«Религиозная экспансия» и внешняя политика

« !"#$#%&'() *+,-(',#)» # .'!/')) -%"#0#+(
!"#$"% &'!'(")#*
!"# $!%&!$'( $!)(* +,#-,!"". /'"&#0'%',1(2 +,#2'&#,(3'&#/24, /2,!$$#/24
+,#'/5#678'5 & "',( +,#9(//#&. : ;#$9( +,#)0#-# &(;! <!+!6 =.0 +#,!>($ &$(%!+$."
+,#=1>6($'(" '/0!"!. : $!3!0( $!/21+'&)(-# &(;! ,(0'-'7 — $( 2#04;# '/0!", $# '
5,'/2'!$/2&#, '$61'%", =166'%" — /2!0! 0(-'2'"$." ?!;2#,#" +#0'2'3(/;#-# 6(*/2&'7.
@(" /!"." ,(0'-'7 $!+#"$'0!, 32# #$! $( +,#/2# /#/2!&07A8!7 9'&'0'%!9'#$$#-#
0!$6)!?2!, $! ;#2#,#" &(,)'0!/4 '/2#,'7.
(-#6$7 ,(0'-'7 ;!; $';#-6! #="',8($!, 32# &.%.&!(2 & +!"72' ,(6$'( &(;!.
(;107,$.* +#65#6 $( /3'2!(2/7 !+,'#,$# (6'$/2&($$# +,!&'04$.", =(%!042(,$!2'&$.".
B(>61 ,(0'-'(* ' +#0'2'3(/;'"' ' #=8(/2&($$."' /#=.2'7"' 1/2!$#&'0!/4 1/2#*3'&!7
#=,!2$!7 /&7%4. C(0'-'7 &"()'&!(2/7 &# &$()$AA +#0'2';1. «D/$#&!$$!7 $! &(,(
6'+0#"!2'7, — +,'%$!(2 =.&)'* -#/16!,/2&($$.* /(;,(2!,4 EF B!60($ D0=,!*2, —
"#>(2 =.24 +#0(%$." '$/2,1"($2#" &$()$(* +#0'2';'. ...:0'7$'( $! +#0'2';1
&#%,#>6!A8(-#/7 ,(0'-'#%$#-# 31&/2&! =16(2 +,#6#0>!24/7»3. C(0'-'7 +,'/12/2&1(2 &
-,!>6!$/;#" #=8(/2&(, /&#A 0#704$#/24 ; $(* 6(;0!,',1(2 (6&! 0' $( ;!>6#(
-#/16!,/2&#. G! "1/104"!$/;#" :#/2#;(, & C#//'*/;#* H(6(,!9'' #2 $(( /18(/2&($$."
#=,!%#" %!&'/'2 /2!='04$#/24, #$! & $("!0#* /2(+($' #=(/+(3'&!(2 0(-'2'"$#/24 &0!/2'.
C1//;!7 +,!&#/0!&$!7 9(,;#&4 7&07(2/7 $(?#,"!04$.", %!2# &0'72(04$." '-,#;#" $!
/9($( ,#//'*/;#* ', )',(, (&,!%'*/;#* +#0'2';'. :,("7 #2 &,("($' CIJ ?!;2'3(/;'
&.+#0$7(2 #26(04$.( +#,13($'7 /&(2/;#* &0!/2' (& 3(" 9(,;#&$.( 3'$#&$';' $';#-6! $(
+,'%$!A2/7).
: +#/0(6$'( 6&! 6(/72'0(2'7 3(0#&(3(/2&# «+,#5#6'2 '/+.2!$'(» -0#=!0'%!9'(*, &
;#2#,#* "$#-'" &'6'2/7 1-,#%! ;!>6#* #26(04$# &%72#* K2$#;10421,$#*,
K2$#,(0'-'#%$#* '6($2'3$#/2'. C!%".&!$'A -,!$'9 "(>61 ;10421,!"', '5
&%!'"#+,#$';$#&($'A /+#/#=/2&1(2 '$?#,"!9'#$$#( 91$!"' ' ;#"+4A2(,'%!9'7.
L0#=!0'%!9'7 +,(6+#0!-!(2 /#%6!$'( 1$'&(,/!04$#* /'/2(". 9($$#/2(* ' &%-076#&.
G! +(,&.* &%-076 &/7;!7 ,(0'-'7 6#0>$! &#/+,'$'"!24 -0#=!0'%!9'A /1-1=#
$(-!2'&$#, '=# 1$'&(,/!0'%" — !$2'+#6 ;!>6#* #26(04$# &%72#* ,(0'-'#%$#* 2,!6'9''.
M/;0A3($'( /#/2!&07(2 +,#2(/2!$2'%" (;#$;,(2$# — (-# !"(,';!$/;!7 &(,/'7),
+##8,7A8'* -0#=!0'%!9'A. D6$!;# $! 6(0( /'21!9'7 ;16! /0#>$((: & ;!2#0'9'%"(,
=166'%"(, '$61'%"( %!0#>($. /&#(-# ,#6! "(5!$'%". /#(6'$($'7, #/2#,#>$#-# /'$2(%! /
-0#=!0'%!9'#$$." +#2#;#". N2' ,(0'-'' $( &.6!A2 #6$#%$!3$# $(-!2'&$#-# #2&(2! $!
1$'&(,/!0'/2/;'* &.%#&. <!2# /1-1=# #2,'9!2(04$# ; -0#=!0'%!9'' #2$#/72/7
+,'&(,>($9. '/0!"! ' +,!&#/0!&'7. D$' ,!//"!2,'&!A2 (( +,(>6( &/(-# ;!;
+#0'2'3(/;1A, ;10421,$1A K;/+!$/'A <!+!6!, /2,!2(-'3(/;!7 9(04 ;#2#,#-# —
+#63'$($'( "1/104"!$/;#-# "',! ' C#//'', 607 3(-# ' $(#=5#6'"# /$!3!0!
6(?#,"',#&!24, ! %!2(" ,!%,1)'24 '5 ,(0'-'#%$1A '6($2'3$#/24.
: #2&(2 "1/104"!$/;'( '6(#0#-' ?!;2'3(/;' &.6&'-!A2 /#=/2&($$.* ;#$9(+2
-0#=!0'%!9'', #/$#&!$$.* $! '/0!"/;#* 2,!6'9'', ;#2#,!7 ,!$# '0' +#%6$# 6#0>$! /2!24
-0#=!04$#* ' ;#2#,1A & /##2&(2/2&'' / '/0!"/;'" &(,#13($'(" 6#0>$. &#/+,'$724 &/(
$!,#6. "',!.
L0#=!0'%!9'#$$.* &.%#& ' #2&(2. $! $(-#, 6!&!(".( ,!%$."' ,(0'-'7"',
/2!$#&72/7 #6$#* '% #/(* +#0'2'3(/;#-# ' ;10421,$#-# =.2'7 3(0#&(3(/2&!. <6(/4 "#>$#
1/"#2,(24 ' K0("($2. +,(/0#&12#-# «;#$?0';2! 9'&'0'%!9'*», $# =#0(( &/(-# K2#
/0#>$#( ' +,#2'&#,(3'&#( &%!'"#6(*/2&'( 2,!6'9'*, & 5#6( ;#2#,#-# #26(04$!7 ,(0'-'7,
/ #6$#* /2#,#$., &.$1>6($! !6!+2',#&!24/7 ; -0#=!0'%!9'', ! / 6,1-#* —
+,'/+#/!=0'&!(2 (( +#6 /(=7.
3
Albright M. Faith and Diplomacy // The Rev. of Faith & Intern. Affairs. — 2006. —
Vol. 4. — Fall. — O 2. — P. 9.
2#0+#" -0#=!0'%!9'', ;#2#,!7 $("./0'"! =(% +,'#,'2(2! '$6'&'6!, 7&07(2/7
%!8'2! +,!& 3(0#&(;!. B1/104"!$/;'* "', $( 15#6'2 #2 K2#* +,#=0("., $# 212 >(
+,(60!-!(2 /&#A &(,/'A (( ,()($'7 & ,!";!5 '/0!"!, ;#2#,!7 ' =.0! +,#&#%-0!)($! &
1990 -. & P!',(. I#'/;' /#=/2&($$#* #,'-'$!04$#* ?#,"10',#&;' +,!& 3(0#&(;! &(612 '
'6(#0#-' +,!&#/0!&'7.
C(0'-'7 3!/2# #;!%.&!(2/7 ?#,"#* &.,!>($'7 /#9'!04$#-# ' +#0'2'3(/;#-#
+,#2(/2!. G!'=#0(( ,(%;# ' +#/0(6#&!2(04$# K2# +,#'/5#6'2 & '/0!"/;#" "',(.
I,!;2'3(/;' & ;!>6#* "1/104"!$/;#* /2,!$(, $! ;!>6#* "1/104"!$/;#* 2(,,'2#,''
6(*/2&1(2 ,(0'-'#%$!7 #++#%'9'7 / 6'!+!%#$#" K$(,-(2';' #2 1"(,($$#* 6#
K;/2,("'/2/;#*. I#0'2'3(/;'* '/0!" +,(60!-!(2 /#=/2&($$1A !042(,$!2'&1 1/2,#*/2&!
#=8(/2&! ' -#/16!,/2&! ' &#&0(;!(2 & /&#A =#,4=1 "'00'#$. "1/104"!$. N2!
!042(,$!2'&! '"((2 ,!%0'3$.( $!9'#$!04$.( ' ,(-'#$!04$.( &!,'!$2., $# (( ;#$(3$!7
9(04 — /#%6!$'( /'/2("., #/$#&!$$#* $! +,'$9'+!5 P#,!$! ' )!,'!2!.
I#0'2'3(/;'* '/0!" +# +,('"18(/2&1 ,!6';!0($, ! (-# +#/0(6#&!2(0' &/(-6!
-#2#&. '62' $! ;#$?0';2. / 6(*/2&1A8(* &0!/24A, ;#2#,!7, +# '5 "$($'A, '%"($'0!
%!+#&(67" '/0!"!. B1/104"!$/;!7 ,(0'-'7 /2!0! #6$'" '% -0!&$.5 ' K??(;2'&$.5
'$/2,1"($2#& /#9'!04$#* "#='0'%!9'', 3("1 %! +#/0(6$'( 2,'69!24 0(2 $!;#+0($#
$("!0# /&'6(2(04/2& — #2 M,!$! 6# ,#//'*/;#-# (&(,$#-# P!&;!%!, #2 ;'2!*/;#*
+,#&'$9'' '$49%7$ 6# Q&,#+., 3'/0# "1/104"!$ & ;#2#,#* +,'=0'>!(2/7 ; 2,'69!2'
"'00'#$!".
R/0#>$'0'/4 #2$#)($'7 "(>61 "1/104"!$!"' ' <!+!6#". G(+,#/2# /;0!6.&!A2/7
'5 #2$#)($'7 / C#//'(*, P'2!(". : K+'9($2,( +,#2'&#,(3'* — S0'>$'* :#/2#;, M,!;,
M,!$, F?-!$'/2!$, I!;'/2!$. :#2 1>( +#32' 6&!69!24 0(2 /18(/2&1(2 $!+,7>($'( $!
(&(,$#" P!&;!%(. G(+,#/2!7 /'21!9'7 & J($2,!04$#* F%''. : /&#( &,("7 <='-$(&
S>(%'$/;'* #2"(3!0 $! -(#+#0'2'3(/;#* ;!,2( 61-1 — «+#01"(/79 $(/2!='04$#/2'».
G.$( ;#$?'-1,!9'7 $(/2!='04$#/2' 6!&$# +,(&%#)0! ?#,"1 +#01"(/79! ' /2!0! ;16!
#=)',$((. C!%#=,!24/7 & ;,'%'/$.5 /'21!9'75 &#%"#>$# 2#04;# +,' !6(;&!2$#",
6'!0(;2'3(/;#" +#$'"!$'' ,(0'-'#%$#-# ?!;2#,!.
C!%1"((2/7, $( #6$#* ,(0'-'(* #=1/0#&0($. +,#2'&#/2#7$'7, ,!%&#,!3'&!A8'(/7
&$12,' "1/104"!$/;#-# "',! ' & /&7%' / $'". R ;#$?0';2#& & T>$#* F%'', $! S0'>$("
:#/2#;(, $! +#/2/#&(2/;#" +,#/2,!$/2&( (/24 /&#' +,'3'$., $# 607 13!/2&1A8'5 & $'5
+#0'2'3(/;'5 /'0 ,(0'-'7 #/2!(2/7 #3($4 &!>$." #,16'(", '/+#04%#&!$'( ;#2#,#-#
$('%=(>$# &(6(2 ; ,!/)',($'A ' 1>(/2#3($'A K2'5 ;#$?0';2#&.
B#>$# +#-,!%$#"1 2,!;2#&!24 +,'3'$. +(,"!$($2$#* ;#$?0';2#-($$#/2' &
'/0!"/;#" "',(. ,(6' /!"'5 "1/104"!$ )',#;# ,!/+,#/2,!$($# "$($'(, 32# -0!&$.(, +#
/12' (6'$/2&($$.( &'$#&$';' !"# ;#$?0';2#& ' $!+,7>($$.5 /'21!9'* $! '5 %("0( —
<!+!6, #&(2/;'* #A%, ! %!2(" C#//'7 (/+,#&#9',#&!&)!7 &#*$. & U(3$(). G! 6(0(
+,'3'$. ;#$?0';2#& $!"$#-# )',(, ' #=1/0#&0($. #$', ,!%1"((2/7, $( 2#04;# &$()$'"
&"()!2(04/2&#", $# ' &$12,($$'" — +#0'2'3(/;'", /#9'!04$#-K;#$#"'3(/;'"
+#0#>($'(" & "1/104"!$/;'5 /2,!$!5 ' #=8(/2&!5.
G! ,1=(>( +,#)0#-# ' $.$()$(-# &(;#& /2,("'2(04$# #=#/2,'0/7 &$12,''/0!"/;'*
;,'%'/. I,#2'&#=#,/2&# & 2#0;#&!$'' '/0!"!, "(>61 ,!%0'3$."' /#=/2&($$# '/0!"/;'"'
'6(#0#-'7"' 1>(/2#3!(2 & /'21!9'A & "1/104"!$/;#" /##=8(/2&(. V'/;1//'7 $#/'2
&/(#=8'* 5!,!;2(,. : C#//'' >( #$! ;,!*$( #=#/2,($! ' =#0(%$($$! $! (&(,$#" P!&;!%(.
:$12,''/0!"/;'* ;,'%'/ $(#26(0'" #2 (-# #2$#)($'* / <!+!6#": /2#,#$$';#&
"#6(,$'%!9'' /3'2!A2 0'9("(,!"'-$%&'()*'$) ('%&(/2$#( (8( /# &,("($ +,#,#;!
B15!""!6! #=&'$($'(), #/1>6!A2 %! 6(?#,"!9'A «'/2'$$#-# '/0!"!», %! #25#6 #2 #/$#&
&(,#13($'7.
R3'2.&!7 #/#=($$#/2' ;!>6#-# #26(04$#-# ;,'%'/!, 2(" $( "($(( ;#$/2!2',1("
$!0'3'( (6'$#-# ;#$?0';2#-($$#-# +#07, ;#2#,#( "#>$# 1+#6#='24 /'/2("(
/##=8!A8'5/7 /#/16#&. @!;, &$12,($$'* ;#$?0';2 & F?-!$'/2!$( — #6$# '% %&($4(&
+,#27>($$#* 9(+'. F?-!$'/2!$ 6(,>'2 & $!+,7>($$#/2' A- J($2,!04$#* F%''. I!;'/2!$
#;!%.&!(2/7 +(,(6 1-,#%#* 2!0'=!$'%!9''. R/'0($'( ,!6';!04$#-# '/0!"! & I!;'/2!$(
1516)!(2 (-# #2$#)($'7 / M$6'(*, ;,'%'/ &#;,1- M,!$! #=#/2,7(2 /'21!9'A $! S0'>$("
:#/2#;(, /'21!9'7 & M,!;( $(-!2'&$# /;!%.&!(2/7 $! #2$#)($'75 "(>61 )''2!"'
/1$$'2!"'. B#>$# +,'&(/2' ' 6,1-'( +,'"(,..
G(&#%"#>$# '%#=,(/2' (6'$/2&($$# &(,$1A /2,!2(-'A &.5#6! '% &/(5 ;#$?0';2#&.
D6$!;# "#>$# &.,!%'24 #=8(( /2,!2(-'3(/;#( &'6($'( /'21!9'' & "1/104"!$/;#" "',(,
& 3!/2$#/2', #+,(6(0'24/7 / +#$'"!$'(" ?($#"($! '/0!"/;#-# ,!6';!0'%"! — ?(,"($2!,
!;2'&$# +(,(2(;!A8(-# +# 1+#"7$12." /##=8!A8'"/7 /#/16!", +#$724, $!/;#04;# #$
#=W(;2'&$# $('%=(>$#( 7&0($'(, ! +,' ;!;'5 #=/2#72(04/2&!5 $#/'2 /;#,((
'$/2,1"($2!04$.* 5!,!;2(,.
D/"./0($'( '/0!"/;#-# ,!6';!0'%"! 6!(2 ;0A3 ; +#$'"!$'A +,#=0(". 2(,,#,'%"!
' /##2&(2/2&($$# /+#/#=/2&1(2 &.,!=#2;( &(,$#-# +#65#6! ; (-# +,"-./ ,'0"&)1. N2#
/0#&# &.6(0($# $( /013!*$#, +#/;#04;1 =#,4=! +,#2'& 2(,,#,'%"! ;!; 2!;#&!7 "#>(2
'"(24 0')4 #-,!$'3($$.* 1/+(5.
11 /($27=,7 2001 -., &#+,(;' )',#;# ,!/+,#/2,!$($$#"1 "$($'A, +,'$9'+'!04$# $(
'%"($'0# #=/2!$#&;1 & "',(. L0!&$.* K??(;2 #2 2(,!;2! — +#32' &$(%!+$#( #/#%$!$'(
2#-#, 32# "', /2!$#&'2/7 '$.". D6$!;# +,#9(// +(,("($ $!3!0/7 %!6#0-# 6# $4A*#,;/;#* 2,!-(6''. R $(-# -01=#;'( ;10421,$.( ' '/2#,'3(/;'( ;#,$'. I#2($9'!0
-,7618(* 2,!$/?#,"!9'' %!;0!6.&!0/7 (8( & 1970-( -#6., ;#-6! & "1/104"!$/;'5
/2,!$!5 #6$! %! 6,1-#* +,#&!0'&!0'/4 K;#$#"'3(/;'( ,(?#,"., ,!%,!=#2!$$.(
%!,1=(>$."' /#&(2$';!"' ' ;#$/1042!$2!"', ' /2!$#&'0!/4 #3(&'6$#* =(%,(%1042!2$#/24
'"'2!9'#$$.5 "#6(0(*. : ;!3(/2&( /2!,2! $!%#&(" '/0!"/;1A ,(&#0A9'A 1978—1979 --.
& M,!$(. D=,1)($'( ;!%!&)(*/7 +,#3$#* ' 1/+()$#* )!5/;#* /'/2(". ' +,'5#6 ; &0!/2'
!72#00. X#"(*$' "$#-'( 2#-6! /3'2!0' #2;0#$($'(" #2 1/2#7&)'5/7 $#," ,!%&'2'7
!?,#-!%'!2/;'5 /2,!$. : K2#" >( ,761 — '/0!"'%!9'7 +!0(/2'$/;#-# 6&'>($'7
/#+,#2'&0($'7, ;#2#,!7 1&($3!0!/4 +#=(6#* $! &.=#,!5 & 2005 -. V&'>($'( '/0!"/;#-#
#/&#=#>6($'7 (XFBF ), +(,'#6'3(/;'( &/+0(/;' !;2'&$#/2' 0'&!$/;#* «X'%=!00.»,
-,!>6!$/;!7 &#*$! & F0>',( & 1990—1991 --., 2,'1"? & 1996 -. 6&'>($'7 «@!0'=!$»...
:/( K2' /#=.2'7 /#+,#&#>6!0'/4 K;/9(//!"' 2(,,#,'%"!, ;#2#,.* / -#6!"' +,(&,!2'0/7 &
+,'&.3$#( #,16'( +#0'2'3(/;#* =#,4=..
,!&$($'7 $.$()$(-# 2(,,#,'%"! / 0A=." 6,1-'" — ',0!$6/;'", =!/;/;'",
2(,,#,'%"#" ,#//'*/;'5 ,(&#0A9'#$(,#& XIX—XX &&., 5#27 ' 6#+1/2'"., $#
$(;#,,(;2$.. (-#6$7)$'* "(>61$!,#6$.* 2(,,#,'%" — $#&.* ?($#"($. @(,,#,'%"
+,(/0(61(2 -(#+#0'2'3(/;'( 9(0', ! (-# '6(#0#-'7 %'>6(2/7 $! /!".5 ;,!*$'5 2,!;2#&;!5
,(0'-''.
18(/2&1A2 "(>61$!,#6$.( 2(,,#,'/2'3(/;'( #,-!$'%!9'', /0#>'0!/4
'$2(,$!9'#$!04$!7, #=W(6'$($$!7 #=8(* ,(0'-'(* «2(,,#,'/2'3(/;!7 /,(6!», ;#2#,!7, +#
"$($'A $(;#2#,.5 /+(9'!0'/2#&, $!/3'2.&!(2 /#2$' 2./73 ' 6!>( "'00'#$. 0A6(*.
@(,,#,'/2. — '6(#0#-' ' '/+#0$'2(0' — /2!&72 /(=7 &$( ,!"#; +#0'2';', %!;#$#&
&#*$., "#,!0', +#/;#04;1 1&(,($., 32# $(/12 #2&(2/2&($$#/24 +(,(6 =#-#", ;#2#,.* 6!(2
'" /!$;9'' $! 0A=.( /!".( >(/2#;'( 6(*/2&'7. @!;#( 31&/2&# /!;,!04$#*
#2&(2/2&($$#/2' +,'6!(2 '" & /#=/2&($$.5 -0!%!5 #/#=.* /2!21/, $# ' 2,(=1(2 -#2#&$#/2'
; /!"#+#>(,2&#&!$'A. D2/A6! — 2(,,#,'/2.-/!"#1='*9.. M%#=,!>!24 '5
'/;0A3'2(04$# ;!; «=!$6'2#& ' $!,;#"!$#&» %$!3'2 $( +#$'"!24 /124 +,#=0(".
2(,,#,'%"!, ! /0(6#&!2(04$#, $( =.24 & /#/2#7$'' &.,!=#2!24 /2,!2(-'A =#,4=. / $'".
Y&07(2/7 0' 2(,,#,'%" &,("($$.", +,(5#678'" 7&0($'(" '0' #$ & #=#%,'"."
=1618(" #/2!$(2/7 +,'&.3$#*, «,12'$$#*» ?#,"#* +#0'2'3(/;#-# 6(*/2&'7? N2#2
&#+,#/ '"((2 +,'$9'+'!04$#( %$!3($'(. R3'2.&!7 60'2(04$#/24 ' 6!>( $(/;#$3!("#/24
;#$?0';2#& ' ;,'%'/#&, /&7%!$$.5 / +#0#>($'(" & "1/104"!$/;#" "',( ' &#;,1- $(-#,
/2,("'2(04$#( +,#$';$#&($'( "1/104"!$ & $("1/104"!$/;1A /,(61, "#>$#
+,(6+#0#>'24, 32# 2(,,#,'%", 1&., '"((2 $("!0.( ,(%(,&.. C!/212 #+!/($'7 & /&7%' /
&#%"#>$." '/+#04%#&!$'(" 2(,,#,'/2!"' #,1>'7 "!//#&#-# 1$'32#>($'7. N2# 2(" =#0((
#+!/$#, 32# «-#/16!,/2&! $( /"#-0' =./2,# !6!+2',#&!24/7 ; $#&." &.%#&!", /&7%!$$." /
1/;#,7A8'"'/7 +,#9(//!"' -0#=!0'%!9'', &;0A3!7 =1,$# ,!/218'* 2,!$/-,!$'3$.*
#=#,#2 ' 6#/21+$#/24 76(,$.5 "!2(,'!0#&, 2(5$#0#-'*, '$?#,"!9'', K;/+(,2'%., ! 2!;>(
&.5#6 $! !&!$/9($1 /1=-#/16!,/2&($$.5 ?'-1,!$2#&»4. D6'$ '% 2!;'5 «?'-1,!$2#&» —
"(>61$!,#6$.* 2(,,#,'%", ;#2#,.* /(-#6$7, ;!; "'$'"1", /+#/#=($ 1-,#>!24
+,'"($($'(" /,(6/2& "!//#&#-# 1$'32#>($'7, ! %!&2,! "#>(2 +(,(*2' #2 /0#& ; 6(01.
@#, 32# ". $!=0A6!(" & $!/2#78(( &,("7, "#>$# & 9(0#" #5!,!;2(,'%#&!24 ;!;
/&#(-# ,#6! «!/'""(2,'3$.* #2&(2» "1/104"!$/2&! $! +,#'-,.) K;#$#"'3(/;#-# '
+#0'2'3(/;#-# /#/27%!$'7 / /#/(67"' — F"(,';#*, Q&,#+#*, ! & '%&(/2$#* /2(+($' ' /
C#//'(*. M/0!"/;'* ,!6';!0'%" (/24 ;#"+($/!9'7 %! $(16!3' "1/104"!$/;#-#
/##=8(/2&! & "',/;'5 6(0!5. G!;#$(9, #$ /2!$#&'2/7 ' /,(6/2&#" /!"#12&(,>6($'7
"1/104"!$/;#* "'-,!9'', &/( -01=>( +,#$';!A8(* & Q&,#+1 5. G( /013!*$# $(;#2#,.(
,!6';!04$.( '/0!"/;'( '6(#0#-' /3'2!A2, 32# $#&.* '/0!"/;'* '"+104/, «'/0!"/;'*
+,'%.&» +,'6(2 & "1/104"!$/;'* "', '% Q&,#+..
C#/2 ,(0'-'#%$#-# /#%$!$'7 ' +#0'2'3(/;!7 !;2'&$#/24 +#6 ,(0'-'#%$."'
0#%1$-!"' +,#7&07A2/7 & ;,'%'/$.5 /'21!9'75. : $(;#2#,.5 ,!/+#0#>($$.5 & Q&,!%''
/2,!$!5, & 2#" 3'/0( $! +#/2/#&(2/;#" +,#/2,!$/2&(, '"((2 "(/2# #=8!7 6("#6(,$'%!9'7
#=8(/2&!, (-# K;#$#"';', /'/2(". #=,!%#&!$'7. D=8(/2&($$.( #2$#)($'7 &/( =#0((
,(-10',1A2/7 2,!6'9'(*, ;!; K2$#;10421,$#*, 2!; ' ,(0'-'#%$#*. N2# '"((2 "(/2# &
-#/16!,/2&!5 J($2,!04$#* F%'', $! ,#//'*/;#" (&(,$#" P!&;!%(. : #=,!8($'' ;
,(0'-'' 0A67" &'6'2/7 &.5#6 '% 2,16$#/2(*. I,'"(3!2(04$#, 32# $.$( ; ,(0'-''
!+(00',1(2 ' +.2!(2/7 '/+#04%#&!24 (( & /&#'5 9(075 /&(2/;!7 &0!/24. : C#//'' ' GL &
$!'=#04)(* /2(+($' K2# 5!,!;2(,$# 607 @!6>';'/2!$! ' U(3$'. : +#&(6($'' 2!6>';/;#-#
+,(%'6($2! N"#"!0' C!5"#$! ' 3(3($/;#-# 0'6(,! C!"%!$! P!6.,#&! %!"(2$. 3(,2.
,(0'-'#%$#* 5!,'%"..
G! A-( C#//'' +#/2(+($$# '/+#6&#04 ?#,"',1(2/7 "1/104"!$/;'* !$;0!&, &
;#2#,#" /#9'!04$.( #2$#)($'7 &/( =#0(( +#63'$($. 2,!6'9'#$$." K2$#,(0'-'#%$."
1/2!$#&;!". Z#704$#( &0!/2' 615#&($/2&#, '/0!"/;!7 #++#%'9'7 ?!;2'3(/;' /##=8!
&./21+!A2 %! )!,'!2'%!9'A #=8(/2&! ' 6(0!A2 K2# &/( =#0(( #2;,.2#. #=0A6($'(
/##2&(2/2&1A8'5 '/0!"/;'" ;!$#$!" $#,"!2'&#& +#&(6($'7 #2;,.2# +#66(,>'&!(2/7
$(;#2#,."' &0'72(04$."' /&(2/;'"' +#0'2';!"'. I,'23(* &# 7%.9(5 /2!0! +#0'-!"'7,
,!/+,#/2,!$($$!7 /,(6' /#/2#72(04$.5 "1/104"!$.
: /&7%' / ;,'%'/#" &(,#72$# 1/'0($'( ,(0'-'#%$#-# ?!;2#,! ' 1;,(+0($'( +#%'9'*
C1//;#* +,!&#/0!&$#* 9(,;&' & C#//''. J(,;#&4 +#04%1(2/7 /(,4(%$." 6#&(,'(" 1
$!/(0($'7, $!"$#-# #+(,(>!7 L#/16!,/2&($$1A 61"1 ' +,!&781A +!,2'A «Q6'$!7
C#//'7». CIJ $( /;,.&!(2 /2,("0($'7 &0'724 $! #=8(/2&# ' -#/16!,/2&#, +,(60!-!7 /&#*
&!,'!$2 #=1/2,#*/2&! /2,!$., #2/2!'&!7 '6(A (( #/#=#-# +12' (32# &(/4"! $!+#"'$!(2
«'/0!"/;1A !042(,$!2'&1»). D3(&'6$#, +,' #=#/2,($'' /#9'!04$#* $!+,7>($$#/2', 3(-#
&0!/24 '"((2 #/$#&!$'7 #+!/!24/7, 9(,;#&4 "#>(2 /!"#,2'%',#&!24 $(6#&#04/2&# '
&./21+'24 +#/,(6$';#" "(>61 +,!&78'" '/2(=0')"($2#" ' #=8(/2&#".
P,#"( 2#-#, &%!'"#6(*/2&'( / CIJ "#>(2 +#%'2'&$# /;!%!24/7 $! !&2#,'2(2( &0!/2',
«$(?#,"!04$#» +,'6!&!7 (* 6#+#0$'2(04$1A 0(-'2'"$#/24.
6,1-#* /2#,#$., 2!;!7
=0'%#/24 &,76 0' /+#/#=/2&1(2 ,#/21 1&!>($'( ; 9(,;&', +#/;#04;1 #$! #;!%.&!(2/7
/#A%$';#" $( +#04%1A8'5/7 6#&(,'(" 1 $!/(0($'7 !6"'$'/2,!2#,#& ' 3'$#&$';#&.
G! K2#" ?#$( #/#=($$# %!"(2$! !;2'&$#/24 +!2,'!,5! P','00!, ;#2#,.*, +#6,!>!7
+,(%'6($21 B(6&(6(&1 ' +,("4(,-"'$'/2,1 I12'$1, "$#-# &,("($' +,#&#6'2 & +#(%6;!5
+# /2,!$( ' %! ,1=(>#", #=8!(2/7 / /!"."' ,!%$."' -,1++!"' $!/(0($'7, &./)'"'
3'$#&$';!"', &#($$."' $!3!04$';!"', ?!;2'3(/;' /2',!7 -,!$4 "(>61 #=8(/2&($$#4
R 76(,$#-# +#,#-! / I#6 ,(6. F. F,=!2#&! ' :. V&#,;'$!; B#/;. J($2, P!,$(-'. —
ING, 2007. — . 78.
5
".: Ethno-Religious Conflict in Europe: Typologies of Radicalisation in Europe’s
Muslim Communities / Ed. by M. Emerson; CEPS. — Brussels, 2009.
B.: CD
+#0'2'3(/;#* 6(72(04$#/24A ' ,(0'-'#%$." /01>($'(". I!2,'!,5 /2!$#&'2/7 /'"&#0#"
+#0'2'%!9'' CIJ, 5#27 +1=0'3$# K2# #2,'9!(2.
S0'%#/24 CIJ ; &0!/2' &.%.&!(2 /;,.2#( ('$#-6! ' #2;,.2#() ,!%6,!>($'( 1
,#//'*/;'5 "1/104"!$, ;#2#,.( /3'2!A2, 32# & /2,!$( $( /#=0A6!(2/7 +,'$9'+ #26(0($'7
,(0'-'' #2 -#/16!,/2&! ' ,!&($/2&! ;#$?(//'*.
G! ,1=(>( +,#)0#-# ' $.$()$(-# &(;#& 0A6' &/( =#04)( /2!0' &$#&4 #/#%$!&!24
/&#A +,'&(,>($$#/24 ; ,(0'-'#%$#* 2,!6'9'' ' ;10421,(. M"+104/ «,(0'-'#%!9''»
'/5#6'2 #2 '/0!"!. Q&,#+! ' F"(,';! &#%&,!8!A2/7 ; ,(0'-'' & %$!3'2(04$#* /2(+($'
=0!-#6!,7 ("1. I#6,!/2(,7&)'* /#=/2&($$1A ,(0'-'#%$1A '6($2'3$#/24 <!+!6 #812'0
-,#%$1A /'01 '$#*, "1/104"!$/;#* ,(0'-'' ', #2&(3!7 $! (( &.%#& (& ;!;#"-2# /"./0(
'$/2'$;2'&$#), +.2!(2/7 K21 '6($2'3$#/24 ,(!$'"',#&!24. : K2#" #2$#)($''
0A=#+.2$#, 32# "$#-'( "1/104"!$( $( ,!//"!2,'&!A2 ;#$?0';2 / (&,#+(*9!"' '
!"(,';!$9!"' ;!; /2#0;$#&($'( 9'&'0'%!9'*, $# /3'2!A2 (-# ;#$?0';2#" "(>61
'/0!"#" ' «=(%=#>$."» <!+!6#" '0' '/0!"#" ' *%(,.$ ($(&(,'("). M%&(/2$. '5
+,'%.&. ; (&,#+(*9!" &(,$124/7 $! /2(%A /&#(* ,(0'-''.
G! +#/2/#&(2/;#" +,#/2,!$/2&( &#%,#>6($'( ,(0'-'' =.0# ,(!;9'(* $! /#&(2/;'*
!2('%". I#$!3!01 #3($4 !;2'&$#(, #$# ; $!3!01 2000-5 -#6#& 3!/2'3$# 12,!2'0# /&#A
K$(,-(2';1. D6$!;# & 2(;18(" 6(/72'0(2'' +#%'9'' ,(0'-'' &$#&4 $!3'$!A2
1/'0'&!24/7, 2#04;# 2(+(,4 ,(34 '6(2 1>( $( # &#%,#>6($'', ! /;#,(( # /&#(-# ,#6!
«,(0'-'#%$#* K;/+!$/''», &2#,>($'' ,(0'-'' & /!".( ,!%$.( /?(,. >'%$'. M K2#2
+,#9(// "#>(2 %!*2' 6#/2!2#3$# 6!0(;#.