 62322 (.73%8 )*%9"26%8, :%/%*.# /*29,2/
&)24'.";3%0% .3."'<.. =*2712 (&20%, /*29,2/&# %423:. *%&&'8&:%0% '3(2&/'4'%33%0%
:"'6./., :.: (.7328>20% :%6)%323/. %423:' (%<6%73%&/' *.<('/'# '3(2&/'4'8 ( &/*.32.
$.4'%3.";3+8 '3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./ %)*212"#2/ &/2)23; 9".0%)*'#/3%&/'
&'/,.4'' ( /%8 '"' '3%8 &/*.32 (*20'%32, %/*.&"') )% %/3%>23'? : '3(2&/'4'#6, :%/%*+2
6%0,/ 9+/; ("%723+ ( ' %92&)2-'(.2/ *.4'%3.";3%2, @:%3%6'-2&:' @AA2:/'(3%2
*.&)*212"23'2 '3(2&/'4'%33+5 *2&,*&%(.
=% 6323'? B.C. B&.,". ' D.E. !23'&%(. 3. &%(*26233%6 @/.)2 *.<('/'# *+3%-3+5
%/3%>23'8 .:/'(3.# *%"; ( &/*./20'-2&:%6 *.<('/'' %/(%1'/&# 6.:*%@:%3%6'-2&:%8
'3(2&/'4'%33%8 )%"'/':2, (:"?-.?F28 &"21,?F'2 @"2623/+: (+9%* '&/%-3':%( '
62/%1%( A'3.3&'*%(.3'# '3(2&/'4'8; %)*212"23'2 &*%:%( *2."'<.4''; (+9%* %*0.3%(,
%/(2/&/(233+5 <. *2."'<.4'? '3(2&/'4'%33%8 )%"'/':'; &%<1.3'2 32%95%1'6%8
3%*6./'(3%-)*.(%(%8 9.<+ A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'# *+3:. '3(2&/'4'8; A%*6'*%(.3'2
9".0%)*'#/3%0% '3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./. [1].
!'.).<%3 %423:' ,*%(3# 9".0%)*'#/3%&/' '3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./. #("#2/&#
1%&/./%-3% >'*%:'6 – %/ (2&;6. 329".0%)*'#/3%0% ,*%(3# 1% 6.:&'6.";3% 9".0%)*'#/3%0%.
G".0%)*'#/3+6 )*'3#/% &-'/./; :"'6./, %9,&".("'(.?F'8 .:/'(3,? 12#/2";3%&/;
'3(2&/%*%( ' &)%&%9&/(,?F'8 )*'/%:, :.)'/.".. H/62/'6, -/% ,*%(23; 9".0%)*'#/3%&/'
6%72/ 9+/; %42323 )%-*.<3%6, (( <.('&'6%&/' %/ 42"28 %423:').
H9F'2 :*'/2*'' %423:' 9".0%)*'#/3%&/' '3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./. )*'(2123+ (
/.9". 1 [1].
I.9"'4. 1 - J*'/2*'' %423:' '3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./.
@"%1'+2$"+%' A"(&2)"
1. H9K2:/'(3+2
1.1. =*'*%13%-:"'6./'-2&:'2
,&"%('#
1.2. L2%0*.A'-2&:%2 )%"%723'2
1.3. M%&/%#3'2 %:*,7.?F28 &*21+
B7%*"+%' A"(&2)"
G%0./+2 )*'*%13+2 *2&,*&+
C."'-'2 0*.3'4 & *.<('/+6' *20'%3.6' '
'3%&/*.33+6' 0%&,1.*&/(.6', 3."'-'2 6%*&:%0% '
*2-3%0% &%%9F23'# & '3%&/*.33+6' 0%&,1.*&/(.6'
=%&/%#33% )%112*7'(.2/&# 3. 9".0%)*'#/3%6
,*%(32
2. M,9K2:/'(3+2
2.1 C.,-3+8 )%/234'."
2.2 N:%3%6'-2&:'8 )%/234'."
2.3. O.:%3%1./2";3.# '
3%*6./'(3.# 9.<.
E+&%:%:(."'A'4'*%(.33+2 3.,-3+2 :.1*+
E+&%:'8 ,*%(23; *.<('/'# *+3%-3+5 %/3%>23'8,
1'(2*&'A'4'*%(.33%&/; @:%3%6'-2&:%8 &*21+,
3."'-'2 @:%3%6':' 32<.('&'6+5 A'3.3&%(%0%
*+3:. ' *+3:. '3(2&/'4'%33+5 ,&",0, )*'26"26+2
&/.(:' @:&)%*/3+5 ' '6)%*/3+5 )%>"'3,
)%"%7'/2";3.# )%"'/':. ( %9".&/' (."?/3%0% :,*&.
M/.9'";3+8 )*.(%(%8 *27'6, 72&/:%2
*20,"'*%(.3'2 %/3%>23'8 &%9&/(233%&/',
<.:%3%1./2";3%2 <.:*2)"23'2 3."%0%(+5 ";0%/ 1"#
)%112*7:' '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/'
B3."'< A.:/%*%(, )2*2-'&"233+5 ( /.9".1 )%:.<+(.2/, -/% ,*%(23; 9".0%)*'#/3%&/'
'3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./. %)*212"#2/&# 3. %&3%(2 %423:' : )*'*%13%-:"'6./'-2&:'5
,&"%('8, 02%0*.A'-2&:%0% )%"%723'#, &%&/%#3'2 %:*,7.?F28 &*21+, 3.,-3%0% '
@:%3%6'-2&:%0% )%/234'."., ,*%(3# *.<*.9%/.33%&/' ' &%%/(2/&/('# 6'*%(+6 &/.31.*/.6
3%*6./'(3%-)*.(%(%8 9.<+.
P.Q. !.1'3. %)*212"'"., -/% 62/%1+ ,",->23'# '3(2&/'4'%33%0% :"'6./. &%
&/%*%3+ 0%&,1.*&/(. 6%73% *.<12"'/; 3. 1(2 0*,))+: )*#6+2 ' :%&(233+2 [2].
J%&(233%2 *20,"'*%(.3'2 (:"?-.2/ *.<3%%9*.<3+2 62/%1+ ' *+-.0' (%<128&/('#,
&/'6,"'*,?F'2 *.<('/'2 '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/', . '6233%: 3."%0%(,?,
.6%*/'<.4'%33,? )%"'/':,, <.F'/, '3/2*2&%( '3(2&/%*%( ' 1*,0'2 62*+ @:%3%6'-2&:%0%
*20,"'*%(.3'# [2]. R0% <.1.-28 #("#2/&# &%<1.3'2 ,&"%('8, &)%&%9&/(,?F'5 *.<('/'?
'3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/', ),/26: &%(2*>23&/(%(.3'# &'&/26+ 3."%0%%9"%723'# '
.6%*/'<.4'%33%8 )%"'/':'; ,&/.3%("23'2 1"# '3(2&/%*%( 3."%0%(+5 ";0%/; *.<*.9%/:'
625.3'<6. <.F'/+ '3(2&/'4'8; *.&>'*23'# '&)%";<%(.3'# &*21&/( 3.&2"23'#; &%<1.3'2 '
*.<('/'2 &2/' '3A%*6.4'%33%-.3."'/'-2&:'5 423/*%(, )*%'<(%1#F'5 &'&/26./'-2&:%2
)*%(2123'2 *28/'30%(+5 %423%: &,9K2:/%( '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/' ' '5 ),9"':.4'?;
%92&)2-23'2 .3/'6%3%)%";3+5 62*; )*21%&/.("23'2 &,9K2:/.6 '3(2&/'4'%33%8
12#/2";3%&/' )%"3%6%-'8 )% A%*6'*%(.3'? &%9&/(233+5 '3(2&/'4'%33+5 A%31%( (
&%%/(2/&/('' & Q212*.";3+8 <.:%3 «H9 '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/' ( $%&&'8&:%8
Q212*.4'', %&,F2&/("#26%8 ( A%*62 :.)'/.";3+5 ("%723'8» %/ 25 A2(*."# 1999 0. S 39QO.
=*#6%2 ,-.&/'2 0%&,1.*&/(. ( '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/' <.:"?-.2/&# (
%&,F2&/("23'' <. &-2/ 9?172/3+5 &*21&/( :.)'/.";3+5 ("%723'8 ( &%%/(2/&/('' &
A212*.";3+6' ' *20'%3.";3+6' 42"2(+6' )*%0*.66.6'. J%3:*2/3+6' A%*6.6' /.:%0%
,-.&/'# #("#?/&#: A'3.3&'*%(.3'2 '3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%2:/%(; A%*6'*%(.3'# )2*2-3#
&/*%2: ' %9K2:/%( /253'-2&:%0% )2*2(%%*,723'# 1"# A212*.";3+5 0%&,1.*&/(233+5 3,71 '
A'3.3&'*%(.3'# '5 <. &-2/ &*21&/( A212*.";3%0% 9?172/.; )*21%&/.("23'# 3. :%3:,*&3%8
%&3%(2 0%&,1.*&/(233+5 0.*.3/'8 )% '3(2&/'4'%33+6 )*%2:/.6; *.<62F23'# 3.
:%3:,*&3%8 %&3%(2 &*21&/( A212*.";3%0% 9?172/. ' &*21&/( 9?172/%( &,9K2:/%(
$%&&'8&:%8 Q212*.4'' 1"# A'3.3&'*%(.3'# '3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%2:/%(.
I.:'6 %9*.<%6, '3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./ ( <3.-'/2";3%8 &/2)23' A%*6'*,2/&#
(%<128&/('26 0%&,1.*&/(. 3. 0.*.3/'' )*.( &%9&/(233%&/' ' 5.*.:/2* )*.(%(%0%
*20,"'*%(.3'#. =*' @/%6 )*'62323'2 /25 '"' '3+5 62/%1%( %)*212"#2/&# ( <.('&'6%&/' %/
@:%3%6'-2&:%8 &'/,.4'' ( &/*.32.
I.:'6 %9*.<%6, 0".(3.# <.1.-. 0%&,1.*&/(., :.: *20,"#/%*. '3(2&/'4'%33+5
)*%42&&%( ( &/*.32 #("#2/&# )*.('";3%2 %)*212"23'2 )*'%*'/2/%( )%112*7:'
'3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%42&&%(.
E ,&"%('#5 .:/'(3%8 '3/20*.4'' ' (&2%9F28 0"%9."'<.4'' )*' %)*212"23''
)*'%*'/2/3+5 3.)*.("23'8 )%112*7:' '3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%2:/%( &"21,2/ ,12"#/; (3'6.3'2
'3(2&/'4'#6 ( :%3:,*23/%&)%&%93+2 /%(.*+ 3. 6'*%(%6 *+3:2, . /.:72 :.)'/."%("%723'#6,
&)%&%9&/(,?F'6 )%(+>23'? :%3:,*23/%&)%&%93%&/' )*%'<(%1&/(.. E )2*(,? %-2*21;,
:%3:,*23/3+2 )*2'6,F2&/(. %92&)2-'(.?/ (+&%:%/253%"%0'-3+2 *.<*.9%/:'. C.
&20%13#>3'8 123; : %/*.&"#6, %9".1.?F'6 )%/234'."%6 ( @/%8 %9".&/' 6%73% %/32&/'
.('.&/*%23'2, 62/."",*0'?, 9'%/253%"%0'? ' 1*,0'2 %/*.&"', ( :%/%*+5 %92&)2-'(.2/&#
&%<1.3'2 <3.-'/2";3%8 )*'9.(%-3%8 &/%'6%&/'.
M"21,2/ %/62/'/;, -/% :.)'/."%("%723'# ( '33%(.4'%33+2 &A2*+ &)%&%9&/(,?/
A%*6'*%(.3'? 3%(+5 3.)*.("23'8 1('723'# :.)'/."., ,(2"'-23'? 20% )*%'<(%1'/2";3%&/',
', &%%/(2/&/(233%, @:%3%6'-2&:%6, *%&/,. M"21%(./2";3%, )*' %0*.3'-233%&/'
'3(2&/'4'%33+5 *2&,*&%( /%-2-3+8 5.*.:/2* )%1%93+5 :.)'/."%("%723'8 )%<(%"#2/ 1%&/'-;
<3.-'/2";3%0% @:%3%6'-2&:%0% @AA2:/.. =*' @/%6 1.33+8 )%15%1 )*%>2" 32%13%:*./3+2
'&)+/.3'# 6'*%(%8 )*.:/':%8 :.: &)%&%9 )*2%1%"23'# %0*.3'-'/2"28 @:%3%6'-2&:%0% *%&/..
E /% 72 (*26#, ( &%&/.( )*'%*'/2/3+5 )*%2:/%( &"21,2/ /.:72 (:"?-./; 62*%)*'#/'# )%
*.<('/'? %/*.&"28, %92&)2-'(.?F'5 (3,/*233'8 &)*%& 3. /%(.*+, *.9%/+, ,&",0' )2*(%8
32%95%1'6%&/'. C26."%(.73+6' 3.)*.("23'#6' #("#?/&# )*%0*.66+ )% %92&)2-23'?
)*%1%(%";&/(233%8 ' @32*02/'-2&:%8 92<%).&3%&/' &/*.3+, . /.:72 )%112*7.3'? 22
%9%*%3%&)%&%93%&/' ' )*%1%(%";&/(233%8 92<%).&3%&/'.
E @:%3%6':2 $%&&'' /*.1'4'%33% %&3%(3+6' :%3:,*23/3+6' )*2'6,F2&/(.6'
%9".1."' :*,)3+2 )*%'<(%1&/(233+2 )*21)*'#/'#, %9".1.?F'2 <3.-'/2";3+6 3.,-3%/253'-2&:'6 )%/234'."%6. E62&/2 & @/'6, 3. &%&/%#3'2 @:%3%6':' ( <3.-'/2";3%8 62*2 ("'#2/
' ,*%(23; *.<('/'# 6."%0% ' &*21320% 9'<32&.. D<(2&/3%, -/% <."%0%6 ,&)2>3%0%
A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'# @:%3%6'-2&:%0% &2:/%*. "?9%0% 0%&,1.*&/(. #("#2/&# %)/'6.";3%2
&%-2/.3'2 :*,)3+5, &*213'5 ' 6."+5 )*21)*'#/'8. T&'"'(.?F22&# ("'#3'2 *.<('/'# 6."%0%
9'<32&. %9,&"%("23% &"21,?F'6' )*'-'3.6': 9%"22 (+&%:%8 %/1.-28 %/ '3(2&/'4'8,
(:".1+(.26+5 ( *.<('/'2 6."%0% 9'<32&., )% &*.(323'? & 3.)*.("23'26 '5 3. *.<('/'2
:*,)3%0%; &%:*.F23'26 &*%:. %:,).26%&/' '3(2&/'4'8, 2&"' %3' 3.)*.("#?/&# 3. *.<('/'2
6."%0% ' &*21320% 9'<32&.; 9%"22 9+&/*+6 ' 12>2(+6 %&,F2&/("23'26 /253'-2&:%0%
)2*2%&3.F23'#, (321*23'26 ' .)*%9'*%(.3'26 3%(%8 /253%"%0'', )*%(2123'26 -.&/'-3%8
.(/%6./'<.4'' )*%'<(%1&/(., 1%&/'723'26 %)/'6.";3%0% &%-2/.3'# 625.3'<'*%(.33%0% '
*,-3%0% /*,1..
E/%*.# )*%9"26., :%/%*.# 1%"73. 9+/; *2>23., #("#2/&# %423:. &/2)23'
32%95%1'6%0% ("'#3'# 0%&,1.*&/(233%0% *20,"'*%(.3'# 3. '3(2&/'4'%33+8 )*%42&& (
&/*.32.
U2";? 0%&,1.*&/(233%0% *20,"'*%(.3'# '3(2&/'4'%33+5 )*%42&&%( ( ,&"%('#5
*+3%-3%8 @:%3%6':' #("#2/&# 32 1%),F23'2 :*'<'&3+5 #("23'8, . /.:72 <.F'/. '
&/'6,"'*%(.3'2 1.33+5 )*%42&&%( ( %)*212"233+5 %/*.&"#5 ' &2:/%*.5. =*' @/%6 (
,&"%('#5 )*%(2123'# *2A%*6, . /.:72 :*'<'&. *20,"'*,?F.# *%"; 0%&,1.*&/(. (%<*.&/.2/, .
( ,&"%('#5 &/.9'";3%&/' ' %7'("23'# @:%3%6':' – %&".92(.2/.
I26 32 62322, ( *.9%/.5 &%(*26233+5 @:%3%6'&/%(, ( -.&/3%&/' =. M.6,@";&%3. [3]
.:423/'*,2/&# <3.-'6%&/; *%"' 0%&,1.*&/(. ( *20,"'*%(.3'' @:%3%6'-2&:'5 )*%42&&%(.
E%)*%& % 62&/2 ' *%"' ( )2*25%13%8 @:%3%6':2 ( 42"%6 ' ( '3(2&/'4'%33%6
)*%42&&2 ( -.&/3%&/' – )*2162/ %7'("233%8 1'&:,&&'' &*21' *%&&'8&:'5 ,-23+5 '
)*.:/':%(. M,/; 1'&:,&&'' &(%1'/&# : )%'&:, %/(2/. 3. (%)*%& % :%3:*2/3%8 *%"'
0%&,1.*&/(. ( *+3%-3%8 @:%3%6':2. I.: )% 6323'? C.C. V,52/1'3%(%8 [4] ' B.P.
V."+>2(. [5] ( 90-5 0%1.5, )*2%1%"23'2 %13%8 :*.83%&/', )*'(2". : 1*,0%8: ( )*%42&&2
,&/*.323'# 0')2*/*%A'*%(.33%0% %0%&,1.*&/("23'#, )*'&,F20% &%(2/&:%8 @:%3%6':2, *%";
0%&,1.*&/(. ( @:%3%6'-2&:'5 )*%42&&.5 32%)*.(1.33% &3'<'".&;, -/% ' )*%(%4'*,2/
:*'<'&3+2 )*%42&&+.
E &"%7'(>'5&# *+3%-3+5 &'&/26.5 0".(3.# <.1.-. 0%&,1.*&/(. – &%<1.3'2
9".0%)*'#/3+5 ,&"%('8 1"# .:/'('<.4'' -.&/3+5 '3(2&/'4'8 )*' %0*.3'-23'' &(%28
A,3:4'' 32)%&*21&/(233%0% '3(2&/%*.. H13.:% *%&&'8&:.# @:%3%6'-2&:.# )*.:/':.
'&/2:>20% 12&#/'"2/'# )%:.<+(.2/, -/% )2*25%13.# @:%3%6':. :.: &'&/26., /*29,2/ 1"#
&/.9'"'<.4'' ' )2*25%1. : 3.*%13%5%<#8&/(233%6, *%&/, 9%"22 .:/'(3%0% ,-.&/'#
0%&,1.*&/(. 32 /%";:% ( &%<1.3'' '3&/'/,4'%3.";3%-)*.(%(%8 %&3%(+ 12#/2";3%&/'
-.&/3+5 '3(2&/%*%(, 3% ' ( )*#6%6 '3(2&/'*%(.3'' ( *2.";3+8 &2:/%* 1"# 1%&/'723'#
32%95%1'6+5 &/*,:/,*3+5 &1('0%(.
E 42"%6, '3A*.&/*,:/,*. ( *+3%-3%8 @:%3%6':2 6%72/ 9+/; %)*212"23. :.:
)%1&'&/26. (<.'6%&(#<.33+5 '3&/'/,/%(, 42"2(%8 A,3:4'28 :%/%*%8 #("#2/&# &%<1.3'2
%9F'5 ,&"%('8 1"# A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'# @:%3%6'-2&:'5 &,9K2:/%( 3. *.<"'-3+5 *+3:.5, -/%
)%<(%"#2/ *.&&6./*'(./; 22 :.: :%6)"2:& )*%'<(%1&/(233%8, :*21'/3%-A'3.3&%(%8,
'3&/'/,4'%3.";3%8, :%662*-2&:%8, &%4'.";3%8, @:%"%0'-2&:%8 ' '3A%*6.4'%33%8
'3A*.&/*,:/,*.
=*' @/%6 : '3A*.&/*,:/,*3+6 A.:/%*.6, ("'#?F'6 3. '3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./
*20'%3. 3.*#1, &% &/2)23;? *.<('/%&/' %9&",7'(.?F'5 %/*.&"28 ' *20,"'*,?F'5
'3&/'/,/%(, &"21,2/ %/32&/' /2**'/%*'.";3%-02%0*.A'-2&:%2 )%"%723'2 *20'%3.. G%";>.#
/2**'/%*'# &/*.3+ %9,&".("'(.2/ <3.-'/2";3+2 /*.3&)%*/3+2 '<12*7:', -/%, ( &(%?
%-2*21;, &3'7.2/ )*'("2:./2";3%&/; *20'%3%(, ,1."233+5 %/ *+3:%( &+*;# ' &9+/..
H-2('13%, -/% &,F2&/(,2/ )*#6.# <.('&'6%&/; 6271, *.<('/%&/;? '3A*.&/*,:/,*+
' @AA2:/'(3%&/;? A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'# )*%'<(%1&/(.: -26 ",->2 %*0.3'<%(.3. ' 9%"22
*.<3%%9*.<3. '3A*.&/*,:/,*., %:*,7.?F.# )*21)*'#/'2, /26 (+>2 @AA2:/'(3%&/;
A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'# @/%0% )*21)*'#/'#, ' 3.%9%*%/, :*'<'& ( 6./2*'.";3%6 )*%'<(%1&/(2
)*'(%1'/ : 32@AA2:/'(3%6, A,3:4'%3'*%(.3'? )*%'<(%1&/(233%8 '3A*.&/*,:/,*+ '
&3'723'? 22 '3(2&/'4'%33%8 )*'("2:./2";3%&/'. M"21%(./2";3%, 3. 1'3.6':, %//%:. '
)*'/%:. '3(2&/'4'8 <3.-'/2";3%2 ("'#3'2 %:.<+(.2/ *.<('/'2 /.:'5 %/*.&"28, :.: &'&/26.
/2"2:%66,3':.4'8, /*.3&)%*/ ' 0%&/'3'-3%2 5%<#8&/(%, /.2. %92&)2-'(.?F'5 ,&"%('#,
)*'(+-3+2 1"# 9%";>'3&/(. 4'('"'<%(.33+5 9'<32&623%(. =*' @/%6 :*,)3+2 ' &*213'2
)*21)*'#/'# %9*.9./+(.?F28 )*%6+>"233%&/' )*21K#("#?/ 9%"22 72&/:'2 /*29%(.3'# :
*.9%-28 &'"2 ' '3A*.&/*,:/,*2, -26 )*21)*'#/'# &A2*+ ,&",0 [6].
M*21' )2*(%%-2*213+5 62*, )*'3#/+5 0%&,1.*&/(%6, :%/%*+2 9,1,/ &)%&%9&/(%(./;
)*'("2-23'? '3(2&/'4'8 ( *20'%3+ $%&&'?, 32%95%1'6% 3.<(./; /.:72 0%&,1.*&/(233%2
,-.&/'2 ( )*%2:/.5 )% *.<('/'? '3A*.&/*,:/,*+, . /.:72 &/'6,"'*%(.3'2 ,-.&/'# -.&/3+5
'3(2&/%*%( ( )%1%93+5 )*%2:/.5 ),/26 )*21%&/.("23'# '6 3."%0%(+5 ";0%/ '"'
3."%0%(%0% :*21'/.. $.&>'*23'2 '3(2&/'4'8 )*'(212/ : *.<('/'? '3A*.&/*,:/,*+, %13.:%
1.33%6, )*%42&&, 32%95%1'6. )%112*7:., :.: '< A212*.";3%0% 423/*., /.: ' (3,/*'
*20'%3. [7].
C,$25,.
=*%(21233+8 .3."'< )*%9"26 0%&,1.*&/(233%0% *20,"'*%(.3'# '3(2&/'4'%33+5
)*%42&&%( ( &%(*26233+5 ,&"%('#5 )%<(%"#2/ (+12"'/; &"21,?F'2 <3.-'6+2 A.:/%*+:
- 32%95%1'6% ,&'"23'2 *20,"'*,?F28 *%"' 0%&,1.*&/(. 3. 3.4'%3.";3%6
'3(2&/'4'%33%6 *+3:2, -/% &(#<.3%, :.: & 3.*.&/.?F'6 6'*%(+6 '3(2&/'4'%33+6
:*'<'&%6, /.: ' & )2*2:%&.6' *.<('/'# *+3:. *%&&'8&:'5 '3(2&/'4'8, (%<3':>'5 ( 3.-."2
*+3%-3+5 *2A%*6;
- 0%&,1.*&/(%, )*2712 (&20%, 1%"73% %92&)2-'(./; ' )%112*7'(./; 9".0%)*'#/3+8
'3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./, :%/%*+8 (:"?-.2/ 0.*.3/'' )*.( &%9&/(233%&/', %)*212"#2/
5.*.:/2* )*.(%(%0% *20,"'*%(.3'# '3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/', ,&/.3.("'(.2/
)*'%*'/2/3+2 &A2*+ 0%&,1.*&/(233%8 )%112*7:', A%*6'*,2/ 9".0%)*'#/3+2 ,&"%('# 1"#
.:/'('<.4'' -.&/3+5 '3(2&/'4'8.
H13%(*26233% & 62*.6' )% )%(+>23'? '3(2&/'4'%33%8 )*'("2:./2";3%&/' &/*.3+
( 42"%6, (%<6%73% &/'6,"'*%(.3'2 '3(2&/'4'%33%8 .:/'(3%&/' ( %)*212"233+5 *20'%3.5 '
%/*.&"#5. E.73+6 :*'/2*'26 )*' (+9%*2 %/*.&"' '"' *20'%3. 1"# ("%723'# :.)'/.".
#("#2/&# 3."'-'2 ( 1.33+5 &2:/%*.5 9".0%)*'#/3+5 1"# '3(2&/%*. ,&"%('8, (:"?-.#
*.<('/,? '3A*.&/*,:/,*,.
D2)2/E(2$ C. F.
J.@.3., )*2)%1.(./2"; A'3.3&%(%8 .:.126'' )*' )*.('/2";&/(2 $Q
G%&')"&6)"
1. B&.," B.C., !23'&%(. D.E. D31'('1,.";3%2 7'"'F3%2 &/*%'/2";&/(% – )2*&)2:/'(3%2
3.)*.("23'2 *.<('/'# &2";&:'5 )%&2"23'8 (3. )*'62*2 P23'30*.1&:%8 %9".&/') //
B:/,.";3+2 )*%9"26+ '3(2&/'4'%33%-&/*%'/2";3%0% )*%42&&. ( M.3:/-=2/2*9,*02 : /26./.
&9. /*. E+). 1 M=9. : M/*%8'<1./ M=9, 2002.
2. !.1'3. P.Q. E"%723'# :.)'/.". ' 0%&,1.*&/(233+2 '3&/*,623/+ ,)*.("23'#
'3(2&/'4'%33%8 12#/2";3%&/;?// E2&/3': IDMGD. - 2003. - S4.
3. M.6,@";&%3 =.: N:%3%6':.: E 2 /. - V.: B"0%3, 1992.
4. V,52/1'3%(. C.C. D3(2&/'4'' ' 0%&,1.*&/(233.# '3(2&/'4'%33.# )%"'/':. //
$%&&'8&:'8 @:%3%6'-2&:'8 7,*3.".– 2002. - S 8.
5. V."+>2( B.P. $%"; 0%&,1.*&/(. ( *20,"'*%(.3'' '3(2&/'4'%33%0% )*%42&&. //E2&/3':
IDMGD. - 2003. - S1.
6. W1.2(. J.E. D3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./ ' '3A*.&/*,:/,*. ' '5 ("'#3'2 3.
:%3:,*23/%&)%&%93%&/; )*21)*'#/'8// P2%3/;2(&:'2 -/23'#. - 2006. - S 4.
7. P.*'%3%( !. D3(2&/'4'%33+8 :"'6./ ( *20'%3.5 & /%-:' <*23'# <.).13%0%
'3(2&/%*.//G.3:%(&:%2 12"% ( V%&:(2. – 2000. - S3 (63).