Кто они НЕОХАРИДЖИТЫ (ваххабиты-«салафиты»)?

реклама
=Z[^meeZZe-DZolZgb
DlhhgbG?HO:JB>@BLU
\ZooZ[blu-©kZeZnbluª?
OZmeybomfZe-oZ\Zjb^`
Ba^Zl_evkl\h©BfZgª
DZaZgv
I_j_\_ekZjZ[kdh]hyaudZgZmqguckhljm^gbdhl^_eZ
h[s_kl\_gghcfukebbbkeZfh\_^_gbyBgklblmlZbk
lhjbb
bfRFZj^`Zgb:GJL
:^u]Zfh\JZfbevDZfbeh\bq
Hl\_lkl\_ggucaZ\uimkd—i_j\ucaZf_klbl_ev
fmnlbyLZlZjklZgZij_^k_^Zl_ev\Zdmnh\<ZebmeeZ
oZajZlY]tdm[
IjZ\hgZi_j_ba^Zgb_wlhcdgb]b\ZjZ[kdhfhjb]bgZe_ijb
gZ^e_`bl ex[hfm fmkmevfZgbgm h^gZdh Z\lhj g_ ij_^hklZ\
ey_lijZ\Z\ghkblv\g__dZdb_-eb[hbaf_g_gby
Ih^ibkZghdi_qZlb
NhjfZl;
I_qZlvhnk_lgZyI_qZlguoebklh\
AZdZa‹ 8
LbjZ`
Ba^Zl_evkl\h©BfZgªDZaZgvmeDGZkujb
Ba^Zl_evkl\h©BfZgª
©
2
WlZ dgb]Z Z^j_kh\ZgZ \k_f l_f dlh bs_l
bklbgmb\qZklghklbl_fdlh^he]h_\j_
fy `be \h lvf_ \ZooZ[blkdhc b^_heh]bb
dlh [ue h[fZgml djZkb\ufb ehamg]Zfb
wlhck_dlu
<hbfy:eeZoZFbehklb\h]hFbehk_j^gh]h
Ij_^bkeh\b_dh\lhjhfmba^Zgbx
AZq_f\ujZaju\Z_l_gZqZklb
fmkmevfZgkdmxmffm"
O\ZeZ :eeZom agZxs_fm jZkdju\Zxs_fm bklbgm
kbevg_cr_fm h[eZ^Zl_ex \eZklb Ih ?]h fbehklb fu l\hjbf
[eZ]h_;eZ]hkeh\_gb_bfbjIhke_^g_fmijhjhdmihkeZgghfm
kjZ^hklghc\_klvx\dZq_kl\_k\_lhqZ^eyfbjh\FmoZffZ^m
^Z h[eZ]h^_l_evkl\m_l b ijb\_lkl\m_l :eeZo _]h \kx _]h k_
fvxbkih^\b`gbdh\>Ze__
WlZ dgb]Z \ua\ZeZ [hevrhc Z`bhlZ` m`_ ^h lh]h dZd
[ueZ ba^ZgZ \ i_j\uc jZa b dhg_qgh `_ m qblZl_e_c \hagbd
\iheg_ aZdhgguc b aZdhghf_jguc \hijhk qlh `_ ihkem`beh
ijbqbghc gZibkZgby wlhc dgb]b" O\ZeZ :eeZom \ ihke_^g__
\j_fygZf_lbeZkvl_g^_gpbyk[eb`_gbyfmkmevfZgkdbofZaoZ
[h\fmkmevfZg_gZwlhfimlbkh\_jrZxl\k_[hevr_ihablb\
guo rZ]h\ b ^Z`_ kha^Zxl ki_pbZevgu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ p_gl
juDjhf_wlh]hfmkmevfZgkdb_mq_gu_q_j_ak\hbdgb]blZd`_
\_^mlijhiZ]Zg^mfmkmevfZgkdh]h_^bgkl\Z\qZklghklbohq_l
kyhlf_lblvdgb]m^hdlhjZFmklZnuZr-RZdZ]ZlZ©BkeZf[bey
fZaZob[ª ©BkeZf [_a fZaoZ[h\ª1 dgb]m mq_gh]h OZkZgZ ZlLmjZ[b©BggZgbfmkebfeyklmkmggbygmZeyrb]bygª©Yfm
kmevfZgbgg_kmggblbg_rbblªlZd`_ohq_lkyhlf_lblvih
abpbxmq_gh]h:ofZ^ZZe-OZebebijbau\Zxs_]hdh\k_h[s_
fmh[t_^bg_gbxfmkmevfZgijbq_fhgkqblZ_lqlhwlh^_ckl
\bl_evgh \hafh`gh ihkdhevdm \k_ jZagh]eZkby kj_^b fmkmev
Ihke_^g__ ba^Zgb_ wlhc dgb]b [ueh ljbgZ^pZluf wlhl nZdl \ i_j\mx
hq_j_^vk\b^_l_evkl\m_lhlhfqlhfmkmevfZghq_gv\hegm_ll_fZ_^bgkl\Z
1
3
fZgk\h^ylkyebrvd\lhjhkl_i_gguf\hijhkZfijZ\Zbg_dZ
kZxlkyhkgh\fmkmevfZgkdhcj_eb]bb
>Z ^_ckl\bl_evgh fmkmevfZgkdZy bklhjby agZ_l fgh
`_kl\h ijbf_jh\ ^h[jhkhk_^kdh]h kms_kl\h\Zgby jZaebqguo
fmkmevfZgkdbo l_q_gbc \ jZfdZo h^gh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z GZijb
f_jrbblug_dhlhjh_\j_fyijZ\beb\?]bil_aZeh`bebhkgh
\umgb\_jkbl_lZ©Ze-:aoZjªdhlhjuciha^g__[_adjh\hijheb
lbyi_j_r_e\jmdbkmggblh\Bohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhrbblu
\h \j_fy k\h_]h ijZ\e_gby g_ ijbgm`^Zeb kmggblh\ baf_gblv
k\hb m[_`^_gby LZd`_ ohq_lky \kihfgblv b[Z^blkdh_ ]hkm
^Zjkl\h\FZjhddh_]hijZ\bl_eb[uebba\_klgudZdjmklZfb
^u bo ijZ\e_gb_ [ueh hq_gv kijZ\_^eb\uf b lhe_jZglguf
hgb g_ ijbl_kgyeb gb b[Z^blh\ gb kmggblh\ gb rbblh\ <k_
wlb l_q_gby ijb gbo `beb hq_gv ^jm`gh b \_eb ^`boZ^ ih^
_^bgufagZf_g_f2.
YjqZcrbf ijbf_jhf lhe_jZglghklb kem`bl ih\_^_gb_
bfZfZ Gmjm^^bgZ Zk-KZebfb dhlhjuc ihk_sZy j_]bhgu
>`Z]eygZHfZg]^_ijh`b\Zebie_f_gZ;Zgm:[m=Zebh[m
qZe bo jh^ghfm ^ey gbo oZg[Zeblkdhfm3 fZaoZ[m \ lh \j_fy
dZd kZf [ue b[Z^blhf : \_^v wlh [ue q_eh\_d h[eZ^Z\rbc
h]jhfghc \eZklvx b hdZaZ\rbc ^hklhcguc hlihj ;jblZgkdhc
bfi_jbb dh]^Z lZ ohl_eZ aZ\eZ^_lv :jZ\bckdbf ihemhkljh
\hf4 >jm]hc ijbf_j ^h[jhkhk_^kdbo b lhe_jZglguo hlghr_
Kf©:o[ZjZe-ZbffZlbZj-jmklZfbbgZªB[gZk-KZ]bjZb©BkeZf[beyfZ
aZob[ª^hdFmklZnuZr-RZdZ]Zlbk-ba^Zgb_ZlZd`_khqb
g_gbyfZjhddZgkdbobklhjbdh\bihwlh\
3
Iha^g__ \ j_amevlZl_ \ZooZ[blkdbo gZ[_]h\ `bl_eb wlh]h j_]bhgZ ih^
kljZohf kf_jlb [ueb \ugm`^_gu ijbgylv \ZooZ[blkdmx b^_heh]bx Ih
^jh[g__h[wlhf[m^_ljZkkdZaZghiha`_
4
Wlhlmq_gucbfh^`Zo_^`be\q_lujgZ^pZlhf\_d_ihob^`j_dhg_p–
k_fb^_kylu_]h^u\\_]h`bagv[ueZdhjhldZghg_kfhljygZwlh:e
eZoh[eZ]h^_l_evkl\h\Ze__[ZjZdZlhfHghklZ\beihke_k_[yh]jhfgh_gZ
mqgh-dmevlmjgh_gZke_^b_b\g_kk\hc\deZ^\jZa\blb_lZdbogZmddZdbk
lhjbyoZ^bknbdoebl_jZlmjZ<kx`bagvhgijbau\ZefmkmevfZgh[t_^b
gblvky ih^ _^bguf agZf_g_f b \_e ^`boZ^ ijhlb\ dhehgbaZlhjh\ – b wlh
ijblhfqlhhg[ueke_i;bh]jZnbblZdboex^_cdZdhgke_^m_lbamqZlv
hl^_evgh
2
4
gbc–aZc^blubrZnb]bluC_f_gZdhlhju_\_dZfb`b\ml[hd
h[hd^jm]k^jm]hf^_eyloe_[bdjh\<q_f`_lh]^Zijh[e_
fZaZq_fgm`gZ^ZggZydgb]Z"
Ijh[e_fZ ebrv \ h^ghc k_dl_ ihy\b\r_cky hlghkb
l_evgh g_^Z\gh b ihklZ\b\r_c k\h_c p_evx \g_k_gb_ jZa^hjZ
f_`^mfmkmevfZgZfbBf_gghihwlhfm__ij_^klZ\bl_ebh[\b
gyxlij_^klZ\bl_e_clh]hbebbgh]hfmkmevfZgkdh]hl_q_gby\
g_\_jbb [he__ lh]h hgb \kx fmkmevfZgkdmx mffm h[ty\beb
aZ[em^rbfb yauqgbdZfb ?keb dlh-eb[h ba fmkmevfZg \uklm
iZ_l ijhlb\ gbo lh hgb lml `_ h[ty\eyxl _]h g_\_jguf Wlh
k_dlZ\ZooZ[blh\dhlhjZyijbagZ_llhevdhf_qb^_gv]b
<ZooZ[bluh[ty\bebqlhq_luj_fmkmevfZgkdbofZaoZ
[Z g_ hlghkylky d kmggbafm ihkdhevdm ijb^_j`b\Zxlky ZrZ
jblkdbo5 m[_`^_gbc b y\eyykv kmnbyfb ydh[u hijh\_j]Zxl
[h`_kl\_ggu_ Zljb[mlu Hgb \hh[s_ hljbpZxl ihgylb_ kmg
gbafZbij_^eZ]Zxlgh\ucl_jfbg–kZeZnbaf6.
<ZooZ[blu h[ty\beb rbblh\-aZc^blh\ b rbblh\^`Z]nZjblh\aZ[em^rbfbbg_\_jgufb
:rZjblu – ihke_^h\Zl_eb :[m Ze-OZkZgZ :[m Fmku Ze-:r]Zjb mf
] ?]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`bl fgh`_kl\h dgb] kj_^b dhlhjuo ©:e-B[ZgZ
]Zg mkme Z^-^bygZª ©FZdZeZl Ze-bkeZfbyª ©:e-ExfZ]ª ©JbkZeZl nb bk
lbokZg Ze-oZm^ nb Ze-dZeZfª < k\hbo dgb]Zo hg hijh\_j]Z_l fmlZabebl
kdmx b^_heh]bx b ^hdZau\Z_l bklbgghklv kmggblkdhc :rZjblkdbo m[_`
^_gbc\gZrb^gbijb^_j`b\Z_lky[hevrbgkl\hfmkmevfZg-kmggblh\hkgh
\hcwlbom[_`^_gbyy\eyxlkykeh\ZZe-:r]Zjb©GZrbkeh\ZbgZrZj_eb
]by – wlh ke_^h\Zgb_ DhjZgm kmgg_ IjhjhdZ k]k fg_gbyf kih^\b`gb
dh\ lZ[b]bgh\ b bfZfh\-oZ^bkh\_^h\ Fu ^_j`bfky wlh]h imlb b imlb
mdZaZggh]hbfZfhf:ofZ^hf[bgOZg[ZehfbhlkljZgy_fkyhll_odlhg_
ke_^m_lwlbfiml_f<hbklbgmwlhijZ\_^gucbfZfmklZfbdhlhjh]h:eeZo
jZkdjuebklbgmbgba\_j]aZ[em`^_gb_ª<blh]_ihemqZ_lkyqlh\ZooZ[blu
hljbpZxl ijbgZ^e_`ghklv bfZfZ :ofZ^Z d kmggblZf b g_ aZ[u\Zcl_ qlh
ZrZjblkdhc Zdu^u ijb^_j`b\Zxlky gZ k_]h^gyrgbc ^_gv fZebdblu b rZ
nb]blu
6
Kf]eZ\m©:oekmggZ–ZoeZ^-^Zeye]bg^ZZe-\ZooZ[byª©Kmggblu\]eZ
aZo\ZooZ[blh\–aZ[em^r__l_q_gb_ª
5
5
<ZooZ[bluh[ty\bebb[Z^blh\aZ[em^rbfbbaZij_lbeb
kh\_jrZlvfhebl\uaZb[Z^blkdbfbbfZfZfb7.
<ZooZ[blu h[ty\beb aZ[em^rbfb ^\b`_gb_ ©;jZlvyfmkmevfZg_ª8.
<ZooZ[blu h[ty\beb aZ[em^rbfb ^\b`_gb_ ©>`ZfZ]Zl
Z^-^Z]\Z\ZZl-lZ[eb]ªbaZij_lbebbf^_ckl\h\ZlvgZl_jjblh
jbbF_ddbbF_^bgu9.
<ZooZ[blu ih f_j_ \hafh`ghklb aZgbfZxl ihklu bfZ
fh\\aZiZ^guokljZgZob\ghkyljZa^hj\fmkmevfZgkdmxmf
fm]^_[uhgbgb[uebijbghkylfmkmevfZgZf]hj_bjZa^hj10.
<ZooZ[blu hihjhqbeb fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo \g_krbo
h]jhfguc\deZ^\\hajh`^_gb_BkeZfZg_kfhljygZlhqlhwlb
mq_gu_m`_ihdbgmebk_cfbj11<qZklghklbbodjblbdZaZljh
gmeZB[g>`ZjbjZZl-LZ[ZjboZ^bkh\_^ZZl-Lbjfbab12bfZfZ
Ze-=ZaZebZ\lhjZdgb]b©Boty]memfZ^-^bgª13Gmjml^bgZZkKZebfb KZb^Z Dml[Z bfZfZ Ze-Ohf_cgb Zr-RZ]jZ\b b ^jm
]bo
<ZooZ[blu\k\hbodgb]Zoh[\bgyxlfmkmevfZg\g_\_
jbbb\ghkyljZa^hj\fmkmevfZgkdmxmffm
<ZooZ[blu bkdZ`Zxl dgb]b fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo Z
aZl_fbkihevamxlbo\k\hbo]gmkguop_eyo14.
Kfn_l\mr_coZB[g;ZaZba^Zggmxhlbf_gbdhfbl_lZdjmig_crbomq_
guoih^ghf_jhfhl]]
8
Kf ©:e-<ZooZ[by \Z Ze-oZjZdZl Ze-bkeZfbyª ©<ZooZ[blu b fmkmevfZg
kdb_^\b`_gbyª
9
Kf khqbg_gby bo mq_gh]h OZfm^Z [bg =Z[^meeu ©:e-DZmem Ze-[Zeb] nb
Zl-Zloabjfbg^`ZfZ]ZZl-lZ[eb]ªwlh^\b`_gb_kqblZ_lkyaZij_s_gguf\
\ZooZ[blkdbokljZgZo
10
Kf ©Fbg ZkZj Ze-\Zofby ebeb [b^Z] Zk-kZeZnbyª ©IZ]m[gu_ ihke_^kl
\bykZeZnblkdbogh\h\\_^_gbcª
11
Kf©:e-OZeZaZe-nbdjb]bg^ZZe-\ZooZ[byª©Bgl_ee_dlmZevgu_rmldb
\ZooZ[blh\ª
12
Kf ©DZcnZ ylZ]ZfZex Ze-oZrZ\by fZ]Z Ze-]meyfZª ©DZd hlghkylky oZ
rZ\bludmq_gufª
13
Kf dgb]b K_ebfZ Ze-Obeyeb \ dhlhjuo hg djblbdm_l ba\_klgh]h dhf
f_glZlhjZDhjZgZKZ]b^ZOZ\\ZOZkZgZZe-;Zggmb^jm]bomq_guo
14
Kf©DZa[Ze-oZrZ\by]ZeyZbffZlZe-Zj[Z]Zª©OZrZ\blkdZyeh`v\Z^
j_kq_luj_obfZfh\ª
7
6
<ZooZ[bluqlh[uijbclbd\eZklbjZa\yaZebl_jjhjgZ
l_jjblhjbb :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkljh\Z h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gguf
ijheblb_djh\bfmkmevfZggZkZfhf`_^_e_\k_wlhkh\_jrZ
ehkvlhevdhjZ^bgZ`b\u^eylh]hqlh[uaZ\eZ^_lvboa_fey
fbbbfms_kl\hf15.
?keb [u bo b^_b bf_eb ohlv dZdmx-lh p_gghklv fu [u
boijbgyebgh^_eh\lhfqlhbog_^Ze_dbcjZamfba[jZeb^_x
Zgljhihfhjnghklb [h]Z lZr[bo [he__ lh]h hgb h[ty\beb
^ha\he_gguf ijheblb_ djh\b l_o dlh ijb^_j`b\Z_lky fg_gby
hlhfqlha_fey\jZsZ_lky\hdjm]khegpZ
GZ ijZdlbd_ kdeZ^u\Z_lky lZdh_ hsms_gb_ qlh bo
_^bgkl\_gghc p_evx y\ey_lky mgbqlh`_gb_ BkeZfZ \hh[s_ B
\ wlhf g_l gbq_]h kljZggh]h \_^v m`_ ihke_ kf_jlb IjhjhdZ
k]khgbihke_^h\ZebaZFmkZceZfhcbklZeb\_jhhlklmigb
dZfbH[jZlgh\ehghBkeZfZbokfh]\_jgmlvlhevdhf_qOZ
eb^Z [bg <Zeb^Z b ^jm]bo kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ k]k Gh
\kihfgbl_dZdhgb\_jgmebkv\BkeZf–hgb\_jgmebkvlhevdh
ihke_lh]hdZdm[bebAZc^Z[bgOZllZ[Zb^jm]bokih^\b`gb
dh\agZ\rbogZbamklv\_kvDhjZgq_fgZg_kebBkeZfmk_jv_a
gmxjZgm
BklbgZ b fm^jhklv ba\_klgZ lhevdh h^ghfm :eeZom gh
ihijhr_kl\bb\_dh\wlZjZgZ\gh\vgZqZeZba\_j]Zlvky]gh_f
<ZooZ[blu\gh\v\_jgmebkv>Zl_i_jvhgbg_ke_^mxlaZe`_
ijhjhdhf h^gZdh hgb ihevamxlky l_fb `_ kZfufb klZjufb
f_lh^Zfbb\gh\vijheb\Zxldjh\vfmkmevfZg16L_i_jv\ZooZ
[blugZ^_\fmkmevfZgkdb_ieZsbiulZxlkyjZajmrblvBkeZf
bagmljbhq_jgblv_]h\]eZaZo^jm]boex^_cBogh\ucehamg]
-©;hjv[Zkfh]behihdehggbq_kl\hfªhg^Z_lbf\hafh`ghklv
h[ty\blvg_\_jgufb\k_ofmkmevfZg`b\msbogZa_fe_
Bf_ggh ihwlhfm y kq_e k\h_c h[yaZgghklxv jZatykgblv
kmlvwlhck_dlub\g_klbk\hc\deZ^\bkdhj_g_gb_wlh]h]ghc
Kf©:e-<ZooZ[bylmZk-kZnnZomgª©Djh\h`Z^gu_\ZooZ[bluª
G_kfhljygZ\k_ihl_jbfmkmevfZgZfm^ZehkvaZf_^eblvjZkijhkljZg_gb_
wlh]h ^\b`_gby dh]^Z _]bi_lkdbc iZrZ FmoZffZ^]Zeb dZd ij_^klZ\bl_ev
HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbb\]kh\_jrbeihoh^gZa_febaZo\Zq_ggu_\ZooZ
[blZfbZ\]hk\h[h^behlgbo\_kvG_^`^
15
16
7
gbdZkqbklh]hl_eZBkeZfZ<k\h_cjZ[hl_yihevah\Zekyljm
^Zfb b e_dpbyfb17 fgh]bo mq_guo ij_^klZ\bl_e_c jZaebqguo
l_q_gbcpblZlZfbba\ZooZ[blkdbodgb]be_dpbc\ukdZau\Z
gbyfbjmdh\h^bl_e_cojbklbZgkdh]hfbjZdhlhju_g_hljbpZ
xl18 ihe_aghklv \ZooZ[blkdhc k_dlu \ ^hklb`_gbb bo p_e_c
>ZyagZxqlhhlghr_gb_\ZooZ[blh\dhfg_[m^_lklZgh\blv
kyom`_bom`_ghg_kfhljygZwlhibrmwlmdgb]m\gZ^_`^_
gZ fbehklv :eeZoZ ihbklbg_ Hg g_ ih]m[bl ^_ygby l_o dlh
l\hjbl[eZ]h_
Ij_^bkeh\b_di_j\hfmba^Zgbx
O\ZeZ:eeZomfbjb[eZ]hkeh\_gb_?]hba[jZgghfmih
keZggbdm^Ze__
GZqbgZyk^g_cFmkZceZfuZe-DZaaZ[ZbGZ^`^Zlu[bg
=ZfbjZZe-OZgbnb\gZr_cmff_\j_fyhl\j_f_gbihy\eyxlky
jZaebqgu__j_lbq_kdb_l_q_gbybk_dlu<hlb\gZr_f\_d_ba
a_f_evG_^`^Z\ujhkjh]kZlZgudhlhjucijhy\beky\^\b`_
gbb \ZooZ[bafZ dhlhjh_ \iehlv ^h gZrbo ^g_c k__l jZa^hj
kj_^b fmkmevfZg h[\bgyy _^bgh[h`gbdh\ \ yauq_kl\_ b ijh
eb\Zy bo djh\v g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh hgb aZy\eyxl ©GZr =hk
ih^v:eeZoª
Fu\wlhcdgb]_ohlbfjZkdjulvi_j_^\ahjhfqblZl_ey
kmlv wlh]h ZglbbkeZfkdh]h ^\b`_gby kem`Zs_]h hjm`b_f bm
^__\ b ojbklbZg \ bo [hjv[_ ijhlb\ BkeZfZ <ZooZ[blu h[\b
gyxlfmkmevfZg\g_\_jbbbf_lh^bqghklZjZxlkymgbqlh`Zlv
k\hboijhlb\gbdh\fu`_hklZ\ey_fdhg_qgu_\u\h^ugZkm^
qblZl_ey imklv hg kZf hl\_lbl k_[_ dh]h ke_^m_l bkdhj_gblv
;hevrbgkl\hgZrboklZl_cihwlhcl_fZlbd_jZaf_s_gh\Bg
l_jg_l_
F_`^m gbfb b gZfb ijhbkoh^beb h`_klhq_ggu_ ^bk
dmkkbbh^gZdh\blh]_\b^ygZrb^hklhcgu_hl\_lub^h\h^u
hgb[ueb\ugm`^_guijbdjulvh^gmbak\hbokljZgbq_d\Bg
l_jg_l_ < gZr_c jZ[hl_ gZf ihfh]Zeb mq_gu_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb
WlZdgb]Zy\ey_lky\a]ey^hffmkmevfZggZwlbooZjb^`blh\
< k\h_c jZ[hl_ y hkgh\u\Zeky lhevdh gZ ^hklh\_jguo \ukdZau\Zgbyo b
dgb]ZoZlZd`_gZijbagZgbyokZfbo\ZooZ[blh\
17
18
8
jZaebqguo fZaoZ[h\ ^Z\Z\rb_ gZf ihe_agu_ n_l\u b gZf
m^Zehkv jZkdjulv kmlv wlhc k_dlu Ihwlhfm fu kqblZ_f k\h_c
h[yaZgghklvx jZkdjulb_ wlhc bklbgu ^ey rbjhdh]h djm]Z qb
lZl_e_c19.
Y dhg_qgh `_ iulZeky aZ\_jrblv wlm dgb]m dZd fh`gh
[uklj__ gh \h \j_fy jZ[hlu \uy\eyebkv \k_ gh\u_ b gh\u_
\_sbdhlhju_[uehijhklhg_h[oh^bfhhk\_lblvYgZklhevdh
[ueih]ehs_gwlhcjZ[hlhcqlhhlju\Zekyhlg__lhevdhlh]^Z
dh]^ZkeurZeijbau\gZmlj_ggxxfhebl\m
B\hlgZklmibefhf_gldh]^Zy\k_-lZdbj_rbehklZgh
\blvkybba^Zlvlhqlhm`_[ueh]hlh\hH^gZdhk\hxjZ[hlmy
gZwlhfg_aZ\_jrZxZgZf_j_\Zxkvb^Ze__ba^Z\ZlvklZlvbb
dgb]b h[ wlhf ^\b`_gbb \ghkys_f jZa^hj \ fmkmevfZgkdmx
mffm Ihwlhfm h`b^Zcl_ gh\uo fZl_jbZeh\ \_^v dZd ba\_kl
gh^h`^vgZqbgZ_lkyki_j\hcdZieb
A^_kv y ohqm h[jZlblv \Zr_ \gbfZgb_ gZ h^gh hq_gv
\Z`gh_ h[klhyl_evkl\h gZrZ dgb]Z djblbdm_l l_o dlh nZgZ
lbqgh ijb^_j`b\Z_lky \ZooZ[blkdbo b^_c b ijhiZ]Zg^bjm_l
bobgbkdhevdhg_aZljZ]b\Z_ll_ofmkmevfZgdhlhju_`b\ml\
F_dd_ b F_^bg_ bkihegyy ij_^ibkZgby k\h_c j_eb]bb b g_
ke_^mxlgbdZdbfl_q_gbyf
Iha^g__ \ZooZ[blu hldjueb gh\uc kZcl gh _]h m`_ dhgljhebjh\Zeb bo
hl\_lkl\_ggu_ ebpZ dhlhju_ g_f_^e_ggh m^Zeyeb l_ \hijhku b khfg_gby
h[s_kl\_gghklb gZ dhlhju_ m gbo g_ [ueh hl\_lZ GZijbf_j fu ebqgh
aZ^Zebbf\hijhkhlghkbl_evghdhff_glZjbydZdu^_Zl-LZoZ\b]^_hg\u
kdZau\Z_l b^_x h g_khklhyl_evghklb fbjh\haaj_gby bf ih^h[guo b hgb
f]gh\_gghm^Zebebwlhl\hijhkGZk_]h^gyrgbc^_gv\ZooZ[bluh[\bgyxl
\g_\_jbbg_lhevdhb[Z^blh\rbblh\ghb\k_q_luj_fmkmevfZgkdbofZa
oZ[Z \ dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Z k\h_c ihabpbb hgb bkihevamxl n_l\u B[g ;ZaZ b
Ze-=mk_cfbgZhydh[ug_khklhyl_evghklbZrZjblkdhcZdu^uihkdhevdmlZ
g_\_jghljZdlm_l[h`_kl\_ggu_Zljb[mlu<blh]_ihemqZ_lkyqlhk_cqZk\
fbj__^bgkl\_ggufbfmkmevfZgZfby\eyxlkylhevdh\ZooZ[blu
19
9
<\_^_gb_
DlhlZdb_oZjb^`blu"
?klvfgh`_kl\hoZ^bkh\\dhlhjuokhh[sZ_lkyhihy\
e_gbb_j_lbq_kdhck_dludhlhjZy[m^_lbklj_[eylv_^bgh[h`
gbdh\hklZ\eyyg_\j_^bfufbyauqgbdh\G_dhlhju_iulZebkv
ljZdlh\Zlv wlb oZ^bku b ]h\hjbeb qlh wlh \k_ `bl_eb ZgGZoZj\ZgZ\uklmib\rb_ijhlb\=ZebY`_gZhkgh\_ZgZebaZ
ijbr_e d \u\h^m qlh wlb oZ^bku g_ hlghkylky gb d h^ghc ba
klhjhg iheblbq_kdh]h dhgnebdlZ kj_^b dhlhjuo [ueb m\Z`Z
_fu_ kZoZ[u BlZd wlh g_ hlghkblky gb d `bl_eyf ZgGZoZj\ZgZgbd\hckdm=Zcrbgbd\hckdmFm]Z\bbIhq_fm"
>Z ihlhfm qlh \ wlbo \hckdZo \_a^_ [ueb m\Z`Z_fu_ kZoZ[u
ihq_fm `_ Ijhjhd k]k \u^_ebe kZoZ[h\ b hklZ\be [_a \gb
fZgbyjZaebqgu_k_dlu"
<lh`_\j_fyyaZf_lbeqlh\ur_mihfygmlu_eh`gu_
j_qb jZkijhkljZgyxl ij_^klZ\bl_eb gh\hc \ZooZ[blkdhc k_d
lubf_gghhgb\gh\vb\gh\vlj_\h`Zldhklbm\Z`Z_fuokih
^\b`gbdh\
Gb`_fuijb\h^bfg_dhlhju_bamihfygmluooZ^bkh\
©;eb`_ d Km^ghfm ^gx ihy\blky ]jmiiZ ex^_c k fh
ehqgufb am[Zfb ]emiufb b^_yfb ijhbaghkysbo emqrb_
j_qbh^gZdhhgb[m^mlihdb^ZlvBkeZflZd`_[ukljhdZdih
db^Z_lklj_eZl_lb\memdZbo\_jZg_ih^gbf_lky\ur_]hj
eZ?keb\ubo\klj_lbl_lhg_ij_f_gghm[_cl_lhldlhm[v_l
bo ihemqbl gZ]jZ^m hl :eeZoZ \ Km^guc ^_gvª i_j_^Ze Ze;moZjb
Hl:[mKZ]b^ZZe-Om^jbi_j_^Z_lkyqlhIjhjhdk]k
kdZaZe ©GZ \hklhd_ ihy\ylky ex^b dhlhju_ [m^ml qblZlv Dh
jZgh^gZdhhgg_ij_klmiZ_l]jZgbpbo]hjeZWlbex^b[m^ml
ihdb^Zlvj_eb]bxlZd`_dZdihdb^Z_lklj_eZl_lb\memdZih
ke_ q_]h hgb g_ \_jgmlky \ j_eb]bx ihdZ klj_eZ g_ \_jg_lky
h[jZlghdl_lb\_ªMIjhjhdZk]kkijhkbeb©DZdh\u`_hl
ebqbl_evgu_dZq_kl\Zwlboex^_c"ªhghl\_lbe©Bohlebqb_f
10
[m^_l[jblv_]heh\uªi_j_^ZeZe-;moZjb20.MFmkebfZkdZaZ
gh©Hgbhl^_eylkyhlex^_cª
H^gZ`^u=Zebj:]hlijZ\beIjhjhdmk]kahehlh
bIjhjhdk]kjZa^_ebe_]hf_`^m:j[Z]ZlhcZe-:djZ]m[bg
OZ[bkm Ze-OZgaZeb Ze-Fm^`Zrb]b =mycghc [bg ;Z^j ZeNZaZjbAZc^hfZl-LZtbh^gbfbaij_^klZ\bl_e_cie_f_gb;Z
gm GZo[Zg =ZevdZfhc [bg =meZkZlZ Ze-=Zfbjb b h^gbf ba
ij_^klZ\bl_e_cie_f_gb;ZgmDbey[MagZ\h_]hihklmid_Zg
kZjubfmoZ^`bjujZkk_j^bebkvbkdZaZeb©Ihq_fmhgjZa^Z_l
ahehlh]eZ\Zfg_^`^bckdboie_f_gZg_gZf"ªIjhjhdk]k
h[tykgyy kdZaZe ©Y `_eZx qlh[u hgb klZeb [eb`_ d gZfª
Q_j_ag_dhlhjh_\j_fydIjhjhdmk]kijbr_eq_eh\_dkaZ
\bkleb\ufb ]eZaZfb [e_klysbfb s_dZfb \uklmiZxsbf
e[hf]mklhc[hjh^hcihkljb`_ggucgZeukhbkdZaZe©HFm
oZffZ^ ih[hcky ;h]Zª b Ijhjhd k]k hl\_lbe ©Dlh `_ ih
[hblky:eeZoZ_kebyhkemrZxkv_]h"Hg^h\_jbefg_`bl_e_c
A_feb g_m`_eb \u g_ ^h\_jy_l_ fg_"ª Dlh-lh ba kih^\b`gb
dh\ihijhkbejZaj_r_gby_]hm[blv\hafh`ghwlh[ueOZeb^
[bg<Zeb^ghIjhjhdk]kaZij_lbem[b\Zlvwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
Dh]^Zhgmr_eIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©Bajh^Zwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
ihy\blky]jmiiZex^_cdhlhju_[m^mlqblZlvDhjZgh^gZdh
hgg_\uc^_l^Zevr_bo]hjeZwlbex^b[m^mlihdb^Zlvj_
eb]bx lZd `_ dZd klj_eZ ihdb^Z_l l_lb\m emdZ Wlb ex^b [m
^mlm[b\ZlvfmkmevfZgbhklZ\eylv\ihdh_yauqgbdh\?keby
^h`b\m^hl_o\j_f_glhg_ij_f_ggh[m^mkjZ`Zlvkykgbfbb
m[b\Zlv lZd `_ dZd [ueb m[blu ]Z^bluª \ ^jm]hf jb\Zyl_
©kZfm^bluªI_j_^ZeZe-;moZjbb^jm]b_
Hl B[g =mfZjZ j:] i_j_^Z_lky qlh hg keurZe dZd
Ijhjhdk]kih\_jgm\rbkvebphfgZ\hklhdkdZaZe©KfmlZ
ijb^_l hllm^Z ]^_ ihy\blky jh] kZlZguª I_j_^Ze FZebd Ze;moZjb Fmkebf :ofZ^ b ^jm]b_ < jb\Zyl_ hl :ofZ^Z kdZaZ
gh©Hgb\uc^mlk\hklhdZª
OZ^bkukihoh`bfb\ujZ`_gbyfb_klvmZg-GZkZbB[gFZ^`b:[m>Z
m^Zb:ofZ^Z
20
11
©Bafh_cmffu\uc^mlex^bk^mjgufb^_ygbyfbhgb
[m^mlqblZlvDhjZgh^gZdhhgg_ih^gbf_lky\ur_bo]hjeZª
Yab^ kdZaZe ©Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe ©<u [m^_l_ kqblZlv qlh
\Zrb^_ygbyimklyd\kjZ\g_gbbkbo^_ygbyfbh^gZdhhgb[m
^mlm[b\ZlvfmkmevfZgIhwlhfm_kebhgbihy\ylkylhm[b\Zc
l_bo_kebhgbihy\ylky\gh\vm[b\Zcl_bo_kebhgbihy\ylky
\gh\vm[b\Zcl_boDZdij_djZkgul_dlhbom[b\Z_lbih]b[Z
_lhlbojmdDZ`^ucjZadh]^Z[m^_l\ujZklZlvwlhljh]:e
eZo [m^_l _]h h[jm[Zlvª Wlb keh\Z Ijhjhd k]k ih\lhjbe
[he__^\Z^pZlbjZaZyklhyebkemrZeªI_j_^Ze:ofZ^
LZdh\ugZb[he__\Z`gu_oZ^bkuihwlhfmih\h^mqZklv
wlbooZ^bkh\^hklh\_jgZZqZklv–g_lMq_gu_^eywlhc_j_lb
q_kdhck_dlub\k_f__ij_^klZ\bl_e_cijb^mfZebl_jfbg©oZ
\Zjb^`ªoZjb^`blu21.
L_jfbg©oZjb^`bluªihy\beky\h\j_f_gZ=Zebj:]bbfbf_gh\Zeb
\k_odlh\uklmibeijhlb\g_]hbebijhlb\_]hklZ\e_ggbdh\GZijbf_j\
©LZjboZe-mfZf\ZZe-fmexdªZl-LZ[Zjblk\]eZ\_©?]hibkvfZd
FZebdm[bgZe-OZjbkmZe-:rlZjbªkdZaZgh©«YgZagZqbeFmoZffZ^Z[bg
:[m;ZdjZk\hbfgZf_klgbdhf\?]bil_ghijhlb\g_]h\hkklZeboZjb^`b
luª \ ^Zgghf kemqZ_ ih^ oZjb^`blZfb bf_xlky \ \b^m klhjhggbdb FmZ
\bb < ^jm]hf ibkvf_ =Zeb gZau\Z_l oZjb^`blZfb klhjhggbdh\=mkfZgZ\
C_f_g_ Dh]^Z hg \ dZq_kl\_ k\h_]h gZf_klgbdZ \ C_f_g_ ihklZ\be =m[Zc
^meem [bg Ze-=Z[[ZkZ Z \h_gZqZevgbdhf KZ]b^Z [bg GZfjZgZ `bl_eb C_
f_gZ\hkklZebijhlb\gboIhwlhfmih\h^m=Zebibr_l©<k\h_fibkvf_
\u ]h\hjbl_ h \hkklZgbb oZjb^`blh\«ª :[m Ze-OZ^b^ ©RZjo gZo^` Ze[Zey]Zª l k Wlbf `_ l_jfbghf =Zeb bf_gm_l `bl_e_c Zg-GZojZ\ZgZ
^_a_jlbjh\Z\rboba_]h\hckdZIha^g__`_l_jfbg©oZjb^`bluªklZeh[h
agZqZlv\k__j_lbq_kdb_]jmiiubk_dlu\ur_^rb_baehgZBkeZfZGZwlhl
`_l_jfbgmdZau\ZxlboZ^bkuIjhjhdZk]k\dhlhjuokdZaZgh©<uc
^ml b hl^_eylky hl ex^_cª ©<uc^ml k \hklhdZª ©Ba fh_c mffu \uc^_l
]jmiiZdhlhjZy[m^_ll\hjblvaehªH^gZdh\lh`_\j_fywlhll_jfbgfh
`_lh[hagZqZlvb\uoh^gZimlb:eeZoZgZijbf_j\DhjZg_kdZaZgh©?keb
dlhihdb^Z_lk\hc^hfgZijZ\eyykvd:eeZomb?]hihkeZggbdmb_keb_]h
>\ imlb@ ihklb]g_l kf_jlv lh \hagZ]jZ`^_gb_ _]h - aZ :eeZohf :eeZo ijhsZxsbcfbehk_j^gucª (4:100), ©?keb[uhgb`_eZeb\uklmiblv\ih
oh^lhijb]hlh\beb[u\h_ggh_kgZjy`_gb_ª (9:46), ©b_kebhgbihijhkyl
ml_[y^ha\he_gby\uklmiblv\ihoh^hl\_qZc©<ugbdh]^Zg_\uklmibl_
khfghc\ihoh^bgbdh]^Zg_klZg_l_kjZ`Zlvky\f_kl_khfghcijhlb\
\jZ]Zª (Fu`_\^Zgghcdgb]_ih^l_jfbghf©oZ\Zjb^`ªoZjb^`b
21
12
B _keb hkgh\guf djbl_jb_f wlhc k_dlu kqblZlv bo
[hjv[mk_^bgh[h`gbdZfbdhlhjuohgbh[\bgyxl\yauq_kl\_
lhklZgh\blkyykghqlhdihgylbx©oZjb^`blªfh`ghhlg_klb
ZajZdblh\ kZnjblh\ g_^`^blh\ b \k_o bf ih^h[guo B hq_gv
i_qZevgh qlh g_dhlhju_ mq_gu_ hlghkyl d gbf l_ iheblbq_k
db_ kbeu gZ klhjhg_ dhlhjuo [ueb kih^\b`gbdb b dhlhju_
\uklmiZebijhlb\=Zeb:qlhdZkZ_lky`bl_e_cZg-GZoZj\ZgZ
lhgbqlhg_k\b^_l_evkl\m_lhlhfqlhmihfygmlu_oZ^bkuhl
ghkylkydgbfLhevdh\h^ghfbaoZ^bkh\ihke_keh\hlhfqlh
wlb ex^b y\eyxlky _j_lbdZfb kdZaZgh ©Kj_^b gbo [m^_l q_
eh\_d k l_fguf p\_lhf dh`b gZ jmdZo _]h m[vxl \ ZgGZoZj\Zg_ =Zeb \_ebl hljm[blv _fm jmdm b [m^_l ^_j`Zlv __
\h\j_fyijhih\_^bª22.
Ke_^m_lhlf_lblvqlhoZ^bkkwlbf^h[Z\e_gb_fkh^_j
`bl\k_[_ke_^mxsb_khfgbl_evgu_fhf_glu
OZ^bk \ wlhf \ZjbZgl_ ijb\h^blky hl Ab Zk-KZ^by hl
:[mKZ]b^ZZe-Om^jbb_]hi_j_^ZelhevdhZa-Amojbijbq_fhg
kkueZekygZ:[mKZeZfmGZkZfhf`_^_e_gbh^bgbamq_gb
dh\:[mKZeZfugbFmoZffZ^[bgB[jZobfZl-LZcbfbgbZe:k\Z^[bg=ZeygbFmoZffZ^[bg=Zfjg_i_j_^Zxl_]h\lZ
dhcnhjf_GZh[hjhlhgbih\_kl\mxlqlh:[mKZeZfZb=ZlZ
[bgYkZjijb^yd:[mKZ]b^mZe-Om^jbkijhkbebmg_]hhoZ
jmjblZobhghl\_lbe©Yg_keurZehoZjmjblZoh^gZdhkeu
rZedZdIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©Bawlhcmffu\uc^_l«ªbg_
mihfygme^h[Z\e_gb_hq_eh\_d_kq_jgufbjmdZfb
Wlh ^h[Z\e_gb_ g_ mihfbgZxl b ^jm]b_ mq_gbdb :[m
KZ]b^ZZe-Om^jb\qZklghklb^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bkugZwlml_fm
i_j_^Zxlkyhl:[mZr-RZ]kZ>`Z[bjZb[gAZc^Z=Z[^jZofZgZ
[bg:[mGZ]bfZ:[mZk-Ku^^udZZg-GZ^`bYab^ZZe-NZdbjZ
FZ][Z^Z[bgKbjbgZb:[mGZ^jughgbh^bgbagbog_ijb
\h^blmihfygmlh]h^h[Z\e_gby
lu[m^_fbf_lv\\b^mlhevdh\ZooZ[blh\-_j_lbdh\ZboijbgZ^e_`ghklvd
_j_kbfuih\he_:eeZoZ^hdZ`_fgb`_
22
Ykgh qlh ihke_^gb_ keh\Z ^h[Z\e_gu \ oZ^bk fu gb \ dh_f kemqZ_ g_
ijbf_f lhl nZdl qlh ydh[u ih\_ebl_ev ijZ\h\_jguo =Zeb ]emfbeky gZ^
ljmiZfbhljm[ZybfjZaebqgu_hj]Zgu
13
QlhdZkZ_lkybfZfZ=Zeblh^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bkuhlg_
]hlZd`_i_j_^Zxlky[_amihfygmlh]h^h[Z\e_gby
HlkZfh]hAbZk-KZ^bbi_j_^Zxlkyjb\Zyluwlh]hoZ^b
kZ lZd`_ [_a ^h[Z\e_gby djhf_ lh]h [_a ^h[Z\e_gby wlhl oZ
^bk i_j_^Zxl lZdb_ kih^\b`gbdb dZd :gZk [bg FZebd =Z[
^meeZ[bg=mfZj=Z[^meeZ[bgFZk]m^:[m;ZdjZlZ:[mAZjj
Ze-=bnZjbJZnb][bg=mfZjZe-=bnZjbKZoe[bgOZgbn:[m
:fZfZZe-;Zoeb=Z[^meeZ[bg=Zfj[bgZe-=Zk=Zfbj[bg<Z
kbey
Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyjb\ZylZi_j_^Z\Z_fh]hhl>`Z[bjZ[bg
=Z[^meeu lh \ h^ghf ba a\_gv_\ p_ihqdb ihke_ g_]h klhbl
Fmkebf[bgFZddbdhlhjuc[ueba\_kl_gl_fqlhkZf\u^m
fu\Ze oZ^bku b bkdZ`Ze kms_kl\mxsb_ oZ^bku Z ke_^h\Z
l_evghwlhljb\ZyllZd`_y\ey_lkyg_^hklh\_jguf23.
GZrbkeh\Zih^l\_j`^Z_llhlnZdlqlh=Zebd`bl_eyf
Zg-GZoZj\ZgZ hlghkbeky emqr_ q_f d k\hbf ijhlb\gbdZf \
RZf_ b i_j_^ k\h_c kf_jlvx hg kdZaZe ©Ihke_ fh_c kf_jlb
g_m[b\Zcl_oZjb^`blh\ih\klZgp_\ª24_keb[u\_]hkeh\Zo
j_qvreZhgZklhysbooZjb^`blZo-_j_lbdZolhihemqbehkv[u
qlh =Zeb ih\_e_\Z_l hldZaZlvky hl h[yaZl_evgh]h ^_ckl\by Z
bf_gghbklj_[e_gby_j_lbdh\
GZ kZfhf ^_e_ bfZf =Zeb kjZ`Zeky k `bl_eyfb ZgGZoZj\ZgZ g_ ba-aZ lh]h qlh hgb [ueb oZjb^`blZfb Z ba-aZ
lh]hqlh\hkklZebijhlb\g_]h<jb\Zyl_Ze-;ZcoZdbi_j_^Zg
ghfhl:[m<Zbey[jZlZB[gKZeZfukdZaZgh©G_dlhkijhkbe
m =Zeb ©DZd fu magZ_f k\hbo fmeh\ \ lhl ^_gv dh]^Z [m^_f
\h_\Zlv k yauqgbdZfb"ª =Zeb kijhkbe ©Ihq_fm k yauqgbdZ
fb"ª Fm`qbgZ hl\_lbe ©K ebp_f_jZfb"ª =Zeb hl\_lbe ©Eb
p_f_juebrvbaj_^dZ\kihfbgZxl:eeZoZªFm`qbgZkijhkbe
©Dlh `_ lh]^Z gZrb ijhlb\gbdb"ª =Zeb hl\_lbe ©Hgb ih
\klZgpuihwlhfmfub\hx_fkgbfbª25.
Kf ^bkk_jlZpbx fZ]bkljZ GZkujZ Zk-KZ[b]b \ dhlhjhc hg ZgZebabjm_l
oZ^bkuhoZjb^`blZo
24
B[g:[mZe-OZ^b^©RZjogZo^`Ze-[Zey]ZªL–K
25
Jb\ZylhlB[g:[mRZc[u\_]hk[hjgbd_ih^ghf_jhf
23
14
BlZdfuk\Zfb\uykgbebqlh`bl_ebZg-GZoZj\ZgZg_
y\eyxlkyl_fbdlhmihfygml\oZ^bkZoIjhjhdZk]kHdhf
`_lh]^Zb^_lj_qv\wlbooZ^bkZo"Qlh[ugZclbhl\_lgZwlhl
\hijhk gZf ke_^m_l ijhZgZebabjh\Zlv \k_ oZ^bku h oZjb^`b
lZo b \u^_eblv \k_ dZq_kl\Z dhlhjufb bo hibku\Z_l Ijhjhd
k]k
:gZebaoZ^bkh\hoZjb^`blZo
KZfufb]eZ\gufbdZq_kl\ZfboZjb^`blh\mihfygmlu
fb\wlbooZ^bkZoy\eyxlky
Ihy\ylky\ihke_^g__\j_fy[eb`_dKm^ghfm^gx
–iiKe_^h\Zl_evghihbkl_q_gbbljbgZ^pZlb\_dh\fugb
dZd g_ fh`_f ml\_j`^Zlv qlh \ oZ^bkZo j_qv reZ h `bl_eyo
Zg-GZoZj\ZgZ ?keb `_ fu ijbkfhljbfky d i_jbh^m bklhjbb
[ebadhfmdgZflhm\b^bfqlh^_ckl\bl_evghihy\beZkvk_dlZ
dhlhjZyh[ty\ey_lfmkmevfZgyauqgbdZfbbaZy\ey_lhlhfqlh
bo kZfbo fh`gh m[b\Zlv Z bo bfms_kl\h ijbk\Zb\Zlv Ij_^
klZ\bl_ebwlhck_dlugZau\ZxlfmkmevfZgkdbomq_guofm[lZ
^b]Zfb b kqblZxl ijZ\ufb lhevdh kZfbo k_[y Fu ]h\hjbf h
k_dl_ \ZooZ[blh\ dhlhju_ k hkh[uf j\_gb_f oZ^bku h oZjb^
`blZohlghkyld`bl_eyfZg-GZoZj\ZgZ
WlZk_dlZ\uc^_llh]^Zdh]^Zex^bjZa^_eylkygZ
jZaebqgu_]jmiiu>Zfukh]eZkgukl_fqlhdh]^Z`bl_eb
Zg-GZoZj\ZgZ \uklmibeb ijhlb\ =Zeb kj_^b fmkmevfZg m`_
[uejZa^hjj_qvb^_lhijhlb\hklhygbbf_`^m=ZebbFmZ\b
_cGhaZf_lvl_qlh\oZ^bk_j_qvb^_lg_hjZa^hj_f_`^mfm
kmevfZgZfbZhjZa^hj_f_`^mex^vfb\hh[s_Qlh`_dZkZ_l
ky \ZooZ[blh\ lh hgb ^_ckl\bl_evgh ihy\bebkv bf_ggh lh]^Z
dh]^Z gZ gZr_c ieZg_l_ pZjbe jZa^hj f_`^m \k_fb ex^vfb
<kihfgbl_ fbjh\u_ \hcgu \kihfgbl_ dhehgbaZpbx fmkmev
fZgkdbo kljZg a_feb dhlhjuo bm^_b b ojbklbZg_ ih^_ebeb
f_`^mkh[hcG_dZ`_lkyeb\ZfkljZggufblhlnZdlqlh\Zo
oZ[blu \klj_qZxl \ rludb ex[u_ ijbau\u d h[t_^bg_gbx
fmkmevfZgkdh]h fbjZ GZijbf_j hgb kZfb aZy\eyxl qlh g_
15
ijbgyebijbau\OZkZgZZe-;Zggudk[eb`_gbxfmkmevfZgkdbo
fZaoZ[h\26.
Hgb\uc^mlk\hklhdZG_\uau\Z_lkhfg_gbyqlh\
oZ^bk_ ih^ \hklhdhf bf__lky \ \b^m G_^`^ < oZ^bk_ hl B[g
=mfZjZykghkdZaZghqlhIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©H:eeZo[eZ
]hkeh\b gZr RZf b C_f_gª Kih^\b`gbdb kdZaZeb ©B gZr
G_^`^ªIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©H:eeZo[eZ]hkeh\bgZrRZf
bC_f_gªKih^\b`gbdb\gh\vkdZaZeb©BgZrG_^`^ªLh]^Z
Ijhjhdk]khl\_lbe©<G_^`^_ihljyk_gbybkfmlubf_g
gh hllm^Z \hagbdg_l jh] kZlZguª27 ijhbag_ky wlb keh\Z Ijh
jhd k]k mdZaZe gZ \hklhd ih^l\_j`^Zy qlh j_qv b^_l h
G_^`^_ B gZ kZfhf ^_e_ \ZooZ[blkdZy k_dlZ aZjh^beZkv \
G_^`^_ [he__ lh]h hgb ijba\Zeb ex^_c i_j_k_eylvky \
G_^`^ohlyk_]h^gybhljbpZxlwlhlnZdl28.
Hgb[m^mlqblZlvDhjZgh^gZdhhgg_ih^gbf_lky
\ur_bo]hjeZ<uklmie_gb_`bl_e_cZg-GZoZj\ZgZ[ueh\u
a\Zgh`_eZgb_fkh[exklbij_^ibkZgbyDhjZgZihkdhevdmhgb
[uebm[_`^_guqlhq_eh\_dg_bf__lijZ\hij_^ihqblZlvk\hb
\u\h^u_keb_klvk\ys_ggucl_dklihwlhfmih\h^mHgbagZ
eb qlh DhjZghf mklZgh\e_gu gZdZaZgby aZ \hjh\kl\h \hkklZ
gb_ b ijhqb_ gZjmr_gby aZdhgZ DZd \b^bl_ DhjZg g_ lhevdh
ih^gyeky \ur_ ]hjeZ `bl_e_c Zg-GZoZjZ\ZgZ gh [he__ lh]h
hgb`_eZebij_l\hjblvaZ\_luDhjZgZ\`bagvQlh`_dZkZ_lky
\ZooZ[blh\ lh hgb evxl djhdh^beh\u ke_au \ k\ys_gg_crbo
f_q_lyogh\lh`_\j_fyde_\_smlgZfmkmevfZgbihevamxl
ky^eyk\hbop_e_cbfms_kl\hfijbgZ^e_`Zsbf\k_ffmkmev
fZgZf;he__ih^jh[ghfuih]h\hjbfh[wlhfgb`_
Hgb l\hjyl aeh Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky `bl_e_c ZgGZoZj\ZgZ lh [hevrbgkl\h bo ih]b[eh qlh `_ dZkZ_lky hk
lZevguolhba\_klghqlhhgbhlebqZebkvk\h_cijZ\_^ghklvx
^Z\Zeb ex^yf [eZ]b_ gZklZ\e_gby b klZjZebkv m^_j`b\Zlv hl
Kf©:e-<ZooZ[by\ZZe-oZjZdZlZe-bkeZfbyª
MZe-;moZjbZl-Lbjfbabb:ofZ^Z
28
GZrb keh\Z ih^l\_j`^Zxl k\b^_l_evkl\Z r_coZ Kme_cfZgZ[bg=Z[^me
\ZooZ[Z [jZlZ hkgh\Zl_ey \ZooZ[blkdh]h ^\b`_gby Z lZd`_ k\b^_l_evkl\Z
B[g;ZrZjZdhlhju_fuijb\_^_fgb`_
26
27
16
^mjgh]h H^gZ`^u kih^\b`gbdb kijhkbeb m IjhjhdZ k]k
©DZdhc \b^ ^`boZ^Z kZfuc emqrbc"ª Hg hl\_lbe ©Keh\h bk
lbgukdZaZggh_\ebphijZ\bl_ex-lbjZgmª29;he__lh]hfgh
]b_ `bl_eb Zg-GZoZj\ZgZ ih]b[eb gZklZ\eyy ijZ\bl_e_clbjZgh\30Qlh`_dZkZ_lky\ZooZ[blh\lhhgbklZjZl_evghh[
\bgyxl fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb b h[ty\eyxl bo hlhr_^rbfb hl
BkeZfZ<kihfgbl_n_l\mB[g;ZaZhlhfqlhkhegp_\jZsZ_l
ky\hdjm]a_febLZd\hlfmkmevfZgbgg_ijbgy\rbcwlmn_l
\my\ey_lkyg_\_jguf_]hdjh\vbbfms_kl\hklZgh\ylky^ha
\he_ggufbDjhf_lh]h\ZooZ[blkdb_dgb]bihegujZaebqghc
de_\_lu\Z^j_kfgh]boba\_klguofmkmevfZgkdbomq_guo
Hgb [m^ml m[b\Zlv fmkmevfZg b sZ^blv yauqgb
dh\DZdba\_klgh`bl_ebZg-GZoZj\ZgZ\h_\Zebijhlb\yauq
gbdh\\qZklghklbh^bgbagbo[ue\h_gZqZevgbd=mfZjZ[bg
Ze-OZlZ[ZOmjdmk[bgAZobjZk-KZ]^bhk\h[h^b\rbcZe-:o\Za
Iha^g__`bl_ebZg-GZoZj\ZgZhldZaZebkvmqZkl\h\Zlv\\hcgZo
f_`^mfmkmevfZgZfbihkdhevdm_s_g_mki_ebijbg_klbijb
ky]moZebnmQlh`_dZkZ_lky\ZooZ[blh\lhbobklhjbyihegZ
kemqZ_\ ijheblby djh\b ijhkluo fmkmevfZg ]jZ[_`Z bo bfm
s_kl\Zbie_g_gbybo`_gHgbbkZfbijbagZxlwlhBklhjby
g_agZ_llZdbo\j_f_gdh]^Z\ZooZ[blu\h_\Zebijhlb\\jZ]h\
BkeZfZ
Bohlebqb_f[m^_l[jblv_]heh\ukh]eZkghjb\Zylm
:ofZ^Z B[g OZ^`Zj ml\_j`^Z_l qlh m ijhlb\gbdh\ =Zeb lZ
dh]hdZq_kl\Zg_[ueh31Qlh`_dZkZ_lky\ZooZ[blh\lhkh\j_
f_ggu_ mq_gu_ b \ qZklghklb f_ddZgkdbc rZnb]blkdbc fmn
lbc r_co :ofZ^ AZcgb >Zoeyg32 ml\_j`^Zxl qlh r_co Fm
I_j_^Ze:ofZ^\k_i_j_^ZlqbdbgZ^_`gu_ex^b
GZijbf_j:[m;beyevb_]h[jZl=mj\Z[bg:[m:^by^Zkfbehklb\blky
gZ^gbf:eeZo
31
B[gOZ^`Zj©NZloZe-;Zjbªghf_j
32
Wlhba\_klgucmq_guc:ofZ^AZcgb>Zoeyghg[uegZklZ\gbdhffgh]bo
ba\_klguo mq_guo ?]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`Zl lZdb_ dgb]b dZd ©:k-KbjZ ZggZ[Z\by\ZZe-ZkZjZe-fmoZffZ^byª©:e-NmlmoZlZe-bkeZfby[Z]^Zfm^ucb
nmlmoZl Zg-gZ[Z\byª ©:e-NZlo Ze-fm[bg nb kbjZl omeZnZ Zj-jZrb^bgª
djhf_ lh]h m g_]h_klvdhff_glZjbbd©:k-KZfZjdZg^byª©:e-BaoZjmnb
Zl-lZ\ob^ª©:evnbyB[gFZebdªLZd`__]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`Zlkhqbg_gby
29
30
17
oZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[ih\_e_\Ze\k_fdlh\klmiZ_l\jy^u
_]h^\b`_gby[jblv]heh\uqlh[umgbohljZklZebgh\u_\h
ehkug_ihagZ\rb_yauq_kl\ZBa\_klghqlhh^gZ`^u`_gsb
gZ ihklZ\beZ _]h \ [_a\uoh^gh_ iheh`_gb_ hgZ kdZaZeZ _fm
©Lu ih\_e_\Z_rv `_gsbgZf [jblv ]heh\u gZeukh Z \_^v \h
ehku – mdjZr_gb_ `_gsbgu Lh]^Z l_[_ ke_^m_l \_e_lv fm`
qbgZf[jblv[hjh^udhlhju_lZd`_y\eyxlkybomdjZr_gb_fª
BFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[g_kfh]hl\_lblv_c33Fmnlbc
Am[_c^Zk-k_b^=Z[^jZofZgZe-:o^Z^]h\hjbe©G_lg_h[oh^b
fhklbibkZlvhijh\_j`_gbyhk_dl_\ZooZ[blh\^hklZlhqghoZ
^bkZIjhjhdZk]k©Bohlebqb_f[m^_l[jblv_]heh\uªwlhl
[b^]ZlijZdlbdm_lkylhevdh\bok_dl_ª34.
BlZd fu \uykgbeb qlh \ oZ^bkZo j_qv b^_l bf_ggh h
j_eb]bhaghc_j_kbZg_hiheblbq_kdhfijhlb\hklhygbbf_`
^m =Zeb b _]h ijhlb\gbdZfb Bf_ggh ihwlhfm fhb ^hjh]b_
[jZlvyy\ayekyaZgZibkZgb_wlhcdgb]b<g_cyih^jh[ghhk
lZgZ\eb\Zxkv gZ hlebqbl_evguo dZq_kl\Zo \ZooZ[blh\ b ijb
\h`m^h\h^uhlhfqlhmihfygmlu_oZ^bku[hevr_\k_]hih^
oh^yl d gbf Djhf_ wlh]h \ wlhc dgb]_ y ijb\h`m fgh`_kl\h
^hklh\_jguo^h\h^h\bbklhjbq_kdbonZdlh\B\hbklbgm\k_
gZklZ\e_gb_lhevdhhl:eeZoZ
=eZ\Zi_j\Zy
AgZdhfkl\hk\ZooZ[bafhf
K_dlZ \ZooZ[blh\-oZrZ\blh\ kqblZ_l qlh hgZ kZfZy kh
\_jr_ggZy gZ kZfhf^_e_hgZkZfZykh\_jr_ggZy\aZ[em`^_
gbb\wlhc]eZ\_\uh[gZjm`bl_dZdlhqghdwlhck_dl_ih^oh
ih Ze]_[j_ ljZdlZl h[ hklZ\eyxs_f fhebl\m khqbg_gb_ ih ZjZ[kdhc klb
ebklbd_ljZdlZlh[bkfbee_ljZdlZlhkZeZ\ZlZoIjhjhdmk]kljZdlZlih
ZjZ[kdhc ]jZffZlbd_ ©:^->mjZj Zk-kmggby nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-\ZooZ[byª
©NblgZ Ze-\ZooZ[byª b ©OmeZkZl Ze-dZeZf nb mfZjZ Ze-[_cl Ze-oZjZfª
Djhf_ mihfygmluo m g_]h _klv _s_ fgh`_kl\h ihe_aguo dgb] < ^Zgghf
khqbg_gbb fu ijb\h^bf hq_gv fgh]h pblZl ba _]h dgb] Mf_j \ ]
]
33
:ofZ^[bgAZcgb>Zoeyg©NblgZZe-\ZooZ[byªK
34
LZf`_
18
^yl dZq_kl\Z mihfygmlu_ Ijhjhdhf k]k \ oZ^bkZo ©Hgb
\uc^ml \ ihke_^g__ \j_fyª ©Hgb \uc^ml lh]^Z dh]^Z f_`^m
ex^vfb [m^_l pZjblv jZa^hjª ©Bo hlebqb_f [m^_l [jblv_ ]h
eh\uªBlZdfugZqbgZ_fagZdhfblv\Zkkwlhck_dlhc
AgZdhfkl\hk\ZooZ[bafhf
<ZooZ[blu ihy\bebkv \ G_^`^_ jh^hgZqZevgbdhf wlhc
k_dlu y\ey_lky r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ <g_rg_
^\b`_gb_ ihy\behkv k p_evx bkijZ\e_gby gZjmr_gbc fmkmev
fZgkdh]h \_jhm[_`^_gby b ijZ\Z [hjv[u k yauq_kl\hf b \ha
\_ebqb\Zgb_f fh]be G_khfg_ggh p_eb [eZ]hjh^gu_ hkh[_g
gh _keb mqblu\Zlv qlh ih keh\Zf \ZooZ[blh\ \ l_ \j_f_gZ
`bl_ebG_^`^Z\_jgmebkv\ihjmyauq_kl\Z35hklZ\bebrZjb
Zl36 b aZgyebkv jZa[h_f37 G_l khfg_gby \ lhf qlh \ a_feyo
G_^`^Z \k_]^Z ihy\eyebkv e`_ijhjhdb \_jhhlklmigbdb _j_
lbdbboZjb^`blu38@bl_ebwlh]hj_]bhgZy\eyxlkyhq_gv`_
klhdbfb b ]jm[ufb ex^vfb ihwlhfm qlh[u khojZgylv \ wlhf
j_]bhg_ihjy^hd\k_]^Zgm`_g[uekbevgucb]jhagucijZ\b
l_ev
>Z\ZooZ[blkdh_^\b`_gb_ijh\ha]eZkbehehamg]b©Bk
ijZ\e_gb_ª b ©;hjv[Z k yauq_kl\hfª ihwlhfm \ kZfhf gZqZe_
ex^b\hkijbgyeb_]hkjZ^hklvxh^gZdhi_j\u_`_rZ]bwlh]h
^\b`_gby \ua\Zeb kbevgh_ jZahqZjh\Zgb_ <ZooZ[blu h[ty\b
eb ^ha\he_gghc djh\v fmkmevfZg-_^bgh[h`gbdh\ [he__ lh]h
jZaj_rbeb m[b\Zlv ^Z`_ ^_l_c \ G_^`^_39 < kdhjhf \j_f_gb
=mkfZg [bg ;ZrZj Ze-OZg[Zeb Zg-G_^`^b mf ] ] ©=mg\Zg
Ze-fZ^`nblZjboZg-GZ^`^ª[]khkibkdhfgZk_e_gguoimgdlh\hlr_coZ
FmoZffZ^Z=Z[^jZaZdZOZfaufm^ZjjbkZ\k\ys_gghfZe-OZjZf_
36
LZf`_
37
LZf`_
38
?j_lbq_kdb_ ZjZ[kdb_ ie_f_gZ g_^`lblh\ ZajZdblh\ b kZnZjblh\ \k_
jh^hfbaG_^`^Z
39
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª-gb`_hklZgh\bfkygZwlhfih^jh[g__Ex
[hc a^jZ\hfukeysbc q_eh\_d ihgbfZ_l qlh g_ \k_ `bl_eb G_^`^Z [ueb
\_jhhlklmigbdZfb kj_^b gbo [ueh fgh]h oZg[Zeblkdbo mq_guo b ijZ\_^
gbdh\
35
19
wlh ^\b`_gb_ ijhgbdeh b \ ^jm]b_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ j_]bhgu40,
]^_ ^Zeh fmkmevfZgZf \hafh`ghklv \dmkblv \kx ]hj_qv jZah
qZjh\Zgbyhll_odlhhohlblkygZfmkmevfZgm[b\Zybo]jZ[y
jZa[hcgbqZy41 b ij_iylkl\my oZ^`byf \ kh\_jr_gbb iZehfgb
q_kl\Z42<fmkmevfZgkdboa_feyogbdh]^Zg_l\hjbehkvgbq_]h
ih^h[gh]h gZ lZdh_ g_ [ueb kihkh[gu ^Z`_ k_dlu ZajZdblh\
kZnZjblh\ b ijhqbo \_jhhlklmigbdh\ Djhf_ lh]h \ZooZ[blu
jZa\_jgmeb l_jjhj ijhlb\ l_o mq_guo43 dhlhju_ \uklmiZeb k
djblbdhc bo m[_`^_gbc b ^_ckl\bc Ih^h[gZy l_jjhjbklbq_k
dZyiheblbdZbgZiZ^_gb_gZ^\Zk\ys_gguoZe-OZjZfZ44\ugm
^beb HkfZgkdb_ \eZklb \ Ob^`Za_ b FmoZffZ^Z =Zeb iZrm \
?]bil_ ijbgylv kbeh\u_ f_ju \ j_amevlZl_ dhlhjuo i_j\h_
\ZooZ[blkdh_]hkm^Zjkl\h[uehmgbqlh`_gh
Bamq_gb_ bklhjbb wlh]h ^\b`_gby ^Z_l \hafh`ghklv
k^_eZlv \u\h^ h lhf qlh _]h jh^hgZqZevgbdZfb klZebg_dhlh
ju_g_\_`_kl\_ggu_rZdbj^uhgh\hagbdeh\©ihke_^g__\j_
fyªdh]^ZfmkmevfZg_hkeZ[ebij_^klZ\bl_ebwlh]h^\b`_gby
\h_\Zebijhlb\fmkmevfZgihkdhevdmihkqblZebboyauqgbdZ
fb45bhklZ\beb\ihdh_gZklhysboyauqgbdh\46R_coKme_c
;he__ih^jh[ghh[wlhf[m^_ljZkkdZaZgh\jZa^_e_h[bklhjbb\ZooZ[ba
fZ
41
Ih^jh[g__\jZa^_e_©Djh\h`Z^gu_\ZooZ[bluª
42
Ih^jh[g__\jZa^_e_©G_^hims_gb_ex^_c^hk\ys_ggh]hZe-OZjZfZª
43
Kj_^b gbo [ueb r_co Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ Zg-G_^`^b b r_co
:ofZ^[bgAZcgb>Zoeyg
44
Bf_xlky\\b^mf_q_lvZe-OZjZf\F_dd_bf_q_lvijhjhdZk]k\F_
^bg_–ii
45
R_co=mkfZgZg-G_^`^b\k\h_cdgb]_©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªhib
ku\Zy fmkmevfZgkdb_ a_feb mdZau\Z_l ©«\k_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ a_feb \h
djm]Ze-OZjZfh\\C_f_g_HfZg_BokZbG_^`^_k_cqZky\eyxlkyyauq_k
dbfb<gbo\ug_gZc^_l_^Z`_fmkmevfZgdhlhju_kh\_jrZxlihdZagu_
^_eZbebfZe_gvdbcrbjdªBakeh\Z\lhjZke_^m_lqlh\k_fmkmevfZg_wlh
]hj_]bhgZkh\_jrZeb[hevrhcrbjd<wlhc`_dgb]_hgkkueZykvgZljZd
lZl r_coZ =Z[^jZofZgZ [bg OZkZgZ hibku\Zy yauq_kl\h fmkmevfZg
ihke_\ha\jZs_gbyr_coZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zba;ZkjumdZau
\Z_l©@bl_eb\k_ogZk_e_gguoimgdlh\\wlboj_]bhgZogZqZebihdehgylv
ky b^heZf fh]beZf ^`bggZf ^_j_\vyf dZfgyf b wlh ijh^he`Zehkv ^h
^\_gZ^pZlh]h\_dZ-]]ª>Zfufh`_fih\_jblvqlh`bl_ebG_
40
20
fZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ Zg-G_^`^b djblbdmy k\h_]h [jZlZ Fm
oZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©Zk-KZ\Z]bd ZebeyobynbZj-jZ^^]ZeyZe-\ZooZ[byªmdZau\Z_lqlh\ZooZ[blu
m[b\Zeb \k_o dlh hldZau\Zeky i_j_k_eblvky \ G_^`^47 \ lhl
G_^`^ h dhlhjhf Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe ©Hllm^Z ijb^ml ih
ljyk_gbybkfmluhllm^Zihy\blkyjh]kZlZguª
Ih kmlb ^_eZ \ZooZ[blu48 djblbdmxl fmkmevfZg ba-aZ
jZagh]eZkbc\h\lhjhkl_i_gguo\hijhkZog_bf_xsbogbdZdh
]hhlghr_gbydhkgh\ZfBkeZfZLhevdhba-aZjZkoh`^_gbc\h
\lhjhkl_i_gguo \hijhkZo hgb h[ty\eyxl fmkmevfZg g_\_jgu
fbWlbex^bke_^mxlaZmq_gb_fB[gLZcfbbb_]hihke_^h
\Zl_e_c b ijb^_j`b\Zxlky [md\Zevghc ljZdlh\db DhjZgZ b
kmgguiheghklvxhljbpZyihiuldbjZpbhgZevgh]hihgbfZgby
k\ys_gguol_dklh\GZkZfhf`_^_e_bob^_bhq_gv^Z`_g_
khklhyl_evgubg_\u^_j`b\Zxl^Z`_fZe_cr_cdjblbdb<Zo
oZ[blkdb_ mq_gu_ g_ fh]ml ijhlb\hklhylv ^h\h^Zf ijb\_^_g
G_^`^Zhlhrebhlj_eb]bbghqlhdZkZ_lkyf_ddZgp_\bf_^bgp_\lhwlh]h
^himklblv g_\hafh`gh <gmdb FmkZceZfu kebrdhf ij_m\_ebqb\Zxl fZk
rlZ[ujZkijhkljZg_gbyyauq_kl\Z
46
<h`^b \ZooZ[bafZ b kZfb wlh ijbagZxl \ gZklZ\e_gbyo ©>ey Zjfbbª
ih^ibkZgguo khlgyfb kZm^bckdbo mq_guo kdZaZgh ©R_klh_ ihke_ lh]h
dZdgZrba_feb[uebh[t_^bg_gugZrZZjfbygbjZamg_\h_\ZeZjZ^bjZk
ijhkljZg_gby_^bgh[h`bybeb^eylh]hqlh[uihfhqvmgb`_gguffmkmev
fZgZf `b\msbf ih khk_^kl\m k gZfb ?^bgkl\_gguc jZa wlh kemqbehkv
dh]^Zfu\h_\Zebijhlb\_\j__\gZklhjhg_Bhj^ZgbbªGZkZfhf^_e_mqZ
klb_ kZm^bckdhc Zjfbb \ wlhc \hcg_ [ueh gZklhevdh g_agZqbl_evguf qlh
g_lkfukeZmihfbgZlvh[wlhfGh[hevr_\k_]hm^b\ey_llhqlhwlbmq_
gu_h[ty\eyxl^`boZ^hf\h_ggu_hi_jZpbbkZm^bckdhcZjfbbijhlb\fm
kmevfZgF_ddbF_^bguLZbnZb^jm]bo]hjh^h\
47
R_co =Z[^jZofZg [bg OZkZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ kjZ\gb\Z_l r_coZ Fm
oZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z k Ijhjhdhf Z B[g KZ]m^Z – k ZgkZjZfb ijb
ky]gm\rbfb Ijhjhdm ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª Gb`_ fu ijb\_^_f
ijbf_judZdg_dhlhju_ba\ZooZ[blkdbomq_guogZau\Zebk\hboihke_^h
\Zl_e_cfmoZ^`bjZfbbZgkZjZfb
48
M^b\ey_lqlh\gZrb^gb\ZooZ[bluklZjZxlky^bklZgpbjh\Zlvkyhlk\h
_]hbf_gbdhlhjuf_s_\q_jZlZd]hj^bebkvJZa\_hgbg_ihfgylqlhbo
ba\_klgucr_coKme_cfZg[bgKZfoZgmf]]gZa\Zeh^gmba
k\hbo dgb] ©:e-OZ^bylm Zk-kmggby \Z Zl-lmonZl Ze-\ZooZ[by Zg-gZ^`^byª
Ze-FZgZj?]bi_l–]]"
21
guffmkmevfZgkdbfbmq_gufb<u\k_]^Zkeurbl_hlgboh^
gb b l_ `_ keh\Z hgb keZ[u \ ljZdlh\d_ DhjZgZ b klhjhgylky
ex[hc ^bkdmkkbb p_ev dhlhjhc ihbkd bklbgu ihkdhevdm agZ
xlg_khklhyl_evghklvk\h_cb^_heh]bb
K\b^_l_evkl\Z\ihevamg_\_`_kl\Z\ZooZ[blh\
Ba\_klgh qlh \ZooZ[blkdb_ mq_gu_ hq_gv g_\_`_kl\_g
guZbojZkkm`^_gbyih\_joghklguwlhih^l\_j`^Zxl\k_dlh
ohlv g_fgh]h h[sZeky k ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb wlhc k_dlu GZijb
f_j r_co B[jZobf Ze-FZgkmj i_j_^Z_l qlh FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[ ©aZij_sZe k\hbf ihke_^h\Zl_eyf qblZlv dgb]b
ih nbdom lZnkbjm b oZ^bkm49 \f_klh wlh]h hg iha\hebe bf
ljZdlh\Zlv Zylu DhjZgZ ih k\h_fm `_eZgbx b ihgbfZgbx
DZ`^uc ba gbo kZf ljZdlm_l DhjZg ^Z`_ \ lhf kemqZ_ _keb
lhedhfg_agZ_l_]hª50.
R_coFmoZffZ^KZebfZe-DbeZgb51jZkkdZau\Zehlhf
dZdh^bgba\ZooZ[blkdbofmnlb_\Zbf_ggh=Z[^meeZ[bgOZ
eZn ijb_oZe \ >ZfZkd b ihijhkbe m g_]h dgb]m ih ZjZ[kdhfm
kbglZdkbkm b fhjnheh]bb Z lZd`_ ihijhkbe ijb[ulv gZ _]h
e_dpbbkhkemrZl_eyfbgZqZevguodmjkh\bamqZxsbfb©DZlj
Zg-gZ^Zªb©Zg-GZ[ZnbZk-kZjnªlhqghlZd`_ihklmibebdZ
abcr_co=Z[^meeZFZjZ]bDhff_glbjmywlb^\ZkemqZyr_co
Ze-DbeZgbibr_l©?keblZdh\mjh\_gvfmnlbybdZabylhqlh
`_fh]mlagZlv^jm]b_\ZooZ[blkdb_mq_gu_"ª-b^h[Z\be©Y
\klj_qZekykhfgh]bfb\ZooZ[blkdbfbmq_gufbb\j_amevlZl_
wlbo\klj_qijbr_ed\u\h^mqlhhgbg_\_`_kl\_ggub^Ze_db
hlagZgbcª
G_ m^b\eycl_kv ^hjh]b_ qblZl_eb wlh ^_ckl\bl_evgh
lZd\_^v^Z`_hkgh\Zl_evwlh]h^\b`_gby[ueg_\_`_kl\_gguf
q_eh\_dhf ?]h [jZl \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:k-KZ\Z]bd Ze-beyoby nb
Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-\ZooZ[byª ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©:eeZo \
Hgb^hkboihjkh[ex^ZxlwlhlaZij_lbomq_gu_aZij_sZxlqblZlvg_
lhevdhdgb]bb[Z^blh\ghbdgb]bK_b^ZDml[Zb:[mZe-:]eyZe-FZm^m^b
50
:e-FZgkmjb ©:l-LZ^` Ze-^`Zfb] ebemkmeª K >Zoeyg ©:^->mjZj
Zk-kmggbyªK– 143.
51
:e-DbeZgb©:g-GZnoZZa-aZdbyªK
49
22
dZq_kl\_ bkiulZgby ex^yf ihkeZe lh]h dlh ijbqbkeyyk_[yd
ihke_^h\Zl_eyfDhjZgZbkmgguihkmlb^_eZ[ue^Ze_dhlbo
gZmdDh]^Z_]hijhkbeb\uklmiblvi_j_^mq_gufbhghldZau
\Zeky b ijbgm`^Ze ex^_c ke_^h\Zlv aZ k\hbf fg_gb_f ?keb
`_dlh-eb[hg_kh]eZrZekykgbflhhgh[ty\eyewlh]hq_eh\_
dZg_\_jguf<wlhfq_eh\_d_g_[uehgb_^bgh]hdZq_kl\Zba
l_oqlhijbkmsbfm^`lZob^Zf;he__lh]h\g_fg_[ueh^Z`_
^_kylhc qZklb g_h[oh^bfuo ^ey wlh]h agZgbc gh g_kfhljy gZ
wlhhgiha\heyek_[_djbqZlv]jhfq_^jm]bog_\_`^ª52.
: \k_f dlh khfg_\Z_lky hlghkbl_evgh bo g_\_`_kl\Z
fu ij_^eZ]Z_f ih]em[`_ hagZdhfblvky k bo b^_yfb b ih\_jo
ghklgufb \u\h^Zfb ihkfhljbl_ gZ n_l\m h lhf qlh khegp_
\jZsZ_lky \hdjm] a_feb \a]eygbl_ gZ klbev dhlhjuf hgb ib
rml k\hb keZ[u_ dgb]b b n_l\u ihkemrZcl_ e_dpbb bo mq_
guo
AZsblgbdb\ZooZ[bafZbkZfbijbagZxlk\h_g_\_`_kl
\h b aZy\eyxl qlh G_^`^ kZf ih k_[_ [ue j_]bhghf g_\_`^
FmoZffZ^OZfb^Ze-NZdbjZatykgyyijbqbguihjZ`_gbyB[g
L_cfbb b B[g DZcfZ Ze->`Z\ab Z lZd`_ ih[_^m FmoZffZ^Z
[bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ibr_l ©Ih ke_^Zf r_comebkeZfZ53 B[g
L_cfbb _]h mq_gbdZ B[g Ze-DZcbfZ ihke_^h\Ze r_comebkeZf
FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ \h \j_f_gZ dhlhjh]h g_^`^bc
kdh_h[s_kl\hm`_[ueh]hlh\hijbgylv_]hmq_gb_<hlebqb_
hl ?]bilZ ]^_ ijhih\_^h\Zeb B[g LZcfby b B[g Ze-DZcbf
G_^`^[ueg_\_`_kl\_ggufj_]bhghfgZk_e_gguf\hkgh\ghf
[_^mbgZfb?]bi_l`_ij_^klZ\eyekh[hc]hkm^Zjkl\hkijZ\b
l_e_f gZf_klgbdZfb Zjfb_c \h_gZqZevgbdZfb mq_[gufb aZ
Kme_cfZg[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ªK
Hq_gvm^b\ey_llhlnZdlqlhhgbbkihevamxlwlhll_jfbg\_^v[hevrbg
kl\hfmkmevfZgg_ijbagZxlbomq_gufbDgb]bwlboex^_cg_ij_ih^Zxl
gb\bgklblmlZogb\mgb\_jkbl_lZo\hlebqb_hldgb]^jm]bofmkmevfZg
kdbo mq_guo \g_krbo h]jhfguc \deZ^ \ jZa\blb_ BkeZfZ Kh\j_f_ggu_
\ZooZ[blukebrdhfqZklhbkihevamxll_jfbg©r_comebkeZfªijbibku\Zy
_]h ^Z`_ FmoZffZ^m [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[m dZd [m^lh hg ij_\ahr_e k\hbo
mqbl_e_cKfFZkZ[boZa-aZeyfnbZj-jZ^^]ZeyfZgdZab[Z]ZeyZr-r_co
Ze-bfZfªk
52
53
23
\_^_gbyfb kmnbckdbfb lZdbyfb dZabyfb mq_gufb b fm^Zj
jbkZfb ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb jZaebqguo fZaoZ[h\ª54 DZd \b^bl_
hgb kZfb ijbagZxl k\h_ g_\_`_kl\h mq_gu_ b ihke_^h\Zl_eb
wlh]h^\b`_gby^Z`_\gZrb^gb^Ze_dbhlkh\j_f_gguob^_c
b bklbgu Dgb]b ^jm]bo fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo gbdh]^Z g_
ojZgylky \ bo ^hfZo ^Z`_ _keb b ojZgylky lh lhevdh \ bkdZ
`_gghf\b^_ih^^_j`b\Zxs_f\ZooZ[blkdmxb^_heh]bx55.
?s_ h^ghc ijbqbghc [ukljh]h jZkijhkljZg_gby \ZooZ
[bafZ [ueh bkihevah\Zgb_ \h_gghc kbeu ^bdbo ie_f_g jZa
[hcgbdh\ dhlhjuo hgb ij_\jZlbeb \ lZd gZau\Z_fh_ ©\hckdh
lZ\ob^Zª >ey wlbo ex^_c g_ kms_kl\h\Zeh gbdZdbo ijbgpb
ih\aZij_lghcdjh\bbaZij_lgh]hbfms_kl\ZB[g;ZrZjjZk
kdZau\Zy h `bagb KZ]m^Z [bg =Z[^me]ZabaZ mq_gbdZ r_coZ
FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z56 ibr_l ©Hg jZahkeZe k\hbo
\_j[h\sbdh\ ih \k_c imklug_ qlh[u hgb kh[jZeb ^ey g_]h
\hckdhkh\k_]hihemhkljh\Zª57<h]eZ\_wlh]h\hckdZij_^\h
^bl_ev \ZooZ[blh\ \uklmibe gZ \hcgm ijhlb\ fmkmevfZg gh
ij_`^_ ^Ze bf gZklZ\e_gb_ ©;m^vl_ l_ji_eb\u \ kjZ`_gbyo
\_^v ih[_^Z ^hklZ_lky lhevdh l_ji_eb\uf < DhjZg_ :eeZo
kdZaZe ©: >\hbgu@ dhlhju_ \ lhl ^_gv h[jZlylky kibghc d
g_\_jguf djhf_ l_o dlh jZa\hjZqb\Z_lky ^ey [hy beb ^ey
\hkkh_^bg_gby k >^jm]bf@ hljy^hf gZ\e_dml gZ k_[y ]g_\ :e
eZoZbijbklZgbs_fbf[m^_l]__ggZ>h]g_ggZy@Kd\_j_glZ
dhc m^_eª (8:16)»58 Wlhl Zyl [ue gbkihkeZg \ hlghr_gbb g_
\_jguo gh dZd \b^bl_ \ZooZ[blu ljZdlmxl _]h \ hlghr_gbb
fmkmevfZg Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky klhev [ukljh]h jZkijhkljZg_gby
\ZooZ[bafZ \ gZrb ^gb lh ijbqbghc wlh]h y\eyxlky ^_gv]b
;eZ]h^Zjy q_jghfm ahehlm bf m^Zehkv dmiblv kh\_klv fgh]bo
ex^_cdjhf_lh]hq_jgh_ahehlhh[e_]qZ_lbf^hklmidkj_^
:e-NZdb©:kZjZ^-^Z]\ZZe-\ZooZ[byªba^\]]K
Kf ^hd FZoZffZ^ =Zm^ Ze-OZlu[ ©:k-KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabZj
Ze-]ZjZ[byZe-oZ^bkª->ZjZe-Fb]jZ^`–K-157.
56
B[g;ZrZjmdZau\Z_lqlhhg[uemq_gbdhfB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z©=mg\Zg
Ze-fZ^`^ǻ.
57
LZf`_
58
LZf`_-170.
54
55
24
kl\Zf fZkkh\hc bgnhjfZpbb ]Za_lZf jZ^bh b l_e_\b^_gbx59.
Djhf_lh]h\ZooZ[bluihevamxlkybl_fqlhy\eyxlkyohay_
\Zfb ^\mo kZfuo [hevrbo fmkmevfZgkdbo k\ylugv Ijhkluf
g_\_`^ZfhgbklZjZxlkyihdZaZlvk\hbke_auijbql_gbbDhjZ
gZ gZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ hg g_ ih^gbfZ_lky m gbo \ur_ ]hjeZ :
\ZooZ[blkdZy \eZklv \ KZm^h\kdhc :jZ\bb hkgh\ZgZ gZ h]g_ b
f_q_60.
<ZooZ[blh\bf_gmxloZrZ\blZfbaZobjblZfb61,
fmrZ[[boblZfb62bfm^`ZkkbfblZfb63
OZrZ\blZfbbf_gh\Zebl_q_gbydhlhju_hlghkbebk_[y
d ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb bfZfZ :ofZ^Z \ qZklghklb oZrZ\blZfb
kqblZxl dZjZfblh\ [Zj[ZoZjblh\ kZebfblh\ kh\j_f_gguo
\ZooZ[blh\ kh\j_f_gguo ^`Zfblh\ b ^jm]b_ k_dlu fm^`Zk
kbfblh\
Bklhjby gZj_q_gby wlbo k_dl oZrZ\blZfb lZdh\Z ©H^
gZ`^u ij_^klZ\bl_eb wlhc k_dlu ihk_lbeb e_dpbx Ze-OZkZgZ
Ze-;Zkjb b ih^gyeb \hijhk h \udb^ur_ Ihke_ ^bkdmkkbb k
gbfb hg kdZaZe ©Wlb ex^b ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc ebrv \_jo
gxx g_ aZiheg_ggmx qZklv dm\rbgZ k \h^hc oZrZ ZeDZdba\_klgh\k_ZjZ[kdb_kimlgbdh\u_dZgZeuijbgZ^e_`Zl\ZooZ[blZf
lZd`_rbjhdhhgbbkihevamxlbi_qZlv:dlhiulZ_lkyhdZaZlvbfijhlb
\h^_ckl\b_lhfmhgbh[ty\eyxl\hcgm
60
Ijbf_jh\lhfm\_ebdh_fgh`_kl\h^hklZlhqghhagZdhfblvkyk^hdeZ^Z
fb h kh[ex^_gbb ijZ\ q_eh\_dZ ba dgb]b ©IjZ\Z q_eh\_dZ \ Dhjhe_\kl\_
KZm^h\kdZy:jZ\byª<wlhckljZg_g_dhlhju_baihke_^h\Zl_e_cfZaoZ[h\
^Z`_ ih^\_j]Zxlky iuldZf < wlhc `_ dgb]_ jZkkdZau\Z_lky h lhf dZdbf
bkiulZgbyf ih^\_j]ky r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Zey\b Ze-FZebdb <ZooZ[bl
kdh_ h[s_kl\h KZm^h\kdhc ZjZ\bb gZklhevdh lhlZeblZjgh qlh rZnb]bl g_
bf__l\hafh`ghklbijhq_klvdmgml\mlj_gg_cfhebl\_Fua^_kv^Z`_g_
iulZ_fkyZgZebabjh\Zlvbklbgghklvbebeh`ghklvbob^_cZlhevdh`_eZ_f
ihdZaZlvbohlghr_gb_dij_^klZ\bl_eyf^jm]bofZaoZ[h\
61
Hlkeh\Z©aZobjª©\g_rgbcªj_qvb^_lh\g_rg_f[md\Zevghfh[tyk
g_gbbDhjZgZboZ^bkh\–ii
62
Hlkeh\Z©lZr[boª©mih^h[e_gb_ªj_qvb^_lh[mih^h[e_gbb<k_\ur
g_]hq_eh\_dmlh_klv?]hZgljhihfhjnbaZpby–ii
63
Hlkeh\Z©lZ^`kbfª©ijbibku\Zgb_l_eZl_e_kghklbªj_qvb^_lhlhf
qlhihke_^h\Zl_ebwlbok_dlijbibku\Zxl<k_\urg_fmgZebqb_l_eZ–ii
59
25
oZedZ64ª k wlh]h fhf_glZ bo b klZeb gZau\Zlv oZrZ\blZfbª
Qlh dZkZ_lky l_jfbgZ ©fm^`Zkkbfbluª lh bf hgb [ueb h[h
agZq_guihlhcijbqbg_qlhijbibku\Zeb:eeZoml_e_kghklv
Z jZa m G_]h _klv l_eh lh hgh ^he`gh [ulv q_f-lh aZiheg_gh
fZormBlZdoZrZ\blu–wlhk_dlZdhlhjZyhlhreZhlijbg
pbiZZ[khexlbaZpbbhqbs_gbylZgabo:eeZoZ65.
R_coFmoZffZ^AZob^Ze-DZmkZjbihwlhfmih\h^mkdZ
aZe ©Ihke_^h\Zl_eb bklbgu gZau\Zeb wlbo ex^_c bf_gZfb
dhlhju_jZkdju\ZebbokmlvHgbgZa\ZebbofmrZ[[boblZfb
ihkdhevdml_mih^h[eyeb:eeZoZq_eh\_dmb^jm]bfkha^Zgbyf
Bo gZa\Zeb fm^`ZkkbfblZfb ihkdhevdm hgb ijbibkZeb :eeZ
om dZq_kl\Z ijbkmsb_ l_eZf Bo gZa\Zeb oZrZ\blZfb ih
kdhevdm hgb [ueb kdehggu d imkluf [_kkfuke_gguf j_qZf
Wlbo ex^_c g_evay ^Z`_ hlg_klb d hl^_evghfm fZaoZ[m \_^v
hgb^Ze_dbhl:eeZoZb?]hihkeZggbdZ«66»
OZrZ\blu ijbagZxl lhevdh [md\Zevgmx ljZdlh\dm Dh
jZgZbkmgguaZqlh[uebgZa\ZguaZobjblZfbBgl_j_kghqlh
B[gL_cfbyg_[ueijhlb\lh]hqlh_]hb_]hmq_gbdh\gZau
\ZebfmrZ[[boblZfb\qZklghklbhgibr_l©L_jfbg©fmrZ[
[boªg_ihjbpZ_lkygb\DhjZg_gb\kmgg_gb\\ukdZau\Zgb
yokih^\b`gbdh\ª67.
;he__ lh]h hg ^Z`_ g_ ijhlb\blky l_jfbgm ©fm^`Zk
kbfªbmdZau\Z_l©Gbh^bgbakZeZnh\g_\uklmiZekdjblbdhc
l_jfbgZ©fm^`Zkkbfªbfm^`Zkkbfblh\\p_ehfª68.
Gb`_fu_s_\_jg_fkydwlhcl_fZlbd_bijb\_^_f^h
\h^u\ihevamlh]hqlh\ZooZ[bluaZkem`b\Zxlwlbob_s_[h
e__]jhfdbogZa\ZgbcQlh`_dZkZ_lkyl_jfbgZ©kZeZnuªdh
<_jhylgha^_kvbf__lky\\b^mqlh-lh\jh^_jmkkdh]h\ujZ`_gby©^ujdZ
hl[m[ebdZª. –ii
65
FmoZffZ^ :[m AZojZ \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©B[g LZcfbyª K – r_co
FZgkmjFmoZffZ^=m\Zck\dgb]_©B[gLZcfby–g_kZeZnblªK– 247.
66
MFmoZffZ^ZZe-DZmkZjb©:k-KZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-bfZfbyª
K
67
B[gLZcfby©:l-LZkbknbjZ^^mkmkZl-lZd^bkª
68
B[gLZcfby©:l-LZkbknbjZ^^mkmkZl-lZd^bkª
64
26
lhjuc hgb ijbibku\Zxl k_[_ lh fu `_eZ_f \ukdZaZlv ke_^m
xs__
AZ[em`^_gb_hlghkbl_evghke_^h\Zgby
aZkZeZnZfb
OZrZ\blu aZy\eyxl qlh \ ihgbfZgbb DhjZgZ b kmggu
g_h[oh^bfh ke_^h\Zlv ijbf_jm kZeZnh\ ihgbfZgb_ k\ys_g
guo l_dklh\ kZeZnZfb ih bo fg_gbx y\ey_lky h[yaZl_evguf
h^gZdhlZdZyihabpbykh^_j`bl^\_hrb[db
<h-i_j\uo kZeZnu jZa^_ebebkv \h fg_gbyo ijb ihgb
fZgbbDhjZgZbkmgguZke_^h\Zl_evghmgbog_[ueh_^bgh]h
fZaoZ[Z _^bghc rdheu h kms_kl\h\Zgbb dhlhjhc aZy\eyxl
wlbex^bBgb`_fuijb\_^_fijbf_julh]hdZdkZeZnu\u
kdZau\Zeb jZaebqgu_ fg_gby b g_ lhevdh ih \hijhkZf ijZ\Z
gh^Z`_ih\hijhkZfm[_`^_gbyZdu^u69.
L_o`_\ZooZ[blh\ijbau\Zxsboke_^h\Zlvfg_gbxkZ
eZnh\ fu \b^bf hljbpZxsbfb rdheu q_luj_o bfZfh\ b aZ
y\eyxsbfb h g_h[oh^bfhklb ke_^h\Zlv bo fg_gbx beb fg_
gbxh^gh]hbamq_guo`b\rbo\i_j\u_ljb\_dZBkeZfZgZ
a\Zggu_\_dZfbkZeZnh\
<h-\lhjuo gb \ h^ghf Zyl_ DhjZgZ gb \ h^ghf oZ^bk_
IjhjhdZk]kg_kdZaZghhlhfqlhgZfke_^m_lhldZaZlvkyhl
\u\h^h\k\h_]hjZamfZbihke_^h\ZlvaZfg_gb_fkZeZnh\l_f
R_coZk-KZddZngZqbgZykkljZgbpuijb\h^blfgh`_kl\hijbf_jh\
B\qZklghklb]h\hjblqlhbfZf:ofZ^bZe-OZnbaZe-DZjZ[bkbjZahrebkv
\hfg_gbyoihih\h^mkha^ZgbyDhjZgZb\dhg_qghfblh]_ij_\jZlbebkv\h
\jZ]h\>Ze__hgmdZau\Z_lqlhZe-;moZjbFmkebfB[gDmeey[:[mKZmj
>Zm^[bg=Zebb^jm]b_lZd`_dZdZe-OZnbaZe-DZjZ[bkbml\_j`^Zebqlh
DhjZg–wlhkha^Zgb_Ihke_wlh]hr_coZk-KZddZnaZ^Z_l\hijhk©AZdZdbf
bawlbofg_gbcfu^he`guke_^h\Zlv"DZdh]hbagbo^he`guijbj^_j`b
\Zlvky"ª-Z^Ze__kZf`_hl\_qZ_l©Fu^he`guhklZ\blv\k_wlbfg_gbyb
h[jZlblvkydDhjZgmbkmgg_ZgZebabjmybol_dkluklhqdbaj_gbyyaudZb
jZamfZ Lh]^Z fu ihklb]g_f bklbgm b ihcf_f dlh ba kZeZnh\ [ue ijZ\ Z
dlhhrb[Zekyihwlhfmfu^he`guijbclbdk\h_fmfg_gbxZg_ke_^h\Zlv
aZ fg_gb_f kZeZnh\ª >Ze__ hg ijb\h^bl ijbf_ju dZd kZeZnu jZahrebkv
\hfg_gbyoih\hijhkZf\b^_eebIjhjhdk]k:eeZoZ\h\j_fy\hag_k_
gby \b^_e eb Km^guc ^_gv \b^_e eb \_ku fh`gh eb \uklmiZlv ijhlb\
bfZfZ–bijhqbf
69
27
[he___kebdlh-eb[hbagZk^hklb]kl_i_gbihgbfZgbyk\ys_g
guol_dklh\kl_i_gbfm^`lZob^Z;he__lh]hl_dkluDhjZgZb
kmggu ijbau\Zxl gZk d g_ihkj_^kl\_gghfm ihgbfZgbx [h`_
kl\_gguoaZdhgh\Keh\Z:eeZoZ©Hl_dhlhju_m\_jh\Zeb«ª
h[jZs_gu b d i_j\uf b ihke_^gbf ihdhe_gbyf fmkmevfZg b
bf_xlkbem\iehlv^hKm^gh]h^gy
<^jm]hff_kl_DhjZgZ:eeZo_s_[he__ykghaZy\ey_l
©: _keb [u hgb >jZgvr_@ khh[sbeb wlh ihkeZggbdm b ij_^\h
^bl_eyf >fmkebfh\@ l_f [ueh [u \_^hfhª (4:83 dZd \b^bf
Zylq_ldhbykghaZy\ey_lhfm^`lZob^Zokihkh[guoihgbfZlv
k\ys_ggu_l_dklu\ex[h_\j_fyb\ex[hff_kl_<wlhfZyl_
g_ kdZaZgh h lhf qlh gZ \_jgh_ ihgbfZgb_ DhjZgZ kihkh[gu
lhevdhfm^`lZob^ubaqbkeZkZeZnh\Ih^\h^yblh]fufh`_f
kdZaZlvqlhgb\DhjZg_gb\oZ^bk_g_llZdh]hrZjbZlkdh]h
^h\h^Z dZd fg_gb_ kZeZnh\ ;he__ \_jguf [m^_l aZy\e_gb_ h
lhf qlh ©ijhklhfm fmkmevfZgbgm g_ ^hklb]r_fm kl_i_gb
\_jgh]hihgbfZgbyk\ys_gguol_dklh\g_h[oh^bfhke_^h\Zlv
aZfg_gb_ffm^`lZob^Zg_aZ\bkbfhhllh]hy\ey_lkyebhgkZ
eZnhf beb oZeZnhf Z lZd`_ aZ _^bgh]eZkguf fg_gb_ wlbo
fm^`lZob^h\ª\k_hklZevgh_y\ey_lkyebrvimklufbkeh\Zfb
?s_\h^ghfZyl_DhjZgZkdZaZgh©?keb`_m\Zkly`[Z
hq_f-gb[m^vlh\haeZ]Zcl___j_r_gb_gZ:eeZoZbIhkeZggb
dZªdZd\b^bl_Zylg_ih\_e_\Z_lke_^h\ZlvaZkZeZnZfb
Ihwlhfmih\h^m\k[hjgbd_oZ^bkh\Ze-;moZjbb
^jm]bo k[hjgbdZo ijb\h^blky jb\Zyl hl :[m >`moZcnu ©Y
kijhkbem=Zeb©?klvebm\ZkdZdZy-eb[hdgb]Z"ªhghl\_lbe
³M gZk g_l gbq_]h djhf_ DhjZgZ b ihgbfZgby ^Zjh\Zggh]h
fmkmevfZgbgm«´ª
DZd \b^bl_ a^_kv lh`_ g_l mihfbgZgby kZeZnh\ Z qlh
dZkZ_lky©ihgbfZgby^Zjh\Zggh]hfmkmevfZgbgmªlhwlbkeh
\ZjZkijhkljZgyxlkygZ\k_ofmkmevfZg]^_[ubdh]^Z[uhgb
gb`beb?kebdlh-eb[hkihkh[_gihgbfZlvk\ys_ggu_l_dklu
lhgbdlhg_\ijZ\_ijbgm`^Zlv_]hke_^h\ZlvaZfg_gb_fkZeZ
28
nh\FukqblZ_fqlhex^bijbau\Zxsb_ke_^h\ZlvaZfg_gb
_fkZeZnh\hrb[Zxlky70.
<h^ghfbaoZ^bkh\IjhjhdZk]kkdZaZgh©FhymffZ
ih^h[gZ^h`^xl_[_g_ba\_klghdZdZydZieyijbg_k_l^h[jh
i_j\Zybebihke_^gyyª71.
OZnba B[g Ze->`Z\ab \ ©>Zn] rm[Zo Zl-lZr[boª k
kdZaZe©BfZfm:ofZ^maZ^Zeb\hijhkbhghl\_lbeLh]^Z
kijZrb\Zxsbc kdZaZe ©Fg_gb_ B[g Fm[ZjZdZ hlebqZ_lky hl
\Zr_]hª :ofZ^ hl\_lbe ³B[g Fm[ZjZd g_ kimklbeky k g_
[_k´ª
BlZd dZd aZy\ey_l r_co Zk-KZddZn fg_gb_ kZeZnh\ g_
fh`_l[ulvh[yaZl_evgufrZjbZlkdbf^h\h^hf
<_jZ h g_h[oh^bfhklb ke_ih]h ke_^h\Zgby aZ fg_gb_f
kZeZnh\ y\ey_lky iheguf hljbpZgb_f jZamfZ Ijb\_j`_gpu
wlhcb^_baZy\eyxl©KZeZnuihljm^bebkvaZgZkhgb^mfZeb
bjZkkm`^Zebfu`_h[yaZguke_^h\ZlvaZbomfhaZdexq_gby
fb ihkdhevdmhgbg_khfg_gghijZ\uªQlh`_dZkZ_lkyDhjZ
gZlhhg\uklmiZ_lkhkm`^_gb_fih^h[guob^_c©<hbklbgm
FuaZklZebk\hbohlph\ijb\_j`_gpZfblZdhc-lh\_jubfu
ke_^m_fihboklhiZfªKlhjhggbdbkZeZnbafZihoh`b
gZl_odh]hdjblbdm_lwlhlZylhgbhldZaZebkvhlbkihevah\Z
gby ^h\h^h\ jZamfZ \ ihgbfZgbb k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ fu `_
kqblZ_fqlhhgbaZ[em`^Zxlky
IjhiZ]Zg^bklu kZeZnbafZ aZy\eyxl ©G_h[oh^bfh ihgbfZlv DhjZg b
kmggmlZddZdboihgbfZebkZeZnuª<lh`_\j_fyh^bgbanZgZlh\kZeZ
nbafZ \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:e-BgkZn nb ZodZf Ze-b]lbdynª K Ze-FZdlZ[Z
Ze-bkeZfby :ffZg mdZau\Z_l ©Fu g_ h[yaZgu ke_^h\Zlv aZ qvbf-eb[h
fg_gb_f^Z`__kebwlhB[gFZk]m^bebdlh-eb[h^jm]hcFuh[yaZguke_
^h\Zlvl_dklmijhjhq_kdbooZ^bkh\ªWlbex^bhl[jZku\Zxl\ukdZau\Zgby
kih^\b`gbdh\dh]^Zl_g_khhl\_lkl\mxlbob^_heh]bbWlbex^bijb\h^yl
oZ^bku h ^hklh\_jghklb dhlhjuo fh`gh jZkkm`^Zlv b [hylky ijb\h^blv
ZyluDhjZgZ^hklh\_jghklvdhlhjuog_\hafh`ghih^\_j]gmlvkhfg_gbx
71
Ijb\h^blky m :ofZ^Z Zl-Lbjfbab ghf_j hg kdZaZe
qlh wlhl oZ^bk oZkZg-]Zjb[ k_b^ oZnba :ofZ^ Ze-=ZfZjb \ ©NZlo Ze\ZooZ[ªZ\lhj©Ze-NZloªmdZau\Z_l©WlhloZ^bk–oZkZghgijb\h
^blky jZaebqgufb imlyfb b fh`_l ^hklb]gmlv kl_i_gb kZoboª Kf ©ZeNZloªhgkhhl\_lkl\m_ll_fZlbd_^jm]booZ^bkh\gZwlml_fm
70
29
>hjh]hcqblZl_ev\ur_\uihagZdhfbebkvk^\b`_gb_f
\ZooZ[bafZ l_i_jv ke_^m_l magZlv _]h hkgh\Zl_ey FmoZffZ^Z
[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[
Hkgh\hiheh`gbd\ZooZ[bafZFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\Zo
oZ[b[gKme_cfZgb[g=ZebZl-LZfbfb72jh^beky\^_j_\g_Ze=mycgZ\G_^`^_\]73]bmf_j\]]Ih
keh\ZfB[g;ZrZjZr_co=Z[^me\ZooZ[\ujhk\h[s_kl\_]^_
dlhfm\j_f_gbm`_kbevghjZkijhkljZgbehkvyauq_kl\h74ih
dehg_gb_^_j_\vyfdZfgyffh]beZfkljhbl_evkl\hfZ\ahe__\
ihdehg_gb_ ^`bggZf `_jl\hijbghr_gb_ jZ^b bo ^h\hevkl\Z
GZqZevgh_ h[jZah\Zgb_ r_co ihemqbe m k\h_]h hlpZ dhlhjuc
[uedZab_f75mg_]h`_hgbamqZeboZg[Zeblkdh_ijZ\hAZl_f
g_kdhevdh jZa _a^be \ F_ddm ]^_ mqbeky m r_coZ FmoZffZ^Z
[bg Kme_cfZg Ze-Dmj^b r_coZ FmoZfZ^Z OZylZ Zk-Kbg^b76 b
^jm]boZiha^g__m_oZe\;Zkjmhldm^Z_]hihkeh\ZfB[g;Z
rZjZijh]gZeb77.
R_com g_ m^Zehkv aZ\_jrblv k\h_ h[jZah\Zgb_ ih
kdhevdm \k_ _]h gZklZ\gbdb \b^_eb \ g_f aZqZldb [_a[h`by
nZgZlbqghc g_gZ\bklb d fmkmevfZgkdbf mq_guf-bfZfZf b
klj_fe_gb_ d g_h]jZgbq_gghc k\h[h^_ \ n_l\Zo >_ckl\bl_ev
ghwlh\b^ghb\keh\Zob^_eZor_coZ\qZklghklbhgibr_l
©;hevrbgkl\h`bl_e_cgZr_]hj_]bhgZ\qZklghklbbOb^`ZaZ
\ p_ehf g_ \_jmxl \ \hkdj_r_gb_ª78 Hg hldjulh aZy\ey_l h
lhfqlh`bl_ebG_^`^ZbOb^`ZaZZke_^h\Zl_evghF_ddbb
F_^bgu y\eyxlky yauqgbdZfb G_ m^b\bl_evgh qlh wlhl q_
Kh]eZkghkeh\Zf_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_chg\uoh^_pbaie_f_gbLZfbf
Qlh khhl\_lkl\m_l ] gh ih keh\Zf >ZoeygZ hg jh^beky \ ]
]
74
Fug_kqblZ_fqlh`bl_ebG_^`^Z[uebyauqgbdZfb\ZooZ[blu`_aZ
y\eyxlqlhboie_fy[uehyauq_kdbf
75
B[g;ZrZj
76
=mkfZg[bg;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
77
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªZe-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe^`ZabjZª
78
Ebqgu_ibkvfZibkvfhk
72
73
30
eh\_d h[ty\be ^ha\he_gguf ijheblb_ djh\b fmkmevfZg Ih
ijbqbg_ih^h[ghc[_ajZkkm^ghckf_ehklbmqbl_evFmoZffZ^Z
[bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z kdZaZe ©:eeZo \\_^_l wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \ aZ
[em`^_gb_Zq_j_ag_]h\\_^_l\aZ[em`^_gb_b^jm]bog_kqZ
klguo jZ[h\ª79 B ^_ckl\bl_evgh hgb hdZaZebkv ijZ\u I_j
\ufdlhgZibkZedjblbdm\Z^j_k_]hm[_`^_gbc[ue_]hjh^
ghchl_p<b^bfhhgohjhrhbamqbebklhjbxFmkZceZfuKZ
^`ZoLZeobZe-:kZ^bbbfih^h[guoIh\ha\jZs_gbbba;Zk
juhl_paZij_lbe80_fmjZkijhkljZgylvk\hb_j_lbq_kdb_b^_b
Zihke_kf_jlbhlpZ_]hi_j\ufijhlb\gbdhfklZejh^ghc[jZl
r_co Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ gZibkZ\rbc ^\_ djblbq_k
db_dgb]b
>Zr_co\ujhk\G_^`^_]^_pZjbehg_\_`_kl\hiha^
g__ _fm g_ m^Zehkv klZlv mq_guf \hafh`gh bf_ggh ihwlhfm
hgj_rbe\hh[s_g_ijh^he`Zlvk\h_h[jZah\Zgb_81R_coh[
eZ^ZeoZjZdl_jhf[mglZjyb\hkklZ\Zeijhlb\\k_oh[s_ijbgy
luo p_gghkl_c djblbdh\Ze \k_ qlh \b^_e \ fmkmevfZgkdbo
>`ZfbevKu^dbZa-AZoZ\b©:e-NZ^`jZk-kZ^udªBa^\?]bil_\].
]K
80
GZ wlh gZf_dZ_l B[g ;ZrZj \ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª ©R_co FmoZf
fZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ \_jgmeky \ ^_j_\gx OZjbfZeZ b ijh^he`be k\h_
h[mq_gb_mhlpZihjbpZyg_\_`_kl\h[b^]Zbyauq_kl\hk\h_]hgZjh^ZHg
[uegZklhevdhmijyfqlhf_`^mgbfbhlphfkhklhyekykljh]bcjZa]h\hj.
Djhf_lh]hhgba-aZk\hbo\haaj_gbcdhgnebdlh\Zekf_klgufgZk_e_gb_f
Ihke_ kf_jlb hlpZ \ ] ] hg jZa\_jgme hldjulmx ijhiZ]Zg^m
k\hbob^_cªFug_\_jbfqlhiheh`_gb_G_^`^Z[uehbf_gghlZdbfdZ
dbf _]h ij_^klZ\be FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ ?]h hl_p [ue dZab_foZg[Zeblhf fmkmevfZgbghf b ij_djZkgh agZe h[s_kl\h \ dhlhjhf `be
Ihq_fm`_hg\i_j\mxhq_j_^vg_\uklmibekdjblbdhcmihfygmluoy\e_
gbc"Fh`_l[ulvhg[ueiehobfdZab_f"Bawlh]hfufh`_fk^_eZlv\u
\h^hlhfqlh[_^Zg_\hlp_Z\kug_dhlhjuc[uenZgZlbdhfjZaj_rZ\
rbfm[b\ZlvfmkmevfZgDZdr_coFmoZffZ^iha\hebek_[_fheqZlv\b^y
aZ[em`^_gb_ k\h_]h gZjh^Z g_m`_eb ih\bgh\_gb_ jh^bl_eyf fh`_l [ulv
ij_\ur_ [hjv[u k yauq_kl\hf b [b^]Z" ;ueZ eb m g_]h ]ZjZglby qlh hg
i_j_`b\_lhlpZqlh[ubkijZ\blv©aZ[em`^_gbyªk\h_]hh[s_kl\Z"
81
>hdlhjFmoZffZ^Ze-FZk]Zjb\dgb]_©:e-DZmZrbnZe-^`Zebynbdmnjb
^Z\eyl Zk-KZ]m^byª ijbagZ_lky ©R_co gbdh]^Z g_ [ue djmiguf mq_guffm^`lZob^hfghg_kfhljygZwlhhlebqZekyk\h_cZdlb\ghklvxª
79
31
kljZgZo>Z\hafh`gh\g_dhlhjuo\_sZohg[ueijZ\h^gZdh
\hkgh\ghf\k_]^Zhrb[ZekyBkZfuf[hevrbfaZ[em`^_gb_f
r_coZ [ueh h[\bg_gb_ fmkmevfZg \ yauq_kl\_ bf_ggh ihwlh
fmhgh[ty\bejZaj_r_gghcbodjh\vbbfms_kl\hDZd\b^bl_
_]hb^_bg_kbevghhlebqZebkvhlb^_coZjb^`blh\
<ha\jZs_gb_ba;Zkju
DZdml\_j`^Z_lB[g;ZrZjr_co[ueba]gZgba;Zkju
Ihke_wlh]hhgbaty\be`_eZgb_ih_oZlv\RZfgh\imlbqmlv
g_mf_jhl`Z`^u82Ihke_wlh]hFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[
gZijZ\beky\^_j_\gxOZjbfZeZ]^_f_`^mgbfb__`bl_eyfb
\kiuogmeZh`_klhq_ggZy^bkdmkkbyihke_dhlhjhchl_paZij_
lbe_fmjZkijhkljZgylvk\hbb^_bHgihkemrZekyhlpZb\l_
q_gb_^\moe_l\iehlv^hkf_jlbhlpZ\]]gbdh]h
g_ihk\ysZe\k\hbb^_bIhke__]hkf_jlbhghkf_e_ebgZqZe
ijhiZ]Zg^m m g_]h ihy\bebkv klhjhggbdb h^gZdh `bl_eb ^_
j_\gb OZjbfZeZ g_^h\hevgu_ ^_ckl\byfb FmoZffZ^Z [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zj_rbebm[blv_]hBhg[ue\ugm`^_g[_`Zlv
\jh^gmx^_j_\gxZe-=mycgZ83.
I_j\uc^h]h\hj
Ihke_lh]hdZdr_coZba]gZebbaOZjZfbeZhg\_jgmeky
\ jh^gmx ^_j_\gx b aZdexqbe ^h]h\hj k gZf_klgbdhf =mkfZ
ghf[bgOZf^hf[bgFm]ZffZjhfdhlhjhfmihh[_sZe©?keb
lu hdZ`_rv fg_ ih^^_j`dm lh [m^_rv ijZ\blv \k_f G_^`
^hfª84 =mkfZg `_gbe _]h gZ k\h_c ie_fyggbp_ Ze->`Z\oZj_
[bgl =Z[^meeZ [bg Fm]ZffZj b r_co [eZ]h^Zjy _]h kdZaZe
©Y gZ^_xkv qlh :eeZo ih^Zjbl l_[_ G_^`^ b \k_o _]h `bl_
e_cª85Wlbkeh\Zhq_gvykgh^Zxlij_^klZ\e_gb_hlhfdlhbo
kdZaZe<]eZaZor_coZhk\h[h^bl_eyZjZ[h\hlyauq_kl\Zfm
kmevfZg_[uebjZ[Zfbdhlhjuofh`gh^Zjblv\f_kl_ka_fey
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
Omk_cg[bg=ZgZf©LZjboG_^`^ª
84
LZf`_
85
Wlbkeh\Zi_j_^Z_lh^bgbadjmig_crbo\ZooZ[blkdbor_coh\=Z[^meeZ
Nbeebib ©LZjbo G_^`^ª k lZd`_ kf B[g ;ZrZj ©=mg\Zg ZefZ^`^«ª.
82
83
32
fb Gh \kdhj_ ih^ ^Z\e_gb_f khk_^gbo gZf_klgbdh\ `bl_e_c
OZjbfZeZmq_guo;Zkjub\h_gZqZevgbdZKme_cfZgZ[bgFm
oZffZ^Z [bg =Zjbj Ze-OZfb^b gZf_klgbd Ze-=mycgu [ue \u
gm`^_g ba]gZlv FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z k_y\r_]h \h
djm]k_[ykfmlmbg_klZ[bevghklv
:fh`_l[ulvB[gFm]ZffZjjZkdmkbeB[g=Z[^me\Zo
oZ[Zbihgyeqlhlhlijbau\Z_ldm[bckl\m[_a\bgguofmkmev
fZg
>h]h\hjkB[gKZ]m^hf
Ihdbgm\Ze-=mycgmr_co\]]gZijZ\bekyd
wfbjmZ^->Zj]bb86FmoZffZ^m[bgKZ]m^mhgb^h]h\hjbebkvh
lhf qlh iheblbq_kdZy \eZklv [m^_l \ jmdZo B[g KZ]m^Z Z j_
eb]bhagZy\jmdZoB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zdjhf_wlh]h^h]h\hjkh
^_j`Zeljbmkeh\by
I_j\h_ r_co g_ bf__l ijZ\Z ij_^ty\eylv ij_l_gabb
B[gKZ]m^mhlghkbl_evghgZeh]h\dhlhju_hg[m^_lkh[bjZlv
k`bl_e_cZ^->Zj]bbb^jm]boih^\eZklguoj_]bhgh\bebj_]b
hgh\dhlhju_hdZ`mlkyih^_]h\eZklvx\[m^ms_fG_ba\_kl
gh ijbgye eb r_co wlh mkeh\b_ gh ih keh\Zf B[g ;ZrZjZ
gZ^_`guc i_j_^Zlqbd87 ijbgye Wlhl ihklmihd B[g ;ZrZj
hijZ\^u\Z_l l_f qlh r_co ohl_e hqbklblv k_[y hl jZaebqguo
ih[hjh\g_ijbagZgguorZjbZlhf
<lhjh_ \eZklv ih gZke_^kl\m ^hklZ_lky ^_lyf FmoZf
fZ^Z [bg KZ]m^Z Lh _klv r_co _]h ihlhfdb ihke_^h\Zl_eb b
mq_gbdb ^he`gu [ueb h]jZgbqblvky lhevdh klZlmkhf mq_guo
r_coh\fmnlb_\b^jm]boj_eb]bhaguo^_yl_e_c88.
G_[hevrZy^_j_\gy\^hebg_OZgbng_ih^Ze_dmhlwj-Jby^Z
GZ^_`guclhevdhm\ZooZ[blh\
88
:e-FZk]Zjbibr_l©Wlhl^h]h\hjhq_gvihoh`gZlhldhlhjucaZdexqb
eb\q_l\_jlhf\_d_bfi_jZlhjDhgklZglbgbojbklbZgkdb_^moh\gu_eb^_
ju<j_amevlZl_wlh]h^h]h\hjZk\_lkdZy\eZklvhdZaZeZkv\jmdZobfi_jZ
lhjZZ^moh\gZy–\jmdZoiZiuKh]eZkgh^h]h\hjmDhgklZglbgij_^hklZ
\be \k_f ojbklbZgZf aZsblm Z lZd`_ \hafh`ghklv kem`blv \ Zjfbb ^ey
aZsblubgl_j_kh\bfi_jbbLhl`_bklhqgbdqlh\ke_^mxs_ckkued_
86
87
33
Lj_lv_r_coh[yam_lkyhklZ\Zlvkyijb\_j`_gp_fk_fvb
KZ]m^Zbgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_\ha]eZ\eylvj_eb]bhagmxijhiZ
]Zg^m\^jm]hck_fv_89.
B[g KZ]m^ kh k\h_c klhjhgu h[_sZe r_com ^_eblvky k
gbfljhn_yfbaZo\Zq_ggufb\h\j_fygZ[_]h\90.
GZqZeh\hcgijhlb\fmkmevfZg
R_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ ebqgh aZgbfZeky
nhjfbjh\Zgb_f \h_gguo hljy^h\91 H^bg ba \ZooZ[blkdbo bk
lhjbdh\jZkkdZau\ZyhlhfdZdr_coFmoZffZ^\i_j\ucjZa
[eZ]hkeh\be k\hb \hckdZ gZ ihoh^ ijhlb\ fmkmevfZg ibr_l
©AZl_f r_co h[ty\be ^`boZ^ b ijba\Ze d g_fm k\hbo \hbgh\
l_ g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh _s_ [ueb g_ ijb\udrbfb d \h_gghfm
^_em ih^qbgb\rbkv \_e_gbx r_coZ \uklmibeb \ ihoh^ Hgb
gZiZebgZg_dhlhju_ba[_^mbgkdboie_f_gbkljhn_yfb`b
\ufbba^hjh\ufb\_jgmebkv^hfhcª92Ijbql_gbbih^h[guo
wibah^h\ \hagbdZxl \hijhku < q_f [ueZ \bgZ l_o [_^mbgh\"
IhdZdhfmijZ\mbobfms_kl\h[uehaZo\Zq_gh\dZq_kl\_ljh
n__\"
H[yaZl_evghklvob^`ju
B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[ h[yaZe \k_o dlh m\_jh\Ze \ _]h mq_
gb_ i_j_k_eylvky d g_fm \ G_^`^ Wlh [ueZ y\gZy [b^]Z ih
kdhevdm^hg_]hdwlhfmijb_fmijb[_]ZelhevdhGZnb][bgZe:ajZd I_j\uf dlh hkm^be wlm [b^]Z [ue jh^ghc [jZl B[g
=Z[^me\ZooZ[ZKme_cfZgdhlhjuc\k\h_cdgb]_©:k-KZ\Z]bd
Ze-beyoby nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-\ZooZ[byª ijb\_e dhff_glZjbc
oZ^bkZ ©G_l i_j_k_e_gby ihke_ \aylby F_ddbª93 Hkgh\u\Zykv
gZwlhfoZ^bk_hgijba\Ze\k_ohklZ\Zlvky\F_^bg_Zi_j_k_
>hdlhjFmoZffZ^=Z[^meeZZe-FZk]Zjb\dgb]_©Ze-DZmZrbnZe-^`Zeby
nbdmnjZ^-^Z\eyZk-KZ]m^byªhg^h\hevgheh]bqghZgZebabjm_lbhijh\_j
]Z_lmkeh\bywlh]h^h]h\hjZkfgZ_]hkZcl_\Bgl_jg_l_
90
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
91
LZf`_
92
L_f`_lk-15.
93
©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ªK
89
34
e_gb_bag__gZa\ZejZkimlkl\hf94B[g;ZrZjihih\h^mwlhc
ob^`jujZkkdZau\Z_l©L_dlhi_j_k_ebeky\Z^->Zj]bydFm
oZffZ^m[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[m`beb\hq_gvly`_euomkeh\byob
gm`^_ Ih ghqZf hgb [ueb \ugm`^_gu aZjZ[Zlu\Zlv k_[_ gZ
`bagvZ^g_fihk_sZlv_]he_dpbbª95>Ze__hgibr_l©R_co
\kyq_kdbklZjZekyihfh]Zlvi_j_k_e_gpZfieZlbeaZgbo^he]b
b^Z\Zebf^_gv]bgZjZaebqgu_gm`^uª96.
;h]h[hyag_gghklvbgZ[h`ghklvr_coZ
Gb`_fumihfyg_fg_dhlhju_ba^_ygbcwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
b_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_cdhlhju_ihb^__y\eyxlky^_ygbyfb\_
^msbfb\:^^ZkhojZgblgZk:eeZo>Zb\p_ehfke_^m_lhl
f_lblv qlh bklhjby \ZooZ[bafZ ihegZ ijbf_jh\ bo \hcg ijh
lb\fmkmevfZgbIjhjhdZk]k
R_co :ofZ^ AZcgb >Zoeyg ibr_l ©FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[ aZij_sZe ijhbaghkblv [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ \ Z^j_k
IjhjhdZk]khkh[hkljh]bfwlhlaZij_l[ue^eyghqbgZdZ
gmg_ iylgbpu b \j_f_gb ihke_ ijhbag_k_gby ijbau\Z gZ fh
ebl\mkfbgZj_lZFh`ghkdZaZlvqlhijhbag_k_gb_kZeZ\Zlh\
Ijhjhdm k]k ^Z`_ j_aZeh kemo r_coZ <k_o dlh kh\_jrZe
\ur_mihfygmlh_hghq_gvkbevghgZdZau\Ze\iehlv^hkf_j
lb Kj_^b _]h klhjhggbdh\ [ue h^bg ke_ihc fmZaabg k hq_gv
djZkb\uf ]hehkhf dhlhjhfm hg lZd`_ aZij_lbe ijhbaghkblv
kZeZ\Zlh^gZdhlhlg_ihkemrZeky_]hbihijhkbe[eZ]hkeh\_
gby Ijhjhdm k]k ihke_ ijbau\Z gZ fhebl\m AZ wlhl ihklm
ihd ke_ihc fmZaabg [ue m[bl Z FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[
dhff_glbjmy _]h m[bckl\h kdZaZe ©>Z`_ ij_ex[h^_cdZ kh
\_jrZ_l f_gvrbc ]j_o q_f lhl dlh ijhkbl [eZ]hkeh\_gby
Ijhjhdmk]kªK\hbfihke_^h\Zl_eyfhgh[tykgyek\hbih
LZf`_kZlZd`_ke_^mxsZyaZg_c
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª
96
LZf `_ kljZggh qlh g_dhlhju_ ba kh\j_f_gguo ihke_^h\Zl_e_c
\ZooZ[bafZklZjZxlkykdjulvwlbnZdlu
94
95
35
klmidbl_fqlhklZjZ_lkykhojZgblvqbkluclZ\ob^Ihkfhljb
l_dZdb_m`Zkgu_^_eZl\hjbewlhlq_eh\_dª97.
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[khk\hbfb\hckdZfbgZ
iZegZjh^gmx^_j_\gxZe-=mycgZbijZdlbq_kdbkjZ\gye__k
a_fe_c < qZklghklb \ iylgbpm hg \hj\Zeky \ f_q_lv wlh]h k_
e_gby ie_gbe wfbjZ =mkfZgZ [bg OZf^Z [bg Fm]ZffZjZ b
h[ty\be _]h yauqgbdhf < h^ghf ba klbohl\hj_gbc ih wlhfm
ih\h^m kdZaZgh ©>Z hlkhog_l ijZ\Zy jmdZ lh]h dlh m[be fm
kmevfZgbgZ lhl aZkem`b\Z_l gZdZaZgby ij_^ibkZggh]h aZ
ij_^gZf_j_ggh_ m[bckl\hª AZl_f hg \uj_aZe \k_o fm`qbg
wlhc ^_j_\gb jZajmrbe ^hfZ k`_] ^_j_\vy kjm[be iZevfu
ie_gbe`_gsbgaZo\ZlbekdhlZihke_wlh]haZij_lbehlkljZb
\Zlv ^_j_\gx aZgh\h b h[ty\be qlh gZ wlm ^_j_\gx gZiZeb
iheqbsZkZjZgqbbkt_eb__\f_kl_kh\k_fb`bl_eyfb98.
<h\j_fyjZaebqguokh[jZgbchgaZqZklmxg_]h\hjy
h[wlhfiulZeky\u^Zlvk_[yaZijhjhdZgZijbf_jhgfh]kdZ
aZlv ©Y \a]eygme gZ ^h]h\hj ijb Om^_c[bb b m\b^_e lh-lh b
lh-lhªLhqghlZd`_ihklmiZebb_]hihke_^h\Zl_ebqlhhq_gv
jZ^h\Zehr_coZ99Ihwlhfmg_m^b\bl_evghqlhg_dhlhju_ex
^b jZkkdZau\Zxl h lhf dZd hg iulZeky \u^Zlv k_[y aZ gh\h]h
ijhjhdZohly\kemoh[wlhfg_aZy\eye100.
?]hgZ^_`ghklv
Bklhjbd \ZooZ[bafZ =mkfZg [bg ;ZrZj Zg-G_^`^b \
k\h_c dgb]_ ©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^nblZjboG_^`^ª101mdZau\Z_l
:ofZ^ [bg AZcgb Z^->Zoeyg ©:^->mjZj Zk-kmggby nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze\ZooZ[byªK
98
<k\h_cklZlv_fuih^jh[ghhklZgZ\eb\Z_fkygZoZ^bkZoihl_f_©H[ty\
e_gb_^ha\he_ggufdjh\hijheblby\f_q_lyoªZlZd`_ijb\h^bf\ukdZau
\ZgbykZfh]hFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
99
>Zoeyg©:^->mjZjZk-kmggby«ªK
100
LZf`_
101
R_co=mkfZg[bg;ZrZj–]]–]]kqblZ_lkyh^
gbfbakZfuo]eZ\guobklhjbdh\\ZooZ[bafZdgb]bdhlhjh]hhq_gvo\Zeyl
< k\h_c dgb]_ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª hg hklZgZ\eb\Z_lky gZ kZfuo \Z`guo
fhf_glZo \ jZa\blbb \ZooZ[blkdh]h ^\b`_gby ijhbahr_^rbo \ –
]]–]]>jm]bfba\_klgufbklhjbdhf\ZooZ[bafZy\ey_lky
r_coOmk_cg[bg=ZggZfZ\lhjdgb]©JZ\^ZlZe-ZndZj\ZZe-ZnoZfebfmj
97
36
©Dh]^ZfmoZ^`bju102i_j_k_e_gpui_j_k_ebebkvdr_comhg
klZjZekybfihfh]ZlvhieZqb\Zebo^he]bbh[_ki_qb\Ze\k_f
\ q_f hgb gm`^Zebkv Djhf_ wlh]h hg jZa^Z\Ze ih^Zjdb \k_f
ij_^klZ\bl_eyf ie_f_g ijb_a`Z\rbf d g_fm GZijbf_j ih
ke_ aZo\ZlZ wj-Jby^Z _fm ^hklZehkv khjhd lukyq fmoZffZ^b
_\103b\k_wlb^_gv]bhgihljZlbegZk\hboihke_^h\Zl_e_cª104.
Ijb wlhf ke_^m_l mqblu\Zlv qlh `bl_eb wj-Jby^Z [ueb fm
kmevfZgZfb-oZg[ZeblZfb b ih dZdhfm ijZ\m r_co fh] h[ty
\blvbobfms_kl\hljhn_yfb"JZa\_wlbex^bg_[uebfmkmev
fZgZfb" : fh`_l hgb ^h[jh\hevgh hl^Zeb wlb ^_gv]b _fm"
Fh`_l hgb g_ agZeb keh\ ©G_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZoZª" :
fh`_l[ulvwlbk\ys_ggu_keh\Zg_kem`beb]ZjZglb_cbog_
ijbdhkgh\_gghklb">Ze__B[g;ZrZjmdZau\Z_l©Hgg_ijbdZ
kZekygbdh^ghfm^bjo_fmbgbdh^ghfm^bgZjmbalhciylhc
qZklbljhn__\dhlhjZy^hklZ\ZeZkv_fmªIhih\h^miylhcqZk
lbljhn__\ohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhljhn_yfbh[ty\ey_lkylhevdh
bfms_kl\h yauqgbdh\ qlh `_ dZkZ_lky bfms_kl\Z fmkmevfZ
gbgZlhhghgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_fh`_l[ulvh[ty\e_ghljhn_
yfb >Ze__ B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l ©<k_ ljhn_cgh_ b aZdylgh_
bfms_kl\hhgkjZam`_jZa^Z\Zeex^yfb[uehq_gvs_^jGZ
ijbf_j hg fh] jZa^_eblv \k_ ljhn_b f_`^m ^\mfy beb lj_fy
\hbgZfb<_kvaZdylb\k_ljhn_b`bl_e_cZ^->Zj]bbihklmiZ
eb\_]hjmdbbhgjZkihjy`Zekybfbihk\h_fmmkfhj_gbxª105.
JZa\_ ih\_^_gb_ r_coZ g_ ihoh`_ gZ ih\_^_gb_ ZlZfZgZ jZa
[hcgbdh\dhlhjucihke_dZ`^h]hgZ[_]Z^_eblgZ]jZ[e_ggu_b
\hjh\Zggu_p_gghklb"
lZ^oZeZe-bfZfªb©DblZ[Ze-]ZaZ\Zl\ZZe-nmlmoZlZj-jZ[[ZgbyªlZd`_hg
kqblZ_lky nZdbohf b ihwlhf ?]h bklhjby ijbagZ_lky [he__ ^hklh\_jghc
q_fbklhjbyB[g;ZrZjZihkdhevdm[ueZgZibkZgZjZgvr_<dgb]Zowlbo
ex^_chq_gvfgh]hjZagh]eZkbcaZbkdexq_gb_fg_kdhevdboj_^dbokh\iZ
^_gbc
102
I_j_k_ebebkvlm^Zhldm^Z\ujhkjh]kZlZgu
103
Fhg_lZ
104
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
105
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
37
;he__lh]hB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[b_]hihke_^h\Zl_ebkh]
jhfguf `_eZgb_f ie_gbeb `_gsbg b ^_l_c Bf_ggh \ ihjm
ihy\e_gby b jZa\blby \ZooZ[bafZ \ G_^`^_ gZqZeh jZkp\_lZlv
ihobs_gb_^_l_cbjZ[hlhj]h\ey
G_dhlhju_baihklmidh\r_coZ
Hg aZij_sZe k\hbf ihke_^h\Zl_eyf qblZlv dgb]b ih
nbdomlZnkbjmoZ^bkmb\_e_ek`b]Zlvbohgdjblbdh\ZelZ
db_yaudh\u_gZmdbdZdkbglZdkbkbh[ty\bebo[b^]Z106.
Hgiha\heyek\hbfihke_^h\Zl_eyfdhff_glbjh\ZlvDh
jZgkh]eZkghk\h_fmihgbfZgbxb`_eZgbx^Z`_g_ZgZebab
jmy Zylu k lhqdb aj_gby ijZ\be yaudZ b eh]bdb Hg ]h\hjbe
©Kh\_jrZcl_ b^`lboZ^ b km^bl_ kh]eZkgh k\h_fm ihgbfZgbx
^Z`_g_aZ]ey^u\Zcl_\wlbdgb]b\_^vhgbkh^_j`Zlbbklbgm
beh`vª107.
IjbgbfZyex^_c\k\hxj_eb]bxbmkeurZ\hlgbo^\Z
k\b^_l_evkl\Z hg ]h\hjbe ©IjbagZc qlh jZgvr_ lu [ue g_
\_jguf ijbagZc qlh l\hb jh^bl_eb mf_jeb g_\_jgufb ijb
agZcqlhlhl-lhblhl-lh[uebg_\_jgufbijbwlhfhggZau\Ze
bf_gZ ba\_klguo fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guoª ?keb q_eh\_d ijb
agZ\Ze\k_wlhlh_]hijbgbfZeb\gh\mxj_eb]bx_kebg_llh
m[b\Zeb ;he__ lh]h r_co h[ty\be qlh \hl m`_ \ l_q_gb_ k_
fbkhl e_l fmkmevfZgkdZy mffZ gZoh^blky \ khklhygbb g_\_
jby108.
<k_odlhg_ke_^h\ZeaZ_]hmq_gb_fhggZau\Zeg_\_j
gufbyauqgbdZfbbh[ty\eye^ha\he_ggufbodjh\vbbfms_
kl\hg_kfhljygZlhqlhwlbex^baZqZklmx[uebkZfufbijZ
\_^g_crbfbex^vfb<k_ok\hboihke_^h\Zl_e_chgijbagZ\Ze
\_jmxsbfbg_kfhljygZlhqlhhgb[uebgZklhysbfbjZkiml
gbdZfb Hg b _]h ihke_^h\Zl_eb h[ty\beb \g_ aZdhgZ [b^]Z
ghr_gb_ qZefu g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh wlh y\ey_lky ijhjhq_kdhc
Wlhh^gZbaijbqbghlklZehklb\ZooZ[blh\\wlboagZgbyo
Bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy wlhfm Z[khexlghfm b^`lboZ^m _]h ihke_^h\Zl_eb b
h[ty\beb^ha\he_gghcdjh\vfmkmevfZg-_^bgh[h`gbdh\
108
:ofZ^ AZcgb >Zoeyg ©OmeZkZl Ze-dZeZf nb [Zyg mfZjZ Ze-[ZeZ^ ZeOZjZfªBa^\KlZf[me_\]
106
107
38
kmgghc Z kZfZ qZefZ ijbagZ_lky dhjhghc ZjZ[h\ Bf_ggh ih
wlhfm kh\j_f_ggu_ \ZooZ[blu \h \j_fy fhebl\u ihklhyggh
ihijZ\eyxl k\hb djZkgu_ ieZldb k\b^_l_evkl\mxsb_ h lhf
dZdhgb\k\h_\j_fyijheb\Zebdjh\vfmkmevfZg
?]hm[_`^_gby
DlhagZdhfkkhqbg_gbyfbr_coZb_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_c
lhlagZ_lqlhbom[_`^_gbybf_xliylvke_^mxsbohkh[_ggh
kl_c
Ijbibku\Zgb_:eeZoml_e_kghklbdZq_kl\ijbkmsbo
kha^ZgbyfZlZd`_f_klhgZoh`^_gby:eeZo`_ij_\ur_\k_]h
wlh]h
Ijbau\ d [hjv[_ k fh]behihdehggbdZfb aZij_l gZ
lZ\Zkkmev109q_j_aIjhjhdZk]kbihk_s_gb__]hfh]beu
H[\bg_gb_ fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb b h[ty\e_gb_ bo
yauqgbdZfb
H[ty\e_gb_ ^ha\he_gguf djh\hijheblby b ]jZ[_`Z
\k_oijhlb\gbdh\^\b`_gby
Dh]^Z ^\b`_gb_ \hagbdeh r_co ijbau\Ze i_j_k_
eylvkydg_fm110.
?]hhlghr_gb_dIjhjhdmk]k
<k\hboj_qZohgaZqZklmxklZjZekyijbgbablvIjhjhdZ
k]kbihwlhfmgZau\Ze_]hihkeZgp_flh_klvbf_e\\b^m
qlh Ijhjhd k]k ebrv i_j_^Ze [h`_kl\_ggh_ ibkZgb_ fbjm,
k_[y`_hggZau\ZekiZkbl_e_flZ\ob^ZBf_gghihwlhfmg_dh
lhju_ba_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_cg_kl_kgyykv]h\hjbeb©FhyiZe
dZ emqr_ FmoZffZ^Z ihkdhevdm hgZ ijbghkbl ihevam y m[b
\Zx_xaf_cªbeb©FmoZffZ^m`_mf_jb[hevr_hlg_]hg_l
gbdZdhc ihevau hg ebrv ihkeZg_p dhlhjuc moh^bl i_j_^Z\
khh[s_gb_ª111 >h kbo ihj ihke_^h\Zl_eb r_coZ aZij_sZxl
gZau\Zlv IjhjhdZ k]k ©gZr ]hkih^bgª B wlhl nZdl hq_gv
Bkihevah\Zgb_ ijhjhdZ k]k \ dZq_kl\_ kj_^kl\Z ijb[eb`Zxs_]h d
:eeZom–ii
110
Kh\j_f_ggu_\ZooZ[bluklZjZl_evghhljbpZxlwlhlnZdl
111
:ofZ^ [bg AZcgb >Zoeyg ©Z^->mjZj Zk-kmggby nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze\ZooZ[byªK
109
39
m^b\ey_l ihkdhevdm Ijhjhd k]k \ k\h_f oZ^bk_ kdZaZe ©Y
]hkih^bg\k_oihlhfdh\:^ZfZgh\wlhf^eyf_gyg_lgbdZdhc
]hj^hklbª112.
Hlghr_gb_ihke_^h\Zl_e_cB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
dk\h_fm\h`^x
Ihke_^h\Zl_eb =Z[^meeu [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z hlghkylky
d g_fm dZd d \_ebdhfm k\ylhfm B[g ;ZrZj \ qZklghklb mih
lj_[ey_l njZam ©^Z hk\ylbl :eeZo _]h ^mrmª113 Hgb \haghkyl
_]h ^h mjh\gy ijhjhdZ b kqblZxl qlh \k_ ijhbahr_^r__ k
Ijhjhdhf k]k ijhbahreh b k gbf lh`_ GZijbf_j hgb
kjZ\gb\Zxlihdmr_gb_gZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zkih
]hg_c KmjZdb [bg FZebdZ aZ Ijhjhdhf k]k kjZ\gb\Zxl
[_]kl\h B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ba OZjbfZeZ k i_j_k_e_gb_f Ijh
jhdZ k]k \ F_^bgm114 ?]h \hcgu ijhlb\ fmkmevfZg kqblZ
xlky ^`boZ^hf gZ[_]b – ihoh^Zfb ih[_^u gZau\Zxlky ©nm
lmoZlªih^^Zggu_–fmkmevfZgZfbZg_ih^qbg_gb__fmkqblZ
_lky\_jhhlklmigbq_kl\hf<k_odlhgZqbgZe\f_kl_kgbfhg
gZau\Ze ZgkZjZfb Z \k_o dlh i_j_k_ebeky d g_fm iha^g__ fmoZ^`bjZfb ?keb dlh-eb[h ba _]h gh\uo kih^\b`gbdh\dh]
^Z-lhkh\_jrZeoZ^`lhhg]h\hjbe_fm©Kh\_jrboZ^`aZgh
\h\_^vlhloZ^`lukh\_jrbedh]^Z[ueyauqgbdhfihwlhfm
I_j_^Zeb Fmkebf b :[m >Zm^ hl :[m OmjZcju :ofZ^ b Zl-Lbjfbab
wlhloZ^bkijbagZebohjhrbfoZkZgB[gFZ^`ZB[g>`ZjbjB[gFZj
^Z\Zcob\k_hgbi_j_^Zeb_]hhl:[mKZ]b^ZZe-Om^jbdjhf_lh]h:ofZ^b
:[m Y]ey i_j_^Zeb _]h hl B[g =Z[[ZkZ \ khklhygbb fZjnm] hlg_k_gguc d
Ijhjhdmk]k?]hijb\h^blB[gDZkbjdh]^Zdhff_glbjm_lZylkm
juZe-:]jZn©Ij_]jZ^uªbmdZau\Z_l©G_lkhfg_gby\lhfqlhFmoZf
fZ^k]ky\ey_lky]hkih^bghfZ[khexlgh\k_oihlhfdh\:^ZfZbi_j\uo
b ihke_^gboª Lh `_ kZfh_ hg ibr_l dhff_glbjmy b Zylu kmju ZeNmjdZg©JZaebq_gb_ªZylkmjuZe-=ZgdZ[ml©IZmdªZylkmjuKZ
[Z;he__lh]h\kyfmkmevfZgkdZymffZijbagZ_l_]h]hkih^bghf\k_]hq_
eh\_q_kl\Z
113
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªb
114
Kf©FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[]Zdb^ZlmomZk-kZeZnby\Z^Z]\Zlmom
Ze-bkeZoby \Z kZgZt Ze-]meZfZt ]Zeycobª ba^ \ DK: jZkijhkljZgy_lky
[_kieZlgh
112
40
hg g_ kgbfZ_l k l_[y h[yaZl_evghklv iZehfgbq_kl\Zª115 ;he__
lh]hB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[aZdexqb\^h]h\hjkB[gKZ]m^hfgZ
qZe ibkZlv ibkvfZ \h`^yf ZjZ[kdbo ie_f_g k ijbau\hf ijb
gylvgh\mxj_eb]bxl_fkZfufhgiulZekyih^jZ`ZlvIjhjh
dm k]k ibkZ\r_fm ibkvfZ ijZ\bl_eyf jZaebqguo ]hkm
^Zjkl\ Ih wlhfm ih\h^m B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l ©AZl_f r_co gZ
ijZ\be ibkvfZ ijZ\bl_eyf ]hjh^h\ ie_f_g b mq_guf \ wlbo
ibkvfZohgijbau\Zeboihke_^h\Zlvbklbg_G_dhlhju_bagbo
ijbgyeb_]hijbau\^jm]b_`_ebrvihkf_yebkvgZ^gbfih
kqblZ\_]hg_\_`^hcª116Ihke_wlbokeh\B[g;ZrZj^_ckl\b
l_evghkjZ\gb\Z_l_]hkIjhjhdhfk]k
?]hh[jZah\Zgb_
KeurZj_qb\ZooZ[blh\h[h[gh\e_gq_kdhfmq_gbbFm
oZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z fh`gh ih^mfZlv qlh hg hklZ\be
ihke_ k_[y h]jhfgh_ gZmqgh_ b dmevlmjgh_ gZke_^b_ qlh _]h
dgb]b aZihegyxl ihedb [b[ebhl_d G_ aZ[u\Zcl_ qlh _]h
`bagv [ueZ hq_gv ijh^he`bl_evghc ihqlb \_d GZ kZfhf `_
^_e_ \Zk ihklb]g_l jZahqZjh\Zgb_ dh]^Z \umagZ_l_qlhr_co
g_gZibkZegbh^ghcdgb]bijb]h^ghc^eybamq_gby\mq_[guo
aZ\_^_gbyo ?]h dgb]b fh`gh gZa\Zlv lhevdh [jhrxjZfb117 b
g_[he__lh]hGh^Z`_wlb[jhrxjuiheguhrb[hdbkeZ[uo
\u^mfZgguo oZ^bkh\ b ^h\h^h\ KZfhc ba\_klghc [jhrxjhc
y\ey_lky ©DblZ[ Zl-lZ\ob^ª ©Dgb]Z _^bgh[h`byª ijhqly __
\ulZd`_fh`_l_m[_^blvky\g_\_`_kl\_baZ[em`^_gbbg_^`
^bckdh]hZ\lhjZ
FmoZffZ^ NZdbo [bg =Z[^me^`Z[[Zj Ze->`Z\b ©:g-Gmkmk Ze-bkeZfby
nbZj-jZ^^]ZeyfZaoZ[Ze-\ZooZ[byªBa^\?]bil_\]K–©:lLZd\byZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZgªK
116
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
117
;hevrbgkl\h\ZooZ[blkdbodgb]ij_^klZ\eyxlbak_[y[jhrxjuqlh[u
k^_eZlvbolhes_hgbklZjZxlkyba^Z\Zlvbo\fbgbZlxjghfjZaf_j_
115
41
<ukdZau\Zgbymq_guohg_f
GZrZkdjhfgZydgb]Zg_fh`_l\dexqblv\k_[y\ukdZ
au\Zgby\k_omq_guo118ihwlhfmfuijb\h^bfebrv\ukdZau
\Zgbyg_dhlhjuo
Jh^ghc[jZlKme_cfZgkdZaZe_fm©FmoZffZ^kdhevdh
klheih\BkeZfZl_[_ba\_klgh"ªHghl\_lbe©IylvªKme_cfZg
kdZaZe©Luijb^mfZer_klhcklheidlhg_ke_^m_laZlh[hc–
lhlg_fmkmevfZgbgª119.
:e-:fbjZk-KZg]ZgbZ\lhj©Km[meZk-kZeZfªgZibkZeh
g_f klbohl\hj_gb_ ©Hg \ k\h_f ljZdlZl_ h[ty\be \k_o `bl_
e_cA_febg_\_jgufb<^hdZaZl_evkl\hk\h_cijZ\hluhgijb
?keb \u `_eZ_l_ ihagZdhfblvky k djblbdZfb \ZooZ[bafZ lh kh\_lm_f
\Zfijhq_klvdgb]mFmoZffZ^ZZe-DZkbjb©:k-KZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZ
\ZZe-bfZfbyª\wlhcdgb]_hgkihklji_j_qbkey_lfgh]b_ljm^u
gZibkZggu_\dZq_kl\_hijh\_j`_gbyb^_cwlh]h^\b`_gbyijbq_fgZwlbo
kljZgbpZo mihfbgZxlky lhevdh gZa\Zgby dgb] b bf_gZ Z\lhjh\ LZd`_ kf
Zl-LZd\b ©:e-NbjdZ Ze \ZooZ[by nb ob^fZl fZg"ª ©Dhfm kem`bl k_dlZ
\ZooZ[blh\"ªk-gZwlbokljZgbpZoijb\_^_gubf_gZmq_guobpb
lZlubabodgb]>Ze__kfr_coFmoZffZ^Ze-Dmj^bZr-RZnb]bdhlhjuc
\ k\h_c dgb]_ \hko\Zey_l ljZdlZl Kme_cfZgZ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z =Z[^meeZ
[bg =Z[^meZlun Zr-RZnb]b ©LZ^`jb^ kZcn Ze-^`boZ^ ebfm^^Z]b Zeb^`lboZ^ª=Znbnml^bgZe-OZg[Zeb©:k-KZ\Z]bd\ZZj-jm]m^ª\^\Z^pZlb
[jhrxjZdhlhju_khdjZlbeFmoZffZ^[bg;ZrbjdZabcB[g=ZnZebdZeOZg[Zeb ©LZoZdmf Ze-fmdZeeb^bg [b fZgg b^^Z]Z lZ^`^b^ Z^-^bgª =ZlZ
Ze-FZddb ©:k-KZjbf Ze-obg^b nb ]bgZd Zg-g_^`^bª BkfZbe Zl-LZfbfb
Ze-FZebdbZl-LmgmkbKZeboZe-DZ\\ZrZl-LmgmkbB[g=Zeb[mgZe-Eyceb
FmklZnZZe-FbkjbZe-;meZdbZe-FZrjbdZe-FZebdbZe->`ZaZbjbFmklZ
nZ Ze-OZfZfb Ze-Fbkjb KZeZfZ Ze-=ZaZfb OZkZg Zr-RZlb Ze-OZg[Zeb
FmoZffZ^ OmkgZcg FZoexn =ZlZ Ze-DZkZf Z^->bfZrdb =Z[^me]Zaba ZeDmjZrb Ze-FZebdb =Z[^mefmokbg Ze-:rbdjb Ze-OZg[Zeb :ofZ^ ZkKbjobg^b Zg-GZdr[Zg^b OZeb^ Ze-;Z]^Z^b :ofZ^ [bg =Zeb Ze-DZ[[Zgb
Ze-;Zkjb Ze-OZnba FmoZffZ^ OZkZg Ze-OZgZnb FmoZffZ^ =ZlZmeeZ ZjJmfb B[jZobf Zj-JZ\b Ze-=bjZdb =bkZ Zk-KZg]Zgb Ze-C_f_gb OZf^meeZ
Z^->Z^`b\bZe-OZgZnbZe-Obg^b=Z[^mjZofZgDmlbFmoZffZ^OZ[b[ZeFmobdd dZabc ;ZjfZeb BkfZbe Zl-LZfbfb Zl-Lmgmkb =Z[^me\ZooZ[ ZrRZ]jZgbXkmnZg-GZ[oZgbZe-NbeZklugb=ZebAZcgme]Z[b^bgZk-Km^Zgb
FmoZffZ^ :g\ZjrZo Ze-DZrfbjb FmoZffZ^ :ofZ^ OZfb^ Zk-Km^Zgb
B[g=Z[b^bgZr-RZfbFmoZffZ^=Z[^jZofZgZk-KZeoZlbZe-Obg^bb^jm
]b_
119
:ofZ^AZcgb>Zoeyg©:^->mjZjZk-kmggby«ªK
118
42
\h^blfgh`_kl\hmf_klguobg_mf_klguo^h\h^h\hgih^h[_g
iZmdmih^kl_j_]Zxs_fmk\hx^h[uqmªDeygmkv:eeZohfkdZ
aZghhq_gvlhqgh
F_ddZgkdbcoZg[Zeblkdbcfmnlbcr_coFmoZffZ^[bg
=Z[^meeZ Zg-G_^`^b Ze-OZg[Zeb mf ] ] \ k\h_c
dgb]_ ©:k-Kmom[ Ze-\Z[bey ]Zey ^ZjZbo Ze-oZgZ[beyª jZkkdZ
au\Zy h[ hlp_ FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ibr_l ©Hg y\
ey_lkyhlphflh]hFmoZffZ^ZdhlhjucjZkijhkljZgbeihfbjm
k\h_ mq_gb_ h^gZdh g_ ke_^m_l hlh`^_kl\eylv hlpZ k kughf
FmoZffZ^ g_ \uklmibe kh k\hbf mq_gb_f ^h l_o ihj ihdZ g_
mf_j_]hhl_pG_dhlhju_mq_gu_fg_jZkkdZau\Zebqlhr_co
=Z[^me\ZooZ[[uek_j^blgZk\h_]hkugZaZlhqlhhghldZaZe
kybamqZlvnbdodZdwlh^_eZeb\k__]hij_^dbb^jmavyK\hbf
khie_f_ggbdZfbijhqbfex^yfhg]h\hjbe©Ijbau\FmoZf
fZ^Zy\ey_lkyaehfh^gZdh\k_ijhbkoh^bllhevdhih\he_:e
eZoZª H _]h hlghr_gbb d B[g L_cfbb b B[g Ze-DZcbfm hl_p
kdZaZe ©Hg hlghkblky d keh\Zf wlbo ^\hbo dZd d k\ys_gguf
l_dklZfb^Z`_g_dhff_glbjm_lbo;he__lh]hhggZiZ^Z_lgZ
ex^_cª ?]h [jZlm Kme_cfZgm gZibkZ\r_fm dgb]m ©NZke ZeoblZ[ nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ª m^Zehkv
kiZklbkvhl]b[_ebLh]^Zhl_pkdZaZe©?kebdlh-eb[hjZkdju
\Zekmlv_]hb^_clhhgiulZekym[blvwlh]hq_eh\_dZ_keb_fm
wlhg_m^Z\ZehkvlhhgaZkueZedh]h-eb[hdlh^_eZewlhlZcgh
HgkqblZe^ha\he_ggufijheblb_djh\bex[h]hdlh\uklmiZe
ijhlb\ g_]hª <a]eygbl_ gZ wlb keh\Z JZa\_ fh] [ulv mq_guf
q_eh\_dhldZaZ\rbckyhlbamq_gbynbdoZblZdkbevghjZa]g_
\Z\rbck\h_]hijZ\_^gh]hhlpZ?
R_co FmoZffZ^Zfbg [bg =Z[b^bg Ze-OZgZnb \ dgb]_
©JZ^^Ze-fmolZj]Zey^mjjZe-fmolZjª\]eZ\_hg_kijZ
\_^eb\hklb jZkkdZau\Zy h \ZooZ[blZo ibr_l ©Wlb ex^b ih
y\bebkv \ G_^`^_ aZo\Zlbeb h[_ K\ylugb h[ty\eyeb k_[y
oZg[ZeblZfb gh fmkmevfZgZfb kqblZeb lhevdh k_[y \k_ hk
lZevgu_^eygbo[uebyauqgbdZfbª
>jm]hc mq_guc >`Zfbe Ku^db Za-AZoZ\b \ ©:e-NZ^`j
Zk-kZ^uª ibr_l ©<ZooZ[blu – wlh k_dlZ hkgh\hiheh`gbdhf
dhlhjhc y\ey_lky FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ <i_j\u_ hg
43
\uklmibe kh k\hbfb b^_yfb \ ] ] Z dh]^Z _fm bk
ihegbehkv iylv^_kyl e_l \uklmibe k hldjulhc Z]blZpb_c \
ihevam k\h_c k_dlu JZkijhkljZg_gb_ k\hbo nZevrb\uo b^_c
hggZqZekG_^`^Z?]hih^^_j`ZeFmoZffZ^[bgKZ]m^wfbj
Z^->Zj]bb ihkl_i_ggh wlZ kfmlZ jZkijhkljZgbeZkv \h fgh]bo
ZjZ[kdboa_feyobho\ZlbeZ\kxZjZ[kdmximklugxK\hbfih
ke_^h\Zl_eyf hg ]h\hjbe ©Y ijbau\Zx \Zk lhevdh d _^bgh[h
`bx hldZam hl yauq_kl\Z b ihdehg_gbx h^ghfm :eeZomª B
\k_ hgb reb aZ gbf lZdbf h[jZahf ihkl_i_ggh hg h\eZ^_\Ze
\k_gh\ufbbgh\ufbl_jjblhjbyfbª120.
=Z[^meeZ [bg Zr-RZjbn Omk_cg iZrZ \ dgb]_ ©Ku^d
Ze-oZ[ZjnboZ\Zjb^`Ze-dZjgZk-kZgb]ZrZjª©IjZ\^b\u_\_
klb h oZjb^`blZo ^\_gZ^pZlh]h \_dZª ibr_l ©WlZ \ZooZ[bl
kdZy [b^]Z ihy\beZkv \ ] ] \ G_^`^_ iha^g__ \
]]hgbaZo\ZlbebF_ddmOZjb^`blZfb`_hgb[u
ebgZa\Zgug_ba-aZlh]hqlhaZo\ZlbebF_ddmZba-aZlh]hqlh
bomq_gb_kZfhihk_[_y\ey_lky[b^]Zª
Djhf_ \ur_i_j_qbke_gguo mq_guo k djblbdhc B[g
=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zb_]hmq_gby\uklmiZebij_^klZ\bl_eb\k_oq_
luj_ofZaoZ[h\
H^gbfbai_j\uodlh\uklmibekhkm`^_gb_f^_ckl\bc
FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z [ue _]h [u\rbc gZklZ\gbd
r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg Kme_cfZg Ze-Dmj^b Z\lhj ba\_klgh]h
rZnb]blkdh]h dhff_glZjby ©OZ\Zrb rZjo B[jg OZ^`Zj ]Zey
fZlgª < qZklghklb hg kdZaZe B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[m ©Ijb^_j`b
k\hc\j_^hghkgucyaudbg_\j_^bfmkmevfZgZfª-h^gZdhhg
g_ihke_^h\Zewlhfmkh\_lmbg_ijb^_j`Zeg_lhevdhyaudgh
bjmdb
OZg[Zeblhf\uklmib\rbfijhlb\g_]h[ue_]hjh^ghc
[jZlr_coKme_cfZgdgb]bdhlhjh]hfumihfygmeb\ur_
>`ZfbeKu^dbZa-AZoZ\b©:e-NZ^`jZk-kZ^udnbZj-jZ^^]Zeyfmgdbjb
Zl-lZ\Zkkmev \Z Ze-dZjZfZl \Z Ze-oZ\Zjbdª K Ba^ \ ?]bil_ \ ]
]
120
44
<qbke_oZg[Zeblkdbomq_guoRZfZ[ueb:ebZr-RZlb
br_co=Z[^medm^mfbZg-GZ[exkb_s_[hevr__]hijhlb\gb
dh\[uehkj_^bkh\j_f_ggbdh\
<ukdZau\Zgbyh_j_lbq_kdhcgZijZ\e_gghklb_]hmq_gby
H _j_lbq_kdhc gZijZ\e_gghklb mq_gby FmoZffZ^Z [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z\ukdZau\ZebkvB[g=Z[b^bgZe-OZgZnb\©JZ^^
Ze-fmolZj]Zey^mjjZe-fmolZjª\]eZ\_©Hg_kijZ\_^eb\hklbª
br_coZk-KZ\bZe-Fbkjb\k\hbokm[dhff_glZjbyodlZnkbjm
©>`ZeZeZcgª Hgb h[Z hlf_qZeb qlh r_co h[ty\ey_l g_\_j
gufbl_odlhijhbaghkblkeh\Z©G_l[h`_kl\Zdjhf_:eeZoZ
ZFmoZffZ^ihkeZggbd:eeZoZª
AZ[em`^_gbyex^_chlghkbl_evgh_]hmq_gby
DZdba\_klgh_]hmq_gb_aZjh^behkv\G_^`^_gZjh^b
g_ g_\_`_kl\Z b ihkl_i_ggh jZkijhkljZgbehkv ih [ebae_`Z
sbf j_]bhgZf L_ dlh `be \^Ze_d_ hg G_^`^Z keurZeb qlh
ihy\behkvgh\h_mq_gb_dhlhjh_ij_\jZlbehg_\_`^bjZa[hc
gbdh\\\hbgh\lZ\ob^Z[hjxsbokykfh]behihdehggbq_kl\hf
Ih wlhc ijbqbg_ fgh]b_ ijhklhex^bgu b ^Z`_ g_dhlhju_
mq_gu_ h[fZgmebkv lZd `_ dZd hgb h[fZgmebkv \ hlghr_gbb
:lZlxjdZWlbex^bih^mfZebqlh^Zggh_mq_gb_g_k_lBkeZ
fmh[gh\e_gb_bkbem
< qZklghklb r_co Zk-KZg]Zgb Z\lhj dgb]b ©Km[me ZkkZeZfªgZibkZe©Ijb\_lkl\b_G_^`^mbl_fdlh_]hgZk_ey_l
yboijb\_lkl\mxg_kfhljygZlhqlhijb\_lkl\b_ba^Ze_dZg_
ijbghkblgbdZdhcihevauªDh]^Z`_hgihgyekmlvwlh]h^\b
`_gby lh gZibkZe ke_^mxsb_ kljhdb ©Y jZkdZyeky \ k\hbo
keh\Zo hlghkbl_evgh G_^`^Z ^h f_gy ^hreb bklbggu_ \_klb
Y^mfZeqlh\G_^`^_^h[jhbgZ^_yekyqlhhggZklZ\blfm
kmevfZg gZ bklbgguc imlv Y hrb[ky \_^v ij_^iheh`_gb_ g_
kihkh[gh\_klbbklbggufiml_fª121.
<ZooZ[blu klZjZxlky aZsblblvky hl ih^h[guo \ukdZau\Zgbc mq_guo
h[\bgyybo\de_\_l_bg_ihke_^h\Zl_evghklbBokhklhygb_ih^h[ghkhklh
ygbxmlhiZxs_]hp_ieyxs_]hkyaZkhehfbgdmGZkZfhf`_^_e_mgbog_l
gbdZdbo ^h\h^h\ ^ey hijZ\^Zgby k\hbo ^_ygbc b k\h_]h mq_gby ihwlhfm
ijbkemrb\Zcl_kvdkeh\Zfbklbgguomq_guo
121
45
Djhf_ g_]h bo mq_gb_ \\_eh \ aZ[em`^_gb_ k_b^Z Fm
oZffZ^Z JZrb^Z Jb^m j_^ZdlhjZ `mjgZeZ ©:e-FZgZjª gZib
kZ\r_]hdgb]m©:e-<ZooZ[by\ZZe-ob^`Zaª122IjbqbghclZdhc
ex[\bd\ZooZ[bafm[ueZg_gZ\bklvd^bgZklbbZrjZnb^h\123
b`_eZgb_bok\_j]gmlvwlhlnZdlke_^m_lmq_klv124.
FmkmevfZgkdb_mq_gu_ijbau\Zxl
FmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z\_jgmlvkydbklbg_
K_]h^gy \ZooZ[baf jZa^_ebeky gZ g_kdhevdh l_q_gbc b
ij_^klZ\bl_eb g_dhlhjuo ba gbo hkf_eb\Zxlky ml\_j`^Zlv
qlh]eZ\uZjZ[kdboie_f_gbj_]bhgh\bkihevah\Zebwlh]hq_
eh\_dZ\k\hbodhjuklguop_eyodh]^Z`_hgihgyewlhbm\b
^_eqlh_]hmq_gb_ijb\_ehdj_ag_b]jZ[_`mfmkmevfZggZ
kbebxgZ^`_gsbgZfblhihki_rbeihdZylvky<k_wlh–eh`
gu_ hijZ\^Zgby k fhf_glZ aZjh`^_gby ^\b`_gby b \iehlv ^h
kf_jlbB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z\k_\ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZh[yaZl_ev
gh [eZ]hkeh\eyebkv kZfbf r_cohf Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky _]h kZfh
hlkljZg_gbyhl^_e[eb`_ddhgpm`bagblh\ZooZ[blkdbcbk
<k\h_f`mjgZe_©:e-FZgZjªhgqZklh\uklmiZe\boaZsblm[he__lh]h
hg^Z`_hijh\_j]Zeba\_klbyhlhfqlhhgbmkljhbebj_agxg_\bgguofm
kmevfZg\LZbn_dh]^Z`_\ZooZ[blukZfbijbagZebwlhlnZdlFmoZffZ^
JZrb^Jb^ZgZkk\h_cdgb]b©:e-<ZooZ[bxg\Z-ob^`ZaªgZibkZe©>Z
`__kebhgbbkh\_jrbebih^h[gmxhrb[dmlhlhqghlZdmx`_kh\_jrbeb
b emqrb_ ex^b – kZoZ[u m[b\rb_ fmkmevfZg ih ijbdZam OZeb^Z [bg Ze<Zeb^Zª Fu lZdh]h hijZ\^Zgby hl r_coZ FmoZffZ^Z JZrb^Z Jb^u ijb
gylv g_ fh`_f jZa\_ fh`gh kjZ\gb\Zlv m[bckl\h ih hrb[d_ k ij_^gZf_
j_gguf m[bckl\hf" FmoZffZ^ JZrb^ Jb^Z \iZe \ aZ[em`^_gb_ hlghkb
l_evgh\ZooZ[bafZlhevdhihlhfmqlhhq_gvkbevghg_gZ\b^_e]hkm^Zjkl\h
ZrjZnb^h\bgZau\ZybolbjZgZfb`_eZek\_j`_gbyboj_`bfZ<kdhj_hg
magZeqlh\ZooZ[bluaZdexqbebkZg]ebqZgZfb^h]h\hjbh[_sZebhdZaZlv
bf ihfhsv \ aZo\Zl_ :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkljh\Z bf_ggh ihwlhfm gZ k
hgibr_l©Fu^mfZ_fqlhg_aZ\bkbfhklb:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Zfh`
gh[ueh[u^hklbqvb^jm]bfbimlyfbª
123
<qZklghklbh^bgbaZrjZnb^h\Zbf_gghbogZf_klgbd\F_dd_iha\h
ebe Zg]ebqZgbgm Ehj_gkm ihk_lblv Ob^`Za gh _keb [u r_co JZrb^ Jb^Z
agZe \kx ijZ\^m h \ZooZ[blZo lh hg ihgye [u qlh bo ihklmidb [ueb _s_
[he__m`Zkgufb
124
Kf_]hljm^ugZibkZggu_ihke_lh]hdZdhgihagZdhfbekyk\ZooZ[ba
fhf[eb`_bmagZe_]hkmlv\qZklghklbdgb]m©:e-OZrZ\by\ZZe-ob^`Zaª
122
46
lhjbd r_co =mkfZg Zg-G_^`^b ibr_l ©Dh]^Z :eeZo hldjue
_fmwj-Jby^dh]^ZBkeZfjZkijhkljZgbeky\j_]bhg_dh]^Z^h
jh]bklZeb[_ahiZkgufbr_cohlhr_ehl^_eb^h\_jbejmdh
\h^kl\h =Z[^me]Zabam ij_^hklZ\b\ _fm b fmkmevfZg b bo dZa
gm Hg klZe m^_eylv[hevr__\gbfZgb_[h]hkem`_gbxbkZfh
h[jZah\Zgbx Gh g_kfhljy gZ wlh =Z[^me]Zaba gbdh]^Z g_
ijbgbfZe j_r_gby [_a _]h mqZklby»125 DZd \b^bl_ keh\Z
\ZooZ[blh\ kZfb k\b^_l_evkl\mxl h[ bo ^_ygbyo LZd`_ h[jZ
lbl_\gbfZgb__s_gZh^bgnZdlhgibr_lh\aylbbwj-Jby^Zb
k\yau\Z_l k wlbf jZkijhkljZg_gb_ BkeZfZ Ba\_klgh qlh \ lh
\j_fy F_ddZ b F_^bgZ _s_ g_ ijbgZ^e_`Zeb \ZooZ[blZf ih
emqZ_lkyqlhlh]^Z^hgboBkeZf_s_g_^hr_eDZ`^ucagZ_l
qlh ihlhfdb FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ghkyl lblme ©:e
Zr-r_coª©K_fvyr_coZªbhgb\iehlv^hgZrbo^g_chklZ
xlkyb^_cgufb\^hogh\bl_eyfb\ZooZ[blkdh]h^\b`_gby126.
GZ wlhf fu aZ\_jrZ_f baeh`_gb_ [bh]jZnbb r_coZ
FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z b h[jZsZ_fky d dhjgyf _]h
b^_heh]bb dhlhjZy [ueZ aZeh`_gZ B[g L_cfb_c b B[g ZeDZcbfhf
B[gL_cfbyZe-OZjZgb
?]h ihegh_ bfy – r_co :ofZ^ [bg =Z[^meoZebf [bg
L_cfbyHgijboh^blky\gmdhfba\_klghfmoZg[ZeblkdhfmnZ
dbomZe-FZ^`^m[bgL_cfbbHjh^beky\]]\OZ
jZg_ gZ hkljh\_ B[g =Zfj jZkiheh`_gghf f_`^m Lb]jhf b
?\njZlhf127 \ ^h\hevgh h[jZah\Zgghc k_fv_ < ] ]
_]h hl_p hiZkZykv fhg]hevkdh]h gZr_kl\by i_j_k_ey_lky \
>ZfZkd
?s_\fheh^hklbB[gL_cfbyhlebqZekyij_djZkghciZ
fylvxbkfure_ghklvxaZqlh[ueijbagZgfgh]bfbmq_gufb
:e-OZnba B[g OZ^`Zj hibku\Zy [bh]jZnbx wlh]h q_eh\_dZ
ibr_l ©Hg \hkoh^be gZfbg[ZjbgZqbgZe]h\hjblvdZdba\_
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
Wlh _s_ h^gh k\b^_l_evkl\h aZ[em`^_gby ihke_^h\Zl_e_c wlh]h ^\b`_
gbyJZa\_dh]^Z-eb[h\BkeZf_agZgb_i_j_^Z\ZehkvihgZke_^kl\m"
127
<b^bfhbf__lky\\b^mF_`^mj_qv_–ii
125
126
47
klg_crb_fmnZkkbjuijb\h^y^Zggu_badgb]ihnbdomoZ^b
km kkueZykv gZ DhjZg kmggm b yaudh\u_ gZmdb ;ueh lZdh_
hsms_gb_ qlh hg qblZ_l wlh \k_ ijyfh ba dgb]b <kdhj_ hg
klZehq_gvihimeyj_ggh\blh]_wlhijb\_ehebrvdkZfhex
[h\ZgbxbkZfh^h\hevkl\mHgih^mfZeqlhij_\ahr_e\k_ob
klZe g_ aZ^mfu\Zykv hl\_qZlv gZ aZf_qZgby b djmiguo b f_e
dbo mq_guo M dZ`^h]h fmkmevfZgkdh]h mq_gh]h hg gZr_e
hrb[dm[he__lh]hhgaZy\beqlhkZf=mfZj\^\Z^pZlbk_fb
kemqZyoijhlb\hj_qbeDhjZgm«128»
Ih kmlb ^_eZ B[g L_cfbx fh`gh gZa\Zlv hkgh\hih
eh`gbdhf oZrZ\bafZ BfZf Zk-Km[db gZibkZe h g_f ke_^mx
sb_kljhdb©Wlbex^biulZxlkyaZihegblvk\hximklhlmZeoZrm hgb [ukljh jZkijhkljZgyxlky gZ \hklhd_ b gZ aZiZ^_
Hgb ml\_j`^Zxl qlh m kh[ulbc g_l gZqZeZ hgh g_ bf__l hl
ghr_gbyd:eeZomª129.
Fgh]b_ ba mq_guo [u\rbo kh\j_f_ggbdZfb B[g L_c
fbbhl\_jgmebkvhlg_]hKj_^bgbo[uebZl-LZ^`Ze-NZaZjb
ba\_klguc dZd Ze-NZjdZo B[g Ze-;mjoZg Ze->`ZeZe ZeNZa\bgbZe-DZfZeZa-AZfeZdZgbFmoZffZ^[bgZe-OZjbjbZe:gkZjbZe-=ZeZZe-Dmgm\bb^jm]b_B[gL_cfbyg_ijbgbfZe
bogZklZ\e_gbyZ\k_[hevr_b[hevr_jZa`b]Zekfmlm
OZ^bkh\_^ Ze-oZnba Ze-nZdbo <Zebm^^bg Ze-=bjZdb \
k\h_cdgb]_©:e-:^`\b[ZZe-fZj^uy]ZeyZe-ZkbeZZe-fZddbyª
ibr_lh[B[gLZcfbbke_^mxs__©Mg_]h[hevr_agZgbcq_f
jZkkm^dZª ©Hg [he__ q_f \ r_klb^_kylb kemqZyo \uklmibe
ijhlb\_^bgh]eZkgh]hfg_gbymq_guob^`fZ]ªFgh]b_ijh
klu_ ex^b h[fZgm\rbkv ihke_^h\Zeb aZ wlbf q_eh\_dhf \
k\yab k wlbf fgh]b_ mq_gu_ ba qbkeZ _]h kh\j_f_ggbdh\ ih
ki_rbebgZibkZlvhijh\_j`_gb_bjZkdjulvl_[b^]Zdhlhju_
hgkh\_jrZe<qZklghklbbfZfZe-oZnbaLZdbx^^bg=Zeb[bg
=Z[^medZnb Zk-Km[db \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:^->mjjZlm Ze-fm^uZª
mdZaZe ©B[g L_cfby \uklmibe k gh\h\\_^_gbyfb \ h[eZklb
B[gOZ^`Zj©:^->mjZjZe-dZfbgZª
:k-Km[db©LZ[ZdZlZr-rZnb]byZe-dm[jZªZk-KZn^bmf]
]©:e-<Znb[bZe-\Znbylª
128
129
48
Zdu^u b gZjmrbe h[s_ijbgylu_ ghjfu b dZghgu BkeZfZ
<gZqZe_ hg iulZeky ihdZaZlv qlh ke_^m_l aZ DhjZghf b kmg
ghc ijbau\Z_l d bklbg_ h^gZdh ihlhf hg gZqZe bafureylv
jZaebqgu_[b^]Zdhlhju_[ueb\k_m`Zkg__bm`Zkg__HggZ
jmrbe b^`fZ] b aZy\be h l_e_kghklb :eeZoZ h lhf qlh Hg
gm`^Z_lky \ K\hbo `_ qZklyo b qlh k Gbf kh \j_f_g_f lh`_
ijhbkoh^yl baf_g_gbyǻ >Ze__ hg i_j_qbkey_l hklZevgu_ aZ
[em`^_gbyB[gL_cfbb\qbkehdhlhjuo\oh^blfg_gb_h[ba
\_qghklbfbjZ<k\hboljm^ZoaZ[em`^_gbyB[gL_cfbbi_j_
qbkeyxl Ze-oZnba :[m KZ]b^ Ze-=ZeZtb r_co Ze-oZnba Ze=bjZdb bklhjbd Ze-oZnba RZfkm^^bg [bg Lmemg b ^jm]b_
ke_^myboijbf_jmGb`_fulh`_j_rbebboi_j_qbkeblv
<hijhkuihdhlhjufB[gL_cfby
\uklmibeijhlb\h[s_]hfg_gbyfmkmevfZg
Bgh]^Z B[g L_cfby ijhlb\hj_qbe b^`fZ]m Z bgh]^Z
fg_gbxijbgylhfmfZaoZ[hfGZijbf_jhgaZy\beqlhdeyl\Z
jZa\h^hf g_ ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc jZa\h^ Z kh\_jrb\rbc __
^he`_g lhevdh bkdmiblv k\hx g_\_jgmx deyl\m GZ kZfhf `_
^_e_gbh^bgbafmkmevfZgkdbomq_guo\wlhf\hijhk_gbdh]^Z
g_ \ukdZau\Ze fg_gby h[ bkdmie_gbb LZd`_ hg aZy\be qlh
jZa\h^ ^Zgguc \ khklhygbb f_gkljmZpbc beb ihke_ iheh\h]h
ZdlZ g_ ^_ckl\bl_e_g130 Hg ^Ze jZaj_r_gb_ kh\_jrZlv lZ\Zn
\h\j_fyf_gkljmZpbc<g_dhlhjuobak\hboljm^h\hgaZy\ey
_lqlh:eeZoihk\hbfjZaf_jZfjZ\_gLjhgmg_[hevr_bg_
f_gvr_ g_]h<^jm]bodgb]ZohgaZy\ey_lqlhagZgb_:eeZoZ
h]jZgbq_gh b g_ fh`_l jZkijhkljZgylvky gZ [_kdhg_qgh_ Z
bf_ggh gZ [eZ]h^_gkl\b_ h[blZl_e_c JZy Hg `_ aZy\be qlh
ijhjhdb g_ [uebaZkljZoh\Zguhl[hevrbo]j_oh\bqlhgZdZ
aZgb_\:^mg_[m^_l\_qgufLZd`_hgml\_j`^Zeqlhl_dklu
Lhju b ?\Zg]_eby g_ [ueb bkdZ`_gu Z [ueb bkdZ`_gu ebrv
bodhff_glZjbbYijhrmijhs_gbym:eeZoZg_lhevdhaZwlb
dgb]bghbm[_`^_gbywlh]hq_eh\_dZ
<^mfZcl_kv kdhevdh ij_ex[h^_ygbc kh\_jrZxl kZeZnblu ihevamykv
_]hn_l\Zfb^ZkhojZgblgZk:eeZohlwlh]h
130
49
Ih^h[gu_fg_gbyhq_gvm^b\eyxlihkdhevdmy\ghijh
lb\hj_qZl bklbg_ Ijb\_^_f \k_]h ^\Z g_[hevrbo ijbf_jZ
i_j\uc[m^_lk\yaZgklZ\Znhf\h\j_fyf_gkljmZpbbZ\lhjhc
kbkdZ`_gbyfbLhjub?\Zg]_ebyDZdfh`ghke_^h\ZlvaZmq_
gufdhlhjucy\ghijhlb\hj_qblDhjZgmb\qZklghklbkeh\Zf
:eeZoZ ©=hj_ l_f dhlhju_ i_j_ibku\Zxl IbkZgb_ >bkdZ
`Zy@kh[kl\_ggufbjmdZfbZihlhfml\_j`^ZxlWlhhl
:eeZoZª"Ihke_lh]hdZd[uebgbkihkeZguwlb[h`_kl
\_ggu_ keh\Z ijboh^bl g_dbc aZ[em^rbc B[g L_cfby b aZy\
ey_l ©G_l LhjZ b ?\Zg]_eb_ g_ [ueb bkdZ`_guª DZd fh`gh
ke_^h\ZlvaZq_eh\_dhfdhlhjucy\ghijhlb\hj_qblkmgg_131b
b^`fZ]m"<k_mq_gu__^bgh]eZkgu\lhfqlh`_gsbgZ\h\j_
fy oZ^`Z g_ lhevdh g_ h[yaZgZ gh b g_ ^he`gZ kh\_jrZlv lZ
\Zn ihkdhevdm lZ\Zn – wlh fhebl\Z DZd ihke_ wlh]h fh`gh
ml\_j`^Zlvqlh`_gsbg_\h\j_fyf_gkljmZpbbjZaj_r_ghkh
\_jrZlvlZ\Zn"
Ba\_klgZ bklhjby h lhf dZd kemrZl_eb ^Z`_ h^gZ`^u
ih[beb B[g L_cfbx ijyfh \ f_q_lb :[m Ze-OZkZg =Zeb Z^>bfZrdb i_j_^Z_l hl k\h_]h hlpZ ©Fu kb^_eb \ f_q_lb b
kemrZebB[gL_cfbxhgqblZeijhih\_^vDh]^Zhg^hr_e^h
Zylh\hLjhg_lhkdZaZe©:eeZojZaf_klbekygZLjhg_lZd`_
:j-JZ[b][bgOZ[b[ijb\h^blkhhl\_lkl\mxsbcoZ^bk\lKgh
f_j]eZ\Z©Qlh^_eZlv`_gsbg_\khklhygbbf_gkljmZpbb\h\j_fyoZ
^`Zª m Ze-;moZjb \ ]eZ\_ ©F_gkljmZpbbª m FmkebfZ ijb\h^blky
oZ^bkghf_j]^_jZkkdZau\Z_lkyhoZ^`_=Zcrb©Dh]^Zyijb[ueZ\
F_ddm m f_gy gZqZebkv f_kyqgu_ y g_ kfh]eZ k^_eZlv lZ\Zn b g_ kfh]eZ
[_]Zlv f_`^m KZnhc b FZj\hc Dh]^Z y ih`Zeh\ZeZkv ijhjhdm k]k hg
kdZaZe ©IhdZ g_ aZ\_jrZlky f_kyqgu_ ^_eZc \k_ qlh ^_eZxl hklZevgu_
iZehfgbdbdjhf_lZ\ZnZªmZe-;moZjbijb\_^_gjb\Zyl©@_gsbgZmdh
lhjhc[uebf_kyqgu_^he`gZ\hkihegblv\k_djhf_lZ\ZnZ=ZlZi_j_^Z_l
hl>`Z[bjZdh]^Zm=Zcrb\h\j_fyoZ^`ZgZqbgZebkvf_kyqgu_hgZ^_eZ
eZ\k_qlhiheh`_ghgh\ha^_j`b\ZeZkvhllZ\ZnZbfhebl\uǻIh^h[gu_
jb\Zylu _klv \ k[hjgbdZo :ofZ^Z Zl-Lbjfbab Zg-GZkZb :[m >Zm^Z B[g
FZ^`bb^jm]booZ^bkh\_^h\
131
50
dZd y gZ wlhf klme_ª - lh]^Z \k_ ex^b gZ[jhkbebkv gZ g_]h
klZsbebkhklmeZbgZqZeb[blvdmeZdZfbbh[m\vx«132»
BfZfZa-AZoZ[bdh]^Z-lhlh`_[ueihjZ`_gmfhfbagZ
gbyfbB[gL_cfbbb\fheh^hklb^Z`_[ue_]hmq_gbdhfLh]
^Z-lh hg b gZibkZe k\hx i_qZevgh ba\_klgmx dgb]m ©:e=mexª Dh]^Z `_ hg magZe bklbgm b m[_^beky \ \ukhdhf_jbb
B[gL_cfbblh\k\h_cdgb]_©;ZygaZ]eZe-]bef\ZZl-lZeZ[ª
gZibkZe©<dhg_qghfblh]_\k_`bl_eb?]bilZbRZfZklZeb
ij_abjZlv_]hg_gZ\b^_lvh[\bgylv\he`bbg_\_jbbDlZdh
fm i_qZevghfm blh]m _]h ijb\_eb \ukhdhf_jb_ klj_fe_gb_ d
\eZklbls_keZ\b_bg_gZ\bklvd\_ebdbfmq_guf>ZkhojZgbl
gZk:eeZohlwlh]hª133.
Wlmbklhjbxijb\h^blB[g;ZllmlZgZkk\hboaZibkhdiml_r_kl\_g
gbdZKh\j_f_ggu_oZrZ\bluiulZxlkyhijh\_j]gmlvih^h[gu_jb\Zylub
gZau\Zxlbo[Zllmlkdhceh`vxghwlh_s_jZak\b^_l_evkl\m_l\ihevambo
g_\_`_kl\Z <_^v ba\_klgh qlh B[g L_cfby [ue ihkZ`_g \ lxjvfm : aZ
qlh"Dhg_qgh`_aZih^h[gu_\ukdZau\ZgbyGhnZdlZ_]haZdexq_gbyhgb
m`_hljbpZlvg_kfh]mlJZa\_hgbkfh]mlhljbpZlvqlhB[gL_cfby\ukdZ
au\Ze fukeb h lhf qlh :eeZo i_j_^\b]Z_lky kimkdZ_lky bf__l gZijZ\e_
gb_bf_klhkb^blgZLjhg_bij"Ih^h[gu_b^_bB[gLZcfbbmihfygmlu
\ lZdbo dgb]Zo dZd ©FbgoZ^` Zk-kmggZª b ©Ze-Fm\ZnZdZª
©FZ^`fm]Ze-nZlZ\Zªdhff_glZjbcdoZ^bkmhgbkoh`^_gbb
k;he__lh]hB[gL_cfbyijb^_j`b\Zekyl_o`_m[_`^_gbcqlhbnZ
jZhg©Nbj]Zmgªkh\j_f_ggbdFmku]kbml\_j`^Zeqlh:eeZo\g_[_:
dZd ba\_klgh hg [ue i_j\uf dlh kdZaZe ©H OZfZg <ha^\b]gb ^ey f_gy
[Zrgx;ulvfh`_lyih^gbfmkv^himl_c-iml_cdg_[_kZf-b\hag_kmkv
d [h]m Fmkuª G_m`_eb ihke_ wlh]h \ZooZ[blu hkf_eylky kdZaZlv
qlhnZjZhg[uegZbklbgghfimlbbm\_jh\Ze\fbkkbxFmku]k"Bdh
g_qgh`_[_akhfg_gbyyjqZcrbfijbf_jhf[h`_kl\_ggh]h\hkk_^ZgbygZ
Ljhg_fh`_l[ulvlhevdh\hkk_^Zgb_B[gL_cfbb?keb[u\ZooZ[blu\gb
fZl_evgh qblZeb Zylu DhjZgZ lh agZeb [u qlh Ljhg h[t_fe_l g_[_kZ b
a_fex\DhjZg_kdZaZgh©?]hljhgh[t_fe_lg_[_kZba_fexªOh
lbfihykgblvqlhklhqdbaj_gbyZjZ[kdh]hkbglZdkbkZ©Ljhgª–wlhnZ]be
bkihegbl_ev^_ckl\by©g_[_kZª–wlhfZn]melhlgZdh]hh[jZs_gh^_c
kl\b_Z©a_feyª-wlhfZ]lmnijb\yaZgguc\hlghr_gbb©g_[_kªIhwlh
fm g_ ki_rbl_ h[\bgylv \h e`b iml_r_kl\_ggbdZ B[g ;Zllmlm l_f [he__
qlh lhqgh lZdhc `_ jb\Zyl ijb\h^bl Ze-oZnba B[g OZ^`ZjZe-=ZkdZeygb\
dgb]_©:^->mjZjZe-dZfbgZª1/154.
133
BfZfZa-AZoZ[bhldZaZekyhll_om[_`^_gbcdhlhju_ijbh[j_e[m^mqb
mq_gbdhf B[g L_cfbb H[ wlhf hg ibr_l \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©Kbyj Z]eyf Zg132
51
B[g L_cfby jZ^b lh]h qlh[u ^hdZaZlv ijZ\hlm k\h_]h
mq_gbyaZqZklmxbkihevah\Ze^h\hevghkljZggu_f_lh^u
: <u^mfu\Zgb_ g_kms_kl\mxsbo b^`fZ]h\ kZeZnh\
ydh[uih^l\_j`^Zxsbo_]hb^_bLZdhc^h\h^qZklhbkihevam
_lky \ _]h dgb]Zo GZijbf_j dhff_glbjmy Zylu h [h`_kl\_g
guoZljb[mlZohgml\_j`^Z_l©Kj_^bkih^\b`gbdh\IjhjhdZ
k]k gbdh]^Z g_ [ueh jZagh]eZkbc ih ih\h^m h[tykg_gby
kfukeZ dhjZgbq_kdbo Zylh\ jZkkdZau\Zxsbo h [h`_kl\_gguo
Zljb[mlZo Y hagZdhfbeky k [hevrbf qbkehf ljZdlh\hd kih
^\b`gbdh\boZ^bkh\ijhq_ehdhehkhlgbjZaebqguolZnkbjh\
bgb]^_g_h[gZjm`beqlhdlh-eb[hbagbodhff_glbjh\ZeZy
lu h [h`_kl\_gguo Zljb[mlZo \ dZdhf-eb[h ^jm]hf agZq_gbb
djhf_[md\Zevgh]hª134<a]eygbl_dZdmihjghwlhlq_eh\_diu
lZ_lky \gmrblv lh q_]h gZ kZfhf ^_e_ g_l Ihkfhljbf qlh
ibr_l Zl-LZ[Zjb lZnkbj dhlhjh]h B[g L_cfby hq_gv kbevgh
o\Zebl b ]h\hjbl qlh hg g_ kh^_j`bl [b^]Z ©Dhff_glZlhju
jZahrebkv \h fg_gbyo ih wlhfm \hijhkm G_dhlhju_ ba gbo
kdZaZeb qlh ih^ ©Ljhghfª bf__lky \ \b^m [h`_kl\_ggh_ agZ
gb_ªIjbwlhfZl-LZ[ZjbkkueZ_lkygZKZ]b^Z[bg>`m[ZcjZ
i_j_^Z\r_]hwlhfg_gb_hlB[g=Z[[ZkZIjbq_flZdbofg_gbc
\u fh`_l_ \klj_lblv h]jhfgh_ fgh`_kl\h gZijbf_j \ dgb]_
©:e-:kfZ\ZZk-kunZlªbfZfZZe-;ZcoZdb135.
Lhqgh lZdhc `_ b^`fZ] hg \u^mfZe iulZykv ^hdZaZlv
qlh :eeZo aZgbfZ_l \ukhdh_ iheh`_gb_ nbabq_kdb b qlh f_k
lhgZoh`^_gb_:eeZoZbf__lk\hb]jZgbpuihwlhfmih\h^mhg
gm[ZeyªWlZdgb]Z[ueZgZibkZgZbfm`_\dhgp_`bagb\g_chghldZau
\Z_lkyhl[md\Zevgh]hihgbfZgbyDhjZgZbijb[_]Z_ld_]hljZdlh\d_lZ\be
blZn\b^baZy\ey_lhlhfqlhm:eeZoZg_lgbdZdbo]jZgbpH[wlhfjZk
kdZau\Z_lB[gOb[[Zg–hibku\Zy[bh]jZnbxZa-AZoZ[bBa\_kl
ghqlhhg\k\h_fgZklZ\e_gbb©:g-GZkuoZZa-aZoZ[byªh[jZlbekybdk\h
_fmmqbl_exB[gL_cfbbkijbau\hfihdZylvky<gZqZe_k\h_]himlbbfZf
Za-AZoZ[bihr_eg_\_jgufiml_fihwlhfmbamqZy_]hdgb]bke_^m_l[ulv
hq_gv\gbfZl_evgufihkdhevdm\dhgp_`bagbhgihdZyekybhldZaZekyhl
\k_og_\_jguom[_`^_gbc
134
B[gL_cfby©LZnkbjkmjZlZg-GmjªK– 179.
135
;he__ ih^jh[gh h[ wlhf \u fh`_l_ ijhq_klv \ dgb]_ FmoZffZ^Z ZeDZkbjb©:k-KZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-bfZfbyªK– 476.
52
\dgb]_©:e-OZfZ\byZe-dm[jZª136ibr_l©«gb\DhjZg_gb\
oZ^bkZo gb \ \ukdZau\Zgbyo kZoZ[h\ lZ[b]bgh\ mq_guo g_l
fg_gbchlhfqlh:eeZog_gZoh^blky\g_[_ªwlhy\gZyeh`v
bB[gL_cfbyij_djZkghagZeh[wlhfbmq_gu_hijh\_j]eb_]h
b^_b:eeZoihwlhfmih\h^m\DhjZg_]h\hjbl©Bdm^Z[u\u
gbih\_jgmebkvh[jZlbl_kvd:eeZomª\oZ^bk_Ijhjhd
k]k kdZaZe ©?keb \u fhebl_kv lh g_ iexcl_ i_j_^ kh[hc
ihbklbg_ \h \j_fy fhebl\u i_j_^ \Zfb :eeZoª137 \ ^jm]hf
oZ^bk_ kdZaZgh ©JZ[ gZb[he__ [ebahd d :eeZom \h \j_fy a_f
gh]hihdehgZª138:eeZog_fh`_l[ulvh]jZgbq_gijhkljZgkl
\hf l_f [he__ g_[_kZfb ih wlhfm ih\h^m fh`gh ijb\_klb
hq_gvfgh]h\ukdZau\Zgbckih^\b`gbdh\blZ[b]bgh\h^gZdh
^ZggZy dgb]Z bf__l g_fgh]h ^jm]mx l_fZlbdm Qlh[u dhfi_g
kbjh\Zlv wlhl g_^hklZlhd fu ohlbf ijb\_klb \ukdZau\Zgb_
RboZ[m^^bgZ [bg >`Zo[ZeZ Ze-OZeZ[b Zr-RZnb]b139 dhlh
juc [ue kh\j_f_ggbdhf B[g L_cfbb ©Kj_^b wlbo ex^_c
ik_\^hkZeZnblh\ _klv l_ dlh de_\_s_l gZ ZgkZjh\ b fmoZ^
`bjh\ ijbibku\Zy bf jZaebqgu_ g_kms_kl\mxsb_ \ukdZau
\ZgbyWlbfex^yfg_m^Zklky^hdZaZlvk\hxijZ\^b\hklv^Z
`__kebhgbihljZlylgZwlh^_eh\k_[h]Zlkl\hbf_xs__kygZ
a_fe_ Wlb ex^b `_eZxl m^h\e_l\hjblv k\hb \eZklgu_ Zf[b
pbb\DhjZg_kdZaZgh©Blum\b^brvqlh_klvb^jm]b_dh
lhju_ohlyl[ulv\_jgufbb\Zfbk\h_fmgZjh^mªWlb
ex^b ijb[_]Zxl d ebp_f_jbx b ik_\^hZkd_lbafm \ blh]_ bo
mq_gb_ij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hcihahehq_ggucgZ\habeb\uqbs_g
gh_ hloh`__ f_klh Hgb ojZgyl k\h_ a_jgurdh \ gZ^_`^_ gZ
lhqlhhghij_\jZlblky\`_fqm`bgmª140.
; H[ty\e_gb_ g_^hklh\_jgufb \k_o oZ^bkh\ ijhlb\h
j_qZsbo mq_gbx B[g L_cfby b _]h ihke_^h\Zl_eb h[ty\eyxl
H^bggZ^pZluc ljZdlZl ba dgb]b ©:j-JZkZbe Ze-dm[jZª B[g L_cfby K
429 – 432.
137
I_j_^ZebZe-;moZjbFmkebf:[m>Zm^bB[gFZ^`Z
138
I_j_^ZebFmkebfZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^b:ofZ^
139
Mf\]]
140
B[g>`Zo[Ze©:e-OZdZbdZe-^`ZebynbZj-jZ^^]ZeyB[gL_cfbynbfZ
ZmjZ^ZomnbZe-nZlZ\ZZe-oZfZ\byªK
136
53
g_^hklh\_jgufb\k_oZ^bkuijhlb\hj_qZsb_bomq_gbxbijb
wlhf ^Z`_ g_ mljm`^Zxl k_[y bo ZgZebahf Ih bo fg_gbx g_
hgb ^he`gu ke_^h\Zlv oZ^bkZf Z oZ^bku ^he`gu ijb^_j`b
\Zlvkybofg_gbyBf_gghihwlhfmbfZfZa-AZoZ[bh[jZsZykv
dB[gL_cfbbkdZaZe©Hll_[yg_kiZkebkv^Z`_oZ^bkuh[hbo
^hklh\_jg_crbok[hjgbdh\^Z`_kj_^bgbolugZr_ekeZ[u_
qZklvbagboluhl\_j]ZqZklvljZdlm_rvih-k\h_fmª141.
< ;jZgv \ Z^j_k k\hbo hiihg_glh\ B[g L_cfby b _]h
ihke_^h\Zl_ebg_]gmrZebkvgbq_fbgh]^Z^Z`_ihdZdhc-eb[h
imklydh\hc ijbqbg_ h[ty\eyeb lh]h beb bgh]h fmkmevfZgbgZ
yauqgbdhf142 Hg kZf jZkkdZau\Z_l h k\h_f hlghr_gbb d m\Z
`Z_fufmq_guf©YkdZaZe_fm©KkZfh]hgZqZeZfmkmevfZg_
jZahrebkv ih \hijhkm jZkimlgbdh\ª h^bg ba klZjp_\ kdZaZe
©G_l wlh g_\_jgh i_j\uf jZagh]eZkb_f [ueh jZagh]eZkb_ \
dZeZf_ª>Ze__B[gL_cfbyijh^he`Z_l©MkeurZ\wlbkeh\Z
yhq_gvjZkk_j^bekybkdZaZe³Luhrb[kywlheh`vbhgZijh
lb\hj_qblb^`fZ]mMl_[yg_lgb\hkiblZgbygbkl_i_gblu
g_kh[ex^Z_rvijZ\beijbebqbyijbjZa]h\hj_khfghcbl\hb
hl\_luhrb[hqgu´ª143<hllZdbfh[jZahfk_[y\_^_loZrZ\bl
kdbcbfZfhgh[\bgy_l\he`bbg_\hkiblZgghklbklZjbdZih
kf_\r_]hkihjblvkgbf<dgb]_©:e-NZdboZe-fmoZaab[B[g
L_cfbyªkjZkkdZau\Z_lkyhlhfdZdh^gZ`^uB[gL_c
fby^Zen_l\mZ^jm]hcnZdbo^Zen_l\mijhlb\hj_qZsmx_]h
n_l\_magZ\h[wlhfB[gL_cfbykdZaZe_fm©LZdh_fh]kdZ
aZlv lhevdh hk_e klhysbc \ k\h_f klhce_ª KZfu_ om^rb_ ba
\ujZ`_gbc hg \u[bjZe ^ey bfZfZ Ze-NZojZ Zj-JZab b bfZfZ
Ze-=ZaZeb gZau\Ze bo bg^bckdbfb b ]j_q_kdbfb puieylZfb
Dh]^Z`_\kihfbgZebB[gZe-FmlZooZjZZe-OZeeblhhgh[au
\Ze _]h B[g Ze-FmgZ^`Zkhf144 kf ©:e-<Znb [b Ze-\Znbylª
©:g-GZkuoZ Za-aZoZ[byª Z lZd`_ m Ze-DZmkZjb \ ©LZdfbeyl Zk-kZcn ZkkZdueªK
142
LZdbx^^bgZe-Omkgb©>Zn]rm[ZofZgrZ[[ZoZ\ZlZfZjjZ^ZªK
143
:e-OZnba B[g =Z[^meoZ^b ©:e-=mdm^ Z^-^mjjby nb fZgZdb[ B[g L_c
fbyª
144
Bf__lky \ \b^m b]jZ keh\ ©B[g Ze-FmlZooZjª ©Kug hqbs_ggh]hª
©B[gZe-FmgZ^`Zkª©>blyhkd\_jg_ggh]hª–ii
141
54
Zk-KZ^^b-DZd\b^bl_bfZfh^bgbahkgh\hiheh`gb
dh\ oZrZ\bafZ [ue kd\_jghkeh\hf gZ yaud_ dhlhjh]h ihklh
yggh[uebebrvjm]Zl_evkl\ZbijhdeylbylhqghlZdbf`_im
l_fb^mlb_]hihke_^h\Zl_eb
>h[Z\eyy d \ur_kdZaZgghfm ohq_lky h[jZlblv \gbfZ
gb_qblZl_eybgZlhlnZdlqlhB[gL_cfbxg_jZaijbau\Zeb
d ihdZygbx gh hg dZ`^uc jZa gZjmrZe k\hb h[_sZgby ?]h
kZ`Zeb\lxjvfmaZij_lbebba^Z\Zlvn_l\u:\ihke_^gbcjZa
hg [ue ihkZ`_g \ lxjvfm gZ hkgh\Zgbb n_l\u kjZam q_luj_o
dZab_\145h^bgbamq_gbdh\B[gL_cfbbB[gRZdbjZe-Dmlm[b
\©=mxgZl-lZ\ZjboªjZkkdZau\Z_lhlhfqlhB[gL_cfbxh[t
y\bebaZ[em^rbfb\ug_kebj_r_gb_hg_h[oh^bfhklbij_^h
kl_j_]Zlv ex^_c hl _]h mq_gby Dh]^Z B[g L_cfby gZqZe ijh
ih\_^h\Zlv k\hb eh`gu_ b^_b hlghkbl_evgh [h`_kl\_gghc
kmsghklb b Zljb[mlh\ B[g DZeZmg ba^Ze khhl\_lkl\mxs__
jZkihjy`_gb_ ih^dj_ie_ggh_ ]hkm^Zjkl\_gghc i_qZlvx <
wlhfjZkihjy`_gbb]h\hjbehkv©<hbfy:eeZoZFbehklb\h]h
Fbehk_j^gh]h G_l ?fm ih^h[by dZd kdZaZgh \ DhjZg_: ©G_l
gbq_]hih^h[gh]h?fmHgkeurZsbc\b^ysbcªO\ZeZ:eeZom
gZklZ\b\r_fm gZk gZ imlv DhjZgZ b kmggu ba[Z\b\r_fm hl
khfg_gbcYk\b^_l_evkl\mxqlhg_l[h`_kl\Zdjhf_:eeZoZ
h^bgHgg_lmg_]hkhlh\ZjbsZyhljbpZxgZebqb_m:eeZoZ
g_^hklZldh\ b ?]h h]jZgbq_gghklv ijhkljZgkl\hf \_^v \ Dh
jZg_ kdZaZgh ©Hg k \Zfb ]^_ [u \u gb [uebª Y k\b^_l_evkl
\mx qlh gZr ]hkih^bg FmoZffZ^ – ?]h jZ[ b ihkeZggbd ba
[jZ\rbcbmdZaZ\rbcimlvkiZk_gby^eyl_odlhkihkh[_gjZa
fureylvh[h`_kl\_gguoagZf_gbyob\ha^_j`b\Z_lkyhlfuk
e_c hlghkbl_evgh [h`_kl\_gghc kmsghklb Fbj b [eZ]hkeh\_
gb__fmZlZd`_\k_f_]hkih^\b`gbdZf\g_krbfk\hc\deZ^\
jZkijhkljZg_gb_\_jub[hjv[mkeh`vxb[b^]Z>Ze__<hbk
lbgm ijZ\bevgZy Zdu^Z hkgh\u BkeZfZ b \_ju aZeh`_ggu_
fZaoZ[Zfb y\eyxlky _^bgkl\_ggh \_jguf iml_f \_^msbf d
kiZk_gbx Z dlh hldehgy_lky hl mihfygmlh]h imlb lhl aZkem
RZnb]blkdbcfZebdblkdbcoZgZnblkdbcboZg[Zeblkdbcqlh[umagZlv
bobf_gZkfjZa^_e©Mq_gu_-kmggbluhl\_qZxlB[gL_cfbbª
145
55
`b\Z_l fmqbl_evgh]h gZdZaZgby Bf_ggh ihwlhfm fu h[yaZgu
bkihegylvwlbaZdhgubaZ[hlblvkyhkhojZgghklbZdu^ubah
ebjmy l_o dlh hl^_ey_lky hl gZk < ihke_^gb_ ]h^u B[g L_c
fby ]h\hjbl b ibr_l h [h`_kl\_gguo Zljb[mlZo b kmsghklb
h^gZdh\k\hboljm^Zohgbaeh`bef_jadb_b^_bhl\_j]gmlu_
fmkmevfZgkdbf [h]hkeh\b_f Hg aZ]h\hjbe h lhf h q_f fhe
qZeb^Z`_kih^\b`gbdbblZ[b]bguHg\uklmibeijhlb\_^b
gh]eZkgh]h fg_gby fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo ?]h eh`gu_ b^_b
jZkijhkljZgbebkv ih fmkmevfZgkdbf kljZgZf b \\_eb \ aZ
[em`^_gb_ijhkluofmkmevfZg?]hmq_gb_ijhlb\hj_qblimlb
fmkmevfZgkdbonZdboh\Zk\hbfn_l\Zfhg^Z_lgZa\Zgbyhl
kmlkl\mxsb_\[h`_kl\_gghfibkZgbb…146» -blZd^Ze__
<b^bfh kZeZnblu g_ h[jZsZxl \gbfZgby gZ lhl nZdl
qlhB[gL_cfbybaebrg_m]em[beky\dZeZfbnZekZnZbf_ggh
ihwlhfmhg\ukdZaZeb^_bhlhfqlh:eeZog_y\ey_lkykha^Z
l_e_f \k_]h kms_]h Hg ibr_l ©«ihke_ \ur_kdZaZggh]h \u
au\Zxl m^b\e_gb_ n_l\u h g_\_jbb l_o dlh hijh\_j]Z_l nZdl
kms_kl\h\Zgby lhevdh :eeZoZ b gbq_]h djhf_ G_]h«147»
Bf_gghihwlhfmg_m^b\bl_evghqlhB[gL_cfbymf_j\lxjv
f_
B[g L_cfby mf_j amevdZ]^Z ] ] ih
ke_ g_]h _]h ^_eh ijh^he`beb mq_gbdb B[g Ze-DZcbf b B[g
DZkbj
Ihke_ \ur_baeh`_ggh]h m gZk \hagbdZxl \hijhku ih
q_fm `_ \ZooZ[blu klhev kbevgh \ha\_ebqb\Zxl wlh]h q_eh\_
dZ"JZa\_bfg_ba\_klgufhf_glu_]h[bh]jZnbb"JZa\_bfg_
ba\_klgu_]hb^_b"JZa\_hgbg_agZxldZdhlghkbebkvdg_fm
mq_gu_ [u\rb_ _]h kh\j_f_ggbdZfb" JZa\_ ihke_ wlh]h _]h
fh`gh gZau\Zlv r_comebkeZf" <k_ bo mq_gb_ y\ey_lky eh`
gufbqm`^ufBkeZfmg_m`_ebBkeZf\l_q_gb_k_fbkhle_l
kms_kl\h\Ze[_a\_ebdbomq_guo"<hbklbgmm:eeZoZg_lgb
©:e-FZdZeZlZk-kmggbyªK– 36.
Kf ©GZd^ fZjZlb[ Ze-b^`fZ] ]Zey oZfbr fZjZlb[ Ze-b^`fZ]ª k B[g OZaf jZa^_e ©MZdnZlm fZ]Z B[g L_cfbyª ba dgb]b ©:k-KZeZnby –
fZjoZeZ aZfZgby fm[ZjZdZ eZ fZaoZ[ bkeZfbª k ^hdlhj FmoZffZ^
KZ]b^Ze-;mlu
146
147
56
dZdbo g_^hklZldh\ b g_l kbeu b fh]ms_kl\Z gb m dh]h djhf_
dZdm\_ebdh]h:eeZoZ
B[gZe-DZcbfkhqm\kl\mxsbcB[ebkm
OZrZ\blkdb_b^_b\\_eb\aZ[em`^_gb_fgh]boijhkluo
fmkmevfZgIhke_^h\Zl_ebr_comebkeZfZb_]hmq_gbdZRZf
km^^bgZkkueZxlkygZkeh\Zk\hbogZklZ\gbdh\^Z`_qZs_q_f
gZDhjZgboZ^bku<b^bfh^eygboh[Zwlbq_eh\_dZy\eyxlky
`b\ufb ^h\h^Zfb :eeZoZ BlZd fu i_j_oh^bf d ih\_kl\h\Z
gbxh`bagbRZfkm^^bgZ
?]hihegh_bfy–FmoZffZ^[bg:[m;ZdjZa-AZj]bgh
[he__ ba\_kl_g dZd B[g Ze-DZcbf Ze->`Z\ab beb B[g AZnbe
dZdkhh[sZ_lh[wlhfB[gJZ^`Z[Hgjh^beky\]]
Z mf_j \ ] ] Wlhl q_eh\_d \kx `bagv khijh\h`^Ze
k\h_]hmqbl_eyb^Z`_kb^_ekgbf\f_kl_\lxjvf_\iehlv^h
_]h kf_jlb gh ihke_ kf_jlb dZq_kl\h bo ^jm`[u baf_gbehkv
Ijb\h^blkyjb\ZylhlhfdZdB[gL_cfbyi_j_^kf_jlvxm\b
^_ekhghk_[_bk\h_fmq_gbd_B[gZe-DZcbfkijhkbemg_]h
©DZdh_f_klhyaZcfmªB[gL_cfbyhl\_lbe©Hq_gv\ukhdh_
^Z`_\ur_g_dhlhjuoba\_klguomq_guoluihqlbkjZ\gyekyk
gZfbghihdZaZgbfZ_rvkl_i_gvjZ\gmxkl_i_gbB[gOma_c
fuª148.
Fug_kh[bjZ_fkydhff_glbjh\Zlvwlhljb\ZylZebrv
ijbklmiZ_fdjZkkdZamhq_eh\_d_dhlhjuclZd`_dZdb_]hgZ
klZ\gbd [ue ihkZ`_g \ lxjvfm ih j_r_gbx fmkmevfZgkdbo
mq_guo gh kZeZnblu g_kfhljy gZ wlh g_ kl_kgyykv kkueZxlky
gZg_]h
< h^ghc ba k\hbo dgb] Z bf_ggh ©:k-KZ\Z]bd ZefmjkZeZ ]Zey Ze-^`Zofby \Z Ze-fm]Zllueyª B[g Ze-DZcbf ib
r_lhlhfqlh:^g_y\ey_lky\_qgufihkdhevdmwlhijhlb\h
j_qbl ijbgpbim [h`_kl\_gghc fbehklb Hg kqblZ_l qlh \ dh
g_qghfblh]_\k_h[blZl_eb:^Zihdbgmlk\h_h[blZebs_bhg
bkq_ag_l?kebke_^h\Zlv_]heh]bd_lhbB[ebkb:[m>`Zoe
bM[Zc[bgOZeZnbNbj]ZmgbOZfZgbDZjmgihdbgml:^b
FmoZffZ^ Ze-Fmkueb ©FmolZkZj Zk-kZ\Z]bd Ze-fmjZkeZ eb B[g ZeDZcbfZe->`Z\abªK 6.
148
57
hdZ`mlky \ JZx \f_kl_ k ijhjhdZfb ijZ\_^gbdZfb b fmq_gb
dZfb < dZq_kl\_ \klmie_gbydwlhfmnjZ]f_glmhgibr_l©<
`bagbq_eh\_dZijhbkoh^blfgh`_kl\hbkiulZgbch^gZdhhgb
dh]^Z-eb[h aZ\_jrZxlky aZqZklmx q_eh\_d [u\Z_l mgb`_g gh
\ dhg_qghf blh]_ mgb`_gb_ kf_gy_lky ijbagZgb_f AZ^mfZc
l_kvgZb[hevrb_[eZ]ZbgZkeZ`^_gbyihklb]Zxlkylhevdhih
ke_ ly]qZcrbo bkiulZgbc b fmq_gbc Ihwlhfm gZb[hevr_fm
gZkeZ`^_gbx ^he`gh ij_^r_kl\h\Zlv gZb[hevr__ bkiulZ
gb_ª149Fuijbgyeb[u_]hkeh\Z_keb[uj_qvreZh^`boZ^_
\wlhffbj_ghdkh`Ze_gbxhgibr_lhfmdZo:^Z?]heh]b
dZ lZdh\Z _keb ijhr_^rbc gZb[hevr__ bkiulZgb_ ihemqZ_l
gZb[hevrmx gZ]jZ^m lh B[ebk ihemqb\rbc kbevg_cr__ ba
gZdZaZgbc :^Z ^he`_g ihemqblv b \ukhqZcr__ ba gZkeZ`^_
gbcJZyIhke_wlh]hhggZqbgZ_lbkdZlvijbqbgmdhlhjZyfh
`_l\u\_klbba:^Zyauqgbdh\bgZoh^bl<qZklghklbhgmdZ
au\Z_l qlh \ bo k_j^pZo _klv g_[hevrZy qZklbqdZ \_ju \_^v
:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©?keblukijhkbrvmgbo©Dlhkha^Ze
g_[_kZ b a_fexª hgb hl\_lyl :eeZoª Z \ h^ghf ba oZ^bkh\
IjhjhdZ k]k kdZaZgh ©<u\_^bl_ ba :^Z dZ`^h]h \ qv_f
k_j^p__klvohly[ug_[hevrZyqZklbqdZ\_juª150Kh]eZkgh_]h
eh]bd_\blh]_\k_^he`guihdbgmlv:^bihiZklv\JZc>Ze__
hg ibr_l ©:^ [ue jZah``_g yauq_kl\hf b g_kijZ\_^eb\hk
lvxihwlhfmgbqlhg_f_rZ_lijbgpbimfbehklbbkijZ\_^eb
\hklb\u\_klbq_eh\_dZba:^Zihke_lh]hdZdhgihemqbe^h
klhcgh_ gZdZaZgb_ª151. IhemqZ_lky kijZ\_^eb\hklv :eeZoZ fh
`_l \hkkh_^bgblv \ JZx IjhjhdZ k]k b M[Zy [bg OZeZnZ
>Ze__ hg ibr_l ©:^ [ue jZah``_g [h`_kl\_gguf ]g_\hf
lhqgh lZd `_ hg fh`_l [ulv b ihlmr_g lh]^Z dh]^Z ?]h ]g_\
ijhc^_lª152 >Ze__ hg ijh^he`Z_l \ lhf `_ ^mo_ b ijb\h^bl
ZyluDhjZgZdhlhju_gZkZfhf^_e_hijh\_j]Zxl_]hb^_bLZ
dh_hsms_gb_dZd[m^lhhgkhqm\kl\m_lkZlZg_b_]hihke_^h
\Zl_eyfb`_eZ_l\u\_klbboba:^Z\ehgh[h`_kl\_gghcfb
©FmolZkZjZk-kZ\Z]bdªK
LZf`_K
151
LZf`_
152
LZf`_K
149
150
58
ehklb ?]h ^h\h^u ^h\hevgh keZ[u b ]emiu ihkdhevdm g_l gb
_^bgh]hk\ys_ggh]hl_dklZdhlhjucfh][ugZijyfmxboih^
l\_j^blv>eylh]hqlh[u^hdZaZlv_]hb^_bijb\_^_ggufbZy
lZfbke_^m_lhq_gvkbevghihljm^blvkybgZclbohly[uhl^Z
e_ggmxljZdlh\dmghijbwlhfke_^m_lmqblu\ZlvqlhhgkZf
aZij_sZeljZdlh\ZlvZyluboZ^bkubijbau\ZeihgbfZlvbo\
[md\Zevghf kfuke_ GZ kZfhf ^_e_ Zylu DhjZgZ hijh\_j]Zxl
_]hl_hjbxh[j_gghklb:^ZgZijbf_j:eeZokdZaZe©L_f`_
dlh hkemrZ_lky :eeZoZ b ?]h IhkeZggbdZ m]hlh\Zg Z^kdbc
h]hgv ]^_ hgb ij_[m^ml \_qghª Z ^Zevr_ _s_ [he__
kljh]h ©<hbklbgm :eeZo g_ gZf_j_g ijhsZlvbeb\_klbijy
fuf iml_f l_o dhlhju_ g_ m\_jh\Zeb b ]j_rbeb jZa\_ qlh
\\_^_l Hg bo \ Z^ \ dhlhjhf hgb ij_[m^ml \_qgh B wlh ^ey
:eeZoZkh\k_fe_]dhª (4:168–b^Ze__©M]hlh\Zghbf\_q
gh_ gZdZaZgb_ª (5:37), ©G_ gZclb bf ba g_]h bkoh^Zª (4:121),
©Bfg_hl\jZlblv_]hgZdZaZgb_–iiª (11:8), ©Bg_[m^_l
hglZfgb`blvgbmfbjZlvª (87:13), ©Ghg_kiZkmlkyhgbhl
Z^kdh]h ieZf_gbª b fgh`_kl\h ^jm]bo yZlh\ k\b^_
l_evkl\mxsbo \ ihevam \_qgh]h ij_[u\Zgby g_\_jguo \ :^m
DZd_s_fh`ghihgylvwlbZylu"Djhf_DhjZgZ\ihevam\_q
ghklb :^Z k\b^_l_evkl\mxl b oZ^bku IjhjhdZ k]k \ qZkl
ghklb \ h^ghf ba gbo kdZaZgh ©< Km^guc ^_gv ijb\_^ml
kf_jlvdkujZlmbkdZ`ml©Hh[blZl_ebJZyªbh[blZl_ebJZy
bkim]Zxlkylh]hqlhboohlyljZaemqblvkboh[bl_evxAZl_f
kdZ`ml ©H h[blZl_eb :^Zª b h[blZl_eb :^Z h[jZ^mxlky lh
fmqlhboohlyljZaemqblvkboh[bl_evxAZl_fkdZ`ml©AgZ
_l_ eb \u dlh wlh"ª b l_ b ^jm]b_ hl\_lyl ©>Z wlh kf_jlvª
aZl_f__kf_jlv–iiaZj_`mlbkdZ`ml³Hh[blZl_ebh[_bo
h[bl_e_c\u\_qghij_[m^_l_lZf]^_gZoh^bl_kvbgbdh]^Zg_
mfj_l_´ª153GZwlh`_mdZau\Zxlkeh\ZIjhjhdZk]k©Hgb
\_qgh ij_[m^ml lZf ]^_ gZoh^ylky b gbdh]^Z g_ mfjmlª beb
©Hgb \_qgh ij_[m^ml \ Z^kdhf h]g_ª DZd \b^bl_ wlb oZ^bku
g_ gm`^Zxlky gb \ dZdhc ljZdlh\d_ dZ`^uc jZamfguc fm
I_j_^ZeB[gFZ^`Zkihoh`bfkfukehfhgijbkmlkl\m_lmZe-;moZjb
Zl-Lbjfbab:ofZ^ZbZ^->Zjbfb
153
59
kmevfZgbg bamqZxsbc Zylu b oZ^bku g_ij_^\aylh kihkh[_g
ihagZlv wlm bklbgm B m^b\ey_l lh qlh ^h kbo ihj gZoh^ylky
ex^bih^h[gu_\ZooZ[blZfba[bjZxsb_\a]ey^uB[gL_cfbb
b_]hmq_gbdZB[gZe-DZcbfZ
Ihq_fm`_fgh]b_h[fZgmebkvkeh\ZfbB[gZe-DZcbfZ"
Ex^bh[fZgmebkvkeh\ZfbB[gZe-DZcbfZih^\mfijb
qbgZf
IjbqbgZ i_j\Zy – Zdlb\gZy ijhiZ]Zg^bklkdZy ^_yl_ev
ghklv kh klhjhgu ihke_^h\Zl_e_c oZrZ\bafZ Hgb ^_ggh b
ghsgh \deZ^u\Zxl k\hb kj_^kl\Z \ wlm ijhiZ]Zg^m ba^Zxl
dgb]bi_qZlZxlklZlvbihklhygghmihfbgZxl_]hbfy\k\hbo
ijhih\_^yo <ZooZ[blu gZklhevdh kbevgh jZ[hlZxl \ wlhc h[
eZklb qlh fheh^u_ ex^b ihiZ\rb_ ih^ bo \ebygb_ qZs_
\kihfbgZxl B[g L_cfbx b B[g Ze-DZcbfZ q_f IjhjhdZ
k]k GZ ^Zgguc fhf_gl keh\Z \ZooZ[blh\ \hkijbgbfZxlky
dZd^he`gh_gh_keb[uex^bagZebkmlvbom[_`^_gbclh[_
`Zeb[uhlgbodZdhlijhdZ`_gguo
IjbqbgZ \lhjZy – B[g Ze-DZcbf [ue hq_gv obljuf q_
eh\_dhf \eZ^_e ijb_fZfb eh]bdb b nbehkhnbb mf_e ih^[b
jZlvg_h[oh^bfu_keh\ZIj_`^_q_fij_^eh`blvgh\mxb^_x
hg ^_eZe hkgh\Zl_evgh_ \\_^_gb_ hq_gv bkdmkgh bkihevah\Ze
ZyluboZ^bkuaZqZklmxqlh[u^hdZaZlvk\hxijZ\hlmijb\h
^be\u^mfZggu_oZ^bku;he__lh]hhgijb\h^beZyluijhlb
\hj_qZsb__]hmq_gbxgh\u^Z\ZeboaZ^h\h^u\ihevamk\hbo
b^_c ihwlhfm g_]jZfhlguc b g_\gbfZl_evguc fh`_l ih^m
fZlv qlh _]h fukeb kljhcgu Z ^h\h^u \_jgu Dhg_qgh `_
ijbf_jhf obljhklb ^ey B[g Ze-DZcbfZ kem`be kZf kZlZgZ <
h^ghf ba klbohl\hj_gbc kdZaZgh ©G_ bf__l agZq_gby dZdbf
[uemq_guc?kebhgaZ[em^bekylh\f_kl_kgbfaZ[em^bebkv
b_]hihke_^h\Zl_ebª
JZ^b kijZ\_^eb\hklb klhbl hlf_lblv qlh g_ \k_ kh\j_
f_ggu_\ZooZ[bluijbagZxlb^_xhle_gghklb:^Z\hijZ\^Z
gb_k\h_]hr_coZhgbml\_j`^Zxlqlhhgkh\_jrbeb^`lboZ^
bhrb[kyh^gZdhg_kfhljygZwlhaZkem`b\Z_lgZ]jZ^uaZk\hc
b^`lboZ^Gh\hagbdZ_l\hijhkZdZdh_hgbf_eijZ\h^_eZlv
60
b^`lboZ^ \ lh \j_fy dh]^Z _klv ykgu_ k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu" B
ihq_fm\ZooZ[blu^himkdZxlih^h[gucb^`lboZ^ghhkm`^Z
xlb^`lboZ^\l_okemqZyodh]^Zg_lk\ys_ggh]hl_dklZhkh
[_ggh_kebwlhlb^`lboZ^ijhlb\hj_qblbob^_yf"
<dhgp_fuohlbf\gh\vhlf_lblvqlhfgh]b_mq_gu_b
\ qZklghklb oZg[Zeblu ihkdhevdm wlb ^\h_ h[uqgh ijbqbkey
xlky d gbf \uklmibeb khijh\_j`_gb_fb^_cB[gL_cfbbb
B[gZe-DZcbfZbh[ty\bebbo_j_lbdZfb
:e-:e[Zgb–oZrZ\blkdbcoZ^bkh\_^
<ZooZ[blu kqblZxl qlh gZ a_fe_ g_ [ueh ^hklhcguo
oZ^bkh\_^h\ ^h lh]h dZd ihy\beky r_co GZkuj Ze-:e[Zgb <
qZklghklb B[g ;Za gZau\Z_l _]h kZfuf h[jZah\Zgguf oZ^bkh
\_^hfgZa_fe_b\p_ehfhgb\k_gZau\Zxl_]h©fmoZ^^bkZe]Zkjª ©oZ^bkh\_^hf \_dZª Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky gZklhysbo oZ^b
kh\_^h\ lh hgb gZau\Zxl bo ©Zr-r_co Ze-fmlZgZdb^ª ©ijh
lb\hj_qb\uc r_coª Fu `_ ij_^eZ]Z_f \uykgblv dZdh_ ba
wlboijha\bs^_ckl\bl_evghy\ey_lky\_jguf">Ze__fukh[b
jZ_fkyij_^hklZ\blv\gbfZgbx^hjh]h]hqblZl_ey^hklh\_jgu_
^h\h^u b mdZaZlv gZ hrb[db Ze-:e[Zgb mihfygmlu_ \ dgb]_
©LZgZdm^Zl Ze-:e[Zgb Ze-mZ^uoZl nbfZ mdZ]Z eyom nb lZkobo
Ze-ZoZ^bk mZ lZ^]bnboZ fbg ZolZ mZ Ze-]ZeZlZl154ª ijbgZ^e_
`Zs_c i_jm r_co OZkZgZ [bg =Zeb Zk-KZddZnZ Zr-RZnb]b
ijbq_ffukh[bjZ_fkyijb\_klbebrvg_[hevrmxqZklv^h\h
^h\bai_j\hcqZklbmihfygmlhcdgb]b
:e-:e[Zgbh[\bgy_lbfZfh\–oZ^bkh\_^h\\g_\_`_
kl\_ghijbwlhfkZf^himkdZ_lhrb[db
:e-:e[Zgbg_hlebqZ_lkyhjb]bgZevghklvxblZd`_dZd
hklZevgu_oZrZ\blug_]gmrZ_lkyq_klvxfmkmevfZgkdbomq_
guo bfZfh\-oZ^bkh\_^h\ ^Z`_ _keb l_o m`_ g_l \ `b\uo <
k\h_c dgb]_ ©:k-KbekbeZ Z^-^Z]bnZª hg h[au\Z_l ZkKmxludjbdmghfbibr_l©M^b\bl_evghdZdZk-Kmxlu\hh[
Ba^ZgZ\ba^Zl_evkl\_©>ZjZe-bfZfZg-gZ\Z\bª\:ffZg_Bhj^Zgby<
i_j\hcqZklbr_coZk-KZdZnmihfbgZ_lljbklZijhlb\hj_qb\uofhf_glh\b
hrb[hdZe-:e[Zgb\h\lhjhcqZklbhgijb\h^blhrb[dbklj_lv_cqZk
lvxdgb]by_s_g_mki_ehagZdhfblvky
154
61
s_g_ihkl_kgyekygZibkZlvwlmdgb]mǻLhqghlZd`_
hgh[au\Z_lbfZfZZa-AZoZ[bZe-oZnbaZB[gZe->`Z\ab
©:k-KbekbeZ Zk-kZoboZª B[g Ob[[ZgZ ©:k-KbekbeZ
Z^-^Z]bnZª Ze-oZnbaZ B[g OZ^`ZjZ ©:k-KbekbeZ Z^^Z]bnZª gh ijb wlhf hg kZf ^himkdZ_l hrb[db b ijh
lb\hj_qbyGZijbf_j
Ze-:e[Zgbdjblbdm_lZk-KmxluZe-FZgZ\bbfZfZ=Z[
^meem[bgZk-Ku^^udZZe-=ZfZjbaZlhqlhhgbijb\_eboZ^bk
©JZkijhkljZgyc ijb\_lkl\b_ dhjfb gm`^Zxsboky ih^^_j`b
\Zc jh^kl\_ggu_ k\yab \uklZb\Zc ghqv dh]^Z ex^b kiyl –
\hc^_rv \ JZc k fbjhfª Ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ ©:k-KbekbeZ Z^^Z]bnZªhghlf_qZ_l©WlhloZ^bkbf__lkeZ[mxp_ihq
dm :^->Zjdmlgb ijb\h^bl _]h hl :[m FZcfmgu hl :[m Om
jZcjuhlg_]h`_wlhloZ^bki_j_^ZebDZlZ^Zh^gZdhhgg_ba
\_klgucbhl\_j]gmlucªgZwlhc`_kljZgbp_hgibr_l©<gb
fZgb_Zk-KmxlubZe-FZgZ\baZimlZebkv\keh\Zowlh]hoZ^b
kZ h[ wlhf y m`_ ]h\hjbe dhff_glbjmy oZ^bk ghf_j b
lhqghlZdmx`_hrb[dmkh\_jrbeZe-=ZfZjbª
Ihwlhfmih\h^mr_coZk-KZddZnibr_l©GZh[hjhlwlh
luaZimlZekylu^himklbe_s_[hevrmxhrb[dmbijhlb\hj_
qb_ihkdhevdm\^jm]hck\h_cdgb]_©Bj\ZZe-]Zebeªlu
gZa\Ze ^hklh\_jguf wlhl `_ oZ^bk k wlhc `_ p_ihqdhc i_j_
^Zlqbdh\ \ qZklghklb lu ibr_rv ©Wlhl oZ^bk ijb\_e :ofZ^
Ze-OZdbf«hlDZlZ^uhl:[mFZcfmguP_ihqdZwlh
]hoZ^bkZ^hklh\_jgZZ\k_i_j_^Zlqbdbdjhf_:[mFZcfmgu
khhl\_lkl\mxl mkeh\byf h[hbo r_coh\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky :[m
FZcfmgulhhggZ^_`gucq_eh\_dOZdbfkdZaZeqlhwlhloZ
^bk ^hklh\_j_g b lhqgh lZdh]h `_ fg_gby ijb^_j`b\Zeky ZaAZoZ[bªª155.
:e-:e[Zgb h[\bgy_l mq_guo-oZ^bkh\_^h\ \ lhf qlh
hgbaZgbfZxlkyijbibkdZfboZ^bkh\\jZaebqgu_k[hjgbdbgh
gZkZfhf^_e_wlboZ^bkulZfijbkmlkl\mxlgZijbf_j\©:kQlh[umagZlvdZdbfbkeh\ZfbZe-:eZ[Zgbihghkbl\_ebdbomq_guoh[
jZlbl_kv d dgb]_ ©DZfmk rZlZbf Ze-:e[Zgbª ijbgZ^e_`Zs_c i_jm ZkKZddZnZ
155
62
KZoboZª oZ^bk ghf_j ba^ -_ ih ih\h^m oZ^bkZ ©?keb dlh-eb[h ba \Zk \ iylgbpm aZ^j_fZe \ f_q_lb lh imklv
i_j_ky^_l gZ ^jm]h_ f_klhª - hg ibr_l ©:l-Lbjfbab mdZaZe
qlhwlhloZ^bkoZkZgkZoboZe-OZdbfhlf_lbeqlhhgkZobogZ
mkeh\byo FmkebfZ b k gbf kh]eZkbeky Za-AZoZ[b >Z hgb lZd
kdZaZeb gh B[g BkoZd ijbkmlkl\mxsbc \ wlhc p_ihqd_ [ue
\u^mfsbdhf Z hgb mihfbgZxl _]h \h \k_o \ZjbZglZo oZ^b
kZ«ª:k-KZddZnihwlhfmih\h^mhl\_qZ_l©<a]eygbl_hgoh
q_l kdZaZlv qlh Zl-Lbjfbab b Za-AZoZ[b aZimlZebkv gZ kZfhf
`_ ^_e_ wlh hg aZimlZeky B[g BkoZd g_ mihfbgZ_lky \h \k_o
\ZjbZglZooZ^bkZ_]hbfyijb\h^blkyebrv\k[hjgbd_bfZfZ
:ofZ^Z156AZ^mfZcl_kvgZ^wlbfª
:e-:e[Zgbijbibku\Z_lg_dhlhju_oZ^bku\g_dhlh
ju_k[hjgbdbghgZkZfhf^_e_hdZau\Z_lkyqlhbolZfg_l
Wlhlijb_fhgijbf_gy_lhq_gvqZklhhkh[_ggh\k\hbo
dgb]Zo ©KZobo Ze-^`Zfb] mZ aby^Zlmomª b ©>Z]bn Ze-^`Zfb]
\Zaby^Zlmomªb\k_dlhkkueZ_lkygZwlbdgb]blZd`_^himk
dZxlhrb[dbDjhf_lh]h\dgb]_©KunZlZk-kZeZªba^Zgb_
khoZ^bk_<Zbey[bgOm^`jZjZkiheh`_gb_jmd\h\j_fy
lZrZoom^Zhgibr_l©©AZl_fhgih^gyeiZe_pbym\b^_edZd
hgr_\_eblbfbh[jZsZ_lkykfhev[Zfbd:eeZomª157ijb\h
^blkym:[m>Zm^ZªR_coZk-KZddZnihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l
©Wlhg_\_jghbwlhloZ^bkijb\h^blkyg_m:[m>Zm^ZZm^jm
]boª.
KeZ[Zy hk\_^hfe_gghklv Ze-:e[Zgb h k[hjgbdZo oZ
^bkh\
:e-:e[Zgb h[\bgy_l fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo \ g_\_`_
kl\_b\ukf_b\Z_lboaZwlhk_[y`_hghlghkbldagZf_gbl_c
rbfoZ^bkh\_^Zfdjhf_lh]hhgh[\bgy_lmq_guo\g_\gbfZ
<hlqlhlZfkdZaZgh©GZfjZkkdZaZeY]dm[gZfjZkkdZaZefhchl_phl
FmoZffZ^Z[bgBkoZdZfg_jZkkdZaZeGZnb]kem]Z=Z[^meeu[bg=mfZjZ
hl =Z[^meeu [bg =mfZjZ dhlhjuc keurZe dZd IhkeZggbd :eeZoZ kdZaZe
³?kebdlh-eb[hba\ZkaZkgme\f_q_lb\iylgbpmlhimklvi_j_ky^_lgZ^jm
]h_f_klh´ª
157
R_co Zk-KZddZn mihfbgZ_l \k_ hrb[db k\yaZggu_ k wlbf oZ^bkhf \
k\h_cdgb]_©LZoabjZe-]Z[^Ze-ZmmZofbglZojbdZe-bk[Z]nbZk-kZeZª
156
63
l_evghklb ohly wlZ oZjZdl_jbklbdZ [hevr_ ih^oh^bl _fm kZ
fhfm ijb\_^_f ijbf_ju \ oZ^bk_ hl B[g FZk]m^Z kdZaZgh
©DhjZg[uegbkihkeZggZk_fbgZj_qbyodZ`^ucba_]hZylh\
bf__ly\gh_bkdjulh_agZq_gb_bmdZ`^h]hbagbo_klvk\hc
qblZl_evª :e-:e[Zgb ih ih\h^m wlh]h oZ^bkZ \ dgb]_ ©Fbr
dZlZe-fZkZ[boªkdZaZe©Bsbl_wlhloZ^bk\©RZjoZk-kmggZª
qlh`_dZkZ_lky©:e-=befªb©NZ^ZbeZe-DmjtZgªlhlZfy_]h
g_gZr_eªR_coZk-KZddZn_fmhl\_qZ_l©?keb[ulu\gbfZ
l_evghbamqZedgb]blhh[gZjm`be[uwlhloZ^bk\dgb]_©:e=befª\]eZ\_©:e-OmkmfZnbZe-DmjtZgª\©RZjoZk-kmggZª
Wlhl oZ^bk ijb\h^blky B[g Ob[[Zghf :[m Y]e_c ZlLZoZ\b Ze-;ZaaZjhf Ze-OZckZfb dhlhjuc hlghkbl _]h d Ze;ZaaZjm:[mY]e_bZl-LZ[ZjZgb\©:e-:\kZlªH^bgba\Zjb
Zglh\wlh]hoZ^bkZbf__l^hklh\_jguoi_j_^Zlqbdh\ª
:e-:e[ZgbbkdZ`Z_lkeh\Zmq_guobbkihevam_lbo\
k\hbop_eyo158.
Ihkdhevdmwlhh[\bg_gb_y\ey_lkyhq_gvk_jv_aguffu
ohlbf ijb\_klb g_kdhevdh ijbf_jh\ R_co Zk-KZddZn \ k\h_c
dgb]_ZgZebabjm_lfgh]b_pblZluZe-:e[ZgbgZZgZebadZ`^hc
pblZluhgaZljZqb\Z_lp_emxkljZgbpmBlZdijbf_ju
:e-:e[Zgb aZohl_e h[ty\blv g_^hklh\_jguf h^bg ba
oZ^bkh\ijhlb\hj_qZsbo_]hm[_`^_gbyfbkwlhcp_evxqZk
lbqghijb\_e[bh]jZnbxh^gh]hbai_j_^Zlqbdh\h^gZdhijb
\_ehg__\bkdZ`_gghf\b^_J_qvb^_lh=Zba_[bgOZ[b[_<
k\h_cdgb]_©Bj\ZZe-]Zebeªhgibr_l©WlhloZ^bkhl
g_k_gdIjhjhdmk]kh^gZdhkqblZ_lkyj_^dbfbeb^Z`_hl
\_j]gmluf G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh i_j_^Zlqbd wlh]h oZ^bkZ =Zba
[bgOZ[b[bkqblZ_lkygZ^_`gufq_eh\_dhfB[g=Z^bkdZaZe
h g_f ©Hg i_j_^Ze oZ^bku dhlhju_ iha^g__ [ueb hl\_j]gm
luªY^mfZxqlhwlhloZ^bklZd`_hlghkblkydboqbkemª
R_coZk-KZddZnmdZau\Z_l©Ih^h[gh_hlghr_gb_Ze-:e[ZgbdgZmqguf
ijb_fZf iheghklvx ebrZ_l _]h Z\lhjbl_lZ \ djm]Zo mq_guo-oZ^bkh\_^h\
LZdb_ihklmidbg_^himkdZxlky^Z`_\aZiZ^ghck\_lkdhcgZmd_bm\hklh
dh\_^h\IhwlhfmfuaZy\ey_fqlhkeh\ZZe-:e[Zgb\hh[s_g_bf_xlgb
dZdhcp_gghklbª
158
64
R_co Zk-KZddZn hl\_qZ_l ©G_l wlhl oZ^bk d lZdh\uf
g_hlghkblkybB[g=Z^bg_]h\hjbewlbokeh\luhrb[kyijb
pblbjh\Zgbb gZ kZfhf ^_e_ B[g =Z^b \ ©:e-DZfbeª kdZaZe©HlObrZfZ[bg=mj\ui_j_^Zxlg_dhlhju_hl\_j]gm
lu_ oZ^bku gh \k_ hklZevgu_ oZ^bku i_j_^Zggu_ bf kqblZ
xlky ijZ\^b\ufbª Hldm^Z lu \aye k\hx pblZlm" L_f [he__
qlh wlhl oZ^bk OZ[b[ hl ObrZfZ [bg =mj\u g_ i_j_^Z\Zeª Y
ij_^eZ]Zxk\h_fmq_klghfmqblZl_exkZfhfmebqgh^Zlvhp_g
dmwlhfmq_eh\_dm
<k\h_cdgb]_©LZoabjZk-kZ^`b^fbgbllboZaZe-dm[mj
fZkZ^`b^ª k 159 Ze-:e[Zgb kkueZ_lky gZ B[g OZ^`ZjZ ZeOZckZfbghm^Zey_lkj_^gxxqZklvpblZluihkdhevdmhgZg_
hl\_qZ_l _]h bgl_j_kZf Hg hldju\Z_l ^\_ kdh[db b gZqbgZ_l
ijb\h^blvkeh\ZB[gOZ^`ZjZaZl_fihke_pblZlu\gh\vklZ
\bl ^\_ kdh[db b ibr_l ©dhg_pª q_f \\h^bl qblZl_ey \ aZ
[em`^_gb_ BlZd \hl _]h keh\Z gZ klj ©< rZnb]blkdhf
fZaoZ[_wlhkqblZ_lky[hevrbf]j_ohfNZdboB[gOZ^`ZjZeOZckZfb \ ©:a-AZ\Z^`bj ]Zg bdlbjZn Ze-dZ[Zbjª mdZ
au\Z_l ©Lj_lvbf q_l\_jluf iyluf r_kluf k_^vfuf \hkv
fuf b ^_\yghkluf ba [hevrbo ]j_oh\ kqblZ_lky ij_\jZs_gb_
fh]be\f_q_lbbjZa`b]Zgb_gZ^gbfbh]g_clZd`_kqblZ_lky
[hevrbf]j_ohfij_\jZs_gb_fh]be\b^heh\kh\_jr_gb_\h
djm] gbo lZ\ZnZ b fhebl\Z \ bo klhjhgmª >Ze__ B[g OZ^`Zj
ijb\h^bl g_kdhevdh oZ^bkh\ b ijh^he`Z_l <gbfZgb_ g_dh
lhju_barZnb]blh\ihkqblZebr_klv\ur_i_j_qbke_gguoih
klmidh\ [hevrbfb ]j_oZfb fg_ dZ`_lkyhgbbkoh^bebbaoZ
^bkh\i_j_qbke_gguofghc\ur_ykghqlhwlboZ^bku^_c
kl\bl_evgh aZij_sZxl bkihevah\Zgb_ fh]be \ dZq_kl\_
f_q_l_c160,ihkdhevdm\oZ^bk_ijhdeyluex^bkh\_jrb\rb_
wlh k fh]beZfb ijhjhdh\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky l_o dlh kh\_jrZ_l
wlhkfh]beZfbijZ\_^gbdh\lhhgbgZa\Zgu©om^rbfbbakh
a^Zgbc\iehlv^hKm^gh]h^gyªWlbkeh\Zkem`Zl^eygZkij_
Ba^Zgb_q_l\_jlh_
:e-:e[Zgb\u^_ebewlmqZklvnjZau`bjgufrjbnlhf\b^bfhhg`_
eZe ihdZaZlv ijhkluf b g_\_`_kl\_gguf ex^yf qlh ydh[u B[g OZ^`Zj
bkihevah\Zekeh\h©ykghª
159
160
65
^mij_`^_gb_f dZd kdZaZgh \ h^ghf ba jb\Zylh\ ©Hkl_j_]Zc
l_kv^_ygbckh\_jr_gguobfbªLh_klvfmkmevfZgkdhcmff_
ke_^m_l hkl_j_]Zlvky wlbo ihklmidh\ \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ hgZ
[m^_lijhdeylZlZd`_dZd[uebijhdeylul_hdhfb^_lj_qv\
oZ^bk_ Bkihevah\Zgb_ fh]be \ dZq_kl\_ f_q_l_c ih^jZamf_
\Z_lih^kh[hckh\_jr_gb_fhebl\\boklhjhgmbjy^hfkgb
fbgZwlhmdZau\Zxlkeh\Z©bfhebl\Z\boklhjhgmªWlhloZ
^bkhlghkblkydfh]beZfijhjhdh\bijZ\_^gbdh\dZdkdZaZgh
h[ wlhf \ jb\Zyl_ ?keb lZf ihdhblky ijZ\_^gbd161 GZrb
mq_gu_ kdZaZeb qlh aZij_sZ_lky kh\_jrZlv fhebl\u m fh]be
ijhjhdh\bijZ\_^gbdh\_kebhgbkh\_jrZxlky\gZ^_`^_gZ
[eZ]hkeh\_gb_ beb ij_ke_^mxl k\h_c p_evx ihqblZgb_
mq_gu_ ihklZ\beb ^\Z mkeh\by« b lZd ^Ze__ ©gZ wlhf aZ
\_jrZxlkykeh\ZB[gOZ^`ZjZª162.
< ^jm]hc dgb]_ Ze-:e[Zgb iulZ_lky h[ty\blv keZ[uf
oZ^bkkh]eZkghdhlhjhfmIjhjhdk]kjZaj_rbe`_gsbgZf
mdjZrZlv k_[y ahehlufb p_ihqdZfb < p_ihqd_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\
wlh]h oZ^bkZ Ze-:e[Zgb h[gZjm`be FmoZffZ^Z [bg =bfZjZlZ
b aZy\be qlh ydh[u :[m OZlbf kdZaZe h[ wlhf q_eh\_d_ ©Hg
g_ kbe_g \ wlhfª kf dgb]m ©@bagv Ze-:e[Zgb b _]h gZke_
^b_ǻ q k GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ :[m OZlbf Zj-JZab \
©:e->`Zjo\ZZl-lZ]^beªkdZaZe©?]hoZ^bkuohjhrb_,
ghhgg_kbe_g\wlhfªdZd\b^bl_hghimklbenjZam©?]hoZ
^bkuohjhrb_ª
< h^ghc dgb]_ Ze-:e[Zgb fh`_l h[ty\blv oZ^bk ^h
klh\_jguf Z \ ^jm]hc lhl `_ kZfuc oZ^bk – hl\_j]gmluf b
hq_gvkljZgguf
:e-:e[Zgb\dgb]_©FmolZkZeZe-]mexª163kih^
ghf_jhf ijb\h^bl oZ^bk hl DZlZ^u [bg Zg-Gm]fZgZ dhlhjuc
keurZe dZd Ijhjhdk]kkdZaZe©Dh]^Z:eeZohk\h[h^beky
hlkha^Zgbylh\hag_kkybklZmZgZLjhgª>Ze__oZjZdl_jbamy
i_j_^Zlqbdh\oZ^bkZhgibr_l©?]hijb\h^ylgZ^_`gu_i_j_
Wlbkeh\ZhgbkdexqbebapblZluB[gOZ^`ZjZ
©:a-AZ\Z^`bjªB[gOZ^`ZjZe-OZckZfb
163
Ba^Zgb_i_j\h_
161
162
66
^Zlqbdb b \ qZklghklb :[m ;Zdj Ze-ObeZe \ k\h_c dgb]_ ³:kKmggZ´ª164 R_co Zk-KZddZn ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©Y g_
agZx ihq_fm l_[y gZa\Zeb ©OZ^bkh\_^hf RZfZª ©OZnbahf
\_dZ b \j_f_gª g_ agZx ihq_fm l\hb ihke_^h\Zl_eb ]h\hjyl
qlh ©l_[_ g_l ih^h[guoª b qlh ©h[h \k_f wlhf fh`gh ^Z`_
deyklvkyklhyf_`^mfZdZfhfbm]ehfDZZ[uª165?keb[uZe:e[Zgbijb\_e\kxp_ihqdmwlh]hoZ^bkZbadgb]bZe-ObeZeZ
lh kjZam `_ klZeh [u ykgh qlh wlhl oZ^bk \u^mfZgguc b hl
\_j]gmlucbgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_^hklh\_jgucqlh[um[_^blv\
wlhf gZr_]h qblZl_ey fu ijb\h^bf p_ihqdm i_j_^Zlqbdh\
BlZd Ze-ObeZe kdZaZe ©GZf jZkkdZaZe :ofZ^ [bg Ze-Omk_cg
Zj-Jbddb jZkkdZaZe B[jZobf [bg Ze-Fmgabj Ze-ObaZfb jZk
kdZaZe FmoZffZ^ [bg NZebo fg_ jZkkdZaZe hl_p hl KZ]b^Z
[bg Ze-OZjbkZ hl =Z[b^Z [bg OZgbgZ dhlhjuc kdZaZe ©H^
gZ`^udh]^Zykb^_e\f_q_lbdhfg_ih^hr_eDZlZ^Z[bgZgGm]fZg b gZqZe jZkkdZau\Zlv ©Y keurZe dZd Ijhjhd k]k
kdZaZe ³Dh]^Z :eeZo hk\h[h^beky hl kha^Zgby lh \hag_kkygZ
Ljhg iheme_`Z aZeh`b\ h^gm gh]m gZ ^jm]mx gh kdZaZe qlh
wlh g_ ^ey q_eh\_dZ´ª R_co Zk-KZddZn hl\_qZ_l ©Ex[hc jZ
amfguc q_eh\_d ihgbfZ_l qlh wlh de_\_lZ \ Z^j_k :eeZoZ b
?]h IjhjhdZ k]k H[jZlbl_kv d ©:e-:kfZ \Z Zk-kunZlª k
355 –bfZfZZe-;ZcoZdbdhff_glbjmywlhloZ^bkhg]h\h
jbl qlh hg hq_gv kljZgguc b hl\_j]gmluc BfZf Za-AZoZ[b \
k\h_cdgb]_©FbaZgZe-b]lb^Zeªhlf_qZ_lqlhwlhloZ
^bkhlghkblkydqbkemhl\_j]gmluooZ^bkh\NZeboZBohq_lky
hlf_lblv qlh kZf Ze-:e[Zgb \ k\hbo dgb]Zo gZau\Z_l oZ^bku
NZeboZg_^hklh\_jgufbbkeZ[ufb166DZdihke_wlh]hfh`gh
ml\_j`^Zlv qlh ^Zgguc oZ^bk y\ey_lky ^hklh\_jguf b khhl
\_lkl\m_l\k_fmkeh\byfZe-;moZjb";he__lh]hwlhaZy\e_gb_
k\b^_l_evkl\m_l \ ihevam lh]h qlh _]h Z\lhj \_kvfZ g_\gbfZ
<km[dhff_glZjbyohglZd`_mdZau\Z_l©WlhloZ^bkmihfbgZ_lB[gZeDZcbf\k\h_cdgb]_©:e->`mxrZe-bkeZfbyªkbml\_j`^Z_lqlhp_
ihqdZoZ^bkZohjhrZybkhhl\_lkl\m_lmkeh\byfZe-;moZjbª
165
Wlb njZau b ih^h[gu_ bf \u fh`_l_ ijhq_klv \ dgb]_ ©OZyl ZeZe[Zgb«ª
166
Kf©:k-KZoboZªb^j
164
67
l_e_gbijhlb\hj_qblkZfhfmk_[_ihkdhevdm\k\h_c`_dgb]_
©KbekbeZZ^-^Z]bnZªoZ^bkhggZau\Z_l_]hhl\_j]
gmluf b hq_gv kljZgguf Fu g_ khfg_\Z_fky qlh wlhl oZ^bk
bf__l bm^_ckdmx yauq_kdmx hkgh\m dhlhjmx :eeZo hijh\_j
]Z_l\K\h_cK\ys_gghcdgb]_©<hbklbgmFukhl\hjbebg_
[_kZba_fexb\k_qlhf_`^mgbfbaZr_klv^g_cbFugb
qmlv g_ mklZebª wlhl Zyl ^hdZau\Z_l qlh Ze-:e[Zgb
kebrdhfe_]dhfuke_gghhlghkblkydZgZebamoZ^bkh\hkh[_g
gh wlh dZkZ_lky dgb] ih Zdu^_ GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ \ dgb]Zo ih
Zdu^_ ^hklh\_jghklb oZ^bkh\ ke_^m_l m^_eylv hkh[h_ \gbfZ
gb_ lZd`_ g_h[oh^bfh ke_^blv qlh[u hgb g_ ijhlb\hj_qbeb
[he__gZ^_`gufdhjZgbq_kdbfl_dklZf
:e-:e[Zgb ijhlb\hj_qbl k_[_ \hko\Zeyy hij_^_e_g
guoebqghkl_c\h^ghcdgb]_bdjblbdmybo`_\^jm]hc
< ©KZobo Zl-lZj]b[ \Z Zl-lZjob[ª k hg \hko\Zeyy
r_coZOZ[b[jZofZgZZe-:]aZfbibr_l©Dba^Zgbxwlhcdgb
]bf_gyih^lhedgmelhlnZdlqlhhgZkhijh\h`^ZeZkvdhff_g
lZjb_f ba\_klgh]h r_coZ OZ[b[jZofZgZ Ze-:]aZfbª gZ wlhc
`_kljZgbp_hgijh^he`Z_l©?s_[he__ih^[h^jbehf_gyqlh
r_co OZ[b[jZofZg Ze-:]aZfb ijh\_jb\rbc wlm dgb]m kdZ
aZeǻWlbkeh\ZkdZaZggu_\Z^j_koZ^bkh\_^Zr_coZOZ[b[
jZofZgZ Ze-:]aZfb Ze-:e[Zgb hijh\_j]Z_l \ dgb]_ ©:^Z[ ab
nZnª k ©< k\h_c dgb]_ Ze-:gkZjb bkihevam_l ^Zggu_ ba
dgb] OZ[b[jZofZgZ Ze-:]aZfb h^gh]h ba \_ebqZcrbo \jZ]h\
kmgguoZ^bkh\_^h\bihke_^h\Zl_e_clZ\ob^Z«wlhmdZau\Z_l
gZ lh qlh hg ljmk \ gZmqghf b ebl_jZlmjghf ieZg_ǻ AZ^m
fZcl_kvgZ^wlbfbkeh\Zfb
:e-:e[Zgb lZd `_ dZd b hklZevgu_ oZrZ\bluik_\^hkZeZnblukeZ[\ZjZ[kdhfyaud_
Ijb\_^_fijbf_ju
< ©Zk-KZoboZª hg ibr_l ©<m^`m[m Ze-Zoa [by^
Za-aZebfª ©G_h[oh^bfh \aylvky aZ jmdb k lbjZghfª Wlh
[hevrZy hrb[dZ ke_^m_l ibkZlv ©<m^`m[m Ze-Zoa ]Zey y^ ZaaZebfª ©G_h[oh^bfh m^_j`Zlv jmdm lbjZgZª \_^v i_j\uc
\ZjbZglih^jZamf_\Z_lih^kh[hcihfhsvlbjZgm<b^bfhZe68
:e[Zgb aZimlZeky qblZy g_dhlhju_ oZ^bku ]^_ i_j_^Zlqbdb
mihlj_[bebwlh\ujZ`_gb_hrb[hqgh
< k\h_f ©:k-KZoboª h[ h^ghf ba oZ^bkh\ hg ib
r_l ©Fhebl\Z ljhbo g_ ijbf_lky fm`qbgu kh\_jrb\r_]h
ih]j_[Zevgmx fhebl\m ^`ZgZaZ b g_ lZ\baª Dhff_glbjmy
ihke_^g__ keh\h \ oZ^bk_ hg ibr_l ©LZd gZibkZgh gh y g_
gZr_e \ ZjZ[kdhf yaud_ lZdh]h keh\Zª R_co Zk-KZddZn hl\_
qZ_l ©>_ckl\bl_evgh \ ZjZ[kdhf yaud_ g_l lZdh]h keh\Z gZ
kZfhf^_e_\wlhfoZ^bk_mihlj_[ey_lky]eZ]he©xfZjª\_e_
gh \ blh]_ oZ^bk ijbh[j_lZ_l kfuke ©fm`qbgZ kh\_jrb\
rbc ih]j_[Zevgmx fhebl\m ^`ZgZaZ _fm g_ [ueh \_e_gh __
kh\_jrZlvª;_^gy]Zg_kfh]ijhq_klvwlh]hkeh\Zg_kfhljygZ
lhqlhhgh\klj_lbehkv_fm\©:l-LZj]b[\ZZl-lZjob[ªk
ghf_jghdkh`Ze_gbxgZrhiihg_glg_\gbfZl_e_g
G_dhlhju_bahrb[hdZe-:e[Zgb\oZ^bkh\_^_gbb
< ©Zk-KZoboZª \ ihke_^g_c kljhqd_ oZjZdl_jb
amyoZ^bkhgibr_l©Wlh^hklh\_jgZyp_ihqdZ\k_i_j_^Zlqb
db wlh]h oZ^bkZ gZ^_`gu_ ex^b \klj_qZxsb_ky \ p_ihqdZo
i_j_^Zlqbdh\ FmkebfZª R_co Zk-KZddZn _fm hl\_qZ_l ©<
wlhc p_ihqd_ _klv KZoe [bg =mkfZg Ze-;Z^`Zeb _]h g_l \ p_
ihqdZoi_j_^Zlqbdh\FmkebfZfu_]hlZfg_h[gZjm`bebDZd
fh`gh gZau\Zlv lZdmx p_ihqdm ^hklh\_jghc"ª Wlh _s_ h^bg
^h\h^\ihevamlh]hqlhZe-:e[ZgbaZimlZekyhgg_kfh]hleb
qblvZe-;Z^`ZebhlKZoeZ[bg=mkfZgZZe-DZg^bdhlhjuc^_c
kl\bl_evghijbkmlkl\m_l\p_ihqdZoFmkebfZ
>Ze__\©:k-KZoboZª\iylhckljhqd_kgbamhg
ibr_l©B[gAZc^–wlhFmoZffZ^[bgAZc^[bg=Z[^meeZb[g
=mfZj [bg Ze-OZllZ[ dhlhjuc ijbagZ_lky gZ^_`guf i_j_^Zl
qbdhfª R_co Zk-KZddZn hl\_qZ_l ©Wlh g_\_jgh B[g AZc^ –
wlh=Z[^jZofZg[bgAZc^dhlhjuckqblZ_lkyhq_gvkeZ[ufi_
j_^Zlqbdhfª
>Ze__ \ ©:k-KZoboZª gZ i_j\hc kljhqd_ hg ib
r_l ©B[g =ZjaZ[ – g_ba\_klguc q_eh\_dª R_co Zk-KZddZn
hl\_qZ_l©G_lgZh[hjhlhggZ^_`guci_j_^ZlqbdZe-OZnba\
©:l-LZdjb[ªmihfbgZ_l_]hih^ghf_jhfª
69
>Ze__ \ ©:k-KZoboZª oZjZdl_jbamy oZ^bk hg
ibr_l ©<k_ _]h i_j_^Zlqbdb djhf_ =Z[[Z^Z [bg KZebfZ gZ
^_`gu_ ex^b hgb ijbkmlkl\mxl \ r_klb k[hjgbdZo qlh `_
dZkZ_lky =Z[[Z^Z lh y g_ gZr_e _]h [bh]jZnbbª R_co ZkKZddZn _fm hl\_qZ_l ©;bh]jZnby =Z[[Z^Z baeZ]Z_lky \ ©LZ
jboª Ze-;moZjb ©Ze->`Zjo \Z Zl-lZ]^beª ©:kKbdZlªB[gOb[[ZgG_ihjZebl_[_ijhkgmlvky"ª
>Ze__ Ze-:e[Zgb \ ©:k-KZoboZª – h oZ^bk_
©Emqrbc aZ\ljZd \_jmxs_]h – wlh nbgbdbª ibr_l ©?]h ijb
\_ebB[gOb[[ZgbZe-;ZcoZdbǻaZl_fgZkijh^he`Z_l
©<gbfZgb_ Ze-Fmgabjb \ ©:l-LZj]b[ª b Ze-OZlu[ ZlLb[jbab\©:e-FbrdZlªhlghkylwlhloZ^bkd:[m>Zm
^mbyg_agZxhldm^Zhgbwlh\ayebªR_coZk-KZddZnhl\_qZ
_l©Yg_agZxhq_fhg]h\hjblghwlhloZ^bk^_ckl\bl_evgh
ijb\h^blkym:[m>Zm^Zih^ghf_jhf=hj_l_fdlhiu
lZ_lky\hag_klbk_[y\ur_oZnbah\ª
:e-:e[Zgb g_\_`_kl\_g_g \ hlghr_gbb ijZ\be oZ
jZdl_jbklbdb i_j_^Zlqbdh\ oZ^bkh\ - ©]bef Ze-^`Zjo \Z ZllZ]^beª
R_coFZofm^KZ]b^FZf^mo\h\\_^_gbbdk\h_cdgb]_
©:g-GZd^ Zk-kZobo ebfZ b]lZjZ^Z ]Zeycob fbg oZ^bk ZefZkZ[boªibr_l©=Zfj[bg=ZedZfZ[bg<ZddZkZe-EyckbZe:e[Zgb ibr_l h g_f ©G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh Zl-Lbjfbab
kqblZ_l =ZfjZ gZ^_`guf _]h ijbagZxl g_ba\_klguf i_j_^Zl
qbdhfª Ih^h[gh_ ihky]Zl_evkl\h gZ bfZfh\ g_ ^himklbfh h
lZdbo ex^yo Ze-;moZjb ]h\hjbe ³Y ihemqbe hl l_[y [hevr_
ihevauq_fluhlf_gy´ªOZ^bkui_j_^Zggu_=ZfjhfkqblZ
eb^hklh\_jgufbbZl-LbjfbabbB[gOb[[ZgbB[gOma_cfZ
Za-AZoZ[b<a]eygbl_gZwlh]hZe-:e[Zgbdhlhjucg_agZdhfk
]b]ZglZfbZ`_eZ_lk_[yihdZaZlvmq_guf
>`mjZc[bgDmeyc[Zg-GZo^bZe-Dmnb
:e-:e[Zgb ibr_l h g_f ©Gbdlh djhf_ :[m Bk
oZdZ Zk-KZ[b]b g_ i_j_^Z\Ze hl g_]h oZ^bkuª R_co FZofm^
hl\_qZ_l_fm©G_lhlg_]hoZ^bkui_j_^Z\Zebb^jm]b_ex^b
:e-OZnba \ ©:l-LZoab[ª ibr_l ©Hl g_]h i_j_^Z\Zeb
Xgmk [bg :[m BkoZd =Zkuf [bg :[m Zg-GZ^`m^ wlb oZ^bku
70
ijb\h^ylky\k[hjgbd_:ofZ^ZªIjbqbghchrb[hdZe-:e[Zgb
kem`bl lh qlh hg \k_]^Z hibjZeky ebrv gZ h^gm dgb]m ©:eFbaZgªkf
R_coKZ]b^[bgFZ[jmdZe-DZgm[b\hl\_lgZijhba\_
^_gbyZe-:e[ZgbgZibkZedgb]m©:e-BfZfZj-JZ[b]fZdZgZlm
om \Z fmkgZ^momª \ g_c hg ]h\hjy h g_\_`_kl\_ Ze-:e[Zgb
hlf_qZ_l qlh hg g_ agZe h[ bfZf_ Zj-JZ[b]_ b ijb\h^bl _s_
iylv^_kylijbf_jh\\dZq_kl\_^h\h^Zhlghkbl_evghg_\_`_kl
\Z wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \ qZklghklb hg ibr_l ©«bgh]^Z _]h g_\_
`_kl\h ijhy\ey_lky \ g_kdhevdbo h[eZklyo oZ^bkh\_^_gby Hg
g_ agZdhf k i_j_^ZlqbdZfb mihfygmlufb \ k[hjgbdZo ^\mo
ba\_klg_crbobfZfh\g_agZ_lhkms_kl\h\Zgbbfgh]booZ^b
kh\ kj_^b dhlhjuo hq_gv fgh]h oZ^bkh\ ba k[hjgbdh\ Ze;moZjbbFmkebfZbaljm^h\dhlhjuohgydh[ukhklZ\bek[hj
gbdbba[jZgguooZ^bkh\g_]h\hjym`_hoZ^bkZobaf_g__ba
\_klguok[hjgbdh\ǻGb`_fuijb\_^_fg_dhlhju_ijbf_ju
< k\h_c dgb]_ ©:^->Z]bnZª hg ibr_l ©Kme_c
fZg[bgRZjoZ[be«<wlhfa\_g_p_ibyg_gZr_egbdh]hdlh
ghkbe[ubfyKme_cfZg[bgRZjoZ[bebebRZjZobeªIhegh_
bfy wlh]h Kme_cfZgZ – Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^jZofZg [bg =bkZ
[bgFZcfmgb[g[bglRZjoZ[beoZ^bkh\_^ubgh]^Zijb\h^yl
_]hbfy\mihfygmlhfkhdjZs_gghf\ZjbZgl_;bh]jZnbywlh]h
q_eh\_dZbaeh`_gZ\©Jb^`ZeZe-;moZjbªmZe-Dbey[Zab
©:l-LZjboZe-dZ[bjª©:e->`Zjo\ZZl-lZ]^beªB[g
:[mOZlbfZ©=beZeZe-oZ^bk«ªdjhf_i_j_qbke_gguor_co
Ze-DZgm[bijb\h^bl_s_^\Z^pZlvbklhqgbdh\]^_mihfbgZ_l
ky wlhl q_eh\_d Wlhl i_j_^Zlqbd h^bg ba ba\_klguo i_j_
^Zlqbdh\Ze-;moZjbb_s_q_luj_obfZfh\
=Z[^meZ]ey[bg=Z[^meeZ[bg:[mNZj\Z
:e-:e[Zgb\©:^->Z]bnZªibr_l©Hgg_ba\_k
l_g_]h[bh]jZnbbyg_h[gZjm`beªGZkZfhf^_e_wlhg_lZd
=Z[^meZ]ey mihfbgZ_lky \h fgh]bo ba\_klguo dgb]Zo gZijb
f_j ©Zl-LZjbo Ze-dZ[bjª Ze-;moZjb ©:l-LZjboª B[g
Fm]bg©:e->`Zjo\ZlZ-lZ]^beªB[g:[mOZlbf^Ze__
m r_coZ Ze-DZgm[b ijb\h^ylky _s_ ^_kylv bklhqgbdh\ k [bh
]jZnb_cwlh]hq_eh\_dZZe-OZnba\©LZdjb[Zl-lZdjb[ªk
71
ibr_l ©GZ^_`guc i_j_^Zlqbd nZdbo h _]h gZ^_`ghklb mih
fbgZxlB[gFm]bgY]dm[[bgKmnvygbZ^->Zjdmlgbª
KZ]b^[bg:r\Z]
< ©Bj\Z Ze-]Zebeª Ze-:e[Zgb ibr_l ©Y g_ gZ
r_e _]h [bh]jZnbbª gZ kZfhf ^_e_ [bh]jZnby wlh]h q_eh\_dZ
kh^_j`blky \ lZdbo dgb]Zo dZd ©Jb^`Ze Ze-;moZjbª ©Jb^`Ze
Fmkebfª ©:l-LZjbo Ze-dZ[bjª ©LZjbo B[g Fm]bgª b djhf_
gbo_s_\r_klgZ^pZlbbklhqgbdZo
@_gZB[g=mfZjZ
:e-:e[Zgb \ ©:k-KZoboª mdZau\Z_l ©<k_ i_j_
^Zlqbdb wlh]h oZ^bkZ gZ^_`gu_ ex^b djhf_ `_gu B[g =mfZ
jZdhlhjmxyg_agZxªgZkZfhf^_e_`_gZB[g=mfZjZy\ey
_lky hq_gv ba\_klghc `_gsbghc __ bfy KZnby [bgl :[m =m
[Zc^Zk-KZdZnbyOZ^bkuhlg__ijb\h^ylbfZfuFmkebfbZe;moZjb167 Z __ [bh]jZnby mihfbgZ_lky \ ljbgZ^pZlb bklhqgb
dZo
LZdh\ Ze-:e[Zgb h^bg ba djmig_crbo ik_\^hkZeZnbl
kdbo fmoZ^^bkh\ A^_kv fu ijb\_eb ebrv g_[hevrmx lhebdm
ba hl\_lh\ b djblbdb mq_guo \ Z^j_k Ze-:e[Zgb _keb f_klh b
l_fZlbdZ dgb]b iha\heyeb [u gZf \dexqblv [hevr__ lh fu
lZd`_ijb\_eb[upblZlubadgb]r_coZ=Z[^meeuZe-OZjbjb
ZlZd`_^jm]bomq_guok^_eZ\rboZgZebaljm^h\Ze-:e[Zgb
<hckdh[jZlv_\>`ZcrZe-bo\Zg
<hagbdgh\_gb_
Ihke_ lh]h dZd r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ aZ
dexqbe ^h]h\hj k B[g KZ]m^hf bf [ueb kha^Zgu ihk_e_gby
^eyfmoZ^`bjh\dhlhju_hggZa\Ze©Ze-ob^`ZjªkZfufba\_
WlZ `_gsbgZ kqblZ_lky h^ghc ba ba\_klg_crbo lZ[b]bghd `bl_evgbp
F_^bguOZ^bkui_j_^Zggu__xkh^_j`Zlky\k[hjgbdZoFmkebfZFZeb
dZ:ofZ^ZZ^->ZjbfbZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^ZB[gFZ^`bQbkeh__jb\Zy
lh\ jZ\gh ijbq_f hgb hq_gv \Z`gu_ b \ hkgh\ghf dZkZxlky \hijhkh\
k\yaZgguo k `_gsbgZfb DZd q_eh\_d kqblZxsbc k_[y mq_gufoZ^bkh\_^hffh`_lg_agZlvlZdbo]b]Zglh\"
167
72
klgufbawlboihk_e_gbc[ueh©Ob^`ZjZe-ZjlZ\byª168wlbk_
e_gby ijbgbfZeb \k_ gh\u_ b gh\u_ ]jmiiu i_j_k_e_gp_\
I_j\uf k hkm`^_gb_f ih^h[gh]h i_j_k_e_gby \uklmibe jh^
ghc [jZl FmoZffZ^Z Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ bf [ueZ
gZibkZgZ dgb]Z ©:k-KZ\Z]bd Ze-beyoby nb Zj-jZ^^b ]Zey Ze\ZooZ[byª \ g_c hg dhff_glbjm_l oZ^bk IjhjhdZ k]k ©G_l
ob^`ju ihke_ \aylby F_ddbª169 Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[
kljh]hhkm^beijbau\di_j_k_e_gbxbaZy\behg_h[oh^bfhklb
hklZ\Zlvky\F_^bg_170.
Ih kmlb ^_eZ mihfygmlu_ ihk_e_gby [ueb \h_ggufb
eZ]_jyfb]^_]hlh\beZkvkbevgZyj_]meyjgZyZjfby171Ijbau\
d i_j_k_e_gbx fh] ij_ke_^h\Zlv lhevdh lZdb_ p_eb gh \ l_
\j_f_gZ`bl_ebihemhkljh\Zh[wlhf^Z`_g_ih^haj_\Zeb
Wlb\h_ggu_eZ]_jybf_ebkljh]mx^bkpbiebgm\k_ih
klmiZxsb_ \ h[yaZl_evghf ihjy^d_ ^he`gu [ueb ihkljbqvky
gZeukh172 ;_^mbgZf ihklmib\rbf \ eZ]_jy FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[qblZee_dpbb\dhlhjuoh[mqZelhfmdZdke_^m
_l fmkmevfZg h[ty\eylv yauqgbdZfb \_^v lh]^Z g_ khklZ\bl
gbdZdh]h ljm^Z bo m[blv B[g ;ZrZj ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l
©Dh]^ZfmoZ^`bjui_j_k_ebebkv\Z^->Zj]bxlh`bagvbo[u
eZ^h\hevghljm^ghc`bebhgb\gm`^_ihghqZfaZgbfZebkv
j_f_kehfZ^g_fihk_sZebe_dpbbFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\Zo
oZ[Zª173 Qbke_gghklv \hckdZ r_coZ jhkeZ b ij_`^_ \k_]h wlh
:e-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabjZª K – >Ze__ [m^_l
kdZaZghqlhbf_gghkob^`ZjgZqZekyjZkdhe\ZooZ[bafZ
169
©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ªK
170
©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ªK– 125.
171
Gb`_ fu jZkkdZ`_f h nbgZgkbjh\Zgbb b kgZ[`_gbb wlh]h \hckdZ hjm
`b_fdhlhjh_hkms_kl\eyeNbebiibh^bgboojbklbZgkdboij_^\h^bl_e_c
\ZooZ[bafZ
172
BgnhjfZpbxh[wlhfijb\h^ylfgh]b_gZ^_`gu_Z\lhjukj_^bdhlhjuo
r_co >Zoeyg \ ©NblgZ Ze-\ZooZ[byª k r_co Ze-FZg]Zfb dhlhjuc
djblbdmy m[bckl\h fmkmevfZg hldZaZ\rboky kljbqvky gZibkZe klbohl\h
j_gb_\dhlhjhfh[jZsZ_lkydFmoZffZ^m[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[m©JZa\_kj_
^b oZ^bkh\ fh_]h ^_^Z bf__lky \ \b^m Ijhjhd FmoZffZ^ k]k – ii
_klvlZdb_dhlhju_ih\_e_\Zxlkljbqv]heh\mgZeukh"ª
173
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
168
73
ijhbkoh^behba-aZlh]hqlhr_cos_^jh\hagZ]jZ`^Ze\hbgh\
\uieZqb\Zebo^he]bB[g;ZrZjihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l©Dh
]^Z fmoZ^`bju i_j_k_ebebkv r_co \uieZqb\Ze bo ^he]b b
h[_ki_qb\Zebo\k_fg_h[oh^bfufª174.
Ijbbamq_gbbi_jbh^ZaZjh`^_gbybjZa\blby\ZooZ[bl
kdh]h^\b`_gbyihy\eyxlky\hijhku
- <h-i_j\uo ba\_klgh qlh r_co FmoZffZ^ g_ [ue [h
]Zl hldm^Z `_ m g_]h [jZebkv ^_gv]b qlh[u kh^_j`Zlv k\hbo
khe^Zl"
- <h-\lhjuo ijbgm^bl_evgZy fh[bebaZpby175 \h_ggu_
eZ]_jy lj_gbjh\db kljb`dZ \hehk \k_ wlh [ueh gh\uf ^ey
ZjZ[kdh]h h[s_kl\Z l_o \j_f_g jZa\_ FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me
\ZooZ[ fh] ^h^mfZlvky ^h \k_]h wlh]h kZf" ?klv g_dhlhju_
nZdlu dhlhju_ mdZau\Zxl gZ lh qlh \k_f wlbf jmdh\h^beb
[jblZgkdb_ hnbp_ju G_dhlhju_ ba gbo ^Z`_ [ueb m[blu \h
\j_fy [h_\uo ^_ckl\bc dZd gZijbf_j dZiblZg R_dkibj176.
>jm]b_ `_ dZd Nbebiib b >bdkhg [ueb ba\_klgu dZd bkdmk
gu_ihedh\h^pu
Wlh \hckdh mqZkl\h\Zeh \ jZaebqguo hi_jZpbyo _]h
qbke_gghklv m\_ebqb\Zehkv b gZdhg_p hgh klZeh ba\_klguf
dZd\hckdh[jZlv_\©^`ZcZe-bo\ZgªLZdh_bfy_fmijb^mfZe
r_co =Z[^meeZ [bg =Z[^meZlun mf ] ] h^bg ba
ihlhfdh\FmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zhgijboh^blky^_^hf
ihfZl_jbdhjhexNZckZem177.
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªM^b\bl_evghqlhk_]h^gyg_dhlhju_ba\Zo
oZ[blh\klZjZxlkymlZblvb^Z`_hljbpZxlwlbnZdlu
175
<ur_fujZkkdZaZebhlhfdZdwlhijhbkoh^beh\qZklghklbB[g;ZrZj
ibr_l©B[gKZ]m^hlijZ\bek\hbo\_j[h\sbdh\dhlhju_ijbau\Zeb[_^m
bgh\\h_\ZlvgZ_]hklhjhg_ª©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
176
Hg[uem[bl\h\j_fykjZ`_gbyZe->`bjZ[\]
177
B[jZobfZe-NZjbk©:roZjmZtbffZlZ^-^Z]\ZobeZeZdZjgZcgªK–
Kf_rguf y\ey_lky lhl nZdl qlh qbkeh \ZooZ[blkdbo bfZfh\ jZ\gh
h^bggZ^pZlb\k_hgb[_^mbgubaG_^`^Zr_klvbagboihlhfdbFmoZffZ
^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z Gbdlh ba mq_guo fmkmevfZgkdhc mffu gbdh]^Z g_
\ha]eZ\eyewlh^\b`_gb_
174
74
I_j\u_\h_ggu_hi_jZpbb
I_j\uc gZ[_] [ue kh\_jr_g gZb[he__ hiulgufb \hb
gZfbwlh]h\hckdZH^gZdhm^b\ey_llhlnZdlqlhhgb\k_ih
iZ^Zeb k \_j[ex^h\ B[g ;ZrZj ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©AZ
l_f r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ \_e_e \uklmiblv gZ
^`boZ^bhgbih^qbgbebkv_fmI_j\h_\hckdhkhklhyeh\k_]h
bak_fbq_eh\_dhgbk_ebgZ\_j[ex^h\Zdh]^Zl_ihfqZebkv
lh\kZ^gbdbihiZ^Zebkgboihkdhevdm\_j[ex^ug_[ueb^ey
gboijb\uqgufb`b\hlgufbG_kfhljygZwlhhgb\gh\vhk_^
eZeb\_j[ex^h\kh\_jrbebihoh^gZg_dhlhju_ba[_^mbgkdbo
ie_f_g b aZo\Zlb\ ljhn_b \_jgmebkv `b\ufb b a^hjh\u
fbª178 <hl a^_kv-lh b ihy\eyxlky \hijhku h \kZ^gbdZo ih
iZI^Z\rbo k \_j[ex^h\ ^ey dhlhjuo wlhl \b^ ljZgkihjlZ [ue
g_ijb\uqgufBa\_klghqlh\l_\j_f_gZ\G_^`^_ex[hcj_
[_ghdmf_e_a^blvgZ\_j[ex^_DZdbfh[jZahf\ajhkeu_ex^b
fh]ebkgboihiZ^Zlv"<_^vwlh[hevrhcihahj^eyfm`qbgu
hkh[_ggh_kebhg\hbgJZa\_ZjZ[u-[_^mbgufh]ebiha\heblv
k_[_miZklvk\_j[ex^Z"
Ijh^he`_gb_aZ\h_\Zgbc
<h\j_fy[h_\uo^_ckl\bc©\hckdh[jZlv_\ªgZqZehbk
ihevah\Zlv gh\mx kljZl_]bx khe^Zlu klZgh\bebkv jy^Zfb b
reb\ZlZdmqlh`_dZkZ_lkydhggbpulhhgZ\uihegyeZjhev
ih^dj_ie_gby lZdZy kljZl_]by [ueZ hq_gv ihoh`Z gZ \hckdZ
gbaZfbb Hgb bkihevah\Zeb wlm kljZl_]bx ijb gZiZ^_gbb gZ
Ze->`ZojZ\]\h\j_fy[bl\kkbeZfbDm\_clZbijbaZ
o\Zl_OZbey179.
< j_amevlZl_ gZ[_]h\ b ]jZ[_`Z \ZooZ[blkdh_ \hckdh
\k_]h aZ iylgZ^pZlv e_l kfh]eh aZ\eZ^_lv h]jhfgufb l_jjblh
jbyfb :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkljh\Z G_\_`_kl\_ggu_ [_^mbgu g_
fh]eb ijhlb\hklhylv lZdhfm kbevghfm \hckdm b [ueb \ugm`
^_gu\klmiZlv\_]hjy^uihkl_i_gghqbke_gghklvwlhcZjfbb
^hklb]eZklZ^\Z^pZlblukyqq_eh\_dK\hb\hcguhgbgZau\Z
178
179
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªLK– 15.
>bdkhg©:jZ[uimklugbªK
75
eb^`boZ^hf180gZ[_]b-]ZaZ\ZlZfbih[_^u–nmlmoZlZfbih
]b[rbo h^ghiheqZg – rZob^Zfb Z k\hbo \jZ]h\ ba qbkeZ fm
kmevfZg–g_\_jgufb
L_jjhjgZZjZ[kdhca_fe_
Wlb g_kf_lgu_ iheqbsZ ihkj_^kl\hf l_jjhjZ mklZgZ\
eb\Zeb\ZooZ[blkdmx\eZklvHgb[uebihoh`bgZ\hckdZFm
kZceZfu mgbqlh`Z\rb_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ hZabku b m[b\Z\rb_
kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ k]k JZagbpZ f_`^m i_j\ufb b ih
ke_^gbfb [ueZ ebrv \ lhf qlh \ZooZ[blkdb_ \hckdZ ^_ckl\h
\Zebih^q_ldbfjmdh\h^kl\hfojbklbZgkdbohnbp_jh\181Nb
ebiib \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:j[Z]mgZ ]ZfZg nb Ze->`ZabjZ Ze]ZjZ[byª ©Khjhd e_l gZ :jZ\bckdhf ihemhkljh\_ª ibr_l
©Dh]^ZfujZahqZjh\Zebkv\Ze-Omk_cg_lhj_rbebbkihevah
\Zlv ©\hckdh [jZlv_\ª \ha]eZ\ey_fh_ OZeb^hf [bg ExZc
NZckZehf Z^->Z\br_f KmelZghf [bg ;Z^`Z^hf Wlh \hckdh
^he`gh [ueh mkljhblv j_agx \ LZbn_ b gZ\_klb kljZo gZ \k_
hk_^eu_ b dhq_\u_ ZjZ[kdb_ ie_f_gZ Ob^`ZaZª182 >Ze__ hg
hibku\Z_l f_jhijbylby mkljh_ggu_ bf ^ey lh]h qlh[u ih^
qbgblv k_[_ =Z[^meem [bg Ze-Omk_cgZ Bhj^Zgkdh]h ©«y \_
e_e =Z[^me]Zabam k g_[hevrbf hljy^hf ba ©\hckdZ [jZlv
_\ª gZiZklv gZ =Z[^meem [bg Ze-Omk_cgZ kh klhjhgu ZeFbeobm[blv_]h<lh`_\j_fyfu\_e_ebB[g=m^\Zgm\hk
klZlv ijhlb\ =Z[^meeu [bg Ze-Omk_cgZ \gmljb Bhj^Zgbb
«IhkdhevdmgZrb\hckdZbf_ebgh\_cr__hjm`b_bfm^Zehkv
mgbqlh`blvg_kdhevdhlukyqie_f_ggZk_ey\rboZe-;ZedZZeOmxlZlie_f_gZ;ZgmKZojZb^jm]bo\h\j_fywlhchi_jZpbb
[uehmgbqlh`_ghfgh]h`_gsbgb^_l_cª183.
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«». 1/14.
?]h_s_gZau\ZxlkljZl_]bq_kdbfjmdh\h^kl\hfghbgh]^Zbfijboh^b
ehkvhkms_kl\eylvbl_ogbq_kdh_jmdh\h^kl\hlh`_
182
KfmGZkujZZk-KZ]b^Z©LZjboZeKZ]m^ªk
183
GZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo«ªK©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZ
Ze-]ZjZ[byZe-oZ^bkªK
180
181
76
Ba\jZs_gb_kmggubh[uqZ_\
MZjZ[kdboie_f_g[uebk\hbaZdhgu\h_ggh]h\j_f_gb
< qZklghklb gbdlh gbdh]^Z gb ih^ dZdbf ij_^eh]hf g_ bf_e
ijZ\Z m[b\Zlv `_gsbg gZkbeh\Zlv bo ]jZ[blv bo bfms_kl\h
wlhkqblZehkvgbahklvxbih^ehklvx>Z`_\lhfkemqZ__keb
ih\_j`_ggh_ie_fy[_`Zehkihey[hyih[_^bl_evgbdh]^Zg_
ijbqbgye\j_^Z`_gsbgZfb^_lyfhgbg_\oh^beb\ihgylb_
\hcgu b ijhlb\gbdZ ©<hckdh [jZlv_\ª gZjmrbeh wlb h[uqZb
\hbgug_jZak\yau\Zeb`_gsbg^eylh]hqlh[u\h`^b\ZooZ
[bafZ184 hihjhqbeb bo q_klv >bdkhg185 \ihke_^kl\bb mkljh
b\rbc jZkdhe ©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª ibr_l ©Wlb nZgZlbdb ba
©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª aZ dhjhldh_ \j_fy klZeb ]jhahc \k_o k\hbo
\jZ]h\ b ^jma_c aZ ]h^u dh]^Z bo a\_a^Z kbyeZ \ j_amevlZl_
m`Zkguo aeh^_ckl\ bf m^Zehkv mijZa^gblv \k_ h[uqZb dhlh
ju_[uebp_ggu^eydZ`^h]hgZklhys_]hZjZ[Z»186Lhqlhhgb
[ueb nZgZlbdZfb lh _klv q_j_a\uqZcgh j_eb]bhagufb ex^v
fb gb \ dh_f kemqZ_ g_ kem`bl hijZ\^Zgb_f bo ihklmidZf
>bdkhg b kZf khh[sZ_l h lhf qlh hgb [_a`Zehklgh m[b\Zeb
`_gsbg b ^_l_c ©<h \j_fy wlbo gZ[_]h\ \hbgu ba ©\hckdZ
[jZlv_\ª gZklhevdh `_klhdh m[b\Zeb `_gsbg b ^_l_c qlh bo
ihklmidZfg_lgbdZdh]hhijZ\^Zgbyª187.
Djhf_lh]hkh]eZkghZjZ[kdbfh[uqZyf[uehaZij_s_
ghm[b\Zlvie_gguogh©\hckdh[jZlv_\ªgZjmrbehbwlhlaZ
ij_l lh`_ >bdkhg ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©< – ]]
©\hckdh [jZlv_\ª [ueh gZ \_jrbg_ k\h_]h fh]ms_kl\Z lh]^Zlh hgb hl\_j]gm\ \k_ [h`_kl\_ggu_ b q_eh\_q_kdb_ aZdhgu
Dhjhev=Z[^me]ZabaebqghbagZkbeh\Ze[he__q_luj_okhlie_ggbpkj_^b
dhlhjuo[ueZb`_gZm[blh]hbfkugZNZckZeZZ^->Z\brZ
185
>bdkhgjh^bekyb[ue\kdhjfe_g\ie_f_gb=ZgaZihwlhfmbkqblZe
k_[y ]Zgablhf K\hbo ^_l_c hg gZa\Ze KZ]m^hf b AZojhc gh BkeZf g_
ijbgye G_kfhljy gZ wlh \h`^b \ZooZ[bafZ gbdh]^Z gbq_]h g_ ij_^
ijbgbfZeb ^h lh]h dZd ihemqZl hl g_]h bgkljmdpbb <ZooZ[blu kZfb
i_j_\_eb_]hdgb]mgZZjZ[kdbcyaudbihwlhfmfuk_cqZkbf__f\ha
fh`ghklvkkueZlvkygZg__
186
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZªK
187
LZf`_K
184
77
klZeb l\hjblv ^_ygby hl mihfbgZgby dhlhjuo klug_l djh\v
Hgbm[b\Zeb\k_obl_odlhk^Zekybl_odlhg_k^Zekyª188.
H[fZgjZkdjul
B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[ b _]h ihlhfdb ihklhyggh ijbau\Zeb
©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª d \hcg_ h[_sZeb bf JZc b aZij_sZeb ^jm
`blv k g_\_jgufb h^gZdh gZ ^_e_ bgh]^Z bo qZklb ijbkh_^b
gyeb d qZklyf gZf_klgbdZ Gh q_j_a g_dhlhjh_ \j_fy \h_gZ
qZevgbdb klZeb aZf_qZlv qlh \ ^_ckl\bl_evghklb kljZl_]bq_k
dbfbjmdh\h^bl_eyfbwlh]h\hckdZ[uebZg]ebckdb_hnbp_ju
lh]^Z-lhhgbbihgyebqlh[uebh[fZgmluqlhbobkihevamxl
\dZq_kl\_hjm^byZg]ebckdbo\eZkl_c189.
HkhagZ\wlmbklbgm\]ij_^\h^bl_eb©\hckdZ[jZ
lv_\ª kh[jZeb \h_gguc kh\_l dhlhjuc ihemqbe gZau\Zgb_
©Kh\_l\:jlZ\byªGZwlhfkh\_l_ijbkmlkl\h\ZebNZckZe[bg
Z^->Z\br B[g OZkeZcg B[g ;Z^`Z^ b ^jm]b_ < j_amevlZl_
kh\_lZ hgb \uklmibeb k k_fvx lj_[h\Zgbyfb kj_^b dhlhjuo
[uehlj_[h\Zgb_gZaZij_lbkihevah\Zgbyl_e_nhgh\bZ\lhfh
[be_c \ fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZgZo lj_[h\Zgb_ ijbgylv rbblh\
Ze-BokZ \ \ZooZ[baf beb `_ \k_o dZagblv H^gZdh wlh _s_ g_
[ueh ibdhf djbabkZ hg gZklZe \ ] dh]^Z ©\hckdZ [jZlv
_\ªhldZaZebkvijbagZlvkugZKZ]m^Zdhjhe_fOb^`ZaZG_^`
^Zb\k_oijbe_]Zxsbol_jjblhjbc
Ihkdhevdm©\hckdh[jZlv_\ij_^klZ\eyehkh[hc]jhagmx
kbem\eZklbihrebgZmklmidbb^Z`_gZrebiylgZ^pZlvmq_
guoba^Z\rbon_l\ukh]eZkghlj_[h\ZgbyfijbgylufgZ\u
r_mihfygmlhf kh[jZgbb Ihke_ [bl\u Zk-KZ[ey ]
©\hckdh [jZlv_\ª mkljhbeh \hhjm`_ggh_ \hkklZgb_ ijhlb\
\h`^_c \ZooZ[bafZ <hkklZgb_ \ha]eZ\beb KmelZg [bg OZfba
Ze-=Zlb NZckZe [bg KmelZg Z^->Z\br Ze-FZlujb190 <k_ ih
LZf`_K
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZªK
190
Hg[ueh^gbfbaljbgZ^pZlbdhfZg^bjh\gZiZ\rbo\f_kl_k=Z[^me]Z
abahfgZwj-Jby^\h\lhjhcjZa=Z[^me]Zabahq_gv^h\_jye_fmbgZagZqbe
_]h k\hbf kh\_lgbdhf GZ _]h kh\_klb e_`bl kf_jlv fgh]bo g_\bgguo fm
kmevfZg:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\ZbBjZdZHg`_hkZ^beF_^bgmb^_j`Ze
__\[ehdZ^_^hl_oihjihdZ__`bl_ebg_k^Zebkv;he__lh]hhg\kxk\hx
188
189
78
lhfdb=Z[^meeu[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zh[ty\bebbooZjb^`blZfb
b^ZebjZaj_r_gb_mgbqlh`blvghdZdwlhk^_eZlv"<_^vgh\Zy
ZjfbykZm^blh\_s_g_khaj_eZ
<hllh]^Z-lhgZihfhsvdgbfijbrebqZklb[jblZgkdhc
j_]meyjghcZjfbbhgbhdZaZebbgZa_fgmxb\ha^mrgmxih^
^_j`dm;jblZgby\k_fbkbeZfbklZjZeZkvmgbqlh`blvl_odlh
ihiulZekyhldjulv__lZcgm©<hckdh[jZlv_\ª[uehhdjm`_gh
b\[ehdZ^ghfdhevp_gZg_]hh[jmrbekyrd\Zeh]gy191[jblZg
kdbodhjhe_\kdbo\ha^mrguokbeDjhf_lh]h;jblZgbygZqZeZ
bgZa_fgmx\h_ggmxhi_jZpbx192<blh]_B[gOZfb^b^jm]b_
ij_^\h^bl_eb ©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª \ lhf qbke_ kug NZckZeZ Ze>Z\brZ [ueb mgbqlh`_gu Z kZfh \hckdh [ueh \ugm`^_gh
k^Zlvky
Dhg_p©\hckdZ[jZlv_\ª
]NZckZeZ^->Z\brk^Zekyij_^klZ\bl_ex;jb
lZgbb >bdkhgm klZ\dZ dhlhjh]h [ueZ \ Dm\_cl_ >h Dm\_clZ
_]h khijh\h`^Ze kwj KK ;_jgl [jblZgkdbc \h_gZqZevgbd \
;Zkj_ ?]h ebrbeb f_qZ qlh kbf\hebabjh\Zeh aZ\_jr_gb_
\j_f_g©\hckdZ[jZlv_\ª:^->Z\brZ^hklZ\beb\wj-Jby^]^_
hg \ mf_j \ ] \ lxjvf_ dhjhey =Z[^me]ZabaZ Bgl_j_kgh
qlhZ^->Z\brkms_kl\h\Zgb_dhlhjh]h[jblZgpuhljbpZxl\h
\j_fyk^ZqbkdZaZe>bdkhgm©H:[mKZ]m^yihjmqZxl_[_aZ
[hlmhfh_ck_fv_ª\h\j_fyk^Zqb\f_kl_kgbf[ueZ_]h`_
gZ ljh_ [jZlv_\ ^\h_ fZe_gvdbo ^_l_c b _s_ ^\Z^pZlv k_fv
jh^kl\_ggbdh\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª lh \ g_f
[ueZ ijh\_^_gZ qbkldZ b \k_ g_m]h^gu_ jmdh\h^bl_eb [ueb
mgbqlh`_gu GZ wlhf aZ\_jrbeZkv bklhjby i_j\h]h \ZooZ[bl
kdh]h \hckdZ kha^Zggh]h B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[hf b _]h kugh\vy
fb \hckdZ ih^qbgb\r_]h k_[_ [hevrmx qZklv Ob^`ZaZ Gh
`bagv[uef_qhfaZg_k_ggufgZ^ie_f_g_fZe-=Z^`fZgbadhlhjh]hijh
bkoh^beZ_]hfZlv
191
Qlh[uij_^klZ\blvk_[_fhsv©\hckdZ[jZlv_\ª^hklZlhqghmagZlvqlh
qbke_gghklv\_j[ex^h\\wlhf\hckd_khklZ\eyeZklhlukyq
192
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZªK
79
_fm gZ kf_gm ijbreh gh\h_ [he__ kbevgh_ \hckdh ]hlh\h_
m[b\Zlv^Z`_iZehfgbdh\
<hckdh>`hgZNbebiib
:g]ebqZg_ ijb^Z\Zeb [hevrh_ agZq_gb_ aZjh`^Zxs_
fmky \ZooZ[bafm hgb aZ[hlbebkv h g_f ihkdhevdm agZeb qlh
wlh^\b`_gb_iha\heblbfg_lhevdhih[_^blvBkeZfghaZgylv
fmkmevfZg f_`^hmkh[ghc \hcghc K p_evx jZa\blby wlh]h
^\b`_gby hgb ihklhyggh ihkueZeb \ j_]bhg k\hbo Z]_glh\
bf_gghwlbex^bbihiZQ^Zebk\_j[ex^h\\h\j_fyi_j\h]hih
oh^Z H^gbf ba gbo [ue R_dkibj ih]b[rbc \h \j_fy [bl\u
\ZooZ[blh\ k jZrb^blZfb Ke_^mxsbf [ue >`hg Nbebiib h
g_ffubih]h\hjbf\wlhfjZa^_e_
DlhlZdhcNbebiib"
Wlh ihedh\gbd =Zjjb >`hg KZgl Nbebiib jh^beky Zij_ey ] gZ hkljh\_ P_cehg193 < ] _]h hl_p i_j__a
`Z_l \ <_ebdh[jblZgbx < ] >`hg hdhgqbe D_f[jb^`
kdbc mgb\_jkbl_l aZl_f bamqZe bklhjbx b bg^bckdh_ ijZ\h
\umqbe njZgpmakdbc g_f_pdbc bg^bckdbc i_jkb^kdbc b
ZjZ[kdbc yaudb AZl_f \_jgmeky gZ \hklhd ]^_ [ue Z]_glhf
[jblZgkdbo \eZkl_c lZd `_ dZd D_lrg_j Ehj_gk FZdfZohg
DhdkFZk[_evDe_clhg=_ev[hgE_ckhgb^jm]b_
<]>`hgNbebiibihemqZ_lgZagZq_gb_\Bg^bx\
dZq_kl\_ Z]_glZ [jblZgkdhc jZa\_^db gh \kdhj_ ihemqZ_l ih
\ur_gb_ b \ ] m`_ klZgh\blky aZf_klbl_e_f ]m[_jgZlhjZ
EZceZ[hjZ aZl_f _]h i_j_\h^yl gZ ^he`ghklv ]eZ\u mijZ\e_
gby gZ^ahjZ aZ i_qZlvx \ I_g^`Z[_ K gZqZehf I_j\hc fbjh
\hc\hcgu;jblZgbymkbeb\Z_lk\hxdhehgbZevgmxiheblbdmb
klZjZ_lky hlh[jZlv l_jjblhjbb HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb gZ ;eb`
g_f\hklhd_b\qZklghklbBjZd<];jblZgkdbcnehlih^
dhfZg^h\Zgb_fkwjZ;_jkbDhdkZ\ukZ^beky\;Zkj_\khklZ\_
dhfZg^gh]h khklZ\Z wlbo [jblZgkdbo qZkl_c [ue b Nbebiib
Q_j_a]h^hg[uegZagZq_gihfhsgbdhf]m[_jgZlhjZihwdhgh
fbq_kdbf \hijhkZf b gZqZe \uimkd ]Za_lu ©:e-:\dZl Ze193
K_cqZkRjb-EZgdZ
80
[Zkjbyª<lh`_\j_fyhgiml_r_kl\m_lihx]mBjZdZkh[bjZ
_l bgnhjfZpbx b \klj_qZ_lky k >bdkhghf dhlhjuc d lhfm
\j_f_gbm`_^he]h_\j_fygZoh^beky\j_]bhg_b[ueagZdhfk
kblmZpb_c
fZy ] [jblZgkdb_ \hckdZ aZo\Zlbeb ;Z]^Z^ b
Nbebiib [ue gZagZq_g \lhjuf ihfhsgbdhf ]m[_jgZlhjZ
djhf_ lh]h \f_kl_ kh k\ys_ggbdhfFZjbZe-DbjfZebhgbgZ
qZeb\uimkd]Za_lu©:e-=ZjZ[ª
GZklmie_gb_gZ:jZ\bckdbcihemhkljh\
< ] \h \j_fy [bl\u \ZooZ[blh\ k jZrb^blZfb dh
lhjuo Zg]ebqZg_ kqblZeb klhjhggbdZfb HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb
ijbZe->`bjZ[[uem[bldZiblZgR_dkibj;eZ]h^ZjyZjZ\bc
kdhc kfml_ Zg]ebqZgZf m^Zehkv hl\e_qv \gbfZgb_ HkfZgkdhc
bfi_jbb b aZo\Zlblv ;Zkjm194 H^gZdh ihke_ kf_jlb mihfygm
lh]h \ZooZ[blkdh]h ihedh\h^pZ bo Zjfby gm`^ZeZkv \ gh\hf
kljZl_]_b_kl_kl\_gghbffh]klZlvlhevdhfbkl_jNbebiib
hdly[jy]hgm`_h^_luc\ZjZ[kdmxh^_`^mijb[ue\
FbgZ Ze-=Zdbj qlh gZoh^blky \ Ze-BokZ qlh[u hllm^Z gZijZ
\blvky\wj-Jby^]^_hg^he`_g[ue\klj_lblvkykdm\_clkdbf
dhgkmevlZglhf [jblZgkdhc dhjhgu ih iheblbq_kdbf \hijhkZf
=Zfbevlhghf195 Gh ih g_ba\_klguf ijbqbgZf _]h fZjrjml
baf_gbekyhgihk_lbex]:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\ZaZl_fgZ
ijZ\beky gZ k_\_j ihke_ q_]h ijh_oZ\ Ob^`Za ^h[jZeky ^h
?]bilZ Z hllm^Z \gh\v ijb[ue \ ;Zkjm <b^bfh hg ijbdb^u
\Zegh\u_]jZgbpu[m^ms_]h\ZooZ[blkdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\Z
<h \j_fy iml_r_kl\by hg jZajZ[hlZe ieZg dhlhjuc
ij_^klZ\be Dhdkm b \ kdhjhf \j_f_gb k gh\ufb aZiZkZfb ^_
g_]bhjm`bygZijZ\beky\:jZ\bckdbcihemhkljh\]^_\imk
lug_Z^->ZogZ\klj_lbekyk\h`^yfb\ZooZ[bafZ
I_j_^>`hghfNbebiibklhyehljbaZ^Zqb
\h-i_j\uok[hjbgnhjfZpbbh[:jZ\bckdhfihemhkljh
\_^ey[jblZgkdhcjZa\_^db
ghy[jy]
<h\j_fywlhcih_a^dbNbebiibi_j_^Ze\ZooZ[blZfwd\b\Ze_glklZlu
kyqj_Zeh\bh[_sZeihklZ\dbgh\_cr_]hhjm`by\[eb`Zcr__\j_fy
194
195
81
\h-\lhjuo \hkiblZgb_ gh\h]h ihdhe_gby \ZooZ[blh\
dhlhju_ ijbdju\Zykv ZjZ[kdbfb h^_`^Zfb [m^ml ijh\h^blv
iheblbdm\u]h^gmx[jblZgkdhcdhjhg_
\-lj_lvbo mkljZg_gb_ HkfZgkdh]h \ebygby gZ :jZ\bc
kdhfihemhkljh\_dhlhjh_hkms_kl\eyehkvihkj_^kl\hfjZrb
^blh\gZk_\_jh-\hklhd_boZrbfblh\\Ob^`Za_
QlhdZkZ_lky^\moi_j\uop_e_clhhghq_gvm^Zqghbo
\uihegbe196 b \hkiblZe fgh`_kl\h \ZooZ[blh\ m]h^guo Zg]
ebqZgZfQlhdZkZ_lkylj_lv_caZ^Zqblhdfhf_glmijb[ulby
Nbebiib\ZooZ[blkdbf\hckdZfijbrehkvhlhclbd;mjZc^_Z
\hckdZfjZrb^blh\dZe-DZkufmihwlhfm[ueZg_h[oh^bfhklv
\ mkdhj_gbb [h_\uo ^_ckl\bc Nbebiib ^h]h\hjbeky k \ZooZ
[blZfb qlh hgb ijh^he`Zl gZklmie_gb_ kjZam `_ ihke_ lh]h
dZdihklmiblgh\h_ih^dj_ie_gb_djhf_wlh]h[jblZgpuh[y
aZebkv ihklZ\blv ^_gv]b hjm`b_ b \h_gguo dhgkmevlZglh\197.
<i_j\hciZjlbbhjm`by\ZooZ[blZf[uehihklZ\e_ghiylvlu
kyq\bglh\hdbklhysbdh\k[h_ijbiZkZfb>`hgNbebiibg_
hkf_ebekyebqghmqZkl\h\Zlv\kZfuoi_j\uo\hcgZoihkdhev
dm[hyekymqZklbdZiblZgZR_dkibjZ\k\yabkwlbfhggZ[ex
Ohq_lky ^h[Z\blv qlh iml_r_kl\my ih :jZ\bckdhfm ihemhkljh\m Nb
ebiibkh[bjZeiheg_crmxbgnhjfZpbyh[wlhfj_]bhg_<p_ehfbf[ueh
i_j_^Zghhdhehjbkmgdh\dhlhju_kh^_j`Zeb^Z`_bah[jZ`_gbyij_^
klZ\bl_e_cZjZ\bckdhcnehjubnZmguDjhf_lh]hhgohjhrhbkke_^h\Ze
C_f_g b HfZg ihk_lbe KZ[Z b OZ^jZfZml qlh \ihke_^kl\bb iha\hebeh
[jblZgpZf e_]dh aZo\Zlblv b wlb a_feb lh`_ ?]h ihoh`^_gby hibkZgu \
dgb]_©:j-Jm[]Ze-oZebªZlZd`_\klZlv_him[ebdh\Zgghc\blZevygkdhf
`mjgZe_ ©:r-RZjd Ze-oZ^bkª \ ] kh kkuedhc gZ GZkujZ Ze-NZjZoZ
©Dbyf Ze-]brZj Zk-KZ]m^by ^bjZkZl lZjboby ebe]ZeydZl Zk-KZ]m^by Ze[jblZgbyªZk-KZnZebgZrj\ZZl-lZ\ab]Ehg^hgklZd`_m>bdkhgZ
©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZªk
197
Fw^`_j >bdkhg ©:e-Dm\_cl \Z ^`ZjZlmoZª i_j_\h^ gZ ZjZ[kdbc >`Z
kbfZZe-Fm[ZjZdZHgkhh[sZ_lqlh\h]eZ\_[jblZgkdhcfbkkbbklhyeNb
ebiib_]hihfhsgbdZfb\hkms_kl\e_gbb[jblZgkdhckljZl_]bb[uebihe
dh\gbd =Zfbevlhg b ihedh\gbd DZgeb\ h[Z Z]_glu [jblZgkdhc jZa\_^db \
BjZd_ Hgb \_aeb k kh[hc kmg^mdb gZ[blu_ ^_gv]Zfb <ZooZ[blZf [ueh
ihklZ\e_ghklhlukyqj_Zeh\Zdjhf_wlh]hdZ`^uc]h^[jblZgkdZydhjhgZ
\u^_eyeZ _s_ ih r_klv^_kyl lukyq j_Zeh\ kf m ^hdlhjZ FmoZffZ^Z ZeOZlu[Z©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byª
196
82
^Ze aZ kjZ`_gbyfb k [Zrgb b ^Z\Ze \ZooZ[blkdbf \h_gZqZev
gbdZfg_h[oh^bfu_dhgkmevlZpbb198.
>ey h[_ki_q_gby mki_rghklb k\h_c iheblbdb mijZ\e_
gby\ZooZ[blkdbf]hkm^Zjkl\hf>`hgNbebiibijbf_gbegh
\u_ ^h kbo ihj g_ bkihevah\Zggu_ f_lh^u < qZklghklb hg
h[ty\be qlh ijbgye BkeZf ohly gZ kZfhf ^_e_ wlh]h g_ k^_
eZe < k\h_c dgb]_ hg gZau\Z_l k_[y >`hghf Nbebiib Z g_
=Z[^meehc >bdkhg ih wlhfm `_ ih\h^m ibr_l ©:jZ[u gZau
\Zeb_]h=Z[^meehcObe[bª199Djhf_lh]hNbebiibih^dmiZe
\h`^_cZjZ[kdboie_f_g[eZ]h^Zjyih^dmiZf_fmm^Zehkvih
emqblvihfhsvg_dhlhjuojZrb^blh\\h\j_fyrlmjfZbo^_
j_\_gvbklhebpu;eZ]h^Zjyih^dmim\h\j_fy[bl\uZj-JZ\^Z
k [hevrhc e_]dhklvx [ueb aZo\Zq_gu ^_j_\gb ;Zc^Z GZkbe b
Zr-RZ]b[Z Z bo `bl_eb kh\_jrZ\rb_ mlj_ggxx fhebl\m \
f_q_lb [ueb bklj_[e_gu \ZooZ[blZfb bfms_kl\h jZa]jZ[e_
gh`_gub^_lbie_g_guIh^dmie_ggu_\ZooZ[blkdb_Z]_glu
ihfh]eb\hckdm\hclb\>`Z[ZeRZffZjb=md^Z]^_gZqZeky
djh\Z\ucl_jjhjijhlb\fbjguo`bl_e_cb[uehm[blhfgh`_
kl\hfbjguodj_klvyg200<blh]_\ZooZ[blZfhldjuekyimlvgZ
OZbe dhlhjuc lZd`_ [ue \ayl [eZ]h^Zjy ij_^Zl_evkl\m _]h
aZo\ZlbebKZnZjZ]ghy[jy]201.
Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyZrjZnblh\\Ob^`Za_lhj_r_gb_ij_
ih^Zlvbfmjhd[uehijbgylhihke_lh]hdZdhgbg_kfhljygZ
m]jhau b ihiuldb ih^dmiZ hldZaZebkv ih^ibkZlv ba\_klgu_
njZgdh-[jblZgkdh-kbhgbklkdb_^h]h\hjuKZcdbkZ;_cdh]
b ;_evnhjZ ] KZeZo Ze-=ZdZ^ ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l
©G_kh]eZkb_Zr-RZjbnZOmk_cgZkieZgZfb;jblZgbbdZkZx
sbfbky kha^Zgby _\j_ckdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z \ IZe_klbg_ klZeb
]eZ\ghc ijbqbghc jZaeZ^Z _]h hlghr_gbc k [jblZgkdhc dhjh
OZcjbOZffZ^©=Z[^meeZNbebiibªK
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZªK
200
GZkuj Zk-KZ]b^ ©LZjbo :e KZ]m^ fZgrmjZl bllboZ^ rZ][ Ze-^`ZabjZ
Ze-]ZjZ[byª[]K.
201
LZf`_K
198
199
83
ghcª202 :g]ebqZg_ hl\_lbeb Zr-RZjbnm Omk_cgm \ZooZ[bl
kdbfgZklmie_gb_f\Ob^`Za_[he__lh]hhgb^h[bebkvba^Z
gby khhl\_lkl\mxsbo n_l\ g_ lhevdh kh klhjhgu \ZooZ[blh\
gh b g_dhlhjuo mq_guo `b\rbo \ j_]bhgZo dhehgbabjh\Zg
guobfbDjhf_lh]h[jblZgkdb_ribhguijb\_eb\khklhygb_
g_]h^ghklb \h_ggu_ kZfhe_lu ijbgZ^e_`Z\rb_ Zr-RZjbnm
dhlhju_ hg bkihevah\Ze \h \j_fy \hcgu ijhlb\ \ZooZ[blh\
Nbebiib i_j_obljbe Zr-RZjbnZ ij_^eh`b\ _fm k\hb ih
kj_^gbq_kdb_ mkem]b \ \hcg_ ijhlb\ \ZooZ[blh\ \ blh]_ _fm
m^Zehkv ihemqblv bgnhjfZpbx h jZkiheh`_gbb qZkl_c ZrRZjbnZ?fmm^Zehkvm[_^blv]eZ\m\ZooZ[blh\\>`b^^_qlh
_]h\hckdhij_\hkoh^bl\hckdhZr-RZjbnZbqlh[hevrbgkl\h
[_^mbgh\ `_eZxl [uklj_cr_]h dhgpZ [h_\uo ^_ckl\bc Nb
ebiib ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©Ihke_ lh]h dZd fu ihl_jyeb
\kyq_kdmxgZ^_`^mgZih^^_j`dmkhklhjhguOmk_cgZj_rbeb
bkihevah\Zlv ©\hckdh [jZlv_\ª \ha]eZ\ey_fh_ OZeb^hf [bg
ExZc NZckZehf Z^->Z\br_f b KmelZghf [bg ;Z^`Z^hf Hgb
mkljhbebihdZaZl_evgmxj_agx\LZbn_dhlhjZy^he`gZ[ueZ
\k_eblv kljZo \ k_j^pZ _s_ g_ ihdhj_gguo [_^mbgh\ b h[e_]
qblv aZ\h_\Zgb_ hklZevguo ]hjh^h\ Ob^`ZaZ Ihke_ lh]h dZd
Omk_cghldZaZekyijh^ZlvIZe_klbgm_\j_yfZg]ebckdb_\eZk
lbj_rbebex[hcp_ghcebrblv_]hij_klheZb\ebygbyZwlh
lj_[h\Zeh agZqbl_evgh]h djh\hijheblby Omk_cg hldZaZeky
ijbgylvgZrblj_[h\ZgbybgZklhyegZlhfqlh`_eZ_llhevdh
h[t_^bg_gby\k_oZjZ[kdboa_f_evih^k\h_c\eZklvxª203.
>hdlhj KZeZo Ze-=ZddZ^ ©>`ZabjZ Ze-]ZjZ[ nb Ze-]Zkj Ze-oZ^bkª Bg
klblmlbkke_^h\ZgbcZjZ[kdhcbklhjbbbdmevlmjuDZbj]KG_l
khfg_gby\lhfqlhZr-RZjbnOmk_cglZd`_kem`behjm^b_fojbklbZgb
bm^__\<qZklghklbdh]^ZFZdfZohgij_^klZ\bl_ev[jblZgkdbo\eZkl_c\
DZbj_ ij_^eh`be _fm \h_\Zlv ijhlb\ HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb b h[t_^bgblv
ZjZ[kdb_a_febhg\ujZabek\h_ihegh_kh]eZkb_Ghdh]^Z_]hkugm\h[f_g
gZZjZ[kdb_a_feb\IZe_klbg_ij_^eh`beb\hklhdBhj^ZgbbhghldZaZeky
ijh^he`Zlv ^biehfZlbq_kdb_ k\yab k [jblZgpZfb b mkljhbe \hhjm`_ggh_
\hkklZgb_RZ][ZgZ]];jblZgkdb_\eZklbbkihevah\Zebijh
lb\g_]hk\h_gh\h_hjm`b_\ZooZ[blkdmxZjfbx\blh]_\]hg[ue
ba]gZgbaOb^`ZaZ
203
GZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ªK
202
84
GZqbgZy k ] \ l_q_gb_ fgh]bo e_l Nbebiib [ue
hkh[uf kh\_lgbdhf \ZooZ[blkdbo \eZkl_c b \g_k h]jhfguc
\deZ^\mklZgh\e_gb_k\yabf_`^m\ZooZ[blZfbbkbhgbklZfb
Bf_ggh q_j_a Nbebiib OZbf b BafZg \h`^b _\j__\ i_j_^Z
\Zeb\ayldb\h`^yf\ZooZ[blh\Zl_\agZd[eZ]h^Zjghklbih
fh]ebbfh\eZ^_lvIZe_klbghc204;he__lh]h\]Nbebi
ib ih^]hlh\be \klj_qm f_`^m \h`^yfb \ZooZ[bafZ b ij_^klZ
\bl_eyfb _\j_ckdh]h ijZ\bl_evkl\Z Bje_ohf b >Z\b^hf [_g
=mjbhghf Bf_ggh ihwlhfm \ZooZ[blkdb_ \eZklb hdZaZeb ih^
^_j`dm fbjh\hfm kbhgbafm \ jZaf_j_ ^_kylb lukyq ^`mg_c
oh\205.
Dhg_p
Ihke_lh]hdZd\ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZ[ueb\ul_kg_guba
Ze-;jbfbbok\yavkZg]ebqZgZfbkhojZgbeZkv206<]gZ
qbgZ_lky i_jbh^ Zf_jbdZgkdh]h ijbkmlkl\by \ j_]bhg_ < fZ_
wlh]h `_ ]h^Z jZ^bh KZm^h\kdhc :jZ\bb h[ty\beh qlh ijZ\b
l_evkl\h ba]gZeh Nbebiib aZ ij_^_eu ]hkm^Zjkl\Z _fm [ueh
ij_^hklZ\e_gh ijZ\h aZ[jZlv k kh[hc \k_ k\h_ bfms_kl\h207.
Nbebiibihdbgmel_jjblhjbxKZm^h\kdhc:jZ\bb]^_ijh\_e
lj_lv\_dZlZcghmijZ\eyy]hkm^Zjkl\hfHgi_j__oZe\;_cjml
b klZe m]jh`Zlv \ZooZ[blZf l_f qlh kh[bjZ_lky jZkdjulv \k_
;he__ ih^jh[gh \ ]eZ\_ h ihfhsb \ZooZ[blh\ \ kha^Zgbb kbhgbklkdh]h
]hkm^Zjkl\Z\IZe_klbg_
205
IjbF_gZobf_;_]bg_Bje_oaZgyeihklfbgbkljZwdhghfbdb_klvnhlh
]jZnbb ]^_ aZkgylZ _]h \klj_qZ k dhjhe_f =Z[^me]Zabahf Kf Nbebiib
©LZjboGZ^`^ªGZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ªOZcjbOZffZ^©:]fb
^Zl Ze-bklb]fZjª b Zl-LZd\b ©:e-NbjdZ Ze-\ZooZ[by nb ob^fZl fZg"ª k
213.
206
:g]ebqZg_ ba]gZeb \hckdZ\ZooZ[blh\baZe-;jbfbZl_ydh[uh[b^_\
rbkv \ ] hlha\Zeb k\h_]h ihkeZ ba Ehg^hgZ ihke_ q_]h ihkhevkl\h
KZm^h\kdhc:jZ\bbimklh\Zeh^h]b[uehhldjulh\gh\v\agZd[eZ
]h^ZjghklbaZihfhsv<_ebdh[jblZgbb\ih^Z\e_gbb\hkklZgby\C_f_g_
207
Nbebiib \ ] \ \Zrbg]lhgkdhf `mjgZe_ ©:r-Rmmg Ze-oZjb^`byª
©<g_rgb_^_eZªdjblbdh\ZekZm^bckdb_\eZklbaZbog_ijZ\bevgh_jZkih
jy`_gb_]hkm^Zjkl\_gghcdZaghcaZlhqlhhgbba]gZ\Zg]ebqZgklZebjZ
[hlZlv k Zf_jbdZgpZfb b mihfygme qlh kh kf_jlvx dhjhey =Z[^me]ZabaZ
_]hfbkkby\j_]bhg_aZ\_jrbeZkv
204
85
bo lZcgu_ ^h]h\hju k BajZbe_f dZkZxsb_ky ijh^Z`b IZe_k
lbgu?]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`Zldgb]b©:cZf]ZjZ[byª©:j[Z]mgZ
]ZfZg nb ^`ZabjZl Ze-]ZjZ[ª b ©LZjbo GZ^`^ \Z lZjbo r_co
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[ª208.
<dhgp_ohq_lky^h\_klb^hk\_^_gbyqblZl_eyqlhr_co
Nbebiibijboh^blkyhlphfba\_klghfm\ukhdhihklZ\e_gghfm
[jblZgkdhfm^biehfZlm=Zjhev^mDbfmNbebiibdhlhjuch^
gh\j_f_gghkem`bejmkkdhcjZa\_^d_D=;Zdh]^Z\]_]h
jZkdjueb[_`Ze\KKKJI_l_jJZcl\k\h_cdgb]_©HohlZgZ
ribhgh\ª ih^jh[gh baeZ]Z_l [bh]jZnbx wlh]h q_eh\_dZ ?]h
hl_p >`hg Nbebiib lZd`_ [ue h[\bg_g \ lhf qlh h^gh\j_
f_gghjZ[hlZegZ[jblZgkdmxbZf_jbdZgkdmxjZa\_^db
LZdh\ [ue >`hg Nbebiib \ha]eZ\b\rbc \ZooZ[blkdh_
^\b`_gb_gb`_fu_s_g_jZa[m^_fmihfbgZlvhg_f209.
=eZ\Z\lhjZy
=_h]jZnby\ZooZ[bafZb
^bkdj_^blZpbyBkeZfZ
GZqbgZy kh \j_f_g Am Ze-OmZckZjZ FmkZceZfu KZ^
`ZoGZ^`^ZlZ[b]=ZfbjZ\iehlv^h^g_c=Z[^meeu[bg=Z[
^me\ZooZ[Z b B[g ;ZaZ ihlhfdZ B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z jZaj_
rb\r_]hm[b\ZlvfmkmevfZg\h\j_fyfhebl\uG_^`^y\ey_l
ky jh^bghc [_^ \uiZ^Zxsbo gZ ]heh\u fmkmevfZg Ih wlhfm
ih\h^m\h^ghfbaoZ^bkh\IjhjhdZk]kkdZaZgh©Hgb\uc
^mlk\hklhdZª
Ibhg_ju\ZooZ[bafZbkZfbaZy\eyxlhlhfqlh\h\j_
f_gZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z`bl_ebG_^`^Zhlklmibeb
hl BkeZfZ \ qZklghklb ba\_klguc \ZooZ[blkdbc mq_guc r_co
=Z[^meZlun ibr_l ©Hgb hldZaZebkv hl lZ\ob^Z b j_eb]bb b
I_j_\h^=mfZjZZ^->bjZ\b;_cjml[]
< dgb]_ ©Dbyf Ze-]brZj Zk-KZ]m^by ^bjZkZl Zl-lZjboby ebe]ZeydZl ZkKZ]m^byZe-[jblZgbyªijbgZ^e_`Zs_ci_jmijhn_kkhjZGZkujZZe-NZjZoZ
p_eZy ]eZ\Z ©:e-Fmed Ze-[jblZgb ]Zcj Ze-fmlZmmZ^` nb Ze-^`ZabjZl Ze]ZjZ[byªkhkb^hdhgpZdgb]bihk\ys_gZ^_yl_evghklb>`hgZNbebi
ib
208
209
86
klZeb h[jZsZlvky aZ ihfhsvx d ijZ\_^gbdZf b^heZf b kZlZ
gbgkdbfbklmdZgZfª210<©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªlZd`_]h\hjblky
hlhfqlh`bl_ebG_^`^Zm`_g_ijbagZ\Zebih\lhjgh]h\hk
dj_r_gby b g_ agZeb j_eb]bhaguo hkgh\211 ;he__ lh]h kZf
r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ aZdexqZy ^h]h\hj k B[g
KZ]m^hf\]]kdZaZe_fm©JZa\_lug_\b^brvqlh
G_^`^ih]jya\yauq_kl\_baZ[em`^_gbb" 212ª<wlhc]eZ\_fu
lZd `_ dZd b \ ij_^u^ms_c `_eZ_f ijb\_klb ijbf_ju lh]h
dZd\ZooZ[bluklZjZxlkybkdZablvbklbgubba\jZlblvg_dhlh
ju_]_h]jZnbq_kdb_ihgylby
Kihj\hdjm]oZ^bkZ©Hllm^Zihy\ylkyihljyk_gby
bkfmluǻ
<ZooZ[blu dhg_qgh `_ hljbpZxl qlh \ oZ^bk_ i_j_
^ZgghfZe-;moZjb:ofZ^hfbZl-L_jfbabj_qvb^_lhG_^`^_
dhlhjucy\ey_lkyboDZZ[hc<wlhfoZ^bk_kdZaZgh©H:eeZo
[eZ]hkeh\bgZrRZfbC_f_gªKih^\b`gbdbkdZaZeb©BgZr
G_^`^ªIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©H:eeZo[eZ]hkeh\bgZrRZf
bC_f_gªKih^\b`gbdb\gh\vkdZaZeb©BgZrG_^`^ªLh]^Z
Ijhjhdk]khl\_lbe©<G_^`^_ihljyk_gbybkfmlubf_g
ghhllm^Z\hagbdg_ljh]kZlZguª213H^gZdhwlhlnZdlhljbpZlv
hq_gv keh`gh b ^ey lh]h qlh[u ^hdZaZlv ijhlb\gh_ ke_^m_l
ijbeh`blv hq_gv fgh`_kl\hmkbebcbihclbhdhevgufbimly
©FZ^`fm]ZlZj-jZkZbe\ZZk-kZbeZg-gZ^`^byªLK–>Zfu
ijbagZ_fqlhG_^`^y\ey_lkyjh^bghckfmluh^gZdhg_\_jbf\lhqlh\k_
`bl_eb G_^`^Z [ueb\_jhhlklmigbdZfb_klvfgh]hkhh[s_gbchlhfdZd
\ZooZ[blum[b\ZebfmkmevfZgG_^`^Z\h\j_fyfhebl\ulh_klvdh]^Zl_
h[sZebkv kh k\hbf =hkih^hf Z wlh k\b^_l_evkl\m_l \ ihevam lh]h qlh \
G_^`^_[uebgZklhysb_fmkmevfZg_
211
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªLK<dhff_glZjbyogZke_^mxs_ckljZgbp_
B[g;ZrZjjZkkdZau\Z_lhjZkijhkljZg_gbbyauq_kl\Z\G_^`^_
212
LZf`_LKkmlhqg_gbyfb=Z[^jZofZgZ[bg=Z[^meZlunZba^Z
gb_\lhjh_;_cjml\ba^Zgbbwj-Jby^Zihoh`ZynjZaZ\klj_qZ_lky\
lk
213
< khhl\_lkl\mxs_c ]eZ\_ m FmkebfZ ijb\h^blky fgh`_kl\h oZ^bkh\ \
dhlhjuojZkkdZau\Z_lkydZdIjhjhdk]kih\_jgm\rbkvgZ\hklhdbmdZ
au\ZyjmdhckdZaZe©KfmlZijb^_lhllm^Z]^_\ujZkl_ljh]kZlZguª
210
87
fb;he__lh]h\ZooZ[blubkZfbijbagZxlqlhih^G_^`^hf
g_ fh`_l bf_lvky \ \b^m gbdZdhc ^jm]hc j_]bhg BlZd gZrb
^h\h^ulZdh\u
?keb fu ]h\hjbf h G_^`^_ lh bf__lky \ \b^m dhg
dj_lguc j_]bhg jZkiheh`_gguc \hklhqg__ Ob^`ZaZ ?keb lu
]h\hjbrvk\h_fmkugm©Ihah\bk\hxfZlvbadhfgZluªlhhg
dhg_qgh `_ g_ klZg_l a\Zlv __ ba dhfgZlu khk_^g_]h ^hfZ
LhqghlZd`_bG_^`^g_fh`_l[ulvjZkiheh`_g\^jm]hfj_
]bhg_
< oZ^bk_ IjhjhdZ k]k hq_gv ykgh mihfbgZ_lky
G_^`^bykghqlhhgjZkiheh`_ggZl_jjblhjbb:jZ\bckdh]h
ihemhkljh\Z Ijhjhd k]k \ mihfygmlhf oZ^bk_ kdZaZe ©B
gZrG_^`^ªlh_klvg_yauq_kdbcZfmkmevfZgkdbcDZdba\_
klgh BjZd \ lh \j_fy _s_ ijbgZ^e_`Ze i_jkZf b \hr_e \ kh
klZ\ fmkmevfZgkdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z lhevdh ijb =mfZj_ ihwlhfm
ih^G_^`^hfbf__lky\\b^mlhevdhG_^`^:jZ\bckdh]hihem
hkljh\Z
<ZooZ[bluaZy\eyxlqlhIjhjhdk]k\k\hbooZ^b
kZo]h\hjblh[BjZd_k\hxihabpbxhgb^hdZau\Zxll_fqlh
Ze->`ZfZeKZnbgb^jm]b_djmigu_kjZ`_gbyf_`^mfmkmev
fZgZfb ijhbahreb bf_ggh \ BjZd_ Gh wlh ij_^iheh`_gb_
hrb[hqgh dZd ba\_klgh gb =Zeb gb =ZcrZ gb Za-Am[Zcj gb
=Zfj [bg Ze-=Zk gb FmZ\by g_ [ueb mjh`_gpZfb BjZdZ hgb
\k_[uebmjh`_gpZfbOb^`ZaZ:ijbkfhljbl_kvd\h`^yfoZ
jb^`blh\GZnb]b[gZe-:ajZdGZ^`^Z[bg=ZfbjZe-OZgZnby
–hgbh[Z[ueb\uoh^pZfbbaG_^`^ZIhq_fmfu^he`guh[
\bgylvBjZd\lh\j_fydZdij_^\h^bl_eboZjb^`blh\[uebba
Ze-YfZfZwj-Jby^dhlhjucgZoh^blky\G_^`^_"?keb\uih
^jh[g__ ihagZdhfbl_kv k jZaebqgufb bklhjbq_kdbfb kh[ulb
yfb lh m[_^bl_kv \ lhf qlh hkgh\gufb kbeZfb oZjb^`blh\
[uebbf_gghie_f_gZba©gZr_]hG_^`^Zª
>jm]hc^h\h^\ZooZlb[h\–m[bckl\hZe-Omk_cgZ[bg
=Zeb ijhbahr_^r__ \ BjZd_ ^Z ijhdeyg_l :eeZo _]h m[bcp
H^gZdhwlhl^h\h^lZd`_hq_gvkeZ[ucKdZdbowlhihj\ZooZ
[blu gZqZeb \kihfbgZlv h[ Ze-Omk_cg_ [bg =Zeb \_^v ^h kbo
ihj hgb ^Z`_ aZij_sZeb gZ\_sZlv _]h fh]bem" <h-i_j\uo
88
m[bckl\h Ze-Omk_cgZ ijhbahreh g_ \ G_^`^_ <h-\lhjuo _]h
m[beb ih ijbdZam Yab^Z [bg FmZ\bb [bg :[m KmnvygZ lh]h
q_eh\_dZ dhlhjuc mkljhbe j_agx kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ
k]k\F_^bg_lh]hq_eh\_dZhdhlhjhf\ZooZ[blu]h\hjyl
©Yab^gZrZOmjdmk214\ZrªWlbex^baZy\eyxlqlhy\eyxlky
oZg[ZeblZfb \ lh \j_fy dZd KZebo [bg :ofZ^ [bg OZg[Ze
kijhkbemhlpZ©Hl_pg_dhlhju_ex^b]h\hjylqlhhgbex[yl
Yab^Zª GZ wlh :ofZ^ hl\_lbe ©JZa\_ q_eh\_d \_jmxsbc \
:eeZoZ fh`_l _]h ex[blv"ª Lh]^Z kug kijhkbe ©Ihq_fm `_
lu_]hg_ijhdeyg_rv"ªHl_phl\_lbe©JZa\_ludh]^Z-gb[m^v
\b^_eqlh[ul\hchl_pdh]h-eb[hijhdebgZe"215ªGm`ghhlf_
lblv qlh wlhl jb\Zyl B[g L_cfbb y\ey_lky g_iheguf ba\_kl
ghqlhbfZf:ofZ^ykgh\ukdZaZekyhijhdeylbbYab^Zkeh\Z
fb©Ihq_fm[ufg_g_ijhdebgZlvq_eh\_dZdhlhjh]hijhdeye
:eeZo"<_^v\DhjZg_kdZaZgh©B[ulvfh`_l_keb\uhl
dZ`_l_kv[m^_l[_aaZdhgb_fbgZjmr_gb_fjh^kl\_gguok\y
a_cHgb–l_dhlhjuo:eeZoijhdeyeebrbekemoZbhke_ibeª
(47:22 –jZa\_fh`_l[ulv[hevr__[_aaZdhgb_q_fm[bc
kl\h"216ªG_kfhljygZlhqlhB[gL_cfby[uej_\ghklgufklh
jhggbdhfHf_y^h\_fmijbrehkvijbagZlv©Yab^g_hlebqZe
ky j_eb]bhaghklvx b ijZ\_^ghklvxª Hibku\Zy ih\_^_gb_ _]h
\hckd\F_^bg_B[gL_cfbyibr_l©«ihke_wlh]h_]h\hckdh
\F_^bg_gZqZehm[b\Zlv\k_oWlh[uehh^ghcba\_ebqZcrbo
g_kijZ\_^eb\hkl_c b ij_klmie_gbc kh\_jr_gguo ih _]h ijb
dZamª <ZooZ[blZf ke_^m_l [he__ ^_lZevgh bamqblv bklhjbx
lh]^Z-lh hgb i_j_klZgml ij_\haghkblv Yab^Z dhlhjuc [ue
kdehg_g d Zedh]hex dZd ml\_j`^Zxl bo `_ mq_gu_217 >Z kh
Omjdmk – B[g AmoZcj Zk-KZ]^b ba\_klguc kih^\b`gbd ijhjhdZ k]k
klhy\rbc \h ]eZ\_ \hckd =mfZjZ j: dhlhjhfm m^Zehkv aZ\h_\Zlv Ze:o\Za Kf ©:l-LZjboª Zl-LZ[Zjb ©:e-DZfbeª B[g Ze-:kbj ©Mk^Ze-]Z[ZªB[gZe-:kbj©:e-DZfmkªZe-NZcjmaZ[Z^b©:lLZ^`ªZa-Am[_c^b
215
B[gL_cfby©FZ^`fm]Ze-nZlZ\Zª
216
B[gZe->`Z\ab©:j-JZ^^]ZeyZe-fmlZ]Zkku[Ze-]Zgb^ªZr-RZ[jZ\b
Zr-RZnb]b©:e-BloZn[bgom[[Ze-ZrjZnª– 64.
217
GZijbf_jB[gDZkbj\©:e-;b^Zy\ZZg-gboZyª
214
89
ojZgblgZk:eeZohlih\_^_gby\ZooZ[blh\dhlhju_ihjbpZxl
kih^\b`gbdh\\hkklZ\rbo\Zg-GZoZjZ\Zg_ghij_\haghkysbo
Yab^Z[bgFmZ\bxm[b\Z\r_]hg_\bgguofmkmevfZg218.
Djhf_ lh]h ijb kjZ\g_gbb BjZdZ k G_^`^hf fh`gh
hlf_lblv qlh BjZd y\ey_lky jZ\gbgghc f_klghklvx jZkiheh
`_gghc gZ f \ur_ mjh\gy fhjy \ lh \j_fy dZd G_^`^
ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc ieZlh \ha\ur_gghklv dhlhjh]h gZ^ mjh\
g_f fhjy [he__ lukyqb f_ljh\ DZd \b^bl_ gZa\Zgb_ ]h\hjbl
kZfhaZk_[y
<ZooZ[blu iulZxlky ^hdZaZlv qlh G_^`^ jZkiheh
`_g g_ \hklhqg__ F_^bgu ihwlhfm fu kh\_lm_f bf ihemqr_
bamqblv ]_h]jZnbx Lhfm dhfm wlh k^_eZlv keh`gh fu kh\_
lm_fh[jZlblv\_jodZjludk_\_jmb\gbfZl_evgh\a]eygmlvgZ
g__lh]^Zhgbm\b^ylqlhkijZ\ZhlF_^bgu[m^_l\hklhd]^_
gZoh^blkyG_^`^aZiZ^g__F_^bguhgbm\b^ylDjZkgh_fhj_
x`g__F_ddmZk_\_jg__LZ[md
G_dhlhju_ba\ZooZ[blh\mihfygmlu_oZ^bkuIjhjh
dZ k]k iulZxlky hlg_klb d C_f_gm Zj]mf_glbjmy wlh l_f
qlhmjh`_gp_fwlh]hj_]bhgZ[ueZe-:k\Z^Ze-=Zgkbdhlhjh]h
m[bebkZfb`_c_f_gpuH^gZdhwlhg_\_jgh\hfgh]booZ^b
kZoIjhjhdZk]kC_f_gmihfbgZ_lkydZd[eZ]h^ZlgZya_fey
Z \hl G_^`^ mihfbgZ_lky dZd bklhqgbd kfmlu GZijbf_j hl
=md[u[bg=ZfbjZ:[mFZk]m^Zijb\h^blkyqlhIjhjhdk]k
mdZaZejmdhc\klhjhgmC_f_gZbkdZaZe©LZf\_jZqlh`_dZ
kZ_lky ]jm[hklb k_j^_p lh hgZ ijbkmsZ iZklmoZf \_j[ex^h\
hgZ lZf ]^_ \ahc^_l jh] kZlZgu \ ie_f_gZo JZ[b]Z b Fm^Zjª
ijb\h^blky m Ze-;moZjb b ^jm]bo < ^jm]hf oZ^bk_ i_j_^Zg
ghf:[mOmjZcjhchlIjhjhdZk]kkdZaZgh©<hld\Zfijb
_oZeb`bl_ebC_f_gZbok_j^pZkZfu_fy]db_hgbgZiheg_gu
\_jhc b fm^jhklvx Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ]hj^hklb b \ukhdhf_jby
Ik_\^hkZeZnblu \uimklbeb hq_gv fgh]h dgb] \ dhlhjuo hijZ\^u\Zxl
wlbolbjZgh\\qZklghklbdlZdbfdgb]Zfhlghkylky©Yab^[bgFm]Z\byZefmnlZjZ ]Zeycobª ©:e-OZ^`Z^` [bg Xkmn Ze-fmnlZjZ ]Zeycobª ©:eOZ^`Z^`[bgXkmnZk-KZdZnb\Z^`Ze-oZ^ZjbnblZjboZe-BkeZfªb^j<
wlbodgb]Zo\ZooZ[blu\uklmiZxlkh[\bg_gbyfb\Z^j_kKZ]b^Z[bg>`m
[ZcjZbf_^bgp_\\uklmib\rboijhlb\wlbolbjZgh\
218
90
lhhgZmiZklmoh\\_j[ex^h\qlh`_dZkZ_lkyihdhyb\_ebqZ
\hklb^hklhbgkl\ZlhhgbmiZklmoh\h\_pªDZd\b^bl_dh]
^Zj_qvaZoh^blhC_f_g_lhhgkh\k_fg_ih^h[_gG_^`^mba
dhlhjh]h \ureb Am Ze-Om\ZckZjZ FmkZceZfZ KZ^`Zo GZ^
`^ZlZ [bg =Zfbj GZnb] [bg Ze-:ajZd b gZdhg_p FmoZffZ^
[bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ gZa\Z\rbc IjhjhdZ k]k ©ihkeZgp_fª
lZjbr219 b h[ty\b\rbc ^ha\he_gghc djh\v fmkmevfZg Wlb
n_l\u kqblZxlky ijbagZggufb bfb \iehlv ^h gZrbo ^g_c
?s_h^gbfk\b^_l_evkl\hflh]hqlh\ZooZ[bluy\eyxlkyg_h
oZjb^`blZfbkem`Zlbon_l\uhlghklbl_evghZr]Zjblh\b[Z
^blh\aZc^blh\^`Z]nZjblh\b^jm]bofmkmevfZg
?keb \u hagZdhfbl_kv k \ZooZ[blZfb ba qbkeZ ij_^
r_kl\_ggbdh\ Ze-:e[Zgb g_ bkihevamxsbfb _]h f_lh^u khj
lbjh\dboZ^bkh\lhm\b^bl_qlhbhgblh`_djblbdmxlG_^`^
\qZklghklb=mkfZg[bg;ZrZjibr_l©AgZc^Zkfbehklb\blky
gZ^lh[hc:eeZoqlhG_^`^–wlhjh^bgZjZagh]eZkbcbkfmlu
aeZ b bkiulZgbc m[bckl\Z b ]jZ[_`Z \jZ`^u f_`^m jZaebq
gufb[_^mbgkdbfbie_f_gZfb«220ª;jZlFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[
^me\ZooZ[Z r_co Kme_cfZg Zg-G_^`^b mihfbgZ_l qlh G_^`^
y\ey_lkyjh^bghckfmlubm^_ey_lwlhcl_f_p_emx]eZ\m©:rRZclZgm nb Zg-gZ^`^ª221 \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:k-KZ\Z]bd Zebeyoby«ª<wlhc]eZ\_hgijb\h^bl^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bkuIjh
jhdZ k]k b djblbdm_l b^_x [jZlZ hlghkbl_evgh ob^`ju \
G_^`^ b ijbau\Z_l \k_o bklbggh \_jmxsbo fmkmevfZg hklZ
\Zlvky \ F_dd_ b F_^bg_ G_kfhljy gZ \k_ dhgljZj]mf_glu
ijhjhq_kdb_ ij_^kdZaZgby ijhy\eyxlky \ h[jZa_ g_hoZjb^`b
lh\ :e-;moZjb i_j_^Z_l hl :[m KZ]b^Z Ze-Om^jb hl IjhjhdZ
k]k ©GZ \hklhd_ ihy\ylky ex^b dhlhju_ [m^ml qblZlv Dh
jZgh^gZdhhgg_ij_klmiZ_l]jZgbpbo]hjeZWlbex^b[m^ml
ihdb^Zlvj_eb]bxlZd`_dZdihdb^Z_lklj_eZl_lb\memdZih
ke_ q_]h hgb g_ \_jgmlky \ j_eb]bx ihdZ klj_eZ g_ \_jg_lky
h[jZlghdl_lb\_ªMIjhjhdZk]kkijhkbeb©DZdh\u`_hl
:ofZ^ [bg AZcgb >Zoeyg ©:^->mjZj Zk-kmggby nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze\ZooZ[byªK– 147.
220
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª
221
©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ªK
219
91
ebqbl_evgu_dZq_kl\Zwlboex^_c"ªHghl\_lbe©Bohlebqb_f
[m^_l [jblv_ ]heh\uª Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky Ze-:e[Zgb lh hg \ dZ
q_kl\_ hijh\_j`_gby ijb\h^bl fgh`_kl\h jZaebqguo oZ^bkh\
b\klmiZ_l\kihjkAmoZcjhfZr-RZ\br_fFmoZffZ^hfFZo
^bZe-BklZg[mebbijhqbfbmq_gufbH^gZdh_]hkihjhlebqZ
_lky hkh[hc ]gmkghklvx \_^v hg dZd b hklZevgu_ \ZooZ[blu
\ha\_ebqb\Z_llh]hdh]hihex[bebihghkbllh]hdh]h\hag_
gZ\b^_e222.
Bihke_^gbfgZrbf^h\h^hfy\ey_lkyoZ^bk\dhlh
jhfih\_kl\m_lkyhlhfqlh\G_^`^_^_\ylv^_kyluoaeZ:o
fZ^ i_j_^Z_l ©GZf jZkkdZaZe :[m =Z[^jZofZg gZf jZkkdZaZe
KZ]b^ gZf jZkkdZaZe =Z[^jZofZg [bg =ZlZ hl GZnb]Z hl B[g
=mfZjZ qlh Ijhjhd k]k ^\Z`^u kdZaZe ©H :eeZo [eZ]h
keh\bgZrRZfbC_f_gªLh]^Zh^bgbaijbkmlkl\mxsbokdZ
aZe ©: gZr \hklhd h IhkeZggbd :eeZoZ"ª B Ijhjhd k]k
hl\_lbe ³Hllm^Z \ahc^_l jh] kZlZgu \ g_f ^_\ylv ^_kyluo
aeZ´ª
Y^mfZxqlh_kebm\Z`Z_fucb[_kijbkljZklgucqblZ
l_ev aZ^mfZ_lky gZ^ gZrbfb ^h\h^Zfb lh hg ihcf_l bo \_j
ghklv Dhg_qgh lh qlh baeh`_gh \ur_ g_ y\ey_lky kljh]bf
ijZ\behfihwlhfmba\_klghqlh\G_^`^_jh^bebkvbg_dhlh
ju_mq_gu_bijZ\_^gbdb
RZldhklvhkgh\bihk\ys_gby
Ijbqbghc gZibkZgby wlh]h jZa^_eZ ihkem`be hl\_l h^
gh]hfh_]h\ZooZ[blkdh]hhiihg_glZdhlhjucgZibkZe©Yoh
qmhl\_lblvl_[_keh\Zfbr_coZ=Z[^meZlunZ[bg=Z[^jZofZgZ
[bg OZkZgZ223 ^Z kfbehklb\blky gZ^ gbf :eeZo dhlhjufb hg
KfgZrmklZlvx©LZokZ[momf^`Zfb]Zg«ª
?]h^_^OZkZgijboh^blkykughfFmoZffZ^m[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[mZkZf
=Z[^meZlunijboh^blky^_^hfij_^u^ms_fmfmnlbxFmoZffZ^m[bgB[
jZobfm <ZooZ[blu kqblZxl qlh bf_ggh hg aZklZ\be aZfheqZlv Zr]Zjblh\
Ze-BokZHgjh^beky\Z^->Zj]bb\]]bmf_j\]]
Ihke_aZo\ZlZZ^->Zj]bb\]B[jZobfiZrZi_j_\_a_]h\f_kl_khlphf
\DZbj]^_hgmqbeky\Ze-:aoZj_mmq_guo-oZg[Zeblh\ihwlhfm_]hkqblZ
xlZaoZjh\p_fIhke_aZ\h_\Zgby;Zoj_cgZ\]]dZdmihfbgZ_l
B[g;ZrZj\©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªhgaZgbfZekyjZkijhkljZg_gb_f
222
223
92
hl\_lbe Ze-=bjZdb >Zm^m [bg >`bj^`bkm Ze-;Z]^Z^bª AZl_f
hg ijb\_e pblZlm ihke_ q_]h ijba\Ze f_gy ijbkh_^bgblvky d
©rdhe_kZeZnh\ªY`_hl\_lbe_fm
©Y ijhq_e l\hc hl\_l \ dhlhjhf lu pblbjm_rv hl\_l
r_coZ=Z[^meZlunZ[bg=Z[^jZofZgZ[bgOZkZgZB[g>`bj^
`bkm224Ze-=bjZdbbf_gyhq_gvh]hjqbehqlhlug_bkihevam
_rv gZklhysmx fmkmevfZgkdmx h[hkgh\Zggmx djblbdm Lu
^he`_g[ueijhZgZebabjh\ZlvdZ`^h_fh_keh\hdZ`^h_ij_^
eh`_gb_ b gZ dZ`^h_ ba gbo gZibkZlv hl\_l ?keb lu gZklhy
sbcmq_guclhlu^he`_gijbgylvbklbgmhldh]h[ulu__gb
mkeurZe b hl\_j]gmlv aZ[em`^_gb_ \ dhlhjhf gZoh^beky ^h
wlh]h FmkmevfZgbg dhlhjhfm :eeZo ih^Zjbe lZdb_ khdjh\b
sZdZdDhjZgbkmggmh[yaZgijb\h^blvbagboykgu_^h\h^u
hkh[_ggh_kebwlb^h\h^uh[jZs_guijhlb\_\j__\bojbklbZg
Lu ij_^Ze k\h_]h r_coZ gZ dhlhjh]h kkueZ_rvky ihkdhevdm
l\hypblZlZg_khhl\_lkl\m_l^ZgghckblmZpbbgb`_yjZatyk
gxl_[_\k_ih^jh[g__
<h-i_j\uo l\hc r_co hl\_j]Z_l ^hklh\_jgu_ oZ^bku b
bkihevam_l keZ[u_ wlh m`_ kZfh ih k_[_ g_ y\ey_lky \_jguf
ih^oh^hfDjhf_lh]hhgba^_\Z_lkygZ^fmkmevfZgZfbh[\b
gy_l bo \ g_\_jbb kf__lky gZ^ bo jh^bghc ?]bilhf gZau\Zy
_]h ©lZlZjkdhc k_fv_cª b ©mgbqlh`bl_e_f ojbklbZgª225 Qlh
\ZooZ[bafZgZl_jjblhjbbwlh]h]hkm^Zjkl\ZBihoh`_qlhB[g>`bj^`bk
hq_gv kbevgh ^hdmqZe \ZooZ[blZf \ wlhf j_]bhg_ bf_ggh ihwlhfm gZ _]h
dgb]b[uehgZibkZghfgh`_kl\hhl\_lh\I_j\ufbahl\_lh\[uehl\_lhlpZ
lh]h q_eh\_dZ h dhlhjhf fu a^_kv ibr_f hg kqblZeky \lhjuf fm^`Z^^b
^hf \ZooZ[blh\ b gZibkZe dgb]m ©:e-DZme Ze-nZke Zg-gZnbk nb Zj-jZ^^
]Zey Ze-fmnlbc >Zm^ [bg >`bj^`bkª AZl_f ihke_^h\Ze hl\_l kugZ dhlh
juc[uegZa\Zg©FbgoZ^`Zl-lZtkbk\ZZl-lZd^bknbZj-jZ^^]Zey>Zm^[bg
>`bj^`bkª ihke_ g_]h hl\_l gZibkZe =Z[^meeZ [bg =Z[^jZofZg :[m ;Z
lug _]h dgb]Z gZau\ZeZkv ©DZrn lZe[bk B[g >`bj^`bkª gh \b^bfh hg
g_ m^h\e_l\hjbeky k\h_c dgb]hc b gZibkZe \lhjmx - ©:e-BglbkZjª AZl_f
_fmhl\_lgZibkZer_co:ofZ^[bg=bkZmf]]_]hdgb]ZgZ
au\ZeZkv©:j-JZ^^]Zeyrm[moZl>Zm^[bg>`bj^`bkZe-=Zgbªgm`ghhl
f_lblvqlhihke_^gbcg_ibkZegbq_]hdjhf_hijh\_j`_gbc
224
?]hihegh_bfy>Zm^Kme_cfZg>`bj^`bkZe-=Zgb
225
GZf`_^hklZlhqghlh]hqlhr_coZe-:aoZjZFmoZffZ^K_b^LZglZ\b\h
\j_fy iylgbqghc ijhih\_^b rZ][ZgZ ] ^_dZ[jy ] kdZaZe
93
dZkZ_lky BjZdZ lh \ g_f gZ\_qgh hklZebkv k_j^pZ g_dhlhjuo
kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ k]k bf_ggh hllm^Z \ureb ba\_kl
g_crb_ oZ^bkh\_^u fukebl_eb h[h]Zlb\rb_ fmkmevfZgkdmx
fukevZ\_^vhgb^_eZebwlh^eylh]hqlh[ug_^`^bckdb_[_
^mbgulh`_kfh]ebklZlvfmkmevfZgZfb^Z`_g_kfhljygZlh
qlh\G_^`^_^_\ylv^_kyluoaeZ226.
<h-\lhjuo ij_`^_ q_f ihclb ^Zevr_ \ k\h_f hijh\_j
`_gbb ohqm hlf_lblv qlh \ZooZ[blu ihjbpZy BjZd ij_`^_
\k_]h \j_^yl k_[_ DZd ba\_klgh \ZooZ[blu ]h\hjyl h k\h_c
k\yabkbfZfhf:ofZ^hfbkqblZxlk_[y_]hihke_^h\Zl_eyfb
blml`_\hagbdZ_l\hijhkZhldm^Z\ur_ebfZf:ofZ^]^_hg
`be"Hgjh^bekybmf_j\;Z]^Z^_ihwlhfm`_eZ_l_\uwlh]h
beb g_l \u h[yaZgu ijbagZlv kl_i_gv BjZdZ >Ze__ \u ml
\_j`^Z_l_ qlh dh]^Z f_ddZgkdb_ b f_^bgkdb_ mq_gu_ ba]gZeb
FmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[ZhghlijZ\bekymqblvky\BjZd
GhdZdgZfba\_klghlZfhgmqbekymZ]_glh\[jblZgkdhcjZa
\_^db Z aZl_f \_jgmeky b jZkkdZaZeqlhydh[ulmjdbijh^Zeb
_]h \ jZ[kl\h Z Zg]ebqZg_ \udmibeb DZd \b^bl_ BjZd ijb
xlbe\Zr_]h\h`^ybh[mqbeIhwlhfm_keb\uex^bq_klblh
^he`guijbagZlvkl_i_gvBjZdZgZ^\Zfb
<-lj_lvbodhg_qghr_coihiulZekydZdfh`ghkbevg__
hq_jgblvBjZdb\kihfgbeqlhbf_ggh\BjZd_ihy\bebkvoZ
jmjblu^`Zofblufm]lZabeblukmnbbbrbbluijhihke_^
gbo hg ibr_l ©JZa\_ g_ ihkl_kgyxlky wlb ex^b lh]h nZdlZ
qlh ihfhsv fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZg :f_jbd_ b ;jblZgbb \ hi_jZpbb ©Ebk
imklugbªgZijZ\e_gghcijhlb\BjZdZy\ey_lkyg_^himklbfhcb\qZklgh
klb _]h keh\Z ©Gb h^gh ZjZ[kdh_ ]hkm^Zjkl\h g_ \ijZ\_ iha\heylv \jZ]Zf
gZiZ^Zlv gZ fmkmevfZg kh k\h_c l_jjblhjbb wlh y\ey_lky aZij_lguf oZ
jZfª Dlh ba \Zrbo g_^`^bckdbo mq_guo ij_\haghkysbo ehamg]b kZeZ
nbafZ kihkh[_g ba^Zlv ih^h[gmx kf_emx n_l\m" G_ aZ[u\Zcl_ qlh dh]^Z
\u \ G_^`^_ kb^_eb [_a _^bgh]h ^bjo_fZ \ dZjfZg_ bf_ggh ?]bi_l rbe
dbk\m ^ey DZZ[u Fu agZ_f ihq_fm \ZooZ[blulZdkbevghg_gZ\b^yl?]b
i_l ^_eh \ lhf qlh bf_ggh _]bi_lkdh_ \hckdh mgbqlh`beh i_j\h_ \ZooZ
[blkdh_ ]hkm^Zjklh\ B[g ;ZrZj ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª
ibr_l ©b ihke_ wlh]h h[blZl_eb G_^`^Z klZeb ih k\h_c kl_i_gb gb`_
jZ[h\ª
226
WlhloZ^bki_j_^Ze:ofZ^b\k__]hi_j_^ZlqbdbgZ^_`gu_ex^b
94
qlh FmkZceZfZ ih[u\Ze \ bo a_feyoª ?]h ihabpby b ^h\h^u
hq_gv^Ze_dbhlbklbgujZa\_fh`ghkjZ\gb\Zlvrbblh\ij_
^Zgghex[ysboIjhjhdZk]kb_]hk_fvxbl_odlhh[ty\be
k_[yijhjhdhfbhlklmib\hl\_jum[b\Zekih^\b`gbdh\Ijh
jhdZ k]k" Bf_ggh ihke_ \hcgu k \_jhhlklmigbdZfb dh]^Z
ih]b[ebfgh]b_agZlhdbDhjZgZ=mfZjgZqZe[hylvkylh]hqlh
DhjZg[m^_lml_jygDZd\b^bl_gZrhiihg_glkbevghaZ[em`
^Z_lky
>Zb\p_ehfyg_\b`mkfukeZ\gh\vhijZ\^u\ZlvBjZd
KdZaZggh]h\ur_m`_^hklZlhqghqlh[uihagZlvkl_i_gvwlh]h
j_]bhgZ GZr hiihg_glbf__lkdehgghklvhl^Z\Zlvij_^ihql_
gb_h^ghfmj_]bhgm\ms_j[^jm]hfmijbq_fhgg_ijb\h^bl
gbdZdbo ijb_fe_fuo rZjbZlkdbo ^h\h^h\ MihfbgZy kl_i_gv
G_^`^Z hg ibr_l ©DZ`^hfm jZamfghfm q_eh\_dm ykgh qlh
`bl_eb G_^`^Z ih k\h_c kl_i_gb \ur_ `bl_e_c ^jm]bo gZk_
e_gguoimgdlh\bwlZkl_i_gvkhojZgyeZkv^hlh]hdZd\l_gZ
k_e_ggu_imgdluih_oZebkZoZ[umq_gu_b\_jmxsb_ªH^bg
bakih^\b`gbdh\IjhjhdZk]khlijZ\bekydh^ghfmbaZjZ[
kdboie_f_gqlh[uijba\ZlvbodBkeZfmh^gZdhl__]hih[b
ebbdh]^Zkih^\b`gbd\_jgmekydIjhjhdmk]klhIjhjhd
k]k kdZaZe _fm ©?keb [u lu ih_oZe d `bl_eyf HfZgZ lh
hgbgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_ih[beb[ubg_h[jm]Zeb[ul_[yªDZd
\b^bl_\wlhfoZ^bk_Ijhjhdk]kmihfbgZ_lhij_\hkoh^kl
\_HfZgZLhqghlZd`_Ijhjhdk]khq_gvohjhrhhlau\Zeky
h `bl_eyo C_f_gZ227 Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky [_^mbgh\ lh DhjZg gZ
ijhlb\h[\bgy_lbo\g_\_jbbbebp_f_jbb©;_^mbgu-mihj
g_crb_ \ g_\_jbb b ebp_f_jbb b gZb[he__ kdehggu_ g_ ijbgb
fZlvij_^ibkZgbcgbkihkeZgguo:eeZohfK\h_fmIhkeZggbdm
<_^v:eeZo–agZxsbcfm^jucªgh_kl_kl\_gghg_\k_
[_^mbgu lZdh\u ihwlhfm DhjZg ^_eZ_l bkdexq_gb_ ©Kj_^b
[_^mbgh\ _klv b lZdb_ dhlhju_ \_jmxl \ :eeZoZ \ Km^guc
^_gv b kqblZxl qlh jZkoh^m_fh_ bfb \h bfy :eeZoZ ijb[eb
abl bo d :eeZom b >gbkihre_l bf@ [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ IhkeZggbdZ
AgZcl_qlhwlhlZdb_klv>[h]hm]h^gu_jZkoh^u@^eygbo–
227
MZe-;moZjbb^jm]bo
95
kj_^kl\h ijb[eb`_gby >d :eeZom@ :eeZo hk_gbl boK\h_cfb
ehklvx\_^v:eeZo–ijhsZxsbcfbehk_j^gucªDjhf_
lh]hIjhjhdk]kkhh[sbeqlh[_^mbguy\eyxlkygZb[he__
`_klhdhk_j^gufb q_jkl\ufb ex^vfb ©GZb[he__ q_jkl\ufb
k_j^pZfbh[eZ^ZxliZklmob\_j[ex^h\hgb`b\mllZf]^_ih
y\blky jh] kZlZgu \ JZ[b]Z b Fm^Zjª b ^jm]hc oZ^bk
©«gZb[he__]hj^_eb\ufbb\ukhdhf_jgufby\eyxlkyiZklmob
\_j[ex^h\ª228 ;he__ lh]h kZf B[g ;ZrZj aZy\ey_l ©Fgh]b_
ba gbo hklZ\beb fhebl\m b ihklª229 b ^jm]Zy pblZlZ ©Fgh]b_
ba gbo e_]dhfuke_ggu \ hlghr_gbb fhebl\u b ihklZ \ f_kyp
JZfZaZg >ey gbo wlhl \_ebdbc f_kyp mih^h[beky h[uqguf
emgguf f_kypZf Hgb [ueb ^Ze_db hl ^jm]bo gZk_e_gguo
imgdlh\ihwlhfm\bokj_^_jZkijhkljZgbehkvg_\_`_kl\hª230.
LZdh\ufklZehiheh`_gb_`bl_e_cG_^`^ZkjZam`_ihke_iZ
^_gbyi_j\h]hKZm^bckdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\ZDZd`_ihke_wlh]h\u
fh`_l_ml\_j`^Zlvqlh`bl_ebG_^`^Zihk\h_ckl_i_gbij_
\hkoh^yl `bl_e_c ^jm]bo fmkmevfZgkdbo j_]bhgh\ G_m`_eb
\Zk g_ m^h\e_l\hjyxl ^h\h^u ba DhjZgZ b kmggu" : fh`_l
[ulv_^bgkl\_ggh\_jguf^h\h^hf^ey\Zky\eyxlky\ukdZau
\ZgbyB[gL_cfbbb_]hmq_gbdh\"
?keb \u ij_^ihqblZ_l_ ba[bjZlv h^gb oZ^bku b hl\_j
]Zlv^jm]b_lh\Zfke_^m_lij_`^_\k_]hbaqbkeZihqblZ_fuo
]hjh^h\ bkdexqblv F_ddm ihkdhevdm bf_ggh __ `bl_eb ijb
qbgyeb \j_^ Ijhjhdm k]k b ba]gZeb _]h Ihwlhfm m\Z`Z_
fu_ [jZlvy gZf ij_`^_ \k_]h g_h[oh^bfh ke_^h\Zlv ^h\h^Zf
k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ Bf_ggh gZ hkgh\_ l_dklh\ fu ^he`gu
ijbgbfZlv h^gb gZk_e_ggu_ imgdlu \ dZq_kl\_ ihqblZ_fuo Z
^jm]b_\dZq_kl\_bklhqgbdZihljyk_gbcbkfmlu
<-q_l\_jluor_coijb\h^bloZ^bkuhl:[mOmjZcju\
dhlhjuoIjhjhdk]kohjhrhhlau\Z_lkyhie_f_gZoLZfbf
LZcbAZoeRb[ZghdZaZ\rbo_fmk]k[hevrmxih^^_j`dm
\h \j_fy ^`boZ^Z b \aylby g_dhlhjuo ]hjh^h\ H^gZdh \gh\v
KfmZe-;moZjbb^jm]bo
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª
230
LZf`_
228
229
96
_]h ^h\h^u kebrdhf ih\_joghklgu hg g_ mq_e qlh qe_gZfb
wlboie_f_g[uebg_lhevdh`bl_ebG_^`^ZghbZjZ[u^jm]bo
j_]bhgh\ djhf_ lh]h ke_^m_l hlf_lblv qlh ^`boZ^ y\ey_lky
h[yaZgghklvx dZ`^h]h a^hjh\h]h fmkmevfZgbgZ ihwlhfm _keb
[ug_dhlhju_baie_f_gg_\uklmibeb[ugZ^`boZ^lhgZgbo
e_]eh[uiylghihahjZOhq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhwlbf`_^h\h^hf
r_coijhlb\hj_qblkZfhfmk_[_<_^vkj_^bih\klZgp_\OZjm
ju dhlhjuo r_co ihghkbl [ueb kih^\b`gbdb =Z[^meeZ [bg
<Zo[Zj-JZkb[bbRZ^`ZjZ[bg:mnbh^bgbamqZklgbdh\;Z^
jZijbq_fhgbh[Zijhbkoh^bebbaie_f_gbLZfbfihwlhfmg_
ihgylgho\Zeblebr_cowlhie_fybeb`_ihjbpZ_l"FukZfb
dhg_qgh`_g_hljbpZ_fkl_i_gbie_f_gbLZfbf\_^vbawlh]h
ie_f_gb\ureblZdb_kih^\b`gbdbdZd=Z[^meeZ[bgB[Z^h
dhlhjuo :eeZo kdZaZe ©Kj_^b [_^mbgh\ _klv b lZdb_ dhlh
ju_ \_jmxl \ :eeZoZ \ Km^guc ^_gvª < ex[hf kemqZ_
ex^_cke_^m_lkm^blvihboihklmidZf\_^v\DhjZg_kdZaZgh
©DZ`^hfmq_eh\_dmFugZ^_ebgZr_xkibkhdkm^v[ub\>_gv
\hkdj_k_gby ij_^klZ\bf _]h _fm \ \b^_ jZa\_jgmlh]h k\bldZª
B \hh[s_ ohq_lky hlf_lblv qlh ijbgZ^e_`ghklv d
ba\_klghfmbm\Z`Z_fhfmie_f_gbij_^:eeZohfg_bf__lgb
dZdh]h agZq_gby \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ kZfufb ihqblZ_fufb
[ueb [u \h`^b dmjZcrblh\ >Z fu m\Z`Z_f ie_f_gZ LZfbf
LZcbbOZ\Zabgmihfygmlu_\oZ^bkZoghwlhgb\dh_fkemqZ_
g_ fh`_l hljbpZlv oZ^bku ij_^mij_`^Zxsb_ gZk h kfmlZo
G_^`^Z
<-iyluo r_co ibr_l ©<h \k_ \j_f_gZ emqrbfb k_e_
gbyfb [ueb l_ ]^_ agZeb b kh[ex^Zeb ijhjhq_kdmx kmggm Z
om^rbfb[uebl_]^_kmggmIjhjhdZk]kg_agZebbg_kh
[ex^Zebǻ>Zwlbkeh\ZdjZkb\uh^gZdhbfbihevamxlkyl_
dlh`_eZ_l\u^Zlvk\h_mq_gb_aZbklbggh_Bfbihevah\Zebkv
b bo ij_^r_kl\_ggbdb dhlhju_ h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gghc djh\v
fmkmevfZgbijba\Zeb\k_oihdb^ZyF_ddmbF_^bgmi_j_k_
eylvky \ G_^`^231 qlh[u ih[jblv ]heh\u b \ujZklblv gh\u_
\hehku dhlhjuo g_ dhkgmeky rbjd Lhqgh lZdbf `_ iml_f
231
H[wlhcob^`j_ibr_lB[g;ZrZjkf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªb
97
b^ml b ihke_^h\Zl_eb wlh]h q_eh\_dZ gZau\Zxsb_ F_^bgm
=heeb\m^hf232.
<-r_kluo r_co ijb\h^bl jb\Zyl hl Zl-LZ[ZjZgb \ dh
lhjhf kdZaZgh ©Ihk_lbe B[ebk BjZd b hlijZ\be \ g_f k\hx
gm`^maZl_fhggZijZ\beky\RZfgh_]hba]gZebhllm^Zih
ke_wlh]hhggZijZ\beky\?]bi_lkg_klZfycphbag_]h\uem
ibekypuie_ghdb?]bi_lgZihegbeky^`bggZfbªWlhljb\Zyl
keZ[ucbklhqdbaj_gbyl_dklZbklhqdbaj_gbyp_ihqdbi_j_
^Zlqbdh\ >hklZlhqgh lh]h qlh \ wlhc p_ihqd_ _klv OZjfZeZ
[bgYotyhdhlhjhfB[gFm]bgkdZaZe©YkeurZehg_flZdb_
\_sb dhlhju_ ^Z`_ mihfbgZlv g_ijbebqghª Zj-JZab kdZaZe
©Wlhlq_eh\_dg_fh`_lkem`blv\dZq_kl\_^h\h^Zª233IhdZ
dhfm `_ ijZ\m \u ijbgbfZ_l_ _]h oZ^bku" Y g_ ohqm ih^gb
fZlv\hijhkjZagh]eZkbchlghkbl_evgh^hklh\_jghklboZ^bkh\
ihkdhevdmwlhij_jh]Zlb\Zmq_guoZe-:aoZjZghfg_lhqghba
\_klgh qlh gZb[he__ yjufb ijhlb\gbdZfb B[g L_cfbb [ueb
mq_gu_ RZfZ bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy bo n_l\_ hg [ue ihkZ`_g \
lxjvfm]^_bmf_jHgbbk_]h^gyy\eyxlkyibhg_jZfbZglb
\ZooZ[blkdh]h ^\b`_gby h^ghc ba dgb] gZibkZgguo bfb y\
ey_lky©:k-KZeZnbyeyckZlfZaoZ[ZgbkeZfbygª©KZeZnbafg_
y\ey_lkyh^ghcbafmkmevfZgkdbordheªIhwlhfmagZcl_qlh
ijb\_^_gguc\ZfboZ^bkij_`^_\k_]hjZ[hlZ_lijhlb\\ZkG_
h[fZgu\Zcl_kv^_gv]Zfb\_^v_klvex^bdhlhju_g_ijh^Zxl
k\hxj_eb]bxaZ^_gv]b
<-k_^vfuoaZl_fgZrhiihg_gl_s_jZaijb[_]Z_ldoZ
^bkmhlZl-LZ[ZjZgb]^_mihfbgZ_lky©gZrBjZdªb]h\hjblky
hihljyk_gbyobkfmlZoAgZcl_`_qlh\p_ihqd_wlh]hoZ^bkZ
_klv h[fZgsbd Ze-OZkZg [bg =Zeb eZ-FZ]fZjb kf h g_f \
©EbkZgZe-fbaZgªghf_j©:e-DZfbenb^m]ZnZZjjb^`Zeª ghf_j >`Z]nZj [bg Ze->`mgZc^ b ZjJZabkdZaZebqlhwlhlq_eh\_d[uee`_phfDZd\b^bl_gZrb
Fgh]b_fheh^u_\ZooZ[blumihlj_[eyxlwlh]hkeh\h\ubkZfbm[_^b
l_kv\wlhf_kebohlvg_fgh]hihh[sZ_l_kvkgbfb
233
Kf ©:^->m]ZnZª Ze-=Zdbeb ghf_j b ©:^->m]ZnZ \Z ZefZljmdbgªghf_j
232
98
hiihg_glu \ dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Z \gh\v ba[jZeb fbjZ` dhlhjuc
jZkk_b\Z_lkyijbijb[eb`_gbb
<-\hkvfuo r_co ibr_l ©Hkgh\guf kfukehf keh\Z
©G_^`^ª y\ey_lky \ha\ur_gghklv ieZlhª >Z k lhqdb aj_gby
yaudZ wlh \_jgh h[ wlhf ibkZe _s_ B[g OZ^`Zj Gh q_]h `_
ohq_l gZr hiihg_gl" Fh`_l \ dZq_kl\_ G_^`^Z hg `_eZ_l
ij_^klZ\blv Mom^ KZnm FZj\m ]hju KbgZckdh]h ihemhkljh
\Z" Fh`_l hg `_eZ_l mih^h[blv bo G_^`^m :jZ\bckdh]h ih
emhkljh\Z"GZkZfhf^_e_dZdb_[uklZjZgbygbijbdeZ^u\Zeb
gZrb hiihg_glu qlh[u ba\jZlblv bklbgm G_^`^ hklZg_lky
G_^`^hf lZd `_ dZd C_f_g hklZg_lky C_f_ghf Z RZf hklZ
g_lky RZfhf BlZd G_^`^ – wlh ba\_klgZy f_klghklv gZ l_j
jblhjbb:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Z
D k\hbf keh\Zf ohqm ^h[Z\blv lhevdh lh qlh y bamqbe
klZju_ b kh\j_f_ggu_234 dZjlu fmkmevfZgkdh]h fbjZ kh[jZg
gu_ijhn_kkhjhfOmk_cghfFmgbkhf\©:leZk_bkeZfkdhcbk
lhjbbªbh[gZjm`beqlhba^j_\e_G_^`^hfgZau\Zekylhevdh
h^bgj_]bhg?keb\ZrbihagZgby]em[`_ihagZgbcmq_guo]_
h]jZnh\lhm^hklhcl_gZkq_klbbihagZdhfvl_kgbfb
<-^_\yluo \ dhgp_ gZr hiihg_gl mdZau\Z_l qlh Fm
oZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[hagZdhfbekykljm^ZfbB[gL_cfbb
b B[g Ze-DZcbfZ dhlhju_ _]h ih^lhedgmeb d \hkklZgbx235
ijhlb\pZjb\rboihjy^dh\dZdkdZaZgh\pblZl_©Hg\hkklZe
qlh[u [hjhlvky k eh`vx wlbo \_jhhlklmigbdh\ b yauqgbdh\
qlh[ujZa\_ylvkhfg_gbybomq_guobihke_^h\Zl_e_cbordh
euª<^jm]hcpblZl_kdZaZgh©Hgj_rbehl\_lblvwlbh[fZg
sbdZf ihdehgyxsbfky fh]beZf b \ha\_ebqb\Zxsbf kha^Z
gby\f_kl_k:eeZohfªF_gym^b\ey_lih^h[gZy[_ajZkkm^gZy
kf_ehklv dZd \u fh`_l_ gZau\Zlv g_\_jgufb fmkmevfZg g_
bf_y gbdZdbo ykguo ^h\h^h\" Ba\_klgh qlh FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[ h[\bgbe \ yauq_kl\_ =mkfZgZ [bg OZf^Z [bg
FZ]fZjZbm[be_]hdh]^Zlhl\uklmiZekiylgbqghcijhih\_
Kf:leZkWgdZjlZ
>Zyg_khfg_\Zxkv\lhfqlhwlbdgb]bhdZaZebgZg_]h\ebygb_H^gZ
dhijhlb\dh]h`_hg\hkklZe"Ijhlb\lbjZgh\beb`_ijhlb\[_aaZsblguo
ex^_c"
234
235
99
^vx\f_q_lbY^mfZx\Zfg_ke_^m_lgZihfbgZlvqlhij_^
ibku\Z_l rZjbZl aZ ij_^gZf_j_ggh_ m[bckl\h <ZooZ[blkdh_
^\b`_gb_ihy\behkv\G_^`^_bijhebehdjh\vfgh]bog_\bg
guo ex^_c \u kZfb ijbagZeb qlh \Zr g_^`^bckdbc gZjh^
[ueih]jyarbf\yauq_kl\_Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyF_ddbbF_^bgu
lhyg_^mfZxqlh\uh[\bgbl___`bl_e_c\wlhf]j_o_<blh
]_ fu ijboh^bf d \u\h^m qlh G_^`^ ih^ ij_^\h^bl_evkl\hf
FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ih\lhjgh hlklmibeky hl j_eb
]bbihq_fm`_\uijh^he`Z_l__]haZsbsZlv"
<-^_kyluo y [eZ]h^Zjx k\h_]h hiihg_glZ aZ lh qlh hg
ijbau\Z_lf_gydkZeZnblkdhcZdu^_^Zygm`^Zxkv\h[eZ]_
gh g_ ke_^m_l aZ[u\Zlv qlh \ hkgh\_ rdheu fh_]h hiihg_glZ
e_`bl mq_gb_ B[g L_cfbb Z \ hkgh\_ fhbo m[_`^_gbc – gZ
ke_^b_ ba[jZggh]h b qbkl_cr_]h ba ijhjhdh\ i_j_^Zggh_ bf
kih^\b`gbdZf Z hl gbo lZ[b]bgZf Djhf_ g_]h y lZd`_ bf_x
[h`_kl\_ggh_ ibkZgb_ dhlhjh_ gbdh]^Z g_ [m^_l bkdZ`_gh
BkeZfhk\h[h^beq_eh\_dZhldhfie_dkZke_^h\ZgbyaZij_^dZ
fb b \_e_e ke_^my ijbf_jm IjhjhdZ k]k kem`blv :eeZom
©IhkeZggbd:eeZoZ–h[jZaph\ucijbf_j^ey\Zk^eyl_odlh
\haeZ]Z_lgZ^_`^ugZ:eeZoZ>\_jbl\ijboh^@Km^gh]h^gyb
ihfbgZ_l:eeZoZfgh]hdjZlghªihwlhfmfmkmevfZgbg
g_ ^he`_g ke_^h\Zlv aZ b^hehf ih bf_gb B[g L_cfby lhevdh
lh]^Z_]hj_eb]by[m^_l\_jghc<u`_\dZq_kl\_ijbf_jZba
[bjZ_l_ bf_ggh B[g L_cfbx b _]h mq_gbdh\ b gZau\Z_l_ wlh
kZeZnbafhf
M\Z`Z_fuc[jZlfhcimlvhlebqZ_lkyl_fqlhyke_^mx
aZIjhjhdhfk]kbg_ij_^ihqblZx_fmfg_gbymq_guo_k
eb bo fg_gby \_jgu y bo ijbgbfZx _keb g_l lh hl\_j]Zx
F_`^m fghc b fhbf =hkih^hf g_l gbdZdh]h ihkj_^gbdZ Qlh
`_dZkZ_lkyl\h_]himlblhhghkgh\ZggZfg_gbbq_eh\_dZih
bf_gb B[g L_cfby lu kqblZ_rv qlh DhjZg b kmggm ke_^m_l
ihgbfZlv lhevdh q_j_a ijbafm ihgbfZgby kZeZnh\236 AgZcl_
Wlbkeh\Zihklhygghih\lhjyxlfgh]b_kZeZnblu_]h`_ijhiZ]Zg^bjm
_lh^bgbabor_coh\=Z[^jZobfZl-LZooZgAgZcl_`_qlh\k_[eZ]h\ke_
^h\Zgbb DhjZgm b kmgg_ ijhjhdZ k]k DZdh\hc `_ [m^_l gZrZ j_eb]by
_keb fu ihke_^m_f aZ B[g L_cfb_c b _]h mq_gbdZfb ijhih\_^gbdZfb kZ
236
100
qlh \k_ [eZ]h \ ke_^h\Zgbb DhjZgm b kmgg_ qlh `_ dZkZ_lky
B[gL_cfbbbB[gZe-DZcbfZlh_keb[uhgb[uebaZsbs_gu
hl hrb[hd lh klZeb [u ijhjhdZfb gZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ hgb kh
\_jrbeb]jm[_crb_hrb[dbBf_gghhgbaZy\bebqlhbyauq
gbdb b g_\_jgu_ ^hklhcgu jZckdhc gZ]jZ^u lh]^Z aZq_f `_
\Zf[hjhlvkykyauqgbdZfbb\hh[s_qlh`_ij_^klZ\ey_lkh
[hcyauq_kl\h\\Zr_fihgbfZgbb"
DZd \b^bl_ ^hjh]b_ qblZl_eb \ZooZ[blkdh_ mq_gb_
bf__l rZldmx hkgh\m hgh ihkljh_gh gZ nZgZlbqghf ke_^h\Z
gbbB[gL_cfbbdhlhjucg_[ueaZsbs_ghlhrb[hdhgb_]h
ihke_^h\Zl_eb \klj_qZy oZ^bku ijhlb\hj_qZsb_ bo mq_gbx
bkdZ`ZebboZ\_^vwlhgZ]eZyij_^gZf_j_ggZyeh`v\hlghr_
gbbIjhjhdZk]k
<gbfZgb_iZfylgbdbklhjbb
H^_ygbyo\ZooZ[blh\\emq_aZjghcF_^bg_
KkZfh]hgZqZeZwdki_^bpbb\hklhdh\_^h\\fmkmevfZg
kdbo kljZgZo bkke_^h\Zeb jZaebqgu_ yauq_kdb_ bklhjbq_kdb_
iZfylgbdb H^ghc ba p_e_c wlbo wdki_^bpbc [ueh \g_k_gb_
f_`^hmkh[bpu\jy^ufmkmevfZgBf_ggh[eZ]h^ZjybfqZklv
fmkmevfZg [ueZ h[ty\e_gZ ihlhfdZfb nZjZhgZ qZklv ihlhf
dZfb`bl_e_c<Z\behgZqZklv–Zkkbjbcp_\qZklv–rmf_jh\b
lZd ^Ze__ H^gb gZjh^u hdZaZebkv ihlhfdZfb Z^blh\ ^jm]b_
kZfm^blh\ lh _klv \hklhdh\_^u ohl_eb ihdZaZlv qlh ydh[u
jZaebqgu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ gZjh^u \hh[s_ gbqlh g_ h[t_^bgy
_l
>Z fu \k_ wlh ihgbfZ_f Wlb ex^b iulZebkv \\_klb
fmkmevfZg \ aZ[em`^_gb_ ihlhfm qlh BkeZf y\ey_lky dhgdm
j_glhfbijhlb\gbdhfaZiZ^ghcbm^_ckdh-ojbklbZgkdhcpb\b
ebaZpbbBihdm^Zfu\b^bfwlh]hdhgdmj_glZmgZk_klv\ha
fh`ghklv _fm ijhlb\hklhylv Gh qlh ^_eZlv k l_fb dlh gZiZ
^Z_l gZ gZrm fmkmevfZgkdmx pb\bebaZpbx bagmljb" Qlh ^_
eZlv k l_fb dlh mgbqlh`Z_l fmkmevfZgkdb_ bklhjbq_kdb_ bk
eZnbafZdhlhju_[ueb^Ze_dbg_lhevdhhl\j_f_gkih^\b`gbdh\ghblZ
[b]bgh\"
101
lhqgbdbbaZ[hlblkyhkhojZg_gbbbm^_ckdbo">Z\IZe_klbg_
_\j_bjZajmrZxlfmkmevfZgkdb_iZfylgbdbbklhjbbghd\_
ebqZcr_fmkh`Ze_gbxlh`_kZfh_ijhbkoh^blgZa_fe_^\mo
\_ebqZcrbofmkmevfZgkdbok\ylugvHkh[_gghkbevghwlh\u
jZ`_gh\F_^bg_bf_gghlZf\ZooZ[bluijbeh`bebk\hbmkb
eby \ mgbqlh`_gbb fmkmevfZgkdbo bklhjbq_kdbo iZfylgbdh\
Dhfm-lh ljm^gh ijbgylv lh qlh y ]h\hjx h^gZdh wlh lZd b
gb`_[m^mlijb\_^_guijbf_ju
< F_^bg_ \ZooZ[blZfb [ueb mgbqlh`_gu fgh]b_ bklh
jbq_kdb_iZfylgbdbfu[ukh]eZkbebkv_keb[ubojZajmrZ
eb ^ey lh]h qlh[u m\_ebqblv f_q_lv IjhjhdZ k]k beb `_
ihkljhblv^jm]b_f_q_lbGhwlbex^bgbq_]hih^h[gh]h^Z`_
g_ aZfureyxl _^bgkl\_gguf bo `_eZgb_f y\ey_lky mgbqlh
`_gb_lh]hq_fmihbofg_gbxfmkmevfZg_fh]mlihdehgylv
ky Wlb ex^b ydh[u ke_^mxl ijbf_jm =mfZjZ [bg Ze-OZllZ[Z
\_e_\r_]hkjm[blv^_j_\hih^dhlhjuf[ueZijbg_k_gZijbky
]Z Jb^\Zg G_ aZ[u\Zcl_ qlh wlh g_ ^hklh\_jgZy bklhjby ih
lhfm qlh p_ihqdZ oZ^bkZ ij_ju\Z_lky fmgdZlu]237 JZajmrZy
fmkmevfZgkdb_ iZfylgbdb bklhjbb \ZooZ[blu \ lh `_ \j_fy
\hajh`^Zxl _\j_ckdb_ b ebp_f_jkdb_ ^Z \u g_ hkeurZebkv
BlZdgZklZeh\j_fyijb\_klbijbf_ju
F_q_lb
<ZooZ[blu jZajmrbeb fgh]b_ bklhjbq_kdb_ f_q_lb Z
\f_klh gbo ihkljhbeb Z\lhfh[bevgu_ klhygdb < qbke_ wlbo
jZajmr_gguo f_q_l_c – RZfk KZgbyl Ze-\Z^Z] =mjk NZ^uo
?klv ^hklh\_jgu_ jb\Zylu ih^l\_j`^Zxsb_ lhl nZdl qlh
Ijhjhd k]k kh\_jrZe \ wlbo f_q_lyo fhebl\u dZdh_ `_
ijZ\h bf_eb \ZooZ[blu bo jZajmrblv" B _kl_kl\_ggh g_evay
jZajmrZlvf_q_lb^eylh]hqlh[ugZbof_kl_kljhblvZ\lhfh
[bevgu_klhygdb:^h\h^uhlghkbl_evghlh]hqlhfmkmevfZg_
Wlmbklhjbxijb\h^blB[g:[mRZc[Zp_ihqdZoZ^bkZij_ju\Z
_lky f_`^m GZnb]hf b =mfZjhf Z dZd ba\_klgh lZdb_ oZ^bku kqblZxlky
keZ[ufb>Zdhg_qghZe-:e[ZgbiulZ_lkyhkihjblvkeZ[hklvwlh]hoZ^bkZ\
k\h_c dgb]_ ©LZoabj Zk-kZ^`b^ª – h^gZdh kms_kl\m_l jb\Zyl hl
B[g =mfZjZ dhlhjuc hljbpZ_l lhl nZdl qlh ex^b gZqZeb oh^blv d wlhfm
^_j_\mbdhg_qgh`_Ze-:e[Zgbih^\_j]Z_lwlhljb\Zylkhfg_gbx
237
102
fh]eb [u ihdehgylvky wlbf bklhjbq_kdbf iZfylgbdZf y\ey
xlky eh`gufb _keb [u p_evx fmkmevfZg [ueh ihdehg_gb_
bklhjbq_kdbf iZfylgbdZf lh \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v hgb klZeb [u
ihdehgylvkyDZZ[_bf_q_lbIjhjhdZk]k
>hfKZ]^Z[bgOZckZfu
Wlh^hf\dhlhjhfhklZgh\bekyIjhjhdk]kkjZam`_
ihke_lh]hdZdijb[ue\F_^bgmHggZoh^beky\^\Z^pZlbf_
ljZo h f_q_lb Dm[Z iha^g__ gZ _]h f_kl_ [ueZ ihkljh_gZ f_
q_lv dhlhjZy klZeZ bklhjbq_kdbf iZfylgbdhf k\b^_l_evkl\m
xs_fhijb[ulbbIjhjhdZk]k\F_^bgmGhg_l\ZooZ[b
lujZajmrb\rb_fmkmevfZgkdmxZdu^mj_rbebmgbqlh`blvb
bklhjbq_kdb_iZfylgbdbwlZf_q_lv[ueZjZajmr_gZ\hdly[j_
]ZgZ__f_kl_\ha\_ebZ\lhklhygdm
Dheh^pu
<ZooZ[blujZajmrbebke_^mxsb_dheh^pu
Dheh^_p :jbk238 - wlh dheh^_p jZkiheh`_gguc \ ^\mo
fbeyo hl F_^bgu239 wlh bf_ggh lhl dheh^_p \ dhlhjuc =mk
fZg [bg =ZnnZg240 kemqZcgh mjhgbe i_jkl_gv IjhjhdZ k]k
:k-KZfom^bihwlhfmih\h^mibkZe©<gZrb^gbwlhldheh^_p
ba\_kl_g dZd Db[Z _]h \h^Z kqblZ_lky kZfhc \dmkghc \ F_^b
g_ª241 <ZooZ[blu `_ bkim]Zebkv qlh fmkmevfZg_ gZqgml ih
dehgylvkywlhfmdheh^pmghjZa\_\udh]^Z-gb[m^v\b^_ebfm
kmevfZgbeb[he__lh]hg_\_jguoihdehgyxsbokydheh^pZf"
Dheh^_p =mjk242 - wlh ebqguc dheh^_p ihkeZggbdZ :e
eZoZk]khgjZkiheh`_ggZihefbeb\hklhqg__f_q_lbDm[Z
B[g KZ]^ \ ©:l-LZ[ZdZl Ze-dm[jZª243 jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf qlh
Ijhjhdk]kibebawlh]hdheh^pZb[eZ]hkeh\be_]hI_j_^Z
_lky hl B[g =mfZjZ qlh Ijhjhd k]k kb^y m djZy wlh]h dh
Kf:k-KZfom^b©<ZnZZe-\ZnZªK– 949.
B[gOb[[Zg©:k-KbdZlª
240
Ijb\h^blkymZe-;moZjbFmkebfZ:[m>Zm^ZZg-GZkZbbB[gKZ]^Z
241
:k-KZfom^b ©<ZnZ Ze-\ZnZª – K \ k\h_c dgb]_ jZkkdZam h[ wlhf
dheh^p_hghl\h^blk_fvkljZgbp
242
LZf`_K– 981.
243
B[gKZ]^©:l-LZ[ZdZlZe-dm[jZª\k\h_cdgb]_hgmihfbgZ_l\k_
[eZ]hkeh\_ggu_dheh^pubadhlhjuoibeijhjhdk]k
238
239
103
eh^pZkdZaZe©Wlhcghqvxy\b^_ekhgdZd[m^lhykb`mmh^
gh]hbabklhqgbdh\JZyª-bf__lky\\b^mdheh^_p=mjkHlBd
jbfu – hl B[g =Z[[ZkZ i_j_^Z_lky qlh Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe
©Dheh^_p =mjk – wlh h^bg ba bklhqgbdh\ JZyª hl =mfZjZ [bg
Ze-OZdZfZi_j_^Z_lkyqlhIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©>Zdheh^_p
=mjk y\ey_lky h^gbf ba bklhqgbdh\ JZy Z _]h \h^Z y\ey_lky
kZfhc \dmkghcª Dh]^Z kih^\b`gbdb hfu\Zeb l_eh IjhjhdZ
k]kihke_kf_jlblh\h^m[jZebbf_gghbawlh]hdheh^pZ244.
I_j_^Z_lkyhlKZ]b^Z[bgJZdbrZhl:gZkZ[bgFZebdZ©Fuk
Ijhjhdhf k]k ijbreb \ Dm[Z b gZijZ\bebkv d dheh^pm
=mjk Ijhjhd k]k kb^_e gZ hke_ Z fu ihiulZebkv ^hklZlv
\h^m h^gZdh \h^u g_ [ueh lh]^Z Ijhjhd k]k kihehkgme
jhl \uiexgme \h^m \ \_^jh b \uebe _]h kh^_j`bfh_ \ dheh
^_pb\^jm]dheh^_pgZihegbeky\h^hcª245<ZooZ[blu`_Zj
]mf_glbjmy k\hb ^_ckl\by hiZk_gb_f i_j_^ yauq_kl\hf jZa
jmrbeb wlb dheh^pu DZdh_ ijZ\h hgb bf_xl jZajmrZlv fm
kmevfZgkdb_bklhjbq_kdb_iZfylgbdb"
Ohefemqgbdh\bi_s_jZ]hjuMom^
J_qvb^_lhohef_gZdhlhjhfklhyebemqgbdb\h\j_fy
[bl\u ijb Mom^_ Wlhl ohef bf_e h]jhfgmx bklhjbdhdmevlmjgmx p_gghklv b ^Z\Ze fmkmevfZgZf \hafh`ghklv _s_
jZaba\e_qvmjhdbbaijbqbgihjZ`_gby\[bl\_ijb]hj_Mom
^_ fmkmevfZg_ _s_ b _s_ jZahkhagZ\Zebg_h[oh^bfhklvih^
qbg_gbyIjhjhdmk]kP_evx`_\ZooZ[blh\y\ey_lkymgbq
lh`_gb_ \k_o fmkmevfZgkdbo dmevlmjgh-bklhjbq_kdbo iZfyl
gbdh\ bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb kg_keb wlhl ohef b k_cqZk khojZ
gbeZkv ebrv g_[hevrZy qZklv Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky i_s_ju ]hju
Mom^dhlhjmxex[ylfmkmevfZg_bdhlhjZyex[blfmkmevfZg
bddhlhjhcih^gyekyIjhjhdk]kihke_[bl\uijbMom^_lh
\ZooZ[bluaZdjueb__jZaebqgufbihkljhcdZfb
Jh\bkl_gZemq_aZjghcF_^bgu
>hdZaZl_evkl\hflhfmkem`ZloZ^bkuba]eZ\u©FZ^`ZZnbZe-^`ZgZbaª
bak[hjgbdZB[gFZ^`bb\^jm]hfjb\Zyl_mB[gKZ]^Z
245
B[gOb[[Zg©:k-KbdZlªghf_j\jb\Zyl_hl:gZkZ[bgFZ
ebdZ
244
104
F_^bgkdbc jh\ ij_^klZ\eye kh[hc iZfylgbd fmkmev
fZgkdhc\h_gghcdmevlmjuIjhjhdk]kebqghmqZkl\h\Ze\
ihkljhcd_ wlh]h j\Z gh \hl ijhreh m`_ g_kdhevdh e_l dZd
\ZooZ[blu aZ\Zebeb _]h a_fe_c ?s_ h^gbf dmevlmjghbklhjbq_kdbf iZfylgbdhf mgbqlh`_gguf \ZooZ[blZfb246 y\
ey_lky f_^bgkdZy kl_gZ d kh`Ze_gbx b f_^bgkdb_ \hjhlZ b
f_q_lv gZoh^b\rZyky [eba g__ \ ] [ueb jZajmr_gu Z
\f_klhgbo[ueZihkljh_gZZ\lhklhygdZ247.
AZ[hlZh_\j_ckdbobklhjbq_kdboiZfylgbdZo
<lh`_\j_fy\ZooZ[bluaZ[hlylkyhkhojZgghklbbklh
jbq_kdboiZfylgbdh\hklZ\rbokyihke_bm^__\bebp_f_jh\
< qZklghklb jy^hf k dj_ihklvx \h`^y bm^__\ F_^bgu
DZ][Z[bgZe-:rjZnZmklZgh\e_gZlZ[ebqdZ©<gbfZgb_bklh
jbq_kdbc iZfylgbd AZij_sZ_lky gZg_k_gb_ ms_j[Z wlhfm iZ
fylgbdm ihkdhevdm hg gZoh^blky \ dhjhe_\kdhf kibkd_ bklh
jbq_kdboiZfylgbdh\‹^ZlZ]ª
QlhdZkZ_lkybklhjbq_kdboiZfylgbdh\k\yaZgguokeb
p_f_jZfb lh ohq_lky gZihfgblv qlh ebp_f_ju g_^Ze_dh hl
f_q_lb Dm[Z ihkljhbeb f_q_lv >ujZj <ZooZ[blu gZqbgZy k
fbojZ[ZjZajmrbebf_q_lvDm[ZZgZijhlb\f_q_lb>ujZjih
kljhbeb gh\mx f_q_lv dhlhjZy \dexqbeZ \ k_[y wlm f_q_lv
G_l khfg_gby \ lhf qlh rZjbZl aZij_lbe ih^h[gh_ :eeZo \
DhjZg_kdZaZe©Gbdh]^Zg_\uklZb\Zc\g_cfhebl\mª<ZooZ
[blu`_ihklmibebgZh[hjhlebrbebfmkmevfZgf_q_lb[eZ
]hkeh\e_gghcIjhjhdhfk]kb\f_klhg__\hajh^bebf_q_lv
ebp_f_jh\ G_l kbeubfh]ms_kl\Zgbmdh]hdjhf_\_ebdh]h
:eeZoZ
Qv_wlh\_e_gb_"QvybgbpbZlb\Z"
Dhg_qgh\h\j_fyijhjhdZk]kwlhckl_gug_[uehhgZ[ueZihkljh
_gZihke__]hkf_jlbghg_kfhljygZwlhhgZlZd`_ij_^klZ\eyeZkh[hciZ
fylgbdfmkmevfZgkdhcbklhjbbIhq_fm-lhg_dhlhju_ex^bij_^ihqblZxl
mgbqlh`Zlv fmkmevfZgkdb_ bklhjbdh-dmevlmjgu_ iZfylgbdb gh \ lh `_
\j_fyaZ[hlylkyhkhojZgghklbbm^_ckdbo
247
WlZf_q_lvgZoh^beZkvjy^hfk_]bi_lkdbfb\hjhlZfbZkg_k_gZhgZ[u
eZlhevdhaZlhqlhq_eh\_dihkljhb\rbc__^Ze_cgZa\Zgb_©F_q_lvNZ
lufuª
246
105
M qblZl_ey fh`_l \hagbdgmlv \iheg_kijZ\_^eb\uc\h
ijhkIhqv_cbgbpbZlb\_ihqv_fmijbdZam\k_wlh^_eZ_lky"
Hl\_l wlh ^_eZ_lky ih bgbpbZlb\_ b ijbdZam ihlhfdh\
FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z < hnbpbZevghf mdZa_ kZm^bc
kdbo \eZkl_c ih ghf_jhf F ih^ibkZgghf r_cohf =Z[
^me]Zabahf [bg =Z[^meehc [bg OZkZghf ]eZ\hc bgki_dpbb
©ih[m`^_gbyd[eZ]hfmªZfj[bZe-fZ]jmnkdZaZgh©IjbdZ
au\Zx ohaybgZ kZ^Z \ dhlhjhf gZoh^ylky ^\_ iZevfu ihkZ
`_ggu_ KZefZghf Ze-NZjbkb ebrblv wlhc qZklb kZ^Z b ij_
\jZlblv __ \ ]hjh^kdhc iZjd qlh iha\hebl gZf ba[Z\blvky hl
ke_^h\ mihfygmluo iZevfª G_ m^b\ey_l eb wlh \Zk" K dZdbo
wlh ihj ]eZ\Z bgki_dpbb ©ih[m`^_gby d [eZ]hfmª gZqZe bk
ihegylv h[yaZgghklb ]_g_jZevgh]h Zjobl_dlhjZ" K dZdbo wlh
ihjhg^he`_gj_rZlv]^_kghkblvf_q_lvb]^_kljhblvZ\lh
klhygdm"Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyl_oiZevflhagZc^hjh]hcqblZl_ev
qlh hgb y\eyxlky kZ`_gpZfb ihkZ`_ggufb kZfbf Ijhjhdhf
k]k<^hklh\_jghfoZ^bk_i_j_^Zgghf:ofZ^hfhlFZofm
^Z [bg Ey[b^Z b =Z[^meeu [bg =Z[[ZkZ jZkkdZau\Z_lky ©«\
lh \j_fy KZefZg [ue jZ[hf b ijhimklbe [bl\u ijb ;Z^j_ b
Mom^_ Ihwlhfm Ijhjhd k]k ihkh\_lh\Ze _fm aZdexqblv kh
k\hbfohaybghf^h]h\hjKZefZgjZkkdZau\Z_l³YaZdexqbek
gbf^h]h\hjqlh[m^mhk\h[h`^_gihke_lh]hdZdihkZ`mljb
klZ iZevf b hl^Zf _fm khjhd hdbc_\248 Lh]^Z Ijhjhd k]k
\_e_e kih^\b`gbdZf ihfhqv fg_ b hgb gZqZeb ijbghkblv ih
ljb^pZlv^\Z^pZlviylgZ^pZlv^_kylvjhkldh\iZevfdZ`^uc
ijbghkbeklhevdhkdhevdhfh]ih`_jl\h\ZlvDh]^Zmf_gygZ
[jZehkvljbklZiZevfIjhjhdk]kkdZaZe©B^b\udhiZc^ey
gboemgdbbyebqgh[m^mkZ`ZlvboªFhb^jmavyihfh]ebfg_
\udhiZlvemgdbihke_q_]hfuklZebih^Z\ZlvIjhjhdmk]k
jhkldb Z hg bo kZ`Ze Y deygmkv :eeZohf \ jmdZo dhlhjh]h
^mrZKZefZgZgbh^bgbawlbojhkldh\g_mf_j«³249ªG_ld
kh`Ze_gbx ^hjh]hc [jZl KZefZg \ZooZ[blu mgbqlh`beb ih
F_jZ\_kZjZ\gZy^bjoZfZfbeb]–©:jZ[kdhjmkkdbckeh\Zjvª
;ZjZgh\<D–lk
249
Ijb\h^blky m B[g =Z[^me[ZjjZ b Zl-LZ[ZjZgb \k_ i_j_^Zlqbdb gZ^_`
gu_ex^b
248
106
ke_^gb_ iZevfu hklZ\rb_ky ihke_ \Zk Ihq_fm `_ ^hjh]hc
qblZl_ev \ZooZ[blu j_rbeb mgbqlh`blv bf_ggh iZevfu ih
kZ`_ggu_Ijhjhdhfk]k"G_m`_eblhevdhwlhf_klhih^oh
^bl^eymkljh_gby]hjh^kdh]hiZjdZ"
<hllZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[blu\uihegyxlk\hxbklhjb
q_kdmxfbkkbx\F_^bg_250^eylh]hqlh[uihkl_i_gghbkdh
j_gblviZfylvh[BkeZf_\wlhf]hjh^_GZf_kl_wlbobklhjb
q_kdbo iZfylgbdh\ k_cqZk \ha\_^_gu kh\j_f_ggu_ a^Zgby Z\
lhklhygdbfZ]Zabgu^`bgkh\bkb]Zj_lkZjhfZlhff_^Z<lh
`_ \j_fy \ZooZ[blu hq_gv j_\ghklgh hlghkylky d bm^_ckdbf
bklhjbq_kdbf iZfylgbdZf dhlhju_ ijbagZgu fbjh\hc bklh
jbq_kdhc p_gghklvx b jy^hf k gbfb mklZgh\e_gu lZ[ebqdb
©<gbfZgb_IZfylgbdbklhjbbª251.
Ih^`h]ZjZ[kdhc[b[ebhl_db\k\ys_gghcF_dd_
DZd[uehkdZaZgh\ur_\ZooZ[bluhq_gvmk_j^gu\bk
dZ`_gbb b baf_g_gbb dZjlu fmkmevfZgkdh]h fbjZ hkh[_ggh
wlh dZkZ_lky F_ddb b F_^bgu >Ze__ fu `_eZ_f jZkkdZaZlv h
lhf dZd hgb ihke_ ie_g_gby dhjhey =Zeb [bg Ze-Omk_cgZ kh
`]ebfmkmevfZgkdmx[b[ebhl_dm
<h\j_fyaZo\ZlZ\ZooZ[blZfbF_ddb[uehm[blhhq_gv
fgh]hgb\q_fg_ih\bgguoex^_ci_j_^aZo\Zlhf]hjh^Zwlbo
[_^gy]g_dhlhjh_\j_fyfhjbeb]heh^hf\j_amevlZl_q_]hhgb
[ueb\ugm`^_gu_klvf_jl\_qbgmbkh[Zd252Ihke_\aylby]h
jh^Z \ZooZ[blu ihklZjZebkv mgbqlh`blv \k_ fmkmevfZgkdb_
bklhjbq_kdb_ iZfylgbdb djhf_ f_q_lb Ze-OZjZf K p_evx
©hqbs_gbyª fmkmevfZgkdh]h khagZgby \ZooZ[blu j_rbeb
mgbqlh`blv deZ^_av fmkmevfZgkdhc fukeb h^gm ba djmig_c
rbo b j_^qZcrbo fmkmevfZgkdbo [b[ebhl_d fbjZ ZjZ[kdmx
[b[ebhl_dm\F_dd_HgZ[ueZkh``_gZ
G_f_gvrb_aeh^_ygbyhgbkh\_jrbebb\F_dd_
L_fdlh`_eZ_lmagZlv[hevr_fukh\_lm_fh[jZlblvkyddgb]_=mfZjZ
=Z[^medZ^bjZ Ze-FZ]jb[b ©:e-:kZj Zg-gZ[Z\by Zeeylb oZ^^ZfZoZ Ze-omdf
Zk-KZ]m^b nb Ze-FZ^bgZ Ze-fmgZmmZjZª ©Ke_^u ijhjhdZ k]k mgbqlh
`_ggu_kZm^bckdbfb\eZklyfb\F_^bg_ª
252
KfjZa^_ehaZo\Zl_F_ddb
250
251
107
Qlh`_kh^_j`Zehkv\wlhc[b[ebhl_d_"
GZ kZfhf ^_e_ wlh [ueh [hevr_ q_f [b[ebhl_dZ wlh
[ue fbgZj_l fmkmevfZgkdhc fukeb ;b[ebhl_dZ kh^_j`ZeZ
j_^dbodgb]jmdhibk_cqZklvbadhlhjuoijbgZ^
e_`ZeZ kih^\b`gbdZf IjhjhdZ k]k b [ueZ aZibkZgZ k _]h
keh\^jm]ZyqZklvijbgZ^e_`ZeZijZ\_^gufoZebnZfb^jm]bf
kZoZ[ZfKj_^bgbo[uebjmdhibkbgZibkZggu_gZrdmjZo]Z
a_e_c dhklyo dZfgyo ^_j_\ygguo b ]ebgyguo ^hs_qdZo djh
f_wlh]h\[b[ebhl_d_ojZgbebkvj_^db_bklhjbq_kdb_p_gghk
lb k\yaZggu_ k bkeZfkdbf b ^hbkeZfkdbf i_jbh^hf253 JZa\_
dlh-gb[m^vaZ\kxbklhjbxBkeZfZkh\_jrbeih^h[gh_"254
WlZ [b[ebhl_dZ kqblZeZkv kZfhc [_ahiZkghc \ fbj_
bf_gghihwlhfm\g__k\habebkvj_^qZcrb_dgb]bkh\k_]hfb
jZbk__]b[_evxfmkmevfZg_ihl_jyebfgh]b_j_^qZcrb_jm
dhibkbb^jm]b_bklhjbq_kdb_p_gghklbHgb\k_[uebkh``_
guwlbfbex^vfbdhlhju_^Z`_g_mf_ebqblZlvbibkZlv
<hl lZdmx gbahklv b ^bdhklv kh\_jrbeh \hckdh \ha
]eZ\ey_fh_ >`hghf Nbebiib l_i_jv \u b kZfb fh`_l_ m[_
^blvky gZkdhevdh \jZ`^_[gh hlghkbebkv \ZooZ[blu dh \k_fm
qlh k\yaZgh k BkeZfhf LZdh_ hlghr_gb_ d fmkmevfZgkdhc
dmevlmj_ ijhy\ey_lky \ bo ^_ckl\byo ^Z`_ ^h kbo ihj \iehlv
^hgZrbo^g_c\ZooZ[bluk`b]Zxldgb]bfmkmevfZgkdboZ\lh
jh\ g_ ih^^_j`b\Zxsbo bo m[_`^_gby <u b kZfb fh`_l_
m[_^blvky \ wlhf _keb ijbkfhljbl_kv d ^_ckl\byf hkh[uo
ih^jZa^_e_gbc ihebpbb \ ZwjhihjlZo dh]^Z l_ ijh\_jyxl [Z
]Z` fmkmevfZg ijb[u\rbo ^ey kh\_jr_gby oZ^`Z Djhf_ lh
]h \ZooZ[blu bkdZ`Zxl b ba\jZsZxl dgb]b deZkkbq_kdbo fm
>hdlhj FmoZffZ^ =m^ Ze-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabjZ Ze]ZjZ[byZe-oZ^bkª–KGZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ª–K
254
AZy\e_gbyhlhfqlhfhg]heukh`]ebfmkmevfZgkdmx[b[ebhl_dm\;Z]
^Z^_y\eyxlkyg_^hklh\_jgufbKf`mjgZe©:e-=ZjZ[bªfZjlk
– klZlvy ©OZev ZleynZ Ze-fZ]me oZddZg fZdlZ[Zl ;Z]^Z^"ª ©>_ckl\b
l_evghebfhg]heumgbqlh`beb[Z^]^Z^kdmx[b[ebhl_dm"ªZ\lhj=Z[^me
fmg]bfZe-:]kZfKe_^h\Zl_evghwlha\_jkl\hkh\_jrbeblhevdh\ZooZ[b
lu
253
108
kmevfZgkdbo Z\lhjh\ hgb bo ba^Zxl gh i_j_^ wlbf ebrg__
m^ZeyxlZihe_agh_^eyk_[y^h[Z\eyxl
=eZ\Zlj_lvy
Bklhjby\ZooZ[bafZ
R_co FmoZffZ^ Omk_cg DZrbn Ze-=ZlZ kdZaZe ©?keb
[u wlb ex^b ijbgbfZeb ykgu_ ^h\h^u lh fu gZihegbeb [u
wlbfb^h\h^Zfbp_eu_lhfZdgb]bwlb^h\h^u[ueb[uykg__
kheg_qguo emq_c gh wlb ex^b g_ ijbgbfZxl gbq_]h djhf_
^\mo ^h\h^h\ f_qZ b ^bgZjZ >ey h^gbo fu ijbf_gy_f h^bg
^h\h^ ^ey ^jm]bo – ^jm]hcª255 < p_ehf bklhjby \ZooZ[blh\
hq_gv ijhklZ hgb [_a ijbqbgu h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gghc djh\v
fmkmevfZgwlbex^b©m[b\ZxlfmkmevfZgbsZ^ylyauqgbdh\
b l\hjyl ijhqb_ g_q_klbyª gb`_ fu ijb\_^_f k\hb ^hdZaZ
l_evkl\Z
A\_jkl\Z\ZooZ[blh\\fmkmevfZgkdbokljZgZo
©Qlh [m^_l_ \eZ^_lv b \eZkl\h\Zlv gZih^h[b_ lbjZ
gh\"ª (26:130).
Hl\ZooZ[blkdh]h^\b`_gbyihkljZ^Zebfgh]b_fmkmev
fZgkdb_kljZguKkZfh]hfhf_glZihy\e_gbywlZ]gmkgZyk_dlZ
\j_^beZfmkmevfZgZfm[b\ZeZbob]jZ[beZ<_a^_dm^Zfh]eb
^h[jZlvkyhgbk_yebl_jjhjbgh]^Zmgbqlh`Zebkvp_eu_ie_
f_gZ dZd gZijbf_j wlh kemqbehkv k ie_f_gZfb Ze-=Z^`fZg
Ze-OZ\Zeb^256b:eJZrb^wlbkh[ulby\iehlv^hKm^gh]h^gy
hklZgmlkyihahjgufiylghf\bklhjbb\ZooZ[bafZ
<ZooZ[blkdbc l_jjhj y\ey_lky j_amevlZlhf bo eh`ghc
Zdu^u eh`guo m[_`^_gbc \_^v dZd ba\_klgh kh]eZkgh bo
mq_gbx\k_fmkmevfZg_g_ihke_^h\Z\rb_aZgbfbkqblZxlky
yauqgbdZfb Z ke_^h\Zl_evgh ihky]Zl_evkl\h gZ bo `bagv
bfms_kl\hb`_gkqblZ_lky^ha\he_gguf?kebdlh-eb[h`_eZ
@mjgZe ©LmjZkmgZª ghf_j ]h^ lj_lbc RZ\\Zev ] fZc
]k
256
:ofZ^:[mOZdZ©ExfZ]Zr-rboZ[ªK–Kh]eZkghgZmqguf^Zg
gufZe-OZ\Zeb^bkq_aebkebpZa_feb\]]\f_kl_qd_=Zjbfbe
255
109
_lih^jh[g__magZlvhlhfdZdhgbh[\bgyxlfmkmevfZg\g_
\_jbblhkh\_lm_fh[jZlblvkyddgb]_©FZ^`fm]ZZj-jZkZbe\Z
Ze-fZkZbe Zg-gZ^`^byª257 ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ nb lZjbo
GZ^`^ª258Bawlbodgb]qblZl_evmagZ_lhlhfdZd\ZooZ[blu
hlghkbebkvdfmkmevfZgZfbdZdb_m`Zku\uiZebgZ^hexih
ke_^gbo G_ aZ[u\Zcl_ h lhf qlh \k_ ihoh^u kh\_jrZebkv
lhevdh ihke_ [eZ]hkeh\_gby FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
:\lhj ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª mdZau\Z_l ©Bf_ggh hg ]hlh\be
\hckdZ b gZijZ\eye bo Hg ibkZe ibkvfZ ]eZ\Zf gZk_e_gguo
imgdlh\hgb_fmhl\_qZebijbkueZeb^_e_]Zpbbbijb_a`Zeb
\]hklbHgijh^he`Zek\hc^`boZ^^hl_oihjihdZaZgbfg_
ihke_^h\Ze\_kvG_^`^ª259.
Bklhjby \ZooZ[bafZ ihegZ ih^h[guo kh[ulbc gZijb
f_j h ]jZ[_`Zo ]h^Z ] B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l ©KZ]m^
\uklmibe kh k\hbf \hckdhf \ klhjhgm Ze-OZjZ^` \ imlb hg
magZe h fgh]hqbke_gghf dZjZ\Zg_ \ur_^r_f ba Ze-BokZ b
ijbgZ^e_`Z\r_f `bl_eyf Ze-OZjZ^`Z Ze-NZj]Z b ^jm]bo ih
k_edh\ Hg kh k\hbfb \hbgZfb ih^kl_j_] dZjZ\Zg m bklhqgbdZ
Zk-KZebfZbdh]^Zlhl[ue[ebahdgZiZeb\k_omgbqlh`beª:
qlh[ueh^Zevr_B[g;ZrZj">Zevr_hgibr_l©Ihke_wlh]h
hgb aZo\Zlbeb \k_ bfms_kl\h dZjZ\ZgZ \k_ ldZgb b \_j[ex
^h\ª260.
>jm]hc ijbf_j B[g ;ZrZj hibku\Zy kh[ulby ]
] ]h\hjbl ©OZ^b [bg DZjfZeZ kh\_jrbe ihoh^ \ Ob^
< wlhc dgb]_ baeZ]Zxlky xjb^bq_kdb_ \u\h^u g_^`^bckdbo \ZooZ[bl
kdh-oZrZ\blkdbomq_guo]^_hgbijboh^yld\u\h^mqlhkh\j_f_ggu_bf
fmkmevfZg_y\eyxlkyg_\_jgufbZke_^h\Zl_evghbog_h[oh^bfhm[b\Zlv
QblZywlmdgb]m\ukZfbfh`_l_m[_^blvky\lhfdZdhcqm^h\bsgucaZ]h
\hj hgb mkljhbeb ijhlb\ \k_c fmkmevfZgkdhc mffu WlZ dgb]Z \i_j\u_
[ueZba^ZgZ\?]bil_\]]Iha^g__]]]eZ
\hc\_^hfkl\Z©N_l\ijbau\ZbgZklZ\e_gbcªih^ghf_jhf[ueh^Z
gh jZaj_r_gb_ gZ lj_lv_ ba^Zgb_ wlhc dgb]b \ ba^Zl_evkl\_ ©>Zj Ze]ZkufZª\wj-Jby^_Wlh^hdZau\Z_lqlh\ZooZ[bluijh^he`Zxlk\hx^_y
l_evghklv\wlhfgZijZ\e_gbb
258
Hg_cfum`_]h\hjbeb\ur_
259
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
260
LZf`_
257
110
`ZagZ^_j_\gxZe-;Zdmf]^_m[be[hevrh_qbkehfm`qbgQ_
j_a^\Zf_kypZhg\gh\vgZiZegZwlm^_j_\gxm[be`bl_e_cb
m\_ekkh[hcfgh`_kl\h\_j[ex^h\bh\_pª261.
?s_ h^bg ijbf_j dhlhjuc ijb\h^bl \ZooZ[blkdbc bk
lhjbdih\_kl\m_lhkh[ulbyo]]©<wlhf]h^mih
\_e_gbx lmj_pdh]h bfZfZ FmoZffZ^ [bg =ZnbkZg k hljy^hf
fmkmevfZggZiZegZdZjZ\Zgb^msbcba;Zg^ZjZ262Ze-=Zdbj\
dhlhjhf[uehg_kf_lgh_qbkeh[h]Zlkl\ª263.
<hl lZd ihklmiZeb g_^`^bckdb_ oZjb^`blu dhlhju_
g_keb fbjm _^bgh[h`b_ Hgb g_ ]gmrZebkv gb fgh]hqbke_g
guf dZjZ\Zghf gb \_j[ex^Zfb b h\pZfb gb [_kqbke_ggufb
[h]Zlkl\Zfb gb l_f [he__ djh\vx g_\bgguo fmkmevfZg DZd
[m^lhhgbg_keurZebkeh\:eeZoZ©<hbklbgml_dlh\hx_l
ijhlb\:eeZoZb?]hIhkeZggbdZbl\hjblgZa_fe_g_q_klb_
[m^ml \ \ha^Zygb_ m[blu beb jZkiylu beb m gbo [m^ml hl
jm[e_gugZdj_kljmdbbgh]bbebhgb[m^mlba]gZgubakljZ
guB\k_>wlbgZdZaZgby@^eygbo–\_ebdbcihahj\wlhffbj_
Z\[m^ms_c`bagb>`^_l@bo\_ebdh_gZdZaZgb_ª (5:33).
A\_jbg_\_^Zxsb_fbehk_j^by
<ZooZ[blulZd`_hlebqbebkvbl_fqlhgZjmrZeb^h]h
\hju\aylu_gZk_[yh[yaZl_evkl\ZHgbm[b\Zebex^_cdhlh
juo kZfb `_ \ayeb ih^ k\hx aZsblm m[b\Zeb ie_gguo264 b
klj_eyeb \ kibgm [_]ms_]h ijhlb\gbdZ265 FmkmevfZgbg ih
LZf`_
FbgZ
263
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
264
<hlebqb_hlg_\_jguoie_gguofmkmevfZgm[b\ZlvaZij_s_ghDZd\b
^bf g_^`^bckdb_ oZjb^`blu h[jZsZebkv k fmkmevfZgZfb lZd `_ dZd k
g_\_jgufb
265
DZdba\_klghwlhaZij_s_gh:\lhjdgb]b©:e-MZ^]ªk–ibr_l
©Kh]eZkghlj_[h\ZgbyffmkmevfZgkdh]hrZjbZlZfmkmevfZgkh\_jrb\rbo
[hevrb_]j_ob[b^]Zke_^m_lijba\ZlvdbkijZ\e_gbx?kebhgbih^qbgyl
kylhbf_xll_`_ijZ\Zbh[yaZgghklbqlhb^jm]b_fmkmevfZg_?keb`_
hgb g_ ih^qbgylky lj_[h\Zgbyf fmkmevfZgkdbo \eZkl_c lh ]eZ\Z \ijZ\_
h[ty\blv bf \hcgm gh ^Z`_ \ wlhf kemqZ_ ^ha\he_gghc klZgh\blky lhevdh
bodjh\v<hbgug_bf_xlijZ\ZijbdZkZlvkydbobfms_kl\m^_lyf`_gZf
261
262
111
bf_gb ;ZllZe Zk-KZoeb ihijhkbe aZsblu m h^gh]h ba ba\_kl
guo \ZooZ[blh\ ih bf_g B[g Obg^b lhl kh]eZkbeky \aylv _]h
ih^k\hxaZsblmbhgbhlijZ\bebkv\eZ]_jv\ZooZ[blh\Dh]
^Z`_hgbhdZaZebkv\rZlj_\ZooZ[blkdh]h\h`^ylhmihfygm
luc fmkmevfZgbg [ue m[bl <hl lZd \ZooZ[blu ihklmiZxl k
fmkmevfZgZfbdhlhjuokZfb`_\ayebih^k\hxaZsblm
Ijb\_^_fijbf_jlh]hdZd\ZooZ[bluklj_eyeb\kibgm
[_]ms_]h \jZ]Z \h \j_fy [bl\u Ze-YlbfZ B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l
©Hgb\_jgmebkvd`bl_eyfZe-DZkufZbk^_eZeb\b^qlhohlyl
aZdexqblv fbjguc ^h]h\hj beb `_ ih]hklblv m gbo Gh \ lhl
`_ fb] ^ey `bl_e_c wlh]h k_e_gby gZqZeky ij_`^_\j_f_gguc
aZoh^khegpZiuevklhyeZklhe[hffmkmevfZg_gZiZebgZ`b
l_e_cZe-DZkufZl_\bkim]_[jhkZebk\hbk_fvbbbfms_kl\h
Z fmkmevfZg_ bo m[b\Zeb Dh]^Z `_ ih[_`^_ggu_ gZqZeb [_
`Zlv fmkmevfZg_ [jhkbebkv bo ij_ke_^h\Zlv b l_o dh]h g_
m[bebm^Zjhf\]jm^vm[b\Zebm^Zjhf\kibgm<lhl^_gv[u
ehm[blhfgh`_kl\h\jZ]h\gZdZ`^h]h\hbgZijboh^behkvih
^\Z^pZlv m[bluo bo [ueh ^Z`_ [hevr_ q_f ijb \aylbb wjJby^ZªDZd\b^bl_\]eZaZo\ZooZ[blh\`bl_ebZe-DZkufZg_
aZkem`b\Zebfbehk_j^by^Z`_\h\j_fy[_]kl\Z<hllZdh\hg
gh\uc\ZooZ[blkdbcBkeZfLZdhgbihklmiZebkjh^kl\_ggu
fbie_f_gZfbZqlh`_lh]^Zfh]eh`^ZlvhklZevguofmkmev
fZg"
>Ze__^hjh]hcqblZl_evfu[m^_fjZkkdZau\Zlvhlhf
qlh \dmkbeb ^jm]b_ fmkmevfZg_ hl jmd \ZooZ[blh\ ijbq_f
kkueZlvkyfu[m^_flhevdhgZbodgb]b266.
Djh\hijheblb_\f_q_lyo
M`ZkZ_l lhl nZdl qlh \ZooZ[blu mkljhbeb l_jjhj ijh
lb\iZehfgbdh\\gmljbf_q_lbZe-OZjZfhlbof_q_cg_kiZk
ebkv gb klZjbdb gb `_gsbgu AZ qlh `_ hgb bo m[b\Zeb" >Z
lhevdhaZlhqlhhgbke_^mykmgg_IjhjhdZk]kijhqebkm
bg_bf_xlijZ\Zm[b\Zlv[_]msboǻ?klvebm\ZooZ[blh\ih^h[gu_aZdh
gubijbgpbiu"
266
Fu g_ ij_ke_^m_f p_evx kh[ex^_gb_ ojhgheh]bq_kdhc ihke_^h\Zl_ev
ghklb
112
jm ©:l-LZm[Zª ©IhdZygb_ª b \ujZabeb k\hc ijhl_kl \ hlgh
r_gbbbm^__\bojbklbZgLZdh\Z\ZooZ[blkdZyZdu^Zijbq_f
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[h[\bgye\g_\_jbbbyauq_kl\_g_
lhevdh ijhkluo fmkmevfZg Z h[\bgbe ^Z`_ :^ZfZ b ?\m kf
_]h dgb]m ©Zl-LZ\ob^ª ©?^bgh[h`b_ª267 <k_ wlh ^_eZehkv
lhevdh ^ey lh]h qlh[u h[ty\blv ^ha\he_gguf m[bckl\h fm
kmevfZg]jZ[_`bobfms_kl\ZbgZkbeb_gZ^bo`_gZfb>Ze__
fuohlbfijb\_klbg_dhlhju_pblZlubadgb]b©LZjboGZ^`^ª
r_coZ Omk_cgZ [bg =ZggZfZ268 \ i_j\hc qZklb wlhc dgb]b hg
ibr_l h ijhba\_^_gbyo FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z Z \h
\lhjhc – h \ZooZ[blkdbo \hcgZo269 Hl\_lkl\_gguf aZ \uimkd
wlhc dgb]b y\ey_lky r_co =Z[^me]Zaba [bg =Z[^meeZ ihlhfhd
B[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
©R_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ kdZaZe ©<hbklbgm
=mkfZg [bg Fm]ZffZj270 ijZ\bl_ev =mycgu g_\_jguc yauq
gbdª Dh]^Z fmkmevfZg_ m[_^bebkv \ lhf qlh wlh ijZ\^Z lh
j_rbeb_]hm[blvHg[uem[bl\jZ^`Z[_]bxgv]
\ f_q_lb ihke_ iylgbqghc fhebl\uª B[g ;ZrZj mdZau\Z_l
©Dh]^Zhgijhbag_kijb\_lkl\b_\dhgp_fhebl\ulhmihfygm
lucq_eh\_dm[be_]h«271ª>hwlh]hbfblhqghlZd`_\f_q_
lb ij_^Zl_evkdb [ue m[bl >ZooZf [bg >ZmmZk ijZ\bl_ev wjJby^Z dh]^Z hg [ue \ ^_j_\mrd_ Ze-=Zjb^ d g_fm [ue ih^h
keZg\ZooZ[blkdbcm[bcpZ
DZd\b^bl_wlbex^bg_]gmrZxlky^Z`_m[bckl\hffm
kmevfZg ijyfh \ f_q_lyo KZfb ih^mfZcl_ jZa\_ fh] [ulv
ijZ\bl_ev=mycgug_\_jgufbebyauqgbdhf"<_^v_]hm[beb\
f_q_lb ihke_ iylgbqghc fhebl\u272 >Z`_ kZfhfm g_\_`_kl
;he__ih^jh[ghkf\]eZ\_©Ihahjgu_kljZgbpudgb]b³:l-LZ\ob^´ª
H^bgbanZdboh\bihwlh\Ze-BokZmf]
269
1746 –]]
270
?]h [he__ \_jgh_ bfy =mkfZg [bg OZf^ [bg Fm]ZffZj B[g ;ZrZj
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
271
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^
272
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªmdZau\Z_l©qlhi_j_^wlbfijZ
\bl_ev=mycguijb_a`ZedFmoZffZ^m[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[m^eyaZdexq_gby
^h]h\hjZl_fkZfufhg`_eZeh[_ahiZkblv`bl_e_ck\h_]hk_e_gbyhll_j
267
268
113
\_gghfmfmkmevfZgbgmba\_klghqlh\i_j\mxhq_j_^v\_jhhl
klmigbdZijbau\ZxldihdZygbxZg_m[b\Zxlij_^Zl_evkdbB
jZa\_fh`_l[ulvg_\_jgufq_eh\_dm[bluc\f_q_lb"
Gh B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[m ^Z`_ wlh]h [ueh g_ ^hklZlhqgh
©Hgkhk\hbf\hckdhfijbr_e\=mycgmb\_e_ejZajmrblvaZ
fhdB[gFm]ZffZjZª273.
Ihke_ wlh]h FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ ihklZ\be lZf
k\h_]hijZ\bl_eygh`bl_eb\hkklZebblh]^Zwlhlq_eh\_d\_
e_e jZajmrblv k_e_gb_ \f_kl_ kh \k_fb `bl_eyfb b aZij_lbe
hlkljZb\Zlv _]h \gh\v274 Dhff_glbjmy wlhl ihoh^ FmoZffZ^
[bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ kdZaZe ©IjZ\bl_ex =mycgu =mkfZgm [bg
Fm]ZffZjmkdZaZebqlhgZ_]h^_j_\gxgZ^\b]ZxlkyiheqbsZ
kZjZgqbZhgihkf_y\rbkvkdZaZe©Fu\uimklbfk\hbodmj
dhlhju_ kdexxl wlm kZjZgqmª Lh]^Z :eeZo jZa]g_\Zeky b gZ
keZegZwlhk_e_gb_iheqbsZkZjZgqbdhlhju_kt_eb_]h\f_k
l_ kh \k_fb `bl_eyfbª275 JZa\_ a^jZ\hfukeysbc q_eh\_d fh
`_l ijbgylv ih^h[gh_ G_ ijZ\^Z eb \u]ey^bl hq_gv ]emih
>Z`_ _keb ijZ\bl_ev =mycgu b kdZaZe ih^h[gh_ jZa\_ wlh y\
ey_lky ]j_ohf" JZa\_ aZ wlh _]h fh`gh h[\bgylv \ g_\_jbb b
ij_^Zl_evkdb m[b\Zlv \ f_q_lb" B dh]^Z kemqZehkv lZdh_ qlh
kZjZgqZih_^ZeZkl_gu^hfh\ex^_cbijhq__"
Deygmkv:eeZohfdjhf_dhlhjh]hg_l^jm]h]h[h`_kl\Z
ih\_^_gb_ FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z hq_gv kbevgh gZih
fbgZ_l\jZ`^m\hklhdh\_^h\\hlghr_gbbBkeZfZlZdh_hsm
s_gb_ qlh hgb ihfh]Zeb ^jm] ^jm]m \ hkms_kl\e_gbb k\hbo
p_e_c
LZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZb^Ze__rebiml_f
mdZaZgguf bo \h`^_f g_ ]gmrZykv m[bckl\Z fmkmevfZg \ f_
q_lyo276[he__lh]h\ugZ\_jgh_ihfgbl_dZdhgbm[bebfm
kmevfZg^_j_\_gv;Zc^ZGZkbebZr-Rm]Zc[Z\f_kyp_jZfZaZ
jhjZ\ZooZ[blh\ghh[gh\bl_evj_eb]bb©emqrbcbaex^_cªg_ijbgye_]h
hijZ\^Zgby
273
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªB[g=ZggZf©LZjboGZ^`^ªLK
274
GZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ªK
275
:l-LZd\b©:e-NbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZgg"ªK– 32.
276
Qlh[umagZlvih^jh[g__kf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
114
g_277dh]^Zl_kh\_jrZebmlj_ggxxfhebl\mIhwlhfmg_m^b
\bl_evgh qlh \ZooZ[blu hdZaZebkv kihkh[gufb m[blv khlgb
klZjbdh\ b `_gsbg jy^hf k f_q_lvx Ze-OZjZf B g_m^b\b
l_evghqlhB[g;Zaba^Zen_l\mjZaj_rZxsmxm[b\Zlv`bl_
e_cBjZdZdh]^Zl_kh\_jrZxlfhebl\m\f_q_lbBf_gghih
wlhfmyijbau\Zx\k_oh[fZgmluofmkmevfZgh^mfZlvkybhl
j_qvkyhlwlboex^_c\_^v_keb\uihfh]Z_l_bflh\uihfh
]Z_l_m[b\ZlvfmkmevfZgZ\h^ghfbaoZ^bkh\ihwlhfmih\h^m
kdZaZgh ©Dlh ohly [u iheh\bghc keh\Z [ue ijbqZkl_g d ijh
eblbxaZij_lghcdjh\bmlh]hgZe[m\Km^guc^_gv[m^_lgZ
ibkZgh ³Ebr_g gZ^_`^u gZ fbehklv :eeZoZ´ª278 B[g =Z[[Zk
ih ih\h^m q_eh\_dZ m[b\r_]h \_jmxs_]h kdZaZe ©JZa\_ ^ey
g_]h _klv ihdZygb_" Y keurZe dZd Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe ©<
Km^guc^_gvm[bcpZ[m^_llZsblvgZk_[_m[blh]hbfq_eh\_
dZZlhlbkl_dZydjh\vx[m^_l]h\hjblv©Kijhkbl__]haZqlh
hg f_gy m[beªª < lZdhf \b^_ wlh [ueh gbkihkeZgh b :eeZo
gbq_]h g_ hlf_gyeª ijb\h^blky m Zg-GZkZb b B[g FZ^`b
:ofZ^ i_j_^Z_l hl FmZ\bb ©:eeZo ijhsZ_l \k_ ]j_ob djhf_
g_\_jbybij_^gZf_j_ggh]hm[bckl\Z\_jmxs_]hªHl:[mKZ
]b^Z Ze-Om^jb b :[m OmjZcju i_j_^Z_lky qlh Ijhjhd k]k
kdZaZe ©?keb [u h[blZl_eb g_[_k b a_feb ijhebeb [u djh\v
ohly[uh^gh]h\_jmxs_]hlh:eeZobo\k_o\\_j][u\h]hgv
:^ZªBf_gghihwlhfmB[g=Z[[ZkkqblZeqlhihdZygb_q_eh
\_dZm[b\r_]h\_jmxs_]hg_^_ckl\bl_evghFmkebfi_j_^Z_l
hl KZ]b^Z [bg >`m[ZcjZ ©Y kijhkbe m B[g =Z[[ZkZ ©Fh`_l
ebihdZylvkylhldlhij_^gZf_j_gghm[be\_jmxs_]h"ªBhg
hl\_lbe ©G_lª Lh]^Z y ijhq_e _fm Zyl ©L_ dhlhju_ g_ \au
KfjZa^_e©R_co>`hgNbebiibª
Ijb\_e Zl-LZ[ZjZgb \ ©:e-DZ[bjª hl B[g =Z[[ZkZ b ^jm]bo hl
:[mOmjZcjuijb\h^blky\\b^_©Dlhihfh]m[blv\_jmxs_]h«ª\lZdhf
`_\b^__]hijb\h^blZe-;ZcoZdb\©:k-KmgZgZe-dm[jZª:[mY]ey\
k\h_fk[hjgbd_B[gFZ^`Z\©:k-KmgZgª<k[hjgbd_bfZfZ
Zj-JZ[b]Z [bg OZ[b[Z ih^ghf_jhfhl>`Z[bjZ[bgAZc^Zijb\h^blky
oZ^bk fmjkZe ©Dlh ohly [u iheh\bghc keh\Z ihfh] m[blv \_jmxs_]h m
lh]h gZ e[m \ Km^guc ^_gv [m^_l gZibkZgh ©Ebr_g gZ^_`^u gZ fbehklv
:eeZoZªª
277
278
115
\Zxl gZjy^m k :eeZohf d ^jm]hfm [h]m g_ m[b\Zxl q_eh\_dZ
dhlhjh]h :eeZo aZij_lbe >m[b\Zlv@ _keb lhevdh hg g_ aZkem
`b\Z_l wlh]h ih ijZ\mª Hg fg_ hl\_lbe ©Wlh f_d
dZgkdbc Zyl hg [ue hlf_g_g f_^bgkdbf «: _keb dlh m[v_l
\_jmxs_]hihmfukemlh\haf_a^b__fm–Z^]^_ij_[m^_lhg
\_qgh :eeZo jZa]g_\Z_lky gZ g_]h ijhdeyg_l _]h b m]hlh\bl
_fm\_ebdh_gZdZaZgb_ª (4:93)».
G_^`^
@bl_eb Z^->Zj]bb \ha]eZ\ey_fu_ B[g KZ]m^hf b B[g
=Z[^me\ZooZ[hfgZqZebih^qbgylvk_[_G_^`^Ijbwlhfhgb
g_]gmrZykv[_aij_^mij_`^_gbygZiZ^ZebgZjh^kl\_ggu_[_
^mbgkdb_ie_f_gZHljy^u\ZooZ[blh\m[b\Zeb\k_oh^gZ`^u
hgb ih hrb[d_ \f_klh ie_f_gb =mlZc[Z gZiZeb gZ ie_fy ZjJZmdZ279 < j_]bhg_ pZjbe oZhk ^_kyldb ex^_c [ueb m[blu Z
bobfms_kl\hjZa]jZ[e_gh280K\hb^_ckl\byhgbhijZ\^u\Zeb
l_f qlh `bl_eb jZa]jZ[e_gguo k_e_gbc hldZau\Zebkv ieZlblv
aZdyl ijZ\bl_ex Z^->Zj]bb GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ hgb g_ [ueb
h[yaZgu wlh ^_eZlv ihkdhevdm `beb ih^ gZqZehf k\hbo jmdh
\h^bl_e_c
G_^`^ ba^j_\e_ keZ\beky l_f qlh [ue j_]bhghf gZk_
e_ggufih^h[gufbjZa[hcgbdZfbijZ\_^guoex^_clZf[ueh
hq_gv fZeh Fu g_ ohlbf ibkZlv h[ wlhf j_]bhg_ kebrdhf
fgh]h b kh\_lm_f qblZl_ex h[jZlblvky d i_j\hc qZklb dgb]b
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªklj4, 45, 46, 47,
>Ze__ gZ klj – hibku\Zy kh[ulby
]]Z\lhjibr_l©<wlhf]h^m=Z[^me]Zabakhk\h
bfb\hckdZfbhkZ^bewj-Jby^b^he]h_\j_fy^_j`Ze_]h`bl_
e_c \ hkZ^_ \h \j_fy dhlhjhc h\eZ^_e g_dhlhjufb [Zrgyfb
aZo\ZlbeZe-FZjdZ[bmgbqlh`befgh]bofm`qbggZk_ey\rbo
wlhl jZchg«ª ^Ze__ hg jZkkdZau\Z_l h [_]kl\_ `bl_e_c wjJby^Z b ^_ckl\byo \ZooZ[blkdbo \hckd ©Ihke_ wlh]h `bl_eb
wj-Jby^Z \h ]eZ\_ k ijZ\bl_e_f [_`Zeb \ imklugx Zk-KZ[oZ b
gZijZ\bebkv\Ze-OZjZ^`Wlh[uehe_lhfihwlhfmfgh]b_ba
279
280
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
LZf`_
116
gbo mf_jeb hl ]heh^Z b `Z`^u«281ª : \hl qlh kemqbehkv ^Z
e__©<hckdZihke_^h\ZebaZ[_]msbfbbklZebbom[b\ZlvaZ
[bjZy k_[_ bfms_kl\h Ihke_ wlh]h =Z[^me]Zaba ^ey hojZgu
^hfh\ \uklZ\be iZljmevguo hnbp_jh\ b [eZ]h^Zjy wlhfm _fm
^hklZebkv\k_^hfZbgZoh^ys__ky\gbobfms_kl\hǻ@bl_eb
wj-Jby^Z[ueboZg[ZeblZfbgh\ZooZ[blukqblZebboyauqgb
dZfb gh ^Z`_ _keb [u wlh [ueh ijZ\^hc lh \ q_f [ueZ \bgZ
^_l_c ih]b[rbo hl ]heh^Z b `Z`^u" Ih dZdhfm ijZ\m hgb
hl[bjZebbfms_kl\h`bl_e_cwj-Jby^Zbo^hfZbiZevfu282?!!
Ob^`Za
GZiZ^_gb_gZF_^bgm
Ob^`ZakqblZ_lky[eZ]hkeh\_ggufj_]bhghfihkdhevdm
\g_fjZkiheh`_gu^\Zk\yluo]hjh^ZF_ddZbF_^bgZh^gZdh
b\g_]hlh`_\lhj]ebkv\ZooZ[blu283:
Emq_aZjgZyF_^bgZ–]hjh^IjhjhdZk]k
<ZooZ[blu ke_^my ijbf_jm Yab^Z [bg FmZ\bb iha\h
eb\r_]h k\hbf \hckdZf \ l_q_gb_ lj_o ^g_c m[b\Zlv `bl_e_c
F_^bgugZiZebgZwlhlk\ys_gguc]hjh^284B[g;ZrZjhib
ku\Zykh[ulby]]mdZau\Z_l©Hgbj_rbeb\h_\Zlv
k f_^bgpZfb b k wlhc p_evx =Z[^me]Zaba \_e_e g_^Ze_dh hl
Fg_g_hklZ_lkygbq_]hdjhf_lh]hqlh[ukdZaZlv©G_l[h`_kl\Zdjhf_
:eeZoZª:\lhj\ujZ`Z_l]hj^hklvkh\_jr_ggufH^gZdhgZfba\_klghqlh
gbdlh ba fmkmevfZg g_ kh\_jrZe ih^h[guo a\_jkl\ lZd ihklmiZeb lhevdh
k_j[u\hlghr_gbb`bl_e_cDhkh\h
282
Djhf_lh]h_klvk\b^_l_evkl\ZhlhfdZd\ZooZ[blukh\_jrZebjZa[hc
gbqvb \ueZadb ijhlb\ `bl_e_c wlh]h ]hjh^Z B[g ;ZrZj \ ©=mg\Zg ZefZ^`^«ªibr_l©<f_kypJZfZaZg]]hgbhlj_aZeb\k_
ih^klmiudwlhfm]hjh^mb^Z`_gZiZebgZ_]h`bl_e_c\ur_^rboba]hjh
^Z^eylh]hqlh[ukh[jZlv^jh\ZAZl_fhgbm[bebbl_odlhijbr_ebfgZ
ihfhsv G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh m NZckZeZ [ueZ [hevrZy Zjfby `bl_eb wjJby^Z ^h\hevgh ^he]h ^_j`Zeb h[hjhgm Gh \kdhj_ ]hjh^ iZe \h \lhjhc
jZaª
283
Kf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
284
<ZooZ[bluhkh[_gghl_dlh`b\_l\Dm\_cl_\k\hboijhih\_^yobe_d
pbyohq_gvqZklh\hko\ZeyxlYab^ZjZa\_hgbg_keurZebdZdbfZf:ofZ^
kdZaZek\h_fmkugm©JZa\_fh`_lex[blvYab^Zq_eh\_d\_jmxsbc\:e
eZoZbkm^guc^_gv"ª
281
117
F_^bgu ihkljhblv dj_ihklv d gZiZ^Zxsbf ijbkh_^bgbebkv
`bl_eb Dm[u Hgb hlj_aZeb \k_ imlb d F_^bg_ b mkljhbeb __
[ehdZ^mdhlhjZyaZlygmeZkvgZg_kdhevdhe_l«Q_j_ag_dhlh
jh_ \j_fy gZqZeZkv i_j_ibkdZ f_`^m KZ]m^hf [bg OZkZghf
DZev]b :ofZ^hf Zl-LZcyjhf b dZabyfb dhlhju_ \ dhg_qghf
blh]_[ueb\ugm`^_guijbky]gmlv\ZooZ[blZfª285.
<hl lZdbf h[jZahf \ZooZ[blu j_rbeb aZo\Zlblv ]hjh^
dhlhjucIjhjhdk]kh[ty\beaZij_lgufHgbhlj_aZebimlb
dwlhfm]hjh^mgZiZ^ZebgZ\k_odlhiulZeky_]hihdbgmlvb
\dhg_qghfblh]_q_j_ag_kdhevdhe_l`bl_eb[ueb\ugm`^_gu
k^Zlvky b ijbky]gmlv KZ]m^m Fh`_l \ZooZ[blu klZgml ml
\_j`^Zlv qlh `bl_eb F_^bgu lh`_ [ueb \_jhhlklmigbdZfb"
DZdZy gbahklv – gZiZklv gZ ]hjh^ dhlhjuc [ue h[ty\e_g aZ
ij_lgufkZfbfIjhjhdhfk]k
:e-OZgZdby
B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l ©< ] ] KZ]m^ kh k\hbf
\hckdhf kh[jZgguf kh \k_o dhgph\ ijhkgm\r_]hky G_^`^Z
gZijZ\beky\Ze-OZgZdbxjZkiheh`_ggmxjy^hfkF_^bghc<
dj_ihklbwlh]h]hjh^Zklhyelmj_pdbc]Zjgbahg\ha]eZ\ey_fuc
=mkfZghf DZrbnhf Z jy^hf k [ebae_`Zsbf \h^h_fhf `beb
ie_f_gZOZj[Dhq_\gbdbmagZ\hijb[eb`_gbb\hckd[_`Zeb
\f_kl_khk\hbfb\_j[ex^Zfbqlh`_dZkZ_lkyhk_^euo`bl_
e_c lh fmkmevfZg_ gZiZeb gZ gbo b hlh[jZeb \k_ gZc^_ggh_
bfms_kl\hªB^Ze__©Ihke_wlh]hKZ]m^ihdbgmeZe-OZgZdbx
bihimlb\F_^bgmaZo\Zlbebfms_kl\hdhq_\uoie_f_gOZj[
Dh]^Z _]h \hckdh ijb[ebabehkv d ]hj_ Mom^ gZ gbo gZiZe lm
j_pdbc]Zjgbahgbie_fyOZj[bfm^Zehkvm[blvljb^pZlvfm
kmevfZgkdbo \kZ^gbdh\ ihke_ q_]h \hckdh KZ]m^Z [ueh \u
gm`^_gh[_`Zlv\F_^bgmª>Zevr_B[g;ZrZjjZkkdZau\Z_lh
lhfdZdwlh\hckdhihdbgmehF_^bgm©AZl_fhgbgZijZ\bebkv
\^hebgmZk-KZnjZ]^_kh`]ebfgh`_kl\hiZevfbm[bebfgh
`_kl\hex^_cIhke_wlh]hhgbgZijZ\bebkv\Ze-OZjjmbhklZ
gh\bebkv m ]hjh^dZ Zk-KZ\ZjbdZ dhlhjuc kjZam `_ hkZ^beb
Hgb klZeb `_qv iZevfu b jZajmrZlv ^hfZ \b^y wlh `bl_eb
285
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
118
kh]eZkbebkv hl^Zlv iheh\bgm k\h_]h bfms_kl\Z b \uieZlblv
^Zgv KZ]m^ ijh\_e a^_kv _s_ g_kdhevdh ^g_c jZa^_ebe ihem
q_ggh_bfms_kl\hbajZkq_lZ\kZ^gbdZf\^\ZjZaZ[hevr_q_f
i_rbfZaZl_fihdbgmewlhl]hjh^ª286<]]\ZooZ
[blkdb_ \hckdZ gZijZ\eyykv \ Ob^`Za \gh\v gZiZeb gZ ZeOZgZdbxb©aZo\Zlbebh\_pbg_fgh]h\_j[ex^h\ª287.
KZnbgZ
Q_j_a ]h^ \ZooZ[blu kh\_jrbeb gh\ucgZ[_]gZimklu
gxijbgZ^e_`Z\rmxie_f_gZfOZj[B[g;ZrZjihwlhfmih
\h^mibr_l©<]]g_aZ^he]h^hkf_jlbhlpZ=Z[
^meeZ [bg KZ]m^ \f_kl_ k =Zeb [bg r_co FmoZffZ^hf288 \h
]eZ\_ \hckdZ fmkmevfZg G_^`^Z ihdbgme Z^->Zj]bx b gZijZ
\beky\Ob^`Za]^_\gh\vgZiZegZie_f_gZOZj[g_^Ze_dhhl
^_j_\gbKZnbgZ?fmm^ZehkvaZo\Zlblvfgh`_kl\h\_j[ex^h\
bh\_pihke_q_]hhgg_gZ^he]haZ^_j`Zeky\KZnbg_ª289<hl
lZdbf h[jZahf \hbgu ©g_kmsb_ fbjm lZ\ob^ª ]jZ[beb gb \
q_fg_ih\bgguoex^_c
Lmj[ZbOba[Z
Wlh^\_g_[hevrb_^_j_\gbjZkiheh`_ggu_\Ob^`Za_
<ZooZ[blugZiZebgZgbo\dhgp_rZ][ZgZ]]m[b
eb[hevrbgkl\h`bl_e_ckh`]ebiZevfubjZa]jZ[bebbfms_
kl\h<h^ghclhevdhLmj[_[uehm[blh[he__lj_olukyqq_eh
\_d<ZooZ[blugZdZaZeb`bl_e_cLmj[uaZlhqlhhgbhdZaZeb
ih^^_j`dm\hckdZfrZjbnb^h\\ha]eZ\ey_fuf=Z[^meehc[bg
Ze-Omk_cghf DZjZl_evgmx hi_jZpbx \ha]eZ\be h^bg ba `_k
lhqZcrbo\ZooZ[blh\NZckZeZ^->Z\br290.
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 163.
LZf`_– 187.
288
DZd \b^bl_ jmdb r_coZ FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z b _]h ihlhfdZ
lh`_bkiZqdZgudjh\vxfmkmevfZg
289
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«». 1/179.
290
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–KB[g;ZrZjibr_l
h[wlhfdh]^ZjZkkdZau\Z_lhkh[ulbyo]©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
– lZf `_ - \u fh`_l_ ijhq_klv h[ bo a\_jkl\Zo \ hlghr_gbb
`bl_e_cOb^`ZaZ\]
286
287
119
LZbnM[bckl\hmq_guob^_l_c
<ZooZ[bludZdhgb]h\hjyl©qlh[uhk\h[h^blvhlyau
q_kl\ZªgZiZebgZLZbngZkZfhf`_^_e_hgbhqbsZeb_]hhl
BkeZfZ<lh\j_fyLZbnkqblZeky\eZ^_gb_frZjbnb^Z=Zeb
[Z[bgFmkZ]b^ZijZ\bl_eyF_ddbF_`^mgbfb\ZooZ[blZfb
[uebaZdexq_gu^h]h\hjuh^gZdhg_kfhljygZwlh\amevdZ]^Z
]n_\jZev]hgbgZiZebgZwlhl]hjh^bmkljhbeb\
g_fj_agxm[b\Zeb\k_obfm`qbgb`_gsbgb^_l_cm[b\Z
eb ^Z`_ feZ^_gp_\ aZdZeu\Zy bo ijyfh gZ l_eZo fZl_j_c291.
Hgb m[beb \k_o b l_o dlh iulZeky kdjulvky \ f_q_lb b l_o
dlhiulZekykdjulvky\k\h_f^hf_;_]msboba]hjh^Z^h]hgy
ebb^h[b\ZebQZklb`bl_e_c]hjh^Z[ueZh[_sZgZaZsblZgh
dh]^Z l_ k^Zebkv iheh\bgZ lZd`_ [ueZ m[blZ HklZ\rboky
fm`qbg b `_gsbg \u]gZeb \ imklugx b aZklZ\beb h[gZ`blv
ky292Ihke_wlh]hgZ]hjh^gZiZeb[_^mbgu-fZjh^_juhgbaZ
o\Zlu\Zeb \k_ qlh gZoh^beb Z h^gm iylmx gZ]jZ[e_ggh]h hl
^Z\Zebk\h_fmij_^\h^bl_exWlbfex^yfkdZaZebqlh\]hjh
^_ kijylZgh ahehlh b hgb gZqZeb bkdZlv _]h ^Z`_ ih^ nmg^Z
f_glZfb^hfh\Ihke_bogZr_kl\bygZmebpZo]hjh^Z\Zeyebkv
jZahj\Zggu_j_eb]bhagu_dgb]bbkljZgbpuDhjZgZ293.
GZkuj Zk-KZ]b^ ihlhfhd h^gh]h ba `bl_e_c OZbey294,
i_j_^Z_lqlh[_^mbguihke_lh]hdZd\uj_aZeb\k_gZk_e_gb_
]hjh^ZgZqZebhljm[Zlv`_gsbgZfjmdb^eylh]hqlh[ukgylv
k gbo ^jZ]hp_gghklb g_kfhljy gZ wlh hgb [ueb hq_gv gZ[h`
gufb ex^vfb ihkdhevdm bkihegyeb fhebl\m \h\j_fy b kh
FmokbgZe-:fbg©DZrnZe-bjlby[ª–KkhkkuedhcgZr_coZ:o
fZ^Z[bgAZcgb>ZoeygZ
292
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K
293
>hdlhj FmoZffZ^ =Zm^ Ze-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabjZ Ze]ZjZ[by Ze-oZ^bkª – K b OZebnZ NZo^ ©>`Zobf Ze-omdf ZkKZ]m^bmZgbjZgZe-\ZooZ[byª:k-KZnZEhg^hg–K– 188.
294
;u\rbcij_^k_^Zl_ev©:kkhpbZpbbgZjh^h\:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Zª
]\ZooZ[blu\udjZeb_]hba;_cjmlZWlhg_m^b\bl_evghr_coZ
Za-AZoZ[b hgb lZd`_ \udjZeb iulZeb hlj_aZeb qZklb l_eZ Z aZl_f m[beb
Kf©DjZ`ZZa-AZoZ[bª\dhff_glZjbyoddgb]_©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyoby«ª
k
291
120
\_jrZeb hfh\_gb_ \h^hc dhlhjZy [ueZ djZkghc hl djh\b bo
`_jl\295.
:e-OZ[ZjZlb \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©LZjbo ]Z^`Zb[ Ze-ZkZj nb
Zl-lZjZ^`bf mZ Ze-Zo[Zjª ibr_l ©@bl_eb LZbnZ hdZau\Zeb
khijhlb\e_gb_ \ZooZ[blZf \ l_q_gb_ lj_o ^g_c aZl_f ]hjh^
iZe\k_fm`qbgu[uebm[bluZ`_gsbgub^_lbie_g_guLZd
hgbihklmiZebkh\k_fbdlhhdZau\Zebfkhijhlb\e_gb_ª296.
<h \j_fy wlhc j_agb [ueb m[blu r_co =Z[^meeZ ZaAZ\Z\b rZnb]blkdbc fmnlbc F_ddb297 r_co =Z[^meeZ :[me
oZcj dZabc F_ddb r_co >`Z]nZj Zr-RZcb hklZevguo hgb
m[beb ihke_ lh]h dZd ihh[_sZeb g_ijbdhkgh\_gghklv298 JZk
kdZau\Zxl qlh \h \j_fy wlhc j_agb [ueb m[blu \k_ kugh\vy
r_coZ =Z[^medZ^bjZ Zr-RZc[b b hg qlh[u kiZklb k\hx
`bagvihr_egZobljhklvDh]^Z\ZooZ[blukh[jZebkv_]hdZa
gblvhgaZieZdZeh^bgbagbokijhkbe©Ihq_fmluieZq_rvh
g_\_jguc"ª - hg hl\_lbe ©Y ieZqm hl jZ^hklb ;jZlvy y \kx
k\hx `bagv ijh\_e\g_\_jbbbyauq_kl\_gh:eeZoih`_eZe
qlh[u y mf_j \_jmxsbf-_^bgh[h`gbdhf :eeZo \_ebd G_l
[h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZoZª iZeZqb \b^y wlh jZkieZdZebkv gZ
qZeb_]hh[gbfZlvp_eh\Zlvbiha^jZ\eylvkijbgylb_fBkeZ
fZ299.
JZa\_\_jmxsbcq_eh\_d[ue[ukihkh[_gm[blvbh]jZ
[blvwlbo_^bgh[h`gbdh\"<k_wlhebrvqZklvaZ]h\hjZijhlb\
bkeZfkdh]h fbjZ hjm^b_f hkms_kl\e_gby dhlhjh]h klZeb
g_^`^bckdb_ oZjb^`blu ©;_^mbgu - mihjg_crb_ \ g_\_jbb b
ebp_f_jbb b gZb[he__ kdehggu_ g_ ijbgbfZlv ij_^ibkZgbc
LZdh\oZjb^`blkdbcnbdo
FmoZffZ^ :^b[ =Zeb[ ©Fbg Zo[Zj Ze-Ob^`Za mZ GZ^`^ nb lZjbo ZeoZ[ZjZlbªK–>ZjZe-YfZfZba^Zgb_i_j\h_
297
Bkihegyeh[yaZgghklbfmnlby^hr_coZ:ofZ^Z[bgAZcgb>ZoeygZ
298
K_b^B[jZobfZj-JZ\bZj-JbnZ]b©:e-:mjZdZe-[Z]^Z^bynbZe-oZmZ^bk
Zg-gZ^`^byª K – 4. – :g-GZ^`Zo ;Z]^Z^ ] ]<k_mihfygm
lu_mq_gu_[ueb\LZbn_ihlhcijbqbg_qlh\wlhf]hjh^_mgbogZoh^b
ebkve_lgb_j_ab^_gpbb
299
©G_^`^mZfmeoZdZlmoZªK©:k-KZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZmZZebfZfbyªK©:e-BkeZfmZZe-mZkbyZk-KZ]m^byªK
295
296
121
gbkihkeZgguo :eeZohf K\h_fm IhkeZggbdm <_^v :eeZo – agZ
xsbcfm^jucª (9:97).
OjbklbZgkdb_b_\j_ckdb_ohay_\Z]eZ\Zjb\ZooZ[bafZ
jZkkueZebk\hb\hckdZih\k_fmj_]bhgmZ\ZooZ[bluihdhjgh
rebbbkdhj_gyebBkeZfH^bgbaij_^\h^bl_e_c\ZooZ[bafZ
>`hg Nbebiib300 \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:j[Z]mgZ ]ZfZg nb Ze^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byªibr_l©Ihke_lh]hdZdfuihl_jyeb\ky
q_kdmx gZ^_`^m gZ ih^^_j`dm kh klhjhgu Omk_cgZ j_rbeb
bkihevah\Zlv©\hckdh[jZlv_\ª301\ha]eZ\ey_fh_OZeb^hf[bg
ExZc NZckZehf Z^->Z\br_f b KmelZghf [bg ;Z^`Z^hf Hgb
mkljhbebihdZaZl_evgmxj_agx\LZbn_dhlhjZy^he`gZ[ueZ
\k_eblv kljZo \ k_j^pZ _s_ g_ihdhj_gguo [_^mbgh\ b h[e_]
qblv aZ\h_\Zgb_ hklZevguo ]hjh^h\ Ob^`ZaZ Ihke_ lh]h dZd
Omk_cghldZaZekyijh^ZlvIZe_klbgm_\j_yfZg]ebckdb_\eZk
lbj_rbebex[hcp_ghcebrblv_]hij_klheZb\ebygbyZwlh
lj_[h\Zeh agZqbl_evgh]h djh\hijheblby Omk_cg hldZaZeky
ijbgylvgZrblj_[h\ZgbybgZklhyegZlhfqlh`_eZ_llhevdh
h[t_^bg_gby\k_oZjZ[kdboa_f_evih^k\h_c\eZklvxª302Ojb
klbZg_ b bm^_b ^hklb]eb k\hbo p_e_c bf m^Zehkv aZ\h_\Zlv
F_ddmk`_qvj_^qZcrmxfmkmevfZgkdmx[b[ebhl_dmZlZd`_
kh\_jrblv^jm]b_^_ygbymihfygmlu_\wlhcdgb]_
F_ddZ@bl_ebF_ddbih_^Zxlljmiubkh[Zd
I_j_^l_fdZdhkZ^blvF_ddm\ZooZ[blui_j_djueb\k_
imlbdg_cbg_dhlhjh_\j_fygZiZ^ZebgZiZehfgbdh\<Fm
oZjjZf ] Zij_ev ] gZqZeZkv [ehdZ^Z ]hjh^Z \k_o
iZehfgbdh\bgZijZ\eyxsboky\]hjh^gZqZebie_gblvbm[b
\ZlvQlh`_dZkZ_lkyiheh`_gby`bl_e_c]hjh^Zlhhgh[ueh
m`Zkguf hgb [ueb \ugm`^_gu aZ [_kp_ghd ijh^Z\Zlv k\h_
bfms_kl\h b ^jZ]hp_gghklb b aZ hq_gv \ukhdmx p_gm ijbh[
<ha]eZ\be \ZooZ[blkdh_ ^\b`_gb_ ihke_ ]b[_eb dZiblZgZ R_dkibjZ \
]
301
©<hckdh [jZlv_\ª [ueh q_f-lh \jh^_ \hckd FmkZceZfu dhlhjh_ lZd`_
mgbqlh`Zeh fmkmevfZg b hl jmd dhlhjh]h ih]b[eb fgh]b_ kih^\b`gbdb
ijhjhdZk]kgh\blh]_wlboijbl_kgbl_e_cmgbqlh`beb^jm]b_ijbl_k
gbl_eb
302
GZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ª–Kb9.
300
122
j_lZlvijh^mdluqlh[ugZdhjfblvk\hbo^_l_cFgh]b_`bl_
eb ]hjh^Z mf_jeb hl ]heh^Z gZ mebpZo \Zeyebkv ljmiu ^_l_c
<ZooZ[blkdbcbklhjbd=mkfZgZg-GZ^`^bibr_l©Fykhhkeh\
bf_jl\_qbgZijh^Z\Zebkvihg_[u\Zeh\ukhdbfp_gZf`bl_eb
]hjh^Z[ueb\ugm`^_guih_^Zlv^Z`_kh[ZdEx^bklZebklh
jhgblvkywlh]h]hjh^Zqbke_gghklv_]h`bl_e_ckbevghkhdjZ
lbeZkvª303.
Dlh jZaj_rbe gZiZ^Zlv gZ F_ddm b hkZ`^Zlv __ `bl_
e_c" JZa\_ bf g_ [ueh ba\_klgh qlh Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe
©<hbklbgm:eeZoh]jZ^beF_ddmhl\hckdZkehgZghhldjue__
^eyk\h_]hIjhjhdZk]kWlhl]hjh^[ueaZij_lguf^hf_gy
bhklZg_lkyaZij_lgufihke_f_gy:eeZolhevdhgZqZkk^_eZe
_]h^ha\he_ggufjZ^bf_gyghijbwlhffg_g_[uehjZaj_r_
ghjm[blv^_j_\vyb^Z`_lhilZlvdhexqdb?keb\wlhf]hjh^_
dlh-lh [m^_l m[bl lh eb[h k_fv_ m[blh]h ij_^hklZ\ey_lky\u
dmi eb[h hgZ kZfZ \ughkbl ijb]h\hjª304 Dlh iha\hebe wlbf
]heh\hj_aZf g_ agZxsbf aZdhgh\ rlmjfh\Zlv F_ddm" Dlh
iha\hebe ^h\h^blv `bl_e_c ]hjh^Z ^h lZdhc kl_i_gb qlh hgb
[ueb \ugm`^_gu _klv fykh hkeh\ f_jl\_qbgmbkh[Zdb^Z`_
g_bf_eb\hafh`ghklbm[jZlvljmiuk\hbo^_l_ckmebp"
;he__ lh]h ^\Z \ZooZ[blkdbo ihedh\h^pZ =mkfZg ZeFm^Zbnb dhlhjuc iha^g__ klZe ijZ\bl_e_f LZbnZ b B[g
RZd[Zg gZiZeb gZ iZehfgbdh\ gZoh^b\rboky \ :jZnZl_ b
m[beb\k_odlhhldZaZekybfih^qbgblvky^Ze__bo\hckdZih
reb\^hebgmFmjjZbgZqZebm[b\Zlv\k_odlhgZijZ\eyeky\
F_ddm \ j_amevlZl_ q_]h `bl_eb Ob^`ZaZ klZeb [hylvky kh
\_jrZlvoZ^`<dhg_qghfblh]_wfbjoZ^`ZhldZaZekyijbgylv
mkeh\by\ZooZ[blh\b\_jgmeky\RZf305.
Ihke_^he]hc[ehdZ^urZjbnb^=Zeb[[bgFmkZ]b^[ue
\ugm`^_g\imklblv\ZooZ[blh\\F_ddmbijbgylv\k_bomkeh
\by \ qbke_ dhlhjuo [ue aZij_l gZ mihfbgZgb_ IjhjhdZ
k]k ihke_ ijhbag_k_gby ijbau\Z gZ fhebl\m ihlhfm qlh
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
Ijb\_ebZe-;moZjbFmkebfb^jm]b_
305
K_b^FmokbgZe-:fbg©DZrnZe-bjlby[ª–K
303
304
123
wlhihfg_gbx\ZooZ[blh\y\ey_lkyg_^ha\he_ggufgh\r_kl
\hf
Kfhf_glZaZo\ZlZj_]bhgZ\ZooZ[blZfb\g_f\hpZjbe
ky oZhk gh \kdhj_ dh]^Z [ue hkZ`^_gZ bo klhebpZ Z^->Zj]by
bf ijbrehkv ihdbgmlv F_ddm306 Ihke_ bo moh^Z rZjbnb^u
\_jgmebkv\F_ddmb^Z`_ihiulZebkv\_jgmlvLZbnghbfwlh
g_m^Zehkvohlyhgbbkfh]ebhlklhylv>`b^^m
< ] ] gZ l_jjblhjbx :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkl
jh\Z \hreb _]bi_lkdb_ \hckdZ dhlhjuf m^Zehkv agZqbl_evgh
hkeZ[blv\ZooZ[blh\baZsblblvF_ddmbF_^bgmhlboihky]Z
l_evkl\307 Ih^jZa^_e_gby _]bi_lkdhc Zjfbb gZoh^bebkv gZ
l_jjblhjbb:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Z^h]]dh]^Z
[ueb\u\_^_gub\ZooZ[blu\]]\gh\vaZo\Zlbeb
F_ddmQ_j_a]h^hgbaZo\ZlbebF_^bgmaZl_fba]gZebrZjb
nb^Z=Zeb[bgZe-Omk_cgZ\BjZdbaZo\Zlbeb>`b^^m
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev ba\_klgh eb \Zf dlh \ha]eZ\eye
\ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZ\h\j_fy\aylbyF_ddb"Wlh[ueojbklbZ
gbgZg]ebqZgbgKZgl>`hgNbebiibdhlhjh]h\ZooZ[blugZ
au\Zeb r_cohf =Z[^meehc Dh]^Z g_dhlhju_ ba [_^mbgkdbo
r_coh\ hkm^beb ihk_s_gb_ >`hghf Nbebiib F_ddb \h_gZ
qZevgbd \ZooZ[blh\ bf hl\_lbe ©;jZlvy-fmkmevfZg_« ?keb
[ug_wlhlq_eh\_dr_co=Z[^meeZNbebiiblh\Zf\hh[s_g_
m^Zehkv [u \aylv wlhl ]hjh^ Hg ij_^klZ\bl_ev Zg]ebqZg g_
Iha^g__ ijhbahreh gZklhys__ aZ\h_\Zgb_ F_ddb Dh]^Z rZjbnb^ =Zeb
[bg Ze-Omk_cg gZoh^beky \ >`b^^_ \ZooZ[blu i_j_djueb ^hjh]b k h^ghc
klhjhgu Z Zg]ebqZg_ – k ^jm]hc ihwlhfm _fm ijbrehkv k^Zlvky ijbgylv
\k_ mkeh\by b \ ] ihdbgm\ :jZ\bckdbc ihemhkljh\ hlijZ\blvky \
BjZd
307
?]bilyg_m`_g_\i_j\ucjZaaZsbsZeb]eZ\gu_fmkmevfZgkdb_k\ylu
gb < rZ][Zg ] yg\Zjv ] ie_f_gZ [_^mbgh\ ba lh]h `_ kZfh]h
G_^`^ZgZiZebgZF_ddmbm[bebgZqZevgbdZ]ZjgbahgZ_]bilygbgZIhke_
wlh]h hgb h^gm aZ ^jm]hc klZeb aZgbfZlv [ebae_`Zsb_ ^_j_\gb Lhqgh lZ
dhc`_kemqZcijhbahr_e\]]g_aZ^he]h^h\hpZj_gby^bgZklbb
dZjfZlh\ DZ`^uc jZa :eeZo ^Z\Ze _]bilygZf \hafh`ghklv aZsblblv fm
kmevfZgkdb_k\ylugb
306
124
m`_eb \u ohlbl_ qlh[u y ]g_\be _]h \ h`b^Zgbb \Zr_]h ^h
\hevkl\Z" 308»
<aylb_ F_ddb g_^`^bckdbfb oZjb^`blZfb _s_ g_ agZ
qblqlh\k_`bl_ebOb^`ZaZboih^^_j`Zeb<ZooZ[blu^hkbo
ihj`bl_e_cwlh]hj_]bhgZgZau\Zxlkmnbyfbbgbdh]^Zg_^h
imkdZxlbo^h^he`ghklbbfZfZ\f_q_lbZe-OZjZfhgb\k_]^Z
klZ\ylk\h_]hq_eh\_dZ-\ZooZ[blZ309LZdhgbhlghkylkydh\k_f
fmkmevfZgZf <_^v fmkmevfZg_ g_ ijbagZxl \ZooZ[blkdmx
_j_kvihwlhfm\ZooZ[blubogZj_dZxloZjb^`blZfbkmnbyfb
jZnb^blZfbbijhqbfbbf_gZfbqlh`_dZkZ_lkymq_guoOb^
`ZaZlhhgb\ZooZ[blh\gZau\Zxlg_^`^blZfbbdZjgblZfb310.
:e-BokZ
<ZooZ[blkdbc bklhjbd hibku\Zy kh[ulby ]
] ]h\hjbl ©< wlhf ]h^m =Z[^me]Zaba \h ]eZ\_ k\hbo
\hckd gZijZ\beky \ Ze-BokZ HklZgh\b\rbkv \ f_kl_qd_ ZlLZjZnZcghggZqZem[b\Zlvf_klguo`bl_e_c[uehm[blhhdh
eh k_fb^_kylb fm`qbg b dhgnbkdh\Zgh fgh]h bfms_kl\Z Ih
ke_wlh]hhggZiZegZZe-FZ[jZa]^_lZd`_mgbqlh`befgh`_
kl\hfm`qbg«311»
Hibku\Zy kh[ulby ] ] hg ]h\hjbl ©< wlhf
]h^m KZ]m^ \h ]eZ\_ fmkmevfZgkdh]h \hckdZ gZijZ\beky \ klh
jhgmZe-BokZjZggbfmljhfhg\g_aZighgZiZegZ`bl_e_cZe=mxgaZo\Zlbefgh`_kl\hkdhlZijh\bZglZjZaebqguo\_s_c
bjZajmrbebo^hfZ«312»
K_b^:[mZe-=ZeyZl-LZd\b©:e-NbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ª–
K
309
Ba\_klghqlh\\ZooZ[blkdbokljZgZo`b\mlbrZnb]blubfZebdblub
oZgZnblubrbblubijhqb_Ij_^klZ\bl_eyfwlbordhejZaj_rZ_lkybam
qZlvbij_ih^Z\ZlvlhevdhoZrZ\blkdh_mq_gb_lZdh\Z\ZooZ[blkdZyl_jib
fhklv
310
DZjg–jh]lh_klvbf__lky\\b^moZ^bkIjhjhdZk]k©Bf_gghhllm
^Z\uc^_ljh]kZlZguª-ii
311
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
312
LZf`_
308
125
Hkh[ulbyo]]hgjZkkdZau\Z_l©Ihke_wlh
]hihdbgm\DZlZjhg313gZijZ\beky\Ze-BokZgZiZegZ`bl_
e_c^_j_\gbZe->`mkkZbm[befgh`_kl\hfm`qbgª314.
Ihke_wlh]hhghibku\Z_lkh[ulby]]bjZk
kdZau\Z_l ©«khe^Zlu kb^y \_johf gZ k\hbo `b\hlguo \k_
h^gh\j_f_ggh\uklj_ebebbak\hbojm`_cHla\mdZ\uklj_eh\
aZljykeZkva_feybmfgh]bo[_j_f_gguo`_gsbgihk_edZZeBokZkemqbeky\udb^urIhke_wlh]hKZ]m^khk\hbfb\hckdZ
fb gZijZ\beky \ Zj-JZdbdZ ]^_ aZ^_j`Zeky gZ g_kdhevdh
^g_c«<wlh\j_fyh^gbohg\_e_edZagblv^jm]bo–\uk_eblv
lj_lvbo – aZdexqblv \ lxjvfm M g_m]h^guo hg hlgbfZe bfm
s_kl\h jZajmrZe ^hfZ klhbe mdj_ie_gby Djhf_ lh]h hg h[
eh`bebogZeh]ZfbjZaf_jhf\lukyqb^bjo_fh\ª>Ze__Z\lhj
jZkkdZau\Z_l dZd hg m[b\Ze ex^_c b wlh ihke_ lh]h dZd hgb
k^Zebkv©«h^gbom[b\Zebijyfh\ihk_ed_^jm]boijb\h^beb
drZljmKZ]m^Zbijbg_fhljm[Zebbf]heh\u\blh]_qbke_g
ghklv`bl_e_cihk_edZhklZeZkvg_agZqbl_evghc<h\j_fywlh
]hihoh^ZKZ]m^aZ\eZ^_eg_kf_lgufb[h]Zlkl\Zfbª315.
Ykgh qlh h^gh\j_f_gguc jm`_cguc aZei [ue k^_eZg
^ey lh]h qlh[u gZim]Zlv `bl_e_c wlh]h j_]bhgZ gh \ q_f `_
\bgZ ^_l_c dhlhju_ ^Z`_ g_ mki_eb jh^blvky" LZdh\Z \ZooZ
[blkdZyj_eb]bylhqghlZdhc`_kemqZcB[g;ZrZjijb\h^bl
dh]^ZjZkkdZau\Z_lhihoh^_\ZooZ[blh\\Ze-OZjZ^`gZboim
lb hdZaZeZkv ^_j_\gy OZjZfZ ©Dh]^Z gZklZeh mljh =Z[^meeZ
\_e_e \k_f bf_xsbf \bglh\db ijhba\_klb h^gh\j_f_gguc
aZeihldhlhjh]hkhljykeZkva_feybfgh]b_[_j_f_ggu_miZ
eb\h[fhjhdLZdbfh[jZahfhq_gve_]dhwlZ^_j_\gy[ueZaZ
o\Zq_gZ«316ª >jm]hc \hijhk jZa\_ fh`gh m[b\Zlv _^bgh[h`
gbdh\l_f[he__ihke_lh]hdZdhgbm`_k^Zebkv"LZdh\\ZooZ
Bf__lky\\b^mKme_cfZg[bg=ZnbkZgkhk\hbf\ZooZ[blkdbf\hckdhf
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
315
LZf`_LK
316
LZf`_
313
314
126
[blkdbcl_jjhjy\eyxsbckyieh^hfjmdojbklbZgkdbohnbp_
jh\G_lkbeubfh]ms_kl\Zdjhf_dZdm:eeZoZ317.
Dm\_cl
Dm\_cllZd`_ih^\_j]kygZiZ^_gbx\ZooZ[blh\dhlhju_
lZd`_m[b\Zeb]jZ[bebgZkbeh\Zebie_gbebg_\bgguoex^_c
gZk_ey\rbowlhlj_]bhgbjZkijhkljZgyebk\hb\ZooZ[blkdmx
j_eb]bx Bo gZiZ^_gby gZ Dm\_cl ijboh^ylky gZ i_j\mx q_l
\_jlvljbgZ^pZlh]h\_dZihob^`j_dhg_p\–gZqZeh\
<ZooZ[blu kh\_jrbeb gZ[_]b gZ Dm\_cl \ ] ]
] ] ] ] ] ] ] ]
<h\j_fyihke_^g_]hihoh^Z\ZooZ[blu^hreb^hZe->`ZojZb
m[beb hdheh lukyqb fm`qbg iha^g__ [ueh _s_ ^\Z ihoh^Z \
]]b]]
Dh]^ZijZ\bl_eb318Dm\_clZb;Zoj_cgZhldZaZebkvieZ
lblv ^`bavx \ZooZ[blu kh\_jrbeb gh\uc ihoh^ b ^_j`Zeb \
[ehdZ^_fgh]b_gZk_e_ggu_imgdlu
<h\j_fy\hcguf_`^m<_ebdh[jblZgb_cbLmjpb_cZg
]ebqZg_ ij_^hklZ\beb \ZooZ[blZf ihegmx k\h[h^m \ j_]bhg_
bf_gghlh]^Z\]]bijhbahrehkjZ`_gb_Ze-OZf^
\dhlhjhfih]b[ebfgh]b_g_\bggu_ex^b
< ] ] \ZooZ[blu kh\_jrbeb gh\uc ihoh^ \
Dm\_cl\h\j_fydhlhjh]hkhklhyeZkv[bl\ZZe->`ZojZijZ\b
l_ey KZebfZ Zk-KZ[ZoZ hl ie_g_gby kiZkeZ lhevdh ih^^_j`dZ
ie_f_gRZffZjbZe-=Z^`fZg
<]]KZebfZk-KZ[Zomf_jbfgh]b_`bl_eb
Dm\_clZ [ueb \ugm`^_gu ijbgylv \ZooZ[baf lhevdh lh]^Z
[jblZgkdb_ Z]_glu319 ij_djZlbeb j_agx \ wlhf j_]bhg_ b ihe
ghklvxihqbgbeb_]hk_[_320.
Qlh[u magZlv dZdb_ _s_ a\_jkl\Z kh\_jrbeb \ZooZ[blu \ Ze-BokZ dZd
hgb kh`]eb iZevfu \h \j_f_gZ KZ]m^Z h[jZlbl_kv d dgb]_ Omk_cgZ [bg
=ZggZfZ©LZjboGZ^`^ªk
318
<Dm\_cl_–KZ[Zoblu\;Zoj_cg_–OZebnblu
319
>_ckl\by[jblZgkdboZ]_glh\b\ZooZ[blkdbohljy^h\\Dm\_cl_gm`^Z
xlky\[he__^_lZevghfjZatykg_gbb:]_gluZg]ebckdhcjZa\_^dbgZklZb
\Zeb gZ lhf qlh[u r_co FmoZffZ^ Zk-KZ[Zo ijZ\bl_ev Dm\_clZ ijbgye
\ZooZ[baf h^gZdh hg \ ] gZh[hjhl baty\be `_eZgb_ ijbkh_^bgblv
317
127
B[g;ZrZjhibku\Zykh[ulby]]k]hj^hk
lvx]h\hjbl©<wlhf]h^mB[jZobf[bg=Zknbyg^\bgmek\hb
hljy^ugZk_\_jbgZiZegZ]hjh^Dm\_clHklZ\b\qZklvk\hbo
\hbgh\\aZkZ^_hghldjulhihr_e\ZlZdmZdh]^Z`bl_eb]h
jh^Zj_rbebhdZaZlvkhijhlb\e_gb_lhgZgbogZiZebhljy^u
kb^_\rb_ \ aZkZ^_ < blh]_ [ueh m[blh ljb^pZlv `bl_e_c Dm
\_clZª321.
H kh[ulbyo ] ] hg ibr_l ke_^mxs__ ©<
wlhf ]h^m FZggZ] Za-AZ][b ih ijbdZam =Z[^me]ZabaZ ihr_e gZ
Dm\_clQZklvk\h_]hhljy^ZhgkijylZe\aZkZ^_ZkhklZevghc
aZo\Zlbe iZkmsbcky jy^hf kdhl dh]^Z `bl_eb ]hjh^Z \ureb
qlh[uaZsblblvk\h_bfms_kl\hgZgbogZiZebkb^_\rb_\aZ
kZ^_bm[beb^\Z^pZlvq_eh\_dª322.
:\lhj wlbo kljhd \ujZ`Z_l ]hj^hklv ^_ckl\byfb wlbo
jZa[hcgbdh\dhlhju_m[b\Zebg_\bgguoex^_cb\hjh\Zebbo
kdhl G_m`_eb `bl_eb Dm\_clZ lZd `_ dZd `bl_eb G_^`^Z323,
[uebyauqgbdZfb"
DZlZj
DZlZjb;Zoj_cg324
k\hba_febdHkfZgkdhcbfi_jbbLh]^Zhgbih^]h\hjbeb_]hjh^gh]h[jZlZ
Fm[ZjZdZ kem`b\r_]h \ZooZ[blZf mkljhblv i_j_\hjhl Fm[ZjZd ghqvx
] \h ]eZ\_ hljy^Z \ZooZ[blh\ \hj\Zeky \h ^\hj_p b m[be k\hbo
jh^guo[jZlv_\FmoZffZ^Zb>`ZjjZoZDZdml\_j`^Z_l>bdkhg©<]
Fm[ZjZd hnbpbZevgh ijbagZe Zg]ebckdh_ ijbkmlkl\b_ \ j_]bhg_ª Kf
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZª–K– 348.
320
Fgh]b_ ba baeh`_gguo nZdlh\ \aylu ba dgb]b ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byªFmoZffZ^Z=Zm^ZZe-OZlu[Z–>ZjZe-fb]jZ^`k
B[jZobf=Z[^me]Zaba=Z[^me]Zgb©KujZ]Ze-mfZjZ^ZjZk-kZdbª
ba^k=Z[^jZofZgGZkujZr-RZfjZgb©FZfeZdZlZe-nZ^Zboª–>Zj
Ze-bgkZglK
321
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
322
LZf`_
323
LZf`_
324
Fuh[t_^bgbebh[_kljZguih^h^gbfblhf`_aZ]heh\dhfihlhfmqlh
hgbhq_gv[ebadb^jm]d^jm]m\gboijZ\bebihlhfdbh^ghcblhc`_^b
gZklbb LZd`_ ba\_klgh qlh dZlZjkdbc mq_guc Y]dm[ [bg Xkmn kiZkZykv
hl\ZooZ[blh\[_`Ze\;Zoj_cg
128
B[g;ZrZjhibku\Zykh[ulby]]jZkkdZau
\Z_l©<wlhf]h^mKme_cfZg[bg=ZnbkZgihijbdZam=Z[^me
]ZabaZgZijZ\bekygZ\hklhdbgZiZegZ`bl_e_cDZlZjZm[be
fgh]h q_eh\_d ba ie_f_gb :[m JZfbo b aZ[jZe bo bfms_kl
\h«ª>Ze__b^_lj_qvhkh[ulbyo]]©<wlhf]h
^m Kme_cfZg [bg =ZnbkZg ih ijbdZam =Z[^me]ZabaZ \h ]eZ\_
hljy^Z ba `bl_e_c Ze-OZjZ^`Z gZijZ\beky \ DZlZj _]h \klj_
lbehljy^baiylb^_kylb\kZ^gbdh\Kme_cfZgboh^he_eihqlb
\k_o m[be b aZ[jZe k kh[hc bfms_kl\h b `b\hlguoª325 AZl_f
ke_^mxlkh[ulby]]©«aZl_fB[jZobf[bg=Znb
kZg\h]eZ\_wlh]hhljy^ZgZijZ\beky\DZlZjgZiZegZ_]h`b
l_e_cm\_efgh`_kl\h\_j[ex^h\dhlhjuoaZl_fijh^Ze\ZeBokZª326.
Bf_ggh wlhl hljy^ gZqZe l_jjhjbabjh\Zlv DZlZj _s_ \
]dh]^ZB[g=ZnbkZggZiZegZie_fy;Zgb=ml[Z327hdjm
`be _]h b mkljhbe [ehdZ^m \ dhg_qghf blh]_ =ml[blu328 \
]][ueb\ugm`^_gu[_`Zlv\;Zoj_cgGhiha^g__
bf\k_`_ijbrehkvijbgylv\ZooZ[bafDjhf_gbo\ZooZ[blu
l_jjhjbabjh\Zeb b ^jm]b_ ie_f_gZ gZk_ey\rb_ DZlZj Hl bo
jmd ihkljZ^Zeb ie_f_gZ NZjboZ Ze-Om\Zcey Ze-Xkmnby ZjJm\Zc^Zb^jm]b_<ZooZ[blug_lhevdhgZiZ^ZebgZgboghb
k_yebf_`^mgbfbjhagv329.
< ] \ZooZ[blu \ha]eZ\ey_fu_ wfbjhf =Z[^meehc
[bg NZckZehf \gh\v gZiZeb gZ wlb ie_f_gZ b hgb [ueb \u
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªLK
LZf`_KWlh_s_h^bgijbf_j]jZ[_`Zb\hjh\kl\Z
327
LZf`_K:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byª
K
328
HgbhlghkbebkvdoZebnblZfb[uebijZ\bl_eyfbDZlZjZ^h]dh]
^Zhgiheghklvx[uehddmibjh\Zg\ZooZ[blZfb
329
:[mOZdZ©ExfZ]Zr-rboZ[ª–>ZjZk-kZdZnZ;_cjml[]–KB[
jZobf =Z[^me]Zaba =Z[^me]Zgb ©KujZ] Ze-mfZjZª – >Zj Zk-kZdb Ehg^hg
1988 –K©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K–Jby^GZ^`b[
Zj-JZcxk©JboZk-kZfmfª–ba^K
325
326
129
gm`^_gu ijbgylv \ZooZ[baf b ijbg_klb ijbky]m330 G_kfhljy
gZwlh\ZooZ[bluhlh[jZebmgboljbklZju[Zpdboromg331.
Dh]^Z `_ `bl_eb DZlZjZ mki_eb klZlv g_\_jgufb" Ih
q_fm=Z[^meeZkjZ`Zekykgbfb"Dlhiha\hebeba^_\ZlvkygZ^
fmkmevfZgZfb^hlZdhckl_i_gbqlhhgb[ueb\ugm`^_guih
dbgmlvjh^gu_a_feb"=^_kdZaZghqlhex^_cfh`ghijbgm`
^Zlvdijbgylbx^jm]hcj_eb]bbbebfZaoZ[Z"=^_^ZghjZaj_
r_gb_k_ylvjZa^hjf_`^mfmkmevfZgZfb"
<ZooZ[blZf^hklZlhqghlh]hihahjZqlhhgb\ugm^bebd
[_]kl\m \ ;Zoj_cg r_coZ Y]dm[Z [bg XkmnZ H^gZdh bf g_
m^Zehkv kehfblv _]h ^mo hg ijh^he`Ze Zglb\ZooZ[blkdmx
ijhiZ]Zg^m\;Zoj_cg_bmf_jkh]jhfguf`_eZgb_f\_jgmlvky
gZjh^bgm^Zhlfklbl:eeZowlbfex^yf332.
;Zoj_cg
=ml[blu hldZaZebkv ieZlblv ^`bavx \ZooZ[blZf lh]^Z
l_gZqZebgZiZ^ZlvgZgbom[b\Zlvb\kyq_kdbmgb`Zlv333B[g
;ZrZj hibku\Zy kh[ulby ] ] khh[sZ_l ©BfZf
j_qv b^_l h NZckZe_ hklZgh\beky m wlh]h bklhqgbdZ b ih
ijhr_kl\bbf_kypZdg_fmijbrebij_^klZ\bl_ebie_f_g;Zo
j_cgZ b ihijhkbeb aZdexqblv fbjguc ^h]h\hj h^gZdh hg bf
hldZaZe«334ª <hl lZd \ZooZ[blu hlghkbebkv d fmkmevfZgZf
gZeZ]Zeb gZ gbo ^`bavx b hldZau\Zebkv aZdexqZlv k gbfb
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
LZf`_
332
Qlh[umagZlvh[wlhfih^jh[g__kfklZlvy©Dmglm\ZooZ[bygª©Y[ue
\ZooZ[blhfª<ZooZ[blu^hklZ\bebg_m^h[kl\hfgh]bfmq_gufgZijbf_j
r_coFmoZffZ^Za-AZ\Z\bZr-RZnb]b[ue\ugm`^_g[_`Zlv\FZkdZlB[g
AZjbd\k\h_cdgb]_©:e-NZloZe-fm[bgªfgh]hjZkkdZau\Z_lhgbobijb
\h^bl \ukdZau\Zgb_ r_coZ aZ-AZ\Z\b ©=Z[^me]Zaba b _]h ihke_^h\Zl_eb
\_^ml k_[y \_kvfZ b \_kvfZ kljZggh H[j_ly kbem hgb ijb[ebabeb d k_[_
g_\_`^ h[ty\b\rbo k_[y mq_gufb Wlb ik_\^hmq_gu_ \jh^_ B[g =Z[^me
\ZooZ[ZgZqZeb^Z\Zlvbfn_l\uhlhfqlhfmkmevfZg_y\eyxlkyyauqgbdZ
fb iha\hebeb bf m[b\Zlv fmkmevfZg ]jZ[blv bo b ^Z`_ `_gblvky gZ bo
\^h\Zog_h`b^Zy]b^^uª
333
B[jZobf =Z[^me]Zgb ©KujZ] Ze-mfZjZª – K Ze-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl
fbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K
334
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 2/130.
330
331
130
fbjgu_^h]h\hjuR_coKZ]b^[bgLZogmgijZ\bl_ev:[m>Z
[b iulZeky m^_j`Zlv bo hl ]jZ[_`Z k\hbo ih^^Zgguo h^gZdh
_fmwlhg_m^Zehkvhgbihlj_[h\Zebqlh[uhgebqghijb[ue\
boklZ\dmIhemqb\]ZjZglbb[_ahiZkghklbhgijb[uedgbfk
[hevrbfdhebq_kl\hfih^Zjdh\gh[uekbevghmgb`_gb\Zo
oZ[blugZklhyebqlh[u`bl_eb;Zoj_cgZieZlbebbf^`bavx
ZlZd`_gZeh`bebgZgbojZaebqgu_\b^urljZnh\335.
< wlhf g_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \_^v hgb b ^h wlh]h
gZiZ^Zeb gZ ;Zoj_cg <h \j_fy h^gh]h ba gZ[_]h\ bf m^Zehkv
aZo\Zlblv qe_gh\ ijZ\ys_c k_fvb dhlhjuo hgb ^_j`Zeb \
lxjvf_ Z^->Zj]bb \iehlv ^h ] ] AZ wlh \j_fy hgb
kh\_jrbebfgh`_kl\hgZ[_]h\gZ;Zoj_cgbm[beb`bl_
e_ckj_^bdhlhjuo[uebr_coJZrb^[bg=Z[^meeZ[bgOZeb
nZ b r_co >Z]b^` dm\_cl_p ih ijhbkoh`^_gbx :eeZo hlh
fklbe\ZooZ[blZfaZdjh\v`bl_e_c;Zoj_cgZdh]^Zhgbi_j_
\habebgZkm^Zoihjholhl\hkieZf_gbekybfgh]b_\ZooZ[blu
k]hj_eb`b\v_fo\ZeZ:eeZom=hkih^mfbjh\336.
HfZg337
GZiZ^_gby \ZooZ[blh\ gZ HfZg lj_[mxl hl^_evgh]h
bamq_gby ihkdhevdm hgb hlebqZebkv hkh[hc ]jm[hklvx b ijh
bkoh^beb hq_gv ijh^he`bl_evgh_ \j_fy < ex[hf kemqZ_ wlb
gZ[_]b ij_ke_^h\Zeb lhevdh h^gm p_ev ]jZ[_` \hjh\kl\h b
m[bckl\h @bl_eb HfZgZ jZa\h^beb \_j[ex^h\ b \_j[ex^bp
dhlhju_ hkh[h p_gbebkv \ZooZ[blZfb \ qZklghklb B[g ;ZrZj
LZf`_– 2/132.
LZf`_lK-157.
337
Ih^HfZghf\h\j_f_gZB[g;ZrZjZbf_eZkv\\b^ml_jjblhjbyH:Wb
HfZgZ ihwlhfm b fu bkihevam_f wlhl lhihgbf bf_ggh \ lZdhf agZq_gbb
Djhf_lh]h^_eh\lhfqlh_keb\_jgmlvkyd\j_f_gZfB[g;ZrZjZlhgZf
[m^_lhq_gvljm^ghhij_^_eblvhq_fbf_gghb^_lj_qvGZijbf_jhgib
r_lh[_]kl\_\HfZgdZaby=Zeb[bgOmk_cgZ[bgFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me
\ZooZ[Z ihke_ iZ^_gby i_j\h]h kZm^bckdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z b _keb [u hg g_
mihfygmeqlhwlhlq_eh\_d[_`Ze\JZkZe-OZcfZlhfuijhklhg_kfh]eb
[uhij_^_eblvb^_lebj_qvh[H:Wbebh[HfZg_
335
336
131
ibr_l©<dZq_kl\_ih^Zjdh\bfZfijbkeZeehrZ^_chfZgkdbo
\_j[ex^bpbg_fgh]h^bjo_fh\ª338.
>hdZaZl_evkl\hflh]hqlhwlbgZ[_]b[uebjZa[hcgbqv
bfb y\ey_lky k\b^_l_evkl\h B[g ;ZrZjZ h kh[ulbyo ]
] dh]^Z f_`^m KZ]m^hf b _]h kugh\vyfb ijhbahr_e
dhgnebdl ba-aZ lh]h qlh ihke_^gbf klZeh g_ o\ZlZlv ih^Zl_c
Qlh `_ hgb k^_eZeb" Hgb ijhklh kgZjy^beb gh\u_ hljy^u
qlh[ul_]jZ[bebfbjguoex^_c©<wlhf]h^mgZqZe_f_kypZ
Amevob^`Z dh]^Z KZ]m^ kh\_jrZe oZ^` _]h kugh\vy Lmjdb
GZkujbKZ]^\h]eZ\_\hckdZ339\f_kl_khk\hbfbkem]ZfbgZ
ijZ\bebkv \ HfZg Ijbqbghc bo \uklmie_gby [ue dhgnebdl
f_`^mgbfbbbohlphfg_kfhljygZlhqlhbohl_p[ues_^j
hgb ihijhkbeb _]h m\_ebqblv bo kh^_j`Zgb_ gh hl_phldZaZe
lh]^Z ihijhkbeb jZaj_r_gby kh\_jrblv gZ[_] gh hl_p \gh\v
hldZaZe Lh]^Z hgb ^h`^Zebkv hlt_a^Z hlpZ \ oZ^` b gZijZ\b
ebkv \ HfZg @bl_eb HfZgZ magZ\ h[ bo ijb[ulbb kh[jZeb
\hckdhbghqvxgZiZebgZkugh\_cKZ]m^Z\j_amevlZl_q_]hl_
ihl_ji_ebihjZ`_gb_ª340Gh\kdhj_dgbfgZihfhsvijbr_e
FmleZd Ze-FZlujb b hgb [eZ]h^Zjy ih^dj_ie_gbx klZeb m[b
\Zlvb]jZ[blv`bl_e_cwlh]hj_]bhgZª
B[g ;ZrZj ]hj^_eb\h \kihfbgZ_l h kh[ulbyo ]
] ©Hgb gZijZ\bebkv \ HfZg aZo\Zlbeb fgh`_kl\h ]h
jh^h\bie_gbebfgh`_kl\h[_^mbgh\ª341DlhbfjZaj_rbeaZ
o\Zlu\ZlvfmkmevfZgkdb_]hjh^Zbie_gblv[_^mbgh\"WlhjZa
j_r_gb_ bf ^ZeZ \ZooZ[blkdh-oZjb^`blkdZy Zdu^Z kh]eZkgh
dhlhjhc\k_fmkmevfZg_y\eyxlkyg_\_jgufbdhlhjuoke_^m_l
m[b\Zlv b ]jZ[blv <ZooZ[blu b kZfb ijbagZxl qlh gZ[_]Zfb
B[g ;ZrZj mihfbgZ_l bo \h fgh]bo f_klZo k\h_c dgb]b ©=mg\Zg ZefZ^`^«ªlklk
339
MdZ`^h]hbagbo[uehljy^\dhgguo\kZ^gbdh\djhf_gbo[uebb
\kZ^gbdb gZ \_j[ex^Zo kf =Z[^jZobf =Zj[^jZofZg ©LZjbo Z^-^Zmey ZkKZ]m^byZe-meyªKOZebnZNZo^©>`ZobfZe-omdfZk-KZ]m^b\Zgb
jZgZe-\ZooZ[byªK
340
B[g ;ZrZj ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª – =Z[^jZobf =Z[^jZofZg
©:^->ZmeyZk-KZ]m^byZe-meyªK– 103.
341
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 2/42.
338
132
gZ HfZg jmdh\h^beb KZ]^ [bg FmoZffZ^ [bg Fm]ZcdZe
©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª =mfZj [bg FmoZffZ^ [bg FmoZf
fZ^ [bg =ZnbkZg wfbj Ze-BokZ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª =Z[^jZofZg [bg B[jZobf ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª OZkZg
JZofZo©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªFmleZdZl-LZcjb©=mg\Zg
Ze-fZ^`^ª KZ]^ [bg FmleZd ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª
;ZllZe Ze-FZlujb [jZl FmleZdZ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª
bmihfbgZ_lkyqlhwlhlq_eh\_dbFmleZd[ueb\h
_gZqZevgbdZfb\hckd\h\j_fyihoh^h\gZHfZg=Z[^meeZ[bg
FZajm]©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªLmjdb[bgKZ]m^\f_kl_kh
k\hbfb [jZlvyfb GZkujhf b KZ]^hf ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª
1/155- :ofZ^Z Zk-KZ^bjb342 m^b\ey_l lh qlh B[g ;ZrZj
gZau\Z_l ihke_^gh]h ij_^\h^bl_e_f fmkmevfZgkdh]h \hckdZ \
HfZg_ b Ze-BokZ343 gh q_j_a g_kdhevdh kljZgbp hg khh[sZ_l
qlhwlhlq_eh\_d[uelbjZghf]jZ[b\rbfg_\bgguoex^_c344.
<hl d_f [ueb \h`^b \ZooZ[blkdh]h BkeZfZ345 >Ze__ fu ijb
\_^_f_s_g_kdhevdhijbf_jh\ha\_jkl\ZogZl_jjblhjbbHfZ
gZ
:[m>Z[b
FmleZdZe-FZlujb\h]eZ\_hljy^Zkhklhy\r_]hbalu
kyqb\kZ^gbdh\kh\_jrbegZ[_]gZHfZggZiZegZie_fy;Zgm
Ykhlh[jZemgbo[hevrh_dhebq_kl\hbfms_kl\Zb\_jgmekyk
gbf \ G_^`^ Iha^g__ B[jZobf [bg =ZnbkZg lZd`_ kh\_jrbe
gZ[_] b m\_e hq_gv fgh]h hfZgkdbo \_j[ex^h\346 H^gZdh wlb
ihoh^u g_ \k_]^Z aZ\_jrZebkv mki_rgh bgh]^Z \ZooZ[blh\
`^ZebaZkZ^uh[h^ghcbagboB[g;ZrZjibr_l©FmleZdZeFZlujb\h]eZ\_k\h_]hhljy^ZgZijZ\beky\HfZggh_]h`^Z
eZaZkZ^Zih^]hlh\e_ggZyB[gLZogmghf347<blh]_fmkmevfZ
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª– 2/133.
LZf`_– 2/86.
344
LZf`_– 2/90
345
B[g;ZrZjg_mihfbgZ_lB[g>`Ze\b\hafh`ghwlhlq_eh\_dihy\beky
iha^g__
346
:[mOZdZ©ExfZ]Zr-rboZ[ª–K–=Z[^jZobf=Z[^jZofZg©:^>Z\eyZk-KZ]m^byZe-meyªK. 93 – 94.
347
R_coKZ]b^[bgLZogmg
342
343
133
g_ihl_ji_ebkbevg_cr__ihjZ`_gb_fgh]b_bagbo[uebm[b
lu Z qZklv mf_jeZ hl `Z`^u«348ª o\ZeZ :eeZom B[g ;ZrZj
gZklZb\Z_l gZ lhf qlh wlbo ex^_c g_h[oh^bfh gZau\Zlv fm
kmevfZgZfb q_f `_ hgb hlebqZxlky hl hklZevguo `bl_e_c
Ob^`ZaZ k\b^_l_evkl\mxsbo qlh g_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZ
oZ" < qZklghklb h[ m[bluo \ZooZ[blZo hg ibr_l ©: ba qbkeZ
fmkmevfZg \ wlhc [bl\_ ih]b[ lZdhc-lh kug lZdh]h-lhª349 GZ
kZfhf ^_e_ ]_jhb B[g ;ZrZjZ [ueb gZklhysbfb jZa[hcgbdZ
fbm[b\Z\rbfbb]jZ[b\rbfbg_\bgguoex^_c350bf_gghih
wlhfmaZkZ^Z;ZgbYky\ey_lky^hklhcgufhl\_lhfwlbfex^yf
JZkZe-oZcfZ
Dh]^ZdZkbfbluhldZaZebkvijbgylv\ZooZ[bafdgbfba
Z^->Zj]bb [ueh ihkeZgh \hckdh dhlhjuf jmdh\h^be JZrb^
[bg KbgZg Ze-FZlujb Ihke_ ijh^he`bl_evghc \hcgu b [eh
dZ^u \ l_q_gb_ ^g_c ]eZ\Z dZkbfblh\ [ue \ugm`^_g ijb
gylv lj_[h\Zgby \ZooZ[blh\ gh kh k\h_c klhjhgu ihlj_[h\Ze
[_ahiZkghklb b khojZg_gby k\h_]h klZlmkZ \h`^y ie_f_gb LZ
dbf h[jZahf ie_fy dZkbfblh\ \ ] ] [ueh \ugm`
^_gh ijbgylv \Zoo[Zabf351 B^_heh]b \ZooZ[bafZ hlijZ\eyy
k\hb\hckdZ\wlhlj_]bhgZe-;jbfb]h\hjbeb©<ufh^`Zo_
^u-_^bgh[h`gbdb \ZrZ aZ^ZqZ \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v gZibkZlv
ibkvfh KZdjm [bg JZrb^m Ze-DZkbfb352 b m[_^blv _]h \ g_h[
oh^bfhklbijbgylbygZr_cj_eb]bbbih^qbg_gbygZf<ijh
lb\ghf kemqZ_ \hxcl_ k gbf \k_fb \hafh`gufb imlyfb _keb
\Zrbokbe[m^_lg_^hklZlhqghlh]^Zyijbrex\Zfih^dj_i
e_gb_baZ^->Zj]bbª353<ZooZ[bluih[_^b\dZkbfblh\hldju
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 2/118.
GZijbf_jkf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
350
LZf`_«
351
:[m OZdZ ©ExfZ] Zr-rboZ[ª – 78 – =Z[^jZobf =Z[^jZofZg ©:^>Z\eyZk-KZ]m^byZe-meyª–b^hdlhjNmZ^KZ]b^Ze-=Z[b^©Kby
kZ;jblZgbynbZe-oZeb^`ª–K-37.
352
IjZ\bl_evJZkZe-OZcfZ
353
:[m OZdZ ©ExfZ] Zr-rboZ[ª – 78 – =Z[^jZobf =Z[^jZofZg ©:^>Z\ey Zk-KZ]m^by Ze-meyª – 93 – Iha^g__ \ ] ] \ZooZ[blu
^hklZ\beb KZdjZ Ze-DZkbfb \ Z^->Zj]bx b aZdexqbeb ih^ kljZ`m <f_klh
348
349
134
eb imlv ojbklbZgkdbf aZ\h_\Zl_eyf k fhjy h^bg ba \h`^_c
\ZooZ[bafZ\]gZibkZeZg]ebqZgZf©«yk^_eZe\k_qlh
[u ihke_^h\Zl_eb FmoZffZ^Z354 g_ kfh]eb \j_^blv \Zrbfdh
jZ[eyfª355 Ihke_ aZ\h_\Zgby \ZooZ[blZfb JZk Ze-OZcfZ ij_
\jZlbeky \ ieZp^Zjf ba dhlhjh]h hgb kh\_jrZeb gZ[_]b gZ
^jm]b_ j_]bhgu HfZgZ Ihwlhfm kmelZg HfZgZ ihevamykv fh
f_glhf jZagh]eZkbc f_`^m Zg]ebqZgZfb b \ZooZ[blZfb [ue
\ugm`^_g gZiZklv gZ JZk Ze-OZcfZ b ih]Zkblv \ZooZ[blkdmx
kfmlmG_kfhljygZwlh\ZooZ[blubkihevah\Zeba_febdZkbfb
lh\^eyjZa`b]Zgbykfmlu\HfZg_bmgbqlh`_gby_]h]hkm^Zj
kl\_gghklb356.
HZabkZe-;jbfb357
< ] ] Ze-;jbfb ih^\_j]ky `_klhdhfm gZr_
kl\bx \ZooZ[blh\ ih^ jmdh\h^kl\hf FmleZdZ Ze-FZlujb
HfZgpu^hkboihj\kihfbgZxlwlhgZr_kl\b_dZdijbf_jq_
eh\_q_kdhc ^bdhklb b a\_jkl\Z Iha^g__ \ ] ] g_
f_g__`_klhdbcgZ[_]kh\_jrbe_]hkug<h\j_fywlh]hgZ[_]Z
ijhbahreZ [bl\Z Ze-=ZlbdZ358 <ZooZ[blu hq_gv ohl_eb aZo\Z
lblv wlb a_feb b ijbkh_^bgblv bo d k\h_fm ]hkm^Zjkl\m Hkh
[_gghhimklhrbl_evgufbwlbgZ[_]bhdZaZebkv^eyie_f_gZgGZ]bf;ZgmDZ][b;ZgmDml[Djhf_gZ[_]h\\ZooZ[bluih^
g_]h ijZ\bl_e_f JZk Ze-OZcfZ [ue gZagZq_g h^bg ba \ZooZ[blkdbo ]eZ\Z
j_cgh^Z`_wlhgZagZq_gb_g_ijbg_kehfbj\JZkZe-OZcfZ
354
Bf__lky\\b^mIjhjhdk]k–ii
355
©Fm^`Za lZjbo ]Zg dZ[Zbe Ze-\ZooZ[by Ze-]ZjZ[byª ©DjZldZy bklhjby
\ZooZ[blkdboZjZ[kdboie_f_gª\k[hjgbd_©FmolZjZlfbgkZ^`Zeyl;mf
[Zcª©Ba[jZggh_ba;hf[_ckdboaZibkhdª–FZdlZ[ZZk-kbjjbyZk-kbykby
;hf[_c–LKgZZg]eya
356
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/215.
357
K_cqZk qZklv wlh]h hZabkZ y\ey_lky l_jjblhjb_c H:W Z ^jm]Zy qZklv
l_jjblhjb_cHfZgZ
358
<ZooZ[blkdb_ kbeu \ha]eZ\ey_fu_ KZ]^hf [bg FmleZdhf Ze-FZlujb
ihl_ji_ebihjZ`_gb_Kf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ªIhke_wlh]h\ZooZ
[blkdh_ \hckdh ihemqbeh ih^dj_ie_gb_ b lhevdh ihke_ wlh]h kfh]eh h^h
e_lvKZ]b^Z[bgLZogmgZ
135
dmiZeb fgh]bo mq_guo Ze-;jbfb359 < dhg_qghf blh]_ Ze;jbfbij_\jZlbeky\_s_h^bg\ZooZ[blkdbcieZp^Zjf
KuoZj
<–]–]]\ZooZ[bluijh^he`beb
k\hb gZ[_]b gZ HfZg <hl qlh ibr_l h[ wlhf ]eZ\guc \ZooZ
[blkdbc bklhjbd =mkfZg [bg ;Zrbj bgh]^Z hg ^himkdZ_l
hrb[db \ gZibkZgbb bf_g \h_gZqZevgbdh\ b lhihgbfh\
©«aZl_f KZ]m^ gZijZ\be =Z[^meem [bg FZajm]Z b _s_ g_
kdhevdbog_^`^bcp_\\k\hxdj_ihklv\Ze-;jbfblZd`_lm^Z
[ue ihkeZg FmleZd Ze-FZlujb k g_^`^bckdbf \hckdhf«Hgb
gZiZeb gZ f_klghklv KuoZj ]^_ khklhyebkv [bl\u ijhlb\ =Z
aZgZ[bgDZckZbKZ]b^Z[bgKmelZgZijZ\bl_eyFZkdZlZ<hc
kdh=ZaZgZihg_keh[hevrb_ihl_jb[uehm[blhhdhehiylbkhl
_]hex^_cIhke_wlh]hdFmleZdmZe-FZlujbijbkh_^bgbebkv
\k_ klhjhggbdb KZ]m^Z \ HfZg_ lh]^Z `bl_eyf KuoZjZ ihl_
jy\rbf lukyqb [hcph\ ijbrehkv k^Zlvky <hckdZ KZ]m^Z
\iehlv^h]m[b\Zeb`bl_e_cwlh]hj_]bhgZbhl[bjZebbo
bfms_kl\hFmleZdaZo\Zlbefgh]b_^_j_\gbKuoZjZbbo`b
l_eyfijbrehkvijbky]gmlvgZ\_jghklvj_eb]bb:eeZoZb?]h
IjhjhdZ b ih^qbgblvky \eZklyf < blh]_ \ jmdZo KZ]b^Z hk
lZekylhevdhFZkdZlZ\jmdZo=ZaZgZlhevdhg_dhlhju_^_j_
\mrdbKuoZjZgZiZ\gZdhlhju_fmkmevfZg_lZd`_aZo\Zlbeb
fgh]h bfms_kl\Z iylmx qZklv dhlhjh]h hlijZ\eyeb KZ]m^m \
Z^->Zj]bxª360.
R_co AZb^ [bg KmelZg jZkkdZaZe qlh bxey ] d g_fm q_j_a ih
kj_^gbdZ h[jZlbeky =Z[^meeZ Ze-DmjZrb b ij_^eh`be _fm gh\mx fZrbgm
aZ q_luj_ lukyqb jmibc Z lZd`_ h[_sZe aZ dZ`^h_ g_nlygh_ f_klhjh`^_
gb_gZc^_ggh_gZl_jjblhjbbZe-;jbfb\uieZqb\Zlvihq_luj_klZfbeeb
hgh\ jmibc gh r_co AZb^ hldZaZeky hl wlh]h ij_^eh`_gby DZd ba\_klgh
=Z[^meeZ Ze-DmjZrb [ue ijhkluf ibkZl_e_f iha^g__ hgb \f_kl_ k Lmjdb
[bg =ZlurZghf gZqZeb ibkZlv dgb]b \ dhlhjuo ijhiZ]Zg^bjh\Zeb \ZooZ
[blkdb_m[_`^_gbyiulZykvkdehgblvdgbfmq_guoZe-;jbfbK_cqZkwlhl
q_eh\_dy\ey_lkyfbeebZj^_jhfhgb_]h_^bghfure_ggbdbihdmiZxl\k_o
dh]h`_eZxlk^_eZlv\ZooZ[blZfbKfGZkujZe-NZjZ^`©DbyfZe-]brZj
Zk-KZ]m^byªK.
360
B[g ;ZrZj ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª – Ohly KZ]m^ aZij_lbe k\hbf
kugh\vyfkh\_jrZlvgZ[_]bgZHfZg^eyk_[yhgbokqblZejZaj_r_ggufb
359
136
GZf lhqgh ba\_klgh qlh bfZf =ZaZg [bg DZck aZgye
k\hc jmdh\h^ysbc ihkl \ ] ] qlh dZkZ_lky KZ]b^Z
[bgKmelZgZlhhg[uekmelZghf\-]]LZd`_ba\_kl
ghqlh\ZooZ[bluhq_gvkbevgh^hdmqZebie_f_gZf`b\rbf\
Ze-;jbfbihwlhfmhgbZbf_gghbo\h`^vFmoZffZ^[bg=Zeb
Zg-GZ]bfb \ ] h[jZlbebkv aZ ihfhsvx d bfZfm =ZaZgm
yg\Zjy]hg\uklmibe\ihoh^bq_j_aq_luj_^gyl_j
jblhjby Ze-;jbfb [ueZ hk\h[h`^_gZ hl \ZooZ[blkdhc hddmiZ
pbbihke_q_]hbfZfgZagZqbek\hbogZf_klgbdh\bdZab_\361,
Zl_gZqZeb\ha\jZsZlvbfms_kl\hgZ]jZ[e_ggh_\ZooZ[blZfb
_]haZdhggufohay_\Zf
RZggZk
<ur_ fu m`_ kdZaZeb qlh \ZooZ[blu [ueb k_dlhc kh
a^ZgghcojbklbZgZfbZbf_ggh[jblZgkdhcjZa\_^dhcihwlhfm
hgb b ^_ckl\h\Zeb kh\f_klgh ihfh]Zy ^jm] ^jm]m dh]^Z [ueZ
g_h[oh^bfhklvLhqghlZd`_hgbihklmibebbk]hjh^hfRZg
gZk Ihke_ lh]h dZd \ ] ] _]h `bl_eb g_ ih^qbgb
ebkv FmleZdm Ze-FZlujb hg [ue ih^\_j]gml Zjlbee_jbckdhc
[hf[Zj^bjh\d_kfhjyihke_q_]hk^ZgFmleZdm
Kmj
< ] ] \ZooZ[blu bkihevamy Ze-;jbfb dZd
ieZp^Zjf gZiZeb gZ ]hjh^ Kmj aZo\Zlbeb _]h mgbqlh`beb
fgh]bo `bl_e_c b aZ\eZ^_eb ^_gv]Zfb b lh\ZjZfb dmiph\ Gh
gZkqZklv_dmiph\kj_^bgbohdZaZebkv[jblZgkdb_ih^^Zggu_
bg^bckdh]h ijhbkoh`^_gby b [jblZgkdb_ \eZklb ihlj_[h\Zeb
hl\ZooZ[blh\ihdbgmlv]hjh^b[hevr_gZg_]hg_gZiZ^Zlv:
^eymkljZr_gby\ZooZ[blkdhcZjfbbn_\jZey]hgbmk
ljhbebihdZaZl_evgu_aZeiukfhjy
>`Z]eyg
B[g;ZrZjhibku\Zykh[ulbyamevdZ]^u]ghy[jy
] jZkkdZau\Z_l ©«KZ]m^ hlijZ\be FmleZdZ \ HfZg b
gZagZqbe_]h]eZ\guf\h_gZqZevgbdhffmkmevfZgkdbo\hckd\
wlhf j_]bhg_ FmleZd kh k\hbfb hljy^Zfb gZijZ\beky \ ba\_
>hdlhjOmk_cg=m[Zc^=Z[[Zr©HfZgZ^-^bfmdjZluyZe-bkeZfbylZdZ
eb^Ze-bfZfmZZl-lZjboZk-kbykbª–Ze->`Z^b^–K
361
137
klguc ]hjh^ >`Z]eyg Ihke_ lh]h dZd ]hjh^ ijh\_e g_dhlhjh_
\j_fy \ [ehdZ^_ FmleZdm m^Zehkv aZo\Zlblv [hevrh_ dhebq_
kl\hkdhlZFmleZdihemqb\ohjhrmx^h[uqmkgye[ehdZ^mb
mr_e : `bl_eb ]hjh^Z h[t_^bgbebkv k ie_f_gZfb `b\rbfb
g_ih^Ze_dmb^\bgmebkvaZFmleZdhf>\_Zjfbb\klj_lbebkv
bijhbahreZdjmigZy[bl\Z\dhlhjhcih]b[ehfgh]hfmkmev
fZg b \ qZklghklb FmleZdª362 Ih^_ehf wlbf \hjZf b jZa[hc
gbdZfjZ^h\Z\rbfkye_]dhc^h[uq_o\ZeZ:eeZom
FZkdZlFZljZo;ZjdZKZfZbeZa-AZobjZ
<ZooZ[blu \ha]eZ\ey_fu_ FmleZdhf gZiZeb gZ KZfZ
363
be ;ZjdZ FZljZo jZa]jZ[beb wlb ]hjh^Z Z aZl_f gZijZ\b
ebkv \ FZkdZl Bf g_ m^Zehkv ij_h^he_lv kl_gu ]hjh^Z lh]^Z
hgb kh`]eb ihk_ehd i_j_k_e_gp_\ k Bg^hklZgZ gZoh^b\rbcky
m]hjh^kdbokl_g
B[g;ZrZjhibku\Zykh[ulby]]jZkkdZau
\Z_l©=eZ\guf\h_gZqZevgbdhf[uegZagZq_gLmjdbbhljy^u
ih^_]hdhfZg^h\Zgb_f^\bgmebkv\HfZgHgbaZo\ZlbebFZ
ljZom[bebfgh`_kl\h`bl_e_cbaZo\Zlbebfgh]h^h[uqbAZ
l_fwlbhljy^u^\bgmebkv\^hevih[_j_`vyaZo\ZlbebOZenZg
b^\bgmebkvgZ>`Z]eygKmjKuoZj\k_wlb]hjh^ZlZd`_[u
eb aZo\Zq_gu < wlh \j_fy KZ]m^ kh\_jrZe iZehfgbq_kl\h
dh]^Z _fm jZkkdZaZeb h ^_ckl\byo _]h \hckd hg hq_gv kbevgh
jZkk_j^bekyª DZd \b^bl_ \ZooZ[blkdb_ ihoh^u ij_^klZ\eyeb
kh[hc gZklhysb_ jZa[hcgbqvb gZ[_]b gZ bo kh\_klb hklZebkv
djh\vbbfms_kl\hfmkmevfZgHfZgZB[g;ZrZjibr_l©Ku
gh\vy KZ]m^Z hdZaZebkv \ hq_gv aZljm^gbl_evghf iheh`_gbb
gh \ukhdhihklZ\e_ggu_ fmkmevfZg_ Z^->Zj]bb b ^jm]bo j_]b
hgh\ aZklmibebkv aZ gboª364 Ihkfhljbl_ \h`^b \ZooZ[bafZ
aZklmiZxlky aZ ex^_c ij_klmib\rbo ]jZgbpu mklZgh\e_ggu_
:eeZohf
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/164 – 165.
< dhgp_ Amevob^`b ] ^_dZ[jv ] \h \j_f_gZ ijZ\e_gby Fm
oZffZ^Z[bgGZkujZZe->`Z[jbkfm=Z[^jZobfZ=Z[^jZofZgZ©:^->Zmey
Zk-KZ]m^byZe-meyª:[mOZdZ©EmfZ]Zr-rboZ[ª– 85 –B[g;ZrZj.
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/156.
364
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/155.
362
363
138
AunZj
<gZqZe_^\Z^pZlh]h\_dZ\ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZ\ha]eZ\
ey_fu_KZ\ZcyghfgZiZebgZAunZjHgbijhrebihGZ^`jZ
gm b OZ^jZfZmlm b m\_eb fgh`_kl\h \_j[ex^h\ Wlhl gZ[_]
[uekh\_jr_gihke_lh]hdZd>`hgNbebiibjZkkdZaZe\ZooZ
[blZf h[ wlhf j_]bhg_ >bdkhg ijbagZeky qlh \ ] ebqgh
\b^_e wlbo \hjh\Zgguo \_j[ex^h\ hg jZkkdZau\Ze qlh hgb
[ueb dhjbqg_\h]h p\_lZ Z bo dhklb [ueb lhgvr_ q_f m l_o
dhlhju_\h^ylky\Ze-BokZ365.
Ih^\h^y blh] fh`gh kdZaZlv qlh \ZooZ[blu m[beb b
h]jZ[bebfgh]bo`bl_e_cHfZgZZhklZ\rb_ky\`b\uo[hykv
aZk\hx`bagv[ueb\ugm`^_guijbgylvgh\mx\ZooZ[blkdmx
j_eb]bxG_lkbeubfh]ms_kl\Zgbmdh]hdjhf_:eeZoZ
;_^u\uiZ\rb_gZ]heh\u\ZooZ[blh\
Bamq_gb_\ZooZ[blkdbogZ[_]h\gZHfZgiha\hey_lk^_
eZlv\u\h^hlhfqlhfgh]b_bawlbogZ[_]h\aZ\_jrbebkvg_
m^ZqghihjZ`_gb_feb[h\wlb]h^ugZbo]heh\u\uiZeb^jm
]b_[_^kl\by
B[g ;ZrZj jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf qlh ihke_ gZqZeZ ih
oh^h\gZHfZg:eeZogZkeZegZG_^`^aZkmomb]heh^<qZkl
ghklb ihke_ ihoh^h\ ] ] dh]^Z [ueh mdjZ^_gh
hq_gv fgh]h kdhlZ \ G_^`^_ [ue lZdhc ]heh^ qlh p_gu gZ
ir_gbpm \hajhkeb \ ljb – q_luj_ jZaZ Z gZ nbgbdb \ ^_kylv
jZaDjhf_wlh]h:eeZogZkeZegZG_^`^qmfmdhlhjZymg_keZ
`bagb fgh]bo `bl_e_c wlh]h j_]bhgZ Ih]b[eb fgh]b_ \ZooZ
[blkdb_ dZabb b mq_gu_ \qbke_ih]b[rbohlqmfu[uebdZ
abc Z^->Zj]bb r_co Omk_cg [bg r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me
\ZooZ[ dhlhjuc ihke_ gZ[_]h\ ^_ebe gZ]jZ[e_ggh_ [h]Zlkl\h
Bo iheh`_gb_ klZeh gZklhevdh ly`_euf qlh wfbj Z^->Zj]bb
[ue \ugm`^_g \u\_kblv ih\_e_gb_ h[ h[yaZl_evghf ihdZygbb
^ey dZ`^h]h `bl_ey wlh]h j_]bhgZ366 JZkkdZau\Zy h kh[ulbyo
] ] hg ibr_l ©< wlhl ]h^ \ HfZg [ueh ihkeZgh
\hckdh\h]eZ\_kZe-FZlujb\f_kl_kgbfb[ueihkeZgdZabc
365
366
>bdkhg©=ZjZ[Zk-kZojZª–K– 336.
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/144 – 145.
139
GZkug[bg=ZebZe-=ZjbgbB\wlhl`_]h^hloheh^Zih]b[eh
hq_gvfgh]hihk_\h\`bl_e_cZ^->Zj]bbbhgbmki_ebkh[jZlv
lhevdh^\_q_l\_jlbª367.
<ZooZ[blkdbc bklhjbd g_ jZa mihfbgZ_l h lhf dZd
:eeZogZdZau\Ze\ZooZ[blh\ihke_ihoh^h\gZHfZg<qZklgh
klbwfbjGZkuj[bgKZ]m^kugdhjheyihke_ihoh^ZgZHfZg
b\ha\jZs_gby\Z^->Zj]bxkbevghaZ[he_ebfmqbeky^\Zf_
kypZihke_q_]hmf_jBhl_p\h\j_fy[he_agbgbjZam_]hg_
gZ\_klbe368.
LhqghlZdZy`_bklhjbyijbdexqbeZkvk;ZllZehfZeFZlujb b ^jm]bfb \h_gZqZevgbdZfb \ha]eZ\ey\rbfb ihoh^u
gZ HfZg ;hevrbgkl\h wlbo ex^_c mf_jeh hl qmfu LZdZy `_
mqZklvihklb]ZeZbdZab_\^_eb\rbogZ]jZ[e_ggu_[h]Zlkl\Z\
qZklghklb FmoZffZ^ [bg Fmdjbg mf_j hl `ZjZ dhlhjuc gZ
qZekymg_]hihke_\ha\jZs_gby\Ze-BokZ369.
Hibku\Zykh[ulby]]B[g;ZrZjmdZau
\Z_l©<wlhf]h^mbfZfjZkk_j^bekygZKZ]^Z[bgFmleZdZZeFZlujbaZlhqlhhgihl_ji_eihjZ`_gb_370\HfZg_bhlkljZ
gbe _]h hl ^he`ghklb \iehlv ^h kf_jlbª371 B ijZ\bevgh k^_
eZe\_^vihjZ`_gb_[uehhq_gv^Z`_kbevguf\h\j_fywlhc
[bl\u[uehm[blhfgh`_kl\h\ZooZ[blh\b\qZklghklbdZabc
=Z[^jZofZg [bg =ZaaZa372 <hl lZdbf h[jZahf :eeZo ^Z_l
\eZklvh^gbflbjZgZfgZ^^jm]bfb
B ^_ckl\bl_evgh _keb \u ijhke_^bl_ bklhjbx \ZooZ
[bafZ lh m\b^bl_ qlh ihke_ dZ`^h]h gZ[_]Z kh\_jr_ggh]h
ijhlb\fmkmevfZg:eeZogZdZau\ZewlbolbjZgh\Mgbqlh`Ze
bo ihk_\u373 gZkueZe ]heh^374 [u\Zeb kemqZb dh]^Z aZ jZa
LZf`_– 2/110.
LZf`_– 1/155-156.
369
LZf`_– 2/134.
370
Bf__lky\\b^mihjZ`_gb_\[bl\_Ze-=ZlbdZ
371
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 2/129.
372
LZf`_– 2/118.
373
LZf`_– 1/49, 2/30, 1/75.
374
LZf`_– 2/27.
367
368
140
mfbjZeh k_fvkhl \ZooZ[blh\375 Ih wlhfm ih\h^m h^bg ba ih
wlh\376gZibkZeke_^mxsb_kljhdb©<k_wlhijhbkoh^bllhevdh
ih\he_:eeZoZHgdZjZ_lex^_caZbo]j_obH^gbogZdZau\Z
_l Z ^jm]bf ^Z_l \hafh`ghklv h^mfZlvkyª Gh d kh`Ze_gbx
wlbex^bg_ba\e_dZxlmjhdbbakemqb\r_]hky
C_f_g
<ZooZ[blkdb_\hckdZ^hrebb^hC_f_gZaZo\Zlbeb_]h
klhebpmKZgZm[bebbh]jZ[bebfgh]bo`bl_e_cwlh]h]hjh^Z
ihke_q_]hgZagZqbebk\h_]h]jZ^hgZqZevgbdZBgh]^Zqbke_g
ghklv \ZooZ[blkdbo \hckd \ C_f_g_ ^hklb]ZeZ iylb^_kylb lu
kyqq_eh\_d377.
B[g;ZrZjhibku\Zykh[ulby]]jZkkdZau
\Z_l h lhf dZd \ZooZ[blu aZo\Zlbeb ]hjh^ Ze-OZ^b^Z ©AZl_f
bfZf KZgu m`_ \ZooZ[blkdbc gZijZ\be \hckdZ \ Ze-OZ^b^m
Hgb hkZ^beb ]hjh^ b \ kdhjhf \j_f_gb hg [ue \ayl« Ihke_
wlh]hKZebomihfygmluc\ur_klZe]hlh\blv\hckdZdaZo\Zlm
Am[Zc^Z>eyaZo\ZlZwlh]h]hjh^Z[uehhlijZ\e_ghlj_olukyq
gh_ \hckdh hgh aZo\Zlbeh wlhl ]hjh^ b h\eZ^_eh _]h g_kf_l
gufb[h]Zlkl\ZfbIhke_wlh]hKZeboh^gmiylmx^h[uqbhl
ijZ\be\Z^->Zj]bxª378.
<ZooZ[blZf ihgjZ\beky \dmk c_f_gkdhc djh\b b ^h[u
qb ihwlhfm hgb \ ] ] kh\_jrbeb gh\uc ihoh^
©Ihke_ wlh]h LZfb[bgRm]Zc[wfbj=ZkbjZ:efZ]b^jm]b_
\h_gZqZevgbdb\h]eZ\_h]jhfgh]h\hckdZkhklhy\r_]hba`b
l_e_cOb^`ZaZDZolZgZb^jm]boj_]bhgh\gZijZ\bebkv\ihj
lh\uc ]hjh^ Ze-Eyoby Ihke_ g_^he]hc hkZ^u ]hjh^ iZe b aZ
o\ZlqbdZf^hklZehkv\k__]h[h]Zlkl\hhgb\u\_aebhq_gvfgh
]hahehlZk_j_[jZldZg_c`_fqm]Zr_edZb^jGZfjZkkdZau
\Zebqlhg_dhlhju_bamqZklgbdh\rlmjfZijbgyeb`_fqm]aZ
LZf`_– 1/179, 1/45.
=Z[^me]Zaba[bgOZf^[bgGZkujkf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 2/34.
377
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª–lK–Ij_^klZ\vl_qlh[ueh[u_keb
[ulZdZyh]jhfgZyZjfby[hjheZkvaZhk\h[h`^_gb_ZjZ[kdboa_f_evhlaZ
iZ^guodhehgbaZlhjh\
378
LZf`_–LK
375
376
141
dmdmjmambklZeb__jZafZeu\Zlv;uehm[blhhq_gvfgh]h`b
l_e_cwlh]h]hjh^ZjZkkdZau\Zxlqlhqbke_gghklvm[bluo^h
klb]eZh^ghclukyqbIhke_jZa]jZ[e_gby[hevrZyqZklv]hjh
^Z [ueZ jZajmr_gZ b kh``_gZ AZl_f hgb gZijZ\bebkv \ ZeOZ^b^Z aZo\Zlbeb _]h kbehc ihke_ jZa]jZ[e_gby ]hjh^Z \k_
[h]Zlkl\h b \ky Zjfby [ueb ih]jm`_gu gZ dhjZ[eb >h\_j_g
gu_ ebpZ KZ]m^Z aZ[jZeb h^gm iylmx qZklv \k_]h [h]Zlkl\Z b
hl\_aeb _]h \ Z^->Zj]bxª379 DZdb_ ih^hgdb Wlb ex^b [ueb
gZklhevdh^bdbfbqlhg_fh]ebhlebqblv`_fqm]hldmdmjmau
Q_f`_hlebqZ_lkybogZr_kl\b_hlgZr_kl\byfhg]heh\"Qlh
wlhaZBkeZfiha\heyxsbcm[b\Zlvb]jZ[blvfmkmevfZg380?
GZ^`jZg
Bklhjbd \ZooZ[bafZ =mkfZg Zg-GZ^`^b381 jZkkdZau\Z_l
h kh[ulbyo ] ] ©< wlhf ]h^m KZ]m^ ih\_e_e =Z[
^me\ZooZ[mNZoZ^m[bgRZ[ZdZgm=Z[b^_bboex^yfZlZd`_
g_dhlhjufhljy^Zfba^jm]boj_]bhgh\ih^]hlh\blvkydihoh
^m gZ GZ^`jZg ;ueh kh[jZgh h]jhfgh_ ljb^pZlblukyqgh_
\hckdh \ imlb hgb gZ g_kdhevdh ^g_c hklZgh\bebkv \ ;Z^j_
]^_ijhbahrehfgh]hkluq_df_`^m\hckdZfbbf_klgufb`b
l_eyfbb[uebihl_jbkh[_boklhjhgª
LZdh\ZdjZldZybklhjby\ZooZ[blkdbogZ[_]h\gZC_f_g
djhf_ lh]h B[g ;ZrZj mihfbgZ_l qlh \ ] ] \ C_
f_g [ueh gZijZ\e_gh \hkvfblukyqgh_ \hckdh \h ]eZ\_ k LZfb
[bg Rm]Zc[hf hl jmd dhlhjh]h ih]b[eh fgh]h ex^_c382 Hk
gh\ghc p_evx wlh]h ihoh^Z [ueh m[bckl\h FmoZffZ^Z =Zeb
LZf`_LK– 152.
KjZ\gbl_ihklmihd\ZooZ[blh\kihklmidhfb[Z^blkdh]h\hckdZ\h]eZ\_
k=Z[^meehc[bgYot_cZe-Dbg^bZe-YfZgbIhke_lh]hdZdhf_y^ujZahjb
eb`bl_e_cKZguwlh\hckdh\_jgmehbfdhgnbkdh\Zggh_bfms_kl\hbg_
ihlj_[h\ZehaZwlhgb_^bgh]h^bjoZfZKfOZebnZ[bgOZcyl©LZjboZeoZebnZªB[gZe-:kbj©:e-DZfbenbZl-lZjboªZe-;ZeZaZjb
klj [ Ze-:knZoZgb ©:e-:]Zgbª – Ze-;ZjZ^b ©:e>`Z\Zobj Ze-fmglZdZª Zr-RZfZob ©:k-KZcjª Zj-JZdbrb ©FZ
kZ[boZa-aZeyfª
381
R_co=mkfZgdZdb\k_\ZooZ[bluibr_l^h\hevghkeZ[hghg_kfhljy
gZwlh\ZooZ[bluijhiZ]Zg^bjmxl_]h\_a^_]^_\hafh`gh
382
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/179.
379
380
142
iZrbLZd`_fh`_l_hagZdhfblvkykgZ[_]hfgZFZoZ\]
]Z\]\ZooZ[blu\hh[s_h[ty\beb\hcgmC_f_gm
BjZd
<ZooZ[blu gZqZeb l_jjhjbabjh\Zlv BjZd \ ] kh
\aju\h\ \ D_j[_e_ aZl_f \ ] ihke_^h\Zeh gZiZ^_gb_ gZ
;ZkjmZ\]khjhdZiylblukyqgh_\hckdhhkZ^beh;Z]^Z^383,
hgbgZeh`bebgZ`bl_e_c]hjh^Z^`bavxZlZd`_dhgnbkdh\Z
eb[hevrmxqZklvbobfms_kl\ZAZl_fhgbgZijZ\bebkvgZk_
\_jb^hc^y^hdmj^kdbojZchgh\ihlj_[h\Zebhlbo`bl_e_c
\uieZlu agZqbl_evghc kmffu ^_g_] H[h \k_ wlhf \u fh`_l_
ijhq_klv \ dgb]_ ]eZ\gh]h bklhjbdZ \ZooZ[bafZ =mkfZgZ [bg
;ZrZjZ384.
KmdZr-Rmxo
Hibku\Zykh[ulby]]B[g;ZrZjjZkkdZau
\Z_l ©< wlhf ]h^m \ f_kyp JZfZaZg KZ]m^ [bg =Z[^me]Zaba
\f_kl_khk\hbfbg_^`^bckdbfb\hckdZfbgZijZ\bekygZk_\_j
b gZiZe gZ Kmd Zr-Rmxo m[be fgh]bo `bl_e_c qZklv bo dh
lhjuomlhgmeZmih[_j_`vyfhjyª385.
Ijb]hjh^ub^hebgZZk-KZfZ\Z
< wlhf `_ ]h^m hgb kh\_jrbeb gZ[_] \ ^hebgm ZkKZfZ\Zh[wlhfihoh^_B[g;ZrZjk]hj^hklvxibr_l©AZl_f
hgKZ]m^\h]eZ\_\ZooZ[blkdh]h\hckdZgZijZ\beky\^hebgm
Zk-KZfZ\Z ?]h eZamlqbdb khh[sbeb _fm qlh m bklhqgbdZ Ze:[vy^ kh[jZehkv fgh`_kl\h [_^mbgkdbo ie_f_g magZ\ wlm
\_klvKZ]m^gZiZegZgboª386>Ze__hgjZkkdZau\Z_lqlh\hc
kdZKZ]m^ihke_^h\ZebaZ[_]msbfbbgZiZ\gZbo^hfZhlh[
jZebbfms_kl\hb\_j[ex^h\
>hdlhj FmoZffZ^ DZfbev ©:^->Z]\Zlm Ze-\ZooZ[by \Z ZkZjmoZ nb ZenbdjZe-bkeZfbZe-oZ^bkª-K
384
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª– 1/152 –kfkh[ulby]]
385
LZf`_–LhqghlZdmx`_bgnhjfZpbx\ufh`_l_h[gZjm`blvm
EhjbfZjZ >` >` < ©MdZaZl_ev Ze-OZeb^`Zª jZa^_e bklhjbb Ihoh^ gZ
KmdZr-RmxobZe-:[vy^hghlghkbldkh[ulbyf]
386
LZf`_– 1/112.
383
143
>Ze__hkh[ulbyo]]hgkhh[sZ_l©<wlhf
]h^mKZ]m^khk\h_cdhggbp_cbhl[hjgufbhljy^ZfbbaG_^`
^Z\gh\vgZijZ\bekygZk_\_jbgZiZegZijb]hjh^uF_ro_^Z
Hg\_e_ek\hbf\hckdZf\ukljhblvky\ebgbxbb^lbgZ]hjh^
ih^h[gh `b\hc kl_g_ Ihke_ wlh]h hg gZiZe gZ g_dhlhju_ [_
^mbgkdb_ie_f_gZbm\_ebokdhlaZl_fgZiZegZZe-Obg^bxb
Ze-OZaZ]be ]^_ f_`^m gbf b `bl_eyfb ijhbahreZ [bl\Z Ih
ke_ wlh]h hg mklZgh\be [ehdZ^m gZ^ ^hebghc Zk-KZfZ\Z h]jZ
[be__`bl_e_cbmgbqlh`be^_j_\vyIhke_wlh]hhggZijZ\be
ky \ klhjhgm ;Zkju hklZgh\beky m Za-Am[ZcjZ ]^_ ijhbahreZ
i_j_klj_edZ f_`^m gbf b `bl_eyfb ^_j_\gb b lhevdh ihke_
wlh]hhg\_jgmekygZjh^bgmª387.
D_j[_eZ
<ZooZ[blu kgZjy^beb ^\Z^pZlblukyqgh_ [_^mbgkdh_
\hckdh b ^\bgmeb _]h \ D_j[_em <hbgu \hj\Zebkv \ ]hjh^ b
gZqZeb m[b\Zlv _]h `bl_e_c jZa]jZ[beb khdjh\bsgbpm388 aZ
[jZeb k kh[hc fgh`_kl\h ahehluo x\_ebjguo p_gghkl_c389,
jZajmrbebgZ^]jh[b_Ze-Omk_cgZbmdjZebhdgh
B[g ;ZrZj o\Zkleb\h jZkkdZau\Z_l h ^_ygbyo k\hbo
g_^`^bckdbo khhl_q_kl\_ggbdh\ \ D_j[_e_ ©«hgb gZijZ\b
ebkv\D_j[_em]hjh^Ze-Omk_cgZ\f_kypamevdZ]^ZFmkmev
fZg_ hkZ^beb wlhl ]hjh^ h[jmrbeb _]h kl_gu b m[beb \k_o
dh]h gZreb gZ jugd_ beb \ k\hbo ^hfZo«390ª Ihkfhljbl_ gZ
wlbog_^`^bckdbo[_^mbgh\dhlhju_fhegb_ghkghb\g_aZigh
\hj\Zebkv \ ]hjh^ b h[jmrbeb _]h kl_gu gZ _]h `bl_e_c LZd
hgbihklmibebkfmkmevfZgZfb\aZij_lgucf_kypQlh`_[u
eh^Zevr_"B[g;ZrZjih\_kl\m_l©«hgbaZ[jZebkkh[hc\k_
qlh gZreb ^jZ]hp_gghklb ahehlh k_j_[jh ^hjh]b_ b j_^db_
DhjZguhjm`b_h^_`^mdh\jubijª391>Zg_^`^bckdb_[_
^mbgu k p_evx ijb[eb`_gby d :eeZom \hjmxl ^Z`_ DhjZgu
<hllZdh\hgoZjb^`blkdbcnbdo
LZf`_–K– 138.
Kbamfjm^ZfbbyohglZfb
389
©ExfZ]Zr-rboZ[ª–K
390
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/121.
391
LZf`_– 1/121 – 122.
387
388
144
FmoZffZ^ OZfb^ Ze-NZdb h^bg ba nZgZlbqguo \ZooZ
[blh\ \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©>`mg^m Ze-BkeZfª k ]hj^hklvx jZkkdZ
au\Z_lhj_ag_\D_j[_e_©<amevdZ]^Z]]KZ]m^kh
k\h_cZjfb_cgZijZ\beky\BjZdbgZiZegZD_j[_emWlhl]h
jh^ aZsbsZeb fgh`_kl\h g_ZjZ[h\ b rbblh\ dhlhju_ ohl_eb
hlklhylv k\hx k\ylugx dmihe bfZfZ rZob^Z Ze-Omk_cgZ b
^jm]b_ba\_klgu_gZ^]jh[byH^gZdh\hckdhlZ\ob^Zih[_^beh
bo kbehc k\h_c \_ju b ij_^Zgghklvx ^_em ^`boZ^Z \ mgbqlh
`_gbb \k_o b^heh\ b \k_]h qlh iulZxlky mih^h[blv :eeZom
Wlh[ueh]jZg^bhagh_kjZ`_gb_wlh[ueZ\_ebdZyj_agy[ueb
ijheblu j_db djh\b gh KZ]m^ b _]h \hckdh \ureb ih[_^bl_
eyfb Hgb jZajmrbeb wlhl [hevrhc dmihe dhlhjuc ij_^klZ\
eyekh[hch^gh]hba\_ebqZcrbob^heh\ydh[umklZgh\e_ggh
]hgZfh]be_Ze-Omk_cgZ[bg=Zeb<hllZdbfh[jZahfhgb^h
klZ\bebjZ^hklvbkZfhfmbfZfmZe-Omk_cgmb\k_f_^bgh[h`
gbdZf ke_^mxsbf ih imlb ^_^Z Ze-Omk_cgZ emqr_]h ba kh
a^Zgbc FmoZffZ^Z k]k >Z [m^_l ^h\he_g :eeZo ZeOmk_cghf b \k_c _]h ij_qbklhc k_fv_cª392 >Z ^_ckl\bl_evgh
[ueb ijheblu j_db djh\b h^gZdh wlh [ueh k^_eZgh g_ jZ^b
^h\hevkl\ZZe-Omk_cgZbIjhjhdZk]kZ^eylh]hqlh[uih
ihegblv \ZooZ[blkdmx dZagm b aZjZ[hlZlv k_[_ dZd fh`gh
[hevr_\_ebdbo]j_oh\393.
Y ^mfZx qlh ihke_ keh\ wlh]h aZdhj_g_eh]h \ZooZ[blZ
g_lg_h[oh^bfhklb^Z\ZlvdZdb_-eb[hdhff_glZjbb>hklZlhq
ghm`_lh]hqlh\ZooZ[blugZau\ZxlZe-Omk_cgZb^hehfb\lh
`_\j_fyijhkylfbehklb:eeZoZ^eyYab^Z[bgFmZ\bb
G_^`_n
<KZnZj]Zij_ev]KZ]m^khk\hbfb\hckdZ
fb hkZ^be G_^`_n g_dhlhjuf _]h \hbgZf ^Z`_ m^Zehkv aZ
[jZlvkygZ_]hkl_gugh`bl_eb]hjh^ZhdZaZebbf^hklhcguc
hlihjbg_kyh]jhfgu_ihl_jbZjfbyKZ]m^Z[ueZ\ugm`^_gZ
hlklmiblv
392
393
FmoZffZ^OZfb^Ze-NZdb©:kZjZ^-^Z]\ZZe-\ZooZ[byª–K
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byª-K
145
Ihke_ i_j\hc g_m^Zqghc ihiuldb \ ^`mfZ^Ze-mojZ Z\
]mklke_^mxs_]h]h^Z\ZooZ[bluij_ijbgyeb\lhjmxihiuldm
aZo\ZlZ]hjh^ZH^gZdh_]h`bl_eb[ueb]hlh\udwlhfmgZiZ
^_gbx b `^Zeb \jZ]Z k hjm`b_f \ jmdZo ihwlhfm \ZooZ[blu
gZijZ\bebkv \ Ze-Omeey `bl_eb dhlhjhc lZd`_ [ueb ]hlh\u
hljZablv gZiZ^_gb_ b \ZooZ[blZf ijbrehkv gZijZ\blvky \
D_j[_em ]^_ bo lZd`_ \klj_lbeh \hhjm`_ggh_ khijhlb\e_gb_
`bl_e_c]hjh^ZijhbahreZdjh\hijheblgZy[bl\Z[ueb[hev
rb_ihl_jbkh[_boklhjhg\blh]_\ZooZ[blu[ueb\ugm`^_
guhlklmiblvbgZijZ\blvkygZx]BjZdZIhke_wlbokh[ulbc
hgb\l_q_gb_lj_oe_lg_^Z\ZebiZehfgbdZf\hafh`ghklbkh
\_jrZlvoZ^`
< ] ] \ZooZ[blu \gh\v \_jgmebkv \ BjZd
qlh[ujZahjblvG_^`_nbD_j[_emhgb[ehdbjh\Zebwlb]hjh
^Zi_j_djueb\k_ih^klmiudgbfbgZqZebm[b\ZlviZehfgb
dh\ gZijZ\eyxsboky \ wlb ]hjh^Z < p_ehf [ueh m[blh klh
iylv^_kylq_eh\_d<hllZdh_m\Z`_gb_hdZaZeb\ZooZ[blu\gm
dmIjhjhdZk]k394.
<hllZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[blukh\_jrbebgZr_kl\b_gZ
a_febBjZdZbgZihfgbeb_]h`bl_eyfhgZr_kl\bbfhg]heh\
Hgb ijbf_gyeb lZdlbdm \u``_gghc a_feb DZd ba\_klgh rZ
jbZlaZij_sZ_lih^h[gh_hlghr_gb_d`b\hlgufbl_f[he__
dfmkmevfZgZf
KljZguRZfZ
G_f_gvrb_a\_jkl\Zkh\_jrbeb\ZooZ[blub\kljZgZo
RZfZ B a^_kv hgb m[b\Zeb ]jZ[beb gZkbeh\Zeb B[g ;ZrZj
jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf qlh hgb kh\_jrbeb \ ]395 m ]hju LZ
\be Zk-kZe^` jy^hf k GZ[exkhf ^Ze__ mdZau\Z_l ©«ihke_
wlh]h \hckdZ ijhrebkv ih^ ^_j_\gyf jZkiheh`_gguf \ hdj_
klghklyo Ze-FZabjb[Z b ;Zkju hgb aZ[bjZeb \k_ qlh gZoh
^bebZaZl_fih^`b]Zeb^_j_\gx@bl_eyf^_j_\_gvm^Zehkv
ba[_`Zlv kf_jlb lhevdh [eZ]h^Zjy lhfm qlh hgb mkeurZ\ h
394
395
©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZ«ª–K– 177.
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/150 – 151.
146
ijb[eb`_gbb\hckdm[_`Zebª396>Ze__hgibr_l©Hgbm[beb
g_dhlhjuo `bl_e_c RZfZ b ih \k_fm j_]bhgm \iehlv ^h >Z
fZkdZ jZkijhkljZgbeky kljZoª DZd \b^bl_ hgb kZfb ijbagZ
xlkyqlhgZ\h^bebgZex^_ckljZohgbg_bf_ebijZ\Zihklm
iZlv k `bl_eyfb RZfZ ih^h[guf h[jZahf ^Z`_ _keb [u l_
[uebyauqgbdZfb
OmjZg
<]]\ZooZ[blugZiZebgZOmjZgmkljhbeb
lZfj_agxg_sZ^beb^Z`_^_l_cjZa]jZ[bebbjZajmrbeb^h
fZ `bl_e_c ]hjh^Z G_ kqblZy q_eh\_q_kdbo ihl_jv m[uldb
`bl_e_c wlh]h ]hjh^Z hl \ZooZ[blkdh]h gZr_kl\by khklZ\beb
ijb[ebabl_evghljbfbeebhgZ^bjoZfh\397.
OZe_[:e_iih
AZl_f gZ[_]b \ZooZ[blh\ ^hklb]eb :e_iih l_f kZfuf
[uei_j_djulimlvf_`^mBjZdhfbRZfhfBohljy^u^hoh
^beb^Z`_^hDZ^bkbb<h\j_fyboihoh^h\[uehm[blhbaZ
o\Zq_gh\ie_gfgh`_kl\h`bl_e_cwlh]hj_]bhgZ:eeZoih`_
eZe qlh[u bo kfmlZ \ureZ aZ ij_^_eu :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkl
jh\Z398.
Bhj^Zgby
< ] kh]eZkgh kljZl_]bq_kdbf ieZgZf Zg]ebqZg
\ZooZ[blu gZiZeb gZ Mff Ze-=Zf^ \hklhd Bhj^Zgbb m[beb
q_eh\_djZahjbebbo^hfZg_dhlhjuoie_gbeb399=eZ\guc
gZklZ\gbd \ZooZ[blh\ Nbebiib ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibkZe ©>h
ijb[ulbylh\ZjZygZoh^beky\Bhj^ZgbbGZfm^Zehkvba]gZlv
=Z[^meem[bgZe-Omk_cgZ_]hk_fvxhlpZb[jZlv_\baOb^`Z
KjZ\gbl_ \hckdZ \ZooZ[blh\ b hk\h[h^bl_evgu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ Zjfbb
dhlhjuoex^b\klj_qZebkjZ^hklvx
397
©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byª–K
398
LZf `_ AZo\Zlb\ OZbe \ ] hgb kdZaZeb _]h `bl_eyf ke_^mxs__
©KemrZcl_h`bl_ebOZbey«Fuijbreblhevdh^eylh]hqlh[u^h\_klb
^h \Zrbo k_j^_p BkeZf ihwlhfm \u h[yaZgu gZf ih^qbgblvky ?keb dlheb[h ba \Zk ih`_eZ_l m_oZlv \ BjZd Kbjbx beb ?]bi_l lh _]h djh\v b
bfms_kl\h [m^ml h[ty\e_gu ^ha\he_ggufb ihkdhevdm \ BjZd_ Kbjbb b
?]bil_ `b\ml g_\_jgu_ b yauqgbdbª M f_gy g_l ^Z`_ dhff_glZjb_\ Kf
:[mZe-=ZeyZl-LZd\b©Ze-NbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ª–K
399
©ExfZ]Zr-rboZ[ª–K©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K
396
147
aZ G_kfhljy gZ wlh hg [ue hq_gv g_k]h\hjqb\ >Z ihke_^gb_
kh[ulbyhdZaZebgZg_]h\ebygb_ghhg^hkboihjkqblZek_[y
ih kl_i_gb \ur_ =Z[^me]ZabaZ b \ur_ f_gy Hg ^h kbo ihj
kqblZe qlh y\ey_lky iheghijZ\guf ijZ\bl_e_f <b^y _]h ih
\_^_gb_yj_rbemdjhlblvwlh]hq_eh\_dZihwlhfm\_e_e=Z[
^me]Zabam gZijZ\blv hljy^ ba ©\hckdZ [jZlv_\ª ba Dbjvyl ZefbeoZ^eylh]hqlh[uhgbijh]gZebbeb^Z`_m[beb=Z[^meem
[bg Ze-Omk_cgZ Z hl B[g =m^\ZgZ fu ihlj_[h\Zeb qlh[u hg
\gmljbBhj^Zgbbhj]Zgbah\Ze\hkklZgb_ijhlb\=Z[^meeu[bg
Ze-Omk_cgZ« M gZrbo ^jma_c [ueh gh\_cr__ hjm`b_ b hgb
mgbqlh`bebg_kdhevdhlukyqie_f_ggZk_ey\rboZe-;ZedZZeOmxlZlZlZd`_ie_fy;ZgmKZoj\lhfqbke_`_gsbgb^_l_c
Ihke_wlh]h=Z[^meeZ[bgZe-Omk_cgihklhyggh^_j`Zejy^hf
k kh[hc k\hb q_fh^Zgu Y kijhkbe m g_]h ©Dm^Z lu kh[bjZ
_rvky"ª-hghl\_lbe©Y]hlh\ihclb\:^?keb\ug_ohlbl_
f_gyaZsblblvlhohly[uhlijZ\vl_\kkuedmdhlpmªLh]^Zy
hl\_lbe_fm©Yl_[_kh\_lh\Zeg_ihfh]Zlvih\klZgpZfdhlh
ju_\hkklZebijhlb\\ZooZ[blh\Zlug_ihkemrZef_gyyl_
[_]h\hjbeqlh_\j_bbf_xlihegh_ijZ\hgZIZe_klbgmblu
\gh\vg_ihkemrZef_gyª«400»
<hl lZdbf h[jZahf \ZooZ[blu \_jgu_ kem]b Nbebiib
m[b\Zeb g_\bgguo ex^_c b \ hkh[_gghklb `_gsbg b ^_l_c
Hgbkem`bebbkem`ZlojbklbZgZfb_\j_yfhgbm`_ihfh]eb
bfaZ\eZ^_lvIZe_klbghcGhih^jh[g__h[wlhfgb`_
OmaZcebZe-EbnZ]
<]]\ZooZ[bluih^ij_^\h^bl_evkl\hf=m
kfZgZZe-Fm^ZbnbgZiZebgZOmaZcem[bebfgh]bofm`qbgb
ie_gbebfgh]bo`_gsbgAZl_fkh\_jrbebgZ[_]gZZe-EbnZ]
]^_ `beb \h`^b ie_f_gb ;Zgm =Zfj M[b\fm`qbgbaZo\Zlb\
`_gsbg\ie_ghgbjZa^_ebihke_^gbobl_[ueb\ugm`^_gu
ihijhkblvihsZ^ubkh]eZkbebkvijbgylv\ZooZ[blkdmxj_eb
]bx401.
GZkuj Zk-KZ]b^ \ k\h_f ©LZjbo«ª – K ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo
Ze-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byZe-oZ^bkª–K
401
>hdlhj FmoZffZ^ =Zm^ Ze-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabjZ Ze]ZjZ[byª–>ZjZe-fb]jZ^`–K
400
148
>hebgZRZffZjb__hdj_klghklb
Hibku\Zy kh[ulby ] ] B[g ;ZrZj ibr_l
©< wlhf ]h^m khklhyeky ©Ihoh^ Zr-rmdjZª KZ]m^ k h]jhfghc
Zjfb_c ba qbkeZ hk_^euo b dhq_\uo `bl_e_c G_^`^Z gZijZ
\beky \ klhjhgm ]hju RZffZj ?fm khh[sbeb qlh m ]hju
RZffZj jy^hf k bklhqgbdhf Zr-RmdjZ kh[jZebkv ie_f_gZ
FZlujOZj[b^jm]b_KZ]m^gZiZe402gZgbom[beg_dhlhjuo
fm`qbgbaZo\Zlbefgh`_kl\hbfms_kl\Zkj_^bdhlhjh]h[u
eh\hk_fvkhl\_j[ex^h\h\pub[he__^\Z^pZlbehrZ^_cIh
ke_ wlh]h KZ]m^ ihdbgme wlhl j_]bhg hl^_ebe h^gm iylmx
qZklv ljhn__\ Z hklZevgh_ jZa^Ze \hbgZf ba jZkq_lZ i_rbf
h^gZ ^hey Z dhgguf – ^\_ª403 Djhf_ mihfygmluo ie_f_g \
wlhfj_]bhg_[uebmgbqlh`_gu[_^mbgkdb_ie_f_gZZa-AZnbj
:e ;Z]b^` b :e AZdZjbl404 Dh]^Z wlb g_\bggu_ ex^b mki_eb
ij_\jZlblvky\g_\_jguodZdihklmibl:eeZokbom[bcpZfb"
Ij_iylkl\by\kh\_jr_gbboZ^`Z
<ZooZ[blu\k_]^Zdh]^Z[ueZ\hafh`ghklvij_iylkl\h
\Zeb iZehfgbdZf \ kh\_jr_gbb oZ^`Z ijb\_^_f ijbf_ju ba
boihahjghcbklhjbb
Bklhjbd \ZooZ[bafZ B[g ;ZrZj Ze-OZg[Zeb \ k\h_c
dgb]_ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ nb lZjbo Zg-GZ^`^ª jZkkdZau\Zy h
kh[ulbyo]]gZkibr_l©Dh]^ZKZ]m^405hl
< ZjZ[kdhf \ZjbZgl_ mihlj_[ey_lky keh\h ©]Z^Zª ijhy\eylv \jZ`^m
\jZ`_kdbgZiZ^Zlv–iiKeh\h©]Z^ZªkZfhihk_[_mdZau\Z_lgZlhqlh
\ZooZ[blu gZiZeb gZ wlb ie_f_gZ k \jZ`_kdbfb p_eyfb lh _klv k p_evx
m[blv b h]jZ[blv Bgl_j_kgh qlh B[g ;ZrZj qZklh mihfbgZ_l wlh keh\h
dh]^Z jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf dZd \ZooZ[blu gZiZ^Zeb gZ fmkmevfZg m[b\Zeb
bob]jZ[bebGZijbf_jkf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª–bb
403
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ª–LK-89.
404
B[jZobf=Z[^me]Zgb©KujZ]Ze-mfZjZª–K
405
Imklvm\Z`Z_fu_qblZl_ebg_^mfZxlqlh\ZooZ[blkdb_\h_gZqZevgbdb
\k_^_eZebihk\h_fmmkfhlj_gbxbihijbqbg_k\h_]hg_\_`_kl\Zm[b\Zeb
fmkmevfZgG_lgZkZfhf^_e_\ZooZ[blkdb_dhjhebb\h_gZqZevgbdb^_c
kl\h\Zeb kh]eZkgh b^_yf B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z b _]h ihlhfdh\ Bf_ggh \Zo
oZ[blkdb_r_cobijbgbfZebijbky]bGZijbf_jB[g;ZrZj\©=mg\ZgZefZ^`^«ªlKjZkkdZau\Z_l©B\wlhf]h^ml_]]r_co
FmoZffZ^^Zkfbehklb\blkygZ^gbf:eeZo\_e_e\k_f`bl_eyfG_^`^Zb
402
149
jZ\bekybaZ^->Zj]bb\F_ddmlhih\_e_eNZjjZ^`m[bgRZj
]Zgm Ze-=Zlbb b _]h ex^yf hldZaZlv iZehfgbdZf ba RZfZ
KlZf[meZ b ijhqbf \ ^hklmi_ \ F_ddm <uihegyy _]h ijbdZa
NZjjZ^` ihkeZe d wfbjm oZ^`Z =Z[^mee_ Ze-=Zafm-iZr_ ih
keZgpZ dhlhjuc \_e_e bf\k_f\ha\jZsZlvkygZjh^bgmª406B
^Ze__ hg k ]hj^hklvx aZy\ey_l ©< wlhf ]h^m `bl_eb RZfZ
?]bilZ BjZdZ b FZjhddh aZ j_^dbf bkdexq_gb_f g_ kfh]eb
kh\_jrblv oZ^`ª Ij_^klZ\vl_ ^hjh]hc qblZl_ev \k_ `bl_eb
RZfZ ?]bilZ BjZdZ b FZjhddh [ueb ebr_gu \hafh`ghklb
kh\_jrblv oZ^` HklZevguf `_ ZjZ[Zf jZaj_rbeb bkihegblv
wlmh[yaZgghklv
HklZevgu_[uebm[blu
<ZooZ[blu \h_\Zeb g_ lhevdh k ZjZ[kdbfb ie_f_gZfb
gZk_ey\rbfb l_jjblhjbx :jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkljh\Z hgb g_
jZagZiZ^ZebgZiZehfgbdh\ijb[u\Z\rbo\F_ddmbajZaebq
guo fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZg <ur_ fu m`_ ijb\_eb g_dhlhju_
ijbf_julh]hdZd\ZooZ[blugZiZ^ZebgZiZehfgbdh\\h\j_fy
[ehdZ^uF_ddbbF_^bgub\l_q_gb_g_kdhevdboe_lg_^Z\Z
ebbf\hafh`ghklvkh\_jrblvoZ^`
JZ^b ^hklb`_gby k\hbo iheblbq_kdbo p_e_c \ZooZ[blu
ij_\jZlbebkZfu_]eZ\gu_fmkmevfZgkdb_k\ylugb\aZeh`gb
dh\<]\ZooZ[blug_^Zeb\hafh`ghklbkh\_jrblvoZ^`
^jm]bo j_]bhgh\ ijbky]gmlv KZ]m^m [bg =Z[^me]Zabam Z _]h gZke_^gbdhf
[ueh[ty\e_gkugª>ZwlhlZd\_^vhgh^bgbamq_gbdh\r_coZkf©=mg
\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª–Bohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlh\k_\ZooZ[blkdb_r_cobjZa[hcgbdb [ueb nZgZlbqgufb ijb\_j`_gpZfb wlh]h mq_gby Ihwlhfm \
h[yaZl_evghf ihjy^d_ dZ`^h_ \hckdh khijh\h`^Ze \ZooZ[blkdbc dZabc
h[yaZgghklv dhlhjh]h g_j_^dh bkihegyeb ihlhfdb r_coZ KqblZ_lky qlh
\ZooZ[blkdbf r_coZf ba\_klgu hkh[u_ lZcgu :eeZoZ kf ©=mg\Zg ZefZ^`^«ª qlh hgb fh]ml l\hjblv qm^_kZ kf ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª
qlh:eeZogZdZau\Z_llh]hdlhhkf_eblkym[blvr_coZkf©=mg\Zg
Ze-fZ^`^«ªqlh[eZ]h^Zjybo[eZ]hkeh\_gbxb^ml^h`^bkf©=mg
\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ǻ b qlh hgb y\eyykv bfZfZfb fmkmevfZg mfbjZxl
fmq_gbdZfbkf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
406
©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª– 1/139.
150
kbjbckdbfiZehfgbdZfhl\_j]eb_]bi_lkdmxdbk\m407baZij_
lbeb _]bi_lkdbf iZehfgbdZfb kh\_jrblv oZ^` Z ihke_ j_\h
expbb\C_f_g_`bl_ebwlhckljZgulZd`_g_[ueb^hims_gu
\F_ddmL_o`_dlhhq_gvkbevgh`_eZekh\_jrblvoZ^`aZ
klZ\beb aZieZlblv hq_gv [hevrb_ ^_gv]b DZd ba\_klgh kh
]eZkgh rZjbZlm mklZgh\e_gb_ p_g gZ ihdehg_gb_ :eeZom aZ
ij_s_gh ;he__ lh]h \ZooZ[blu ^Z`_ m[b\Zeb iZehfgbdh\ <
qZklghklb \ ] ] [ueb jZkklj_eygu iZehfgbdb ba
C_f_gZZ\]]iZehfgbdbbaBjZgZ
M[bckl\hc_f_gkdboiZehfgbdh\
< ] \ZooZ[blu ij_^Zl_evkdb jZkklj_eyeb ]jmiim
iZehfgbdh\ ba C_f_gZ DZd ba\_klghiZehfgbdb\k_]^Zoh^yl
[_a hjm`by Dh]^Z kZm^bckdhc jZa\_^d_ klZeh ba\_klgh qlh \
F_ddm gZijZ\ey_lky ]jmiiZ iZehfgbdh\ ba C_f_gZ gZ\klj_qm
bf [ueb \ukeZgu \h_ggu_ hljy^u Khe^Zlu khh[sbeb qlh
[ueb ihkeZgu ^ey bo hojZgu gh dh]^Z c_f_gpu hdZaZebkv \
^hebg_LZgmfZkhe^Zlubohdjm`bebbk\_jomgZqZebjZkklj_
eb\ZlvBawlhc]jmiiu\`b\uohklZebkvlhevdh^\Zq_eh\_dZ
Dhg_qgh \ZooZ[blkdb_ \eZklb ihiulZebkv hijZ\^Zlvky l_f
qlhkhe^Zluhrb[ebkvbijbgyebiZehfgbdh\aZwdklj_fbklh\
baOb^`ZaZh^gZdhwlh[uehgZ]ehceh`vx<h-i_j\uorZjb
Zl g_ iha\hey_l m[b\Zlv ex^_c lhevdh ih ih^haj_gbx <h\lhjuo ^\Z k\b^_l_ey hklZ\rboky \ `b\uo ih^l\_j^beb lhl
nZdlqlhkhe^Zlug_dhlhjh_\j_fybokhijh\h`^Zebbmki_eb
m[_^blvky qlh hgb [ueb [_ahjm`gufb408 DZd \u ^mfZ_l_
kdhevdh c_f_gkdbo iZehfgbdh\ m[beb \ZooZ[blu" Lukyqm
^\_klb409.
M[bckl\hiZehfgbdh\baBjZgZ
<h \j_fy wlhc [hcgb ih]b[eh iZehfgbdh\ b [hev
rh_ qbkeh [ueh jZg_gh < wlhl ]h^ bjZgkdb_ iZehfgbdb reb
_^bghc ]jmiihc \ujZ`Zeb k\h_ hlj_q_gb_ hl g_\_jguo ijb
Ki_pbZevgh_ ihdju\Zeh ^ey DZZ[u dhlhju_ h[uqgh ba]hlZ\eb\Zehkv \
?]bil_–ii
408
Ze-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K– 199.
409
LZf`_–K
407
151
au\Zeb fmkmevfZg d _^bgkl\m b kdZg^bjh\Zeb ehamg]b
©Kf_jlv :f_jbd_ Kf_jlv KKKJ Kf_jlv BajZbex Fmkmev
fZg_ h[t_^bgycl_kvª Dh]^Z wlZ ]jmiiZ [ueZ g_^Ze_dh hl ZeOZjZfZ b kh[bjZeZkv gZijZ\blvky \ f_q_lv qlh[u kh\_jrblv
lZ\Zn\ZooZ[blkdb_\h_ggu_hldjuebihgbfh]hgvbaZ\lhfZ
lh\b\bglh\hdH:eeZogZdZ`bwlboex^_c410.
<ZooZ[blumamjibjh\Zebf_klhbfZfZ\f_q_lbZe-OZjZf
AZ \kx bklhjbx BkeZfZ gb h^gh ^\b`_gb_ gbdh]^Z g_
iha\heyehk_[_aZo\Zlu\Zlvbmamjibjh\Zlvf_klhbfZfZ\F_
q_lb Ze-OZjZf Mq_gu_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb jZaebqguo fZaoZ[h\
bkihegyebh[yaZgghklbbfZfZ\wlhcf_q_lbqblZebijhih\_^b
b^Z\Zeb\_jmxsbfgZklZ\e_gby<gZrb`_^gbgbh^bgmq_
guc dZdbf [u h[jZah\Zgguf hg gb [ue g_ ^himkdZ_lky d bk
iheg_gbxh[yaZgghkl_cbfZfZoZlu[Zbebfm^ZjjbkZ\f_q_lb
Ze-OZjZfb^Z`_\f_q_lbIjhjhdZk]kWlbihkluaZgbfZxl
lhevdh\ZooZ[blu-oZrZ\bluR_co=Zeb>`Z[bjaZgbfZ\rbc
ihklbfZfZ\wlhcf_q_lbg_dhlhjh_\j_fy[ueba]gZghllm^Z
lhevdh aZ lh qlh \h \j_fy fhev[u dmgml hldZaZeky ijhkblv m
:eeZoZ ihfhsb ^ey \hckd \hr_^rbo gZ l_jjblhjbx BjZdZ
F_q_lv Ze-OZjZf y\ey_lky ^hklhygb_f fmkmevfZg \k_]h fbjZ
b gbdlh g_ bf__l ijZ\h __ mamjibjh\Zlv ih dZdhfm `_ ijZ\m
wlh^_eZxl\ZooZ[blu"411
:qlh^Zevr_"
M\Z`Z_fu_ qblZl_eb \hl fu b aZ\_jrbeb ]eZ\m h djh
\Z\hc bklhjbb \ZooZ[bafZ djhf_ mihfygmluo fh`gh ijb\h
^blv _s_ fgh`_kl\h ijbf_jh\ \ZooZ[blkdh]h l_jjhjZ Ih aZ
\_jr_gbbwlhc]eZ\u\hagbdZxl\hijhkuG_m`_eb\k_`bl_eb
Qlh[u ebqgh m[_^blvky \h \k_o wlbo a\_jkl\Zo fh`_l_ hagZdhfblvky k
j_amevlZlZfb jZ[hlu f_`]hkm^Zjkl\_gghc dhfbkkbb ih ijZ\Zf q_eh\_dZ
baeh`_ggufb\dgb]_©IjZ\Zq_eh\_dZ\DK:ªk–ZlZd`_kdgb
]hcNZo^ZZe-DZolZgb©J_agyiZehfgbdh\\KZm^bbª-Zk-KZnZEhg^hg
411
FmkmevfZgkdb_mq_gu_\f_q_lbZe-OZjZf\k_]^ZqblZebijhih\_^bdh
lhju_[uebihe_agu^eyfmkmevfZgbgbdh]^Zg_\uklmiZebkijhih\_^yfb
\ q_klv klhe_lby \hagbdgh\_gby DK: dZd wlh k^_eZe r_co Zk-Km^Zck \
]]fgh]b_ex^b\h\j_fywlhcijhih\_^bijhklhihdbgmebf_
q_lv
410
152
:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Z[ueb\_jhhlklmigbdZfb"AZkem`beb
ebhgbdk_[_lZdh_hlghr_gb_"G_m`_ebhgb[uebojbklbZgZ
fb b bm^_yfb hldZaZ\rbfbky ieZlblv ^`bavy" G_m`_eb kZeZ
nuihklmiZebih^h[gufh[jZahf"G_m`_ebkih^\b`gbdbIjh
jhdZ k]k k lZdhc `_ `_klhdhklvx m[b\Zeb _^bgh[h`gbdh\"
:fh`_l[ulvkZoZ[Zfwlh[uehaZij_s_ghZ\ZooZ[blZfjZa
j_r_gh" Ihq_fm wlb [_^mbgu m[b\Zeb bf_ggh l_o dlh k\b^_
l_evkl\h\Zeqlhg_l[h`_kl\Zdjhf_:eeZoZ"G_m`_ebhgbg_
[hyebkv qlh Ijhjhd k]k \ Km^guc ^_gv ij_^ty\bl ijhlb\
gbo bkd" <kihfgbl_ dh]^Z h^bg ba kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ
k]k m[be q_eh\_dZ kdZaZ\r_]h ©G_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :e
eZoª^mfZyqlhlhlijhbaghkblwlbkeh\Zlhevdhba-aZkljZoZ
lhIjhjhdk]kkbevghhljm]Ze_]hbkdZaZe©:luaZ]eygme
_fm\k_j^p_"ªIhdZdhfm`_ijZ\m\ZooZ[bluiha\heyxlk_[_
m[b\Zlv l_o dlh ijbagZ_l qlh g_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZoZ"
DZdfh]mlwlboZrZ\blude_\_lZlv\Z^j_kijZ\_^guokZeZnh\"
<lh`_\j_fyhgb\k_og_m]h^guoh[ty\eyxloZjb^`blZfbZ
jZa\_kZfbhgbg_ihklmiZxlih^h[ghoZjb^`blZf"Ddhfm`_
wlhll_jfbgih^oh^bl[hevr_\k_]h"<a]eygbl_gZwlbo\ZooZ
[blh\-oZrZ\blh\ gZ bo m[_`^_gby b \u m\b^bl_ qlh hgb lZd
`_ dZd b bm^_b ijb^_j`b\Zxlky Zgljhihfhjnbklkdhc ljZd
lh\db [h`_kl\_gguo Zljb[mlh\ b lZd `_ `_klhdb dZd oZjb^
`blu412.
<ZooZ[blu[he__`_klhdbb[he__hiZkguq_fboij_^
r_kl\_ggbdb Zk-kZnjblu Ze-ZajZdblu Zg-gZ^`^blu413 Hgb
b^mliml_fk\hboijZ^_^h\baie_f_gb;ZgmOZgbn414dh]^Zl_
hlklmibebhl\_ju
M\Z`Z_fu_ qblZl_eb fu ihagZdhfbeb \Zk k bklhjb_c
\ZooZ[bafZZlZd`_kg_dhlhjufbbabom[_`^_gbcihwlhfm\
©KZdlZe-dZggZ]ªR_co:ofZ^[bgOZf^Ze-OZebeb–K-58.
Bf__lky \ \b^m qlh \k_ wlb ^\b`_gby [ueb ij_^klZ\e_gu `bl_eyfb
G_^`^ZbgZqbgZebkvkie_f_gb;ZgmOZgbn
414
Ba\_klgh qlh kh\j_f_ggZy \ZooZ[blkdZy weblZ ^Z`_ ]hj^blky l_f nZd
lhfqlhijhbkoh^blbaie_f_gbFmkZceZfu;ZgmOZgbnLZd`_kfmB[g
;ZrZjZ©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
412
413
153
ke_^mxs_c]eZ\_fuhklZgh\bfkygZbom[_`^_gbyo[he__ih
^jh[gh
=eZ\Zq_l\_jlZy
M[_`^_gbyZdu^ZoZrZ\blh\
<ZooZ[blkdZy Zdu^Z ih k\h_c kmlb y\ey_lky h[gh\e_g
ghc Zdu^hc oZrZ\blh\ dhlhju_ ijbibku\Zeb :eeZom l_e_
kghklv b kqblZeb qlh Hg lZd `_ dZd ex^b oh^bl kf__lky b
kh\_jrZ_l ijhqb_ ^_ygby ih^h[gu_ ex^kdbf Bf_ggh h ih
ke_^h\Zl_eyo wlhc Zdu^u bfZf Ze-oZnba Ze-Dmjlm[b \ k\h_c
dgb]_©:l-LbadZjªkkdZaZe©GZb[he__\_jgufy\ey_lky
fg_gb_hlhfqlhwlbex^b–g_\_jgu_\_^vbom[_`^_gbygb
q_fg_hlebqZxlkyhlm[_`^_gbcl_odlhihdehgy_lkybklmdZ
gZf b bah[jZ`_gbyfª Lh `_ kZfh_ h gbo kdZaZe b bfZf ZgGZ\Z\b\©:e-FZ^`fm]rZjoZe-fmoZaaZ[ª<hldZdbf
iml_f ke_^mxl ihke_^h\Zl_eb FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
<ZooZ[blu b kZfb agZxl g_khklhyl_evghklv k\hbo m[_`^_gbc
bf_gghihwlhfmhgb[hylky\klmiZlv\hldjulu_^bkdmkkbb<
wlhc]eZ\_fu[m^_f]h\hjblvh[m[_`^_gbyowlbooZjb^`blh\
\_^v bf_ggh h gbo Ijhjhd k]k kdZaZe ©Hgb [m^ml qblZlv
DhjZgghhgg_ih^gbf_lky\ur_bo]hjeZª
Kl_j`_gvoZrZ\blkdhcZdu^u
Kl_j`g_f oZrZ\blkdhc Zdu^u y\ey_lky ijbibku\Zgb_
:eeZoml_e_kghklbbkhhl\_lkl\_gghdZq_kl\ijbkmsbol_eZf
DZd ba\_klgh \ZooZ[blu ijbqbkeyxl k_[y d oZg[Zeblkdhfm
fZaoZ[mbf_gghihwlhfm\wlhcdgb]_fu[m^_fijb\h^blvhi
jh\_j`_gby gZibkZggu_ ijhlb\ gbo h^gbf ba oZg[Zeblkdbo
mq_guo Fu [m^_f kkueZlvky gZ dgb]m ©>Zn] rm[Zo ZllZr[bo [b Zdmnn Zl-lZgaboª ©MkljZg_gb_ khfg_gbc \ hl
ghr_gbb mih^h[e_gby ihs_qbgZfb hqbs_gbyª Z\lhjhf
dhlhjhc y\ey_lky bfZf :[m Ze-NZjZ^` =Z[^jZofZg [bg Ze>`Z\ab Ze-OZg[Zeb mf ] ] WlZ dgb]Z [ueZ ijh
\_j_gZ b mlhqg_gZ FmoZffZ^hf Fmgbjhf bfZfhf ©P_gljZ
ihfhsb b dmevlmjguo bkke_^h\Zgbcª – >Zj Ze-^`bgZg Zy
;_cjmlEb\Zg
154
G_dhlhju_\u^_j`dbba\\_^_gbyFmoZffZ^ZFmgbjZ
©O\ZeZ :eeZom =hkih^m fbjh\ Fbj b [eZ]hkeh\_gb_
gZr_fm ]hkih^bgm FmoZffZ^m Z lZd`_ \k_f _]h kih^\b`gb
dZf b ihke_^h\Zl_eyf >Z [m^_l ^h\he_g :eeZo \k_fb mq_gu
fb dhlhju_ aZsbsZeb j_eb]bx b ijbeh`beb k\hb mkbeby \
^_e_hljZ`_gbygZiZ^hdg_\_jguo[_a[h`gbdh\fm`^Zkkbfb
lh\415 fmrZ[[boblh\416 b ^jm]bo aZ[em^rbo k_dlZglh\ Wlb
mq_gu_jZatykgbebgZfqlh_klvbklbgZZqlh–eh`vYm^hk
lhbeky q_klb hagZdhfblvky k dgb]hc ©:e-;Za Ze-Zrom[ Zefmgdb^ ]Zey fmoZebnb Ze-fZaoZ[ª ijbgZ^e_`Zs_c i_jm mq_
gh]h=Z[^jZofZgZ[bg:[mZe-OZkZgZ=Zeb[bgFmoZffZ^ZZeDmjZrbZl-LZcbfbZe-;ZdjbZe-;Z]^Z^bZe-OZg[Zebba\_klgh
]hdZdB[gZe->`Z\ab<wlhcdgb]_hghijh\_j]Z_lkeh\Zl_o
dlhijbibku\Z_lbfZfm:ofZ^m[bgOZg[Zemeh`gu_m[_`^_
gbybde_\_s_lgZg_]hGhdZ`^hfmba\_klghqlhgZ^hexwlh
]h \_ebdh]h bfZfZ \uiZeb keh`g_crb_ bkiulZgby h^gZdh hg
\uklhye b ih[_^be WlZ dgb]Z y\ey_lky ykguf hl\_lhf fm[lZ
^b]Zfijb^_j`b\Zxsbfkyb^_cfm^`Zkkbfblh\HgZ_klvhk
ljucf_qrZjbZlZjZaysbcbom[_`^_gbyhgZ–hkljh_dhiv_
jZamfZ\haghkys__^h\h^urZjbZlZYkgu_^h\h^uwlhcdgb]b
jZajmrZxl \k_ eh`gu_ b^_b ijbkmsb_ wlbf aZ[em^rbf ex
^yfǻ
<u^_j`dbba\\_^_gbykZfh]hB[gZe->`Z\ab
©YaZf_lbeqlhg_dhlhju_bagZrbodhee_]\ukdZau\Z
xl eh`gu_ b^_b hlghkbl_evgh hkgh\ \_ju Ljh_ ba gbo :[m
=Z[^meeZ [bg OZfb^ _]h mq_gbd dZabc Ze-NZjjZ b ;bg ZaAZ]mgb^Z`_hkf_ebebkvgZibkZlvdgb]bdhlhjufbhihahjbeb
gZrfZaoZ[ZkZfbhimklbebkv^hmjh\gyijhklhex^bgh\;h
`_kl\_ggu_ dZq_kl\Z hgb khhlg_keb kh k\hbfb q_eh\_q_kdbfb
hsms_gbyfb Z mkeurZ\ qlh :eeZo kha^Ze q_eh\_dZ \ k\h_f
HlZjZ[kdh]h©lZ^`kbfª–ijbibku\Zgb_l_e_kghklbmih^h[e_gb_l_em
Wlhl l_jfbg mdZau\Z_l qlh \ZooZ[blu ijbibku\Zxl :eeZom l_e_kghklv –
ii
416
HlZjZ[kdh]h©lZr[boª–mih^h[e_gb_Wlhll_jfbgmdZau\Z_lqlh\Zo
oZ[blumih^h[eyxl:eeZoZex^yf–ii
415
155
h[jZa_ijbibkZeb?fmh[jZaebph]eZaZjhlyaudbam[u^\_
jmdbiZevpudbklv]jm^v[_^jh]he_gvgh]bbl^ªH^gbba
gbo kdZaZeb ©Fu g_ keurZeb qlh[u mihfbgZeZkv ]heh\Zª
>jm]b_kdZaZeb©Hgfh`_lgZkihljh]Zlvbfufh`_fihljh
]Zlv ?]h Hg kihkh[_g ijb[ebablv jZ[Z d k\h_c [h`_kl\_gghc
kmsghklbª Lj_lvb kdZaZeb ©Hg ^urblª Wlb ex^b gZqZeb
ljZdlh\Zlv[h`_kl\_ggu_dZq_kl\Z\ijyfhfkfuke_b^Zebbf
gh\u_^hk_e_g_ba\_klgu_bf_gZgZdhlhju_g_l^h\h^Zgbkh
klhjhgujZamfZgbkhklhjhguk\ys_gguol_dklh\Hgbg_h[
jZsZxl\gbfZgbygZl_dkludhlhju_mdZau\ZxlgZi_j_ghkgh_
agZq_gb_[h`_kl\_gguoZljb[mlh\Bfg_^hklZlhqghqlhhgb
\u^mfZeb Zljb[ml ©^_ckl\b_ª d g_fm hgb ^h[Z\beb Zljb[ml
©kmsghklvªaZl_fhgb\u^mfZebdZq_kl\ZkmsghklbbkdZaZeb
©Fug_kh[bjZ_fkyljZdlh\ZlvwlbdZq_kl\Zkh]eZkghijZ\beZf
yaudZ fu g_ klZg_f gZau\Zlv jmdm fbehklvx fh]ms_kl\h b
^\b`_gb_ – ^h[jhlhc ]he_gv – ljm^ghklvxª GZh[hjhl hgb
aZy\beb ©Fu [m^_f ljZdlh\Zlv wlb Zljb[mlu lZd dZd _klv \
ijyfhf kfuke_ kh]eZkgh lhfm qlh gZf ba\_klgh h q_eh\_d_
Hkgh\Z \ ijyfhc ljZdlh\d_ keh\ Z g_ i_j_ghkghcª < lh `_
\j_fy bf g_ gjZ\blky qlh bo gZau\Zxl fmrZ[[boblZfb hgb
aZy\eyxl ©Fu kmggbluª -ohlygZkZfhf^_e_bokeh\Z–y\
gh_ mih^h[e_gb_ ;h]Z q_eh\_dm b d kh`Ze_gbx aZ gbfb ih
ke_^h\Zeb g_dhlhju_ ijhklhex^bgu Y \k_f bf ^Ze gZklZ\e_
gb_ ©JZa\_ \u g_ y\ey_l_kv ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb bfZfZ dhlhjuc
^Z`_ih^ie_lvxiZeZqZkdZaZe©DZdyfh]mkdZaZlvlhq_]hg_
kdZaZe:eeZoª"G_kf_cl_\\h^blv[b^]Z\fZaoZ[wlh]hbfZfZ
<uaZy\ey_l_qlh[m^_l_ljZdlh\Zlv\ijyfhfkfuke_boZ^bku
lh`_Ba\_klgheb\Zfqlhdh]^ZojbklbZgZfkdZaZebqlhBb
kmk^mo[h`bclhhgbih^mfZebqlh\FZjvyf\k_ebeky[h`_
kl\_gguc Zljb[ml gZau\Z_fuc ^mohf ?keb \u ml\_j`^Z_l_
qlh\hag_k_gb_Ze-bklb\Zijhbahrehk[h`_kl\_gghckmsghk
lvx lh \u m`_ i_j_ghkbl_ :eeZoZ \ dZl_]hjbx hsmsZ_fh]h
G_ aZ[u\Zcl_ qlh hkgh\hc y\ey_lky jZamf bf_ggh [eZ]h^Zjy
_fmfuihagZebkms_kl\h\Zgb_:eeZoZb?]hba\_qghklv?keb
[u\ukdZaZeb©Fu[m^_fqblZlvoZ^bkubihfZedb\Zlvª-lh
\Zfgbdlhgbq_]hg_kdZaZe[u\u`_j_rbebboljZdlh\Zlv\
156
[md\Zevghf agZq_gbb G_ \ghkbl_ \ fZaoZ[ wlh]h ijZ\_^gh]h
bfZfZ lh q_]h \ g_f g_ [ueh <u ijb\g_keb \ wlhl fZaoZ[
]gmkgh_ ihwlhfm k_cqZk ex^b ih^ keh\hf ©oZg[Zeblª ihgb
fZxl–©fm^`ZkkbfªAZl_fdk\hbfm[_`^_gbyf\u^h[Z\beb
ihqblZgb_ Yab^Z [bg FmZ\bb gh \Zf ba\_klgh qlh \Zr bfZf
jZaj_rbeijhdebgZlvwlh]hq_eh\_dZBa-aZlZdbodZd\u:[m
FmoZffZ^Zl-LZfbfbkdZaZe³WlhlfZaoZ[ihdjuekyihahjhf
dhlhjucg_kfh`_lhlfulv\iehlv^hKm^gh]h^gy´ª
<a]eygbl_ gZ wlb keh\Z gZkdhevdh hgb khhl\_lkl\mxl
gZr_c k \Zfb k_]h^gyrg_c ^_ckl\bl_evghklb Kh\j_f_ggu_
oZjb^`blu\ZooZ[bluiheghklvxi_j_gyeb\k_gZke_^b_k\h
boij_^dh\hihahjghklbdhlhjh]hibkZeB[gZe->`Z\abHgb
\_jmxlb`b\ml\khhl\_lkl\bbkwlbfgZke_^b_f
G_dhlhju_ijbf_jueh`guo
oZrZ\blkdbom[_`^_gbc
OZrZ\blu ijb^_j`b\Zxlky g_dhlhjuo b^_c k\yaZgguo
k[h`_kl\_ggufbbf_gZfbbZljb[mlZfbbh[_sZgbyfbgZ]jZ^
\JZxbgZdZaZgbc\:^mZlZd`_k^jm]bfbiheh`_gbyfbhl
ghkysbfbkydh[eZklbZdu^u<k_odlhg_kh]eZk_gkbob^_y
fb hgb h[ty\eyxl g_\_jgufb jZkimlgbdZfb aZ[em^rbfb b
fm[lZ^b]ZfbGZkZfhf`_^_e_mgbog_l^hklZlhqguo^h\h^h\
^ey^hdZaZl_evkl\Zk\h_cijZ\hluBklhqgbdhfwlbob^_ckem
`Zl g_dhlhju_ oZ^bku bf_xsb_ lhevdh kl_i_gv ZoZ^417 qlh
\iheg_ ^himkdZ_l hrb[dm i_j_^ZlqbdZ beb aZ[u\qb\hklv beb
_s_dZdb_-eb[hg_^hklZldbBf_gghihwlhfmhgbkZfbimlZxl
ky \ k\h_c Zdu^_ aZqZklmx \u fh`_l_ aZf_lblv dZd hgb ijb
kemrb\Zxlkydfg_gbxl_omq_guodhlhjuo\q_jZ_s_hl\_j
]ZebZaZ\ljZhgbfh]mlhlj_qvkyhllh]h\hqlh\_jbeb\q_jZ
Fgh]b_kmggblkdb_mq_gu_gZibkZebhijh\_j`_gbybob^_heh
]bb kj_^b gbo Ze-DZmkZjb Zk-KZddZn ijhn_kkhj :[m =m^Z
r_co :[m BkoZd Zr-RbjZab bfZf :[m ;Zdj Zr-RZrb b ^j
Kj_^bdgb]djblbdmxsbo\ZooZ[blkdmxb^_heh]bx\ufh`_
< h^ghf ba a\_gv_\ p_ihqdb i_j_^Zlqbdh\ lZdh]h oZ^bkZ ijbkmlkl\m_l
lhevdhh^bgi_j_^Zlqbd–ii
417
157
l_ \klj_lblv ©:e-FmolZkZjª gZibkZgguc ]jmiihc rZnb]bl
kdbomq_guo©:l-LZadbjZZr-rZjdbyªbfZfZZa-Am[_c^b
OZrZ\blu-\ZooZ[blu ihke_^h\Z\ aZ kZlZghc aZ[em^b
ebkv \h fgh]bo \hijhkZo k\yaZgguo k Zdu^hc ^Ze__ fu mih
fyg_fg_dhlhju_bagbo
Ml\_j`^_gb_hlhfqlh:eeZo–wlhl_eh
B[g L_cfby \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:l-LZkbk nb jZ^^ mkmk ZllZd^bkª ih k\h_fm h[uqZx qm\kl\my k\hx g_hkihjb
fmxijZ\hlmibr_l©Gb\DhjZg_gb\kmgg_gb\keh\ZokZ
eZnh\ b bfZfh\ g_l hijh\_j`_gby lh]h qlh :eeZo y\ey_lky
l_ehfbqlh?]hZljb[mluy\eyxlkyl_eZfbbeby\e_gbyfbZd
pb^_gpbyfbª DZd \b^bl_ _]h keh\Z ijhlb\hj_qZl Zylm \ dh
lhjhfkdZaZgh©G_lgbq_]hih^h[gh]h?fmª (42:11), ©Bg_[u
eh jZ\gh]h ?fmª : l_e_kghklv m`_ kZfZ ih k_[_ _klv
ih^h[b_Ijhjhdk]k\h^ghfbak\hbooZ^bkh\kdZaZe©G_l
gbq_]h ihoh`_]h gZ G_]h jZ\gh]h b ih^h[gh]h ?fmª418 < dZ
q_kl\_gZb[he__yjdh]hhl\_lZ\ZooZ[blZfohqmijb\_klbjb\Z
yl Ze-;ZcoZdb h[ bfZf_ :ofZ^_ ©BfZf :ofZ^ hljbpZy l_e_
kghklv :eeZoZ kdZaZe ©;h`_kl\_ggu_ Zljb[mlu \aylu ba bk
lhqgbdh\ rZjbZlZ b ZjZ[kdh]h yaudZ Mq_gu_-yaudh\_^u ih^
wlbfkeh\hfl_eh–iibf_xl\\b^mkm[klZgpbxh[eZ^Zx
smxjZaf_jhfdZdbf-eb[hkhklZ\hfbh[jZahfqlh`_dZkZ_l
ky :eeZoZ lh hg ij_\ur_ \k_]h wlh]h ihwlhfm fu g_ \ijZ\_
gZau\Zlv ?]h l_ehf L_f [he__ qlh \ rZjbZl_ g_l ^h\h^h\
ih^l\_j`^ZxsbolZdhcZljb[mlª
>Ze__ B[g Ze-DZcbf \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:k-KZ\Z]bd ZefmjkZeZªml\_j`^Z_lqlhm:eeZoZ_klv]he_gvZdjhf_wlh]h
jZkkm`^Z_l h lhf qlh _keb :eeZo \ DhjZg_ ]h\hjbl h[ h^ghc
]he_gb lh wlh g_ agZqbl qlh \lhjhc m g_]h g_l©Ihkfhljbl_
:eeZo \ DhjZg_ khh[sZ_l gZf h[ h^ghc ]he_gb dhlhjZy y\ey
_lky?]hZljb[mlhfGhjZa\_wlhk\b^_l_evkl\m_lhlhfqlhm
G_]h g_l \lhjhc ]he_gb" GZijbf_j \Zf dlh-lh kdZaZe ©Y hl
djue k\hc ]eZaª beb ©Ijbhldjue dhe_ghª beb ©Ijbhldjue
Ijb\h^blkymZe-OZdbfZ\©:e-FmklZ^jZdª\oZ^bk_hlM[Zy[bgDZ][Z
p_ihqdZoZ^bkZ^hklh\_jgZ
418
158
]he_gvªjZa\_wlhih^jZamf_\Z_lqlhmg_]hg_l\lhjh]hlZdh]h
`_"419»
>Ze__B[gZe-DZcbfml\_j`^Z_lqlhm:eeZoZ_klv[hd
^`Zg[ < ©:k-KZ\Z]bd Ze-fmjkZeZª b ©FmolZkZj ZkkZ\Z]bdªhibjZykvgZkeh\Z:eeZoZ©H]hj_fg_aZlh
qlhy[ueg_jZ^b\ihhlghr_gbxd\ZjZ[kdhf\ZjbZgl_©nb
^`Zg[beeyoª - ii :eeZomª ibr_l ©DhjZg ih^
l\_j`^Z_lgZebqb_m:eeZoZlZdh]hZljb[mlZdZd©[hdªbjZa
\_]^_-gb[m^vkdZaZghqlhmG_]hg_l\lhjh]h[hdZ"Ih^h[guc
h[hjhl g_ y\ey_lky k\b^_l_evkl\hf \ ihevam lh]h qlh \lhjhc
lZdhc `_ hlkmlkl\m_l GZijbf_j Ijhjhd k]k =bfjZgm [bg
OmkZbgm kdZaZe ©Kh\_jrZc fhebl\m klhy _keb g_ fh`_rv
klhy lh kb^y _keb g_ fh`_rv kb^y lh gZ [hdmª - wlh `_ g_
agZqblqlhmwlh]hq_eh\_dZ[uelhevdhh^bg[hdªDZd\b^bl_
wlhl ©mq_gucª kjZ\gb\Z_l :eeZoZ k =bfjZghf [bg OmkZbghf
mih^h[ey_l ?]h _fm LZdh_ fh] gZibkZlv lhevdh aZ[em^rbc
ke_i_p?kebdlh-eb[h\ukdZau\Z_lih^h[gu_b^_blhwlhagZ
qbllhevdhlhqlhwlhlq_eh\_d\_jgmeky\h\j_f_gZyauq_kl\Z
DZd khh[sZ_l B[g Ze-=ZjZ[b Ze-FZebdb \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:e=Z\Zkufª :[m Y]ey kem`b\rbc ijbf_jhf ^ey B[g
L_cfbb b \h\k_ kdZaZe ©<u fh`_l_ h[yaZlv f_gy \k_f q_f
m]h^gh djhf_ [hjh^u b ihklu^guo f_klª OZnba B[g Ze>`Z\ab \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©>Zn] rm[Zo Zl-lZr[bo [b Zdmnn ZllZgaboª ih^jh[gh ZgZebabjm_l \k_ b^_b wlbo mq_guo b ijb\h
^blq_ldb_bykgu_hijh\_j`_gby?keb`_\uhagZdhfbl_kvk
dgb]hc ©B[lZe Zl-lZ\beª420 lZd`_ ijbgZ^e_`Zs_c i_jm B[g
Ze-DZcbfZlhihcf_l_qlhmwlh]hq_eh\_dZg_[ueh^Z`_we_
f_glZjguoagZgbch[BkeZf_dZdml\_j`^Z_lB[gZe->`Z\ab
<hijhkh^\b`_gbb
=mkfZg [bg KZ]b^ Z^->Zjbfb \ k\h_f hijh\_j`_gbb
gZibkZgghfijhlb\;ZrZjZZe-FZjbkbgZklj]h\hjbl©Hg
kha^Ze q_eh\_dZ ijbdZkZykv d g_fm K\hbfb jmdZfbª hg mih
:e-Fmkueb©FmolZkZjZk-kZ\Z]bdZe-fmjkZeZebB[gZe-DZcbfª->Zj
Ze-]ZkufZwj-Jby^–K– 32.
420
Ijb\h^blky k khdjZs_gb_f ba dgb]b ©:l-LZg^b^ [b fZg ]Z^^Z^Z ZllZ\ob^ªr_coZOZkZgZZk-KZddZnZk– 23.
419
159
fbgZ_lwlhg_kdhevdhjZab\ufh`_l_ijbclbd\u\h^mhlhf
qlh:eeZoke_ibeq_eh\_dZba]ebguK\hbfbjmdZfbGZk
kdZaZgh©@b\hc\_qghkmsbc«Hg^\b`_lky_kebih`_eZ_l
fh`_lih^gbfZlvkybkimkdZlvkyo\ZlZlvbhlimkdZlv\klZ\Zlv
bkZ^blvkyWlb\k_dZq_kl\Zijbkmsb?fmihlhfmqlhbf_ggh
^\b`_gb_hlebqZ_l`b\h_hlf_jl\h]h<k_`b\h_g_ij_f_ggh
^\b`_lky Z \k_ f_jl\h_ gZoh^blky \ ihdh_ª :e-DZmkZjb ih
wlhfm ih\h^m gZibkZe ke_^mxs__ ©;h`_kl\h wlh]h ZkkZ^`Zabckdh]h421[_^gy]b\klZ_loh^bl^\b`_lky\_jhylghhg
ihaZbfkl\h\Ze wlb \_jh\Zgby m k\hbo khk_^_c ihdehgy\rboky
dhjh\_422Dlh^_ckl\bl_evgh\_jbl\wlhlhlih_^bgh]eZkghfm
fg_gbx mq_guo y\ey_lky g_\_jguf =hj_ l_f dlh kh\_jrZ_l
k\hb fhebl\u b aZdexqZ_l [jZdb ijh^he`Zy ijb^_j`b\Zlvky
ih^h[guom[_`^_gbc?s_[hevr__]hj_l_fdlhibr_ldgb]b
\dhlhjuobaeZ]Z_lwlbm[_`^_gbybjZkijhkljZgy_lwlbdgb]b
kj_^bex^_c<hldZdh]hlZ\ob^Zhgbijb^_j`b\Zxlkyª
3.<hijhkh\ha\ur_gghklb
=mkfZgZ^->ZjbfbgZkibr_l©Dlh\ZfkdZaZeqlh
\_jrbgZ ]hju g_ fh`_l [ulv [eb`_ d :eeZom q_f __ ih^gh
`b_ dlh \Zf kdZaZe qlh \_jrbgZ fbgZj_lZ g_ fh`_l [ulv
[eb`_d:eeZomq_f_]hhkgh\Zgb_ª:e-DZmkZjbgZwlhhl\_
qZ_l©Wlbkeh\ZmdZau\ZxlgZlhqlhwlhlq_eh\_dki_pbZevgh
ih^gbfZeky gZ ]hjm b gZ fbgZj_l qlh[u ihkfhlj_lv gZ k\h_
[h`_kl\h <b^bfh lZd `_ ihklmiZe _]h oZjjZgblkdbc gZklZ\
gbdbaKZb[uex[b\rbcihdehgylvkyl_eZfgZoh^ysbfkygZ
>Z_lky gZf_d gZ hkgh\hiheh`gbdZ oZrZ\blkdbo b^_c FmoZffZ^Z [bg
DZjjZfZ Zk-KZ^`Zab dhlhjuc y\ey_lky Z\lhjhf yauq_kdhc Zdu^u H _]h
ihke_^h\Zl_eyo – dZjjZfblZo dhlhjuo \hki_\Z_l B[g L_cfby bfZf =Z[
^medZ^bjZe-;Z]^Z^b\k\h_cdgb]_©MkmevZ^-^bgªkkdZaZeke_^mx
s__©Fuh[yaZguh[ty\blvg_\_jgufbdZjjZfblkdbofm^`Zkkbfblh\Oh
jZkZgZihlhfmqlhhgb\ukdZau\ZxlkyhgZebqbbm:eeZoZgb`g_c]jZgb
puBf_gghkg__ihbofg_gbxgZqbgZ_lkyLjhgDjhf_lh]hhgbkqblZ
xl qlh :eeZo ih^\_j`_g baf_g_gbyfª ;he__ ih^jh[gh hg ibr_l h gbo \
k\h_cdgb]_©:e-Nmjmd[ZcgZZe-nbjZdªkDjhf_g_]hijb\_j`_gp_\
wlbo b^_c h[ty\beb g_\_jgufb Ze-Dmjlm[b \ ©:l-LbadZjª k b ZgGZ\Z\b\©:e-FZ^`fm]ª
422
J_qvb^_lh[bm^_yo–ii
421
160
\_jom GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ :eeZo ij_\ur_ ihgylby f_klh [eb
ahklvd:eeZomhij_^_ey_lkyg_f_klhf\DhjZg_ihwlhfmih
\h^m kdZaZgh ©Ihdehgbkv b ijb[ebavkyª b \ oZ^bk_ IjhjhdZ
k]klZd`_kdZaZgh©GZb[he__[ebahdjZ[dk\h_fm=hkih^m
\h\j_fya_fgh]hihdehgZªijb\h^blkymZg-GZkZbb^jm]bo
: d q_fm gZk ijbau\Z_lwlhl[_^gy]Z"Hg]h\hjblgZf©AZ[_
jbkv gZ ]hjm beb fbgZj_l lh]^Z lu klZg_rv [eb`_ d k\h_fm
;h]mªJZa\_fh`_l[ulv[hevr__g_\_jb_q_fwlh"ª
<hijhk h \hkk_^Zgbb :eeZoZ qbkl Hg hl \k_]h qlh
_fmijbibku\Zxlg_\_jgu_gZLjhg_
LZdh]hfg_gbyijb^_j`b\ZebkvZ^->ZjbfbB[gL_cfby
b B[g Ze-DZcbf =mkfZg Z^->Zjbfb ih wlhfm ih\h^m gZ k ibr_l©>ZHgkb^blgZLjhg_h^gZdhjy^hfkkh[hchklZ\be
jZkklhygb_\q_luj_iZevpZªZgZkhgijh^he`Z_l©?keb
[uHgih`_eZelhhk_^eZe[udhfZjZgh[eZ]h^Zjy?]hfh]m
s_kl\mbfbehk_j^bxdhfZjkfh][u_]hm^_j`Zlvg_]h\hjy
m`_ h ljhg_ª423 :e-DZmkZjb ih wlhfm ih\h^m hl\_qZ_l ©Wlhl
q_eh\_d ijb\h^bl ijbf_j k \hh[jZ`Z_fuf \hkk_^Zgb_f :eeZ
oZgZkibg_dhfZjZb`_eZ_lkdZaZlvqlhLjhg[hevr_dhfZjZb
:eeZogZg_fl_f[he__fh`_lkb^_lvIh^h[guc\a^hjykeu
rZe lhevdh hl Zk-KZ^`Zab b B[g L_cfbb Ze-OZjjZgbª ;he__
lh]h g_dhlhju_ fm^`Zkkbfblu ml\_j`^Zxl qlh \ Km^guc
^_gv Hg jy^hf k Kh[hc ihkZ^bl IjhjhdZ FmoZffZ^Z k]k
Qlh[u^hdZaZlvbklbgghklvk\hboml\_j`^_gbchgb\u^mfZeb
g_kdhevdh oZ^bkh\ b ijbibkZeb Z^->Zjdmlgb ^\mklbrb_ ©G_
hl\_j]Zcl_qlhHgkb^blg_hl\_j]Zcl_qlhHgfh`_lkZ^blv
kyª-^Zih]m[bl:eeZowlboe`_ph\
Ij_^iheZ]Z_lkyqlhwlh^\mklbrb_Z^->Zjdmlgbijbib
kZe eb[h B[g DZ^br eb[h _]h gZklZ\gbd Ze-=ZrZjb H^bg ba
mfZebr_gguo ij_^klZ\bl_e_c bo k_dlu kdZaZe ©?keb [u dlheb[hihdeyekyjZa\h^hfqlh:eeZoihkZ^bljy^hfkKh[hcgZ
Lh `_ kZfh_ ibr_l B[g L_cfby \ dgb]_ ©:l-LZkbk nb jZ^^ mkmk ZllZd^bkª
423
161
Ljhg424 FmoZffZ^Z lh y kdZaZe [u ©>Z lu ijZ\ª ^Z \ha^Zkl
_fm:eeZoihaZkem]Zf
H^bg ba mq_guo r_co Ze-DZgm[b kdZaZe ©< gZke_^bb
hklZ\e_gghf Ijhjhdhf k]k \u g_ gZc^_l_ k\b^_l_evkl\ \
ihevam lh]h qlh :eeZo aZgbfZ_l \ha\ur_ggh_ iheh`_gb_ \
hkyaZ_fhf nbabq_kdhf – ii ieZg_ wlh fg_gb_ hkgh\Zgh gZ
keZ[uo b \u^mfZgguo k\b^_l_evkl\Zo Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ^hklh
\_jguolh\gbo\ug_gZc^_l_mdZaZgbygZwlhª>Ze__hg]h
\hjbl ©LZdh]h g_l g_ lhevdh \ ij_^Zgbyo hl IjhjhdZ k]k
ghb\ij_^Zgbyohl_]hkih^\b`gbdh\?keb`_\klj_lbl_ih
^h[gh_ lh agZcl_ qlh wlh eh`vª Fu [jhkZ_f oZrZ\blZf \u
ah\ imklv hgb ijb\_^ml gZf ohly [u h^gh ^hklh\_jgh_ k\b^_
l_evkl\h\ihevamlh]hqlh:eeZojZkiheh`bekygZLjhg_beb
\hag_kky gZ g_]h \ nbabq_kdhf ihgbfZgbb wlh]h keh\Z Djhf_
lh]hfu[jhkZ_fbf\uah\bijb]eZrZ_fgZhldjulmx^bkdmk
kbxihwlhfm\hijhkmZlZd`_ih^jm]bf\hijhkZfZdu^u
OZrZ\blubf_lZnhjufZ^`Za
Ik_\^hkZeZnbluiheghklvxhl\_j]ZxlgZebqb_f_lZnhj
\ DhjZg_ b kmgg_ Zj]mf_glbjmy wlh l_f qlh f_lZnhjZ kh^_j
`bl\k_[_^hexe`bQlh[ujZatykgblvqblZl_exkmlv\_s_c
fu \gZqZe_ ohl_eb [u ^Zlv hij_^_e_gb_ f_lZnhju F_lZnhjZ
fZ^`Zaihfg_gbxmq_guoaZgbfZxsbokyklbebklbdhcZjZ[
kdh]h yaudZ – wlh i_j_ghk hkgh\gh]hagZq_gbykeh\Z\ihevam
dZdh]h-lh ^jm]h]h gh lhevdh \ lhf kemqZ_ _keb f_`^m wlbfb
^\mfyagZq_gbyfb_klvdZdZy-eb[hk\yavbijbkmlkl\m_lh[klh
yl_evkl\hg_^himkdZxs__bkihevah\Zgb_hkgh\gh]hagZq_gby
GZijbf_j :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Qlh[u l_[y \ajZklbeb
ih^ Fhbf ]eZahfª lh _klv ©qlh[u l_[y \ajZklbeb ih^
Fhbf ijbkfhljhfª DZd \b^bl_ \ ^Zgghf Zyl_ g_ bf__lky \
\b^m gZklhysbc ]eZa b \ DhjZg_ k kmgghc lZdbo ijbf_jh\
hq_gvfgh]h
Fg_gb_ h lh qlh \ Km^guc ^_gv Ijhjhd k]k [m^_l kb^_lv gZ Ljhg_
jy^hfk:eeZohfy\ey_lky[b^]ZHgh\hkoh^bldB[gL_cfbb©FbgoZ^`
Zk-kmggZª– 261.
424
162
Ihq_fm`_ik_\^hkZeZnbluhljbpZxlfZ^`Za">Zihlh
fmqlhhgiheghklvxjZajmrZ_lboZgljhihfhjnbklkdmxl_h
jbx ?keb hgb \k_ keh\Z mdZau\Zxsb_ gZ q_eh\_dhih^h[b_
gZqgmlljZdlh\Zlv\f_lZnhjbq_kdhfagZq_gbblhmgbog_hk
lZg_lkygbdZdbo^h\h^h\^eyih^l\_j`^_gbyk\hbom[_`^_gbc
>jm]Zy ijbqbgZ – hgb kljh]h ke_^mxl ijbf_jm k\h_]h gZklZ\
gbdZ B[g L_cfbb dhlhjuc kqblZe i_j_ghkgmx ljZdlh\dm k\y
s_gguol_dklh\g_^himklbfhc[b^]Zbg_ijbagZ\Zef_lZnhju
Ihwlhfm g_kfhljy gZ _]h aZ[em`^_gb_ mq_gbdb \ugm`^_gu
ke_^h\ZlvaZk\hbfmqbl_e_fM\Z`Z_fucr_coFmoZffZ^Ze=ZaZab bgki_dlhj j_eb]bhaguo nZdmevl_lh\ ©:e-:aoZjZª
ijhn_kkhj ZjZ[kdh]h yaudZ b ebl_jZlmju ijb ih^]hlh\bl_ev
ghf bgklblml_ ©:a-AZdZdbyª y\eyykv khZ\lhjhf dgb]b ©B[g
L_cfby eyckZ kZeZnbygª425 ©B[g L_cfby g_ kZeZnblª ijb
gZ^e_`Zs_c i_jm r_coZ FZgkmjZ FmoZffZ^Z Ze-=m\ZckZ h[
hlghr_gbb B[g L_cfbb d f_lZnhjZf ibr_l ©G_\abjZy gZ
fg_gby _]h klhjhggbdh\ y g_ ihkl_kgyxkv aZy\blv qlh B[g
L_cfby [ue ebr_g ebl_jZlmjgh]h \dmkZ b ihwlhfm \hh[s_ g_
fh]ijhgbdgmlv\lZcguZjZ[kdh]hyaudZª426HljbpZgb_f_lZ
nhjbq_kdhc ljZdlh\db k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ kem`bl _s_ h^gbf
^h\h^hf \ ihevam keZ[hklb ihabpbb oZrZ\blh\ik_\^hkZeZnblh\hgbg_\khklhygbbihgylvgbDhjZggbkmg
gmgbkZfZjZ[kdbcyaudQlh`_dZkZ_lkyfmkmevfZgkdhcmf
fu lh hgZ aZ j_^dbf bkdexq_gb_f ^himkdZ_l f_lZnhjbq_k
dmx b i_j_ghkgmx ljZdlh\dm >Ze__ \ dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Z fu oh
lbfijb\_klb\ukdZau\Zgbymq_guoij_^klZ\bl_e_cfZaoZ[h\
:r-RZ\dZgbihwlhfmih\h^m\k\h_cdgb]_©BjrZ^ZenZomeª gZ k ibr_l©Ih_^bgh]eZkghfmfg_gbxmq_guo\
ZjZ[kdhf yaud_ kms_kl\mxl f_lZnhju b i_j_ghkguc kfuke
?^bgkl\_gguc dlh g_ kh]eZk_g k wlbf - :[m BkoZd ZeBknZjZbgbgh_]hg_kh]eZkb_mdZau\Z_lgZkeZ[h_agZgb_yau
dZ ?fm ke_^m_l [eb`_ ihagZdhfblvky k wlbf yaudhf ihagZlv
Ba^-\h©>ZjZg-gZo^ZeZ-]ZjZ[byªlk]
: ke_^h\Zl_evgh g_ fh]ml ijhgbdgmlv \ lZcgu DhjZgZ b kmggu ih
kdhevdmhgbgbkihkeZgugZZjZ[kdhfyaud_–ii
425
426
163
_]h bklbgu b f_lZnhju dhlhju_ ykgu ex[hfm agZlhdm yaudZ
Ijb\h^y^h\h^uhg]h\hjbl©?keb[u\ZjZ[kdhfyaud_ijb
kmlkl\h\Zebf_lZnhjulhex^yf[ueh[uljm^ghihgylv^jm]
^jm]Zihkdhevdm\g_dhlhjuokblmZpbyoh[klhyl_evkl\Zhljb
pZxsb_ hkgh\gh_ agZq_gb_ fh]ml [ulv ml_jyguª GZ kZfhf
^_e_wlbh[klhyl_evkl\Zg_fh]ml[ulvml_jyguZkms_kl\h\Z
gb_ f_lZnhj ykg__ kheg_qgh]h ^gyª B[g >`Zgb ih wlhfm ih
\h^mibr_l©;hevrZyqZklvyaudZij_^klZ\e_gZf_lZnhjZfbb
i_j_ghkgufkfukehf=h\hjylqlhydh[u:[m=ZebZe-NZjbkb
ijb^_j`b\Z_lky lhqdb aj_gby Ze-BknZjZbgb y lZd g_ ^mfZx
ihkdhevdmagZx_]hdZd[hevrh]hagZlhdZZjZ[kdh]hyaudZIh
kdhevdm f_lZnhju b i_j_ghkgu_ agZq_gby ijbkmlkl\mxl \
ZjZ[kdhf yaud_ hgb lZd`_ ijbkmlkl\mxl b \ DhjZg_ Ijbq_f
bo hq_gv fgh]h gh ihagZlv bo fh]ml lhevdh l_ dlh hlebqZ_l
hkgh\gh_agZq_gb_hli_j_ghkgh]h=h\hjylqlhaZobjblu427g_
ijbagZxl i_j_ghkgmx ljZdlh\dm k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ wlh g_
m^b\bl_evgh\_^vwlhg_i_j\uc\hijhk\dhlhjhfhgbijhy\
eyxl aZdhkg_ehklv b g_`_eZgb_ ihagZlv bklbgmª >Ze__ hg
ijh^he`Z_l ©Wlhl \hijhk gZklhevdh yk_g qlh y ^Z`_ g_ [m^m
ijb\h^blvijbf_jh\f_lZnhjbi_j_ghkguoagZq_gbc\DhjZg_
Bihkdhevdmhgbijbkmlkl\mxl\DhjZg_lhl_f[he__ijbkml
kl\mxlb\kmgg__keb`_dlh-eb[hwlhhljbpZ_llhhgg_^h
klhbg^Z`_lh]hqlh[u_fmhl\_lbebª
Ijbf_jgh lh `_ kZfh_ ibr_l KZ^udoZg \ k\h_c dgb]_
©OmkmeZe-fZfmeª
B[gDm^ZfZZe-OZg[Zeb\©JZ\^ZlZg-gZaujªlk
ijb\_^y g_dhlhju_ ba Zylh\ DhjZgZ ibr_l ©DZd \b^bl_ \k_
wlhy\ey_lkyf_lZnhjbq_kdhcbi_j_ghkghcljZdlh\dhcDhjZgZ
lhl dlh g_ ijbagZ_l wlh]h y\ey_lky ]hj^_eb\uf mijyfp_f Z
lhldlhijbagZ_lgh]h\hjbl©Y[ug_gZa\Zewlhf_lZnhjhcª
-\iZ^Z_l\[_kihe_aguckihj\h[eZklbl_jfbgheh]bbª.
Hl ZjZ[kdh]h ©aZobjª ©ykgucª ©y\gucª ©[md\Zevgucª Bf_xlky \
\b^ml_dlhhl^Z_lij_^ihql_gb_[md\ZevghfmihgbfZgbxk\ys_gguol_dk
lh\–ii
427
164
:k-Kmxlu ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©LujZa Ze]bfZfZª ibr_l ©HljbpZgb_ f_lZnhj b i_j_ghkgh]h kfukeZ
mdZau\Z_lgZ]emihklvbg_^Ze_dhklvq_eh\_dZª428.
M\Z`Z_fucr_co=bkZ[bg=Z[^meeZ[bgFZgb]kdZaZe
©<k_q_luj_bfZfZ–b:[mOZgbnZbFZebdZZr-RZnb]bb
:ofZ^ – ijbagZ\Zeb f_lZnhju b i_j_ghkgu_ agZq_gby Bo
hq_gv fgh]h \ yaud_ª >Ze__ hg ijb\h^bl \ukdZau\Zgb_ :[m
OZgbnu ©I_j_ghkguc kfuke aZf_gy_l bklbgguc lhevdh gZ
keh\ZoZg_gZ^_e_JZa\_\ug_\b^bl_qlhh^ghblh`_fh`
ghh[hagZqblvjZaebqgufb\ujZ`_gbyfb>eygZk\Z`ghqlh
[u \_jghc [ueZ hkgh\Z b _keb hkgh\Z g_ ^himkdZ_l ijyfh]h
ihgbfZgby wlh]h \ujZ`_gby lh fu ^he`gu ijb[_]gmlv d i_
j_ghkghfm Lhqgh lZd `_ ijhbkoh^bl dh]^Z ijb aZdexq_gbb
[jZdZbkihevam_lkykeh\h³^Zjx´ªDhff_glbjmywlh\ukdZau
\Zgb_r_coibr_l©Wlbkeh\Zykghk\b^_l_evkl\mxl\ihevam
kms_kl\h\Zgby ijyfh]h b i_j_ghkgh]h agZq_gbcª >Ze__ hg
ijb\h^bl ijbf_ju lh]h dZd bfZf FZebd bkihevah\Ze i_j_
ghkgu_ agZq_gby keh\ ijb ljZdlh\d_ Zylh\ DhjZgZ b oZ^bkh\
©:eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Fu ihqblZ_f L_[yª B[g Ze-DZkbf
kdZaZe©YkeurZekeh\ZFZebdZ³IhqblZgb_–wlhfhebl\Z´ª
<hlghr_gbbkfukeZZylZ©?keb\uex[bl_:eeZoZª, -FZebd
kdZaZe ©Ih\bgmykv ?fmª ih ih\h^m keh\Z ©agZq_gb_ª ©lZ
\beª\Zyl_©Bg_ba\_klgh_]hagZq_gb_ª, - FZebdkdZaZe©G_
ba\_klgZbklbgZª>Ze__hgibr_l©:e-OZlu[\©:e-NZdbo\Z
Ze-fmlZnZddboª–ibr_l©<kmgg_IjhjhdZk]k
lZd`_dZdb\DhjZg__klvi_j_ghkgu_bf_lZnhjbq_kdb_qZ
klgu_bh[sb_agZq_gby«GZijbf_jmZe-;moZjbijb\h^blky
oZ^bk ©Fg_ [ueZ \_e_gZ ^_j_\gy ih`bjZxsZy ^jm]b_ ^_j_\
gb«ªB[g<Zo[kdZaZe©YkijhkbemFZebdZ©QlhagZqblih
`bjZxsZy ^jm]b_ ^_j_\gb"ª b hg hl\_lbe ´AZ\h_\u\ZxsZy
bo´ª429.
Djhf_wlh]hkfr_coKZ]b^Ze-DZgm[b©Zk-KZcnZe-oZ^^ª–K– 28.
@mjgZe ©:^->uyª kZnZj – jZ[b]mevZ\\Zev ] fZc-bxgv ]
ihke_^gyy klj ih^ aZ]heh\dhf ©:e-FZ^`Za ]bg^Z Ze-ZbffZ Ze-Zj[Z]Zª k
ijh^he`_gb_f\ke_^mxs_fghf_j_
428
429
165
Kf_rgh lh qlh \ZooZ[blu k [hevrbf ihql_gb_f hlgh
kbebkvdr_comFmoZffZ^m=ZebZk-KZ[mgbghdh]^ZhggZib
kZe k\hc lZnkbj ©KZn\Zl Zl-lZnZkbjª hgb g_ lhevdh hl\_jgm
ebkvhlg_]hghbgZqZeb]hg_gbyijhlb\g_]h<q_f`_ijb
qbgZ" IjbqbgZ [ueZ lhevdh \ lhf qlh hg ih^\_j] ljZdlh\d_
Zylukh^_j`Zsb_bgnhjfZpbxh[h`_kl\_gguoZljb[mlZoqlh
ijhlb\hj_qbl \ZooZ[blkdhc b^_heh]bb <h \lhjhf lhf_ wlh]h
lZnkbjZgZkhgijb\h^blhq_gvaZ[Z\gmxbklhjbx©JZk
kdZau\Zxl qlh h^gZ`^u d m\Z`Z_fhfm mq_ghfm ijbr_e mq_
gucgm`ghhlf_lblvqlhhg[ueke_ihl\_j]Zxsbci_j_ghk
gmx ljZdlh\dm DhjZgZ b f_lZnhju b gZqZe _]h djblbdh\Zlv
Lh]^Z m\Z`Z_fuc mq_guc kdZaZe ©Qlh lu kdZ`_rv h keh\Zo
:eeZoZ ©Dlh ke_i \ wlhc `bagb ke_i b \ [m^ms_c b d lhfm
`_hg[he__^jm]boaZ[em^rbcªdZdlu^mfZ_rvhq_f
a^_kvb^_lj_qvhnbabq_kdhcke_ihl_beb^moh\ghc"ª-bhgg_
gZr_eqlhhl\_lblv:qlh\ukdZ`_l_hr_co_B[g;Za_dhlh
juclZd`_ebr_gnbabq_kdh]haj_gby"430
OZrZ\blkdZylZdby431
Ik_\^hkZeZnblu-fm^`Zkkbfblu ij_^klZ\eyxl k\h_]h
=hkih^Z \ h[jZa_ l_eZ k ^\mfy ]eZaZfb ^\mfy jmdZfb ^\mfy
gh]Zfb ijbq_f \k_ wlh le_ggh djhf_ ebpZ [h`by432 B ihke_
lZdh]h aZy\e_gby hgb _s_ hkf_eb\Zxlky hljbpZlv qlh g_ y\
eyxlkyfm^`ZkkbfblZfb>Zmgbo_klvhijZ\^Zgb_hgbihke_
<]Za_l_©FZgZjZe-oZ^bª‹amevob^`Z]fZjl]kdZaZgh
qlh r_co B[g ;Za aZ^Z\r_]h _fm wlhl \hijhk kbevgh h[jm]Ze b \_e_e \u
]gZlv
431
K g_h[oh^bfufb kkuedZfb gZ dgb]m =Zeb Ze-DmjZgb Ze-=Zfbeb ©:e<ZooZ[bylm\ZZl-lZ\ob^ª–>ZjZk-kbjZ;_cjml–K
432
Kfn_l\uZe-:e[Zgb–K–<qZklghklbhgibr_l©«fuh[y
aZgu hljbpZlv lhl nZdl qlh \_ebdbc mq_guc-oZ^bkh\_^ Ze-;moZjb ljZdlh
\Ze wlhl Zyl bf__lky \ \b^m Zyl ©<k_ le_ggh djhf_ ebdZ ?]hª \_^v hg
ghkbl_evkZeZnblkdhcZdu^uo\ZeZ:eeZomªGZkZfhf`_^_e_Ze-;moZjb
ih^\_j]Z_l wlhl Zyl ljZdlh\d_ b h[tykgy_l keh\h ©ebdª keh\hf ©pZjkl\hª
Kf DblZ[ Zl-lZnkbj Q ;Z[ lZnkbj kmjZl ©Ze-DZkZkª djhf_ wlh]h hg
ljZdlh\Ze©kf_oªdZd©fbehklvªKf©NZloZe-[Zjbª
430
166
dZ`^h]h ih^h[gh]h aZy\e_gby433 ]h\hjyl ©DZd wlh ijbebq_kl
\m_l ?]h \_ebqbxª : ]^_ `_ f_klh [h`_kl\_gghfm \_ebqbx
ihke_lh]hdZddG_fmijb^_eZebhj]Zguh]jZgbqbeb?]h\j_
f_g_f ijhkljZgkl\hf ^\b`_gb_f b ^Z`_ le_gghklvx djhf_
ebpZ" Bo Zdu^Z ihkljh_gZ gZ hq_gv rZldhc hkgh\_ dhlhjZy \
eh]bd_gZau\Z_lky©ijbgylb_ihkuehdbhljbpZgb_\u\h^h\ª\
dZeZf_gZau\Z_lky©hljbpZgb_khklZ\ghcqZklbmq_gbbyªZkh
\j_f_gguf yaudhf wlh fh`gh gZa\Zlv ©ijbgylb_ lZr[boZ b
lZ^`kbfZkhldZahfhlbogZa\ZgbyªWlbex^bdjblbdmxlrb
blkdmx lZdbx Z kZfb ijbf_gyxl wlhl `_ ijbgpbi \ hlghr_
gbb[h`_kl\_gguobf_gbZljb[mlh\
Bkke_^h\Zl_ev\ZooZ[blkdh]hmq_gby^he`_gkdehgblvky
dh^ghfmba^\moEb[hhg^he`_gaZy\blvqlhbomq_gu_gb
q_]hg_ihgbfZxleb[hqlhhgbhibku\Zy:eeZoZbkihevamxl
lZdbxI_j\uc\ZjbZglg_ih^oh^blihkdhevdmbkke_^h\Zl_ex
ij_djZkgh ba\_klgh qlh B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[ B[g ;Za Ze:e[Zgbbbomqbl_evB[gL_cfbyij_djZkghagZebqlhagZqbl
[md\ZevgZyljZdlh\dZk\ys_gguol_dklh\bqlhbag__\ul_dZ
_l Ihwlhfm aZsbsZy k\hb m[_`^_gby hgb \ugm`^_gu hljb
pZlv _]h g_hlt_fe_fu_ we_f_glu Bo keh\Z _klv y\guc lZ^`
kbf hl ijhklhex^bgh\ hgb wlh ^Z`_ g_ kdju\Zxl Hgb aZy\
eyxl qlh DhjZg hljbpZ_l ©Zg-gb^^ª ©jZ\_gkl\hª ©fbkeª
©ih^h[b_ª©Ze-dmnª©jZ\_gkl\hbih^h[b_ªghg_hljbpZ_l
©Zr-rZ[boª ©ihoh`_klvª ihwlhfm kqblZxl _]h ^himklbfuf
klhqdbaj_gbybrZjbZlZbjZamfZ434.
HgbaZy\eyxl©Fug_ijbibku\Z_f:eeZomgbq_]hlh]hqlhHgg_kh
h[sbehk_[_ªIhke_wlh]h]h\hjyl©Hg\hag_kkygZLjhgK\h_ckmsghk
lvxª\dZdhff_kl_DhjZgZbebkmggukdZaZgh©kmsghklvxª"
434
B[g L_cfby \ ©Zj-JbkZeZ Zl-lZ^fbjbyª k ibr_l ©Hgb Zljb[mlb\
ghklv gZau\Zxl mih^h[e_gb_f b mjZ\gb\Zgb_f ihwlhfm b g_ kh]eZkgu k
gZfbª B ^Ze__ ijh^he`Zy ©G_dhlhju_ ex^b gZau\Zxl wlh ©Zl-lZr[boª
©ihoh`_klvª b qlh bgl_j_kgh wlhl l_jfbg g_ ijhlb\hj_qbl gb jZamfm
gbl_dklZfRZjbZlbjZamfh[yau\ZxlgZkhljbpZlv©Zg-gb^^ª©jZ\_gkl
\hª ©fbkeª ©ih^h[b_ª ©Ze-dmnª ©jZ\_gkl\h b ih^h[b_ª Kh]eZkgh aZ
dhgZfZjZ[kdh]hyaudZhibkZgb_g_jZ\ghhibku\Z_fhfmbjZamflZd`_g_
hljbpZ_l©Zr-rZ[boª©ihoh`_klvªkh]eZkghl_jfbgheh]bbfmlZabeblh\
433
167
:a-AZoZ[b dh]^Z [ue ihke_^h\Zl_e_f B[g L_cfbb ib
kZe©Fug_h[yaZgu^h\h^blv^h\k_h[s_]hk\_^_gby\k_^ha
\he_ggu_ agZgby ^hklZlhqgh _keb hgh [m^_l ba\_klgh ebrv
ba[jZgghc]jmii_mq_guoª435dZdwlhihoh`_gZagZgbybm^__\
b ojbklbZg kdju\Zxsbo bo hl rbjhdbo fZkk < ©Kbyj Z]eyf
Zg-gm[Zeyª Za-AZoZ[b ibr_l ©Qlh dZkZ_lky kimkdZ
:eeZoZ–iilhfuh[yaZgu\wlh\_jblvghij_^ihqlbl_ev
ghg_\^Z\Zlvky\h\k_ih^jh[ghklbk\yaZggu_kgbfªHgbf_
_l\\b^mqlh\^Z\Zlvky\wlhfh`ghghemqr_hldZaZlvkyLh
_klv hg kh]eZrZ_lky kh \k_fb \u\h^Zfb fm^`Zkkbfblkdh]h
mq_gby gh kh\_lm_l g_ jZa]eZrZlv bo qlh[u hgb g_ [ueb bk
ihevah\Zgu ijhlb\ gbo Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ijhklhex^bgh\fm^`Zkkbfblh\lhhgbom^rb_bag_\_`^hgbnZgZlbqgh\hk
o\Zeyxlk\hxrdhemgZau\Zxl__©rdhehclZ\ob^Zª©rdhehc
kZeZnh\ªghbf^Z`_g_ba\_klgZkmlvlZdboihgylbcdZd©lZ
\beª©ljZdlh\dZª©lZn\b^ª©hldZahlm]em[e_ggh]hZgZebaZ
agZq_gbyªb©fZ^`Zaª©f_lZnhjZbi_j_ghkguckfukeª
: bo klm^_glu b \uimkdgbdb ^mfZxl qlh [md\Zevguc
ih^oh^ d ZgZebam dhjZgbq_kdbo Zylh\ y\ey_lky h[s_ijbgyluf
ijbgpbihf\k_okZeZnblkdbomq_guob\k_ofZaoZ[h\G_dhlh
ju_bagbo^Z`_g_ihgbfZxlqlhagZqblbdq_fm\_^_l[md
\ZevgZyljZdlh\dZk\ys_gguol_dklh\?keb\uh^ghfmbawlbo
\uimkdgbdh\ kdZ`_l_ ©<Zrb mq_gu_ ml\_j`^Zxl qlh :eeZo
kb^blgZLjhg_bdh]^Zohq_lkimkdZ_lkykg_]hgZA_fexlZd
dZd wlh k^_eZe B[g L_cfby \ h^ghc ba f_q_lyo RZfZ kimk
lb\rbkvkfbg[ZjZ436LZdh_fg_gb_\_^_ldlhfmqlh\uh]jZ
gbqb\Z_l_ :eeZoZ ijhkljZgkl\_ggh-\j_f_ggufb jZfdZfb b
ijbibku\Z_l_ _fm khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ dZq_kl\Zª - hg \Zf hl\_
lbl©G_lwlhg_]h\hjblhlhfqlhfumih^h[ey_f:eeZoZq_
=Zeb Ze-DmjZgb ©:e-<ZooZ[bylm \Z Zl-lZ\ob^ª – K Hg g_ mdZaZe
bklhqgbd gh \hafh`gh bf__lky \ \b^m ©LZadbjZl Ze-omnnZaª – 14,
beb©KbyjZ]eyfZg-gm[Zeyª:a-AZoZ[baZsbsZefm^`Zkkbfblh\b
hkh[_ggh =Z[^me]Zgb dhlhjh]h _]bi_lkdb_ nZdbob ijb]h\hjbeb d kf_jlb
\b^bfhbf_ggh\k\yabkwlbfhgij_^ihq_efg_gb_h[h]jZgbq_gbbihagZ
gbcijhklhex^bgh\
436
Kfi_j\mx]eZ\m
435
168
eh\_dmbijbibku\Z_f?fml_ehHgkb^bllZddZdijbebq_kl
\m_l?]h\_ebqbxkimkdZ_lkylZddZdijbebq_kl\m_l?]h\_eb
qbxª Wlhl [_^gy]Z ^mfZ_l qlh keh\Z ©dZd ijbebq_kl\m_l ?]h
\_ebqbxª jZaj_rZxl \k_ ijh[e_fu b \hijhku Hg ihoh` gZ
lh]hq_eh\_dZdhlhjuc_klvbiv_l\k\_leh_\j_fykmlhdZaZ
l_f ml\_j`^Z_l qlh ^_j`bl ihkl lZd dZd ijbebq_kl\m_l _]h
ihklm b _kl lZd dZd ijbebq_kl\m_l kmsghklb ihklZ ?fm b \
]heh\mg_ijb^_lqlhhl_]hkmsghklbm`_gbq_]hg_hklZehkv
>Ze__ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb pblZlm hl Zk-Km[db ba dhlh
jhc klZgh\blky ykgh qlh mihfygmlZy lZdby [ueZ ba\_klgZ
ij_^dZf \ZooZ[blh\ ©R_co =Z[^mkZeyf kdZaZe ©OZrZ\blu b
fmrZ[[boblu mih^h[eyxsb_ :eeZoZ ?]h kha^Zgbyf ^_eylky
gZ^\_]jmiiuh^gZbagbog_kdju\Z_lk\hbom[_`^_gbcb^m
fZ_lqlhijZ\Z^jm]Zy[hykvdjblbdbfZkdbjm_lkyih^rdhem
kZeZnblh\ª437.
OZrZ\blkdmxlZdbx\ulZd`_fh`_l_m\b^_lv\dgb]Zo
B[gZe-DZcbfZb_]hgZklZ\gbdZB[gL_cfbbHgbaZimlu\Zxl
keh\Z bkihevamxl djZkb\u_ \ujZ`_gby ibrml ^ebggu_ \\_
^_gby hkh[_ggh _keb j_qv b^_l h lZ^`kbf_ <k_ wlh ^_eZ_lky
^eylh]hqlh[u\\_klbqblZl_ey\aZ[em`^_gb_Ijbql_gbbbo
dgb] kha^Z_lky \i_qZle_gb_ qlh hgb ohlyl kdZaZlv lh q_]h
hq_gvkbevghkl_kgyxlkyLZdh\klbevbodgb]b_keb[uex^b
magZeb qlh djh_lky \ bo ijhba\_^_gbyo lh ^Z\gh m`_ kh`]eb
[uboBjZa\_fh`_l[ulvkemqZcghklvxlhlnZdlqlhk_f_gZ
wlh]heh`gh]hmq_gby\ahrebbf_gghgZjh^bg_FmkZceZfu"
B^_yba\_qghklbfbjZb]jZgbp438
FmkmevfZgkdZy Zdu^Z ykgh jZatykgbeZ qlh :eeZo [ue
i_j\uf Ze-:\\Zev b lhevdh ?fm ijbkmsZ ba\_qghklv < ^h
klh\_jghf k[hjgbd_ Ze-;moZjb ijb\h^blky oZ^bk IjhjhdZ
k]k©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]hdjhf_G_]hª\^jm]hf
jb\Zyl_©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]h\f_kl_kGbfª\lj_lv
_fjb\Zyl_©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]h^hG_]hª<^hklh
:k-Km[db©LZ[ZdZlZr-rZnb]byª– 8/222.
KhdjZs_ggh ba dgb]b ©Zl-LZg[bo \Z Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey fm]lZdZ^ db^Zf Ze]ZeZf\ZZe-oZ^^ªOZkZg[bg=ZebZk-KZddZnZr-RZnb]b–K– 14.
437
438
169
\_jguok[hjgbdZolZd`_ijb\h^blkyoZ^bk\dhlhjhfkdZaZgh
©I_j\hc \_svx dhlhjmx khl\hjbe :eeZo [ueh I_jh B Hg
\_e_e_fmaZibkZlv\k_qlhijhbahc^_l^hKm^gh]h^gyª439GZ
hkgh\_wlbooZ^bkh\mq_gu_ijbrebd_^bgh]eZkghfmfg_gbx
hlhfqlh:eeZoba\_q_gHgi_j\ucbg_[uehgbq_]h^hG_]h
[he__ lh]h mq_gu_ _^bgh]eZkgh ijbagZeb g_\_jguf lh]h dlh
g_ kh]eZk_g k wlbf ml\_j`^_gb_f D wlhfm fg_gbx ijbkh_^b
gbekyB[gOZaf\©FZjZlb[Ze-b^`fZ]ªkb_]h`_mih
fygmeoZnbadZabc=by^\k\h_cdgb]_©:r-RbnZªQlh`_ih
wlhfm ih\h^m ]h\hjyl oZrZ\blu" Hgb kqblZxl qlh fbj ba\_
q_g k\hbfb dZl_]hjbyfb b ih^jZamf_\Zxl p_ihqdm kh[ulbc
g_bf_xsbogZqZeZbebba\_qgh]hl\hjpZIhemqZ_lkyqlhdZ
l_]hjbb kms_kl\h\Zeb h^gh\j_f_ggh k :eeZohf b m gbo g_
[ueh gZqZeZ LZdh_ fg_gb_ \ukdZau\Z_l ba\_klg_crbc oZrZ
\blkdbcbfZfB[gL_cfbyZe-OZjjZgbdhlhjh]hhgbgZau\Zxl
r_comebkeZf DZabc =by^ ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ k\h_c ©:rRbnZª ibr_l ©<k_o nbehkhnh\ b [_a[h`gbdh\ kqb
lZxsbo qlh fbj ba\_q_g beb \_q_g Z lZd`_ \k_o khfg_\Zx
sbokyihwlhfmih\h^mfuijbagZ_fg_\_jgufbª
>Ze__ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb pblZlu ba dgb] kZfh]h B[g
L_cfbb
< dgb]Zo ©FmZnZdZl kZobo Ze-fZgdme eb kZjbo ZefZ]dmeª ba^Zgghc \ dZq_kl\_ km[dhff_glZjb_\ d ©FbgoZ^`
Zk-kmggZª ©>Zjm lZ]Zjm^ Ze-]Zdeª hg ibr_l
©;hevrbgkl\h oZ^bkh\_^h\440 hlghkyl dZl_]hjbb g_ d ijhbah
r_^r_fm Z d ba\_qghfm Ihwlhfm hgb hl^_eyxl ijhbkoh`^_
gb_dZl_]hjbchlijhbkoh`^_gby_^bgbplZd`_dZd\k_ex^b
hlebqZxl ijh^he`_gb_ dZl_]hjbb hl ijh^he`_gby _^bgbp b
kml_cª
Ijb\h^bl:[mY]eyhlB[g=Z[[ZkZr_coOmk_cg:kZ^kdZaZeqlh
wlhloZ^bkbf__l^hklh\_jgmxp_ihqdm
440
Ihwlhfmih\h^mr_coZk-KZddZnkdZaZe©NjZaZ©[hevrbgkl\hoZ^bkh
\_^h\ªy\ey_lkyde_\_lhcihlhfmqlhoZ^bkh\_^ubhklZevgu_fmkmevfZg
kdb_mq_gu_\k_odlh\ukdZau\Z_lkyh[ba\_qghklbfbjZg_aZ\bkbfhdZl_
]hjbZevghcbeb_^bgbqghcijbagZxlg_\_jgufbª
439
170
<©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZªhgibr_l©>Zhl^_ev
gucij_^f_lwlh]hfbjZg_fh`_l[ulvba\_qgufghqlhdZkZ
_lky\hagbdgh\_gbydZl_]hjbblhhgZ\_qgZª
< ©:e-FmZnZdZª hg ibr_l ©H[yaZl_evgh ba
\_qguffh`_l[ulvlhevdh\hagbdrZydZl_]hjbyZg_\hagbd
rZy_^bgbpZª441.
B[gL_cfbydhff_glbjmyoZ^bk=bfjZgZ[bgOmkZbgZ
gZkibr_l©>Z`__kebij_^iheh`blvh^gh\j_f_ggh_km
s_kl\h\Zgb_ dZl_]hjbb \f_kl_ k Gbf lh wlh g_ ijhlb\hj_qbl
gbrZjbZlmgbjZamfm442gZh[hjhlwlhk\b^_l_evkl\h?]hkh
\_jr_gkl\Zª
M B[g OZafZ _klv hl^_evgZy ]eZ\Z ©?^bgh]eZkgh_
fg_gb_ h g_\_jbb lh]h dlh ijhlb\hj_qbl _^bgh]eZkghfm fg_
gbxmq_guo\\hijhkZoZdu^uªA^_kvB[gOZafibr_l©Mq_
gu__^bgh^mrguhlghkbl_evghlh]hqlh:eeZo_^bgg_lmG_
]hkhlh\Zjbs_cHgkha^Zl_ev\k_]hkms_]hdjhf_G_]h:eeZo
kms_kl\h\Zeh^bgbg_[uehgbq_]h^jm]h]h\f_kl_kGbfAZ
l_fHgihK\h_fm`_eZgbxkhl\hjbe\k_\_sb>mrbkhl\hj_
gu Ljhg khl\hj_g b \_kv fbj khl\hj_gª B[g L_cfby djblb
dmybhijh\_j]Zykeh\ZB[gOZafZgZk–ibr_l©F_
gym^b\eyxlkeh\Zhlhfqlhdjblbdmxsb_b^_xhkms_kl\h
\Zgbblhevdh:eeZoZbgbq_]h^jm]h]h\f_kl_kGbfy\eyxlky
g_\_jgufbª
B^_y h[ ba\_qghklb fbjZ [ueZ hijh\_j]gmlZ q_lujvfy
djmigufbmq_gufbdZab_f=by^hfbfZfhfoZnbahfB[g>Z
dbdhf Ze-=b^hf bfZfhf oZnbahf Ze-Om^`Z AZcgm^^bghf Ze=bjZdb b bfZfhf-oZ^bkh\_^hf FmoZffZ^hf AZob^hf ZeDZmkZjb B[g OZ^`Zj \ dgb]_ ©NZlo Ze-[Zjbª gZ h^ghc kljZ
gbp_ijb\h^blfg_gb_ljhbo©GZrr_coZe-=bjZdbdhff_g
lbjmyZl-LbjfbabkdZaZe©>Zwlh\_jghmq_gu_h[ty\bebg_
\_jguf lh]h dlh hijh\_j]Z_l h[s_ijbgylh_ dZd gZijbf_j
fhebl\Z beb hijh\_j]Z_l ihemq_ggh_ ih ^hklh\_jguf p_ihq
K\yl:eeZodZd`_hgZ\h^ghblh`_\j_fyfh`_l[ulvbba\_qghcb
ijhbahr_^r_c":eeZoij_\ur_\k_]hlh]hqlhml\_j`^Zxlwlbex^b
442
:dm^Z`_^_ekyoZ^bk©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]h\f_kl_kGbfª":
dm^Z^_ehkv_^bgh]eZkgh_fg_gb_mq_guo"
441
171
dZf beb aZy\ey_l h[ ba\_qghklb fbjZ DZabc =by^ b ^jm]b_
aZy\eyxlqlh_klv_^bgh]eZkgh_fg_gb_hlghkbl_evghh[t
y\e_gbyg_\_jguflh]hdlhijb^_j`b\Z_lkyfg_gbyh[ba
\_qghklbfbjZB[g>ZdbdZe-=b^ihwlhfmih\h^mkdZaZe
©?klv l_ dlh \ukdZau\Z_l g_jZamfgu_ b^_b b ba[bjZ_l
klhjhgmnbehkhnh\443Hg^mfZ_lqlh\uklmiZxsbckb^_
_c h[ ba\_qghklb fbjZ g_ y\ey_lky g_\_jguf < dZq_kl\_
^h\h^Zhgijb\h^blkeh\ZhlhfqlhfmkmevfZgbgg_h[yaZg
ijbgbfZlv \k_ _^bgh]eZkgu_ fg_gby mq_guo Wlhl ^h\h^
a^_kv g_ mf_kl_g ihkdhevdm fg_gb_ h[ h[ty\e_gbb g_\_j
guf klhjhggbdZ b^_b h[ ba\_qghklb fbjZ ih^l\_j`^Z_lky
g_ lhevdh _^bgh]eZkguf fg_gb_f mq_guo gh b ^hklh\_j
gufbfmlZ\Zlbj444k\ys_ggufbl_dklZfbªBfZfFmoZf
fZ^AZob^[bgOZkZgZe-DZmkZjbgZm^b\e_gb_B[gL_cfbb\
k\h_cdgb]_©GZd^fZjZlb[Ze-b^`fZ]ªkhl\_qZ_l©G_l
gbq_]hm^b\bl_evgh]h\lhfqlhmq_gu__^bgh]eZkghijbagZeb
g_\_jguf lh]h dlh aZy\ey_l h kms_kl\h\Zgbb _s_ h^gh]h kh
a^Zl_ey LZd`_ g_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \ lhf qlh hgb ijb
agZebg_\_jguflh]hdlhaZy\ey_lhkms_kl\h\Zgbbq_]h-eb[h
beb dh]h-eb[h gZjy^m k :eeZohf ^h \_s_c ;hevr_ m^b\ey_l
fg_gb_ B[g L_cfbb dhlhjuc hkf_ebeky aZy\blv h kms_kl\h
\Zgbbba\_qguokh[ulbcbba\_qguodZl_]hjbchlhfqlh:e
eZo ih^\_j`_g \ebygbx kh[ulbc Wlhl q_eh\_d \hkklZ_l ijh
lb\ ^h\h^h\ B[jZobfZ ]k ijb\_^_gguo \ DhjZg_ b ijhlb\
keh\ IjhjhdZ k]k ©;ue :eeZo b g_ [ueh gbq_]h \f_kl_ k
GbfªZdZdba\_klghB[gL_cfbyijbagZ_l^hklh\_jghklvoZ
^bkh\bah[hbok[hjgbdh\B\hh[s_dZdfh`_lkms_kl\h\Zlv
dZl_]hjbydhlhjhcg_l"Wlhijhlb\hj_qb_g_ijbagZxllhev
dhh[eZ^Zl_eb[hevgh]hjZkkm^dZª
LZdh\ufb [ueb b^_b B[g L_cfbb ^moh\gh]h hlpZ oZ
rZ\bafZDjhf_lh]hhg_s_aZy\eyehlhfqlhm:eeZoZ_klv
]jZgbpuhij_^_eye?fmf_klhh]jZgbq_ggh_LjhghfaZy\eye
J_qvb^_lh[B[gL_cfbb
Kihkh[ i_j_^Zqb dZdhc-eb[h bgnhjfZpbb ijb dhlhjhf \ dZ`^hf a\_g_
i_j_^Zlqbdh\ gZklhevdh [hevrh_ qbkeh ex^_c qlh g_ fh`_l \hagbdgmlv
ih^haj_gb_h[bok]h\hj_–ii
443
444
172
qlh=hkih^vkb^blgZLjhg_Kf©:e-FmZnZdZªb^jAZ
gbf ihke_^h\Ze _]h ij_^Zgguc mq_gbd B[g Ze-DZcbf baeh
`b\rbck\hbb^_b\©;Z^Ztb]Ze-nZ\Zb^ª–JZa\_hgb
g_ keurZeb keh\ :eeZoZ ©G_l gbq_]h ih^h[gh]h ?fm b Hg
keurZsbc\b^ysbcªbeb©Bg_[ue?fmjZ\_ggbh^bgª"Djh
f_ lh]h Ijhjhd k]k \ h^ghf ba oZ^bkh\ kdZaZe ©H :eeZo
Lui_j\ucbg_[uehgbq_]h^hL_[yLuy\gucbg_lgbq_]h
ij_\ur_L_[yLukdjulucbg_lgbq_]hgb`_L_[yª-ke_^h
\Zl_evgh m G_]h g_l ]jZgbp Gh lZdh\Z oZrZ\blkdZy Zdu^Z \h
\k_c__djZk_g_lkbeubfh]ms_kl\Zgbmdh]hdjhf_:eeZoZ
<k_\urg_]h<_ebdh]h
<u^mfZgguck[hjgbdkmggu
G_hoZjb^`blu qZklh kh\_lmxl ex^yf hagZdhfblvky k
dgb]hc©DblZ[Zk-kmggZªydh[uijbgZ^e_`Zs_ci_jm=Z[^me
eu [bg :ofZ^Z [bg OZg[ZeZ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky gZklhysbo mq_
guo-oZ^bkh\_^h\ lh hgb \hh[s_ hljbpZxl ijbgZ^e_`ghklv
mihfygmlh]hk[hjgbdZwlhfmq_eh\_dm<h-i_j\uoi_j_^Zlqbd
wlh]h k[hjgbdZ g_ ba\_kl_g Z \h-\lhjuo hg kh^_j`bl hq_gv
]gmkgu_ jb\Zylu \ hlghr_gbb :eeZoZ Ijb\_^_f g_dhlhju_
ijbf_ju
: GZ k kdZaZgh ©JZa\_ fh`_l [ulv \hag_k_gb_ Zebklb\Z q_f-eb[h ^jm]bf djhf_ kb^_gby"ª Ijb wlhf \ZooZ[b
luhkf_eb\Zxlkyml\_j`^Zlvqlhg_ijbibku\Zxl:eeZomgb
q_]h qlh Hg g_ khh[sbe h k_[_ =^_ `_ hgb gZreb Zljb[ml
©kb^_gb_ª"<dZdhfbaZylh\DhjZgZ"
;GZkkdZaZgh©Hg445\b^_e?]hkb^ysbfgZaheh
lhfLjhg_dhlhjuc^_j`Zebq_l\_jhZg]_eh\h^bgbadhlhjuo
[ue\h[jZa_fm`qbgu\lhjhc–\h[jZa_ev\Zlj_lbc–\h[jZ
a_[udZq_l\_jluc–\h[jZa_dhjrmgZ<k_hgb\a_e_ghfkZ^m
Zih^Gbfdh\_jkhldZggucbaahehlZª:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe
©<_ebdbc]j_owlhkeh\hijhbaghkbfh_bomklZfbª (18:5).
<GZkkdZaZgh©AZl_fHgijb^_ldgbfi_rdhfª
445
<hafh`ghbf__lky\\b^mIjhjhdk]k–ii
173
= GZ k kdZaZgh ©:eeZo k\h_c jmdhc gZibkZe Lhjm
^eyFmku]kFmkZ]k\wlh\j_fykb^_ehldbgm\rbkvgZ
kdZemba`_fqm`guo^hs_q_dHgkeurZekdjbii_jZBojZa
^_eyeZ lhevdh ij_]jZ^Zª LZdh_ hsms_gb_ qlh hgb ^hkeh\gh
i_j_gbfZxlk\hxZdu^mhlbm^__\
>GZkkdZaZgh©:eeZoijbdhkgmekyK\hbfbjmdZfb
lhevdhd:^Zfm]kK\hbfbjmdZfbHgkha^ZeJZcbgZibkZe
LhjmK\hbfbjmdZfbHgkdZlZe`_fqm`bgmihkZ^be\g__\_
lhqdmbkdZaZe©JZklbihdZYg_m^h\e_l\hjxkvb\u\h^b\k_
qlh\gmljbl_[yªBhgZ\u\_eZj_dbbieh^uª
?GZkkdZaZgh©Dh]^Z=hkih^vkZ^blkygZLjhglh
keur_gkdjbidZd[m^lh\kZ^gbdk_egZgh\hhk_^eZggmx\_j[
ex^bpmª
@ GZ k kdZaZgh ©Hg kZ^blky gZ Ljhg b hklZ\ey_l
jy^hfkKh[hcjZkklhygb_\q_luj_iZevpZª
AGZkkdZaZgh©:eeZo\l_gbh[eZdh\kimkdZ_lkyk
LjhgZd_]hhkgh\Zgbx«Hgijboh^bldgbf«B\hlHg^Z`_
ijhoh^bli_j_^gbfbª446.
BGZkkdZaZgh©HghldjueqZklvK_[yª
D GZ k kdZaZgh ©B \gmrbe Hg h^ghc ba ]hj qlh
`_eZ_l kimklblvky gZ g__ Z hgZ ijhy\beZ ^_jahklv < lh `_
\j_fy ]hjZ KbgZc ijhy\beZ k\hx kdjhfghklv b kdZaZeZ ©Dh
fg_ ijb^_l lh qlh ij_^ibkZghª lh]^Z :eeZo kdZaZe ©Y kim
smkv gZ l_[y ba [eZ]h^Zjghklb aZ l\hx kdjhfghklv b ^h\hev
kl\hij_^ibkZggufª
E GZ k kdZaZgh ©B gZqZe l\hc =hkih^v iml_r_kl
\h\ZlvihA_fe_ª
B[g Ze-DZcbf \ dgb]_ ©B^`lbfZ] Ze-^`mxr Ze-bkeZfbyª K ih^
j_^Zdpb_c=b\Z^ZZe-Fm]lbdZZ\ba^Zgbb©>ZjZe-dmlm[Ze-]befbyªgZK
ibr_l©MG_]hgZdZ`^hfg_[_k\hcljhgKimklb\rbkv\g_[_kZwlh]h
fbjZHgkZ^blkygZljhg«Dh]^Z`_gZklmiZ_lmljhhg\haghkblkybkZ^blky
gZK\hcljhgªI_j_^wlbfhlju\dhfj_qvb^_lh\u^mfZgghfaZklmigbq_
kl\_©Yijb^mdfh_fm=hkih^mbm\b`mqlhHgkb^blgZk\h_fljhg_beb
eh`_ª B[g Ze-DZcbf g_ h]jZgbqbeky bkdZ`_gb_f fmkmevfZgkdhc Zdu^u
ghij_^eh`begh\mxbg^mbklkdmx\qZklghklbhgibr_l©IhqblZcl_dh
jh\ªBihke_wlh]h\ZooZ[bluhkf_eb\Zxlkyml\_j`^Zlvqlhg_y\eyxlky
fm^`ZkkbfblZfb
446
174
F GZ k kdZaZgh ©: \lhjZy ?]h jmdZ imklZ \ g_c
g_lgbq_]hª
GGZkkdZaZgh©Bihljh]Zehg_]hª
H GZ k kdZaZgh ©B Hg deZ^_l h^gm gZ ^jm]mx«b
ijbdZkZ_lkydK\h_cklmig_ª
IGZkkdZaZgh©M:^Zk_fvfhklh\gZ^dhlhjufb
gZoh^blkyKujZl:eeZogZq_l\_jlhffhkl_Dh]^ZjZ[u[m^ml
ijhoh^blv jy^hf k Gbf Hg [m^_l gZoh^blvky gZ q_l\_jlhf
fhklmª
<a]eygbl_ ^hjh]b_ qblZl_eb gZ wlm de_\_lm JZg__ \u
hagZdhfbebkv k de_\_lhc baeh`_gghc \ dgb]_ Z^->Zjbfb l_
i_jv`_\uhagZdhfbebkvkkh^_j`Zgb_fk[hjgbdZijbibku\Z
_fh]h=Z[^mee_[bg:ofZ^m[bgOZg[ZemJZa\_wlhg_de_\_lZ
\Z^j_k\k_cfmkmevfZgkdhcmffub\Z^j_k__mq_guo"
DZd \b^bl_ \ZooZ[blu ihevamxlky dgb]Zfb k\hbo gZ
klZ\gbdh\–dZaby:[mY]ebB[gL_cfbbZe-OZjjZgb_]hmq_
gbdZ B[g Ze-DZcbfZ b ^jm]bo Z\lhjh\ ?keb \u aZf_lbeb lh
m[_`^_gbywlboex^_clhqgh_ih\lhj_gb_bm^_ckdhc447Zdu^u
ihwlhfm fu ijhkbf m :eeZo ijhs_gby ^Z`_ aZ lh qlh gZf
ijboh^blkyijb\h^blvbagbopblZlu
;hevr_ \k_]h m^b\ey_l lh qlh \ZooZ[blZf m^Zehkv jZk
ijhkljZgblv k\hb b^_b kj_^b g_dhlhjuo fmkmevfZgkdbo ^\b
`_gbc Y ^mfZx ijbqbgZ wlh]h djh_lky \ lhf qlh wlb ex^b
kebrdhfkf_ehhi_jbjmxloZ^bkZfbbodhff_glZjbyfbb^h
klh\_jghklvxFu`_\Zfij_^hklZ\beb\hafh`ghklvm[_^blv
ky\lhfgZkdhevdhbkihjq_gghcy\ey_lkyZdu^Zwlboex^_c
OZrZ\blublZoZ\blkdZyZdu^Z
L_dkllZ\ob^ZgZibkZggucbfZfhf:[m>`Z]nZjhfZlLZoZ\bZe-OZgZnb[uegZklhevdhZ\lhjbl_lgufbijbagZgguf
\ kj_^_ fZaoZ[h\ qlh h^bggZ^pZlv oZgZnblkdbo mq_guo gZib
kZeb d g_fm dhff_glZjbb G_ hklZ\beb __ [_a \gbfZgby b oZ
rZ\blu < qZklghklb =Zeb [bg =Zeb [bg FmoZffZ^ [bg Fm
447
Badgb]r_coZKZ]b^ZZe-DZgm[b
175
oZffZ^448[bgKZebo[bg:[mZe-=baam\b^_\bgl_j_kfmkmev
fZgdwlhcdgb]_gZqZebkdZ`Zlv__l_dkldhff_glbjh\Zlv__
kh]eZkghk\hbfoZrZ\blkdbfm[_`^_gbyfb\g_k\g__we_f_g
lu lZ^`kbfZ Hg ijbdju\Zeky ehamg]Zfb \ha\jZs_gby d imlb
kZeZnh\ gh ih kmlb ^_eZ ebrv pblbjh\Ze dgb]b B[g L_cfbb
©FbgoZ^` Zk-kmggZª b ©Ze-FmZnZdZª ?]h baeh`_gb_ y\gh
ijhlb\hj_qbl hkgh\Zf DhjZgZ kmggu _^bgh]eZkghfm fg_gbx
fmkmevfZgkdbomq_guobb^_yfbfZfZZl-LZoZ\bKh\j_f_ggu_
fm^`ZkkbfblulZd`_g_h[hreb__klhjhghc\qZklghklbr_co
Ze-:e[Zgb ydh[u ijh\_jbe oZ^bku b mlhqgbe l_dkl dgb]b b
\g_kg_dhlhju_jZatykg_gbyIhke_q_]hh^bgba_]hmq_gbdh\
AZobj Zr-RZ\br449 g_kdhevdh jZa i_j_ba^Ze wlm dgb]m Fm^
`Zkkbfblu [_kieZlgh jZa^Z\Zeb wlb dgb]b ihke_^h\Zl_eyf
jZaebqguo fZaoZ[h\ \ gZ^_`^_ \u^Zlv __ aZ ©h[gh\e_ggmx
kmggblkdmxZdu^mªQlh`_gZibkZgh\wlhfdhff_glZjbb"
<h-i_j\uoeh`gZyZdu^Z
:\lhj wlh]h dhff_glZjby B[g :[m Ze-=baa gZ k ibr_l©<hagbdZ_l\hijhkfh`_lebkms_kl\h\Zgb_dZl_]hjbc
[ulv\_qguf\hlghr_gbbijhreh]hb[m^ms_]h"Beb`_hgb
\_qgu lhevdh \ [m^ms_f" : fh`_l lhevdh \ ijhrehf" Fm
kmevfZgZf ba\_klgh ljb hl\_lZ gZ wlhl \hijhk GZb[he__ keZ
[ufy\ey_lkyfg_gb_hlhfqlhdZl_]hjbbg_fh]ml[ulv\_q
gufbgb\ijhrehfgb\[m^ms_fLZdh]hfg_gbyijb^_j`b
\Zebkv>`Zof[bgKZn\Zgb:[mZe-OmaZceZe-=Zeeyn<lhjh_
fg_gb_]eZkblqlhdZl_]hjbbfh]ml[ulv\_qgufblhevdh\[m
^ms_fbg_fh]ml–\ijhrehfLZdh]hfg_gbyijb^_j`b\Zxl
ky [hevrbgkl\h fmlZdZeebfh\ bg_dhlhju_baihke_^h\Zl_e_c
ba qbkeZ nZdboh\ Lj_lv_ fg_gb_ ]eZkbl qlh hgb fh]ml [ulv
\_qgufb b \ ijhrehf b \ [m^ms_f dZd h[ wlhf aZy\eyxl
bfZfu-oZ^bkh\_^uª Ihkfhljbl_ dZd eh\dh oZrZ\blu ijbib
ku\Zxl m[_`^_gby g_\_jguo bfZfZf-oZ^bkh\_^Zf B[g :[m
Ze-=baaaZy\ey_lqlhydh[ubfZfu-oZ^bkh\_^uijbagZ\Zebba
Wlhg_hrb[dZ\_]hbf_gb^_ckl\bl_evgh_klvih\lhj_gbyMf\]
]
449
Ijb gZibkZgbb gZr_]h ljm^Z fu bkihevah\Zeb \hkvfh_ ba^Zgb_ wlhc
dgb]b
448
176
\_qghklv dZl_]hjbc b kh[ulbc dhlhju_ y\eyxlky kha^Zgbyfb
gZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ bfZfu-oZ^bkh\_^u klhjhgbebkv ih^h[guo
b^_c Fgh]b_ Zylu DhjZgZ hl\_j]Zxl ih^h[gu_ m[_`^_gby
gZijbf_j :eeZo kdZaZe h k_[_ ©Hg i_j\ucª Wlh `_ ih^
l\_j`^ZxlboZ^bkuIjhjhdZk]kgZijbf_j©;ue:eeZob
g_[uehgbq_]hdjhf_G_]hª
Ijbibku\Zgb_ :eeZom ]hehkZ a\mdh\ b [md\ GZ k
hg ibr_l ©Hg ]h\hjbl ]hehkhf dhlhjuc fh`gh mkeu
rZlvª B[g L_cfby jZatykgyy mdZaZe qlh wlhl ]hehk ih^h[_g
]jhfm ©FmZnZdl kZjbo Ze-fZ]dmeª ba^ZgZ \ \b^_ km[
dhff_glZjbyd©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZª
Hgibr_lhlhfqlh:eeZoydh[uih^\_j`_g\ebygbx
kh[ulbc oh^bl b ijb\_lkl\m_l ex^_c Kf k ©?keb dlheb[h gZf kdZ`_l qlh wlh k\b^_l_evkl\m_l h \ebygbb kh[ulbc
gZ:eeZoZlhfuhl\_lbfqlhwlhb_klvkmlvgZrbokeh\Dlh
ba bfZfh\ kdZaZe qlh kh[ulby gZ G_]h g_ \ebyxl"ª K\hc \u
\h^ hg ih^l\_j`^Z_l oZ^bkhf dhlhjuc fu [m^_f ZgZebabjh
\Zlvgb`_\wlhfoZ^bk_kdZaZgh©Dh]^Zh[blZl_ebJZy[m^ml
gZoh^blvky\JZxlh\g_aZighihy\blkyk\_lª
Hgijbibku\Z_l:eeZom]jZgbpuKfk©Ih\h
ijhkm ]jZgbp \hh[s_ g_ fh`_l [ulv gbdZdh]h kihjZ \_^v hl
jbpZxsbc]jZgbpuhljbpZ_lkms_kl\h\Zgb_kZfh]h=hkih^Zª
Wlhm`_y\gh_aZ[em`^_gb_hghy\ey_lkyieh^hf_]h[hevgh]h
jZamfZhghibku\Z_l:eeZoZhkgh\u\ZykvgZk\hboagZgbyoh
fZl_jbZevguo l_eZo B[g OZ^`Zj \ ©EbkZg Ze-fbaZgª hijh\_j]Z_lwlhfg_gb_keh\Zfb©HljbpZgb_]jZgbpgb\dh_f
kemqZ_g_y\ey_lkyhljbpZgb_fkms_kl\h\Zgby=hkih^ZªBfZf
:[m FZgkmj Ze-;Z]^Z^b ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:eNmjmdªibr_l©Kmggblu\hlebqb_hlobrZfblh\dZj
jZfblh\ b fm^`Zkkbfblh\ _^bgh]eZkgh hljbpZxl gZebqb_dZ
dbo-eb[h ]jZgbp m Kha^Zl_ey wlh]h fbjZª Ba\_klgh qlh B[g
L_cfby h[\bgye \ g_\_jbb l_o dlh hljbpZe kms_kl\h\Zgb_
]jZgbp:eeZoZ\©:e-FmZnZdZªhgibr_l©<k_\ur_
i_j_qbke_ggh_mdZau\Z_lgZgZebqb_]jZgbpZdlhg_ijbagZ_l
wlh]h – y\ey_lky g_\_jguf \ hlghr_gbb lh]h qlh gbkihkeZe
:eeZoª < blh]_ \k_ fmkmevfZg_ b mq_gbd B[g L_cfbb bfZf
177
Za-AZoZ[b y\eyxlky g_\_jgufb BfZf Za-AZoZ[b kZf \ ©FbaZg
Ze-b]lb^Zeª ibr_l ©<hijhk h ]jZgbpZo y\ey_lky imk
lhc [helh\g_cª Z \ ©Kbyj Z]eyf Zg-gm[Zeyª hg mdZau
\Z_l ©:eeZo ij_\ur_ \kydbo ]jZgbp Hg ij_\ur_ \k_]h qlh
_fm ijbibku\Zxl ^h[Z\eyy d kdZaZgghfm \ k\ys_gguo l_dk
lZoǻ
B[g :[m Ze-=baa ijbibku\Z_l :eeZom k\yav k ijhkl
jZgkl\hfbf_klhfKfk©Dh]^Zfu]h\hjbfhijhkljZg
kl\_bgZijZ\e_gbblhij_`^_\k_]hbf__f\\b^mkms_kl\mx
s__ Z dZd ba\_klgh hgh fh`_l [ulv eb[h kha^Zl_e_f eb[h
kha^Zgb_fª Lhqgh d lZdbf `_ f_lh^Zf ijb[_]Z_l B[g ZeDZcbfdh]^Z`_eZ_l^hdZaZlvqlh:^g_\_q_gIhkfhljbl_gZ
keh\Z B[g :[m Ze-=baaZ dZd mf_eh hg ijbjZ\gye kha^Zl_ey d
kha^Zgbyfg_lkhfg_gby\lhfqlhwlhih^oh^yauqgbdh\>Z
e__gZwlhc`_kljZgbp_B[g:[mZe-=baaibr_l©?kebfuih^
ijhkljZgkl\hf bf__f \ \b^m lh g_kms_kl\mxs__ f_klh dhlh
jh_ gZoh^blky gZ^ fbjhf lh lZf kms_kl\m_l lhevdh :eeZo B
wlhy\ey_lky\_jgufml\_j`^_gb_fªDZd\b^bl_hghij_^_ebe
:eeZom f_klh gZ^ fbjhf b gZa\Ze _]h g_kms_kl\mxsbf f_k
lhfIhke_wlh]hg_lgbq_]hm^b\bl_evgh]h\lhfqlhhgbke_
^my©OZ^bkmhjZ[ug_ªluqmliZevp_f\g_[hLhevdh\hlhk
lZ_lky\hijhkdZd`_wlhf_klhfh`_l[ulvg_kms_kl\mxsbf"
JZa\_ fh`gh mdZaZlv gZ g_kms_kl\mxs__" ?s_ [hevr_ m^b\
eyxl keh\Z B[g :[m Ze-=baaZ gZ k ©Ihbklbg_ ijhkljZg
kl\h[_a]jZgbqghªJZa\_g_m^b\bl_evghqlhwlhlq_eh\_dh]
jZgbqb\Z_l:eeZoZij_^_eZfbZh[h^ghfba?]hkha^Zgbc]h
\hjblqlhmg_]hg_l]jZgbp"
>Ze__hgaZy\ey_lh[ebahklb:eeZoZdg_dhlhjufqZ
klyf fbjZ Kf k ©G_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \ lhf qlh
:eeZo fh`_l [ulv [ebahd d g_dhlhjuf qZklyf fbjZ ^Z`_ g_
kfhljygZlhqlhHggZLjhg_\ur_g_[_kJZa\_Hgg_fh`_l
ijb[ebablvdk_[_dZdh_-eb[hbaK\hbokha^Zgbc"DlhhljbpZ_l
wlhlhlmfZey_l?]h\hafh`ghklbª
178
HgaZy\ey_lhlhfqlh:eeZodZ`^mxghqvkimkdZ_lky
\ g_[_kZ wlh]h fbjZ450 Kf k ©>\_gZ^pZlh_ _`_ghsgh_
gbkoh`^_gb_\g_[_kZfbjZEx[hcgZjh^fbjZ^himkdZ_lqlh
fh`gh kimkdZlvky k\_jom \gba LjbgZ^pZlh_ mdZaZgb_ gZ nb
abq_kdh_ f_klh \\_jom DZd wlh k^_eZe lhl dlh451 emqr_ agZ_l
k\h_]h =hkih^Zª Qlh `_ hg kdZ`_l h[ ZylZo ©?keb Fhb jZ[u
kijhkyll_[yh[hFg_lhY[ebahdª, ©:Fu[eb`_dg_fmq_f
\u gh \u wlh]h g_ \b^bl_ª, ©Hg k \Zfb ]^_ [u \u gb [uebª,
©Hg\g_[_kZobgZa_fe_HgagZ_l\Zr_lZcgh_by\gh_bagZ
_l qlh \u ijbh[j_lZ_l_ª, ©Fu [he__ [ebadb d g_fm q_f
yj_fgZy \_gZª : qlh hg kdZ`_l h oZ^bkZo IjhjhdZ k]k
©GZb[he__[ebahdjZ[dk\h_fm=hkih^m\h\j_fya_fgh]hih
dehgZª Fmkebf ©H :eeZo Lu fhc ihimlqbd \ imlb b fhc
gZf_klgbd ^hfZª Zl-Lbjfbab oZ^bk oZkZg-kZobo BfZf FZ
ebddhff_glbjmyoZ^bkhgbkoh`^_gbbkdZaZeqlhj_qvb^_lh
[h`_kl\_gghf \_e_gbb ©Gbkoh^bl \_e_gb_ gZr_]h =hkih^Z
HgkZfihklhyg_gbg_bkq_aZ_lª452.
<h-\lhjuo de_\_lZ \ Z^j_k bfZfZ Zl-LZoZ\b B[g :[m
Ze-=baaijbibku\Z_l_fmeh`gmxZdu^mKfk©Fg_gb_h
lhf qlh m kh[ulbc _klv gZqZeh \_^_l d hljbpZgbx lh]h qlh
:eeZo \gZqZe_ gbq_]h g_ ^_eZe Z aZl_f ijbklmibe d ^_ckl
\bxª WlZ q_imoZ ijhlb\hj_qbl DhjZgm ©Hg i_j\ucª – b oZ
^bkZfIjhjhdZk]k©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]h\f_kl_k
Gbfª©;ue:eeZobg_[uehgbq_]hdjhf_G_]hª
?keb[uB[g:[mZe-=baaohlvg_fgh]hkl_kgyekylhg_
gZibkZe[u\k_]hwlh]h\lhcdgb]_\dhlhjhcbfZfZl-LZoZ\b
gZ k aZy\be ©:eeZo ij_\ur_ ]jZgbp p_e_c mkeh\bc hj
]Zgh\ bgkljmf_glh\ Hg g_ h]jZgbq_g gb h^gbf ba r_klb gZ
ijZ\e_gbcijhkljZgkl\ZªG_m`_ebZe-:e[ZgbbZr-RZ\brg_
ihkl_kgyebkvihklZ\blvk\hbih^ibkbih^wlbfihahjhf"
DZd ba\_klgh \ ex[hc fhf_gl \j_f_gb gZ h^ghc iheh\bg_ a_feb ghqv
ihwlhfm\hagbdZ_l\hijhkgZl_jjblhjbxdZdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\ZHgkimkdZ_l
ky"
451
<_jhylghbf__lky\\b^mIjhjhdk]k–ii
452
Kf B[g =Z[^me[Zjj ©Zl-LZfob^ª – oZnba Za-AZoZ[b ©Kbyj Z]
eyfZg-gm[Zeyª– 8/105.
450
179
<-lj_lvboqlh[u^hdZaZlvk\hbm[_`^_gbywlhlq_eh\_d
bkihevam_l\u^mfZggu_oZ^bku453GZijbf_jhgijb\_eoZ^bk
©Dh]^Zh[blZl_ebJZy[m^mlgZoh^blvky\JZxlh\g_aZighih
y\blky k\_l Hgb ih^gbfml k\hb \ahju b m\b^yl qlh wlh bo
=hkih^v ijbr_e bo gZ\_klblv k\_jom B hg kdZ`_l bf ³Fbj
\Zf«´ª < p_ihqd_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ wlh]h oZ^bkZ ijbkmlkl\m_l
:[m =Zkuf Ze-=Z[[Z^Zgb ihegh_ bfy dhlhjh]h =Z[^meeZ [bg
=m[Zc^meeZ:a-AZoZ[b\©Ze-FbaZg«ªihih\h^m
wlh]h q_eh\_dZ kdZaZe ©KeZ[ucª :e-OZnba B[g OZ^`Zj \
©EbkZg Ze-fbaZgª kdZaZe ©:e-=Zdbeb i_j_^Z_l hl g_]h
oZ^bk dhlhjuc \hkoh^bl d Ze-NZ^em Zj-JZdZrb d ;bg ZeFmgdZ^bjm d >`Z[bjm \ wlhf oZ^bk_ kdZaZgh ©Dh]^Z h[blZ
l_eb JZy [m^ml gZoh^blky \ JZx lh \g_aZigh ihy\blky k\_lª
wlhloZ^bkgbdlhdjhf_g_]hg_i_j_^ZeªKf©:^->m]ZnZZedZ[bjª ih^ Z\lhjkl\hf Ze-=Zdbeb Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ZeNZ^eZZj-JZdZrbh^gh]hbai_j_^Zlqbdh\wlh]hoZ^bkZlhba
\_klgh qlh _]h oZ^bku h[uqgh hl\_j]Zebkv :e-OZnba \ ©ZlLZdjb[ª ih^ ghf_jhf b B[g =Z^b \ ©Ze-DZfbe nb Z^^m]ZnZª ibrml ©Ze-;moZjb i_j_^Ze hl B[g =mycgu
qlhwlhlq_eh\_dg_^hklhbglh]hqlh[ui_j_^Z\ZlvoZ^bkuª454.
Ihkfhljbl_ dZd wlb oZrZ\blu qlh[u ^hdZaZlv bklbgghklv
k\hbom[_`^_gbcijb[_]Zxldihfhsb\u^mfZgguooZ^bkh\
LZdh\B[g:[mZe-=baablZdh\um[_`^_gbygZdhlhjuo
kljhblky \ZooZ[baf jZkijhkljZgyxsbc wlb m[_`^_gby kj_^b
ex^_cIhke_\k_]hwlh]hg_m^b\bl_evghqlh=ZebZe-DZjbZeOZgZnb\dhff_glZjbbd©:e-NbdoZe-Zd[ZjªkkdZaZeh[
wlhf q_eh\_d_ ©Hg ke_^h\Ze eh`guf iml_f b bkihevah\Ze
jhkkdZagbfm[lZ^b]h\ª
<ZooZ[bluihjmqbebr_comRm]Zc[mZe-:jgZmlm^hdlhjm=Z[^mee_ZlLmjdb ^hdlhjm =Zeb NZdbob ^hdlhjm :ofZ^m Ze-=Zfb^b b KZebom [bg
=Z[^jZofZgmkdjulvwlhlihahjihwlhfmhgbm^Zebebbawlhcdgb]b\u^m
fZggu_ oZ^bku b \uimklbeb ih^ gh\uf gZau\Zgb_f ©FmoZaaZ[ rZjo ZeZdu^ZZl-lZoZ\byª–>ZjB[gJZ^`Z[F_^bgZ]]
454
OZkZgZk-KZddZn©Zl-LZg^b^[bfZg]Z^Z^ZZl-lZ\ob^ª–K
453
180
G_dhlhju_jZah[eZq_gbydgb]b©:l-LZ\ob^ª
©?^bgh[h`b_ªijbgZ^e_`Zs_ci_jmFmoZffZ^Z
[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
R_co Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ Zg-GZ^`^b ibkZe h
lhfqlh_]h[jZlFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[g_lhevdhg_^h
klb] kl_i_gb b^`lboZ^Z gh ^Z`_ ^_kylhc qZklb wlhc kl_i_gb
Qlh[u ^hdZaZlv bklbgghklv _]h keh\ fuohlbfijhZgZebabjh
\Zlvh^gmbadgb]B[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z©DblZ[Zl-lZ\ob^Zeeyab
omZoZddmeeZob]ZeyZe-]Z[b^ª\_^vkeh\Zq_eh\_dZ\k_]^Zk\b
^_l_evkl\mxl h[ mjh\g_ _]h jZa\blby OZrZ\blu d wlhc dgb]_
hlghkylkykhkh[ufihql_gb_fjZa^Zxl__[_kieZlgh?keb`_
\u hagZdhfbl_kv k g_c lh g_ h[gZjm`bl_ gbq_]h gh\h]h qlh
hijZ\^u\Zeh[ulZdh_\gbfZgb_dg_c;m^mqbdgb]hcihZdu
^_dZdk\b^_l_evkl\m_lh[wlhfgZa\Zgb_hgZ^he`gZ[ueZkh
^_j`Zlv kZfu_ ^hklh\_jgu_ k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu gZ kZfhf `_
^_e_ \ g_c ijbkmlkl\mxl g_ lhevdh keZ[u_ gh ^Z`_ \u^mfZg
gu_oZ^bku;he__lh]hr_cobgh]^Z^h[Z\ey_ldwlbfoZ^bkZf
k\hbkeh\ZZdh]^Z^Z_lkkuedmlhaZqZklmxhgZg_\_jgZyGZ
ijbf_j\]eZ\_©Dh]^Z`_Hg^Zjh\Zebfh[hbf[eZ]hq_klb\h
]hkugZhgbklZebijbagZ\ZlvgZjy^mkGbf_s_bkhmqZklgb
dh\ª hg dhff_glbjmy Zyl ijb\h^bl bklhjbx ^bkdj_^blbjm
xsmxgZr_]hijZhlpZijhjhdZ:^ZfZ]kb_]h`_gmOZ\\m
< bklhjbb jZkkdZau\Z_lky h lhf qlh hgb h[Z ydh[u \iZeb \
yauq_kl\hWlmbklhjbxi_j_^Z_lB[g:[mOZlbfhlB[g=Z[
[ZkZ hgZ hq_gv ba\_klgZ Z h __ eh`ghklb agZ_l ^Z`_ kZfuc
keZ[ucklm^_glg_`_eZxsbcmqblvkyKh]eZkghwlhcbklhjbb
dh]^ZOZ\\ZaZ[_j_f_g_eZdg_cb:^Zfm]kijbr_eB[ebkb
kdZaZe ©Y \Zr ^jm] dhlhjuc klZe ijbqbghc \Zr_]h ba]gZgby
baJZy?kebyaZohqmlhj_[_ghdjh^blkykjh]ZfbbjZahj\_l
l\hc `b\hl ?keb y aZohqm lh k^_eZx k j_[_gdhf qlh aZohqm
GZah\bl_ _]h =Z[^meoZjbk455ª Hgb hldZaZebkv b j_[_ghd jh
^bekyf_jl\ufOZ\\ZaZ[_j_f_g_eZ\gh\vb\gh\vijbr_ekZ
lZgZb\gh\vhgbhldZaZeb_fmb\gh\vj_[_ghdjh^bekyf_jl
\ufDh]^Z`_hgZaZ[_j_f_g_eZ\lj_lbcjZabijbr_ekZlZgZ
455
:e-OZjbk–h^ghbabf_gkZlZgukfukeihemqZ_lkyjZ[kZlZgu–ii
181
lh hgb ^Zeb kh]eZkb_ b ^_ckl\bl_evgh gZa\Zeb j_[_gdZ =Z[
^meoZjbkhf Ihwlhfm-lh :eeZo b kdZaZe \ DhjZg_ ©Dh]^Z `_
Hg^Zjh\Zebfh[hbf[eZ]hq_klb\h]hkugZhgbklZebijbagZ
\ZlvgZjy^mkGbf_s_bkhmqZklgbdh\ª (7:190).
KZfuc ykguc q_ldbc hl\_l ih wlhfm ih\h^m fu fh`_f
gZclb m l_o mq_guo dhlhjuo \ZooZ[blu ihqblZxl B[g DZkbj
ih ih\h^m wlhc bklhjbb \ k\h_f agZf_gblhf lZnkbj_ ibr_l©WlZbklhjbyijbreZdgZfhlex^_cibkZgbyª456B[g
OZaf \ dgb]_ ©:e-NbkZe nb Ze-fbeZe \Z Ze-Zo\Z \Z Zg-gboZeª
ibr_l ©G_dhlhju_ kkueZxlky gZ jb\Zyl kh]eZkgh dhlhjhfm
:^Zf]kgZa\Zek\h_]hkugZ=Z[^meoZjbkgZkZfhf^_e_wlb
jb\Zylu \u^mfZggu_ b eh`gu_« P_ihqdZ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ wlbo
jb\Zylh\g_^hklh\_jgZgZkZfhf^_e_wlhlZyljZkkdZau\Z_lh
yauqgbdZoª
GZf ba\_klgh qlh FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ [ue
ls_keZ\gufq_eh\_dhfkqblZ\rbfk_[y\_ebdbfmq_gufBk
lhdb wlh]h ls_keZ\by dhg_qgh `_ \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v bkoh^yl
hlg_]hkZfh]hghiha^g__hgh[uehih^^_j`Zgh_]h^jmavyfb
\hklhdh\_^Zfbdhlhju_ij_\jZlbeb_]h\dhiv_^eymkfbj_gby
BkeZfZ Kh]eZkgh bo ieZgZf \ZooZ[baf ^he`_g [ue hl\e_qv
fmkmevfZghl^`boZ^Zijhlb\bm^__\bojbklbZgbaZ`_qv\bo
kj_^_f_`^hmkh[gmx\hcgmk\hh[jZ`Z_fufrbjdhfbihdeh
M^b\ey_llhqlh\ZooZ[bluyjhklghaZsbsZxlk\h_]h^_^ZIhke_lh]h
dZdr_co=Z[^jZofZg[bgOZkZgbajh^ZB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[ZhagZdhfbekyk
mihfygmlufbkeh\ZfbB[gDZkbjZlh\k\h_cdgb]_©NZloZe-fZ^`b^rZjo
dblZ[ Zl-lZ\ob^ª gZibkZe ©Wlh]h g_ fh`_l [ulvª - b \k_ Hg k
jZ^hklvxh[\bgblijhjhdh\\yauq_kl\_gh^hihke_^g_]h[m^_laZsbsZlv
k\h_]h ^_^Z Ihwlhfm agZcl_ qlh jb\Zyl hl Ze-OZkZgZ ijb\_^_gguc m ZlLbjfbab :ofZ^Z Ze-OZdbfZ Zl-LZ[Zjb Z^>ZceZfb y\ey_lky keZ[uf :a-AZoZ[b hl\_j]_]h\k\h_cdgb]_©ZeFbaZg«ª:e-OZkZgijbkmlkl\mxsbc\p_ihqd_i_j_^Zlqbdh\wlhloZ^bkZ
[ueh[fZgsbdhfbkZf\u^mfZewlmp_ihqdmGZkZfhf^_e_hghlDZlZ^u
keurZelhevdhjb\ZylZe-=ZdbdZKj_^bdhff_glZjb_\dwlhfmZylm_klvb
^jm]b_jb\Zylui_j_^Zggu_Ze-OZkZghfhl=mfZjZ[bgB[jZobfZZe-;Zkjb
B[g=Z^bh[wlhfq_eh\_d_kdZaZe©Hgi_j_^Z\ZehlDZlZ^ulhqlhlhlg_
]h\hjbeª:[mOZlbfhg_fkdZaZe©?]hoZ^bkug_fh]ml[ulv^h\h^hfªZ
:ofZ^kdZaZe©Mg_]hfgh`_kl\hhl\_j]gmluooZ^bkh\ª
456
182
g_gb_ffh]beZf:\_^vIjhjhdk]k\h^ghfbak\hbooZ^b
kh\ykghkdZaZeqlhkZlZgZm`_ihl_jyegZ^_`^mgZlhqlhfm
kmevfZg_ \_jgmlky \ g_\_`_kl\h yauq_kl\h b gZqgml _fm ih
dehgylvkyQlh`_dZkZ_lkyijhjhdh\lhgbdlhbafmkmevfZgg_
bf__lijZ\Zih^haj_\Zlvbo\aZ[em`^_gbb^h\h^ys_f^hyau
q_kl\Z Ih ih\h^m bklhjbb h[ :^Zf_ ]k mihfygmlhc \ur_
bfZf Ze-Dmjlm[b \ k\h_f lZnkbj_ kdZaZe ©FmkmevfZgbg kh
a^hjh\uf k_j^p_f ^mrhc – ii gb aZ qlh g_ ih\_jbl \ wlm
bklhjbxª457 Fg_ dZ`_lky qlh B[g =Z[^me\ZooZ[ g_ gZr_e
\j_f_gb qlh[u ijhq_klv wlb kljhdb >Z b \hh[s_ dZd fh`gh
[ueh gZau\Zlv ©Dgb]hc lZ\ob^Zª dgb]m kh^_j`Zsmx lZdb_
]jm[_crb_hrb[db"B\gh\vih\lhjyykvyohqmkdZaZlv©Bk
lhjby h ijhjhd_ :^Zf_ ]k mihfygmlZy \ur_ y\ey_lky
\u^mfdhcbkm_\_jghceh`vxª
G_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \ lhf qlh q_eh\_d kihkh[
guch[he]Zlvbhihjhqblvijhjhdh\kihkh[_gihklmiblvlhqgh
lZd `_ b \ hlghr_gbb fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo LZdbf h[jZahf
hgihklmibe\hlghr_gbbr_coZZe-;mkZcjbdhlhjuc\klboh
l\hj_gbb h Ijhjhd_ k]k kdZaZe ©H ]hkih^bg kha^Zgbc h
lhlddhlhjhfmy[m^m\au\Zlvhihfhsb\lhl^_gvdh]^ZgZ
klZg_l\k_h[sZy[_^Zª?keb[uFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[
[ue[unZdbohfZg_b^_heh]hfg_hoZjb^`bafZlh_fm[ueh
[u ba\_klgh qlh \h fgh]bo oZ^bkZo khh[sZ_lky h lhf dZd \
km^guc ^_gv ex^b [m^ml bkdZlv ih^^_j`db m ijhjhdh\ Z l_
[m^mlgZijZ\eylvbodFmoZffZ^mk]kHgb\k_\f_kl_kdZ
`ml_fm©Ijhkbm:eeZoZaZklmigbq_kl\Zbhgh[m^_ll_[_^Z
jh\ZghijhkbmG_]hbHgl_[_hl\_lblªWlhloZ^bki_j_^Z_l
[hevrbgkl\hoZ^bkh\_^h\hljZaebqguokih^\b`gbdh\Ijhjh
dZ k]k JZa\_ fh`gh ihke_ wlh]h gZau\Zlv yauqgbdhf Ze;mkZcjbkdZaZ\r_]hlhevdhlhqlhkh^_j`blky\oZ^bkZoIjh
jhdZk]k"Wlheh`vg_^himklbfhqlh[u\dgb]_ihZdu
^_fmkmevfZgkdbomq_guoh[\bgyeb\yauq_kl\_
:e-Dmjlm[b©:e->`Zfb]ebZodZfZe-DmjtZgª–kmjZ©:e-:]jZnªZyl
190.
457
183
< ]eZ\_ ©Hgb g_ \ha^Zeb :eeZom ^he`guf h[jZahfª
FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ ijb\h^bl oZ^bk hl :[m
AZjjZ©Ih^gh`b_LjhgZihkjZ\g_gbxkkZfbfLjhghfih^h[
gh `_e_aghfm dhevpm [jhr_gghfm \ imklug_ gZ A_fe_ª Ih
ke_^gb_keh\Z©gZA_fe_ªy\eyxlky^h[Z\e_gb_fkZfh]hr_coZ
\_^vhghq_gvex[bl^h[Z\eylvdjb\ZylZfhlk_[y
:l-LZ[Zjb ijb\h^bl wlhl oZ^bk ih^ ghf_jhf hl
B[g AZc^Z dhlhjuc kqblZ_lky keZ[uf i_j_^Zlqbdhf :e;ZcoZdb ijb\h^bl _]h \ ©:k-KunZlª gZ k Z :[m GZ]bf \
©:e-Omebyª \ p_ihqd_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ bo jb\ZylZ ijb
kmlkl\m_lYoty[bgKZ]b^Ze-DmjZrbZk-KZ]^bhdhlhjhfB[g
OZ[[Zg\©:e-FZ^`jmobgªibr_l©Hgi_j_^Z_lbkdZ
`_ggu_oZ^bkuhlB[g>`ZjboZZ_]hjb\Zyluhl^hklh\_jguo
ex^_c kh^_j`Zl hrb[db ihwlhfm _]h jb\Zylu g_evay ijbgb
fZlv \ dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Zª :e-=Zdbeb ih ih\h^m wlh]h oZ^bkZ
kdZaZe©G_ke_^mcl_aZgbfªkf©Ze-FbaZgª
Qlh[u hijh\_j]gmlv wlhl jb\Zyl ^hklZlhqgh hlf_lblv
qlh \ qbke_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ ijbkmlkl\m_l h[fZgsbd B[jZobf
[bg ObrZf [bg Yoty Ze-=ZkkZgb h dhlhjhf hq_gv ih^jh[gh
jZkkdZau\Z_l B[g :[m OZlbf Z \ dhgp_ ^h[Z\ey_l ©« hg
e`_pª =Zeb [bg Ze-Omk_cg [bg Ze->`mgZc^ ih ih\h^m wlh]h
kdZaZe ©:[m OZlbf ijZ\ g_ ke_^m_l i_j_^Z\Zlv oZ^bku wlh]h
q_eh\_dZª :[m AZj]Z kdZaZe ©Hg e`_pª :a-AZoZ[b kdZaZe
©OZ^bku wlh]h B[jZobfZ hl\_j]Zxlkyª kf ©EbkZg Ze-fbaZgª
Za-AZoZ[b ghf_j ©:e->`Zjo \Z Zl-lZ]^beª ghf_jBf_gghihwlhfmr_coRm]Zc[Ze-:jgZml[ue\u
gm`^_g ijbagZlv ©P_ihqdZ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ wlh]h oZ^bkZ hq_gv
keZ[ZyªIhkmlb^_eZwlhloZ^bk\u^mfZgguc
<]eZ\_©H^bgba\b^h\rbjdZ–ijhkv[Zhihfhsbg_m
:eeZoZ«ª hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bk hl B[g ExoZc]b ©<h \j_f_gZ
IjhjhdZk]k`beebp_f_jdhlhjuchq_gv\j_^befmkmevfZ
gZf b l_ kdZaZeb ^jm] ^jm]m ©Ihc^_fl_ ihijhkbfihfhsbm
ihkeZggbdZ :eeZoZª - b Ijhjhd k]k bf kdZaZe ©Ijhkbl_
ihfhsbg_mf_gyZm:eeZoZªªWlheh`gucoZ^bkB[gEx
oZc]ZaZimlZekyihih\h^mkfukeZwlh]hoZ^bkZZdjhf_lh]hb
_]hp_ihqdZlh`_aZimlZggZyWlhloZ^bkijb\h^blkym:ofZ^Z
184
hlq_eh\_dZkeurZ\r_]hkeh\Z=m[Z^u[bgZk-KZfblZ
©<au\Zcl_ g_ dh fg_ Z d :eeZomª JZa\_ dh]^Z-gb[m^v kih
^\b`gbdbIjhjhdZk]k[uebgZklhevdhkeZ[uqlh[u`Zeh
\ZlvkygZebp_f_jh\458?
< ]eZ\_ ©H^bg ba \b^h\ rbjdZ – ghr_gb_ [jZke_lh\ b
gblhd«ª \ dZq_kl\_ k\h_]h ^h\h^Z hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bk ©Dlh
ghkbl lZebkfZg lhfm :eeZo g_ k^_eZ_l ijh^he`_gby dlh gh
kbljZdh\bgmlhfm:eeZog_ijhy\blk\hxfy]dhklvª459\p_
ihqd_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\ wlh]h oZ^bkZ ijbkmlkl\m_l FZrjZo [bg
=ZoZghdhlhjhfB[gOb[[ZgkdZaZe©Hgi_j_^Z_lhl\_j]gmlu_
oZ^bkuhl=md[uwlbfoZ^bkZfg_evayke_^h\ZlvªZwlhloZ^bk
dZd jZa i_j_^Zg hl wlh]h q_eh\_dZ :k-Kmxlu ih ih\h^m wlh]h
oZ^bkZkdZaZe©KeZ[ucª460.
< ]eZ\_ ©=Z^Zgb_ ih a\_a^Zfª hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bk ba
k[hjgbdh\ :ofZ^Z b B[g Ob[[ZgZ < p_ihqd_ wlh]h oZ^bkZ
ijbkmlkl\m_l:[mOZjbaba\_klgucl_fqlhi_j_^Z\Zehl\_j]
gmlu_oZ^bku:ofZ^[bgOZg[ZebZg-GZkZbkdZaZebqlhwlhl
oZ^bkkeZ[uc;ueh[u\hh[s_ohjhrh_keb[uhg\wlhc]eZ
\_ijb\_eohly[uh^bg^hklh\_jgucoZ^bk
< ]eZ\_ ©H e_q_gbb b lZebkfZgZoª hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bk
©DlhghkbldZdmx-eb[h\_svlhl[m^_lij_^klZ\e_g_cª<p_
ihqd_wlh]hoZ^bkZijbkmlkl\m_lB[g:[mEycebbfZf:ofZ^
h g_f kdZaZe ©M g_]h iehoZy iZfylv b aZimlZggu_ oZ^bkuª
Rm][ZkdZaZe©Y_s_g_\b^_eq_eh\_dZklZdhciehohciZfy
lvxª < ihevam keZ[hklb wlh]h oZ^bkZ \ukdZaZeky b Yoty [bg
KZ]b^ Ze-DZllZg < jb\Zyl_ wlh]h `_ oZ^bkZ hl Zg-GZkZb ijb
kmlkl\m_l=Z[[Z^[bgFZckZjZZe-FmgdZjbbfZf:ofZ^hg_f
DlhkdZaZeqlhaZij_sZ_lkyh[jZsZlvkyaZihfhsvxd`b\hfmijhjhdm"
>Z`_ bo \h`^v B[g L_cfby \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:l-LZ\Zkkmev \Z Ze-\Zkbeyª k
ibr_l ©Kh]eZkgh kmgg_ d `b\hfm fh`gh h[jZsZlvky k ijhkv[hc h
fhev[_ b ^jm]hc ihfhsb gZ dhlhjmx hg kihkh[_gª R_co FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[bkihevam_lmihfygmlu_keZ[u_oZ^bku^eylh]hqlh[uh[ty
\blv ^ha\he_gghc djh\v fmkmevfZg ih wlhfm ih\h^m m g_]h _klv ^Z`_ hl
^_evgZy]eZ\Z©<_klbhlhfqlhqZklvwlhcmffuihdehgy_lkyb^heZfª
459
Ijb\h^blkym:ofZ^Z:[mY]ebbZl-LZ[ZjZgb
460
>`ZeZem^^bgZk-Kmxlu©Ze->`Zfb]Zk-kZ]bjª–L‹
458
185
kdZaZe ©KeZ[uc i_j_^Zlqbdª Z :[m >Zm^ kdZaZe ©Hg g_ kb
e_gª
< wlhc `_ ]eZ\_ hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bk ©H JmZcnb] \ha
fh`gh lu ijh`b\_rv ^he]h«461ª < p_ihqd_ i_j_^Zlqbdh\
wlh]h oZ^bkZ ijbkmlkl\m_l g_ba\_klguc q_eh\_d RZc[Zg ZeDZl[Zgb<^jm]hfjb\Zyl_wlh]hoZ^bkZijbkmlkl\m_lB[gEx
oZc]ZhdhlhjhfB[gFZo^bkdZaZe©Gbh^bgbaoZ^bkh\wlh]h
q_eh\_dZ y g_ kqblZx ^hklhcgufª bfZf :ofZ^ kdZaZe ©Y aZ
ibku\Zx oZ^bku wlh]h q_eh\_dZ gh agZx qlh hgb g_ fh]ml
kem`blv\dZq_kl\_^h\h^ZªYoty[bgFm]bgkdZaZe©Gbh^bg
ba _]h oZ^bkh\ g_ bf__l p_gghklbª : \ jb\Zyl_ hl Zg-GZkZb
ijbkmlkl\m_lg_ba\_klgucbf_gghihwlhfm\p_ihqd_i_j_^Zl
qbdh\kdZaZgh©I_j_^gbf[uemihfygml^jm]hcq_eh\_dª
< ]eZ\_ ©JZ^b :eeZoZ fh`ghijhkblvlhevdhJZcªijb
\h^blky oZ^bk ©JZ^b :eeZoZ fh`gh ijhkblv lhevdh JZcª oZ
^bkkeZ[ucijb\h^blkym:[m>Zm^ZZ^->ZceZfb
h[Z\ZjbZglZi_j_^Zguhl>`Z[bjZ<©:e-FmoZaaZ[ªkdZaZgh
©<p_ihqd_i_j_^Zlqbdh\wlh]hoZ^bkZijbkmlkl\m_lKme_cfZg
[bg Fm]Za h dhlhjhf Yoty kdZaZe ©Hg gbqlhª =Z[^meoZd b
B[g Ze-DZllZg kdZaZeb ©Hg keZ[uc i_j_^Zlqbdª KeZ[uf _]h
ijbagZe^Z`_Ze-:e[Zgbkf©Ze-FbrdZlª
<]eZ\_©Hgbg_\ha^Zeb:eeZom^he`gufh[jZahfªhg
ijb\h^bl jb\Zyl ©AgZ_l_ eb \u dZdh\h jZkklhygb_ f_`^m g_
[_kZfb b a_fe_c"ª - fu hl\_lbeb ©Wlh \_^hfh :eeZom b ?]h
ihkeZggbdmªHghl\_lbe©F_`^mgbfbiylvkhle_lhlh^gh]h
g_[Z ^h ^jm]h]h lZd`_ iylvkhl e_l lhesbgZ g_[_k lZd`_ ih
iylvkhl e_l GZ^ k_^vfuf g_[hf gZoh^blky fhj_ ]em[bgZ dh
lhjh]hjZ\gZjZkklhygbxf_`^mg_[hfba_fe_cGZ^wlbffh
j_f\hk_fvdhaeh\jZkklhygb_hldhiulZh^gh]hbagbo^h[_^
jZ jZ\gh jZkklhygbx f_`^m g_[hf b a_fe_c GZ^ gbfb gZoh
^blkyljhg\ukhlZdhlhjh]hjZ\gZ\ukhl_f_`^mg_[hfba_f
e_c AgZgb_462 :eeZoZ \ur_ wlh]h ?fm ba\_klgu \k_ ^_ygby
Ijb\h^blkymZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^Zb:ofZ^Z
Fm^`Zkkbfblu hkgh\u\Zykv gZ wlhf oZ^bk_ ml\_j`^Zxl qlh :eeZo
y\ey_lkyl_ehfgZkZfhf`_^_e_oZ^bkkhh[sZ_llhevdhhlhfqlhagZgb_
:eeZoij_\ur_\k_]hwlh]h
461
462
186
ihlhfdh\:^ZfZª463>Ze__fuijb\_^_fZgZebalZojb^`wlh
]hoZ^bkZ
Yoty [bg Ze-=Zey <Zdb] [bg Ze->`ZjjZo h g_f kdZaZe
©Hg h[fZgu\Z_lª :ofZ^ [bg OZg[Ze kdZaZe ©Hg e`_p ijb
^mfu\Z_l oZ^bkuª - m^b\bl_evgh qlh g_kfhljy gZ wlh :ofZ^
ijh^he`Z_l ijb\h^blv _]h oZ^bku Yoty [bg Fm]bg h[ wlhf
q_eh\_d_ kdZaZe ©Hg g_gZ^_`gucª =Zfj [bg Ze-NZeZk b Ze;moZjb kdZaZeb ©?]h oZ^bku hl\_j]Zxlkyª B[jZobf Ze>`Z\oZjbkdZaZe©WlhkeZ[ucr_coªkf©:e-DZfbenb^m]Z
nZZj-jb^`Zeª‹©:e-DZrnZe-oZkbk]ZffZgjm
fby[b\Z^]Ze-oZ^bkªk‹
KZffZd[bgOZj[=Z[^meeZ[bgFm[ZjZdhg_fkdZaZe
©?]hoZ^bkukeZ[u_ªg_kfhljygZlhqlhB[gOb[[ZgbgZa\Ze
_]hgZ^_`gufq_eh\_dhfghaZl_fkdZaZe©HgqZklhhrb[Z_l
kyªKmnvygZk-KZ\jbkdZaZe©HgkeZ[uci_j_^Zlqbdª>`Zjbj
kdZaZe©Y\b^_edZdKZffZd[bgOZj[hlijZ\eyegm`^mklhyª
Rm][Z lh`_ kqblZe _]h keZ[uf i_j_^Zlqbdhf kf ©:e-DZfbe
nb^m]ZnZZj-jb^`Zeª‹B[gZe->`Z\abmihfbgZ_l
wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \ dgb]_ ©:^->m]ZnZ \Z Ze-fZljmdbgª©KeZ[u_
bhl\_j]gmlu_ª‹b]h\hjbl©Rm][ZbKmnvygZkKZ\jbkqblZeb_]hkeZ[ufi_j_^ZlqbdhfªB[g=ZffZjkdZaZe
©=h\hjyl hg qZklh hrb[Zeky h _]h oZ^bkZo \ukdZau\Zeb jZa
ebqgu_fg_gbyB[gFm]bgkdZaZe©Hgijb\h^bloZ^bkudh
lhjuogbmdh]hg_l«ªKZebo[bgFmoZffZ^kdZaZe©?]hkqb
lZxl keZ[ufǻ =Z[^jZofZg [bg Xkmn [bg OZjjZr kdZaZe
©< _]h oZ^bkZo qm\kl\m_lky keZ[hklvª Djhf_ gbo KZffZdZ
keZ[ufijbagZ\ZebZe-;moZjbbFmkebf
=Z[^meeZ [bg =mfZcjZ Ze-Dmnb ;ue gZklZ\gbdhf KZf
fZdZ [bg OZj[Z :a-AZoZ[b h g_f \ ©:e-FbaZg«ª ibr_l ©<
Ijb\h^blky m :ofZ^Z =Z[^Z [bg OZfb^Z :[m >Zm^Z Zl-Lbjfbab B[g
FZ^`b =mkfZgZ [bg KZ]b^Z Z^->Zjbfb \ _]h hl\_l_ ^`ZofblZf B[g :[m
Z^->mgvb \ dgb]_ ©:e-FZlZjª B[g :[m =ZkufZ \ ©:k-KmggZª :[m Y]eb
B[g OmaZcfu \ ©:l-LZ\ob^ª B[g :[m OZlbfZ :[m :ofZ^Z Ze-OZdbfZ \
©:e-DmgZª Zl-LZ[ZjZgb \ ©:e-DZ[bjª :[m R_coZ \ ©:e-=ZaZfZª :eOZdbfZ\©:k-KuoZoªZe-Eydeyb\©:k-KmggZªZe-;ZcoZdb\©:e-:kfZ\Z
Zk-kunZlªhlZe-=Z[[ZkZ[bg=Z[^mefmllZeb[Z
463
187
g_f _klv g_\_`_kl\hª Z \ ©:e-Fm]gZª ibr_l ©Hg g_ ba\_k
l_gªB[jZobf[bgZe-OZj[bkdZaZe©Y_]hg_agZxª\©EbkZg
Ze-fbaZgªkdZaZgh©G_ba\_klgucª‹:e-=Zdbebb
B[g=Z^bijbagZebwlh]hq_eh\_dZkeZ[ufi_j_^Zlqbdhf=Z[
^meeZ[bg=mfZcjijb\h^ywlhloZ^bkkkueZ_lkygZZe-:ogZnZ
[bg DZckZ Ze-;moZjb ih wlhfm ih\h^m kdZaZe ©Y g_ keurZe
qlh[u hg \klj_qZeky k Ze-:ogZnhf [bg DZckhfª DZd \b^bl_
i_j_^Zlqbdbwlh]hoZ^bkZh[fZgsbdbZlZd`_keZ[u_g_ba\_
klgu_ex^b.
< wlhc `_ ]eZ\_ hg kkueZ_lky gZ oZ^bk ©JZkklhygb_
f_`^mg_[_kZfbiylvkhle_lªijb\h^blkymZl-Lbjfbab
dhlhjuckdZaZe©OZkZgi_j_^ZlqbdoZ^bkZgbdh]^Zg_\klj_
qZekyk:[mOmjZcjhcªBa\_klghqlhwlhlZe-OZkZgijb^mfu
\Ze oZ^bku b \ha\h^be p_ihqdb d :[m OmjZcj_ < ©:e-FbaZg
kdZaZgh©Hghq_gvfgh]hnZevkbnbpbjh\Ze\k_oZ^bkuydh[u
i_j_^Zggu_ hl :[m OmjZcju bf_xl h[hj\Zggu_ p_ihqdbª <
^jm]hf jb\Zyl_ i_j_^Zgghf hl g_]h `_ khh[sZ_lky qlh jZk
klhygb_ hl h^gh]h kehy a_feb ^h ^jm]h]h jZ\gh iylbklZ ^gyf
k_]h^gy`_gZfba\_klghqlhwlhg_lZdDZd\b^bl_wlhljb\Z
ylhl\_j]gmlucZoZ^bkkZfihk_[_\u^mfZgguc
Djhf_\k_]h\ur_i_j_qbke_ggh]h\wlhcdgb]__klvoZ
^bku \hh[s_ [_a kkuehd gZ bklhqgbd Ihwlhfm dhff_glZlh
jZfwlhcdgb]bijbrehkvkZfbfijhZgZebabjh\ZlvwlboZ^bku
b^ZlvbooZjZdl_jbklbdmbhgbhq_gvjZ^h\Zebkvdh]^ZgZoh
^beboZ^bk\dZdhf-eb[hbaba\_klguok[hjgbdh\Yg_ohqm\
^Zgghcdgb]_ZgZebabjh\ZlvwlboZ^bkuihkdhevdmmihfygmlh
]hm`_^hklZlhqgh^eylh]hqlh[um[_^blvkyqlhwlhlq_eh\_d
ihkeh\ZfKme_cfZgZ[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zg_bf__l^Z`_h^ghc
^_kylhc^hebagZgbcg_h[oh^bfuo^eyb^`lboZ^Z464.
QblZywlmdgb]m\ufh`_l_aZf_lblvqlhr_cohq_gvkbevghkbfiZlbab
jm_l bm^_ckdhc b^_heh]bb GZijbf_j hg ijb\h^bl keh\Z bm^_ckdh]h k\y
s_ggbdZ©HFmoZffZ^\gZrbodgb]ZokdZaZghqlh:eeZoih^gbf_lg_[_
kZk\hbfiZevp_f«ª<^jm]hff_kl_hgm`_kZfibr_l©Wlbjb\Zylu^h
klZebkvgZfhlbm^__\bhgbg_[uebhl\_j]gmlubg_ih^\_j]ebkvljZdlh\
d_ªDZd\b^bl_r_coijbau\Z_lg_hl\_j]Zlvwlbbklhjbbbg_dhff_glb
464
188
Ohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlh\ihke_^g__\j_fygZljm^ur_c
oZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z[uegZ\_^_glZdgZau\Z_fuc
fZjZn_l\k_g_gm`gh_m^ZebebZ\k_g_h[oh^bfh_^h[Z\beby
gZ^_xkvqlh\[m^ms_fgZfm^Zklkyijh\_klbZgZebawlboljm
^h\b\uy\blvwlbbkijZ\e_gby
AgZcl_ h \ZooZ[blu \u kljhbl_ k\hb m[_`^_gby gZ
eh`guo oZ^bkZo \u^mfZgguo [_kkh\_klgufb h[fZgsbdZfb b
g_ba\_klgufb ex^vfb b \ lh `_ \j_fy \u hklZ\ey_l_ ^hklh
\_jgu_keh\Z:eeZoZboZ^bkuIjhjhdZk]k
<ZooZ[blubdj_kl
M r_coZ B[g ;ZaZ kijhkbeb ©Y\ey_lky eb g_\_jb_f
ghr_gb_ dj_klZ"ª B hg hl\_lbe ©G_l \ wlhf g_l gbq_]h
kljZrgh]h<h-i_j\uoke_^m_laZ^mfZlvkyg_k_lebwlhBkeZ
fm ihevam" ?keb ^Z lh wlh mdjZr_gb_ beb ih^Zjhd ke_^m_l
ijbgylvbhgkqblZ_lky^ha\he_gguf«bl^ªDh]^Z`_kijZ
rb\Zxsbc \hafmsZykv kijhkbe ©Gh wlh `_ dj_kl"ª - r_co
hl\_lbe©>Z`__kebdj_klª465.
LZdh\ m\Z`_fu_ qblZl_eb \ZooZ[baf lZdh\u djmig_c
rb_\ZooZ[blkdb_mq_gu_ijbdeZ^u\Zxsb_k\hbmkbeby\bk
dhj_g_gbbBkeZfZ:eeZo\_e_egZf[ulv\hiihabpbbdbm^_
yfbojbklbZgZfZ\ZooZ[blkdb_mq_gu_kqblZxlqlhghr_gb_
dj_klZ g_k_l ihevam BkeZfm [he__ lh]h hgb jZaj_rZxl m[b
\Zlv`bl_e_cBjZdZ^Z`__kebl_kh\_jrZxlfhebl\m\f_q_
lb Z m[bckl\h fmkmevfZg-b[Z^blh\ kh]eZkgh bo b^_heh]bb
y\ey_lkyh^gbfbaiml_cijb[eb`_gbyd:eeZom
R_coFmoZffZ^[bgKZeboZe-=mk_cfbg\k\h_fbgl_j
\vx ^ey ]Za_lu ©:e-Fmkebfmgª ©FmkmevfZg_ª ‹ hl
] kdZaZe ©?keb fu ij_^iheh`bf qlh ijZ\bl_e_f
jh\ZlvZIjhjhdk]kkh\_lh\Zeg_ijbgbfZlvboaZijZ\^mghbg_h[\b
gylvjZkkdZaqbdZ\he`b
465
Kf ^hdlhj FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^meeZ Ze-FZk]Zjb ©Ze-:^beey Ze-dZl]by
]Zey ]Z^Zf rZj]byl Z^-^Zmey Zk-KZ]m^byª ©>hklh\_jgu_ ^h\h^u \ ihevam
g_khhl\_lkl\bykZm^bckdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\ZaZdhgZfrZjbZlZª–KFmd
[be [bg OZ^b Ze-<Z^b]b Ze-YfZgb h^bg ba mq_gbdh\ B[g ;ZaZ gZibkZe d
wlhcn_l\_hijh\_j`_gb_
189
fmkmevfZgkdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z klZe g_\_jguc lh wlh g_ agZqbl
qlhfmkmevfZg_^he`gu\hkklZlvijhlb\g_]h\_^vwlhfh`_l
ijb\_klbd[_kihjy^dZfoZhkmbfZkkh\ufm[bckl\ZfªLZdh\Z
\ZooZ[blkdZyZdu^Zijbau\ZxsZy[ulvihdhjgufbg_\_jguf
Fu `_ kh\_lm_f r_com =mk_cfbgm kh\_jrblv _s_ [he__ [eZ
]hjh^gucihklmihdp_eh\ZlvbfjmdbbfheblvkyaZgbo
K\ylugbb[_kihdhckl\hh[hevrbo^_j_\vyo
<ZooZ[blu kqblZxl g_^himklbfuf ihk_s_gb_ fh]beu
ijhjhdZ FmoZffZ^Z k]k WlZ b^_y \hkoh^bl d B[g L_cfbb
dhlhjuc kqblZe aZij_lguf oZjZf466 ihk_s_gb_ fh]beu Ijh
jhdZk]kb\k_ohklZevguoijhjhdh\\hh[s_[he__lh]hhg
deZkkbnbpbjh\Ze wlhl ihklmihd dZd yauq_kl\h467 Ih _]h fg_
gbxdmjZcrblkdbcb^he©EylªklZeblh]hfm\Z`_gbyZjZ[h\d
h^ghfm ba ijZ\_^gbdh\468 Bkoh^y ba wlhc n_l\u \ZooZ[blu
h[ty\beb \k_o fmkmevfZg ihk_sZxsbo fh]bem IjhjhdZ
k]kyauqgbdZfbbjZaj_rbebm[b\Zlv
Gh jZa\_ fh`_l [ulv aZij_lguf ihk_s_gb_ fh]beu
IjhjhdZk]k"Ba\_kl_goZ^bkIjhjhdZk]k\dhlhjhfhg
kdZaZe ©Y aZij_sZe \Zf gZ\_sZlv fh]beu l_i_jv `_ y jZaj_
rbe \Zf wlh lZd gZ\_sZcl_ `_ boǻ ijb\h^blky m FmkebfZ
Zg-GZkZbZl-Lbjfbab:[m>Zm^Zb:ofZ^Z
Djhf_ lh]h m Zg-GZkZb _klv ^jm]hc jb\Zyl k kbevghc
p_ihqdhc©«yaZij_sZe\ZfgZ\_sZlvfh]beul_i_jv`_dlh
`_eZ_lfh`_lbogZ\_sZlvǻIjbf_jghlZdhc`_oZ^bk_klvm
FZebdZ<^jm]hfjb\Zyl_Ijhjhdk]kkdZaZe©YaZij_sZe
\Zfljb\_sbh^ghcbadhlhjuo[uehihk_s_gb_fh]bel_i_jv
`_ \u bo fh`_l_ gZ\_sZlv \hafh`gh wlh ijbg_k_l \Zf ^h[
jh«469ª KZf Ijhjhd k]k gZ\_sZe fh]bem k\h_c fZl_jb gh
_fmg_[ueh^ZghjZaj_r_gbyfheblvkyh__ijhs_gbb\h^ghf
baoZ^bkh\h[wlhfkdZaZgh©Yihijhkbemk\h_]h=hkih^ZjZa
B[gL_cfby©Ze-NZlZ\ZZe-dm[jZª©FZ^`fm]Ze-nZlZ\Zª/520.
Kf B[g L_cfby ©Bdlb^Z Zk-kujZl Ze-fmklZdbf fmoZebnZ Zoe Ze^`ZobfªK
468
LZf`_K
469
Ijb\h^blkymFmkebfZZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^Z:ofZ^ZbZl-Lbjfbab
466
467
190
j_r_gby fheblvky h ijhs_gbb fh_c fZl_jb gh Hg g_ jZaj_
rbefg_yihijhkbemG_]hjZaj_r_gbygZ\_sZlv__fh]bemb
HgjZaj_rbefg_ª470.
DZd \b^bf :eeZo jZaj_rbe gZ\_sZlv fh]beu \ p_ehf
ihq_fm `_ ihk_s_gb_ bf_ggh fh]beu IjhjhdZ k]k ^he`gh
[ulvaZij_lguf"
GZijbf_j ;beye [bg JZ[Zo gZoh^ykv \ RZf_ \h kg_
m\b^_eIjhjhdZk]kdhlhjuckdZaZe_fm©H;beyeqlhwlh
aZ q_jkl\hklv" G_ gZklZeh eb ^ey l_[y \j_fy ihk_lblv gZk"ª
Ijhkgm\rbkv ;beye k_e gZ dhgy b gZijZ\beky \ F_^bgm ?]h
_^bgkl\_gghc p_evx [ueh ihk_s_gb_ fh]beu IjhjhdZ
k]k >h[jZ\rbkv ^h _]h fh]beu hg miZe gZ a_fex b aZieZ
dZeª471.
Djhf_lh]h\k[hjgbd_oZ^bkh\bfZfZ:ofZ^Z[bgOZg
[ZeZ kh^_j`blky oZ^bk h Fm]Za_ \ dhlhjhf Ijhjhd k]k aZ
\_sZe _fm gZ\_sZlv k\hx fh]bem Ijh\h`Zy Fm]ZaZ \ C_f_g
Ijhjhdk]kkdZaZe_fm©HFmZa\hafh`ghlu[hevr_f_gy
g_m\b^brvdh]^Z\_jg_rvkyihk_lbfhxf_q_lvbebfh]bemª
FmZaaZieZdZeZIjhjhdk]kih\_jgm\rbkvebphfdF_^b
g_ kdZaZe ©<hbklbgm [hevr_ ijZ\ gZ f_gy bf_xl [h]h[hya
g_ggu_g_aZ\bkbfhdlhhgbb]^_ª<ZjZ[kdhcj_qbkeh\h©ey
]yeeyª©ygZ^_xkvª©fh`_l[ulvªbkihevam_lky^eyi_j_^Zqb
kfukeZgZ^_`^ub`_eZgbybqZklbpZ©ZgªlZd`_bkihevam_lky
^ey jZatykg_gby p_eb b gZ^_`^u Ke_^h\Zl_evgh \ keh\Zo
IjhjhdZ k]k kh^_j`blky aZ\_sZgb_ Fm]Zam gZ\_klblv f_
q_lv IjhjhdZ k]k b _]h fh]bem ih \ha\jZs_gbb ba C_f_
gZ472.
Ijb\h^blkymFmkebfZZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^ZB[gFZ^`bb:ofZ^Z
B[g Ze-:kbj ©Mk^ Ze-]Z[Zª – L K lh `_ kZfh_ mihfbgZ_lky b
B[g=ZkZdbjZ
472
Djhf_ lh]h ih ^Zgghc l_f_ kf ^hdlhj FmoZffZ^ KZ]b^ JZfZ^Zg Ze;mlu©NbdoZk-kbjZZg-gZ[Z\byª–K–ba^Zgb__LZd`_yohqm
h[jZlblv\gbfZgb_gZlhlnZdlqlhkih^\b`gbdbijhjhdZk]kb\qZkl
ghklb =mfZj [bg Ze-OZllZ[ baty\be `_eZgb_ [ulv ihohjhg_gguf jy^hf k
Ijhjhdhfk]k
470
471
191
Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyoZ^bkZ©Ij_^gZf_j_ggu_iml_r_kl\by
kh\_jrZxlkylhevdhdlj_ff_q_lyff_q_lbZe-OZjZff_q_lb
IhkeZggbdZ :eeZoZ k]k b f_q_lb Ze-:dkZª lh \ g_f j_qv
b^_l lhevdh h f_q_lyo \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ gZf [ueh [u aZ
ij_s_gh kh\_jrZlv ij_^gZf_j_ggu_ iml_r_kl\by k p_evx gZ
\_klblv jh^kl\_ggbdh\ \ ihbkdZo agZgbc ^ey kh\_jr_gby
^`boZ^Zb\ihbkdZoijhiblZgbyaZjZ[hldZ?keboZrZ\blub
^Ze__ [m^ml bkihevah\Zlv_]h\dZq_kl\_^h\h^ZlhwlhmdZau
\Z_lgZboh]jZgbq_gghklv
FmkmevfZgkdb_ mq_gu_ gZibkZeb hq_gv fgh]h dgb] \
dhlhjuo h[tykgbeb g_h[oh^bfhklv ihk_s_gby fh]beu Ijhjh
dZk]kbawlboljm^h\ohq_lky\u^_eblv©RbnZZk-kZdZfnb
abyjZl oZcj Ze-ZgZfª bfZfZ Zk-Km[db ©OmeZkZl Ze-\ZnZª ZkKZfom^b ©:e-FZ\Zob[ Ze-^bgbyª Ze-DZklZeZgb ©LmonZl ZaammZj \Z Ze-^`Z\Zobj Ze-fmglZaZfª B[g OZ^`Zj :l-L_jfbab
ihke_ lh]h dZd ijb\_e oZ^bku h ihk_s_gbb fh]beu IjhjhdZ
k]kgZibkZe©Hkgh\u\ZykvgZwlhfmq_gu_k^_eZeb\u\h^
qlhihk_s_gb_fh]beg_y\ey_lkyhkm`^Z_fuf^_ygb_fLZdh]h
fg_gby ijb^_j`b\Zebkv B[g Ze-Fm[ZjZd Zr-RZnb]b :ofZ^
bBkoZdªGhfg_dZ`_lkyqlhwlhfg_gb_^eyg_hoZjb^`blh\
g_ijb_fe_fhihkdhevdm\wlhfkibkd_hlkmlkl\mxlbf_gZB[g
L_cfbbb_]hmq_gbdZB[gZe-DZcbfZ
GZnhg_\ur_mihfygmlh]h\g_^hmf_gbbgZkhklZ\eyxl
ke_^mxsb_ihklmidb\ZooZ[blh\^moh\gufhlphf\ZooZ[bafZ
y\ey_lky B[g L_cfby d dhlhjhfm ihke_^h\Zl_eb ijboh^beb \
gZ^_`^_ gZ [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ ;bg =Z[^meoZ^b \ ©:e-=mdm^ Z^^Zjbyª k – ibr_l ©< dj_ihklv ihke_ kf_jlb B[g
L_cfbb ijb[ueZ ]jmiiZ ex^_c Bf iha\hebeb \hclb b i_j_^
hfh\_gb_f mkhir_]h jZaj_rbeb ijhclb \ _]h l_fgbpm Wlb
ex^bkb^_ebjy^hfkgbfqblZebDhjZgb\gZ^_`^_gZ[eZ]h
keh\_gb_kfhlj_ebgZg_]hbp_eh\Zeb_]hl_ehZaZl_fmreb
AZl_f ijbreb `_gsbgu b kh\_jrbeb lh `_kZfh_GZ_]hih
]j_[Zevgu_ghkbedbex^b\gZ^_`^_gZ[eZ]hkeh\_gb_[jhkZeb
k\hb ieZldb b qZefu hgb ibeb \h^m dhlhjZy hklZeZkv ihke_
hfh\_gby_]hl_eZb^_ebeb^mrbklu_\_s_kl\Zdhlhju_deZ
eb \ wlm \h^m =h\hjyl qlh _]h lx[_l_cdZ [ueZ ijh^ZgZ aZ
192
iylvkhl ^bjo_fh\ Z gblhqdZ gZ dhlhjhc \bk_e f_rhq_d kh
jlmlvx hl [eho [ueZ ijh^ZgZ aZ iylv^_kyl ^bjo_fh\ Ihke_
_]hihohjhgex^b_s_^he]h_\j_fyoh^bebdfh]be_ªG_m`_
eb B[g L_cfby y\ey_lky bkdexq_gb_f ba \ZooZ[blkdh]h
aZij_lZZfh`_l[ulv_]hihke_^h\Zl_eb[uebyauqgbdZ
fb"
>moh\guf hlphf kh\j_f_ggh]h \ZooZ[bafZ dZd ba\_kl
ghy\ey_lkyFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Fgh]b_fmkmevfZg_
\b^y g_ijbfbjbfh_ hlghr_gb_ \ZooZ[blh\ dh \k_fm qlh k\y
aZgh k fh]beZfb ^mfZxl qlh fh]beu bo ij_^\h^bl_e_c lh`_
\u]ey^yl hq_gv kdjhfgh b g_ \u^_eyxlky gZ^ mjh\g_f a_feb
LZdh_ ij_^klZ\e_gb_ g_\_jgh gZ kZfhf ^_e_ \ZooZ[blu ij_
\jZlbebfh]bemFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z\G_^`^_\gZ
klhysbc fZaZj GZ^ g_c ihkljh_gh \ukhdh_ djZkb\h_ a^Zgb_
hl^_eZggh_fjZfhjhf<gmljbfhe_evgh]h^hfZ\wj-Jby^_\u
\_r_gZlZ[ebqdZgZdhlhjhc\u]jZ\bjh\Zgl_dklijbky]bFm
oZffZ^Z[bgKZ]m^ZFmoZffZ^m[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[mbmihk_
lbl_e_c_klv\hafh`ghklvijbdhkgmlvkydg_cqlh[uihemqblv
[eZ]hkeh\_gb_ I_j_^ l_f dZd \hclb \ wlm f_q_lv \u h[yaZgu
kgylvh[m\vqlh`_dZkZ_lkyhklZevguof_q_l_clh\ug_h[y
aZguwlh^_eZlv^Z`__kebgZ\Zr_ch[m\b]jyavkh\k_]hfbjZ
Ihkfhljbl_ gZ wlbo \ZooZ[blh\ aZij_sZxsbo ihk_s_
gb_fh]beuIjhjhdZk]kbkqblZxsbohrb[dhckljhbl_ev
kl\hf_q_lbgZ^_]hfh]behcJZa\_hgbg_kha^Zebk_[_gh\h]h
b^heZihbf_gbFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ["
AZ[em`^_gbyoZrZ\blh\
Nbdo \ZooZ[blh\-g_hoZjb^`blh\ y\ey_lky hq_gv ih
\_joghklguf >ey gbo ^`boZ^ – wlh \hcgZ ijhlb\ fmkmevfZg
dhlhjuo hgb h[ty\beb yauqgbdZfb b fm[lZ^b]Zfb bo Zdu^Z
\jZsZ_lky\hdjm][hjv[uk\hh[jZ`Z_fuffh]behihdehggbq_
kl\hf Hgb kqblZxl qlh :eeZo gZoh^blky gZ g_[_ ihwlhfm
hkm`^ZxldZ`^h]hdlhkqblZ_la_fexrZjhh[jZaghc\_^vwlh
m^ZjihboZdu^_QlhdZkZ_lkyLjhgZb_]hih^gh`bylhhgb\
\ZooZ[blkdhc b^_heh]bb bf_xl fZl_jbZevgu_ nhjfu Gh lml
\hagbdZ_l \hijhk dZd Ljhg b _]h ih^gh`b_ fh`_l h]jZgbqb
193
\Zlv:eeZoZbh^gh\j_f_gghho\Zlu\Zlvg_[_kZba_fex"?keb
\uijb\_^_l_wlbfex^yf^h\h^ubaDhjZgZlhhgbg_ijbfml
bo beb [m^ml ljZdlh\Zlv ih-k\h_fm Qlh[u \g_klb ykghklv \
wlhl\hijhkfuohlbfijb\_klbn_l\mr_coZ:ofZ^Z[bgOZf
^ZZe-OZebeb
?fm[ueaZ^Zg\hijhk©:eeZo\DhjZg_]h\hjbl©G_l
:eeZo _]h ih^gye d K_[_ª qlh \u kdZ`_l_ ih ih\h^m l_o dlh
bkihevam_lwlhlZyl\dZq_kl\_^h\h^ZgZgZoh`^_gb_:eeZoZ\
g_[_kZo"ª
Hghl\_lbe©Wlhg_\_jgh_ij_^klZ\e_gb_DZdba\_klgh
B[jZobf]kkdZaZek\hbfkhie_f_ggbdZf©YgZijZ\eyxkvd
k\h_fm=hkih^mª-ZkZfgZijZ\beky\RZfg_m`_eb:eeZo\
wlh \j_fy gZoh^beky \ RZf_" < h^ghf ba oZ^bkh\ IjhjhdZ
k]k kdZaZgh ©?keb dlh-eb[h ba \Zk kh\_jrZ_l fhebl\m lh
imklv g_ iex_l i_j_^ kh[hc \hbklbgm f_`^m gbf b db[ehc
:eeZo473», - jZa\_ wlh agZqbl qlh :eeZo klhbl i_j_^ dZ`^uf
fheysbfky" Dhg_qgh `_ g_l \ ZjZ[kdhf yaud_ _klv ihgylb_
bklbgubihgylb_f_lZnhjudhlhju_kh^_j`Zlkyb\DhjZg_k
kmgghclh`_Ihwlhfmkeh\Z©Hgih^gye_]hdK_[_ªmdZau\Z
xl gZ m\Z`_gb_ ihq_l b ijb[eb`_gb_ Lhqgh lZd `_ \ kemqZ_
kf_jlb ijZ\_^gbdZ fu ]h\hjbf ©:eeZo aZ[jZe _]h d K_[_ª
BklbgZ`_ba\_klgZh^ghfm:eeZomª
Ijhlb\hj_qby\Zdu^_
OZrZ\blu-\ZooZ[blu y\eyxlky y\gufb ijhlb\gbdZfb
ljZdlh\dblZt\be\p_ehfbljZdlh\db[h`_kl\_gguoZljb[m
lh\\qZklghklbGhlZdZyihabpbyaZqZklmxijb\h^blbodijh
lb\hj_qbxGZijbf_jr_coB[g;Za\h^ghcbak\hbon_l\l
k]h\hjbe©Lhedh\Zgb_[h`_kl\_gguoZljb[mlh\g_^h
imklbfhbaZij_lghªgh\lh`_\j_fyhg\wlhc`_dgb]_l
k©ihklhyggh_ijbkmlkl\b_:eeZoZª©Ze-fZ]byªªljZdlm
_l dZd ©agZgb_ª KkueZykv gZ kZeZnh\ hg ibr_l ©Ihklhyggh_
Ijb\h^blkymZj-JZ[b]Z[bgOZ[b[Z\©:e->`Zfb]Zk-kZoboªoZ^bki_
j_^Zghl:[mKZ]b^ZZe-Om^jbDjhf_lh]hoZ^bkijb\h^blkymZe-;moZjb
FmkebfZZg-GZkZb:ofZ^ZbFZebdZ\bojb\ZylZo_klvg_[hevrb_jZaeb
qbygh\k_hgbkkueZxlkygZB[g=mfZjZ
473
194
ijbkmlkl\b_ :eeZoZ ih^jZamf_\Z_l _]h hih\_s_gghklv h ^_y
gbyojZ[h\ǻDZd\b^bl_hg]h\hjblg_hnbabq_kdhfijbkml
kl\bbZbf_gghhagZgbb<lgZkhgkkueZykvgZZlLZefZdZgb mdZau\Z_l ©FmkmevfZg_-kmggblu _^bgh]eZkgu \
lhf qlh keh\Z :eeZoZ ©Hg k \Zfb ]^_ [u \u gb [uebª b bf
ih^h[gu_ ]h\hjyl h agZgbb :eeZoZǻ Ihq_fm `_ B[g ;Za
kZfk_[_ijhlb\hj_qbl"
B[g ;Za y\ey_lky \_jguf mq_gbdhf b ihke_^h\Zl_e_f
B[gL_cfbbdhlhjuclZd`_\iZe\ih^h[gh_ijhlb\hj_qb_Hg
aZij_sZe ljZdlh\Zlv [h`_kl\_ggu_ Zljb[mlu gh kZf \ lh `_
\j_fyljZdlh\Ze©ihklhyggh_ijbkmlkl\b_:eeZoZªbijbibku
\Ze wlm ljZdlh\dm kZeZnZf474 [h`_kl\_gguc kemo b aj_gb_ hg
ljZdlh\Ze dZd ©agZgb_ª ijboh^ ©:e-;ZdZjuª b ©:e =bfjZgª
hgljZdlh\ZedZdgZ]jZ^maZboql_gb_475bl^476
;hevr_ \k_]h kf_rbl lh qlh hgb \_^v hl\_j]Zxl b aZ
ij_sZxlljZdlh\Zgb_©Zl-lZ\beªbB[g;ZaebqghaZy\ey_lh[
wlhf \ k\hbo n_l\Zo l k Y ^mfZx qlh m wlbo ex^_c
g_l ijbgpbih\ h lZdbo :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©G_m`_eb \u
ijbagZ_l_h^gmqZklvIbkZgbyZ^jm]mxhl\_j]Z_l_"ª
AZy\e_gby oZrZ\blh\ h lhf qlh ydh[u kZeZnu \ha^_j
`b\Zebkv hl ljZdlh\Zgby ©Zl-lZ\beª y\ey_lky eb[h j_amevlZ
lhf g_\_`_kl\Z B[g ;Za kZf ijbagZ_lky qlh g_ kfh] hagZdh
fblvkykh\k_fbk[hjgbdZfboZ^bkh\eb[hj_amevlZlhfnZgZ
lbafZ GZ kZfhf ^_e_ kZeZnu ljZdlh\Zeb k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu b
^_eZebwlhhq_gv^Z`_qZklh>Ze__fuijb\_^_fijbf_judh
lhju_oZrZ\blug_kfh]mlhljbpZlvGZijbf_jh^bgbakZfuo
\_ebdbo kih^\b`gbdh\ =Z[^meeZ [bg =Z[[Zk dhff_glbjmy
keh\Z©b\lhl^_gvdh]^Zhldjh_lky]he_gvª-kdZaZe
©J_qv b^_l h \_ebdhc ljm^ghklbª477 Fm^`Zob^ dhff_glbjmy
keh\Z :eeZoZ ©Dm^Z [u \u g_ ih\_jgmebkv lZf ebd :eeZoZª
B[gL_cfby©FZ^`fm]Ze-nZlZ\Zª– 5/231.
LZf`_– 5/232.
476
Kf ^hdlhj =Z[^me]Zauf Ze-FZl]Zgb ©Ze-FZ^`Zam nb Ze-ex]Z \Z ZeDmjtZgZe-dZjbf[ZcgZZe-b^`ZaZ\ZZe-fZg]ª–<Zo[Z– 2/830 – 831.
477
B[gOZ^`ZjZe-=ZkdZeZgb©NZloZe-[Zjbª– 13/428.
474
475
195
(2:115), -kdZaZe©Lh_klvdb[eZ:eeZoZª478:ofZ^[bgOZg[Ze
dhff_glbjmykeh\Z©bijbr_el\hc=hkih^vªkdZaZe©IjbreZ
?]h gZ]jZ^Zª479 :e-;moZjb dhff_glbjmy keh\Z :eeZoZ ©<k_
le_ggh djhf_ ebdZ ?]hª - kdZaZe ©Djhf_ ?]h pZjkl\Zª480 hg
`_ ljZdlh\Ze ©kf_oª dZd ©fbehklvª481 H r_cob-fm^`Zkkbfblukfh`_l_eb\ukdjulvkyhlbklbgu"
>ha\he_gb_e`b
Fgh]b_ fmkmevfZg_ hdZau\Zxlky \ g_^hmf_gbb dh]^Z
keurZl dZd \ZooZ[blu-oZrZ\blu iheb\Zxl bo ]jyavx e`b b
de_\_lu Hgb [_a ijb\_^_gby dZdbo-eb[h ^h\h^h\ h[he]Zeb b
hde_\_lZebfgh]b_fZaoZ[uHg_dhlhjuo^Z`_kdZaZebqlhl_
ydh[u^ha\heyxlfm`_eh`_kl\hghkdju\Zxlwlhhlrbjhdhc
h[s_kl\_gghklb482BebgZijbf_jihke_^h\Zl_e_crdhedhlh
ju_hljbpZxl\hafh`ghklvebp_aj_gby:eeZoZb\wlhffbj_
b \ ihke_^mxs_f hgb gZau\Zxl [_a[h`gbdZfb ijbdju\Zx
sbfbkyDhjZghfLhqghlZd`_hgbihklmiZxlb\hlghr_gbb
mq_guo-Zglb\ZooZ[blh\483. <k_wlhhgb^_eZxl^eylh]hqlh[u
jZah[sblvfmkmevfZg
H^gbf ba ijbf_jh\ de_\_lu \ Z^j_k fmkmevfZgkdbo
fZaoZ[h\klZeh\uklmie_gb_^hdlhjZ=mfZjZZe-:rdZjZ\Bhj
^Zgkdhfmgb\_jkbl_l_\dhlhjhfhgh[ty\beqlhb[Z^bluiha
\heyxlh^gh\j_f_gguc[jZdk`_gsbghcb__l_l_cMkeurZ\
wlbkeh\Zijhn_kkhj:fbgGZbn\klZebijhq_eoZ^bkhaZij_
l_ lZdh]h [jZdZ ba k[hjgbdZ bfZfZ Zj-JZ[b]Z [bg OZ[b[Z LZ
dbfh[jZahf=mfZjZe-:rdZj[uehihahj_gijb\k_oij_ih^Z
\Zl_eyobklm^_glZoGhhldZaZekyebhghlwlh]hfg_gby"
:e-;ZcoZdb©:e-:kfZ\ZZk-kunZlª–K
B[gDZkkbj©:e-;b^Zy\ZZg-gboZyª– 10/327.
480
:e-;moZjb©KZoboZe-;moZjbª–LK©DblZ[Zl-lZnkbjª©LZn
kbjkmjZlZe-DZkZkª
481
B[gOZ^`ZjZe-=ZkdZeZgb©NZloZe-[Zjbª– 6/40.
482
<DhjZg_kdZaZgh©<_ebdbc]j_owlhkeh\hijhbaghkbfh_bomklZfbª
483
Ijhn_kkhjZ KZeZoZ Fmg^ZdZjZ djblbdh\Z\r_]h \ZooZ[blkdbc wdklj_
fbaf\hlghr_gbbfmkmevfZghgbh[\bgbeb\jZkimlkl\_lhqghlZd`_hgb
ihklmibebkr_cohfGmjmeoZddhfZe-Obg^bdjblbdh\Z\rbfboaZlhqlh
hgb\g_kebjZkdhe\jy^ufmkmevfZgBg^bb
478
479
196
H^gbf ba ijbf_jh\ de_\_lu \ Z^j_k fmkmevfZgkdbo
mq_guoy\eyxlkykeh\ZAmoZcjZZr-RZ\brZh[bfZf_Ze-=ZeZ
Ze-;moZjbboZnba_Zk-KZoZ\b\dgb]_©:j-JZ^^Ze-\ZnbjªHg
ibr_lqlhydh[uZk-KZoZ\boZjZdl_jbamyZe-=ZeZZe-;moZjb\
k\h_cdgb]_©:^->ZmZe-eZfb]ªkdZaZe©Hg\k_]^Z[ue
\ [ebadbo hlghr_gbyo k ijZ\bl_eyfbª GZ kZfhf ^_e_ ZkKZoZ\b ibr_l ©?keb d g_fm ijb_a`Zeb \ukhdhihklZ\e_ggu_
qbgubijZ\bl_eb]hkm^Zjkl\ZlhhggZqbgZeqblZlvbfijhih
\_^bdhlhju_bgh]^Zfh]eb[ulv^h\hevgh]jm[ufb;he__lh
]hhgibkZeibkvfZkZfhfmkmelZgm\dhlhjuokljh]hlj_[h\Ze
hlg_]h[hjhlvkykg_kijZ\_^eb\hklvxªR_coOZkZg[bg=Zeb
Zk-KZddZn \klj_lbeky k fm^`Zkkbfblhf AmoZcjhf ZrRZ\br_f qlh[u hijh\_j]gmlv wlm de_\_lm Qlh `_ hl\_lbe
_fm Zr-RZ\br" Hg \k_]h ebrv ihh[_sZe m^Zeblv wlb kljhdb
ba ke_^mxs_]h ba^Zgby dgb]b h^gZdh g_ \uihegbe k\h_]h
h[_sZgby qlh k\b^_l_evkl\m_l \ ihevam nZgZlbafZ wlbo ex
^_c484.
Ij_^Zl_evkl\h b eh`v hlghkylky d l_f dZq_kl\Zf dhlh
ju_ ebrZxl q_eh\_dZ \_ju >Z rZjbZl jZaj_rZ_l fmkmevfZ
gZfijb[_]Zlvdobljhklyfghg_jZaj_rZ_leh`vbij_^Zl_ev
kl\hQlh`_dZkZ_lkyihklmidh\wlboex^_clhwlhfh`ghjZk
p_gblvlhevdhdZdij_^Zl_evkl\hfmkmevfZgkdhcmffuihiul
dm ihk_ylv jhagv :eeZo h[_sZe ijhdeylb_ g_kijZ\_^eb\uf
©>Z[m^_lijhdeylb_:eeZoZgZ^g_q_klb\pZfbª
GZijhly`_gbb\k_ck\h_cbklhjbboZrZ\bluihklhyggh
ijZdlbdh\Zeb eh`v b kqblZeb __ ^himklbfhc dZd kj_^kl\h
[hjv[u kh k\hbfb hiihg_glZfb Bf_ggh ihwlhfm bfZfm ZkKm[db Zr-RZnb]b ijbrehkv gZibkZlv hijh\_j`_gb_ \ Z^j_k
l_ofm^`Zkkbfblh\dhlhju_aZy\bebqlhydh[uhgby\eyxlky
ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb bfZfZ :ofZ^Z BfZf Zk-Km[db bf hl\_lbe
©«^ey ijh^\b`_gby k\hbo m[_`^_gbc hgb iha\hebeb k_[_
eh`vHgbhkh[_gghde_\_smlgZl_odlh\k_fk\hbfbfms_kl
\hf b kbeZfb klZjZ_lky bf ijhlb\hklhylv H^ghfm ba djmi
Kfr_coOZkZgZk-KZddZn©Zl-LZg^b^[bfZgg]Z^Z^Zl-lZ\ob^ªK28.
484
197
g_crbo fm^`Zkkbfblh\ [ue aZ^Zg \hijhk ©Fh`gh eb de_\_
lZlv\Z^j_kbfZfZZr-RZnb]b"ª-bhghl\_lbe©JZa\_lug_
kqblZ_rv^ha\he_gghc_]hdjh\v"ªbdh]^ZkijZrb\ZxsbckdZ
aZe ©>Zª kijZrb\Z_fuc hl\_lbe ³Lh]^Z b \k_ hklZevgh_ y\
ey_lky ^ha\he_gguf KiZkZc fmkmevfZg hl _]h \ebygby ex[u
fb^hklmigufbimlyfb´ªB^Ze__hgijh^he`Z_l©LZdh\Zbo
Zdu^Z hgb kqblZxl k_[y fmkmevfZgZfb-kmggblZfb GZ kZfhf
`_^_e_\bojy^Zog_l^Z`_gZklhysbomq_guoHgbh[ty\eyxl
g_\_jgufb \k_o ij_^klZ\bl_e_c fmkmevfZgkdhc mffu b Zi_e
ebjmxldbfZfm:ofZ^m[bgOZg[ZemdhlhjucgZkZfhf^_e_
hlj_dkyhlgbo«485»
<ur_ fu ijb\_eb ijbf_ju dZd wlb ex^b de_\_sml \
Z^j_kbfZfh\-jh^hgZqZevgbdh\q_luj_ofZaoZ[h\Djhf_lh]h
hgb i_j_ba^Zxl bo dgb]b gh i_j_^ wlbf bkdZ`Zxl bo m^Zeyy
lhqlhijhlb\hj_qblbob^_heh]bbb^h[Z\eyylhqlhkhhl\_l
kl\m_lHgbi_j_ba^Zxl©:e-DZrrZnªghi_j_^wlbfm^Zeyxl
\k_\ukdZau\ZgbyZa-AZfZorZjbijhlb\hj_qZsb_oZrZ\blkdhc
b^_heh]bbb[_adZdbo-eb[hkkuehdbihykg_gbc^h[Z\eyxllh
qlh\u]h^ghbfJZa\_wlhg_ijbf_j]gmkg_cr_ce`b486?
>hdlhj =Z[^mefZ^`b^ ;Z^Z\b jZkkdZau\Zy h ijbqZkl
ghklb \ZooZ[blh\ d jZaebqguf kfmlZf \ bkeZfkdhf fbj_ ib
r_l ©<k_ wlb j_\hexpbb b i_j_\hjhlu [ueb hj]Zgbah\Zgu
fukebl_eyfb-kmggblZfb b nZdboZfb-oZg[ZeblZfb ihke_^h\Z
l_eyfb Zoe oZ^bkª487 ;he__ lh]h wlb ex^b lj_[mxl kqblZlv
g_\_jgufb\k_odlhg_h[\bgy_l\g_\_jbbrbblh\488>hdlhj
FmoZffZ^ KZ]b^ JZfZ^Zg Ze-;mlu ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l
©«hl\_lkl\_gghklv i_j_^ :eeZohf gZmdhc b ex^vfb aZklZ\
ey_l f_gy ij_^mij_^blv fmkmevfZg h ^_ygbyo ex^_c gZau\Z
xsbo k_[y ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb ijhjhq_kdbo oZ^bkh\ b ijbau\Z
©Zl-LZ[ZdZlZr-rZnb]byª– 1/193.
Ih^jh[g__\^jm]bo]eZ\Zo
487
>hdlhj=Z[^mefZ^`b^;Z^Z\b©LZjboZk-kbykb\ZZe-nbdjª–K
488
LZf`_
485
486
198
xsbo fmkmevfZg ke_^h\Zlv aZ kh[hcª489 ^Ze__ hg ijb\h^bl
ijbf_jude_\_lu\ZooZ[blh\\_]hZ^j_k
Bf_gghhlgbobkoh^ylk_]h^gyrgb_kfmlu\bkeZfkdhf
fbj_bde_\_lZ\Z^j_k\k_omq_guodhlhju_g_kh]eZkgukbo
m[_`^_gbyfb490 DZd ibr_l :[m AZojZ ©Wlb ex^b k [hevrhc
e_]dhklvx ijbagZxl k\hb m[_`^_gby _^bgkl\_ggh \_jgufb Z
qm`b__^bgkl\_gghhrb[hqgufb491ªgZhkgh\_wlh]hhgbkqb
lZxl^eyk_[y^ha\he_gguf^Z`_de_\_lZlv\Z^j_kk\hbohiih
g_glh\:e-;mluihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l©Wlbex^bgZklhevdh
g_gZ\b^yl fmkmevfZg b aZ\b^mxl bf qlh ]hlh\u ^Z`_ hkjZ
fblvq_klvk\hbohiihg_glh\ª492Ihwlhfmg_m^b\bl_evghqlh
hgbde_\_sml^Z`_\Z^j_kbfZfh\-hkgh\hiheh`gbdh\q_luj_o
fZaoZ[h\ h q_f [he__ ih^jh[gh fu jZkkdZ`_f \ ke_^mxs_c
]eZ\_
=eZ\ZiylZy
JZaysZy\ZooZ[blkdZyfukev
K[hevrbfij_m\_ebq_gb_ffugZau\Z_f\ZooZ[blkdmx
_j_kvfukevxB\wlhfjZa^_e_fuohlbfjZkkdZaZlvhg_dhlh
juohkh[_gghklyowlhc©fukebªdhlhju_\ujZ`_gu\©^mjguo
^_ygbyoªb\lhfqlh©hgbqblZxlDhjZgghhgg_ih^gbfZ_l
ky\ur_bo]hjeZª
De_\_lZ\ZooZ[blh\\Z^j_kq_luj_obfZfh\
Gb^eydh]hg_y\ey_lkyk_dj_lhfqlhfm^`Zkkbfblub
\qZklghklbB[gL_cfbyB[gZe-DZcbf:[mY]eyZ^->Zjbfb
b ^jm]b_ de_\_lZeb \ Z^j_k :eeZoZ b ?]h IjhjhdZ < wlhc `_
]eZ\_fuohlbfijb\_klbijbf_jubode_\_lu\Z^j_kq_luj_o
bfZfh\-hkgh\hiheh`gbdh\ fZaoZ[h\ Fu aZf_lbeb qlh g_dh
:e-;mlu©Ze-EZfZaoZ[byª–Khgijb\_eijbf_jubode_\_lu\_]h
Z^j_k
490
<k\h_cdgb]_©Ze-EZfZaoZ[by[b^]ZlmoZ^^b^mZr-rZjb]ZZe-bkeZfbyª
– K Ze-;mlu ibr_l ©<k_ keh\Z Ze-FZ]kmfb h Z^->Zoey\b y\eyxlky
eh`vxª
491
FmoZffZ^:[mAZojZ©Ze-FZaZob[Ze-bkeZfbyª–K
492
:e-;mlu©Ze-EZfZaoZ[by«ª–K
489
199
lhju_ ex^b g_ lhevdh kqblZxl oZrZ\blkdbo ©mq_guoª kmggb
lZfbghb\ha\_ebqb\Zxlboihwlhfm^Ze__fuohlbfihdZaZlv
hrb[hqghklvwlh]hfg_gby493.
BfZf:[mOZgbnZ
Fm^`Zkkbfblu ijbibkZeb _fm \ukdZau\Zgb_ ©Dlh ]h
\hjbl©Yg_agZx\g_[_fhc=hkih^vbebgZa_fe_ª–lhlg_
\_jguc :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Fbehklb\uc \hag_kky gZ
LjhgªZdZdba\_klgh?]hLjhggZ^k_fvxg_[_kZfb«ª
GZkZfhf^_e_wlheh`vbde_\_lZ\Z^j_k:[mOZgbnu
Wlh \ukdZau\Zgb_ i_j_^Z_l :[m Fmlu] Ze-;Zeob ba\_klguc
e]mgbh[fZgsbdB[gFm]bghg_fkdZaZe©Hggbqlh`_kl\hª
\^jm]hf\ukdZau\ZgbbkdZaZe©HgkeZ[ªBfZf:ofZ^kdZaZe
©G_ke_^m_li_j_^Z\ZlvlhqlhjZkkdZau\Z_lwlhlq_eh\_dª:e;moZjb kdZaZe ©Wlhl q_eh\_d keZ[ hg jZkkdZau\Z_l lh qlh
\a[j_^_l _fm \ ]heh\mª :g-GZkZb kdZaZe ©Hg keZ[ª :[m OZ
lbf kdZaZe ©Hg [ue fmj^`bblhf e`_phfª : Za-AZoZ[b ml
\_j`^Z_l qlh wlhl q_eh\_d \u^mfu\Ze oZ^bku B[g :[m Ze=baa fm^`Zkkbfblkdbc dhff_glZlhj lZoZ\blkdhc Zdu^u l k pblbjmy B[g DZkbjZ ibr_l ©:[m Fmlu] – wlh ZeOZdZf [bg =Z[^meeZ [bg FZkeZfZ Ze-;Zeob BfZf :ofZ^ [bg
OZg[ZeYoty[bgFm]bg=Zfj[bg=ZebZe-NZeeZkZe-;moZjb
:[m>Zm^:[mOZlbfZj-JZab:[mOZlbfFmoZffZ^[bgOb[
[ZgZe-;ZklbB[g=Z^bbZ^->ZjdmlgbijbagZ\Zeb_]hkeZ[uf
i_j_^ZlqbdhfªGh\wlhc`_dgb]_gZkhgihwlhfmih\h
^m ibr_l ©G_ h[jZsZcl_ \gbfZgb_ gZ lh]h dlh wlh hljbpZ
_l«ª – ihwlhfm kZfb hp_gbl_ _]h Djhf_ \ur_mihfygmlh]h
e`_pZ\p_ihqd_i_j_^Zlqbdh\wlh]hjb\ZylZijbkmlkl\m_l:[m
BkfZbeZe-:gkZjbba\_klgucdZdR_comebkeZf_]hkeh\Z\h
h[s_g_ke_^m_lijbgbfZlvihkdhevdmhg[ueg_lhevdhfm^
<wlhfjZa^_e_bkihevah\Zgu^Zggu_ba\\_^_gbyr_coZOZkZgZ[bg=Z
eb Zk-KZddZnZ d dgb]_ ©>Zn] rm[Zo Zl-lZr[bo [b Zdmnn Zl-lZgaboª - >Zj
bfZfZg-GZ\Z\bba^:ffZg]]–K–ijbgZ^e_`Zs_c
i_jm bfZfZ oZnbaZ :[m Ze-NZjZ^`Z =Z[^jZofZgZ B[g Ze->`Z\ab ZeOZg[Zebmf]]bdgb]b©Zk-KZcnZe-oZ^^ªk– 1ijbgZ^
e_`Zs_ci_jmr_coZKZ]b^Z[bgFZ[jmdZZe-DZgm[b
493
200
`Zkkbfblhf gh b ijb^_j`b\Zeky fg_gby h [h`_kl\_gghf \h
iehs_gbb b _^bghkmsghklb ;h]Z k kha^Zgbyfb H[ wlhf aZy\
ey_lB[gL_cfbybfZfZk-Km[db\©:l-LZ[ZdZlZe-dm[jZªl
kkkueZykvgZZa-AZoZ[b
Gh ^Z`_ _keb wlh \ukdZau\Zgb_ bklbggh lh bfZf B[g
=Z[^mkZeyf\©OZeeZj-jmfmaªdZdih\_kl\m_lh[wlhf=ZebZeDZjb\dhff_glZjbbd©:e-NbdoZe-Zd[Zjªkibr_l©Dlh
]h\hjbl©Yg_agZx\g_[_fhc=hkih^vbebgZa_fe_ª–lhl
g_\_jgucihlhfmqlhwlhlq_eh\_d^mfZ_lqlh:eeZomijbkm
s_dZdh_-lhf_klhhgfmrZ[[boª
=Zeb Ze-DZjb dhff_glbjmy h[_ pblZlu ibr_l ©Fu
^he`guijbgylvlhqdmaj_gbyB[g=Z[^mkZeyfZbhldZaZlvkyhl
lhc qlh ijb\_^_gZ \ dhff_glZjbb d lZoZ\blkdhc Zdu^_ :
djhf_ lh]h :[m Fmlu] ih k\b^_l_evkl\m fgh]bo m\Z`Z_fuo
mq_guoba\_klguch[fZgsbdbkhqbgbl_evoZ^bkh\ª
D lhfm `_ bfZf :[m OZgbnZ \ ©:e-<Zkuyª kZf hijh
\_j]ZejZkiheh`_gb_:eeZoZgZLjhg_<dhff_glZjbbd©:eNbdoZe-Zd[ZjªkkdZaZgh©FuijbagZ_fqlh:eeZo\ha
g_kkybklZ\ZgZLjhgghHgg_gm`^Z_lky\g_fHggZg_fg_
kb^bl Hg ojZgbl_ev LjhgZ b \k_o hklZevguo kha^Zgbc ?keb
[uHg\q_f-eb[hgm`^Zekylhg_kfh][ukha^Zlv\k_kms__:
_keb [u Hg gm`^Zeky \ kb^_gbb lh \hagbdZ_l \hijhk ]^_ `_
Hg [ue ^h kha^Zgby LjhgZ <hbklbgm :eeZo ij_\ur_ \k_]h
wlh]hª
BfZfFZebd[bg:gZk
Hgb ml\_j`^Zxl qlh hg kdZaZe ©<hag_k_gb_ ba\_klgh
gh qlh hgh ba k_[y ij_^klZ\ey_l – g_ba\_klgh \_jblv \ g_]h
h[yaZl_evghZkijZrb\Zlvhg_f–[b^]Zª
<lZdhcnhjf_hlg_]hg_[uehaZnbdkbjh\Zghgb^hklh
\_jgh]hgbohjhr_]hgbkeZ[h]h\ukdZau\ZgbyGZkZfhf^_
e_ hg kdZaZe ©DZd wlh ijhbahreh – g_ ih^^Z_lky hkfuke_
gbxgh\hag_k_gb_g_y\ey_lkyq_f-eb[hg_ba\_klguf\_
jZ \ g_]h h[yaZl_evgZ Z kijZrb\Zlv h[ wlhf – [b^]Zª Wlh
hijh\_j]Z_l\k_^h\h^ufm^`Zkkbfblh\
201
B[g Ze-EZ[Zg \ ©BloZn Zk-kZ^Zl Ze-fmllZdbgZª l k
dhff_glbjmy keh\Z FZebdZ ibr_l ©DZd wlh ijhbahreh
g_ih^^Z_lkyhkfuke_gbxªlh_klvg_ih^^Z_lkyhkfuke_gbx
gZ hkgh\_ Zljb[mlh\ ijbkmsbo kha^Zgbyf b ijbibku\Zgb_
wlboZljb[mlh\:eeZomijhlb\hj_qbljZamfmZke_^h\Zl_evgh
bogZebqb_m:eeZoZke_^m_lhljbpZlv©gh\hag_k_gb_g_y\
ey_lkyq_f-eb[hg_ba\_klgufªlh_klvklhqdbaj_gbyyaudh
\_^h\ wlh \iheg_ ykgh_ ihgylb_ B fmkmevfZgbg ^he`_g _]h
ijbagZ\Zlv \ lhc f_j_ \ dhlhjhc hgh khhl\_lkl\m_l [h`_kl
\_gghckmlb:eeZoZihlhfmqlhZev-bklb\ZhlghkblkydjZa^_
eZf\_ju\:eeZoZb?]hdgb]b©KijZrb\Zlvh[wlhf–[b^
]Zª lh _klv gh\h_ ^ey BkeZfZ ihlhfm qlh kih^\b`gbdb Ijh
jhdZk]kihgbfZebyaudh\hckfukewlh]hkeh\ZbljZdlh\Z
eb_]hkhhl\_lkl\_ggh?]h[h`_kl\_gghckmlbDh]^Z`_ihagZ
gby ex^_c hlghkbl_evgh e_dkbdb ZjZ[kdh]h yaudZ klZeb keZ
[ufbhgbklZebimlZlvky\wlhf\hijhk_bbkdZlvgZg_]hhl\_
luª
< ^jm]hf k\h_f \ukdZau\Zgbb bfZf FZebd kdZaZe
©Fbehklb\uc\hag_kkygZljhglZddZdkhh[sbeh[wlhf\Dh
jZg_Bg_ke_^m_laZ^Z\Zlv\hijhk©dZd"ªihkdhevdmwlhl\h
ijhk g_ khhl\_lkl\m_l [h`_kl\_gghc kmsghklbǻ Wlh ykguc
hl\_lfm^`ZkkbfblkdhcZdu^_hkgh\ZgghcgZ\hijhk_©dZd"ªb
hl\_l_gZwlhl\hijhk494.
BfZfZr-RZnb]b
Fm^`Zkkbfblu ijbibku\Zxl _fm keh\Z ©KmggZ dhlh
jhcijb^_j`b\Zxkvyb^jm]b_gZrboZ^bkh\_^umgZke_^h\ZgZ
gZfbhlKmnvygZFZebdZb^jm]bobaZdexqZ_lky\k\b^_l_ev
kl\_ qlh g_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZoZ qlh FmoZffZ^ ?]h ih
keZggbd qlh :eeZo gZ ljhg_ \ g_[_kZo ih K\h_fm `_eZgbx
fh`_lijb[eb`ZlvkydK\hbfkha^Zgbyfbgbkoh^blv\g_[_kZ
wlh]h fbjZ«ª b l^ WlZ pblZlZ ijb\_^_gZ \ ©FmolZkZj Ze-
Kf ©BloZn Zk-kZ^Zl Ze-fmllZdbgZª – L K ©>Zn] Zr-rm[Zo ZllZr[boª - K – OZkZg Zk-KZddZn ©DblZ[ ]Zdb^Z Zoe Zk-kmggZ \Z Ze^`ZfZ]Zª–K-30.
494
202
]mexªkkhkkuedhcgZr_comebkeZfZ:[mZe-OZkZgZZeOZdZjbboZnbaZ:[mFmoZffZ^Z[bgB^jbkZZr-RZnb]b
<k_ wlh]h eh`v wlb keh\Z ijbibkZgu bfZfm ZrRZnb]b^Zb\p_ehfdgb]Z©FmolZkZjZe-]mexªy\ey_lky^h
\hevghijhlb\hj_qb\hc495.
Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky i_j_^Zlqbdh\ wlh]h \ukdZau\Zgby lh
lZdgZau\Z_fucr_comebkeZf:[mZe-OZkZgZe-OZdZjb[ueba
\_klguf h[fZgsbdhf \u^mfu\Z\rbf oZ^bku OZnba ZaAZoZ[b\©FbaZgZe-b]lb^ZeªlkkdZaZehg_fke_^m
xs__©:[mZe-DZkbf[bgZe-=ZkZdbjkdZaZeqlhwlhlq_eh\_d
g_ [ue gZ^_`guf : B[g Zg-GZ^`Zj khh[sZe qlh hg [ue h[
\bg_g\\u^mfu\ZgbboZ^bkh\bp_ihq_ddgbfª;bgOZ^`Zj\
©EbkZg Ze-fbaZgª bg^bckdh_ ba^Zgb_ kdZaZe ©;hev
rbgkl\h _]h oZ^bkh\ [ueb kljZggufb hl\_j]gmlufb b \u^m
fZggufb G_dhlhju_ oZ^bkh\_^u kdZaZeb qlh hg \u^mfu\Ze
oZ^bkudh]^Z`be\:knZoZg_ªR_coZk-KZddZndhff_glbjmy
wlh kdZaZe ©B[g L_cfby Ze-OZjjZgb \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©Ze<ZkuylmZe-dm[jZnbZe-]Zdb^Z\ZZ^-^Z]\ZªgZau\Z_lwlh]hh[
fZgsbdZ r_comebkeZfhf :[m FmoZffZ^ Ze-FZd^Zkb kdZaZe
qlhhg[uefm^`Zkkbfblhfbihwlhfmmq_gu_ba^Zebn_\lmh
^ha\he_gghklb _]h dZagb Kf dgb]m ³Za-AZce ]Zey ZjjZm^ZlZcgb´ª
DZd [ueh kdZaZgh \ur_ fm^`Zkkbfblu ml\_j`^Zxl
qlh \ukdZau\Zgb_ bfZfZ Zr-RZnb]b [ueh i_j_^Zgh hl g_]h
:[m Rm]Zc[hf gh dZd ba\_klgh wlhl q_eh\_d jh^beky q_j_a
^\Z]h^Zihke_kf_jlbZr-RZnb]bkf©LZjbo;Z]^Z^ª
LZdZdu^Zdhlhjmxfm^`ZkkbfbluiulZxlkyijbibkZlvbfZfm
Zr-RZnb]b gZ kZfhf ^_e_ _fm g_ ijbgZ^e_`bl bfZf ZaAZoZ[b \ ©EbkZg Ze-fbaZgª ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l
©Wlhfm q_eh\_dm ijbibkZeb fgh]h_ b \ qZklghklb \u^mfZg
guc oZ^bk h ij_bfms_kl\Zo ghqb =ZrmjZ b Zdu^m ZrRZnb]bǻ
>Ze__Zk-KZddZnibr_l©<hafh`ghZe-=ZrZjbmihfy
gmluc\p_ihqd_i_j_^Zlqbdh\y\ey_lkyl_f`_q_eh\_dhfqlh
495
IjbgZ^e_`bli_jmGZkujZZe-:e[Zgb
203
bZe-OZdZjb?s_h^gbf\u^mfsbdhf\wlhcp_ihqd_y\ey_lky
B[gDZ^brdhlhjuclZd`_\u^mfu\ZeoZ^bkuDh]^Zyijhq_e
dgb]m ©LZ[^b^ Za-aZeyf Ze-fmoZcyfª k ijbgZ^e_`Zsmx
i_jmZe-DZmkZjblhh[gZjm`beke_^mxs__©:du^Zijbibku
\Z_fZybfZfmZr-RZnb]bmZe-DmjZgby\ey_lkyde_\_lhc\_]h
Z^j_k b i_j_^Z_lky q_j_a h[fZgsbdh\ Ze-=ZrZjb b B[g DZ^b
rZª LZdbf h[jZahf \k_ ihiuldb ijbibkZlv bfZfm ZrRZnb]b fm^`Zkkbfblkdmx Zdu^m [ueb ls_lgufb O\ZeZ :e
eZom
BfZf:ofZ^[bgOZg[Ze
<ZooZ[bluh[ty\eyxlk_[yihke_^h\Zl_eyfbbfZfZ:o
fZ^Zbl_fkZfufde_\_smlgZg_]hbihahjyl_]h<hlebqb_hl
gbohggbdh]^Zg_h[ty\eye^ha\he_gghcdjh\vfmkmevfZg^Z
`__kebhgb[uebfm[lZ^b]Zfb\©FmolZkZjZj-jZ\^Zªihwlh
fmih\h^mkdZaZgh©?kebq_eh\_dijbagZ_lh[_rZoZ^ulhfu
g_ fh`_f ijbagZlv _]h g_\_jguf ^Z`_ \ lhf kemqZ_ _keb hg
fm[lZ^b]Fu^he`guihiulZlvky^ZlvljZdlh\dm_]hkeh\Zfb
ihklmidZfZfh`_l[ulvhgaZimlZekyLhqghlZdh]h`_fg_
gby ijb^_j`b\Zeky gZr mqbl_ev :[m Ze-=Z[[Zk B[g L_c
fbyª496<ZooZ[blu`_gZjmrbebwlbijbgpbiubgZqZebm[b
\Zlv fmkmevfZg lhevdh aZ lh qlh hgb kh\_jrZxl dZdmx-eb[h
[b^]Z <ZooZ[blu hde_\_lZeb bfZfZ :ofZ^Z lZd `_ dZd hde_
\_lZeb _]h ij_^r_kl\_ggbdh\ Ze-DZgm[b ih wlhfm ih\h^m ib
r_l ©BfZf :ofZ^ ih^\_j]ky ly`_ehfm bkiulZgbx g_\_`^u
ijbibkZeb_fmjZaebqgu_ba\jZs_ggu_\ukdZau\Zgby\h[eZk
lb Zdu^u H[ wlhf aZy\eyxl B[g Ze->`Z\ab B[g Zk-KZeZo
B[g=Z[^mkZeyfbfZfZk-Km[db_]hkugZl-LZ^`Za-AZoZ[bb
^jm]b_ª497.
Djhf_\ur_mihfygmlh]hhgbijbibkZebbfZfm:ofZ^m
djblbdm ^`ZofbafZ Za-AZoZ[b ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©«hg
g_ ibkZe ©:j-JbkZeZ Ze-bklZo[Zjbª b g_ djblbdh\Ze ^`Zofb
lh\ \k_ wlh _fm ijbibkZebª >Ze__ hg ijb\h^bl [he__ dhg
Kme_cfZg[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[©Zk-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyobyª–Kkhkkuedhc
gZ©FmolZkZjZj-jZ\^Zª
497
R_coKZ]b^[bgFZ[jmdZe-DZgm[b©Zk-KZcnZe-oZ^^ª–K
496
204
dj_lgu_ ijbf_ju b aZy\ey_l ©Deygmkv :eeZohf bfZf :ofZ^
g_]h\hjbeih^h[gh_imklv:eeZoih]m[blwlbode_\_lgbdh\ª
>Ze__hgaZy\ey_l©Ihkfhljbl_gZwlbog_\_`_kl\_gguooZ^b
kh\_^h\ hgb agZeb qlh \k_ wlh ijbibkZgh bfZfm :ofZ^m b
fheqZebª498.
OZrZ\bluaZimlu\ZxlfmkmevfZgkdmxfukev
Ohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhoZrZ\blu^Z`_g_mf_xlqblZlv
ijhkluf^hdZaZl_evkl\hfwlh]hkem`bllhlnZdlqlh\h\j_fy
oZ^`Z]]mk_j^ghjZa^Z\Zebi_j\h_ba^Zgb_dgb]b
dhlhjmx\uqblZ_l_Gh_keb^hbok\_^_gby^hoh^blqlh-eb[h
ijhlb\hj_qZs__ bo m[_`^_gbyf lh hgb ijbeZ]Zxl \k_ mkbeby
^ey_]hmgbqlh`_gbyGb`_fuohlbfijb\_klbijbf_ju[hjv
[u oZrZ\blh\ k jZaebqgufb ijhy\e_gbyfb fmkmevfZgkdhc
fukeb
<h-i_j\uohgbmgbqlh`Zxl\k_dgb]bijhlb\hj_qZsb_
bo m[_`^_gbyf Bf_ggh ihwlhfm [ueZ kh``_gZ ZjZ[kdZy [b[
ebhl_dZ\F_dd_K_]h^gy`_hgbaZqZklmxkdmiZxllbjZ`dgb
]bdhlhjZybfg_gjZ\blkybk`b]Zxl__Qlh`_dZkZ_lkydgb]
K_b^Z Dml[Z lh hgb \hh[s_ aZij_s_gu \ \ZooZ[blkdbo kljZ
gZo
<h-\lhjuohgbijb[_]ZxldbkdZ`_gbxba\_klguoj_^
dbo dgb] qlh-lh ^h[Z\eyxl qlh-lh m[Z\eyxl Z aZl_f ba^Zxl
wlbdgb]b
Bfb[ueba^Zgk[hjgbdZe-;moZjb\nhjf_gZ[hjZlh
g_gvdbo dgb`_q_d gh i_j_^ _]h ba^Zgb_f hgb [_a ij_^mij_`
^_gbym^Zebebbawlhcdgb]bg_dhlhju_oZ^bku
R_coFmoZffZ^GmjbZ^->bkmjb\k\h_cdgb]_©Jm
^m^ ]Zey rm[moZl Zk-kZeZnbyª k ibr_l ©Ex[bfuf ^_
ehf kZeZnblh\ y\ey_lky bkdZ`_gb_ b m^Ze_gb_ oZ^bkh\ GZ
ijbf_jGm]fZgZe-:emkbbkdZabelZnkbjk\h_]hhlpZbjZdkdh
]h r_coZ FZofm^Z Ze-:emkb ©Jmo Ze-fZ]Zgbª _keb [u g_ wlh
bkdZ`_gb_ lh wlZ dgb]Z [ueZ [u ijbagZgZ h^gbf ba kZfuo
emqrbobiheguodhff_glZjb_\DhjZgZª
498
:a-AZoZ[b©KbyjZ]eyfZg-gm[Zeyª–L–K
205
BkdZ`_gb_ lZnkbjZ ©:e-DZrrZnª ijbgZ^e_`Zs_]h
i_jmZa-AZfZorZjbWlhllZnkbjkbkijZ\e_gbyfbbbkdZ`_gb
yfb [ue ba^Zg \ wj-Jby^_ \ ba^Zl_evkl\_ ©:e-=Z[bdZgª GZ
ijbf_j \ DhjZg_ kdZaZgh ©EbpZ \ lhl ^_gv [m^ml kbylv b
\abjZlvgZ=hkih^Zk\h_]hª 75:22 –\ZooZ[blum^Zebeb\k_
dhff_glZjbb Za-AZfZorZjb b \klZ\beb k\hb \ j_amevlZl_ ih
emqbekygh\uc\ZooZ[blkdbcZg_aZfZorZjblkdbclZnkbj
Hgb i_j_ba^Zeb dgb]m ©Ze-Fm]gbª ijbgZ^e_`Zsmx
i_jm B[g Dm^Zfu Ze-OZg[Zeb b m^Zebeb p_emx ]eZ\m ©:eBklb]ZgZª©Ihbkdihfhsbª
Hgb i_j_ba^Zeb k[hjgbd FmkebfZ ij_^\Zjbl_evgh
bkdexqb\ ba g_]h oZ^bku ih\_kl\mxsb_ h [h`_kl\_gguo Zl
jb[mlZo
Hgb \ ] ] \ wj-Jby^_ ba^-\h ©>Zj Zeom^Zª i_j_ba^Zeb dgb]m ©:e-:adZjª ijbgZ^e_`Zsmx i_jm
bfZfZZg-GZ\Z\bbbkdZabebkeh\ZZ\lhjZZlhqlhg_kfh]eb
bkdZablvijhklhm^Zebeb<qZklghklbba]eZ\uhoZ^`_[ueh
m^Ze_gh\k_qlhk\yaZghkihk_s_gb_ffh]beuIjhjhdZk]k
Hgbba^Zebdgb]m©:e-B[ZgZnbmkmeZ^-^bygZªijb
gZ^e_`Zsmxi_jm:[mZe-OZkZgZZe-:r]Zjbbm^Zebebbag__
\k_qlhijhlb\hj_qblboba\jZs_gghcZdu^_<qZklghklbhgb
m^Zebeb_]hkeh\Z©Ih^\hag_k_gb_f:eeZoZgZLjhgbf__lky
\\b^mlhqlhHgkdZaZeblhlkfukedhlhjucHg\eh`be\wlh
keh\hWlh\hag_k_gb_g_hsmsZ_fhg_k\yaZghkjZkiheh`_gb
_f jZaf_s_gb_f \hiehs_gb_f b i_j_^\b`_gb_f G_ Ljhg
^_j`bl :eeZoZ Z :eeZo ^_j`bl Ljhg b Zg]_eh\ ih^^_j`b\Z
xsbo _]h K\h_c ;h`_kl\_gghc fbehklvx Hg \ur_ LjhgZ b
\ur_ \k_]h kms_]h h^gZdh wlh g_ k\yaZgh k _]h [ebahklvx d
Ljhgmbdg_[_kZfHg\ur_LjhgZK\h_ckl_i_gvxlZd`_dZd
\ur_ K\h_c kl_i_gvx q_f \k_ kms__ Gh g_kfhljy gZ wlh Hg
[ebahd d dZ`^hfm K\h_fm kha^Zgbx Z d q_eh\_dm [eb`_ q_f
_]h yj_fgZy \_gZ B Hg y\ey_lky k\b^_l_e_f \k_o kh[ulbcª
=^_`_wlbij_djZkgu_keh\Z499?
499
Kfmr_coZOZkZgZZk-KZddZnZ
206
AmoZcj Zr-RZ\br b GZkuj Ze-:e[Zgb ihklmibeb
hq_gvg_dhjj_dlghihhlghr_gbxdbfZfmZk-Km[dbAgZyqlh
hgy\ey_lkyyjufZglbfm^`Zkkbfblhfhgb\g_keb_]hkeh\Z\
ba\jZs_gguc dhff_glZjbc lZoZ\blkdhc Zdu^u ijbgZ^e_`Z
sbc i_jm B[g :[m Ze-=baaZ Hgb \ayeb wlm pblZlm ba dgb]b
©Fm]b^ Zg-gb]Zfª b bkdZab\ \dexqbeb \ mihfygmluc dhf
f_glZjbc \ ke_^mxs_f \b^_ ©<k_ wlb q_luj_ fZaoZ[Z aZ bk
dexq_gb_fg_dhlhjuofmlZabeblh\bfm^`Zkkbfblh\ijb^_j
`b\Zxlky h^ghc Zdu^u Hgb \k_ ijb^_j`b\Zxlky bklbgghc
lZoZ\blkdhc Zdu^u ijbgylhc jZggbfb b iha^gbfb mq_gufbª
GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ bfZf Zk-Km[db \ ©Fm]b^ Zg-gb]Zfª k ibr_l ©OZgZnblu rZnb]blu fZebdblu b m\Z`Z_fu_ oZg[Z
eblu ke_^mxl h^ghc b lhc `_ Zdu^_ Zoe Zk-kmggZ \Z Ze^`ZfZ]Z baeh`_gghc \ mq_gbb :[m Ze-OZkZgZ Ze-:r]Zjb
Ebrv qZklv oZgZnblh\ b rZnb]blh\ ijbgyeZ fmlZabebaf Z
qZklv oZg[Zeblh\ fm^`Zkkbfbaf qlh `_ dZkZ_lky fZebdblh\
lhhgb\k_[_abkdexq_gbyy\eyxlkyZr]ZjblZfbMihfygmlh_
Zr]Zjblkdh_ mq_gb_ aZdexq_gh \ Zdu^_ :[m >`Z]nZjZ ZlLZoZ\b ijbgylhc b ba[jZgghc mq_gufb \k_o fZaoZ[h\ǻ
KjZ\gbl_wlb^\_pblZlublh]^Z\uihcf_l_dZdaZb]ju\Zxl
ik_\^hkZeZnblukfmkmevfZgkdbfgZke_^b_f500.
<-lj_lvbohgbkhdjZsZxldgb]bba\_klguofmkmevfZg
kdbo Z\lhjh\ Zj]mf_glbjmy wlh l_f qlh `_eZxl h[e_]qblv bo
^ey qblZl_ey Gh ijb wlhf m^Zeyxl ^h\hevgh bgl_j_kgu_ b
\Z`gu_l_abkuZbgh]^Zbp_eu_]eZ\uLZdh\hboij_^Zl_ev
kl\h\hlghr_gbbba\_klg_crbomq_guo^ZgZdZ`_lbo:eeZo
ihaZkem]Zf<_^v?fm\_^hfhlhqlhkdjulhhlgZk501.
<-q_l\_jluo hgb ba^Zxl dgb]b ba\_klguo mq_guo
ij_^\Zjbl_evgh m^Zeb\ ba gbo dhff_glZjbb < qZklghklb hgb
ba^Zebdgb]m©:e-:kfZ\ZZk-kunZlªZe-;ZcoZdbghi_j_^ba
^Zgb_f m^Zebeb ba g__ dgb]m ©NmjdZg Ze-DmjZgª r_coZ Ze=ZaZfbb\\_^_gb_hlZe-DZmkZjbDjhf_lh]hhgbg_mdZaZeb
Kfmr_coZOZkZgZZk-KZddZnZ\©:l-LZg^b^[bfZg]Z^Z^ZZl-lZ\ob^ª
k–mgZk_kl_kl\_gghijb\h^blkykkhdjZs_gb_f
501
>ey [he__ ihegh]h hk\_^hfe_gby kf FmoZffZ^ Ze-DZkbjb ©:kKZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-bfZfbyª–K– 508.
500
207
qlh ihykg_gby d l_dklm Ze-;ZcoZdb ijbgZ^e_`Zl i_jm ZeDZmkZjbZ\ke_^mxs_fba^Zgbb\hh[s_m^Zebeb\k_ijbf_qZ
gbyZe-DZmkZjb
<-iyluo ba^Zgb_ h^ghbf_gguo dgb] < qZklghklb hgb
gZibkZeb dgb]m ©Ze-:kfZ \Z Zk-kunZlª b ijbibkZeb __ B[g
L_cfbb ohly hg gbdh]^Z \ `bagb gbq_]h ih^h[gh]h g_ ibkZe
Dgb]ZklZdbfgZa\Zgb_fijbgZ^e_`bli_jmbfZfZZe-;ZcoZdb
Z \ZooZ[blu ba^Zeb k\hx lhevdh ^ey lh]h qlh[u \\_klb fm
kmevfZg \ aZ[em`^_gb_ >jm]Zy dgb]Z ijbibkZggZy B[g L_c
fbb gZau\Z_lky ©>ZdZbd Zl-lZnkbjª H[_ wlb dgb]b kh^_j`Zl
ebrvg_dhlhju_ba_]hn_l\
<-r_kluo l_jjhj ijhlb\ mq_guo Hgb \udjZeb r_coZ
GZkujZ Zk-KZ]b^Z ba Eb\ZgZ JZa\_jgmeb ljZ\ex r_coZoZ^bkh\_^Z=Z[^meeuZe-OZ[Zrbh[\bgb\_]h\lhfqlhhgkh
a^Zegh\ucoZ[ZrblkdbcfZaoZ[ohlygZkZfhf^_e_wlhlmq_
guc ijb^_j`b\Z_lky Zr]Zjblkdbo m[_`^_gbc JZa\_jgmeb
ljZ\ex r_coZ Ze-FZddb FmoZffZ^Z Ze-=me\b Ze-FZebdb <k_
wlh^_eZ_lky^eylh]hqlh[ug_\kieueZbklbgZ
<-k_^vfuo hgb jZa\_jgmeb ljZ\ex g_m]h^guo ba^Z
l_evkl\ < qZklghklb h^ghc ba bo `_jl\ [ueh ba^Zl_evkl\h
©>ZjZe-bfZfZg-GZ\Z\bª\Bhj^Zgbbdhlhjh_\dhg_qghfblh
]_hgbih^qbgbebk_[_AZqZklmx\ufh`_l_m\b^_lvqlhfgh
]b_babodgb]\uoh^yl[_amihfbgZgbygZa\Zgbyba^Zl_evkl\Z
<-\hkvfuodjZ`Zbmgbqlh`_gb_jmdhibk_c<qZklghk
lb hgb i_j_ba^Zeb dgb]m oZnbaZ Za-AZoZ[b ©Kbyj Z]eyf Zggm[Zeyª Z ^\Z^pZlv lj_lbc lhf kh^_j`Zsbc djblbdm \ Z^j_k
r_coZB[gL_cfbbg_[ueba^Zg=h\hjylqlhhg[ueml_jyg
Dm^Z `_ fh]eZ ^_lvky wlZ dmevlmjgh-bklhjbq_kdZy p_gghklv"
G_lkhfg_gby\lhfqlhoZrZ\bluihklZjZebkv^eylh]hqlh[u
kdjulv __ hl ]eZa fmkmevfZg G_^Z\gh \ h^ghf ba bhj^Zgkdbo
mgb\_jkbl_lh\[ueihcfZgklm^_gl-oZrZ\bldhlhjuchklZ\Ze
ky\[b[ebhl_d_gZghqvbdjhfkZegZqZklbdgb]bg_khhl\_l
kl\mxsb_ bo m[_`^_gbyf G_kfhljy gZ lh qlh hgb iulZxlky
kdjulvbklbgmbfg_m^Zklkykdjulvk\_l[h`_kl\_gghcj_eb
]bb
208
<-^_\yluo hgb bkihevamxl dZiblZeu ^ey j_deZfu k\h
boba\jZs_gguom[_`^_gbcbih^Z\e_gby\k_ohklZevguoijh
y\e_gbcqbklhcfmkmevfZgkdhcfukeb
>ZoZrZ\bluijbdeZ^u\Zxl\k_mkbebb^eylh]hqlh[u
ba\jZlblv fmkmevfZgkdmx fukev hgb ijbibku\Zxl fmkmev
fZgkdbf mq_gufkeh\Zdhlhju_l_g_]h\hjbebJ_deZfbjmxl
k\hbo mq_guo qlh[u \hag_klb bo gZ mjh\_gv fmkmevfZgkdbo
k\_lbegZmdbJZa\_hgb^hklb]ebmki_oZ":eeZo\DhjZg_kdZ
aZe ©Hgb lsZlky k\hbfb mklZfb ih]Zkblv k\_l :eeZoZ Gh
:eeZo `_eZ_l aZ\_jrblv K\hc k\_l dZd [u g_gZ\bklgh wlh
gb[uehg_\_jgufªG_kfhljygZwlhgZfke_^m_lih^hc
lb d wlhc ijh[e_f_ k_jv_agh ih^gylv __ gZ k_f_cguc b ]hkm
^Zjkl\_ggucmjh\_gv:dlb\ghba^Z\Zlvijhba\_^_gbyfmkmev
fZgkdbodeZkkbdh\qlh[u\ZooZ[blug_mki_ebbg_kfh]ebbo
bkdZablv
G_gZ\bklvB[gL_cfbbdqe_gZfIjhjhq_kdh]h
^hfZ
B[g L_cfby [ue j_\ghklguf ihdehggbdhf Hf_y^h\
Ihwlhfmhg\uklmiZe\boaZsblmbh[\bgyeboijhlb\gbdh\Z
bf_ggh=Zeb[bg:[mLZeb[Zj:]Hgh[\bgbe_]hih^\Z^
pZlbk_fbimgdlZfml\_j`^ZyqlhhggZjmrbeiheh`_gbyDh
jZgZZ_^bgkl\_gguf_]hklj_fe_gb_f[uehklj_fe_gb_d\eZ
klb<k\h_cdgb]_©:e-FbgoZ^`ª502hgibkZe©GZfg_ke_^h
\Zehijbky]Zlv=Zebdhlhjuc[ue^Ze_dhlihgylbykijZ\_^eb
\hklb FmkmevfZgkdb_ mq_gu_ kh]eZkgu k l_f qlh \hcgu dh
lhju_\_e=Zebg_[uebh[yaZl_evgufbbl_f[he__jZaj_r_g
gufbª b ^Ze__ ©G_l [he__ m`Zkgh]h ^_ygby q_f ijheblb_
djh\b lukyq g_\bgguo fmkmevfZg < m[bckl\_ wlbo ex^_c g_
[ueh gbdZdhc – gb j_eb]bhaghc gb fbjkdhc – ihevau Wlh
lhevdhkihkh[kl\h\ZehjhklmaeZ\fbj_ªWlbfbkeh\ZfbB[g
L_cfby \uklmiZ_l \ aZsblm ijhlb\gbdh\ =Zeb \ RZf_ gZ kZ
fhf `_ ^_e_ =Zeb ihklmiZe kh]eZkgh Zylm ©Lh kjZ`Zcl_kv
ijhlb\ lhc dhlhjZy g_kijZ\_^eb\Zª Gh ^ey B[g L_c
502
B[gL_cfby©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZZg-gZ[Z\byª– 2/203 –b
209
fbbwlhg_^h\h^hgh[\bgy_l=Zeb\Zf[bpbyo\`_eZgbbk_
ylv l_jjhj ©«lZdbf h[jZahf ihklmiZe NZjZhgª ©«g_ [m^_l
kqZkleb\\Km^guc^_gvlhldlhk__ll_jjhjª503.
B[gL_cfby^eyih^^_j`dbbijhiZ]Zg^uHf_y^h\ih
]m[b\rboijZ\_^gucoZebnZlbij_\jZlb\rbo_]h\fhgZjobx
g_]gmrZ_lkygbq_fhg^Z`_]hlh\h[ty\blvkeZ[ufboZ^bku
bf_xsb_kl_i_gv^hklh\_jghklbfmlZ\Zlbj
<hl qlh hg ibr_l ih ih\h^m oZ^bkZ h =ZffZj_ ©L_[y
m[v_l ]jmiiZ [mglZj_cª ©Ih ih\h^m oZ^bkZ h =ZffZj_ y ohqm
kdZaZlv wlbf ex^yf qlh g_dhlhju_ gZreb \ g_f g_^hklZl
dbª504 b ^Ze__ ©: g_dhlhju_ oZjZdl_jbah\Zeb _]h dZd keZ
[ucª505.
B dZd \k_]^Z B[g L_cfby506 hrb[Z_lky >Zgguc oZ^bk
bf__lkl_i_gv^hklh\_jghklbfmlZ\Zlbjihlhfmqlh[uei_j_
^Zg ^\Z^pZlvx q_lujvfy kih^\b`gbdZfb IjhjhdZ k]k H
lhfqlhhgy\ey_lkyfmlZ\ZlbjmdZau\ZxloZnbaZk-Kmxlu\
©:e-OZkZbk Ze-dm[jZª oZnba FmjlZ^Z Za-Am[_c^b \
©EZdl Ze-Zebª – Ze-FZgZ\b \ ©RZjo Ze-^`Zfb] ZkkZ]bjªNZc^Ze-dZ^bjB[g=Z[^me[Zjjihwlhfmih\h
^m \ ©:e-Bklb]Z[ª dhff_glZjbb d ©:e-BkZ[Zª ibr_l
©Iml_f fmlZ\Zlbj hl IjhjhdZ k]k [ue i_j_^Zg oZ^bk
©=ZffZj l_[y m[v_l ]jmiiZ [mglZj_cª Wlhl oZ^bk kqblZ_lky
h^gbf ba kZfuo ^hklh\_jguo < g_f Ijhjhd k]k khh[sZ_l
gZfhkh[ulbyo[m^ms_]hZe-]Zc[ªB[gOZ^`Zj\©NZloZe[Zjbªijb\h^blbf_gZkZoZ[h\i_j_^Z\rbowlhloZ^bk
ZaZl_fmdZau\Z_l©«<wlhfoZ^bk_gZfi_j_^Zghhkh[h_ijh
jhq_kdh_agZgb_hgy\ghk\b^_l_evkl\m_l\ihevamkl_i_gb=Z
ebb=ZffZjZbdjblbdm_lboijhlb\gbdh\«507»
LZf`_– 2/202 – 205, 232 – 234.
LZf`_– 2/204.
505
LZf`_– 2/208.
506
Ihih\h^mfgh]bo\hijhkh\hgaZy\ey_lhkms_kl\h\Zgbbb^`fZ]Zohly
gZkZfhf^_e_lZdh\h]hg_lKfjZa^_eh[B[gL_cfbb\gZqZe_dgb]b
507
B ihke_ wlh]h oZrZ\blu hkf_eb\Zxlky ml\_j`^Zlv qlh B[g L_cfby g_
y\ey_lkynZgZlbdhf
503
504
210
H[\bgyy bfZfZ =Zeb B[g L_cfby \ ©:e-FbgoZ^`«ª
ibr_l ©FmZ\by bagZqZevgh [ue ijhlb\ \hcgu hg
klj_fbekydfbjmZ_]hijhlb\gbd`Z`^Ze\h_\Zlvª>Ze__hg
^h\hevgh aZimlZgguf kihkh[hf ihdZau\Z_l qlh =Zeb ij_^Ze
\kx fmkmevfZgkdmx mffm ©Ze-FbgoZ^`«ª – 237):
©Fu g_ fh`_f hljbpZlv lhl nZdl qlh =Zeb gZagZqZe k\hbo
jh^kl\_ggbdh\gZjZaebqgu_hl\_lkl\_ggu_ihklu\h_\Zeijh
lb\ fmkmevfZg b m[b\Ze ^Z`_l_odlhkh\_jrZefhebl\u\u
ieZqb\ZeaZdylbihklbekyªDh]^Z`__fmijbrehkvaZsbsZlv
kih^\b`gbdh\ ba qbkeZ `bl_e_c Zg-GZoZjZ\ZgZ hg gZibkZe
©H^gZdhkj_^bgbo[uebex^bdhlhju_kjZ`Zebkvb\dZq_kl
\_ ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z k\h_c ijZ\hlu bf_eb k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu b
b^`fZ]ª
B[g L_cfby bkihevam_l \k_ \hafh`ghklb qlh[u mgb
ablv =Zeb ©Kj_^b q_luj_o ba\_klguo bfZfh\ g_l gb h^gh]h
dlhkkueZeky[ugZ=Zeb\\hijhkZonbdoZFZebdmqbekymf_
^bgp_\ dhlhju_ g_ hibjZebkv gZ fg_gby =Zeb :[m OZgbnZ
Zr-RZnb]bb:ofZ^h[jZsZebkvdjb\ZylZfB[g=Z[[ZkZdh
lhjuc [ue g_aZ\bkbfuf fm^`lZob^hf b ^Z`_ g_ ijbkemrb
\Zekyd=Zebª508LZdmxkl_i_gv\]eZaZoB[gL_cfbbaZgbfZ_l
=Zebkih^\b`gbddgZke_^bxdhlhjh]hh[jZsZebkv\k_q_lu
j_bfZfZ509.
;he__ lh]h B[g L_cfby kh\_jrbe _s_ [he__ ih^euc
ihklmihdhgh[\bgbe^hqvIjhjhdZk]kNZlufm\lhfqlh
hgZ[ueZkdehggZdebp_f_jbxhdhlhjhf:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZ
aZe©Kj_^bfmgZnbdh\_klvlZdb_dlhaehkeh\blhl_[_ba-aZ
fbehklugb ?keb bf i_j_iZ^_l qlh-eb[h ba fbehklugb lh
hgb jZ^u Z _keb `_ g_ i_j_iZ^_l lh hgb k_j^ylkyª (9:58).
<hlqlhhgibr_l©BhgZihklmibeZlhqghlZd`_dh]^Z:[m
©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZª– 4/142 – 143.
;he__ lh]h r_co oZ^bkh\_^ =Z[^meeZ [bg Zk-KZ^ud Ze-=ZfZjb \ ©:kKm[oZk-kZnbjªkibr_l©G_dhlhju_gZau\Zxl_]hr_comebkeZfhfGZ
kZfhf`_^_e_hg[uegZku[blhf\jZ]hf=ZebHgh[\bgbeNZlufm\lhf
qlhhgZ[ueZkdehggZdebp_f_jbxª<hllZdh\hgwlhlr_comebkeZf
508
509
211
;Zdj hldZaZeky \u^_eblv _c ^hex ba gZke_^kl\Z IjhjhdZ
k]kª510.
>hlZdhcih^ehklb_s_gbdlhg_himkdZeky^Z`_bm^_b
aZdeylu_ \jZ]b mffu g_ ]h\hjbeb ih^h[gh_ h =Zeb Lhevdh
B[g L_cfby kdZaZe qlh =Zeb klj_fbeky d \eZklb lhevdh hg
kdZaZeqlh=Zeb^Ze_dhlkijZ\_^eb\hklblhevdhhggZa\Ze_]h
[mglZj_fbmih^h[b\_]hNZjZhgmaZy\beqlh=Zebg_aZkem
`b\Z_l JZy JZa\_ fh] =Zeb [ulv lZdbf dZdbf _]h hibku\Z_l
B[gL_cfby"<_^vhg[ueq_l\_jlufijZ\_^gufoZebnhfih^
agZf_gZfbdhlhjh]hkjZ`Zebkvkih^\b`gbdbIjhjhdZk]k
IhabpbyB[gL_cfbbhlghkbl_evgh=Zebijb\h^bl_]hd
ijhlb\hj_qbx Hg h[\bgy_l \ lbjZgbb =Zeb gh g_ h[\bgy_l
Zedh]hebdZYab^Zm[b\r_]h\gmdZIjhjhdZk]kZe-Omk_cgZ
HijZ\^u\Zy _]h ihklmihd hg ibr_l ©Yab^ g_ [he__ ]j_r_g
q_fbm^_bHgbm[b\Zebk\hboijhjhdh\ihwlhfmm[bckl\hZeOmk_cgZ g_ fh`_l [ulv [he__ ]j_oh\guf ihklmdhfª511 B[g
L_cfbyg_\b^blgbq_]hkljZrgh]h\lhfqlhFmZ\byhljZ\be
Ze-OZkZgZZYab^m[beZe-Omk_cgZKkueZykvgZbm^__\hg]h
\hjblqlhhgbkh\_jrZeb_s_[he__m`Zkgu_ihklmidbZ:e
eZoebrvjZa]g_\ZekygZgbomgbabebijhdeye©Bhgbih^\_j
]ebkvmgb`_gbx[_^ghklbb]g_\m:eeZoZaZlhqlhhgbhijh
\_j]Zeb agZf_gby :eeZoZ b m[b\Zeb [_a \kydhc ijbqbgu ijhjh
dh\aZlhqlhhkemrZebkv:eeZoZbij_klmibebª (2:61).
B[g L_cfby kqblZe qlh Ze-Omk_cg [bg =Zeb ]hkih^bg
fheh^_`b JZy \uklmib\ ijhlb\ Yab^Z hrb[ky < ©:eFbgoZ^`«ªhgihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l©Wlhg_\_jghHl_]h
ihklmidZ [hevr_ aeZ q_f ^h[jZ <k_ dlh \uklmiZ_l ijhlb\
ijZ\bl_ey gZ^_e_ggh]h \eZklvx klj_fylky d aem Z g_ d ^h[
jmª512.
B[gL_cfby©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZª–LZd`_kfmoZnbaZ:ofZ^Z
Ze-=ZfZjb ©=Zeb [bg :[m LZeb[ bfZf Ze-]Zjbnbgª – K - R_co Ze=ZfZjbmihfbgZ_lkeh\ZB[gL_cfbbhlhfqlhm=Zebihlmibebkvgh]lbhl
kbevghc\jZ`^u\hlghr_gbb`_gijhjhdZk]k
511
©FbgoZ^`Zk-kmggZ«ª– 2/247.
512
LZf`_– 2/241.
510
212
<hagbdZ_l \hijhk ihq_fm `_ B[g L_cfby b \ZooZ[blu
lZdhlghkylkydqe_gZfijhjhq_kdh]h^hfZ"Y^mfZxqlhgZb
[he__ \_jguf hl\_lhf [m^ml keh\Z ijhn_kkhjZ Ze-=ZddZ^Z
©IjbagZgb_ ijZ\hlu Ze-Omk_cgZ Z\lhfZlbq_kdb mdZau\Z_l gZ
lbjZgbx Yab^Z B \k_]^Z gZfgh]h e_]q_ h[\bgblv mr_^r_]h
ijZ\bl_eyq_fgZklhys_]hª513.
DZd\b^bl_B[gL_cfbyhq_gvkbevghaZ[em`^Z_lkygh
g_kfhljygZwlhkh\j_f_ggu_ik_\^hkZeZnbluij_\haghkyl_]h
\ur_ q_f ij_\haghkyl kZoZ[h\ IjhjhdZ k]k Qlh `_ hgb
kdZ`ml ih ih\h^m k\b^_l_evkl\ B[g ;Zllmlu h[ B[g L_cfbb"
Fh`_l[ulvhge]Ze"Bebhrb[ky":fh`_l[ulvfg_gb_B[g
L_cfbb y\ey_lky g_agZqbl_evguf ijhklbl_evguf ijhklmi
dhf"DZdkbevghaZ[em`^Zxlky\ZooZ[blu514.
B\dhgp_ohq_lkygZihfgblvqlh\ZooZ[bluaZij_sZxl
]h\hjblv ©dZjjZfZ :eeZom \Z^`oZomª ©^Z ihqlbl :eeZo _]h
ebdªihke_mihfbgZgby=Zebj:]HgbgZau\Zxlwlh[b^]Z
<_^v g_ hg _^bgkl\_gguc dlh gbdh]^Z g_ ihdehgyeky b^heZf
\ZooZ[blulh`_bfg_ihdehgyebkv
<ZooZ[blukqblZxlqlhkmggbluaZ[em^rb_ex^b
Dh]^Z \u keurbl_ keh\Z \ZooZ[blh\ h kZeZnZo \Zf
ij_^klZ\eyxlky kih^\b`gbdb IjhjhdZ k]k gh d kh`Ze_
gbxhgbih^wlbfl_jfbghfbf_xl\\b^mB[gL_cfbxb_]h
ihke_^h\Zl_e_c K_[y hgb bf_gmxl kmggblZfb Z \k_o hklZev
guooZgZnblh\rZnb]blh\fZebdblh\boZg[Zeblh\–g_m^h
klZb\ZxllZdhcq_klbGb`_fuohlbfijb\_klb\ukdZau\Zgby
g_dhlhjuo ba\_klguo \ZooZ[blh\-oZrZ\blh\ B gZqg_f k =Z[
^meeu[bg=Z[^jZofZgZ:[m;ZlugZmf]]©?k
eb\ZfklZg_lwlhba\_klghlh\uihcf_l_hrb[dml_odlhhl
ghkblZrZjblh\dkmggblZfdZdkdZaZghmZk-KZnZjbgbFh`_l
[ulv hg \dexqbe bo \ qbkeh kmggblh\ ih ijbqbg_ fgh]hqbk
e_gghklb515 Wlh ba\_klgh h^ghfm :eeZom gh g_dhlhju_ iha^
=Z[[ZkFZofm^Ze-=ZddZ^©:[mZr-rmoZ^Zª – 106.
: agZ_l_ ihq_fm hgb \uklmiZxl ijhlb\ ihk_s_gby fh]beu ijhjhdZ
k]k"Hl\_lhq_gvijhklB[gL_cfby[ueijhlb\wlh]h
515
DZdhcgZ[h`guc
513
514
213
gb_ oZg[Zeblu lh`_ ijbkh_^bgbebkv d gbfª516 DZd \b^bl_
wlhlq_eh\_dm[_`^_gqlhZrZjblug_y\eyxlkykmggblZfb
@b\rbckh\k_fg_^Z\ghmq_gucB[g;Zaibr_l©?klv
\b^u Zdu^u dhlhju_ hdZau\Zxl iZ]m[gh_ \ebygb_ gZ \_jgmx
kmggblkdmx Zdu^m D wlbf \b^Zf fh`gh hlg_klb \_jh\Zgby
^`Zofblh\ b fmlZabeblh\ hljbpZxsb_ kh\_jr_ggu_ [h`_kl
\_ggu_bf_gZbZljb[mlu«Dgbf`_hlghkylkybZrZjblu517,
hljbpZxsb_h^gbbijb[Z\eyxsb_^jm]b_Zljb[mlu«Qlh`_
dZkZ_lky gZklhysbo kmggblh\ lh hgb ijbagZxl b ih^l\_j`^Z
xl\k_lhqlh:eeZokhh[sbehk_[_ª518<ugZ\_jgh_aZf_lb
eb qlh B[g ;Za g_ hlghkbl ZrZjblh\ d kmggblZf Z hlghkbl d
gbflhevdhihke_^h\Zl_e_cB[gL_cfbb519Ijh[e_fZkZrZjb
lZfbaZdexqZ_lkyebrv\lhfqlhihkeh\ZfB[g;ZaZZrZjb
lu hljbpZxl b hl\_j]Zxl g_dhlhju_ [h`_kl\_ggu_ Zljb[mlu
gZkZfhf`_^_e_hgbebrvhibku\Zxl:eeZoZdZq_kl\Zfbkh
hl\_lkl\mxsbfb ?]h [h`_kl\_gghc kmsghklb b kkueZykv gZ
Zyl©G_lgbq_]hih^h[gh]h?fmª-hljbpZxl\k_Zgljhihfhj
nbklkdb_ ljZdlh\db Keh\h ©jmdZª \ Zyl_ ©JmdZ :eeZo gZ^ bo
©FZ^`fm]ZlZj-jZkZbe\ZZe-fZkZbe:g-gZ^`^byªIbkvfZbn_l\ur_c
oZ=Z[^meeu[bg=Z[^jZofZgZ:[m;ZlugZ–KWlbkeh\Zijb\h^ylky
ihke_ ijh^he`bl_evgh]h \klmie_gby ]^_ hg djblbdm_l ZrZjblkdb_ b^_b
Hkh[_ggh bf g_ ihgjZ\beZkv b^_y h lhf qlh \_jmxsb_ g_ m\b^yl :eeZoZ
\hhqbxZrZjbluljZdlmxlkhhl\_lkl\mxsbcZylb]h\hjylhlhfqlh:e
eZo^Zjm_lwlbfex^yfagZgb_
517
Wlhy\guc\u\h^bohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhj_qvb^_lhfZlmjb^blZolh`_
ihkdhevdmbomq_gb_ihqlbgbq_fg_hlebqZ_lkyhlZrZjblkdh]hg_dhlhju_
mq_gu_^Z`_\ukdZau\Zxlfg_gb_hlhfqlhjZaebqb_f_`^mZrZjblZfbb
fZlmjb^blZfbk\h^blkyebrvdl_jfbgheh]bbFmoZffZ^:[^hdhff_glb
jmy©:e-=ZdZb^Ze-]Z^Z^byªibr_l©G_kljZgghqlh\ZooZ[blug_kqblZxl
fZlmjb^blh\fmkmevfZgZfb>_eh\lhfqlhhgbke_^myijbf_jm:[mOZ
gbnuml\_j`^Zxlqlhq_eh\_d^he`_gihagZlv:eeZoZk\hbfjZamfhfQlh
`_dZkZ_lkyZrZjblh\lhhgb\wlhf\hijhk_hl^Zxlij_^ihql_gb_k\ys_g
gufl_dklZfª
518
B[g;Za©Ze-:du^ZZk-kZoboZ\ZfZx^Z^^moZª–ba^-\h©B[gL_cfbyªK
519
Mr_coZfgh]h\ukdZau\Zgbc]^_hghl^_ey_lZrZjblh\hlkmggblh\yd
kh`Ze_gbx g_ kfh] ihemqblv g_h[oh^bfmx dgb]m gh \ wlhf g_l gbq_]h
kljZrgh]hgb`_fuijb\_^_f\ukdZau\Zgbyr_coZ=mk_cfbgZ
516
214
jmdZfbªZrZjbluljZdlmxldZd[h`_kl\_ggh_fh]ms_kl\hih
kdhevdmgZebqb_nbabq_kdhcjmdbg_khhl\_lkl\m_l:eeZomgb
klhqdbaj_gby?]h[h`_kl\_gghckmsghklbgbklhqdbaj_gby
e_dkbdheh]bb ?s_ \ h^ghf ba Zylh\ kdZaZgh ©Hg ihieue ih^
GZrbf ijbkfhljhf520» (54:14), - bf__lky \ \b^m qlh dhjZ[ev
GmoZ]kieueih^ijbkfhljhf:eeZoZb\g_fg_b^_lj_qb
hgZebqbbmG_]hnbabq_kdh]h]eZaZ<hllZdB[g;Zahlghkbl
ky d fmkmevfZgZf \ p_ehf b d kmggblZf \ qZklghklb \ qbkeh
ihke_^gbo hg hlghkbl lhevdh l_o k qvbf fg_gb_f _]h b^_b
kh\iZ^Zxl
G_ ^mfZcl_ qlh B[g ;Za h^bghd \ k\hbo m[_`^_gbyo
^Ze__ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb \ukdZau\Zgby ^jm]h]h ©[he__ l_j
ibfh]hª kZeZnblkdh]h eb^_jZ r_coZ FmoZffZ^Z [bg KZeboZ
Ze-=mk_cfbgZ521©GZwlhl\hijhkfuhl\_lbfl_fqlhkmggblu
jZa^_eyxlky gZ ^\_ rdheu i_j\Zy – rdheu B[g L_cfbb __
ihke_^h\Zl_ebhl^Zxlij_^ihql_gb_[md\ZevghfmljZdlh\Zgbx
k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ \lhjZy – ZrZjblu522 b fZlmjb^blu523 __
ihke_^h\Zl_eb hl^Zxl ij_^ihql_gb_ i_j_ghkghfm b Zee_]hjb
q_kdhfm ljZdlh\Zgbx [h`_kl\_gguo bf_g b Zljb[mlh\ Fu
kqblZ_f qlh f_`^m wlbfb ^\mfy rdheZfb _klv h]jhfgh_ jZa
ebqb_ \ ijbgpbibZevghf ih^oh^_ d \hijhkm [h`_kl\_gguo
bf_g b Zljb[mlh\ I_j\Zy rdheZ kqblZ_l g_h[oh^bfuf khojZ
g_gb_ [md\Zevgh]h kfukeZ k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ ih\_kl\mxsbo
h [h`_kl\_gguo bf_gZo b Zljb[mlZo b hljbpZgb_ ex[h]h [h
]hih^h[by b lh`^_kl\_gghklb524 <lhjZy rdheZ kljhblky gZ
<ZjZ[kdhf\ZjbZgl_mihlj_[e_ghkeh\h©Z]xgªh^ghbaagZq_gbcdhlh
jh]h©]eZaZª–ii
521
Bak[hjgbdZ©FZ`^fm]ZlnZlZ\Z\ZjZkZbenZ^ueylZr-r_coFmoZffZ^
[bgKZeboZe-=mk_cfbgª–L–Kbihke_^mxsb_Wlbn_l\ukh[jZgu
NZo^hf[bgGZkujhfZk-Kme_cfZghfbba^Zgu\i_j\u_\]]–
ba^-\h©Ze-<ZlZgªwj-Jby^kebqghcih^ibkvxZe-=mk_cfbgZ
522
Hij_^_e_gb_[ueh^Zgh\ur_
523
FZlmjb^blu–ihke_^h\Zl_eb:[mFZgkmjZZk-KZfZjdZg^bZe-FZlmjb^b
mf]kh\j_f_ggbdZZe-:r]Zjb;ueh^gbfbamq_guo-fmlZdZeebfh\
\kemqZ_jZagh]eZkbcoZgZnbluhl^Zxlij_^ihql_gb__]hb^_yf
524
R_coij_^klZ\ey_lkh[hcdeZkkbq_kdbcijbf_jfm^`ZkkbfblZGZK
wlhc`_dgb]bgZ\hijhkhgZebqbbm:eeZoZ]eZahghl\_qZ_l©>Zm<k_
520
215
ijbgpbi_i_j_ghkghcljZdlh\db[h`_kl\_gguobf_gbZljb[m
lh\DZd\b^bl_wlh^\_kh\k_fjZaebqgu_rdheuǻ>Ze__hg
ijb\h^bl ijbf_j lh]h dZd ZrZjblu b fZlmjb^blu ljZdlmxl
Zyl ©lhfm qlh Y kha^Ze K\hbfb jmdZfbª b dZd _]h ihgbfZxl
ihke_^h\Zl_ebB[gL_cfbbihke_q_]hibr_l©Babaeh`_ggh
]h \ur_ klZgh\blky ykgh qlh l_jfbg ©kmggbluª [he__ ih^oh
^bli_j\hcrdhe_525g_`_eb\lhjhc?kebfuh[_rdheuhlg_
k_fdkmggblZflhwlh[m^_lg_kijZ\_^eb\hZrZjbZl\uklmiZ
_l ijhlb\ g_kijZ\_^eb\hklb K ^jm]hc klhjhgu jZamf lZd`_
ijhlb\blky lhfm qlh[u h[t_^bgblv ^\_ ijhlb\hiheh`ghklb
ih^ h^gbf b l_f `_ gZa\Zgb_fª526 B gZdhg_p hg ^_eZ_l \u
\h^ ©;_kijbkljZklguc b gZmqguc \a]ey^ iha\hey_l k^_eZlv
\u\h^hlhfqlhi_j\ZyrdheZijb^_j`b\ZxsZykyijbgpbih\
[md\Zevgh]h ljZdlh\Zgby bf__l [hevr_ ijZ\ gZau\Zlvky kmg
gblZfb g_`_eb \lhjZy bkihevamxsZy i_j_ghkgmx ljZdlh\
dmª527.
Gh ik_^hkZeZnblu aZreb _s_ ^Zevr_ l_i_jv hgb lj_
[mxl qlh[u kmggblu hldZaZebkv hl wlh]h gZa\Zgby Zoe ZkkmggZ \Z Ze-^`ZfZ]Z ?keb hgb `_eZxl hlj_qvky hl gZk lh
imklvijb^mfZxlk_[_gh\h_bfygZijbf_j©kZeZnbluª528H[
wlhf]h\hjblky\bodgb]_©Jmy\Zdb]byªkGZwlmdgb]m
r_co OZeb^ [bg OZfb^ Ze-:^Zf Ze-=ZkdZeygb gZibkZe hijh
\_j`_gb_ ©:j-Jm^m^ Zk-kZeZnby ]Zey ^m]Zl Zk-kZeZnbyª ©Hl
\urg_]h:eeZoZ_klv^\Z]eZaZªjZa\_wlhkZfhihk_[_g_y\ey_lkymih^h[
e_gb_f b hlh`^_kl\e_gb_f \_^v :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©G_l gbq_]h ih
^h[gh]h?fmª"
525
L_ihke_^h\Zl_eyfB[gL_cfbb
526
Kf_rgh qlh \ZooZ[blu kkueZxlky gZ jZamf \_^v kZfb hgb hoZb\Zxl
dZ`^h]h dlh ijb\h^bl bf eh]bq_kdb_ ^hdZaZl_evkl\Z KZf ih k_[_ gZijZ
rb\Z_lky \u\h^ h lhf qlh ^h\h^u jZamfZ hgb bkihevamxl lhevdh \ k\hbo
dhjuklguop_eyo
527
©FZ^`fm]nZlZ\Z\ZjZkZbenZ^ueylZr-r_coFmoZffZ^[bgKZeboZe=mk_cfbgª–L–K
528
DZd mdZau\Z_l ^hdlhj FmklZnZ Zr-RZdZ]Z \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©BkeZf [bey
fZaZob[ªk–i_j\ufbdlhgZa\Zek_[ykmggblZfb[uebZrZjblu
bf_gghihwlhfm\ZooZ[blukgbfbb[hjxlkyhgbg_`_eZxlqlh[uZrZjb
lu[uebkl_i_gvx\ur_q_fhgb
216
\_lkZeZnblh\ik_^hkZeZnblZfª529JZa\_fh`_l[ulv[hevrbc
nZgZlbaf q_f lhl qlh m \ZooZ[blh\" DZd ba\_klgh B[g L_c
fby [ue ^Ze_d hl \_dZ kZoZ[h\ jZa\_ fh`gh _]h gZa\Zlv kZeZ
nblhf" Wlb nZgZlbdb lj_[mxl qlh[u fmkmevfZg_ hldZaZebkv
hlk\hbofZaoZ[h\bijbgbfZeblhevdhbob^_bghg_m`_ebm
fmkmevfZgg_fh`_l[ulvk\h_]hfg_gby"
AgZcl_ qlh hlghr_gb_ d kmggbafm hij_^_ey_lky g_ hl
ghr_gb_fddZdhfm-eb[hfZaoZ[mZijZ\_^gufb^_ygbyfbkh
hl\_lkl\mxsbfb imlb IjhjhdZ k]k b g_\Z`gh dZdhc rdh
eu\uijb^_j`b\Z_l_kv
<jZs_gb_a_feb–m^Zjih\ZooZ[blkdhcZdu^_
Ohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlh\ZooZ[blui_j_`b\Zxlbgl_ee_d
lmZevguc djbabk ^_eh \ lhf qlh bo m[_`^_gby ijhlb\hj_qZl
kh\j_f_gguf ih^l\_j`^_gguf ijZdlbdhc gZmqguf ^Zgguf
Beb^jm]bfbkeh\ZfbwlbgZmqgu_^Zggu_gZghkylkf_jl_ev
gucm^ZjihboZdu^_<k\yabkwlbfhgbijZdlbq_kdbh[ty\b
eb\hcgmkh\j_f_gghcgZmd_?keb[u\k_[ueh[u\bo\eZklb
lh hgb \hh[s_ aZij_lbeb [u ij_ih^Z\Zgb_ kh\j_f_gguo k\_l
kdbo gZmd \ k\hbo kljZgZo GZijbf_j h^bg ba gbo =Z[^medZ
jbf[bgKZeboZe-OZfb^\k\h_cdgb]_©Ob^ZylZe-oZcjZgnb
fZktZeZZ^-^ZmjZgª\uklmiZ_l\aZsblml_hjbbh]_hp_gljbq_
kdhf530kljh_gbb\k_e_gghcWlZdgb]Zba^ZgZ\hq_gv^hjh]hf
i_j_ie_l_ gh ijh^Z_lky ih kf_rghc p_g_ \k_]h j_Zeh\531.
Kh\j_f_gguc \a]ey^ gZ kljh_gb_ \k_e_gghc gZjmrZ_l \ZooZ
[blkdmxZdu^mihkdhevdm\g_cg_hklZ_lkyf_klZ;h]mkb^y
s_fmgZljhg_\g_[_^Zijhklblf_gy:eeZoWlbex^bh[\b
gbeb \ aZ[em`^_gbb ^Z`_ r_coZ Za-Abg^Zgb dZd [m^lh hg
L jZa^_e \lhjhc ©;ZcgZ Zk-kZeZnby \Z Zoe Zk-kmggZª K ba^ZgZ \
] ] Ba-aZ [hyagb i_j_^ l_jjhjbklbq_kdbf Zdlhf ohay_\Z ba^Z
l_evkl\Zg_mdZaZeb_]hgZa\Zgby
530
Kh]eZkghwlhcmklZj_\r_cl_hjbbp_gljhf<k_e_gghcy\ey_lkyA_fey–
ii
531
<ZooZ[blkdb_ lbih]jZnbb `b\ml gZ ^hlZpbb jZ\gu_ fbeebZj^m ^heeZ
jh\ \u^_ey_fuo _`_]h^gh gZ jZkijhkljZg_gb_ \ZooZ[bafZ Kf ©Jbyo ZkkZfmfª ©Zk-KZ]m^by \Z ^mZev Ze-^`ZabjZ [Z]^Z oZj[ Ze-oZeb^` –
1994». -ba^– K
529
217
_^bgkl\_gguc532 dlh \_jbl qlh a_fey \jZsZ_lky \hdjm] kheg
pZ>Ze__fuohlbfijb\_klbg_dhlhju_pblZlubamihfygmlhc
dgb]b
GZkhgibr_l©<gZr_\j_fygZ]heh\ufmkmevfZg
\uiZeZ gh\Zy [_^Z Kh\j_f_ggu_ agZgby [eZ]h^Zjy \jZ]Zf[_a[h`gbdZf gZqZeb ijhgbdZlv \ BkeZf b kf_rb\Zlvky k j_
eb]bhagufb agZgbyfb Wlb kh\j_f_ggu_ agZgby fh`gh jZa^_
eblv gZ ^\Z \b^Z533 i_j\uf \b^hf y\eyxlky [_kihe_agu_ agZ
gbydhlhju_\eb\Zxlky\rZjbZlbhkeZ[eyxl_]hR_comebk
eZf B[g L_cfby ih wlhfm ih\h^m kdZaZe ©?keb [_kihe_agu_
agZgbykf_rb\Zykvkihe_agufbhkeZ[eyxl\lhju_lhklZgh
\ylky aZij_lgufbª534 <lhjhc \b^ – \j_^gu_ agZgby jZajmrZ
xsb_ Zdu^m d gbf hlghkylky gZijbf_j agZgby h \jZs_gbb
A_feb\hdjm]KhegpZb^jm]b_agZgby[_a[h`gbdh\ª
>Ze__ hg ijb\h^bl jZa^_e ©L_hjby h \jZs_gbb a_feb
\_^_ldZl_bafmªk]^_jZkkdZau\Z_lhlhfdZdwlZl_hjby
jZajmrZ_lboZdu^m
Ihke_ wlh]h gZ k hg gZiZ^Z_l gZ ]_heh]bx b ibr_l
©Wlbmq_gu_aZ[em^bebkvb\\_eb\aZ[em`^_gb_^jm]boª
AZl_fhgk\uklmiZ_lkh[\bg_gbyfb\Z^j_kr_coZ
Za-Abg^Zgb ©:a-Abg^Zgb hlghkblky d l_f mq_guf dhlhju_
\iZeb \ aZ[em`^_gb_ b iulZxlky h[t_^bgblv fbjkdb_ b j_eb
]bhagu_ gZmdb h^gZdh bf wlh g_ m^Zehkvǻ Ihke_ wlh]h hg
ijb\h^bl \ukdZau\Zgb_ B[g Ze-DZcbfZ b kha^Z_lky \i_qZle_
gb_qlhgbdlhg_bf__lijZ\Zhl\_j]Zlvkeh\Zwlh]h©Z\lhjbl_
lZª
<ZooZ[blu h[\bgyxl \ aZ[em`^_gbb \k_o kh\j_f_gguo b jZggbo fm
kmevfZgkdbofukebl_e_c<qbkehaZ[em^rbo\\ZooZ[blkdhfkibkd_\oh^yl
b B[g KbgZ :\bp_ggZ b B[g Jmr^ :\_jjhwk >Z b \ p_ehf \ZooZ[baf
hq_gv kbevgh gZihfbgZ_l ojbklbZgkdmx p_jdh\v b bgd\babpbx h[\bgb\
rmx\_j_kb=Zebe_y
533
Ijhrmg_km^blvkljh]hZ\lhjZwlhcdgb]baZklbebklbq_kdmxkeZ[hklvb
]jZffZlbq_kdb_hrb[db\_^vhg\ZooZ[bl
534
DZdihoh`bbokeh\ZgZj_qbjZggboij_^klZ\bl_e_cojbklbZgkdhcp_jd
\bbaZf_lvl_bo^h\h^Zfby\eyxlkyg_DhjZgbg_kmggZZ\ukdZau\Zgby
h^gh]hbahkgh\hiheh`gbdh\
532
218
AZl_fhggZkaZy\ey_l©IjbagZgb_\jZs_gbya_feb
_s_ [he__ m`Zkgh q_f ijbagZgb_ ijhbkoh`^_gby q_eh\_dZ ba
h[_avyguªMf_gy^Z`_g_ldhff_glZjb_\
GZ k ijb\h^blky bgl_j_kguc aZ]heh\hd ©LjZdlh\dZ
k\ys_gguol_dklh\\ihevam\jZs_gbya_feby\ey_lkyeh`ghc
ljZdlh\dhcª Gh ihq_fm-lh hg g_ ijb\h^bl gb _^bgh]h ZylZ b
gb_^bgh]hoZ^bkZ\^hdZaZl_evkl\hk\h_cihabpbb?]hkZfuf
©\_khfuf Zj]mf_glhfª kem`Zl keh\Z ©R_comebkeZf kdZ
aZeǻ
>Ze__ gZ k ih^ aZ]heh\dhf ©D q_fm \_^_l l_hjby h
\jZs_gbb a_febª hg ibr_l ©KljZrgZ g_ kZfZ l_hjby Z lhl
Zl_bafddhlhjhfmhgZgZkihkl_i_gghih^\h^bl\_^vkh]eZk
gh wlhc l_hjbb \hdjm] A_feb kh \k_o klhjhg kms_kl\m_l [_k
djZcgbcdhkfhkª
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev \u k\hbfb ]eZaZfb m\b^_eb dZd
wlb ex^b ijbagZeb g_khklhyl_evghklv k\hbo m[_`^_gbc \_^v
\jZs_gb_A_febb__hdjm]eZynhjfZ\gZrb^gb^Z`_g_lj_
[mxl^hdZaZl_evkl\
Ohq_lky hlf_lblv qlh kZfuc djmiguc \ZooZ[blkdbc
mq_gucr_co=Z[^me]Zaba[bg=Z[^meeZ[bg;Zalh`_ijb^_j
`b\Z_lky wlh]h fg_gby gh ebrv k lhc jZagbp_c qlh ih _]h
fg_gbx lhl dlh \_jbl \h \jZs_gb_ a_feb y\ey_lky \_jhhl
klmigbdhf aZkem`b\Z_l kf_jlghc dZagb Z _]h bfms_kl\h
^he`gh [ulv i_j_^Zgh \ ihevam h[s_fmkmevfZgkdhc dZagu
[Zcl Ze-fZe Ze-fmkebfbg Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky r_coZ Ze=mk_cfbgZ lh hg j_dhf_g^m_l mqbl_eyf ]_h]jZnbb \hh[s_ g_
mihfbgZlvl_hjbxh\jZs_gbbA_febgZk\hbomjhdZo535.
GZk–wlhc`_dgb]bhg\uklmiZ_lkh[\bg_gbyfb
\Z^j_kK_b^ZDml[ZZ\lhjZdgb]b©FZ]Zebf]ZeyZl-lZjbdªb
fhy jmdZ ^Z`_ hldZau\Z_lky pblbjh\Zlv \k_ qlh hg gZibkZe
;he__lh]h_]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`blhl^_evgZydgb]Z©BgZjZlZ^^Zj[ EbfZ nb lZnkbj Dml[ fbg ZkZj Ze-]Zj[ª536 :eeZo bkiu
©FZ^`fm]nZlZ\Z\ZjZkZbenZ^ueylZr-r_coFmoZffZ^[bgKZeboZe=mk_cfbgª–L–Kn_l\Z‹
536
>jm]hcoZrZ\bl=Z[^meeZ[bgFmoZffZ^Z^->Z\brgZibkZedgb]m©:eFZmjb^Za-aZeyenbZl-lZg[bo]ZeyZolZZa-aueyeª\dhlhjhchglZd`_djb
535
219
lu\Z_l gZk _\j_ckdhc hddmiZpb_c B_jmkZebfZ b \ZooZ[blkdhc
hddmiZpb_c^\mokZfuo[hevrbok\ylugv
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev f_gy hq_gv i_qZeyl gZiZ^db wlbo
ex^_c gZ \_ebdbo fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo gh _s_ [he__ f_gy
i_qZebl lhl nZdl qlh wlb fm^`Zkkbfblu mgb`Zxl :eeZoZ
ij_^klZ\eyy_]h\h[jZa_l_eZih^h[gh]hq_eh\_q_kdhfmGhy
m\_j_gqlhaZdZlbo\eZklbhq_gv[ebahdhgbbkq_agmljZgvr_
q_faZdhgqblkyg_nlv:eeZo\_ebdb_]hgZdZaZgb_g_hl\jZlb
fh
KZlbjbq_kdZy\ZooZ[blkdZyfukev
G_m^b\bl_evghqlh\ZooZ[blu[hjxsb_kykjZamfhfb
eh]bdhckljZ^Zxlhlg_mjZ\gh\_r_gghklbk\hbo\a]ey^h\Hgb
k\ylh\_jyl\g_ih]j_rbfhklvB[gL_cfbbb_]hmq_gbdh\bg_
^himkdZxl \hafh`ghklb eh]bq_kdh]h ih^oh^Z d hkfuke_gbx
bob^_c^Z`_\lhfkemqZ__kebj_qvb^_lhle_gghklb:^ZIh
wlhcijbqbg_kh\j_f_ggu_\ZooZ[blu^eyaZsbluk\hbom[_`
^_gbc\ugm`^_gugZiZ^ZlvgZfmkmevfZgkdbomq_guo<qZkl
ghklb ^hdlhj KZebo [bg NZmaZg Ze-NZmaZg ijhn_kkhj \ Bk
eZfkdhf Mgb\_jkbl_l_ bf bfZfZ FmoZffZ^Z [bg KZ]m^Z \u
klmibekgZiZ^dZfbgZijhn_kkhjZ^hdlhjZFmoZffZ^ZKZ]b^Z
JZfZ^ZgZ Ze-;mlu dhlhjuc ba\_kl_g \h \k_f bkeZfkdhf fbj_
k\hbfb\_kdbfb^h\h^Zfb\ukdZaZggufbijhlb\b^_cjZaebq
guo[_a[h`gbdh\
I_jm^hdlhjZZe-;mluijbgZ^e_`bldgb]Z©:k-KZeZnby
fZjoZeZZa-aZfZgbyfm[ZjZdZeyfZaoZ[bkeZfbª537\wlhcdgb
]_ hg jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf dZd \ZooZ[blu ba[jZeb k_[_ gh\h_
bfy ©kZeZnbluª dh]^Z ij_`g__ ©\ZooZ[bluª bf gZ^h_eh
Djhf_lh]h\dgb]_hg\uklmiZ_lkaZsblhclZdbomq_guodZd
Ze-DZmkZjbZe-DZrbjbbFmoZffZ^Ze-=Zey\bZe-FZebdb538b
lbdm_l K_b^Z Dml[Z b gZau\Z_l _]h fm[lZ^b]hf ^`Zofblhf ZrZjblhf b
fmlZabeblhfkfkb
537
Djhf_g__hgy\ey_lkyZ\lhjhfba\_klghcdgb]b©NbdoZk-kbjZªb©>Z
\Z[blZe-fZkeZoZnbZr-rZjb]ZZe-bkeZfbyª
538
WlhfZebdblkdbcmq_guc`be\F_dd__]hjh^hkeh\gZy\hkoh^bldIjh
jhdmk]kHg\uklmiZekhkm`^_gb_fjZaebqguoeh`guofhf_glh\\Zo
220
ih^jh[ghbkihevamygZmqgu_^h\h^u^hdZau\Z_laZ[em`^_gb_
B[g L_cfbb < hl\_l gZ wlm dgb]m ^hdlhj Ze-NZmaZg gZibkZe
dgb`hgdm©GZaZjZl\ZlZ]db[Zl]ZeyfZnbdblZ[Zk-kZeZnbyeb
FmoZffZ^ KZ]b^ JZfZ^Zg« fbg Ze-oZnZ\Zlª539 Hgb \k_]^Z
ba^Zxl ih^h[gu_ dgb`hgdb dh]^Z iulZxlky ohlv dZd-gb[m^v
hl\_lblvk\hbfhiihg_glZf<wlhcdgb]_Z\lhjh[\bgber_coZ
Ze-;mlu\lhfqlhhgg_agZdhfkbklhjb_ckbg_m\Z`Z_l
k\hbo hiihg_glh\ k Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky _]h ^h\h^h\ lh hgb
^h\hevgh keZ[u b fu \ dZq_kl\_ ijbf_jZ qlh[u ihdZaZlv g_
khklhyl_evghklv \ZooZ[blkdhc fukeb ohlbf ijb\_klb g_dhlh
ju_ba_]h^h\h^h\
K ©Ih ih\h^m Ze-;ZcoZdb ohq_lky kdZaZlv qlh hg
[uekdehg_gdlZ\bexljZdlh\d_ihwlhfmfug_fh`_fiheZ
]ZlvkygZg_]h\wlhfjZa^_e_ª
K ©Ih ih\h^m oZnbaZ B[g OZ^`ZjZ Ze-=ZkdZeygb
ohq_lky hlf_lblv qlh hg [ue ih^\_j`_g \ebygbx ZrZjbafZ
ihwlhfmfug_fh`_fijbgylv_]hkeh\Zª-^_eZ_lkygZf_dgZ
Zdu^m
K ©Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky Ze-OZlu[b lh hg ijbf_gye lZ
\bed[h`_kl\_ggufbf_gZfbZljb[mlZfbihwlhfmg_fh`_l
kem`blv^h\h^hfª
<hagbdZ_l \hijhk ]^_ `_ a^_kv gZmqguc ih^oh^" JZa\_
gZklhysbc mq_guc [_a dZdbo-eb[h ^h\h^h\ klZg_l hl\_j]Zlv
\ukdZau\Zgbyh^gbomq_guo\ihevam^jm]bo"?keb^h\h^uZe;ZcoZdb Ze-OZlZ[b B[g OZ^`ZjZ g_ fh]ml [ulv ijb_fe_fu
fblhqvb`_^h\h^uke_^m_lijbgylv"
Hl\_l \ZooZ[blh\ gZf ba\_kl_g g_hkihjbfufb Z\lhjb
l_lZfb dhg_qgh `_ y\eyxlky B[g L_cfby b _]h mq_gbd B[g
Ze-DZcbf <k_ ^h\h^u b b^_b ^he`gu [jZlvky lhevdh ba dgb]
oZ[blkdh]h mq_gby aZ wlh \ZooZ[blkdb_ \eZklb ijb\e_deb _]h d km^_[ghc
hl\_lkl\_gghklbbhg[uem\he_gkjZ[hlu?]hh[\bgbeb\jZkijhkljZg_
gbbfZeh]hrbjdZbqe_gkl\_\_]bi_lkdhfkmnbckdhfhj^_g_Ihj_r_gbx
km^Z‹hl]_fm[uehaZij_s_ghihdb^Zlvl_jjb
lhjbx DK: LZdbf h[jZahf \ZooZ[blu ihklmiZxl kh \k_fb k\hbfb hiih
g_glZfb
539
Ba^. 2-_]]>ZjZe-\ZlZgwj-Jby^
221
oZrZ\blh\ dZd gZijbf_j \hh[jZ`Z_fuc k[hjgbd oZ^bkh\
=Z[^meeu [bg :ofZ^Z [bg OZg[ZeZ540 Djhf_ lh]h Ze-NZmaZg
\uklmiZ_l \ aZsblm b^_b h le_gghklb :^Z541 kh]eZkgh _]h ml
\_j`^_gbyf wlZ b^_y g_ y\ey_lky [b^]Z Z bf__l hkgh\Zgb_ \
DhjZg_bkmgg_:eeZok\yldZdZyde_\_lZ
KeZ[hklv b g_khklhyl_evghklv b^_c \ZooZ[bafZ \ i_j
\mx hq_j_^v \ujZ`Z_lky \ lhf qlh [hevrbgkl\h bo dgb] gZ
ibkZgh gZ l_fm rbjdZ dhlhjuc ydh[u ijhy\ey_lky q_j_a ih
dehg_gb_ fh]beZf Hgb g_ ijbg_keb gbdZdhc ihevau \hajh`
^_gbx fmkmevfZgkdhc mffu Bo ihklhygghc ^_yl_evghklvx
[uebgZiZ^dbgZfmkmevfZgkdbomq_guobfukebl_e_cb\qZ
klghklb gZ FmoZffZ^Z :[^h OZkZgZ Ze-;Zggm K_b^Z Dml[Z
FmoZffZ^Z Ze-=ZaZeb b ^jm]bo Dh]^Z fu ]h\hjbf h[ h]jZgb
q_gghklb \ZooZ[blkdhc fukeb lh bf__f \ \b^m g_ bfZfoZlu[h\ Z ij_`^_ \k_]h djmiguo mq_guo ijhn_kkhjh\ mgb
\_jkbl_lh\ Yjdbf ijbf_jhf lZdbo kem`bl ^hdlhj =mfZj Ze:rdZjdhlhjucg_kfhljygZlhqlh\jZsZ_lky\gZmqguodjm
]Zog_hklZ\ey_lk\hb\ZooZ[blkdb_m[_`^_gbybbaeZ]Z_lbo\
k\hbodgb]Zog_bf_xsbogbdZdhcgZmqghcp_gghklb
DZdoZrZ\bluhlghkylkydmq_guf
MoZrZ\blh\\hh[s_g_lihgylbyahehlhck_j_^bgu_k
eb hgb dhfm-eb[h kbfiZlbabjmxl lh ihqblZxl Z _keb dh]heb[h\hag_gZ\b^yllh\jZ`^mxlKl_i_gv\ZooZ[blkdh]hnZgZ
lbafZ ijhy\ey_lky \ lhf qlh hgb ij_^Zgu k\hbf Z\lhjbl_lZf
^Z`_ [hevr_ q_fkih^\b`gbdZfIjhjhdZk]kIhkemrZcl_
bo j_qb dh]^Z hgb mihfbgZxl B[g L_cfbx B[g Ze-DZcbfZ
B[gDZkbjZbijhqbo\ZfihdZ`_lkyqlhhgb]h\hjylhijhjh
dZobihkeZggbdZo
Wlhl ijb_f ba^Z\gZ ba\_kl_g oZrZ\blZf gZijbf_j
=Zeb[bgZe-FZ^bgb\k\h_\j_fyibkZe©:eeZo^Zeih^^_j`
dm wlhc j_eb]bb ^\mfy \_ebdbfb ex^vfb :[m ;Zdjhf ZkKu^^udhf \ i_jbh^ \_jhhlklmigbq_kl\Z b :ofZ^hf [bg OZg
540
541
Hg_^hklh\_jghklbwlhcdgb]b[uehkdZaZgh\ur_
KfaZ]heh\hdh[B[gZe-DZcbf_
222
[Zehfdh]^Zlh]hiulZebfmlZabebluª542JZa\_fh`ghkjZ\
gb\Zlv :[m ;ZdjZ \h_\Z\r_]h ijhlb\ \_jhhlklmigbdh\ b :o
fZ^Z[bgOZg[ZeZhldZaZ\r_]hkyijbagZlvb^_xhkha^Zgghklb
DhjZgZ Gh B[g Ze-FZ^bgb aZoh^bl _s_ ^Zevr_ Ze-FZcfmgb
hlg_]hi_j_^Z_l©Gbdlhihke_kf_jlbIjhjhdZk]kg_k^_
eZe^eyBkeZfZgbq_]h\_ebdh]hdjhf_:ofZ^Z[bgOZg[ZeZª
M g_]h kijhkbeb ©: :[m ;Zdjª - hg hl\_lbe ©B :[m ;Zdj
\_^vmg_]h[uehfgh]hihfhsgbdh\Zm:ofZ^Z[bgOZg[ZeZ
gbdh]hg_[uehª543;he__lh]hwlbex^b^Z`_]hlh\uijb[_]
gmlvdhe`b=Zeb[bgZe-FmZnnZdba\_klgucdZdZe-OZkZgZe=Z[b^i_j_^Z_l\ukdZau\Zgb_hlhfqlh:ofZ^[bgOZg[Zekh
\_jrbe oZ^` r_klv^_kyl jZa544 >hdlhj FmklZnZ Zr-RZd]Z
dhff_glbjmy wlh \ukdZau\Zgb_ kdZaZe ©DZd ba\_klgh k\hc
i_j\uc oZ^` :ofZ^ [bg OZg[Ze kh\_jrbe \ ] ] Z
mf_j \ ] ] ^Z`_ _keb [u hg kh\_jrZe oZ^` dZ`^uc
]h^ fu g_ ihemqbeb [u mihfygmlmx pbnjmª545 D eh`guf
fh`gh hlg_klb b jb\Zylu hl Zj-JZ[bdZ [bg Kme_cfZgZ h lhf
qlhhgydh[ukeurZedZdZr-RZnb]bkdZaZe©Dlhijhlb\hj_
qbl :ofZ^m [bg OZg[Zem – lhl g_\_jguc546ª g_l khfg_gby \
lhfqlhZr-RZnb]blZdh]hg_]h\hjbeLhqghlZdbf`_y\ey
_lkyjb\Zyl©<^_gvkf_jlbbfZfZ:ofZ^Z[bgOZg[ZeZieZdZ
eb b fmkmevfZg_ b bm^_b b ojbklbZg_ b ^Z`_ yauqgbdb b
^\Z^pZlv lukyq q_eh\_d ba bo qbkeZ ijbgyeh BkeZfª547 :aAZoZ[b ^Z`_ \ugm`^_g [ue dhff_glbjh\Zlv wlhl jb\Zyl keh
\Zfb©?keb[u^\Z^pZlvlukyqq_eh\_dijbgyeh[uBkeZflh
dZdfbgbfmf^_kylvq_eh\_djZkkdZaZeh[uh[wlhfª
YjqZcrbf ijbf_jhf oZrZ\blkdh]h nZgZlbafZ kem`bl
bklhjby ijhbahr_^rZy k bfZfhf fmnZkkbjh\ B[g >`Zjbjhf
Zl-LZ[ZjbHgbdjblbdh\Zeb_]haZlhqlhhg\dgb]_©Bolbeyn
Ze-nmdZoZª gZa\Ze bfZfZ :ofZ^Z nZdbohf Z g_ oZ^bkh\_^hf
B[g:[mY]ey©LZ[ZdZlZe-oZgZ[beyª– 1/13.
LZf`_– 1/17.
544
LZf`_– 1/331.
545
>hdlhjFmklZnZZr-RZd]Z©BkeZf[beeyfZaZob[ª– 467 – 468.
546
LZf`_– 1/13.
547
LZf`_– 1/18.
542
543
223
Hg bf hl\_lbe ©Y g_ \b^_e hl g_]h gb h^gh]h jb\ZylZ b g_
keurZe gb h[ h^ghf gZ^_`ghf mq_gbd_ª lh]^Z hgb gZ[jhkb
ebkv gZ g_]h b ^Z`_ aZdb^Zeb _]h ^hf dZfgyfb ?fm qlh[u
kiZklbk\hx`bagvijbrehkvijb[_]gmlvdihfhsbihebpbbb
ba\bgblvkyi_j_^gbfb
Qlh `_ [ueh ^Zevr_" OZrZ\blu ijh^he`Zeb g_gZ\b
^_lvbfZfZZl-LZ[Zjb^Z`_ihke_kf_jlbHgbg_^Zeb_]hjh^
kl\_ggbdZfijhg_klbghkbedbk_]hl_ehf^hdeZ^[bsZbhgb
[ueb \ugm`^_gu ihohjhgblv _]h ghqvx \h ^\hj_ ^hfZ :aAZoZ[b^Z`_ihwlhfmih\h^mkdZaZe©Yg_\b^_eq_eh\_dZ[h
e__ h[jZah\Zggh]h q_f FmoZffZ^ [bg >`Zjbj gh d kh`Ze_
gbx oZg[Zeblu hq_gv kbevgh mgb`Zeb _]hª548 Hgb h[\bgbeb
_]h\jZnb^baf_549bijh^he`Zeb\j_^blv_fm^Z`_ihke_kf_j
lb B[g Ze-:kbj ibr_l ©< wlhf ]h^m mf_j FmoZffZ^ [bg
>`Zjbj Zl-LZ[Zjb Z\lhj ©Zl-LZjboª gZibkZgghc \ ;Z]^Z^_
?]h ihohjhgbeb ghqvx \h ^\hj_ ^hfZ ihlhfm qlh lheiZ ijh
klhex^bgh\ g_ ^ZeZ \hafh`ghklb _]h jh^guf ijh\_klb ihoh
jhgu ^g_f Hgb h[\bgyeb _]h \ jZnb^baf_ b [_a[h`bb =Zeb
[bg =bkZ ih wlhfm ih\h^mkdZaZe³Deygmkv:eeZohf_keb[u
\u kijhkbeb wlbo ex^_c h jZnb^baf_ b [_a[h`bb lh hgb g_
kfh]eb [u \Zf hl\_lblv ihkdhevdm g_ agZxl qlh wlh lZ
dh_´ª550.
>jm]bfyjdbfijbf_jhfoZrZ\blkdh]hnZgZlbafZy\ey
_lky :[m ;Zdj Ze-OZeeZe551 Hg hde_\_lZe :[m Ze-OZkZgZ :o
:a-AZoZ[b©Ze-=b[Zjª– 2/146.
KjZ\gbl_ihklmidbwlboex^_ck\ukdZau\Zgb_fnZdboZ:[mOZfb^ZZeBknZjZbgb ©>ey lh]h qlh[u dmiblv lZnkbj FmoZffZ^Z [bg >`ZjbjZ
fh`gh^Z`_kt_a^blv\DblZcª
550
Fm^`bjm^^bgZe-=Zebfb©Zg-GZ^`^ZZe-ZofZ^nblZjZ^`bfZkoZ[:o
fZ^ª– 1/38.
551
Wlhl q_eh\_d kqblZ_lky h^gbf ba hkgh\hiheh`gbdh\ oZrZ\bafZ hg kh
[bjZejZaebqgu_^hklh\_jgu_bg_^hklh\_jgu_jb\Zyluh[bfZf_:ofZ^_b
_]h ihke_^h\Zl_eyo b baeh`be \k_ wlh \ dgb]Zo ©:e-=befª ©:e-=beZeª b
©:k-KmggZªkf\©Ze-=Z\ZkuffbgZe-dZ\Zkufª–Hgb_]hih
ke_^h\Zl_eb ijbibku\Zeb bfZfm :ofZ^m jZaebqgu_ g_kms_kl\mxsb_ \u
kdZau\Zgby hkh[_ggh \ h[eZklb Zdu^u Z lZd`_ ijbibku\Zeb \u^mfZggu_
oZ^bkuIjhjhdmk]kBf_gghihwlhfm\oZg[Zeblkdhfnbdo_hq_gvfgh
548
549
224
fZ^Z[bgZe-OZkZgZ[bg>`mgZc^ZZl-Lbjfbab552dhlhjuckqb
lZeky [hevrbf agZlhdhf oZ^bkh\553 b [ue gZklZ\gbdhf Ze;moZjbbZl-Lbjfbab:[m;ZdjZe-OZeeZeh[wlhf\_ebdhfq_
eh\_d_ gZibkZe ke_^mxs__ ©FmoZffZ^ [bg Xgmk Ze-;Zkjb
kdZaZe qlh wlhl q_eh\_d ba\_klguc ih ijha\bsm Zl-Lbjfbab
[ue fm[lZ^b]hf b [_a[h`gbdhf hg hl\_j] Zglb^`Zofbckdb_
jb\Zylu«ª < ^jm]hf f_kl_ hg ibr_l ©Wlhl Zl-Lbjfbab [ue
^`Zofblhfbhl\_j]Zekl_i_gvIjhjhdZk]kǻ:gZkhg
mdZau\Z_l©:[m=ZebBkfZbe[bgB[jZobfZe-OZrbfbjZkkdZ
au\ZeqlhwlhlZl-Lbjfbab[uefm[lZ^b]hfb^`Zofblhf«hg
hl\_j] kl_i_gv IjhjhdZ k]k Hg – g_\_jguc b \_jhhlklmi
gbdª
Ba\_klgheb\Zfm\Z`Z_fucqblZl_evhdZdhc©kl_i_gb
IjhjhdZk]kªb^_lj_qv"AgZ_l_eb\uihq_fmwlhlq_eh\_d
[ue m^hklh_g lZdbo oZjZdl_jbklbd dZd g_\_jguc fm[lZ^b]
\_jhhlklmigbd [_a[h`gbd ^`Zofbl b ij" IjbqbgZ [ueZ \
lhfqlhhghl\_j]oZ^bk\dhlhjhf]h\hjbehkvhlhfqlhydh
[uIjhjhdk]k\Km^guc^_gv[m^_lkb^_lvgZLjhg_jy^hf
k:eeZohf<hbklbgm:eeZoij_\ur_wlh]h
<hl lZdbf h[jZahf \ZooZ[blu-oZrZ\blu hlghkylky d
k\hbf hiihg_glZf ^Z kfbehklb\blky :eeZo gZ^ \k_fb mq_gu
fbdhlhju_ih^\_j]ebkvgZiZ^dZfwlboex^_c
F_`^m^\mfyfmnlbyfb
<ur_fum`_kdZaZebqlhoZrZ\blZfk\hckl\_ggh\ha
\_ebqb\Zlvk\hbomq_guobijb^mfu\Zlv^eygbokh\k_fg_kh
hl\_lkl\mxsb_lblmeuLhqghlZd`_hgbihklmibebkB[g;Z
ahf ihke_ _]h kf_jlb \ Bgl_jg_l_ ihy\beky gh\uc kZcl ih^
gZa\Zgb_f ©R_comebkeZf B[g ;Zaª ?keb [u wlb ex^b mdZaZ
]hjZaebqguokhfgbl_evguobijhlb\hj_qb\uo\ukdZau\Zgbc:[mAZojZih
wlhfmih\h^mkdZaZe©Ihijbqbg_wlh]hihy\ey_lkyfgh`_kl\hkhfg_gbch
ijbgZ^e_`ghklb lh]h beb bgh]h \ukdZau\Zgby bfZfm :ofZ^mª kf Fm
oZffZ^:[mAZojZ\dgb]_©:ofZ^[bgOZg[Zeªk– 170.
552
H^bg ba mq_gbdh\ bfZfZ :ofZ^Z gZ g_]h kkueZxlky Ze-;moZjb b ZlLbjfbabkfhg_f\©LZoab[Ze-dZfZeª–ih^ghf_jhf
553
B[gOma_cfZ_]hgZau\Ze©khkm^hfoZ^bkh\ªwlhlq_eh\_dba\_kl_gih
wlhfmfug_[m^_fijb\h^blviho\Zeumq_guo-kh\j_f_ggbdh\\_]hZ^j_k
225
ebqlhhg[uemq_guf\g_krbfk\hc\deZ^\jZa\blb_DK:lh
fug_bf_eb[ugbq_]hijhlb\Ghihkdhevdmhgbba[jZeblb
lme ©r_comebkeZfª lh fu \ugm`^_gu jZatykgblv bklbgm <
k\h_f ih\_kl\h\Zgbb fu \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v [m^_f hibjZlvky
gZ\ukdZau\Zgbybn_l\uwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
Dhjj_kihg^_glZfb `mjgZeZ ©:e-FZ^`ZeeZª554 _fm [ue
aZ^Zg \hijhk ©AgZ_l_ eb \u gZbamklv dZdb_-eb[h ba\_klgu_
deZkkbq_kdb_dgb]b"ªHghl\_lbe©G_lyg_agZxbogZbamklv
fubofgh]hqblZebgh[hevrmxqZklvygZbamklvg_agZxY
g_kdhevdh jZa ijhq_e k[hjgbdb Ze-;moZjb b FmkebfZ qblZe
k[hjgbdbZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^ZbB[gFZ^`bghg_kfh]boaZ
\_jrblv Djhf_ lh]h y ijhq_e [hevrmx qZklv ©:e-FmkgZ^ª
bfZfZ:ofZ^Zk[hjgbdZZ^->ZjbfbbB[gDmlZc[uYijhrm
m:eeZoZqlh[uhgijbgyefhb^_ygbybhgbihrebgZihev
amª
<hl lZdh\ r_co B[g ;Za hg g_ kl_kgyykv aZy\ey_l h
lhf qlh g_ agZ_l wlb dgb]b gZbamklv [he__ lh]h ijbagZ_lky
qlhg_dhlhju_bagbo^Z`_g_kfh]iheghklvxijhq_klvBhkh
[_ggh m^b\ey_l qlh hg g_ ijhq_e iheghklvx ©:e-FmkgZ^ª
bfZfZ :ofZ^Z lh]h bfZfZ iml_f dhlhjh]h hg ydh[u ke_^m_l
Gh g_kfhljy gZ wlh hg aZgbfZe ihkl fmnlby Ihkl q_eh\_dZ
dhlhjuch[yaZgagZlvkh^_j`Zgb_k[hjgbdh\oZ^bkh\gZbamklv
\ijhlb\ghfkemqZ_dZdhgfh`_lba^Z\Zlvn_l\u"
LZdh\uf[uefmnlbcdhlhjucfZehagZeghqZklh\u
ghkbej_r_gbyGZijbf_jhgaZy\beqlh\m[_`^_gbyoZdu^_
qe_gh\hj]ZgbaZpbb©;jZlv_\-fmkmevfZgª_klvbatygugh\lh
`_\j_fygZkljZgbpZo`mjgZeZ©:e-FZ^`ZeeZªijbagZeky©Y
agZdhf k bo ljm^Zfb \ g_^hklZlhqghc f_j_ fg_ g_ m^Zehkv
iheghklvx hagZdhfblvky k ijhba\_^_gbyfb r_coZ OZkZgZ b
^jm]boqe_gh\wlhchj]ZgbaZpbbªDZdhgfh`_lkm^blvh[hj
]ZgbaZpbb_kebhg^Z`_g_agZdhfk__iheh`_gbyfb"
Lhqgh lZdmx `_ g_h[^mfZggmx n_l\m ‹ hg ba^Ze
] ] kh]eZkgh wlhc n_l\_ fmkmevfZgZf aZ
ij_sZehkvkh\_jrZlvfhebl\maZbfZfhf-aZc^blhf©QlhdZkZ
554
23 –]‹K
226
_lky fhebl\u aZ aZc^blZfb lh y kqblZx qlh hgZ g_^_ckl\b
l_evgZªDh]^Z`_\k_c_f_gkdb_nZdbob–baZc^blubrZnb
]blu–\h^bg]hehk\ujZabebk\h_\hafms_gb__fmq_j_a]h^
] ] ijbrehkv \aylv k\hb keh\Z h[jZlgh b
aZy\blv©>hf_gy^hreh\hafms_gb_mq_guoC_f_gZ555ihih
\h^m wlhc n_l\u« Ihwlhfm y j_rbe i_j_kfhlj_lv __ \gh\v«
B l_i_jv aZy\eyx qlh hldZau\Zxkv hl wlhc n_l\u ihkdhevdm
hgZ[ueZkebrdhfh[h[s_gghcªB^Ze__hgaZy\be©Fuh[y
aZgukm^blvhex^yoihbokeh\Zfb^_eZf«<hkgh\_dZ`^uc
fmkmevfZgbg qbkl hl dZq_kl\ aZij_sZxsbo kh\_jr_gb_ fh
ebl\u aZ gbfª LZdh\ mq_guc ba^Zxsbc ihki_rgu_ n_l\u k
h[\bg_gbyfb fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb Hg b ^jm]b_ \ZooZ[blkdb_
mq_gu_bkiulu\Zxlg_ij_h^hebfh_`_eZgb_h[\bgylvex^_c\
p_ehfbfmkmevfZg\qZklghklb\g_\_jbb<wlhf`_]j_o_hg
h[\bgbe b b[Z^blh\ Kijhkbl_ aZ qlh" <k_]h ebrv aZ lh qlh
hgbg_\_jyl\\hafh`ghklvebp_aj_gby:eeZoZ\wlhffbj_b
ihke_^mxs_fZlZd`_hl\_j]Zxll_abkhle_gghklb:^Z556H[
jZsZykv d gbf \ k\h_c n_l\_ ‹ hl ]
] hg ^\Z`^u ih\lhjbe ©F_q b lhevdh f_qª :
\_^v hg ij_djZkgh agZ_l qlhbaZc^blulh`_ijb^_j`b\Zxlky
wlbom[_`^_gbcDZdh_`_hijZ\^Zgb_ihke_wlh]hgZc^mlk\h
_fmr_com557\ZooZ[blu"
Ba\_klgh qlh r_co hl\_j]Ze \kydmx \hafh`ghklv ^bZ
eh]Z k fmkmevfZgZfb \ p_ehf b k bo ij_^klZ\bl_eyfb \ qZkl
ghklb558 Hg hq_gv Z]j_kkb\_g dh]^Z gZqbgZ_lky kihj f_`^m
gbfbfmkmevfZgZfbgh\lh`_\j_fyhgg_ijhlb\^bZeh]Zk
ojbklbZgZfb Dh]^Z dhjj_kihg^_glZfb `mjgZeZ ©:eR_co=Z[^jZofZgZe-OZcbjihke_kf_jlbB[g;ZaZgZibkZehl\_lgZwlm
n_l\m©:j-JZ^^]ZeyB[g;ZajZbkoZcZdb[ZjZe-]meZfZnbZk-KZ]m^byoZm
eyfZdZe]meylZr-rb]ZeZfygdZjb^m[Z]^ª
556
Kf©:e-OZddZ^-^Zfb]ªr_coZ:ofZ^ZZe-OZebeb
557
R_coke_]dhklvxba^Z_ln_l\ubijhlb\hklZevguofmkmevfZgbijh
lb\MkZfu[bgEZ^_gZ
558
Dh]^Z r_co B[g ;Za h[ty\be b[Z^blh\ g_\_jgufb fmnlbc kmelZgZlZ
HfZg:ofZ^Ze-OZebebij_^eh`bemkljhblv^bkdmkkbxjy^hfkDZZ[hcgZ
]eZaZofmkmevfZgqlh[uhgZljZgkebjh\ZeZkvKFBghr_coB[g;ZahldZ
aZekyhlwlhc^bkdmkkbb
555
227
FZ^`ZeeZª_fm[ueaZ^Zg\hijhk©DZd\ukfhljbl_gZ^bZeh]
f_`^m BkeZfhf b ojbklbZgkl\hf"ª - hg hl\_lbe ©?keb ih
y\blky g_h[oh^bfhklv \ lZdhf ^bZeh]_ lh y hlghrmkv d g_fm
iheh`bl_evghGhdhg_qgh`_hg^he`_g[ulvhkgh\ZggZDh
jZg_bkmgg_ZlZd`_klZ\blvk\h_cp_ex^h\_^_gb_^hgbobk
lbgubijbau\bodBkeZfmª;ueh[uohjhrh_keb[uhg[ue
lZdjZkiheh`_gd^bZeh]mkfmkmevfZgkdbfbfZaoZ[Zfb559.
LZdbf[ue[u\rbcfmnlbcDK:dhlhjhfmg_^hklZ\Z
eh agZgbc h oZ^bkZo b fbehk_j^by d fmkmevfZgZf Hg ijbau
\Zeh[gZ`blvf_q^`boZ^Zijhlb\fmkmevfZgb[ueg_ijhlb\
^bZeh]ZkojbklbZgZfbIhdZdhfm`_ijZ\m\ZooZ[blugZa\Zeb
_]h©r_comebkeZfhfª"
Qlh`_fh`ghkdZaZlvhgh\hffmnlbbDK:r_co_=Z[
^me]Zaba_[bg=Z[^mee_"@mjgZe©:e-FZ^`ZeeZªih^aZ]heh\
dhf©KZm^bckdbcfmnlbcaZdhlhjufkh\_jrbebfhebl\m-4
fbeebhgZ fmkmevfZgª560 jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf qlh hg ih ijZ\m
fh`_l aZgbfZlv wlm kl_i_gv Qlh dZkZ_lky mihfygmlhc fhebl
\ulhhgZ[ueZkh\_jr_gZgZ:jZnZl_ghyg_^mfZxqlh\k_
ijbkmlkl\mxsb_ h^gh\j_f_ggh kh\_jrbeb fhebl\m klhy aZ
gbfDZdb_`__s_hlebqbybf__lwlhlq_eh\_d"@mjgZe©:eFZ^`ZeeZªkhh[sZ_lqlhhgaZsblbekl_i_gvfZ]bkljZb^hd
lhjZ561 bf_y \k_]h ebrv k\b^_l_evkl\h h ihemq_gbb kl_i_gb
ebp_gpbZlZ G_m`_eb m \ZooZ[blh\ ebp_gpbZl jZ\_g kl_i_gb
^hdlhjZ">Zkfbehklb\blky:eeZogZ^gZmdhc\DK:
<ih^h[ghcihabpbbg_lgbq_]hkljZggh]h\_^vhgke_^m_lijbf_jmk\h
_]h gZklZ\gbdZ B[g L_cfbb dhlhjuc \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©:e->`Z\Z[ Zk-kZobo
ebfZg[Z^^ZeZ^bgZe-FZkboª\_^_lkihdhcgmxb\a\_r_ggmx^bkdmkkbxk
\hh[jZ`Z_fufbojbklbZgZfbgh\lh`_\j_fy\^jm]bodgb]Zohghq_gv
kbevgh[jZgblfmkmevfZg
560
K
561
K\hx^hdlhjkdmx^bkk_jlZpbxhgaZsblbefZy]gZnZdmevl_l_
hkgh\j_eb]bb
559
228
=eZ\Zr_klZy
OZrZ\blkdbcnbdo
OZrZ\blkdbcnbdo\p_ehfb\ZooZ[blkdbc\qZklghklb
hlebqZ_lky l_f qlh _]h \u\h^u kebrdhf ih\_joghklgu b g_
h[^mfZggu Hgb ijbdZkZxlky d DhjZgm b oZ^bkZf ^_eZxl aZ
y\e_gbyhgb^Z`_qblZxlDhjZgh^gZdhdZdkdZaZgh\oZ^bk_
hgg_ih^gbfZ_lky\ur_bo]hjeZ.
<ZooZ[blkdbcf_kyp
Ih\he_:eeZoZkeh`behkvlZdqlhm\ZooZ[blh\g_lgb
_^bghcijb_fe_fhcb^_bbgb_^bgh]hijb_fe_fh]hihklmidZ
>Z`_ f_kyp JZfZaZg kh]eZkgh \ZooZ[blkdhfm rZjbZlm fh`_l
[ulv \k_]h ^\Z^pZlv \hk_fv ^g_c : klhygb_ gZ :jZnZl_
fh`ghkh\_jrZlveb[h\\hkvfhceb[h\^_kyluc^_gvamevob
^`bWlhj_Zevgu_bklhjbq_kdb_nZdlu[ue]h^dh]^Z\ZooZ
[blu^_ckl\bl_evghihklbebkvlhevdh^\Z^pZlv\hk_fv^g_cZ
\]]r_klhc^_gvf_kypZamevob^`Z[uei_j_g_k_g
gZaZ^ b h[ty\e_g iyluf ^g_f Djhf_ mihfygmluo ijbf_jh\
[ueh fgh]h ^jm]bo dh]^Z \ZooZ[blu ^himkdZeb hrb[db \ dZ
e_g^Zj_ gZjmrZeb fmkmevfZgkdh_ e_lhkqbke_gb_ Ijbq_f wlh
ijhbkoh^behg_lhevdh\h[uqgu_ghbaZij_lgu_-k\ys_ggu_
f_kypu>Ze__fuijb\_^_f[he__ih^jh[gu_ijbf_ju
<]]\ZooZ[bluihb]jZebbkihklhfbkoZ
^`_f :kljhghfu hij_^_ebeb qlh yg\Zjy ] fheh^hc
f_kyp f_kypZ RZ\Zev ihy\blky lhevdh \ \ lh \j_fy dZd
aZoh^khegpZ\F_^bg_kjZagbp_c\g_kdhevdhfbgml\^jm]bo
]hjh^ZoDK:^he`_g[ueijhbahclb\DZd`_\ZooZ[b
lu fh]eb mkljhblv ijZa^gbd jZa]h\_gby gZ ke_^mxsbc ^_gv"
R_coZe-DZj^Z\bihwlhfmih\h^maZy\beqlhwlhl^_gvy\ey
_lkyh^gbfba^g_cf_kypZJZfZaZgbjZa]h\_gb_\g_fg_^him
klbfh:_keb^himklblvqlhf_kypfh`_lijh^eblvky^\Z^pZlv
229
\hk_fv ^g_c lh k lZdbf `_ mki_ohf fh`gh ^himklblv qlh \
g_ffh`_l[ulvbljb^pZlvh^bg^_gv562.
B dlh ijbkemrZeky d keh\Zf r_coZ lhl gZ ijZdlbd_
m[_^bekyqlh\wlmghqvm\b^_lvf_kyp[ueh^h\hevghkeh`gh
Z\ke_^mxsmxhg[ueohjhrh\b^_g
<h \j_fy oZ^`Z lh]h `_ ] ] \ZooZ[blu j_
rbeb qlh f_kyp amevdZ]^Z jZ\_g ^gyf Z f_kyp amevob^`Z
gZklmiZ_lfZjlZ]gh\_^vwlhg_khhl\_lkl\m_l^_ckl
\bl_evghklb ;ueh lhqgh ba\_klgh qlh gh\uc f_kyp ^he`_g
[uejh^blvkylhevdh\ih\j_f_gbDK:563lh_klvq_j_a
ljb k ebrgbf qZkZ ihke_ aZoh^Z khegpZ B ijZdlbdZ ihdZaZeZ
qlh^_ckl\bl_evghwlhlf_kypg_\hafh`ghm\b^_lv_]hg_\b
^_eb^Z`_\>ZdZj_klhebp_K_g_]ZeZdhlhjucy\ey_lkykZfhc
aZiZ^ghcfmkmevfZgkdhcklhebp_cLZff_kyp^he`_g[ueih
y\blvky\lh_klvaZfbgmlm^haZoh^ZkhegpZQlh`_dZ
kZ_lky ihgylby gh\uc f_kyp lh b^_l j_qv h lhf iheh`_gbb
dh]^ZemgZgZoh^blkyf_`^mkhegp_fba_fe_cbm]heiZ^_gby
jZ\_g]jZ^mkZf564<wlh\j_fy_]h_s_g_\hafh`ghm\b^_lv
hg[m^_l\b^_glhevdhq_j_a\hk_fgZ^pZlvqZkh\ihke_jh`^_
gby gh\h]h f_kypZ565 DZd `_ \ZooZ[blZf \k_-lZdb m^Z_lky _]h
m\b^_lv":fh`_l[ulvgZjmrZ_lkyijb\uqgucaZdhghf_jguc
Kimlgbdh\ucdZgZe©:e->`ZabjZªijh]jZffZ©RZjbZlb`bagvªghqv
yg\Zjy]HgaZy\beqlhfmkmevfZg_y\eyxlky_^bghcgZpb_cbbf
ke_^m_l[ulv_^bgufbb\\hijhkZoihklZlh`_
563
Ohq_lky hlf_lblv lhqghklv ^Zgguo Zkljhghfbb Mq_gu_ aZ ^_kyldb e_l
^h kheg_qgh]h aZlf_gby ] k lhqghklvx ^h k_dmg^u hij_^_ebeb
dh]^Zhgh[m^_lb\dZdboj_]bhgZo_]h[m^_l\b^gh>eylh]hqlh[uk^_eZlv
lZdb_ jZkq_lu ke_^m_l [ulv hq_gv lhqguf b \gbfZl_evgh ke_^blv aZ ^\b
`_gb_fg_[_kguol_e>Zggu_Zkljhghfbblhqv\lhqvkh\iZebkgZklhysbf
aZlf_gb_fFh]mlebihke_wlh]h[ulvdZdb_-eb[hkhfg_gbyihih\h^m\u
qbke_gbyfmkmevfZgkdbof_kyp_\"
564
Dh]^Zwlhlm]hejZ\_gbeb[ebahddgmexgZklmiZ_lkheg_qgh_aZlf_gb_
565
Bf_ggh ihwlhfm bgh]^Z fh`gh m\b^_lv fheh^hc f_kyp mljhf < lZdbo
kemqZyo g_dhlhju_ ih ijbqbg_ k\h_]h g_\_`_kl\Z kqblZxl qlh ijhbahreZ
hrb[dZ qlh[u jZa\_ylv ih^h[gu_ khfg_gby kh\_lm_f h[jZlblvky d kZclm
www.moonsighting.com.
562
230
oh^ kh[ulbc ijhbkoh^bl qm^h \ j_amevlZl_ dhlhjh]h bf m^Z
_lkym\b^_lvfheh^hcf_kyp"
<q_f`_a^_kvdjh_lkylZcgZ"Ihq_fmwlbex^bklZdhc
e_]dhklvxbkdZ`Zxle_lhbkqbke_gb_"
FukqblZ_fqlhlZcgZdjh_lky\ke_^mxs_f
<h-i_j\uo \ZooZ[blu hibjZxlky gZ fg_gby g_gZ^_`
guo Zkljhghfh\ g_ ihgbfZxsbo jZagbpu f_`^m jh`^_gb_f
gh\h]hf_kypZb\hafh`ghklvx_]hm\b^_lvZwlhdZdfumih
fygmeb \ur_ [hevrZy hrb[dZ Djhf_ lh]h \ZooZ[blu ihev
amxlky^ZggufbZkljhghfbb^eylh]hqlh[um^hklh\_jblvky\
\hafh`ghklb ebp_aj_gby f_kypZ Z g_ m[_^blvky \ hlkmlkl\bb
lZdhc\hafh`ghklbZkljhghfby`_gZffh`_l^Zlvlhevdhbg
nhjfZpbxh[hlkmlkl\bb\hafh`ghklbm\b^_lvf_kyp
<h-\lhjuo oZrZ\blkdh-\ZooZ[blkdbc nbdo ^h\hevgh
ba\jZs_ghgbijbgbfZxlk\b^_l_evkl\hex[h]hq_eh\_dZg_
aZ\bkbfh hl lh]h kh\_jrZ_l eb hg fhebl\m beb g_l ihklblky
beb g_l ijZ\_^gbd hg beb jZkimlgbd Ihwlhfm _keb ^\h_ k]h
\hjylkyihih\h^mlh]hqlh\b^_ebf_kyplh\ZooZ[blubkZfb
ij_djZlyl ihkl b \_eyl ij_djZlblv _]h k\hbf ihke_^h\Zl_eyf
IjbwlhfhgbkihdhcghaZy\eyxlqlhIjhjhdk]kijbgbfZe
k\b^_l_evkl\h^\hboex^_c
Wlh_s_h^bgbaijbf_jh\ih\_joghklgh]hhlghr_gbyd
j_eb]bbAgZcl_`_qlhIjhjhdk]kijbgbfZek\b^_l_evkl
\h g_ dZ`^h]h fmkmevfZgbgZ hg ijh\_jye g_l eb dZdbo-eb[h
h[klhyl_evkl\ lj_[mxsbo hldZaZ hl k\b^_l_evkl\Z lh]h beb
bgh]h q_eh\_dZ Bf_ggh ihwlhfm :eeZo \ DhjZg_ ih ih\h^m
]j_rgbdh\ kdZaZe ©B gbdh]^Z g_ [_jbl_ bo \ dZq_kl\_ k\b^_
l_e_cb[hhgb–ij_klmiZxsb_aZdhgaZbkdexq_gb_fl_oba
gbodhlhju_ihke_wlh]h>gZ\_lZ@jZkdZyebkvbaZ]eZ^beb\b
gmªKZoZ[ublZ[b]bgulZd`_g_ijbgbfZebk\b^_l_ev
kl\h ex[h]h q_eh\_dZ ijbgy\r_]h BkeZf Z ijh\_jyeb _]h gZ
gZ^_`ghklv566?klva^_kvb^jm]ZyklhjhgZk\b^_l_evkl\hkih
;he__ lh]h kih^\b`gbdb jZahrebkv \h fg_gbyo ih ih\h^m ijbgylby
k\b^_l_evkl\Zl_odlhm`_ihemqbem]heh\gh_gZdZaZgb_LZjbdihke_^h\Z
l_evrdheuoZ^bkh\ijb\h^bljb\Zyl\dhlhjhfkhh[sZ_lkyhlhfqlh=m
fZj[bgZe-OZllZ[gZdZaZe:[m;ZdjZlmRb[ey[bgFZ]^[Z^Zb=Znb]ZaZ
566
231
^\b`gbdZ ihdZy\r_]hky \ g_\_jbb b ijbgy\r_]h BkeZf gb \
dh_fkemqZ_g_fh`_l[ulvjZ\ghk\b^_l_evkl\mex[h]h^jm]h
]h q_eh\_dZ hkh[_ggh _keb lhl g_^`^bckdbc [_^mbg ij_^db
dhlhjh]h \hafh`gh dh]^Z-lh m`_ hlj_dZebkv hl BkeZfZ Mq_
guf-oZ^bkh\_^Zfba^Z\gZba\_kl_gijbgpbiihdhlhjhfmhgb
ijbgbfZebk\b^_l_evkl\Z\k_okih^\b`gbdh\bi_j_ijh\_jyeb
k\b^_l_evkl\ZboZ^bku\k_ohklZevguo>Z`_deyl\uq_eh\_dZ
g_^hklZlhqgh \ ex[hf kemqZ_ ke_^m_l ijh\_jblv _]h gZ^_`
ghklv b g_ijbqZklghklv d \_ebdbf ]j_oZf Fu h[yaZgu aZsb
sZlvk\hxj_eb]bxhle`bjZaebqguode_\_lgbdh\
R_coZe-DZj^Z\bm`_^Z\gh\g_kij_^eh`_gb_ijbgylv
oZgZnblkdbcijbgpbikh]eZkghdhlhjhfmijbgbfZ_lkylhevdh
k\b^_l_evkl\h hq_gv [hevrhc ]jmiiu ex^_c567 Djhf_ lh]h
lhqlhhgbhde_\_lZebZe-Fm]bjmh[\bgb\lh]h\ij_ex[h^_ygbbZaZl_f
ihlj_[h\ZehlgboihdZygbybkdZaZe©IhdZcl_kvblh]^Zy[m^mijbgbfZlv
\Zrb k\b^_l_evkl\Zª LZdh]h `_ fg_gby ijb^_j`b\Zebkv =Z[^meeZ [bg
=ml[Z =mfZj [bg =Z[^me]Zaba KZ]b^ [bg >`m[Zcj LZmk Fm^`Zob^ ZrRZ][b =bdjbfZ Za-Amojb FmoZjb[ [bg >ZkZj RmjZco FmZ\by [bg Dm
jZª:[mZa-AbgZ^ihwlhfmih\h^mkdZaZe©MgZk\F_^bg_ihjy^hdlZdh\
_keb de_\_lgbd hldZaZeky hl k\h_c de_\_lu b ihdZyeky lh fu ijbgbfZ_f
_]h k\b^_l_evkl\hª :r-RZ][b b DZlZ^Z kdZaZeb ©?keb dlh-eb[h de_\_lZe
gZk_[ybihemqbeaZwlhgZdZaZgb_lhfuijbf_f_]hk\b^_l_evkl\hª:kKZ\jbkdZaZe©?kebjZ[Z\gZqZe_gZdZaZebaZde_\_lmZaZl_fhk\h[h^beb
lh_]hk\b^_l_evkl\hijb_fe_fhªGh_klvbl_dlhkqblZeqlhk\b^_l_evkl
\hde_\_lgbdZg_ijb_fe_fhKfmZe-;moZjb]eZ\m©Hm]heh\guogZdZaZgb
yoª©Om^m^ª©?keb\hjmhljm[bebjmdmlhihke_wlh]h_]hk\b^_l_evkl\h
ijb_fe_fhLhqghlZd`_ihklmiZxlbkh\k_fbhklZevgufbihemqb\rbfb
k\h_gZdZaZgb_ªHlFZebdZi_j_^Z_lkyjb\Zyl©;ueaZ^Zg\hijhkijbgb
fZ_lky eb k\b^_l_evkl\h q_eh\_dZ ihemqb\r_]h m]heh\gh_ gZdZaZgb_" Hl
\_l[uelZdh\©>Z_kebhgihdZyekyª«ªDZd\b^bl_g_dZ`^h_k\b^_l_ev
kl\hijb_fe_fh
567
Dhg_qghwlhlijbgpbifh`ghhkihjblvmqblu\ZylhlnZdlqlhijbgZ
klmie_gbb f_kypZ JZfZaZg Ijhjhd k]k ijbgbfZe k\b^_l_evkl\h h^gh]h
q_eh\_dZZijb_]haZ\_jr_gbb–^\moGh\wlhfkemqZ_ke_^m_lijh\_jylv
gZ^_`ghklvwlbok\b^_l_e_cBf_gghlZdihklmiZxl\HfZg_ihwlhfmmgbo
g_lgbdZdboijh[e_fkhij_^_e_gb_ff_kyp_\>hdlhjFmklZnZZr-RZ[ZdZ
ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©BkeZf [bey fZaZob[ª ibr_l ©<hl m`_ \
l_q_gb_g_kdhevdboe_l\hklhqgu_fmkmevfZg_gZqbgZxlihklf_kypZJZfZ
aZggZh^bg^_gvjZgvr_iheh`_ggh]hQlh`_dZkZ_lkyb[Z^blh\bij_^klZ
232
keh\Z k\b^_l_e_c g_h[oh^bfh k\_jylv k ^Zggufb Zkljhghfbb
<_^vZkljhghfby\hlebqb_hlZkljheh]bby\ey_lkylhqghcgZ
mdhck\yaZgghckfZl_fZlbdhc?keb_klv^Zggu_Zkljhghfbb
lhg_lgbdZdhcihlj_[ghklb\ki_pbZevguodhfbkkbyoihhij_
^_e_gbx gZqZeZ b dhgpZ f_kypZ Dh]^Z Zkljhghfby aZy\ey_l h
g_\hafh`ghklbm\b^_lvf_kyplhwlhagZqblqlh_]h^_ckl\b
l_evghg_[m^_l568.
Ihwlhfmjmdh\h^bl_eyffmkmevfZgkdbo]hkm^Zjkl\ke_
^m_l [ulv hkh[h hklhjh`gufb \gbfZl_evgufb b g_ ih^^Z
\Zlvky gZ ijh\hdZpbb \ZooZ[blh\ < oZ^bk_ IjhjhdZ k]k
kdZaZghqlhmdZ`^h]hgZjh^Zk\hcf_kyp569wlhk\yaZghkjZa
\bl_e_c ^jm]bo l_q_gbc lh hgb ihklmiZxl \_jgh ihkdhevdm ke_^mxl ijh
jhq_kdhfmoZ^bkmªba^k
568
Fg_gb_hkhihklZ\e_gbbk\b^_l_evkl\k^ZggufbZkljhghfbb\ukdZaZeb
fgh]b_mq_gu_GZijbf_jB[jZobf[bg=mfZjmf]]mq_guc
ba :e`bjZ \ k\h_f ibkvf_ fbgbkljm hkgh\gh]h b j_eb]bhagh]h h[jZah\Z
gbbgZibkZe©?kebdhfg_ijb^_lq_eh\_dbaZk\b^_l_evkl\m_lqlhhg\b
^_e f_kyp b _]h keh\Z [m^ml ih^l\_j`^Zlvky ^Zggufb Zkljhghfbb lh y
ijbfm_]hk\b^_l_evkl\hbh[ty\exhgZqZe_f_kypZGh_kebdhfg_ijb^_l
q_eh\_d b aZk\b^_l_evkl\m_l qlh m\b^_e f_kyp gh ^Zggu_ Zkljhghfbb [m
^ml]h\hjblvhlhfqlhf_kypm\b^_lvg_\hafh`ghbqlhhgaZc^_l^haZoh
^ZkhegpZbeb\f_kl_kgbflhhl\_j]gm_]hk\b^_l_evkl\hªLhqghlZdh]h
`_fg_gbyijb^_j`b\ZekybfZfLZdbx^^bgZk-Km[dbBo\ukdZau\Zgby\u
fh`_l_ijhkemrZlvgZkhhl\_lkl\mxsbodZkk_lZoZlZd`_\dgb]Zo^hdlhjZ
FmoZffZ^ZKZeboZGZkujZ
569
I_j_^Z_lkyhlDmjZc[ZqlhMffmZe-NZ^e[bglZe-OZjbkhlijZ\beZ_]h
\RZfdFmZ\bb©Yijb[ue\RZfbkihegbeihjmq_gb_b\wlh\j_fyfu
m\b^_ebgh\ucf_kypf_kypZJZfZaZgWlh[ueh\ghqvgZiylgbpmihwlhfm
\ km[[hlm fu gZqZeb ihkl < dhgp_ JZfZaZgZ y \_jgmeky \ F_^bgm ]^_
\klj_lbekyk=Z[^meehc[bg=Z[[ZkhfdhlhjucaZ^Zefg_jZaebqgu_\hijh
ku dh]^Z j_qv aZreZ h f_kyp_ hg kijhkbe m f_gy ©<u dh]^Z m\b^_eb gh
\ucf_kyp"ª-yhl\_lbe©<ghqvgZiylgbpmªHgkijhkbe©Lu\b^_e_]h
ebqgh"ª-yhl\_lbe©>Zb^jm]b_lh`__]hm\b^_ebbgZqZebihklbFmZ
\bygZqZeihkl\f_kl_kgZfbªB[g=Z[[ZkkdZaZe©:fu\b^_eb_]h\ghqv
gZ km[[hlm ihwlhfm k_cqZk ijh^he`Z_f ihkl ^h l_o ihj ihdZ g_ m\b^bf
f_kyprZ\\ZeybebihdZjZfZaZgg_^hihegblky^hljb^pZlb^g_cªYkijh
kbe©G_m`_ebl_[_g_^hklZlhqghf_kypZm\b^_ggh]hFmZ\b_c"ª-hghl\_
lbe ©G_l Ijhjhd k]k gZf \_e_e ihklmiZlv bf_ggh lZdª Ijb\h^blky m
FmkebfZZihoh`b_oZ^bkuijb\h^ylkymZl-LbjfbabZg-GZkZb:[m>Zm^Z
b:ofZ^Z
233
ghklvx]_h]jZnbq_kdh]hiheh`_gbylh]hbebbgh]h]hkm^Zjkl
\ZemgZlZd`_dZdbkhegp_^\b`_lkyihkljh]hmklZgh\e_g
gufbq_ldbfaZdhgZfIhwlhfmhgZg_fh`_l\^jm]ihy\blvky
lhevdhba-aZlh]hqlh\F_dd_bebF_^bg_j_rbebgZqZlvbeb
aZ\_jrblvihkl
< dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Z y ohqm ijb\_klb \ukdZau\Zgby ba\_
klgh]hmq_gh]h-ZkljhghfZOZeb^ZRZ\dZlZ570.
<hijhk ‹ ©>h f_gy ^hreZ bgnhjfZpby qlh \ DK:
gh\uc f_kyp m\b^_eb ] lh _klv bo ihkl ^he`_g [ue
gZqZlvky]gh\lh`_\j_fyfg_[uehba\_klghqlh\
wlhl \_q_j emgZ ^he`gZ [ueZ aZclb ihqlb h^gh\j_f_ggh k
khegp_f ihwlhfm fg_ dZ`_lky qlh \ DK: \b^_eb \hh[jZ`Z_
fucf_kypG_fh]eb[u\uijheblvk\_lgZwlhl\hijhk"AZjZ
g__[eZ]h^Zj_gª
Hl\_l©DZd\b^bl_\ubkZfbm[_^bebkv\aZ[em`^_gbb
\eZkl_cDK:>Zfulh`_keurZebboaZy\e_gbyihwlhfmih
\h^mbohlbfhlf_lblvqlhmgbodZ`^ucf_kypjh`^Z_lkygZ
h^bg^_gvjZgvr_q_f\hklZevguoj_]bhgZoGh\hagbdZ_l\h
ijhkZdZdlZdh_\hh[s_fh`_l[ulv"Fg_dZ`_lkyqlhboaZ
y\e_gby hkgh\Zgu gZ bkihevah\Zgbb dZe_g^Zjy k mdZaZgb_f
kjhdh\ ihy\e_gby ©gh\hemgbyª dhlhjh_ nZdlbq_kdb g_ \b^gh
M f_gy gZ jmdZo _klv ih^h[guc dZe_g^Zjv aZ ljb^pZlv e_l b
_keb\u\g_]h\a]eyg_l_lhh[gZjm`bl_qlhdZ`^ucf_kypgZ
qbgZ_lky gZ ke_^mxsbc ^_gv ihke_ gh\hemgby571 ih =jbg\bqm
dhlhjuck_cqZkkqblZ_lky\k_fbjgh-ijbgylufhlkq_lhfUTC).
Yg_^mfZxqlhhgbgZkZfhf^_e_\b^ylgZklhysbcfheh^hc
f_kyp AZqZklmx ex^b ih^\_j`_gu \ebygbxk\h_]h\hh[jZ`_
gby eb[h \b^yl jZaebqgu_ Zlfhkn_jgu_ wnn_dlu b y\e_gby
DZd \hafh`gh m\b^_lv f_kyp dhlhjuc aZr_e jZgvr_ aZoh^Z
KhegpZ"ª
R_co y\ey_lky iZdbklZgp_f ih ijhbkoh`^_gbx `b\_l \ KR: [he__
ih^jh[gh \u fh`_l_ hagZdhfblvky k _]h hl\_lZfb gZ Zg]ehyauqghf kZcl_
http://moonsighting.com.
571
Lh_klv\ZooZ[bluih^gZqZehff_kypZihgbfZxlgh\hemgb_
570
234
<hijhk ‹ ©Ij_^ijbgbfZebkv eb d_f-eb[h ihiuldb
^h\_klb^h\eZkl_cDK:572hrb[hqghklvboihabpbb"Bon_l\u
y\eyxlky ijbqbghc oZhkZ kj_^b fmkmevfZg KR: < gZr_c
kljZg_[uebf_q_lb\dhlhjucgZqZehfJZfZaZgZ[uehh[ty\
e_gh^_dZ[jy]ª
Hl\_l ©>Z lZdb_ ihiuldb ij_^ijbgbfZebkv ;ueb b
ibkvf_ggu_ h[jZs_gby b ^_e_]Zpbb gZijbf_j ba IZdbklZgZ
Bg^bbISNAK_\_jgZy:f_jbdZgh\eZklbDK:g_ih`_eZeb
d gbf ijbkemrZlvky Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ISNA lh hgZ h[ty\beZ
qlh ] gh\uc f_kyp m\b^_lv g_\hafh`gh ke_^h\Zl_ev
gh ] y\ey_lky ihke_^gbf ^g_f RZ][ZgZ Z ]
gZqbgZ_lkyJZfZaZg573».
<hijhk ‹ ©<k_ djhf_ HfZgZ b LmgbkZ [eb`g_\hk
lhqgu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ kljZgu gZqZehf JZfZaZgZ h[ty\beb
]Ihkmgg_IjhjhdZk]k\lhfkemqZ__keb^\h_fm
kmevfZgm\b^_ebgh\ucf_kyplh\kymffZh[yaZgZijbklmiblv
d ihklm574 JZa\_ g_ fh`_l qZklv fmkmevfZg ^_eZlv lh `_ qlh
^_eZxl^jm]b_?keb[uehh[ty\e_ghqlhdlh-eb[hm\b^_egh
\uc f_kyp JZfZaZgZ lh \hh[s_ g_ ke_^m_l h[jZsZlvky d ^Zg
guf Zkljhghfbb ?keb ^Z`_ \uykgblky qlh ijhbahreZ dZdZylhhrb[dZlh]j_oaZgZrg_\_jgucihkl[m^_le_`Zlvlhevdh
gZk\b^_l_eyoª
Hl\_l ©<Zrb ihke_^gb_ keh\Z ijhlb\hj_qZl DhjZgm
:eeZo g_ jZa ih\lhjy_l ©B gbdlh g_ ihg_k_l ghrb >]j_oh\@
^jm]h]hªwlhlZylih\lhjy_lky\DhjZg_iylvjZa
bª
G_dhlhju_^h\h^uihih\h^maZ[em`^_gby\ZooZ[blh\\
\hijhk_hfheh^hff_kyp_
A^_kvbf_xlky\\b^mr_cobhl\_qZxsb_aZwlhl\hijhk
?kebf_kypg_\b^_ggZAZiZ^_lhl_f[he___]hg_\hafh`ghm\b^_lvgZ
<hklhd_ ?keb [u hg [ue \b^_g \ ZjZ[kdbo kljZgZo lh \ KR: b ih^Z\gh
[ue[u\b^_gihkdhevdmihke__]hjh`^_gbyijhreh[uqZkh\
574
< \hijhk_ kh^_j`blky g_kdhevdh hrb[hd b h^gZ ba gbo aZdexqZ_lky \
lhfqlh^eygZqZeZf_kypZJZfZaZg^hklZlhqghk\b^_l_evkl\Zh^gh]hq_eh
\_dZZ^eyaZ\_jr_gby^\hbo
572
573
235
< l_e_]jZff_ dhfbkkbb ih n_l\Zf DK: i_j_^Zgghc jZfZaZgZ]‹Z^j_kh\ZgghcBhj^ZgbyZeY^m^ZfoZk-Kmd]hkih^bgmOZbexFZf^mom:[mAZc^m[ueh
kdZaZgh ©;eZ]h^Zjbf \Zk aZ iha^jZ\e_gby k gZqZehf f_kypZ
JZfZaZgbaZ\Zr_gZihfbgZgb_hkjhdZoihy\e_gbygh\h]hf_
kypZ\]gh`_eZ_f\ZfgZihfgblvqlhhij_^_e_gb_gZqZ
eZ f_kypZ ih^h[gh hij_^_e_gbx \j_f_gb fhebl\u ?keb kh
]eZkgh f_ddZgkdhfm dZe_g^Zjx \h \j_fy aZoh^Z khegpZ \ha
jZkl f_kypZ jZ\_g qZkZf lh ij_^u^msbc ^_gv575 kqblZ_lky
gZqZehff_kypZihkdhevdmkh]eZkghob^`j_kmldbgZqbgZxl
ky ihke_ aZoh^Z khegpZ Ghqv ij_^r_kl\m_l ^gx ihklZ >Z
ijbf_l :eeZo \Zr ihkl b \_jg_l _]h gZf gZ ke_^mxsbc ]h^
Iha^jZ\ey_f \Zk k gZklmiZxsbf ijZa^gbdhf b [eZ]h^Zjbf aZ
khljm^gbq_kl\h DK:wj-Jby^<ukrZy dhfbkkby ih n_l
\ZfFmoZffZ^[bg:ofZ^ª
Ijhn_kkhjOZbev:[mAZc^y\ey_lkyqe_ghfBhj^Zgkdh
]h Zkljhghfbq_kdh]h h[s_kl\Z JAS b j_]meyjgh ihemqZ_l hl
\ZooZ[blh\ ibkvfZ ih ih\h^m hij_^_e_gby gZqZeZ f_kyp_\ ih
ob^`j_<h^ghfbalZdboibk_f[uehkdZaZgh©?kebRZ]
[ZgZ ijboh^blky gZ ^_dZ[jy lh \hajZkl f_kypZ [m^_l kh
klZ\eylv qZkh\ lh _klv [hevr_ lj_[m_fh]h qZkh\ ih
wlhfm ^_dZ[jy hij_^_ey_lky dZd i_j\uc ^_gv f_kypZ jZfZ
aZg < lZdbo kemqZyo dZd ba\_klgh f_kyp aZoh^bl ^h aZoh^Z
khegpZªLZdh\\ZooZ[blkdbcf_kyp
;b^]Z
Kh\j_f_ggu_ ik_\^hkZeZnblu \k_ qlh g_ bkoh^bl hl
IjhjhdZ k]k ijbagZxl [b^]hc \\h^ys_c \ aZ[em`^_gb_
>ey h[hkgh\Zgby k\h_c ihabpbb hgb ijb\h^yl oZ^bk
©«om^rb_ ba ^_ygbc – gh\r_kl\Z \k_ gh\r_kl\Z y\eyxlky
[b^]ZZdZ`^Zy[b^]Z\\h^bl\aZ[em`^_gb_ª576Wlh_s_h^bg
ijbf_j ih\_joghklgh]h hlghr_gby \ZooZ[blh\ d \hijhkZf
L_i_jv \u ihgyeb ihq_fm \ZooZ[blu ihklhyggh imlZxl dZe_g^Zjv hgb
bkihevamxlba\jZs_ggucih^oh^
576
K g_[hevrhc jZagbp_c wlhl oZ^bk ijb\h^blky m Zg-GZkZb FmkebfZ b
^jm]booZ^bkh\_^h\
575
236
nbdoZ Qlh[u jZatykgblv wlhl \hijhk [he__ ih^jh[gh fu oh
lbfijb\_klbpblZlubadgb]b©:j-JZxZe-fm]lZ[Zjmnbomdfb
kZeZlb Zk-kZnZjª ijbgZ^e_`Zs_c i_jm KZ]b^Z [bg FZ[jmdZ
Ze-DZgm[b :\lhj ibr_l ©OZ^bk ©IjZ\^b\_crb_ keh\Z – wlh
keh\Z :eeZoZ \ ?]h Dgb]_ emqrbc imlv – wlh imlv IjhjhdZ
FmoZffZ^Zk]kom^rb_ba^_ygbc–wlhgh\r_kl\ZdZ`^h_
gh\r_kl\h_klv[b^]ZZdZ`^Zy[b^]Z\\h^bl\aZ[em`^_gb_ªy\ey_lkyh[sbfoZ^bkhfkqZklgufkfukehf?]hihykgy_loZ
^bk ©Dlh ihke_ k_[y hklZ\bl \ BkeZf_ [eZ]h_ gZqbgZgb_ lhl
ihemqblk\hxgZ]jZ^mbgZ]jZ^m\k_ol_odlhihklmibekh]eZk
gh _]h ijbf_jm ijbq_f gZ]jZ^Z _]h ihke_^h\Zl_e_c g_ [m^_l
mf_gvr_gZ : dlh ihke_ k_[y hklZ\bl \ BkeZf ^mjgh_ gZqbgZ
gb_ lhl ihemqbl k\hc ]j_o b ]j_o \k_o l_o dlh ihklmibe kh
]eZkgh_]hijbf_jmijbq_f]j_ob_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_cg_[m^ml
mf_gvr_guª577WlhloZ^bk^hklh\_j_gbijb\h^blkymFmkeb
fZ Zg-GZkZb Zl-Lbjfbab B[g FZ^`b Zl-LZyebkb :ofZ^Z
B[g Ob[[ZgZ B[g :[m RZc[u Zl-LZoZ\b B[g >`Z]^u ZlLZ[ZjZgb Ze-;ZcoZdb Ze-;Z]Z\b Wlhl oZ^bk mdZau\Z_l gZ lh
qlh g_ \k_ gh\r_kl\Z ijb^mfZggu_ ex^vfb y\eyxlky aehf
Kj_^bgbo_klvb[eZ]b_keh\Zbihklmidbb^mjgu_ghbl_b
^jm]b_ gh\r_kl\Z gZau\Zxlky [b^]ZMq_gu_ihwlhfmih\h^m
gZibkZebhq_gvfgh]hdgb]b]eZ\fug_[m^_fijb\h^blv\k_
bo keh\Z Z ebrv k^_eZ_f ba gbo \u\h^ h lhf qlh gh\r_kl\Z
^_eylky gZ ^\Z \b^Z d i_j\hfm hlghkylky ^_ygby ijhlb\hj_
qZsb_DhjZgmkmgg_bb^`fZ]mwlhl\b^[b^]Z^_ckl\bl_evgh
\\h^blfmkmevfZg\aZ[em`^_gb_bf_gghh[wlhf\b^_\oZ^b
<ZooZ[blu iulZxlky ^hdZaZlv qlh wlhl oZ^bk hq_gv qZklguc b k\yaZg
ebrv k ijbau\hf IjhjhdZ k]k d kih^\b`gbdZf hdZaZlv fZl_jbZevgmx
ihfhsv ^_e_]Zpbb ba Fm^ZjZ H[ wlhf ]h\hjblky \ ©FZ^`fm] nZlZ\Z \Z
jZkZbenZ^ueylr_coFmoZffZ^[bgKZeboZe-=mkZcfbgªkh[jZgghcNZo
^hf[bgGZkujhfZk-Kme_cfZghfbba^Zgghc\wj-Jby^_>ZjZe-\ZlZgl
kGhlZdZyihabpbyijhlb\hj_qblihklmidZfbklbgguokZeZnh\dZdh
\ufb [ueb ijZ\_^gu_ oZebnu ijb\g_krb_ \ BkeZf fgh]b_ [eZ]hjh^gu_
ljZ^bpbb<qZklghklb=mfZj[bgZe-OZllZ[ij_^eh`bekh\_jrZlvfhebl\m
lZjZ\bodhee_dlb\gh\f_q_lbbm\_ebqblvdhebq_kl\hjZdZ]Zlh\^h^\Z^pZ
lbJZa\_wlbex^bg_[uebl_fbdlh[hevr_gZkk\Zfb[hyekyijb\g_k_gby
[b^]Z\BkeZf"
577
237
k_ kdZaZgh ©«Z dZ`^Zy [b^]Z \\h^bl \ aZ[em`^_gb_ª dh \lh
jhfm\b^mhlghkylky[eZ]b_keh\Zb^_ygbyaZdhlhju_bkihe
gbl_evihemqZ_lgZ]jZ^mbf_gghhgbo\oZ^bk_kdZaZgh©Dlh
ihke_ k_[y hklZ\bl \ BkeZf_ [eZ]h_ gZqbgZgb_ǻ Ih^h[gh_
fg_gb_ \ukdZau\Zeb bfZf Zr-RZnb]b i_j_^Zgh :[m GZ]b
fhf\©OmebyZe-Z\ebyªZe-;ZcoZdb=baam^^bg[bg=Z[^mkZ
eyf \ ©:e-DZ\Z]b^ª b ©:l-LZj]b[m ]Zg kZeyl Zj-jZ]Zb[ ZefZm^m]Zª Zg-GZ\Z\b \ ©RZjo kZobo Fmkebfª b ©LZoab[ ZeZkfZ \Z Zk-kunZlª B[g OZaf Ze-=ZaZeb \ ©Boty ]memf Z^^bgª B[g Ze-:kbj \ ©:g-GboZyª :[m RZfZ \ ©FZ]Zebf ZkkmggZgª Zk-Kmxlu \ ©:e-:fjm [b Ze-bllb[Z] \Z Zg-gZox ]Zg
Ze-b[lb^Z]ª ©Omkg Ze-fZdkZ^ª b ©Ze-FZkZ[bo nb kZeZl ZllZjZ\boªZe-DZklZeZgb\©BjrZ^Zk-kZjbªB[gFZebd\©Fm
[ZjZdZe-ZaoZjrZjofZrZjbdZe-Zg\Zjª=ZebZe-DZjb\©RZjo
Ze-fbrdZlªZa-AZjdZgb\©RZjoZe-fm\ZllZªZe-OZe[b\©Bg
kZgZe-]mxgªB[g=Z[b^bg\©RZjoZe-fbrdZlªZr-RZgdblu
Ze-FZebdb \ ©AZ^me-fmkebfª bfZf Zk-KZebfb \ ©FZ]Zjb^`
Ze-ZfZeªb^jm]b_
H[ wlh `_ ibr_l B[g OZ^`Zj \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©NZlo Ze[Zjbª ©?keb hgZ [b^]Z y\ey_lky ^_ygb_f ihhsjy_fuf rZ
jbZlhf lh ijbagZ_lky [eZ]hc _keb `_ hgZ y\ey_lky ^_ygb_f
ihjbpZ_fuf rZjbZlhf lh ijbagZ_lky ^mjghc ?keb `_ hgZ g_
hlghkblky gb d i_j\hfm gb dh \lhjhfm \b^m lh ijbagZ_lky
^ha\he_gguf^_ygb_ffm[Zo^_eysbfkygZiylv\b^h\ª
H[wlhf`_ibr_lB[gL_cfby\©FZ^`fm]Ze-nZlZ\Zª
lk©«bgh]^Zhg]h\hjbelZdZbgh]^Zih-^jm]hfmb
ihiuldZ h[t_^bgblv ^\Z ^_ygby y\ey_lky g_ kmgghc Z [b^]Z
hgZfh`_l[ulvbgh]^Zb^ha\he_gghcªZg_fgh]hgb`_l
khgmdZau\Z_l©«[b^]Zg_hlghkblkygbdihhsjy_fhfm
gbdaZij_lghfm^eyl_odlh__kh\_jrZ_l_klvk\h_cijbf_j
Z^eyl_odlhhklZ\ey_l–k\hcª
G_dhlhju_ mq_gu_ kdZaZeb qlh oZ^bk ©dZ`^Zy [b^]Z
\\h^bl\aZ[em`^_gb_ªg_k_lhq_gvh[sbckfukeBih^[b^]Z
bf__lky\\b^m\k_qlhg_bf__lih^kh[hcrZjbZlkdmxhkgh
\m H[ wlhf ibkZeb Zk-KZcb^ Zk-KZgZ^ \ ©RZjo Ze-fbrdZlª
B[gJZ^`Z[\©>`Zfb]Ze-]mexf\ZZe-ZodZfªB[gOZ^`ZjZe238
OZclZfb \ ©:l-LZ[vbbg [b rZjo Ze-Zj[Z]bgª Za-AZjdZrb \
©:e-B[^Z]ªZe-EZdgZ\b\©LmonZlZe-ZovyjªFmoZffZ^;Zobl
Ze-Fmlu]b\k\h_fljZdlZl_h[b^]Z
LZdh]h`_fg_gbyijb^_j`b\ZekybB[gOZ^`Zj\k\h
_f ©NZlo Ze-[Zjbª hg g_ jZa mdZau\Z_l ©:e-Fmo^ZkZZl gh\
r_kl\Z ijhbkoh^bl hl _^bgkl\_ggh]h qbkeZ ©fmo^ZkZª gh\
r_kl\h < oZ^bk_ IjhjhdZ k]k ih wlhfm ih\h^m kdZaZgh
©?kebdlh\\_e\wlhgZr_^_ehlhq_]h\g_fg_[uehlhhgh
[m^_l hl\_j]gmlhª - lh _klv bf__lky \ \b^m \\_e lh qlh g_
bf__lrZjbZlkdhchkgh\ubbf_gm_lkyl_jfbghf©[b^]Zª?keb
`_mwlh]hgh\h]h^_ygby_klv\rZjbZl_hkgh\Zlhhghg_gZ
au\Z_lky [b^]Zª < ^jm]hf f_kl_ hg mdZau\Z_l ©;b^]Z – wlh
^_ygb_g_bf_xs__ijbf_jZ<rZjbZl_hghy\ey_lkyZglbih
^hfkmggubihwlhfmihjbpZ_lkyª
DZd \b^bl_ fu k \Zfb bf__f jZagh]eZkby ebrv \ l_j
fbgheh]bbkmlv`_\ukdZau\Zgbck\h^blkydlhfmqlhgh\u_
^_ygby ijhlb\hj_qZsb_ k\ys_gguf l_dklZf ijbagZxlky ih
jbpZ_fhc [b^]Z Z gh\u_ ^_ygby kh\iZ^Zxsb_ kh kfukehf
k\ys_gguol_dklh\bg_kmsb_\k_[_ihevamijbagZxlkyh^h[
jy_fhc[b^]Zbeb`_fh]ml[ulvhlg_k_gudjZajy^m^ha\he_g
guo^_ygbcHkgh\gufdjbl_jb_f\wlhf\hijhk_y\ey_lkygZ
ebqb_ beb hlkmlkl\b_ rZjbZlkdhc hkgh\u Gh _keb wlZ hkgh\Z
gZfg_ba\_klgZwlh_s_g_agZqblqlh__g_l<k_\ur_ijb\_
^_ggu_ \ukdZau\Zgby mq_guo k\h^ylky bf_ggh d wlbf aZdex
q_gbyf
Ba\_klgh qlh kih^\b`gbdb IjhjhdZ k]k ihke_ _]h
kf_jlb\g_keb\BkeZffgh]hgh\h]hqlh\h\j_f_gZIjhjhdZ
k]kba\_klghg_[uehDlZdbfgh\uf^_ygbyffh`ghhlg_k
lb aZieZgbjh\Zggh_ kljhbl_evkl\h gh\uo ]hjh^h\ hj]ZgbaZ
pbx \ukrbo ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo kh\_lh\ ^b\Zg \\_^_gb_ e_lh
kqbke_gbyihob^`j_^h[Z\e_gb_i_j\h]hZaZgZdihjy^dmiyl
gbqghc fhebl\u aZibkv DhjZgZ b _]h dhibjh\Zgb_ \ k_fb wd
a_fieyjZoBgbdlhgb\bo\j_f_gZgbiha`_g_h[ty\beqlh
kih^\b`gbdbkh\_jrbebqlh-lhaZij_lgh_
M^b\ey_l lh qlh \ZooZ[blu aZij_sZxl ijhbaghkblv
©Bklbgm kdZaZe <k_\urgbc :eeZoª ©KZ^ZdZeeZo Ze-]Zaufª
239
ih aZ\_jr_gbb ql_gby DhjZgZ ihkdhevdm wlh]h ydh[u g_l \
kmgg_Ghwlh\ujZ`_gb__klvkDhjZg_©KdZ`b>FmoZffZ^@
³:eeZo ]eZ]he_l bklbgm´ª mqlbl_ qlh ^ey gZk bf__l
agZq_gb_ h[sbc kfuke njZau Z g_ qZklghklv __ ijbqbgu ih
wlhfm g_kfhljy gb gZ qvb ij_l_gabb fu aZy\ey_f ©Bklbgm
kdZaZe :eeZo b bklbgm kdZaZe ?]h ihkeZggbdª Gh _keb m`_
[ulv^hdhgpZihke_^h\Zl_evgufblhfulj_[m_fhl\ZooZ[b
lh\^hdZaZl_evkl\Z^ha\he_gghklbijhbag_k_gbynjZau©>Zhk
\ylbl :eeZo _]h ^mrmª ihke_ bf_gb FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me
\ZooZ[Z578>_eh\lhfqlhm\ZooZ[blh\g_lhkgh\hiheZ]Zxs_
]h ijbgpbiZ \ \hijhk_ h [b^]Z ihwlhfm hgb \b^yl gh\r_kl\Z
bf_ggh\l_o^_ygbyodhlhju_\k_fmkmevfZg_ijbagZxlkmg
ghc Gh lh]^Z \hagbdZ_l \hijhk ihq_fm hgb g_ hkm`^Zxl ih
klmidb mq_guo dhlhju_ ijhklZ\beb \ DhjZg_ lhqdb b oZjZdZ
lu" JZa\_ wlh g_ [b^]Z kh\_jr_ggu_ ihke_ IjhjhdZ k]k"
<_^v dh]^Z kih^\b`gbdb aZibku\Zeb DhjZg kh keh\ IjhjhdZ
k]khgbaZibkZeb_]h[_alhq_dboZjZdZlh\Ihq_fm`_hgb
kZfbk_[_ijhlb\hj_qZlbijh^he`ZxlqblZlvDhjZgklhqdZfb
boZjZdZlZfb"Ihq_fmhgbkljhylf_q_lbkfbojZ[Zfb"–\_^v
wlh]hijbIjhjhd_k]kg_[uehhgbihy\bebkvlhevdhq_j_a
^_\yghklhe_lihke__]hkf_jlb=^_`_q_ldbcbykgucdjbl_
jbc\ZooZ[blkdh]hihgylby©[b^]Zª"
G_ y\ey_lky k_dj_lhf qlh \ZooZ[blu h[ty\eyxl [b^]Z
^Z`_ijZa^gh\Zgb_jh`^_gbyIjhjhdZk]khgbkqblZxlqlh
wlh y\ey_lky \ha\jZlhf d yauq_kl\m bm^Zbafm b ojbklbZgkl
\m579 Ba\_klgh qlh B[g OZ^`Zj Ze-=ZkdZeygb gZa\Ze wlh ^_y
gb_ihhsjy_fhc[b^]Z<dZq_kl\_^h\h^Zhgijb\_ebklhjbxh
lhfdZdIjhjhdk]kihijb[ulbb\F_^bgmmagZehlhfqlh
bm^_b ihklylky \ ^_gv =ZrmjZ B dh]^Z hg ihbgl_j_kh\Zeky m
gbo h ijbqbg_ wlh]h ihklZ hgb hl\_lbeb ©< wlhl ^_gv :eeZo
kiZkFmkm]khlnZjZhgZihwlhfmfuihklbfkyba[eZ]h^Zj
ghklb d :eeZom aZ ?]h fbehklvª B lh]^Z Ijhjhd k]k hl\_
Kf©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^ªbih^h[gu_
Kf dhff_glZjbb r_coZ FmoZffZ^Z OZfb^Z Ze-NZdb d dgb]_ B[g L_c
fbb©Bdlb^ZZk-kujZlZe-fmklZdbfªk
578
579
240
lbe©Ybf_x[hevr_ijZ\\hlghr_gbbFmku]kq_f\uªb gZqZe ihklblvky \ wlhl ^_gv b \_e_e ihklblvky k\hbf kih
^\b`gbdZf B[g OZ^`Zj dhff_glbjmy wlhl oZ^bk ibr_l
©WlhloZ^bkmdZau\Z_lgZlhqlh[eZ]h^Zjghklv:eeZom\^_gv
dh]^ZHgbaebegZK\hbojZ[h\fbehklvy\ey_lky[h]hm]h^guf
^_ehf : jZa\_ fh`_l [ulv [hQevrZy [h`_kl\_ggZy fbehklv
q_f jh`^_gb_ IjhjhdZ k]kª LZdh]h `_ fg_gby ijb^_j`b
\Zebkv fgh]b_ ^jm]b_ mq_gu_ b \ qZklghklb oZnba B[g ZeOZg[Zeb B ^Z`_ B[g L_cfby ih wlhfm ih\h^m ibr_l ©G_dh
lhju_ ex^b \ha\_ebqb\Zxl ^_gv jh`^_gby IjhjhdZ k]k b
ij_\jZsZxl_]h\hkh[ucj_eb]bhaguch[jy^Dhg_qgh`_hgb
aZlZdh_[eZ]h_gZf_j_gb_bihqblZgb_IjhjhdZk]kihemqZl
gZ]jZ^mhl:eeZoZª580ZaZg_kdhevdhkljZgbp^hwlh]hhgmdZ
au\Z_l ©:eeZo gZ]jZ^bl wlbo ex^_c aZ bo ex[h\v b klZjZ
gb_ª581.
<ZooZ[blkdb_[b^]Z
jZfZaZgZ]]ihke_mlj_gg_cfhebl
\u h^bg bo oZrZ\blkdbo \h`^_c dhlhjuo gZau\Zxl ©\ZrZ
k\_lehklv k\ys_gkl\hª582 \hkk_^Zy i_j_^ FZdZf B[jZobfZ
]kqblZee_dpbxhlhfdZdb_^_ygby^_eZxldjh\vfmkmev
fZgbgZ583^ha\he_gghc<h\j_fywlhce_dpbbhgmihfygmeqlh
]j_rgbdb[m^mlgZoh^blvky\:^miylvkhle_l584.
B[gL_cfby©Bdlb^ZZk-kujZl«ª–K
LZf`_k<b^bfhwlbkeh\Zhq_gvaZ^_ebr_coZFmoZffZ^ZOZfb
^Z Ze-NZdb ihwlhfm hg kdZaZe ©DZd `_ hgb fh]ml aZ wlh ihemqblv gZ]jZ
^m"?keb^Z`_dlh-eb[hkdZ`_lqlhhgbkh\_jrbebb^`lboZ^lhfuhl\_
lbf ³JZa\_ wlh fh`gh gZa\Zlv b^`lboZ^hf"´ª <a]eygbl_ gZ ©q_ldb_ b yk
gu_ª^h\h^uwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
582
Y^mfZxqlhwlh[uer_coFmoZffZ^KZeboZe-=mk_cfbgDhg_qghbaaZ[hevrh]hqbkeZijbkmlkl\h\Z\rboyg_jZa]ey^_e_]hebpZghg_kfhljy
gZ wlh ^mfZx qlh wlh [ue hg ihkdhevdm \ wlh \j_fy e_dpbb qblZe lhevdh
hg
583
Ihbofg_gbxIhkfhljbl_gZbohkgh\gh_aZgylb_bhkgh\gmxl_fZlbdm
e_dpbcDZdihke_wlh]hhgbfh]mlijhbaghkblvj_qbhdjZcghklyo"
584
©Hgb l\_j^yl ³G_ ho\Zlbl gZk h]hgv gb \ dh_f kemqZ_ jZa\_ qlh gZ
kqblZggu_^gb´Hl\_qZcbf³Beb\uihemqbebgZlhh[_sZgb_:eeZoZ–Z
580
581
241
Dhg_qgh dZ`^h_ aZy\e_gb_ lj_[m_l ^hdZaZl_evkl\ b
r_co\dZq_kl\_^h\h^Zijb\_eoZ^bkhlhfqlh[h]Zlu_\hc^ml
\JZcgZiylvkhle_l585iha`_q_f[_^gu_Ih_]hfg_gbxwlh
]hkjhdZ^hklZlhqgh^eylh]hqlh[u]j_rgbdbihemqbebgZdZ
aZgb_ aZ k\hb ^_ygby ihdbgmeb :^ b ijbkh_^bgb\rbkv d fm
kmevfZgZf_s_g_\hr_^rbf\JZc\hreb\f_kl_kgbfb
Yij_^eZ]ZxqblZl_exkZfhfmk^_eZlv\u\h^h[mf_kl
ghklbbijb_fe_fhklblZdbo\u\h^h\Ghmf_gyebqgh\hagbd
\hijhkZihdZdhfmijZ\mwlb]j_rgbdb\hc^ml\JZch^gh\j_
f_ggh k =Z[^jZofZghf [bg =Zmnhf b ^jm]bfb m\Z`Z_fufb
kih^\b`gbdZfb"
H :eeZo fu iheghklvx kh]eZkgu k l_f q_eh\_dhf dh
lhjucgZa\ZebaoZrZ\blZfbbom[_`^_gby^_ckl\bl_evghimk
lhl_euhgbg_kh^_j`Zlgbq_]hqlh_klv\DhjZg_bkmgg_Bo
p_ev–ihdZaZlvex^yfe_]dh\_kghklvbo]j_oh\bf_gghihwlh
fmFmoZffZ^Dml[gZa\Zebo©g_hfmj^`bblZfbª
Ihkfhljbl_ gZ wlbo ex^_c dhlhju_ ydh[u [hjxlky k
[b^]Z GZ kZfhf ^_e_ hgb kZfb y\eyxlky bah[j_lZl_eyfb kZ
fuo \_ebqZcrbo [b^]Z b h[e_]qbl_eyfb ]j_oh\guo ^_ygbc
:eeZomfuijbgZ^e_`bfbdG_fm\ha\jZsZ_fky
B[g;Zab\jZs_gb_A_feb
R_co =Z[^me]Zaba [bg =Z[^meeZ [bg ;Za [ue h^gbf ba
l_o dlh aZsbsZe \ZooZ[blkdmx Zdu^m b ^_eZe \k_ qlh[u kh
ojZgblv __ `bag_kihkh[ghklv Ijb wlhf hg g_ ]gmrZeky gbdZ
dbfbkj_^kl\Zfb\iehlv^haZimlu\ZgbyZylh\DhjZgZboZ^b
kh\ IjhjhdZ k]k kljh]h ke_^my ijbf_jm k\hbo ij_^r_kl
\_ggbdh\R_cohq_gvkf_e\k\hboaZy\e_gbyohgke_]dhklvx
h[\bgy_l fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb b k lZdhc `_ e_]dhklvx ^_eZ_l
aZy\e_gby ijhlb\hj_qZsb_ ^h\h^Zf jZkkm^dZ H^gbf ba ijb
f_jh\lZdboaZy\e_gbcy\ey_lkyn_l\Z]\dhlhjhckdZaZ
keh\mK\h_fm:eeZogbdh]^Zg_baf_gbl-beb`_\uihg_\_^_gbx\ha\h^b
l_gZ:eeZoZgZijZkebgm´ª (2:80).
585
OZ^bk©;_^gu_\hc^ml\JZcgZiylvkhle_lbiheh\bgm^gyjZgvr_q_f
[h]Zlu_ª
242
gh ©B^_y h lhf qlh Khegp_ g_ih^\b`gh586 Z A_fey bf__l
djm]emxnhjfmy\ey_lkyijhlb\ghcbm`ZkghcDlhml\_j`^Z
_l qlh A_fey \jZsZ_lky Z Khegp_ g_ih^\b`gh y\ey_lky aZ
[em^rbf g_\_jguf ?]h ke_^m_l ijba\Zlv d ihdZygbx Z _keb
hldZ`_lky lh dZagblv dZd g_\_jgh]h b \_jhhlklmigbdZ Z bfm
s_kl\h dhgnbkdh\Zlv \ ihevam fmkmevfZgkdhc ]hkm^Zjkl\_g
ghcdZagu[ZclZe-fZeZe-fmkebfbgª
< ] ] <k_fbjgZy gZmqgZy dhfbkkby ih n_l
\Zfijbau\mbgZklZ\e_gbyf\wj-Jby^_ba^ZeZ[jhrxjmr_c
oZ]^_[uebkh[jZgu\k__]h^h\h^u\ihevamlh]hqlhA_fey
gZoh^blky \ khklhygbb ihdhy <hl g_dhlhju_ ba gbo ©<k_ kZ
eZnu b \ qZklghklb B[g L_cfby B[g DZkkbj b B[g ZeDZcbf _^bgh]eZkgh \ukdZaZebkv \ ihevam lh]h qlh a_fey
g_ih^\b`gZªLZdh\_]hi_j\uc^h\h^Qlh`_dZkZ_lkyklbey
baeh`_gbylhhg^h\hevghkeZ[Gh[hevr_\k_]hm^b\ey_llh
qlhhgbh[jZsZxlkydDhjZgmbkmgg_
R_co aZy\eye qlh \ l_ ]h^u dh]^Z [ue ajyqbf bf_e
q_klvebqghgZ[ex^Zlv^\b`_gb_KhegpZbm[_^beky\lhfqlh
g_[hk\h^ g_ rZjhh[jZaguc Z dmihehh[jZaguc b ih^^_j`b\Z
_lkyZg]_eZfb587?keb[uKhegp_[ueh[ug_ih^\b`ghlhgZf
g_[ueb[u\_^hfu\j_f_gZ]h^ZZ\j_fy\h\k_oqZklyok\_lZ
[ueh[uh^bgZdh\uf588.
AZy\e_gb_r_coZhlhfqlhKhegp_g_ih^\b`gh_s_h^bg^h\h^\ihevam
lh]hqlhhg`b\_l^Ze_dhhlj_Zebckh\j_f_gghc`bagbDjhf_lh]hr_co
^_eZ_lb^jm]b_g_h[^mfZggu_aZy\e_gbyh[\bgyy\g_\_jbbl_odlhljZd
lm_l[h`_kl\_ggu_Zljb[mluqlhydh[uih_]hfg_gbx\_^_ldhljbpZgbx
wlbo Zljb[mlh\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ^Zgghc n_l\u lh __ kfuke \ lhf qlh[u
h[ty\blvg_\_jgufb\k_ol_odlh\_jblqlhA_fey\jZsZ_lky\hdjm]Kheg
pZb\hdjm]k\h_chkbGh^Zggu_k_]h^gyrg_cgZmdbgZfykghihdZau\Zxl
qlh\k_a\_a^ubieZg_lu^\b`mlkyihk\hbfhj[blZf\jZs_gb_ieZg_l\h
djm] k\h_c hkb y\ey_lky ijbqbghc kf_gu ^gy b ghqb Z \jZs_gby \hdjm]
k\_lbeZ–ijbqbghckf_gu\j_f_g]h^Z
587
Fu \Zf kh\_lm_f \aylv dZjZg^Zr gZjbkh\Zlv dZjlbgm hibku\Z_fmx
r_cohfbihkfhlj_lvqlhihemqblky
588
<hl _]h \lhjhc ^h\h^ gh dZd gZf ba\_klgh ijbqbghc \hagbdgh\_gby
\j_f_g]h^Zy\ey_lkybf_ggh\jZs_gb_a_feb\hdjm]khegpZ
586
243
>Ze__ hg \ k\h_c dgb]_ ibr_l ©Fgh]b_ ij_ih^Z\Zl_eb
Zkljhghfbb ijb^_j`b\Zxlky b^_c h lhf qlh Khegp_ g_ih
^\b`gh Z A_fey \jZsZ_lky \hdjm] g_]h wlh y\gh_ g_\_jb_ b
aZ[em`^_gb_ Wlh fg_gb_ ijhlb\hj_qbl DhjZgm kmgg_ b \u
kdZau\Zgbyf kZeZnh\ DZd g_ fh`_l [ulv g_\_jguf q_eh\_d
ijhlb\ysbckyijbjh^_\_s_c"ª-b^Ze__\dZq_kl\_^h\h^Zhg
ibr_l©?keb[uA_feyijbreZ\^\b`_gb_lhq_eh\_dhklZeky
[ugZf_kl_bgbdm^Zg_kfh][u^h[jZlvkyIj_ih^Z\Zgb_wlhc
bgnhjfZpbb mqZsbfky b klm^_glZf ijb\h^bl bo d [_a[h`bx
k_cqZk fgh]b_ fmkmevfZg_ gZqZeb ijbagZ\Zlv wlb b^_b gZmq
gufnZdlhfª
Ijh^he`Zy k\hx Zj]mf_glZpbx hg ibr_l ©?keb [u
dZdhgbml\_j`^ZxlA_fey^\b]ZeZkvlh^\b]Zebkv[ubkljZ
gu b ^_j_\vy b j_db \k_ ijbreh [u \ ^\b`_gb_ AZiZ^gu_
kljZguhdZaZebkv[ugZ\hklhd_Z\hklhqgu_gZaZiZ^_b^Z`_
db[eZk^\bgmeZkv[ukf_klZ?keb[uA_fey^\b]ZeZkvlhex
^bihqm\kl\h\Zeb[uwlhlZd`_dZdhgbqm\kl\mxl^\b`_gb_
dhjZ[eykZfhe_lZb^jm]bodjmiguo\b^h\ljZgkihjlZª589.
FmkmevfZg dhlhju_ ijbagZxl qlh a_fey bf__l rZjh
h[jZagmxnhjfmr_coh[\bgbe\lhfqlhhgbke_^mxlaZfg_
gb_f ex^_c `_eZxsbo ba\jZlblv fmkmevfZgkdmx Zdu^m hl
dZau\Zxlkybkihevah\Zlvk\hcjZamfbmih^h[eyxlky[_afha]
euf`b\hlguf
Bih^\h^yblh]r_coB[g;ZaaZy\ey_l©Q_eh\_dijb
^_j`b\Zxsbckyfg_gbyh\jZs_gbbA_feby\ey_lkyg_\_jguf
b aZ[em^rbf hg g_ ijbagZ_l DhjZg b kmggm _]h ke_^m_l ijb
a\ZlvdihdZygbx?keb`_hghldZ`_lkyihdZylvky_]hke_^m_l
m[blvdZdg_\_jgh]hb\_jhhlklmigbdZZbfms_kl\hdhgnbkdh
\Zlv\ihevamfmkmevfZgkdhcdZaguª590.
H:eeZo^ZjmcgZr_fmjZamfmm\_j_gghklvbihdhc
Wlh ykgh_ aZy\e_gb_ r_coZ Fu g_ klZ\bf k\h_c p_evx \ubkdb\Zgb_
hrb[hd mq_guo gZk \hafmsZ_l lhl nZdl qlh hg h[ty\ey_l ^ha\he_gghc
djh\v fmkmevfZg <_^v ^ey wlh]h ke_^m_lh[eZ^Zlv[_kkihjgufb^Zggufb
gZf`_lhqghba\_klghqlhr_coy\ey_lky`_jl\hcfZehe_lgbo\ZooZ[blh\
HgbaZqblu\Zxl_fmhlju\dbbadgb]K_b^ZZe-Dml[ZbgZhkgh\_wlh]hhg
589
590
244
LZdmxqmrvg_kmlfgh]b_\ZooZ[blu\qZklghklbr_co
=Z[^medZjbf [bg KZebo Ze-OZfb^b ^Z`_ gZibkZe dgb]m ©Ob
^ZylZe-oZcjZgnbfZkZeZZ^-^ZmjZgª
Ihq_fm`_\ZooZ[bluaZsbsZxlb^_xhg_ih^\b`ghklb
A_feb"
<ZooZ[blu\p_ehfkqblZxlqlh\k_kh\j_f_ggu_gZmdb
jZajmrZxlfmkmevfZgkdmxZdu^mIjh[e_fZ\lhfqlhb^_yh
\jZs_gbb a_feb ^_ckl\bl_evgh jZajmrZ_l bo fm^`Zkkbfbl
kdmx Zdu^m hkgh\Zggmx gZ ij_^klZ\e_gbb h lhf qlh :eeZo
gZoh^blky \ g_[_ Bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb aZy\eyxl qlh ©B^_y h
\jZs_gbb A_feb om`_ l_hjbb h ijhbkoh`^_gbb q_eh\_dZ hl
h[_avyguªFugZ^__fkyqlhwlZn_l\Z[m^_llheqdhf^eyfgh
]boex^_cqlh[uhgbi_j_kfhlj_ebk\hb\a]ey^ubi_j_klZeb
ke_^h\ZlvaZ\ZooZ[blZfb
N_l\Zhkimlgbdh\uoZgl_ggZo
K_dlZ \ZooZ[blh\ hlebqZ_lky l_f qlh ex[bl h[\bgylv
ex^_c\g_\_jbbaZij_sZlvbjZkij_^_eylvdh]h\JZcZdh]h
\ :^ Hgb \jZ`^_[gu dh \k_fm qlh bf g_\_^hfh Bf_ggh ih
wlhfmhgbki_rZlaZij_lblv\k_gh\h_JZgvr_hgbaZij_sZeb
bkihevah\Zgb_ Z\lhfh[be_c l_e_]jZnZ l_e_nhgZ591 k_]h^gy
`_hgbaZij_sZxlbkihevah\Zgb_kimlgbdh\uoZgl_gg
Fuohlbfij_^klZ\blv\Zr_fm\gbfZgbxn_l\mh^gh]h
ba ©k\_lbeª \ZooZ[bafZ \ dhlhjhc hg h[ty\ey_l g_\_jgufb
l_odlhihevam_lkykimlgbdh\ufbZgl_ggZfb
<hijhk ©;m^_l eb ebr_g JZy lhl dlh ijb `bagb ihev
ah\Zekykimlgbdh\ufbZgl_ggZfb"ª
Hl\_l ©?keb gZ dh]h-eb[h :eeZo gZeh`be hl\_lkl\_g
ghklv aZ ^jm]bo Z hg ih^\_e k\hbo ih^hi_qguo lh :eeZo eb
rblwlh]hq_eh\_dZJZyWlZhl\_lkl\_gghklvfh`_l[ulv\_eb
dhc fh`_l [ulv fZehc d g_c `_ hlghkblky hl\_lkl\_gghklv
fm`qbguaZk\hxk_fvxIjhjhdk]kihwlhfmih\h^m\h^
ba^Z_ln_l\uhaZij_l__]hdgb]bfhev[uaZg_]hBf_gghmq_gu_^ZxlgZ
ijZ\e_gb_h[s_kl\_gghcfukeb
591
Jby^GZ^`b[Zj-JZcbk©JbyoZk-kZfmfZk-KZ]m^by\Z^Z\eylZe-^`ZabjZ
[Z]^ZoZj[Ze-oZeb^`-]]ª–L–K
245
ghfbak\hbooZ^bkh\kdZaZe©Fm`qbgZiZklmok\h_ck_fvbb
hl\_lkl\_g_g aZ g__ª592 Bkoh^y ba wlh]h _keb dlh-eb[h mfb
jZyhklZ\ey_l\k\h_f^hf_kimlgbdh\mxZgl_ggmlhlij_^Z_l
k\hxk_fvxhggZjmrZ_laZ\_lb[m^_lebr_gJZydZdh[wlhf
kdZaZgh \ oZ^bk_ª <hl lZdbf h[jZahf wlhl kf_euc fmnlbc k
e_]dhklvx ebrbe JZy fgh]bo fmkmevfZg fbjZ lZdh_ hsms_
gb_qlhdexqbhlJZy\_]hjmdZo
<h-i_j\uoqlhhghl\_lbll_fdlhdmibekimlgbdh\mx
Zgl_ggmqlh[ukfhlj_lvfmkmevfZgkdb_i_j_^Zqb"Bebhlke_
`b\Zlv\j_f_gZfhebl\u\F_dd_"
<h-\lhjuobkihevah\Zgb_kimlgbdh\uoZgl_gg^Z_lfm
kmevfZgZf[hevr_k\h[h^u\aZsbl_k_[yhl^mjgh]hHgi_j_
klZg_l kfhlj_lv f_klgu_ jZa\jZlgu_ i_j_^Zqb b aZf_gbl bo
fmkmevfZgkdbfblh`_kZfh_[m^ml^_eZlvb_]h^_lb
<-lj_lvboqlhhghl\_lblfmkmevfZgZf`b\msbf\aZ
iZ^guokljZgZob`_eZxsbfqlh[ubo^_lbagZebyaudDhjZ
gZ b kfhlj_eb fmkmevfZgkdb_ i_j_^Zqb fmkmevfZgkdb_ gh\h
klb"
KdZdhce_]dhklvxwlbex^b^_eyl^jm]bogZ\_jmxsbo
bg_\_jguoDZde_]dhhgbjZkij_^_eyxlf_klZ\JZx^Z`_g_
bamqb\kmlb\hijhkZ<q_f`_jZagbpZf_`^mdZgZehf©:jZ[
kZlªb^jm]bfbdZgZeZfbdhlhju_b^mlihf_klghfml_e_\b^_
gbx":qlhhgkdZ`_lihih\h^mwlbodZgZeh\"
<-q_l\_jluohgbkZfbg_\_^Zylh]h\iZ^Zxl\ijhlb
\hj_qb_Bor_cobaZy\eyxlqlh]j_rgbdbg_hklZgmlky\:^m
gZ\_qgh bf_ggh \ wlhf hgb jZkoh^ylky k b[Z^blZfb DZd `_
hgb fh]ml ml\_j`^Zlv qlh q_eh\_d bkihevamxsbc kimlgbdh
\mxZgl_ggmg_\hc^_l\JZc"JZa\_wlhg_y\gh_ijhlb\hj_qb_
\\ZooZ[blkdhfmq_gbb"
<-iyluobkoh^ybawlhcn_l\ubkihevah\Zgb_Bgl_jg_
lZlZd`_^he`gh[ulvaZij_s_gguf\_^v\Bgl_jg_l_jZa\jZlZ
^Z`_[hevr_q_fgZkimlgbdh\uodZgZeZo
<hllZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[blupblbjmxloZ^bkuIjhjhdZk]kZaZl_f
^_eZxl\u\h^u
592
246
<-r_kluo kh]eZkgh wlhc n_l\_ ke_^m_l aZij_lblv l_e_
nhgb^jm]b_ijbkihkh[e_gbybbgkljmf_glu\_^vex^bfh]ml
bkihevah\Zlvbo\^mjguop_eyo
<-k_^vfuo ohqm aZy\blv qlh gZ kZfhf ^_e_ \ZooZ[blu
^Z`_ g_ agZxl ijhlb\ q_]h [hjxlky <_^v kj_^kl\Z k\yab ih
klhyggh jZa\b\Zxlky b \hafh`gh \ kdhjhf \j_f_gb fh`gh
[m^_l ijbgbfZlv kimlgbdh\u_ dZgZeu g_ bf_y ki_pbZevghc
Zgl_gguIhwlhfmg_Zgl_ggugm`ghaZij_sZlvZ\hkiblu\Zlv
k\hbo ^_l_c lZd qlh[u hgb kfhlj_eb kimlgbdh\u_ dZgZeu ba
[bjZl_evgh b klhjhgbebkv aZij_lgh]h <_^v \ f_kyp jZfZaZg
gZfibsZlh`_^hklmigZghfu`_\ha^_j`b\Z_fkyhlg__>Z
fh`gh ihkh\_lh\Zlv fmkmevfZgZf aZdhiZlv k\hb ]heh\u \ i_
khd gh wlh [m^_l k\b^_l_evkl\hf ihegh]h g_\_`_kl\Z hlghkb
l_evgh^moZBkeZfZ
<-\hkvfuo ^Z fmkmevfZgbg [m^_l ij_^Zl_e_f k\h_c
k_fvbghlhevdh\lhfkemqZ__keb\hkiblZ_l__[_agjZ\kl\_g
ghcbij_^hklZ\bl_ckj_^kl\Z\_^msb_djZa\jZlmbiZ^_gbx
GZkZfhf`_^_e_r_comke_^h\Zeh[uijbau\ZlvfmkmevfZgd
[h]h[hyag_gghklbwlh[he__p_ggh_[h]Zlkl\h
<-^_\yluor_comke_^h\Zeh[uh[tykgblvqlhkimlgb
dh\u_Zgl_ggu–wlhlZdhc`_bgkljmf_glblZdh_kj_^kl\hbg
nhjfZpbb dZd b ^jm]b_ B \k_ aZ\bkbl hl lh]h \hkihevam_lky
eb bf q_eh\_d \h [eZ]h beb`_\h\j_^FmkmevfZgZf`_ke_
^m_l dZd fh`gh Zdlb\g__ bkihevah\Zlv wlh kj_^kl\h ^ey jZk
ijhkljZg_gbyBkeZfZ
<-^_kyluowlZn_l\Zkha^ZeZ\h[s_kl\_lZdhcj_ahgZgk
qlh ^Z`_ g_dhlhju_ fmkmevfZg_ hldZau\Zebkv \u^Z\Zlv k\hbo
^hq_j_c aZfm` aZ l_o ex^_c dhlhju_ ihevah\Zebkv kimlgbdh
\ufb Zgl_ggZfb Z ^jm]b_ fmkmevfZg_ \ayebkv aZ hohlgbqvb
jm`vybgZqZebklj_eylvihgbfDlhbf^ZeijZ\hihjlblvqm
`h_bfms_kl\h"LZdh\uieh^uj_eb]bhaghcke_ihlu
WlZ n_l\Z [ueZ ba^ZgZ fmnlb_f r_cohf FmoZffZ^hf
[bg KZebohf Ze-=mk_cfbghf ] ] Z
] ] hg ihklZ\be ih^ g_c ih^ibkv qlh
agZqbeh_]hkh]eZkb_gZjZkijhkljZg_gb_\i_qZlb
247
>\b`_gb_\fhebl\_
<h \j_fy jZ^bhi_j_^Zqb ©Gmj ]Zey Z^-^Zj[ª ©K\_l gZ
imlbªr_comB[g;ZamaZ^Zeb\hijhkh^himklbfhklb\a]ey^Z
gZqZku\h\j_fyfhebl\uFu^mfZebqlhr_cohq_gvjZa]g_
\Z_lky ba-aZ lZdh]h ]emih]h \hijhkZ b e_]dhfuke_ggh]h hlgh
r_gbydfhebl\_\h\j_fydhlhjhcq_eh\_dh[yaZgh[sZlvkyk
:eeZohf \eZklbl_e_f \k_]h kms_]h \ k\yab k q_f ebrgb_
^\b`_gby \h \j_fy fhebl\u y\eyxlky m`Zkguf ihklmidhf B
gZkhq_gvm^b\behl\_lr_coZ©<wlhfg_lgbq_]hkljZrgh]h
_keb q_eh\_d ohq_l magZlv \j_fyª593 : jZa\_ fh`gh kfhlj_lv
gZqZkukdZdhc-lh^jm]hcp_evx"
LZdh\ ba\jZs_gguc \ZooZ[blkdbc nbdo <a]eygbl_ gZ
bfZfh\f_q_lbZe-OZjZfaZmqb\rboDhjZggZbamklvKdhevdh
^\b`_gbchgbkh\_jrZxl\h\j_fyfhebl\u"Hgbl_j_[ylb]
jZxl k\hbf ieZldhf dhlhjuf hgb aZf_gbeb qZefm kbf\heb
abjh\Z\rmx ijhjhq_kdmx kmggm b ijbagZggmx bfb ebrv dZd
qZklvgZjh^guoljZ^bpbc594GhjZa\_hgbg_y\eyxlkykZeZnb
lZfb" Djhf_ lh]h \h \j_fy fhebl\u hgb iha\heyxl k_[_ b]
jZlv h^_`^hc [hjh^hc mkZfb ;he__ lh]h \h \j_fy ghqghc
fhebl\u f_kypZ jZfZaZg ] fu \b^_eb dZd h^bg ba gbo
k_e^eylh]hqlh[uihiblvdhn_Z_]h]he_gb[ueb\ulygmlu
i_j_^fheysbfbky.
Ihkfhljbl_dZdhgbaZoh^yl\f_q_lbb^Z`_g_kgbfZ
xl h[m\v bo ^Z`_ g_ \hegm_l qlh gZ dh\ju ihiZ^Z_l ]jyav
Hgb ebrv aZy\eyxl qlh ijhlbjZxl ih\_joghklv wlhc h[m\b
fZko >Z \h \j_f_gZ IjhjhdZ k]k ihe f_q_lb [ue mkleZg
]Zevdhc b f_edbfb dZf_rdZfb ihwlhfm ihk_s_gb_ f_q_lb \
h[m\b g_ [ueh ghgk_gkhf K_cqZk `_ fu k\hbfb ]eZaZfb \b
^bfdZdwlbex^bk\h_c]jyaghch[m\vxlhiqmldh\ju\f_q_
Dh]^Zg_dhlhju_nZgZlbqgu_ihke_^h\Zl_ebr_coZmagZebh[wlhcn_l
\_ lh g_ ih\_jbeb k\hbf mrZf Lh]^Z fu ihkh\_lh\Zeb bf kZfbf aZ^Zlv
wlhl\hijhkr_com
594
H^bgbaijhn_kkhjh\-\ZooZ[blh\]]\h\j_fyi_
j_^Zqb©<hijhkubhl\_luªih\lhjhfmkZm^bckdhfmdZgZemaZy\be©Wlhl
ieZlhd ^ey gZk ijbylg__ Z lhl dlh `_eZ_l kh[ex^Zlv kmggm imklv ghkbl
qZefmª
593
248
lb:_keb\ubfk^_eZ_l_aZf_qZgb_lhhgbihkf_xlkybkdZ
`ml ©LZdh\Z kmggZ ^hjh]hc r_coª <hl lZdh\ hg \ZooZ[bl
kdbcnbdok\yaZgguckfhebl\hc
P_gZ`_gsbgu
<ur_fum`_mihfygmebhlhfqlh\ZooZ[blkdbcnbdo
hlebqZ_lkyl_fqlhkebrdhfih\_joghkl_g?s_h^gbfyjdbf
ijbf_jhf wlhfm kem`bl n_l\Z hl jZ[b]mevZ\\Zey ]
] kh]eZkgh dhlhjhc [ue hij_^_e_g fZoj `_gsbg
FZoj ^_\kl\_ggbp [ue mklZgh\e_g \ j_Zeh\ fZoj `_g
sbgum`_[u\r_c\[jZd_ghg_bf_\r_c^_l_c[uemklZgh\
e_g\j_Zeh\ZfZoj`_gsbguk^_lvfb[uemklZgh\e_g
\j_Zeh\<hllZdmxgh\mx[b^]Z\u^mfZeb\ZooZ[blu
Hgbhij_^_ebebdZdb_`_gsbgukdhevdhklhyl
<hl hgZ p_gghklv q_eh\_q_kdhc `bagb Wlb ex^b g_
lhevdh g_ ihgbfZxl kfuke fZojZ gh ^Z`_ aZdhgh\ rZjbZlZ
JZa\_fZoj–wlhp_gZaZdhlhjmxfm`qbgZihdmiZ_l`_gsbgm"
JZa\_ bkeZfkdbc rZjbZl dh]^Z-eb[h mklZgZ\eb\Ze p_gm `_g
sbg" Dhg_qgh `_ g_l kh]eZkgh rZjbZlm `_gsbgZ – wlh [_k
p_ggh_khdjh\bs_jZ^bdhlhjh]hfm`qbgZ^Z`_`_jl\m_lk\h
_c`bagvxFZoj–wlhkbf\heihy\e_gbygh\h]hqbklh]hg_
ihjhqgh]h k_f_cgh]h ]g_a^urdZ < ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ kZfuf
[hevrbffZojhf^he`_g[ue[ulvfZoj\uieZq_ggucaZ^hqv
IjhjhdZk]kNZlufmj:]
<hl lZdh\ bgl_ee_dlmZevgh-^moh\guc mjh\_gv wlbo ex
^_c
<ZooZ[bafbhldjulb_ihklu^guof_kl]ZmjZl
F_gy m^b\beZ _s_ h^gZ \ZooZ[blkdZy n_l\Z <h \j_fy
h^ghc ba i_j_^Zq ©Gmj ]Zey Z^-^Zj[ª \ZooZ[blkdbc r_co aZ
y\beqlhfm`qbgZf^ha\he_ghh]heylvk\h_[_^jh\ijbkmlkl
\bbihklhjhggbobqlhwlZqZklvl_eZg_hlghkblkydihgylbx
]Z\jZl < dZq_kl\_ ^h\h^Z hg ijb\_e kemqZc dh]^Z Ijhjhd
k]kkb^_e^hfZb_]h[_^jh[uehh]he_gh>Zijhklblf_gy
:eeZo
Lh]^Z-lhyihgyeihq_fm\ZooZ[blugZ^_\ZxlgZklhevdh
dhjhldb_rlZgbrdbqlh\h\j_fyjmdm]Z\b^gZbogZ]hlZ
249
Gh lZdh\ \ZooZ[blkdbc nbdo ihq_fm-lh hgb hl^Zeb
ij_^ihql_gb_ bf_ggh wlhfm oZ^bkm \ lh \j_fy dh]^Z Ijhjhd
k]kykghaZy\be©;_^jh– ]Z\jZl595ªjZa\_ihke_wlh]hoZ^b
kZ fh`gh ml\_j`^Zlv qlh [_^jh g_ y\ey_lky ]Z\jZlhf" : qlh
`_ ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ZooZ[blZf hl\_lbeb fmkmevfZgkdb_ mq_
gu_":e-;ZcoZdbihwlhfmih\h^mibkZe©<oZ^bk_mihlj_[e_
gh keh\h ©h[gZ`behkvª gh wlh g_ agZqbl qlh Ijhjhd k]k
h[gZ`be k\h_ [_^jh ij_^gZf_j_ggh Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky i_j\h]h
oZ^bkZ \ dhlhjhf jZkkdZau\Z_lky h lhf dZd hldjuehkv [_^jh
IjhjhdZ k]k dh]^Z hg ijh_a`Ze ih madhc mebp_ lh keh\h
©h[gZ`beª fh`_l hlghkblvky d aZ[hjm aZ dhlhjuc aZ^_e Ijh
jhdk]kijh_a`Zyihwlhcmadhcmehqd_b\j_amevlZl_wlh]h
_]h[_^jhh[gZ`behkvQlh`_dZkZ_lky[_^jZlh[hevrbgkl\h
mq_guoijbagZxlqlhhghy\ey_lky]Z\jZlhf<h^ghfbajb\Z
ylh\hl:gZkZkhh[sZ_lkyhlhfqlhhgkb^_egZijhlb\Ijhjh
dZ k]k gh g_ ]h\hjblky h lhf qlh _]h ]he_gv [ueZ hldju
lZª596BfZfZl-LZoZ\b\©RZjofZ]ZgbZe-ZkZjªdhff_glbjmy
oZ^bkhlhfqlhIjhjhdk]kkb^_ekg_ijbdjuluf[_^jhf\
ijbkmlkl\bb:[m;ZdjZb=mfZjZghijbdjue_]hdh]^Z\hr_e
=mkfZglhhgibr_l©Qe_guijhjhq_kdhck_fvbi_j_^Zebwlhl
oZ^bkkh\k_fih-^jm]hfmª597LZf`_hgijh^he`Z_l©WlboZ
^bkuk\b^_l_evkl\mxl\ihevamlh]hqlh[_^jhy\ey_lky]Z\jZ
lhfbg_l^hklh\_jguooZ^bkh\hijh\_j]Zxsbowlh<k_mq_
gu_ijbagZxlqlh[_^jhy\ey_lky]Z\jZlhfijbhldjulbbdh
lhjh]h fhebl\Z ihjlblky lZd `_ dZd ihjlblky ijb h]he_gbb
^jm]boqZkl_cl_eZª598Bf_gghihwlhfmfmkmevfZgkdb_mq_gu_
hq_gv kljh]h hlghkylky d wlhfm \hijhkm Z bfZf FZebd ^Z`_
OZ^bk ^hklh\_j_g ijb\h^blky m Ze-;moZjb \ ©:l-LZjboª Z lZd`_ m ZlLbjfbab:[m>Zm^Z:ofZ^ZZ^->ZjbfbB[g:[m=ZkufZZe-OZdbfZZlLZ[ZjZgb Ze-;ZcoZdb Z^->Zjdmlgb Ze-OZfb^b Zl-LZoZ\b b ^Z`_ m Ze:e[Zgb
596
:e-;ZcoZdb©:k-KmgZgª–‹
597
:l-LZoZ\b©RZjofZ]ZgbZe-ZkZjª– 1/473.
598
LZf`_– 1/475.
595
250
aZy\be©YkqblZxfZdjmohf^Z`_h]he_gb_]he_gbi_j_^k\h_c
kh[kl\_gghc`_ghcª599.
DZd \b^bl_ \ZooZ[blu ij_^gZf_j_ggh gZjmrZxl k\hb
fhebl\ubfugbq_]hkwlbfg_fh`_fih^_eZlv
<ZooZ[blujZaj_rbebmihlj_[e_gb_f_jl\_qbgu
<ZooZ[bluh[ty\beb^ha\he_ggufoZeye^eymihlj_[
e_gby\ibsmfykhihklZ\ey_fh_baojbklbZgkdbokljZgHgb
iml_r_kl\my ih ?\jhi_ ^Z`_ g_ aZ[hlylky h ihbkd_ ihgZklhys_fm ^ha\he_ggh]h fykZ DZd [ueh kdZaZgh \ur_ bo
nbdo hq_gv ih\_joghklguc b madbc bf ^hklZlhqgh lh]h qlh
:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©IbsZex^_cIbkZgby^ha\he_gZ\Zfª
Ihwlhfm hgb [_a \kydbo khfg_gbc ihk_sZxl ©FZd^h
gZev^kuª b ijhqb_ aZ\_^_gby h[s_iblZ JZa\_ \ZooZ[blkdbf
nZdboZfg_ba\_klghqlhkh\j_f_ggu_ojbklbZg_i_j_^jZa^_e
dhc m[b\Zxl `b\hlgh_ ijb ihfhsb we_dljbq_kdh]h lhdZ bf
dZ`_lkyqlhijhklh_aZ[b\Zgb_ijbghkbl`b\hlghfm[hevGh
]^_ `_ m \ZooZ[blh\ ^hdZaZl_evkl\h lh]h qlh fykh lZdh]h `b
\hlgh]h ^ha\he_gh \ ibsm" : fh`_l [ulv f_jl\_qbgZ dmi
e_ggZymojbklbZgy\ey_lky^ha\he_gghc\ibsm"
Ba\_klghqlh_\jhi_ckdb_fmkmevfZg_lh`_ijhba\h^yl
fykhIhq_fm`_\ZooZ[blug_ihdmiZxlfykhmgbo"Ijh[e_
fZ\lhfqlhklhqdbaj_gby\ZooZ[blh\_\jhi_ckdb_fmkmev
fZg_y\eyxlkyeb[haZ[em^rbfbZrZjblZfbfykhbajmddhlh
juoaZij_lbeB[gL_cfby600eb[hyauqgbdZfb-rbblZfb
>Zwlh^_ckl\bl_evghlZdG_kfhljygZlhqlhrbblu\h
\j_fy dZ`^h]h oZ^`Z ^_fhgkljZlb\gh hlj_dZxlky hl yauqgb
dh\g_kfhljygZlhqlhhgbh[ty\beb\hcgmkZfhfm[hevrhfm
kZlZg_ – :f_jbd_ g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh hgb ^hklZ\eyxl [_kih
dhckl\hBajZbexbZlZdmxl_]hkx]ZEb\ZgZg_kfhljygZ\k_
wlh\ZooZ[bluh[ty\eyxlboyauqgbdZfbHgbaZij_sZxlrb
blkdh_ fykh b jZaj_rZxl m[b\Zlv wlbo ex^_c <hl gZijbf_j
n_l\Z h^gh]h ba djmiguo \ZooZ[blkdbo mq_guo qe_gZ dhfbk
kbbihn_l\Zf
599
600
:e-Dmjlm[b©Ze->`Zfb]ebZodZfZe-DmjtZgªkmjZ©Ze-:]jZnªZyl
Dhff_glZjbcZk-KZddZnZddgb]_Za-AZoZ[b©:e-=mexªk
251
<hijhk ©M\Z`Z_fuc r_co =Z[^meeZ [bg =Z[^jZofZg
Ze->`Z[bjbg fbj \Zf fbehklv b [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ :eeZoZ« <
gZr_f]hjh^_`b\_ljZnb^bljZ[hlZxsbcfykgbdhf601dg_fm
aZ fykhf ijboh^yl kmggblu jZnb^blu Z lZd`_ ^bj_dlhjZ g_
dhlhjuoj_klhjZgh\bdZn_DZdfu^he`guhlghkblkydwlhfm
q_eh\_dm" >ha\he_gh eb ^ey ijb_fZ \ ibsm fykh `b\hlguo
aZ[bluobf"ª
Hl\_l ©Fbj \Zf fbehklv b [eZ]hkeh\_gb_ :eeZoZ«
Fykh`b\hlguoaZ[bluojZnb^blZfby\ey_lkyaZij_lguf^ey
ijb_fZ\ibsmihkdhevdm\hkgh\ghf\k_jZnb^bluy\eyxlky
yauqgbdZfb<h\j_fyly]hlbljm^ghkl_chgbaZihfhsvxh[
jZsZxlkyd=Zeb[bg:[mLZeb[m<hafh`gh\ug_jZakeurZ
ebdZdhgbgZoh^ykvgZ:jZnZl_KZn_bFZj\_kh\_jrZylZ
\Znh[jZsZxlkykfhev[Zfbdkugh\vyf=Zebbk\hbfbfZfZf
WlhgZklhys__yauq_kl\hb\_jhhlklmigbq_kl\hBofh`gh^Z
`_ m[b\Zlv Djhf_ lh]h fu keurZeb dZd hgb ijbibku\Zxl
=Zeb j:] Zljb[mlu ijbkmsb_ lhevdh :eeZom Hgb \_jhhl
klmigbdb aZf_lvl_ qe_g dhfbkkbb ih n_l\Zf imlZ_l iZ^_
`b602 wlb ex^b ij_\jZlbeb =Zeb \ ]hkih^Z kha^Zl_ey agZx
s_]h khdjulh_ b jZkihjy`Zxs_]hky \h \k_e_gghc ih k\h_fm
mkfhlj_gbx«]]ª
Dhfbkkbbihn_l\Zf\ha]eZ\ey_fhcB[g;Zahf[ueaZ
^Zg ihoh`bc \hijhk ©Qlh \u kdZ`_l_ ih ih\h^m fykZ `b\hl
guo aZ[bluo yauqgbdZfb `b\msbfb \ fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZ
gZo b ih ijbqbg_ g_\_`_kl\Z h[ty\eyxsbfb k_[y fmkmevfZ
gZfb"ª < n_l\_ ‹ hl ] ] kdZaZgh
©Wlh fykh ih^h[gh fykm ba jmd yauqgbdh\ ihdehgy\rboky
Ze-EZlmZe-=maa_FZgZlm<m^mKm\Z]mY]mkmY]mdmGZkjmb
ijhqbf [h`_kl\Zf Hgh aZij_lgh ^ey gZklhysbo fmkmevfZg
ihkdhevdm y\ey_lky f_jl\_qbghc ;he__ lh]h wlb ex^b om`_
yauqgbdh\ihkdhevdmy\eyxlky\_jhhlklmigbdZfbª
<ZooZ[bluhq_gvex[ylgZau\Zlvrbblh\jZnb^blZfbwlh^_eZ_lkyih
lhfmqlhl_hldZaZebkvijhdebgZlv=Zebj:]khf_y^kdbofbg[Zjh\
602
<ZjZ[kdhfhjb]bgZe_n_l\ubkihevah\ZgZnhjfZ©fmjlZ^^bgªZ^he`
gh[ulv©fmjlZ^^mg». –ii
601
252
<hl\Zfbn_l\Zkh]eZkghdhlhjhcfykhbajmdrbblh\
aZij_lgh Z bo kZfbo fh`gh m[b\Zlv WlZ n_l\Z hkgh\ZgZ gZ
e`bqlhydh[urbbluh[h`_kl\eyxl=ZebBawlhcn_l\ufu
fh`_f k^_eZlv \u\h^ h lhf qlh lZdbfb `_ yauqgbdZfb y\ey
xlky b kmggblu b kmnbb603 b ^jm]b_ ©g_\_`_kl\_ggu_ª fm
kmevfZg_ Fykh `b\hlguo aZ[bluo wlbfb ex^vfb y\ey_lky
aZij_lguf \ ibsm Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky fykZ `b\hlguo aZ[bluo
ojbklbZgZfb dhlhju_ hldjulh ijh\ha]eZrZxl BbkmkZ kughf
[h`vbf604 lh hgh ih fg_gbx \ZooZ[blh\ ^ha\he_gh \ ibsm
Ihkfhljbl_ ^hjh]b_ [jZlvy oZrZ\blu mihlj_[eyxl \ ibsm
fykh`b\hlguoaZ[bluoojbklbZgZfbb^Zxlbf\hafh`ghklv
bkihevah\Zlv k\hb a_feb \ dZq_kl\_ ieZp^ZjfZ ^ey gZiZ^_gby
gZ fmkmevfZg Hgb \imklbeb ojbklbZg gZ l_jjblhjbx DK: \
lh \j_fy dZd Ijhjhd k]k \ h^ghf ba k\hbo oZ^bkh\ kdZaZe
©ImklvgZZjZ\bckdhfihemhkljh\_g_[m^_l^\moj_eb]bcª605.
LZdh\u\ZooZ[bluki_rZsb_h[\bgylvfmkmevfZg\g_
\_jbbGZwlhfnhg_yohqmijb\_klb\ukdZau\Zgb_h^gh]hba
gZrbo mq_guo r_coZ-fh^`Zo_^Z KZ]b^Z [bg OZenZZgZ ZeOZebeb606 ©Hkl_j_]Zcky h[\bgylv fmkmevfZg h[jZsZxsboky
\klhjhgmdb[eu\g_\_jbbbyauq_kl\_IhagZchkgh\u\dh
Kmggblh\\ZooZ[bluhlghkyldaZ[em^rbfkmnbyf-yauqgbdZfkfdgb]m
©DZcnZgZnoZfmZl-lZ\ob^"ª©DZdke_^m_lihgbfZlvlZ\ob^"ªFmoZffZ^Z
:ofZ^Z;ZrfbeyBkeZfkdbcmgb\_jkbl_lP_gljijhiZ]Zg^uDK:
604
Fuohlbfqlh[ugZrbhiihg_glug_ihevah\Zebkv^\hcgufbklZg^Zj
lZfb ?keb fu gZqZeb ^bkdmkkbx h rbblZo b ojbklbZgZo lh ke_^m_l ih
fgblv qlh i_j\u_ ijhbaghkyl rZoZ^m Z lZd`_ ]h\hjyl ©;bkfbeeyª i_j_^
aZ[h_f`b\hlgh]hqlh`_dZkZ_lky_\jhi_ckdboojbklbZglhfgh]b_bagbo
^Z`_hljbpZxlkms_kl\h\Zgb_Kha^Zl_ey
605
Wlh[uehh^gbfbaihke_^gboaZ\_sZgbcIjhjhdZk]k<lZdhf\b^_b
ihoh`_f\b^_hghijb\h^blkymFZebdZ:ofZ^ZZl-LZ[ZjZgb=Z[^jZaZdZ
B[g JZo\by Zr-RZ\dZgb Ze-FmllZdb Ze-Obg^b Ze-OZckZfb Za-AZcey]b
:^->ZjdmlgbkdZaZeqlhwlhloZ^bk^hklh\_j_g
606
Wlhl q_eh\_d \g_k k\hc \deZ^ \ ba]gZgb_ Zg]ebqZg ba fmkmevfZgkdbo
a_f_evb\h_\Ze[hdh[hdkbfZfhf-rZob^hf=ZaZghf[bgDZckhfdhlhjh
]h\jZ]baZdhiZeb`b\v_f
603
253
lhju_ hgb \_jyl < ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ lu fh`_rv ijb\_klb d
ih]b[_ebbbobk_[yª607.
Y^mfZxqlhmm\Z`Z_fuoqblZl_e_cihke_wlbokeh\g_
hklZehkv khfg_gby qlh \ZooZ[blu y\eyxlky g_hoZjb^`blZfb
gZ^_\rbfb fmkmevfZgkdb_ h^_`^u ^ey ^hklb`_gby k\hbo
]gmkguo p_e_c ^ey lh]h qlh[u hldjulh \h_\Zlv ijhlb\ fm
kmevfZgBohlebqbl_evgufbq_jlZfby\eyxlkyg_mf_j_gghklv
nbdoZ b ba\jZs_gghklv Zdu^u Z lZd`_ n_l\u jZaj_rZxsb_
m[b\Zlvg_\bgguofmkmevfZg
Mobsj_gbyjZ^bij_ex[h^_ygby
<ZooZ[blu h[ty\beb \hcgm rbblkdhfm \j_f_gghfm
[jZdm©fmlZªdhlhjucaZdexqZ_lkykh[hx^gh]hkh]eZkbyh[_
bo klhjhg Hgb kqblZxl qlh wlhl [jZd y\ey_lky jZkimlkl\hf
gh \ lh `_ \j_fy hgb h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gghc gh\mx [b^]Z
nhjfm [jZdZ dhlhjmx gZau\Zeb ©aZ\Z^` fbkvyjª ©[jZd iml
gbdZª608 Wlhl \b^ [jZdZ hldjulh ijhiZ]Zg^bjm_lky \ DK: \
]Za_lZo b `mjgZeZo im[ebdmxlky khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ n_l\u <
qZklghklb`mjgZe©:e-=ZjZ[byªba^Z\Z_fuc\wj-Jby^_\
ghf_j_aZ]]ih^aZ]heh\dhf©KijZrb\Zcl_magZ
lhdh\ªhim[ebdh\Zen_l\mB[g;ZaZ
Kmlv wlh]h [jZdZ aZdexqZ_lky \ lhf qlh fm`qbgZ b
`_gsbgZ\klmiZxl\h[uqguc[jZdghmg_]h_klvk\hbhleb
qby
\h-i_j\uohgkh\_jrZ_lkylZcgh
\h-\lhjuofm`qbgZg_h[yam_lkykh^_j`Zlv`_gsbgm
\-lj_lvbofm`qbgZg_h[yam_lkymg__ghq_\Zlv
©LZfob^ dZ\Z]b^ Ze-bfZgª – Ba^ ©<baZjZl Zl-lmjZkª HfZg l – K
224.
608
Dkh`Ze_gbxboijbf_jmihke_^h\Zer_coXkmnZe-DZj^Z\bBa\_klgh
qlhhgjZkkfZljb\Z_lwlhl\b^[jZdZdZdkj_^kl\h[hjv[uky\e_gb_fklZjuo
^_\ghfh`_leb[ulvlZdh_kj_^kl\hhijZ\^Zgguf"<lh`_\j_fyg_dhlh
ju_\ZooZ[blkdb_mq_gu_m`_hldZaZebkvhlk\hbon_l\ihwlhfmih\h^m<
qZklghklb r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg KZebo Ze-=mk_cfbg h[ty\be wlhl [jZd g_
khhl\_lkl\mxsbfghjfZfk\ys_ggh]hrZjbZlZ\hafh`ghbf_gghihwlhfm
hg[uebkdexq_gbadhfbkkbbihn_l\Zf
607
254
\-q_l\_jluoq_eh\_dhl\_lkl\_ggucaZ`_gsbgmhl_p
[jZl^y^y^_^bijijbkmlkl\h\Zlvg_h[yaZgu
\-iyluofm`qbgZbf__lkdjulh_gZf_j_gb_jZklhj]gmlv
wlhl[jZd\[m^ms_f609.
Fu`_ihwlhfmih\h^mohlbfhlf_lblvqlh\h-i_j\uo
lZcguc [jZd fh`_l klZlv ijbqbghc lh]h qlh ihke_ kf_jlb
fm`qbgu lZcgZy `_gZ b __ ^_lb klZgml lj_[h\Zlv k\h_c ^heb
gZke_^kl\Zqlhijb\_^_lddhgnjhglZpbbf_`^mwlbfbk_fvy
fb:bkeZfkdbcrZjbZlgZh[hjhl[hj_lkykex[ufb\b^Zfb
dhgnjhglZpbbf_`^mfmkmevfZgZfbbijb\b\Z_lbf[jZlkdmx
ex[h\v ^jm] d ^jm]m K ^jm]hc klhjhgu lZcgh_ ijh\_^_gb_
wlh]h[jZdZm`_kZfhihk_[_klhqdbaj_gbyg_dhlhjuonZdb
oh\y\ey_lkyijbqbghcqlh[uh[ty\blv_]hg_^_ckl\bl_evguf
©OZrbyZ^->Zkmdb]ZeyrZjoZe-dZ[bjª–<h^ghf
ba oZ^bkh\ IjhjhdZ k]k ]h\hjblky h g_h[oh^bfhklb ]eZkgh]h
aZdexq_gby[jZdZ©=jZgbpZf_`^m^ha\he_ggufbaZij_lguf
–a\md[m[gZgZk\Z^v[_ªijb\h^blkymZg-GZkZbB[gFZ^`bb
:ofZ^ZHl=Zcrbj:]i_j_^Z_lkyoZ^bk\dhlhjhfkdZaZ
gh ©H[ty\eycl_ ex^yf h \Zr_f [jZdhkhq_lZgbb b [_cl_ \
[m[guªijb\h^blkymB[gFZ^`bHlhf`_kZfhfkhh[sZ_l
kyb\^jm]booZ^bkZoijb\_^_gguom:ofZ^ZZl-LbjfbabB[g
FZ^`bbZg-GZkZb
Djhf_lh]h^eymklZgh\e_gbyhlph\kl\Z\kemqZ_jZa\h
^Z wlhc iZju _klv g_h[oh^bfhklv qlh[umkm^vb[ueZbgnhj
fZpby h kh`bl_evkl\_ kmijm]h\ gh wlh fh`_l [ulv ba\_klgh
lhevdh \ kemqZ_ ]eZkgh]h ijh\_^_gby h[jy^Z [jZdhkhq_lZgby
Bf_gghihwlhfmfZebdbluaZy\eyxl©?kebkmijm]b^h]h\Zjb
\Zxlkykhk\b^_l_eyfbhlhfqlh[u[jZd[uelZcguflhwlhl
[jZd ijbagZ_lky g_^_ckl\bl_evgufª =eZkgh_ ijh\_^_gb_ [jZ
dhkhq_lZgby\fZebdblkdhfnbdo_h[yaZl_evghnZja610.
Ba\hijhkh\aZ^Zgguofmnlbyf\Dm\_cl_klZehykghqlhmwlh]h[jZdZ
_klv^_\ylv\b^h\b\ZooZ[blu^Z`_g_kh[bjZxlkydZd-eb[hmihjy^hqb\Zlv
bebh]jZgbqb\Zlvwlhl[jZdihkdhevdmwlhg_\bobgl_j_kZoFu`_\^Zg
ghcdgb]_jZkkfhljbf\k_\ZjbZgluih^jh[gh
610
:e-FZgZ\b©NZc^Ze-dZ^bjª–LoZ^bk
609
255
<©DZrnZe-oZnZªmZe-=Z^`exgbijb\h^blkyoZ^bk‹
\dhlhjhfkdZaZgh©H[ty\eycl_hijh\_^_gbb[jZdhkhq_
lZgbyijh\h^bl__]h\f_q_lyobkhijh\h`^Zcl_a\mdZfb[m[
gZªijb\h^blkymZl-Lbjfbabhl=Zcrb>ZwlhloZ^bkijb
agZg keZ[uf gh ihkdhevdm _klv lZdb_ `_ oZ^bku kh kl_i_gvx
oZkZgbkZobolhbwlhloZ^bklh`_ih^gbfZ_lky^hbomjh\gy
Ijbf_jhf^hklh\_jguooZ^bkh\kem`bljb\ZylB[gFZ^`bhl
B[gFZgb]Zhl:gZkZhl=Zcrb\dgb]_©:e-EZbZe-fZdZku^ª
bjb\Zyl:ofZ^ZhlB[gZa-Am[ZcjZkh]eZkghdhlhjhfmIjhjhd
k]k kdZaZe ©H[ty\eycl_ h ijh\_^_gbb [jZdhkhq_lZgbyª m
Zk-KZoZ\b ijb\h^blky ^hiheg_gb_ d wlhfm oZ^bkm ©gh kdju
\Zcl_ ihfhe\dmª < ^jm]hf jb\Zyl_ hl B[g Ob[[ZgZ OZdbfZ
Zl-LZ[ZjZgb aZy\be qlh oZ^bk ^hklh\_j_g :[m GZ]bfZ B[g
Za-Am[ZcjZZlZd`_\jb\Zyl_Zl-LZ[ZjZgbhlOb[ZjZ[bg:k\Z
^Z kdZaZgh ©Ijh\h^bl_ [jZdb ]eZkgh b h[ty\eycl_ h[ bo ijh
\_^_gbbª < jb\Zyl_ Z^->ZceZfb hl Mffm KZeZfZ kdZaZgh
©Ijh\h^bl_ [jZdhkhq_lZgb_ ]eZkgh Z ihfhe\dm lZcghª :lL_jfbabZg-GZkZbB[gFZ^`ZbZe-OZdbfi_j_^ZxloZ^bkhl
FmoZffZ^Z [bg OZlu[Z ©=jZgbpZ f_`^m ^ha\he_gguf b aZ
ij_lguf–a\mdb[m[gZijb[jZdhkhq_lZgbbª
<h-\lhjuobkiheg_gby\k_oy\guomkeh\bc[jZdZg_^h
klZlhqgh g_h[oh^bfh qlh[u [ueb mkljZg_gu \k_ ijbqbgu
^_eZxsb_ [jZd g_^_ckl\bl_evguf Bf_ggh ihwlhfm mq_gu_
aZy\beb qlh [jZd lZoebe611 lZd`_ y\ey_lky g_^_ckl\bl_evguf
kf ©FZ[^Z Zj-jb^Z nb Ze-]mdm^ª ;jZd fbkvyj
hq_gvihoh`gZlhqlhkh\_jrZxlbm^_bbojbklbZg_aZ\h^y
sb_djhf_`_g_s_bex[h\gbp:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©:g_
jZkimlgbpZfbblZcgufb\haex[e_ggufbªg_dhlhju_fmnZk
kbju kdZaZeb qlh j_qv b^_l h `_gsbgZo dhlhju_ \h \j_f_gZ
g_\_`_kl\ZaZ\h^bebk_[_ex[h\gbdh\Bf_gghihwlhfm=mfZj
Nbdlb\gZynhjfZ[jZdZKh]eZkghrZjbZlmfm`qbgZljb`^uh[ty\b\
rbck\h_c`_g_nhjfmemjZa\h^Zfh`_l`_gblvkygZg_c\gh\vlhevdhih
ke_lh]hdZdhgZ\uc^_laZfm`aZ^jm]h]hblhllZd`_h[ty\bl_cjZa\h^
?keb\lhjhc[jZd`_gsbguaZdexqZ_lkyebrv^eylh]hqlh[uk^_eZlv^ha
\he_gguf__ihke_^mxsbc[jZdki_j\uffm`_flhlZdhcnbdlb\guc[jZd
gZau\Z_lkylZoebe–ii
611
256
[bgZe-OZllZ[gZdZau\Zek\hboih^^ZgguoaZkh\_jr_gb_lZc
guo [jZdh\ b ]h\hjbe ©?keb [u wlh [ueh jZgvr_ lh y ihsZ
^be [u l_[yª612 LZcguc [jZd hq_gv gZihfbgZ_l y\e_gb_ ih
oh`^_gbc gZ klhjhg_ b ihwlhfm ijZ\_^gZy `_gsbgZ ^he`gZ
klhjhgblvky_]h
<©:e->`Zfb]Zk-kZ]ujª>`ZeZem^^bgZZk-Kmxlu\iy
lhf lhf_ ijb\h^blky oZ^bk \ dhlhjhf kdZaZgh ©Hg Ijhjhd
k]kbkiulu\Zeg_ijbyagvdlZcguf[jZdZf^hl_oihjihdZ
[jZqmxsb_kyg_[beb\[m[_gªijb\h^blkymkugZbfZfZ:o
fZ^Z hl :[m OZkZgZ Ze-FZaZgb b \ ©DZga Ze-]mffZeª m ZeFmllZdbZe-Obg^bZk-KmxluaZy\beqlhwlhlohjhrbcoZkZg
oZ^bk
<-lj_lvbohkgh\ghcp_evxddhlhjhcklj_fblkybkeZf
kdbc rZjbZl y\ey_lky mklZgh\e_gb_ kijZ\_^eb\hklb Bf_ggh
ihwlhfm ^ey l_o dlh g_ kihkh[_g [ulv kijZ\_^eb\uf f_`^m
`_gZfb :eeZo ^Ze kh\_l ©?keb `_ \u hiZkZ_l_kv qlh g_
kfh`_l_ aZ[hlblvky h gbo h^bgZdh\h lh `_gbl_kv gZ h^
ghcª<kmgg_IjhjhdZk]kihih\h^mg_kijZ\_^eb\hk
lbf_`^m`_gZfbkdZaZgh©Dlh[ue`_gZlgZ^\mo`_gsbgZob
[ue g_kijZ\_^eb\uf f_`^m gbfb lhl \ Km^guc ^_gv \hkklZ
g_lebrviheh\bghck\h_]hl_eZªijb\h^blkymZl-Lbjfbabb
Ze-OZdbfZdhlhjuckdZaZe©OZ^bk^hklh\_j_gbkhhl\_lkl\m_l
lj_[h\Zgbyfh[hbor_coh\ªlZdh]h`_fg_gbyijb^_j`b\Zeky
b Za-AZoZ[b Qlh dZkZ_lky ZylZ ©?keb `_ \u hiZkZ_
l_kv qlh g_ kfh`_l_ aZ[hlblvky h gbo h^bgZdh\h lh `_
gbl_kvgZh^ghcªlhj_qvb^_lhjZ\ghfjZkij_^_e_gbbfZl_
jbZevguo kj_^kl\ b \j_f_gb f_`^m \k_fb `_gZfb \ ijhlb\
ghf kemqZ_ fm` [m^_l g_kijZ\_^eb\ Z dZd ba\_klgh g_kijZ
\_^eb\hklv aZij_s_gZ rZjbZlhf kf ©;Z^Zb] Zk-kZgZb]ª
:eeZo <k_\urgbc ihykgyy ijZ\Z `_g kdZaZe ©@_g
sbgubf_xl>ihhlghr_gbxdfm`vyf@lZdb_`_ijZ\ZdZd
bh[yaZgghklbªkmggZIjhjhdZk]kykghdhff_glb
BfZf FZebd ©Ze-Fm\ZllZª ]eZ\Z h lZcghf [jZd_ bfZf Zr-RZnb]b
©FmkgZ^ªloZ^bk‹©DZgaZe-]mffZeªZe-FmllZdbZe-Obg^bl
©LZcguc[jZdª©GZceZe-Z\ljZªZr-RZ\dZgbl]eZ\Zh[jZd_
612
257
jm_lwlhlZyl©<ubf__l_ijZ\Z\hlghr_gbbk\hbo`_gbhgb
bf_xlijZ\Z\hlghr_gbb\Zk«BoijZ\Z\hlghr_gbb\ZkaZ
dexqZxlky \ ^h[jhf hlghr_gbb dhlhjh_ ijhy\ey_lky \ h[_k
i_q_gbb h^_`^hc b ibs_cª ijb\h^blky m B[g FZ^`b b ZlLbjfbabdhlhjucoZjZdl_jbah\ZewlhloZ^bkdZdoZkZg-kZobo
Djhf_lh]hkh]eZkghaZdhgZfrZjbZlZ`_gZbf__lijZ\hgZlh
qlh[ufm`ghq_\Zemg__IjbgZjmr_gbb`_mkeh\bc[jZdZhg
kqblZ_lkyg_^_ckl\bl_evguf
<-q_l\_jluohldZa`_g_\ijh\_^_gbbmg__ghqb^him
kdZ_lky lhevdh ebrv \ lhf kemqZ_ dh]^Z fm` `_eZ_l gZdZaZlv
k\hx `_gm aZ dZdhc-eb[h g_^ha\he_gguc ijhklmihd lh _klv \
\hkiblZl_evguop_eyo=^_`_hrb[dZ\aZdhgZo:eeZoZbeb\
aZdhgZo\ZooZ[blh\"
<-iyluo `bev_ b h[_ki_q_gb_ y\eyxlky g_hlt_fe_fu
fbijZ\Zfb`_gsbgu:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©:hl_pj_[_g
dZ kh]eZkgh h[uqZx h[_ki_qb\Z_l ijhiblZgb_ b h^_`^m fZ
l_jbª (2:233), ©Imklv h[eZ^Zxsbc ^hklZldhf mieZqb\Z_l
kh]eZkghk\h_fm^hklZldmª (65:7), ©Ihk_eycl_bolZf]^_\u
kZfbihk_ebebkv–ih\Zr_fm^hklZldmªZ\hlghr_gbb
jZa\_^_gguo `_g rZjbZl ih\_e_\Z_l ©G_ \u]hgycl_ >jZa\_
^_gguo `_g@ ba bo `bebs b imklv hgb hklZxlky lZf _keb
lhevdh g_ kh\_jrZl y\gmx f_jahklv LZdh\u mklZgh\e_gby
:eeZoZ Dlh ij_klmibl mklZgh\e_gby :eeZoZ lhl kh\_jrbl
g_q_klb_ \h \j_^ k_[_ª DZd \b^bl_ :eeZo jZaebqgufb
njZaZfb ^Z_l ihgylv qlh `_gsbgZ bf__l ijZ\h gZ `bev_ b
h[_ki_q_gb_ b wlh ijZ\h y\ey_lky jZfdZfb mklZgh\e_ggufb
:eeZohfZij_klmib\rbcwlbijZ\beZg_kijZ\_^eb\\i_j\mx
hq_j_^vihhlghr_gbxdk_[_Bf_gghihwlhfmnZdbobkdZaZ
ebqlhg_hlt_fe_fufbmkeh\byfb[jZqgh]h^h]h\hjZy\eyxl
kybglbfgu_hlghr_gbyghq_\dZh[_ki_q_gb_fZojbijhq__
b hldZa hl h^gh]h ba wlbo mkeh\bc ^_eZ_l [jZd g_^_ckl\bl_ev
guf613.
:e-FZ\jb^b©:e-OZ\bª– 9/503, 9/Ze-DZkZgb©Ze-;Z^Zb]ª–
3/1544.
613
258
<-r_kluoqlhdZkZ_lkyk\b^_l_evkl\hKZ\^_[bglAZf
]ZOZ\eb[bglFmoZffZ^[bgFZkeZfZ]h\hjysbohlhfqlh
hgbihk\h_fm`_eZgbxmklmibebk\h_ijZ\hgZghq_\dmlhwlh
m`_[ueh\h\j_fy[jZdZZg_^hg_]h:e-;moZjbi_j_^Z_lqlh
=ZcrZ j:] dhff_glbjmy Zyl ©?keb `_gsbgZ hiZkZ_lky
qlhfm`[m^_l^mjghh[jZsZlvkykg_cbebba[_]Zlvª (4:128),
kdZaZeZ ©?keb fm` klZe jZ\gh^mr_g d `_g_ b `_eZ_l jZa\_k
lbkv k g_c lh hgZ fh`_l kdZaZlv _fm ©Y mklmiZx l_[_ qZklv
fhbo ijZ\ª \hl ih wlhfm ih\h^m b [ue gbkihkeZg wlhl Zylª.
B[g >`Zjbj i_j_^Z_l qlh dh]^Z g_dlh kijhkbe m =mfZjZ
j:] h kfuke_ wlh]h ZylZ lh hg jZa]g_\Zeky b m^Zjbe wlh]h
q_eh\_dZDh]^Z^jm]hcq_eh\_dkijhkbem=mfZjZj:]hlhf
`_ hg hl\_lbe ©Ohjhrh kijZrb\Zcl_ h[ wlhf < wlhf Zyl_
b^_lj_qvhfm`qbg_`_gZdhlhjh]hihklZj_eZbm`_g_fh`_l
jh`ZlvLh]^Zhg`_gblkygZ^jm]hckihkh[ghcjh`Zlv^_l_cZ
k i_j\hc `_ghc hgb khklZ\eyxl hkh[uc ^h]h\hjª H^gZdh \k_
wlb jb\Zylu g_ k\b^_l_evkl\mxl \ ihevam lh]h qlh mkeh\by
fh`ghklZ\blv^haZdexq_gby^h]h\hjZa^_kv_klvjZagbpZ
\h \k_o i_j_qbke_gguo kemqZyo hldZa hl k\hbo ijZ\
ijhbkoh^be m`_ \h \j_fy [jZdZ Z g_ ^h _]h aZdexq_gby Hgb
kdZaZeb qlh _klv jZagbpZ f_`^m mklZgh\e_gb_f mkeh\bc ijh
lb\hj_qZsborZjbZlm^haZdexq_gby[jZdZbhldZahf`_gsb
gu hl k\hbo ijZ\ ihke_ _]h aZdexq_gby Ihke_ lh]h dZd [jZd
aZdexq_g `_gsbgZ bf__l ijZ\h \hh[s_ hldZaZlvky hl \k_o
k\hboijZ\bebhlboqZklbLh`_kZfh_dZkZ_lkyfZojZ[jZd
]^_ hl\_j]Z_lky \uieZlZ fZojZ kqblZ_lky g_^_ckl\bl_evguf
gh`_gsbgZfh`_lhldZaZlvkyhlfZojZihke__]haZdexq_gby
\i_j_qbke_gguokemqZyoj_qvb^_lhklZjuo`_gsb
gZoZ\gZr_fkemqZ_hlhfqlhfm`qbgZgZr_ek_[_^jm]mx
<-k_^vfuoihfg_gbx[hevrbgkl\Zmq_guohlkmlkl\b_
ihi_qbl_eyg_\_klu^_eZ_l[jZdg_^_ckl\bl_evguf<DhjZg_
kdZaZgh ©G_ ij_iylkl\mcl_ bf \klmiZlv \ [jZdª Z
Ijhjhd k]k \ h^ghf ba oZ^bkh\ kdZaZe ©G_l [jZdZ djhf_
259
dZdkihi_qbl_e_fª614lh_klvj_qvb^_lhg_^_ckl\bl_evghklb
lZdh]h[jZdZGZwlhmdZau\Z_loZ^bkhl=Zcrbj:]©?keb
`_gsbgZ \klmibeZ \ [jZd [_a jZaj_r_gby ihi_qbl_ey lh __
[jZdg_^_ckl\bl_e_gg_^_ckl\bl_e_gg_^_ckl\bl_e_g«615ª:
dZdba\_klgh[jZdfbkvyjhlebqZ_lkyl_fqlhfh`_lijhbkoh
^blv[_aihi_qbl_ey
<-\hkvfuo :eeZo <k_\urgbc \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Ba
agZf_gbc?]h–lhqlhHgkhl\hjbeba\ZkkZfbo`_g^ey\Zk
qlh[u\ugZoh^bebmkihdh_gb_\gbobmqj_^beex[h\vb>\aZ
bfgmx@[eZ]hkdehgghklvf_`^m\Zfb<hbklbgm\h\k_fwlhf
–ykgu_agZf_gby^eyex^_cdhlhju_jZafureyxlª:
jZa\_ fh`_l [ulv mkihdh_gb_ b ijhqghklv \ lhf qlh q_eh\_d
bagZqZevghkh[bjZ_lkyjZajmrblv"JZa\_fh`_l[ulvex[h\vb
fbehk_j^b_\[jZd_dhlhjucklZ\blkh[hxp_evebrvbkihev
ah\Zlv`_gsbgm"DZdhce_]dbcimlv^eyh\eZ^_gby`_gsbghc
b m^h\e_l\hj_gby k\h_c ihohlb gZreb wlb ex^b gZau\Zxsb_
ih^h[gh_khklhygb_[jZdhf
<-^_\yluogZb[he__g_gZ\bklguf^ey:eeZoZba^ha\h
e_gguo ^_ygbc y\ey_lky jZa\h^616 JZa\h^ – wlh kj_^kl\h ij_
djZs_gby[jZdZ\lhfkemqZ__keb\k_ihiuldb_]hkhojZgblv
g_ ^Zeb gbdZdbo ieh^h\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky [jZdZ fbkvyj lh hg
bagZqZevgh hkgh\Zg gZ jZa\h^_ blh] \k_]^Z bagZqZevgh ba\_k
l_gWlbex^bebrv`_eZxlgZkeZ^blvky`_gsbghcJZa\_ih
^h[gh_bkihevah\Zgb_jZa\h^Z^himkdZ_lkyrZjbZlhf"
<-^_kyluo [jZd fbkvyj y\ey_lky h[fZghf ^ey `_gsb
guf_qlZxs_chkqZkleb\hckmijm`_kdhc`bagb\ehg_rZjb
Zlkdh]h [jZdZ Fm` aZdexqZxsbc ih^h[guc [jZd ij_^gZf_
j_gghh[fZgu\Z_l`_gm\_^v_fmaZ\_^hfhba\_kl_gdhg_pwlh
]h[jZdZb_]hkjhdGhg_aZ[u\Zcl_qlhIjhjhdk]k\h^
Ijb\h^blkym:ofZ^ZbkhklZ\bl_e_c©:k-KmgZgª<ihevam^hklh\_jgh
klbwlh]hoZ^bkZ\ukdZaZebkvB[gZe-FZ^bgbbZl-L_jfbab
615
Ijb\h^blkym:ofZ^Zm\k_okhklZ\bl_e_c©:k-KmgZgªdjhf_Zg-GZkZb
<ihevam^hklh\_jghklbwlh]hoZ^bkZ\ukdZaZebkvZl-L_jfbab:[m=Z\ZgZ
B[gOb[[ZgbZe-OZdbf
616
<hkgh\_wlh]hdhg_qgh`_e_`blkeZ[ucoZ^bkghl_dklurZjbZlZih^
l\_j`^Zxlwlhml\_j`^_gb_
614
260
ghfbak\hbooZ^bkh\kdZaZe©Dlhh[fZgu\Z_llhlg_bafh_c
mffuª617.
<-h^bggZ^pZluofm`\wlhf[jZd_g_lhevdhh[fZgu\Z
_l`_gmhgbkihevam_l__ZaZl_f\u[jZku\Z_llZd`_dZd\hed
\u[jZku\Z_l ^h[uqm dhlhjhc m`_ gZkulbeky b i_j_oh^bl d
^jm]hc
<-^\_gZ^pZluo [jZd fbkvyj [jhkZ_l l_gv gZ h[uqguc
[jZdij_^ibkZggucrZjbZlhf<_^v[jZd–wlhk\ys_gguckh
xa \ dhlhjhf `_gsbgZ `b\_l ih^ hojZghc b aZ[hlhc fm`qb
guZ[jZdfbkvyjij_\jZsZ_lwlhihgylb_\b]jmrdm;jZdfb
kvyjbkdhj_gy_lm\Z`_gb_`_gudfm`m^_l_cdhlpm\_^vhgb
\ugm`^_gu [ulv gZklhjh`_ b g_ ^h\_jylv fm`m b hlpm dhlh
juc\ex[mxfbgmlmfh`_lbo[jhkblvWlhl[jZdij_\jZsZ_l
`_gsbgm \ k_dkmZevgmx b]jmrdm fm`qbgu hg ^Ze_d hl l_o
\ha\ur_gguo ihgylbc \eh`_gguo \ [jZd k\ys_gguf bkeZf
kdbfrZjbZlhf
<-ljbgZ^pZluo g_kfhljy gZ lh qlh [jZd lZoebe kh^_j
`bl\k_iheh`_ggu_mkeh\byfZojk\b^_l_eb]eZkghklvBk
eZf _]h aZij_sZ_l ihlhfm qlh hg bf__l hij_^_e_gguc kjhd
Fm`qbgmkh]eZkb\r_]hkygZlZdhc[jZdIjhjhdk]kgZa\Ze
©dhaehf \ayluf \ Zj_g^mª Bf_ggh ihwlhfm gZb[he__ mfgu_
nZdbob aZy\beb qlh ex[hc [jZd h]jZgbq_gguc dZdbf-eb[h
i_jbh^hf\j_f_gby\ey_lkyg_^_ckl\bl_evguf618.
<-q_lujgZ^pZluo[jZdfbkvyj–wlhbah[j_l_gb_obljh
klb ^ey lh]h qlh[u h[hclb aZdhgu mklZgh\e_ggu_ :eeZohf
wlhf_lh^bdZbm^__\jZkklZ\ey\rbok\hbk_lb\iylgbpmb\u
gbfZ\rbo \ ihg_^_evgbd ihlhfm qlh :eeZo aZij_lbe bf eh
\blvju[m\km[[hlmDZd\b^bl_\ZooZ[bluke_^mxlijbf_jm
bm^__\ g_ lhevdh \ Zdu^_ gh ^Z`_ b \ nbdo_ Gh g_ m^b\eyc
l_kvwlhfm\_^vbok_dlZ[ueZkha^ZgZdZdjZa^eylh]hqlh[u
bkdZablv b bkdhj_gblv gZklhysbc qbkluc BkeZf Bo Zdu^Z
©:k-KZoboªFmkebfZ
R_coDZjZ>Z]bijhn_kkhjDZlZjkdh]hmgb\_jkbl_lZ\h\j_fyi_j_^Zqb
©RZjbZlb`bagvªihdZgZem©Ze->`ZabjZªhl\_qZyr_comZe-DZj^Z\baZ
y\be qlh [jZd fbkvyj y\ey_lky aZij_s_gguf kf Zjob\ kZclZ dZgZeZ ©Ze>`ZabjZª
617
618
261
aZy\ey_l ©H ex^b \hjmcl_ ij_ex[h^_ckl\mcl_ ivygkl\mcl_
gh lhevdh g_ aZ[u\Zcl_ ]h\hjblv ©G_l [h`_kl\Z djhf_ :eeZ
oZªlh]^Z\u\dmkb\g_[hevrh_gZdZaZgb_\k_jZ\gh\hc^_l_\
JZcªJZa\_hgbg_qblZebqlh:eeZokdZaZe©:lh]hdlhhk
emrZ_lky :eeZoZ b ?]h ihkeZggbdZ b ij_klmibl ?]h aZdhgu
Hg\\_j]g_l\Z^kdbch]hgv<_qghlhl\g_fij_[m^_lbm]h
lh\Zgh _fm mgbabl_evgh_ gZdZaZgb_ª H^gZdh g_kfhljy
gZwlhhgbbah[j_lZxl\k_gh\u_bgh\u_imlbqlh[u©i_j_ob
ljblvª:eeZoZbgZjmrblv?]haZij_lu
<-iylgZ^pZluowlbex^bg_ihgbfZxlkmlbfmkmevfZg
kdh]h [jZdZ Hgb ^mfZxl qlh rZjbZl ij_^ibkZe [jZd lhevdh
^ey lh]h qlh[u fm`qbgZ m^h\e_l\hjye k\hb iheh\u_ ihlj_[
ghklb Z gZkulb\rbkv h^ghc `_gsbghc \u[jZku\Ze __ b hl
ijZ\eyeky d ^jm]hc GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ fmkmevfZgkdbc [jZd –
wlhk\ys_gguckhxaf_`^mfm`qbghcb`_gsbghckha^Zgguc
gZhkgh\_ex[\bm\Z`_gbybmkihdh_gby?]hp_ev–kha^Zgb_
ijZ\_^ghc k_fvb jh`^_gb_ b \hkiblZgb_ ijZ\_^guo ^_l_c
Khhl\_lkl\m_leb\ZooZ[blkdbc[jZdwlbfmkeh\byfblj_[h\Z
gbyf"
<-r_klgZ^pZluo ^Z fu kqblZ_f qlh [jZd fml]Z [ue
hlf_g_gfZgkmoghg_kfhljygZwlhihgZr_fmfg_gbxhg\
lukyqmjZaemqr_q_f\ZooZ[blkdbc[jZdfbkvyj<h\j_fyaZ
dexq_gby [jZdZ fml]Z `_gsbgZ agZ_l qlh hg aZdexqZ_lky
lhevdhgZ\j_fyb\klmiZ_l\g_]hhkhagZgghbihk\h_fm`_
eZgbx Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky \ZooZ[blkdh]h [jZdZ fbkvyj lh wlh
ij_^Zl_evkl\h`_gsbgug_ih^haj_\Zxs_ch]gmkguoaZfuk
eZofm`qbguHgZ\klmiZy\[jZdgZ^__lkyqlhh[j_eZgZ^_`
gh]hkimlgbdZ`bagbgh\h^bgij_djZkguc^_gvih^h[ghjZk
dZlm ]jhfZ ijha\mqbl keh\h ©jZa\h^ª : hgZ ^Z`_ g_ ih^haj_
\Z_l h ijbqbg_ jZa\h^Z \_^v hgZ g_ kh\_jrbeZ gbdZdh]h ijh
klmidZ
<-k_fgZ^pZluo[jZdfbkvyjgb\dh_fkemqZ_g_y\ey_l
kyj_r_gb_f\hijhkZh©klZjuo^_\ZoªgZh[hjhlhgkha^Z_l\
h[s_kl\_ \k_ gh\u_ b gh\u_ ijh[e_fu k\yaZggu_ k ^_lvfb
gZke_^h\Zgb_f b ij KlZlbklbq_kdbc hijhk `_gsbg Dm\_clZ
ihdZaZe qlh hgb g_ kqblZxl wlhl [jZd \hafh`ghklvx jZaj_
262
rblv mihfygmlmx ijh[e_fm J_r_gb_f ijh[e_fu ©klZjuo
^_\ª fh`_l [ulv lhevdh mkljZg_gb_ jZaebqguo gZpbhgZevghie_f_gguo kl_j_hlbih\ [hjv[Z k jhkdhrvx b jZklhqbl_evkl
\hf mf_gvr_gb_ kmffu fZojZ _kl_kl\_ggh ih^ dhgljhe_f
]hkm^Zjkl\Z
RZjbZl hq_gv e_]dh j_rbe ijh[e_fm ©klZjuo ^_\ª hg
ij_^ibkZeh[uqgucZ^ey`_eZxsbo–iheb]Zfguc^hq_lu
j_o `_g [jZd Ijhjhq_kdZy kmggZ kZfZ ij_^ibku\Z_l gZf ih
f_j_ \hafh`ghklb mf_gvrZlv kmffm fZojZ b g_ ihoh^blv gZ
bm^__\ b ojbklbZg aZ\h^ysbo k_[_ ex[h\gbp g_ bf_xsbo
ijZ\ZgbgZkh^_j`Zgb_gbgZghqe_]BlZd[jZdfbkvyj–wlh
ihjbpZ_fZy[b^]Zwlh]j_odhlhjucihg_kml\ZooZ[blub\k_
dlh[m^_l_]hijZdlbdh\Zlv
<-\hk_fgZ^pZluo wlb \ZooZ[blu-oZrZ\blu aZy\eyxl
qlhy\eyxlkykZeZnblZfbgh]^_`_bokZeZnbaf"JZa\_\kmg
g_ IjhjhdZ k]k _klv oZ^bku khh[sZxsb_ h [jZd_ fbkvyj"
>Z`_h^bgbabomq_guoB[gDm^ZfZmihfbgZyh[jZd_
k ^g_\gufb b ghqgufb `_gZfb mdZau\Z_l qlh fm` h[yaZg
[ulv m h^gbo ^g_f Z m ^jm]bo ghqvx Gh kkueZykv gZ ZeFZj\bab i_j_^Zxs_]h hl :ofZ^Z [bg OZg[ZeZ ]h\hjbl qlh
lZdhc [jZd g_ ij_^ibkZg BkeZfhf Djhf_ wlh]h B[g Dm^ZfZ
khh[sZ_lhlhfqlhlZcguc[jZdaZij_s_gihkdhevdmhgijh
lb\hj_qbl mkeh\byf fmkmevfZgkdh]h [jZdZ Lh `_ kZfh_ fu
\b^bfb\rZnb]blkdhffZaoZ[_
GZklhysbc fmkmevfZgkdbc [jZd – wlhg_fml]Zg_\j_
f_gguc g_ lZoebe g_ fbkvyj wlh [jZd kh]eZkgh ;h`v_fm aZ
dhgm b kmgg_ IjhjhdZ k]k k kh[ex^_gb_f \k_o mkeh\bc b
lj_[h\ZgbcDlhkh[ex^Z_l\k_wlblj_[h\Zgbybmkeh\bylhfm
iha\he_gh `_gblvky gZ ^\mo lj_o b q_luj_o `_gsbgZo ?keb
`_hgg_kihkh[_gkh[exklb\k_mkeh\byb[ulvkijZ\_^eb\uf
lh bf__l ijZ\h `_gblvky lhevdh gZ h^ghc b _fm ij_^ibkZg
ihkl
<ZooZ[blu ihgbfZxl j_eb]bx hq_gv ih\_joghklgh b
ijbfblb\ghgh\wlhfg_lgbq_]hm^b\bl_evgh]h\_^v:eeZoh
gbo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©;_^mbgu–mihjg_crb_\g_\_jbbbebp_
f_jbbbgZb[he__kdehggu_g_ijbgbfZlvij_^ibkZgbcgbkihk
263
eZgguo :eeZohf K\h_fm IhkeZggbdm <_^v :eeZo – agZxsbc
fm^jucªwlbex^bba\jZsZxlihgylbyg_ijbkemrb\Z
xlkydgZklZ\e_gbyfihahjylBkeZfbrZjbZlhgbqblZxlDh
jZgghhgg_ih^gbfZ_lky\ur_bo]hjeZ
<-^_\ylgZ^pZluo `bl_eb G_^`^Z ba\_klgu k\h_c ]b
i_jk_dkmZevghklvx k_dk – wlh _^bgkl\_ggZy l_fZ jZa]h\hjh\
gZ bo kh[jZgbyo619 H^gZdh hgb [hylky k\hbo `_g b ihwlhfm
gbdh]^Zg_[_jmlgb\lhjmxgbl_f[he__lj_lvxbebq_l\_j
lmx Bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb bah[j_eb gh\uc \b^ [jZdZ gZa\Zg
gucfbkvyjR_conZdboGmoZe-Dm^ZihkheBhj^Zgbb\BjZ
g_ gZau\Ze wlhl [jZd ©[jZdhf ljmkh\ª b mq_gu_ \uklmiZx
sb_aZ_]hjZaj_r_gghklv^Z`_[ueb\ugm`^_gukh]eZkblvky
kwlbf
>Zwlh[jZdljmkh\ihkdhevdm\g_ffm`qbgZg_[_j_l
gZk_[yhl\_lkl\_gghklvaZk\hxk_fvxZ\_^v:eeZo\DhjZg_
kdZaZe ©Fm`vy - ihi_qbl_eb >k\hbo@ `_gª Zwlbex^b
mgbqlh`beb ihgylb_ ihi_qbl_evkl\Z jZ^b m^h\e_l\hj_gby
k\hboihreuop_e_c
;jZd fbkvyj _klv mgb`_gb_ `_gsbgu b hq_gv ykgh ih
dZau\Z_l d_f gZ kZfhf ^_e_ y\eyxlky \ZooZ[blu Kdhevdh
kehfZgguo ^_\bqvbo `bag_c hklZ_lky ihke_ wlbo obsgbdh\
JZa\_ihke_wlh]h`_gsbgukfh]ml^h\_jylvfm`qbgZf"
Fg_ h^gh\j_f_ggh klZgh\blky b kf_rgh b ]jmklgh
dh]^Z y \kihfbgZx kemqZc ijhbahr_^rbc \ ?\jhi_ H^bg ba
\ZooZ[blh\gZoh^beky\h^ghcba_\jhi_ckdbokljZg_fm[ueh
ljm^gh k^_j`b\Zlv k\hx ihohlv b \ k\yab k wlbf hg aZy\be
©>Z\Zcl_mgbqlh`bf620\k_bm^_ckdb_bojbklbZgkdb_]hjh^Zª
Hp_gbl_lmijbqbgmba-aZdhlhjhchg`_eZ_lmgbqlh`blvojb
klbZgkdh-bm^_ckdmx pb\bebaZpbx JZa\_ _fm g_ba\_klgh qlh
BkeZf ijbr_e dZd fbehklv ^ey fbjh\" JZa\_ _fm g_ba\_klgh
qlh p_ev BkeZfZ – hk\h[h`^_gb_ q_eh\_q_kl\Z ba fbjkdhc
Bamq_gb_jugdZKFB\DK:ihdZaZehqlh[hevrbgkl\hajbl_e_cdZgZeZ
LBC khklZ\eyxl fheh^u_ \ZooZ[blu dhfiZgbb \_^msb_ k\hc [bag_k \
wlhch[eZklb^Z`_hldZaZebkvhlk\h_cj_deZfuihkdhevdm\g_cg_lg_h[
oh^bfhklb
620
<b^bfhwlhgh\uckihkh[jZkijhkljZg_gbyBkeZfZ
619
264
lxjvfubmdZaZgb__fmimlbdijhklhjZfh[hbofbjh\"DZdmx
`_j_eb]bxohlylij_^klZ\blv\gbfZgbxex^_cwlb©kiZkbl_
ebq_eh\_q_kl\Zª">`boZ^hfwlboex^_cy\ey_lky\hcgZmgbq
lh`_gb_ fmkmevfZg wlh ^ey gbo ^Z`_ \Z`g__ q_f \hcgZ ijh
lb\ bm^__\ b ojbklbZg Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky bo ^`boZ^Z \ fbjgh_
\j_fy lh hg aZdexqZ_lky \ aZfZkdbjh\Zgghf ij_ex[h^_ygbb
^ZkhojZgblgZk:eeZohlwlh]h
<hbklbgm \ZooZ[blkdbc \a]ey^ gZ \k_ wlb \hijhku
hq_gv mahd b ih\_joghkl_g >Z`_ _keb fu hklZ\b\ ij_l_gabb
rZjbZlZh[jZlbfkyd\hijhkmhjZa\h^_kqbklhfZl_jbZevghc
lhqdb aj_gby lh agZcl_ qlh \ _\jhi_ckdbo kljZgZo ihke_^kl
\by jZa\h^Z [he__ ly`_eu_ ^ey fm`qbgu q_f \ fmkmevfZg
kdbo?kebjZa\_^_ggZy`_gZ_\jhi_cpZg_\uc^_laZfm`lhhg
[m^_lh[yaZgh[_ki_qb\Zlv__^hdhgpZ`bagbBf_gghihwlhfm
hgb hl^Zxl ij_^ihql_gby ]jZ`^Zgkdbf [jZdZf `_gsbgZ b __
ex[h\gbd`b\mlbjh`Zxl^_l_c[_a[jZdZGm]hkih^Z\ZooZ
[bluihq_fm`_\ug_aZdexqZ_l_[jZdbkbm^_cdZfbbojbk
lbZgdZfb\?\jhi_b:f_jbd_"GZkdhevdh`_ba\jZs_gh\Zr_
h[s_kl\h
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev \hl \u b hagZdhfbebkv k \ZooZ
[blkdbf nbdohf b Zdu^hc <u hagZdhfbebkv k m[_`^_gbyfb
l_oex^_cm;h]Zdhlhjuo_klvjmdbgh]bb^jm]b_hj]Zgudh
lhjuckf__lkybk_f_gblijb[_]_Hgkb^blgZljhg_bhklZ\
ey_l k djZ_rdm jZkklhygb_ \ q_luj_ iZevpZ qlh[u \ Km^guc
^_gvihkZ^blvjy^hfkkh[hcijhjhdZFmoZffZ^Zk]k;he__
lh]h Hg ^Z`_ kb^bl \ h]g_ \ hdjm`_gbb Z]_eh\ Wlb ex^b
keurZlkeh\Zghg_ihgbfZxlbokfukeZBfijbrehkvba^Zlv
n_l\mhlhfqlha_feyiehkdZyZg_[_kZ–dmihe\ha^\b]gmluc
gZ^ g_c \_^v \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ ^ey bo [h`_kl\Z \hkk_^Zx
s_]hgZ\_jomg_hklZ_lkyf_klZ:fmkmevfZgbgg_ijbagZx
sbcwlmn_l\m^he`_g[ulvm[blH:eeZoqbklLuLuij_
\ur_\k_]hwlh]hg_lgbq_]hih^h[gh]hL_[_Lug_h]jZgbq_g
ijhkljZgkl\hfbjZamfg_\khklhygbbL_[yihklbqv
FmkmevfZgbg h[yaZg [ulv g_ijbfbjbfuf k \jZ]Zfb
BkeZfZ Hg ^he`_g \kemo aZy\blv h[ hiZkghklb Bf_ggh ih
wlhfm fu ijbau\Z_f hj]ZgbaZpbb ih ijZ\Zf q_eh\_dZ b ih
265
ijZ\Zf`_gsbguh[jZlblv\gbfZgb_gZwlhl[jZdfbkvyjFu
ijbau\Z_f bo \f_kl_ k gZfb ^Zlv hlihj wlbf ij_ex[h^_yf
h[ty\eyxsbfk_[yfmkmevfZgZfbWlh\hedb\h\_qv_crdmj_
GZ bo yaudZo ihklhyggh Zylu DhjZgZ gh bo k_j^pZ ^Ze_db hl
_]h ihgbfZgby Dj_^h wlhc k_lu – h[\bg_gb_ fmkmevfZg \g_
\_jbb b mgbqlh`_gb_ Wlb ex^b k ]hj^hklvx aZy\eyxl h lhf
dZd m[b\Zeb fmkmevfZg Ob^`ZaZ b h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gghc
djh\v fmkmevfZg BjZdZ ^Z`_ lh]^Z dh]^Z l_ kh\_jrZxl fh
ebl\m621.
Ijhqlbl_baZ^mfZcl_kv
Ijhjhdk]k\h^ghfbak\hbooZ^bkh\kdZaZe©;eb`_
d Km^ghfm ^gx ihy\blky ]jmiiZ ex^_c k fheh^ufb am[Zfb,
]emiufbb^_yfbijhbaghkysb_emqrb_j_qbh^gZdhhgb[m
^mlihdb^ZlvBkeZflZd`_[ukljhdZdihdb^Z_lklj_eZl_lb\m
emdZbo\_jZg_ih^gbf_lky\ur_]hjeZ?keb\ubo\klj_
lbl_lhg_ij_f_gghm[_cl_lhldlhm[v_lboihemqblgZ]jZ^m
hl:eeZoZ\Km^guc^_gvªi_j_^ZeZe-;moZjb
<^jm]hfoZ^bk_kdZaZgh©Bafh_cmffu\uc^mlex^bk
^mjgufb^_ygbyfbhgb[m^mlqblZlvDhjZgh^gZdhhgg_ih^
gbf_lky\ur_bo]hjeZªYab^kdZaZe©Ijhjhdk]k©<u[m
^_l_kqblZlvqlh\Zrb^_ygbyimklyd\kjZ\g_gbbkbo^_ygby
fb h^gZdh hgb [m^ml m[b\Zlv fmkmevfZg Ihwlhfm _keb hgb
ihy\ylky lh m[b\Zcl_ bo _keb hgb ihy\ylky \gh\v m[b\Zcl_
bo _keb hgb ihy\ylky \gh\v m[b\Zcl_ bo DZd ij_djZkgu l_
dlhbom[b\Z_lbih]b[Z_lhlbojmdDZ`^ucjZadh]^Z[m^_l
\ujZklZlvwlhljh]:eeZo[m^_l_]hh[jm[ZlvªWlbkeh\ZIjh
jhd k]k ih\lhjbe [he__ ^\Z^pZlb jZa Z y klhye b kemrZeª
I_j_^Ze:ofZ^
DZdklZlv\ZooZ[blhf"
Gb`_ y ohqm ijb\_klb kZlbjbq_kdmx klZlvx gZr_]h
[jZlZgZa\Z\r_]hky:[mFZebdhf622WlZklZlvy[ueZhim[eb
N_l\Z[ueba^ZgZfmnlb_fB[g;Zahf
Wlhh^bgba[jZlv_\-ZrZjblh\kdhlhjufbfg_ihkqZkleb\behkvihagZ
dhfblvky\Bgl_jg_l_iha^g__yk\klj_lbekykgbfbebqgh
621
622
266
dh\ZgZ\Bgl_jg_l_]hgZhq_gv`b\hbdjZkhqgh^Z_l
ij_^klZ\e_gb_hik_\^hkZeZnblZo
©Ihk\ysZ_lky dZ`^hfm [jZlm b dZ`^hc k_klj_ `_eZx
sbfijbkh_^bgblvkyd\ZooZ[blZf<gZr_cklZlv_fujZkkdZ
`_f \Zf dZd ijZ\bevgh bkihegylv fhebl\m ih-\ZooZ[blkdb
?keb \u ohlbl_ [ulv bklbgguf \ZooZ[blhf lh ^he`gu hagZ
dhfblvky k wlhc klZlv_c Dh]^Z [m^_l ijhbag_k_g dZfZl623 gZ
fhebl\m lu h[yaZg aZgylv f_klh \ i_j\hf jy^m `_eZl_evgh
ijyfhihaZ^bbfZfZDh]^Zlu\klZg_rvihaZ^bg_]hl_[_ke_
^m_l \ulZsblv ba dZjfZgZ fbk\Zd624 ^ebghc \ ihef_ljZ iexk
fbgmk g_kdhevdh kZglbf_ljh\ g_ bf__l agZq_gby Ihke_ wlh]h
l_[_ ih\hjZqb\Zykv ba klhjhgu \ klhjhgm qlh[u \k_f [ueh
ohjhrh \b^gh ke_^m_l gZqZlv qbklblv am[u G_ aZ[u\Zc lu
ijbf_jih^jZ`Zgby\k_^he`guagZlvijhjhq_kdmxkmggm?k
eb\h\j_fyqbkldbam[h\\hjlmhdZaZebkvdmkhqdbibsbaZkl
jy\rb_f_`^mam[Zfblhgbq_]hkljZrgh]hijh]ehlbbo>Z`_
_keb l\hb ^_kgu gZqgml djh\hlhqblv lh \ wlhf g_l gbq_]h
kljZrgh]h[hevrbgkl\hmq_guowlh^himkdZxll_f[he__qlh
h[ wlhf ibr_l r_co KZgZ^m^^bg :[m >`ZefZ[m G_ h[jZsZc
\gbfZgbygZl_odlh]h\hjblqlhwlh]hg_gm`gh^_eZlvg_ih
kj_^kl\_ggh i_j_^ fhebl\hc wlb ex^b gbq_]h g_ agZxl hgb
fm[lZ^b]b hgb [m^ml gZdZaZgu aZ lh qlh bkdZ`Zxl oZ^bku
IjhjhdZ k]k Fu `_ bkihegy_f _]h kmggm ihwlhfm dexqb
hlJZyb:^Z\gZrbojmdZoH[yaZl_evgh\_jlbkvbaklhjhgu\
klhjhgm\k_^he`gul_[y\b^_lvGbq_]hkljZrgh]h_kebijb
wlhf lu \udhe_rv ]eZa dhfm-eb[h ba k\hbo [jZlv_\ agZgb_
ij_\ur_wlh]hm\_qvyDh]^Z\k_fheysb_kyklZgml\jy^l_[_
g_h[oh^bfhihklZ\blvgh]bdZdfh`ghrbj_g_[hckymiZklv
lu^he`_g[ulvihoh`gZi_j_\_jgmlmx[mdm©Yª\hllh]^Zlu
bkihegbrvkmggmg_hklZ\brvf_klZgbkZlZg_gbk\hbf[jZ
lvyf ?keb klhysb_ jy^hf [m^ml hlh^\b]Zlv k\hb gh]b lh lu
h[yaZgbogZklb]gmlvk\hbfbgh]ZfbgZf_dZygZlhqlh^_eZ
DjZldbc ijbau\ gZ h[yaZl_evgmx qZklv fhebl\u ijhbaghkblky g_ih
kj_^kl\_gghi_j_^nZjahf–ii
624
IZehqdZbadhjg_cb\_l\_c^_j_\v_\^eyhqbs_gbyihehklbjlZ–ii
623
267
_rvwlhij_^gZf_j_ggh^Z[uh[mqblvbokmgg_AZihfgbl\hy
fhebl\Z g_ ijhklh fhebl\Z Z mjhd ^ey klhysbo jy^hf ?keb
l\hc khk_^ kijZ\Z beb ke_\Z \hafmlblky ihke_fhebl\ulhlu
^hklb]k\h_cp_eb\hll_i_jvlukfh`_rvh[tykgblv_fmdZd
ke_^m_l kh\_jrZlv fhebl\m ih kmgg_ b ihemqblv gZ]jZ^m hl
k\hbo ^jma_c \ZooZ[blh\ \eZ^_xsbo JZ_f b :^hf Dh]^Z lu
[m^_rvkh\_jrZlva_fghcihdehgl_[_ke_^m_l\ulygmlvkydZd
fh`gh^Zevr_bgbq_]hkljZrgh]h_kebl\hc`b\hldhkg_lky
iheZ ?keb ki_j_^b l_[_ f_rZxl gh]b fheysboky lh ihklZ\v
k\hx ]heh\m f_`^m gbfb JZkijZ\v ehdlb dZd fh`gh rbj_
qlh[u[ueZ\b^gZ[_ebagZl\hboih^fur_dgbq_]hkljZrgh]h
_keb wlh f_rZ_l l\hbf khk_^yf KlZjZcky qlh[u l\hy ]heh\Z
himkdZeZkv gZ ihe k kbevguo ]jhohlhf QblZc \k_ kmju b fh
ebl\ulZdqlh[ul\hbkhk_^bkeurZebbaZihfbgZebqlhbdh
]^Zke_^m_lqblZlv
?kebjy^hfklh[hcklhblfm[lZ^b]gZijbf_joZgZnbl
g_ ih^gbfZxsbc jmdb \ fhebl\_ b g_ kdeZ^u\Zxsbc bo gZ
]jm^bbeb`_fZebdbl\hh[s_g_kdeZ^u\Zxsbcjmdblhih
ke_fhebl\uluh[yaZgkljh]hih]h\hjblvkgbfLuh[yaZg_]h
hlqblZlv aZ hklZ\e_gb_ kmggu \ fhebl\_ b ihkh\_lh\Zlv hagZ
dhfblvky k dgb]hc B[g ;ZajZfblZ ©Gmj Ze-fmoZeey nb ZodZf
Zk-kZeyª GZqgb jZa]h\hj fy]dh eZkdh\uf ]hehkdhf g_^`^bc
kdbo r_coh\ b k j_abgh\hc meu[dhc gZ ebp_ ?keb `_ hg g_
ijbf_l l\hb gZklZ\e_gby lh ij_^ty\b k\hc ^h\h^ AZ^Zc \h
ijhk©Dlh[hevr_agZ_l"Ybeblu"ª?kebhghl\_lblqlhlu
agZ_rv [hevr_ lh \k_ ijh[e_fu j_r_gu _keb `_ hg g_ ^Zkl
lZdh]hhl\_lZlhihijhkb_]hi_j_qbkeb\_sb^_eZxsb_ijb
qbgu g_ ^_ckl\bl_evgufb i_j_qbkeb \b^u bah[j_l_gby oZ^b
kh\ i_j_qbkeb \b^u duykZ ;m^v m\_j_g hg g_ kfh`_l gZ wlh
hl\_lblv Gh hkl_j_]Zcky l_o dlh ih l\h_fm fg_gbx kfh`_l
hl\_lblvgZwlb\hijhku?kebl_[_ihiZekylZdhckh[_k_^gbd
lh khrebkv gZ dZdmx-eb[h ijbqbgm [hev \ `b\hl_ ]heh\_
Dh]^Z _klv g_h[oh^bfhklv rZjbZl jZaj_rZ_l b ijb\jZlv Ih
ke_ \k_]h wlh]h fh`_rv gZijZ\blvky d k\hbf [jZlvyf\ZooZ[blZf jZkkdZaZlv h k\h_c fhebl\_ b h lhf dZd lu ih[_
268
^bewlh]hfm[lZ^b]Z<hllh]^Z-lhl\hyfhebl\Z[m^_lkhhl\_l
kl\h\ZlvlhfmqlhkdZaZebgZrbm\Z`Z_fu_mq_gu_ǻ
Ohqm kdZaZlv qlh ih kmgg_ am[u ke_^m_l qbklblv ijb
hfh\_gbbZg_i_j_^fhebl\hcHqbs_gb_am[h\i_j_^fhebl
\hc fh`_l ijb\_klb d djh\hl_q_gbx ba ^_k_g qlh gZjmrZ_l
hfh\_gb_ZlZd`_ex^yf[m^_lg_ijbylghkfhlj_lvdZd\uwlh
^_eZ_l_ JZa\_ BkeZf ij_^ibku\Z_l gZf ijbex^gh ijh]eZlu
\ZlvdmkhqdbibsbaZkljy\rb_f_`^mam[Zfb"
Ohq_lky Z\lhjm wlhc klZlvb :[m FZebdm k^_eZlv aZf_
qZgb_aZlhqlhhgg_kh\_jrbegbhjnh]jZnbq_kdbogb]jZf
fZlbq_kdbo hrb[hd Wlh g_ ih-oZrZ\blkdb b g_ ih\ZooZ[blkdbmgbo\ug_gZc^_l_gb_^bghc\_jghcnjZau
=eZ\Zk_^vfZy
Kmggblu^ZxlhlihjoZrZ\blZf
BkeZf ij_^klZ\ey_l kh[hc j_eb]bx q_ldbo b ykguo ^h
\h^h\b^hdZaZl_evkl\Hggbdh]hg_ijbgm`^Z_lZijbau\Z_ld
ihbkdm GZ ^h\h^u hg ijbau\Z_l hl\_qZlv ^h\h^Zfb Z g_ f_
qhfG_lijbgm`^_gby\j_eb]bbDZdlhevdh]^_-gb[m^vihy\
eyeky oZrZ\baf mq_gu_ jZaebqguo j_]bhgh\ ki_rbeb _]h hi
jh\_j]gmlv b jZatykgblv ex^yf _]h g_khklhyl_evghklv b hiZk
ghklv<i_j\mxhq_j_^vwlbfbmq_gufb[ueboZg[Zebluwlh
[ueh\ua\Zghl_fqlh\ZooZ[blu\k_]^ZklZjZebkvijbdjulvky
h^_`^Zfb oZg[ZebafZ Gb`_ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb \ukdZau\Z
gbyhijh\_j`_gbybhl\_lumq_guoq_luj_ofZaoZ[h\oZrZ\b
lZf b \ qZklghklb bo \h`^x B[g L_cfbb DZd fm^ju keh\Z
ijhjhdZ FmoZffZ^Z k]k h[ wlbo ex^yo ©Hgb [m^ml ihdb
^Zlvj_eb]bxklZdhc`_[ukljhlhcdZdklj_eZihdb^Z_lemdª
Dgb]b[jZlZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
< wlhf jZa^_e_ j_qv ihc^_l h[ ba\_klghc dgb]_ r_coZ
Kme_cfZgZ[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z625©:k-KZ\Z]bdZe-beyobynbZjB[g;ZrZjmdZau\Z_lqlhhgmf_j\]]lh_klvhgmf_jq_
j_a ^\Z ]h^Z ihke_ FmoZffZ^Z [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z kf ©=mg\Zg ZefZ^`^«ªHr_co_Kme_cfZg_Z\lhjihqlbgbq_]hg_ibr_llhevdh
625
269
jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-\ZooZ[byª ©;h`_kl\_ggZy]jhaZ\hl\_l\ZooZ[b
lZfª >Ze__ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb pblZlu ba wlhc dgb]b hgb
[hevr_Z^j_kh\Zgul_fklm^_glZfdhlhju_^he]h_\j_fy`beb
\ baheypbb hl bklbgu Fu gZ^__fky qlh :eeZo hk\_lbl bo
k_j^pZ
AgZdhfkl\hkdgb]hc
WlZhq_gvihe_agZydgb]Z\ureZbakZfuo`_klhdboih
e_ckjZ`_gbyk\ZooZ[bafhf?_Z\lhjhfy\ey_lkyjh^ghc[jZl
FmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[ZDgb]Zba^Z\ZeZkvihg_kdhevdm
jZa\?]bil_RZf_b^jm]boj_]bhgZoEmqrbfbbawlboba^Z
gbc kqblZxlky _]bi_lkdh_ ba^Zgb_ ] ] b ba^Zgb_
lbih]jZnbb ©:e-Nmlmoª ] k dhff_glZjbyfb r_coZ Fm
oZffZ^Z Omkg_cgZ FZoexnZ j_dlhjZ k_lb bgklblmlh\ ©:e:aoZjª Djhf_ g__ i_jm Z\lhjZ ijbgZ^e_`bl dgb]Z ©NZke ZeoblZ[ nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ª ©YkgZy
j_qv \ hl\_l FmoZffZ^m [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[mª Fu `_ k \Zfb
[m^_f jZkkfZljb\Zlv _]bi_lkdh_ ba^Zgb_ ba^Zl_evkl\Z ©:eBgkZgªkmlhqg_gbyfbB[jZobfZFmoZffZ^ZZe-;ZlZ\bkhklh
ys__bakljZgbp
Hl ba^Zl_ey ©< gZrb ^gb dh]^Z dhkfbq_kdb_ dhjZ[eb
g_\_jguo^hklb]ebEmgubFZjkZdh]^Zhgbbkke_^mxlpZjkl
\h:eeZoZ\ihbkd_wdhghfbq_kdhc\u]h^u_s_`b\uik_\^h
kZeZnblu]hlh\u_hklZgh\blva_fgh_\jZs_gb_^eyih^l\_j`
^_gby k\h_c eh`ghc Zdu^u Bo Zdu^Z hkgh\ZgZ gZ ihklmeZl_
]eZkys_f h lhf qlh ydh[u :eeZo gZoh^blky gZ\_jom :eeZo
ij_\ur_ lh]h qlh hgb ?fm ijbibku\Zxl Hgb kqblZxl qlh
dZ`^h]h g_\_jgh]h b fmkmevfZgbgZ \_jys_]h \h \jZs_gb_
A_febke_^m_laZj_aZlvDlh`_lh]^ZhklZg_lkygZA_fe_"Hgb
aZij_sZxlihk_s_gb_fh]beuIjhjhdZk]khkgh\u\ZykvgZ
mdZau\Z_lqlhhg\h_\Zeijhlb\\ZooZ[blh\©<wlhf]h^m]eZ\ub`bl_eb
OZjfZey\h]eZ\_kdZab_fKme_cfZghf[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[hfh[ty\beb\hc
gmfmkmevfZgZfHgbkf_klbebwfbjZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^meem[bgFm[Z
jZdZk_]hihklZbba]gZebbaihk_edZǻlk)WlZpblZlZmdZau\Z_l
gZ lh qlh r_co Kme_cfZg hlqZy\rbkv \ b^_heh]bq_kdhf ijhlb\hklhygbb
i_j_r_ed\h_gghfmh^gZdh:eeZom[uehm]h^ghqlh[uhgihl_ji_eihjZ
`_gb_
270
lhfqlhhgmf_jZke_^h\Zl_evghgZ^hihk_sZlvg__]hZf_
q_lvHgbkh\_lmxlg_gZau\Zlv_]h©]hkih^bghfªbg_bkihev
ah\Zlv_]hebqghklvdZdkj_^kl\hijb[eb`Zxs__d:eeZomª626.
Ij_^bkeh\b_ hl j_^ZdlhjZ ©:\lhj dgb]b Kme_cfZg [bg =Z[
^me\ZooZ[ \klmiZ_l \ [hjv[m kh k\hbf [jZlhf g_^`^bckdbf
r_cohf FmoZffZ^hf [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[hf kha^Zl_e_f \ZooZ
[blkdh]h^\b`_gby\ur_^rbfbalh]h`_j_]bhgZqlhbFm
kZceZfZ Ze-DZaaZ[ h[ty\b\rbc k_[y ijhjhdhf Fgh]b_ fm
kmevfZg_ wlh]h j_]bhgZ ih^^Zebkv _]h gZms_gbyf hldZaZebkv
\uieZqb\ZlvaZdylb:[m;Zdj[ue\ugm`^_gh[ty\blvbf\hc
gmdhlhjZyijh^he`ZeZkv^hl_oihjihdZg_[uem[blFmkZc
eZfZ
< k\h_ \j_fy Ijhjhd k]k ij_^mij_^be fmkmevfZg h
kh[ulbyodhlhju_[m^mlijhbkoh^blv\G_^`^_Kh]eZkghh^
ghfmbaoZ^bkh\Ijhjhdk]kmdZau\Zyh^ghfmbag_^`^bc
p_\gZG_^`^kdZaZe©Hllm^Zijb^mlihljyk_gbybkfmluhl
lm^Z\ue_a_ljh]kZlZguª<^jm]hf^hklh\_jghfoZ^bk_i_j_
^Zgghf:[mOmjZcjhckdZaZgh©GZqZehg_\_jbygZ\hklhd_ªihke_q_]hIjhjhdk]kmdZaZegZG_^`^
<ZooZ[bafihy\bekybf_ggh\wlhfj_]bhg_bf_ggh_]h
`bl_ebba[jZebb^_baZobjblh\627b\qZklghklbB[gL_cfbb
bf_ggh hgb hl\_j]eb Ze-\Zkbey IjhjhdZ k]k b bf_ggh hgb
aZy\bebqlh:eeZoaZgbfZ_lnbabq_kdb\ukhdh_iheh`_gb_ǻ
©«>ZfZaoZ[hfjZkijhkljZg_gguf\wlhfj_]bhg_y\
ey_lky fZaoZ[ :ofZ^Z [bg OZg[ZeZ gh hgb ihaZbfkl\h\Zeb m
g_]h lhevdh nbdo hldZaZ\rbkv hl Zdu^u« ;he__ lh]h hgb
h[ty\beb g_\_jgufb \k_o k\hbo hiihg_glh\ _keb \u g_ k gb
fblh\u–g_\_jgucª
>Ze__h[jZsZykvd\ZooZ[blZfj_^Zdlhjibr_l©<hbk
lbgmBkeZf–wlhj_eb]byfbehklbIhdZdhfmijZ\m\ude_\_
s_l_ gZ fmkmevfZg" Ih dZdhfm ijZ\m \u h[ty\ey_l_ fmkmev
fZgg_\_jgufb"<uh[ty\ey_l_\hcgmk\hbf[jZlvyf"Ij_l_g
626
627
Kf[he__ih^jh[gh\klZlv_©:ojZf]Zey[ZeZ[ZeZZ^-^moª
Klhjhggbdb^hkeh\ghcljZdlh\dbk\ys_gguol_dklh\–ii
271
abb dhlhju_ \u ij_^ty\ey_l_ k\hbf [jZlvyf \ i_j\mx hq_
j_^vfh`ghij_^ty\blv\Zfª
<u^_j`dbbadgb]b
<gZqZe_k\h_cdgb]br_coKme_cfZgi_j_qbkey_lmkeh
\by dhlhjuf ^he`_g khhl\_lkl\h\Zlv bfZf b gZklhysbc fm
kmevfZgkdbcmq_gucqlh`_dZkZ_lkyh[jZah\Zl_evgh]hmjh\gy
k\h_]h[jZlZlhgZk–hgmdZau\Z_l©GZ]heh\uex^_c
\uiZehly`dh_bkiulZgb_hgbihke_^h\ZebaZq_eh\_dhfk\y
au\Zxsbf k_[y k DhjZghf b kmgghc ^_eZxsbf ba gbo \u\h
^uGh_keb\uijb]eZkbl_wlh]hq_eh\_dZqlh[uhg\uklmibe
i_j_^mq_gufblhg_^h`^_l_kv_]hHgh[yau\Z_lex^_cke_
^h\ZlvaZk\hbfbb^_yfbZlh]hdlhkgbfg_kh]eZk_gh[\bgy
_l \ g_\_jbb Wlhl q_eh\_d g_ lhevdh g_ kihkh[_g kh\_jrZlv
b^`lboZ^gh^Z`_g_h[eZ^Z_l^_kylhc^he_cagZgbcg_h[oh
^bfuo ^ey wlh]h b ijb wlhf iha\hey_l k_[_ \uklmiZlv i_j_^
ex^vfbª
>Ze__ ih^ aZ]heh\dhf ©Bo Zdu^Z – Zdu^Z oZjb^`blh\ª
hg jZatykgy_l qlh _]h [jZl ba[jZe ^ey k_[y oZjb^`blkdmx
Zdu^m GZ k – hg h[jZsZykv d k\h_fm [jZlm ibr_l
©<a]eygb gZ kih^\b`gbdh\ IjhjhdZ k]k jZa\_ hgb dh]^Zeb[hki_rbebjZa\_hgbdh]^Z-eb[hklj_fbebkvh[\bgylvex
^_c\g_\_jbb"IhkfhljbgZ^_ygbyIjhjhdZk]kgZ^_ygby
fmkmevfZgkdbobfZfh\bfh`_l[ulvwlhklZg_l^eyl_[ygZ
ab^Zgb_fFh`_l[ulvlh]^Zluhl\jZlbrvkyhllhc[_^udh
lhjmx bf_gm_rv kmgghcª Wlb keh\Z ijbgZ^e_`Zl mq_ghfm
dhlhjuc ijboh^beky [jZlhf FmoZffZ^m [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[m
Fh`_l[ulvgZgboh[jZlyl\gbfZgb_l_ke_ipudhlhju_ih
ke_^h\ZebaZwlbfdjh\h`Z^guf_j_lbdhfjZaj_rZxsbfm[b
\ZlvfmkmevfZg?]h^_ygbybk\b^_l_evkl\Zjh^kl\_ggbdh\yk
ghjZkkdZau\Zxlhlhfd_fhg[ue628.
H^ghfm ba ihke_^h\Zl_e_c wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \_e_eb\uklmiblvkijhih\_
^vxgZibkZgghcgZebkld_[mfZ]bHgi_j_imlZ\ebkldb[mfZ]bkq_eqlh
oml[ZijbgZ^e_`bl_]hhiihg_glZfbgZqZelhilZlv__gh]Zfb?]h^Z`_g_
\hegh\Zeh lh qlh lZf [ueb ijb\_^_gu keh\Z :eeZoZ b \ukdZau\Zgby ijh
jhdZk]k<hl^hlZdhckl_i_gbwlbex^bg_m\Z`xlgZke_^b_BkeZfZ
628
272
GZ k h[jZsZykv d \ZooZ[blZf hg ibr_l ©H jZ[u
:eeZoZ ih[hcl_kv :eeZoZ b ?]h gZdZaZgby \_^v \u ijbg_keb
klhevdh ]hjy fmkmevfZgZf :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©: l_ dh
lhju_ aehkeh\yl h \_jmxsbo fm`qbgZo b `_gsbgZo [_ah
\kydhcgZlhijbqbgu\a\Zeb\ZxlgZk_[y[j_fygZ\_lZby\
gh]h]j_oZª:\_^v\bgZwlboex^_c[ueZlhevdh\lhf
qlhhgbg_ihke_^h\ZebaZ\ZfbHgbg_klZebh[\bgylv\g_\_
jbbl_odh]hk\ys_ggu_l_dkluh[ty\bebfmkmevfZgZfb?keb
[u hgb ihke_^h\Zeb aZ \Zfb lh ihiZeb [u ih^ ]g_\ [h`bc
\_^v Ijhjhd k]k \ k\h_f oZ^bk_ kdZaZe ©Y g_ [hxkv qlh
fhx mffm mgbqlh`bl \jZ] beb iheqbsZ ^bdZj_c y [hxkv aZ
[em^rbobfZfh\_kebex^bihke_^mxlaZgbfblhaZ[em^ylky
Z _keb g_ ihke_^mxl lh [m^ml m[bluª ijb\h^blky m ZlLZ[ZjZgbhl:[mMfZfuªIhke_wlh]hhgmihfbgZ_l:[m;Zd
jZ =mfZjZ =mkfZgZ =Zeb h[tykgy_l qlh hgb gbdh]h g_ ijb
gm`^Zebke_^h\ZlvaZk\hbffg_gb_fIhke_wlh]hgZkh[
jZsZ_lky d \ZooZ[blZf ©<u h[\bgy_l_ \ g_\_jbb \k_o dlh g_
ijbgbfZ_l\Zrbob^_cG_m`_eb\ugZklhevdh[_a]j_rgu"?k
eb g_l lh ihq_fm \u kqblZ_l_ qlh bf__l_ ijZ\h ijbgm`^Zlv
^jm]boke_^h\ZlvaZ\Zfb"YohqmaZ^Zlv\hijhk_klvebkj_^b
\Zkohly[uh^bgdlhkhhl\_lkl\m_lmkeh\byfij_^ty\ey_fuf
dbfZfZfbmq_guf;he__lh]h_klvebmdh]h-eb[hba\Zkohly
[uh^ghbadZq_kl\ijbkmsbogZklhysbfbbfZfZfbmq_guf"
HldZ`bl_kvhlk\h_]hnZgZlbafZQlh\ukh[bjZ_l_kvhl\_lblv
:eeZom \ Km^guc ^_gv" G_m`_eb \Zk g_ kljZrbl ?]h gZdZaZ
gb_"ª
M\Z`Z_fu_ [jZlvy khklhygb_ \ZooZ[blh\ hibku\Z_fh_
r_cohf Kme_cfZghf b _]h gZklZ\e_gby \h`^yf \ZooZ[bafZ
hklZxlkyZdlmZevgufbbihk_c^_gv<ur_gZfb[uehijb\_
^_gh^hklZlhqghijbf_jh\ih^l\_j`^Zxsbo_]hkeh\Z
R_coKme_cfZglZd`_dZdb_]h[jZl[ue\uoh^p_fba
G_^`^Zghwlhg_ihf_rZeh_fmjZkdjulvkmlvG_^`^Zhdh
lhjhc mihfbgZ_l Ijhjhd k]k \ k\hbo oZ^bkZo >ey wlhc l_
fuhg^Z`_hl\_ehl^_evgmx]eZ\m©KZlZgZ\G_^`^_ªk.
< wlhc ]eZ\_ hg ijb\h^bl oZ^bku IjhjhdZ k]k ih\_kl\mx
sb_h\hajh`^_gbbg_\_jby\G_^`^_hihy\e_gbbihljyk_gbc
273
bkfmlJZa\_fh`_l\lZdhfj_]bhg_ihy\blvkyh[gh\bl_evj_
eb]bb"JZa\_wlhg_ijhlb\hj_qbloZ^bkZfIjhjhdZk]k"
>Ze__ gZ k ke_^m_l ]eZ\Z ©G_^`^bckdb_ kfmlu –
[b^]Zª\g_chgijb\h^y^h\h^ubaDhjZgZbkmggujZatykgy
_leh`ghklv\ZooZ[blkdh]himlb
Hlebqbl_evghc q_jlhc wlhc ]eZ\u y\ey_lky kljh]bc gZ
mqgucih^oh^bbkdj_gghklvHgijb\h^blykgu_^h\h^ub\u
jZ`Z_lk\h_`_eZgb_\_jgmlvk\h_]h[jZlZ\ehghbklbgghc\_
juh^gZdhdZdkdZaZgh\DhjZg_©<hbklbgmlug_kfh`_rv
gZklZ\blv gZ ijyfhc imlv l_o dh]h ex[brv Wlh :eeZo \_
^_l ijyfuf iml_f dh]h ih`_eZ_l b Hg emqr_ agZ_l l_o
dlhklmibegZijyfhcimlvª (28:56).
< wlhc dgb]_ fu gZreb hq_gv fgh]h ^h\h^h\ ijhlb\
\ZooZ[bafZ g_dhlhju_ ba gbo \u h[gZjm`bl_ \ jZa^_e_ ©<h
ijhku `^msb_ hl\_lh\ª <ZooZ[blu aZy\eyxl qlh r_co Km
e_cfZg jZkdZyeky \ lhf qlh gZibkZe wlm dgb]m Ohqm kdZaZlv
qlh ih^h[gu_ j_qb \u fh`_l_ mkeurZlv h fgh]bo mq_guo
[u\rbo \ hiihabpbb d \ZooZ[blZf Gh \k_ wlb aZy\e_gby gb
kdhevdhg_mfZeyxlp_gghklbdgb]gZibkZgguobfb
Mq_gu_q_luj_ofZaoZ[h\hl\_qZxloZrZ\blZf
H^gZbafm^jhkl_c:eeZoZdjh_lky\lhfqlhHgjZkk_
ebe ex^_c ih jZaebqguf j_]bhgZf A_feb Ihwlhfm [_^mbgu
ij_^ihqblZxl `bagv \ imklugyo Z hk_^eu_ – \ ]hjh^Zo h^gb
ij_^ihqblZxl ]hjgu_ ihk_edb ]^_ \b^gu kg_`gu_ \_jrbgu
^jm]b_jZ\gbggu_]hjh^ZGhaZqZklmxg_\_`_kl\hijb\h^bld
lhfmqlhq_eh\_dgZqbgZ_lkqblZlvk\hxa_fexhkh[_gghk\y
s_gghcb^mfZ_lqlhhgZihk\h_ckl_i_gbij_\hkoh^bl^jm]b_
j_]bhguBgh]^Zex[h\vdk\h_cjh^bg_fh`_lijb\h^blv^Z`_
d\jZ`^_bg_gZ\bklbdZdkdZaZgh\h^ghcbaihkeh\bp©Q_eh
\_d \jZ`^_[_g d g_ba\_^Zgghfmª Ohq_lky hlf_lblv qlh ih
^h[gZy]bi_jljhnbjh\ZggZyex[h\vdjh^bg_aZqZklmxkm`Z_l
djm]hahj q_eh\_dZ Hg gZqbgZ_l kfhlj_lv gZ fbj q_j_a s_ev
k\h_]h aZ[hjZ Bf_ggh ihwlhfm lZdb_ ex^bg_ijbgbfZxlgb
dZdbo gZklZ\e_gbc b kh\_lh\ Lhqgh\lZdhf`_khklhygbbgZ
oh^bebkv oZrZ\blu b gZoh^ylky ik_\^hkZeZnblu Hgb kqblZ
274
xlqlhboimlvy\ey_lky_^bgkl\_ggh\_jgufb^Z`_g_`_eZ
xlhklZgh\blvkybijh\_klbZgZebak\hbom[_`^_gbcIhwlhfm
g_l gbq_]h m^b\bl_evgh]h \ lhf qlh oZrZ\blu jvygh hlklZb
\Zxlk\hxlhqdmaj_gbyijbau\Zxldg_c^jm]boex^_cbkjZ
`Zxlky k l_fb dlh g_ kh]eZk_g k gbfb < ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_
hgbm\b^_\bklbgmg_ij_f_gghklZeb[uihke_^h\Zl_eyfbh^
gh]hbaq_luj_ofZaoZ[h\
OZrZ\bluijbau\ZxlfmkmevfZgihke_^h\Zlvihboim
lb kmggblu `_ gZijhlb\ kqblZxl bo yauqgbdZfb b kem]Zfb
bm^__\g_dhlhju_aZy\eyxlqlhoZrZ\blu^Z`_hiZkg__bm^_
_\ Bf_ggh ihwlhfm gb`_ fu ohlbf ijb\_klb \ukdZau\Zgby
g_dhlhjuobakmggblkdbomq_guohoZrZ\blZo
A^_kv fu ohlbf ijb\_klb ba[jZggu_ \ukdZau\Zgby g_
dhlhjuo rZnb]blkdbo mq_guo kj_^b dhlhjuo :[m BkoZd ZrRbjZabbfZf:[m;ZdjZr-RZrbb^jm]b_BlZdmB[g=ZkZ
dbjZ\©LZ[bbgdZa[Ze-fmnlZjZªkkdZaZgh©<hbfy:e
eZoZ Fbehklb\h]h Fbehk_j^gh]h :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©B
dlh`_g_q_klb\__lh]hdlhkdjuebf_xs__kymg_]hhl:eeZoZ
k\b^_l_evkl\h"ª Bf_ggh ihwlhfm gZb[he__ hl\_lkl
\_ggu_ mq_gu_ nZdbob j_rbeb gZibkZlv wlh ibkvfh < g_f
hgb hkm`^Zxl ^_ckl\by oZrZ\blh\ b g_dhlhjuo oZg[Zeblh\
aZeh`b\rbo\;Z]^Z^_gZqZehf_jadhc[b^]ZWlbex^b\uklm
ibebkj_qZfbdhlhjuo\ug_mkeurbl_^Z`_hl[_a[h`gbdh\
hgb ba\jZlbeb hkgh\u rZjbZlZ Hgb h[\bgbeb g_\_jgufb
\k_o dlh hljbpZ_l [h]hih^h[b_ ?]h ijhbkoh`^_gb_ aZ\bkb
fhklvhlijhkljZgkl\Zb\j_f_gbih^\_j`_gghklvkh[ulbyfb
baf_g_gbyfWlbex^b\h\j_fyk\hbokh[jZgbc\f_q_lyogZ
jugdZob^jm]boaZ\_^_gbyoijhdebgZxl\_jmxsboOZrZ\blu
mijyfhaZy\eyxlqlhbo;h]h[eZ^Z_lgh]Zfbam[ZfbiZevpZ
fbkgbkoh^blK\h_ckmsghklvx\h[jZa_xghrbiml_r_kl\m
_lgZhke_GZ_]h]heh\_k\_jdZxsZydhjhgZZgZgh]Zolmneb
baahehlZ«bl^ª
< ^jm]hf aZy\e_gbb ]jmiiu mq_guo kdZaZgh
©«g_m`_eb \u ohlbl_ kdZaZlv qlh m \Zr_]h ]hkih^Z lZdh_ `_
[_ah[jZagh_bmjh^eb\h_ebphdZdbm\Zk"G_m`_ebHgbf__l
lZdh_ `_ ls_^mrgh_ l_eh dZd m \Zk" G_m`_eb m G_]h _klv
275
iZevpu dbklb b gh]b gZ dhlhju_ gZ^_lu ahehlu_ lmneb" :e
eZo ij_\ur_ \k_]h wlh]h ^Z [m^_l ijhdeylb_ lhfm kZlZg_ dh
lhjuc \Zf lZdh_ gZmsZ_l Ih\_ebl_ev ijZ\h\_jguo ihdeyeky
qlh _keb \u g_ hldZ`_l_kv hl wlbo m[_`^_gbc lh hg h[gZ`bl
ijhlb\\Zkk\h_cf_qbkh``_l\Zrb`bebsZª
Gh wlb ex^b g_ kihkh[gu mkeurZlv jZamfgu_ j_qb bo
mf aZlmfZg_g nZgZlbafhf \ ijhlb\ghf kemqZ_ Ijhjhd k]k
g_kdZaZe[uhgbo©?kebhgbihy\ylkym[_cl_boª
BfZf B[g Ze-DZrbjb \ ©BloZn Zk-kZ^Zl Ze-fmllZdbgZ
[brZjobovy]memfZ^-^bgªlKh\h`^yowlhck_dlu
ibr_l ke_^mxs__ ©< kj_^_ g_\_`_kl\_ggh]h ijhklhgZjh^vy
ihy\beZkv ]jmiiZ ex^_c dhlhjZy aZy\ey_l ©Fu [m^_f ihgb
fZlv k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu [md\Zevgh Z baeh`_ggh_ lZf h]jZgb
qb\Zlv ba\_klgufb gZf jZfdZfb b ]jZgbpZfb Fu g_ bf__f
ijZ\Z dhff_glbjh\Zlv keh\Z k\ys_gguo l_dklh\ ihkdhevdm
:eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Gh g_ agZ_l _]h lhedh\Zgby gbdlh
djhf_ :eeZoZª ª Wlb ex^b hiZkg__ ^ey BkeZfZ q_f bm
^_b ojbklbZg_ yauqgbdb b h]g_ihdehggbdb >_eh \ lhf qlh
aZ[em`^_gbyg_\_jguoykguZaZ[em`^_gbywlboex^_ckdju
lu hgb kihkh[gu \\_klb \ aZ[em`^_gb_ g_]jZfhlguo fmkmev
fZgWlbex^baZy\eyxlqlh;h]bf__lhj]Zgukb^blkimkdZ
_lkyjZkiheZ]Z_lkyiheme_`Z\haghkblkybk\yaZgkgZijZ\e_
gbyfb ijhkljZgkl\Z <Zf fh]ml ihgjZ\blvky bo j_qb \u gZq
g_l_ ij_^klZ\eylv ;h]Z hsmsZ_fuf b ihkl_i_ggh \hev_l_kv \
wlmk_dlmª
:l-LZdb Ze-Omkgb Zr-RZnb]b \ ij_^bkeh\bb d dgb]_
©>Zn] rm[Zo fZg rZ[[ZoZ \Z lZfZjjZ^Z \Z gZkZ[Z aZebdZ bey
Zk-kZcb^ Ze-^`Zebe :ofZ^ª ibr_l ©>Ze__« Ijbqbghc gZib
kZgby wlhc dgb]b y\bebkv ex^b ijhih\_^mxsb_ lZcgh_ aeh b
hlghkysb_ k_[y d fZaoZ[m \_ebdh]h bfZfZ :ofZ^Z Ijhkluf
ex^yfwlbex^bjZkdju\Zxlk\h_mq_gb_Zi_j_^mq_gufb[h
ylkyhg_f]h\hjblvWlbex^bom`_l_odlhhldjulhhlklmiZ_l
hl \_ju hgb \\h^yl \ aZ[em`^_gb_ ijhklhex^bgh\ <g_rg_
wlb ex^b \u]ey^yl gZ[h`gufb jZ[Zfb :eeZoZ g_ jZkklZxlky
khk[hjgbdZfboZ^bkh\GZkZfhf`_^_e_lZdb_ex^bdZdB[g
OZfb^ b dZabc B[g Za-AZ]mgb y\eyxlky fmrZ[[boblZfb b
276
ijbibku\Zxl :eeZom Zljb[mlu g_ ijbebq_kl\mxsb_ ?]h [h
`_kl\_gghc kmsghklb Wlb ex^b – ihke_^h\Zl_eb kZfbjby629,
bo m[_`^_gby koh^gu k m[_`^_gbyfb bm^__\ b ojbklbZg hgb
ij_^klZ\eyxl;h]Z\l_e_kghfh[jZa_ª
:e-=Znbnb Ze-Ynb]b \ dgb]_ ©FZjoZf Ze-]beZe Zefm]Z^^ZeZ nb ^Zn] Zr-rm[Zo \Z Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-fm]lZabeyª
ibr_l©OZg[Zeblkdb_mq_gu_iha^g_]hi_jbh^Zba\jZlbebj_
eb]bxk^_eZebfgh`_kl\h]emiuo\ukdZau\Zgbchgbh[e_deb
:eeZoZ \ fZl_jbZevgh_ l_eh b mih^h[beb ?]h kha^Zgbyf :[m
;Zdj B[g Ze-=ZjZ[b \ dgb]_ ©:e-=Z\Zkufª ih wlhfm ih\h^m
ibr_l©YkeurZehlfgh]bogZ^_`guogZklZ\gbdh\qlhdZabc
:[mY]eyZe-OZg[ZebijbmihfbgZgbb:eeZoZ]h\hjbe©=h\h
jbl_fg_hg_f\k_qlhm]h^ghyijbgbfZx\k_djhf_[hjh^u
bihklu^guof_klªG_dhlhju_mq_gu_ihwlhfmih\h^mkdZaZ
ebqlh³wlhy\gh_g_\_jb_ba^_\Zl_evkl\hgZ^:eeZohfLZdbo
b^_cfh`_lijb^_j`b\Zlvkylhevdhg_\_`^ZbaZgbfgb\dh
_f kemqZ_ g_evay ke_^h\Zlv hg g_ bf__l ijZ\Z [ulv bfZfhf
Wlhlq_eh\_dmih^h[bekyyauqgbdZfihdehgyxsbfkyb^heZf
Hg ihdehgy_lky g_ :eeZom Z b^hem dhlhjh]h kha^Ze \ k\h_f
jZamf_ :eeZo ij_\ur_ \k_]h qlh ?fm ijbibku\Zxl [_a[h`
gbdb b Zl_bklu´ª >Ze__ hg ibr_l ©B[g Ze->`Z\ab ihklmibe
hq_gv ohjhrh qlh gZibkZe hijh\_j`_gb_ b^_c wlbo ex^_c <
wlhfhijh\_j`_gbbhgibr_lqlhhgbmih^h[beb:eeZoZq_eh
\_dm Hgb hihjhqbeb oZg[Zeblkdbc fZaoZ[ bf_ggh ihwlhfm
k_cqZk keh\h oZg[Zebl Zkkhpbbjm_lky k ihgylb_f fm^`Zkkb
fblª Hg `_ ibr_l ©Wlb ex^b ebrv aZb]ju\Zxl k j_eb]b_c
hgbg_ihagZeb:eeZoZ\bomq_gbbg_lb^hebBkeZfZH[sZ
ykvk\Zfbhgbmgb`Zxl\Zk^hmjh\gyj_[_gdZª>Ze__hgmdZ
au\Z_l ©Hgb hldjulh mih^h[eyxl :eeZoZ q_eh\_dm AZ gbfb
ihke_^h\Zebg_dhlhju_ijhklhex^bguIjbq_fhihahjbebkvb
l_b^jm]b_ª
B[g =Z[^mkZeyf \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©LZ[ZdZl Zr-rZnb]byª
k – ibr_l ©OZrZ\blu mih^h[eyxsb_ :eeZoZ kh
a^Zgbyf ^_eylky gZ ^\_ ]jmiiu h^gbaZy\eyxlhk\hbom[_`
629
Q_eh\_dij_^eh`b\rbcbm^_yfihdehgylvkyl_evpm–ii
277
^_gbyo hldjulh ©ih^h[gh lhfm dZd deygmlky i_j_^ \Zfb b
ijbwlhfiheZ]ZxlqlhhgbijZ\uLZdagZcl_hgb–e`_puª
dh\lhjhc]jmii_hlghkylkyoZrZ\bluijbdju\Zxsb_
ky kZeZnbafhf ^ey ^hklb`_gby hij_^_e_gguo p_e_c hgb ©oh
lyl[ulv\_jgufbb\Zfbk\h_fmgZjh^mªQlh`_dZ
kZ_lky gZklhysbo kZeZnh\ lh hgb ijb^_j`b\Zebkv ijbgpbih\
lZ\ob^Z b hqbs_gby lZgabo :eeZoZ hl \k_o g_^hklZldh\ hgb
[ueb^Ze_dbhllZr[boZblZ^`kbfZBf_gghihwlhfm\k_fm[
lZ^b]bklZjZl_evghhlghkylk_[ydkZeZnblZf<h^ghfbaklb
ohl\hj_gbcihwlhfmih\h^mkdZaZgh©Hgbhlghkylk_[ydEyc
ebghEyceb^Ze_dhlgboªDZdfh`ghml\_j`^ZlvqlhkZeZnu
ijb^_j`b\Zebkvb^_clZ^`kbfZlZr[boZbg_\uklmiZebijh
lb\wlbo[b^]Z"<_^v:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©G_imlZcl_bk
lbgu k eh`vx g_ kdju\Zcl_ bklbgu _keb \u agZ_l_ __ª
(2:42), ©><kihfgbFmoZffZ^@dZdkl_odhfm^Zjh\ZghIbkZ
gb_ :eeZo \aye aZ\_l >]h\hjy@ <u g_ij_f_ggh [m^_l_ jZat
ykgylvIbkZgb_ex^yfg_[m^_l_>gbhldh]h@kdju\Zlv_]h
Ghhgbhlr\ujgmeb>wlhl@aZ\_lbihemqbebaZwlhgbqlh`
gmx ieZlm Kdhev f_jadh lh qlh hgb ihemqZxlª (3:187),
©Qlh[ulujZatykgbeex^yflhqlh[uehgbkihkeZghij_`
gbfihkeZggbdZf-[ulvfh`_lhgbh^mfZxlkyªDZd
ba\_klgh mq_gu_ y\eyxlky gZke_^gbdZfb ijhjhdh\ ihwlhfm
hgb h[yaZgu ijh^he`Zlv bo ^_eh \ DhjZg_ ih wlhfm ih\h^m
kdZaZgh ©B h[jZam_lky ba \Zk h[sbgZ dhlhjZy [m^_l ijbau
\Zlvd^h[jmih[m`^Zlvd[eZ]hfmbhl\jZsZlvhl^mjgh]h
B [m^_l lZdbf ex^yf [eZ`_gkl\hª H^gbf ba kZfuo
[hevrboahey\ey_lkyijbibku\Zgb_l_e_kghklb:eeZombmih
^h[e_gb_?]hkha^ZgbyfZ\_ebqZcrbf[eZ]h^_ygb_fy\ey_lky
\_jZ \ _^bgh[h`b_ b hqbs_gb_ :eeZoZ hl \k_o g_^hklZldh\
KZeZnu`_fheqZebihlhfmqlh\bo\j_f_gZwlZ[b^]Z_s_g_
ihy\beZkv gh ba\_klgh qlh hgb \uklmibeb ijhlb\ l_o dhlh
ju_[uebbfba\_klguBf_gghihwlhfmfmkmevfZgZfm^Zehkv
h^_j`Zlv \_jo gZ^ dZ^ZjblZfb ^`ZofblZfb ^`Z[jblZfb b
^jm]bfb k_dlZglZfb Wlh [ue bo ^`boZ^ b wlhl ^`boZ^ [ue
^\mo\b^h\keh\hfbf_qhfQ_f`_hlebqZxlkyoZrZ\bluhl
^jm]bofm[lZ^b]h\"Lhevdhl_fqlhkdju\Zxlk\hbm[_`^_gby
278
©Hgb fh]ml kdjulv k\hb >]j_oh\gu_ ^_eZ@ hl ex^_c gh g_
kdjhxlbohl:eeZoZlZddZdHggZoh^blkykj_^bgbodh]^Z
hgb \lZcg_ aZfureyxl g_m]h^gh_ ?fm Gh :eeZom ba\_klgh
lh qlh hgb \_jrZlª <k_f k_dlZf mq_gu_ hl\_qZeb
hldjulhdjhf_oZrZ\blh\dhlhjufmq_gu_hl\_qZeblZ\ob^hf
b hqbs_gb_f :eeZoZ hl \k_o g_^hklZldh\ Ihwlhfm oZrZ\blu
^he]h_ \j_fy hklZ\Zebkv mgb`_ggufb ©B klhbl bf lhevdh
aZ`_qvh]hgv\hcgu:eeZo>g_f_^ey@]Zkbl_]hHgbmk_j^kl
\mxl gZ a_fe_ >l\hjy@ g_q_klb_ gh :eeZo g_ ex[bl g_q_k
lb\p_\ªG_kfhljygZwlhhgb^hkboihjbkihevamxl\k_
\hafh`ghklb\k_kfmluqlh[uijhy\blvk\h_mq_gb_ª
Lh `_ kZfh_ gZibkZe B[g >`Z[oZe \ k\h_f hl\_l_ B[g
L_cfbb kf ©Zl-LZ[ZdZl Ze-dm[jZª ijbgZ^e_`Zsmx i_jm ZlLZ^`ZZk-Km[db
KZf `_ Zk-Km[db ih ih\h^m oZrZ\blh\ \ k\h_c dgb]_
©LZ[ZdZlZr-rZnb]byZe-dm[jZªlkibr_l©LZdh\Zbo
Zdu^ZhgbkqblZxlk_[yfmkmevfZgZfb[he__lh]hkmggblZfb
Gh _keb \u ihagZdhfbl_kv k gbfb ih[eb`_ lh m\b^bl_ qlh
kj_^b gbo g_l gb h^gh]h mq_gh]h Wlb ex^b h[\bgyxl \ g_\_
jbb fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo b hlghkyl k_[y d ihke_^h\Zl_eyf
bfZfZ:ofZ^ZdhlhjucgZkZfhf^_e_hlj_dkyhlgboª
Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky bklhdh\ kh\j_f_ggh]h \ZooZ[blkdh]h
^\b`_gby lh ba\_klgh qlh FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ hl
ijZ\bek\hbomq_guodmq_gufF_ddbbF_^bgu©L_ijb[u\
\ wlb k\ys_ggu_ ]hjh^Z baeh`beb mq_guf k\hb m[_`^_gby
Mq_gu_ F_ddb b F_^bgu ^Zeb bf bkq_jiu\Zxsbc hl\_l b
ijb\_eb lZdb_ ^h\h^u dhlhju_ l_ [ueb g_ \ khklhygbb hkih
jblv Lh]^Z mq_gu_ k\ys_gguo ]hjh^h\ ihgyeb gZkdhevdh g_
\_`_kl\_ggu\ZooZ[blu:gZebabjmyboZdu^mhgbh[gZjm`b
eb\g_cfgh`_kl\hfhf_glh\mdZau\Z\rbogZg_\_jb_\ZooZ
[blh\ J_amevlZlhf wlhc n_l\u y\beky h[sbc \u\h^ mq_guo h
lhf qlh \ZooZ[blu y\eyxlky g_\_jgufb qlh ih^l\_j`^_gh
dZab_fª630Bf_gghihwlhfmZrjZnblugZqZeb\u\_rb\Zlv]h
630
:ofZ^[bgAZcgb>Zoeyg©NblgZZe-\ZooZ[byª–K
279
eh\u m[bluo \ZooZ[blh\ jy^hf k F_ddhc wlh [ueb ex^b ih
dbgm\rb_ehghfmkmevfZgkdhcmffu631.
R_coKZeZfZZe-DZ^Z]bZr-RZnb]bkdZaZe©«wlbex
^b \hkihevah\Zebkv ^h\_jqb\hklvx g_\_`^ b \u^Zeb k_[y aZ
ihke_^h\Zl_e_c kZeZnh\ ba qbkeZ kih^\b`gbdh\ b lZ[b]bgh\
GZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ hgb [ueb ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb r_coh\ fmrZ[
[boblh\bfm^`Zkkbfblh\lhedh\Z\rboDhjZgbkmggmdZdbf
\a^mfZ_lky Wlb ex^b bkdZ`Zeb kfuke DhjZgZ ij_^ihqblZeb
\u^mfZggu_bkeZ[u_oZ^bku_kebl_khhl\_lkl\h\Zebbob^_
yfbhl\_j]Zeb^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bku_kebl_ijhlb\hj_qbebbo
b^_heh]bb«632»
FmkmevfZgkdbcnbehkhnFmoZffZ^:[^hhgboibr_l
©WlZk_dlZh[eZ^Z_l^Z`_[he__madbfdjm]hahjhfq_fijhklu_
fmdZeeb^u Wlb ex^b kqblZxl qlh h[yaZgu ke_^h\Zlv [md
\Zevghfm kfukem l_dklh\ g_\abjZy gZ lh qlh ^bdlmxl hkgh\u
j_eb]bbªIjhn_kkhjFmoZffZ^JZrb^Jb^Zdhff_glbjmywlb
kljhdb gZibkZe ©Wlh k_dlZ Zoe oZ^bk beb l_ dh]h gZau\Zxl
\ZooZ[blZfbª633.
LZdh\u \ukdZau\Zgby mq_guo-kmggblh\ h[ wlhc k_dl_
IjbkemrZxlkyebdgbfoZrZ\blu"<_jgmlkyeb\ehghbklbg
ghcj_eb]bb"
G_dhlhju_mq_gu_hijh\_j]Z\rb_ijhba\_^_gby
B[gL_cfbb
Gb`_ fu ijb\h^bf kibkhd oZgZnblkdbo fZebdblkdbo
rZnb]blkdbo b oZg[Zeblkdbo mq_guo \uklmib\rbo k hijh
\_j`_gb_fb^_cB[gL_cfbbZlZd`_gZa\Zgbydgb]g_dhlhjuo
bagbo
DZabc fmnZkkbj ;Z^jm^^bg FmoZffZ^ [bg B[jZobf
[bg>`ZfZ]ZZr-RZnb]b
FmoZffZ^Ze-DZkbjb©:k-KZeZnby[ZcgZZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-bfZfbyª–
K
632
KZeZfZZe-DZ^Z]b©NmjdZgZe-DmjZg[ZcgZkunZlZe-oZebd\ZkunZlZedZmgª–K
633
FmoZffZ^:[^h©:e-BkeZf\ZZg-gZkjZgbyª–K
631
280
DZabc FmoZffZ^ [bg Ze-OZjbjb Ze-:gkZjb ZeOZgZnb
DZabcFmoZffZ^[bg:[m;ZdjZe-FZebdb
DZabc:ofZ^[bg=mfZjZe-FZd^ZkbZe-OZg[Zeb
;eZ]h^Zjy n_l\_ wlbo mq_guo \ ] ] B[g L_c
fby[ueihkZ`_g\lxjvfmkf©=mxgZl-lZ\ZjboªB[gRZdb
jZ Ze-Dmlm[b b ©GZ^`f Ze-fmolZ^bª B[g Fm]lZffZ ZeDmjZrb
OZnba fm^`lZob^ LZdbx^^bg Zk-Km[db mf \ ]
]D_]hijhba\_^_gbyfbhlghkylky©:e-B]lb[Zj[b[Z
dZZe-^`ZggZ\ZZg-gZjª©:^->mjjZZe-fm^uZnbZj-jZ^^]Zey
B[gL_cfbyª©RbnZZk-kmdZfnbabyjZloZcjZe-ZgZfª©:gGZaZj Ze-fmoZddZd nb Ze-oZeZn [b Zl-lZeZd Ze-fm]ZeeZdª
©GZd^Ze-b^`fZ]\ZbnlbjZdnbfZkZbeZe-bfZg\ZZl-lZeZdª
NZdbo FmoZffZ^ [bg =mfZj [bg FZddb ba\_klguc
dZdB[gZe-FZjoZemf]]ebqgh\klmiZe\^bkdmk
kbbkB[gL_cfb_c
OZnba KZeZom^^bg Ze-=Zeyb mf ] ] \u
klmiZekdjblbdhcB[gL_cfbb
R_co :ofZ^ [bg Yovy Ze-Dbey[b Ze-OZeZ[b ba\_kl
guc dZd B[g >`Zo[Ze mf ] ] kh\j_f_ggbd B[g
L_cfbb ?]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`bl dgb]Z ©JbkZeZ nb gZnb Ze^`boZª
DZabc DZfZex^^bg [bg Za-AZfeydZgb mf ]
]\klmiZe\^bkdmkkbbkB[gL_cfb_cbgZibkZe^\Zhi
jh\_j`_gbyh^ghgZl_fmjZa\h^ZZ\lhjh_ihih\h^mihk_s_
gbyIjhjhdZk]k
DZabcKZnbx^^bgZe-Obg^bmf]]^bk
dmlbjh\ZekB[gL_cfb_c
NZdbooZ^bkh\_^=Zeb[bgFmoZffZ^Ze-;Z^`bZrRZnb]b mf ] ] >bkdmlbjh\Ze k gbf ih q_lujgZ^
pZlb\hijhkZf
Bklhjbd Ze-NZoj [bg FZ]eZf Ze-DmjZrb mf ]
] _]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`bl dgb]Z ©GZ^`f Ze-fmolZ^b \Z
jZ^`fZe-fm]lZ^bª
IbkZjvkmelZgZB[gDZeZmgZmf\]]
281
OZnba Za-AZoZ[b mf ] ] kh\j_f_ggbd
B[g L_cfbb _]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`Zl dgb]b ©;Zyg aZ]e Ze-]bef
\ZZl-lZeZ[ª©:g-GZkuoZZa-aZoZ[byª
FmnZkkbj :[m OZyg Ze-:g^Zemkb mf \ ]
] _]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_`bl dgb]Z ©LZnkbj Zg-gZoj Ze-fZ^
fbgZe-[ZojZe-fmoblª
NZdbo b iml_r_kl\_ggbd B[g ;ZllmlZ mf \ ]
]_]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`bldgb]Z©JboeylB[g;ZllmlZª
NZdboLZ^`m^^bgZk-Km[dbmf]]Z\lhj
dgb]b©LZ[ZdZlZr-rZnb]byZe-dm[jZª
Mq_gbd ij_^u^ms_]h bklhjbd B[g RZdbj ZeDmlm[bmf]]Z\lhjdgb]b©=mxgZl-lZ\Zjboª
R_co =mfZj [bg :[m Ze-YfZg Ze-EZofb Ze-NZdbob
Ze-FZebdb mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:l-LmonZ ZefmolZjZnbZj-jZ^^]ZeyZe-fmgdbjZa-abyjZª
DZabcFmoZffZ^Zk-KZ]^bZe-FbkjbZe-:ogZgbmf
]] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:e-FZdZeZ Ze-fZj^uy nb Zj-jZ^^
]Zey fZg xgdbjm Za-abyjZ Ze-fmoZffZ^byª ba^ZgZ \f_kl_ k
©:e-;ZjZobgZk-kZlu]ZªijbgZ^e_`Zs_ci_jmZe-=ZaZfb
R_co=bkZZa-AZ\Z\bmf]]Z\lhjdgb]b
©JbkZeZlnbfZktZeZlZl-lZeZdª
R_co :ofZ^ [bg=mkfZgZe->`ma^`ZgbZe-OZgZnb
mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:e-:[oZk Ze-^`Zeby nb ZjjZ^^]ZeyB[gL_cfbyª
OZnba B[g OZ^`Zj Ze-=ZkdZeygb mf \ ]
] Z\lhj dgb] ©Z^->mjZj Ze-dZfbgZ nb Z]vyg Ze-fbZ ZkkZfbgZª©EbkZgZe-fbaZgª
OZnba<Zebm^^bgZe-=bjZdbmf\]]Z\
lhj dgb]b ©:e-:^`\b[Z Ze-fmj^uy nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey Ze-ZkbeZ
Ze-fZddbyª
NZdbobklhjbdB[gDZ^uRmo[ZlZr-RZnb]bmf\
]]Z\lhjdgb]b©LZjboB[gDZ^uRmo[Zª
NZdbo :[m ;Zdj Ze-Omkgb mf ] ] Z\lhj
dgb]b©>Zn]rm[ZofZgrZ[[ZoZ\ZlZfZjjZ^Z\ZgZkZ[ZaZebdZ
beybfZf:ofZ^ª
282
:njbdZgkdbc r_co :[m =Z[^meeZ [bg =ZjZnZ ZeFZebdb mf ] ] gZibkZe hijh\_j`_gb_ b^_c B[g
L_cfbb
=Zeym^^bg Ze-;moZjb Ze-OZgZnb mf ] ]
hg h[ty\be g_\_jguf B[g L_cfbx b \k_o dlh gZau\Z_l _]h
©r_comebkeZfhfª kf m oZnbaZ Zk-KZoZ\b \ ©:^->Zm Zeeyfb]ª
29. R_co:ofZ^Za-AZjjmdZe-NZkbZe-FZebdbmf]
]
OZnba Zk-KZoZ\b mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b
©:e-B]eyg[bZl-lZm[boebfZgaZfZZl-lZjboª
DZabc Ze-;Zy^u Ze-OZgZnb h^bggZ^pZluc \_d Z\
lhjdgb]b©BrZjZlZe-fZjZffbg]befZe-bfZfª
3 R_co :ofZ^ [bg FmoZffZ^ Ze-<Zlbjb mf \ ]
] Z\lhj dgb]b ©JZ\^Zl Zg-gZaujbg \Z omeykZl fZgZdb[
Zk-kZebobgª
R_co B[g OZ^`Zj Ze-OZckZfb mf ] ]
Z\lhj dgb] ©:e-NZlZ\Z Ze-oZ^bkbyª634 ©:e->`Z\oZj Ze A^_kv fu ohl_eb [u ijb\_klb g_dhlhju_ ba keh\ B[g OZ^`ZjZ ZeOZckZfbh[B[gL_cfbb
< ©:e-NZlZ\Z Ze-oZ^bkbyª k hg mdZau\Z_l ©Mq_gu_ bamqb\rb_ b
djblbdh\Z\rb_ b^_b B[g L_cfbb aZy\eyeb h lhf qlh hg [ue aZ[em^rbf
q_eh\_dhf?keb\uohlbl_\wlhfm[_^blvkylhfu\Zfkh\_lm_fh[jZlblv
kydbfZfmFm^`lZob^m:[mZe-OZkZgmZk-Km[db_]hkugmZl-LZ^`mbfZfm
r_com Ze-=baam [bg >`ZfZ]Z Z lZd`_ d ^jm]bf _]h kh\j_f_ggbdZf b bfZ
fZf–oZgZnblZffZebdblZfrZnb]blZfboZg[ZeblZfKm^yihbokeh\Zf
b^_b wlh]h q_eh\_dZ \hh[s_ g_ bf_xl gbdZdhc p_gghklb hg aZ[em^rbc
fm[lZ^b]g_\_`^Z^ZkhojZgblgZk:eeZohl_]hhrb[hdbb^_cªGZk
hgi_j_qbkey_l\k_m[_`^_gby\dhlhjuoB[gL_cfbyjZkoh^bekykkmggb
lZfb©«qlhfbjba\_q_gbkms_kl\m_l\_qgh\f_kl_k:eeZohfhgaZy\ey
_lqlh:eeZoh[yaZgk\h_ckmsghklvxbg_bf__lk\h[h^u^_ckl\byijbib
ku\Z_l :eeZom l_e_kghklv gZijZ\e_gb_ b ^\b`_gb_ :eeZo `_ ij_\ur_
\k_]hwlh]hHg]h\hjblqlh:eeZojZaf_jhfkLjhggb[hevr_gbf_gvr_
:eeZoij_\ur_wlhcde_\_lubg_\_jbyª>Ze__gZkhgibr_l©Hkl_
j_]Zcl_kvijbkemrb\ZlvkydlhfmqlhgZibkZgh\dgb]ZoB[gL_cfbb_]h
mq_gbdZB[gZe-DZcbfZZe->`Z\abb^jm]boex^_cihke_^h\Z\rboaZk\h
bf \hh[jZ`_gb_f :eeZo hke_ibe bo k_j^pZ \ahju b \\_e \ aZ[em`^_gb_
wlbo ex^_c gbdlh djhf_ :eeZoZ g_ gZklZ\bl gZ imlv bklbgguc Wlb [_a
634
283
fmgZaaZf nb abyjZl Ze-dZ[j Ze-fm]ZaaZfª ©OZrby Ze-b^Zo nb
Ze-fZgZkbdª
[h`gbdb mgbqlh`bl_eb rZjbZlZ \hahfgbeb h k_[_ qlh ke_^mxl imlb bk
lbgghfmh^gZdhwlhg_lZdǻ
< dhff_glZjbyo d ©FZgZkbd Zg-GZ\Z\bª k ba^-\h ©Zk-KZeZnbyª hg
ibr_l ©B^_y B[g L_cfbb h aZij_lghklb ihk_s_gby fh]beu IjhjhdZ
k]kg_bf__lgbdZdhcp_gghklbZe-=baa[bg>`ZfZ]ZbZl-LZdbZk-Km[db
mdZau\Zxl qlh wlhl q_eh\_d aZ[em^beky Hg g_ lhevdh g_ ihagZe kl_i_gv
IjhjhdZ k]k gh b ijbgbabe kl_i_gv :eeZoZ Hg ijbibkZe :eeZom gZ
ijZ\e_gb_ jmdm gh]m ]eZab^jm]b_hj]ZguFgh]b_mq_gu_h[ty\beb_]h
g_\_jguf^Z\ha^Zkl_fm:eeZokh]eZkgh_]h^_ygbyfbmgbabl_]hihke_
^h\Zl_e_cª < ©:e->`Z\oZj Ze-fmgZaaZf nb abyjZl Ze-dZ[j Zg-gZ[Z\b ZefmdZjjZfª ih ih\h^m B[g L_cfbb hg ibr_l ke_^mxs__ ©Hg ke_^h\Ze aZ
ieh^Zfbk\h_]h[hevgh]hjZkkm^dZb\j_amevlZl_wlh]h\iZe\lZdb_[b^]Z
dhlhju_ gbdlh ^h g_]h g_ kh\_jrZe < \hijhk_ lZ\ob^Z hg ijb^_j`b\Zeky
oZrZ\blkdbobdZjjZfblkdbob^_chlhfqlhm:eeZoZ_klvqZklbgZijZ\
e_gb_f_klhqlhHgih^gbfZ_lkykimkdZ_lkyqlhHgih^\_j`_g\ebygbx
kh[ulbcK^jm]hcklhjhguhgihr_eiml_foZjb^`blh\bh[ty\beg_\_j
gufb \_ebqZcrbo fmkmevfZgkdbo bfZfh\ b mq_guoǻ < wlhc `_ dgb]_
^Ze__kdZaZgh©<ufh`_l_kdZaZlv©DZdkZeZnufh]ebaZy\eylvh^himklb
fhklbihk_s_gbyfh]beuIjhjhdZk]k\lh\j_fydZdB[gL_cfbyhljb
pZ_l^himklbfhklvwlh]h";he__lh]hhgaZij_sZ_l^Z`_kh\_jr_gb_iml_
r_kl\byjZ^bwlh]hbkhdjZs_gb_fhebl\u\h\j_fywlh]himl_r_kl\byHg
ml\_j`^Z_l qlh \k_ oZ^bku ih\_kl\mxsb_ h ihk_s_gbb fh]beu IjhjhdZ
k]ky\eyxlkykeZ[ufbb\u^mfZggufbG_dhlhju_ba_]hoZg[Zeblkdbo
ihke_^h\Zl_e_cijb^_j`b\ZxlkylhqghlZdh]h`_fg_gbyªYhl\_qm©Dlh
lZdhcB[gL_cfbyqlh[ufuijbkemrb\Zebkvdlhcqmrbdhlhjmxhgg_k"
Mq_gu_bamqb\rb__]hb^_bbgZke_^b_kdZaZebqlhhg[uebkihjq_gguf
aZ[em^rbfq_eh\_dhfGZijbf_j:e-=baa[bg>`ZfZ]ZgZibkZehg_f³Hg
[ueijhklufaZ[em^rbfjZ[hf:eeZoZ:eeZomgbabe_]haZeh`gu_n_l\u
ba^Zggu_ bf´ª < ^jm]hc dgb]_ ©RZjo Zr-rZfZbeª B[g OZ^`Zj ZeOZckZfbibr_l©B[gZe-DZcbfjZkkdZau\Zyhk\h_fmqbl_e_B[gL_cfbb
ibr_l h lhf qlh ydh[u :eeZo iheh`be K\hx jmdm f_`^m _]h ie_q :e=bjZdbihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l©Fug_gZrebwlhfmgbdZdh]hih^\_j`^_
gby \ kmgg_ IjhjhdZ k]kª Wlh [ueb eh`gu_ \b^_gby hkgh\Zggu_ gZ
eh`guom[_`^_gbyo<k_kmggblkdb_mq_gu_\uklmibebkdjblbdhcb^_ch
l_e_kghklb:eeZoZh?]hk\yabkgZijZ\e_gb_fbijhqboba\jZs_gguob^_c
wlh]hq_eh\_dZb_]hihke_^h\Zl_e_c>Zhq_jgbl:eeZobobboihke_^h\Z
l_e_cQlh`_dZkZ_lkybfZfZ:ofZ^Zb_]hfZaoZ[Zlhhgbg_ijbqZklgudh
\k_fmwlhfm\_^vg_dhlhju_mq_gu_gZa\Zebih^h[gu_b^_bg_\_jb_fª
284
R_coFmoZffZ^[bg=Zeb[bg=bjZdbZ^->bfZrdb
mf\]]
R_co >`ZeZem^^bg Z^->Z\Zgb mf ] ]
_]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`bldgb]Z©RZjoZe-]m^Z^byª
DZabc:[m=Z[^meeZZe-FmdjbZ\lhjdgb]b©Gmamf
Ze-ZebnbkmemdZe-ZfZebª
=Zeb Ze-DZjb Ze-OZgZnb mf ] ] Z\lhj
dgb]b©RZjoZr-rbnZebZe-dZ^uZe-=by^ª
OZ^bkh\_^ FmoZffZ^ [bg =Zeb [bg =Zeyg ZkKu^^udb Ze-FZddb mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:eFm[jb^Ze-fm[dbnbjZ^^Zk-kZjbfZe-fZgdbª
R_co =Z[^jZmn Ze-FZgZ\b Zr-RZnb]b mf ]
]Z\lhjdgb]b©RZjorZfZbeebl-Lbjfbabª
R_co :ofZ^ Ze-OZnZ^`b Ze-Fbkjb Ze-OZgZnb mf
]]Z\lhjdgb]b©RZjoZr-rbnZebZe-dZ^u=by^ª
Bklhjbd:ofZ^:[mZe-=Z[[ZkZe-Fmdjbmf]
]Z\lhj©:aoZjZj-jby^ª
R_co FmoZffZ^ Za-AZjdZgb Ze-FZebdb mf ]
]Z\lhjdgb]b©RZjoZe-fZ\Zob[Ze-eZ^Zgbyª
R_co =Z[^me]Zgb Zg-GZ[emkb mf ] ]
djblbdh\ZeB[gL_cfbx\hfgh]bok\hbodgb]Zo
NZdbokmnbcFmoZffZ^FZo^b[bg=ZebZk-Kuy^b
ba\_klgucdZdZj-JZ\\Zkmf]]lZd`_\uklmiZek
djblbdhcb^_cB[gL_cfbb
K_b^ FmoZffZ^ :[m Ze-OZ^b Zk-Kuy^b mf ]
]Z\lhjdgb]b©DZey^ZlZe-^`Z\oZjª
Fmnlbc FmklZnZ [bg :foZ^ Zr-RZlb Ze-OZg[Zeb
Z^->bfZrdb mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:g-Gmdme ZrrZj]bynbZj-jZ^^]ZeyZe-\ZooZ[byª
FZofm^ OblZ[ Zk-Km[db mf ] ] Z\lhj
dgb]b©:^->bgZe-oZebkZmbjrZ^Ze-oZedbey^bgZe-oZddª
Fmnlbc emq_aZjghc F_^bgu r_co oZ^bkh\_^ Fm
oZffZ^ Zr-RZgdblb mf ] ] Z\lhj dgb]b ©Examf
Zl-lZeZd Zk-kZeyk ^mn]ZlZg [bfZ ey yklZlu]m Ze-]Zebf ^Zn]Z
omª
285
R_co KZeZfZ Ze-=ZaZfb Zr-RZnb]b mf ]
] Z\lhj dgb]b ©:e-;ZjZobg Zk-kZlu]Z nb jZ^^ [Z]^ Ze[b^Z]Zr-rZgb]ZªbklZl_c\_]bi_lkdhc]Za_l_©:e-Fmkebfª
Fmnlbc ?]bilZ r_co FmoZffZ^ ;Zobl Ze-Fmlu]b
mf]]Z\lhjdgb]b©LZlobjZe-nmZ^fbg^ZgZkZeb]lbdZ^ª
>h\_j_ggh_ ebph fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo \ hkfZg
kdhf oZebnZl_ r_co FmoZffZ^ AZob^ Ze-DZmkZjb mf ]
]Z\lhjdgb]©FZdZeZlZe-DZmkZjbªb^j
B[jZobf[bg=mkfZgZk-KZfgm^bZe-FbkjbgZrkh
\j_f_ggbdZl\hjdgb]b©GmkjZlZe-bfZfZk-Km[db[bjZ^^ZkkZjbfZe-fZgdbª
F_ddZgkdbc mq_guc FmoZffZ^ Ze-=ZjZ[b ZlLZ[[Zgbmf]]Z\lhjdgb]b©;ZjZZlZe-Zr]Zjbbg
fbg]ZdZb^Ze-fmoZebnbgª
R_coFmoZffZ^XkmnZe-;ZgmjbZe-;ZdbklZgbZ\
lhjdgb]b©FZ]ZjbnZk-kmggZgrZjokmgZgZl-Lbjfbabª
R_co FZgkmj FmoZffZ^ =mxk h^bg ba kh\j_f_g
guo mq_guo ©:e-:aoZjZª Z\lhj dgb]b ©B[g L_cfby eyckZ kZ
eZnbygª
FZjhddZgkdbcoZ^bkh\_^r_co=Z[^meeZZe-=ZfZjb
Z\lhj dgb] ©BldZg Zk-kmg]Z nb lZodbd fZ]gZ Ze-[b^]Zª ©:kKm[oZk-kZnbjnblZodbdZk-kZeylZe-fmkZnbjª©:j-JZkZbeZe]ZfZjbyªb^j
:e-FmkgZ^ :[m Ze-:r[Ze KZebf [bg >`Zg^Zg Ze:g^Zemkb \ ] ] _s_ [ue `b\ _]h i_jm ijbgZ^e_
`bldgb]Z©:e-OmeZkZlZe-dZnbynbZe-ZkZgb^Ze-]Zebyª
OZf^meeZZe-;ZjZ^`m\bZ\lhjdgb]b©:e-;ZkZbjª
R_co FmklZnZ :[m KZcn Ze-OZfZfb h[ty\b\rbc
B[gL_cfbxg_\_jguf\k\h_cdgb]_©=ZmkkZe-]b[Z^[b[Zyg
Zj-jZrZ^ª ?]h ihabpbx ih^^_j`Zeb r_co FmoZffZ^ KZ]b^
Ze-=mjnbr_coXkmnZ^->Z^`Z\br_coFZofm^:[m>ZdbdZ
r_coFmoZffZ^Ze-;Zobjbr_coFmoZffZ^=Z[^menZllZoZe=ZgZlbr_coOZ[b[meeZZe->`ZdgbZr-RZgdblur_co>Zkm
db=Z[^meeZZe-=ZjZ[br_coFmoZffZ^OZnbgb;beye
286
OZnba :ofZ^ [bg Zk-KZ^ud Ze-=ZfZjb Z\lhj dgb]
©Ob^Zyl Zk-kZ]jZª b ©:e-DZme Ze-^`Zebª \ gbo hg djblbdm_l
B[gL_cfbxbgZau\Z_l_]he`_phf
FmoZffZ^ [bg =bkZ [bg ;Zg^ZjZg Zk-KZ]^b ZeFbkjb
=ZeZ\b[bgLZobjZe-OZ^^Z^Ze-OZ^jZfb
NZ^ueyl r_co =bkZ Ze-FZgb] mq_guc ba H:W \u
klmiZ_lkdjblbdhcB[gL_cfbb\h\j_fye_dpbcbmjhdh\
R_co =Z[^meeZ [bg FmoZffZ^ Ze-OZjZjb ZeOZ[ZrbZ\lhjdgb]b©:e-FZdZeZlZk-kmggbynbdZrn^Zeyeyl
:ofZ^ [bg L_cfbyª pblZlu ba dhlhjhc fu qZklh ijb\h^bf \
k\h_cdgb]_djhf_g___]hi_jmijbgZ^e_`bldgb]Z©BaoZjZe]Zdb^ZZk-kmggby[brZjoZe-]Zdb^ZZl-lZoZ\byª
<a]eygbl_m\Z`_fucqblZl_evm\Z`Z_fucbkdZl_evbk
lbgukdhevdhmq_guo\uklmibehkdjblbdhcB[gL_cfbbG_
m`_eb \u ^h kbo ihj ^mfZ_l_ qlh hg fh`_l gZau\Zlvky bfZ
fhf"G_m`_eb\u^mfZ_l_qlh_]hkeh\Zfh`ghklZ\blv\ur_
keh\:eeZoZb?]hihkeZggbdZk]k"
:e-;moZjbZe-Obg^bij_^hkl_j_]Z_l
hlik_\^hkZeZnbafZ
R_co =Z[^meeZ Ze-;moZjb ij_^k_^Zl_ev ©Bg^bckdh]h
h[s_kl\Zmq_guoZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-^`ZfZ]Zª\h\j_fyk\h_]h
bgl_j\vx ^ey eb\Zgkdhc ]Za_lu ©FZgZj Ze-om^Zª635 ij_^hkl_
j_] fmkmevfZg hl \ZooZ[blkdhc b ik_^hkZeZnblkdhc kfmlu
>Ze__ fu ijb\h^bf hlju\hd ba wlh]h bgl_j\vx ©< fmkmev
fZgkdbo kljZgZo ihy\beZkv ijhlb\h_kl_kl\_ggZy k_dlZ ihke_
^h\Zl_eb dhlhjhc gZau\Zxl k_[y kZeZnblZfb gZ kZfhf ^_e_
hgb^Ze_dbhlkZeZnbafZ\ijhlb\ghfkemqZ_hgbg_ijhlb\h
klZ\eyeb [u k_[y fmkmevfZgZf Wlb ex^b aZy\eyxl qlh ijb
rebqlh[uba[Z\blvBkeZfbfmkmevfZghlyauq_kl\Zihdeh
g_gbyfh]beZfbijb\_klbdkem`_gbx:eeZomgh^_eh\lhf
qlhfmkmevfZg_g_ihdehgyxlkyfh]beZfIhdZdhfm`_ijZ\m
wlbex^bgZau\ZxlfmkmevfZgfh]behihdehggbdZfb"Fuh[y
635
:\]mkl]‹
287
aZgu\uklmiblvijhlb\wlhckfmlubij_^hl\jZlblv__jZkijh
kljZg_gb_ªHijbqbg_ijhgbdgh\_gbywlhckfmlu\Bg^bxhg
kdZaZe ke_^mxs__ ©Hgb [ueb \g_^j_gu \ Bg^bx Zg]ebqZgZ
fb `_eZ\rbfb jZah[sblv bg^bckdbo fmkmevfZg GZrb mq_
gu_ m`_ ^Z\gh ihgyeb hiZkghklv wlhc k_dlu b gZibkZeb fgh
`_kl\h dgb] k djblbdhc b hijh\_j`_gb_f \ bo Z^j_k ]^_ jZk
djueb\k_aZ[em`^_gbybba\jZs_gby\ZooZ[bafZª
Ihkfhljbl_ gZkdhevdh ijhgbpZl_e_g wlhl q_eh\_d Ba
\_klghqlhmbklhdh\\ZooZ[bafZklhyebZg]ebqZg_`_eZ\rb_
ih]ZkblvieZfy^`boZ^Z\fmkmevfZgkdhfh[s_kl\_Hgb\dm
kbeb]hj_qvkhijhlb\e_gbyfmkmevfZgBg^bb`_eZ\rbohk\h
[h^blvk\hba_febhlojbklbZg
>Ze__ hg kdZaZe ©Fu ij_^hkl_j_]Z_f fmkmevfZg hl
gbo636 g_ ^ey lh]h qlh[u k_ylv jhagv gZh[hjhl qlh[u khojZ
gblvfmkmevfZgkdh__^bgkl\hQlh\u[m^_l_^_eZlv_kebm\b
^bl_ qlh \ ^hf \Zr_]h khk_^Z `_eZ_l aZe_alv \hj" Ijhfheqb
l_"Beb`_ij_^hkl_j_`_l_khk_^Z"ª
DZd \b^bl_ ^hjh]hc qblZl_ev fmkmevfZgkdb_ mq_gu_
\k_]h fbjZ ij_^hkl_j_]Zxl fmkmevfZg hl wlhc kZeZnblkdh\ZooZ[blkdhc kfmlu p_ev dhlhjhc hl\e_qv fmkmevfZg hl ]eh
[Zevguo ijh[e_f b aZgylv bo f_`^hmkh[bp_c h[\bg_gbyfb \
g_\_jbbbyauq_kl\_<_^vbf_gghkwlh]hgZqZeFmoZffZ^[gm
=Z[^me\ZooZ[h[\bgb\rbcijhjhdZ:^ZfZ]k\yauq_kl\_
R_co=Z[^meeZZe-;moZjbaZgbfZ_lihkl]eZ\u©Bg^bc
kdh]h h[s_kl\Z mq_guo Zoe Zk-kmggZ \Z Ze-^`ZfZ]Zª b ^_dZgZ
nZdmevl_lZ©KZb^FZ^ZgbªjZkiheh`_ggh]h\bg^bckdhcijh
\bgpbbFZg]Zehj
;_g]Zevpuijhlb\hklhyloZrZ\blZf
R_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^mkZeyf Ze-DZaufb ZeOmk_cgb – h^bg ba [_g]Zevkdbo mq_guo dhlhju_ \ k\h_\j_fy
ih g_agZgbx ihke_^h\Zeb ijbau\Zf \ZooZ[bafZ Gh \kdhj_
dh]^Z bklbgZ i_j_^ gbf jZkdjueZkv hg ihdZyeky b \klmibe \
636
Ik_\^hkZeZnblh\
288
[hjv[mkwlhck_dlhc_]hkbevg_crbfhjm^b_f\wlhf^_e_[u
ehagZgb_bykgu_^h\h^u
Dhjj_kihg^_gl ]Za_lu ©FZgZj Ze-om^Zª637 \klj_lbeky k
gbf \ h^ghf ba mgb\_jkbl_lh\ klhebpu ;Zg]eZ^_r – >ZddZ
<h\j_fywlhc\klj_qbr_cojZkkdZaZeqlh[ueqe_ghf\ZooZ
[blkdhck_dlu\l_q_gb_lj_oe_lGhaZl_f:eeZoih`_eZegZ
klZ\blv_]hgZimlvbklbguF_`^mgbfb[_g]Zevkdbfmq_guf
r_cohf =ZabameoZddhf Ze-DZ^bjb ba\_klguf dZd :kZ^ Ze;Zg]ZebijhbahreZ^bkdmkkby\h\j_fydhlhjhcr_coijb\_e
hq_gv kbevgu_ ^h\h^u qlh baf_gbeh \a]ey^u i_j\h]h Ihke_
wlh]h r_co FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^mkZeyf Ze-DZaufb Ze-Omk_cgb
ij_\jZlbeky \ g_ijbfbjbfh]h [hjpZ k \ZooZ[bafhf <h \j_fy
mihfygmlh]hbgl_j\vxr_coaZy\be©AZihke_^gb_]h^umf_
gy [ueh hq_gv fgh]h \klj_q b ^bkdmkkbc k \ZooZ[blZfb Hkh
[_ggh fg_ aZihfgbeZkv ^bkdmkkby k RZnbdhf FmoZffZ^hf
^bj_dlhjhf \ZooZ[blkdh]h mgb\_jkbl_lZ \h \j_fy dhlhjhc y
ijb\_e_fmgZklhevdh\_kdb_^h\h^uqlhhgg_gZr_eqlhfg_
hl\_lblv D [hevrhfm kh`Ze_gbx \ZooZ[blu aZy\eyxl qlh
ke_^mxlDhjZgmbkmgg_gZkZfhf`_^_e_hgbihke_^h\Zl_eb
kZlZgukZeZnblug_ijbqZklgud\ZooZ[bafmª
GZklZ\eyy k\hbo kemrZl_e_c r_co Ze-DZaufb ]h\hjbl
©<ZooZ[blkdZy Zdu^Z ijhlb\hj_qbl l_f ijbgpbiZf dhlhjufb
jmdh\h^kl\h\Zebkv Ijhjhd k]k _]h kih^\b`gbdb ijZ\_^
gu_kZeZnubmq_gu_-oZeZnu^Z[m^_l^h\he_gbfb\k_fb:e
eZo Ihwlhfm y ohqm ij_^hkl_j_qv fmkmevfZghl\ZooZ[blkdbo
gh\r_kl\ b ijbau\Zx \k_o k\hbo dhee_] mqbl_e_c b mq_guo
mk_j^ghbk_jv_aghjZkijhkljZgylvbklbggmxZdu^mHkh[_ggh
ZdlmZevghwlh\gZrb^gbdh]^Zbkihjq_gghklvbjZa\jZljZk
ijhkljZgyxlkyklZdhc[ukljhlhcIhwlhfmfmkmevfZg_^he`
gu[ulv]hlh\uijhlb\hklhylv\gmlj_gg_cb\g_rg_ckfml_ª
Fu ijhkbf m :eeZoZ qlh[u hg aZsblbe r_coZ ZeDZaufbhl\ZooZ[blh\DZdba\_klghwlbex^bba[jZebbm^_c
kdbcimlvl_jjhjZgh:eeZo\DhjZg_kdZaZe©:eeZohojZgbl
_]hemqr_Hg–kZfucfbehk_j^gucbafbehklb\uoª (12:64).
637
‹
289
< `mjgZe_ ©FZgZj Ze-om^Zª638 [ueZ him[ebdh\ZgZ klZ
lvy \ dhlhjhc jZkkdZau\Zehkv h lhf dZd \ZooZ[blu m[beb
fmnlby >Z]_klZgZ r_coZ FmoZffZ^-KZb^Z :[m[ZdZjh\Z b _]h
[jZlZJhkkbckdh_bgnhjfZpbhggh_Z]_glkl\h©Bgl_jnZdkªkh
h[sbehqlhhgbih^hj\Zeb639fZrbgmfmnlby\klhebp_>Z]_
klZgZFZoZqdZe_
Fmnlbc:[m[ZdZjh\[ueba\_kl_gk\h_cg_ijbfbjbfhk
lvxd\ZooZ[blZfbh[ty\beboZdu^mba\jZs_gghcbkihjq_g
ghchggZa\ZebojZajmrbl_eyfbZe-fmojb[bg640<ugZ\_j
gh_ ihfgbl_ ihke_^gb_ kh[ulby gZ ]jZgbp_ >Z]_klZgZ b Q_q
gb ^Z`_ ij_ab^_glm Bqd_jbb :keZgm FZkoZ^h\m ijbrehkv
ijb[_]gmlv d g_dhlhjuf kj_^kl\Z qlh[u ij_^hl\jZlblv ihdm
r_gb_ \ZooZ[blh\641 G_^Z\gh \ h^ghc ba iZdbklZgkdbo f_q_
l_c ik_^hkZeZnblZfb \h \j_fy fhebl\u [ueZ jZkklj_eygZ
]jmiiZfmkmevfZgAZqlh`_hgbihkljZ^Zeb"LhevdhaZlhqlh
[uebrbblZfb642Ij_^iheZ]Z_lkyqlhwlhll_jZdl[uef_klvx
>`mfZ^Zemey]k_gly[jv]‹
Dmj[ZgoZ^`b HfZj KZoZ[h\ jmdh\h^bl_ev hl^_eZ kghr_gbc k ]hkm^Zj
kl\_ggufbhj]ZgZfbijb>moh\ghfmijZ\e_gbbfmkmevfZg>Z]_klZgZ\k\h
_f bgl_j\vx ^ey _`_g_^_evghc ]Za_lu ©<_jkbyª ‹ hl Z\]mklZ – 6
k_gly[jy khh[sbe ©«]^_ [u gb ihy\bebkv \ZooZ[blu \_a^_ gZqbgZ_lky
kfmlZ \hhjm`_ggu_ dhgnebdlu b djh\hijheblb_ª Dhff_glbjmy bo f_lh
^bdm hg kdZaZe ©Hgb hq_gv e_]dh ih^dmiZxl ex^_cª DZd ba\_klgh \k_
l_jjhjbklbq_kdb_Zdluijhbahr_^rb_\?]bil_:e`bj_IZdbklZg_b^jm
]bofmkmevfZgkdbokljZgZoy\eyxlky^_eZfbjmd\ZooZ[blh\ba\jZs_ggZy
Zdu^Z dhlhjuo ijbau\Z_l m[b\Zlv ijhlb\gbdh\ h[\bgb\ bo \ yauq_kl\_
PblZlu ba \ur_mihfygmlh]h bgl_j\vx [ueb i_j_\_^_gu ^ey ZjZ[kdbo
KFBfhkdh\kdbfdhjj_kihg^_glhfOZgbRZ^b
640
Wlh^_ckl\bl_evghlZd]^_[ugbihy\eyebkvwlbex^b\_a^_gZqbgZ_lky
kfmlZ\hcgZbjZajmoZ
641
Ijbau\ \ZooZ[blh\ lZdh\ ©Beb lu ke_^m_rv aZ gZfb dZd ihkemrgZy
h\_qdZbeb`_f_qª
642
24/11/14]\h\j_fyi_j_^Zqb©DZ^ZyªgZkimlgbdh\hfdZgZe_
©:e->`ZabjZª h[km`^Zeky \hijhk f_`ie_f_gguo hlghr_gbc \ IZdbklZg_
;hevrbgkl\h ]hkm^Zjkl\_gguo b iheblbq_kdbc ^_yl_e_c IZdbklZgZ aZy\b
eh qlh IZdbklZg ^h ihy\e_gby \ZooZ[blh\[ue\_jhl_jibfhckljZghc]^_
fbjghihkhk_^kl\m^jm]k^jm]hf`bebbrbblubkmggbluKZfufbba\_
klgufb\ZooZ[blkdbfbhj]ZgbaZpbyfbIZdbklZgZy\eyxlky©H[s_kl\hfm
kmevfZgkdbomq_guoª©>`Zf]byl]meZfZZe-BkeZfª©H[s_kl\hihke_^h
638
639
290
\ZooZ[blh\aZ^_ckl\byrbblh\gZx]_Eb\ZgZLhqghlZdb_`_
Zdpbb \ZooZ[blu kh\_jrZeb b jZg__ B[g L_cfbb m^Zehkv ba
^Zlvn_l\mhg_\_jbbrbblh\bm[_^blvh^gh]hbakmelZgh\kh
\_jrblv ihoh^ gZ rbblkdmx ijh\bgpbx DZkmj\Zg ;eZ]h^Zjy
wlhfm DZkmj\Zg ba fmkmevfZgkdhc rbblkdhc ijh\bgpbb ij_
\jZlbeky\ojbklbZgkdmx643.
Y[ue\ZooZ[blhf
DZd ba\_klgh gZb[he__ hk\_^hfe_ggufb h `bagb lhc
bebbghck_dluy\eyxlkyl_dlh\k\h_\j_fyhdZaZekyih^__
\ebygb_f>Ze__y`_eZxijb\_klbibkvfhh^gh]hbafheh^uo
ex^_c dhlhjhfm m^Zehkv \ue_alv ba iZmlbgu \ZooZ[bafZ dh
lhjhchg[uehdmlZgkfhf_glZk\h_]hihy\e_gbygZk\_l
GZ k\h_c kljZgbp_ \ Bgl_jg_l_ y ihf_klbe ke_^mxs__
^\mklbrb_©Heh\dZq-ZrZjblg_m`_ebluih^^ZekyoZrZ\bl
kdhc kfml_ª IjhqblZ\ bo wlhl fheh^hc q_eh\_d gZibkZe fg_
ke_^mxs__©«Yg_eh\dZq-ZrZjblyfheh^hcq_eh\_d`bl_ev
DZlZjZ ijb^_j`b\Zxkv fZebdblkdh]h fZaoZ[Z \ nbdo_ b ZrZ
jblkdhcrdheu\Zdu^_Ijh[e_fZ[ueZebrv\lhfqlhyjh
^bekyb\ujhk\wlhfh[s_kl\_ghihgy\bklbgmygZqZehl\_
qZlv wlbf ex^yf keh\Zfb baeh`_ggufb \ dgb]Zo gZrbo m\Z
`Z_fuo mq_guo644 Wlbo k_dlZglh\ gZau\Zxl oZrZ\blZfb wlh
gZa\Zgb_bfhq_gvih^oh^blihlhfmqlhhlgbobkoh^ylimklu_
j_qbbodgb]bebr_guihe_aguoagZgbcZr_cobimklhkeh\yl
Wlb ex^b dZ`^uc jZa ih^ gh\ufb gZa\Zgbyfb i_j_ba^Zxl
dgb]bB[gAmn_ceyba\_klgh]hdZdB[gZe-DZcbfb_]hmqbl_
eyB[gL_cfbbFudZ`^uc^_gv\b^bfgh\u_aZ]heh\dbih^
dhlhjufb \k_]^Z gZibkZgh ©B[g L_cfbyª Hgb ^Z`_ g_ mki_
\ZxlqblZlvdgb]bdhlhju_ba^Zxl_keb\u\gbfZl_evghijb
\Zl_e_coZ^bkZª©>`ZfZ]ZZoeZe-oZ^bkª<h\j_fymihfygmlhci_j_^Zqb
lZd`_ ijbkmlkl\h\Ze ij_^\h^bl_ev ©<ZooZ[blkdhc Zjfbb kih^\b`gbdh\ª
dhlhjuc gZa\Ze rbblh\ g_\_jgufb =eZ\Z kmggblkdbo mq_guo IZdbklZgZ
\k_]^ZiulZ\rbckygZeZ`b\ZlvdhglZdlkh\k_fbb^_cgufbl_q_gbyfb[ue
\ugm`^_ggZa\Zlv\ZooZ[blh\kZlZgbklZfb
643
Kf©:e-;b^Zy\ZZg-gboZyªB[gDZkkbj–Kh[ulby]]
644
Bf__lky\\b^mdeZkkbdZfZebdblh\bZrZjblh\–ii
291
]ey^bl_kvlhaZf_lbl_qlhhgb^Z`_g_m^hkm`bebkvihf_gylv
gZa\Zgb_lh]hbebbgh]hjZa^_eZkh^_j`Zgbydgb]bHgbkh[b
jZxlg_kdhevdhjZa^_eh\bajZaebqguodgb]ZaZl_fi_j_ba^Z
xlbodZdgh\mxdgb]mBijbwlhf\k_]^Zih^ibku\Zxl©hlj_
^Zdlbjh\Zgh b i_j_ijh\_j_ghª y `_ ij_^eh`be [u bf ibkZlv
©kdhibjh\ZghªHgbebrvdhibjmxlhl^_evgu_]eZ\uZaZl_f
ih^ibku\Zxl r_co lZdhc-lh kug lZdh]h-lh kZeZnbl oZrZ\bl
blZd^Ze__^hdhgpZ\k_oj_]Zebc
Y`_^eyk_[yba[jZeebrvh^gmj_]Zebx©ZrZjblª645b
k^_eZe wlh ^ey lh]h qlh[u gZklZ\eylv wlbo ijhklhex^bgh\
^mfZxsboqlh\eZ^_xlbkeZfkdbffbjhfGZkZfhf^_e_hgb
ba-aZ k\h_]h keZ[hmfby h]jZgbq_gghklb dZ`^uc ^_gv l_jyxl
klhjhggbdh\:\dZq_kl\_k\h_]hwe_dljhggh]hZ^j_kZyba[jZe
k\ys_gguc ]hjh^ F_^bgm \_jy qlh b hl h^gh]h __ gZa\Zgby
bkoh^bl[eZ]h[ZjZdZYk^_eZewlhihlhfmqlhwlbex^bf_
rZxlfmkmevfZgZfgZ\_sZlvfh]bemIjhjhdZk]kbkZfb__
g_gZ\_sZxlKj_^bgbo_klvlZdb_dlhkh\_jrbeoZ^`^_kyl
dbjZaghgbh^gh]hjZaZg_gZ\_klbefh]beuIjhjhdZk]k
Hg hijZ\^u\Z_lky keh\Zf ©<_^v wlh \k_]h ebrv kmggZ»646 Wlb
ex^b gZklhevdh g_gZ\b^yl IjhjhdZ k]k qlh ^Z`_ aZij_sZ
xl_]h\hko\ZeylvgZau\Zywlh[b^]hcbyauq_kl\hf
<k\h_\j_fyy[ueh^gbfbagboy[ueaZ[em^rbfgh
wlhg_m^b\bl_evgh<_^v_keb\uihc^_l_\f_q_lvqlh[ubam
qZlvk\hxj_eb]bxlhhgbhdjm`Zl\Zkk\h_c©aZ[hlhcªqlh[u
hl]hjh^blv\Zkhl[h`_kl\_ggh]hk\_lZaZdexq_ggh]h\keh\Zo
mq_guomffuIjhjhdZk]kHlgbo\ukeurbl_h^gbbl_`_
keh\Z ©;b^]Z yauq_kl\h fh]behihdehggbq_kl\h \au\Zgb_ d
q_fm-eb[hihfbfh:eeZoZª<blh]_\ulh`_ij_\jZsZ_l_kv\
h^gh]hbagbogZqbgZ_l_ih^haj_\Zlv\yauq_kl\_dZ`^h]hfm
kmevfZgbgZb^Z`_kZfh]hk_[y
WlhlxghrZh[jZah\Zgbkdjhf_gfu\k_]^Z]hlh\uihfh]ZlvlZdbfex
^yf
646
G_dhlhju_ ba wlbo ]emiph\ aZy\eyxl qlh ihk_s_gb_ fh]beu IjhjhdZ
k]ky\ey_lky[b^]Z=^_`_eh]bdZ\bokeh\Zo"G_m`_ebqlh[uij_\jZ
lblv wlh ^_ygb_ \ kmggm Ijhjhd k]k kZf ebqgh ^he`_g [ue ihk_lblv
k\hxfh]bem"
645
292
Y ohqm jZkkdZaZlv h^gm hq_gv bgl_j_kgmx b kf_rgmx
bklhjbxijhbahr_^rmxkhfghc\^gb\ZooZ[bafZH^gZ`^u
ybfhb^jmavygZ\_klbebh^gh]hbaba\_klguobdjmiguo\Zo
oZ[blkdbo r_coh\ <klj_qZy gZk hg kdZaZe ©>Z ijb\_lkl\m_l
\Zk:eeZoª©OZcydmf:eeZoªWlbkeh\ZgZklhevdhijhgbdeb
\^mrmfh_]h^jm]Zqlhhg\k_\j_fyjZa]h\hjZ^mfZeh[wlhf
b ijb jZkklZ\Zgbb kijhkbe m r_coZ ©: jZa\_ fu fh`_f kdZ
aZlv qlh :eeZo ijb\_lkl\m_l"ª R_co \iZe \ kfyl_gb_ hq_gv
aZkfmsZeky b gZqZe \kemo jZkkm`^Zlv ©>Z ijb\_lkl\m_l \Zk
:eeZo« :eeZo ijb\_lkl\m_l \Zk« :eeZo ijb\_lkl\m_l«ª - Z
aZl_fkdZaZe©Deygmkv:eeZohf^hjh]hc[jZlyg_agZxhl\_
lZ gZ l\hc \hijhk Ihbsb \ dgb]Zo Z ihlhf khh[sb fg_ hl
\_lªIhkfhljbl_gZwlhg_\_`_kl\hGhyohqm\ZfkdZaZlvqlh
fhclh\ZjbsgZqZebkdZlvjulvky\dgb]Zob\dhg_qghfblh]_
h[gZjm`beqlhlZd]h\hjblvfh`gh\_^v\wlhfkemqZ_fug_
ijbibku\Z_f:eeZomgbq_]hqlh[u?fmg_ijbebq_kl\h\Zeh
Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky f_gy ebqgh lh y h^gZ`^u aZ^Ze wlhfm
r_com\hijhk©IhjlblkyebfZeh_hfh\_gb_dh]^ZbaghkZl_
q_ldjh\v"ª<hlgZklhevdhy[ueg_\_`_kl\_g_gMkeurZ\\h
ijhk hg gZqZe mkbe_ggh jZafureylv Fg_ ihdZaZehkv qlh y
aZ^Zekeh`g_crbc\hijhkhlghkysbckydlhgdhklyfnbdoZ<
blh]_ hg fg_ hl\_lbe ©Y g_ agZxª Ij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ dZabc
h[ty\b\rbc k_[y ijhiZ]Zg^bklhf lZ\ob^Z \ DZlZj_ g_ agZ_l
^_ygbcihjlysbofZeh_hfh\_gb_DZdhgfh`_ljZkkm`^Zlvh
^_ygbyo ^_eZxsbo g_^_ckl\bl_evghc \_jm" < blh]_ y ihkl_
i_gghgZqZeihgbfZlvqlhlZdh_\ZooZ[baf
D h]jhfghfm kh`Ze_gbx DZlZjm \uiZeh wlh \_ebdh_
bkiulZgb_ <ZooZ[blu k fhf_glZk\h_]hihy\e_gbyijbf_jgh
iylv^_kyle_lgZaZ^aZo\Zlbeb\k_f_q_lbH^bgbam\Z`Z_fuo
r_coh\fg_jZkkdZau\Zeqlh\ZooZ[baf[ueijbg_k_g\DZlZj
g_^`^bckdbf mq_guf FmoZffZ^hf [bg FZgb]hf Dh]^Z hgb
\i_j\u_ihy\bebkv\DZlZj_lhihk_sZykh[jZgbyfmkmevfZg
]h\hjbeb©Fbjl_fdlhihke_^h\ZeaZbklbghcª©:k-KZeyfm
]Zey fZgg bllZ[Z]Z Ze-om^Zª LZdh_ hsms_gb_ qlh hgb ijb
\_lkl\h\Zeb g_\_jguo b [ueb i_j\hijhoh^pZfb BkeZfZ \ gZ
r_fj_]bhg_<kZfu_i_j\u_]h^uihke_k\h_]hihy\e_gbyhgb
293
kh`]ebfgh`_kl\hfZebdblkdbodgb]g_dhlhju_baaZ[em^rbo
dZlZjp_\ ^Z`_ ihfh]Zeb bf \ wlhf Fgh]b_ dZlZjkdb_ mq_gu_
ihkljZ^Zeb hl bo jmd Z r_co Y]dm[ [bg Xkmn ^Z`_ [ue \u
gm`^_g i_j_k_eblvky \ ;Zoj_cg647 >_lb r_coZ jZkkdZau\Zeb
qlhhgi_j_^kf_jlvxhq_gvkbevghohl_e\_jgmlvky^hfhch^
gZdhB[gFZgb]g_iha\hebe_fmwlhk^_eZlvbaZklZ\beaZfhe
qZlv \k_o _]h klhjhggbdh\ < DZlZj_ wlh]h q_eh\_dZ ihfgyl
fgh]b_ \_^v _]h mq_gbdZfb [ueb \uimkdgbdb ©:e-:aoZjZª
mgb\_jkbl_lh\BjZdZZlZd`_fgh]b_f_klgu_`bl_eb>hkbo
ihj khojZgbebkv jmdhibkgu_ dgb]b gZibkZggu_ wlbf q_eh\_
dhf Gh _klv g_dhlhju_ ex^b `_eZxsb_ bo hlj_^Zdlbjh\Zlv
qlh[u ij_^klZ\blv Zdu^m `bl_e_c DZlZjZ dZd Zdu^m oZrZ\b
lh\
Dh]^Z y gZqZe ihbkdb \ Bgl_jg_l_ lh ^mfZe qlh hgb
_s_g_mki_ebaZoeZfblv_]hk\hbffmkhjhfghdkh`Ze_gbx
hdZaZehkvqlhm`_kms_kl\m_lhq_gvfgh]hkZclh\kbo]emiu
fb b^_yfb kZclh\ ]^_ hgb ihghkyl djmig_crbo mq_guo Wlb
ex^b baeZ]Zxl k\hb m[_`^_gby b \b^bfh ^mfZxl qlh gbdlh
g_ kfh`_l bo hijh\_j]gmlv A^_kv \ DZlZj_ y qZklh \klmiZx k
gbfb \ ^bkdmkkbb Y g_ ]h\hjx bf qlh y\eyxkv ZrZjblhf y
^_eZx wlh g_ ba-aZ kljZoZ lZd ihkh\_lh\Ze fg_ h^bg ba fhbo
gZklZ\gbdh\<_^vwlbex^blhedhfg_agZxlk\h_cZdu^udZd
`_hgb[m^mlhk\_^hfe_guh[Zdu^_k\hbohiihg_glh\"Bgh]^Z
hgb ZrZjblkdb_ iheh`_gby Zdu^u ijbgbfZeb aZ oZrZ\blkdb_
bhklZ\Zebkvhq_gv^h\hevgulh]^Z-lhybihgyefm^jhklvkh
\_lZfh_]hgZklZ\gbdZǻ
Fu ihkh\_lh\Zeb gZr_fm m\Z`Z_fhfm [jZlm khojZgylv
\k_aZibkb^bkdmkkbc\hafh`gh_fmm^Zklkyba^Zlvdgb]mih^
aZ]heh\dhf©Y[ueoZrZ\blhfªbfgh]b_ijhaj_xl[eZ]h^Zjy
_c \ h^ghf ba klbohl\hj_gbc kdZaZgh ©Y ihagZdhfbeky kh
aehf h^gZdh g_ ^ey lh]h qlh[u _]h l\hjblv Z ^ey lh]h qlh[u
aZsblblvkyhlg_]h\_^vg_agZxsbcaeZfh`_l\iZklv\g_]hª
DZlZj;Zoj_cgbHfZgy\eyxlkyhq_gv^jm`_kl\_ggufbbjh^kl\_ggufb
]hkm^Zjkl\ZfbDh]^Z\]]\ZooZ[bluie_gbeboZebnblh\qZklv
boih^^Zgguo[_`ZeZ\DZlZjkfB[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª
–Iha^g__qZklv`bl_e_cDZlZjZ\f_kl_kk_fvyfbi_j_[jZeZkv\HfZg
647
294
Ibkvfhj_dlhjmmgb\_jkbl_lZ
<ZooZ[blu ihklhyggh l_jyxl k\hb ihke_^h\Zl_e_c
IjbqbgZ wlh]h djh_lky \ lhf qlh \ZooZ[blkdZy b^_heh]by h[
eZ^Z_l^\mfy[hevrbfbg_^hklZldZfbH^gbfbagboy\ey_lky
^moh\gZy h]jZgbq_gghklv ^hklZlhqgh m`_ lh]h qlh hkgh\hih
eh`gbd wlhc b^_heh]bb FmoZffZ^ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[ gZa\Ze
IjhjhdZ k]k ihkeZgp_f <lhjuf g_^hklZldhf y\ey_lky bg
l_ee_dlmZevgZy h]jZgbq_gghklv dhlhjZy f_rZ_l bf ^Z`_ qb
lZlv dgb]b fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo Ijh[e_fZ \ lhf qlh bo
dgb]bijhlb\hj_qZlboik_\^hkZeZnblkdhcb^_heh]bbIhwlhfm
\ ^Zgghf jZa^_e_ dgb]b y ohqm ijb\_klb ibkvfh gZibkZggh_
<Zbe_fZe-FZk]Zjbq_eh\_dhf\uj\Z\rbfkybadh]l_c\ZooZ
[blh\ Wlh ibkvfh648 Z^j_kh\Zgh ^hdlhjm ;Zdjm [bg =Z[^mee_
[bg;Zdjm:\lhjibr_l©Y\ujhk\g_^`^bckdhck_fv_ijb
^_j`b\Z\r_cky oZg[Zeblkdh]h fZaoZ[Z \ nbdo_ b kZeZnbafZ \
Zdu^_ H^gZdh ke_ih_ ke_^h\Zgb_ gZrbf Z\lhjbl_lZf f_gy g_
m^h\e_l\hjyehyohl_efukeblvb\b^_lv[he__rbjhdhK\hbf
k\_jklgbdZfylh`_kh\_lmxih[hevr_aZ^mfu\ZlvkyZgZebab
jh\ZlvbkdZlvbklbgmbf_gghlZdhcaZ\_lgZfhklZ\beIjhjhd
k]k \ k\h_f oZ^bk_ ³Fm^jhklv ^ey fmkmevfZgbgZ ih^h[gZ
aZ[em^r_c \_j[ex^bp_ imklv hg aZ[bjZ_l __ k_[_ ]^_ [u gb
gZr_e ihkdhevdm bf__l gZ g__ ihegh_ ijZ\h´ª649 Ih ih\h^m
B[gL_cfbbhgmdZau\Z_l©JZa\_lhevdhhgaZkem`b\Z_llblm
eZ©r_comebkeZfª"JZa\_hklZevgu_g_^hklhcguwlh]hlblmeZ"
: fh`_l [ulv wlhl lblme gbkihkeZg ki_pbZevgh ^ey g_]h"
Fgh]b_kh\j_f_ggu_fheh^u_ex^b^mfZxlqlhwlhlq_eh\_d
Hgh [ueh him[ebdh\Zgh gZ h^ghf ba fmkmevfZgkdbo nhjmfh\ \ Bgl_j
g_l_
649
Ohq_lkykdZaZlvqlhm`_\hfgh]bo\ZooZ[blkdbo]hkm^Zjkl\Zofheh^u_
ex^b gZqZeb aZ^mfu\Zlvky b bkdZlv Fgh]b_ gZqZeb ijhy\eylv bgl_j_k d
Zm^bh-e_dpbyf r_coZ :ofZ^Z [bg OZf^Z Ze-OZebeb p_gu gZ _]h dZkk_lu
\hajhkeb^hlukyqbkZm^bckdboj_Zeh\:g_dhlhjuoklm^_glh\^Z`_hlqbk
ebebba\mah\aZlhqlhhgb\k\hbodhfgZlZoojZgbebdZkk_luke_dpbyfb
wlh]h r_coZ Ihkfhljbl_ gZkdhevdh wlb ex^b l_jibfu JZa\_ fu dh]^Zgb[m^v k`b]Zeb dgb]b beb dZkk_lu B[g ;ZaZ" G_l hgb ojZgylky \ gZrbo
[b[ebhl_dZo \_^v b^_x g_\hafh`gh ih[_^blv h]g_f b f_qhf __ fh`gh
ih[_^blvlhevdhq_ldbfbbykgufb^h\h^Zfb
648
295
[ue\hh[s_[_a]j_r_gGZkZfhf`_^_e_hgijhklhcmq_guc
kihkh[guckh\_jrZlvhrb[db?kebhgijZ\lhfuijbf_f_]h
ihabpbx _keb hrb[ky lh hl\_j]g_f Hkgh\guf djbl_jb_f \
BkeZf_ y\ey_lky DhjZg b kmggZ Ih g_dhlhjuf \hijhkZf y g_
kh]eZrZxkvkB[gL_cfb_clZd`_mg_]hhq_gvfgh]hjZaebq
guoijhlb\hj_qb\uofhf_glh\ªJZatykgyykmlvkh\j_f_ggh]h
ik_\^hkZeZnbafZ hg ibr_l ©Fgh]b_ ex^b ih g_agZgbx ijh
^he`Zxl kqblZlv qlh ihke_^h\Zl_eb \ZooZ[blkdh]h ^\b`_gby
ijb^_j`b\ZxlkykZeZnblkdhcZdu^ubgZke_^byGZkZfhf^_
e_wlhg_lZd\hkgh\_wlh]h^\b`_gbygZe_`Zlb^_bB[g
L_cfbb ihwlhfm [he__ \_jguf gZa\Zgb_f [ueh [u g_ ©kZeZ
nbafª Z ©l_cfbafª >Z b \ p_ehf wlh g_ dZdh_-lh k\ys_ggh_
mq_gb_Zh[uqgh_b^_heh]bq_kdh_l_q_gb_ª
Ih ih\h^m ihke_^kl\bc jZkijhkljZg_gby wlh]h ^\b`_
gbyhgibr_l©>Zykh]eZrmkvkl_fqlhfmkmevfZgkdh_h[jZ
ah\Zgb_klZehkbevg__gh\h[s_kl\_ihy\beZkvgZijy`_gghklv
b jZah[s_gghklv JZagu_ b^_heh]bq_kdb_ ]jmiiu g_ fh]ml
ijbclb d \aZbfhihgbfZgbx b ^bZeh]m Hkh[h kbevgZy hlqm`
^_gghklvijbkmlkl\m_l\hlghr_gbyof_`^mrbblZfbbkmggb
lZfb:wlhdZdba\_klghg_m]h^ghgb:eeZomgb?]hihkeZg
gbdmª JZkkdZau\Zy h fheh^uo \ZooZ[blZo hg ibr_l ©Fheh
^u_ex^bkdhlhjufbfg_^h\_ehkv[_k_^h\Zlvg_agZxlq_]h
ohlyl>eygbog_ljZaebqbcf_`^mp_evxbkj_^kl\hfb^__cb
iml_f__^hklb`_gbyHgboh^ylihdjm]mmdhlhjh]hg_ldhg
pZª
LZdh\u ieh^u jZkijhkljZg_gby \ZooZ[bafZ \ fmkmev
fZgkdbo kljZgZo – p_eh_ ihdhe_gb_ fheh^_`b [em`^Zxs_c \
ihl_fdZo?s_[he__om^rbfy\ey_lkykhklhygb_l_odlhijh
^he`Z_ljZkijhkljZgylvwlbb^_b
GZklZ\e_gb_Za-AZoZ[b
GZklZ\e_gb_bfZfZRZkm^^bgZFmoZffZ^Z[bg:ofZ^Z
Za-AZoZ[bZr-RZnb]bmf]]B[gL_cfbb650)
LZd`_ba\_klghdZd©:e-DZ[[ZgªJmdhibkvwlh]hgZklZ\e_gbyojZgblky\
dZbjkdhc[b[ebhl_d_ih^ghf_jhf[bijbgZ^e_`blnZdbomfmnZkkb
jm b bklhjbdm :[m ;Zdjm b[g :ofZ^m [bg FmoZffZ^m Ze-:kZ^b Z^650
296
©<h bfy :eeZoZ Fbehklb\h]h Fbehk_j^gh]h O\ZeZ
:eeZomH=hkih^b[m^vfbehklb\dhfg_ijhklbfhbhrb[db
bkhojZgbfhx\_jmYi_qZexkvhg_^hklZld_i_qZebkh`Ze_x
hgZklhys_fiheh`_gbbkmggukdmqZxihijZ\_^guf[jZlvyf
y i_qZexkv h lhf qlh bkq_aeb fgh]b_ mq_gu_ b ijZ\_^gbdb
[u\rb_ k\_lhqZfb wlhc mffu DZd gZf g_ o\ZlZ_l aZdhggh]h
^bjoZfZbohjhrbo^jma_c
KqZkleb\ul_dlh\b^blk\hbhrb[dbbg_\b^blqm`b_
b]hj_l_fdlhg_\b^blk\hbogh\b^blqm`b_>hdZdboihj
lu[m^_rv\b^_lvkhjbgdb\]eZaZohdjm`Zxsbobg_aZf_qZlv
[j_\gh \ k\h_f ]eZam" >h dZdbo ihj lu [m^_rv \ha\_ebqb\Zlv
k_[ybmgb`Zlvmq_guo"JZa\_lug_keurZekeh\IhkeZggbdZ
:eeZoZ ©<kihfbgZcl_ k\hbo ihdhcguo lhevdh ^h[jhf \_^v
hgb m`_ lZf dm^Z rebª651 Y agZx qlh lu fg_ kdZ`_rv Lu
gZqg_rv ]h\hjblv qlh wlb ex^b g_ ihagZeb BkeZf ijbr_^
rbcdgZfkehamg]hf^`boZ^ZG_lgZh[hjhlbf_gghhgbih
agZeb BkeZf \_jgh b aZdjueb ]eZaZ gZ lh qlh bo g_ dZkZ_lky
DZd kdZaZe h[ wlhf IhkeZggbd :eeZoZ ©Emqrbc BkeZf – wlh
hklZ\e_gb_lh]hqlhl_[yg_dZkZ_lkyª652.
Wcluym\_s_\Zxl_[ybf_g_f:eeZoZI_j_klZgv\j_
^blvgZfFuagZ_fqlhluh[eZ^Z_rvdjZkghj_qb_fbmf_gb
_f ijb\h^blv ^h\h^u AgZc `_ qlh Ijhjhd k]k g_ ex[be
>bfZrdbZr-RZnb]bba\_klghfmdZdB[gDZ^uRmo[Zmf]]
I_jm wlh]h q_eh\_dZ ijbgZ^e_`Zl dgb]b ©LZ[ZdZl nmdZoZ Zr-rZnb]byª
©LZnkbj Ze-DmjtZg Ze-dZjbfª ©:a-AZce ]Zey lZjbo Za-AZoZ[bª b ^jm]b_
MihfygmlZyjmdhibkv[ueZi_j_ibkZgZkjmdhibkbdZabydZab_\;mjoZgm^
^bgZba\_klgh]hdZdB[g>`ZfZ]Zmf]]ZlZ\k\hxhq_j_^v
[ueZ i_j_ibkZgZ k jmdhibkb oZnbaZ nZdboZ :[m KZ]b^Z Ze-=ZeZb Z^>bfZrdb mf ] ] i_jm dhlhjh]h ijbgZ^e_`bl [he__ ljb^pZlb
dgb]ihjZaebqghcl_fZlbd_Hg`_aZibkZewlhgZklZ\e_gb_khkeh\kZfh]h
bfZfZ Za-AZoZ[b Djhf_ wlh]h kms_kl\m_l b ^jm]Zy jmdhibkv wlh]h gZklZ\
e_gby HgZ ojZgblky \ ©>Zj Ze-dmlm[ Za-aZobjbyª \ >ZfZkd_ ih^ ghf_jhf
1347. Djhf_lh]hl_dklwlhcjmdhibkbijb\_^_g\dgb]_oZnbaZZk-KZoZ\b
©:e-B]eyg[bZl-lZm[boebfZgaZffZZl-lZjboªb\dgb]_kZfh]hZa-AZoZ[b
©KbyjZ]eyfZg-gm[Zeyª
651
Ijb\h^blkymZe-;moZjbbZg-GZkZb
652
Ijb\h^blkymZl-Lbjfbab
297
dh]^ZaZ^Zxlfgh]h\hijhkh\<h^ghfba_]hoZ^bkh\kdZaZgh
©;hevr_ \k_]h ^ey k\h_c mffu y [hxkv djZkghj_qb\uo ebp_
f_jh\ª653;_kihq\_ggh_fgh]hkeh\b_mf_js\ey_lk_j^pZ^Z`_
\lhfkemqZ__kebhghk\yaZghk^ha\he_ggufQlh`_lu^mfZ
_rv ih ih\h^m fgh]hkeh\by \ hlghr_gbb j_q_c nbehkhnh\ b
g_\_jguo">hdZdboihjlu[m^_rvpblbjh\Zlvj_qbg_\_jguo
nbehkhnh\gZdhlhju_gZfijboh^blkyhl\_qZlv^h\h^ZfbjZ
amfZ"LuhljZ\bekyy^Zfbnbehkhnbbb^hr_e^hlhckl_i_gb
qlhklZeijbibku\Zlv:eeZoml_e_kghklvDZdkbevghykdmqZx
ih l_f ex^yf dhlhju_ qblZeb DhjZg b aZ^mfu\Zebkv gZ^ _]h
kfukehfmihfbgZeb:eeZoZbkljZrbebkv?]hfheqZebb^m
fZeb Dh]^Z fu \kihfbgZ_f h[ wlbo ijZ\_^gbdZo gZ gZk gbk
oh^bl[h`_kl\_ggZyfbehklvghhgZg_[m^_lgbkoh^blv_keb
fu[m^_fboijhdebgZlv
F_q OZ^`Z^`Z b yaud B[g OZafZ [ueb hq_gv [ebadb
^jm] d ^jm]m lu `_ bkihevah\Ze b i_j\h_ b \lhjh_ Lu h[ty
\be kmgghc b hkgh\hc lZ\ob^Z l_ [b^]Z dhlhju_ fu kqblZeb
\_johf aZ[em`^_gby L_o dlh g_ke_^m_laZlh[hclugZau\Z
_rv g_\_jgufb b hkeZfb L_o dlh hldZau\Z_lkyh[\bgylvex
^_c \ g_\_jbb lu h[ty\ey_rv [he__ g_\_jgufb q_f nZjZhg
Lu ihk_ye \ ^mrZo ex^_c klhevdh khfg_gbc qlh [m^_rv kqZ
kleb\_kebl_[yijbagZxl\_jmxsbf
=hj_ l_f dlh ihke_^h\Ze aZ lh[hc \_^v hgb \iZeb \
_j_kv<k_l\hbihke_^h\Zl_eb–g_\_`_kl\_ggu_]emipu]hlh
\u_aZsbsZlvl_[yghgZkZfhf^_e_hgbl\hb\jZ]bIhkfhl
jbdlhaZlh[hcke_^m_lJZa\_wlhg_ijhklhex^bgubg_\_`
^u"?keblug_\_jbrvfhbfkeh\Zfh[jZlbk\hc\ahjgZih
ke_^h\Zl_e_c654.
H \_jmxsbc kdhevdh `_ lu _s_ ih^^Z\Zykv k\hbf
kljZklyf b `_eZgbyf [m^_rv \j_^blv ijZ\_^gbdZf" Kdhevdh
\j_f_gblu_s_[m^_rvb^lbgZih\h^mk\hbo`_eZgbc">hdZ
dbo ihj lu [m^_rv \ha\_ebqb\Zlv k_[y b mgb`Zlv ^jm]bo" >h
dZdboihjlu[m^_rviho\Zeylvkyk\hbfbj_qZfbhklZ\eyy^h
653
654
Ijb\h^blkym:ofZ^Z
LhqghlZdb_`_ihke_^h\Zl_ebmkh\j_f_gguo\ZooZ[blh\
298
klh\_jgu_ oZ^bku" >h dZdbo ihj lu [m^_rv hl\_j]Zlv hijh
\_j]Zlvh[ty\eylvkeZ[ufb^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bku655?
G_ gZklZeh eb \j_fy h^mfZlvky" G_ gZklZeh eb \j_fy
ihdZylvky" JZa\_ lu g_ jZaf_gye k_^vfhc ^_kylhd" JZa\_ g_
ijb[ebabekyfb]ijhsZgbykwlbffbjhf"<_^vlubg_^mfZ
_rvhkf_jlbgZh[hjhlgZkf_oZ_rvkygZ^l_fbdlh]h\hjblh
g_c656 Y ^mfZx qlh lu g_ [m^_rv ke_^h\Zlv wlhfm gZklZ\e_
gbx \_^v lu \k_]^Z hl\_qZe gZ fhb keh\Z fgh]hqbke_ggufb
lhfZfbdgb]<b^bfhlu[m^_rvijh^he`Zlvk\h_^_eh^hl_o
ihjihdZhl_[_g_kdZ`ml©GZdhg_p-lhaZfheqZeª
LuaZf_lbedZdhlghrmkvdl_[_yl\hc[u\rbc^jm]b
ihke_^h\Zl_ev:agZ_rvebludZdhlghkylkydl_[_l\hb\jZ
]b"Kj_^bgbohq_gvfgh]hijZ\_^gbdh\bm\Z`Z_fuomq_guo
qlh`_dZkZ_lkyl\hboihke_^h\Zl_e_clhkj_^bgboh^gbe`_
pujZkimlgbdbbg_\_`^u
Y[eZ]h^Zj_gl_[_aZl\hxdjblbdm\_^vlumdZau\Z_rv
fg_gZfhbhrb[db<h^ghfba\ukdZau\ZgbckdZaZgh©>ZgZ
klZ\bl:eeZogZijyfhcimlvlh]hdlhmdZaZegZfhbhrb[db
=hj_ fg_ _keb y g_ mki_x ihdZylvky _^bgkl\_gguf e_dZjkl
\hf^eyf_gyy\ey_lky[h`_kl\_ggh_ijhs_gb_O\ZeZ:eeZom
=hkih^mfbjh\[eZ]hkeh\_gb_:eeZoZgZr_fm]hkih^bgmIjh
jhdmbIhkeZggbdmFmoZffZ^mk]kZlZd`_\k_c_]hk_fv_b
kih^\b`gbdZfª
BfZfZa-AZoZ[b[ueh^gbfbamq_gbdh\B[gL_cfbbgh
ihgy\hrb[hqghklvb^_ck\h_]hmqbl_eyihdbgme_]hb^he]h_
\j_fygZ^_yekygZ_]hihdZygb_H^gZdh\b^yqlhhgg_`_eZ
_ljZkdZb\Zlvkyb[hykvaZfheh^uorZdbj^h\hggZibkZedgb
]m©;ZygaZ]eZe-]bef\ZZl-lZeZ[ªi_j_ba^Zggmxih^j_^Zdpb
_cZe-DZmkZjb657<wlhcdgb]_gZkhg^Z_lke_^mxsbckh
\_l ©BamqZc hkgh\gh_ b qZklgh_ eh]bdm fm^jhklv nbehkh
nbx b^_b jZggbo mq_guo gh \k_]^Z ijb^_j`b\Zcky DhjZgZ
kmggu b ijbgpbih\ aZeh`_gguo kZeZnZfb B y gZ^_xkv qlh
B[gL_cfbyhl\_j]hq_gvfgh]b_^hklh\_jgu_oZ^bku
BfZfZa-AZoZ[bg_ij_m\_ebqb\Z_l\_^vhg\k\h_\j_fy[uemq_gbdhf
B[gL_cfbbbagZ_lkmlv_]hm[_`^_gbcbfZg_ju
657
Ik_\^hkZeZnbluhq_gvkbevghg_gZ\b^ylwlh]hq_eh\_dZ
655
656
299
lh]^Zklh[hcg_ijhbahc^_llhqlhijhbahrehkB[gL_cfb_c
Hg himklbeky ^h lh]h qlh gZqZe hlj_dZlvky h[\bgylv \ g_\_
jbb b e`b Z \_^v ^h wlh]h hg [ue q_eh\_dhf ijhgbaZgguf
k\_lhfGhdkh`Ze_gbxwlhlk\_lihf_jdª
DZd \b^bl_ m\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev bfZf Za-AZoZ[b [_j_l
mjhdbba`bagbB[gL_cfbbbij_^hkl_j_]Z_lrZdbj^h\qlh
[uhgbg_himklbebkv^hlZdh]hmjh\gy
=eZ\Z\hkvfZy
Kd_f^jm`Zl\ZooZ[blu"
K_dlZ \ZooZ[blh\ \jZ`^_[gZ dh \k_f fmkmevfZgkdbf
^\b`_gbyfihbofg_gbx\_jgufy\ey_lkylhevdhimlvik_\
^hkZeZnbafZBf_gghihwlhfmbamqZybobklhjbx\ufh`_l_
m\b^_lv dZd fgh]h hgb \h_\Zeb k fmkmevfZgZfb h[\bgyeb \
g_\_jbbbjZkimlkl\_fmkmevfZgkdbomq_guoGhijbwlhfhgb
hq_gv ^jm`_kl\_ggu ih hlghr_gbx d bm^_yf b ojbklbZgZf
Wlb ex^b fbehk_j^gu d g_\_jguf b `_klhdb d fmkmevfZgZf
<kihfgbl_ oZ^bku \ dhlhjuo Ijhjhd k]k ]h\hjbe ©«hgb
[m^ml m[b\Zlv fmkmevfZg«ª ©«hgb g_ ijbdhkgmlky d yauq
gbdZf«ª©«hgb[m^mll\hjblvf_jadb_^_ygby«ªBf_gghh[
wlhffubih]h\hjbf\wlhfjZa^_e_
IjbagZgby
?s_ \q_jZ f_q \ZooZ[blh\ ij_ke_^h\Ze fmkmevfZg k_
]h^gy wlbf aZgbfZ_lky bo yaud <ZooZ[blu k ihfhsvx bgl_
e_dlmZevguo kj_^kl\ ij_ke_^mxl fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo k_]h
^gy ^ey lh]h qlh[u h[ty\blv ^ha\he_gghc bo djh\v aZ\ljZ
R_co OZeb^ [bg OZfb^ Ze-=ZkdZeygb \ dgb]_ ©:j-Jm^m^ ZkkZeZnby]Zey^m]ZlZk-kZeZnbyª658lkihwlhfmih\h^m
ibr_l©Ohq_lkyh[jZlblv\gbfZgb_gZhlghr_gb_gZrbo[jZ
lv_\ kZeZnblh\ d gZrbf [jZlvyf \ :e`bj_ KZeZnblu \gbfZ
WlZdgb]ZjZkijhkljZg_gZ\OZeb^`_ghihihgylgufijbqbgZf\g_cg_
mdZaZghgZa\Zgb_ba^Zl_evkdh]h^hfZ<dgb]_Z\lhjhl\_qZ_lgZg_dhlhju_
e_dpbb \ZooZ[blh\ ba^Zggu_ gZ Zm^bh-dZkk_lZo bgZ^\_dgb]b©NbdoZe\Zdb] [ZcgZ Zg-gZaZjby \Z Zl-lZl[bdª b ©Jmy \Zdb]by nb Ze-fZgZob^` Z^^Z]Z\byª
658
300
l_evghke_^ylaZbo^_ckl\byfbghgbh^bgbagbog_hlf_lbe
bo mki_oh\ hgb h[jZsZxl \gbfZgb_ lhevdh gZ hrb[db \lh
juo659 GZijbf_j hgb aZy\eyxl ©>_fhgkljZpbb b mqZklb_ \
f_klguo \u[hjZo aZij_sZxlkyª : fh`_l [ulv \f_klh wlh]h
ke_^m_lijhklhihfhqvk\hbf[jZlvyf"G_lgZh[hjhl\ZooZ[b
lu]hlh\ubfgZ\j_^blvbf_gghihwlhfmhgbh[\bgbebr_coZ
=Z[[ZkZ Ze-FZ^Zgb jmdh\h^bl_ey ©NjhglZ kiZk_gbyª \ lhf
qlh hg [_j_l \ayldb JZkkdZau\Zxl qlh \h \j_fy h^ghc ba _]h
\klj_q k fheh^ufb kZeZnblZfb jZa]hj_eky kihj ih ih\h^m
ijh^\b`_gby ij_^klZ\bl_e_c ©;jZlv_\-fmkmevfZgª gZ ]hkm
^Zjkl\_ggu_ ihklu h^gb aZy\eyeb qlh wlh ijbg_k_l ihevam
BkeZfm^jm]b_ml\_j`^Zebqlhwlhijbg_k_l\j_^:eeZok\yl
g_lkbeubfh]ms_kl\Zgbmdh]hdjhf_G_]hJZa\_fh`ghih
^h[gufh[jZahfjZkkm`^Zlvh\Zrbo[jZlvyo\:e`bj_"<Zrb
keh\Z mdZau\Zxl ebrv gZ nZgZlbaf `_eZgb_ ijbgZ^e_`Zlv d
dhgdj_lghc iZjlbb aZsbsZlv bgl_j_ku hl^_evgh]h ^\b`_gby
:]^_`_lh]^Zf_klhbkeZfkdhfm[jZlkl\m"Ijbg_k_leblZdZy
ihabpbyihevambkeZfkdhfmijbau\mb\hajh`^_gbx"Ohq_lky
hlf_lblvqlh[jZlvykZeZnblubkZfb_s_g_hij_^_ebebkvkh
k\h_cihabpb_cbf_gghihwlhfmh^gbaZij_sZxlkha^Zgb_fm
kmevfZgkdboiZjlbcbmqZklb_\gboZ^jm]b_gZh[hjhlaZy\
eyxlhg_h[oh^bfhklbwlh]hH^gbaZij_sZxl[Zeehlbjh\Zlvky
gZ\u[hjZo\iZjeZf_glbjZaebqgu_]hkm^Zjkl\_ggu_hj]Zgu
Z ^jm]b_ aZy\eyxl h g_h[oh^bfhklb wlh]h QZklv kZeZnblh\
djbqZlh[Zf_jbdZgkdhfaZ]h\hj_^jm]b_`_gZau\Zxl_]h[h
`_kl\_gguf bkiulZgb_f KeurZ \k_ wlh y ohqm kdZaZlv ³<u
k\hbfb `_ jmdZfb m`_ ih]m[beb kZeZnbaf lZdh_ hsms_gb_
qlh \u k]h\hjbebkv g_ h[t_^bgylvky´ª >Ze__ gZ k hg ib
r_l ©;hevrbgkl\h ik_\^hkZeZnblh\ kqblZ_l ^ha\he_gguf
DZd gb ]hjvdh wlh keurZlv kZeZnblu-\ZooZ[blu kZfb ijbagZxlky \
m[bckl\Zo fmkmevfZg :e`bjZ h^bg ba jmdh\h^bl_e_c ©<hhjm`_ggh]h bk
eZfkdh]hnjhglZª\bgl_j\vxEhg^hgkdhc]Za_l_©:e-OZyªhl]k
aZy\be©Ba\_klghqlh©<hhjm`_ggucbkeZfkdbcnjhglªijb^_j`b\Z_l
ky kZeZnblkdhc Zdu^u b ba[bjZ_l kZeZnblkdb_ ijb_fu b kj_^kl\Z Hg g_
ijbfbjbf \ hlghr_gbb rbblh\ Hgb ijbagZxlky \_jhhlklmigbdZfb \u
klmib\rbfbijhlb\rZjbZlZª
659
301
ij_iylkl\h\Zlv b gZahceb\h \j_^blv fmkmevfZgkdbf mq_guf
ijhiZ]Zg^bklZf b \h`^yf jZaebqguo fmkmevfZgkdbo ^\b`_
gbcBf_gghihwlhfmhgbex[ylh[jmrb\ZlvkygZgbokdjblb
dhcª
<u aZf_lbeb qlh ik_\^hkZeZnblu ba[jZeb lZdlbdm hi
ihabpbhgbjh\Zgby \ hlghr_gbb \k_o fmkmevfZgkdbo gZqbgZ
gbcIhwlhfm\iheg_eh]bqghqlhmfmkmevfZgihy\ey_lky\h
ijhk Z fh`_l [ulv kZeZnbaf bkihevam_lky ki_pbZevgh ^ey
jZajmr_gbyBkeZfZbagmljb"Fh`_l[ulvih^ebqbghcaZsblu
Zdu^udjh_lky`_eZgb___mgbqlh`blv"
<ZooZ[blubbkeZfkdb_^\b`_gby
<ZooZ[blu ijhy\eyxl hldjulmx \jZ`^m \ hlghr_gbb
\k_o fmkmevfZgkdbo b^_c Hgb ijhlb\gbdb q_luj_o fZaoZ[h\
Bf_ggh hgb h[ty\beb h g_\_jbb oZgZnblZ Ze-DZmkZjb rZnb
]blZ Zk-Km[db oZg[ZeblZ B[g Ze->`Z\ab Iha^g__ hgb \uklm
ibeb ijhlb\ i_j_^h\uo b^_c lZdbo fmkmevfZgkdbo fukebl_
e_cdZdFmoZffZ^:[^hbfZffmjrb^OZkZgZe-;ZggZrZob^
K_b^ Ze-Dml[ b hklZevguo Hgb kljh]h ke_^mxl ijbf_jm B[g
Ze-DZcbfZ aZy\b\r_]h ©Fu ^he`gu hldjulh \jZ`^h\Zlv k
l_fb dlh hljbpZ_l wlh«660ª Ih^ hljbpZgb_f B[g Ze-DZcbf
bf__l \ \b^m hljbpZgb_ Zgljhihfhnbklkdhc ljZdlh\db k\y
s_gguo l_dklh\ k rbjhdbf kfukehf Wlb mq_gu_ ljZdlh\Zeb
mihfygmlu_ k\ys_ggu_ l_dklu g_ \ ijyfhf kfuke_ Z \ i_j_
Kf_]hihwfm©:r-RZnbynbZe-bglbkZjebenbjdZZg-gZ^`byª<wlhc
ihwf_hgbaeZ]Z_lmq_gb_k\h_]hmqbl_eyB[gL_cfbb<hl\_lgZwlmihwfm
:k-Km[db gZibkZe dgb]m ©:k-KZcn Zk-kZdue nb Zj-jZ^^ ]Zey B[g AZnbeª
gZ k :k-Km[db ibr_l ©Lhl dlh hlau\Z_lky h fmkmevfZgZo ih^h[guf
h[jZahf aZkem`b\Z_l lhevdh f_qZª LZdZy ihabpby oZrZ\blh\ g_ y\ey_lky
k_dj_lhfgZijbf_jba\_klgucoZrZ\blkdbcr_coZe-OZkZg[bgZe-=Z[[Zk
Zj-Jmklmfb h dhlhjhf Za-AZoZ[b \ ©Kbyj Z]eyf Zg-gm[Zeyª l k ibkZe©Hg[uekebrdhf`_klhd\hlghr_gbbkmgguªlh_klvba[jZeijbg
pbimih^h[e_gbybZgljhihfhjnbaZpbb\k\h_fklbohl\hj_gbboZjZdl_jb
am_l ZrZjblh\ ke_^mxsbf h[jZahf ©:rZjblu – aZ[em^rb_ _j_lbdb hgb
ih^h[gu l_f dlh ihdehgyeky Ze-EZlm b Ze-=maa_ hgb hldjulh aZy\eyxl h
k\h_fg_\_jbb\=hkih^ZaZ^mfZcl_kvgZ^boj_qZfbHgbhljbpZxsb_Wlb
ex^b\_jgmebkvd\_j_k\hboijZhlph\ª
660
302
ghkghfkkh[ex^_gb_f\k_olj_[h\ZgbcZjZ[kdh]hyaudZnjZ
a_heh]bbbklbebklbdb
<ZooZ[blu \jZ`^_[gu dh \k_f fmkmevfZgkdbf l_q_gb
yfR_coKZebo[bgNZmaZgZe-NZmaZgi_j_qbkeyy\jZ]h\\Zo
oZ[bafZ ibr_l ©< gZklhys__ \j_fy fu i_j_`b\Z_f i_jbh^
dh]^ZdgZfih^fZkdbjh\dhcfmkmevfZgkdh]hijbau\Zijhgb
dZxl jZaebqgu_ eh`gu_ ^\b`_gby Hgb bf_xl jZaebqgu_ gZ
a\Zgby gZijbf_j ©Bo\Zg fmkebfbgª ©;jZlvy-fmkmevfZg_ª
©:l-LZ[eb]ª b ^j Hgb ijbdju\Zxlky ehamg]Zfb \hajh`^_gby
fmkmevfZgkdh]h ijbau\Z gZ kZfhf `_ ^_e_ ij_ke_^mxl _^bg
kl\_ggmxp_ev–mgbqlh`_gb_BkeZfZ?kebwlhg_lZdlhih
q_fm hgb ihdb^Zxl k\hb kljZgu b _^ml d gZf g_m`_eb fu
[hevr_gm`^Z_fky\ijbau\_q_fbokhie_f_ggbdb"Hgbijb
[u\Zxl d gZf qlh[u bkdZablv gZr qbkluc ijbau\ \\_klb \
aZ[em`^_gb_gZrmfheh^_`vihk_ylvkfmlmb\jZ`^mHgb\b
^yl_^bgkl\hgZrbofmkmevfZgkdbo]hkm^Zjkl\bijZ\bl_evkl\
b`_eZxljZajmrblvwlh_^bgkl\h«661ªDZd\b^bl_\ZooZ[blu
kqblZxl qlh `b\ml \ oZebnZl_ qlh `_ dZkZ_lky hklZevguo
^\b`_gbc\jh^_©;jZlv_\-fmkmevfZgªlhhgbhrb[Zxlkyih
kdhevdm[ueb\\_^_gu\aZ[em`^_gb_lZdbfbex^vfbdZdOZ
kZgZe-;ZggZ662LhqghlZd`_hgbhlghkylkybd^jm]bf^\b`_
gbyf
Kh\j_f_ggh_ \ZooZ[blkdh_ ^\b`_gb_ \ k\h_c [hjv[_
ijhlb\ fmkmevfZgkdbo l_q_gbc bkihevah\Zeh jZaebqgu_ imlb
GZijbf_j \ [hjv[_ ijhlb\ ©;jZlv_\-fmkmevfZgª \ -o ]h^Zo
\_dZhgbbkihevah\Zebg_ijbyagv>`ZfZey=Z[^mggZkujZd
wlhciZjlbb>_eZebkvihiuldbih^qbgblvk_[_r_coZFmoZf
fZ^Z Dml[Z FmoZffZ^Z Ze-=ZaZeb dh]^Z `_ hgb g_ ^Zeb j_
amevlZlh\663 \ZooZ[blu gZqZeb ba^Z\Zlv dgb]b \ dhlhjuo ih
KZ]^[bg=Z[^jZofZgZe-OmkZbg©Z^->Z]\ZbeyeeZo<ZfZbolZkkZl[bob
^`ZajblZZe-]ZjZ[\ZlZd\bffZgZob^`Z^-^Z]\ZZe-\Znb^ZbeycoZª
662
KZebf Ze-Obeyeb KZ]b^ OZ\\Z ©Ze-Bo\Zg Ze-fmkebfmg ^`ZfZ]Zl Zefmkebfbgª–K
663
R_co FmoZffZ^ Dml[ \uklmiZy \ ] \ h^ghf ba hl_e_c DZlZjZ k
e_dpb_cgZl_fm©DhjZg–_^bgkl\_ggucimlv\hajh`^_gbygZr_cpb\beb
aZpbbªbdjblbdmy\a]ey^u\ZooZ[blh\hlhfqlh]j_rgbdbijh\_^ml\:^m
661
303
ghkbeb wlbo ex^_c < qZklghklb \ dgb]_ ©:e-Bo\Zg ZefmkebfmgnbZe-fbaZgªhgb\uklmibebkdjblbdhcKZb^ZDml
[ZZe-=ZaZebb:[mZe-:eyZe-FZm^m^b>Z`_OZkZgZe-;ZggZ
ijbau\Z\rbc d h[t_^bg_gbx jZaebqguo fmkmevfZgkdbo ^\b
`_gbcih^\_j]kybodjblbd_
Djhf_lh]hqlh[uihk_ylvjhagvkj_^bfmkmevfZgbhk
eZ[blvbo_^bgkl\h\ZooZ[blugZqZebkha^Z\Zlv\fmkmevfZg
kdbo kljZgZo k\hb p_glju Z lZd`_ hdZau\Zlv fZl_jbZevgmx
ih^^_j`dml_fhj]ZgbaZpbyfdhlhju_k_yebg_gZ\bklvbjhagv
\fmkmevfZgkdhfh[s_kl\_Ohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhwlhl\hijhk
\hh[s_ gm`^Z_lky \ [he__ ^_lZevghf b ]em[hdhf bkke_^h\Z
gbb
<deZ^\ZooZ[blh\\hkgh\Zgb_BajZbey
<\_^_gb_
<ZooZ[blub\ZooZ[bafy\eyxlky^_lbs_fojbklbZgkdh[jblZgkdhc jZa\_^db p_evx dhlhjhc [ueh hl\e_qv \gbfZgb_
fmkmevfZg hl ^_ckl\bl_evgh \Z`guo b gZkmsguo ijh[e_f
Bf_ggh ihwlhfm \ZooZ[blu g_kdhevdh jZa ij_^Zeb fmkmevfZg
b\qZklghklbhdZaZebmkem]mkbhgbafmhjm^h\Z\r_fmjmdZfb
Zg]ebqZg \ aZo\Zl_ iZe_klbgkdbo a_f_ev B ohq_lky hlf_lblv
qlhk\hc\deZ^\wlh\g_kebg_lhevdhijZ\bl_eb-\ZooZ[blugh
bbomq_gu_hgb^_ckl\h\ZebjmdZh[jmdm
<ZooZ[blu–hjm`b_ojbklbZg
Ihke_lh]hdZd\ZooZ[bluihijhkv[_Zg]ebqZgba]gZeb
rZjbnblZOmk_cgZb_]hkugZIZe_klbgZ[ueZi_j_^ZgZbm^_
yf<]gZdhgn_j_gpbbh©IjZ\beZomijZ\e_gbyl_jjblh
jbyfbOb^`ZaZªfmkmevfZgkdbfbkljZgZfb[ueih^gyl\hijhk
h g_h[oh^bfhklb hqbklblv IZe_klbgm Kbjbx BjZd b ih[_j_
`vy:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Zhlbgha_fgh]hijbkmlkl\by\Zo
oZ[blu`_gZklhyebgZlhfqlh[uwlhl\hijhk[uekgylkih\_
kldb^gy
hq_gvg_ijh^he`bl_evgh_\j_fyij_^hkl_j_]fmkmevfZghlih^h[guo\ha
aj_gbckdZaZ\qlhhgbijbkmsbbm^_yf
304
<deZ^\ZooZ[blh\\mgbqlh`_gb_HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbb
<ZooZ[blu\g_kebk\hc\deZ^b\mgbqlh`_gb_oZebnZ
lZ\h-i_j\uohgbjZkrZlu\ZebfmkmevfZgkdh__^bgkl\hbagm
ljb Z \h-\lhjuo kihkh[kl\h\Zeb ijhgbdgh\_gbx ojbklbZg b
bm^__\\wlhlj_]bhg
JZkrZlu\Zgb_ fmkmevfZgkdh]h _^bgkl\Z aZdexqZehkv \
lhf qlh \ZooZ[blu \h_\Zeb ijhlb\ HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb b l_o
ijZ\bl_e_c dhlhju_ __ ih^^_j`b\Zeb >hklZlhqgh lh]h qlh
\ZooZ[blu\h\j_fy[bl\uijhlb\rZjbnblZFZk]m^Z[bgYovb
[bg;ZjZdZlZ664m[beb^\_lukyqbq_luj_klZkhe^Zl-fmkmevfZg
HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbb
Ihfhsv ojbklbZgZf b bm^_yf \ ijhgbdgh\_gbb \ j_]b
hg aZdexqZeZkv \ lhf qlh hgb hl\e_deb \hckdZ :e JZrb^Z
dh]^Z Zg]ebqZg_ \lhj]ebkv \ ;Zkjm b ohq_lky hlf_lblv qlh
[jblZgpuijbagZxlwlhlnZdlhnbpbZevgh665Djhf_lh]hk\h
bfbgZ[_]Zfbb\hcgZfbhgbhl\e_dZebrZjbnblh\qlhlZd`_
kihkh[kl\h\ZehdhehgbaZpbbfmkmevfZgkdbokljZgke_^kl\b_f
dhlhjhc klZe aZo\Zl IZe_klbgu kbhgbklZfb H[jZlbl_kv d
^g_\gbdZf OZbfZ <_cpfZgZ dhlhjuc ibr_l ©Fu g_ kfh`_f
aZ\eZ^_lv IZe_klbghc ^h l_o ihj ihdZ kms_kl\m_l HkfZgkdZy
bfi_jby ihwlhfm \ [hjv[_ k g_c fu ^he`gu bkihevah\Zlv
;jblZgbxª HkfZgkdZy bfi_jby jmogmeZ b k\hc \deZ^ \ wlh
\g_keb\ZooZ[blubkdj_ggb_666kem]bojbklbZgbkbhgbklh\
B[g;ZrZj©=mg\ZgZe-fZ^`^«ª- 1/113.
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZZe-]ZjZ[byª–K
666
Ba\_klgh qlh \ZooZ[blu \\hcg_ijhlb\HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbbbkihevah
\Zeb \k_ \hafh`gu_ kj_^kl\Z :\lhj ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^«ª fgh]h ibr_l h
lhf dZd \ZooZ[blu m[b\Zeb lmjdh\ gZijbf_j kf l k – H^bg ba
\ZooZ[blkdbo\h`^_c\k\h_fibkvf_drZjbnblm=Z[^mee_[bgZe-Omk_cgm
hl]ibr_l©DZ`^ucq_eh\_diZljbhlbqghgZkljh_ggucdk\h_c
j_eb]bbbZjZ[kdhfmijhbkoh`^_gbx^he`_g\_klb^`boZ^ijhlb\lmjdh\
\_^vbf_gghhgbk_]h^gyy\eyxlkyae_crbfb\jZ]ZfbBkeZfZbZjZ[h\ª:
Zg]ebqZg_ hdZaZebkv ^jmavyfb BkeZfZ kf GZkuj Ze-NZjZ^` ©Dbyf Ze]mrZjZk-KZ]m^byªK–Ihwlhfm-lhgZkk_]h^gybm^b\eyxlaZy\e_
gbykh\j_f_gguo\ZooZ[blh\hlhfqlhhgbg_\h_\ZebkHkfZgkdhcbfi_
jb_c
664
665
305
Mkuieyy \gbfZgb_ fmkmevfZg \ZooZ[blu kem`Zl ojbk
lbZgZfbbm^_yf
<]\IZe_klbg_\kiuogmeh\hkklZgb_ijhlb\[jb
lZgp_\ dhlhju_ ih^]hlZ\eb\Zeb ihq\m ^ey i_j_^Zqb wlbo a_
f_evbm^_yf-kbhgbklZf<ZooZ[bluba^_kvj_rbebihfhqvZg
]ebqZgZfqlh[umkuiblv[^bl_evghklvfmkmevfZgbmkihdhblv
\hkklZgb_ ]eZ\u \ZooZ[blh\ gZibkZeb iZe_klbgkdbf fmkmev
fZgZf ibkvfh-\haa\Zgb_ ©GZrbf [jZlvyf-ZjZ[Zf \ IZe_klb
g_Fuhq_gvkbevghi_j_`b\Z_faZ\Zkbih^^_j`b\Z_fihab
pbx ZjZ[kdbo ijZ\bl_e_c b \ qZklghklb wfbjZ =Z[^meeu <
k\yabkwlbffuijbau\Z_f\Zkdkihdhckl\bxhklZgh\bl_\hk
klZgb_b^Zcl_\hafh`ghklv[jblZgkdbf\eZklyf\hkklZgh\blv
kijZ\_^eb\hklvih\he_:eeZoZ<_jvl_fu\k_]^Z[m^_fih^
^_j`b\Zlv\Zkª
<blh]_ijbau\ZiheZ]ZlvkygZZg]ebqZgbgZ:eeZoZiZ
e_klbgkdb_fmkmevfZg_jZa^_ebebkvgZ^\ZeZ]_jyh^gbkh]eZ
kbebkv k wlbf \haa\Zgb_f ^jm]b_ – g_l gh ihkl_i_ggh \k_
kdehgbebkvdfg_gbxkh]eZkb\rboky
<ZooZ[blug_h]jZgbqbebkvwlbf\haa\Zgb_fZijbkeZ
eb d jmdh\h^ys_c \_jomrd_ iZe_klbgp_\ k\hx ^_e_]Zpbx dh
lhjmx lZcgh \ha]eZ\eye >`hg Nbebiib <ZooZ[blu h[jZlb
ebkv d gbf kh keh\Zfb ©«gZkdhevdh gZf ba\_klgh m [jblZg
p_\ g_l `_eZgby \Zk h[fZgmlv hgb \ k\h_ \j_fy h[_sZeb gZ
rbf jh^bl_eyf j_rblv iZe_klbgkdmx ijh[e_fmª Gh iZe_k
lbgpu ihgyeb qlh p_evx \ZooZ[blh\ [ueh ih]Zkblv ieZfy
^`boZ^Z ihwlhfm ihwl =Z[^jZobf FZofm^ bf hl\_lbe ©>ey
q_]h \u ijbreb" Qlh[u ihk_lblv f_q_lv Ze-:dkZ beb `_ ^ey
lh]h qlh[u ihijhsZlvky k g_c" G_m`_eb \u kh[bjZ_l_kv ijh
^Zlvwlmk\ylugx\_^vaZ\ljZmgZkg_hklZg_lkygbq_]hdjhf_
ke_a"ª
Mgb`_gb_iZe_klbgkdhc^_e_]Zpbb
Iha^g__iZe_klbgkdZy^_e_]Zpbyijb[ueZdjmdh\h^bl_
eyf \ZooZ[blkdh]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z b ijb\_aeZ k kh[hc ebklh\db
qlh[u^h\_klb^hex^_ciheh`_gb_iZe_klbgkdh]hgZjh^ZGh
306
\ZooZ[bluaZij_lbebjZkijhkljZgylvwlbebklh\dbb\_e_ebbo
k`_qv
<ZooZ[bluijh^ZxlIZe_klbgm
<ZooZ[blum`_ba^Z\gZ[ueb]hlh\uijh^ZlvIZe_klbgm
bm^_yf<h\j_fydhgn_j_gpbb]]\Ze-BokZjmdh
\h^bl_ev \ZooZ[blkdhc ^_e_]Zpbb ihh[_sZe [jblZgpZf ke_^m
xs__ ©Y lukyqm jZa ]hlh\ aZy\blv gZr_fm ^jm]m kwjm I_jkb
Dhdkm iheghfhqghfm ij_^klZ\bl_ex ;jblZgbb qlh i_j_^ gZ
fbg_lgbdZdboij_]jZ^fu]hlh\ui_j_^ZlvIZe_klbgmbm^_yf
beb dhfm-eb[h ^jm]hfm \ aZ\bkbfhklb hl lh]h q_]h ih`_eZ_l
[jblZgkdZy klhjhgZ Fu ]hlh\u kem`blv ;jblZgbb \iehlv ^h
Km^gh]h ^gyª667 Ibkvf_ggu_ ^hdmf_glu wlhc dhgn_j_gpbb
[ueb ih^ibkZgu dhjhe_f =Z[^me]Zabahf ] \ ZaAZojZg ijb[ue Bjebo ih\_j_gguc ;_g =mjbhgZ _]h \klj_lbe
gZke_^gbd ij_klheZ NZckZe p_evx _]h ijb_a^Z [ueh ijh^e_
gb_ ^\mklhjhggbo ^h]h\hjh\ Ijbf_jgh \ lh `_ \j_fy \ZooZ
[blkdZy^_e_]Zpby\ha]eZ\ey_fZy>`hghfNbebiib668ijb[u
eZ\Ehg^hg^eymqZklby\dhgn_j_gpbb©<ha\jZs_gb_bm^__\
gZa_fexh[_lh\ZggmxIZe_klbgmª<h\j_fywlhcdhgn_j_g
pbbNbebiib\g_kij_^eh`_gb_hk\h[h^blv\k_ZjZ[kdb_kljZ
gu669 hl dhehgbZevgh]h j_`bfZ \ h[f_g gZ i_j_^Zqm \k_c IZ
e_klbgubm^_yf
Jmdh\h^be wlbf ijh_dlhf r_co =Z[^meeZ Nbebiib dhlhjuc iha^g__
ijbagZekyqlh[jblZgkdZyjZa\_^dZieZlbeZ]eZ\_\ZooZ[blkdh]h]hkm^Zjkl
\Zih^`mg_coh\_`_f_kyqghZdh]^Z\ZooZ[blu\]wdkljZ^bjh\Z
eb_]hbakljZguhg]jhabekyjZkdjulvwlmlZcgm\k_fmfbjm:jk_jEhjb
ihkhe BajZbey \ Ehg^hg_ lZd`_ ijbagZeky qlh \ZooZ[blZf [ueZ ij_^eh
`_gZ\ayldZ\jZaf_j_fbeebhgh\^heeZjh\ijbq_fOZbf<_cpfZgebqgh
agZeh[wlhf
668
Nbebiib hq_gv ^he]h_ \j_fy bkihegye h[yaZgghklb fbgbkljZ \g_rgbo
^_e DK: \ lh `_ \j_fy gZqbgZy k e_l hg ]hlh\be d wlhc ^he`ghklb
ijbgpZNZckZeZ
669
KfNbebiib©Khjhde_lgZ:jZ\bckdhfihemhkljh\_ªOZcjbOZffZ^
©:]fb^Zl Ze-bklb]fZjª GZkuj Zk-KZ]b^ ©LZjbo :e KZ]m^ª :[m Ze-=Zey
Zl-LZd\b©:e-NbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ªGZkujZe-NZjZ^`©Db
yfZe-]mrZjZk-KZ]m^byª–K
667
307
H]jZgbq_gby
Ihke_ \lhjhc fbjh\hc \hcgu \ ZjZ[kdhf h[s_kl\_ gZ
qZebkeurZlvky]hehkZlj_[mxsb_hkm^blvih^^_j`dmhdZau
\Z_fmxZf_jbdZgpZfb_\j_yf\hl\_lgZwlhZ\]mklZ]
\eZklbDK:gZijZ\bebZdlb\bklZfwlh]h^\b`_gbyl_e_]jZffm
\dhlhjhc]h\hjbehkv©«^hgZk^hrebk\_^_gbyqlh]jZ`^Z
gZfbZjZ[kdbo]hkm^Zjkl\\ukdZau\Zxlkyb^_bhg_h[oh^bfhk
lbkha^Zgbyhj]ZgbaZpbbdhlhjZyaZcf_lkyjZaj_r_gb_fiZe_
klbgkdhcijh[e_fuFukqblZ_fqlhwlhg_ijbg_k_lgbdZdhc
ihevauHq_f\u[m^_l_jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv\h\j_fyk\hbodhgn_
j_gpbc"Fh`_l[ulvaZdexqbl_dZdb_-eb[h^h]h\hjuZfh`_l
[ulvh[ty\bl_\hcgm"Fuij_^eZ]Z_fgZijZ\blv^\hbo^_e_]Z
lh\ ZjZ[kdbo kljZg h^gbf ba gbo [m^_l =Z[^jZofZg =ZaaZf
qlh[uhgb\uklmibeb\KR:\dZq_kl\_ij_^klZ\bl_e_cb\u
kdZaZeb[uk\hbih`_eZgbyih^Zgghfm\hijhkmªI_j_^hlt_a
^hf=Z[^jZofZgZ=ZaaZfZ\KR:\eZklbDK:^Zebk\h_kh]eZ
kb_gZba^Zgb_]Za_luZjZ[kdbfmgb\_jkbl_lhfh^gZdhihkh\_
lh\Zebdhjj_kihg^_glZfg_djblbdh\ZlvZf_jbdZgp_\bZg]eb
qZg©Fuijhkbf\Zrbo`mjgZebklh\qlh[uhgb[ueb[_kijb
kljZklgu g_ djblbdh\Zeb Zg]ebqZg b Zf_jbdZgp_\ GZh[hjhl
imklv hgb bsml ^h\h^u ^hdZau\Zxsb_ kijZ\_^eb\hklv wlb
ex^_c b fu gZ^__fkyqlhih\he_:eeZoZwlhijb\_^_ldih
eh`bl_evgufj_amevlZlZfª670.
K_b^ Dml[ \ ] \ `mjgZe_ ©:j-JbkZeZª ih wlhfm ih\h^m \ klZlv_
©GZklZeq_j_^ZjZ[h\dZd`_hgbihklmiyl"ªgZibkZe©Kj_^bgZkkebrdhf
fgh]h ©mfguo ex^_cª kh\_lmxsbo g_ ki_rblv b ba[bjZlv ©fbjgu_ imlb
jZaj_r_gby ijh[e_fª Hgb ml\_j`^Zxl qlh \ wlhf kemqZ_ fu khojZgbf h
k_[_ ohjhr__ fg_gb_ \ ]eZaZo pb\bebah\Zggh]h lh _klv aZiZ^gh_\jhi_ckdh]h fbjZ Gh q_]h `_ fu ^hklb]eb \ j_amevlZl_ ihklhyggh]h
h`b^Zgby"ª >Ze__ mihfygm\ mgb`_gby hg ijh^he`Z_l ©Ihke_ wlh]h gZ
klZe q_j_^ _\j_ckdbo l_jjhjbklh\ dhlhju_ gZqZeb jZa]h\Zjb\Zlv k Zg]eb
qZgZfb gZ _^bgkl\_ggh ihgylghf bf yaud_ Lh]^Z gZrb ©mq_gu_ fm`bª
aZy\beb ©HklZ\vl_ \k_ dZd _klv Imklv _\j_b ijh^he`Zxl k\hc l_jjhj <
dhg_qghf blh]_ hgb ihl_jyxl kbfiZlbb pb\bebah\Zggh]h fbjZ Z fu gZ
h[hjhlijbh[j_l_fboª<blh]_ijhbahrehh[jZlgh_KR:\klZebgZklh
jhgm _\j__\ iha\hebeb bf [_kij_iylkl\_ggh i_j_k_eylvky k IZe_klbgm b
ij_^eh`beb kha^Zlv dhfbkkbx dhlhjZy aZcf_lky jZkke_^h\Zgb_f ij_klmi
670
308
Mgb`_gb_
<ZooZ[blug_ij_^ijbgyebgbdZdbof_j^eylh]hqlh[u
ij_^hl\jZlblvjZa^_e_gb_IZe_klbgu?keb[uhgbijb]jhabeb
ij_djZlblvihklZ\dbg_nlblhdhg_qgh`_fbj\klZe[ugZbo
klhjhgmh^gZdhwlhg_[uehk^_eZgh<ghf_j__]bi_lkdh]h
`mjgZeZ©:objmkZ]ZlbgªhlfZy]iZe_klbgkdbc`mj
gZebkl b ibkZl_ev :[m AZdZjb gZibkZe ©L_i_jv gZklZe q_j_^
KR: hgb j_rbeb ih^_eblv IZe_klbgm f_`^m _\j_yfb b ZjZ
[Zfb G_dhlhju_ ij_^klZ\bl_eb ZjZ[kdhc ^_e_]Zpbb `_eZeb
ihf_rZlv wlhfm g_dlh wfbj =Z^be :jkeZ kdZaZe ^_e_]ZlZf
©I_j_^\Zfbhq_gv\u]h^guc^hdmf_glgh\u[hbl_kvaZb]ju
\Zlv k gbfª Z h^ghfm ba \ZooZ[blh\ hg aZy\be ©?keb [u \u
hlijZ\bebkv d fbgbkljm \g_rgbo ^_e KR: b ijb]jhabeb [u
ij_djZlblv ihklZ\db g_nlb lh \_kv dhg]j_kk \klZe [u gZ klh
jhgm ZjZ[h\ª :jZ[u gZdZaZeb wlhc ^_e_]Zpbb aZsbsZlv k\hb
bgl_j_kuGh__]eZ\Zh[fZggufiml_fm[_^be\k_oqe_gh\^_
e_]Zpbb\lhfqlhKR:ijhlb\jZa^_eZIZe_klbguQe_gu^_
e_]Zpbb\_jy\lhqlhboij_^\h^bl_evy\ey_lky[ebadbf^jm
]hf >`hj^`Z <Z^ahjlZ kh\_lgbdZ Zf_jbdZgkdhc ^_e_]Zpbb
ihke_^h\Zeb_]hkh\_lmª
Djhf_lh]h^_e_]ZpbbZjZ[kdbokljZggZijZ\beb\klh
ebpm DK: l_e_]jZffm k ij_^eh`_gb_f hdZaZlv ^Z\e_gb_ gZ
KR:ihh[_sZ\ij_djZlblvihklZ\dbg_nlbGhhllm^Zijbr_e
hl\_l©FuklhbfgZaZsbl_ijZ\Zf_jbdZgp_\ihkdhevdmDh
jZgh[yaZegZkdwlhfmª
Ihiuldb\ZooZ[blh\hk\h[h^blvIZe_klbgm
<h\j_fy\hcguaZhk\h[h`^_gb_IZe_klbgugZqZ\r_c
kyfZy]\eZklbDK:gZijZ\bebhl^hk\hbog_
h[mq_gguo khe^Zl qlh[u hgb \h_\Zeb gZ klhjhg_ fmkmevfZg
H^gZdh b wlh g_[hevrh_ ih^jZa^_e_gb_ g_ kfh]eh ihiZklv gZ
e_gbcbj_r_gb_fwlhcijh[e_fu:jZ[ugZqZeb\hafmsZlvkygh©fm^j_
puªkdZaZeb³G_ki_rbl_\hkklZ\Zlvimklvwlb]emipu_\j_b^_eZxlk\h_
^_ehimklvijh^he`Zxll_jjhjfu`_k\ZfbaZkem`bfkbfiZlbbpb\beb
ah\Zggh]h fbjZ´ª L_i_jv \u ihgbfZ_l_ ihq_fm wlb ©fm^ju_ª \ZooZ[blu
g_gZ\b^_ebK_b^ZDml[Z"
309
ihe_ kjZ`_gby ihkdhevdm dhjhev <hklhqghc Bhj^Zgbb g_ ^Ze
bf \hafh`ghklb ijh_oZlv ih l_jjblhjbb k\h_]h ]hkm^Zjkl\Z
Iha^g__ \k_ wlb khe^Zlu [ueb gZijZ\e_gu \ _]bi_lkdb_ \h_g
gu_mqbebsZihkdhevdm\hh[s_g_mf_eb\h_\Zlv
Djhf_lh]h\eZklbDK:^eylh]hqlh[uihfhqviZe_k
lbgpZf ihklZ\beb bf hjm`b_ H[ wlhf hjm`bb LZoZ ZeOZrbfb h^bg ba \h_gZqZevgbdh\ kdZaZe ke_^mxs__ ©WlZ
iZjlbyhjm`by[ueZ^hklZ\e_gZkZfhe_lhfgZ\h_ggucaZ\h^\
Kbjbb GZf ij_^klhyeh _]h jZkkhjlbjh\Zlv gh fu g_ kfh]eb
wlh]h k^_eZlv ihlhfm qlh hgh [ueh kh\_jr_ggh jZaguf LZf
[ueb fZma_ju fZjlbgu njZgpmakdb_ Zg]ebckdb_ hkfZgkdb_
_]bi_lkdb_b]j_q_kdb_\bglh\dbGbmh^ghcbawlbo\bglh\hd
g_[uehfZ]ZabgZfu\hh[s_g_kfh]ebbfb\hkihevah\Zlvkyª
>Ze__ hg ijh^he`Z_l ©Kj_^b wlbo \bglh\hd fu gZreb ^Z`_
nblbevguc b dj_fgb_\uc fmrd_l wlb \bglh\db bkihevah\Z
ebkv\h\j_fy\hcgf_`^m\ZooZ[blZfbb_]bi_lkdhcZjfb_c\
gZqZe_^_\ylgZ^pZlh]h\_dZª
LZcgh_ij_^Zl_evkl\h
<ZooZ[blu [hyebkv qlh \hcgZ aZ hk\h[h`^_gb_ IZe_k
lbgu aZlyg_lky ihwlhfm gZqZeb \_klb lZcgu_ i_j_]h\hju k
Zf_jbdZgpZfb b [jblZgpZfb ijbau\Zy l_o ijb]jhablv h[_bf
klhjhgZf<jZkk_dj_q_gghfibkvf_Zf_jbdZgkdh]hih\_j_ggh
]h \ >`b^^_ hl yg\Zjy ] jZkkdZau\Z_lky h lhf dZd \h
\j_fy \klj_qb ij_^klZ\bl_e_c KR: <_ebdh[jblZgbb b DK:
ij_^klZ\bl_ev ihke_^gbo \ukdZaZe k\hb hiZk_gby ih ih\h^m
lh]hqlhaZlygm\rZyky\hcgZfh`_lm]jh`ZlvfbjmbklZ[bev
ghklb \h \k_f j_]bhg_ b ij_^eh`be KR: b <_ebdh[jblZgbb
\uklmiblv k lj_[h\Zgb_f ij_djZlblv \h_ggu_ ^_ckl\by Z \
kemqZ_ hldZaZ ijbgylv wdhghfbq_kdb_ b \h_ggu_kZgdpbbijh
lb\h[_boklhjhg
BklbggZyp_gZIZe_klbgu\]eZaZo\ZooZ[blh\
>`hgNbebiib\k\h_cdgb]_©Khjhde_lgZ:jZ\bckdhf
ihemhkljh\_ªjZkkdZau\Zyh[hlghr_gbb\ZooZ[blh\d\hijhkm
h IZe_klbg_ ibr_l ©<hijhk h IZe_klbg_ g_ \hegh\Ze wlbo
ex^_c hgb kqblZeb qlh IZe_klbgZ g_ klhbl lh]h qlh[u ihj
310
lblv k\hb ^jm`_kl\_ggu_ k\yab k Zg]ebqZgZfb b Zf_jbdZgpZ
fbª B ^Ze__ ijh^he`Zy ©Km^v[m IZe_klbgu hgb iheghklvx
^h\_jbeb k\hbf emqrbf ^jmavyf-Zg]ebqZgZf b [ueb ]hlh\u
ih^qbgblvkyex[hfmlj_[h\Zgby<_ebdh[jblZgbbª
<wlhfg_lgbq_]hm^b\bl_evgh]h
H^gbf ba mkeh\bc khljm^gbq_kl\Z Zg]ebqZg k \ZooZ[b
lZfb [ueh lh qlh ihke_^gb_ g_ ^he`gu \f_rb\Zlvky \ dheh
gbaZlhjkdmx iheblbdm Zg]ebqZg \ j_]bhg_ \ lhf qbke_ g_
^he`gu ij_iylkl\h\Zlv aZo\Zlm IZe_klbgu <ZooZ[blu g_
lhevdh^h[jhkh\_klgh\uihegbebwlhmkeh\b_ghb[he__lh]h
ihkh\_lh\Zeb jZa^_eblv IZe_klbgm f_`^m ZjZ[Zfb b _\j_yfb
qlh[ui_j\u_g_hq_gvkbevgh\hafmsZebkv
Ih^ehklv\ZooZ[blkdbofZde_jh\biZljbhlbafkmelZgZ
=Z[^meoZfb^Z671
BajZkk_dj_q_gguo[jblZgh-Zf_jbdZgkdboZjob\h\ijb
agZgbcNbebiibbklZl_c]:jkZjZEhjb\uklmib\r_]h\
aZsblm OZbfZ <_cpfZgZ klZeh ykgh qlh \ZooZ[blu ijh^Zeb
IZe_klbgm aZ ^\Z^pZlv fbeebhgh\ nmglh\ kl_jebg]h\ :jkZj
EhjbaZy\ey_lqlhwlZb^_yijbgZ^e_`ZeZ>`hgmNbebiib
G_baf_ggZyiheblbdZ\ZooZ[blh\
Ij_^Zl_evkdZy iheblbdZ \ZooZ[blh\ g_ baf_gbeZkv
\iehlv^hgZrbo^g_cHgbg_mqZkl\h\Zeb\\hcgZoZjZ[kdbo
kljZg ijhlb\ BajZbeygbdh]^Zg_\uklmiZebijhlb\ojbklbZg
bbm^__\GZh[hjhlhgb\k_]^ZklZjZebkvmlbohfbjblvZjZ[h\
Z bgh]^Z ^Z`_ ih^dmiZeb bo \ayldZfb qlh[u l_ g_ \uklmiZeb
ijhlb\\jZ]Z
Hgbih^dmiZxl
<]gZqZeZkvZjZ[h-bajZbevkdZy\hcgZZbxgylh
]h`_]h^ZdhjhevDK:\uklmiZy\FmklZd[ZebyaZy\be©>h
jh]b_[jZlvyy\_jgmekyd\Zfhl\ZrboZf_jbdZgkdbob_\jh
i_ckdbo[jZlv_\dhlhjuo\ulZdkbevghex[bl_bdhlhju_ex
[yl\ZkǻDh]^Z`_balheiuihkeurZebkvijhl_klublj_[h
671
Ba\_klghqlhhghldZaZekyijh^ZlvIZe_klbgm_\j_yf–ii
311
\Zgby ij_djZlblv ihklZ\db g_nlb ihebp_ckdb_ gZqZeb ba[b
\Zlvex^_c^m[bgdZfb
Djhf_ lh]h hgb \k_]^Z iulZebkv mlbohfbjblv ]hehkZ
l_odlhaZy\eyehg_h[oh^bfhklbhk\h[h`^_gbyB_jmkZebfZb
f_q_lbZe-:dkZ<qZklghklbr_co:k]Z^Zl-LZfbfbbfZff_
q_lb Ze-:dkZ jZkkdZau\Ze qlh \ ] \ZooZ[blu iulZebkv
ih^dmiblv_]hbij_^eZ]Zebh^bgfbeebhg^heeZjh\qlh[uhg
i_j_klZe ^_eZlv aZy\e_gby h g_h[oh^bfhklb hk\h[h`^_gby iZ
e_klbgkdboa_f_ev\h[s_fbf_q_lbZe-:dkZ\qZklghklb
AZq_f\h_\Zlvk_\j_yfb"
<]hnbp_ju-\ZooZ[blugZijZ\beb\fbgbkl_jkl\h
h[hjhguDK:l_e_]jZffm\dhlhjhckhh[sZehkvqlh\h_ggu_
dhjZ[eb BajZbey ijbr\Zjlh\Zebkv d [_j_]Zf DK: ©b gZqZeb
\ukZ^dm^_kZglZgZgZrma_fexHgbijh\hpbjmxlgZrbih^
jZa^_e_gby ihwlhfm fu ijhkbf jZaj_r_gby hldjulv h]hgv ih
gZrbf \jZ]Zf kbhgbklZfª < hl\_l ijbreZ l_e_]jZffZ ©Hgb
g_gZiZ^mlgZ\ZkihdZ\ug_[m^_l_boZlZdh\ZlvAgZcl_qlh
gb h^bg bm^_c g_ klhbl lh]h qlh[u gZ gbo ljZlblv iZljhgu
:eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Wlh bo jmdb [m^ml kdh\Zgu b ijh
deyluhgbªª<hllZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[bluaZb]ju\Zxl
khkeh\Zfb:eeZoZ
?\j_b-^jmavy
JZkkdZau\Zyh[hlghr_gbyof_`^m\ZooZ[blZfbb_\j_
yfb ohq_lky ijb\_klb pblZlm ba Zf_jbdZgkdbo]Za_lhp_j_fh
gbb\klj_qbdhjheyDK:\KR:©?]h\klj_qZebij_^klZ\bl_
eb kj_^kl\ fZkkh\hc bgnhjfZpbb b \ qZklghklb NjZgd hkgh
\Zl_evkbhgbklkdhchj]ZgbaZpbb©OZZj_pªba^Zxs_c\IZe_k
lbg_h^ghbf_ggmx]Za_lmª672.
Fbjguc^h]h\hjk_\j_yfb
Fgh]b_ ex^b g_ ih^haj_\Zxl h lhf qlh iheblbdZ \Zo
oZ[blh\ ba^Z\gZ hjb_glbjh\ZgZ gZ \h`^_c kbhgbafZ ?keb \u
h[jZlbl_ \gbfZgb_ gZ \ZooZ[blkdb_ ijZa^gbdb dhlhju_ hgb
ijh\h^ylgZAZiZ^_lh\qbke_ijb]eZr_gguogZi_j\hff_kl_
672
?`_^g_\gZy]Za_lZ©Seattle Post IntelligenceªhlfZjlZ]
312
\u m\b^bl_ bf_gZ _\j__\-kbhgbklh\ ij_^klZ\bl_e_c KFB
<ZooZ[blu ^Z`_ g_ kdju\Zeb lhl nZdl qlh ih^ibkZeb Dwfi^_\b^kdbc^h]h\hj]
< ] h^bg ba \h`^_c \ZooZ[bafZ \ bgl_j\vx ^ey
©<Zrbg]lhgihklªaZy\be©Fuk_\j_yfb^\hxjh^gu_[jZlvy
ihwlhfm g_ ^himklbf bo ba]gZgby fu `_eZ_f `blv k gbfb \
fbj_ª673Zbxgy]h^bgbaij_^klZ\bl_e_ciheblbq_k
dhc weblu aZy\be ©Fu ]hlh\u ijbagZlv BajZbev« h^gZdh
lhevdhihke_lh]hdZdhgmj_]mebjm_lk\hbhlghr_gbykkhk_
^yfb b hij_^_eblky kh k\h_c iheblbdhc \ hlghr_gbb iZe_k
lbgp_\ªdh]^Z`_mg_]hkijhkbeb©QlhagZqblhij_^_eblvkyk
iheblbdhc\hlghr_gbbiZe_klbgp_\"ª-hghl\_lbe©BajZbev
emqr_agZ_lqlhbf__lky\\b^mª
N_l\um]h^gu_bm^_yf
B^_yaZdexq_gbyfbjZk_\j_yfbbagZqZevghijbgZ^e_
`ZeZ\ZooZ[blkdhfm^moh\_gkl\mZdh]^ZZjZ[kdb_]hkm^Zjkl\Z
gZqZebkdehgylvkygZklhjhgm?]bilZ\ZooZ[bluh[e_debk\hx
b^_x \ [he__ ijb\e_dZl_evguc nZglbd b \ ] \h \j_fy
dhgn_j_gpbb \ NZk_ ij_ih^g_keb __ dZd ©:jZ[kdbc ijh_dl
mj_]mebjh\Zgby [eb`g_\hklhqghc ijh[e_fuª :jZ[kdb_ ijZ
\bl_evkl\Z ijbgyeb wlm b^_x b gZqZeb bkdZlv gh\u_ g_ \h_g
gu_674 imlb jZaj_r_gby wlbo ijh[e_f K p_evx ijh^he`_gby
wlhc iheblbdb \ZooZ[blkdh_ ^moh\_gkl\h gZqZeh ba^Z\Zlv kh
hl\_lkl\mxsb_n_l\u
<h-i_j\uo B[g ;Za ba^Ze n_l\m jZaj_rZxsmx aZdex
qblv fbjguc ^h]h\hj k _\j_yfb kh]eZkgh n_l\_ ^himkdZehkv
aZdexq_gb_b\j_f_ggh]hbihklhyggh]h^h]h\hjZDjhf_lh]h
hg h[ty\be kmgghc ihk_s_gb_ f_q_lb Ze-:dkZ WlZ n_l\Z fh
`_l[ulveb[hk\b^_l_evkl\hfg_\_`_kl\Z__Z\lhjZbeb`_hg
ij_^gZf_j_ggh iulZ_lky m]h^blv _\j_yf-kbhgbklZf AZdexq_
gb_ ^h]h\hjZ Z\lhfZlbq_kdb kbf\hebabjm_l ijbagZgb_ ijZ\h
«Washington postsª hl ] Wlh bgl_j\vx [ueh i_j_\_^_gh gZ
ZjZ[kdbcyaudbba^Zgh\g_dhlhjuoZjZ[kdbo]Za_lZob\qZklghklb\[_c
jmlkdhc]Za_l_©:e-OZyª
674
<ZooZ[blu]hj^ylkywlhcb^__c
673
313
f_jghklb aZo\ZlZ iZe_klbgkdbo a_f_ev b \ qZklghklb f_q_lb
Ze-:dkZDjhf_lh]h^h]h\hjy\ey_lkyhldjulufij_^Zl_evkl
\hf iZe_klbgp_\ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky ihk_s_gby f_q_lb Ze-:dkZ
lh gZ ^Zgguc fhf_gl wlh [m^_l kihkh[kl\h\Zlv lhevdh mkbe_
gbxwdhghfbdbBajZbey
Gh qlh m^b\bl_evgh r_co B[g ;Za ijbau\Z\rbc d
k[eb`_gbxk_\j_yfbgbdh]^Zg_ijbau\Zedk[eb`_gbxkfm
kmevfZgkdbfbfZaoZ[Zfb
LZd`_h[jZsZ_lgZk_[y\gbfZgb_blhlnZdlqlhfmn
lbc DK: aZij_lbe khljm^gbq_kl\h k jZa\_^dhc KKKJ jZ[h
lZ\r_cijhlb\ki_pkem`[BajZbeybhkm^be^_ckl\by>`ZfZ
ey=Z[^mggZkujZIha^g__r_coB[g;Zaba^Zen_l\mkh]eZkgh
dhlhjhc bm^_yf b ojbklbZgZf iha\heyehkv gZoh^blvky gZ l_j
jblhjbb DK: ;he__ lh]h \ZooZ[blkdb_ k\ys_ggbdb h[jZsZ
ebkv k fhev[Zfb aZ Zf_jbdZgkdbo \h_gguo dhlhju_ reb m[b
\ZlvbjZdkdbo`_gsbgklZjbdh\b^_l_cHgjZaj_rbem[b\Zlv
bjZdp_\^Z`__kebl_kh\_jrZebfhebl\mG_dhlhju_ex^bb
\ qZklghklb r_co Xkmn Ze-DZj^Z\b iulZebkv h[tykgblv wlb
n_l\u klZjhklvx B[g ;ZaZ b ^Z\e_gb_f gZ g_]h kh klhjhgu
\eZkl_cDK:h^gZdhhgaZy\beqlh\k_wlbn_l\u[uebba^Zgu
bf\a^jZ\hfjZkkm^d_b[_a\kydh]hijbgm`^_gby
>jm]Zy \ZooZ[blkdZy n_l\Z ijbgZ^e_`bl GZkujm^^bgm
Ze-:e[Zgb\g_chgijba\ZeiZe_klbgp_\ihdbgmlvk\hba_feb
b hklZ\blv bo _\j_yf WlZ n_l\Z [ueZ him[ebdh\ZgZ fgh]bfb
fbjh\ufbKFBZdm\_clkdbc`mjgZe©:e-Fm^`lZfZ]ªhim[
ebdh\Zeihwlhfmih\h^mhl\_lumq_guoDjhf_lh]hr_co=Z
ebZe-NZdbjZe-Mj^mgb\uklmibek[e_klysbfhijh\_j`_gb_f
wlhcn_l\uba^ZggufgZZm^bh-dZkk_lZo
DZd \b^bl_ \ZooZ[blu h[eZqbebkv \ jyku fmkmevfZg
kdbo k\ys_ggbdh\ b \_^ml ^_yl_evghklv m]h^gmx _\j_yf675 b
ojbklbZgZf
<Zf_jbdZgkdbo\hckdZo^_kZglbjh\ZgguogZl_jjblhjbxDK:[uebb
_\j_bh^bgbagboihijb[ulbbihp_eh\Zea_fexbkdZaZe©GZdhg_p-lhfu
\_jgmebkv d l_[_ h OZc[Zjª <hl lZdmx mkem]m hdZaZeb mq_gu_ \ZooZ[blu
fmkmevfZgZf\k_]hfbjZ
675
314
AZij_lijhdeylbc\Z^j_kbm^__\bojbklbZg
Dh]^Z fu oZ^`b ijb[ueb \ f_^bgkdbc Zwjhihjl kem
`Zsb_-lZfh`_ggbdb gZqZeb h[ukdb\Zlv gZr [Z]Z` DZd \u
^mfZ_l_ qlh hgb bkdZeb" =Zrbr" Hibmf" G_l hgb bkdZeb
dgb]b b h[gZjm`b\ dgb]m r_coZ Ze->`ZclZeb ©DZ\Z]b^ ZeBkeZfªh[ty\bebgZfqlhhgZy\ey_lkyaZij_s_gghcFugZ
^_ykv gZ ihgbfZgb_ ihiulZebkv h[tykgblv qlh wlZ dgb]Z y\
ey_lkyebrvk[hjgbdhfihijZ\mq_luj_ofZaoZ[h\GhhgbaZ
y\beb qlh dgb]m ijb^_lky k`_qv Fu kdZaZeb ©Gh fh`_l
[ulv \u hrb[ebkvª Hgb hl\_lbeb ©G_l bf_ggh wlZ dgb]Z
bf_ggh k wlbf gZa\Zgb_f aZibkZgZ \ gZr_f q_jghf kibkd_ª
M^b\bl_evgh dgb]b fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo \ q_jghf kibkd_
Wlb ex^b \hxxl k ex[ufb ijhy\e_gbyfb fmkmevfZgkdhc
fukebhgbkqblZxlqlh\_kvfmkmevfZgkdbcfbj^he`_gke_
^h\Zlv aZ B[g LZcfb_c b B[g Ze-DZcbfhf Ihwlhfm g_ `^bl_
hlwlboqlhhgb[m^mlfukeblveh]bq_kdb
Qlh ih^_eZlv fu ebrbebkv wlhc dgb]b gh \ Km^guc
^_gv ij_^ty\bf kq_l wlbf ex^yf AgZy iheblbdm \ZooZ[bafZ
fuijb[_]ebd[he__obljhcmeh\d_bgZqZeb\_klbijhlb\g_]h
[hjv[m\h\k_fbjghck_lbBgl_jg_l
?s_h^ghcdgb]hcgZoh^ys_cky\q_jghfkibkd_y\ey
_lky ©;Zae Ze-fZ^`om^ nb fmoZeynZl Zg-gZkZjZ \Z Ze-yom^ª
ijbgZ^e_`ZsZy i_jm r_coZ Zk-KZebfb Ba gZa\Zgby dgb]b
\b^gh qlh Z\lhj gZoh^blky \ hiihabpbb d bm^_yf b ojbklbZ
gZf <ZooZ[blu ijyfh gZ ]jZgbp_ k`b]Zxl wlm dgb]m gh \ lh
`_\j_fy\DK:jZaj_r_ghijh^Z\Zlvdgb]m©:e-BflZ]\ZZefmZgZkZª676 ijbgZ^e_`Zsmx i_jm :[m OZcygZ Zl-LZ\ob^b
bfZfZf_q_lbZe-OZjZf
<ur_ [ueh kdZaZgh qlh \ZooZ[blu y\eyxlky ^_lbs_f
Zg]ebqZgp_evxwlhck_dluy\ey_lkyjZajmr_gb_BkeZfZbagm
ljb Bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb ihklhyggh \h_\Zeb k fmkmevfZgZfb
hldZau\Z\rbfbky ijbgbfZlv bo b^_heh]bx Bo b^_heh]Zfb
[uebojbklbZg_^eydhlhjuokh]eZkgh\ZooZ[bafm^Z`_:^g_
<g_cj_qvb^_lhaZij_lguogZkeZ`^_gbyo]hfhk_dkmZebaf_bij_ex[h
^_ygbb
676
315
\_q_gK_]h^gy`_hgb\uklmibebkgh\hcb^__cbomq_gu_aZ
ij_lbebijhdebgZlvbm^__\bojbklbZg\h\j_fyijhih\_^_c<
hkh[hf jZkihjy`_gbb ^ey ijhih\_^gbdh\ hl ]
]aZghf_jhf[uehkdZaZgh©«[uehaZf_q_
gh qlh g_dhlhju_ ijhih\_^gbdb \ k\hbo ijhih\_^yo ijhdeb
gZxlbm^__\bojbklbZgijbq_fmihfbgZxl^Z`_gZa\Zgbyg_
dhlhjuo]hkm^Zjkl\DhjZgg_ijbau\Z_lgZkdwlhfmª677LZdh
\um[_`^_gby\ZooZ[blh\hgbaZsbsZxl\jZ]h\:eeZoZijb
au\Zxlex[blvbob\lh`_\j_fym[b\ZxlfmkmevfZgbh[t
y\eyxl jZaj_r_gghc bo djh\v ^Z`_ \ Ze-OZjZf_ Bf_ggh ih
wlhfm dh]^Z Zf_jbdZgkdb_ \hckdZ \hreb \ BjZd kZm^bckdb_
ijhih\_^gbdbgZfbg[ZjZofhebebkvaZgbogZau\Zybo\hbg
kl\hf:eeZoZGhohq_lkyhlf_lblvqlhlZdZyiheblbdZg_y\
ey_lkyq_f-eb[hgh\ufdh]^ZZg]ebqZg_aZo\Zlbeb;Zkjm\Zo
oZ[blkdbc wfbj gZijZ\be I_jkb Dhdkm l_e_]jZffm \ dhlhjhc
[ueh kdZaZgh ©=hkih^bgm I_jkb Dhdkm iheghfhqghfm ij_^
klZ\bl_ex <_ebdh[jblZgbb ^Z ijh^eblky __ keZ\Z GZklmie_
gb_\Zrbo\hckd\BjZd_hdZaZehh]jhfgmxihfhsvfmkmevfZ
gZfFu]hlh\u\_qghkem`blv\Zfª678.
LZdh\Z]hjvdZyijZ\^Z\ZooZ[blkdhcbklhjbbWlbex^b
b k_cqZk ijh^he`Zxl k\hx iheblbdm bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb
k`b]Zxl \k_ g_m]h^gu_ dgb]b _keb `_ ihy\ey_lky g_h[oh^b
fhklvba^ZlvdZdmx-eb[hdgb]my\eyxsmxkydeZkkbq_kdhclh
hgbi_j_^ba^Zgb_fj_^Zdlbjmxl__bbaufZxl\k_qlhg_kh
hl\_lkl\m_lbob^_heh]bb679.
<k_ dlhg_kh]eZk_gkb^__caZij_lZijhdeylbc\Z^j_k
bm^__\ b ojbklbZg ih^\_j]Zxlky ]hg_gbyf ;he__ lh]h ih^
\_j]Zxlky]hg_gbyf^Z`_l_dlh\uklmiZ_lkdjblbdhcdhffm
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^meeZZe-FZk]Zjb©:e-:^beeyZe-dZl]byª–FmZkkZ
kZlZj-jZnb^–K– 70.
678
>hdlhj FmoZffZ^ =Zm^ Ze-OZlu[ ©KZnZoZl fbg lZjbo Ze-^`ZabjZ Ze]ZjZ[byª–>ZjZe-fb]jZ^`–KlZd`_kfGZkujZe-NZjZ^`©DbyfZe]mrZjZk-KZ]m^byª–K–b– 90.
679
KfZe-DZmkZjbdhff_glZjbbddgb]_©Ze-:kfZ\ZZk-kunZlªZe-;ZcoZdb
ih^j_^Zdpb_cZe-DZmkZjbk
677
316
gbafZ Bkdj_ggbc \ZooZ[bl680 gZibkZ\rbc dgb]m ©:k-Kmxn
Ze-[ZlbjZ ]Zey bevoZ^ Zr-rmx]by Ze-dZnbjZª681 [ue ebr_g
]jZ`^Zgkl\Zbba]gZg\C_f_gB\gZrb^gbB[g;Zab_fmih
^h[gu_ ijh^he`Zxl h[\bgylv \ jZkimlkl\_ b [b^]Z \k_o dlh
ijhlb\hj_qblbob^_heh]bbJZa\_klhblihke_wlh]hm^b\eylv
kylhfmqlh\ZooZ[bluk`b]ZxlfmkmevfZgkdb_dgb]b"
<ZooZ[blkdh-ojbklbZgkdb_\h`^b
K_]h^gyfgh]b_ijhklu_fmkmevfZg_h[km`^Zxl\hijhk
k\yaZgguckn_l\hc\ZooZ[blkdbomq_guohlghkbl_evgh^himk
lbfhklb bkihevah\Zgby ojbklbZgkdhc Zjfbb \ \hcg_ ijhlb\
fmkmevfZg DZd ba\_klgh aZ \kx bklhjbx BkeZfZ \hh[s_ gb
dh]^Zg_ih^gbfZekywlhl\hijhkih^gbfZebkv\hijhkuhlhf
fh`ghebihevah\Zlvkyih^^_j`dhcg_\_jguo\\hcg_kg_\_j
gufb gh gbdh]^Z gb h^bg nZdbo g_ jZaj_rZe bkihevah\Zlv
g_\_jguo\\hcg_ijhlb\fmkmevfZgQlh`_dZkZ_lky\ZooZ[b
lh\ lh ^ey gbo g_l lZdbo ijh[e_f b B[g ;Za g_ i_j\uc dlh
ba^Zen_l\mh^himklbfhklbwlh]h?s_^hg_]hi_j\u_\ZooZ
[blkdb_ wfbju ihevah\Zebkvih^^_j`dhcZg]ebckdh]hojbklb
Zgkdh]h]hkm^Zjkl\Z\k\hbo\hcgZoijhlb\fmkmevfZgGZijb
f_j Ze-BokZ [ue h^gbf ba ]hjh^h\ HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb \Zo
oZ[blu \f_klh lh]h qlh[u ih^qbgylvky fmkmevfZgkdhfm oZ
ebnm \uklmibeb ijhlb\ g_]h b \ ] ] hkZ^beb ZeBokZB[g;ZrZj]hj^_eb\hhibku\Zyl_kh[ulbyjZkkdZau\Z
_lhlhfdZdhlkljZoZmfgh]bo[_j_f_gguo`_gsbgkemqbeky
\udb^ur jZkkdZau\Z_l h lhf dZd hgb gZiZ^Zeb gZ imlgbdh\
Ihke_^h\Zl_evB[gL_cfbb
:\lhjhfwlhcdgb]by\ey_lkyFmd[beb[gOZ^bZe-<Z^b]b<ZooZ[blug_
bf_ebgbq_]hijhlb\dh]^Zhgdjblbdh\ZebihghkbefmkmevfZgghba]gZ
eb_]hdh]^ZhggZqZeihghkblvdhffmgbklh\Fu`_\k_]^Zjmdh\h^kl\m
_fkydhjZgbq_kdbfijZ\behf©H\udhlhju_m\_jh\Zeb;m^vl_klhcdb>\
\Zr_c \_j_ \@ :eeZoZ k\b^_l_evkl\my [_kijbkljZklgh B imklv \ZrZ g_
gZ\bklv d dhfm-eb[h g_ \_^_l \Zk d ijbkljZklbx ;m^vl_ ijb\_j`_gu
kijZ\_^eb\hklb b[h hgZ [eb`_ d [h]h[hyag_gghklb KljZrbl_kv :eeZoZ
\_^v :eeZo \_^Z_l h lhf qlh \u l\hjbl_ª JZa\_ ijZ\bevgh ihklm
iZxl fmkmevfZg_ ih^^_j`b\Zxsb_ l_o dlh ihghkbl fmkmevfZg b aZsb
sZ_l[_a[h`gbdh\"
680
681
317
]jZ[bebbobm[b\Zebg_kfhljygZ\k_wlhZe-BokZg_kdehgbe
k\hx]heh\mi_j_^\ZooZ[blZfbbg_ih^qbgbekybf
DZd`_bfm^Zehkvih^qbgblvk_[_wlhl]hjh^"
L_jjblhjbyf_`^mDm\_clhfbDZlZjhf\k__s_hklZ\Z
eZkv\jmdZohkfZgp_\qlh^hklZ\eyeh[hevrb_g_m^h[kl\ZZg
]ebqZgZf^eyijh^\b`_gby\OZeb^`_682<k\yabkwlbfhgbk
m^h\hevkl\b_f ihevah\Zebkv ih^^_j`dhc k\hbo \ZooZ[blkdbo
Z]_glh\dhlhju_ihke_[bl\uijbZj-JZ\^_]^_[uem[blwfbj
G_^`^Z=Z[^me]Zaba[bgJZrb^683\ukdZaZebk\hx]hlh\ghklv
gZiZklvgZZe-BokZ<k\yabkwlbfhgbh[jZlbebkvdZg]ebqZ
gZf aZ ihfhsvx ijhkbeb ihklZ\blv hjm`b_ b hdZaZlv ih^
^_j`dmkfhjyIhkdhevdmm;jblZgbbb__khxagbp[uebk\hb
ieZguhgbkqblZebqlh\j_fyj_rZxs_]hgZklmie_gby_s_g_
ijbreh lh\ZooZ[blh\ihijhkbebg_ki_rblvLh]^Z\ZooZ[b
lu h[jZlbebkv aZ ihfhsvx d kwjm I_jkb Dhdkm ih\_j_gghfm
;jblZgbb\OZeb^`_684ghhglZd`_ihijhkbebog_ki_rblv
< ] hgb h[jZlbebkv k lhc `_ ijhkv[hc d Zg]ebc
kdhfm ih\_j_gghfm \ Dm\_cl_ >bdkhgm hg bf hl\_lbe qlh
;jblZgby ^Zkl bf \hafh`ghklv aZ\eZ^_lv Ze-Bokhc gh lhevdh
lh]^Z dh]^Z wlh [m^_l hl\_qZlv __ bgl_j_kZf b dh]^Z Lmjpby
[m^_lg_\khklhygbbhljZablvgZklmie_gb_
Q_j_a^\Z]h^Zih^oh^ysbcfhf_glgZklmibegZ;ZedZ
gZo C_f_g_ b ^jm]bo hdjZbgZo HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb gZqZebkv
\hkklZgbybLmjpby[ueZ\ugm`^_gZkhkj_^hlhqblvk\hb\hc
kdZ bf_ggh \ wlbo j_]bhgZo Lh]^Z-lh b gZklZe q_j_^ \ZooZ[b
lh\gZiZklvgZZe-BokZgZklmie_gb_[uehgZagZq_ghgZZi
j_ey ] ^`mfZ^Zemey ] =hjh^ [ue \ayl ijb ih^
^_j`d_ Zg]ebckdh]h hjm`by b kljZl_]h\ Oh^ b kljZl_]by gZ
klmie_gby [ueb jZajZ[hlZgu [jblZgkdbf hnbp_jhf E_clrfZ
GZkujZe-NZjZ^`©DbyfZe-]mrZjZk-KZ]m^byª–K
Hg[uehq_gvmfgufb^Zevgh\b^gufq_eh\_dhfFh`ghkdZaZlvqlhhg
jZgvr_ \k_o jZkdmkbe ieZgu Zg]ebqZg bf_ggh ihwlhfm hg gZqZe ibkZlv
ibkvfZ lmj_pdbf \eZklyf H^gh ba wlbo ibk_f [ueh ihemq_gh \ KlZf[me_
]
684
I_jkbAZdZjbyDhdkbf_e_\j_ckdb_dhjgbbjZ[hlZegZZg]ebckdmxjZa
\_^dm
682
683
318
ghfQlh`_dZkZ_lkyhjm`bylh[jblZgpuihklZ\beb\ZooZ[b
lZfgh\_crb_\lh\j_fy\bgh\dbF
Kem`[Z[_ahiZkghklb\ZooZ[blh\
JZkijZ\Z gZ^ `bl_eyfb Ze-BokZ [ueZ ihjmq_gZ \ZooZ
[blkdhfmie_f_gb:e>`ZeZ\bba\_klghfmk\hbfbdjh\Z\ufb
aeh^_ygbyfb =hjh^ iZe q_j_a f_kyp ihke_ gZqZeZ hkZ^u b \
g_f ihy\beZkv gh\Zy agZf_gblZy ©LxjvfZ jZ[h\ª dhlhjZy
jZgvr_ [ueZ ba\_klgZ dZd ©Dj_ihklv B[jZobfZª <h`^v ie_
f_gb =Z[^mefmokbg b[g >`ZeZ\b ebqgh ihohjhgbe `b\v_f
fgh`_kl\hfmkmevfZg
Ohq_lky \kihfgblv _s_ h^bg fhf_gl \ZooZ[blkdhc bk
lhjbb Jmdh\h^bl_e_f kem`[u [_ahiZkghklb \ZooZ[blh\ [ue
gZagZq_g bm^_c Z]_gl Zg]ebckdhc jZa\_^db ba\_klguc dZd
FZo^b[_dHg_kl_kl\_gghih^jmdh\h^kl\hf>`hgZNbebi
ib©ijbgyeBkeZfªihke_q_]haZgyewlhlihkl?]h`_jl\Zfb
klZeb fgh]b_ fmkmevfZg_ _]h ij_jh]Zlb\hc [ueb hlk_q_ggu_
jmdbgh]bghkuiheh\u_hj]Zgubij<k_wlhhg^_eZejZ^b
©\hkiblZgbyih^^Zgguo\^mo_BkeZfZª685.
H[yaZl_evkl\Z
<lhf_[jblZgkdh]hZjob\Zkh^_j`blkyl_e_]jZffZ
\bp_-]m[_jgZlhjZ Zg]ebckdhc dhjhgu \ dhlhjhc hg kh\_lm_l
\ZooZ[blZfdZdfh`gh[uklj__ba]gZlvlmjdh\baZe-BokZbZeDZlunZ qlh[u \bp_-]m[_jgZlhj Bg^bb fh] fbjguf iml_f
ijbkh_^bgblvwlba_febdk\hbf
H^bg ba \ZooZ[blh\ aZgy\ jmdh\h^ysbc ihkl bxgy
]gZibkZeI_jkbDhdkmke_^mxs__©Ybkiulu\Zxd\Zf
^jm`_kl\_ggu_ qm\kl\Z ihwlhfm gZ^_xkv qlh hlghr_gby
f_`^mgZfb[m^mllZdbfb`_l_ieufbdZdbfbhgb[uebf_`
^m \Zfb b fhbfb ij_^r_kl\_ggbdZfbª686 Ih^l\_j`^Zy _]h
GZkuj Zk-KZ]b^ ©LZjbo :e KZ]m^ª – K Zl-LZd\b ©:e-NbjdZ Ze\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ª–K
686
Bf__lky\\b^mFmoZffZ^[bgKZ]m^[bgFZj^moI_j_^Z_lkyqlhr_co
Kme_cfZg^_^FmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[ZghkbebfyRmefZgDZjdmab
`be \ Lmjpbb b [ue bm^__f ^hgfZ ^_gf_ <f_kl_ k k_fv_c hg ihdbgme
lmj_pdbc]hjh^;mjkZbi_j_k_ebeky\RZfgh\kdhj_[ueba]gZghllm^ZaZ
685
319
ij_^Zgghklv [jblZgkdhc dhjhg_ [jblZgkdbc ihkhe \ KlZf[me_
hdly[jy ] aZibkZe ©Hg ijbagZ_l gZr_ ijbkmlkl\b_ \
OZeb^`_bijh\h^bl\Ze-BokZiheblbdmm]h^gmx[jblZgkdhc
dhjhg_ª
:g]ebckdbc ihedh\gbd Embk I_e_ iheblbq_kdbc ih\_
j_gguc[jblZgkdhcbfi_jbb\;mrZoZj-]]\k\h_c
dgb]_ ©Iml_r_kl\b_ \ wj-Jby^ b hkh[Zy ihqlZª ibr_l h lhf
qlh[jblZgkdZybfi_jbyb\ZooZ[blubf_ebh[sb_p_eb687Hg
jZkkdZau\Z_lhlhfdZd[ueihkeZgd\ZooZ[blZfqlh[uh[km
^blvbo[m^msb_gZ[_]bgZkhk_^gb_]hkm^Zjkl\ZbjZajZ[hldb
ieZgZ\h_gguo^_ckl\bcijhlb\LmjpbbgZ\hklhd_688.
BlZd fu \uykgbeb qlh \ZooZ[blu b [jblZgkdZy bfi_
jby [ueb khxagbdZfb Ihwlhfm \ZooZ[blu g_ ^he`gu h[b
`ZlvkygZlhqlhbogZau\Zxlg_hoZjb^`blZfb<_^vhgb\h_
\Zeb ijhlb\ fmkmevfZg b h[_ki_qb\Zeb [_ahiZkghklv yauqgb
dh\689.
<ZooZ[baf–^_lbs_bm^__\bojbklbZg
Ij_^klZ\vl_ k_[_ ^ebggh[hjh^uo ex^_c \ h^_`^Zo ^h
k_j_^bgusbdhehlhdydh[uijheb\Zxsboke_au\h\j_fyfh
ebl\u\f_q_lbZe-OZjZfFh`_l_eb\uih\_jblvqlhk_dlZd
dhlhjhchgbijbgZ^e_`Zly\ey_lky^_lbs_fbm^__\bojbklb
Zg">ZwlhlZdwlh]hjvdZyijZ\^Zb\wlhfjZa^_e_fuohlbf
lh qlh ki_dmebjh\Ze j_eb]b_c Ba RZfZ hg i_j_[jZeky \ ?]bi_l hldm^Z
lZd`_ [ue ba]gZg b [_`Ze \ F_ddm gh b lZf _]h g_ ijbgyeb Hg [_`Ze \
F_^bgmghf_^bgpulZd`_jZkdmkbeb_]hb_fmijbrehkv[_`Zlv\G_^`^
<k_ wlb kh[ulby ijhbahreb \k_]h aZ q_luj_ ]h^Z Hg ihk_ebeky \ Ze=mycg_ ]^_ gZr_e ij_djZkgmx ihq\m ^ey jZkijhkljZg_gby _j_lbq_kdbo
b^_cA^_kvhg\u^Zek_[yaZihlhfdZJZ[b]bbijb^mfZebklhjbxhlhfqlh
_]h hl_p i_j_k_ebeky \ FZjhddh Kf k_b^ :[m Ze-=Zeb Zl-LZd\b ©:eNbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ª–K
687
I_e_©Iml_r_kl\b_\wj-Jby^bhkh[ZyihqlZª\i_j_\h^_^hdlhjZ=bku
:fbgZ–K
688
LZf`_–K
689
LZd`_kf>bdkhg©:e-Dm\_cl\Z^`ZjZlmoZªGZkujZe-NZjZ^`©Dbyf
Ze-]mrZj Zk-KZ]m^byª Bkke_^h\Zgb_ kZm^bckdh-[jblZgkdbo hlghr_gbc –
K–:[mZe-=ZebZl-LZd\b©:e-NbjdZZe-\ZooZ[bynbob^fZlfZg"ªK– 357.
320
ijb\_klb ykgu_ b ^hklh\_jgu_ ^h\h^u ^hdZau\Zxsb_ bklbg
ghklv gZrbo ml\_j`^_gbc Fu lZd`_ ijbghkbf k\hb ba\bg_
gby _keb kj_^b gbo \klj_lylky g_ hq_gv ^hklh\_jgu_ ^h\h^u
Fg_`Zedhl_obkdj_ggbofmkmevfZgdhlhju_ihke_^h\ZebaZ
b^_yfb \ZooZ[bafZ WlZ dgb]Z ij_^gZagZqZ_lky bf_ggh ^ey
gbo y bkdj_gg_ `_eZx \ua\heblv bo ba wlhc aeh\_s_c iZmlb
guqlh[uy^iZmdZg_mki_eijhgbdgmlv\boqbklh_l_eh
Klhqdbaj_gbyl_hjbb<ZooZ[bluhl^Zebij_^ihql_gb_
fm^`Zkkbfblkdhc Zdu^_ dhlhjZy y\ey_lky hkgh\hc ojbklbZg
kl\Z B[g L_cfby ihaZbfkl\h\Ze wlm Zdu^m ba ojbklbZgkdbo
dgb] i_j_\_^_gguo k ]j_q_kdh]h yaudZ b jZkijhkljZg_gguo \
OmjjZg_ Mq_gu_ RZfZ h[ty\beb B[g L_cfbx _j_lbdhf b
ijb]h\hjbeb d aZdexq_gbx \ dj_ihklb ]^_ hg b mf_j <ZooZ
[bluj_Zgbfbjh\ZebojbklbZgkdmxZdu^mB[gL_cfbbbgZqZ
ebjZkijhkljZgylv__h]g_fbf_qhfkj_^b`bl_e_c:jZ\bckdh
]hihemhkljh\ZZlZd`_h[ty\beb^ha\he_ggufbdjh\vbbfm
s_kl\hfmkmevfZg-_^bgh[h`gbdh\
K lhqdb aj_gby ijZdlbdb <ZooZ[blkdh_ \hckdh ihemqZ
ehg_ihkj_^kl\_ggmxfZl_jbZevgmxb\h_ggmxihfhsvhl\b
p_-]m[_jgZlhjZ Bg^bb >`hg Nbebiib ebqgh i_j_^Z\Ze \h`
^yf\ZooZ[blh\djmigu_kmffu^_g_]_klvk\b^_l_evkl\Zqlh
hgbihemqZebihr_klv^_kyllukyqj_Zeh\\]h^Zi_j_^gZiZ
^_gb_f <_ebdh[jblZgbb gZ ;Zkjm \ZooZ[blu ^ey \hhjm`_gby
[_^mbgkdbo ie_f_g \hxxsbo ijhlb\ B[g JZrb^Z ihemqbeb
klhlukyqj_Zeh\Djhf_lh]h[jblZgkdb_hnbp_judhgkmevlb
jh\Zeb690 \ZooZ[blkdbo \h_gZqZevgbdh\ hlghkbl_evgh kljZl_
]bb \_^_gby \hcg b kgZ[`Zeb hjm`b_f ;h_\ufb ^_ckl\byfb
g_ihkj_^kl\_ggh jmdh\h^be >`hg Nbebiib gZ[ex^Z\rbc aZ
gbfb k \urdb ihlhfm qlh [hyeky mqZklb dZiblZgZ R_dkib
jZ691.
>bdkhg ©:e-Dm\_cl \Z ^`ZjZlmoZª <ur_ [ueh kdZaZgh qlh hnbp_ju
=ZfbevlhgbDZgebnijb[ueb\j_]bhgki_pbZevgh^eywlh]h
691
OZcjbOZffZ^©=Z[^meeZNbebiibª–K
690
321
Q_f`_[ueZ\ua\ZgZlZdZykbevgZyex[h\v
f_`^mZg]ebqZgZfbb\ZooZ[blZfb"
<h-i_j\uo [jblZgpu gZ hkgh\_ ]hjvdh]h bg^bckdh]h
hiulZagZebqlh_kebhgbohlylgZ^he]hbijhqghaZdj_iblvky
gZ :jZ\bckdhf ihemhkljh\_ lh bf ke_^m_l ih]Zkblv ieZfy
^`boZ^Z JZa\_ hgb ohl_eb ih\lhjblv hrb[db ^hims_ggu_ \
Bg^bb"
:g]ebqZg_ gZ[jZebkv obljhklb b fm^jhklb ba k\hbo
ij_^u^msbodhehgbaZlhjkdboihoh^h\bm\b^_eb\\ZooZ[baf_
l_kbeudhlhju_ihfh]ebbfhl\e_qvfmkmevfZghlgZklhys_
]h ^`boZ^Z ;eZ]h^Zjy Zg]ebckdbf ^_gv]Zf b hjm`bx \ZooZ
[blkdbc^`boZ^ij_\jZlbeky\\hcgmijhlb\fmkmevfZgdhlh
ju_ ydh[u ih]jyaeb \ yauq_kl\_ b [b^]Z ?keb \u ijhke_^bl_
bklhjbx \ZooZ[blkdbo \hcg lh aZf_lbl_ qlh hgb gbdh]^Z g_
\h_\Zeb ijhlb\ bm^__\ b ojbklbZg <ZooZ[blu ihdhjgh kdeh
gbeb k\hb ]heh\u i_j_^ Zg]ebqZgZfb ^Z`_ lh]^Z dh]^Z l_ gZ
dZaZebboaZijhklmidb692<kibkd_\ZooZ[blkdbo\h_gguoij_
klmie_gbc lhevdh fmkmevfZgkdb_kljZgub]hjh^ZF_ddZLZ
bnF_^bgZDZlZjDm\_clHfZg;ZkjZC_f_gb]hkm^Zjkl\Z
RZfZ ;he__ lh]h \ZooZ[blu ^Z`_ ]hj^ylky l_f qlh \h_\Zeb
ijhlb\fmkmevfZgFZjhddh?]bilZBjZgZbLmjpbb
<h-\lhjuoHkfZgkdZybfi_jby[ueZih^h[gZdhklbaZ
kljy\r_c \ ]hje_ ojbklbZgkdh-bm^_ckdbo bfi_jbZebklh\ ih
wlhfm\ZooZ[bafy\bekyh^gbfbakj_^kl\iha\heb\rboZg]eb
qZgZf^hklb]gmlvk\hbop_e_c\ZjZ[kdbokljZgZoBf_gghih
wlhfm dh]^ZFmoZffZ^=Zebh^_j`Zeih[_^mgZ^\ZooZ[blZfb
b [ue ]hlh\ iheghklvx mgbqlh`blv bo \hckdZ lZd `_ dZd wlh
kemqbehkv \ ] ;jblZgby =_jfZgby b Jhkkby kh[jZeb
kjhqgmx dhgn_j_gpbx ] dm^Z ^ey jZaj_r_gby wlhc ijh
[e_fu[ueZijb]eZr_gZbLmjpby
<ZooZ[blubkijZ\ghkem`bebZg]ebqZgZfb^_ckl\h\Zeb
lhqgh ih mdZaZgghfm ieZgm HkfZgkdZy bfi_jby qlh[u ij_
GZijbf_j dh]^Z \ZooZ[blu m[beb g_dhlhjuo [jblZgkdbo ih^^Zgguo
bg^bcp_\\hfZgkdhf]hjh^_KmjZg]ebqZg_mkljhbebihdZaZl_evgmxdZjZ
l_evgmxZdpbxZ\ZooZ[bluijbagZebk\hxg_ijZ\hlm
692
322
djZlblv\hcgm\]^Z`_ijbagZeZ\eZ^uq_kl\h\ZooZ[blh\
gZ^ G_^`^hf gh dh]^Z :g\Zj-iZrZ ihijhkbe \ZooZ[blh\ ih
fhqv \ aZsbl_ ;Zkju hl Zg]ebqZg hgb hl\_lbeb qlh aZgylu
\hcghc ijhlb\ B[g JZrb^Z693 <bp_-]m[_jgZlhj ;jblZgbb \
Bg^bb yg\Zjy ] \ujZabek\hx[eZ]h^Zjghklv\ZooZ[b
lZf aZ lh qlh hgb ij_iylkl\h\Zeb B[g JZrb^m b hg g_ kfh]
hdZaZlv ih^^_j`dm HkfZgkdhc bfi_jbb Fbkl_j D_gbk LhfZk
aZy\eyeqlh\ZooZ[blu[uebihklhyggufbkhxagbdZfb;jblZ
gbb b ©ihfh]Zeb k\hbf [jblZgkdbf khxagbdZf \hckdZfb \h
\j_fybo\hcgijhlb\Lmjpbb\]b]ª694.
Dh]^Z ij_^klZ\bl_eb bjZdkdbo fmkmevfZg hldZaZebkv
ijbagZlv [jblZgkdbc fZg^Zl \ j_]bhg_ \ ] dZd ibr_l h[
wlhf =Z[^jZaZd Ze-Omkgb \ dgb]_ ©LZjbo Ze-\baZjZl Ze]bjZdbyªlh[jblZgpZfijbrehkv\gh\vijb[_]gmlvdihfhsb
\ZooZ[blh\ dhlhju_ ghqvx fZjlZ kh\_jrbeb dZjZl_evguc
gZ[_]kp_evx©\jZamfblvªbjZdp_\<blh]_[jblZgpuihemqb
eblhqlhohl_eb
A^_kv fu \gh\v ohlbf ijb\_klb iha^jZ\bl_evgmx l_e_
]jZffm\h`^y\ZooZ[blh\gZijZ\e_ggmxI_jkbDhdkm\k\yab
kh \aylb_f ;Zkju ©=hkih^bgm I_jkb Dhdkm ij_^klZ\bl_ex
[jblZgkdhc dhjhgu \ j_]bhg_ ^Z ijh^eblky __ \_ebqb_ GZ
klmie_gb_\Zrbo\hckd\BjZd_y\behkvh]jhfghcih^^_j`dhc
bq_klvx^eyfmkmevfZgFu]hlh\u\_qghih^^_j`b\ZlvgZrb
^jm`_kl\_ggu_hlghr_gbybihfh]Zlv\Zfª695.
Ihfhsv\ZooZ[blh\k\hbfZg]ebckdbf^jmavyfg_h]jZ
gbqbeZkvlhevdhZjZ[kdbfbkljZgZfb>hdlhjKZeZoZe-=ZddZ^
ibr_l qlh wfbj \ZooZ[blh\ ijbau\Ze fmkmevfZg Bg^bb \h_
\ZlvgZklhjhg_:g]ebb\h\j_fyh[_bofbjh\uo\hcg696.
IhwlbfijbqbgZfZg]ebqZg_\k_]^Zih^^_j`b\Zeb\Zo
oZ[blh\bihwlhc`_ijbqbg_hgbihfh]ebbf\]dh]^Z
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–K
LZf`_hgijb\h^blkkuedbgZhnbpbZevgu_^hdmf_glu
695
:e-OZlu[©KZnZoZlfbglZjboZe-^`ZabjZª–KkhkkuedZfbgZbk
lhqgbdb
696
>hdlhj KZeZo Ze-=ZddZ^ ©>`ZabjZ Ze-]ZjZ[by nb Ze-]Zkj Ze-oZ^bkª –
Bgklblmlbkke_^h\ZgbcZjZ[kdhcbklhjbbbdmevlmjuDZbj–K
693
694
323
©<hckdh [jZlv_\ª jZkdju\r__ lZcgm \ZooZ[bafZ ihiulZehkv
mgbqlh`blvwlmk_dlm
M[bckl\hfmkmevfZgbihfhsvdhehgbaZlhjZf
<ZooZ[blu l_jjhjbabjh\Zeb fmkmevfZg l_o j_]bhgh\
dm^Z kfh]eb ^h[jZlvky Hgb iha\hebeb k_[_ \h_\Zlv k fmkmev
fZgZfbh[\bgyybo\hloh^_hl[h`_kl\_gguoij_^ibkZgbcgh
\ lh `_ \j_fy hgb gbdh]^Z g_ \h_\Zeb ijhlb\ bm^_hojbklbZgkdbo dhehgbaZlhjh\ < k\h_f ibkvf_ bg^bckdhfm ]_
g_jZe-]m[_jgZlhjm h^bg ba \ZooZ[blkdbo wfbjh\ ibkZe ©Fu
ihklhyggh \hx_f ijhlb\ l_o ex^_c dhlhju_ gZau\Zxl k_[y
fmkmevfZgZfbGZkZfhf^_e_hgbhlhrebhlij_^ibkZgbcKh
a^Zl_ey b ?]h ijhjhdZ FmoZffZ^Z Y g_ kh[bjZxkv \h_\Zlv k
d_f-eb[h^jm]bfdjhf_gboY]ZjZglbjmxqlh^Z`_g_kh[b
jZxkvijb[eb`Zlvkyd\Zrbf[_j_]Zfyke_^mxZdu^_FmoZf
fZ^Z \u `_ fh`_l_ ^_eZlv lh qlh \Zf aZ[eZ]hjZkkm^blkyª697.
LZdh\u\ZooZ[blu\hxxsb_ijhlb\fmkmevfZgbh[\bgyxsb_
bo \ \hh[jZ`Z_fhf hloh^_ hl j_eb]bb gh ij_^hklZ\eyxsb_
[_ahiZkghklvbhojZgmg_\_jgufgZklhysZyf_qlZojbklbZg
<ZooZ[blu g_ h]jZgbqbebkv lhevdh l_f qlh \h_\Zeb
k\hbfbkbeZfbdjhf_wlh]hhgbijba\Zebdk_[_gZih^^_j`dm
[jblZgkdbc \h_ggh-fhjkdhc nehl dhlhjuc ^_j`Ze \ [ehdZ^_
ijb[j_`gu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ ]hjh^Z H^bg ba \ZooZ[blkdbo
wfbjh\gZibkZe\k\h_fibkvf_ke_^mxs__©Fu^Z_f\Zf]Z
jZglbb\Zr_cg_ijbdhkgh\_gghklbZlZd`_g_ijbdhkgh\_gghk
lb \k_o \Zrbo khxagbdh\ gh \aZf_g wlh]h ijhkbf khojZgblv
gZklhysmx ^bkehdZpbx \h_gguo km^h\ [ehdbjmxsbo ihjlu
gZrbo\jZ]h\ª698.
<ZooZ[blkdbcijhba\heijb\_edlhfmqlhojbklbZg_ba
`Zehklb d g_\bgguf fmkmevfZgZf ihlj_[h\Zeb hl \ZooZ[blh\
©DjZldh_ hibkZgb_ \ZooZ[blkdbo ie_f_gª ba kh[jZgby ba[jZgguo [hf
[_ckdbo aZibkhd ba^Zgh lZcghc iheblbq_kdhc [hf[_ckdhc dZgp_eyjb_c
]–LkgZZg]eYa
698
D_eeb >` ; ©;jblZgby \ I_jkb^kdhf aZeb\_ -]]ª – Ba^-\h
©Hdknhj^ª – K gZ Zg]e ya k ijbeh`_gbyfb nZdkbfbe_ ibk_f
\ZooZ[blkdbowfbjh\kih^ibkyfbbi_qZlyfb
697
324
ij_djZlblvboa\_jkl\Z<qZklghklb[jblZgkdbcih\_j_gguc\
;Zkj_\b^yihke_^kl\byj_agbb]jZ[_`Zkhklhjhgu\ZooZ[bl
kdboie_f_g\]ihlj_[h\Zeqlh[uhgb\_jgmebqZklvgZ
]jZ[e_ggh]hohay_\Zf\hl\_lgZwlhlj_[h\Zgb_\ZooZ[blkdbc
wfbj gZibkZe ©DZd \u fh`_l_ lj_[h\Zlv qlh[u fu \_jgmeb
bfms_kl\hdhgnbkdh\Zggh_m`bl_e_c?]bilZ>`b^^uRZo
jZ Ze-FZdeZ FZkdZlZ ;Zkju b i_jkh\" Hgb \k_ klhjhggbdb
KZ]b^Z[bgKmelZgZhgb\k_gZrb\jZ]bFu[m^_fm[b\Zlvbo
\_a^_ ]^_ \klj_lbf ihkdhevdm wlh \_e_gb_ :eeZoZ :eeZo \_
ebdª699 <k_ ykgh kdZaZgh ae_crb_ \jZ]b – wlh fmkmevfZg_ Z
[eb`Zcrb_khxagbdb–ojbklbZg_
<ZooZ[blugZjmrbeb\k_ghjfuijbebqby^Z`_ghjfu
ihqblZ_fu_ojbklbZgZfbIhwlhfm[jblZgpu[ueb\ugm`^_gu
ih^m]jhaZfbihlj_[h\Zlvqlh[uhgbhklZ\beb\ihdh_fbjguo
ex^_c>Zmgbabl:eeZo\ZooZ[blh\
Ihke_aZdZlZ;jblZgkdhcbfi_jbb\ZooZ[blui_j_reb\
jmdb gh\h]h ohaybgZ – KR: gZklZe gh\uc \_d \ dhlhjhf g_
[uehg_h[oh^bfhklb\©<hckd_[jZlv_\ª
N_l\uhihfhsbdhehgbaZlhjZf
<ZooZ[blkdb_mq_gu_b\qZklghklbdjmig_crbcbagbo
B[g ;Za ba^Ze n_l\m jZaj_rZxsmx ij_^hklZ\e_gb_ \h_gguo
[Za ^ey \hckd KR: gZiZ\rbo gZ fmkmevfZg BjZdZ700 ;he__
lh]hhgba^Zen_l\m\dhlhjhcjZaj_rbem[b\ZlvbjZdp_\^Z
`_ _keb l_ kh\_jrZxl fhebl\m Gh ihq_fm `_ lh]^Z hg ba^Ze
n_l\m aZij_sZxsmx >`ZfZex =Z[^mggZkujm bkihevah\Zlv
bgnhjfZpbxkh\_lkdhcjZa\_^db\h\j_fy\hcguijhlb\BajZ
bey701?
B[jZobf =Z[^me]baa =Z[^me]Zgb ©KujZ] Ze-mfZjZª - ba^-\h ©>Zj ZkkZdbªEhg^hg–lK
700
;he__lh]hoZ^bkh\_^r_coJZ[b]Ze-FZ^oZebgZibkZedgb]m\dhlhjhc
iulZ_lky ^hdZaZlv qlh Zf_jbdZgh-[jblZgkdb_ \hckdZ ij_^ihqlbl_evg__
bjZdkdbofmkmevfZg
701
R_co=Z[^me]Zaba[bg=Z[^meeZ[bg;Za©GZd^Ze-dZmfbylZe-]ZjZ[byª©Ze-FZlZ[Ze-bkeZfbªba^Zgb_-_]]–Kbihke_^mxsb_
R_co B[g ;Za \ wlhc n_l\_ ^hr_e ^h lh]h qlh aZij_lbe ihevah\Zlvky ih
fhsvx bg`_g_jh\ b \jZq_c _keb hgb y\eyxlky g_\_jgufb Gh g_fgh]h
699
325
:ij_^k_^Zl_evdhfbkkbb\ukrbomq_guoihn_l\Zfba
^Zen_l\mjZaj_rZxsmxdhjhexDK:ghkblvdj_klbaZy\be
qlh wlh hl\_qZ_l bgl_j_kZf BkeZfZ Wlm n_l\m fu ijb\h^beb
\ur_
LZd`_ \ur_ fu mihfygmeb h lhf qlh \ZooZ[blkdb_
mq_gu_ba^Zebn_l\maZij_sZxsmxijhdebgZlvbm^__\bojb
klbZg wlm n_l\m hgb Zj]mf_glbjh\Zeb l_f qlh ijhdeylb_ g_
y\ey_lky ^_ygb_f ijbkmsbf fmkmevfZgZf L_dkl mihfygmlhc
n_l\u[ue^h\_^_g^hdZ`^h]hbfZfZ-ijhih\_^gbdZDK:
<ZooZ[blu \ aZjh^ur_ ^mrbeb ex[h_ ^\b`_gb_ \ klh
jhgmh[t_^bg_gbyfmkmevfZgkdbokljZg<qZklghklbhgbijh
lb\hklhyebh[t_^bg_gbxKbjbbb?]bilZ\]bihljZlbeb
^`mg_coh\qlh[ug_^himklblvwlh]hh[t_^bg_gby
]702.
LZd`_\ZooZ[blu\uklmiZebijhlb\h[t_^bg_gbyk_\_j
gh]h b x`gh]h C_f_gZ Eb\ZgkdZy ]Za_l ©:g-Gb^Zª hl
] ibkZeZ ©Ihke_ ih^ibkZgby khhl\_lkl\mxs_]h ^h
]h\hjZf_`^mk_\_jgufbx`gufC_f_ghfkZm^bckdb_\eZklb
\ki_rghfihjy^d_klZebkha^Z\Zlv\h_ggu_eZ]_jy^ey[_`_g
p_\ ba ^_fhdjZlbq_kdh]h C_f_gZ Djhf_ lh]h hgb kha^Zeb
©:jfbx hk\h[h`^_gby x`gh]h C_f_gZ b OZ^jZfZmlZª ykgh
qlhbop_evx[uedhgljhevgZ^\k_fOZ^jZfZmlhfª
>Z ^hjh]b_ fhb [jZlvy fmkmevfZg_ \ZooZ[blu ijhlb\
h[t_^bg_gbyfmkmevfZgghaZkhxagbq_kl\hkbm^_yfbbojbk
lbZgZfb Gh hiZkg__ \k_]h lh qlh \ZooZ[blu gZ^_\ h^_`^u
[h]h[hyag_gguo r_coh\ ijhih\_^mxl \hcgm ijhlb\ fmkmev
fZgqlh[ufmkmevfZg_\h_\Zeb^jm]ijhlb\^jm]ZbaZ[uebh
kZfuo\Z`guoijh[e_fZo
<Z`gh_ aZf_qZgb_ g_kfhljy gZ \k_ baeh`_ggh_ fu oh
lbf h[jZlblv \gbfZgb_ qblZl_ey gZ lh qlh g_ \k_ \ZooZ[blu
ij_ke_^mxl p_ev ihfhqv bm^_h-ojbklbZgkdbf dhehgbaZlhjZf
G_l jZ^bdZevgu_ \ZooZ[blu-oZjb^`blu \uklmiZxl aZ [hjv[m
iha^g__ ba^Ze n_l\m jZaj_rZxsmx ijbkmlkl\b_ bm^_h-ojbklbZgkdhc Zj
fbbKR:gZl_jjblhjbbDK:JZa\_wlhg_gZihfbgZ_l\Zfbm^_ckdbomq_
guobkdZ`Z\rbo[h`_kl\_ggh_mq_gb_"
702
=Z[^jZofZgZr-RZfjZgb©NZckZeZe-dZZlbe\ZZe-dZlbbeª–K
326
kbm^_yfbojbklbZgZfbbhklZevgufb\jZ]Zfbj_eb]bbhgbg_
\b^ylgbq_]hdjhf_djh\Z\h]himlbl_jjhjZ>jm]Zyiheh\bgZ
[he__ ehyevgu_ y\eyxlky bkdj_ggbfb h[fZgmlufb ex^vfb
hgb^mfZxlqlh^_ckl\mxljZ^b^h\hevkl\Z:eeZoZHgbkqb
lZxlk\ys_gguf\k_qlhhdjm`Z_lF_ddmbF_^bgmbg_agZ
xlqlh\ZooZ[blu\h\j_fy[ehdZ^u^h\_eb`bl_e_cF_ddb^h
]heh^ghc kf_jlb Hgb ^h kbo ihj ^mfZxl qlh FmoZffZ^ [bg
=Z[^me\ZooZ[ y\ey_lky h[gh\bl_e_f j_eb]bb \h_\Z\rbf ijh
lb\[b^]Zb\hajh`^Z\rbfijhjhq_kdmxkmggmIhwlhfmgZrZ
k \Zfb h[yaZgghklv ^h\_klb ^h bo k\_^_gby \kx wlm bgnhjfZ
pbxjZa[m^blvbohk\h[h^blvbahdh\g_\_`_kl\ZDZd[ulZf
gb [ueh h[fZgmlu_ [_^gy]b y\eyxlky bkdj_ggbfb fmkmevfZ
gZfbg_\_^ZxsbfbhlZcguoieZgZok\hbo\h`^_c<dhg_q
ghfblh]_:eeZoh[t_^bgblwlmmffm\DhjZg_ihwlhfmih\h
^m kdZaZgh ©Fu m`_ ij_^gZq_jlZeb \ IkZelbjb ihke_ lh]h
dZd baj_deb >ex^yf@ gZab^Zgb_ qlh a_fey ^hklZg_lky \ gZ
ke_^kl\hFhbfijZ\_^gufjZ[Zfª (21:105).
=eZ\Z^_\ylZy
AZdexq_gb_
<ZooZ[baf – wlh k_dlZ hl\_j]ZxsZy ex[hc ^bZeh] k
^jm]bfb fmkmevfZgkdbfb ^\b`_gbyfb Ih fg_gbx _]h ihke_
^h\Zl_e_c \ZooZ[baf y\ey_lky aZ\_jr_gghc j_eb]b_c \hieh
s_gb_fBkeZfZg_\hafh`ghkms_kl\h\Zgb_bklbgugb^hg_
]hgbihke_Beb\ukgbfbbebijhlb\gboBf_gghihwlhfm
[hevr__jZkijhkljZg_gb_wlZk_dlZihemqbeZ\G_^`^_bijb
[j_`guo]hkm^Zjkl\ZoI_jkb^kdh]haZeb\Z
Fu `_ agZ_f qlh \ZooZ[baf – wlh ih]Zgh_ ^_j_\h \u
jhkr__ \ ]jyaghc em`_ hgh g_ bf__l ijhqghc hkgh\u [_amk
eh\ghwlh^_j_\hiZ^_lih\he_:eeZoZIjbqbgu_]haZ]gb\Z
gbyaZeh`_gu\kZfhfmq_gbbfu\_jbfqlhdhg_pwlhck_dlu
[ebahdlZd`_dZdaZ\ljZrgbc^_gv
G_a^hjh\u_ihke_^kl\by\ZooZ[blkdbogh\r_kl\
Dhgnebdl f_`^m kZeZnblZfb b ^hdlhjhf FmoZffZ^hf
KZ]b^hf JZfZ^Zghf Ze-;mlu \ugm^be ihke_^g_]h gZibkZlv
327
dgb]m ©:k-KZeZnby fZjoZeZ aZfZgby fm[ZjZdZ ey fZaoZ[ ZebkeZfbª703 ©KZeZnbaf – [eZ]hkeh\_gguc bklhjbq_kdbc i_jb
h^Zg_bkeZfkdZyk_dlZª]^_hg^hdZau\Z_lqlhkh\j_f_ggu_
kZeZnblkdb_b^_by\eyxlky[b^]Z<wlhcdgb]_hgibr_l©<hi_j\uokfhf_glZihy\e_gbywlhc[b^]ZfmkmevfZg_g_agZeb
ihdhy b fbjghc `bagb Hgh \g_keh \ bo jy^u jhagv b g_gZ
\bklvWlZaZjZaZijhgbdeZ\hfgh]b_j_]bhgufmkmevfZgkdh]h
fbjZbijbg_keZfmkmevfZgZf\jZ`^mK_]h^gyih^\b^hffm
kmevfZgkdh]h\hajh`^_gbywlbb^_bgZqZebijhgbdZlv\?\jh
im b :f_jbdm b fu m`_ keurbf h ljZ]bq_kdbo ihke_^kl\byo
^_yl_evghklbwlboex^_c<]]y[ueijb]eZr_ggZ
dhgn_j_gpbx©<k_fbjghcfmkmevfZgkdhceb]bª]^_\klj_lbe
ky kh fgh]bfb ijhiZ]Zg^bklZfb BkeZfZ ba jZaebqguo j_]bh
gh\fbjZGhf_gykbevghhi_qZebehlhqlhdh]^Zybgl_j_kh
\ZekymgbohjZkijhkljZg_gbbbkeZfkdh]hijbau\Zhgb\k_\
h^bg]hehkaZy\eyeb©GZr_c_^bgkl\_gghcijh[e_fhcy\ey_l
ky jhagv b \jZ`^Z dhlhjmx k_xl ij_^klZ\bl_eb kZeZnblkdhc
h[sbguǻWlZjhagvb\jZ`^Zijb\_eZdlhfmqlhZ^fbgbkl
jZpby <Zrbg]lhgZ [ueZ \ugm`^_gZ \f_rZlvky b aZdjulv f_
q_lv gZ g_kdhevdh f_kyp_\ < f_q_lb IZjb`Z dhgnjhglZpby
gZ]g_lZeZkv\l_q_gb_lj_oe_lbihebp_ckdbfijbrehkv\aylv
__ rlmjfhf : gZ \hafms_ggu_ \ha]eZku fmkmevfZg ©DZdh_
ijZ\h \u bf__l_ \ju\Zlvky \ f_q_lv \ h[m\b"ª - ihebp_ckdb_
hl\_qZeb ©=emipu wlh \u \ugm^beb gZk ijb[_]gmlv d wlbf
f_jZfǻ < h^ghf ba j_]bhgh\ fmkmevfZgkdh]h fbjZ fmkmev
fZg_ \uklmibeb k hjm`b_f gZ aZsblm k\h_c jh^bgu dZd `_
ihklmibeb \ wlhf kemqZ_ kZeZnblkdb_ h[sbgu704" KZeZnblu
h[\bgbebwlbofmkmevfZg\yauq_kl\_\fh]behihdehggbq_kl
\_705 b bkihevah\Zgbb lZ\Zkkmey <ke_^ aZ wlbf ihke_^h\ZeZ b
khhl\_lkl\mxsZy n_l\Z hnbpbZevguo mq_guo djm]h\ H^bg ba
Ba^-\h©>ZjZe-nbdjª>ZfZkdKbjby]
AZf_lvl_qlhr_cohq_gvlhq_g\k\hbo\ujZ`_gbyohggZau\Z_lbokZ
eZnblkdbfbh[sbgZfbwlhmdZau\Z_lgZlhqlhg_kfhljygZ\b^bfh__^bg
kl\h\bojy^Zo_klvjZah[r_gghklv
705
Wlh h^bg ba hrb[hqguo \ZooZ[blkdbo l_jfbgh\ hg mdZau\Z_l gZ kdm^
ghklvboe_dkbdb
703
704
328
mq_guofmkmevfZgwlh]hj_]bhgZ[ue\ugm`^_gaZy\blv©DZd
\ufh`_l_h[\bgylvgZk\yauq_kl\_\_^vfudZ`^uc^_gvih
iylvjZabkihegy_ffhebl\m\dhlhjhcijhbaghkbf©L_[_fu
ihdehgy_fkybdL_[_\au\Z_fhihfhsbª"ªGhjZa\_wlbex^b
fh]mlmkeurZlvah\ª706.
>Ze__r_coibr_lhlhfdZd^\b`_gb_\ZooZ[bafZkih
kh[kl\h\Zeh jZa\blbx l_hjbb b bklhjbq_kdh]h ZgZebaZ fm
kmevfZgkdh]h gZke_^by707 klhjhggbdZfb ^bZe_dlbq_kdh]h fZ
l_jbZebafZ DZd ba\_klgh fZjdkbklkdZy l_hjby [Zabjm_lky gZ
b^__ [hjv[u ijhlb\hiheh`ghkl_c hkgh\u\Zykv gZ dhlhjhc
fZjdkbklu bkke_^my bklhjbx BkeZfZ k^_eZeb \u\h^ h lhf
qlh kZeZnbaf gZqbgZy k fhf_glZ ihy\e_gby BkeZfZ \ujZ`Ze
bgl_j_kuh^gh]hbaijhlb\h[hjkl\mxsbodeZkkh\bijh^he`Z
_l\ujZ`Zlvbo\iehlv^hgZrbo^g_c708R_co;mlumdZau\Z
_l ©Fm[lZ^b]b-\ZooZ[blu khkem`beb ij_djZkgmx kem`[m ih
ke_^h\Zl_eyf^bZe_dlbq_kdh]hfZl_jbZebafZFh`gh^Z`_kdZ
aZlvqlhhgbjZ[hlZeb\h^ghcdhfZg^_dhg_qghyg_bf_x\
\b^mqlh\aZbfhihfhsv\ZooZ[blh\bfZjdkbklh\[ueZaZjZg__
aZieZgbjh\ZgghcghnZdlhklZ_lkynZdlhfFZjdkbklubkke_
^my bklhjbx fmkmevfZgkdbo ^\b`_gbc k^_eZeb aZdexq_gb_ h
lhf qlh b \ fmkmevfZgkdhf fbj_ lh`_ reZ f_`deZkkh\Zy
[hjv[Z dhlhjZy [ueZ ihke_^kl\b_f hij_^_e_gguo bklhjbq_k
dbo b ]_h]jZnbq_kdbo h[klhyl_evkl\ Ih bo fg_gbx bf_ggh
[hjv[Z f_`^m kZeZnblZfb b eb[_jZeZfb ijb\_eZ fmkmevfZg
kdbcfbjd_]hl_i_j_rg_fmkhklhygbxª
Hibku\Zy g_\_`_kl\h b g_khagZl_evghklv709 kZeZnblh\
hg ibr_l ©;hevrhc ljZ]_^b_c y\ey_lky lhl nZdl qlh [hev
rbgkl\hgZrbokZeZnblkdbo[jZlv_\gZklhevdhkbevghm\e_q_
gu k\hbfb m[_`^_gbyfb qlh kfhljyl gZ fbj lhevdh q_j_a
ijbafm kZeZnbafZ Bo jZamf [_a^_ckl\m_l hgb aZdjuebkv \
:e-;mlu©:k-KZeZnby–fZjoZeZaZfZgby«ª– K– 245.
Ih^gZke_^b_fbf__lky\\b^mDhjZgbkmggZ
708
:e-;mlu©Zk-KZeZnby–fZjoZeZaZfZgby«ª–K– 249.
709
AZf_lvl_qlhr_co^_eZ_lih^h[gu_aZy\e_gbyg_kfhljygZk\h_m\Z`_
gb_dh\k_ffmkmevfZgkdbfb^_cgufl_q_gbyf
706
707
329
kdhjemi_ \ZooZ[bafZ bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgb g_ aZf_qZxl qlh
ijhbkoh^bl\hdjm]gboqlh^_eZxlbo\g_rgb_\jZ]b«710»
Ijbf_qZl_evgh lh qlh g_kfhljy gZ \hagbdgh\_gb_mq_
gbyB[gL_cfbb\RZf_hghg_gZrehlZf^eyk_[y[eZ]h^Zl
ghc ihq\u < RZf_ [ueh hq_gv fgh]h gZklhysbo fmkmevfZg
kdbo mq_guo ihwlhfm ik_\^hkZeZnbafm ijbrehkv ba[jZlv
G_^`^ jh^bgm FmkZceZfu gZk_e_ggmx g_\_`_kl\_ggufb [_
^mbgkdbfb ie_f_gZfb < lh `_ \j_fy m^b\ey_l lhl nZdl qlh
f_^bgpuihlhfdbkih^\b`gbdh\IjhjhdZk]kihke_^h\Zeb
aZ ijhiZ]Zg^bklZfb b^_c B[g L_cfbb b kihdhcgh kemrZxl
dZd l_ ydh[u ieZqml \ fhebl\_ K\yl :eeZo Hg bkiulu\Ze
kih^\b`gbdh\\hckdZfbFmkZceZfubbkiulu\Z_lgZkik_\^h
kZeZnblZfbjZajmrZxsbfb_^bgkl\hfmkmevfZgkdhcmffu
<hijhkulj_[mxsb_hl\_lZ
M\Z`Z_fu_\ZooZ[blu\Zr_\_jhm[_`^_gb_kljhblky
gZ kms_kl\h\Zgbb ;h]Z dhlhjuc gZoh^blky \ nbabq_kdhf
kfuke_\ur_\Zk\f_kl_gZau\Z_fhfg_[hfBf_gghihwlhfm
\u g_ ^himkdZ_l_ fukeb h lhf qlh A_fey djm]eZy Ih wlhfm
ih\h^m \u ba^Z_l_ ^Z`_ p_eu_ dgb]b gZijbf_j ©Ob^Zyl ZeoZcjZgnbfZkZeZZ^-^ZmjZgªBf_ggh\k\yabkwlbf\uh[\b
gy_l_ \ aZ[em`^_gbb K_b^Z Dml[Z b r_coZ Za-Abg^Zgb ;he__
lh]h \Zr \h`^v B[g ;Za jZaj_rbe m[b\Zlv l_o ex^_c dhlh
ju_\_jyl\lhqlhA_feydjm]eZyb\jZsZ_lky\hdjm]KhegpZ
Ghqlh`_ijhbahc^_lk\Zrbf\_jhm[_`^_gb_fdh]^Zh^bgba
\Zrbo kugh\ ih^gbf_lky \ dhkfhk b aZy\bl qlh A_fey ^_ckl
\bl_evghdjm]eZy"
<Zrbr_cobbgZklZ\gbdbaZdhlhjufb\uke_^m_l_
aZy\eyxlhlhfqlh:^g_\_q_gGhg_m`_eb\ukZfbgbdh]^Z
g_ qblZeb keh\ :eeZoZ \ DhjZg_ ©hdZ`mlky \ Z^kdhf h]g_
ij_[m^mllZf\_qghª (98:6), ©HgbaZohlylkiZklbkvhlh]gy
gh gb aZ qlh g_ kiZkmlky m]hlh\Zgh bf \_qgh_ gZdZaZgb_ª
" G_m`_eb \u g_ keurZeb b g_ qblZeb oZ^bku IjhjhdZ
k]k ]eZkysb_ ©< Km^guc ^_gv ijb\_^ml kf_jlv \ h[jZa_
710
:e-;mlu©Zk-KZeZnby–fZjoZeZaZfZgby«ª–K
330
[_ehch\puZ\jb\Zyl_hl:[mDmjZc[Z^h[Z\e_gh©bihf_klyl
__f_`^mJZ_fb:^hfªMh[blZl_e_cJZykijhkyl©AgZ_l_eb
\udlhwlh"ª-hgbhl\_lyl©>Zwlhkf_jlvªAZl_fkijhkylm
h[blZl_e_c :^Z ©H h[blZl_eb :^Z agZ_l_ eb \u dlh wlh"ª hgbhl\_lyl©>ZagZ_fwlhkf_jlvªAZl_f[m^_l\_e_ghaZj_
aZlv wlm h\pm ihke_ q_]h h[blZl_eyf JZy b :^Z h[ty\yl ©H
h[blZl_ebJZy\Zk`^_l\_qgZy`bagv[_akf_jlbHh[blZl_eb
:^Z \Zk `^_l \_qgZy `bagv [_a kf_jlbª Ihke_ wlh]h Ijhjhd
k]k ijhq_e Zyl ©Ba\_sZc bo h ^g_ ]hj_kl_c <_^v j_r_gb_
>h[ bo gZdZaZgbb@ ijbgylh gh hgb g_ \_^Zxl >h[ wlhf@ b g_
\_jmxlª (19:39), -bmdZaZejmdhcgZwlhlfbjª:fh`_l[ulv
\u`Ze__l_B[ebkZ:[m>`ZoeZbM[Zy[bgOZeZnZ":fh`_l
[ulv \u ij_^gZf_j_ggh b hldjulh \uklmiZ_l_ ijhlb\ keh\
:eeZoZ b ?]h ijhjhdZ" Ijb\_^bl_ ^h\h^u iha\heyxsb_ \Zf
g_\hkijbgbfZlvwlbZyluboZ^bku
M[_`^_gb_ h le_gghklb :^Z y\ey_lky h^gbf ba klhe
ih\^`ZofbafZlh]^ZihdZdhfmijZ\m\u\k\hboijhih\_^yo
gZau\Z_l_^`ZofblZfbfmkmevfZggZoh^ysboky\hiihabpbbd
\Zr_fm ^\b`_gbx" <_^v wlh hij_^_e_gb_ [hevr_ ih^oh^bl
\ZfZg_bf
GZ aZj_ k\h_c bklhjbb \u ijbau\Zeb ex^_c i_j_k_
eylvky\G_^`^H[wlhfibr_lbKme_cfZg[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[
b \Zr bklhjbd-e_lhibk_p B[g ;ZrZj Gh \_^v dZd ba\_klgh
©ihke_\aylbyF_ddbi_j_k_e_gby[ulvg_fh`_lª<k[hjgbd_
FmkebfZ ih wlhfm ih\h^m ijb\h^blky ke_^mxs__ \ukdZau\Z
gb_IjhjhdZk]k©Emqrbff_klhf^eygboy\ey_lkyF_^b
gZb_kebdlh-eb[hbagboih`_eZ_l__ihdbgmlvba-aZZglbiZ
lbb d g_c lh :eeZo aZf_gbl wlh]h q_eh\_dZ [he__ ijZ\_^guf
dhlhjucih`_eZ_l`blv\wlhf]hjh^_Dlhg_kfhljygbgZqlh
[m^_l`blv\F_^bg_lhfmy[m^maZklmigbdhfbk\b^_l_e_f\
Km^guc ^_gvª Ih dZdhfm ijZ\m \u ijbau\Zeb ex^_c i_j_k_
eylvky \ G_^`^" JZa\_ \u g_ keurZeb keh\ IjhjhdZ k]k
©GZqZeh g_\_`_kl\Z gZ \hklhd_ª - dZd jZa lZf ]^_ gZoh^blky
G_^`^ < ^jm]hf oZ^bk_ kdZaZgh ©< C_f_g_ ijbkmlkl\m_l \_
jZ Z kfmlZ ijb^_l hllm^Z ]^_ ihy\blky jh] kZlZguª LZd`_ \
h[hbo^hklh\_jguok[hjgbdZoijb\h^blkyoZ^bkhlB[g=mfZ
331
jZj:]]^_Ijhjhdk]kmdZau\ZygZ\hklhdkdZaZe©LZf
^j_fe_lkfmlZª<k[hjgbd_Ze-;moZjb\dgb]_©Hiylgbqghc
fhebl\_ªijb\h^blkyfhev[ZIjhjhdZk]k©H:eeZo[eZ]h
keh\b gZr RZf b C_f_gª Dlh-lh kdZaZe ©B gZr G_^`^ª
Ijhjhdk]k\gh\vih\lhjbe©H:eeZo[eZ]hkeh\bgZrRZf
b C_f_gªg_dlh\gh\vih\lhjbe©BgZrG_^`^ªLh]^ZIjh
jhd k]k kdZaZe ©LZf ihljyk_gby b kfmlu hllm^Z \ujZkl_l
jh] kZlZguª Ihoh`bc oZ^bk hl B[g =mfZjZ ijb\h^blky m Ze;moZjb\]eZ\_©HkfmlZoªmZl-Lbjfbab\]eZ\_©Ke_^uªb\
k[hjgbd_ bfZfZ :ofZ^Z < wlhf oZ^bk_ jZkkdZau\Z_lky h lhf
dZd Ijhjhd k]k kh\_jrbe fhev[m ©H :eeZo [eZ]hkeh\b
gZrmF_^bgmgZrkZ]gZrfZ^^gZrC_f_gbgZrRZfª-Z
aZl_fih\_jgm\rbkvgZ\hklhd\klhjhgmkhegpZkdZaZe©Hl
lm^Z \ujZkl_l jh] kZlZguª Ihq_fm `_ \u gZ aZj_ k\h_c bklh
jbbijbau\Zebex^_ci_j_k_eylvky\ijhdeylu_a_febbhklZ\
eylv[eZ]h^Zlgu_F_ddmbF_^bgm"
<uml\_j`^Z_l_qlh_keb[ug_\ZooZ[baflh`bl_eb
:jZ\bckdh]h ihemhkljh\Z \gh\v \_jgmebkv [u d b^hehihdehg
gbq_kl\mGhjZa\_\ug_keurZeboZ^bkIjhjhdZk]ki_j_
^ZggucFmkebfhfhl=Zcrb\]eZ\_©HkfmlZoª©G_ijhc^_l
b ^gy k ghqvx dZd gZqgml ex^b ihdehgylvky Ze-EZlm b Ze=maa_ª Y kijhkbeZ ©Gh \_^v :eeZo \ DhjZg_ kdZaZe ©Hg –
lhl dhlhjuc ihkeZe K\h_]h IhkeZggbdZ k jmdh\h^kl\hf d
ijyfhfm imlb b bklbgghc \_jhc qlh[u \hag_klb __ ij_\ur_
ex[hc j_eb]bb dZd [u g_gZ\bklgh wlh gb [ueh fgh]h[h`gb
dZfªIjhjhdk]khl\_lbe©>Zlh\_jghghgZklmibl
^_gv dh]^Z :eeZo gZre_l gZ A_fex eZkdh\uc \_l_j dhlhjuc
mihdhbl \k_o l_o \ qvbo ^mrZo [ueZ ohly [u qZklbqdZ \_ju
Ihke_q_]hgZa_fe_hklZgmlkylhevdhom^rb_bakha^Zgbc:e
eZoZdhlhju_b\_jgmlkydj_eb]bbk\hbohlph\b^hehihdehg
gbq_kl\mªOZ^bki_j_^ZghlFmoZffZ^Z[bgZe-FmkZgguhl
:[m;ZdjZZe-OZgZnbhl=Z[^meoZfb^Z[bg>`Z]nZjZ<dgb]_
©H\_j_ªijb\h^blkyoZ^bkhlZe-<Zeb^Z[bgRm^`Z]ZhlOZ
jmgZ[bg=Z[^meeubOZ^`Z^`Z[bgZr-RZ]bjZdhlhju_kdZ
aZebqlhbfi_j_^ZeOZ^`Z^`[bgFmoZffZ^hlB[g>`mjZc
^`Z hl :[m Za-Am[ZcjZ keurZ\r_]h jZkkdZa >`Z[bjZ [bg
332
=Z[^meeuhlIjhjhdZk]k©<fh_cmff_\iehlv^hKm^gh]h
^gy[m^_l]jmiiZfmkmevfZgdhlhju_[m^mlkjZ`ZlvkyaZbklb
gmbih[_^ylGZklmibl\j_fydh]^Z[m^_lgbkihkeZgBkZ[bg
FZjvyf ]k b wfbj fmkmevfZg ih`_eZ_l mklmiblv _fm k\h_
f_klh \ fhebl\_ gh BkZ ]k kdZ`_l ©Ihki_rb kh\_jrb k
gZfbfhebl\m:eeZoihqlbewlmmffmbk^_eZeh^gbowfbjZfb
gZ^^jm]bfbªDZd\b^bl_wlboZ^bkuykgh]h\hjylqlhb^heh
ihdehggbq_kl\h\_jg_lky\fmkmevfZgkdb_j_]bhgulhevdhih
ke_ lh]h dZd i_j_^ Km^guf ^g_f mfjml \k_ fmkmevfZg_ B
=ZcrZ kijZ\_^eb\h aZf_lbeZ qlh mihfygmluc Zyl hljbpZ_l
\hafh`ghklv\ha\jZs_gbyfmkmevfZgdyauq_kl\mLh`_kZfh_
ih^l\_j`^Z_lky b ijhjhq_kdhc kmgghc <u `_ ijhlb\hj_qZ
wlbfZylZfboZ^bkZfaZy\ey_l_hlhfqlh\_kvfmkmevfZgkdbc
fbj ihdehgyeky b^heZf DZd \u \hh[s_ fh`_l_ hljbpZlv k\_
^_gbykhh[s_ggu_Ijhjhdhfk]k711?
<uaZij_sZ_l_qblZlv712fgh]b_dgb]bfmkmevfZgkdbo
mq_guo qlh `_ dZkZ_lky dgb] lZdbo fmkmevfZgkdbo fukebl_
e_cdZdK_b^Dml[lhbo\hh[s_g_evay\\hablv\\ZrbkljZ
guQ_f\k_wlh\ua\Zgh"Q_]h\u[hbl_kv"Fh`_lhgbhiZkgu
Lj_lbc b q_l\_jluc \hijhku ijb\_^_gu ba dgb]b ©:k-KZ\Z]bd Zebeyoby«ª Kme_cfZgZ [bg =Z[^me\ZooZ[Z gZf ijbrehkv bo agZqbl_evgh
khdjZlblvihkdhevdmZ\lhjijb\h^blhq_gvih^jh[gu_^h\h^u
712
GZijbf_jdgb]b:[mOZfb^ZZe-=ZaZebDhg_qgh`_\uke_^m_l_kh\_
lZfk\h_]hr_coZB[gL_cfbbdhlhjucihwlhfmih\h^mibr_l\©RZjoZe]Zdb^Z Ze-ZknZoZgbyª k >jm]hc r_co =Z[^meZlun [bg =Z[^jZofZg
mkeurZ\hlhfqlhg_dhlhju_fmkmevfZg_m\e_dZxlkyql_gb_f©:e-Bovyª
gZibkZedgb]m©FZ^`fm]Zj-jZkZbe\ZZe-fZkZbeZg-gZ^`^byª]^_\lhf_
gZk–djblbdm_lbihghkblbfZfZZe-=ZaZeb;he__lh]hhghkf_
ebekyaZy\blvqlhydh[uZa-AZoZ[bgZau\Zedgb]bZe-=ZaZeb©\\h^ysbfb\
aZ[em`^_gb_ªlhl`_bklhqgbdk?keb\ukjZ\gbl_©:e-Bovyªbdgb
]b ijb\_j`_gp_\ b^_b h le_gghklb :^Z lh ijb^_l_ d \u\h^m qlh i_j\Zy
dgb]Z \h fgh]h jZa emqr_ Qlh `_ dZkZ_lky Za-AZoZ[b lh hg \ k\h_ \j_fy
[uebkdj_ggbfihke_^h\Zl_e_fB[gL_cfbbbbf_ggh\wlh\j_fygZibkZe
k\hx dgb]m ©:e-FbaZgª ]^_ g_dhlhjuo mq_guo gZa\Ze ©`b\hlgufbª
©oZc\ZgªgZijbf_j=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z[bgFmkmFmkm[bg=Z[^meem
<dgb]_©:k-Kbyj«ªh^gh]hmq_gh]hhggZa\Ze©kh[Zdhcª
Hl _]h yaudZ ihkljZ^Ze ^Z`_ Ze-OZdbf dhlhjh]h hg \ ©:e-FmklZ^jZdª
gZau\Z_lg_\_`^hc
711
333
^ey \Zr_c Zdu^u" JZa\_ q_eh\_d ihkljhb\rbc ijhqgh_ a^Z
gb_[hblky\_ljZ"<kihfgbl_IjhjhdZk]kjZa\_hg[hyeky
dh]h-eb[hbebq_]h-eb[h"G_lhg^Z`_`be[hdh[hdkbm^_y
fb:\uk_ebebobaF_^bgulhevdhaZij_^Zl_evkl\hG_m`_
eb \ \Zrbo ]eZaZo dgb]b fmkmevfZgkdbo mq_guo om`_ bm^_c
kdbo"G_m`_eb\Zkg_mkljZb\Z_lijbf_jIjhjhdZk]k"
<Zrbba^Zl_evkl\Zb[b[ebhl_dbihegudgb]ih^h[
guo ©:e-Bo\Zg Ze-fmkebfmg nb Ze-fbaZgª < wlbo dgb]Zo \u
djblbdm_l_ b ihghkbl_ lZdbo fmkmevfZgkdbo fukebl_e_c dZd
K_b^ Dml[ FmoZfZ^ Ze-=ZaZeb b :[m Ze-:]ey Ze-FZm^m^b
>Z`_ OZkZg Ze-;ZggZ g_ mp_e_e hl \Zr_c djblbdb < q_f `_
[ueZ_]h\bgZ">Zlhevdh\lhfqlhhgijbau\Zedk[eb`_gbx
ij_^klZ\bl_e_c \k_o fmkmevfZgkdbo l_q_gbc Q_f `_ \Zf ih
f_rZehwlhk[eb`_gb_"
<uklhbl_aZfgh]bfb[_^Zfb\uiZ\rbfbgZ]heh\u
fmkmevfZg aZ \hcgZfb f_`^m jZaebqgufb fmkmevfZgkdbfb
^\b`_gbyfb <Zrb ]jyagu_ jmdb ijhgbdeb ^Z`_ \ :n]Zgbk
lZg713 bf_ggh \u [ueb ijhlb\gbdZfb h[t_^bg_gbyZn]Zgkdbo
]jmiibjh\hd d dhlhjhfm ijbau\Ze :[^meeZ =ZaaZf j_^Zdlhj
`mjgZeZ ©:e->`boZ^ª <Zr `mjgZe ©:e-Fh^`Zo_^ª [ue \u
ims_g\dZq_kl\_hiihabpbb_]h`mjgZem
<gbfZl_evguc gZ[ex^Zl_ev aZf_lbl \Zrb djh\Z\u_
ke_^u\Km^Zg_Eb\Zg_b:e`bj_Bf_ggh\u[uebijbqbghc
kfml jZa]hj_\rboky \ j_kim[ebdZo [u\r_]h KKKJ JZa\_ \u
g_ ihfgbl_ qlh bfZf kh[hjghc f_q_lb =jhagh]h J_kim[ebdb
Q_qgy [ue m[bl lhevdh aZ k\hc hldZa ijbkh_^bgblvky d \ZooZ
[blkdhfm^\b`_gbxIhfgbl_eb\uqlhba\_klb_h[wlhf[u
ehjZkijhkljZg_gh\Zfbq_j_aKFB<_ebdh[jblZgbb"Dhfm`_
\ukem`bl_gZkZfhf^_e_"
< jZaebqguo j_]bhgZo fbjZ \u kha^Zeb bkeZfkdb_
p_glju\k_wlbp_gljuij_ke_^h\Zebk\h_cp_evxjZkijhkljZ
g_gb_ \ZooZ[blkdhc b^_heh]bb b k_yeb jhagv \ jy^Zo fmkmev
?keb\u`_eZ_l_[he__ih^jh[ghmagZlvh\ZooZ[blkdhckfml_\:n]Zgb
klZg_lhhagZdhfvl_kvkbgnhjfZpb_ckhhl\_lkl\mxsbokZclh\b\qZklgh
klb k dgb]hc ^hdlhjZ FmoZffZ^Z Ze-FZk]Zjb jZaf_s_gghc gZ kZcl_
www.ummah.net/cdlr.
713
334
fZg Wlb nZdlu ohjhrh ba\_klgu `bl_eyf KR: b AZiZ^ghc
?\jhiuQlhdZkZ_lky\Zrbof_q_l_clh\gbolZ`_kblmZpby
^he`ghklv bfZfZ fh]ml aZgbfZlv lhevdh m]h^gu_ \Zf ebpZ Z
bamqZlvkylhevdhm]h^gZy\Zfebl_jZlmjZ<Zr_ihy\e_gb_\g_
ijbgZ^e_`Zsbo\Zff_q_lyo\k_]^Z\ghkbljhagvbkfmlm\jy
^u fmkmevfZg YjqZcrbf ijbf_jhf kem`bl f_q_lv ]hjh^Z
DjZgnbev^ <_ebdh[jblZgby >h \Zr_]h ihy\e_gby f_klgu_
fmkmevfZg_ `beb \ fbj_ b kh]eZkbb ^he`ghklv bfZfZ \k_]^Z
bkihegyelhldlhemqr_agZeDhjZg\k_ijh[e_fubdhgnebd
lu jZaj_rZebkv ihex[h\gh gZ kh[jZgbb ijboh^Z f_q_lb Hgb
gbdh]^Z g_ dhgnebdlh\Zeb gZ ihq\_ ijbgZ^e_`ghklb d lhfm
bebbghfmfZaoZ[mdlhfmbebbghfml_q_gbxK\Zrbfihy\
e_gb_f f_q_lv jZa^_ebeZkv gZ fZaoZ[u b k_dlu b ihkl_i_ggh
himkl_eZ < qvbo bgl_j_kZo \u \k_ wlh ^_eZ_l_" JZa\_ d wlhfm
gZkijbau\Z_lBkeZf"
<ZrZdjh\Z\Zybklhjbyijb\h^blfgh`_kl\hijbf_
jh\fZkkh\h]hm[bckl\ZfmkmevfZg\ubom[b\Zebb^hbihke_
aZo\ZlZF_ddbkF_^bghc;he__lh]h\uk]hj^hklvxibr_l_
gZijbf_j \ ©=mg\Zg Ze-fZ^`^ª h k\hbo aeh^_ygbyo \ ZeBokZ DZlZj_ ;Zoj_cg_ DZlun_ KZ[oZg_ >`Z[Ze_ RZffZj
Bhj^Zgbb kljZgZo RZfZ HfZg_ BjZd_ b l^ Dlh \Zf jZaj_
rbe m[b\Zlv ie_gblv b ihjZ[hsZlv g_\bgguo fmkmevfZg"
Fh`_l_eb\uijb\_klb^h\h^ugZ^ha\he_gghklvwlbo^_ygbc"
B\gZrb^gb\u[_a\kydbo^hdZaZl_evkl\[_akm^Zb
ke_^kl\by \gmljb f_q_lb Ze-OZjZf ie_lvfb ba[b\Z_l_ g_\bg
guo b [_aaZsblguo ex^_c >Z`_ _keb hgb \bgh\gu jZa\_
fh`gh bkihegylv m]heh\gu_ gZdZaZgby \gmljb f_q_lb" JZa\_
fh`ghmgb`ZlvbgZdZau\Zlvq_eh\_dZ^h\ug_k_gbykm^_[gh]h
j_r_gby" Dhfbkkbb ZjZ[kdbo b g_ZjZ[kdbo kljZg ih ijZ\Zf
q_eh\_dZ mklZgh\beb qlh \Zfb [ueh hlk_q_gh fgh`_kl\h jmd
gh]b]heh\g_\bgguoex^_c<Zrba\_jkl\ZhibkZgu\blh]h
\hf hlq_l_ ] gZa\Zgghf ©Omdmd Ze-bgkZg nb Ze-fZfeZdZ
Ze-]ZjZ[by Zk-KZ]m^byª ©IjZ\Z q_eh\_dZ \ Dhjhe_\kl\_ KZm
^h\kdZy :jZ\byª <u gZjmrZ_l_ g_ lhevdh ghjfu f_`^mgZ
jh^gh]h gh ^Z`_ b rZjbZlkdh]h ijZ\Z Gb Ijhjhd k]k gb
ijZ\_^gu_ oZebnu gb h^bg bo oZebnh\ ijbr_^rbo ihke_
335
gbog_kh\_jrZeblh]hqlhkh\_jrbeb\uQ_f\ua\Zgh\Zr_
oh[[b–hlk_dZlvq_eh\_q_kdb_hj]Zgu"
1 <u k g_h[uqZcghc e_]dhklvx [_a dZdhc-eb[h hkgh
\Zl_evghc ijbqbgu h[\bgy_l_ fmkmevfZg \ yauq_kl\_ Lhqgh
lZd`_ ihklmiZeb kZnjblu ZajZdblu b bf ih^h[gu_ Gh _klv
kms_kl\_ggh_hlebqb_hgbg_bf_eblhc\eZklbdhlhjmxbf_
_l_ \u ihwlhfm bf g_ m^Zehkv ijbf_gblv k\hb m[_`^_gby gZ
ijZdlbd_<b^bl_eb\umk_[y_s_dZdh_-eb[hhlebqb_hlgbo"
<u djblbdm_l_ b[Z^blh\ aZ lh qlh hgb ^himkdZxl
oZebnkl\h g_dmj_crblh\ Gh jZa\_ g_ \u ba]gZeb ZrjZnblh\
ba:jZ\bckdh]hihemhkljh\Zijbih^^_j`d_Zg]ebqZg"Ihq_fm
[u \Zf k_cqZk g_ i_j_^Zlv \eZklv dmj_crblZf" Ihq_fm \u
ij_^hklZ\ey_l_ \hafh`ghklv mijZ\eylv lhevdh ihlhfdZf ie_
f_gb;ZgmOZgbn"
<u\h_\Zebijhlb\HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbbbba]gZeb__
\hckdZ ba Ob^`ZaZ b Ze-BokZ \u \h_\Zeb ijhlb\ \hckd Fm
oZffZ^Z=Zebghiha^g___]hkugmB[jZobfmm^Zehkvie_gblv
wfbjZ Z^->Zj]bb =Z[^meem b ^hklZ\blv _]h \ DZbj Iha^g__ \
]714 ^ey bkiheg_gby dZagb _]h ^hklZ\beb \ KlZf[me Ih
q_fm`_\uhldZaZebkvih^qbgylvkyaZdhgghfmoZebnm"
<hl\_l\ZooZ[blZf
fmoZjjZfZ ] fZy ] h^bg ba \ZooZ[bl
kdbo \h`^_c \uklmiZy \ LZbn_ \ ijbkmlkl\bb jmdh\h^bl_e_c
^jm]bo]hkm^Zjkl\aZy\be©A^_kvex^b^_eylkygZljb]jmiiu
h^gbgZkih^^_j`b\Zxlbihfh]ZxlgZf^jm]b_g_ih^^_j`b
\Zxl b g_ ihfh]Zxl Z lj_lvb – mijyfh khijhlb\eyxlky Qlh
dZkZ_lkyi_j\uolhfubfij_^klZ\ey_fl_`_ijZ\Zqlhbf_
_f kZfb <lhjuo fu iulZ_fky m[_^blv \ bklbgghklb k\h_]h
imlb–iiZlj_lvbffuh[_sZ_flhqlhh[_sZe:eeZo\Zy
l_©<hbklbgml_dlh\hx_lijhlb\:eeZoZb?]hIhkeZggb
dZbl\hjblgZa_fe_g_q_klb_[m^ml\\ha^Zygb_m[blubeb
jZkiylubebmgbo[m^mlhljm[e_gugZdj_kljmdbbgh]bbeb
hgb[m^mlba]gZgubakljZguB\k_>wlbgZdZaZgby@^eygbo–
?]bi_lkdbf\hckdZf\khklZ\_–lukq_eh\_d\]m^Zehklvmk
i_rghijh\_klbwlmhi_jZpbx
714
336
\_ebdbcihahj\wlhffbj_Z\[m^ms_c`bagb>`^_l@bo\_
ebdh_gZdZaZgb_ª (5:33)».
<hllZdbfh[jZahf\ZooZ[blu\k_ok\hbohiihg_glh\ba
qbkeZ fmkmevfZg h[ty\beb ©l_fb dlh \hx_l ijhlb\ :eeZoZ b
?]hIhkeZggbdZbl\hjblgZa_fe_g_q_klb_ª>Zkfbehklb\bl
ky:eeZogZ^:[mOZfahcZe-FmolZjhf[bg=ZmnhfZr-RZjb
dhlhjuc hl\_qZy gZ \ur_mihfygmlh_ aZy\e_gb_ \ZooZ[blh\
kdZaZe©LZd`_dZdg_dhlhju_ex^b^_eylgZkgZljb]jmiiu
fu lh`_ ^_ebf bo gZ ljb ]jmiiu i_j\u_ – yauqgbdb ihdeh
gyxsb_kyb^heZf\lhju_–g_\_jgu_baqbkeZex^_cibkZgby
Zlj_lvb–ijZ\bl_ebg_`_eZxsb_ijZ\blvkh]eZkghlhfmqlh
gbkihkeZe:eeZoªO\ZeZ:eeZomdhlhjucba[Z\begZkhlb^_c
\ZooZ[bafZ
<u^mfZ_l_qlhhgb_^bgu«
M q_eh\_dZ ijbgy\r_]h \ZooZ[baf \ i_j\mx hq_j_^v
ihy\eyxlkyijh[e_fuwlbq_kdh]hieZgZHgkjZam`_gZqbgZ_l
g_]Zlb\gh hlghkblvky d hdjm`Zxsbf715 K\hbo mq_guo hgb
dhg_qgh hq_gv kbevgh ihqblZxl gh _keb l_ ohly [u g_fgh]h
gZqbgZxl ijhlb\hj_qblv hkgh\Zf \ZooZ[bafZ lh \k_ fZkdb
kjZam`_kiZ^ZxlbklZgh\blkyykghqlhwlbex^b\hh[s_g_
y\eyxlkyij_^klZ\bl_eyfbbkeZfkdh]hmq_gby
Qlh[ujZkklZ\blv\k_lhqdbgZ^©iªfuohlbfijb\_klb
\gbfZgbx qblZl_ey ^bkdmkkbb b i_j_[jZgdb f_`^m \ZooZ[bl
kdbfbmq_gufb-oZ^bkh\_^ZfbFuba[jZebbf_gghboihlhfm
qlh hgb \kx k\hx `bagv ihk\ylbeb bamq_gbx oZ^bkh\ Z ke_
^h\Zl_evgh ^he`gu [ulv agZdhfu k fmkmevfZgkdhc wlbdhc b
fhjZevx Hp_gbl_ bo keh\Z khhl\_lkl\mxl eb hgb lhfm qlh
kdZaZgh\oZ^bkZo"
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_cohfFmoZffZ^hf
FZo^bZe-BklZg[mebbr_cohfZe-:e[Zgb
A^_kvfubf__f\\b^mlh]hZe-BklZg[mebdhlhjucy\
ey_lky Z\lhjhf dgb]b ©LmonZl Ze-]Zjmkª Hg b r_co AmoZcj
<b^bfh hgb ke_^mxl ijbf_jm B[g L_cfbb ihghkb\r_]h fmkmevfZg
kdbomq_guo
715
337
Zr-RZ\br [ueb mq_gbdZfb Ze-:e[Zgb \ l_q_gb_ khjhdZ e_l
hgb kqblZebkv _]h kZfufb \_jgufb ihke_^h\Zl_eyfb B \hl
ihke_khjhdZe_l^jm`[uhg\hldjulhfibkvf_Z^j_kh\Zgghf
Ze-:e[Zgb ibr_l ©Lu g_\hkiblZgguc ^mjZdª Z ^Ze__ ©Lu
aZ\b^m_rvfg_m`_klh]hfhf_glZdh]^ZyhldZaZekyijbgylv
l\hbo^_l_cgZ[_kieZlgh_h[mq_gb_Fuklh[hc[_k_^h\Zebh[
wlhf y gZa\Ze ijbqbgu ih dhlhjuf g_ fh]m ijbgylv bo gZ
[_kieZlgh_h[mq_gb_Yl_[_ih^jh[ghh[tykgbeqlhfhbij_
ih^Z\Zl_evgbpuklZebkh\eZ^_evpZfbZlu\hl\_lgZwlh]g_\
ghihljyk]heh\hcLuihevah\Zekyfghc\l_q_gb_fgh]boe_l
gh y g_ bf_x ijZ\Z iha\heblv l_[_ h[mqZlv k\hbo ^_l_c aZ bo
kq_lYg_kdhevdhe_lh[mqZel\hxjh^kl\_ggbpmZlu^Z`_g_
ih[eZ]h^Zjbe f_gy aZ wlh Lu ihke_^h\Ze ijbf_jm r_coh\[_a[h`gbdh\ dhlhju_ kqblZxl qlh bo mq_gbdb h[yaZgu [_a
\haf_a^gh hdZau\Zlv bf \kyq_kdb_ mkem]bª Gb`_ hg ibr_l
©AZl_flumdjZe^_gv]bkZeZnblh\l_[_^Z`_\]heh\mg_ijb
rehqlhgZl_[_e_`blhl\_lkl\_gghklv716aZh[s__bfms_kl\h
;he__ lh]h lu ^Z`_ hldZaZeky hl j_r_gby wlh]h \hijhkZ kh
]eZkgh aZdhgZf rZjbZlZ Djhf_ wlbo y ohqm l_[_ gZihfgblv b
^jm]b_ ihklmidbª >Ze__ hg ibr_l ©< lm ghqv y kdZaZe l_[_
wlb keh\Z \ gZ^_`^_ bkijZ\blv l\h_ ^mjgh_ ih\_^_gb_ª b ^Z
e__ ©Lu g_\hkiblZgguc ^mjZd b ]gmkguc q_eh\_dª AZl_f hg
ibr_l ©?keb lu gm`^Zeky \ ^_gv]Zo ^ey ijhiblZgby lh l_[_
ke_^h\Zeh [u h[jZlblvky aZ ihfhsvx d k\hbf [jZlvyf b hgb
ihfh]eb [u l_[_ gh lu g_[eZ]h^Zjguc ba[jZe wlhl ]gmkguc
ihklmihdǻ
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_cohfAmoZcjhfZr-RZ\br_f
br_cohfZe-:e[Zgb
>Ze__ y ij_^eZ]Zx hagZdhfblvky k dhff_glZjb_f ZrRZ\brZ d dgb]_ ©:l-LZn^ue Ze-dbeZ[ ]Zey dZkbj fbffZg eZ
[bkZ Zk-kby[ª717 ba^-\h ©Ze-FZdlZ[Z Ze-bkeZfbyª BlZd hg
716
717
DZdij_djZkgh[_a\haf_a^ghkem`blvlZdbfr_coZf
Wlhemqr__balh]hqlhhgbibrml^jm]h^jm]_
338
ibr_l©Yh[jZsZxkvdkh\j_f_gghfm;Ze]Zfm718b_]hihke_
^h\Zl_eyfyh[jZsZxkvddh\ZjghfmkZlZg_dlhfmdh]hhih
ahjbeb b gZ aZiZ^_ b gZ \hklhd_ Ihke_^h\Z\ aZ wlbf q_eh\_
dhffuqmlv[uehg_ijbgyebkeZ[u_oZ^bkuaZ^hklh\_jgu_
Gh \ dhg_qghf blh]_ gZrb ^mrb hl\_j]eb wlh aeh b bf_ggh
ihwlhfm y gZibkZe wlm dgb]mª >Ze__ hg ibr_l ©Gh [hevr_
\k_]h f_gy m^b\beh lh qlh g_dhlhju_ ba gZrbo r_coh\ aZy\
eyxl k\hbf klm^_glZf ©KemrZcl_kv f_gy ke_ih ke_^mcl_ aZ
fghc ijbgbfZcl_ fhb keh\Z g_ kihjvl_ \_^v y \Zf g_ e]mª
>Z`__kebhgg_e`_ljZa\_g_fh`_lhgaZ[ulvbebhrb[blv
ky" Wlh y\gh_ \ukhdhf_jb_ \_^v ^Z`_ \ Km^guc ^_gv :eeZo
ij_^hklZ\bl ex^yf \hafh`ghklv kihjblv b ij_ibjZlvky Wlhl
q_eh\_dij_\jZlbek_[y\b^heZ^ZkhojZgblgZk:eeZohlih
^h[gh]hg_\_`_kl\Zª
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_coZfb=Z[^jZaZdhfZr-RZc^`b
JZ[b]hfZe-FZ^oZebb;Zdjhf:[mAZc^hf
:r-RZc^`bibr_l©«\wlhfhldjulhfibkvf_yohqm
h[jZlblvky d r_com JZ[b]m [bg OZ^b Ze-FZ^oZebª - b ^Ze__
©JZa\_lu\i_j\ucjZaihklmiZ_rvih^h[gufh[jZahf\hlgh
r_gbb ijhiZ]Zg^bklh\ klm^_glh\ b ^Z`_ mq_guo" LZdh_ hsm
s_gb_ qlh wlh dZq_kl\h m \Zk \jh`^_ggh_«ª ©<b^bfh \u \
dZq_kl\_ k\h_]h ZfiemZ ba[jZeb ihghr_gb_ fmkmevfZg b hkh
[_ggh fmkmevfZg-ijhiZ]Zg^bklh\ª >Ze__ hibku\Zy ihklmidb
Ze-FZ^oZebhgibr_l©Wlhlq_eh\_d\klZegZklhjhgmfm[lZ
^b]h\baZ[em^rbohg[hj_lkykkmggblZfbWlheh`gucimlv
Hg kem`be klhjhggbdZf gh\h\\_^_gbc b kfmlu \k_ _]h ih
klmidbhrb[hqguZkeh\Zeh`guHgih^h[_gkZlZg_dhlhjuc
agZ_lbklbgmgh[hj_lkykg_c_]hkZeZnbafij_^klZ\ey_lkh
[hc [hjv[m k bklbghc < wlhf q_eh\_d_ g_l gbq_]h ohjhr_]h
hg ]hj_ ^ey BkeZfZ fu \k_ h[yaZgu hl\_jgmlvky hl g_]h ?]h
j_qb ijb]h^gu lhevdh ^ey \_^_gby kihjZ k g_\_`^hc hg hlh
r_e hl kZeZnbafZª >Ze__ hg ijh^he`Z_l jm]Zgv \ Z^j_k ZeJ_qvb^_lh;Ze]Zf_<ZeZZf_[bg=ZmjZ[bgBkjZbedhlhjuchldZaZeky
hl [h`_kl\_ggh]h hldjh\_gby Kf ©:e->`Zfb] eb-ZodZf Ze-DmjZgª ZeDmjlm[bkmjZ©Ij_]jZ^uªZyl
718
339
FZ^oZeb Z aZl_f ibr_l ©K wlbfb keh\Zfb \u \uklmibeb i_
j_^ klm^_gZfb rZjbZlkdh]h nZdmevl_lZ gZ dhlhjhf y ij_ih
^ZxAgZyqlh\u`b\_l_\F_^bg_bijbagZ\Zy\Zkg_ij_j_dZ
_fufZ\lhjbl_lhfklm^_gluaZ^Z\Zeb\ZfjZaebqgu_\hijhku
GZkZfhf`_^_e_r_coJZ[b][bgOZ^bdjblbdmxsbcf_gyb
fhboklm^_glh\ba[jZegh\ucimlvdjblbdbfmkmevfZgdgb]b
^\b`_gbc Hg \u^Z_l wlhl imlv aZ imlv Zoe Zk-kmggZ \Z Ze^`ZfZ]ZgZkZfhf`_^_e_wlhg_kijZ\_^eb\ucimlvh[\bg_gby
fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb [b^]Z b _j_kbª ©hg gZa\Ze wlhl imlv
©Imlv kmggblh\ djblbdmxsbo ex^_c dgb]b b l_q_gbyª gZ
kZfhf`_^_e_wlhimlvfm[lZ^b]h\ª>Ze__hghijZ\^u\Zykv
o\Zkleb\hibr_l©Yo\ZeZ:eeZomg_agZxgbdZdh]h^jm]h]h
bklbggh]himlbdjhf_imlbkZeZnh\«Ymqbekymbomq_guo«
JZa\_yfh]ijbgylvkZeZnbaf^eylh]hqlh[ujZajmrblv_]h"
;he__lh]hl\hbihke_^h\Zl_ebbmq_gbdb\Dm\_cl_ijbagZeb
f_gy kZeZnblhf gZb[he__ yjhklgh aZsbsZxsbf kZeZnbafª
©«y \ k\h_c dgb]_ ©Ze-Omlml Ze-]Zjb^Z eb mkme Z^]by ZkkZeZnbyª gbdh]h g_ mihfygme ih bf_gbª ©<u hkf_eb\Z_l_kv
aZy\eylvqlhK_b^Dml[kh\_jrbe\k_\hafh`gu_[b^]ZbjZa
jmrbe \k_ ba\_klgu_ hkgh\u BkeZfZªIhke_wlh]hhgba[jZ\
jhevZ^\hdZlZibr_l©G_m`_eb\Zfg_ba\_klghqlhhg\_jbe
\Km^guc^_gvjZa\_ihke_wlh]h_]hfh`ghgZau\ZlvkZlZghc
\h`^_f g_\_jby jZajmrb\rbf hkgh\u BkeZfZ"ª Ihke_ wlh]h
hg aZy\be ©<Zr imlv imlv h[\bg_gby fmkmevfZg \ g_\_jbb
y\ey_lky ijh^he`_gb_f ^_eZ oZjb^`blh\ gh ^Z`_ oZjb^`blu
g_]h\hjbebih^h[gh]hhk\hbohiihg_glZoL_i_jvfu\b^bf
qlh\kZeZnbaf__klvl_q_gb_ijb\g_kr__\g_]hlhq_]h\g_f
g_ [ueh Kj_^b ijhiZ]Zg^bklh\ wlb ex^b oZjb^`blu« kj_^b
ijZ\bl_e_c – fmj^`bblu kj_^b ijhklh]h gZjh^Z – jZnb^blu
kj_^bbm^__\bojbklbZg–dZ^ZjbluR_coJZ[b]\Zrimlvy\
ghg_y\ey_lkyiml_fZoeZk-kmggZ\ZZe-^`ZfZ]Z\_^vdZdba
\_klgh kmggblu [ueb hq_gv fbehk_j^u \ hlghr_gbb k\hbo
hiihg_glh\ª H^bg ba djmiguo oZrZ\blkdbo mq_guo h[ ZeFZ^oZeb gZibkZe ke_^mxs__ ©Wlhl q_eh\_d b _]h ihke_^h\Z
l_ebkemrZ\rb__]hdZkk_luhkf_ebebkvgZau\ZlvfmkmevfZg
g_\_jgufb b aZ[em^rbfb fm[lZ^b]Zfb Fg_ ba\_klgh qlh
340
r_co JZ[b] ij_djZkgh agZdhf k f_lh^Zfb djblbdb b iho\Zeu
ihwlhfmyohqmaZy\blvqlhhggZjmrbewlbf_lh^uZ\_^vdZd
ba\_klgh hgb [ueb aZeh`_gu _s_ jZggbfb mq_gufboZ^bkh\_^Zfb ?]h djblbdZ ij_\jZlbeZkv \ [_ahkgh\Zl_evgmx
[jZgv ij_m\_ebq_gb_719 b g_kijZ\_^eb\hklvª ©«\Zr f_lh^
ijb\_egZrmdm\_clkdmxfheh^_`vdlhfmqlhdZ`^ucih^jh
klhd gZqZe kqblZlv k_[y bfZfhf-fmoZ^^bkhf Hgb gZijZ\h b
gZe_\hgZqZebh[\bgylvfmkmevfZg\g_\_jbb[b^]ZbaZ[em`
^_gbyo ^Z`_ kZfuo bkdj_ggbo fmkmevfZg-ijhiZ]Zg^bklh\ b
p_eu_ fmkmevfZgkdb_ ^\b`_gbyª ©Y agZx qlh fh_ ibkvfh
fh`_l ihklbqv lZ `_ mqZklv qlh ihklb]eZ ibkvfh ;ZdjZ :[m
AZc^Zdhlhjhfm\uhl\_lbeb]gmkg_cr_cjm]Zgvxª©G_kfhljy
gZ\k_wlhy\u\_^m\ZkgZqbklmx\h^mYjZkkdZ`mex^yf\k_
qlh\ukdju\Z_l_YihdZ`mbfkmlv\Zr_]hlZcgh]hfZaoZ[Zy
jZkkdZ`mh\ZrbolZcguok]h\hjZobhlhfdZd\ukdju\Z_l_720
k\h_bklbggh_ebphLh]^Zex^bihcfmlqlh\u^Ze_dbhlimlb
Ze-kmggZ Dh]^Z \uc^_l \lhjh_ ba^Zgb_ dgb]b ©:e-Omlml Ze]Zjb^Z«ªex^bmagZxlh\k_oklheiZo\Zr_]hfZaoZ[Zh\k_o
\Zrbo\ukdZau\Zgbyob\ukdZau\Zgbyo\Zrboklm^_glh\Wlhc
dgb]b[m^_l^hklZlhqghqlh[uih]Zkblv\ZrmkfmlmbihdZaZlv
kmlv\Zr_]hfZaoZ[Zª
M\Z`Z_fu_ [jZlvy oZrZ\blu k m^h\hevkl\b_f ijhfu
\Zxl dhklhqdb fmkmevfZg dh]^Z `_ bf g_ gZ dh]h de_\_lZlv
hgb gZqbgZxl ihghkblv^jm]^jm]ZG_m`_ebwlbg_hoZjb^`b
lub_klvbklbggu_ghkbl_ebijhjhq_kdhckmggu"
IZ^_gb_\ZooZ[bafZ
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev \ur_ \u ihagZdhfbebkv k djh\Z
\hcbklhjb_cwlhcoZjb^`blkdhck_dlubeh`gufbm[_`^_gb
yfb__ihke_^h\Zl_e_cihwlhfmg_\uau\Z_lkhfg_gbyqlhdh
g_p \ZooZ[bafZ [ebahd Hkh[_ggh mkbebeZkv g_gZ\bklv d \Zo
oZ[bafm ihke_ \lhjhc \hcgu \ I_jkb^kdhf aZeb\_ Bf_ggh
lh]^Z B[g ;Za ba^Ze n_l\m h lhf qlh dZ`^uc djblbdmxsbc
DZd[uyohl_eqlh[uwlbkeh\Zijhqebex^bh[fZgmlu_oZrZ\blkdhc
b^_heh]b_c
720
LZdh\Z\ZooZ[blkdZylZdby
719
341
\\h^ Zf_jbdZgkdbo \hckd gZ l_jjblhjbx DK: y\ey_lky aZ
[em^rbf Fgh]b_ bkdj_ggb_ \ZooZ[blu \uklmibeb ijhlb\
wlhcn_l\uihwlhfmykghqlh\bojy^Zog_l_^bgkl\ZK_cqZk
fgh]b_ \ZooZ[blu ihemqb\rb_ k\_lkdh_ h[jZah\Zgb_ ihl_jy
ebm\Z`_gb_dB[g;Zamy^mfZxqlhwlhy\ey_lkygZdZaZgb_f
:eeZoZ\wlhffbj_aZlhqlhhgh[\bgye\g_\_jbbfmkmevfZg
< ihke_^gb_ ]h^u \ DK: ijhbahreb g_dhlhju_ kh[u
lbydhlhju_ih\e_debaZkh[hchlkljZg_gb_fgh]boik_\^hkZ
eZnblh\hlim[ebqguo\uklmie_gbcb^bkdmkkbcZlZd`_ijh
[m^beb \ k_j^pZo fmkmevfZg ZglbiZlbx d wlbf ex^yf ;he__
lh]hg_dhlhju_bagbo[ueb^Z`_ba[bluiZedZfb\lh\j_fy
dh]^Z aZgbfZebkv ^_ehf dhlhjh_ hgb gZau\Zxl ©ijbau\hf d
:eeZomªG_^Z\ghfu\klj_qZebkvkg_dhlhjufbbakZm^bckdbo
[jZlv_\ dhlhju_ hq_gv kbevgh `Zeh\Zebkv gZ ih\_^_gb_ \Zo
oZ[blh\ dhlhju_ ihklhyggh qbgbeb bf \j_^ < qZklghklb g_
dhlhju_ ba \ZooZ[blh\ \ kZfh_ `Zjdh_ \j_fy ^gy dh]^Z ex^b
ij_^Zxlky^g_\ghfmhl^uomoh^bebihmebpZfkhohlgbqvbfb
jm`vyfb b klj_eyeb ih kimlgbdh\uf iZjZ[hebq_kdbf Zgl_g
gZf >_eh ^hreh ^h lh]h qlh ijhklu_ fmkmevfZg_ gZqZeb
ij_^gZf_j_ggh gZjmrZlv \ZooZ[blkdb_ aZij_lu b ^Z`_ g_dh
lhju_ `_gsbgu klZeb \uoh^blv gZ mebpu g_ ihdju\Zy ebp
ebrv [u ^hkZ^blv \ZooZ[blZf G_agZgb_ b g_kh[ex^_gb_ \Zo
oZ[blZfb we_f_glZjguo ijZ\be ikboheh]bb ijb\_eh d lhfm
qlh ex^b ihl_jyeb m\Z`_gb_ d g_dhlhjuf \Z`guf p_gghklyf
j_eb]bb < blh]_ q_eh\_d hl\_lkl\_gguc aZ ijbau\ ^Z]\Z
^Z`_ [ue kgyl k ihklZ <hafh`gh i_j_Zll_klZpby g_dhlhjuo
hl\_lkl\_gguoebpijb\_^_ldbkijZ\e_gbxgug_rg_]hkhklh
ygby\ZooZ[blkdh]hh[s_kl\Z
<k_ wlh mdZau\Z_l gZ [ebadbc dhg_p \ZooZ[blkdh]h j_
`bfZ <kihfgbl_ bklhjbx Zl_bafZ _]h a^Zgb_ jmogmeh gZ ]h
eh\u k\hbo kha^Zl_e_c lh `_ kZfh_ ijhbahc^_l b k \ZooZ[ba
fhf b ^Z`_ jZgvr_ q_f aZdhgqblky g_nlv \ DK: Q_f b^_b
fm^`Zkkbfblh\ emqr_ b^_c fZl_jbZebklh\-[_a[h`gbdh\" >Z
gbq_f I_j\u_ hljbpZxl \k_ _kl_kl\_ggu_ gZmdb Z \lhju_
kqblZxlj_eb]bxaehf
342
AZ\_jrZxs__keh\h
M\Z`Z_fuc qblZl_ev \hl \u b ihagZdhfbebkv k \ZooZ
[bafhf <u magZeb qlh \ZooZ[blu h[ty\eyxl ^ha\he_gghc
djh\v fmkmevfZg-fhghl_bklh\ hldZau\Zxlky \h_\Zlv k g_\_j
gufbh[ty\eyxlfmkmevfZgyauqgbdZfbijb^_j`b\Zxlky\_
jhmq_gbyhq_gvihoh`_]hgZbm^_ckdh_ijb\_lkl\mxlaZo\Zl
qbdh\ oZebnZlZ b dhehgbaZlhjh\ fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZg mgb
`ZxlIjhjhdZk]kbaZij_sZxlihk_s_gb__]hfh]beuIh
ke_lh]hdZd\u\k_wlhmagZebm\Zk_kl_kl\_ggh^he`guih
y\blvky\hijhku^eyqv_cihevauhgb\k_wlh^_eZxl"GZdh]h
jZ[hlZxl"
FuihiulZ_fkyhl\_lblvgZwlb\hijhkuOhlyfubg_
\_jbf\h\k_fbjgucZglbbkeZfkdbcaZ]h\hjghg_lkhfg_gby\
lhfqlh\jZ]bBkeZfZ^_gghbghsghkljhylijh_dlumgbqlh
`_gby gZr_c pb\bebaZpbb < DhjZg_ ih wlhfm ih\h^m :eeZo
kdZaZe ©LZd `_ >dZd b \ F_dd_@ Fu b \ >^jm]bo@ ]hjh^Zo h[
jZlbeb \ ]j_rgbdh\ \eZklv ij_^_j`Zsbo jZ^b lh]h qlh[u
hgb hkms_kl\eyeb lZf k\hb dh\Zjgu_ aZfukeu Gh ih\_jgm
ehkv bo dh\Zjkl\h ijhlb\ gbo kZfbo Z hgb b g_ \_^Zxl >h[
wlhf@ª (6:123), ©Gbdh]^Zg_[m^ml^h\hevgulh[hcgbbm^_b
gbojbklbZg__kebg_ihke_^m_rvaZbomq_gb_fKdZ`b>hFm
oZffZ^@³Lhevdhimlv:eeZoZ–wlhijyfhcimlv´:_keblu
ihke_^m_rv aZ bo `_eZgbyfb ihke_ lh]h dZd l_[_ y\behkv
>[h`_kl\_ggh_@ agZgb_ lh :eeZo g_ [m^_l l_[_ gb ihdjh\b
l_e_f gb aZklmigbdhfª : Ijhjhd k]k \ h^ghf ba
oZ^bkh\ khh[sZ_l ©<kdhj_ gZklmibl \j_fy dh]^Z \k_ gZpbb
kh[_jmlky b gZ[jhkylky gZ \Zk lZd `_ dZd gZ[jZku\Zxlky `b
\hlgu_gZk\hx^h[uqmªWlbk\ys_ggu_l_dkluykgh]h\hjyl
hlhfqlh\jZ]bBkeZfZ\[hjv[_kgbfbkihevamxljZaebqgu_
f_lh^ubkj_^kl\ZZhkh[_gghhiZkguf\jZ]hffmkmevfZgkl\Z
y\ey_lky©Hj]ZgbaZpbyk\h[h^guofZkhgh\ªbf_gghhgZkh[b
jZ_l\k_bm^_h-ojbklbZgkdb_kbeu\h^bgdmeZd
L_f dlh g_ agZdhf k fZkhgkdbf ^\b`_gb_f fu ohlbf
ihykgblvqlhwlh^\b`_gb_ihy\behkv\?]bil__]hhkgh\Zl_
eyfb [ueb bm^_b Bf_ggh k gbf [ueb k\yaZgu dj_klh\u_ ih
oh^u lZcghc p_evx dhlhjuo [ueh hk\h[h`^_gb_ Khehfhgh\Z
343
ojZfZLZd`_lZcgu_kbeufZkhgkl\ZklhylaZnjZgpmakdhcj_
\hexpb_c FZkhgkl\h ihklZ\beh k\h_c p_evx h[t_^bgblv ih^
k\hbfb agZf_gZfb \k_ kZlZgbklkdb_ kbeu wlh]h fbjZ Kj_^b
f_lh^h\ b kj_^kl\ fZkhgkdh]h kh\jZs_gby \u fh`_l_ \klj_
lblvbk_dkbZedh]hevb^_gv]bb\eZklv\k_wlhihfh]Z_lbf
\eZkl\h\ZlvgZ^mfZfbq_eh\_q_kl\Z
FZkhgu^_j`Zl\k\hbojmdZo\kxfbjh\mxwdhghfbdm
bf_ggh ihwlhfm hgZ ihkljh_gZ gZ jhklh\sbq_kl\_ H[eZ^Zgb_
[hevr_cqZklvxfbjh\h]h[h]Zlkl\Ziha\hey_lbfdhgljhebjh
\Zlv KFB >Z`_ fmevlnbevfu hgb bkihevamxl ^ey jZkijhkl
jZg_gby[_a[h`byjZa\jZlZbjZkims_gghklbFZkhgubkihev
amy k\h_ fZl_jbZevgh_ ]hkih^kl\h iulZxlky ihkljhblv pZjkl
\hkZlZgu
FZkhgu ij_^klZ\eyxl kh[hc \k_fbjgh_ ^\b`_gb_ kh
]eZkgh bo ieZgZf [ueb jZah``_gu h[_ fbjh\u_ \hcgu b ih
ke_^gyy \hcgZ aZ g_nlv \ I_jkb^kdhf aZeb\_ GZ k_]h^gyr
gbc ^_gv kZfuf [hevrbf ieZp^Zjfhf fZkhgkl\Z y\ey_lky
KR: Z _]h ijh\h^gbdhf Zf_jbdZgkdbc ^heeZj gZ dhlhjhf
bah[jZ`_g>`hj^`<Zrbg]lhgq_eh\_dijbxlb\rbcfZkhgh\
\ KR: b hdZaZ\rbc bf g_hp_gbfu_ mkem]b FZkhgu `_eZxl
\hkiblZlv q_eh\_q_kl\h \ ^mo_ [_a[h`by qlh[u ex^b jh`^Z
ebkv b mfbjZeb [_a ;h]Z qlh[u hgb \k_ klZeb kem]Zfb :glb
ojbklZZe-FZkboZ^->Z^`Ze
BkeZf m`_ k\hbf h^gbf ihy\e_gb_f gZg_k kljZrguc
m^Zj ih fZkhgkl\m bf_ggh ihwlhfm fZkhgkl\h gZqbgZy kh
\j_f_g IjhjhdZ k]k b dj_klh\uo ihoh^h\ \iehlv ^h gZrbo
^g_c klZjZehkv bkdhj_gblv _]h gh \k_ ihiuldb g_ ijbg_keb
lj_[m_fh]h j_amevlZlZ b fZkhgu j_rbeb bkihevah\Zlv gh\h_
kj_^kl\h«
FZkhgu ijbkemrZebkv d kh\_lm AhcfZjZ ©hl^Zeblv fm
kmevfZg hl BkeZfZ b ebrblv _]h fheh^_`v klhcdhklb b fh
jZevguomklh_\ªbihkl_i_ggh\fmkmevfZgkdbokljZgZogZqZ
eb jZkijhkljZgylvky gZjdhlbdb b aZiZ^gu_ nbevfu : djhf_
\k_]hwlh]hfZkhgubah[j_ebgh\ucbkeZfBkeZfhkgh\Zgguc
gZ f_q_ b ^`boZ^_ h^gZdh wlhl ^`boZ^ [ue h[jZs_g ijhlb\
kZfbofmkmevfZgWlhlbkeZf[uehkgh\ZggZfhghl_baf_ijb
344
agZ\Z\r_f [h]Z bf_xs_]h nhjfm >ey wlh]h bkeZfZ \k_ hk
lZevgu_ fmkmevfZg_ [ueb yauqgbdZfb Wlh gh\h_ m[_`^_gb_
h[yaZl_evgh ^he`gh [ueh ghkblv fmkmevfZgkdb_ h^_ygby b
\eZ^_lvdjmig_crbfbfmkmevfZgkdbfk\ylugyfb
Ih aZ^Zgbx fZkhgkl\Z R_dkibj Nbebiib >bdkhg b
Dhdkkha^Zebwlhlgh\ucbkeZfZ_]hdjh\vxklZeZg_nlv
Gh\uc bkeZf \hiehlbeky \ \ZooZ[blkdhf rZjbZl_ dh
lhjuc ijh\ha]eZkbe ehamg]b hk\h[h`^_gby fmkmevfZg hl yau
q_kl\Z b ydh[u ijbr_e qlh[u hk\h[h^blv q_eh\_q_kl\h ba
lxjvfuwlh]hfbjZb\u\_klb_]hgZijhklhjuh[hbofbjh\
Ghba\_klgheb\ZooZ[blZfqlhgZkZfhf^_e_hgbkem
`Zl \jZ]Zf BkeZfZ" Qm\kl\mxl eb hgb wlh721" ;m^_l eb m gbo
g_fgh]h \j_f_gb qlh[u hklZgh\blvky b aZ^mfZlvky h gZijZ\
e_gbb\dhlhjhfhgb^\m`mlky"Kfh]mlebhgbhqgmlvkyhlg_
hoZjb^`blkdbob^_c"
:eeZoihwlhfmih\h^m\DhjZg_kdZaZe©L_oqvbmkbeby
\wlhc`bagb[uebls_lguZ\_^vhgb^mfZebqlhihklmiZ
xlgZbemqrbfh[jZahfª (18:104).
>Zfu\_jbf\:eeZoZbgZ^__fkygZ?]hihfhsvbdZ
dbf [u ieZq_\guf gb [ueh khklhygb_ fmkmevfZg fu qblZ_f
keh\Z:eeZoZ©Hgbkljhbebdhagb:eeZo`_jZkkljZb\Zebo–
\_^v:eeZoemqr_\k_ojZkkljZb\Z_ldhagbª (8:30), ©Hgb–ih
ke_^h\Zl_ebrZclZgZH^Z<hbklbgmklhjhggbdbrZclZgZ
ihg_krb_mjhgª (58:19), -bdgZf\ha\jZsZ_lkyhilbfbaf
K\b^_l_evkl\h=hkih^Z
Dh]^ZwlZdgb]Zm`_ihqlb[ueZ]hlh\Zdba^Zgbxf_gy
gZqZeb h^he_\Zlv khfg_gby hlghkbl_evgh khhl\_lkl\by __ kh
^_j`Zgby ^_ckl\bl_evghklb <_^v ex^yf k\hckl\_ggh hrb
[Zlvkybke_^h\ZlvaZk\hbfbhrb[hqgufbb^_yfbIhwlhfmy
j_rbegZijZ\blvky\f_q_lvbkh\_jrblvfhebl\mbklboZjZ722,
<gh\vohqmih\lhjblvkybkdZaZlvqlhfgh]b_ihke_^h\Zl_eb\ZooZ[bafZ
g_ ih^haj_\Zxl dlh bo bkihevam_l b \ dZdbo p_eyo Hgb k\ylh \_jyl \ lh
qlhFmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[[ueh[gh\bl_e_fk\h_]h\_dZ
722
P_evx wlhc fhebl\u y\ey_lky hij_^_e_gb_ gZbemqr_]h ba ^\mo bf_x
sboky\ZjbZglh\
721
345
ybkihegbewlmfhebl\mZihke_g__khfghckemqbehkvlhhl
q_]h ih[_`Zeb ih dh`_ fmjZrdb Y gZm]Z^ hldjue DhjZg gZ
qZe qblZlv b i_j\ufb ihiZ\rbfbky fg_ ZylZfb [ueb ©LZd
dZd`_:eeZomg_ih^\_j]gmlvbogZdZaZgbx_kebhgbg_^himk
dZxl d AZij_lghc f_q_lb >ihke_^h\Zl_e_c FmoZffZ^Z@ g_
[m^mqb__kljZ`Zfb"?_kljZ`Zfb>fh]ml[ulv@lhevdh[h
]h[hyag_ggu_gh[hevrbgkl\hbog_\_^Z_lh[wlhf:fhebl
\Zboijb>F_ddZgkdhf@ojZf_[ueZebrvk\bklhfblj_kdhf
>B[m^_lbfkdZaZgh@LZd\dmkbl_`_fmdbaZlhqlh\u[u
eb g_\_jmxsbfb <hbklbgm g_\_jmxsb_ jZkoh^mxl k\h_ bfm
s_kl\hgZlhqlh[ukh\jZlblv>\_jmxsbo@kimlb:eeZoZb
hgbbajZkoh^mxl\k_Ihlhfhgb[m^mlkh`Ze_lvh[wlhfZ
\ke_^aZl_fhgb[m^mlih[_`^_guL_`_dhlhju_g_m\_jh
\Zeb [m^ml hlijZ\e_gu \ Z^ qlh[u :eeZo hl^_ebe ]j_rgh]h
hl ^h[jh]h k\Zebe ]j_rgbdh\ >\ dmqm@ h^gh]h gZ ^jm]h]h kh
[jZebo\k_o\f_kl_bihf_klbe\Z^mBf_gghhgbbkmlvih
l_ji_\rb_ m[ulhd KdZ`b >FmoZffZ^@ g_\_jguf qlh _keb
hgb \ha^_j`Zlky hl >kh\jZs_gby \_jmxsbo k imlb :eeZoZ@
lh bf [m^ml ijhs_gu bo ijhreu_ ]j_ob ?keb `_ hgb \gh\v
h[jZlylky >d \jZ`^_ k fmkebfZfb@ lh \_^v m`_ \ ^Z\gb_
\j_f_gZ >aZ ih^h[gu_ ^_ygby@ [ueb gZdZaZgu ^j_\gb_ ihdhe_
gby KjZ`Zcl_kv k g_\_jgufb ihdZ hgb g_ i_j_klZgml kh
\jZsZlv>\_jmxsbokimlb:eeZoZ@bihdZhgbg_[m^mlihdeh
gylvkylhevdh:eeZom?keb`_hgb[m^ml>kh\jZsZlvkimlb
\_jmxsbo@lh\_^v:eeZo\b^bllhqlhhgb\_jrZl?keb`_
g_\_jmxsb_g_i_j_klZgml>k[b\Zlv\Zkkimlb@lh^Z[m^_l
\Zf ba\_klgh qlh :eeZo – \Zr ihdjh\bl_ev Ij_djZkguc hg
ihdjh\bl_ev b ij_djZkguc aZklmigbdª (8:36 – Deygmkv
:eeZohfqlhwlbZyluf_gym[_^beb\lhfqlhwlmdgb]mke_
^m_lba^ZlvdZdfh`ghkdhj__Y__i_j_kfhlj_eaZgh\h^h[Z
\be g_dhlhju_ ^h\h^u b nZdlu [_a dhlhjuo hgZ dZaZeZkv [u
keZ[hcbg_^hklh\_jghc
Bf_ggh ihwlhfm y ebqgh kh\_lmx dZ`^hfm khfg_\Zx
s_fmky k_klv \ h^bghq_kl\_ h[jZlblvky d :eeZom kh\_jrblv
fhebl\mbklboZjZbihijhkblvm:eeZoZgZklZ\e_gbyb:eeZo
jZkdjh_l_fmbklbgm
346
BlZd^hjh]hcqblZl_evy^h\_e^h\Zklhqlhfg_[ueh
ba\_klghh\ZooZ[blZoH:eeZo[m^vk\b^_l_e_f
GZwlhfyaZ\_jrZxwlmdgb]mbihke_^g_cfhev[hc[m
^ml keh\Z ©O\ZeZ :eeZom =hkih^m fbjh\ª K\yl Lu h :eeZo
o\ZeZL_[_fuk\b^_l_evkl\m_fqlhg_l[h`_kl\Zdjhf_L_[y
fuijhkbfmL_[yijhs_gby
Ihwlbq_kdh_ijbeh`_gb_
<ZooZ[baf\l\hjq_kl\_ebl_jZlhjh\
Hgbij_\jZlbebkv\k_dlm]hj^_ph\b]heh\hj_ah\
:eeZo\_ebdHgkhdjmrbeg_\_`_kl\h
Wlmdgb]myohqmaZ\_jrblvg_kdhevdbfbklbohl\hj_gb
yfb r_coZ :[m ;ZdjZ =Z[^jZofZgZ [bg FmoZffZ^Z RboZ[Z
mf ] ] k[hjgbd _]h klbohl\hj_gbc [ue ba^Zg \
Kbg]Zimj_\]]k– 114.
Hgb ij_\jZlbebkv \ k_dlm ]hj^_ph\ b ]heh\hj_ah\Hgb
\iZeb\aZ[em`^_gb_HgbijbibkZeb:eeZoml_ehbmih^h[beb
?]hkha^ZgbyfHgbbkdZabebj_eb]bxaZ^Z\Zy\hijhk©=^_"ª
Hgb h[ty\beb ©Dlh \ha\_ebqbl k\ylugb =hkih^Z lhl yauq
gbdªHgbihke_^h\ZebaZmq_gb_fB[gL_cfbbbB[g=Z[^me
\ZooZ[ZHgbhl\_jgmebkvhlbklbgubihke_^h\ZebaZk\hbfb
\_jh\Zgbyfb Ho _keb [u fh_fm klbohl\hj_gbx \gyeb ke_^m
xsb_bklbg_K_]h^gy–wlhk_dlZg_\_`^hgb^mfZxlqlh^h
klZlhqghhlebqZlvfm`kdhcjh^hl`_gkdh]hHgbg_ihgbfZxl
k\h_]h g_\_`_kl\Z K_[y hgb gZau\Zxl Zoe Ze-oZ^bk gh oZ^b
kh\g_ihgbfZxl
Hgbhlh[jZebmex^_cijhiblZgb_
Kme_cfZgZe-=bkb723gZibkZehgboke_^mxs__:
Hgb hlh[jZeb m ex^_c ijhiblZgb_ Z aZl_f ]hj^_eb\h
ijhrebkvgZ^bohklZgdZfb\r_edh\uoh^_ygbyoHgbdeyebkv
hlhfklblv djh\vx b m[b\Zeb ijyfh \gmljb k\ylugv < k\ylu
723
GZkujZk-KZ]b^©LZjbo:eKZ]m^ª–L–K
347
gyo e_`Zeb m`ZkZxsb_ hklZgdb m[bluo ?keb [u hgb klu^b
ebkvkljZgbpbklhjbblhg_kh\_jrbeb[uwlh]h
:eeZo\_ebdHgba\_eg_\_`_kl\h
Klbohl\hj_gb_ ijb\_^_ggh_ gb`_ ijbgZ^e_`bl i_jm
Z\lhjZ k_c dgb]b Y gZibkZe _]h ^ey gZr_]h [jZlZ-fZebdblZ
aZsbsZxs_]h fZaoZ[ b [hjxs_]hky k g_hoZjb^`blZfb F_gy
ihjZabeZ kbeZ _]h ^h\h^h\ klhcdhklv b [eZ]hjh^gu_ fZg_ju
>ZhdZ`_l:eeZo_fmih^^_j`dm«
:eeZo \_ebd Hg ba\_e g_\_`_kl\h b aZkbyeZ bklbgZ b
haZjbeZ \k_ \hdjm] H eh\dbc ZrZjbl g_m`_eb lu ijhf_gye
k\hb dhjgb gZ ]hj^_eb\uc oZrZ\baf" JZa\_ l_[_ g_ba\_klgh
qlh oZrZ\blu bkiZqdZeb a_fex lZ^`kbfhf" Hgb h[\bgbeb \
g_\_jbb\k_odlhg_kh]eZk_gkgbfbb\ha]hj^bebkvl_fqlh
kh`]eb fmkmevfZgkdb_ dgb]b Hgb m[b\Zeb gZ[h`guo b gm`
^Zxsboky Z kljZgm lZ\ob^Z h[ty\beb dhjhe_\kl\hf < k\h_f
dhjhe_\kl\_ hgb h[ty\beb ^ha\he_gguf lh qlh aZij_lbe :e
eZoBoaZdhgu^_ckl\mxllhevdhgZkeZ[uoZkbevguohgbh[
oh^ylklhjhghcKdhevdhjmd[uehhlk_q_ghg_kijZ\_^eb\hgh
\_^vwlhebrvjmdbkeZ[uoHfZaoZ[aeZihl\h_fm\_e_gbx\
k\ys_gghf Ze-OZjZf_ \ k\ys_ggu_ f_kypu \h \j_fy lZ\ZnZ
[ueb m[blu `_gsbgu b djh\v iZehfgbdh\ ebeZkv j_dhc gZ
k\bldbDhjZgZ<lhl^_gvhklZ\rb_ky\`b\uo[uebih]j_[_
gu \f_kl_ k m[blufb >Z\gh m`_ hgb aZo\Zlbeb k\ys_ggmx
F_^bgmbF_ddmZbo`bl_e_cfhjbeb]heh^hf\[ehdZ^_Wlb
g_^`^bckdb_[_^mbgukh\_jrbeblhgZqlhg_ih^gyeZkvjmdZ
fhg]heh\ b bo ij_^\h^bl_ey OmeZ]m H agZxsbc [jZl ijb^b
gZboZ^j_k\bgl_jg_l_blum\b^brvbog_\_`_kl\hIjb^bb
jZkk_c bo aZ[em`^_gby Ijb^b b aZ[jhkZc bo k\_lhf [h`_kl
\_gghcdgb]bbih[_`^Zxs_ckmgguIjhjhdZk]kFbjl_[_
hl l\hbo [jZlv_\ \ fmkmevfZgkdbo kljZgZo Wlb ex^b ijbky]
gmeb:eeZom\lhfqlh[m^ml`blv[_a[b^]Zg_ijbqbgyl\j_
^Zg_\_jgufijbagZxlZoedblZ[k\hbfb[jZlvyfbghhl\_j]
gmlfmkmevfZgkdb_^\b`_gbyH^hjh]hc[jZlijb^b\Bgl_j
g_lbhdZ`bihfhsvk\h_cj_eb]bbimklvhgZgZihegblky`_f
qm`bgZfbih^h[gufbl_[_ª
348
Dgb]b
;b[ebh]jZnby
졎 èߍ”Ì’Äãì”óª èߍ™©î¤ßòӔ󩍪ВߍՍ­í÷ ìòˎӮߍñ퍮ߍâô덮‘‡
1.
ðë쩍ªÐ‘
쮸èàß æÃîߍ ­© ìæôç®× Ýü§ “î˪ߍ ”䋃 ®ì·ƒ ì±­ŽÔߍ åŽäœË æ‘ âô덮‘‡
ðëìÁ콎ó®ß
ìÁìåªèßìò׎´ß­©ìã÷É®»ìòèÐߍª’Ë°ó°Ìߍª’Ëâô덮‘‡
•í®ô‘쮸èߍí”ËŽ’Äàß©Ž·­ùìîæã”㪧òӔô‘Žëîߍ”×®ÔߍìñîؘߍðàÌߍ
ðëìÁìò‘®ÌߍŽ˜Üߍ­©ìª‹îÔߍʒèãíª‹í°ßÊä ãìòäœôìߍ®Ü‘
“®ëŽØߍìò‘®Ìߍ®ÜÔߍ­©ì鮼Ëíꗎô£Þ’è£æ‘ªä£ƒì“®ë¯î‘ƒ
ìò‘®Ìߍ®ÜÔߍ­©Ê’Äߍªì̘ãì”ôìØÔߍ配­ð鮼Ëíꗎô£êôäô—摍쓮ë¯î‘ƒ
“®ëŽØߍ
“®ëŽØߍì”ôŸ«îäèߍ”Ì’Ääߍì”ôãü³ùë¬äߍ쓮ë¯î‘ƒ
ì•í®ô‘ìÁì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ìïŽôßí÷”ôà£ìâôÌç
ì”ӎ؜ߍ­©ìŽëîߍª’Ë摪ä¤ã“®ô³òÓ Žì¸ßÊäß ìÖôؤ— ”׎£î‘ƒªä£ƒ
”¤Ô»òçŽÄó®’ߍҤ˜äߎ‘“©îŸîãÞ»÷”ÃîĨäߍíì¦ó­Ž—åíª‘ì•í®ô‘
ðëìô´ßìñ®ãŽÀߍ”’˜ÜãìɎèØߍÂسíìòàôà¨ßªä£æ‘ªä£ƒ
ìÁìâàÜߍÊãîŸ­©ì”ô‘ŽëîߍðàË©®ßòӔôè´ß­­ªßìåü£©òèó¯æ‘ªä£ƒ
쓮ëŽØߍìò’à¤ßò‘Ž’ߍì”ô‘ŽëîߍðàË©®ßòӔôè´ß•ûŽØäߍåîè̑ﮧ÷”Ì’Äߍ퓮ëŽØߍ
Á ìì ì፮¤ß ªà’ߍ ムåŽô‘ òÓ áüÜߍ ”»ü§ ìåü£© òèó¯ æ‘ ªä£ƒ
ááŽËÝî’蘳
áìÝî’蘳ì”ô‘Žëîߍ”è˜Óìåü£©òèó¯æ‘ªä£ƒ
Ö¸ã©ìòãü³ù˜ÜäߍÁ쪟Ž´ã­î’Øߍ«Ž¨—æ㪟Ž´ß®ó¬¤—ìò玒ß÷
ðëìÁìòãü³ù˜Üäߍ씤ô¤¼ßšó©Ž£÷”à´à³ìò玒ß÷
­©•í®ô‘âô덮‘‡ÞÀÔߍªä¤ãÖôؤ—ì”Ïü’ߍžìç¡®· ìªóª¤ßò‘ƒæ‘
ðëìðßí÷”Ì’ÄߍìÞô ߍ
˜ÜäߍìÁ ìò玒ß÷ ®»Žç ªä¤ã Öôؤ— ì”ó펤Äߍ “ªôØÌߍ ¡®· ì°Ìߍ ò‘ƒ 摍
Ö¸ã©ìòãü³ù
®¼ãì”óªä¤äߍ”è´ßÁì”à‘Žè¤ß•ŽØ’ÃìðàÌóò‘ƒæ‘
•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©ì”‘ŽÐߍª³ƒì®ô›÷æ‘
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©ì¦ó­Ž˜ßòÓÞãŽÜߍì®ô›÷æ‘
ðëì•í®ô‘ì®ÜÔߍ­©ìšóª¤ß®›÷ó®ÏòӔóŽìèߍì®ô›÷æ‘
ðëìñ©îä¤äߍâǎ۪ä¤ãÖôؤ—ìªôèÌߍ¼Ì˜äߍðàË©®ßìñ¯î ߍ摍
ì”ôäàÌߍ ˜Üߍ ­© ìò¿ŽØߍ ª’Ë êØØ£ ìæôÛí®˜äߍí ïŽÔÌÀߍ ìñ¯î ߍ 摍
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘
ìюشߍðàË摍洣¦ô¸ßÖôؤ—ìêó°ðè˜ßÒۄ‘êô’¸˜ßê’·ÊÓ©ìñ¯î ߍ摍
®ôèã ªä¤ã ŽìØØ£ ò˜ß ”Ì’Äߍ ðàË ŽÀóƒ Žçªä˜Ë ª×í åŽäË ðë ìÁ ñíîèߍ áŽãù ­© ”ËŽ’Ã
•í®ô‘ìåŽè ߍ­©ì”ôӎ؜ߍ™Ž¤‘÷í•Žãª¨ß°Û®ãìáŽãù
쮋° ߍì”àôä ߍ•ŽËî’Ääߍìæôô䘳®ß”ä‹÷­Ž’§ƒì®ôмߍ摍
”ôäô—摍”’˜ÜãÁìŽë©ŽÀóŽã픤ô¤¼ß“ªôØÌߍ쯎‘摍
349
ðëìÁìòãü³ù˜Üäߍ®¸çì”ô‘®Ìߍ”ôãîØߍªØç쯎‘摍
ì”ó®ô¨ß”Ì’Ääߍ쭎Գ÷‹Ž Ëí­Ž¼ã÷‹®ÏòÓ­ŽÈèߍ”Ô¤— ì”Ãîđ摍
ðëìÁ
ìòØÔߍªãŽ£ªä¤ãÖôؤ—ìâô¤ ߍÞ냔Ôߎ¨ãâôؘ´äߍÁ®¼ßïŽÀ˜×ì”ôäô—摍
ðë쓮ëŽØߍ
Öôؤ— ﮒÜߍ ”óîä¤ßí ì”ó®ãª˜ß ”ߎ³®ß ²‹ŽÔç ìﮒÜߍ ”óîä¤ß ì”ôäô— 摍
©ªÐ‘ìòߪ’Ìߍݎ䟔̒ÄãíÞäÌãìòØÔߍªãŽ£
˜Üߍ­©ìŽÄË­©ŽØߍª’Ëò葍ðÔļãíªä¤ãÖôؤ—ìﮒÜߍï페Ôߍì”ôäô—摍
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ
•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ì­îèߍ“­î³®ô´Ô—ì”ôäô—摍
¦ó­Ž—åíª‘ì®¼ã­Žèäߍ”Ì’ÃìދŽ´äߍíދŽ³®ßÉîä ãì”ôäô—摍
•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ”’˜Üäߍì”óî’èߍ”è´ßŽìèãì”ôäô—摍
á°£æ‘ûɎäŸù—®ãŽ˜Û¶ãŽëðàËɎäŸù—®ãªØçì”ôäô—摍
ì®ÜÔߍ ­© ì偮Øߍ ®ô´Ô— òÓ åŽô’ߍ Ê㎟ ñ®’Äߍ ®ô´Ô— ìñ®’Äߍ ®ó®Ÿ 摍
ðë
ìÁìæ۪ߍ©Ž‘ƒ­ªô£ì”ôçŽäœÌߍѭŽÌäߍ“®‹©²à ã”Ì’Äã앎؜ߍ ì厒£æ‘
á
™®˜ß ïŽô£‡ ­© ì”è㎜ߍ ”‹Žäߍ åŽô˃ òÓ ”èãŽÜߍ ­­ªß ìòçüØ´Ìߍ ® £ 摍
•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ
˜Üߍ­©ìŽÄË­©ŽØߍª’ËðÔļãÖôؤ— ìó¬ì˜ßó®Ø— ìòçüØ´Ìߍ® £æ‘
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ
ì•í®ô‘ì®ÜÔߍ­©ìó¬ì˜ßó¬ì—ìòçüØ´Ìߍ® £æ‘
ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©ìñ­Ž¨’ߍ¢ô¤»¡®¸‘ñ­Ž’ߍ¢˜ÓìòçüØ´Ìߍ® £æ‘
ì•í®ô‘
ò’à¤ß ò‘Ž’ߍ ðÔļ㠔̒Äãí ”’˜Üã ì”ôœóª¤ß ï페Ôߍ ìòä˜ôìߍ ® £ 摍
ðëìÁ쮼ãìé©ûíƒí
”ôÔà´ß”’˜Üäߍ”Ì’ÃìñíîèߍڳŽèãðàËê˜ô·Ž£ìòä˜ôìߍ® £æ‘
©ªÐ‘ìðèœäߍ”’˜ÜãìÞ¤èߍíïîë÷íÞàäߍòÓÞ¼Ôߍìᰣ摍
ðëì•í®ô‘ì­©Ž»­©ìﮒÜߍ•ŽØ’ÄߍìªÌ³æ‘
ÁîĨ㮼Øߍ®‹Ž§«ìåîßîÃ摍
ðë쓮ëŽØߍì”ó®ôã÷”Ì’Ääߍ쭎˜¨äߍ­ªßðàË­Ž˜¤äߍ©­ìæ󪑎Ë摍
ìÁì®ÜÔߍ­©ì­Ž÷Û¯®ô믭î˜ÛªßÖôؤ— ìݎŸ®ßïŽÔÌ¿òÓÞãŽÜߍ ìñªË摍
ðëìÁì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ì”óŽìèߍí”󍪒ߍì®ôœÛ摍
•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ì®ô’Üߍ¦ó­Ž˜ßìñ­Ž¨’ߍ
Ö¸ã©ìò‘­ŽÔߍ”’˜Üã”ôãü³ù”Ìó®¸ß©ªì—”˪‘®Ä§ƒ”ô’ë¬ãüߍìòÃî’ߍ
ò‘®Ìߍ®ÜÔߍ­©ì“ª·®ß”Óü¨ß¦ó­Ž—°ŸîãÊã”óî’èߍ“®ô´ßêØÓ ìòÃî’ߍ
ð듩ŽË‡ìÁìָ㩮ÜÔߍ­©í•í®ô‘
ìæôãƒð´ôË©ÖôàÌ—í¡®·”䟮—ì”»Ž¨ßÕ­í÷í½Žó®ßð߇”࣭ìòàô‘
”ãŽèäߍìÊó¯î˜ßí®¸èߍí”ÓŽ¤¼àßáŽó÷”´³†ã
™®˜ßïŽô£‡ ­© ìñ®›îÜߍ ªë¯ ªä¤ã ¦ô¸ß Öôà̗ 앎Լߍí ïŽä³÷ ìòØìô’ߍ
•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ
•í®ô‘ì”Ó®Ìäߍ­©ìﮒÜߍæè´ßìòØìô’ߍ
350
ª»®äߍ Ž´£í ”󮼒ߍ ”ó…®ß æô‘ Ýüìߍ •î’› ì®äË æ‘ âô덮‘‡ ½îô‘
åîß÷”Ì’Äãì®»Žç¢ßŽ»ªä¤ã©êôàËÖ÷àËíêßáª×íê̟­ìÞôˎ䳇®ä˔î·÷æãêàØçì”ôÜàÔߍ
ÂØ´ã씜óª¤ß
ìÁì•í®ô‘ì”ôãü³ù­ªßìÞ¤èߍíÞàäߍòәìò玤’´ß®Ô̟
•Žã®Üߍí Þ³î˜ß ñ®Üèã ðàË ©®ß òÓ Õ©Ž¼ß ® Ôߍ ìñíŽë°ß òת» ÞôäŸ
ðëáŽË®¼ãÁìÕ­î¨ßí
òçîçŽØߍɍªóù÷ª¤ßíâߎÌߍáªöתؘÌãðàË©I®ßíêô’è˜ß ìюØI´ßòàËæ‘æ´£
®¸èߍ­©ð߇“­Ž·‡åíª‘å©­÷ììì”ôèÃîߍ֋Ž›îߍ핎’˜Üäߍ”ó®óªãïªß
ªô£î˜ßòӚôàœ˜ß”ß펤ãݎđ‡ ªô£î˜ß©÷ªËæä‘ ªóªè˜ß ìюشߍòàËæ‘æ´£
ðëìÁìå©­÷ìñíîèߍáŽãù­©ì”ôãü³ù“ªôØÌߍ
”è´ß Þëƒ “ªôØË íƒ ”ó펤Äߍ “ªôØÌߍ ¡®· ¢ô¤» ìюشߍ òàË æ‘ æ´£
ŽìôàóŽãí¹ìñíîèߍáŽãù­©ìÁì”ËŽä ߍí
ì¦ô¸ßÝª’Ë摰ó°Ìߍª’Ëê˜ËŽ’à ðàËÑ®·ƒìª ç¦ó­Ž— ìáŽ÷èÏ æ‘ æô´£
”ó©î̴ߍ
Áìò³Žô´ß¦ó­Ž˜ßí”ãŽãùªôߎؗ”ôãü³ù”ôÍ®äóªßåŽäË쵎’Ϫô’Ëæô´£
ªóª ߍ­©
®¸èߍ ”è³í ­© ì”ôÔà´ß “ŽË© ðàË ”ôÔà´ß ©í©®ß ìòçüØ´Ìߍ ªãŽ£ æ‘ ªßŽ§
厘àÔÐã
ðë쮼ã쓩ŽÌ´ß”Ì’Äã쩍ªÐ‘¦ó­Ž—ìñ©ªÐ’ߍôĨߍ
ÁìåªèßìÊó¯î˜ßí®¸èàߎԼߍì”ô‘Žëîߍ卮ôçíñ©î̴ߍâܤߍâô¤ŸìªìӔÔôà§
ðëì
ìæôóüäàß âàÌߍ ­© ì°ó°Ìߍª’Ë Úàäߍ ªìË òÓ “®ó° ߍ ꒷ ìòàÛ­°ß æóªß ®ô§
ì•í®ô‘
Ù­Ž’äߍⳎŸó®Ì—ìŽì—­ŽŸí–óîÜߍìåî´Üó©
âçŽÏ æ‘ ©î̳ 鮸çí êØØ£í ê˜äŸ®— ðàË Ñ®·ƒ ì¤¼ß ®Ëìåî´Üó©
áì–óîÜߍìÁìòä Ìߍ卮ä ߍ
™®˜ß ïŽô£‡ ­© ìòäàÌäߍ ðàÌó æ‘ æ䣮ߍª’Ë ¢ô¤¼— ìŎԤߍ “®Û¬— ìò’ë¬ß
”ã®Üäߍ”Üä‘òÜäߍᮤߍ”’˜Üãìò‘®Ìߍ
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ì”ߎ³®ß”´³†ãìïü’èߍáü˃®ô³ìò’ë¬ß
òàË æ‘ æ´£ êœó©Ž£ƒ ®§í êôàË ÖàËí êß áª× 쭎ÔÐߍ òàÌàß îàÌߍ ìò’ë¬ß
ðëìÁìñíîèߍáŽãù­©ìåŽIäËìюشߍ
Áì”Ó®Ìäߍ­©ìñíŽ ’ߍªä¤ãÖôؤ—ìݍª˜Ëûå°ôãìò’ë¬ß
ìÁ ì•í®ô‘ 쮸èßí ”ËŽ’Äàß Ê󭎸äߍ ­© ì”ôäô— æ‘û ò’ë¬ß ”¤ô¼çìò’ë¬ß
ðë
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ì”äܤߍ­©ì¢ô¤¼ßÊ㎠ߍìô’£æ‘Êô‘®ß
žôà¨ß ®£ ªÌ‘ “®ó° ߍ Ýí©í ”ó©î̴ߍ áîäI´ß ¡Žó­ ì²Kó®ß ô ç ½Žó­
Áì
ìÁ쓎ô¤ß”’˜Ü㭍©•í®ô‘ì±îãŽØߍ®ëîŸæã±í®ÌߍŽ—ìñªô‘°ß
ðë ®óªÐߍ Á ìòçîôì¼ß åŽôÜßí ”ôãü³ù ”ôèóªß •Ž´³†äߍ ìñ퍰Ðߍ ®ôë¯
ðëì•í®ô‘쮸èߍ핎³­ªàß
®äË ó®Ì— 폎ëîߍª’Ë æ‘ ªä¤ã ¦ô¸ß “îË©í ª ç ¦ó­Ž— ìò’àôÓ åîŸ –玳
•í®ô‘ì”ôàë÷”’˜Üäߍ•­î¸èãìñ퍮óªß
351
ðë쓮ëŽØߍì”ôèô´¤ß”Ì’ÄãìﮒÜߍ”ôÌӎ¸ß•ŽØ’Ãìòܒ´ß
åŽä˔èÄà³ì™®˜ß“­¯íÁìåŽäóùªËîתôìä—ìòàôà¨ßåŽÔà§æ‘ªô̳
Á쩎ؘËûòÓ©Ž£õšó©Ž£„‘¬§ƒæãðàË©Ž¤ßÒô´ßìò‘îèØߍÙí®’ã摪ô̳
ðëìñ®ãŽÀߍ”’˜Üãì
Ö¤àãìåîÛ÷•ŽÔ»íÖߎ¨ß•ŽÔ»æô‘偮ØߍåŽ×®Óì”ãªØãòˎÀØߍ”ãü³
òØìô’àߕŽÔ¼ßíïŽä³÷Ž‘
ì”ôŸ«îäèߍʑŽÄäߍ”Û®·ìÁìâóîؗ픳­©ïô̳•ŽÔ߆ã ìòßüìߍâôà³
ðë
áª×íêØØ£ì”ô‘ŽëîߍðàË©®ßòӔôìßùÖˍî¼ßìñª èߍŽëîߍª’Ëæ‘åŽäôà³
®¼ãì厴çù­©ÁìñíŽÄ’ߍªä¤ãâô덮‘‡êôàËÖIàËíêß
•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ìðÔļäߍ­©­Ž’§„‘ŽÓîߍïŽÓíìñ©îìä´ß
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ìﮒÜߍº‹Ž¼¨ßìòÃîô´ß
®‹Ž§¬ß ­© 쮼ã ì”ô‘©÷ ”Ì’Ääߍ ìэ®·÷ ¤‘ ю¤—ù ìñ퍮’¸ß
•ŽËî’Ääàß
•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©ì­Ž’§÷ðؘèã¡®·­ŽÃí÷ÞôçìòçŽÛî¸ß
ªô̳ªä¤äߔôÔà´ßŽ˜Ûòӎãðà˕Ž’ôØ̗핍®Èç ì卯îÔߍ卯îÓ摢ߎ»
ðë콎ó®ßì®¸èàßæÃîߍ­©ìÁ앍îÔìߍæãåŽÀã­
ðëìÁ쮘ó­•îäàëÖôؤ—ì•ŽôÓîߎ‘òӍîߍìñªÔ¼ßÞôà§æóªß¡ü»
ì”ô‘®Ìߍ•Ž³­ªßí™î¤’ߍªìÌãìšóª¤ß®¼Ìߍòӏ®Ìߍ“®ó°Ÿ 쩎ØÌߍ¡ü»
“®ëŽØߍ
ðëì•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ìÙîàäߍíâã÷¦ó­Ž—ìñ®’Äߍ
”Ì’Äã ìšóª¤ß Þܸã òÓ ­Ž›õ òçŽÌã íƒ ­Ž›õ òçŽÌã ¡®· ìñ펤Äߍ
ðëìªèìߍìò‹ŽÔļäߍ
Ýî£í”ó©î̴ߍòÓïŽäàÌߍ­Ž’Û”Œôë²ô‹­¯Ž‘摍ðàË©®ßì®Kô¨ßæ䣮ߍª’Ë
Õ®¸ß ”’˜Üã Êó¯î—ì®Kô¨ß æ䣮ߍª’Ë òçŽë ê˜ËŽ’à ðàË Ñ®·ƒ ìªÌ‘ î¿®Øèó âß ”Ìô¸ß “üÏ ÝŽØã
Áìììì”ó­î³ì“Žä£ìªóª ߍ
áîôߍŽ˜Û”à´à³ì”ôäô—摍¬ÌäߍêôØÔߍìñíŽ×®¸ßæ䣮ߍª’Ë
Ž˜Üߍ ­© ìªô£î˜ß Ž˜Û ¡®· ªô äߍ ¢˜Ó ì¦ô¸ß ݁ æ´£ æ‘ æ䣮ߍª’Ë
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ
ìÁ ì•í®ô‘ ì厴çù ­© ìÞô˜Øߍí ޗŽØߍ Þ¼ôÓ ìò獮ä¸ß ®»Žç æ䣮ߍª’Ë
•í®ô‘ì厴çù­©ì¢‹ŽÀÔߍ”Üàäãìò獮ä¸ß®»Žçæ䣮ߍª’Ë
”’˜Üã ìÊèäßí “¯ŽŸù æô‘ âó®Üߍ 偮Øßí ”Ðàߍ òÓ ¯Ž äߍ ìòèÌÄäߍ âôÈÌߍª’Ë
”’ëí
”Ì’Äã ì”ô‘Žëîߍ ”×®Ôߍ ꒷ ðàË ©®ß òÓ ”ô۰ߍ ”¤Ôèߍ ìòçüôÜߍ ­©ŽØߍª’Ë
Ö¸ã©ìôÔߍ
– ®ôԴߍ ”Ì’Äã ì卭íªß ”ß„´ã òÓ å®ô¤ß ”óªë ìªôä¤ß ¢ßŽ» æ‘ âó®Üߍª’Ë
½Žó®ß
ìðëìÁì”ôäô—摪䣃•ûü¿Ò¸ÛòӔôKè´
J ߍ•ûŽØäߍìò¸’¤ßª’Ë
•í®ô‘ìÊ󭎸äߍ­©
ìòãü³ùÕ®¸äߍòÓòè´ßë¬äàßñ®ÜÔߍíò³Žô´ß¦ó­Ž˜ßìñíª‘ªô äߍª’Ë
ìÁ쓪Ÿì”Ó®ÌäߍáüË
352
½Žó®ß ”’˜Üã ìª ç ¦ó­Ž— òÓ ª äߍ åîèË ìñª èߍ òà’è¤ß ®¸‘ æ‘ åŽäœË
Ս¯®ßª’˪ä¤ã¦ô¸ßêôÓ卪à’ߍïŽä³ƒÂ’¿íêèãÝí÷ï° ߍ±®ìÓª×í쮸ç¦ó­Ž—åíª‘ì”œóª¤ß
ì•í®ô’‘”ô玜ߍ”Ì’Äߍðàˎìô߇­Ž¸ã“©íªÌãÊ¿îãòӎçªä˜Ëª×íÒó®¸ßá®¤ßŽ‘±­ªäߍ“°ä£
¦ô¸ßÝª’Ë摍ÒôÄàߍª’Ëæ‘æ䣮ߍª’ËŽìØØ£ò˜ßíìá”è³
챎èߍ”è´ßƒðà˚󩎣÷æã®ì˜·Žä˱Ž’ßùÞó°ãíïŽÔ¨ßÒ¸Ûìòçîà Ìߍ
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©
ì”ôäàÌߍ ˜Üߍ ­© ìò Ìà× æôムòÄÌäߍª’Ë © Öôؤ— ì®ô’Üߍ ïŽÔÌÀߍ ìòàôØÌߍ
ìÁì•í®ô‘
•í®ô‘ì“®ô´ß­©ìªô£î˜ßí”ô‘ŽëîߍìòàãŽÌߍò獭îÜߍòàË
잤ߍ•­î¸è㔴³†ã쓭îèäߍ”èóªäߍ­Ž›æãáªìäߍìò‘®Ðäߍ­©ŽØߍª’Ë®äË
ðëìÁì卮ìÃ
ðëʒÃì”ô‘Žëîߍ“î˪ߍ®›ƒìòØÔߍ
ðëìÁì”ó©î̴ߍ”ôè›îߍíáü³ùìòçŽÄ¤ØߍªìÓ
®¸èàß ŽÔ¼ß 읎 ¤àß ”ó©î̴ߍ ”¤‘¬äߍ ”¼× ”Ü㠓­° ã ìòçŽÄ¤Øߍ ªìÓ
ðëìÁìåªèßìÊó¯î˜ßí
ìæôäôœÌߍ¢ßŽ»æ‘ªä¤ã¦ô¸ßÞ‹Ž³­íï페ÓÉîä ã ìåŽäôà´ß®»Žç摪ìÓ
½Žó®ßŽ‘®¸èàßæÃîߍ­©”Ì’Ãìðë”è³ìÁ
Þô ߍ­©ì•í®ô‘ìÂô¤äߍ±îãŽØߍìñ©Ž‘¯í®ôÔߍ
•í®ô‘ì”ôàë÷”’˜Üäßìª ç¦ó­Ž—ìò’àôÓ
˜Üߍ ­© ”Ì’Äã ì偮Øߍ áŽÜ£÷ Ê㎠ߍ ðä´äߍ ò’îØߍ ®ô´Ô— ìò’îØߍ
ðëìÁì”ó®¼äߍ
ðëìÁ쓮ëŽØߍìʋ®¸ßô—®—òÓʋŽè¼ßÊ‹ª‘ìò玳ŽÜߍ
©­îԴۃ•ŽËî’Äã ò³­ŽÔߍžôà¨ßòӎôçŽÄó®‘ ìòààôÛ
”ó°ôàÜçùŽ‘ìåªç­üÛ
ÕîØ£ ì”ô‘®Ìߍ “®ó° ßí žôà¨ß òÓ åŽ´çù ÕîØ£ æË ÉŽÓªàß ”ôßíªß ”è àߍ
ìÁì”ó©î̴ߍ”ô‘®Ìߍ”ÜàääߍòÓ厴çù
ìÁì®ÄהãîÜ£”䟮—ìžôà¨ßÞôߩ읝®äó­îß
ðëìÁì”ߎ³®ß”´³†ãìݎäÌߍ°ðèÛìñªèìߍòؘäߍ
ðë쮼ã쭎èäߍ”Ì’ÄãìÁì”óª èߍދŽ´äߍíދŽ³®ß”Ëîä ã
”’˜Üäߍ•­î¸èãìⳍîØߍæËò¨ó­Ž—°ŸîãìñŽ’ãü ³•­Ž˜¨ã”Ëîä ã
”ó°ôà çù”Ðàߎ‘ñŽ’ãô³Žô´ßí”ó®´ß
”ô‘Žëîߍ ދŽ’Øߍ æË ò¨ó­Ž— °Ÿîã ìñŽ’ãî‘ •ü ³ æ㠕­Ž˜¨ã ”Ëîä ã
”ó°ôàÜçù”Ðàߎ‘ìñŽ’ãô³Žô´ßí”ó®´ß”’˜Üäߍ•­î¸èãì”ô‘®Ìߍ
Áì•í®ô‘쐘ÜߍâߎËìªä£ƒŽ¤»ƒâŸ®—òÓªä£÷žìèߍìòäôàÌߍæóªß®ô ã
ì
ìæôã÷æ´£Öôؤ—쏎ëîߍª’Ë摪ä¤ãɎ’—ƒòӏŽô—­ûÒ¸Ûìæôã÷æ´¤ã
ðëìÁ
ì“î˪ߍå톷°Û®ã”ôãü³ù”Ì㎠ߍìîªô£î˜ßâìÔçÒôÛ ìÞô䷎‘ªä£ƒªä¤ã
”ó©î̴ߍ”ô‘®Ìߍ”Üàääߍ
”ãŽäôߍ ­© Á ìò—®’ ߍ ¦ó­Ž— òÓ ª çí ¯Ž ¤ß ­Ž’§ƒ æã ìßŽÏ ó©ƒ ªä¤ã
ìÁìэ®·ùí”䟮˜ßíš¤’àß
•Ž³­ªàß ®óªÐߍ °Û®ã ì”ôãŽãùí ”è´ß Þëƒ æô‘ ”ôÔà´ß ìñ®ôœÜߍ ªä¤ã
ðëì•í®ô‘ìÁì”ôãü³ù
353
æ‘û”תç°ßíɪ’ߍÞëƒðàË©®ßòӔ೮äߍÖˍî¼ß®¼˜¨ãìòà»îäߍªä¤ã
ðëìÁ쓮ëŽØߍ”’˜Üãì”ó¯î ߍâôØߍ
ªä¤ã Öôؤ— ì”ôäô— 摍 ×Žèã òÓ ”ó­ªß ©îØÌߍ ìñ©Žìߍª’Ë æ‘ ªä£ƒ æ‘ ªä¤ã
•í®ô‘ì”ôäàÌߍ˜Üߍ­©ìòØÔߍªãŽ£
ïŽô£‡ ­© ì”ô‘®Ìߍ “®ó° ߍ ¦ó­Ž— òÓ ”ôçŽì’èߍ ”Ô¤˜ß ìòçŽì’èߍ ”Ôôà§ æ‘ ªä¤ã
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘ìáîàÌߍ
ì”ó©î̴ߍ ”ßíªß ”ôË®· áªË ðàË ”ôÌÄØߍ ”ß©÷ ìñ®Ì´äߍ ª’Ë æ‘ ªä¤ã
Êó¯î˜ßí®¸èàߪӍ®ß”´³†ã
Á êôàË ïŽäàÌߍ ïŽè›í ”ô£ü»ù ê—îË©í ”ôÔà´ß ꗪôØË Žëîߍª’Ë æ‘ ªä¤ã
Ɏ’óûíïªìó”ó©î̴ߍ
摪ä¤ã¦ô¸ß•ŽÔ߆ã”Ëîä ãæä¿ì”ô¼¨¸ßÞ‹Ž³®ß 쏎ëîߍª’Ë摪ä¤ã
ìÁ콎ó®ßì½Žó®ßÊ‘ŽÄãìòØôàÌߍ¢ßŽ»ªä¤ãíì卯îÔߍ卯îÓ摢ߎ»¢ô¤¼—쏎ëîߍª’Ë
ðë ˜Üäߍ ʒà ìªô’Ìߍ ðàË  Ö£ îë ñ¬ß ªô£î˜ß Ž˜Û 쏎ëîߍª’Ë æ‘ ªä¤ã
ìָ㪑òãü³ù
áìÁì•í®ô‘쩍î ߍ­©ì”ô‘Žëîߍòëé¬ëì”ôèÐ㩍ä¤ã
쓮ëŽØߍ ì”Àìèߍ ”Ì’Äã ì¡ü»ù òÓ ”ô‘Žëîߍ “î˪ߍ ®›ƒ ìòØÔߍ ªãŽ£ ªä¤ã
ðë
ðëìÁì”×­Ž¸ßì¢˜Ôߍ­©ì¯Ž ¤ßíåîô‘Žëîߍ쎿­ªô·­ªä¤ã
­© ìòãü³‡ë¬ãû”Û­Ž’ã”ôè㯔࣮ã”ôÔà´ß ìòÃî’ߍåŽÀã­ªô̳ªä¤ã
ìÖ¸ã©ì®ÜÔߍ
ìÁ씛ª¤ß­©ì”ôçªäߍíâàÌߍÊã”ô獮¼èߍíáü³ùì骒˪ä¤ã
òãîØߍ ™®˜ß “­¯í ìÁ ìæôóªô̳î’߁ “®ô³ òÓ æô’äߍ ¢˜Ôߍ ìÖó¯­ æ‘
ðëìð³®ãª’˪ä¤ã©–®ãŽËâÌèäߍª’ËÖôؤ—åŽä˔èÄà³ì”ӎ؜ߍí
®Ìäߍ­©ìšóª¤ß”ô‘®Ìߍ“®ó° ߍ¦ó­Ž—æ㕎¤Ô» ìôĨߍ½î˪ä¤ã
áìÁì•í®ô‘쮸èߍí”ËŽ’Äàß
ë¬ã ðàË ©®ß òÓ ”ôãü³ù ¹î¼èߍ ìñíŽ ß ­Ž’ ߍª’Ë æ‘ êôØÓ ªä¤ã
áŽË®¼ãÁì”ô‘Žëîߍ
áü´ß­©ìšóª¤ßòãü³ù®ÜÔߍòӎ뮛ƒí”ô‘Žëîߍ“î˪ߍì®ëŽ¿ÞãŽÛªä¤ã
ðëìÁì•í®ô‘쮸èߍí”ËŽ’Äàß
ìÁì”ôÔà´ß•Žì’·ðàË©í©­ìñ­îœóªßñ­îçªä¤ã
ì•í®ô‘ìò‘®Ìߍ™®˜ßïŽô£‡­©ìòçŽÌäߍ¡í­®ô´Ô—ìò³îß÷©îä¤ã
Áì”ߎ³®ß”´³†ã쩍÷îË­Ž¸‘©Öôؤ—ìݎŸ®ßïŽä³ƒòÓݎäÜߍó¬ì—ìñ°äߍ
•í®ô‘ìðëì
Áìë¬ãü‘áü³‡ì”ÌܸߍðÔļã
ìÁì”ô‘®Ìߍ”Àìèߍ­©ìñŽôÔà³²ôߔôäô—摍ì²óî˪ä¤ã­î¼èã
ðëì•í®ô‘ì®ÜÔߍ­©ìÁìÝî»øßÊ㎠ߍŽ˜ßìñ­î¼èäߍ
”ËŽ’Äߍªô×씳­©ížó®¨—­î¨ßòӓ©­îߍšó©Ž£÷ìò̑Ž´ß®»Žç
ÞÔÐã ì”ô‘®Ìߍ “®ó° ߍ Ì· ©Ž¤— •­î¸èã ì©î̳ ݁ ¦ó­Ž— ìªô̴ߍ ®»Žç
¦ó­Ž˜ß
ì”ôçŽÄó®’ߍ”ó©î̴ߍ•Ž×üÌàߔô¨ó­Ž—”³­© ñ©î̴ߍµ®ÌߍáŽô× ì®Ôߍ®»Žç
åªèßìÊó¯î˜ßí®¸èàߎԼߍ
354
­©Á쯎 ¤ßíª ç”ôçŽÄó®’ߍ֋Ž›îߍòӔô‘®Ìߍ“®ó° ߍì“îÔ»ò¤˜Óñª ç
åŽè’ßìò׎´ß
ðëìà£ìòËîߍ­©ìæôÛí®˜äߍíïŽÔÌÀߍìò‹Ž´èߍ
ÂØ´ãì”ãŽØ˜³û”’˜ÜãìêØÔߍíÝî»÷òÓ®¼˜¨ãÊ¿îߍŽ˜ÛìòçíŽè ߍðô¤ó
쯎 ¤ß òÓ ”ôãü³ù ­Ž›öß ©î̳ ݁ ®ô㪗 ”¼× Êôؒߍ ìñ®ŸŽìߍ Ò³îó
•í®ô‘ìðëìÁ왍®˜ßïŽô£ùÊôؒߍ”´³†ã
=Za_lu
Washington posts“ªó®Ÿ
­Ž¨ßòÓ­ª¼—”ó©î̳åîäà´äߍ“ªó®Ÿ
Seattle Post Intelligence“ªó®Ÿ
”ôçªèàߍ“Žô¤ß“ªó®Ÿ
”ó©î̴ߍ½Žó®ß“ªó®Ÿ
”ôçŽè’àߍèߍ“ªó®Ÿ
”ôË÷”ô³í®ßŽô³®ôӓªó®Ÿ
@mjgZeu
”ó®¼äߍ”ËŽ³®§”à ã
”ó®¼äߍ”ߎ³®ß”à ã
”ô‘®Ìߍ”¨´èߍ”ô—­ŽãùïŽôÀߍ”à ã
”ô˜óîÜߍò‘®Ìߍ”à ã
åªèßæ㓭©Ž¼ßì”ó©î̴ߍ”à äߍ”à ã
â×왍®˜ßïŽô£ù–ô’ߍ݁”´³†ãìŽè›®—”à ã
”ô—í®ô’ߍïªìߍ­Žèã”à ã
Bgl_jg_lkZclu
www.ummah.net
http:moonsighting.com
www.saha.net
3.
www.aljareh.net
–箘çùŽ‘š¤’ߍ®’Ë”¤ô¼èߍ“®Û¬ãìñ©î̳âߎ˔‹Žã
Dhfivxl_jgu_ijh]jZffu
™Kª¤äߍžãŽç®‘
Òó®¸ßñî’èߍšóª¤ß”Ëî³îãì”ôäߎÌߍ
Òó®¸ßñî’èߍšóª¤àߔô’ë¬ß”Ëî³îäߍ왍®˜ß”´³†ã
Ž—­ŽÜ燲àÃì–Óî³í®ÜóŽã
E_dpbbl_e_-bjZ^bh-i_j_^Zqb
åîó°Ôà˜ßŽ‘ ”ô玜ߍ “ŽèØߍ (Issues and Answers) žãŽç®‘ ìæóªß Òô³ ªä£ƒ
ðëìì”Ìä ߍáîó ìñ©î̴ߍ
­ªßðàË­îçžãŽç®‘ì”ã®Üäߍ”Üãæãáü³ùïªç”ˍ«‡
ìììì”Ìä ߍáîóìŽóŽÀמãŽç®‘“®ó° ߍ“Žè×
á®óŽèó”àôß쓎ô¤ßí”Ìó®¸ßžãŽç®‘ì“®ó° ߍ“Žè×
Õªèԑ ñ­ŽÀ¤ß šÌ’ߍ ð߇ ŽèØó®Ã 偮Øߍ åîè̑ “®¿Ž¤ã ìÄ× ªä¤ã
5.
®’䘒³®ì·ì®Äהßíª‘”£íªßå®ô·
355
Kh^_j`Zgb_
IJ?>BKEH<B?DH<LHJHFMBA>:GBX ................................................................. 3
A:Q?F<UJ:AJU<:?L?G:Q:KLB(FMKMEVF:GKDMXMFFM)?.......................... 3
IJ?>BKEH<B?DI?J<HFMBA>:GBX ................................................................... 8
<<?>?GB? ............................................................................................................ 10
DlhlZdb_oZjb^`blu" ....................................................................................... 10
:gZebaoZ^bkh\hoZjb^`blZo........................................................................... 15
=E:<:I?J<:Y ..................................................................................................... 19
AG:DHFKL<HK<:OO:;BAFHF ........................................................................... 19
AgZdhfkl\hk\ZooZ[bafhf ................................................................................ 19
K\b^_l_evkl\Z\ihevamg_\_`_kl\Z\ZooZ[blh\ ............................................. 22
<ZooZ[blh\bf_gmxloZrZ\blZfbaZobjblZfbfmrZ[[boblZfbb
fm^`ZkkbfblZfb ................................................................................................ 25
AZ[em`^_gb_hlghkbl_evghke_^h\ZgbyaZkZeZnZfb ..................................... 27
FmoZffZ^[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[............................................................................ 30
<ha\jZs_gb_ba;Zkju....................................................................................... 32
I_j\uc^h]h\hj .................................................................................................. 33
>h]h\hjkB[gKZ]m^hf ..................................................................................... 33
GZqZeh\hcgijhlb\fmkmevfZg ........................................................................ 34
H[yaZl_evghklvob^`ju .................................................................................... 35
;h]h[hyag_gghklvbgZ[h`ghklvr_coZ ........................................................... 35
?]hgZ^_`ghklv................................................................................................... 37
G_dhlhju_baihklmidh\r_coZ ........................................................................ 38
?]hm[_`^_gby .................................................................................................... 39
?]hhlghr_gb_dIjhjhdmk]k...................................................................... 40
Hlghr_gb_ihke_^h\Zl_e_cB[g=Z[^me\ZooZ[Zdk\h_fm\h`^x................ 41
?]hh[jZah\Zgb_.................................................................................................. 42
<ukdZau\Zgbymq_guohg_f ............................................................................. 42
<ukdZau\Zgbyh_j_lbq_kdhcgZijZ\e_gghklb_]hmq_gby ............................ 45
AZ[em`^_gbyex^_chlghkbl_evgh_]hmq_gby ................................................ 46
FmkmevfZgkdb_mq_gu_ijbau\ZxlFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z
\_jgmlvkydbklbg_ ............................................................................................. 47
B[gL_cfbyZe-OZjZgb ...................................................................................... 48
<hijhkuihdhlhjufB[gL_cfby\uklmibeijhlb\h[s_]hfg_gby
fmkmevfZg ........................................................................................................... 50
B[gZe-DZcbfkhqm\kl\mxsbcB[ebkm .......................................................... 58
Ihq_fm`_fgh]b_h[fZgmebkvkeh\ZfbB[gZe-DZcbfZ" ............................. 61
:e-:e[Zgb–oZrZ\blkdbcoZ^bkh\_^ .............................................................. 62
<hckdh[jZlv_\>`ZcrZe-bo\Zg ................................................................... 74
<hagbdgh\_gb_.................................................................................................... 74
I_j\u_\h_ggu_hi_jZpbb ................................................................................ 76
Ijh^he`_gb_aZ\h_\Zgbc .................................................................................. 77
356
L_jjhjgZZjZ[kdhca_fe_.................................................................................. 77
Ba\jZs_gb_kmggubh[uqZ_\ ........................................................................... 78
H[fZgjZkdjul.................................................................................................... 79
Dhg_p©\hckdZ[jZlv_\ª..................................................................................... 81
<hckdh>`hgZNbebiib .................................................................................... 81
DlhlZdhcNbebiib" .......................................................................................... 82
GZklmie_gb_gZ:jZ\bckdbcihemhkljh\......................................................... 82
Dhg_p ................................................................................................................... 87
=E:<:<LHJ:Y ..................................................................................................... 88
=?H=J:NBY<:OO:;BAF:B>BKDJ?>BL:PBYBKE:F: .................................... 88
Kihj\hdjm]oZ^bkZ©Hllm^Zihy\ylkyihljyk_gbybkfmlu«ª .................... 89
RZldhklvhkgh\bihk\ys_gby.......................................................................... 94
<gbfZgb_iZfylgbdbklhjbbH^_ygbyo\ZooZ[blh\\emq_aZjghcF_^bg_
............................................................................................................................ 103
AZ[hlZh_\j_ckdbobklhjbq_kdboiZfylgbdZo.............................................. 108
Ih^`h]ZjZ[kdhc[b[ebhl_db\k\ys_gghcF_dd_....................................... 110
=E:<:LJ?LVY. ................................................................................................... 111
BKLHJBY<:OO:;BAF: ..................................................................................... 111
A\_jkl\Z\ZooZ[blh\\fmkmevfZgkdbokljZgZo............................................. 112
A\_jbg_\_^Zxsb_fbehk_j^by..................................................................... 114
Djh\hijheblb_\f_q_lyo ................................................................................ 115
G_^`^ ................................................................................................................ 119
Ob^`Za............................................................................................................... 120
LZbnM[bckl\hmq_guob^_l_c.................................................................... 123
F_ddZ@bl_ebF_ddbih_^Zxlljmiubkh[Zd ........................................... 125
:e-BokZ ............................................................................................................. 128
Dm\_cl................................................................................................................ 130
DZlZjb;Zoj_cg................................................................................................ 131
HfZg................................................................................................................... 134
;_^u\uiZ\rb_gZ]heh\u\ZooZ[blh\.......................................................... 142
C_f_g................................................................................................................. 144
BjZd ................................................................................................................... 146
KljZguRZfZ.................................................................................................... 150
>hebgZRZffZjb__hdj_klghklb.................................................................. 152
Ij_iylkl\by\kh\_jr_gbboZ^`Z .................................................................. 153
HklZevgu_[uebm[blu.................................................................................... 154
M[bckl\hc_f_gkdboiZehfgbdh\................................................................... 154
M[bckl\hiZehfgbdh\baBjZgZ...................................................................... 155
<ZooZ[blumamjibjh\Zebf_klhbfZfZ\f_q_lbZe-OZjZf ......................... 155
:qlh^Zevr_" ................................................................................................... 156
=E:<:Q?L<?JL:Y .............................................................................................. 157
M;?@>?GBY(:DU>:) O:R:<BLH< .................................................................. 157
Kl_j`_gvoZrZ\blkdhcZdu^u ........................................................................ 158
357
G_dhlhju_\u^_j`dbba\\_^_gbyFmoZffZ^ZFmgbjZ .............................. 158
<u^_j`dbba\\_^_gbykZfh]hB[gZe->`Z\ab ............................................. 159
G_dhlhju_ijbf_jueh`guooZrZ\blkdbom[_`^_gbc ............................... 161
OZrZ\blubf_lZnhjufZ^`Za..................................................................... 166
OZrZ\blkdZylZdby........................................................................................... 170
B^_yba\_qghklbfbjZb]jZgbp...................................................................... 173
<u^mfZgguck[hjgbdkmggu .......................................................................... 177
OZrZ\blublZoZ\blkdZyZdu^Z ...................................................................... 179
G_dhlhju_jZah[eZq_gbydgb]b©:l-LZ\ob^ª©?^bgh[h`b_ª
ijbgZ^e_`Zs_ci_jmFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ................................. 185
<ZooZ[blubdj_kl............................................................................................ 193
K\ylugbb[_kihdhckl\hh[hevrbo^_j_\vyo .............................................. 194
AZ[em`^_gbyoZrZ\blh\ .................................................................................. 198
Ijhlb\hj_qby\Zdu^_ ..................................................................................... 199
>ha\he_gb_e`b ................................................................................................ 200
=E:<:IYL:Y ..................................................................................................... 204
J:AYS:Y<:OO:;BLKD:YFUKEV..................................................................... 204
De_\_lZ\ZooZ[blh\\Z^j_kq_luj_obfZfh\ ................................................ 204
BfZf:[mOZgbnZ ............................................................................................ 204
BfZfFZebd[bg:gZk ..................................................................................... 206
BfZfZr-RZnb]b............................................................................................. 207
BfZf:ofZ^[bgOZg[Ze ................................................................................. 208
OZrZ\bluaZimlu\ZxlfmkmevfZgkdmxfukev............................................. 209
G_gZ\bklvB[gL_cfbbdqe_gZfIjhjhq_kdh]h^hfZ ................................. 214
<ZooZ[blukqblZxlqlhkmggbluaZ[em^rb_ex^b ..................................... 218
<jZs_gb_a_feb–m^Zjih\ZooZ[blkdhcZdu^_ ........................................... 222
KZlbjbq_kdZy\ZooZ[blkdZyfukev ................................................................. 225
DZdoZrZ\bluhlghkylkydmq_guf................................................................. 227
F_`^m^\mfyfmnlbyfb .................................................................................. 230
=E:<:R?KL:Y .................................................................................................. 234
O:R:<BLKDBCNBDO ........................................................................................ 234
<ZooZ[blkdbcf_kyp......................................................................................... 234
;b^]Z .................................................................................................................. 241
<ZooZ[blkdb_[b^]Z.......................................................................................... 246
B[g;Zab\jZs_gb_A_feb .............................................................................. 247
N_l\Zhkimlgbdh\uoZgl_ggZo....................................................................... 250
>\b`_gb_\fhebl\_......................................................................................... 253
P_gZ`_gsbgu.................................................................................................. 254
<ZooZ[bafbhldjulb_ihklu^guof_kl]ZmjZl.......................................... 255
<ZooZ[blujZaj_rbebmihlj_[e_gb_f_jl\_qbgu........................................ 256
Mobsj_gbyjZ^bij_ex[h^_ygby ................................................................... 259
Ijhqlbl_baZ^mfZcl_kv ................................................................................. 271
DZdklZlv\ZooZ[blhf" ..................................................................................... 272
358
=E:<:K?>VF:Y................................................................................................. 275
KMGGBLU>:XLHLIHJO:R:<BL:F ............................................................... 275
Dgb]b[jZlZFmoZffZ^Z[bg=Z[^me\ZooZ[Z ................................................ 275
<u^_j`dbbadgb]b .......................................................................................... 277
Mq_gu_q_luj_ofZaoZ[h\hl\_qZxloZrZ\blZf........................................... 280
G_dhlhju_mq_gu_hijh\_j]Z\rb_ijhba\_^_gbyB[gL_cfbb ................. 286
:e-;moZjbZe-Obg^bij_^hkl_j_]Z_lhlik_\^hkZeZnbafZ .......................... 293
;_g]Zevpuijhlb\hklhyloZrZ\blZf .............................................................. 294
Y[ue\ZooZ[blhf............................................................................................. 297
Ibkvfhj_dlhjmmgb\_jkbl_lZ ........................................................................ 301
GZklZ\e_gb_Za-AZoZ[b..................................................................................... 303
=E:<:<HKVF:Y ................................................................................................ 306
KD?F>JM@:L<:OO:;BLU? ............................................................................ 306
IjbagZgby ......................................................................................................... 307
<ZooZ[blubbkeZfkdb_^\b`_gby.................................................................. 308
<deZ^\ZooZ[blh\\hkgh\Zgb_BajZbey......................................................... 310
<\_^_gb_............................................................................................................ 310
<ZooZ[blu–hjm`b_ojbklbZg........................................................................ 311
<deZ^\ZooZ[blh\\mgbqlh`_gb_HkfZgkdhcbfi_jbb ............................... 311
Mgb`_gb_iZe_klbgkdhc^_e_]Zpbb................................................................ 313
<ZooZ[bluijh^ZxlIZe_klbgm ...................................................................... 313
H]jZgbq_gby ..................................................................................................... 314
Mgb`_gb_ .......................................................................................................... 315
Ihiuldb\ZooZ[blh\hk\h[h^blvIZe_klbgm................................................. 316
LZcgh_ij_^Zl_evkl\h ...................................................................................... 317
BklbggZyp_gZIZe_klbgu\]eZaZo\ZooZ[blh\ ............................................ 317
<wlhfg_lgbq_]hm^b\bl_evgh]h................................................................... 317
Ih^ehklv\ZooZ[blkdbofZde_jh\biZljbhlbafkmelZgZ=Z[^meoZfb^Z ... 318
G_baf_ggZyiheblbdZ\ZooZ[blh\ .................................................................. 318
Hgbih^dmiZxl ................................................................................................. 318
AZq_f\h_\Zlvk_\j_yfb" ................................................................................ 318
?\j_b-^jmavy ..................................................................................................... 319
Fbjguc^h]h\hjk_\j_yfb ............................................................................. 319
N_l\um]h^gu_bm^_yf ................................................................................... 320
AZij_lijhdeylbc\Z^j_kbm^__\bojbklbZg ................................................ 321
<ZooZ[blkdh-ojbklbZgkdb_\h`^b.................................................................. 324
DZd`_bfm^Zehkvih^qbgblvk_[_wlhl]hjh^" ............................................ 324
Kem`[Z[_ahiZkghklb\ZooZ[blh\................................................................... 325
H[yaZl_evkl\Z ................................................................................................... 326
<ZooZ[baf–^_lbs_bm^__\bojbklbZg......................................................... 327
Q_f`_[ueZ\ua\ZgZlZdZykbevgZyex[h\vf_`^mZg]ebqZgZfbb
\ZooZ[blZfb" .................................................................................................... 328
M[bckl\hfmkmevfZgbihfhsvdhehgbaZlhjZf............................................ 331
359
N_l\uhihfhsbdhehgbaZlhjZf .................................................................... 332
=E:<:>?<YL:Y ................................................................................................. 334
A:DEXQ?GB? ..................................................................................................... 334
G_a^hjh\u_ihke_^kl\by\ZooZ[blkdbogh\r_kl\........................................ 335
<hijhkulj_[mxsb_hl\_lZ ........................................................................... 337
<hl\_l\ZooZ[blZf .......................................................................................... 344
<u^mfZ_l_qlhhgb_^bgu« ......................................................................... 344
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_cohfFmoZffZ^hfFZo^bZe-BklZg[mebbr_cohfZe:e[Zgb............................................................................................................... 345
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_cohfAmoZcjhfZr-RZ\br_fbr_cohfZe-:e[Zgb346
Hlghr_gbyf_`^mr_coZfb=Z[^jZaZdhfZr-RZc^`bJZ[b]hfZe-FZ^oZeb
b;Zdjhf:[mAZc^hf....................................................................................... 346
IZ^_gb_\ZooZ[bafZ ......................................................................................... 349
AZ\_jrZxs__keh\h ......................................................................................... 350
K\b^_l_evkl\h=hkih^Z.................................................................................... 353
IHWLBQ?KDH?IJBEH@?GB?............................................................................. 354
<:OO:;BAF<L<HJQ?KL<?EBL?J:LHJH<........................................................ 354
Hgbij_\jZlbebkv\k_dlm]hj^_ph\b]heh\hj_ah\ ...................................... 354
Hgbhlh[jZebmex^_cijhiblZgb_ ................................................................ 355
:eeZo\_ebdHgba\_eg_\_`_kl\h................................................................. 355
;B;EBH=J:NBY .................................................................................................. 357
KH>?J@:GB? ..................................................................................................... 364
360
Скачать