К.Г. Пугин ЭКОНОМИЧЕСКОЕ ОБОСНОВАНИЕ РАЗРАБОТКИ

!" 504.064+628.477
.!. "#$%&
!"#$%&' ()*&+(),-(.' &$$,!/+0)1!,-$%&'
2+,&1!3(&4!$%&' 5(&0!"$&1!1
' ()(*+,-. (- (/(.)(01)+- 21321/(4 +
561 (078 (4016(0 (1( «,*3»
!"#"$% &'()%*%+, -.,+,/(0%!.,% ,1,!+,)#+(% '#2'#1,".( !"#'34 56#.,)34 ,")#6,) /%"#667'8(0%!.,8, .,/1(+#"#. 9!&,6$2,)#+(% ,")#6$+34 56#.,) 7)%6(0()#%" &',(2),*("%6$+,!"$ *,/%++,: &%0(, !+(;#%" 7*%6$+3: '#!4,* .,.!#, '#!4,* #86,/%'#"# ( ,.#"35%:.
!"#$%&$ '!(%): /%"#667'8(0%!.(: .,/1(+#", ,")#6$+3: 56#.,
-.,+,/(.#, /%"#66,.,+<%+"'#".
#$%&' () &*+,-./', 0 $/1*/.2%&-*( 0&*&+&' 3 40&.&5(6/-0&7 8.,%/
6/.&3/6/-*3& 8+/$913.1/* -/+2/)%:/ *+/;&3,%(1, 13.1/*-1 7/*,..<+5(1.
=& -*/8/%( <>/+;,, %,%&-(7&5& &0+<?,@>/' -+/$/, 6/+%,1 7/*,..<+5(1
3 %,A/' -*+,%/ ),%(7,/* 3*&+&/ 7/-*& -+/$( &*+,-./' 8+&7:A./%%&-*(
8&-./ *&8.(3%&-4%/+5/*(6/-0&5& 0&78./0-,, &*.(6,1-2 3:-&0&' +/-<+-&/70&-*2@ (, 0,0 -./$-*3(/, ;&.2A(7( &*B&$,7( [1, 2, 3].
B<$A/%(/ 0,6/-*3, &0+<?,@>/' -+/$: 3/$/* 0 +&-*< ),;&./3,/7&-*( %,-/./%(1. =& 7%/%(@ 7/$(0&3, ;&.// 8&.&3(%: 3-/B ;&./)%/' 3:):3,/*-1 3+/$%:7 3&)$/'-*3(/7 B(7(6/-0(B, C()(6/-0(B ( .&5(6/-0(B C,0*&+&3 -+/$:. D/5&$%1 3 6/+%&' 7/*,..<+5(( 6,-*& 7&?/*
&0,),*2-1 ;&.// E/./-&&;+,)%:7 8+(7/%(*2 8+&E/--, 7/%// ),5+1)%1@>(' &0+<?,@><@ -+/$<, 6/7 0&%*+&.(+&3,*2 - ;&.2A(7( ),*+,*,7( <+&3/%2 ),5+1)%/%(' *+,$(E(&%%:B 8+&E/--&3 ( &+5,%()&3:3,*2
;&+2;< - 4*(7( ),5+1)%/%(17(. F &*+,-.1B 7/*,..<+5(( 3 %,-*&1>//
3+/71 ;&.2A(7 -8+&-&7 8&.2)</*-1 +,)+,;&*0, 7,.&&*B&$%:B */B%&.&5('. =&$ 7,.&&*B&$%:7 8+&()3&$-*3&7 8&%(7,/*-1 8+&()3&$-*3&,
3+/$%&/ 3&)$/'-*3(/ 0&*&+&5& %, &0+<?,@><@ -+/$< %/ 8+/3:A,/*
<+&3%1, $&8<-*(7&5& -,%(*,+%:7( %&+7,7(, %& &8+/$/./%%,1 6,-*2
&*B&$&3 3-/ ?/ (7//* 7/-*& (-&&*3/*-*3/%%&, (7/@*-1 &*3,.:, ),B&+&%/%(1 &*B&$&3 ( *.8.). #+5,%(),E(1 ;/)&8,-%:B ),B&+&%/%(' &*B&$&3
7/*,..<+5(( *+/;</* ;&.2A(B 0,8(*,.2%:B 3.&?/%(' ( 3 8&-./$<@>/7 8&$$/+?,%(1 (-8+,3%&5& -&-*&1%(1 ),>(*%:B -&&+<?/%(' [4, 5,
6, 7] 8+( -&;.@$/%(( */B%(6/-0(B +/5.,7/%*&3 [8].
21
F 4*&' -31)( &+5,%(),E(1 +,)+,;&*0( -*,+:B A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3
7/*,..<+5(6/-0(B 8+/$8+(1*(' (7//* ,0*<,.2%&/ )%,6/%(/.
G/.2 &+5,%(),E(( +,)+,;&*0( A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 #H# «I<-&3-0&'
7/*,..<+5(6/-0(' ),3&$» (IJK) – ()3./6/%(/ 7/*,..(6/-0&' 6,-*( ()
&*3,.2%:B A.,0&3 $&7/%%&5& 8+&()3&$-*3, $.1 $,.2%/'A/5& 8/+/$/.,
3 E/B,B ),3&$,.
F 40&%&7(6/-0&7 &;&-%&3,%(( +,)+,;&*0( A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3
#H# «IJK» (-8&.2)&3,.-1 7/*&$ 8&*&0, %,.(6%&-*( (Net present value
method), &$%(7 () &-%&3%:B 4./7/%*&3 0&*&+&5& 13.1/*-1 &E/%0, $/%/?%&5& 8&*&0,, 5/%/+(+</7&5& 3 */6/%(/ +1$, 3+/7/%%:B 8/+(&$&3.
L,-6/*: 3:8&.%1.(-2 - 8&)(E(( %,-*&1>/5& 3+/7/%(, *./. +/,.(),E((
-B/7: $(-0&%*(+&3,%(1 8&*&0&3 %,.(6%&-*( ( (B -<77(+&3,%(1. L/)<.2*,* 13.1/*-1 &-%&3%:7 0+(*/+(/7 &E/%0(. "+&7/ *&5&, 3 $,%%&7
+,)$/./ &8+/$/.1@*-1 *,0(/ 8&0,),*/.(, 0,0 3%<*+/%%11 %&+7, &0<8,/7&-*( 8+&/0*, (FM#), 0&*&+,1 $&.?%, ;:*2 3:A/ 8+(%1*&' -*,30(
$(-0&%*(+&3,%(1, ( -+&0 &0<8,/7&-*( 8+&/0*,.
!/%/?%:/ 8&*&0( 8+&/0*, &E/%(3,.(-2 3 -&&*3/*-*3(( - *+/;&3,%(17( J(%(-*/+-*3, 40&%&7(0( 3 8&-*&1%%:B E/%,B.
F ;()%/--8.,%/ +,--7,*+(3,/*-1 8+&/0* +/,.(),E(( +,)+,;&*0(
A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 3 $3, 4*,8,:
– 1-' 4*,8 – 8/+/+,;&*0, 300 *:-. * A.,0, 3 5&$;
– 2-' 4*,8 – 8/+/+,;&*0, &0&.& 1 7.% * A.,0, 3 5&$.
=+( &E/%0/ 4CC/0*(3%&-*( $,%%&5& 8+&/0*, ;:.( 8+(%1*: %/
-+/$%(/ )%,6/%(1 8&0,),*/./', &8+/$/.1@>(B 4CC/0*(3%&-*2, , %,(;&.// %()0(/, 8&4*&7< 8+&3/+0, 3,+(,%*, %, <-*&'6(3&-*2 7&?/* ),0.@6,*2-1 *&.20& 3 ()7/%/%(( -&$/+?,%(1 7/*,..(6/-0&' C+,0E(( 3 A.,0&3:B &*3,.,B.
#;9N7 A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 #H# «IJK» 8& 40-8/+*%&' &E/%0/ ),3&$-0(B -.<?; -&-*,3.1/* 10–12 7.% *.
=& $,%%:7 8+&3/$/%%:B (--./$&3,%(' – 8/+/+,;&*0( A.,0&3
#H# «IJK» %, <-*,%&30/ J,5%(*&5&+-0&5& 0&7;(%,*, – -&$/+?,%(/ 7/*,..(6/-0(B C+,0E(' 3 &;>/7 &;9N7/ A.,0, -&-*,3.1/* 15 %, (.(
1500 *:-. *, 3 7,--/ A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3. F A.,0&3:B &*3,.,B 6<5<% 3-*+/6,/*-1 3 3($/ 0,8/.2 3 -&-*,3/ A.,0,, 3 3($/ 0<-0&3 %/8+,3(.2%&' C&+7:
( 3 3($/ A,+&3&5& -/57/%*, – «$&%:A0&». O(7(6/-0(' -&-*,3 7/*,..(6/-0&' -&-*,3.1@>/' 8+,0*(6/-0( -&&*3/*-*3</* B(7(6/-0&7< -&-*,3< 6<5<%,. J/*,..(6/-0,1 C+,0E(1 A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 3 &-%&3%&7 -&$/+?(*
22
30.@6/%(1 6<5<%,, 3 0&*&+:B (7//*-1 0,56 % 3,%,$(1. #;9N7 3,%,$(1 3
A.,0&3:B &*3,.,B 7&?%& &E/%(*2 3 8,4 *:-. *, 6*& -&&*3/*-*3</* 8+(7/+%& 4-./*%/7< 3:8<-0< 38 % C/++&3,%,$(1 3 C/++&-8.,3%&7 E/B/. "+&7/
7/*,..&&*-/3, 3 &*3,.,B -&$/+?(*-1 &0&.& 1,6 % .&7, &5%/<8&+&3, 0&*&+:' 8&-./ ()7/.26/%(1 7&?/* (-8&.2)&3,*2-1 3 &5%/<8&+%&7 8+&()3&$-*3/ ),3&$,.
"&%/6%:7 8+&$<0*&7 8/+/+,;&*0( &*3,.2%&5& A.,0, *,0?/ 13.1@*-1 6(-*:/ A.,0(, 0&*&+:/ 7&5<* ($*( %, 8+&()3&$-*3& -*+&(*/.2%:B 7,*/+(,.&3. #$%,0& 3 ;()%/--8.,%/ 4CC/0* &* +/,.(),E(( A.,0&3&5& >/;%1 %/ &8+/$/.1/*-1, *,0 0,0 $& %,-*&1>/5& 3+/7/%( %/ %,'$/%& <$&3./*3&+(*/.2%&' -B/7: /5& +/,.(),E((.
=+( E/%/ 6<5<%, 59 $&... DPH/* ( E/%/ 3,%,$(1 9 $&... DPH/05
7/*,..(6/-0<@ -&-*,3.1@><@ A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 8+( 100 % ()3./6/%((
7&?%& &E/%(*2 -./$<@>(7 &;+,)&7:
1500000 * · 59 $&... DPH/* + 8400 * · 9000 $&... DPH/* =
= 164100 *:-. $&... DPH.
=&.<6/%%,1 7,5%(*%,1 C+,0E(1 (7//* -*+<0*<+<, 8+(3/$/%%<@
3 *,;.. 1.
Q,;.(E, 1
!"#$!#"% &%'()!(*+ ,"%$-))
R+,0E(1, 77
0–10
10–50
50–250
>250
!&.1, %
20,0
20,0
38,1
21.9
D&$/+?,%(1 Fe, %
65
70
83
94
K,7<-&+/%%&-*2 7/*,..&&*-/3, A.,0&3:7( 30.@6/%(17( *,0?/
8&$*3/+?$,/*-1 ( 8+,0*(0&' 8/+/+,;&*0( A.,0&3 %, $+<5(B ),3&$,B,
0&*&+,1 8+(3/$/%, 3 *,;.. 2.
Q,;.(E, 2
.%&#/*"0((*/!1 &0!%22**!/03% 42%$*35&) 3$2670()8&)
R+,0E(1, 77
0–10
10–50
50–250
>250
MQJ", %
20
40
30
10
D/3/+-*,.2, %
58,00
15,74
12,96
13,30
JJ", %
50–52
20–22
7
15–17
23
=+( &;9N7/ 8/+/+,;&*0( A.,0, %, 1-7 4*,8/ 300 *:-. * 3 5&$ ( %,
2-7 4*,8/ &0&.& 1 7.% * 3 5&$ ( -&$/+?,%(( 7/*,..(6/-0(B C+,0E(' 15 %
&;9N7 3:B&$, 7/*,..&&*-/3, 8& C+,0E(17 8+/$-*,3./% 3 *,;.. 3.
Q,;.(E, 3
9:;<& 35=*>% &0!%22**!/03% ?* ,"%$-)8&
R+,0E(1, 77
0–10
10–50
50–250
>250
S*&5&
1-' 4*,8, *
9000
9000
17145
9855
45000
2-' 4*,8, *
27000
27000
51435
29565
135000
=+,0*(0, 8/+/+,;&*0( A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 8&0,):3,/*, 6*& C+,0E(1
0–10 77 (-8&.2)</*-1 3 ,5.&7/+,E((, C+,0E(1 10–250 77 – 3 7/*,..&A(B*/ $&7/%%:B 8/6/', , C+,0E(1 3:A/ 250 77 7&?/* (-8&.2)&3,*2-1
3 $&7/%%&' 8/6( 8&-./ 8+/$3,+(*/.2%&5& ()7/.26/%(1, 3 7,+*/%&3-0(B
8/6,B (.( 3 $<5&3&' 8/6( $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, 6<5<%,. =+(%E(8(,.2%:/
-B/7: 8/+/+,;&*0( +,).(6%:B C+,0E(' 8+(3/$/%: %, +(-<%0/.
L(-. #;>,1 -B/7, 8/+/+,;&*0( 7/*,..&&*-/3, () A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 #H# «IJK»
24
L,--7,*+(3,/7,1 */B%&.&5(6/-0,1 -B/7, 8/+/+,;&*0( 30.@6,/*
-./$<@>(/ &-%&3%:/ &8/+,E((:
1. S)3./6/%(/ 7/*,..(6/-0&' -&-*,3.1@>/' ( +,)$/./%(/ // %,
C+,0E(( %, <-*,%&30/ 8/+/+,;&*0( A.,0&3.
2. R+,0E(1 0–10 77 (-8&.2)</*-1 $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, ,5.&7/+,*,
0,0 ),7/%(*/.2 &0,.(%:.
3. R+,0E(1 10–250 77 (-8&.2)</*-1 3 7/*,..&A(B*/ $&7/%%:B
8/6/'.
4. R+,0E(1 3:A/ 250 77 (-8&.2)</*-1 $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, 6<5<%,
3 $<5&3&' 8/6( 8&-*&1%%&5& *&0, $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, 7/.@>(B A,+&3.
!.1 8+&3/+0( 3&)7&?%&-*( 8+(7/%/%(1 7/*,..&&*-/3, 8+( 8+&()3&$-*3/ ,5.&7/+,*, +,%// %, ),3&$/ ;:.( 8+&3/$/%: -8/E(,.2%:/
+,;&*: 8& -8/0,%(@ ,5.&7/+,*, - (-8&.2)&3,%(/7 7/*,..&&*-/3, A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 #H# «IJK», 8&.<6/%%:B - <-*,%&30( J,5%(*&5&+-0&5&
0&7;(%,*, (TJ#). F +/)<.2*,*/ 4*&' +,;&*: ;:.& <-*,%&3./%&, 6*&
33/$/%(/ 7/*,..&&*-/3, 3 A(B*< 8+( ,5.&7/+,E(( $,/* 3&)7&?%&-*2
8&.<6/%(1 8+(%E(8(,.2%& %&3&5& 8+&6%&5& 7,*/+(,.,, 8+(5&$%&5& $.1
8/+/+,;&*0( 0,0 3 $&7/%%&' 8/6(, *,0 ( 3 $+<5(B 7/*,..<+5(6/-0(B
,5+/5,*,B. F +/)<.2*,*/ 40-8/+(7/%*&3 *,0?/ ;:.& ),C(0-(+&3,%&
-%(?/%(/ +,-B&$, *&8.(3, 3 1,4–1,5 +,),.
F 0,6/-*3/ ;,)&3&5& &;9N7, 8+&()3&$-*3, ,5.&C,;+(0( 8+(%1*
&;9N7, +,3%:' 84,5 *:-. * ,5.&7/+,*,. =+( 4*&7 +,-B&$%:' 0&4CC(E(/%* %, -&;-*3/%%<@ &0,.(%< -&-*,3.1/* 0,193 */*, %, 8&0<8%<@ &0,.(%< – 0,228 */*.
U&$&3,1 8&*+/;%&-*2 3 7/*,..&&*-/3/ C+,0E(( 0–10 77 8+( 8&.%&'
),7/%/ 8&0<8%&' &0,.(%: $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, ,5.&7/+,*, -&-*,3(*:
84,5 · 0,228 = 19,3 *:-. */5&$.
S) 4*&5& -./$</*, 6*& %, 1-7 4*,8/ +,)+,;&*0( A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3
3/-2 8&.<6/%%:' &;9N7 7/*,..&&*-/3, C+,0E(( 0–10 77 ;<$/* (-8&.2)&3,% $.1 ),7/>/%(1 8&0<8%&' &0,.(%:. L,-B&$%:' 0&4CC(E(/%* %,
1 * ,5.&7/+,*, -&-*,3(* 0,107 */*.
=+( 8/+/+,;&*0/ A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 (2-' 4*,8) 8&0<8%,1 &0,.(%,
7&?/* ;:*2 8&.%&-*2@ ),7/%/%, %, 7/*,..&*-/3, - 0&4CC(E(/%*&7
+,-B&$, 0,228 */*, 8+( 4*&7 &0&.& 2,34 *:-. * C+,0E(( 0–10 77 7&?/*
;:*2 +/,.()&3,%& %, -*&+&%< 8& E/%/ &0,.(%: (.( (-8&.2)&3,%& $.1
8.,30( 3 $<5&3&' 4./0*+&8/6( $.1 8+&()3&$-*3, A,+&3 .(;& (-8&.2)&3,%& 54,6 % &* &;>/5& &;9N7, 4*&' C+,0E(( 3 $&7/%%&' 8/6(. D*+<0*<+, C+,0E(( 0–10 77 8+(3/$/%, 3 *,;.. 4.
25
Q,;.(E, 4
!"#$!#"% ,"%$-)) 0–10 &&
R+,0E(1, 77
+5
1–5
0–1
!&.1 C+,0E((, %
54,6
41,4
4
!.1 $,.2%/'A(B +,-6/*&3 %, 2-7 4*,8/ +,--7,*+(3,/*-1 3,+(,%*
8+(7/%/%(1 C+,0E(( 5–10 77 $&7/%%&' 8/6(, 8+( 4*&7 4,51 *:-. *
3 5&$ $&.?%& ;:*2 +/,.()&3,%& %, -*&+&%<.
",0 8&0,),.( +,-6/*:, 8+&()3&$-*3& 7/.@>(B A,+&3 3 TJ#
C/++&-8.,3%&5& E/B, 7&?/* -&-*,3(*2 9–12 *:-. */5&$. =&*+/;%&-*2
8/6( 3 7/*,..&&*-/3/ 8+( <-.&3((, 6*& &%, ;<$/* +,;&*,*2 %, 100 %
7/*,..&&*-/3,, %, 2-7 4*,8/ ;<$/* 8&0+:*, 8&.%&-*2@ ), -6/* 4*&'
C+,0E((, , &-*,*&0 (-8&.2)</*-1 3 3($/ *&3,+%&' 8+&$<0E((. " 7&7/%*< +/,.(),E(( 2-5& 4*,8, +,)+,;&*0( A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3 $<5&3,1 8/62
$.1 8+&()3&$-*3, 7/.@>(B A,+&3 3 TJ# C/++&-8.,3%&5& E/B, <?/
$&.?%, ;:*2 33/$/%, 3 40-8.<,*,E(@.
F $&7/%%:/ 8/6( %, 1-7 4*,8/ 7&?/* ;:*2 ),5+<?/%& 26,15 *:-.
*/5&$, %, 2-7 4*,8/ – 83,74 *:-. */5&$, () 0&*&+:B &0&.& 5,29 *:-. */5&$
-&-*,3.1/* C+,0E(1 5–10 77.
V,.,%- +,-B&$, 7/*,..&&*-/3,, 8&.<6,/7&5& 8<*/7 8/+/+,;&*0(
A.,0&3:B &*3,.&3, 8+/$-*,3./% 3 *,;.. 5.
Q,;.(E, 5
@%2%(/ "%/=*>% &0!%22**!/03% (!5/. !)
=&*+/;(*/.2
H5.&C,;+(0,
!&7/%%:' E/B
!<5&3,1 8/62
=+&$,?, %, -*&+&%<
SQ#U#
0–10
9,00
1-' 4*,8
10–250
>250
26,15
9,00
26,15
0–10
19,27
5,39
9,85
2,34
9,85
27,00
2-' 4*,8
10–250
>250
78,45
11,14
18,41
78,45
29,55
",0 8&0,):3,@* +,-6/*:, 8+( (-8&.2)&3,%(( 3 $&7/%%&' A(B*/
7/*,..&&*-/3, C+,0E(( 10–250 77, 8&.<6/%%&5& () &*3,.2%:B A.,0&3,
<3/.(6(3,/*-1 8+&()3&$(*/.2%&-*2 8/6(, -%(?,/*-1 <$/.2%:' +,-B&$
26
0&0-,, +,-B&$ ,5.&7/+,*, ( &0,*:A/'. L/)<.2*,*: +,-6/*,, 8+/$&-*,3./%%:/ ),3&$&7, 8+( +,).(6%&' -*/8/%( &*$/./%(1 7/*,.., &* A.,0,
8+(3/$/%: 3 *,;.. 6.
Q,;.(E, 6
A0B#21!%!5 "%/70!% ?") "%B2)7(*+ /!0?0()
*!>020()8 &0!%22% *! 42%$%
=&0,),*/.(
L,-B&$ 7/*,..&8+&$<0*,, 05/*
D&$/+?,%(/ A.,0, 3 7/*,..&8+&$<0*/, %
=+(+&-* 8+&()3&$(*/.2%&-*( 8/6(, %
D%(?/%(/ +,-B&$, 0&0-,, 05/*
D%(?/%(/ +,-B&$, &0,*:A/', 05/*
1
100
10
2,8
15
134
2
100
15
2,4
13
127
3
100
20
1,9
10
119
L,-6/*: ;:.( 8+&3/$/%: - (-8&.2)&3,%(/7 8+&5+,77: &8+/$/./%(1 8&0,),*/./' $&7/%%&' 8.,30( %, &-%&3/ ;,.,%-&3&' .&5(0&-*,*(-*(6/-0&' 7&$/.( $&7/%%&5& 8+&E/--,, +,)+,;&*,%%&' SJWQ
+# LHM.
?)/*$ 2)!0"%!#"5
1. =<5(% ".U. D%(?/%(/ 40&.&5(6/-0&' %,5+<)0( -*,./8.,3(.2%&5& 8+&()3&$-*3, ), -6/* (-8&.2)&3,%(1 7/.0&$(-8/+-%:B ?/./)&-&$/+?,>(B &*B&$&3 3 7/*,..<+5(( // M,<6%:/ (--./$&3,%(1 ( (%%&3,E((. –
2010. – Q. 4. – X 3. – D. 64–71.
2. D%(?/%(/ 40&.&5(6/-0&' %,5+<)0( 8+( &;+,>/%(( -& A.,0,7(
6/+%&' 7/*,..<+5((: 7&%&5+,C(1 / ".U. =<5(% [( $+.]. – =/+72: S)$-3&
=/+7. 5&-. */B%. <%-*,. – 2008. – D. 315.
3. =<5(% ".U., ",.(%(%, W.F., O,.(*&3 H.L. L/-<+-&-;/+/5,@>(/
*/B%&.&5(( -*+&(*/.2-*3, ,-C,.2*&;/*&%%:B $&+&?%:B 8&0+:*(' - (-8&.2)&3,%(/7 &*B&$&3 8+&()3&$-*3, // F/-*%(0 =UQ . +;,%(-*(0,. –
=/+72, 2011. – X2. – D. 60–70.
4. =<5(% ".U., F,'-7,% Y.S., ",.(%(%, W.F. 8+,3./%(/ 47(--(17( *&0-(6%:B 0&78&%/%*&3 8+&7:A./%%:B &*B&$&3 7/*,..<+5(6/-0(B, %/C*/8/+/+,;,*:3,@>(B ( B(7(6/-0(B 8+/$8+(1*(' 8<*/7 (B
(-8&.2)&3,%(1 3 -*+&(*/.2%&' &*+,-.( // K,>(*, &0+<?,@>/' -+/$:
3 %/C*/5,)&3&7 0&78./0-/. – 2011. – X7. – D. 31–35.
5. =<5(% ".U., O&$1A/3 J.V. H%,.() 40&.&5(6/-0(B +(-0&3 8+(
+,)7/>/%(( *3/+$:B &*B&$&3 7/*,..<+5(( %, 8&.(5&%/ - 8+&*(3&C(.2*27
+,E(&%:7 40+,%&7 () %/C*/-&$/+?,>(B &*B&$&3 // K,>(*, &0+<?,@>/'
-+/$: 3 %/C*/5,)&3&7 0&78./0-/. – 2011 – X7. – D. 44–48.
6. =<5(% ".U., F(-0&3 J.F. =+(7/%/%(/ %/C*/),5+1)%/%%:B 5+<%*&3 $.1 <-*+&'-*3, 8.&>,$&0 -0.,$(+&3,%(1 &*B&$&3 6/+%&' 7/*,..<+5(( // K,>(*, &0+<?,@>/' -+/$: 3 %/C*/5,)&3&7 0&78./0-/. – 2010. –
X 6. – D. 49–54.
7. Y%0&3-0(' Z.F. ".,--(C(0,E(1 5/&(78.,%*,*%:B 0&%-*+<0E(',
(-8&.2)</7:B 8+( -*+&(*/.2-*3/ ( +/7&%*/ *+,%-8&+*%:B &;9/0*&3 //
D*+&(*/.2%:/ 7,*/+(,.:. – 2011. – X7. – D. 51–53.
8. "&0&$//3, M.W., "&6/*0&3 H.F., Y%0&3-0(' Z.F. J/*&$(6/-0(/
8&$B&$: +/,.(),E(( 8+(%E(8&3 */B%(6/-0&5& +/5<.(+&3,%(1 3 $&+&?%&7
B&)1'-*3/ // F/-*%(0 =UQ . #B+,%, &0+<?,@>/' -+/$:, *+,%-8&+*, ;/)&8,-%&-*2 ?()%/$/1*/.2%&-*(. – =/+72, 2011. – X1. – D. 44–56.
=&.<6/%& 15.09.2011
28