Становление гарантий обеспечения законности при

ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
343.1
Kuchinskaya Anna Vasilievna
(603950,
,
, 3)
postgraduate student
Nizhny Novgorod academy of the Ministry of internal of Russia (3 Ankudinovskoe shosse, Nizhny
Novgorod, 603950)
E-mail: [email protected]
The establishment of guarantees of legality
by manufacture on criminal cases against minors
-
,
The article gives a historical analysis of the evolution
of the concept of the rule of law in the Russian criminal
procedure legislation and given periodization of becoming criminal procedure guarantees the legality of the investigation of crimes committed by juveniles.
.
:
,
,
,
,
-
Keywords: legality, the principle of legality, evidence, proceedings in criminal cases involving minors,
procedural safeguards.
.
-
,
,
1917
.
-
.
.
«
-
,
,
,
,
:
,
[1, . 7].
.
-
,
,
»
.
—
«
», «
»
,
[2; 3; 4].
,
.
,
-
I
,
.
,
,
.
278
[5, . 151—152].
ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
-
.
,
I
«
[7],
,
».
.
,
(1832 .),
—
.
1864
.
-
.
-
.
,
( 1991 .)
,
-
«
,
,
,
».
-
,
-
,
.
,
13
-
.
.
12
«
-
».
.
,
262
«
-
» [6].
,
1917
( . 75
,
-
. 389.17
).
,
,
,
,
[8, . 348],
,
,
-
.
[9]
.
(1917—1991
.)
,
-
.
.
(
) [10].
,
-
,
-
.
1864
1918
-
,
,
,
,
.
1923, 1926
(
,
1857 .
-
).
1960
,
.
( . 95, 413, 706, 759)
-
,
—
.
, 2016,
1 (33)
279
ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
.
6
,
,
-
11 —
,
,
«
»
-
.
,
14
,
54 424
38 127
,
,
7%
[14,
-
. 179].
.
1897
,
-
.
-
,
»
,
-
[15, . 13].
-
,
.
-
—
1935
«
»,
,
-
[16].
-
,
,
,
-
,
-
.
,
-
.
1941
.
5%
[11].
[17].
-
,
.
.
32
1960
-
XIX
,
1917
,
112%,
1910
,
.
-
1901
,
,
,
1965
4
1991
5%
[18, . 107].
35% [12].
—
( . 40
1923 .).
. 38
,
1922 .,
-
-
[19].
,
,
,
-
.
,
,
»
».
280
,
» [13, . 34].
1918—1920
«
«
-
—
-
,
,
-
,
),
.
,
ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
-
,
.
.
,
,
,
1991
,
,
,
14%
. 19]).
,
-
,
1994 .,
(
-
7
.
,
-
[20,
-
2000 .
[29, . 7].
.
2014 .,
,
5,72%
[21].
,
.
:
.
:
,
,
.
,
. «»
(
. 1 .2
. 151
,
,
1.
-
,
,
//
3.
. . 1.
4.
.«
»
.
., 2013.
5.
. ., 2008.
.
-
6.
20
1864 . //
. URL: http://constitution.garant.ru/history/act16001918/3137/
7.
,
.
//
-
,
. 1980.
,
.
,
8.
.
-
,
9.
-
:
,
.
10.
[28, . 8].
.
:
.
,
/
.
. ., 2001.
:
,
:
.
//
.
1 (33)
4.
.
//
, 1993.
,
, 2016,
-
. ., 1926.
-
.
. ., 1987. . 2.
)
,
:
., 2003.
2.
).
,
.
.
,
,
,
.
[22; 23; 24; 25; 26],
(
(
-
[30, . 7]
).
,
[27].
,
:
.
-
., 1998.
281
ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
11.
.
29.
,
,
//
. 2014.
12.
//
13.
.
.
(
., 2014.
.
.…
1950- — 1991 .):
.
-
15.
.
:
.
16.
.
. 1937.
7
.
., 2012.
Notes
1. Pigolkin A.S. Theory of state and law: textbook.
Moscow, 2003.
2. Likhachev D.S. Grand heritage // Selected works
in three volumes. Leningrad, 1987. Vol. 2.
-
5. Rogov V.A. History of state and law of Russia.
Moscow, 2008.
1935 .
.
//
. 2010.
18.
:
.
/
.
19.
1.
.
.
-
., 2005.
.
-
:
. 2012.
20.
//
4.
.
:
., 2012.
21.
//
. URL: http://crimestat.ru/social_
portrait
22.
.
:
:
., 2011.
.
23.
,
2012.
24.
,
.
.
:
,
:
,
27.
:
.
.,
13. Krasnov D.A. The history of the state policy in the
fight against juvenile delinquency in the RSFSR (the end
of the 1950—1991): dissertation... candidate of legal sciences. Moscow, 2014.
.,
//
« ». URL: http://www.nan.ru/
28.
.
.…
.
.
.
., 2011.
10. Kudryavtsev V.N. Legality: the content and the
current state of // Law of the Russian Federation. Moscow, 1998.
-
-
almanax.html
9. Vitruk N.V. Legality: concept, the protection and
promotion // General theory of law: lecture course. Nizhny Novgorod, 1993.
12. Zach A.I. Characteristics of juvenile delinquency
// Children criminals. Moscow, 1912.
., 2005.
.
8. Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. M.M. Rassolov, V.O. Lucin, B.S. Ebzeev. Moscow, 2001.
.,
/
.
7. Plotnieks A.A. Formation of the concept of socialist legality in the general theory of law // Jurisprudence.
1980.
4.
11. Dolmatov S.A. Circumstances to be considered
when sentencing juveniles in the history of the national
criminal legislation // Herald TomGU. 2014.
381.
., 2010.
.
6. Charter of criminal proceedings on 11.20.1864 //
Website of the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
URL: http://constitution.garant.ru/history/act1600-1918/
3137/
-
.
:
:
., 2013.
4. Uzhankov A.N. «Word on Law and Grace» and
other creations of metropolitan Hilarion of Kiev. Moscow,
2013.
4.
17.
25.
:
2006.
26.
.
.
.
., 1990.
//
.
.…
3. Complete collection of Russian chronicles. Vol. 1.
Laurentian chronicle. Leningrad, 1926.
., 1929.
.
.
.
//
.
30.
., 1912.
.
.
:
.
381.
.
14.
282
.
-
14. Yakubson V.R. Employment Home for juvenile offenders in the institutions to combat juvenile delinquency
// Prison reform and the prospects for the forced labor in
the USSR. Moscow, 1929.
15. Melnikova E.B. Juvenile justice: history and modernity. Moscow, 1990.
16. Bulatov S.Y. Law of April 7, 1935 in the Soviet
penal law // Socialist legality. 1937.
4.
17. Emelin S.M. Fighting with a minor crime in the
Great Patriotic war // Juvenile justice issues. 2010.
1.
18. Criminology: textbook / ed. N.F. Kuznetsova and
V.L. Lunev. Moscow, 2005.
ÒÐÈÁÓÍÀ ÌÎËÎÄÎÃÎ Ó×ÅÍÎÃÎ
19. Shtykova N.N. Soviet juvenile justice: the stages
of development // Questions of juvenile justice. 2012.
4.
20. Kalacheva E.N. Activity of the lawyer to provide
legal assistance to minors: monograph. Moscow, 2012.
21. Crime rates in Russia // Portal legal statistics.
URL: http://crimestat.ru/social_portrait
22. Kaljuzhnaja L.G. Juvenile justice and protection
of the rights of minors in Russia: the constitutional and
legal aspects: the monograph. Moscow, 2011.
23. Markovicheva E.V. Juvenile criminal proceedings: models, features, principles. Moscow, 2012.
24. Melnikova E.B. Juvenile justice: problems of
criminal law, criminal procedure and criminology. Moscow, 2010.
25. The juvenile justice system in the Russian Federation: problems of criminology. St. Petersburg, 2006.
, 2016,
26. Juvenile law: textbook for universities / ed.
A.V. Zaryaev, V.D. Malkov. Moscow, 2005.
27. Maksudov R.R., Flyamer M.G. Juvenile justice:
the interaction of state and society in responding to
crime and deviant behavior of minors // Almanah «Questions of Juvenile Justice». URL: http://www.nan.ru/almanax.html
28. Arkhipova N.O. Theoretical and legal aspects
of the formation of juvenile justice in the Russian
Federation: dissertation... candidate of legal sciences.
oscow, 2011.
29. Skorodelov I.V. Significant violations of the criminal procedure law and the factors in the pre-trial stages
of the criminal process: dissertation... candidate of legal
sciences. Moscow, 2013.
30. Klotchkov V.V. Actual problems of the theory of
law and the prosecutor’s supervision. Moscow, 2012.
1 (33)
283