Grachev_K voprosu

!"
!""#
!
!
! "
!
!" #
$% & '$# ()* "+,'' '
"-. %# + ,/,'0
1(2 %(%34/,'2 1/2 /(), $ ' * ' /(),
+,+('*+
"
"
" !+
*%)%1
!"#$% $&'()* #$'+ &,% '-.!//0* /,1)$/,"2/0* )''"!&$.,-!"2'()* + /).!% ')-!-3
$'')4 />(K..//V-1.)>>-S&?(&@@1)'&./.&S,/(/>/5/@'-,.'&@-1'/K>/S(&@
'.*? /@/V../@'0 (&V/'/@R/@/V./@') L66 &(/..2/" 66 &R/R/('" <==9M6 / 2&2
R/2&S*>&'R(&2')2&"V/AU).@'>/-1&X)?@;)K:'(&S)1.*S&V/>&.);">'/K1)@
) S()'A./5/ &.&)S&'/(&6 / ,&..*K @K)(./0 /(5&.)S&4)) S,(&>//?(&..);" >/
>@KK)(V)S/(-2/@'A@'(&,&:'R()K(./I==K))/./>1/>2L6&,>&"<=77M6
/@'/;../ '?.//5)1@2/ (&S>)')" )@R/AS/>&.) 2/KRA:'(/>" )S-1.)
).3/(K&4)) )S (&S)1.*? )'(&'-(.*? )@'/1.)2/> R()>/,)' 2 '/K-" 1'/ /(5&.* S(
.); .&?/,;'@; > R/@'/;../K .&R(;+.) ) S&1&@'-: 3/2-@)(-:' )S/V(&+.) V)S2/
(&@R//+..*? R(,K'/>6 (S-A'&' 15/ K*U4*" /@-X@'>;:X) &22/K/,&4):
?(-@'&)2&"(&V/'&:'>/,.//V(&S./K(+)K"1'/R()>/,)'2)?R(.&R(;+.):)2&2
@,@'>)2(&@@'(/0@'>-(3(&24))6
-X@'>-' K./+@'>/ K'/,)2" .&R(&>..*? .& --1U.) S(.); - @&V/>)
,;X)? :,06 &)V/ (&@R(/@'(&...*K) ;>;:'@;F !'/,)2& >/@@'&./>.); S(
.);R//:(W55-"-1U.)S(.);R/K'/,-)A;K&/(&4);0'@&" -2/
>/,@'>/ !&(5&(' 6 /(V''" -1U.) S(.); R/ !)(S&2&()K- /(V2/>-
L66//>A>&"<==IM),(6
,.&2/" >*UR(1)@..* K'/,)2) '(V-:' +,.>./5/ >*R/..); /R(
,..*? 2/KR2@/> -R(&+..)0 ) K(/R();')0 .& R(/';+.)) ,)'A./5/ R()/,&
>(K.)6(S-A'&'15/-S&.)K&:X5/@;)SS&/,.//V(&S);-R(&+..)0K/+'(&S
>)'A@; 1->@'>/ R(),&.);" K/./'/.))" 1'/ .5&')>./ @2&+'@; .& 2&1@'> >*R/
..);-R(&+..)0).R/S>/)',/@')5.-'A+&K/5/(S-A'&'&6/W'/K-./V?/,)K
R/)@2./>*?@(,@'>)@R/@/V/>>/S,0@'>);.&S()'A.*0&.&)S&'/("2/'/(*R/K)K/
R(/3)&2')2))2/((24))(3(&24))5&S&"V-,-''(V/>&'A/'S&.)K&:X5/@;R/@'/
;../5/&.&)S&@)'-&4)))R/)@2&(&4)/.&A./5/(U.);6
'&2)K@(,@'>&KK/+.//'.@'))5(/>*-R(&+..);">2/'/(*?S()'A.*0&.&
)S&'/( /@-X@'>;' 3/2-@)(/>2- S(.); R() R()4)>&.)) L,&('@" V)A;(," K).)
V/-).5M))R().&V:,.))S&,>)+-X)K@;/V]2'/KL.&@'/A.*0'..)@"V&,K).'/.M6
$332')>./@'A)5(*S&2:1&'@;>'/K"1'/)5(&:X)0.S&,-K*>&'@;/(&V/'
K*U45&S&6:V/01/>2"-1&@'>-:X)0>).'(@./0K-)5("@'(K)'@;>*)5(&'A6
/W'/K- R()2&,*>&' K&2@)K-K -@))0 ,; ,/@')+.); R//+)'A./5/ (S-A'&'&6
&2)K /V(&S/K" > )5(&? @ )SK..)K ,)@'&.4)) 3/2-@)(/>2)" K*U4* /'>1&:X) S&
)SK..)2()>)S.*?(-@'&)2&R/-1&:''(.)(/>/1.*0W332'.&)V/2&1@'>../6
,-'/'K')'A"1'/@-X@'>-'V/AU/2/)1@'>/@R/(')>.*?)R/,>)+.*?
)5(" > 2/'/(*? S()'A.*0 &.&)S&'/( )5(&' . K&/ >&+.-: (/A6 / @ -1'/K '/5/"
!""#$% &'()!*!+
,-.,/ #01$ 23,, )4
, /
!"
!""#
1'/R()&./K&);?(3(&24))2/.'&2'.*>),*@R/('&L3-'V/"V&@2'V/"5&.,V/">/
0V/),(6MS&R(X.*)SS&R/>*U../5/()@2&R/-1.);'(&>K*6'()4&'A./@2&
S*>&:'@;.&@/@'/;.)/(5&.&S(.);@)/>*>),*@R/('&L';+&;&'')2&"&(K@R/('"
V/,)V),).5M)>),*@R/('&@&2(/V&')1@2)K)WK.'&K)L5)K.&@')2&"R(*+2)>>/
,-"3)5-(./2&'&.)M6/W'/K-.&)V/R/,?/,;X)K);>;:'@;'&2))5(*2&2,&('@"
V)A;(,"V/-).5LK).)V/-).5M".&@'/A.*0'..)@"V&,K).'/.),(6
())5(>,&('@)5(/2,/+.R/@'/;../3/2-@)(/>&'AS(.)'/.&/@'(Y,(/
')2&LV)S+&X-:'/12-M"'/.&@2'/(K)U.)">2/'/(*0/.?/1'R/R&@'AL,&A.::
'/12-M6 &2)K /V(&S/K" R(/)@?/,)' '(.)(/>2& &22/K/,&4)/../5/ R(/4@@&6 /K)K/
W'/5/S&G=K).)5(*)5(/2>@(,.KR(/?/,)'D==8==KL6/.:?/>"<==IM"1'/R//
+)'A./@2&S*>&'@;.&(&V/'/R/(./,>)5&'A./5/&RR&(&'&6
(.)(/>2&K*U4"/'>1&:X)?S&R(/K.)?(-@'&)2&"R(/)@?/,)'R())5(
>V)A;(,6//>A>&66L<==IM>@>/0(&V/'@@*&'@;.&2.)5-)S>@'./5/(-@@2/5/
>(&1&" &,]:.2'R(/3@@/(&&.&'/K)))3)S)//5)),/(&)A'(V(&.'& @/?(&.
.))S(.);".&R)@&..-:)K>7I=D5/,-6.06)A'(V(&.'R)U'FS>@?)5(">
2/)?/V*2./>../R(/>/,;'S)K.)>1(&",;S&.)K&:X)?@;>@AR/1'),.A'(-,./:
,; 5&S (&V/'&: V)A;(, 2&2 R(>/@?/,./ @(,@'>/ ,; R/R(&>.); -'/K.); 5&S
V/AU/5/S&@-+)>&'/,/V(.);\6&2)>,&('@">V)A;(,)5(/2,/+.@K/'('A
.&-,&(.-:1&@'A2);".&-1&@'/2V)'2&">2/'/(*0./V?/,)K//@-X@'>)'A-,&("1'/V*
V)'/2R/2&')@;R/.-+./0'(&2'/())".&U&("R/2/'/(/K-,/+.R/R&@'AV)'/2).&
-S-">2/'/(-:,/+.R/R&@'AU&(6&2)K/V(&S/K"?(-@'&)2,/+.@R(/4)(/>&'A
.&@'1&'21'*((&S./-,&..*'/12)6(/KW'/5/)5(/2,/+.K*@../R(,@'&
>)'A'(&2'/():R/'&U&(/>R/@-,&(&6;W'/5//.,/+.>S5;,/K.&()@/>&'A
'(&2'/():R/'&V)'2&),(-5)?U&(/>6&..&;R(/4,-(&@?/+&@/@R4)&A.*K)-R
(&+..);K).&@.;').&R(;+.);@K*U45&S6
S>@?(&S./>),./@'0V)A;(,&.&)V/R/,?/,;X)K;>;'@;R-6$'//V];@
.;'@;.@2/A2)K)R()1).&K)6/R(>*?"R(/@'/'&R(&>))5(*R/S>/;')5(&'A,&+
.R/,5/'/>../K-1/>2-6/>'/(*?"@//'./U.)(&SK(/>-S*)U&(&'&2/>/"1'/
. @/@'&>;' V/AU/5/ '(-,& S&V)'A U&( > -S-6 ,/>&'A./" K.AU >(/;'./@')"
1'/ )5(&:X) V-,-' .(>.)1&'A ) (&@@'(&)>&'A@; )SS& .-,&1./5/ -,&(&6 '('A)?"
2(/K'/5/"1'/U&(*(&S,;:'@;.&4A.*)R//@&'*"/.))K:'@R2'()S94>
'/>L2(&@.*0"/(&.+>*0"+'*0"S.*0"2/()1.>*0"@).)0"3)/'/>*0"1(.*0)
V*0M" 1'/ S&@'&>;' /@-X@'>;'A R(/4@@ &22/K/,&4)) U&(/> @ (&S)1./0 ,)../0
@>'/>/0>/.*6
V)A;(, V/AU-: (/A )5(&' . '/A2/ '/1./@'A" ./ ) @)& -,&(&6 /W'/K-
,&..&;)5(&R/K)K/'(.)(/>2)S()'A./5/&.&)S&'/(&"@R/@/V@'>-'(&S>)'):2//(
,).&4))K*U1./0K/'/()2)6
() -1' '(.)(-:X5/ W332'& R(/4@@/> &22/K/,&4)) ) /'@-'@'>)) '(&>K&
')SK&,&('@)R-;>;:'@;.&)V/V&5/R();'.*K))5(&K),;:,0@>*@/2/0@'
R.A:.&(-U.);(3(&24))6
/ ,).&K)1.*K) )5(&K)" ?/(/U/ >/S,0@'>-:X)K) .& S()'A.*0 &.&)S&
'/(";>;:'@;.&@'/A.*0'..)@)V&,K).'/.6.)(&S(U.*,;5(-RR)K:X)?5
2-:)@(,.::@'R.A.&(-U.);(3(&24))6
!""#$% &'()!*!+
,-.,/ #01$ 23,, )4
,/3
!"
!""#
/ >(K; )5(* > .&@'/A.*0 '..)@ > &2')>.-: (&V/'- >/>2&'@; V/AU&;
5(-RR& K*U4" ->)1)>&'@; ,;'A./@'A @(,@./@/@-,)@'/0 ) ,*?&'A./0 @)@'K6
$'&)5(&(2/K.,-'@;>2&1@'>1.);V/A.*K"@'(&,&:X)K.&)V/(&@R(/@'(&
...*K) @(,1./@/@-,)@'*K) S&V/>&.);K) ) S&V/>&.)K /(5&./> S(.); L66
&(1-2/>&"66R(&?"7997a66;V).).&"<==DM6
&@'/A.*0 '..)@ N W'/ @R/(' ) (&S>1.)6 5(& > .&@'/A.*0 '..)@ (2/
K.,-'@;R().&(-U.)),*?&.);"R/>(+,.))/R/(./,>)5&'A./5/&RR&(&'&),(-
5)?S&V/>&.);?6+.)S&R/'/KK;1&NR(2(&@.&;5)K.&@')2&,;5&S6/K)@
@);Z
.&S>&&.&@'/A.*0'..)@.&)V/R(@R2')>.*K>),/K@R/('&"U)(/
2/,/@'-R.*K)@-+&X)KS,/(/>A:L66;V).).&"<==DM6
; V/ W332')>./5/ >/S,0@'>); .& S()'A.*0 &.&)S&'/( R() )5( > .&
@'/A.*0'..)@./V?/,)K/)@R/AS/>&'A4>'.*U&()2)L66&.2/>"<=7=M6/V
?/,)K/"1'/V*U&()2))K);(2-:/2(&@2-L+'*0"(/S/>*0"@).)0"S.*0M)K.;
)@A>R(/4@@)5(*.@2/A2/(&S6$'/V-,'@R/@/V@'>/>&'AR/@'/;../K-)SK..):
(&V/'*K*U45&S&">(S-A'&'15/V-,'/@-X@'>;'A@;'(.)(/>/1.*0W332'6
5(&>V&,K).'/.R/S>/;',/@')5&'A'&2/5/+&2')>)(-:X5/>);.);.&/V
K..*R(/4@@*>/(5&.)SK"1'/),(-5)>),*K*U1./0(&V/'*"./R/WK/4)/.&A
./K- >/S,0@'>):" ,/@'-R./@')" ).'(@&K S&.)K&:X)?@; /.& S.&1)'A./ )? R(>/@
?/,)'L66!&>(/K&')@"<==DM6
,/>&'A./" )@R/AS/>&.) >@? >*UR(1)@..*? )5( .& S&.;');? @/ @'-
,.'&K)" )K:X)K) ,32'* (3(&24))" ;>;'@; .&)V/ R()KK*K) @(,@'>&K)
,;(U.);S&,&1R/R(,K'-3)S)1@2&;2-A'-(&6
&# ( #!)*!"##'"$#% "&#"!$
76 &(/..2/66,/(/>A)3)S)1@2&;2-A'-(&@'-,.'&F1V6R/@/V)E66&(/
..2/"66&R/R/('6NS,6<"R((&V6!6FA3&!F!"<==96NGG8@6F)6
<6 &(1-2/>&665(&,/@'-R.&;>@KE66&(1-2/>&"66R(&?6N!6"79976
G6 /.:?/>6/4)&A./K,)4).@2)0&@R2'>);.);S&.;')0,&('@.&1/>2&6<==IF
pkktFEE‚‚‚6qmvkesmekjv6v€EmvkcfujeEkcteE77CDsjqcfchjqmvke
D6 !&>(/K&')@" 66 ()K..) V&,K).'/.& > /S,/(/>)'A./0 3)S)1@2/0 2-A'-(
:,0 @(,.5/ >/S(&@'& E 66 !&>(/K&')@F >'/(36 ,)@6 \ 2&.,6 R,6 .&-26 RV6" "
<==D6N<D@6
C6 &.2/>66&,-5&R(/S(.);E66&.2/>6N!6F@'(A"<=7=6N<D=@6F)6
86 ;V).).&66&@'/A.*0'..)@>@)@'K3)S)1@2/5/>/@R)'&.);@'-,.'/2'?
.)1@2/5/>-S&F)@66662&.,6R,6.&-2F7G6==6=DF(&@./;(@2"<==D6N7GCf6
H6 //>A>& 66 &2 V*@'(/ --1U)'A S(.) E 66 //>A>&6 N !6 F a VF
@'(AVa&,)K)(F"<==I6N7CH"^<_@6
I6 &,>&6(-+)R(/')>V)S/(-2/@')6NV6F)'("<=776N7<I@6F)6
!""#$% &'()!*!+
,-.,/ #01$ 23,, )4
,/,