1str

K:LuedbgZ G:L_fqbgZ Ihkh[b_ ihZg]ebckdhfmyaudm êyf_^bpbgkdbo mqbebs K:LuedbgZG:L_fqbgZ Ihkh[b_ ihZg]ebckdhfmyaudmêy f_^bpbgkdbomqbebs :GFB Fhkd\Z± ;;D:g]e L J _ p _ g a _ g l ij_ih^Z\Zl_evZg]ebckdh]hyaudZFhkdh\kdh]hf_^bpbgkdh]h mqbebsZFhk]hjbkihedhfZNK@hem^h\Z LuedbgZK:L_fqbgZG: LIhkh[b_ihZg]ebckdhfmyaudmêyf_^bpbgkdbomqbebs ±F:GFB±kbe Ihkh[b_kh^_j`bll_klugZf_^bpbgkdmxl_fZlbdm^bZeh]b mijZ`g_gby b keh\Zjv L_klu bgl_j_kgu b ihagZ\Zl_evgu ih kh^_j`Zgbx b kgZ[`_gu dhff_glZjb_f P_evihkh[by±jZa\b lb_gZ\udh\ql_gbybihgbfZgbyki_pbZevghcf_^bpbgkdhceb l_jZlmju Z lZd`_ gZ\udZ mklghc j_qb gZ l_fu ij_^mkfhlj_g gu_ijh]jZffhc ,6%1 ;;D:g]e B :g]e ©:GFBª <k_ijZ\ZkhojZg_guGbdZdZyqZklv^Zggh]hba^Zgbyg_fh`_l[ulv \hkijhba\_^_gZ khojZg_gZ \ ex[hc bgnhjfZpbhgghc kbkl_f_ baf_ g_gZbebi_j_\_^_gZ\^jm]hc\bêx[ufbkj_^kl\Zfbwe_dljhggufb f_oZgbq_kdbfb nhlhdhibjh\Zevgufb aZibku\Zxsbfb beb bgufb ^jm]bfb[_ajZaj_r_gbyba^Zl_ey IJ?>BKEH<B? GZklhys__ihkh[b_khklZ\e_ghgZhkgh\_FbgbfmfZZg]ebckdhce_dkbdb êyf_^bpbgkdbobnZjfZp_\lbq_kdbomqbebs Z\lhjLuedbgZK: \dhlh juc \hreb gZb[he__ mihlj_[bl_evgu_ f_^bpbgkdb_ keh\Z b j_q_\u_ dhgkl jmdpbb <ihkh[bbbkihevah\Zguhjb]bgZevgu_ qZklbqghZ^Zilbjh\Zggu_ l_dklu baZg]ebckdhcbZf_jbdZgkdhcf_^bpbgkdhcebl_jZlmjuZlZd`_hl_q_kl\_g gu_l_dklu <k_l_dkludjhf_i_j\h]h²0\IDPLO\hkgh\ZgugZf_^bpbgkdhcl_fZ lbd_L_dkl0\IDPLO\^ZgdZdk\yamxs__a\_gh<hfgh]bol_dklZoihkh[by nb]mjbjmxlqe_guwlhck_fvb Ihkh[b_khklhblbajZa^_eh\ JZa^_e²QZklbl_eZq_eh\_dZ JZa^_e,,²H[sZyf_^bpbgkdZyl_jfbgheh]by JZa^_e,,,²;he_agbbmohâZ[hevgufb JZa^_e,9²E_dZjkl\Z JZa^_e9²Am[h\jZq_[gZyl_jfbgheh]by JZa^_e9,²F_^bpbgkdZyfhaZbdZ Djhf_lh]h\ihkh[bbbf_xlky :g]ehjmkkdb_l_fZlbq_kdb_\ujZ`_gbybjZa]h\hjgbd JmkkdhZg]ebckdbcl_fZlbq_kdbckeh\Zjv :g]ehjmkkdbckeh\Zjv < ihkh[b_ \\_^_gu gh\u_ l_dklu b mijZ`g_gby Ihiheg_g beexkljZlb\ gucfZl_jbZe >ZggZydgb]ZagZdhfblkf_^bpbgkdhcl_jfbgheh]b_cZlZd`_khkeh\Zfb b\ujZ`_gbyfbg_h[oh^bfufbêyg_keh`ghc[_k_ûgZZg]ebckdhfyaud_\ k\h_c jZ[hl_ \Zf \hafh`gh ijb^_lky ijhq_klv ihykg_gby d mihlj_[e_gbx bghkljZggh]h e_dZjkl\Z beb h[tykgblvky k bghkljZgp_f dhlhjhfm \g_aZigh ihgZ^h[beZkvf_^bpbgkdZyihfhsv <dgb]_kh^_j`Zlkyg_lhevdhl_dkluihf_^bpbg_ghbxfhjbklbq_kdb_ jZkkdZaubrmldbgZf_^bpbgkdmxl_fZlbdm :\lhju J:A>?E, 3$5762)7+(+80$1%2'< A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zb\ujZ`_gbydl_dklm ,QXUVH>Q~V@if_^k_kljZf_^[jZl Y WR moZ`b\Zlv aZ[hevguf NLQG>NDLQG@Z^h[juceZkdh\uc VPLOH>VPDLO@imeu[dZ WDLO>WuO@Z\ukhdbc VWURQJ>VWUuD@Zkbevgucdj_idbc DORWRIfgRUR WREHLQJRRGKHDOWKohjhrhk_[y qm\kl\h\ZlvKHDOWK>KHO@Qa^hjh\v_ SURYHUE>µSUuY~E @Qihkeh\bpZ WRQJXH>WAD@iyaud WKHWRQJXHLVQRWVWHHOEXWLWFXWVFS yaudg_h[moghm[blvfh`_l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l\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW LV $QQ" ,V KHU IDPLO\ ODUJH" ,V KHU PRWKHU D GRFWRU" :KDWLVVKH",VKHUIDWKHUDWDOORUDVKRUWPDQ":KDWLVKHUIDWKHU" +RZROGLVKHUEURWKHU"+RZROGLVKHUJUDQGPRWKHU" ,, I_j_\_^bl_ ke_^mxsb_ ij_êh`_gby gZ Zg]ebckdbc yaud mihlj_[b\keh\Zbebkeh\hkhq_lZgby^Zggu_gb`_ Y mqmkv mqZsZyky \ f_^bpbgkdhf mqbebs_ M gZk [hevrZy k_fvyFhyfZfZ²f_^k_kljZMg__fgh]hjZ[hluFhxk_kl jmah\mlHev]ZFhy[Z[mrdZqm\kl\m_lk_[yohjhrh D ORW RI ZRUN LV LQ JRRG KHDOWK D PHGLFDO VFKRRO D ODUJH IDPLO\ D QXUVHVLVWHU VQDPH ,,,KhklZ\vl_jZkkdZahk\h_ck_fv_bkihevamyke_^mxsb_ keh\Zbebkeh\hkhq_lZgby P\QDPHLVP\IDPLO\LVNLQGDPHGLFDOVFKRRODQXUVHDGRFWRUDORW RIZRUNWREHLQJRRGKHDOWK ,9GZibrbl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZglQRl_dklm $QQ LV D VWXGHQW RI WKH PHGLFDO VFKRRO +HU IDPLO\ LV QRW ODUJH +HU PRWKHULVDGRFWRU+HUIDWKHULVDZRUNHU+HLVDWDOOVWURQJPDQ+HKDVD ORWRIZRUN+HUJUDQGPRWKHULV6KHLVLQJRRGKHDOWK A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm KXPDQ>µKMXP~Q@Zq_eh\_q_ kdbc ERG\>¶VuGL@Ql_eh KHDG>KHG@i]heh\Z KDLU>K0~@i\hehku IDFH>IHLV@iebph FKHHN>W LN@is_dZ H\H>DL@i]eZa HDU>L~@imoh KHDOWK\>¶KHOL@Za^hjh\uc WRRWK>WX@ S/WHHWK>WL@ iam[ PRXWK>PDX@Qjhl KDQG>KÙQG@idbklv jmdb OHJ>OHJ@igh]Z IRRW>IXW@ S/IHHW>ILW@ iklmigy QRVH>QRX]@Qghk DUP>DP@ijmdZ VWURQJ>VWUuD@Zkbevgucdj_idbc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jZ\gb FZeahehlgbd^Z^hjh] MIJ:@G?GBY ,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDWFRORXULV\RXUKDLU"V\RXUKDLUORQJRUVKRUW",V\RXUIDFH URXQG"$UH\RXUFKHHNVURV\":KDWFRORXUDUH\RXUH\HV"$UH\RXU WHHWKKHDOWK\" ,,KdZ`bl_<RXDUHULJKW ©<uijZ\uª _kebkh]eZkgubeb <RXDUHZURQJ ©<ug_ijZ\uª _kebg_kh]eZkgu H[jZa_p$QQ VKDLULVORQJ²<RXDUHULJKWKHUKDLULVORQJ ²<RXDUHZURQJKHUKDLULVVKRUW $QQ V H\HV DUH EURZQ +HU FKHHNV DUH QRW URV\ 3HWH V KDLU LV EORQGH3HWHKDVVWURQJOHJV ,,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhkuij_ih^Z\Zl_ey kfjbkgZk :KDWGR\RXVHHLQWKHSLFWXUHVLQWKHVWURZ" LQWKHQGUGDQGWK URZV" ,9I_j_\_^bl_rmldm 2QHGD\DPRWKHUJDYHKHUVRQDQHZELF\FOH >EDLVLNL@ ²\_ehkbi_^ 7KHER\WRRNWKHELF\FOHDULGZHQWLQWRWKH\DUG +LVPRWKHUZHQWLQWRWKH\DUGWRRDQGORRNHGDWKHUVRQZLWKDVPLOH2QKLV ILUVWURXQG ihke_i_j\h]hdjm]Z KHFULHG/RRN0DQRKDQGV2QKLV VHFRQG URXQG KH FULHG /RRN 0D QR IHHW 2Q KLV WKLUG URXQG KH FULHG /RRN0DQRWHHWK 9 Ijh\_^_f b]jm MqZsb_ky QR hq_j_^b hibku\Zxl \g_r ghklv h^gh]h ba ijbkmlkl\mxsbo Z \h^ysbc ^he`_g hl]Z ^Zlvdh]hhgbaZ^mfZeb\_]hhlkmlkl\b_ A:GYLB?A <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm UXOH>UXO@iijZ\beh DLU>0~@Q\ha^moY WR ijh\_ljb\Zlv WRZDVK>Zu@Ymfu\Zlvky ZDLVW>ZHLVW@iwîhyk VKRZHU> DX~@i^mr WRKXUU\>KUL@Ylhjhiblvky PHDO>PLO@i_^Z ]_VW>UHVW@Qhlûo WRHDW>LW@Y_klv WRULVH>UDL]@Yih^gbfZlvky HDUO\>µ~OL@DGYjZgh 58/(62)*22'+($/7+ :KHQ\RXJHWXSDLUWKHURRP 'RPRUQLQJH[HUFLVHVHYHU\GD\ :DVKWRWKHZDLVWRUWDNHDVKRZHU 'RQ¶WKXUU\ZKHQ\RXKDYH\RXUPHDO" :RUNDQGKDYHDUHVW (DWLQWLPH *RWREHGLQWLPHDQGULVHHDUO\ 3URYHUE (DUO\ WR EHG HDUO\ WR ULVH PDNHV D PDQ KHDOWK\ ZHDOWK\DQGZLVH MIJ:@G?GB? GZc^bl_\l_dkl_5XOHVRI*RRG+HDOWKke_^mxsb_keh\h khq_lZgby dj_idh_ a^hjh\v_ ijh\_ljb\Zlv dhfgZlm ^_eZlv mlj_ggxx aZjy^ dm mfu\Zlvky ^h ihykZ ijbgbfZlv ^mr \h\j_fy ijbgbfZlv ibsm hlûoZlveh`blvkykiZlv /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ,ZLOOQRWZDVKP\IDFHVDLGOLWWOH$QQ2K\RXDUHDEDGJLUOVDLGWKH JUDQGPRWKHU :KHQ , ZDV D OLWWOH JLUO , DOZD\V ZDVKHG P\ IDFH <HV VDLG$QQDQGORRNDWLWQRZ 3URYHUE7ZRKHDGVDUHEHWWHUWKDQRQH <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm QHDUVLJKWHG>µQL~·VDLWWLG@Z[ebahjmdbc IDUPHG>µIDVDLWLG@Z^Zevghahjdbc WRQHHG>QLG@Ygm`^Zlvky JODVVHV>µJODVL]@Qhqdb WRWDNHFDUH>N0~@ RI [_j_qvaZ[h lblvky OLJKW>ODLW@Qk\_l WRUXE>UE@Yl_j_lv H\HEDOO>µDLEuO@Q]eZagh_y[ehdh GHOLFDWH>µGHOLNLW@Zojmidbc WREHWLUHG>µWDL~G@[ulvmklZeuf KDUPIXO>KDPIXO@Z\j_^guc WRH[DPLQH>LJ¶]ÙPLQ@Yijh\_jylv WRWUHDW>WULW@Ye_qblv GLVHDVH>GL¶]L]@QaZ[he_\Zgb_ RFXOLVW>µuNMXOLVW@Q]eZaghc\jZq (<(6 +HLVIDUVLJKWHG 6KHLVQHDUVLJKWHG 7KH\QHHGSURSHUNLQGRIJODVVHV²Bfgm`guijZ\bevgu_hqdb 7DNHFDUHRI\RXUH\HV *LYHWKHH\HVPXFKOLJKWDWKRPHDWVFKRRODWWKHRIILFH 'RQRWUXERUSUHVVWKHH\HEDOOV7KH\DUHYHU\GHOLFDWH &ORVH\RXUH\HVIRUDIHZPLQXWHVLI\RXUH\HVDUHWLUHG,WJLYHVUHVW WRWKHH\HV 5HPHPEHUWKDWVPRNHLVKDUPIXOWRWKHH\HV ([DPLQH\RXUH\HVHYHU\\HDU$GRFWRUZKRIUHDWVWKHH\HGLVHDVHV LVFDOOHGDQRFXOLVW 3URYHUE%HDXW\OLHVLQORYHU VH\HV KjZ\gb+HQRohjhrmfbeZih fbemohjhr MIJ:@G?GBY KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb ;_j_]bl_]eZaZG_ljbl_]eZaZ>uf\j_^_gêy]eZaIjh\_jycl_]eZaZ dZ`ûc]h^ ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDWFRORXUDUH\RXUH\HV" EOXHEURZQJUH\ +RZPXVW\RXWDNH FDUHRI\RXUH\HV"+RZFDQ\RXJLYHUHVWWRWKHH\HV"'R\RXZHDU JODVVHV" ,,,I_j_\_^bl_rmldm 7ZR(QJOLVKPHQZHUHWDONLQJDERXW\RXQJSHRSOHLQRXUGD\V2QHRI WKHP VDLG <RXQJ SHRSOH QRZ DUH VR GLIIHUHQW IURP ZKDW ZH ZHUH WKLUW\ \HDUV DJR /RRN DW WKDW \RXQJ SHUVRQ ZLWK VKRUW KDLU VPRNLQJ D FLJDUHWWH DQGZHDULQJMHDQV:KDWLVLW±DER\RUDJLUO" ,W¶VDJLUOVDLGDPLGGOHDJHGSHUVRQVLWWLQJQHDUWKHPRQDEHQFK 7PVRUU\VLUVDLGWKHILUVW(QJOLVKPDQ$UH\RXKHUIDWKHU" ,¶PQRWZDVWKHDQVZHU, PKHUPRWKHU A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRNHHS>NLS@Ykh^_j`Zlv JXP>JP@Q^_kgZ FRQGLWLRQ>N~Q¶GL ~Q@Qkhklhygb_ EUXVK>EU @Qs_ldZY WR qbklblv ULQVH>ULQV@QihehkdZgb_Y WR ih ehkdZlv PHDO>PLO@Q_^Z WRXVH>MX]@Ymihlj_[eylv IRRG>IXG@QibsZ WRFKHZ>W X@Y`_\Zlv WRFUDFN>NUÙN@Ydhehlv QXW>QW@QRSH[ VXJDU>µ XJ~@QkZoZj GHQWLVW> GHQWLVW@Qam[ghc\jZq WZLFH>WZDLV@DGY^\Z`û 0287+ <RXPXVWNHHSWKHPRXWKJXPVDQGWHHWKLQKHDOWK\FRQGLWLRQ%UXVK \RXUJXPVDQGWHHWKDQG ULQVH\RXUPRXWKLQWKHPRUQLQJDQGDIWHUHYHU\ PHDO'RQ WXVHPHWDOWKLQJVWRFOHDQ\RXUWHHWKDIWHUPHDOV([DPLQH\RXU WHHWKUHJXODUO\WZLFHD\HDU8VHIRRGZKLFK\RXPXVWFKHZ ,I\RXZDQWWRKDYHVWURQJDQGKHDOWK\WHHWK %UXVK\RXUWHHWKHYHU\GD\ 5LQVH\RXUPRXWKDIWHUPHDO 1HYHUFUDFNQXWVZLWKWHHWK 'RQRWHDWPXFKVXJDU 6HHWKHGHQWLVWWZLFHD\HDU ³OVKRZHGKLPDTXLFNZD\WRFOHDQKLVWHHWK±WRELWHDSLHFHRIVRDS 3URYHUE.HHS\RXUPRXWKVKXWDQG\RXUHDUVRSHQ A:IHFGBL?BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB LQ5XVVLDQjZa\]h^^\ZjZaZ\^_gv LQ(QJOLVKRQFHD\HDUWZLFHDGD\ MIJ:@G?GBY ,GZc^bl_bgl_jgZpbhgZevgu_keh\Z\l_dkl_ ,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb \a^hjh\hfkhklhygbb^\Z`û\]hîhke__ûqbklblvam [ug_mihlj_[eycl_ihehkdZlvjhl ,,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku +DYH\RXKHDOWK\WHHWK":KHQGR\RXEUXVK\RXUWHHWK" +RZRIWHQGR\RXVHHWKHGHQWLVW"$UH\RXDIUDLGRIJRLQJWRWKH GHQWLVW" ,9<uibrbl_bal_dklZ\k_qlhdZkZ_lkymoh^ZaZam[Zfb 9 Ijhqlbl_ hl\_lu fZevqbdZ b aZdhgqbl_ \hijhku am[gh]h \jZqZ ' H Q W L V W 'R\RX" <hm1R,GRQ W,GRQ WULQVHP\PRXWKDIWHUHDFKPHDO '+RZRIWHQGR\RX" %,H[DPLQHP\WHHWKRQFHD\HDU '$UH\RX" %<HV,DP,DPYHU\PXFKDIUDLGRIJRLQJWRWKHGHQWLVW ''R\RX" %<HV,GR,FUDFNQXWVZLWKP\WHHWK %HOLHYHOWRU1hW $:RPDQZLWK7ZR7RQJXHV 2IFRXUVHWKHUHQHYHUOLYHGDPRUHXQKDSS\\RXQJZRPDQWKDQ WKLV ZRPDQ RI )UDQNIXUW *HUPDQ\ 6KH KDG WZR WRQJXHV EXW FRXOG QRWVSHDNDZRUG /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ' R F W R U 6KRZPH\RXUWRQJXHOLWWOH$QQ $ Q Q 1R , VKDQ W 0\ PRWKHU DOZD\V SXQLVKHV gZdZau\Z_l PH ZKHQ,VKRZP\WRQJXHWRP\VLVWHUDWKRPH Hl]Z^Zcl_j_[mk % H D U 2K'RFWRUP\WHHWKP\WHHWK,DPLOO+HOSPH'RFWRU ' R F W R U ,¶OOKHOS\RXEXW\RXPXVWQRWHDWPXFK Hl\_lKRQH\ I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl +$1'6 +XPDQKDQGVFDQGRGLIIHUHQWZRUN 7KHUHDUHVRPHUXOHVIRU\RXUKDQGV :DVK\RXUKDQGVEHIRUHPHDOV :DVK\RXUKDQGVDIWHUWKHXVHRIWKHWRLOHW 6RDS\RXUKDQGVZHOO :KHQ\RXULQVH\RXUKDQGVZLWKUXQQLQJZDWHUFRXQWWR .HHSWKHQDLOVVKRUW 'RQ WELWH\RXUQDLOV ,GLIIHUHQW> GLIU~QW@ZjZaebqguc WRLOHW>µWuLOLW@QlmZe_l VRDS>VRXS@QfuehY WR gZfueb\Zlv UXQQLQJZDWHUa^kljmy\hû FRXQW>NDXQW@Qkq_lY WR kqblZlv QDLO>QHLO@Qgh]hlv ELWH>EDLW@QmdmkY WR dmkZlv 3URYHUE7RZRUNZLWKWKHOHIWKDQG KjZ\gbJZ[hlZlvkimklyjmdZ \Z MIJ:@G?GBY <klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dªkeh\ZKDQGbebDUPZaZl_f hibrbl_jbkmgdbihevamykv^Zggufbij_êh`_gbyfb 7KLV LV D QXUVH ZLWK D 5DLVH \RXU ZKHQ \RX ZDQW WR WKHUPRPHWHULQKHU VSHDNDWWKHOHVVRQ $QXUVHLVKROGLQJD :KHQ \RX PHHW \RXU IULHQG \RX EDE\LQKHU VKDNH ,, Ihkfhljbl_ gZ jbkmghd b gZah\bl_ r_klv qZkl_c l_eZ gZa\Zgb_dZ`^h]hij_^f_lZihijhbaghr_gbxkh\iZ^Z_lkgZ a\ZgbyfbjZaebqguoqZkl_cl_eZ H l \ _ l FKHVW KDQGVHOERZ /ERZ QDLOVKDLU KDUH H\H EDOO ,EDOO /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 0 R W K H U 1HOO\GLG\RXZDVK\RXUKDQGVEHIRUHGLQQHU" 1H\<HV0XPP\\RXFDQVHHLWLI\RXORRNDWWKHWRZHO ihehl_gp_ ,GRQ¶WXQGHUVWDQGZK\,PXVWZDVKP\KDQGVEHIRUHVFKRRO :K\QRW" ,QHYHUSXWWKHPXSLQFODVV <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm KDELW>µKÙELWOQijb\uqdZ GDLO\>µGHLOL@Z_`_^g_\guc WRFRYHU>µNY~@YaZdju\Zlv WRFRXJK>NuI@YdZreylv WRVQHH]H>VQL]@YqboZlv QHDWO\> QLWOL@DGYhijylghZddmjZlgh WRKDQJXS>KÙ¾J@Y\_rZlv *22'+$%,76 <RX PXVW KDYH WKH KDELW WR EUXVK\RXUWHHWK <RX PXVW KDYH WKH KDELW WR WDNHDGDLO\EDWK &RYHU\RXUQRVHDQGPRXWK <RX PXVW KDYH WKH KDELW WR GR ZKHQ\RXFRXJKDQGVQHH]HG PRUQLQJH[HUFLVHV <RXPXVWKDYHWKHKDELWWR GUHVVQHDWO\ <RXPXVWKDYHWKHKDELWWR KDQJXS\RXUFORWKHV /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7KHQXUVHEDWKHGWKHWZLQV/DWHUVKHKHDUGWKHWZLQVODXJKLQJLQEHG 6KHVDLG³:KDWDUH\RXFKLOGUHQODXJKLQJDW"³ ³2KQRWKLQJ´VDLG(GQD³2QO\\RXKDYHEDWKHG(GLWKWZLFHDQGGLGQ W EDWKHPHDWDOO´ A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm DVDVlZddZd DQ\ERG\>µHQLEuGL@SURQaêx[hc ZLWKRXW>ZL¶èDXW@SUHS[_a GU\>GUDL@Zkmohc WRSURWHFW>SUu·WHNW@YwZsbsZlvij_^hojZgylv ZHDWKHU>µZHè~@ih]h^Z +$,5 +HUHDUHVRPHUXOHVIRU\RXUKDLU .HHS\RXUEUXVKFOHDQDQGGRQ WJLYHLWWRDQ\ERG\ ,I\RXKDYHGU\KDLUSURWHFWLWIURPWKHVXQ 'RQ¶WZDVK\RXUKDLUDVRIWHQDV\RXUIDFH 'RQ¶WJRRXWZLWKRXWDKDWLQFROGZHDWKHU %HOLHYH,WhU1hW D GDUNKDLUHG SHUVRQ KDV RQ KLV KHDG DERXW KDLUV D EORQG ± DERXWKDLUVDQGDUHGKHDGHGSHUVRQRQO\DERXW /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7 H D F K H U 1LFNZK\GLGQ W\RXFRPE ijbq_kZe \RXUKDLU DWKRPH" 1LkN1RFRPE jZkq_kdZ PLVV 7 H D F K H U &RXOGQ W\RXWDNH\RXUIDWKHU VFRPE" 1LkN1RKDLUPLVV MIJ:@G?GB? Hibrbl_ jbkmgdb gZ k bkihevamy ba\_klgu_ \Zf keh\Z b keh\hkhq_lZgby A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm KHDUW>KDW@Qk_j^p_ EORRG>EOG@Qdjh\v ZRQGHUIXO >µZQG~IXO@ Z m^b\bl_ev guc GXULQJ>µGMX~UL¾@SUHS\l_q_gb_ WRVWUHQJWKHQ>µVWUH¾~Q@Ymdj_ieylv GLVHDVH>GL¶]L]@[he_agv UHJXODU>µUHTMXO~@ZijZ\bevguc UHJLPHQ> UH!LPHQ@Qj_`bf WRWDNHVPE VSXOVHsmiZlv WRIHHOVPE VSXOVHimevk ` LQVXFKDZD\lZdbfh[jZahf EHDW>ELW@Qm^Zj YHLQ>YHLQ@Q\_gZ FDSLOODU\>N~·SLO~UL@QdZibeeyj DUWHU\>µ.W~UL@QZjl_jby WRFDUU\>NÙUL@Yg_klb FHOO>VHO@Qde_ldZ EORRGSUHVVXUH>µEOGSUH ~@Q %3 Zjl_jbZevgh_^Z\e_gb_ EORRGWHVWZgZebadjh\b FDUGLRJUDPRIRQH VKHDUWdZj^bh ]jZff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k_euc WRGRJRRGaîjbghkblvihevam OLNHaîh^h[gh PHGLFLQH>µPHGVLQ@Qe_dZjkl\h MIJ:@G?GBY ,GZc^bl_wlbkeh\hkhq_lZgby\l_dkl_ mdj_iblv k_j^p_ aZsblblv k_j^p_ wlh e_]dh b ihe_agh smiZlv imevklZdbfh[jZahfdhgljhebjh\ZlvjZ[hlmk_j^pZm^Zjh\\fb gmlm imevk [m^_l mqZs_gguf imevk [m^_l ghjfZevguf baf_jblv ^Z\e_gb_ijhkemrZlvk_j^p_k^_eZlvZgZebadjh\b ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku +RZkZQ\RXVWUHQJWKHQ\RXUKHDUW"&DQ\RXWDNHDQ\ERG\ VSXOVH" :KDWGR\RXOHDUQZKHQ\RXWDNHWKHSXOVH"+RZPDQ\EHDWVLVWKH SXOVHRIDKHDOWK\SHUVRQ":KHQGRHVWKHKHDUWZRUNIDVWHU":KHUHGR DUWHULHVFDUU\EORRG":KHUHGRYHLQVFDUU\EORRG" ,,,GZibrbl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZglihke_^mxs_fml_dklm $UWHULHV FDUU\ EORRG IURP WKH KHDUW 9HLQV FDUU\ EORRG WR WKH KHDUW %ORRGKDVRQO\UHGDQGZKLWHEORRGFHOOV7RGD\GRFWRUVFDQQRWWDNHEORRG SUHVVXUHDQGEORRGWHVWV 'RFWRUVFDQWDNHDFDUGLRJUDPRIDSDWLHQW VKHDUW %HOLHYH,WRU1RW 'LIIHUHQW+HDUWV 7KHOLRQ e_\ KDVWKHVPDOOHVWKHDUWRIDOOZLOGDQLPDOV ^bdbo`b\hl guo .LQJ3KLOLSWKH6HFRQGRI6SDLQ NbebiidhjhevBkiZgbb ZDVD FRZDUG ljmk EXWKHKDGWKHODUJHVWKHDUWRIDQ\NQRZQ ba\_klguc PDQ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7 H D F K H U -LPP\ZK\GRQ W\RXZDVK\RXUIDFH",FDQVHHZKDW\RXKDG IRUEUHDNIDVWWKLVPRUQLQJ / L W W O H E R \ :KDWZDVLW" 7 H D F K H U (JJV / L W W O H E R \ :URQJ g_ijZ\bevgh WKDWZDV\HVWHUGD\ -LPDQGKLVPRWKHUZHUHZDLWLQJIRU-LP VPXVLFWHDFKHU 0 R W K H U 'LG\RXZDVK\RXUKDQGV" -LP<HV 0 R W K H U $QG\RXUIDFH" - L P <HV0RWKHU 0 R W K H U $QGGLG\RXZDVKEHKLQG\RXUHDUV" -LP2QKHUVLGH,GLG0RWKHU 1LkN0XPP\\HVWHUGD\3HWHFDPHWRVFKRROZLWKGLUW\ ]jyagufb KDQGVDQGGLUW\IDFH+LVHDUVZHUHGLUW\WRR 0 R W K H U 'LG\RXWHOOKLPDERXWLW" 1LkN2KQR,ZDQWHGWREHSROLWH [ulv\_èb\uf A:GYLB? 6.(/(721 Bkihevamy ^Zggu_ keh\Z gZah\bl_ dhklb kd_e_lZ b kjZ\ gbl_Zg]ebckdh_gZa\Zgb_keZlbgkdbf SDULHWDO>S~ UDLLWL@Zl_f_gghc IURQWDO>µIUQWO@Zeh[guc WHPSRUDO>µWHPS~U~O@Z\bkhqgucRFFLSL WDO>uN¶VLSLWO@ZaZluehqguc VNXOO>VNO@Qq_j_i FHUYLFDO>µV~YLN~O@Zr_cguc YHUWHEUD>µY~WLEU~@Qiha\hghd YHUWHEUDH>µY~WLEUL@iha\hgdb FODYLFOH>µNOÙYLNO@QdexqbpZ VFDSXOD> VNÙSMXO~@QehiZldZ ULE>ULE@Qj_[jh WKRUD[>µuUÙNV@Q]jm^gZyde_ldZ GRUVDO> GuV~O@Zkibgghc VSLQH>VSDLQ@Qiha\hghqgucklhe[ OXPEDU>µOPE~@Zihykgbqguc SHOYLV>µSHOYLV@QlZa VDFUXP>µVHLNU~P@Qdj_kl_p FRFF\[>µNuNVLNVOQdhiqbd KXPHUXV>µKMXP~U~V@Qie_q_\Zydhklv XOQD>µOQ~@Qehdl_\Zydhklv UDGLXV> UHLGL~V@Qemq_\Zydhklv SKDODQJHV>I¶ÙOÙQ!L]@QnZeZg]b IHPXU>µILP~@Q[_^jh ILEXOD>µILEMXO~@QfZeZy[_jph\Zydhklv WLELD> WLEL~@Q[hevrZy[_jph\Zydhklv MIJ:@G?GBY ,Ijhqlbl_gZa\Zgbydhkl_cihZg]ebckdb ,, GZc^bl_bgZibrbl_ihZg]ebckdbbiheZlbgkdbgZa\Zgby dhkl_cZ ]heh\u[ lmeh\bsZ\ lZaZ] \_jog_cdhg_qgh klb^ gb`g_cdhg_qghklb DHGLJHEVGU?MIJ:@G?GBY ,=ey^ygZjbkmghdgZah\bl_qZklbl_eZq_eh \_dZ < kemqZ_ hrb[db ^jm]hc mqZsbcky ^he `_g\Zk[ukljhihijZ\blv $7KLVLVDIRRW mdZau\ZygZdbklvjmdb <1R\RXDUHZURQJ7KLVLVDKDQG ,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb >Zcl_\ZrmjmdmyohqmihsmiZlv\Zrimevk >Zcl_\Zrmjmdmyohqmbaf_jblv^Z\e_gb_M\Zk ^Z\e_gb_ ghjfZevgh_ Hldjhcl_ jhl b ihdZ`bl_ yaud<ua^hjh\uHldjhcl_jhlbihdZ`bl_am [u <u ^he`gu aZ[hlblvky h \Zrbo am[Zo <u ^he`guijh\_jylv]eZaZdZ`ûc]h^ ,OO GZah\bl_ b ihdZ`bl_ gZ dZjlbg d_dhklbZ ]heh\u[ lmeh\bsZ \ lZaZ ] \_jog_c dhg_qghklb ^ gb`g_cdhg_qghklb ,9<ijZ\hcdhehgd_gZc^bl_i_j_ \h^dZ`^h]hZg]ebckdh]hkeh\Z JZ[hlm\uihegycl_gZ i_jnhdZjl_ KDQG H\H OHJ ERG\ DUP EUXVK WRSWK KHDG BBBBBBB ,iZe_p ,,]heh\Z ,,,jmdZ ,9am[u 9kh^_j`Zlv 9,]eZa 9,,gh]Z 9,,,dbklvjmdb KF©F_lh^bq_kdb_mdZaZgbyªK WRH[DPLQH IHHW FQHHN WRNHHS ,;klhiZ ;klhiu ;,hkfZljb\Zlv ;,,l_eh ;,,,s_dZ ;,9am[ ;9qbklblv ;9,keurZlv ;9,,ihehkdZlv 9DZdb_keh\Z\ufh`_l_\u^_eblv\wlhcp_ihqd_[md\"Ih ke_^gyy [md\Z dZ`^h]h keh\Z y\ey_lky i_j\hc [md\hc ke_ ^mxs_]h H\HDULJKWRHVNLQDLOHJXPRXWKDQG 9,AZdhgqbl_klbohl\hj_gb_ihôh^ys_cihkfukemjbnfhc (DUVIRUKHDULQJ 7HHWKIRUELWLQJ (\HVIRUVHHLQJ /HJVIRUZDONLQJ 7RQJXHVIRUWHVWLQJDQGIRU 9,,I_j_\_^bl_rmldm :KDW VWKHPDWWHU"$UH\RXEOLQG" 6SHDNORXGHU, PGHDI J:A>?E,, *(1(5$/0(',&$/7(50,12/2*< A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm GLHW> GDL~W@Q^b_lZ GLVHDVH>GL¶]L]OQ[he_agv FDUHIXO>µN0~IXO@Z\gbfZl_evgucaZ [hleb\uc SK\VLFDO>µIL]LN~O@Znbabq_kdbc QHHG>QLG@Qgm`^ZY WR gm`^Zlvky PHQWDO>µPHQWO@Zmfkl\_gguc LPSRUWDQW>LP SuW~QW@Z\Z`guc WRFRQVLVW RI >N~Q VLVW@Ykhklhylv ba SURWHLQ> SURXWLQ@Q[_ehd FDUERK\GUDWH> N.ERX¶KDLGUHLW@Q m]e_jh^ IDW>IÙW@Q`bjZ`bjguc PLQHUDOV>µPLQ~U~O]@a^fbg_jZev gu_kheb ILVK>IL @Qju[Z PHDW>PLW@Qfykh NLGQH\>µNLGQL@QihqdZ FKHHVH>µW L]@Qkuj EXWWHU> EW~@QfZkeh PL[HG>PLNVW@Zkf_rZgguc IUXLW>IUXWOQnjmdlieh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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb khojZgblv a^hjh\v_ nbabq_kdZy mfkl\_ggZy jZ[hlZ gm`^Zlvky \ [hevrhf dhebq_kl\_ ibsb \Z`gh agZlv khklhbl ba [_edh\ b m]e_\h ^h\ ,, GZqgbl_ ij_êh`_gby k WKHUH LV OLWWOH fZeh ² êy ij_^f_lh\ dhlhju_g_evaykhkqblZlvbeb WKHUHDUHIHZ fZeh ±êyij_^f_ lh\dhlhju_fh`ghkhkqblZlv VXJDULQP\WHDEUHDGRQWKHWDEOHPHDWLQKLVVRXS VRXSLQWKHSDQVDOWLQWKHVRXSDSSOHVRQWKHSODWHFKHHVHRQ KLVEUHDGILVKRQWKHSODWHPLONLQKHUFRIIHH ,,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW PXVW D SHUVRQ GR LI KH ZDQWV WR EH LQ JRRG KHDOWK" :KR QHHGV PRUH IRRG SHRSOH RI SK\VLFDO ZRUN RU SHRSOH RI PHQWDO ZRUN" :KDWPXVWDGLHWRIDKHDOWK\SHUVRQFRQVLVWRI" ,9I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl7DEOH0DQQHUV 7DEOH0DQQHUV 6LWIDFLQJWKHWDEOHGRQ¶WVLWVLGHZD\V $IWHUVWLUULQJV\RXUWHDUHPRYHWKHVSRRQDQGSODFHLW RQWKHVDXFHU 'RQ WXVHDVSRRQLQVWHDGhIDIRUN 'RQ WSXW\RXUNQLIHLQ\RXUPRXWK 9HJHWDEOHVSRWDWRHVPDFDURQLDUHSODFHGRQ\RXUIRUN ZLWKWKHKHOSRI\RXUNQLIH 7U\WRPDNHOLWWOHQRLVHZKHQ\RXHDW 'RQ WWDONZLWK\RXUPRXWKIXOO )LUVWFKHZDQGWKHQ VZDOORZ 'RQ WSXW\RXUHOERZVRQWKHWDEOH ,IIRRGLVYHU\KRWTXLFNO\GULQNVRPHZDWHU 'RQ WIRUJHWWRVD\WKDQN\RXYHU\PXFK IDFLQJ>µIDLVL¾@aêbphfd VLGHZD\V> VDLGZHL]@DGY[hdhf WRVWLU>VW~@Yf_rZlv WRUHPRYH>UL¶PXYOYa^m[bjZlv WRSODFH>SOHLV@Yihf_rZlv VDXFHU>µVuV~@Q[ex^p_ LQVWHDGRI>LQ¶VWHG@SUHS\f_klh IRUN>IuN@Q\bedZ NQLIH>QDLI@Qgh` WRWU\>WUDL@YklZjZlvky QRLVH>QuL]@Qrmf IXOO>IXO@Ziheguc WRFKHZ>W X@Y`_\Zlv WRVZDOORZ>µVZuORX@Y]ehlZlv WRIRUJHW>Iu JHW@Y IRUJRWIRUJRWWHQ aZ[u\Zlv /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 2QHGD\ZKHQDPRWKHUDQGKHUOLWWOHVRQ7RUQZHUHHDWLQJWKHLUGLQQHUWKH PRWKHUVDLG7RUQZK\DUH\RXZLSLQJ\RXUPRXWKZLWKWKHEDFNRI\RXU KDQG" %HFDXVHWKHEDFNRIP\KDQGLVFOHDQHUWKDQWKHIURQWVDLGOLWWOH7RP $YLVLWRUDVNVDOLWWOHJLUO:KDWZLOO\RXGRP\GHDUZKHQ\RXDUHDV ELJDV\RXUPRWKHU".HHSDGLHWVD\VWKHFKLOG 0 R W K H U <RXXQGHUVWDQGPH-RKQ\RXPXVWQRWHDWDQ\ PRUHWRQLJKW,W¶VGDQJHURXVWRVOHHSRQDIXOOVWRPDFK - R K Q KHU\RXQJVRQ 1HYHUPLQGDERXWWKDW0RWKHUGHDU,FDQVOHHSRQ P\EDFN A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRSD\DWWHQWLRQWR>~·WHQ HQ@h[jZsZlv \gbfZgb_ WRSUHVFULEH>SULV NUDLE@Yijhibku\Zlv SDWLHQW>µSHL ~QOQiZpb_gl[hevghc WHPSHUDWXUH> WHPSULW ~@Ql_fi_jZlmjZ SRRU>SX~@Ziehohc[_^guc DSSHWLWH>µÙSLWDLW@QZii_lbl KLJK>KDL@Z\ukhdbc WREHFRPH>EL¶NP@YklZgh\blvky ZHDN>ZLN@ZkeZ[uc FDORULF>N~ OuULN@ZdZehjbcguc WRGRDORW^_eZlvfgh]h WRWUHDW>WULW@Qe_qblv 7+(',(7 FRQWLQXHG 0\PRWKHUWHOOVPHWKDWLQDKRVSLWDOWKH\ SD\VSHFLDO DWWHQWLRQ WRWKH GLHW,QDKRVSLWDOWKHGRFWRUXVXDOO\SUHVFULEHVWKHGLHWIRUHYHU\SDWLHQW $Q\SDWLHQWZLWKKLJK WHPSHUDWXUHKDVDYHU\SRRUDSSHWLWHDQGVRD QXUVHPXVWEHYHU\FDUHIXO ,I D SDWLHQW KDV KLJK WHPSHUDWXUH IRU D ORQJ WLPH KH EHFRPHV YHU\ ZHDNDQGLWLVYHU\LPSRUWDQWWRJLYHKLPKLJKFDORULFGLHW IRRG $FDUHIXOQXUVHGRHV DORWWRKHOSWKHSDWLHQWWREHFRPHKHDOWK\<RX FDQWUHDWPDQ\GLVHDVHVE\GLHW MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb \ukhdZy l_fi_jZlmjZ iehohc Zii_lbl h[jZlblv \gbfZgb_ \ l_q_ gb_ ^he]h]h \j_f_gb \ukhdhdZehjbcgZy ibsZ aZ[hlblvky hkeZ[_lv hq_gv\Z`ghe_qblv ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KR SUHVFULEHV D GLHW LQ D KRVSLWDO" :KDW DSSHWLWH KDV D SDWLHQW ZLWKKLJKWHPSHUDWXUH":KDWLVWKHGLHWRIDSDWLHQWZKRKDVKLJKW°RUD ORQJWLPH":KDWIRRGPXVWWKHQXUVHJLYHDSDWLHQWZLWKKLJKW°" ,,,I_j_\_^bl_^bZeh]gZZg]ebckdbcyaudbkihevamykeh\hkh q_lZgby ^Zggu_ gb`_ aZl_f ijhqlbl_ b jZau]jZcl_ ^bZeh]\ebpZo :Mfh_]hkugZ\ukhdZyl_fi_jZlmjZmg_]hiehohcZii_lbl <<u^he`gu[ulvhkh[_ggh\gbfZl_evguk_cqZk\hlghr_gbb_]h iblZgby :Hghq_gvkeZ[lZddZdmg_]h^he]h^_j`blkyl_fi_jZlmjZ <>Z\Zcl__fm\ukhdhdZehjbcgmxibsmKLJKWHPSHUDWXUHSRRUDSSH WLWHWRSD\VSHFLDODWWHQWLRQWREHFRPHZHDNKLJKFDORULFIRRG /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH <RXUKXVEDQGLVWRRIRQGRIVWURQJFRIIHHVDLGWKHGRFWRU\RXPXVW QRWOHWKLPKDYHLW+HJHWVWRRQHUYRXV g_j\gbqZ_l %XW'RFWRU\RX VKRXOGVHHKRZQHUYRXVKHLVZKHQ,JLYHKLPZHDNFRIIHH 7 H D F K H U 7RPP\QDPHILYHWKLQJVWKDWFRQWDLQPLON 7 R P P \ %XWWHUDQGFKHHVHLFHFUHDPDQGWZRFRZV LFHFUHDPfhjh`_gh_FRZ>NDX@dhjh\Z A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm RYHUGRVDJH>RXY~¶GRXVL!@ii_j_^habjh\ dZ KDUPIXO>µK.PIXO@Z\j_^guc GRVH>GRXV@Q^haZijb_f FROG>NRXOG@Qijhklm^Z IOX>IOX@Q]jbii UHVLVWDQFH>UL¶]LVW~QV@Qkhijh lb\ey_fhklv 9,7$0,16 9LWDPLQV SOD\ D YHU\ LPSRUWDQW UROH LQ KXPDQ KHDOWK 2YHUGRVDJH RI VRPHYLWDPLQVPD\EH KDUPIXOVRSHRSOHPXVWWDNHQRUPDO GRVHV RIYL WDPLQV :KHQWKHZLQWHUPRQWKVFRPH\RXUIRRGEHFRPHVSRRURIYLWDPLQV :LQWHULVWKHWLPHIRUYLUXV>YDL~UL~V@LQIHFWLRQVFROGVDQGIOXDQG\RXU UHVLVWDQFH LV HVSHFLDOO\ ORZ 7DNH YLWDPLQV $ ' K HYHU\ GD\ 7KH\ DUH RIWHQFDOOHGZLQWHUYLWDPLQV ,QWHUHVWLQJ)DFWV <RXZLOOILQG YLWDPLQ$ LQ FDUURWV ILVKRLO HJJV <RXPXVWWDNH YLWDPLQ$WRSURWHFWH\HVLJKWLQ FUHDVHUHVLVWDQFHWRLQIHFWLRQ YLWDPLQ$LVRIWHQFRPELQHGZLWK RWKHUYLWDPLQVHVSHVLDOO\YLWDPLQ' YLWDPLQ< LQ OLYHU HJJV \HDVW YLWDPLQ < WR VWUHQJWKHQ QHUYRXV V\VWHP&RRNLQJGHVWUR\VYLWDPLQ% 7DNHLWGDLO\ Ijh^he`_gb_ <RXZLOOILQG YLWDPLQK LQ FKHUU\RUDQJH OHPRQIUXLW DQGYHJHWDEOHV YLWDPLQ' LQ PLONHJJV ILVK\HDVW YLWDPLQ( LQ VR\D IUXLW <RXPXVWWDNH YLWDPLQ K WR LQFUHDVH UHVLVWDQFH WR LQIHFWLRQ ,W KHOSV WR UHFRYHU DIWHULOO QHVV7DNHLWGDLO\ YLWDPLQ'WRKHOSWKHERG\LQIRUPD WLRQRIERQHVDQGVWURQJWHHWK YLWDPLQ ( WR LPSURYH SRRU EORRG FLUFXODWLRQLQWUHDWPHQWRIWKURPERVLV YDULFRVHYHLQV WRSURWHFW>SU~µWHNW@YaZsbsZlv H\HVLJKW>µDLVDLW@Qaj_gb_ WRLQFUHDVH>LQ¶NULV@Yih\urZlv \HDVW>MLVW@Q^jh``b WRGHVWUR\>GLV WUuL@YjZajmrZlv WRUHFRYHU>UL¶NY~@Y\ua^hjZ\eb\Zlv LOOQHVV>µLOQLV@Q[he_agv ERQH>ERXQ@Qdhklv WRLPSURYH>LP¶SUXY@YmemqrZlv WUHDWPHQW>µWULWP~QW Qe_q_gb_ MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb khojZgblvaj_gb_mdj_iblvg_j\gmxkbkl_fmih\ukblvkhijhlb\ ey_fhklv bgn_dpbb ijbgbfZcl_ _`_^g_\gh memqrZlv iehoh_ djh\h h[jZs_gb_e_q_gb_\Zjbdhaguo\_g ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW GR ZH WDNH YLWDPLQ $ IRU" &DQ YLWDPLQ $ VWUHQJWKHQ WKH QHUYRXVV\VWHP"+RZRIWHQPXVWZHWDNHYLWDPLQ%":KDWGRHVYLWD PLQKJLYHWRKXPDQKHDOWK" A:GYLB? :$7(5 :DWHU LV YHU\ LPSRUWDQW WR DOO OLYLQJ WKLQJV ,Q WKH OLYLQJ ERG\ ZDWHU FDUULHVIRRGVWXIIVIURPRQHSDQRIWKHERG\WRDQRWKHU 0DQJHWVRQHKDOIRIKLVZDWHULQWKHIRRGKHHDWVHVSHFLDOO\LQIUXLWDQG YHJHWDEOHV 0RUHWKDQSHUFHQWRIWKHERG\LVFRPSRVHG RIZDWHU'DLO\ZHORVH VRPHZDWHU 7KH KXPDQ ERG\ JLYHV RII hl^Z\Zlv DERXW SLQWV RI ZDWHU HYHU\ WZHQW\IRXUKRXUVWKURXJKWKHOXQJVVZHDW JODQGVDQGNLGQH\V:HPXVW UHSODFH LW ,I SHU FHQW RI WKHERG\ZDWHULVORVWZLWKRXWUHSODFHPHQWV WKHUHZLOOEHVHULRXVVLJQVRILOOQHVV,IRIWKHERG\ZDWHULVORVWD SHUVRQPD\GLH 7KHPD[LPXPWLPHWKDWDSHUVRQFDQJRZLWKRXWZDWHULVDERXWGD\V OLYLQJ>µOLYL¾@Z`b\hc WRFDUU\>µNÙUL@Yi_j_ghkblv IRRGVWXII> IXGVWI@Yijh^mdluiblZ gby WRFRPSRVH>N~P¶SRX]@YkhklZ\eylv WRORVH>OX]@ ORVW >O2VW@Yl_jylv SLQW>SDLQW@QibglZ ijb[ebaebl jZ VZHDW>VZHW@Qihl JODQG>JOÙQG@Q`_e_aZ WRUHSODFH>UL SOHLV@YaZf_sZlv UHSODFHPHQWQaZf_s_gb_ VHULRXV>µVL~UL~V@Zk_jv_aguc VLJQ>VDLQ@QagZdijbagZd LOOQHVV>µLOQLV@Q[he_agv WRGLH>GDL@YmfbjZlv I_j_\_^bl_ke_^mxsb_l_dklu $\HDUROGZRPDQZKRZDVYHU\VWRXWGHFLGHGWREHFRPHWKLQQHU 6KHGLGQ WHDWEXWWHUDQGRWKHU IDWVDQGHYHQGLGQ WKDYHEUHDNIDVW,WZDV XQZLVH,WZRXOGEHEHWWHUIRUKHU WRJRRQDIUXLWGLHWIRUWKUHHGD\V WR RPLW FDUERK\GUDWH DQG IDW DW RQH PHDO DQG UHGXFH FDUERK\GUDWH DQGIDWLQDOOPHDOV VWRXW>µVWDXW@Ziheguc WKLQ>LQ@Zom^hsZ\uclhgdbc RWKHU>µè~@Z^jm]hc XQZLVH>µQ¶ZDL]@Zg_[eZ]hjZamfguc LWZRXOGEHEHWWHU[ueh[uemqr_ WRRPLW>R X ¶PLW@Ya^g_mihlj_[ eylv WRUHGXFH>UL¶GMXV@Ymf_gvrZlv $\HDUROGJLUOZKRZDVWRRWKLQZDVDGYLVHGWRWDNHH[WUDFDUER K\GUDWHEHWZHHQPHDOV)RRGVZKLFKZLOOEHJRRGIRUKHUDUHDFXSRIF D FDR>N~N.RX@PDGHZLWKDOOPLONH[WUDFUHDP UDZWRPDWRHVHWF JLUOZDVDGYLVHG^_\hqd_ih kh\_lh\Zeb H[WUD >HNVWU~@ Z ^h[Z\hqguc DGY ^h [Z\hqgh FUHDP>NULP@Qkeb\dbdj_f UDZ>]u@Zkujhc WRPDWR>Wu·P.WRX@Qihfb^hj $ \RXQJ PDQ ZKR JRW WLUHG TXLFNO\ DQG ZDV RIWHQ VKRUW RI EUHDWKH DVNHGIRUPHGLFDODGYLFH +HZDVWROGWRHDWIRRGULFKLQLURQDQGOLYHU WZLFH D ZHHN &XFXPEHUV PLON UDGLVKHV DSSOHV DQG OHPRQV DUH ULFK LQ LURQ WRJHWWLUHG> WDL~G@YmklZ\Zlv WREHVKRUWRIEUHDWK>EUH@kljZ^Zlv hûrdhc DGYLFH>~G YDLV@Qkh\_l KHZDVWROG_fmkdZaZeb_fm\_e_eb ULFK>ULW @Z[h]Zluc LURQ>µDL~Q@Q`_e_ah FXFXPEHU>µNMXN~PE~@Qh]mj_p UDGLVK>µUÙHGL @Qj_^bk MIJ:@G?GBY ,AZihegbl_lZ[ebpm : < K ' ? Ijh^mdlukh^_j`Zsb_ \blZfbgu Bo^_ckl\by ,,Ba^Zgguokeh\gZibrbl_ij_êh`_gbyZaZl_fijhbag_kbl_dZ` ^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhfg_]ey^y\l_ljZ^v SUHVFULEHGWKHKRVSLWDOWKHGRFWRULQWKHSDWLHQWDGLHWVSHFLDO SRRUDSDWLHQWKLJKKDVWHPSHUDWXUHZLWKYHU\DSSHWLWH KXPDQYLWDPLQVKHDOWKLPSRUWDQWSOD\DQSDUWLQ IRRGSUHVHQWDUHNLQGVYLWDPLQVLQDOORI ,,,I_j_\_^bl_PHdFl $ER\FRPHVXSWRDQXUVHLQWKHKRVSLWDODQGVD\V0\PRWKHULVRQH RIWKHSDWLHQWVRI\RXUKRVSLWDODQGWKHGRFWRUWHOOVPHWKDWVKHPXVWKDYHD KLJKFDORULFGLHWEXW,GRQ WNQRZZKDWLWLV:LOO\RXKHOSPH"7KHQXUVH WHOOVKLPWREX\EXWWHUPLONFKHHVHDQGIUXLW WRFRPHXS>NP@Yihôh^blvWREX\>EDL@YihdmiZlv ,9Hl]Z^Zcl_j_[mk Hl\_l7ZRKHDGVDUHEHWWHUWKDQRQH A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ILUVWDLG>HLG@i_j\Zyihfhsv WRVDYH>VHLY@YkiZkZlv LQMXUHG>µLQ!~G@ZihkljZ^Z\rbc PHWKRG>µPH~G@Qf_lh^ DFFLGHQW>µÙNVLG~QW@Qg_kqZklguc kemqZc FDOP>N.P@Zkihdhcguc WRDFW>ÙNW@Y^_ckl\h\ZlvQihklmihd WRPHDQ>PLQ@Y PHDQW >PHQW@agZ qblvih^jZamf_\ZlvW SDQLF>µSÙQLN@QiZgbdZ VRXO>VRXO@Q^mrZ ),567$,' (YHU\ERG\ PXVW NQRZ KRZ WR JLYH WKH ILUVW DLG 7KH ILUVW DLG VDYHV PDQ\OLYHV7KHILUVWDLGLVWKHKHOSZKLFK\RXJLYHWRDQ LQMXUHG SHUVRQ <RXPXVWNQRZGLIIHUHQWPHWKRGVRIKHOSLQJLQDFFLGHQWV:KHQ\RXJLYH WKHILUVWDLG\RXPXVWEHFDOPDQGDFWZLWKRXWSDQLF 5(0(0%(5626PHDQV6DYH2XU6RXO MIJ:@G?GBY , KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm i_j\Zy ihfhsv hdZaZlv i_j\mx ihfhsv kiZkZlv `bagv [ulv kih dhcguf ^_ckl\h\Zlv kihdhcgh [_a iZgbdb ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhkudjbkmgdm bkihevamyij_û^msbcl_dkl :KRPGR\RXVHHLQWKHSLFWXUH" :KDWLVWKHPDWWHUZLWKWKHSDWLHQW" +RZPXVWDSHUVRQDFWZKHQKHJLYHV WKHILUVWDLG":KDWGRHV626PHDQ" EUXLVH>EUX]@Qmrb[kbgyd WRIDOO>Iu@Y IHOOIDOOHQ >IHO IuOQ@Y hiZ^Zlv EUXLVHGSODFH>EUX]G@Qmrb[e_ggh_ f_klh WRORRN>OXN@Y\u]ey^_lvkfhlj_lv VZROOHQ >µVZRXO~Q@ SDUW ,, hl WR VZHOO himorbc VFUDWFK>VNUÙW @QpZjZibgZ LRGLQH> DL~GLQ@Qch^ WRKXUW>K~W@Yijbqbgblv[hev FORWK>NOu@QldZgv WRZHW>ZHWtYfhqblv WRUHOLHYH>UL¶OLY@Yh[e_]qblv SDLQ>SHLQ@Q[hev WRFRQVXOW>NuQ¶VOW@Ykh\_lh\Zlvky %58,6( :KHQ \RX IDOO RQ \RXU NQHH \RX JHW D EUXLVH RQ LW 7KH EUXLVHG SODFH ORRNVUHGDQGVZROOHQDWILUVW,IWKHUHLVDVFUDWFKRQ\RXUNQHHSXWLRGLQH RQLW ,I\RXUNQHHKXUWV \RXYHU\PXFKWDNHVRPHFORWKZHWLWLQFROGZDWHU DQGSXWLWRQWKHEUXLVH,WZLOOUHOLHYHWKHSDLQ ,IWKHEUXLVHZDVYHU\EDG\RXPXVWFRQVXOWDGRFWRU MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb kbgyd mrb[e_ggh_ f_klh jZkimor__ f_klh pZjZibgZ gZ dhe_g_ ihfZaZlvch^hfdhe_gh[hebl ijbqbgy_l[hev \aylvldZgvgZfhqblv \\h^_h[e_]qblv[hev ,,Ijhqlbl_l_dklbkdZ`bl_qlhfZevqbdk^_eZeg_ijZ\bevgh $ER\IHOWLQWKHVWUHHWDQGKXUWKLVNQHHEDGO\+LVNQHHORRNHGUHGDQG VZROOHQEXWKHGLGQ WJRKRPHDWRQFH,QDQKRXUZKHQKHILQLVKHGSOD\LQJ ZLWKKLVIULHQGVKHZHQWKRPH+HWRRNVRPHFORWKZHWLWLQKRWZDWHUDQG SXWLWRQKLVEUXLVH ,,,Hibrbl_jbkmghd :KDWLVLQWHUHVWLQJWKHUHLVQ W DVFUDWFKRQ\RXUPRWRUF\FOH A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm EOHHGLQJ>µEOLGL¾@idjh\hl_q_gb_ WRIORZ>IORX@Y IOHZIORZQ l_qv VFDUOHW> VN.OLW@DZeuc ZRXQG>µZXQG@QjZgZ EDQGDJH >µEÙQGL!@ Y a^ i_j_\yau \Zlv WLJKWO\>µWDLWOL@DGYlm]h WRUDLVH>UHL]@Yih^gbfZlv OLPE>OLP@Qdhg_qghklv WREUHDWKH>EUL@YûrZlv VHYHUH>VL¶YL~@Dly`zeuc kZV_>NHLV@QkemqZc EORRGWUDQVIXVLRQ >WUÙQV¶IMX~Q@ i_ j_eb\Zgb_djh\b %/((',1* :KHQ WKH EORRG IORZV KRUQ DQ DUWHU\ LW LV VFDUOHW :KHQ WKH EORRG IORZVIURPZYHLQLWLVGDUNUHG 6WRSWKHEOHHGLQJDVVRRQDVSRVVLEOH dZdfh`gh[uklj__ 7KHVLPSOH PHWKRGLVWRSXWFOHDQFORWKRYHUWKHZRXQGDQGEDQGDJHLWWLJKWO\ ,I WKH EOHHGLQJ LV IURP DQ DUP RU OHJ UDLVH WKH OLPE ,I D SHUVRQ KDV QRVHEOHHGDIWHUDEDGEUXLVH\RXPXVWSXWDFROGFRPSUHVVRQWKHQRVH7KH SHUVRQ PXVW EUHDWKH WKURXJK KLV PRXWK ,Q VHYHUH FDVHV GRFWRUV PDNH EORRGWUDQVIXVWRQV MIJ:@G?GBY KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb djh\vl_q_lbaZjl_jbbhklZgh\blvdjh\hl_q_gb_gZeh`blvqbklmx ldZgv dj_idh i_j_\yaZlv djh\hl_q_gb_ ba ghkZ kbevguc m^Zj iheh `blvdhfij_kkgZ«ly`_eu_kemqZbi_j_eb\Zgb_djh\b ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku , :KDW FRORXU LV WKH EORRG ZKHQ LW IORZV IURP DQ DUWHU\" D YHLQ" +RZPXVWZHEDQGDJHWKHZRXQG":KDWPXVWZHGRLIWKHEOHHGLQJLV IURPDQDUPDOHJRUQRVH" ,,,Ijhqlbl_bi_j_kdZ`bl_ <HVWHUGD\ ZKHQ , ZDV VLWWLQJ LQ WKH URRP DQG GRLQJ P\ KRPHZRUN , KHDUG P\ JUDQGPRWKHU V YRLFH $QQ KHOS PH 0\ JUDQQ\ ZDV LQ WKH NLWFKHQ,LPPHGLDWHO\UDQWKHUHDQGVDZWKDWP\JUDQGPD VKDQGZDVEOHH G LQJ6KHWROGPHWKDWZKLOHZDVKLQJDFXSVKHEURNHLWDQGFXWKHUKDQGQHDU WKH WKXPE , VDZ GDUN EORRG DQG XQGHUVWRRG WKDW WKH ROG ZRPDQ FXW KHU YHLQ,WROGKHUWRUDLVHKHUKDQG7KHQ,WRRNDFOHDQFORWKDQGIDVWHQHGLW WLJKWO\RYHUWKHFXWWLQJ$VWKHFXWWLQJZDVGHHSP\JUDQQ\KDGORJRWRWKH SROLFOLQLFWRDVXUJHRQ IRUPHGLFDODLG OVXUJHRQ>µV~!~Q@Q[bS\S] /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 2QHGD\WKHQHZFOHUNFDPHZLWKDQH\HFORVHGOHIWDUPLQMXUHGULJKW IRRWEOHHGLQJDQGZLWKDOOKLVFORWKHVEDGO\WRUQ jZahj\Zgguc 7KHGLUHF WRUDVNHGKLP :K\DUH\RXODWHE\WZRKRXUV"7KHFOHUNDQVZHUHG,IHOORXWRIDQ HLJKWVWRUH\ZLQGRZ bahdgZwlZ`Z 7KHGLUHFWRUVPLOHG$QGLWWRRN\RXWZRKRXUVIRUWKDW" A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm IUDFWXUH>IUÙNW ~@ii_j_ehf hleZl IUDFWXUD WREUHDN>EUHLN@Y EURNHEURNHQ ehfZlvQi_j_ehf ERQH>ERXQ@idhklv FORVHG>NORX]G@ZaZdjuluc RSHQZhldjuluc WRFRPSODLQ>N~P¶SOHLQ@Y`Zeh\Zlvky gZ[hev WRPRYH>PXY@Y^\b]Zlvky VZHOOLQJ>µVZHOL¾@ihimohev WRDSSHDU>~·SL~@Yihy\eylvky VSOLQW>VSOLQW@QrbgZ WRELQG>EDLQG@Yi_j_\yau\Zlv ;UD\V> HNV¶UHL]@ij_gl]_gh\uemqb SODVWHUFDVW> SO.VW~ N.VW@]bikh\Zy ih\yad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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb hldjuluc i_j_ehf aZdjuluc i_j_ehf f_klh i_j_ehfZ [hev klZ gh\blky kbevg__ iulZlvky ^\b]Zlvky himohev ihy\ey_lky g_ iha\h eycl_dhfmeb[h^\b]Zlvkyk^_eZlvj_gl]_ggZdeZû\Zlv]bik ,,Ijhqlbl_^bZeh]bjZau]jZcl__]h\ebpZo * U D Q Q \ :KDWLVWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX$QQ"<RXORRNSDOH [e_^gZy $QQ7KHUH VQRWKLQJWKHPDWWHUZLWKPH*UDQQ\ *%XW,VHHWKDWVRPHWKLQJLVZURQJ $:HOO,IHOORQWKHVNDWLQJULQNDQGKXUWP\ULJKWOHJEDGO\ */HWPHWDNHRII\RXUVKRH$QQ $7KDQN\RX*UDQQ\,FDQGRLWP\VHOI *,DPDIUDLG\RXKDYHDIUDFWXUH $'RQ WEHDIUDLG*UDQQ\,W VQRWDIUDFWXUH<RXVHHWKHUH LVQRVZHOOLQJRQP\OHJ *%XW,ZDQW\RXWRKDYHDQ;UD\H[DPLQDWLRQ $$OOULJKW, OOFRQVXOWDGRFWRU ,,,Hibrbl_dZjlbgdm ,9I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl $&DVH 0 L O L W L D P D Q 'RFWRUWKLVJLUOZDVLQDFDUDFFLGHQW :LOO\RXH[DPLQH KHUDQGVHHLIVKHKDVDQ\EURNHQERQHV 'RFWRUH[DPLQHGWKHSDWLHQW ' R F W R U :HOO VKH KDV VRPH EUXLVHV DQG DEUDVLRQV RQ WKH OHJV , GRQ W WKLQNVKHKDVDIUDFWXUHEXW, PJRLQJWRWDNHVHYHUDO;UD\VWRPDNHVXUH RILW PLOLWLDPDQ>PL¶OL ~P~Q@Qfbebpbhg_j DEUDVLRQ>~µEUHLQ@QkkZ^bgZ DFFLGHQW>µÙNVLG~QW@Qw^Z\Zjby WRPDNHVXUH> X~@m[_^blvky /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7hP+RZGLG\RXEUHDN \RXUDUP" 1 L k N 'R \RX VHH WKRVH VWDLUV klmi_gvdb RYHUWKHUH" 7hP<HV 1LkN:HOODQG,GLGQ¶W ,I\RXZDQWWKHWKLQJGRQH ZHOOGRLW\RXUVHOI A:GYLB? IDLQWLQJ> IHLQWL¾@Qh[fhjhd FDXVH>Nu]@QijbqbgZY WR \uau \Zlv HPRWLRQ>L¶PRX ~Q@Q^mr_\gh_\he g_gb_ ZDQWRIIRRG]heh^ IDWLJXH>I ~·WLJ@QmklZehklv ORVHFRQVFLRXVQHVV>µOX]µNuQ LVQLV@ l_jylvkhagZgb_ EUDLQ>EUHLQ@Qfha] VZHDW>VZHW@QihlbkiZjbgZ WR IHHO GL]]\ qm\kl\h\Zlv ]heh\hdjm `_gb_ ZHDN>ZLN@ZkeZ[uc VKDOORZ> ÑORX@Zih\_joghklguc VORZ>VORX@Zf_ê_gguc WROD\>OHL@Y ODLG iheh`blv IODW>IOÙW@DGYiehkdh WRORRVH>OXV@Ya^hkeZ[blv WRFRYHU>µNY~@Yihdju\Zlv WRVSULQNOH>µVSL¾NO@Y[jua]Zlv )$,17,1* 7KH FDXVHRI IDLQWLQJ PD\ EH GLIIHUHQW VWURQJ HPRWLRQ ZDQW RI IRRG IDWLJXHRUSDLQ ,QIDLQWLQJSHUVRQORVHVFRQVFLRXVQHVV%ORRGGRHVQ WJHWWRWKHEUDLQ 7KHIDFHRIDSHUVRQEHIRUHIDLQWLQJJHWVYHU\SDOHDQGVZHDWDSSHDUVRQKLV IRUHKHDG+HIHHOVGL]]\DQGZHDN+LVEUHDWKLQJLVVKDOORZ+LVSXOVHLV ZHDNDQGVORZ ,I\RXKHOSDSHUVRQZKRORVWKLVFRQVFLRXVQHVV /D\WKHSHUVRQIODWRQKLVEDFN 5DLVHKLVIHHWDOLWWOH /RRVHKLVGUHVV &RYHUKLPZDUPO\DQGRSHQWKHZLQGRZ 6SULQNOHFROGZDWHURQKLVIDFH *LYHWKHSHUVRQWREUHDWKHLQDPPRQLD> ~µPRXQM~@ZDWHU gZrZluj guckibjl MIJ:@G?GBY ,I_j_\_^bl_gZjmkkdbcyaudke_^mxsb_keh\hkhq_lZgby WKHFDXVHRIIDLQWLQJZDQWRIIRRGWKHIDFHJHWVSDOHVZHDWDSSHDUVKH IHHOVGL]]\VKDOORZEUHDWKLQJZHDNSXOVHVORZSXOVH ,,KhklZ\vl_g_[hevrhcjZkkdZahlhfdZd\uihfh]ebq_eh\_dmih l_jy\r_fm khagZgb_ gZ mebp_ Bkihevamcl_ keh\Z b keh\hkhq_lZ gbybal_dklZ A:GYLB? VKRFN> uN@Qrhd GDQJHURXV>µGHLQGU~V@ZhiZkguc ORVVQihl_jy UDSLG>µUÙSLG@ZmqZs_gguc WR NHHS KLP TXLHW > NZDL~W@ a^ g_ lj_\h`blv_]h 6+2&. 6KRFNLVYHU\GDQJHURXV /RVVRIEORRGFDQFDXVHVKRFN 6HYHUHSDLQRUVWURQJHPRWLRQFDQFDXVHVKRFNWRR7KHIDFHRIDSHUVRQ LQVKRFNLVXVXDOO\SDOHDQGWKHVNLQLVFROG%UHDWKLQJLVUDSLGDQGVKDO ORZ7KHSXOVHLVUDSLG ,I\RXKHOSDSHUVRQZKRLVLQVKRFN /D\KLPIODWRQKLVEDFN 5DLVHKLVIHHWOLWWOH &RYHUKLPZLWKEODQNHWVWRNHHSKLPZDUP *LYHKLPDZDUPGULQN .HHSKLPTXLHW MIJ:@G?GBY ,GZc^bl_\l_dkl_6KRFNkhhl\_lkl\mxsb_keh\hkhq_lZ gby hq_gvhiZk_gihl_jydjh\b\ua\Zlvrhddh`Zoheh^gZymqZs_g gh_ûoZgb_iheh`blvgZkibgmih^gylvgh]bgZdjulvh^_yehfl_i eh_iblv_ ,, <klZ\vl_ \f_klh lhq_d gm`gu_ ih kfukem keh\Z SDOH UDSLG WR NHHS ZDUP IODW EDFN ijhqlbl_ dZ`^h_ ij_êh`_ gb_p_ebdhfbih\lhjbl__]hg_]ey^y\dgb]m :KHQDSHUVRQLVLQVKRFNKLVIDFHLV« 7KHSXOVHDQGEUHDWKLQJ RIDSHUVRQLQVKRFNDUH«,I\RXKHOSDSHUVRQLQVKRFNOD\KLP«RQ KLV«,WLVLPSRUWDQW«DSHUVRQLQVKRFNV <HOLHYH,WRU1hW $0DQZLWK7ZR+HDUWV -RVHSKGH0DLZDVERUQZLWKWZRKHDUWV+HOLYHGLQWKHQLQHWHHQWKFHQ WXU\LQ1DSOHV G_Zihev <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm SRLVRQLQJ> SuL]QL¾@ihljZ\e_gb_ WRHPSW\>µHPSWL@Yhihjh`gylv VWRPDFK>µVWP~N@i`_em^hd SRLVRQ>µjuL]Q@Qy^ DVSK\[LD>ÙV¶ILNVL~@im^mrv_ Zknbdkby SURPSWZ[ukljuc 32,621,1* 7KHILUVWDLGIRUSRLVRQLQJLVWRHPSW\WKHVWRPDFK'RLWDVVRRQDV SRVVLEOH*LYHPXFKZDWHUWRGULQN²JODVVHV 6RPHSRLVRQVFDXVHVKRFNRWKHUV²DVSK\[LD,QHYHU\FDVHWKHSD WLHQWQHHGVSURPSWPHGLFDOFDUH MIJ:@G?GBY , GZc^bl_ \ l_dkl_ 3RLVRQLQJ khhl\_lkl\mxsb_ keh\Z b keh\hkhq_lZgby i_j\Zyihfhsvijb«hqbklblv`_em^hd\dZ`^hfkemqZ_iZpb _glugm`^Zxlky\[ukljhcf_^bpbgkdhcihfhsb ,, Hij_^_ebl_ ijZ\bevgu_ hl\_lu gZ \hijhk :KDW DUH WKH DLGVIRUSRLVRQLQJ" OD\WKHSHUVRQGRZQJLYHWKHSHUVRQIRXURUHLJKWJODVVHVRIZD WHUWDNHRIIWKHSHUVRQ VGUHVVH[DPLQHWKHSHUVRQ¶VPRXWK /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 'RFWRUFDOOHGDVPDOOER\FRPHXSWRRXUKRXVHTXLFNO\ :KRLVLOODW\RXUKRXVH"DVNHGWKHGRFWRU (YHU\ERG\EXW djhf_ PH,ZDVQDXJKW\ dZijbagbqZe VRWKH\GLG Q W JLYH PH DQ\ RI WKH QLFH PXVKURRPV ]jb[h\ )DWKHU KDG SLFNHG kh [jZe LQWKHIRUHVW A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm VXQVWURNH>µVQVWURXN@kheg_qgucm^Zj GU\>GUDL@Zkmohc KHDGDFKH>µKHGHLN@Q]heh\gZy[hev WRFRRO>NXO@hoeZ`^ZlvDGMijhoeZ^guc VSRQJH>VSQ!@Q]m[dZ WRNHHSXSYih^^_j`b\Zlv EORRGFLUFXODWLRQ>V~NMX¶OHL Q@Q djh\hh[jZs_gb_ 6816752.( ,WLVYHU\GDQJHURXVWRIDOODVOHHS aZkuiZlv LQWKHRSHQDLUZKHQWKH VXQLVKRWRUWREHLQWKHKRWVXQIRUDORQJWLPHZLWKRXWDKDW<RXPD\JHW DVXQVWURNH :KHQDSHUVRQKDVDVXQVWURNHKHKDVDKLJKWHPSHUDWXUH+LVVNLQLV YHU\KRWGU\DQGUHG+HKDVDEDGKHDGDFKHDQGFDQHYHQORVHFRQVFLRXV QHVV,I\RXKHOSDSHUVRQZKRKDVDVXQVWURNH 7DNHWKHSDWLHQWLQWRDFRRODQGVKDG\ l_gbklh_ SODFH 3XWKLPRQKLVEDFN 5DLVHKLVKHDGDQGVKRXOGHUVDOLWWOH 3XWFROGFORWKRQKLVKHDG &RROKLVERG\ZLWKFROGZDWHU 5XEKLVVNLQZLWKDVSRQJHWRNHHSXSEORRGFLUFXODWLRQ MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb gZ hldjulhf \ha^mo_ \ukhdZy l_fi_jZlmjZ kmoZy djZkgZy dh`Z kbevgZy ]heh\gZy [hev ihl_jylv khagZgb_ i_j_g_klb \ ijhoeZ^gh_ f_klhke_]dZijbih^gylv]heh\mh[l_j_lvdh`m]m[dhc ,,Ijhqlbl_^bZeh]bjZau]jZcl__]h\ebpZo ,QWKH&RXQWU\ 3 H W H 0DZKHUHDUH\RX" 0 h W K H U ,¶PLQWKHNLWFKHQ3HWH:KDW VWKHPDWWHU" 30\IULHQG1LFNIHHOVEDG+HKDVDEDGKHDGDFKHDQGKLVVNLQLVYHU\ KRW0:KHUHLVKH" 3+HLVRQWKHEDQNRIWKHULYHU+HZDVO\LQJLQWKHVXQIRUDORQJWLPH 0+HSUREDEO\KDVDVXQVWURNH,VDQ\ERG\ZLWKKLP" 3<HV%RULVLVWKHUH 0 'RQ W ZDVWH WLPH 5XQ EDFN TXLFNO\ DQG WDNH 1LFN WR D VKDG\ SODFH 5DLVHKLVKHDGDOLWWOH3XWDZHWFORWKRQKLVKHDG,¶OOWDNHVRPHPHGL FLQHDQGFRPHLQDPLQXWH SUREDEO\> jUuE~EOL@DGY\_jhylgh WR ZDVWH >ZHLVW@ Y l_jylv WR ZDVWHWLPHl_jylv\j_fy A:GYLB? MIJ:@G?GBY ,Ih^Zgghcko_f_khklZ\vl_ij_êh`_gbyIhevamykvjmkkdb fbkeh\hkhq_lZgbyfb <RX GEHWWHU]eZ]he \ujZ`_gb_kh\_lZ±<Zf[uemqr_<RX G EHWWHUe_qv\ihkl_ev H[jZa_p<RX¶GEHWWHUJRWREHG <RX¶GEHWWHUihfZaZlvjmdmch^hfgZfhqblvldZgv\oheh^ghc\h ^_biheh`blv__gZ]heh\miheh`blvdhfij_kkgZmohih^gylv]heh \mgh]bûrZlvghkhf ,,KgZqZeZi_j_\_^bl_jmkkdb_keh\hkhq_lZgbygZZg]ebckdbc yaudZaZl_fkhklZ\vl_ij_êh`_gbygZqbgZykeh\Zfb /HW l_ jZaj_rbl_fg_ beb +HOSl_ ihfh]bl_fg_ H[jZa_p/HWP_ihfhqv\Zf /HWPHKHOS\RX /HWP_iheh`blv^_\hqdmgZdjh\ZlvjZkkl_]gmlv_cieZlv_gZdjulv __h^_yehfhldjulvhdgh^Zlv\Zfiblv_ H [ j Z a _ p +HOSP_ KLPKHUXVWKHP \ufulv iZeZlm +HOSKLPWRZDVKWKHZDUG +HOSPH«hklZgh\blvdjh\hl_q_gb_iheh`blvdhfij_kkgZ]heh\m jZkl_j_lv _]h dh`m ]m[dhc iheh`blv [hevgh]h \ fZrbgm iheh`blv fZevqbdZgZkibgm D H G L J H E V G U ?M I J : @ G ?G B Y ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb m f_gy hq_gv [hebl gh]Z iheh`bl_ oheh^guc dhfij_kk ± wlh h[ e_]qbl [hev \q_jZ m f_gy [ueh kbevgh_ djh\hl_q_gb_ aZ\ljZ ^hdlhj k^_eZ_l\Zfi_j_eb\Zgb_djh\bhgZ`Zem_lkygZ[hev\jmd_fuk_c qZk k^_eZ_fj_gl]_gbgZeh`bf]bikh\mxih\yadmhgZmiZeZ\h[fh jhdmg_]hkeZ[ucbf_ê_ggucimevkmg__mqZs_ggh_bih\_joghkl gh_ûoZgb_ ,,GZibrbl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZglihke_^mxs_fml_dklm ,QIDLQWLQJWKHSHUVRQGRHVQ WORVHFRQVFLRXVQHVV7KHIDFHRIWKHSHUVRQ JHWVSDOH+LVEUHDWKLQJLVVKDOORZ+LVSXOVHLVUDSLG5DLVHKLVKHDGDOLWWOH 7KHQJLYHWKHSHUVRQWREUHDWKHLQDPPRQLDZDWHU ,,,Ijh\_^bl_ijh]jZffbjh\Zggucdhgljheve_dkbdb<ijZ\hc dhehgd_ gZc^bl_ i_j_\h^ dZ`^h]h Zg]ebckdh]h keh\Z jZ[hlm \uihegycl_gZi_jnhdZjl_ ,djh\hl_q_gb_ EUXLVH ,,`Zeh\Zlvky WRKXUW ,,,keZ[uc WRUHOLHYH ,9mrb[ ZRXQG 9h[e_]qblv WREUHDWKH 9,ihdju\Zlv GDQJHURXV 9,,h[fhjhd ZHDN 9,,,hiZkguc IDLQWLQJ ,;kbevguc WRFRPSODLQ ;jZgZ SDLQ ;,ij_^hojZgylv ;,,[hev ;,,,]bikh\Zyih\yadZ ;,9ûrZlv ;9ijbqbgylv[hev J:A>?E,,, ',6($6(6$1'1856,1* A:GYLB? GZibrbl_ gZa\Zgby bah[jZ`_gguo a^_kv ij_^f_lh\ bkihevamy ^Zggu_ Zg]ebckdb_ keh\Z b \ujZ`_gby b keh\Zjv gZ k ² AZ ihfgbl_\ujZ`_gbykwlbfbkeh\Zfb DLUULQJ> 0~UL¾@ WRJLYHDQDLUULQJWRDEHGSDWLHQW EHGSDQ>µE~GSÙQ@ WRJLYHDEHGSDQWRDEHGSDWLHQW WRWDNHDZD\ m[jZlv DEHGSDQIURPD EHGSDWLHQW FRPSUHVV>µNuPSUHV@WRSXWDFROG KRW FRPSUHVVRQ FXSV>NSV@WRSXWFXSVRQWKHEDFN FKHVW GURSSLQJERWWOH>µEuWO@ WRGURS GURSV HQHPD> HQLP~@ WRJLYHDZDUPHQHPD WRJLYHDFOHDQVLQJ hqbklbl_evgZy HQHPD WRJLYHDPHGLFLQDO e_q_[gZy HQHPD IHHGLQJFXS>µIWGL¾NS@ WRJLYHDIHHGLQJFXSRIPLON WHD ZDWHUVRXS WRDEHGSDWLHQW KRWZDWHUEDJ ERWWOH WRILOODKRWZDWHUEDJZLWK WRSXWDKRWZDWHUEDJRQ« WRFKDQJHZDWHULQWKHKRWZDWHUEDJ LFHEDJ>µDLVEÙJ@ WRILOODQLFHEDJZLWKLFH FROGZDWHU WRSXWDQ,FHEDJRQ« WRFKDQJHLFHLQWKHLFHEDJ ZKHHOFKDLU> ZLOW 0~@ WRWDNHDSDWLHQW¶LQDZKHHOFKDLU LQWRDZDUG SLSHWWH>SL¶SHW@ WRSLSHWWH PXVWDUGSODVWHUV>µPVW~G SO.VW~]@ WRSXWPXVWDUGSODVWHUVRQWKH EDFN FKHVWKHDUWQHFN VFLVVRUV>µVL]~]@ WRFXWDEDQGDJHZLWKVFLVVRUV VRDS>VRXS@ WRVRDS DSLHFH dmkhd RIVRDS VWLFNLQJSODVWHU WRSXWDVWLFNLQJSODVWHURQ V\ULQJH>µVLULQ!@ WRERLODV\ULQJH WRVWHULOL]HDV\ULQJH WRDVVHPEOH GLVDVVHPEOH DV\ULQJH WKHUPRPHWHU>~ PuPLW~@ WRSXWDWKHUPRPHWHU WRWDNHDWKHUPRPHWHURXW WRUHDGDWKHUPRPHWHU WRVKDNHDWKHUPRPHWHU EDVLQ>EHLVQ@ WREULQJDEDVLQWRDEHGSDWLHQW IRUZDVKLQJ VSRQJH>VSQG@ WRZDVKDSDWLHQWZLWKDVSRQJH VWUHWFKHU>µVWUHW ~@ WREHRQDVWUHWFKHU WRFDUU\DVWUHWFKHU WRFDUU\DSDWLHQWRQDVWUHWFKHU MIJ:@G?GB? KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb IhklZ\vl_ ]jZ^mkgbd e_`Zq_fm [hevghfm <ugvl_ ]jZ^mkgbd b ijhqlbl_ ihdZaZgb_ K_kljZ ^he`gZ k[blv ]jZ^mkgbd >Zcl_ [hevghfm ihbevgbd k qZ_f IhklZ\vl_ hqbklbl_evgmx debafm wlhfm[hevghfmK_kljZ^he`gZ^Zlvkm^ghe_`Zq_fm[hevghfm GZihegbl_]j_edm]hjyq_c\h^hcKf_gblze_^\imauj_q_j_a qZkZHl\_abl_[hevgh]hgZdZlZed_\hi_jZpbhggmxIheh `bl_oheh^gucdhfij_kkgZ]heh\m,,IhklZ\vl_[ZgdbgZkibgm AZdZiZcl_^\_dZieb\ghkIhklZ\vl_]hjqbqgbdbgZk_j^ p_GZfuevl_ohjhrhjmdbK_kljZ^he`gZdbiylblvrijbp fbgml A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRWDNHWKHWHPSHUDWXUH>W_PSULW ~@ baf_jylvl_fi_jZlmjm FKDUW>W .W@QdZjlZWHPSHUDWXUH FKDUWl_fi_jZlmjgucebkl PHGLFLQH>µPHGVLQ@Qe_dZjkl\h WRFDUU\RXW>µNÙUL@Y\uihegylv SUHVFULSWLRQ>SULV NULS ~Q@Qij_îb kZgb_j_p_il ZDUG>ZuG@QiZeZlZ WRH[DPLQH>LJ·]ÙPLQ@YRFfZljb\Zlv [hevgh]h ZDUGQXUVHiZeZlgZyk_kljZ FRQGLWLRQ>N~Q GL ~Q@Qkhklhygb_ WRSUHVFULEH>SULV NUDLE@Yijhibku \ZlvgZagZqZlv LQMHFWLRQ>LQ¶!HN ~Q@Q\ijukdb\Z gb_bgt_dpby SUDFWLFH> SUÙNWLV@QijZdlbdZ DWWHQWLYH>~µWHQWLY@D\gbfZl_evguc WRREVHUYH>~E¶]~Y@YgZ[ex^Zlv FKDQJH>W HLQ!@Qbaf_g_gb_ ,1$+263,7$/ , DP D QXUVH , ZRUN DW D WKHUDSHXWLF >W HUDSHYWLN@ l_jZi_\lbq_kdbc KRVSLWDO0DQ\GRFWRUVDQGQXUVHVZRUNDWWKHKRVSLWDO2XUKRVSLWDOLVYHU\ ODUJH :RUN DW WKH KRVSLWDO EHJLQV DW R FORFN LQ WKH PRUQLQJ 7KH QXUVHV EHJLQWRWDNHWKHSDWLHQWV¶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ihfgbl_ke_^mxsb_\ujZ`_gbykhkeh\hf SDWLHQW EHGSDWLHQWe_`Zqbc[hevghc VLWWLQJSDWLHQWkb^yqbc[hevghc XSSDWLHQWoh^yqbc[hevghc LQSDWLHQWklZpbhgZjguc[hevghc RXWSDWLHQWZf[meZlhjguc[hevghc MIJ:@G?GBY ,<klZ\vl_gm`gu_ihkfukemkeh\Z WRREVHUYH DQXUVH¶ WRSUHVFULEH µWRH[DPLQH LQIHFWLRQV DKRVSL WDO PHGLFLQHV¶ ,ZRUNDWDP,QWKHPRUQLQJWKHQXUVH"JLYHWKHSDWLHQWV ,QWKHPRUQLQJWKHGRFWRUVWKHSDWLHQWV7KHGRFWRUVRPHPHGLFLQH RU$QDWWHQWLYHQXUVHWULHVDQ\FKDQJHLQDSDWLHQW VFRQGLWLRQ ,,KhklZ\vl_bgZibrbl_ij_êh`_gbybake_^mxsbokeh\ Ijhqlbl_dZ`^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhfbih\lhjbl__]h g_]ey^y\l_ljZ^v PHGLFLQHVSDWLHQWVJLYHQXUVHVWRWKHLU RXUPDQ\ZRUNKRVSLWDOGRFWRUVQXUVHVDQGDW H[DPLQHSDWLHQWVHYHU\GRFWRUVPRUQLQJWKHLU LQMHFWLRQVSUHVFULEHVRUGRFWRUVRPHPHGLFLQHWKHZDUG ,,,Ijb^mfZcl_ij_êh`_gbckhkeh\hf SDWLHQW b\ujZ`_gby fb\dexqZxsbfbwlhkeh\h ,9Hibrbl_jbkmghd /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 2 O G G R F W R U <RXKDYHFXUHG bae_qbeb \RXUSDWLHQW :KDWLVWKHUHWRZRUU\DERXWQRZ" < R X Q J G R F W R U ,GRQ WNQRZZKLFKRIWKHPHGLFLQHVFXUHGKLP A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,VWXGHQWQXUVHmqZsbckyf_^bpbgkdh ]hmqbebsZ VLFN>VLN@Z[hevghc WROHDUQ>~Q@ OHDUQW YbamqZlv FDUH>N0~@Qy^moh^ WR ZHDU >Z0~@ ZRUH ZRUQ Y ghkblv WREHSURXG>SUDXG@]hj^blvky VSRWOHVV> VSuWOLV@Zqbkluc VXUJHU\>µV~!~UL@Qa^hi_jZpby ZKHHOFKDLU>µZLOW ~@Qdj_keh dZlZedZ QXUVHU\>µQ~V~UL@Qykeb WREHDIUDLG>~µIUHLG@[hylvky WRWU\>WUDL@YklZjZlvky $678'(171856( $QXUVHWDNHVFDUHRISHRSOHZKRDUHVLFN7KLVLVKHUZRUN 0HQFDQEH QXUVHVWRR 6KHJRHVWRDPHGLFDOVFKRROWR OHDUQZKDWVKHPXVWNQRZWR JLYHJRRGFDUH WRVLFNSHRSOH7KHQXUVHPXVWEHDJRRGVWXGHQWLQVFKRRO 6KHPXVWEHKHDOWK\KHUVHOIHDWLQWLPHJHWSOHQW\RIUHVWDQGH[HUFLVHVXVH JRRG SHUVRQDO K\JLHQH >µKDL !LQ@ 6KH PXVW EH D KDSS\ SHUVRQ DQG PXVW OLNHSHRSOH:KHQVKHLVDVWXGHQWQXUVHVKH ZHDUV DXQLIRUP>MXQLIuP@ 6KH LV SURXG RI KHU XQLIRUP DQG NHHSV LW VSRWOHVV VR VKH DOZD\V ORRNV SURIHVVLRQDO 'XULQJ KHU SUDFWLFH VKH JLYHV SDWLHQWV PHGLFLQH EULQJV WKHP PHDO 6RPHWLPHV VKH ZRUNV LQ WKHRSHUDWLQJURRPKHOSLQJWKHGRFWRUZKRGRHV VXUJHU\RQDSDWLHQW 6KHKHOSVSHRSOHWRZDONDQGWDNHVWKHPLQDZKHHOFKDLU6KHORYHVWR ZRUNLQWKHQXUVHU\ZKHUHVKHKHOSVWRWDNHJRRGFDUHRIEDELHV6RPH WLPHVVKHUHDGVRUSOD\VZLWKVPDOOFKLOGUHQVRWKH\ZRQ¶WEHDIUDLGRIWKH KRVSLWDO6KHVWXGLHVKDUG6KHWULHVWRPDNHDEHWWHUSHUVRQRIKHUVHOI :KHUHLVWKHSDWLHQW" +HLVRXWWRVPRNH A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklZf WRUHVSHFW>ULV SHNW@Ym\Z`Zlv TXLHWO\>µNZDL~WOL@DGYkihdhcghlboh VKHHW> LW@Qijhklugy SLOORZ>µSLORX@Qih^mrdZ SDWLHQW>µSHL ~QW@Zl_ji_eb\uc UXGH>UXG@D]jm[uc WRZRUU\>µZUL@Y[_kihdhblvky RUGHU>µuG~@Qij_îbkZgb_ PLVWDNH>PLV WHLN@Qhrb[dZ ZQJ]m>µÙ¾JUL@Zk_j^blucjZa^jZ `_gguc VFDU>VN.@DrjZf 285%(67:$5'1856( 1LQDOYDQRYDLVRXUEHVWZDUGQXUVH6KHZRUNVDWRXUKRVSLWDODQGHY H U\ERG\UHVSHFWVKHUYHU\PXFK,QWKHPRUQLQJVKHDOZD\VFRPHVLQWRWKH ZDUG ZLWK D VPLOH RQ KHU IDFH $QG HYHU\ SDWLHQW ZKHQ KH VHHV KHU NLQG VPLOH IHHOV EHWWHU (YHU\WKLQJ VKH GRHV LQ WKH ZDUG VKH GRHV TXLFNO\ DQG TXLHWO\ ,I WKHUH LV D EHGSDWLHQW LQ WKH ZDUG 1LQD FRPHV XS WR KLP 6KH EUXVKHV KLV VKHHWV RU FKDQJHV WKHP LI LW LV QHFHVVDU\ 6KH VKDNHV KLV SLO ORZ7KHQ1LQDEULQJVDEDVLQDQGZDVKHVWKHSDWLHQW VIDFHDQGKDQGV6KH LVHVSHFLDOO\SDWLHQWZLWKROGSHRSOH1LQDPDNHVLQMHFWLRQVSXWVPXVWDUG SODVWHUVDQGFXSV6KHQHYHUKXUWVKHUSDWLHQWZLWKDUXGHZRUG 7KH GRFWRUV DOZD\V VD\ :KHQ 1LQD LV DW ZRUN ZH GRQ W ZRUU\ :H NQRZWKDWHYHU\WKLQJZLOOEHDOOULJKW 6RPH*RRG5XOHVIRU1XUVHV 5HDGWKHRUGHURIWKHGRFWRUEHIRUH\RXJLYHPHGLFLQH" ,I\RXPDGHDPLVWDNHLQ\RXUZRUN\RXPXVWIHOOWKHGRFWRUDERXWLW DWRQFH 'RQRWEHUXGHZKHQ\RXVSHDNZLWKSDWLHQWV /HDUQWRFRQWURO\RXUIHHOLQJV:KHQ\RXDUHDQJU\²FRXQWWRD KXQGUHG>µKQGULG@ 'RQ WJRVVLS>VLS@ kie_lgbqZc DERXW\RXUSDWLHQWV 1HYHUVD\WKHZRUGLQFXUDEOH>LQ¶NMX ~U~EO@ g_bae_qbfuc 3URYHUE +H ODXJKV >O.IV@ DW D VFDU >VN.@ WKDW QHYHU IHOW D ZRXQG >ZXQG@ [md\Zevgh Lhl kf__lky gZ^ rjZfhf dlh gbdh]^Z g_ [ue jZg_g KjLhlkf__lkygZ^kljZ^Zgbyfbq_eh\_dZdlhkZfgbdh]^Zg_ kljZ^Ze A:IHFGBL? +HDUWVOLNHGRRUVZLOORSHQZLWKHDVH e_]dh 7RYHU\YHU\OLWWOHNH\V dexq :HWKDQN\RXPXFKDQG,I\RXSOHDVH A:GYLB? MIJ:@G?GBY ,IhaZ^Zgghcfh^_ebihklZ\vl_\hijhkuddZ`^hfmij_êh`_gbx :KRKRVSLWDO":KHUHGRHV"'RHVVKH" 1LQD,YDQRYDZRUNVDWRXUKRVSLWDO :KHQ":KDWGRLQWKHPRUQLQJ":KRVHVKHHWVDQGSLOORZV" ,QWKHPRUQLQJ1LQDEUXVKHVKHUSDWLHQWV¶VKHHWVDQGVKDNHVSLOORZV ,V"+RZLQMHFWLRQV":KDWYHU\ZHOO":LWKZKRP" 6KHLVSDWLHQWZLWKROGSHRSOHDQGPDNHVLQMHFWLRQVYHU\ZHOO ,, BkijZ\vl_ g_\_jgu_ QR kfukem ij_êh`_gby K\h_ ml\_j`^_gb_ gZqbgZcl_keh\Zfb1RWKDWLVQ WULJKWbeb7KDW¶VZURQJ H[jZa_p'RQ WZDVK\RXUKDQGVEHIRUHGLQQHU7KDW VZURQJ<RX PXVWZDVK\RXUKDQGVEHIRUHGLQQHU 'RQ WUHDGWKHRUGHURIWKHGRFWRUEHIRUH\RXJLYHPHGLFLQHV1HYHU WHOOWKHGRFWRUDERXW\RXUPLVWDNH<RXPD\EHUXGHZKHQ\RXVSHDNZLWK SDWLHQWV*RVVLSDERXW\RXUSDWLHQWV ,,,>hihegbl_ke_^mxsb_ij_êh`_gbymihlj_[b\gh\u_keh\Z EHGSDWLHQWVFDUUHVSHFWSDWLHQWDQJU\ 0\ IDWKHU LV D JRRG ZRUNHU (YHU\ERG\ KLP YHU\ PXFK 0\ PRWKHULVDYHU\SHUVRQ6KHQHYHUJHWV3HWHFXWKLVILQJHUODVWZHHN +HKDVDRQKLVILQJHU7KHUHDUHPDQ\LQWKLVZDUG ,9 <uibrbl_ ba l_dklZ ij_êh`_gby h lhf dZd GbgZ B\Zgh\Z moZ`b\Z_laZe_`Zqbfb[hevgufbi_j_kdZ`bl_wlhihZg]ebckdb 9I_j_\_^bl_ibkvfhgZZg]ebckdbcyaud >hjh]hc;hjbk YgZoh`mkv\[hevgbp_Mf_gy[ueh\hkiZe_gb_e_]dbo SQHXPR QLD <l_q_gb_g_^_ebmf_gy[ueZ\ukhdZyl_fi_jZlmjZ<jZqbgZagZ qbebfg_mdheuL_i_jvyqm\kl\mxk_[yemqr_A^_kvfgh]hohjhrbo \jZq_cbk_kl_jGZrZemqrZyiZeZlgZyk_kljZ²GbgZB\Zgh\Z<k_ __hq_gvm\Z`ZxlHgZhq_gv\gbfZl_evgZ DWWHQWLYH dk\hbf[hevguf GZrb\jZqb]h\hjyl©Dh]^ZGbgZgZjZ[hl_fuagZ_fªqlh\k_[m^_l \ihjy^d_ªYgZ^_xkv KRSH qlh\_jgmkvhq_gvkdhjh VRRQ >hk\b^Zgby l\hcB]hjv 9,<umqbl_gZbamklvijZ\beZ6RPHJRRGUXOHVIRUQXUVHV A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRWDNHWKHSXOVH>SOV@ijhsmiu\Zlv imevk UDGLDO> UHLGM~O@Zemq_\hc QHUYRXV>µQ~Y~V@Zg_j\guc IDVW>I.VW@Z[ukljuc EHDWLQJ>µELWL¾@i[b_gb_ k_j^pZ imevkZpby +2:727$.(7+(38/6( $QXUVHORRNVDIWHUKHUSDWLHQWVLQWKHGD\WLPHRUDOQLJKWDQGFDQVHHDQ\ FKDQJHVLQWKHSDWLHQWV¶FRQGLWLRQ0DQ\RIWKHFKDQJHVDUHYHU\LPSRUW DQW 7KHQXUVHPXVWEHFDUHIXOZKHQVKHWDNHVWKHSDWLHQW VSXOVH,WLVQRWGLII L FXOWWRWDNHWKHSXOVH3XWWKUHHILQJHUVRIWKHOHIWKDQGRYHU WKHUDGLDODU WHU\0DQ\SDWLHQWVDUHQHUYRXVZKHQWKH\VHHDQXUVHRUDGRFWRUDQGWKH SDWLHQW VSXOVHLVIDVWHU 7KDW VZK\WKHQXUVHPXVWZDLWDIHZVHFRQGVEHIRUHVKHEHJLQVWRFRXQW WKHSXOVH,IWKHQXUVHVHHVDQ\FKDQJHVLQWKHEHDWLQJRIWKHSXOVHVKHPXVW LPPHGLDWHO\WHOOWKHGRFWRU&KDQJHVLQWKHSXOVHDUHYHU\LPSRUWDQW 5(0(0%(5:KHQ\RXWDNHWKHSXOVH\RXPXVWQRWH ,ILWLVGHHSRUVKDOORZ> ÙORX@ WKHUDWH WKHVWUHQJWKRIWKHEHDWLQJ WKHUK\WKP WRQRWH>QRXW@YaZf_qZlvhlf_qZlv GHHS>GLS@Z]em[hdbc UDWH>UHLW@QqZklhlZ UK\WKP>ULçP@Qjblf MIJ:@G?GBY ,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KHQGRHVWKHZRUNRIWKHQXUVHEHJLQDWWKHKRVSLWDO" :KDWGRHV WKH QXUVH GR LQ WKH PRUQLQJ" :KDW GRHV WKH GRFWRU DVN WKH ZDUG QXUVH ZKHQ KH FRPHV WR KLV ZDUG" +RZ PXVW WKH QXUVH FRXQW WKH SXOVH" :KDW PXVW WKH QXUVH GR LI VKH VHHV DQ\ LUUHJXODULW\ LQ WKH EHDWLQJ RI WKH SXOVH" ,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb baf_jylv l_fi_jZlmjm ijh\_ljblv iZeZlm khklhygb_ [hevgh]h ijZdlbdZaZf_qZlvex[u_baf_g_gbykqblZlvimevkg_f_ê_ggh ,, =ey^y gZ jbkmghd jZkkdZ`bl_ dZdgZ^hijhsmiu\Zlvimevk /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ' R F W R U V Z L I H 1RZP\GHDU\RXPXVWIRUJHW\RXUSURIHVVLRQLI\RX JRWRVHHRXUIULHQGVZLWKPH + H U K X V E D Q G :KDWKDYH,GRQH" ' R F W R U V Z L I H :K\\RXIHHOWKHSXOVHRIHYHU\RQHZKRJLYHV\RXWKH KDQG A:GYLB? Ihkfhljbl_ gZ dZjlbgdm GZibrbl_ gZa\Zgby [he_ag_c bkihev amy^Zggu_keh\Zb\ujZ`_gbybkeh\ZjvgZKAZihfgbl_\ujZ `_gbykwlbfbgZa\Zgbyfb KHDGDFKH>µKHGHLN@ WRKDYHDEDGKHDGDFKH WRWDNHDWDEOHWIRUDKHDGDFKH WRRWKDFKH>µWXHLN@ WRKDYHDWRRWKDFKH WRULQVHWKHPRXWK VWRPDFKDFKH>µVWP~NHLN@ WRKDYHDVWRPDFKDFKH WRWDNHDWDEOHWIRUDVWRPDFKDFKH WRNHHSDGLHW HDUDFKF>µL~UHLN@ WRKDYHDQHDUDFKH WRSXWDZDUPFRPSUHVV RQWKHHDU KHDUWDFKH> K.WHLN@ WROLVWHQWRWKHKHDUW WRKDYHDEDG ZHDN KHDUW WRKDYHDKHDOWK\KHDUW VRUHWKURDW>µVu¶URXW@ WRKDYHDVRUHWKURDW WRJDUJOHWKHWKURDW EOHHGLQJ>µEOLGL@ WRVWRSWKHEOHHGLQJ WKHEOHHGLQJLVIURPDQDUP OHJ QRVH FRXJK>NuI@ WRQDYHDGU\FRXJK WRKDYHDEDGFRXJK FROGLQWKHKHDG WRKDYHDEDGFROGLQWKHKHDG WRKDYHDUXQQLQJQRVH IUDFWXUH>µIUÙNW ~@ WRKDYHDQRSHQ FORVHG IUDFWXUHWRSXWVSOLQWV WRSXWDSODVWHUFDVW VXQVWURNH>µVQVWURXN@ WRJHWDVXQVWURNH WRFRROWKHERG\ IHYHU> ILY~@ WREHLOO WRNHHS VWD\ LQEHG WRFDWFKDFROG MIJ:@G?GB? KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb M wlh]h [hevgh]h keZ[h_ k_j^p_ Ijhihehsbl_ ]hjeh <u ^he`gu [ukljh hklZgh\blv djh\hl_q_gb_ M fZevqbdZ hldjuluc i_j_ehf gh]b Ijbfbl_ lZ[e_ldm hl ]heh\ghc [heb GZeh`bl_ rbgugZjmdmIhihehsbl_jhlihke__û<u^he`guijb^_j`b \Zlvky ^b_lu M ^_\hqdb kbevgZy [hev \ `b\hl_ Iheh`bl_l_i eucdhfij_kkgZmoh A:GYLB? I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl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hev\k_j^p_ SUHVVXUH> SUH ~@Q^Z\e_gb_ WR FKHFN WKH <J baf_jylv djh\ygh_ K\SRWHQVLYH >KDLS~µWHQVLY@ Z hlghky sbcky d ihgb`_gghfm djh\yghfm ^Z\e_gb_ ^Z\e_gbx K\SHUWHQVLRQ >KDLS~ WHQ ~Q@ i ih\u r_ggh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ WRIULJKWHQ>µIUDLWQ@Yim]Zlv K\SRWHQVLRQ >KDLS~µWHQ ~Q@ Q ihgb K\SHUWHQVLYH >KDL~·WHQVLY@ Z hlghky `_ggh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ sbcky d ih\ur_gghfm djh\yghfm DQDHPLD >~ QLPM~@ Q Zg_fby fZeh ^Z\e_gbx djh\b_ GLVHDVH>GL ]]@Q[he_agv AZihfgbl_gZa\Zgby[he_ag_cdhlhju_\Zg]ebckdhfyaud_ mihlj_[eyxlky[_aZjlbdey SQHXPRQLD>QMX¶PRXQM~@LQIOXHQ]DDSSHQGLFLWLV>~SHQGL VDLWLV@ MIJ:@G?GBY ,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW LV EORRG SUHVVXUH" :KDW NLQGV RI EORRG SUHVVXUH GR \RX NQRZ":KDWPXVW\RXNQRZZKHQ\RXFKHFNWKHSDWLHQW V%3":KDW GRHVDK\SHUWHQVLYHSDWLHQWRIWHQFRPSODLQRI":KDWGRHVWKHGRFWRUSUH VFULEHWKHK\SHUWHQVLYHSDWLHQW" ,,GZibrbl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZglQRl_f_%ORRG3UHVVXUH 7KH EORRG SUHVVXUH FDQ EH KLJK ORZ DQG QRUPDO +LJK EORRG SUHVVXUH QHYHUIULJKWHQVSDWLHQWV7KHQXUVHPXVWQRWFDOPDSDWLHQWZLWKKLJKEORRG SUHVVXUH3DWLHQWVZLWKKLJK%3FDQZRUNKDUG/RZ%3LVQRWDVHULRXVGL V HDVH7KHQXUVHPXVWEHYHU\DWWHQWLYHWRWKHSDWLHQWVZLWKKLJK%3 ,,,I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl $1,1&85$%/(',6($6( 0U%ODFNZDVLQIHFWHGZLWKK\SRFKRQGULD +HQHYHUPRYHGZLWKRXWD EDWWHU\RISLOOVDQGWDEOHWV+HZDVVXUHWKDWKHKDGKHDUWWURXEOH+HFR Q VXOWHGDKHDUWVSHFLDOLVWZKRH[DPLQHGKLPFDUHIXOO\$WODVWWKHGRFWRUVDL G 0U%ODFN,DPDIUDLG\RXKDYHDQLQFXUDEOHGLVHDVH<HV\HVVDLG0U %ODFN,NQHZLW7HOOPH²ZKDWLVLW")HDUZDVWKHDQVZHU LQFXUDEOH >LQ¶NMX~U~EO@ Z g_bae_qb fuc K\SRFKRQGULD >KDLSRX NuQGUL~@ Q m] g_l_ggh_khklhygb_^moZ WR PRYH >PXY@ Y _a^blv i_j_^\b ]Zlvkykf_klZgZf_klh IHDU>IL~@ikljZo A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm XULQH> MX~ULQ@QfhqZ FRQYHUVDWLRQ>NuQY~µVHL ~Q@QjZa]h GLDJQRVLV>GDL~JµQRXVLV@Q^gZ]gha \hj ZKDW¶VWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX" }Qlhk\Zfb" ZKDW¶VZURQJZLWK\RX" WUHDWPHQW> WULWP~QW@Qe_q_gb_ WRERWKHU> Euç~@Y[_kihdhblv WHVW>WHVW@QZgZebaY WR bkiulu\Zlv ijh\_jylv $77+('2&725¶6 )RUDZHHN,IHOWSDLQLQP\VWRPDFKDQG,GHFLGHGWRFRQVXOWDGRFWRU +HUHLVWKHFRQYHUVDWLRQEHWZHHQPHDQGWKHGRFWRU 9 R O N R Y *RRGPRUQLQJ ' R F W R U *RRGPRUQLQJ:KDWLV\RXUQDPH" 9 R O N R Y 0\QDPHLV9RONRY ':KDW¶VWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX" 9,KDYHDVWRPDFKDFKHIRUDZHHNDQG,ZDQWWRILQGRXW ZKDW¶VZURQJ ZLWKPH '6KRZPHZLWK\RXUILQJHUWKHSODFHZKHUHLWKXUWV\RX 9+HUHGRFWRU ''RHVWKLVSDLQJRWRDQRWKHUSODWH" 9,WJRHVWRP\EDFNVRPHWLPHV ''RHVLWERWKHU\RXDWQLJKW" 90RVWRIWKHWLPH ' :H OO WDNH ;UD\V RI \RXU VWRPDFK DQG PDNH VRPH PRUH WHVWV EORRG WHVWXULQHWHVW,¶OOWHOO\RXWKHGLDJQRVLVDIWHU,KDYHDOO\RXUWHVWVDQG ,¶OOSUHVFULEH\RXVRPHWUHDWPHQW MIJ:@G?GBY ,<klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dijhims_ggu_keh\Z ;UD\VVKRZERWKHUVPDWWHUZURQJ :KDWLVWKHZLWK\RX",ZDQWWRILQGRXWZKDW¶VZLWKPHPH WKHSODFHZKHUHLWKXUWV\RX7KLVSDLQPHDWQLJKW7DNHRI\RXU VWRPDFK ,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb m g_]h kbevgZy ]heh\gZy [hev ]^_ m \Zk [hebl" k^_eZcl_ ZgZeba djh\b b j_gl]_g `_em^dZ m g__ [hevgh_ k_j^p_ \q_jZ m f_gy hq_gv [he_eam[\Zk[_kihdhbl[hev\`_em^d_" ,,,Hibrbl_jbkmghd ,9 Ih h[jZapm ^bZeh]Z gZ k jZau]jZcl_ kp_gdm M \jZqZ bkihevamyjbkmghd /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 3 D W L H Q W 2K'RFWRU,KDYHSDLQLQP\EDFN ' R F W R U 'R\RXIHHOWKHSDLQDOOWKHWLPH" 31R,GRQ W2QO\VRPHWLPHV '+HUHDUHWKHWDEOHWV7DNHRQHWDEOHWILYHPLQXWHVEHIRUHWKHSDLQEHJLQV A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm IHYHU>µILY~@i`ZjebohjZ^dZ ULVH>UDL]@iih^t_f V\PSWRP>µVLPSW~P@iijbagZdkbf ilhf DFKH>HLN@e[hev lmiZyijh^he`b l_evgZy WRUHSODFH>UL¶SOHLV@YklZ\blvbeb deZklvgZf_klhkf_gylv GDPS>GÙPS@Z\eZ`guc EHGFORWKHV> EHGNORXç]@Qihkl_evgh_ [_ev_ )(9(5 )HYHULVWKHULVH RIWKHERG\WHPSHUDWXUHDERYHQRUPDO7KHV\PSWRPV RIKLJKWHPSHUDWXUHDUHKHDGDFKHDFKHVDOORYHUWKHERG\UHGIDFHKRWGU\ VNLQORVVRIDSSHWLWHTXLFNSXOVHDQGEUHDWKLQJ ,I D SHUVRQ KDV IHYHU KH PXVW VWD\ LQ EHG DQG GULQN SOHQW\ RI ZDWHU 7KH QXUVHPXVWNHHSWKHSDWLHQWZDUP7KHQXUVHPXVWJLYHKLPPRUHEODQNHWV DQG KRW GULQNV :KHQ WKH SDWLHQW LV VZHDWLQJ UHSODFH WKH GDPS EHG FORWKHV DVTXLFNO\DVSRVVLEOH dZdfh`gh[uklj__ DQGGUHVVWKHSDWLHQW LQ D FOHDQ ZDUP EHGJRZQ ghqgZy jm[ZrdZ RU S\MDPDV >S~µ!.P~]@ ib`ZfZ :KHQ WKH WHPSHUDWXUH LV QRUPDO WKH SDWLHQW PD\VLWLQEHGDQG WKHQKDYHDVKRUWZDON MijZ`g_gby ,I_j_\_^bl_l_dklu 7KHFKLOGKDVDKLJKWHPSHUDWXUH+HZDQWVWRVOHHS+LVWKURDWLVVRUH KH FDQ KDUGO\ VZDOORZ DW DOO 7KH WRQVLOV DUH UHG DQG VZROOHQ 7KLV LV D W\SLFDOFDVHRIDFXWHWRQVLOOLWLVLQDFKLOG 7KHGRFWRUSUHVFULEHVDWUHDWPHQWWKDWLVHIIHFWLYHDQGWKHSDWLHQWJHWV EHWWHUYHU\VRRQ OVZDOORZ>µVZuORX@Y]ehlZlv 0U.LVD\HDUROGWHDFKHU+HFDPHWRWKHGRFWRUEHFDXVHRIDSHU VLVWHQWKHDGDFKH+LV%3ZDVWZRKXQGUHGRYHURQHKXQGUHG7KHGRFWRU GLDJQRVHGDUWHULDOVSDVP/XQJVZHUHFOHDU/LYHUQRWSDOSDEOH SHUVLVWHQW >S µVLVW QW@ Z a^ ihklhyg guc VSDVP>VSÙ]P@QkiZaf OLYHU QRW SDOSDEOH>µSÙOS~EO@i_q_gv g_ijhsmiu\Z_lky ,,BkijZ\vl_ke_^mxsb_ij_êh`_gby_kebhgbg_\_jguih kfukem H [ j Z a _ p )HYHULVWKHIDOORIWKHERG\WHPSHUDWXUHEHORZQRUPDO 7KLVLVZURQJ)HYHULVQRWWKHIDOORIWKHERG\WHPSHUDWXUHEHORZQRU PDO)HYHULVWKHULVHRIWKHERG\WHPSHUDWXUHDERYHQRUPDO 7KHV\PSWRPVRIKLJKWHPSHUDWXUHDUHDSDOHIDFHVORZSXOVHDQGD JRRGDSSHWLWH $IHYHULVKSHUVRQPXVWJRIRUDZDON 'XULQJWKHIHYHUWKHSDWLHQWQHHGVZDUPWK l_ieh $QXUVHPXVWQRWUHSODFHGDPSEHGFORWKHVZKHQDSDWLHQWLVVZHDW LQJ :KHQWKHWHPSHUDWXUHLVGRZQWRQRUPDOWKHSDWLHQWPXVWOLHLQEHG ,,, JZkkdZ`bl_ ihZg]ebckdb dZdb_ kbfilhfu ihy\eyxlky m [hevgh]hijb\ukhdhcl_fi_jZlmj_ ,9<uibrbl_bal_dklZbjZkkdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdbdZdgZ^h ihklmiZlvk[hevgufmdhlhjh]h\ukhdZyl_fi_jZlmjZ 9Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhkudjbkmgdm ³+HZDVKHUHDPRPHQWDJRZKHQ,ZDVSUHSDULQJ ]hlh\beZ KLVLQMHF WLRQ´ ,:KDWGR\RXVHHLQWKHSLFWXUH":KHUHLVWKHQXUVH":KDWGRHV WKHQXUVHKDYHLQKHUKDQG":KDWLVVKHJRLQJWRGR":KHUHLVWKHSD WLHQW"'R\RXWKLQNWKHSDWLHQWOLNHVWKHLQMHFWLRQ":KRLVWKHWKLUGSHU VRQLQWKHZDUG" A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRKDYHDUXQQLQJQRVH WRKDYHDFROG IOX>IOX@Q]jbii LQWKHKHDGbf_lvkbevgucgZkfhjd WRVWD\>VW~L@YhklZ\Zlvky WRVWULSWRWKHZDLVWjZa^_lvky^hihykZ VLFNOLVW>µVLNOLVW@Q[hevgbqgucebkl $9,6,72)$'2&725 2QHGD\P\PRWKHUIHOOLOO0\IDWKHUORRNHGDWKHUDQGVDLG<RXGRQ W ORRNZHOO:KDWLVWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX" ³,KDYHDEDGKHDGDFKHDQGDUXQQLQJQRVH /HW VWDNH\RXUWHPSHUD WXUH2K\RXUWHPSHUDWXUHLVYHU\KLJK,PXVWFDOOLQDGRFWRU ,QVRPHKRXUVWKHGRFWRUFDPH+HDVNHGP\PRWKHU:KDWLVWKHPDW WHUZLWK\RX",GRQ WIHHOZHOO,KDYHDUXQQLQJQRVHDFRXJKDEDGKHD G DFKHDQGDVRUHWKURDW :HOO,PXVWH[DPLQH\RX)LUVW,VKDOOIHHO\RXUSXOVH,WLVIDVW*LYH PH\RXUDUP,ZDQWWRFKHFN\RXU%33OHDVHEHTXLHWRU\RXUEORRGSUHV VXUHZLOOJRXS,W VRYHU7KDWLVDQRUPDO%3IRU\RX,¶OOOLVWHQWR \RXUKHDUWDQGOXQJV6WULSWRWKHZDLVW %UHDWKHSOHDVH1RZPDNHDGHHS EUHDWKDQGVWRSEUHDWKLQJIRUDPRPHQW$OOULJKW*RRQEUHDWKLQJSOHDVH 3OHDVH RSHQ \RXU PRXWK DQG VD\ DK 6KRZ PH \RXU WRQJXH , VHH \RX KDYH D IOX <RX PXVW VWD\ LQ EHG IRU VRPH GD\V ,OO SUHVFULEH \RX VRPH PHGLFLQH 7DNH LW UHJXODUO\ <RX DUH D QXUVH \RXUVHOI DQG \RX NQRZ LW LV QHFHVVDU\+HUHLVDVLFNOLVW IRU\RX&RPHWRPHLQWKUHHGD\VLI\RXIHHO EHWWHU*RRGE\H A:IHFGBL? Kms_kl\mxl ^\Z l_jfhf_ljZ êy baf_j_gby l_fi_jZlmju l_jfh f_ljP_evkby K bl_jfhf_ljNZj_g]_clZ ) qblZ_lky lZd WKLUW\VL[ SRLQW ILYH GHJUHHV &HOVLXV beb WKLUW\VL[ SRLQWILYH&HQWLJUDGH MijZ`g_gby ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb y \uibrm \Zf e_dZjkl\Z m f_gy kbevgZy ]heh\gZy [hev y ohqm ijh\_ jblv \Zr_ djh\ygh_ ^Z\e_gb_ hldjhcl_ jhlbkdZ`bl_©Zª\u^he`guihe_`Zlv \ihkl_ebg_kdhevdh^g_cmf_gy[hebl ]hjeh ihdZ`bl_ yaud qlh k \Zfb" y k_[y iehoh qm\kl\mx ^Z\e_gb_ ih^gb fZ_lky ûrbl_ g_ ûrbl_ wlh ghj fZevgh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ ,, KhklZ\vl_ b gZibrbl_ ij_êh `_gby ba ke_^mxsbo keh\ ijhqlb l_ dZ`^h_ ij_êh`_gb_ p_ebdhf b ih\lhjbl_ _]h g_ ]ey^y \ l_l jZ^v 0RWKHUGLGP\IHHOQRWZHOO GHFLGHGDGRFWRUPRWKHUFDOOLQWRP\ NHHSKHEHGPXVWLQGD\VIRUVRPH WKHWKUHHDGD\WLPHVGRFWRUKLPWRWDNHWROGPHGLFLQH ,OO<uibrbl_bal_dklZbaZihfgbl_l_njZaukdhlhjufb \jZqh[jZsZ_lkydiZpb_glmijbhkfhlj_ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH $ FKDPSLRQ ZDV WROG WKDW KH KDG D KLJK WHPSHUDWXUH +RZ KLJK LV LW 'RFWRU"KHDVNHG$KXQGUHGDQGRQH VDLGWKHGRFWRU$QGZKDWLVWKH ZRUOGUHFRUG fbjh\hcj_dhj^ "DVNHGWKHFKDPSLRQ A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WR FDWFK >NÙW @ Y FDXJKW >Nu W@ aZjZ KHZDVVLFNRI_fmgZ^h_eh ablvkyWRFDWFKDFROGijhklm^blvky VDXVDJH>µVuVL!@Qdhe[ZkZ WRVWUHQJWKHQ>VWUH¾~Q@Ymdj_ieylv WRVKLYHU> LY~@Y^jh`Zlv WRJDUJOH> J.JO@YihehkdZlv 3(7(&$8*+7$&2/' BBBBBBB IhNZj_g]_clmjZ\gy_lkyijb[ebabl_evgh°ihP_evkbx 2QFH3HWHFDPHKRPHIURPVFKRROYHU\HDUO\+HGLGQRWIHHOZHOO+H VKLYHUHGDQGVQHH]HGDWVFKRROVRWKHWHDFKHUVHQWKLPKRPH*UDQQ\ [Z [mrdZ WROGKLPWRJRWREHGDQGEURXJKWKLPDKRWZDWHUERWWOH$V3HWH KDGDVRUHWKURDWDQGDEDGFRXJK*UDQQ\JDYHKLPDJODVVRIKRWPLON6KH WRRNKLVWHPSHUDWXUH,WZDVKLJK²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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb iehohk_[yqm\kl\h\Ze_]hagh[behhgqboZe]j_edZ[hevgh_]hj eh kbevguc dZr_ev klZdZg ]hjyq_]h fhehdZ baf_jbeZ l_fi_jZlmjm l_fi_jZlmjZ[ueZ\ukhdhc\ua\ZeZ\jZqZ\ukemrZek_j^p_be_]db_ hkfhlj_e \k_ l_eh ihklZ\be ^bZ]gha \uibkZe e_dZjkl\h ihehkdZlv ]hjeh hklZ\Zlvky \ ihkl_eb ihl_jye Zii_lbl fgh]h ibe klZe [e_^ guflhb^_eh\iheg_a^hjh\ ,,Hibrbl_jbkmgdbgZk ,,,<klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dihôh^ysb_ihkfukemkeh\Zbebkeh\hkh q_lZgby^Zggu_gb`_ JDUJOHGORVWDSSHWLWHSUHVFULEHGDFRXJKPXVWDUGSODVWHUV 3HWHKDGDQGKLVPRWKHUSXWRQKLVEDFN+HDQGEHFDPH YHU\ ZHDN 7KH GRFWRU VRPH PHGLFLQH 6KH KHU WKURDW WKUHH WLPHV D GD\ ,9Ij_^klZ\vl_k_[_qlh\uijhklm^bebkvHibrbl_\Zr_khklhy gb_ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 6KH WRRN KHU KXVEDQG V WHPSHUDWXUH UHDG WKH WKHUPRPHWHU DQG JDYH D FDOOWRWKHGRFWRU 'HDU'RFWRUSOHDVHFRPHDWRQFH0\KXVEDQG VWHPSHUDWXUHLV 7KHGRFWRUVDLG'HDU0DGDP,FDQGRQRWKLQJ6HQGIRUWKHILUHEULJDGH ih`ZjgZydhfZg^Z A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm O SQHXPRQLD >QMX¶PRXQM~@ i \hkiZe_ gb_e_]dbo SDLQIXO>µSHLQIXO@Z[he_ag_gguc IOXVKHGSSihdjZkg_\r__ GHOLULXP>GL¶OLUL~P@i[j_^ 31(8021,$ 3QHXPRQLDEHJLQVVXGGHQO\,QPRVWFDVHVWKHWHPSHUDWXUHULVHVTXLFNO\ 7KHSXOVHDQGEUHDWKLQJDUHIDVW&RXJKEHJLQVHDUO\DQGDWILUVWLVGU\DQG SDLQIXO7KHSDWLHQWIHHOVLOOKDVDIOXVKHGIDFHDQGGU\WRQJXH ,QVHYHUHFDVHVWKHUHPD\EHGHOLULXP$SDWLHQWLQGHOLULXPLVYHU\UHVW OHVVDQGWKHQXUVHPXVWSD\VSHFLDODWWHQWLRQWRVXFKSDWLHQWV 3DWLHQWVZLWKSQHXPRQLDQHHGUHVWDQGVOHHS7KHEHVWSRVLWLRQIRUDSD WLHQW LV KDOIVLWWLQJ )UHVK DLU LV YHU\ LPSRUWDQW *LYH VXFK SDWLHQWV PXFK GULQN7KHGLHWPXVWEHOLJKW MIJ:@G?GBY ,<klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dkeh\Zbebkeh\hkhq_lZgbybal_d klZ ZDVLOOOLJKWIOXVKHGIDVWWRQJXHKDOIVLWWLQJ 7KHSDWLHQWZLWKSQHXPRQLD7KHSDWLHQWKDVDIDFHDQGDGU\ 7KHSXOVHDQGEUHDWKLQJDUH7KHEHVWSRVLWLRQLV7KHGLHWPXVWEH ,,I_j_kdZ`bl_l_dklQRke_^mxsbfdexq_\ufkeh\Zf ULVHVIDVWGU\SDLQIXOIHHOVLOOIOXVKHGIDFHGHOLULXPQHHGVUHVWIUHVK DLUPXFKGULQNOLJKW ,,,I_j_\_^bl_l_dFl $ \RXQJ PDQ RI IHOO LOO ZLWK WKH JULSSH 7KH LOOQHV EHJDQ ZLWK D FROD GXULQJVL[GD\VKHKDGIHYHU KLJKWHPSHUDWXUH DQGSDLQLQWKHOLPEV+H FRXJKHGDQGKDGDEDGKHDGDFKH2QWKHVHYHQWKGD\WKHGRFWRUVHQWKLPWR WKH KRVSLWDO LQ WKH KRVSLWDO WKH \RXQJ PDQ FRPSODLQHG RI WKH SDLQ LQ WKH OLPEVDQGLQWKHULJKWSDUWRIWKHFKHVW+LVWHPSHUDWXUHZDV°7KHGRFWRU GLDJQRVHG SQHXPRQLD DV D FRPSOLFDOLRQ DIWHU WKH JULSSH 7KH GRFWRU SUH VFULEHGVRPHVXOIDGUXJVZKLFKWKHSDWLHQWWRRNGXULQJDZHHN%\WKHHQG RIWKHZHHNKHIHOWDQGORRNHGPXFKEHWWHU+LVWHPSHUDWXUHIHOOWRQRUPDO KHVOHSWZHOODQGKLVDSSHWLWHZDVJRRG6RRQKHOHIWWKHKRVSLWDODQGZHQW WRDVDQDWRULXP O FRPSWLFDWLRQ >NuPSOL NHL Q@ Q hkeh` g_gb_ GUXJ>GUJ@Qe_dZjkl\hkj_^kl\h VXOID >µVOI~@ GUXJV kmevnZfb^gu_ ij_iZjZlu VDQDWRULXP >VÙQ~µWuUL~P@ Q kZgZ lhjbc /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 3 U R G X F H U R I W K H I L O P 1RZ\RXPXVWMXPSIURPWKHIRXUWKVWRU\ wlZ` :kWRU$QGLI,JHWLQMXUHGRUNLOOHG 3 U R G X F H U ,WGRHVQ¶WPDWWHU g_\Z`gh EHFDXVHLW¶VWKHODVWVFHQHLQWKH SLFWXUH ³<RXUOHJH[HUFLVHVKDYHDUULYHGDWODVW´ A:GYLB? I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl 75($70(17$1'1856,1*2)3$7,(176:,7++($57 ',6($6(6 5HVW LV RI JUHDWLPSRUWDQFHLQWKHWUHDWPHQWDQGQXUVLQJRIDKHDUWGLV HDVH 7KH SDWLHQW LV NHSW LQ EHG .HHS WKH SDWLHQW IUHH RI IHDU DQG ZRUU\ 7KHQXUVHPXVWZDVKDQGIHHGKLPXQWLOWKHGRFWRUVD\VKHPD\GRLWKLP VHOI7KHQWKHQXUVHPXVWDOORZ RQO\OLWWOHDFWVDWILUVWWKHQELJJHUDFWVKH PD\ZDVKKLVIDFHDQGQHFN7KHQDGD\hUWZRODWHUKLVDUPVDQGVRRQ 'RQ¶W NHHS SDWLHQWV LQ EHG ZKHQ WKH\ FRXOG EH LQ D FKDLU 'RQ¶W NHHS WKHPLQDFKDLUZKHQWKHGRFWRUDGYLVHGWKHPWRZDON WUHDWPHQW>µWULWP~QW@Qe_q_gb_ QXUVLQJ>µQ~VL¾@imoh^ WR NHHS IUHH RI a^ h]jZ`^Zlv h[_ j_]Zlv WRDOORZ>~µODX@Yiha\heylv MIJ:@G?GBY , KhklZ\vl_ b gZibrblz ij_êh`_gby ba ke_^mxsbo keh\ ijhqlbl_dZ`^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhfbih\lhjbl__]hg_ ]ey^y\l_ljZ^v LQSDWLHQWLVEHGNHSWWKH ZRUU\DQGWKHNHHSIHDURISDWLHQWIUHH DGYLVHGWKHWRZDONGRFWRUSDWLHQWWKH WKHKLVIDFHSDWLHQWDVNHGQXUVHWKHZDVKWRDQGQHFN ,,GZibrbl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZgl 5HVWLVRIJUHDWLPSRUWDQFHLQWKHQXUVLQJRIKHDUWGLVHDVHV6XFKDSD WLHQWLVQRWNHSWLQEHG7KHSDWLHQWPD\ZDVKKLPVHOIIURPWKHILUVWGD\VRI KLVLOOQHVV+HFDQHDWDWWKHWDEOH7KHSDWLHQWPXVWQRWGRPRUQLQJH[HU FLVHVGXULQJWKHILUVWGD\VRIKLVKHDUWGLVHDVH ,,,I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl )URPWKH+LVWRU\RI0HGLFLQH 7KHVHDUFKIRUKHDOWKLVDVROGDVPDQ VKLVWRU\,Q%DE\ORQLWZDVDFXV WRP WR VKRZ WKH VLFN LQ WKH VWUHHWV VR WKDW SDVVHUVE\ FRXOG VD\ KRZ WR WUHDWWKHVLFNIURPWKHLURZQH[SHULHQFH ,WZDVQRWDOORZHGWRSDVVWKHVLFN PDQLQVLOHQFH $SDS\UXVZDVIRXQGGDWHGIURP<K %&%HIRUH&KULVW^hgZ r_cwju DERXWVXUJHU\DQGWKHWUHDWPHQWRIZRXQGV7KHQDQRWKHUSDS\UXV ZDVIRXQGZLWKDERXWSUHVFULSWLRQVVRPHRIWKHVHSUHVFULSWLRQVGRFWRUV XVH WRGD\ 3HRSOH OHDUQW PXFK IURP (J\SWLDQ PDQXVFULSWV DQG IURP HP EDOPHGERGLHV([DPLQDWLRQVRIVRPHRIWKHVHERGLHVVKRZHGPDQ\LQWHU HVWLQJ IDFWV )RU H[DPSOH SHRSOH RI WKRVH WLPHV NQHZ VXFK GLVHDVHV DV UKHXPDWRLGDUWKULWLVWXEHUFXORVLVDQGDSSHQGLFLWLV ,VHDUFK>V~W @Qihbkd FXVWRP>µNVW~P@Qh[uqZc SDVVHUE\>µS.V~EDL@QSR[R`bc H[SHULHQFH>LNV¶SL~UL~QV@Qhiul `bag_gguc SDS\UXV>S~µSDL~U~V@QiZibjmk PDQXVFULSW >µPÙQMXVNULSW@ Q jmdh ibkv HPEDOPHG >LP¶E.PG@ D [ZevaZfbjh \Zgguc ,9Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDWZDVWKHFXVWRPLQ%DE\ORQ":KDWGLGSDVVHUVE\KDYHWRGR ZKHQWKH\SDVVHGDVLFNPDQ":KDWSDS\UXVZDVIRXQGGDWHGIURP %&":KDWGLGSHRSOHOHDUQIURP(J\SWLDQPDQXVFULSWVDQGHPEDOPHG ERGLHV" A:GYLB?AA <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm , LQIHFWLRXV >LQ IHN ~V@ Z bgn_d VSUHDG>VSUHG@QjZkijhkljZg_gb_ WR ZHDU >Z0~@ Y ZRUH >Zu@ ZRUQ pbhggucaZjZaguc >ZuQ@ ghkblv h^_`^m WRORRNDIWHUmoZ`b\Zlv aZ[hevguf JRZQ>JDXQ@QoZeZl WDVN>W.VN@QaZ^ZqZaZ^Zgb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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb aZ[hlblvky h [hevghf ij_^hl\jZlblv jZkijhkljZg_gb_ bgn_dpbb ghkblvfZkdmghkblvoZeZllsZl_evghfulvjmdb ,,AZdhgqbl_ij_êh`_gbybkihevamykeh\hkhq_lZgby^Zggu_ gb`_ ,WLVLPSRUWDQW ,WLVGDQJHURXV ,WLVZURQJ ,WLVQHFHVVDU\ QRWWRGLVLQIHFWEHGFORWKHVDIWHUXVHWRSUHYHQWWKHVSUHDGRILQIHFWLRQ WRZHDUDPDVNDQGDVSHFLDOJRZQWRSXWDQLQIHFWLRXVSDWLHQWDQGDWKHU D SHXWLFDO SDWLHQW LQWR WKH VDPH ZDUG WR ZDVK KDQGV FDUHIXOO\ DIWHU JRLQJ IURPDQLQIHFWLRXVSDWLHQW ,,, <uibrbl_ ba l_dklZ ijZ\beZ ih\_^_gby f_^jZ[hlgbdZ \ bgn_dpbhgghfhl^_e_gbbbjZkkdZ`bl_hgboihZg]ebckdb A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm VFDUOHWIHYHU>µVN.OLWµILY~@YkdZjeZ lbgZ WRSDVV>S.V@Yi_j_oh^blv WKURXJK>UX@SUHSq_j_akd\hav WRYRPLW>µYuPLW@YkljZ^Zlvj\hlhc WRUHPDLQ>UL¶PHLQ@YhklZ\Zlvky UDVK>UÙ @Qkuiv WRSHHO>SLO@Yr_emrblvky WRLVRODWH>µDLV~OHLW@Ybahebjh\Zlv QRXULVKLQJ>µQUL L¾@ZiblZl_evguc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klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dke_^mxsb_keh\Zbkeh\hkhq_lZgby bal_dklZih\lhjbl_dZ`^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhf DVNLQUDVKPRXWKQRVHLQIHFWLRXVGLVHDVHVEHLVRODWHGIOXVKHG 7KH GLVHDVH SDVVHV WKURXJK WKH DQG 7KH IDFH LV 7KHFKLOGZLWKVFDUOHWIHYHUPXVW 7KHILUVWV\PSWRPLQPDQ\ LV« ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDWPXVWZHGRWRSUHYHQWWKH VSUHDGRILQIHFWLRQ":KDWLVWKH ILUVW V\PSWRP RI PDQ\ LQIHFWLRXV GLVHDVHV" :KDW DUH WKH ILUVW V\PSWRPVRIVFDUOHWIHYHU" +RZ FDQ WKH GLVHDVH SDVV IURP RQHSHUVRQWRDQRWKHU" :KDW GLHW PXVW D FKLOG ZLWK VFDUOHWIHYHUKDYH" ³&RPHLQ+HLVLQJRRGKHDOWKQRZ´ ,,, GZah\bl_ ihZg]ebckdb \k_ kbfilhfu ijb aZ[he_\Zgbb kdZjeZlbghc A:GYLB? <umqbl_Feh\Zdl_dklm PHDVOHV>µPL]O]@idhjv VLJQ>VDLQ@QagZdijbagZd GLVOLNH>GLV¶ODLN@ig_ijbyagvhl\jZ s_gb_ K\JLHQH>µKDL!LQ@Q]b]b_gZ PRLVW>PuLVW@Z\eZ`guc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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb ijbagZd kbevghc ijhklmû qbkluc b \eZ`guc aZ mrZfb bgn_d pbhggh_aZ[he_\Zgb_i_j\u_kbfilhfu[ulv\gbfZl_evguf]b]b_gZ jlZij_^hl\jZlblvjZkijhkljZg_gb_bgn_dpbb ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku ,V PHDVOHV DQ LQIHFWLRXV GLVHDVH" +RZ GRHV WKH GLVHDVH SDVV" :KDWDUHWKHV\PSWRPVRIPHDVOHV"+RZPXVWWKHQXUVHORRNDIWHUDSD WLHQWZLWKPHDVOHV" ,,,Ijhqlbl_hl\_lfZl_jbmdhlhjhcaZ[he_ej_[_ghdb ijb^mfZcl_\hijhkdhlhjucf_^k_kljZaZ^ZeZ[u_c 1bUV_" 0 R W K H U 0\VRQKDVDYHU\KLJKWHPSHUDWXUH 1" 0<HVKHKDVDUXQQLQJQRVHDQGDGU\FRXJKWRR 1" 0<HVWKHOLJKWERWKHUVKLPYHU\PXFK 1" 07KHUDVKDSSHDUHG\HVWHUGD\ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 0 R W K H U %REE\ZK\DUH\RXVWDQGLQJLQIURQWRIWKHPLUURUZLWK\RXU H\HVFORVHG" % R E E \ , ZDQW WR VHH ZKDW , ORRN OLNH dZd y \u]ey`m ZKHQ ,¶P VOHHSLQJ 2QHGD\DQDEVHQWPLQGHG jZkk_ygguc GRFWRUZHQWWRWKHKRVSLWDO+H SXWDQRWH7KHGRFWRULVRXWRQKLVGRRU:KHQKHFDPHKRPHIURPKLV ZRUNKHVDZWKHQRWHRQWKHGRRUUHDGLWDQGVDLG2KKHLVQRWDWKRPH, VKDOOFRPHODWHU iha^g__ A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,LQIOXHQ]D>LQIOX¶HQ]~@Q]jbii\bjmk gucbgnexwgpZ PLOG>PDLOG@Zaê_]dbc GHSUHVVHG>GL SUHVW@SDUW,,iR^Z\e_g guc ,1)/8(1=$ ,QIOXHQ]D LV D YHU\ LQIHFWLRXV GLVHDVH 7KH GLVHDVH FDQ EH PLOG RU VH YHUH 7KH V\PSWRPV RI LQIOXHQ]D DUH KLJK WHPSHUDWXUH KHDGDFKH JHQHUDO SDLQV ,QPRVWFDVHVWKHSDWLHQWPXVWVWD\LQEHGEHZDUPGULQNPXFKZDWHU 7KHSDWLHQWPXVWVWD\LQEHGXQWLOWKHWHPSHUDWXUHLVQRUPDODQGIRUWKHQH[W WZRRUWKUHHGD\VKHPD\EHXSIRURQO\VKRUWSHULRGV$IWHULQIOXHQ]DS D WLHQWVIHHOZHDNDQGRIWHQGHSUHVVHG $VLQIOXHQ]DLVYHU\LQIHFWLRXV\RXPXVWUHPHPEHU 1HYHU VKDNH KDQGV ZKHQ \RX KDYH D FROG &ROGV SDVV WKURXJK q_j_a WKHKDQGV%XWGRQ WVD\,FDQQRWVKDNHKDQGV,KDYHDFROG/HWLWEHDV LI\RXIRUJRW aZ[ueb WRVKDNHKDQGV%XW\RXPXVWEHYHU\SROLWH \_èb \uc LQVSHHFK MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb ly`_eh_aZ[he_\Zgb_\ukhdZyl_fi_jZlmjZ[heb\h\k_fl_e_e_] dbckemqZchklZ\Zlvky\ihkl_ebqm\kl\h\Zlvk_[ykeZ[uf ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku 'R\RXNQRZWKHV\PSWRPVRILQIOXHQ]D"+RZORQJPXVWWKHSD WLHQWVWD\LQEHG"+RZGRHVWKHSDWLHQWIHHODIWHULQIOXHQ]D" ,,, <uibrbl_ ba l_dklZ b i_j_kdZ`bl_ ihZg]ebckdb j_dh f_g^Zpbb[hevghfm]jbiihf ,9IhklZ\vl_\hijhkudke_^mxsbfhl\_lZf ,QIOXHQ]DLVDYHU\LQIHFWLRXVGLVHDVH7KHV\PSWRPVRILQIOXHQ]D DUHKLJKWHPSHUDWXUHKHDGDFKHJHQHUDOSDLQV 7KHSDWLHQWPXVWVWD\LQ EHG $IWHULQIOXHQ]DWKHSDWLHQWVIHHOZHDN 9I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl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µLQIOX¶HQ]~@Q]jbii MRLQW>!uLQW@QkmklZ\ WREHKRDUVH>KRV@Yhojbigmlv WRVQHH]H>VQL]@YqboZlv WRVWD\>VWHL@YhklZ\Zlvky /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH $UH\RXIHHOLQJYHU\LOO"DVNHGWKHGRFWRU6KRZPH\RXUWRQJXH ,W¶VQRXVH'RFWRUVDLGWKHSDWLHQW1RWRQJXHFDQWHOO\RXKRZLOO, IHHO A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ULFNHWV> ULNLWV@QjZobl VLGH>VDLG@QklhjhgZ[hd SURWUXGLQJ>SU~WUXGL¾@Za^jZoblbqguc EHOO\> EHOL@Q`b\hl ODFN RI Qg_^hklZlhdhlkmlkl\b_ 5,&.(76 7KH ILUVW V\PSWRPV RI ULFNHWVPD\DSSHDUYHU\HDUO\ZKHQWKHFKLOGLV RQO\RUPRQWKVROG 7KH EDFN RI WKH KHDG VZHDWV DQG D ZHW SODFH DSSHDUV RQ WKH SLOORZ 7KH EDE\WRVVHV \_jlbl KLVKHDGIURPVLGHWRVLGHDQGWKHEDFNRIWKHEDE\ V KHDGEHFRPHVEDOG eukuc 7KH FKLOG RIWHQ FULHV VOHHSV EDGO\ 7KH FKLOG KROGV XS KLV KHDG ODWHU WKDQ RWKHU FKLOGUHQ GR VLWV ODWHU ZDONV ODWHU *URZQ XS FKLOGUHQ ZLWK ULFNHWV KDYHSURWUXGLQJEHOOLHVELJKHDGVDQGFURRNHG bkdjb\e_gguc OHJV 7KH FDXVH RI ULFNHWV LV ODFN RI VXQOLJKW YLWDPLQ ' LQ WKH IRRG DQG ZURQJFDUHRIWKHFKLOGUHQ ,IDPRWKHUIHHGVKHUEDE\FRUUHFWO\NHHSVWKHEDE\LQWKHRSHQDLUIRU PDQ\KRXUVKHUEDE\ZLOOQRWKDYHULFNHWV MIJ:@G?GBY , <klZ\vl_ \f_klh lhq_d keh\Z ULFNHWV DSSHDU VLGH beb VZHDW Z aZl_fijhqlbl_dZ`^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhf 7KHSDWLHQWIHOWSDLQLQKLVULJKW5HGUDVKRQKLVERG\/DFNRI YLWDPLQ'LQWKHIRRGPD\FDXVH+HZRUNHGKDUGLQWKHJDUGHQDQG KLVIDFHZDVFRYHUHGZLWK ,, I_j_\_^bl_ h[ty\e_gb_ dhlhjh_ fh`gh \b^_lv \ ^_lkdhc iheb debgbd_ bkihevamcl_keh\Zbal_dklZ Jh^bl_eb>_lb^he`gufgh]hgZoh^blvkygZk\_`_f\ha^mo_IjZ \bevghdhjfbl_k\hbo^_l_c^Z\Zcl_bf\blZfbg©>ª±\k_wlhihfh `_l\Zf\ujZklblv JURZXS a^hjh\uoj_[yl ,QWHUHVWLQJ)DFWV )HVWLYDO )RU PDQ\ FHQWXULHV SHRSOH RI VRPH YLOODJHV LQ (QJODQG GUHVV WKHLU ZHOOVHDFK\HDURQDFHUWDLQGD\ 'XULQJWKHGUHDGIXOGD\VRIWKH%ODFN'HDWK VRWKHSODJXH ZDVFDOOHG±PDQ\SHRSOHGLHGLQ(QJODQG%XWWKHSHRSOHRIVRPHYLOODJHV VXUYLYHGWKDQNVWRWKHFOHDQQHVV RIWKHLUZHOOV:KHQLQWKHSODJXH HQGHGWKHILUVWIHVWLYDOZDVKHOG LQWKRVHYLOODJHV 3HRSOHGHFRUDWHGWKHLUZHOOVZLWKIORZHUVZLWKEHDXWLIXOJDUODQGV ]bj eygû 7KHVHIHVWLYDOVDUHKHOGHDFK\HDU FHQWXU\>µVHQW XUL@Q\_d WRGUHVV>GUHV@YgZjy`Zlv ZHOO>ZHO@Qdheh^_p GUHDGIXO>µGUHGIXO@DkljZrguc SODJXH>SOHLJ@QqmfZ VXUYLYH>V~µYDLY@YhklZlvky\`b\uo FOHDQQHVV>µNOLQQLV@QqbklhlZ ZDVKHOGa^[uemkljh_g WRGHFRUDWH>µGHN~UHLW@YmdjZrZlv A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm VXUJLFDO>µV~!LN~O@Zobjmj]bq_kdbc GHSDUWPHQW>GL¶S.WP~QW@Qhl^_e_gb_ VXUJHRQ> V~!~Q@Qobjmj] SRVWRSHUDWLYH>µSRXVW uS~U~WLY@Zih ke_hi_jZpbhgguc UHDFWLRQ>UL¶ÙN ~Q@Qa^hkeh`g_gb_ VZHOOLQJQa^\hkiZe_gb_ RSHUDWLQJURRP> uj~U_LWL¾@Q hi_jZpbhggZy GUHVVLQJ>µGUHVL¾@Qi_j_\yadZ ih\yadZ ZRXQG>ZXQG@QjZgZ GXW\>µGMXWL@Qh[yaZgghklv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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb khklhygb_ [hevgh]h ihke_ hi_jZpbb objmj]bq_kdh_ hl^_e_gb_ hk fZljb\Zlv[hevguo^Z\Zlvg_h[oh^bfu_bgkljmdpbbhi_jbjh\Zlvljb jZaZ\g_^_exobjmj]bq_kdZyk_kljZiZeZlgZyk_kljZhimohev ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KHUH GRHV $QQ V IDWKHU ZRUN" :KHQ GRHV KLV ZRUN EHJLQ" :KRPGRHVKHDVNDERXWWKHSDWLHQWV FRQGLWLRQ"+DVKHPDQ\RSHUDWLRQV GXULQJDZHHN"+DYH\RXEHHQDWDVXUJLFDOGHSDUWPHQW" ,,, GZc^bl_ \ l_dkl_ keh\Z dhlhju_ fh`gh khq_lZlv kh keh\Zfb SRVWRSHUDWLYH VXUJLFDO /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ) L U V W Z R P D Q 0\VRQLVLQEHGDYLFWLP `_jl\Z IRRWEDOO 6 H F R Q G Z R P D Q %XW,GLGQ WNQRZWKDWKHSOD\HGIRRWEDOO ) L U V W Z R P D Q +HGRHVQ W%XWKHLVDIRRWEDOOIDQ [he_evsbdnml[h eZ DQG KH VSUDLQHG KLV ODU\Q[ a^ ihl_jye ]hehk DW WKH PDWFK ODVW 6XQGD\ A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,DPEXODQFH>µÙPEMXO~QV@ifZrbgZ kdhjhcihfhsb DEGRPLQDO>~E¶GuPLQO@Z[jxrghc DSSHQGLFLWLV>~SHQGL¶VDLWLV@QZii_g^b pbl JRZQ>JDXQ@QoZeZl JORYH>JOY@Qi_jqZldZ DQDHVWKHVLD>ÙQLV¶L]M~@QZg_kl_aby h[_a[heb\Zgb_ VFDOSHO>µVNÙOS~O@QkdZevi_ev WRODVW>O.VW@Yijh^he`Zlvky VXFFHVVIXO>V~N¶VHVIXO@Zm^Zqguc ,17+(23(5$7,1*5220 , VDZ VRPH RSHUDWLRQV GXULQJ P\ SUDFWLFH LQ WKH RSHUDWLQJURRP <HV WHUGD\DQ DPEXODQFH EURXJKWDPDQWRRXUKRVSLWDO7KHSDWLHQWIHOWDVH YHUHDEGRPLQDOSDLQ7KHGRFWRUGLDJQRVHG DSSHQGLFLWLV 7KHSDWLHQWZDVSUHSDUHGIRUWKHRSHUDWLRQDQGSXWRQWKHRSHUDWLQJWDEOH 7KHGRFWRUZDVKHGKLVDUPVDQGKDQGVGULHGWKHPRQDVWHULOHWRZHOSXWRQ WKHJRZQDQGWKHJORYHV7KHDVVLVWDQWJDYHWKHSDWLHQWDQDHVWKHVLD7KH QXUVHJDYHWKHVXUJHRQDVFDOSHODQGKHEHJDQWKHRSHUDWLRQ,WODVWHGIRU DERXWDQKRXUDQGZDVVXFFHVVIXO MIJ:@G?GBY ,I_j_\_^bl_gZjmkkdbcyaudke_^mxsb_keh\Zbkeh\hkhq_lZ gby GXULQJ P\ SUDFWLFH DQ DPEXODQFH IHOW D VHYHUH DEGRPLQDO SDLQ GLDJ QRVHGDSSHQGLFLWLVDVWHULOHWRZHOSXWRQWKHJRZQWKHJORYHVJDYHKLP DQDHVWKHVLDDVFDOSHOODVWHGZDVVXFFHVVIXO ,,IhaZ^Zgghcfh^_ebihklZ\vl_\hijhkuddZ`^hfmij_êh`_gbx hl\_lvl_gZwlb\hijhku :KRIHOW":KDWIHHO":DVVHYHUH" 7KHSDWLHQWIHOWDVHYHUHDEGRPLQDOSDLQ :KDW«GR":KDWSXWRQ":K\DVWHULOHWRZHO" 7KHGRFWRUZDVKHGKLVKDQGVGULHGWKHPRQDVWHULOHWRZHOSXWRQ WKHJRZQDQGWKHJORYHV ,,,=ey^ygZjbkmghdgZkjZkkdZ`bl_qlh^_eZ_l^hdlhji_j_^ l_fdZdijbklmiblvdhi_jZpbb ,9KhklZ\vl_bgZibrbl_ij_êh`_gbybake_^mxsbokeh\aZl_f ijhqlbl_dZ`^h_ij_êh`_gb_p_ebdhfbih\lhjbl__]hg_]ey ^y\l_ljZ^v LQVDZURRPRSHUDWLQJ,RSHUDWLRQVVRPHWKH EHIRUHGRFWRUDUPVWKHZDVKHGRSHUDWLRQWKHKLVKDQGVDQG WKHJDYHWRVFDOSHOQXUVHDVXUJHRQWKH VXFFHVVIXORSHUDWLRQWKHZDV A:GYLB? ,QWHUHVWLQJ)DFWV I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl 7KH0DQ:KR'LVFRYHUHG&KORURIRUP 0DQ\\HDUVDJRQRERG\NQHZDERXWFKORURIRUP$QGZKHQWKHGRFWRU RSHUDWHG RQ D SDWLHQW WKH SDWLHQW VXIIHUHG JUHDW SDLQ $ \RXQJ GRFWRU LQ (GLQEXUJK>µHGLQE~U~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µVI~@YkljZ^Zlv WR RYHUFRPH >RXY~NP@ RYHUFDPH RYHUFRPH ih[_^blv ij_\hafhqv a^ kgylv WRORRNIRUYbkdZlv XQSOHDVDQW>Q¶SOH]QW@Zg_ijbylguc VPHOO>VPHO@QaZiZo WREUHDWKHLQ>µEULçLQ@Y\^hogmlv GLVFRYHU\>GLV¶NY~UL@QRldjulb_ WRKXUW>K~W@Y KXUWKXUW ijbqbgblv [hev MIJ:@G?GB? Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW ZDV WKH QDPH RI WKH GRFWRU ZKR GLVFRYHUHG FKORURIRUP" :KHUHGLGKHOLYH"+RZGLGKHGLVFRYHUWKHSRVVLELOLWLHV \hafh`ghklb RIFKORURIRUP"'R\RXWKLQNLWZDVDEUDYHDFWLRQ":K\":K\ZDVWKH GLVFRYHU\RIFKORURIRUPYHU\LPSRUWDQW"+RZGLG'U6LPSVRQKHOSWKH SDWLHQWV" <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm WRWRXFK>WW @YdZkZlvkyljh]Zlv VZDE>VZuE@QlZfihg VWLWFK>VWLW @Qkl_`hdrh\ IRUFHSV VLQJbSO >µIuVHSV@Q ibgp_lobjmj]bq_kdb_sbipu WRSURWHFW>SU~µWHNW@YaZsbsZlv GXVW>GVW@Qiuev VHFXUH>VL¶NMX~@ZijhqgucgZ^_`guc 1XUVH V:RUNDWWKH6XUJLFDO'HSDUWPHQW )URPP\SUDFWLFHDWWKHVXUJLFDOGHSDUWPHQW,OHDUQWVRPHYHU\LPS RU WDQWWKLQJVWKDW,WKLQNHYHU\QXUVHPXVWUHPHPEHU :KHQWKHQXUVHSXWVWKHGUHVVLQJRUFKDQJHVLWVKHPXVWZHDUDPDVN 7KH QXUVH V ILQJHUV PXVW QRW WRXFK DQ\ VWHULOH PDWHULDO 7KH QXUVH PXVWWDNHWKHVZDEVGUHVVLQJVRUWDNHRXWWKHVWLWFKHVRQO\ZLWKIRUFHSV 7KHQXUVHPXVWNHHSWKHZRXQGGU\ 0RVWVXUJLFDOZRXQGVQHHGFDUHIXODWWHQWLRQ7KHQXUVHZKRWDNHVFDUH RI WKH ZRXQGV PXVW SURWHFW WKHP IURP GXVW DQG PDNH WKH GUHVVLQJ VH FXUH MIJ:@G?GBY ,AZdhgqbl_ij_êh`_gbybkihevamykeh\hkhq_lZgby^Zggu_gb`_ ,WLVLPSRUWDQW,WLVQHFHVVDU\,WLVGDQJHURXVWRWRXFKVWHULOHPD WHULDOZLWKILQJHUVWRZHDUDPDVNWRWDNHRXWWKHVWLWFKHVZLWKIRUFHSV ,,I_j_\_^bl_jmkkdb_keh\hkhq_lZgbygZZg]ebckdbcyaudb aZdhgqbl_ij_êh`_gby 7KH QXUVH PXVW ghkblv fZkdm dh]^Z f_gy_l ih\yadm 7KH QXUVHPXVWQRW ljh]Zlvkl_jbevgucfZl_jbZeiZevpZfb 7KHQXUVH PXVW [jZlvlZfihguih\yadblhevdhibgp_lhf 7KHQXUVHPXVW aZsblblvjZgmhliueb ,,,Ihkfhljbl_gZjbkmghdbhl\_lvl_ gZ\hijhku :KHUHDUHWKHQXUVHDQGWKHSDWLHQW" :KDWLVWKHQXUVHJRLQJWRGR":KDW LV VKH KROGLQJ LQ KHU KDQGV" ,V WKH SDWLHQWDIUDLGRUQRW" ,9JZkkdZ`bl_hjZ[hl_iZeZlghck_klju\objmj]bq_kdhfhl^_e_ gbb /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH $:KHQ,ZDVLQKRVSLWDO e_`Ze\[hevgbp_ DOOP\IULHQGVFDPHWRVHH PHHYHU\YLVLWLQJGD\ %2K\RXKDYHYHU\QLFHIULHQGV $<HVDQG,KDGDYHU\QLFHQXUVH A:GYLB? I_j_\_^bl_l_dklu )5207+(+,6725<2)0(',&,1( 7KH FOLQLFDO PHGLFLQH DQG VDIHJXDUG RI SHRSOH V KHDOWK JUHDWO\ GHYHO RSHGLQ5RPDQWLPHV7KHQDPHRI*DOHQ>µJHLOLQ@LVZLGHO\NQRZQ*DOHQ ZRUNHGILUVWDVDVXUJHRQDWDVFKRROIRUJODGLDWRUV +HZHQWWR5RPHZKHQ KHZDVWKLUW\WZR\HDUVROGDQGWKHUHKHKDGPXFKSUDFWLFHEXWKHFRQWLQ XHGWRH[SHULPHQWRQOLYLQJDQLPDOVHVSHFLDOO\DSHV DQGSLJV7KH5RPDQ DUP\ DOZD\V KDG D ZHOO RUJDQL]HG VHUYLFH RI VXUJHRQV 7KH VFKRRO IRU JODGLDWRUVZDVDQLGHDOVFKRROIRUWUDLQLQJ LQVXUJHU\ ,VDIHJXDUG>µVHLIJ.G@QhojZgZ WRGHYHORS>GL¶YHO~S@YjZa\b\Zlv JODGLDWRU>µJOÙGLHLW~@Q]eZ^bZlhj DSH>HLS@Q q_eh\_dhh[jZagZy h[_av ygZ WRRUJDQL]H>µuJ~QDL]@YRSUDgbah \ZlvmkljZb\Zlv VHUYLFH>µV~YLV@Qkem`[Z WUDLQLQJ>µWUDLQL¾@Qlj_gbjh\dZ $&$6(+,6725< ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± ± :KDWGLVHDVHVKDG\RXLQWKHSDVW" ,KDGWKHPXPSVVFDUOHWIHYHUDQGSQHXPRQLD±$QGPHDVOHV ZKRRSLQJFRXJKFKLFNHQSR[" <HV,KDGDOOWKHFKLOGKRRGGLVHDVHV :KDWDERXWDGXOWGLVHDVHV"+DG\RX7% KHDUWRUNLGQH\WURXEOH" 1R +DG\RXDQ\RSHUDWLRQV" <HV,KDGP\DSSHQGL[RXWDQGP\WRQVLOVDUHRXWWRR 'LG\RXHYHUEUHDNDQ\ERQHV" ,EURNHP\DUPZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOGDQGWKDW¶VDOO FDVHKLVWRU\bklhjby[he_agb PXPSV>PPSV@Qk\bgdZ L<>µWL¶EL@ FRdS lm[_jdme_a +2:$3,/27%528*+70(',&,1( /LWWOH 1LQD OLYHG LQ WKH IDU QRUWK RI WKH 5XVVLD LQ D OLWWOH YLOODJH 1LQD KDGQHYHUVHHQDWUDLQRUDQDLUSODQH6KHVDZRQO\ERDWV%RDWVFDPHWRKHU YLOODJHRQO\LQVXPPHU1RERDWVFDPHLQZLQWHUDWDOO%XW1LQDOLNHGKHU YLOODJH YHU\ PXFK 6KH OLNHG WR VOLGH RQ WKH VQRZ DQG WR PDNH VQRZEDOOV DQGVQRZPHQ %XWQRZ1LQDFRXOGQRWSOD\6KHFRXOGQ WHYHQHDW1LQDZDVYHU\LOO 7KHUHLVRQO\RQHPHGLFLQHWKDWZLOOPDNH1LQDZHOOVDLGWKHGRFWRU $QG,KDYHQ WJRWWKLVPHGLFLQH:HFDQJHWLWRQO\LQDELJFLW\,¶OOVHQGD WHOHJUDPDWRQFH,QDIDUDZD\FLW\WKLVPHGLFLQHZDVJLYHQWRDSLORW7KH SLORWZDQWHGWREULQJPHGLFLQHLQWLPH$OOWKHSHRSOHZHUHZDLWLQJIRUWKH DLUSODQH6RRQWKHSODQHODQGHGRQWKHVQRZDQGWKHSLORWJDYHWKHPHGLFLQH WRWKHGRFWRU6ROLWWOH1LQDZDVVDYHG Ijhqlbl_bi_j_\_^bl_klbohl\hj_gb_ 0\0RWKHU :KRIHGPHZKHQ,ZDVDFKLOG $QGKHOGPHLQKHUDUPVVRNLQG" ±0\PRWKHU :KRVDWDQGZDWFKHGP\FKLOGLVKKHDG :KHQ,ZDVVOHHSLQJLQP\EHG" ±0\PRWKHU :KHQSDLQDQGLOOQHVVPDGHPHFU\ :KRORRNHGXSRQP\KHDY\H\H" ±0\PRWKHU :KRUDQWRKHOSPHZKHQ,IHOO $QGZRXOGVRPHIXQQ\VWRU\WHOO" ±0\PRWKHU $QGFDQ,HYHUVWRSWREH 6RORYLQJDQGVRNLQGWRWKHH :KRZDVVRYHU\NLQGWRPH 0\PRWKHU" $QGZKHQ\RXDUHVLFNDQGROGDQGJUH\ 0\KHDOWK\DUPVKDOOEH\RXUVWD\ $QG,VKDOOFDOP\RXUSDLQVDZD\ 0\PRWKHU )URP3RHPV6RQJV3OD\V3URVYHLFKHQLH0 IXQQ\>µIQL@Zkf_rghc ZRXOG>ZXG@WHOOh[uqghjZkkdZau\Z eZZRXOGi_j_^Z_la^_kvih\lhjy_ fhklv^_ckl\by WRWKHH>çL@ QRwP dl_[_ FDOPDZD\kfy]qZlvmkihdZb\Zlv A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ZHDOWK>ZHO@i[h]Zlkl\h PDWFK >PÙW @i FRQWHVW > NuQWHVW@Q } khklyaZgb_fZlq WREHRYHUdhgqZlv URXQG>UDXQG@Zdjm]euckmlmeuc WRJRLQIRUaZgbfZlvky VLFN>VLN@Z[hevghc WRWLUH>µWDL~@YmklZ\Zlvmlhf eylvky WRGHYHORS>GL¶YHO~S@YjZa\b\Zlv SOHDVXUH>µj__@im^h\hevkl\b_ SDUWLFLSDQW>j.¶WLVLS~QW@imqZkl gbd VSHFWDWRU>VSHN WHLW~@iajbl_ev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dZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb aZgbfZlvky kihjlhf djh\hh[jZs_gb_ mdj_ieylv a^hjh\v_ ^hklZ \blvm^h\hevkl\b_jZa\b\ZlvfurpujZ[hlZk_j^pZ ,,DZd^_ckl\mxlnbabq_kdb_mijZ`g_gbygZhj]Zgbafq_eh\_ dZ"<uibrbl_bal_dklZ\k_ªqlhhlghkblkydwlhcl_ f_ ,,,Ih^[_jbl_ih^\Zkeh\Zkijhlb\hiheh`gufagZq_gb_f H [ j Z a _ p FROG²KRW JRRGJLYHJROLNHVLFNVWURQJWDNHFRPHKDWHEDGKHDOWK\ZHDN ,9I_j_\_^bl_h[ty\e_gb_dhlhjh_fh`ghbgh]^Zm\b^_lv\ rdhe_ FZevqbdbb^_\hqdb AZgbfZcl_kvkihjlhfKihjlmdj_ibl\Zr_a^hjh\v_b^hklZ\bl\Zf m^h\hevkl\b_Ijboh^bl_\gZrmkihjlb\gmxk_dpbx VSRUWVRFLHW\ 9I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl *$0(6$1'632576 7HQQLVDQGWDEOHWHQQLVDUHZRQGHUIXOJDPHV<RXQJDQGJURZQXSSHR SOHFDQSOD\WKRVHJDPHV 7KH\JLYHJRRGSK\VLRORJLFDO>IL]L ~ Ou!LN~O@UHVXOWVRQWKHERG\ 6ZLPPLQJLVDYHU\JRRGIRUPRIH[HUFLVH7KHUHLVDULYHURUDVZLP PLQJSRROLQPDQ\WRZQV<RXPD\SUDFWLVHVZLPPLQJLQZLQWHUDVZHOODV LQVXPPHU +LNLQJ lmjbaf LVYHU\SRSXODUDPRQJWKH\RXWK7KHVXQ VUD\VVOHHS DQG JDPHV LQ WKH RSHQ DLU DUH YHU\ LPSRUWDQW IRU \RXQJ PHQ *URZQXS SHRSOHDOVROLNHKLNLQJ7KHVXQDQGWKHDLUDUHJRRGPHGLFLQHV :DONLQJDQGUXQQLQJDUHYHU\JRRGH[HUFLVHV<RXPXVWEUHDWKHWKURXJK \RXU QRVH ZKHQ \RX UXQ /HDUQ KRZ WR SOD\ DQG OHDUQ WR SOD\ ZHOO 3OD\ ZHOODQGSOD\WRZLQ JDPH b]jZ b b]jh\hc \b^ kihjlZ VSRUWV g_b]jh\hc \b^ khklyaZgbc nml[hel_ggbkbl^ ieZ\Zgb_eu`bdhgvdb A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm VWLFN>VWLN@QiZedZ KHDWWUHDWPHQW> KLW WULWP~QW@ e_q_gb_l_iehf PDVVDJH> PÙV.@ifZkkZ` WRNHHSXS>µNLSS@Yijh^he`Zlv WRFDUU\RXW>µNÙULµDXW@Y\uihegylv LQVWUXFWLRQ>LQ¶VWN ~Q@imdZaZgb_ bgkljmdpby WR JURZ OHVV >µJURX¶OHV@ klZgh\blvky f_gvr_ $%2870<81&/( :KHQP\XQFOHZDV VL[W\ILYH \HDUVROGKHFRXOGQRWZDONZLWKRXW DVWLFN+LVULJKWOHJKXUWKLPYHU\PXFK+HFRQVXOWHGDGRFWRU7KHGRF WRUH[DPLQHGKLPFDUHIXOO\+HVHQWWKHSDWLHQWWR;UD\DQGZKHQP\XQFOH EURXJKW WKH ;UD\ SLFWXUH WKH GRFWRU JDYH KLP KHDW WUHDWPHQW PDVVDJH DQGH[HUFLVHVWZLFHRU WKUHHWLPHVDZHHNIRUWKUHHPRQWKV$WWKHHQGRI WKDW WLPH WKH GRFWRU DGYLVHG KLP WR NHHS XS WKH H[HUFLVHV HYHU\ GD\ 0\ XQFOH FDUULHGRXWDOOKLVLQVWUXFWLRQVDQGWKHSDLQ JUHZOHVVDQGWKHROG PDQFRXOGHYHQZDONZLWKRXWDVWLFN ,Hibrbl_jbkmghd MIJ:@G?GBY ,,AZihfgbl_ 6LPSOH5XOHVIRU+HDOWK Klhcijyfh 6WDQGHUHFW>L¶UHNW@ Kb^bijyfh 6LWHUHFW >urbdZdfh`gh]em[`_ %UHDWKHLQDVPXFKIUHVKDLUDV\RX FDQ 6OHHSZLWK\RXUZLQGRZVRSHQHYHU\ Kib\k_]^Zkhldjulhcnhjlhqdhc QLJKW >_j`bgh]bkmobfbb\l_ie_ .HHS\RXUIHHWGU\DQGZDUP Ke_^baZqbklhlhcl_eZ .HHS\RXUERG\FOHDQ Ghkbqbklmxh^_`^m :HDUFOHDQFORWKHV Ke_^baZqbklhlhcam[h\ .HHS\RXUWHHWKFOHDQ :KHQ\RXDUHUHDGLQJRUZULWLQJOHW Dh]^ZluqblZ_rvbebibr_rv k\_l^he`_g[ulvke_\Z WKHOLJKWFRPHIURPEHKLQG\RXUOHIW VKRXOGHU =meycdZdfh`gh[hevr_gZk\_ 7DNHORQJZDONVLQWKHRSHQDLUDV `_f\ha^mo_ PXFKDV\RXFDQ Kibg_f_g__qZkh\\kmldb *HWSOHQW\RIVOHHS ,,,Ijhqlbl_bi_j_\_^bl_klbohl\hj_gb_ 7KH'RFWRU :KHQ,DPLOO,JRWREHG $QGRQWKHSLOORZOD\P\KHDG 7KHGRFWRUFRPHVDQGVD\V'HDUPH :KDWHYHUFDQWKHPDWWHUEH" +HIHHOVP\SXOVHDQGVHHVP\WRQJXH +HWHVWVP\KHDUWDQGWKHQHDFKOXQJ +HDVNVKRZROG,DPDQGWKHQ +HWDNHVKLVSDSHUDQGKLVSHQ $QGPDNHVDQRWHRIWKLQJV WKDWWDVWH 6RKRUULGWKDW, PVXUHLW¶VZDVWH 7RWDNHWKHP%XWKHVD\V(DFKQRRQ 7DNHWKLVDQG\RX OOEHEHWWHUVRRQ )URP$URXQG<RX3URVYHVFKHQLH/ 'HDUPH;h`_fhc \ujZ`_gb_ m^b\e_gby :KDWHYHUkZiWKHPDWWHUEH"Qlh[u wlhfh]ehkemqblvky" PDNHVDQRWHRIWKLQJVa^\uibku\Z _le_dZjkl\h KRUULGm`Zkguc , PVXUHLW VZDVWHym\_j_gqlh[_k ihe_agh /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH $ GRFWRU WROG KLV SDWLHQW WKDW WKHUH ZDV QRWKLQJ UHDOO\ WKH PDWWHU ZLWK KLP$OO\RXQHHGLVPRUHRXWGRRUOLIHZDONWZRRUWKUHHPLOHVUHJXODUO\ HYHU\GD\DQG\RX OOIHHOPXFKEHWWHU:KDW¶V\RXUEXVLQHVV" ,DPDSRVWPDQ ihqlZevhg GRFWRU A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,HDVLO\>µL]LOL@DGYe_]dh QHUYRXVWHQVLRQ>µWHQ HQ@g_j\gh_ gZijy`_gb_ WZLFHDVPRUH\^\ZjZaZ[hevr_ WRPRYH>PXY@Y^\b]Zlvky SK\VLFDOO\LQDFWLYHSHRSOH>µIL]LN~OL LQ¶ÙNWLY@ex^bdhlhju_g_aZgbfZ xlkynbabq_kdbfbmijZ`g_gbyfb WRIHHOUHIUHVKHGqm\kl\h\Zlvk_[y [h^jufh[gh\e_gguf SRVWXUH>µSuVW ~@QhkZgdZihaZ WROLIWVSLULWVih^gbfZlvgZkljh_gb_ PDNHXS\RXUPLQGijbfbl_j_r_ gb_ GDLO\H[HUFLVHV_`_^g_\gZyaZjy^dZ ZLWKRXWIDLO>IHLO@h[yaZl_evgh $%287(;(5&,6(6 ([HUFLVHVDUHQHFHVVDU\DQGYHU\LPSRUWDQWWRHYHU\SHUVRQ,IDJURZQ XSSHUVRQGRHVQ WH[HUFLVHKHFDQHDVLO\JHWKHDUWGLVHDVHQHUYRXVWHQVLRQ DQGRWKHULOOQHVVHV %XV GULYHUV rhn_ju Z\lh[mkh\ ZKR VLW DOO GD\ KDYH KHDUW GLVHDVHV WZLFHDVPRUHWKDQFRQGXFWRUV dhg^mdlhju ZKRPRYHDOOGD\ 3K\VLFDOO\LQDFWLYHSHRSOHJHWROGHDUOLHUWKDQWKRVHZKRH[HUFLVH ,I \RX GR GDLO\ H[HUFLVHV \RX IHHO UHIUHVKHG \RX KDYH JRRG SRVWXUH *RRGSRVWXUHOLIWVVSLULWV3RRUSRVWXUHRIWHQFDXVHVIDWLJXH 3D\ DWWHQWLRQ WR WKH ZD\ \RX VWDQG ZDON DQG VLW 0DNH XS \RXU PLQG WKDW\RXZLOOGR\RXUGDLO\H[HUFLVHVPLQXWHVZLWKRXWIDLO MIJ:@G?GB? <klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dkeh\Zbebkeh\hkhq_lZgby WRIHHOUHIUHVKHGWRJHWROGZLWKRXWIDLODKHDUWGLVHDVH 3K\VLFDOO\ LQDFWLYH SHRSOH HDUOLHU WKDQ WKRVH ZKR H[HUFLVH <RXPXVWGR\RXUGDLO\H[HUFLVHV,IDSHUVRQGRHVQ WH[HUFLVHKHFDQ HDVLO\JHW,I\RXGRGDLO\H[HUFLVHV\RX D H G L J H E V G U ?M I J : @ G ?G B Y < ijZ\hc dhehgd_ gZc^bl_ i_j_\h^ dZ`^h]h Zg]ebckdh]h keh\Z jZ[hlm\uihegycl_gZi_jnhdZjl_ , [hev ,, kuiv ,,, ]heh\gZy[hev ,9 \uibku\Zlvj_p_il 9 djh\hl_q_gb_ 9, [hev\k_j^p_ 9,, \_ljygZyhkiZ 9,,,kdZjeZlbgZ ,; gZkfhjd ; dZr_ev ;, objmj] ;,, [_kihdhblv ;,,,e_`Zqbc[hevghc ;,9qboZlv ;9djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ ,,<uibrbl_baZihfgbl_i_j\u_ijbagZdbke_^mxsbobgn_dpbhgguo aZ[he_\Zgbc WRSUHVFULEH EHGSDWLHQW VFDUOHWIHYHU EORRGSUHVVXUH KHDUWDFKH WRERWKHU FKLFNHQSR[ FRXJK WRVQHH]H SDLQ VFDUOHWIHYHUPHDVOHVLQIOXHQ]DULFNHWV ,,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb qlhk\Zfbkemqbehkv"\uiehoh\u]ey^bl_mf_gykbevgZy]heh\ gZy[hev\q_jZmg__ihy\beZkvkuivgZdh`_dZdZym\Zkl_fi_jZlm jZ"mg_]hgZkfhjdbkbevgucdZr_ev^Zcl_\Zrmjmdmybaf_jx\Z r_^Z\e_gb_hldjhcl_jhlbkdZ`bl_©Zª\u^he`guhklZ\Zlvky\ih kl_eb\l_q_gb_g_^_eb^hdlhjihkh\_lh\Ze_fm^_eZlvmlj_ggxxaZ jy^dm ,9Ijh\_^bl_]jZnbq_kdbc^bdlZglihl_f_+HDOWKLVDERYHZHDOWK b$ERXWH[HUFLVHV 'DLO\ H[HUFLVHV DUH YHU\ LPSRUWDQW 3K\VLFDOO\ LQDFWLYH SHRSOH IHHO UH IUHVKHGDQGORRNZHOO$ZHDNPDQWLUHVTXLFNO\'R\RXUGDLO\H[HUFLVHV DQG\RXZLOOKDYHSRRUSRVWXUH3RRUSRVWXUHOLIWVVSLULWV([HUFLVHVLQFUHDVH KHDUWDFWLRQDQGEORRGFLUFXODWLRQ([HUFLVHVGRQRWVWUHQJWKHQQHUYRXVV\V WHP*RLQIRUVSRUWVDQG\RXZLOOEHKHDOWK\ J:A>?E,9 0(',&,1( A:GYLB? Bkihevamy keh\Z gZ k \uibrbl_ gZa\Zgby bah[jZ`_gguo a^_kvij_^f_lh\ AZihfgbl_\ujZ`_gbykgZa\Zgbyfbe_dZjkl\_gguonhjf ,SRZGHU>µSDXG~@WRWDNHDSRZ GHUIRU« DVZHHW ELWWHU SRZGHU WDEOHW>µWÙEOLW@ WRWDNHDWDEOHWWKUHHWLPHVDGD\ DKDOIWDEOHW WKHVHWDEOHWVKDYHQRVLGHHIIHFWV SLOO WRWDNHWKHSLOODIWHU GXULQJEHIRUH PHDO WRWDNHVRPHPLONDIWHUWKHSLOO RLQWPHQW>µuLQWP~QW@WRSXWWKHRLQW PHQWRQ« VXSSRVLWRU\>V~µSu]LW~UL@ WRNHHSWKHVXSSRVLWRULHVLQFRROSODFH JOREXOH> JOuEMXO@ WRZDVKWKHKDQGVEHIRUHWKHXVHRI WKHJOREXOHV DPSXOH> ÙPSMXO@ WRNHHSWKHDPSXOHVLQDGDUNSODFH WRJLYHLQMHFWLRQV VROXWLRQ>VuµX ~Q@ WRUHDGWKH'RFWRU VLQVWUXFWLRQEH IRUHJLYLQJWKHVROXWLRQ PL[WXUH> PLNVW ~@ WRVKDNHWKHERWWOHZLWKWKHPL[WXUH EHIRUHXVH LQIXVLRQ>LQ¶IMXQ@ WRWDNHDQLQIXVLRQ GHFRFWLRQ>GL¶NuN Q@ WRJLYHDGHFRFWLRQIRXUWLPHVDGD\ EHIRUHPHDO GURSV WRNHHSWKHGURSVLQDGDUNSODFH WRZDVKWKHSLSHWWHEHIRUH DIWHU XVH WRGURSILYHGURSV WLQFWXUH>µWL¾NW ~@ WRWDNHWZHQW\GURSVRIWKHWLQFWXUH WDEOHVSRRQIXO>µWHLEOVSXQIXO@ WRWDNHDWDEOHVSRRQIXORI WHDVSRRQIXO>WLVSXQIXO@ WRWDNHDWHDVSRRQIXORQDQHPSW\ VWRPDFK SUHVFULSWLRQ>SULV¶NULS Q@ WRJLYHDSUHVFULSWLRQ WRSUHVFULEHPHGLFLQH WUHDWPHQW MIJ:@G?GB? KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb <havfbl_Zfimeuk\blZfbghf<Ijbfbl_klheh\u_eh`db l_ieh]hhl\ZjZ<a[helZcl_fbdklmjmi_j_^mihlj_[e_gb_fIjb fbl_wlbdZiebkfhehdhf>Zcl_j_p_ilih`ZemcklZ<uibrbl_ e_dZjkl\hhl]heh\ghc[hebOjZgbl_k\_qbbjZkl\hju\l_fghfb ijhoeZ^ghff_kl_G_ijbgbfZcl_wlbihjhrdbgZ]heh^guc`_em ^hd A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm DWWKHFKHPLVW V>µNHPLVWVO\Zil_d_ SDWHQW>µSHLW~QW@ZiZl_glh\Zgguc DPSXOH>µÙPSMXO@QZfimeZ JOXFRVH>µJOXNRXV@Q]exdhaZ FDPSKRU>µNÙPI~@QdZfnZjZ SLOO>SLO@Qibexey FRXJKPL[WXUH>µNuI PLNVW ~@fbdklm jZhldZrey QDVDOGURSV>µQHL~O@dZieb\ghk FRGOLYHURLO>µNuGµOLY~µuLO@ju[bc `bj RLQWPHQW>µuLQWP~QW@QfZav VOHHSLQJGUDXJKW>µVOLSL¾µGU.IW@ kghl\hjgh_ OD[DWLYH>µOÙNV~WLY@QkeZ[bl_evgh_ kj_^kl\h VHGDWLYH>µVHG~WLY@Qmkihdhbl_evgh_ kj_^kl\h DGKHVLYHSODVWHU>~G¶KLVLYSO.VW~@ ebidbcieZklujv e_cdhieZklujv KRWZDWHUERWWOHQ]j_edZ PHGLFLQHGURSSHU> GUuS~@ibi_ldZ $77+(&+(0,67¶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klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dkeh\Zihôh^ysb_ihkfukem PXVWDUGSODVWHUYLWDPLQVFRGOLYHURLOKHDUWGURSV +H RIWHQ XVHV 6KH JDYH KHU GDXJKWHU ,WDNHWKHVH WZRWLPHVDGD\6KHSXWVHYHU\HYHQLQJ ,, <u[_jbl_ ba l_dklZ gZa\Zgby l_o f_^bdZf_glh\ dhlhju_ bk ihevamxl ijb ijhklm^guo aZ[he_\Zgbyo b e_]dbo jZg_gbyo GZah \bl_lZd`_ij_^f_lulmZe_lZ ,,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb ijbgbfZcl_wlbihjhrdbihke__ûihklZ\vl_]hjqbqgbdbgZkib gm\u^he`gubf_lv^hfZ[bglchê_cdhieZklujvk_j^_qgu_dZi eb^Zcl_fg_]j_edm 'RFWRULVLWDEVROXWHO\QHFHVVDU\IRUP\KXVEDQG WRWDNHWKLVPHGLFLQHLQFROGZDWHU" ,9Ijhqlbl_bi_j_\_^bl_ ) D W K H U 'RFWRUZKHQ,FDPHKRPH,IRXQGP\OLWWOHER\DVOHHS$WILUVW WKDWVHHPHGQRUPDOEXWZKHQ,HQWHUHGWKHEDWKURRP,IRXQGWKHERWWOH RIP\ZLIH VVHGDWLYHRQWKHIORRU, PDIUDLGWKHFKLOGWRRNVRPHRILW ' R F W R U 'R\RXNQRZZKDWNLQGRI VHGDWLYHLWZDV" )1RGRFWRU,RQO\NQRZLWZDVRQHRIWKHVHGDWLYHV+HUHLWLV ' :HOO LW LV EHWWHU WR GR D VWRPDFK ZDVKLQJ 1XUVH KDYH HYHU\WKLQJ UHDG\IRUWKHVWRPDFKZDVKLQJ WRVHHP>VLP@YdZaZlvky VHGDWLYH >µVHG~WLY@ Q kghl\hjgh_ mk ihdZb\Zxs__kj_^kl\h ZKDWNLQGRIqlhaZ ZDVKLQJ>µZu LQ@Qijhfu\Zgb_ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 0XPP\,KDYHDVWRPDFKDFKHVDLG1HOO\DOLWWOHJLUORIVL[7KDW V EHFDXVH \RX KDG QR OXQFK <RXU VWRPDFK LV HPSW\ imklhc <RX ZRXOG IHHOEHWWHULI\RXKDGVRPHWKLQJLQLW 7KDW DIWHUQRRQDIULHQGFDPHWRVHH1HOO\ VPRWKHU:KLOHWKH\WDONHG WKHIULHQGVDLGWKDWKHKDGDEDGKHDGDFKHWKHZKROHGD\ 7KDW VEHFDXVHLWLVHPSW\VDLG1HOO\<RXZRXOGIHHOEHWWHULI\RX KDG \u[uqm\kl\h\Zebk_[yemqr__keb[um\Zk[ueh VRPHWKLQJLQ LW A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm VXOIRQDPLGHV> VOI~Q~µPDLG]@kmev nZgbeZfb^gu_ij_iZjZlu WRGLVFRYHU>GLV NY~@Y^_eZlvhl djulb_ VXOIDGUXJVe_dZjkl\_ggu_kmevnZ fb^gu_ij_iZjZlu GUXJ>GUJ@ie_dZjkl\h ZLGHO\> ZDLGOL@DGYrbjhdh PHQLQJLWLV>PHQLQ¶!DLWLV@Qf_gbg]bl PXPSV>PPSV@Qk\bgdZ LQSODFHRI\f_klh DQWLELRWLF>ÙQWLEDL¶uWLN@QZglb[bhlbd WRSURGXFH>SU~ GMXV@Yijhba\h^blv VLGHHIIHFW>µVDLGLIHNW@Qih[hqguc wnn_dlHIIHFWQ\ha^_ckl\b_ QDXVHD> QuVM~@QlhrghlZ 7+(68/)21$0,'(6 6XOIRQDPLGHVZHUHGLFRYHUHGLQ6XOIDGUXJV ZHUHZLGHO\ XVHG LQ PHGLFLQH GXULQJ :RUOG :DU ,, 6XOID GUXJV WUHDW PDQ\ LQIHFWLRXV GLV HDVHV7KH\DUHDOVRSUHYHQWLQJPHQLQJLWLVVFDUOHWIHYHUPXPSVFKLFNHQ SR[ 6XOIRQDPLGHV DUH RIWHQ XVHG LQ SODFH RI DQWLELRWLFV 6RPHWLPHV VXO IRQDPLGHV SURGXFH WR[LF >µWuNVLN@ VLGHHIIHFWV QDXVHD YRPLW KHDG DFKHUDVK MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb [ue hldjul rbjhdh ijbf_gyebkv e_qZl bgn_dpbhggu_ [he_agb ij_^hl\jZsZlv\f_kl_^Z\Zlvih[hqgu_y\e_gby ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KHQ ZHUH VXOIRQDPLGHV GLVFRYHUHG" :KHQ ZHUH VXOID GUXJV ZLGHO\XVHG":KDWGLVHDVHVGRVXOIDGUXJVWUHDW"'RVXOIDGUXJVSUR GXFHVLGHHIIHFWV" ,,, KhklZ\vl_ b gZibrbl_ ij_êh`_gby ba ke_^mxsbo keh\ aZl_f ijhqlbl_ dZ`^h_ ij_êh`_gb_ p_ebdhf b ih\lh jbl__]hg_]ey^y\l_ljZ^v WUHDWGLVHDVHVGUXJVPDQ\VXOIDLQIHFWLRXV SUHYHQWPXPSVVXOIDVFDUOHWGUXJVIHYHUFKLFNHQSR[DQG VXOIDVLGHHIIHFWVVRPHWLPHVGUXJVSURGXFH VXOIRQDPLGHVZHUHLQGLVFRYHUHG /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7KH GRFWRU VPLOHG DV KH HQWHUHG WKH URRP <RX ORRN PXFK EHWWHU WR GD\ <HV,IROORZWKHLQVWUXFWLRQVRQ\RXUPHGLFLQHERWWOH :KDWZHUHWKH\" .HHSWKHERWWOHWLJKWO\FRUNHG WLJKWO\FRUNHGdj_idhaZdjuluc <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm SHQLFLOOLQ>SHQL VLOLQ@ii_gbpbeebg RUDOO\>µuU~OL@DGYaîjb_f\gmljv LQWURPXVFXODUO\>LQWU~µPVNMXO~OL@ \gmljbfur_qgh WRSLFDOO\> WuSLN~L@DGYf_klgh VWUHSWRP\FLQ>VWUHSWRX¶PDLVLQ@Q klj_ilhfbpbg VROXEOH>µVuMXEO@ZjZkl\hjbfuc VROXWLRQ>V~µOX ~Q@ijZkl\hj YDULHW\>Y~µUDL~WL@ijZaghh[jZab_ PLFUREH>µPDLNURXE@ifbdjh[ ZOOHUJLF>~µO~!LN@ZZee_j]bq_kdbc LQVWHDGRI>LQ¶VWHG~Y@DGY\f_klh $%287$17,%,27,&6 7KHWHUPDQWLELRWLFPHDQV DQWL±DJDLQVWELRV±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l\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KDW GRHV WKH WHUP DQWLELRWLF PHDQ" :KR GLVFRYHUHG WKH ILUVW DQWLELRWLFV" +RZ LV SHQLFLOOLQ JLYHQ WR WKH SDWLHQWV" ,V VWUHSWRP\FLQ VROXEOHLQZDWHU"'RHVQHRP\FLQJLYHDOOHUJLFUHDFWLRQV" ,, GZc^bl_ \ l_dkl_ b aZihfgbl_ Zg]ebckdb_ wd\b\Ze_glu jmkkdbokeh\©\gmljvª©\gmljbfur_qghª©f_klghª ,,,GZah\bl_ihZg]ebckdbZglb[bhlbdbdhlhju_\uagZ_l_ /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ,DPLOOVDLG3HWHWRKLVPRWKHU,DPYHU\LOO<HVWHUGD\,KDGDEDG KHDGDFKHWRGD\,KDYHDIHYHU3OHDVHFDOOLQDGRFWRU 6RRQ WKH GRFWRU FDPH +H IHOW 3HWH V SXOVH DQG ORRNHG DW KLV WRQJXH 7KHQWDNLQJDSLHFHRISDSHUKHZURWHDSUHVFULSWLRQ+HJDYHLWWR3HWHUV PRWKHUDQGVDLG >~µULUR¶PDLVLQ@ >µQLuµPDLVLQ@ /HWKLPWDNHLWWKLVHYHQLQJ imklvhgwlhijbf_lk_]h^gy\_q_jhf %HIRUH JRLQJ WR EHG WKDW QLJKW 3HWH VZDOORZHG ijh]ehlbe WKH SDSHU :KHQKHJRWXSQH[WPRUQLQJKHVDLGWRKLVPRWKHU1RZ,IHHOTXLWHZHOO DJDLQ:DVQ WLWDYHU\QLFHSUHVFULSWLRQ" Ijb^mfZcl_jZkkdZadjbkmgdm A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,FROOHFWLRQ>N~¶OHN ~Q@ik[hj PHGLFLQDO>PH¶GLVLQ@Ze_dZjkl\_gguc SODQW>SO.QW@ijZkl_gb_ WRFXOWLYDWH>µNOWLYHOW@Ya^\ujZsb\Zlv OHDI>OLIOiebkl fgqOHDYHV URRW>UXW@dhj_gv VHHG>VLG@ik_fy IXOO\>µIXOL@DGYiheghklvx WRVSRLO>VSuLO@Yihjlblv 0(',&,1$/3/$176 7KH FROOHFWLRQ DQG XVH RI PHGLFLQDO SODQWV EHJDQ PDQ\ WKRXVDQGV \HDUVDJR +LSSRFUDWHV>KL¶SuNU~WL]@LVWKHIDWKHURIPHGLFLQHZKROLYHGLQ*UHHFH ZURWH LQ KLV ERRNV DERXW VXFK GUXJV DV KHPORFN >KHPO uN@ [heb]heh\ JHQWLDQ>µ!HQ L~Q@ ]hj_qZ\dZ DQGPDQ\RWKHUV 7RGD\ PDQ\ GUXJ SODQWV DUH FXOWLYDWHG DQG PDQ\ GUXJ SODQWV DUH FRO OHFWHGIURPILHOGVDQGZRRGV 6RPHGUXJVDUHPDGHIURPIUXLWVOHDYHVIORZHUVURRWVVHHGVRIWKH SODQWV ,W LV YHU\ LPSRUWDQW WR FROOHFW SODQWV LQ SURSHU WLPH k\h_\j_f_ggh /HDYHVDUHFROOHFWHGZKHQWKH\DUHIXOO\ GHYHORSHG7KHWLPHRIWKHGD\LV DOVRLPSRUWDQWLQWKHFROOHFWLRQRIGUXJSODQWV )ORZHUVDUHFROOHFWHGEHIRUHWKHWLPHRISROOLQDWLRQ>S uOL¶QHL ~Q@ hiu e_gb_ )UXLWV DUH FROOHFWHG ZKHQ WKH\ DUH IXOO\ JURZQ EXW XQULSH g_aj_ euc 7RGU\SODQWVFRUUHFWO\LVDOVRYHU\LPSRUWDQW,ILWLVPDGHFDUHOHVVO\WKH GUXJPD\EHVSRLOHG 'UXJSODQWVZKLFKKDYHJOLFRVLGHVPXVWEHGULHGDWDORZWHPSHUDWXUH 'LJLWDOLVOHDYHVPXVWEHGULHGLQWKHVDPHZD\ MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb kh[bjZlv k\h_\j_f_ggh ihjZ hiue_gby g_aj_eu_ njmdlu ijZ \bevgh kmrblv wlh k^_eZgh g_[j_`gh fh`gh bkihjlblv ijb gbadhc l_fi_jZlmj_l_f`_h[jZahf ,,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku :KHQGLGWKHFROOHFWLRQRIPHGLFLQDOSODQWVEHJLQ":KDWDUHVRPH GUXJVPDGHRI":KHQLVLWLPSRUWDQWWRFROOHFWPHGLFLQDOSUDQWV":KHQ DUHIORZHUVDQGIUXLWVFROOHFWHG"+RZPXVWGUXJSODQWVZLWKJOLFRVLGHVEH GULHG" ,,, I_j_kdZ`bl_ l_dkl bkihevamy ^Zggu_ keh\Z b keh\hkhq_ lZgby WKHFROOHFWLRQDQGXVHDUHFXOWLYDWHGDUHFROOHFWHGIUXLWVOHDYHVURRWV VHHGVLQJRRGWLPHIXOO\GHYHORSHGWKHWLPHRISROOLQDWLRQXQULSHPD\EH VSRLOHGDWDORZWHPSHUDWXUH /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ' R F W R U <RXIROORZHG P\SUHVFULSWLRQVRIFRXUVH 3 D W L H Q W ,QGHHG,GLGQRWGRFWRUIRU,VKRXOGKDYHEURNHQP\QHFN ' R F W R U %URNHQ\RXUQHFN" 3 D W L H Q W <HVIRU,WKUHZ\RXUSUHVFULSWLRQRXWRIDWKLUGIORRUZLQGRZ 2QFHDIDPRXVDFWRUZDVYHU\LOO+HKDGWRWDNHPHGLFLQHRIDYHU\GDUN FRORXU 2QH GD\ KLV VLVWHU JDYH KLP VRPH LQN E\ PLVWDNH ih hrb[d_ :KHQ VKH VDZ KHU PLVWDNH VKH FULHG LQ KRUURU \ m`Zk_ 2K 7RPP\ , JDYH\RXLQNLQVWHDGRI \f_klh \RXUPHGLFLQH 1HYHUPLQGVDLGWKHDFWRU,¶OOVZDOORZ ijh]ehqm DSLHFHRIEORWWLQJ SDSHU dmkhdijhfhdZl_evghc[mfZ]b BBBBBBBBB WRIROORZ\uihegylvke_^h\Zlvihke_^h\Zlv ,QWHUHVWLQJ)DFWV $ )UHQFKPDQ 1LFRW E\ QDPH VDZ D PLUDFXORXV SODQW LQ 3RUWXJDO DQG EURXJKWLWWR)UDQFH,WZDVWREDFFRSODQW1LFRWEHOLHYHGWKDWWKHSODQWFRXOG FXUH FDQFHU KHDGDFKHV DQG PDQ\ RWKHU GLVHDVHV %XW WLPH VKRZHG WKDW KH ZDVDEVROXWHO\ZURQJ:HRZH1LFRWWKHZRUGQLFRWLQH A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm DQDWRP\>~µQÙW~PL@QZgZlhfby WRJRWREHGeh`blvkykiZlv eh `blvky\ihkl_ev GLVWULFWGRFWRUjZchgguc\jZq WKUHHWLPHVDGD\ljbjZaZ\^_gv EHIRUHPHDO^h_û VKDNHWKHERWWOHZHOOEHIRUHXVLQJ ohjhrh\a[helZcl_[mluedmi_j_^ mihlj_[e_gb_f DIWHUPHDOihke__û IHHOJRRGqm\kl\h\Zlvk_[yohjhrh SKDUPDFRORJ\>IDP~µNu~!L@QnZj fZdheh]by VXEMHFW>µVE!LNW@Qij_^f_l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~µGUHV@Yh[jZsZlvky WREHVXUH> X~@[ulvm\_j_gguf WRVXEVWLWXWH> VEVWLWMXW@Qhrb[Zlvky WREHPLVWDNHQ>PLV WHLN~Q@YaZf_gylv %H&DUHIXOZLWK0HGLFLQHDW+RPH .HHSWKHPHGLFLQHLQDORFNHG ER[RQDVHSDUDWHVKHOIEH\RQGWKH UHDFKRIFKLOGUHQ 5HDGWKHODEHOEHIRUH\RXRSHQWKHERWWOHRUER[5HDGWKHLQVWUXF WLRQVDQGGRVHFDUHIXOO\ 6KDNHWKHERWWOHZLWKOLTXLGV RUWKHODVWGRVHFDQEHWRRVWURQJ .HHSWKHPHGLFLQHLQDFROGSODFH ORFNHG>ONW@ZaZi_jluc VHSDUDWH>µVHSULW@Zhl^_evguc EH\RQGWKHUHDFKRIFKLOGUHQ>EL¶MuQG ç~ULW @qlh[uj_[_ghdg_fh]^hklZlv ODEHO>µOHLEO@Qwlbd_ldZ OLTXLG>µOLNZLG@Q`b^dhklv MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb qlhk\Zfb"y[ueZ[hevgZhgZe_]eZ\ihkl_evybaf_jbeZl_fi_ jZlmjml_fi_jZlmjZ[ueZ\ukhdhcmf_gy[uebfur_qgu_[heb\u a\Zlv \jZqZ \jZq \gbfZl_evgh hkfhlj_eZf_gyhgZ\uibkZeZfg_e_ dZjkl\ZijbgbfZcl_wlhe_dZjkl\h^\ZjZaZ\^_gv^h_ûwlblZ[e_l dbohjhrbhl]heh\ghc[hebijbgbfZcl_wlmfbdklmjmq_luj_jZaZ\ ^_gvihke__ûi_j_^mihlj_[e_gb_f\a[Zelu\Zcl_ ,,Ihkfhljbl_gZjbkmghdbjZkkdZ`bl_qlh\ugZg_f\b^b l_ Z aZl_f ij_^klZ\vl_ qlh \u f_^k_kljZ >hdlhj \uib kZe [hevghfm g_kdhevdh j_p_ilh\ Hl^Z\Zy bo _fm kdZ`bl_ gZ dZdmx e_dZjkl\_ggmx nhjfm hgb \uibkZgu b h[tykgbl_ dZdboijbgbfZlv ,,,Ih aZ^Zgguf fh^_eyf ih klZ\vl_ \hijhku d ke_ ^mxsbf ij_êh`_gbyf hl\_lvl_ gZ wlb \hijh ku :KR":KHQ" 7KH GLVWULFW GRFWRU FDPH LQ WKH PRUQLQJ 'LG":KDW" 6KHSUHVFULEHGFRXJKPL[WXUH /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 'RFWRU<RXFRXJKPRUHHDVLO\WKLVPRUQLQJ 3DWLHQW<HVGRFWRU,SUDFWLVHGWKHZKROH \kx QLJKW A:GYLB? Ijhqlbl_bi_j_kdZ`bl_l_dkl 7KH3UHVFULSWLRQRQWKH'RFWRU $PDQIHOOLOODQGWKHGRFWRUZDVVHQWIRU7KHGRFWRUFDPH+HH[DP LQHGWKHSDWLHQWDQGWKHQKHDVNHGIRUDSHQLQNDQGSDSHUDVKHZDQWHGWR ZULWHDSUHVFULSWLRQ%XWWKHUHZHUHQRVXFKWKLQJVLQWKHKRXVHVRWKHS D WLHQW¶V ZLIH ZHQW RXW WR WDNH WKHP IURP VRPHERG\ 6KH ZDV DEVHQW IRU D ORQJWLPHDQGWKHGRFWRUWRRNDSLHFHRIFRDO ZURWHWKHSUHVFULSWLRQRQWKH GRRUZLWKLWDQGZHQWDZD\1RERG\LQWKHKRXVHFRXOGUHDGRUZULWH/DWLQ 6RWKH\WRRNWKHGRRURIILWVKLQJHV FDUULHGLWWRWKHFKHPLVW¶V VKRSDQG JRWWKHPHGLFLQH DSLHFHRIFRDOdmkhdm]ey /DWLQ> OÙWLQ@eZlugv KLQJH>KLQ!@Qi_ley FKHPLVW>µNHPLVW@QZil_dZjv I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl )URPWKH+LVWRU\RI0HGLFLQHLQ(J\SW 7KHHDUO\(J\SWLDQP\WKRORJ\ WHOOVXVDYHU\LQWHUHVWLQJVWRU\+RUXV WKH*RGRI+HDOWKLQILJKWZLWK6HOI7KHGHPRQRIHYLO ORVWDQH\H7KH H\HZDVUHVWRUHGWRKLPE\DPLUDFXORXVPHDQV7KHH\HKDGDVLJQ5 ZKLFKPHDQW5HFLSHV$QGWKHP\WKRORJ\VD\VWKDWWKHZRUG5HFLSH ZULWWHQ DW WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI HYHU\ SUHVFULSWLRQ ZDVWDNHQIURPWKHVLJQRI WKHH\HRI+RUXV P\WKRORJ\>PLµuO~!L@Qfbnheh]by ILJKW>IDLWMQ[hjv[ZY WR [hjhlvky HYLO>µLYO@Qaeh WRUHVWRUH>ULV¶WuOY\hkklZgZ\eb\Zlv \ha\jZsZlv gZij_`g__f_klh PLUDFXORXV>PL¶UÙNMXO~V@Qk\_jot_k l_kl\_gguc WRPHDQ>PLQ@Y PHDQW agZqblv hagZqZlv 5HFLSH>µUHVLSL@Qj_p_il VLJQ>VDLQ@QagZd /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 0 R W K H U 2K 7RP , IRUJRW WR VKDNH WKH ERWWOH EHIRUH , JDYH \RX WKLV PHGLFLQH / L W W O H E R \ 'RQ¶WZRUU\,¶OOMXPSXS ihîju]gm VHYHUDOWLPHV A:IHFGBL? $YRLG6HOI7UHDWPHQW $SHUVRQZKRWKLQNVKHFDQFXUH KLPVHOIZLWKRXWWKHGRFWRU VFRQVXOWD WLRQ PDNHV D PLVWDNH 7KHUH DUH KXQGUHGV RI FDXVHV RI KHDGDFKH DQG WKH SHUVRQGRHVQ WNQRZZKDWPHGLFLQHKHQHHGV +H FDQ VWRS KLVV\PSWRPVEXWKHGRHVQ WFXUH WKHFDXVHRIWKHP7KH LOOQHVVPD\EHFRPHPRUHVHULRXV $ SUHVFULSWLRQ LV XVXDOO\ ZULWWHQ IRU D FHUWDLQ SHUVRQ 1HYHU XVH PHG L FLQHVSUHVFULEHGQRWIRU\RX WRFXUH>NMX~@Y\ue_qb\Zlv I_j_\_^bl_l_dkl $WWKH&KHPLVW¶V6KRS 2QHGD\DPDQFDPHWRWKHFKHPLVW VVKRS+DYH\RXDQ\WKLQJWRFXUHD KHDGDFKH"KHDVNHGWKHFKHPLVW 7KH FKHPLVW WRRN D ERWWOH IURP WKH VKHOI KHOG LW XQGHU WKH JHQWOHPDQ V QRVHDQGWRRNRXWWKH FRUN7KHVPHOOZDVVRVWURQJWKDWWHDUVFDPHLQWR WKHPDQ VH\HVDQGUDQGRZQKLVFKHHNV :KDWGLG\RXGRWKDWIRU"KHVDLGDQJULO\ DVVRRQDVKHFRXOGVSHDN DJDLQ <RX ZDQWHG VRPHWKLQJ JRRG IRU \RXU KHDGDFKH $QG , JDYH LW WR \RX2KVDLGWKHPDQ%XWP\ZLIHKDVDKHDGDFKHQRWPH FRUN>NuN@Qijh[dZ VPHOO>VPHO@QaZiZo DQJULO\>µÙ¾JULOL@DGYk_j^blh D H G L J H E V G U ?M I J : @ G ?G B Y ,<ijZ\hcdhehgd_gZc^bl_i_j_\h^dZ`^h]hZg]ebckdh]hkeh\Z jZ [hlm\uihegycl_gZi_jnhdZjl_ SLOOV GUXJV PXVWDUGSODVWHU 3RZGHU KRWZDWHUERWWOH LFHEDJ VRDS RUDOO\ RLQWPHQW VROXEOH , ,, ,,, ,9 9 9, 9,, 9,,, ,; ; ;, ;,, ;,,, ;,9 ;9 jZkl\hjbfuc ibexeb imaujvkhev^hf e_cdhieZklujv ijb_f\gmljv fueh dhfij_kk ]hjqbqgbdb ]m[dZ ihjhrhd lZ[e_ldb e_dZjkl\h fZav fbdklmjZ ]j_edZ ,,<klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dihôh^ysb_ihkfukemkeh\Zbkeh\hkhq_ lZgby^Zggu_gb`_bi_j_\_^bl_ij_êh`_gby 6RPHWLPHVVXOIRQDPLGHVSURGXFH6WUHSWRP\FLQLVJLYHQDQG ,WLVYHU\LPSRUWDQWWRWDNHPHGLFLQHV6KDNHWKHERWWOHOLTXLGV 5HDGWKHEHIRUH\RXRSHQDERWWOHRUER[ZLWKPHGLFLQHV ODEHOEHIRUHXVLQJLQJRRGWLPHVLGHHIIHFWVLQWURPXVFXODUO\RUDOO\ ,,, Ijh\_^bl_ ]jZnbq_kdbc ^bdlZgl QR l_fZf 6RPH UXOHV IRU QXUVHVX$YRLGVHOIWUHDWPHQW :KHQ\RXJLYHPHGLFLQHV\RXPXVWZDVK\RXUKDQGV<RXPD\JLYHDQ\ PHGLFLQH\RXOLNH1HYHUWHOOWKHGRFWRUDERXW\RXUPLVWDNH<RXPD\XVH VRPHPHGLFLQHSUHVFULEHGIRUDQRWKHUSHUVRQ ,9AZdhgqbl_ij_êh`_gbybkihevamykeh\hkhq_lZgby^Zggu_gb`_ ,WLVLPSRUWDQW ,WLVGDQJHURXV ,WLVQHFHVVDU\ WRXVHVRPHPHGLFLQHSUHVFULEHGIRU\RXUIULHQGQRWWRNHHSWKHPHGL FLQHLQDFROGSODFHWRWHOOWKHGRFWRUDERXW\RXUPLVWDNHWRUHDGWKHSU H VFULSWLRQFDUHIXOO\WRVXEVWLWXWHRQHGUXJIRUDQRWKHUWRNHHSWKHPHGLFLQH LQDORFNHGER[ J:A>?E9 '(17$/7(50,12/2*< GZc^bl_gZa\Zgbybah[jZ`_gguoa^_kvij_^f_lh\gZK A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm ,XSSHU>µj~@Z\_jogbc ORZHU>µORX~@Zgb`gbc MDZ>!u@Qq_exklv ERQ\> ERXQL@Zdhklguc VWUXFWXUH> VWUNW ~@ikljmdlmjZ VHW>VHW@QgZ[hj SHUPDQHQW>µS~P~Q~QW@D iRklhygguc 7((7+ 7KH WHHWK DUH LQ WKH XSSHU DQG ORZHU MDZV 7KH WHHWK DUH QRW ERQ\ VWUXFWXUHV 0DQKDVWZR VHWVRIWHHWKRQO\7KHILUVWVHWEHJLQVWRGHYHORSZKHQ WKHKXPDQEDE\LVWKUHHRUVL[PRQWKVROG%\WKHWLPHWKHFKLOGLVWZRDQG DKDOI\HDUVROGKHXVXDOO\KDVKLVILUVWVHWRIWHHWK±WZHQW\LQDOO7KH\DUH NQRZQDVPLONWHHWK 7KHVHFRQGVHWRIWHHWKLVFDOOHGWKHSHUPDQHQWWHHWK7KHUHDUHWZHQW\ HLJKWSHUPDQHQWWHHWKE\WKHWLPHKHLVWKLUWHHQRUIRXUWHHQ MIJ:@G?GBY ,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb \_jogyyq_exklvgb`gyyq_exklvfhehqgu_am[uba\_klgudZd ,,<klZ\vl_\f_klhlhq_dgm`gucij_êh] 7KHWHHWKDUHWKHXSSHUDQGORZHUMDZV RQLQ WKHWLPHWKHFKLOGLVWZRKHKDVWZHQW\WHHWK DWE\ 0DQKDVWZRVHWVWHHWKRQO\ RIDW /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ' H Q W L V W +DYH\RXVHHQDQ\VPDOOER\VULQJP\EHOODQGUXQDZD\" 3 R O L F H P D Q 7KH\ZHUHQRWVPDOOER\V²WKH\ZHUHJURZQXSV \ajhk eu_ $ 7KLV LV WKH VHFRQG GD\ \RXU ZLIH KDV D WRRWKDFKH :K\ GRQ W \RX GR VRPHWKLQJDERXWLW" %%XW,GR,SXWFRWWRQZRRO \Zlm LQP\HDUV A:GYLB? <umqbl_keh\Zdl_dklm GHQWLVW>µGHQWLVW@iam[ghc\jZq WRRWKDFKH> WXLHLN@iam[gZy[hev WREHDIUDLG RI >~µIUHLG@[hylvky q_ ]he GHQWDO QXUVH > GHQWO µQ~V@ f_^k_kljZ \am[ghfdZ[bg_l_ SUREH>SURXE@iahg^ GHQWDOPLUURU>µGHQWOµPLU~@am[gh_ a_jdZeh GHFD\HG>GL¶NHLG@Zbkihjq_gguc WRILOO>ILO@YaZiehf[bjh\Zlv am[ WHPSRUDU\>µWHPS~U~UL@Z\j_f_gguc ILOOLQJ >ILOL¾@ i iehf[Z WR SXW D ILOOLQJaZiehf[bjh\Zlv am[ \RXUWRRWKLVZRUNLQJORRVH\Zram[ rZlZ_lky WRH[WUDFW>LNV¶WUÙNW@Ym^Zeylv WR JLYH VPE DQ LQMHFWLRQ ^_eZlv bgt_dpbx WRULQVH>ULQV@YihehkdZlv WRVSLWRXWYkiexgmlv GHQWDO IRUFHSV >µGHQWO µIuVHSV@ ob jmj]bq_kdb_sbipu $77+('(17,67¶6 <HVWHUGD\LQWKHHYHQLQJ,KDGDEDGWRRWKDFKH,ZDVDWKRPHZKHQP\ PRWKHUFDPH 0 R W K H U :KDW VWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RXGHDU" $ Q Q ,KDYHDEDGWRRWKDFKH0XPP\ 0<RXPXVWVHHDGHQWLVW $2K0XPP\,DPDIUDLGRIJRLQJWRKLP 0%XW\RXPXVWJRWRKLPRU\RXZLOOIHHOEDG ,QWKHPRUQLQJ,ZHQWWRWKHGHQWLVW7KHGHQWDOQXUVHOHWPHLQ $ Q Q *RRGPRUQLQJ'RFWRU ' H Q W L V W *RRGPRUQLQJ6LWGRZQSOHDVH:KDW¶VWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX" $,KDYHDEDGWRRWKDFKH '2SHQ\RXUPRXWKSOHDVH $7KHGRFWRUWRRNDSUREHDQGDGHQWDOPLUURUDQGH[DPLQHGP\WHHWK '+DYH\RXDQ\SDLQLQWKLVWRRWK" $1R,KDYHQ W ' %XW LW LV D GHFD\HG WRRWK DQG , PXVW ILOO LW 7RGD\ , VKDOO SXW RQO\ D WHPSRUDU\ILOOLQJ%XW2KGRHVWKLVWRRWKKXUW\RX" $<HVLWGRHV '<RXUWRRWKLVZRUNLQJORRVH,PXVWH[WUDFWLW6RWRGD\,VKDOOH[WUDFW WKLVWRRWKDQGLQWZRRUWKUHHGD\V,¶OOSXWDILOOLQJLQWKDWRQH $2K'RFWRU,DPDIUDLG3OHDVHGRQ WH[WUDFWWKHWRRWK ':HOOZHOO mkihdhcl_kv P\GHDU,¶OOJLYH\RXDQLQMHFWLRQDQGLQ WHQ PLQXWHV ,¶OO H[WUDFW WKH WRRWK <RX ZLOO QRW IHHO DQ\ SDLQ 5LQVH \RXUPRXWKSOHDVHDQGVSLWRXW7HQPLQXWHVSDVVHG '2SHQ\RXUPRXWK,¶OOWDNHWKH GHQWDOIRUFHSVDQGLQDPLQXWHHYHU\ WKLQJ ZLOO EH DOO ULJKW +HUH LV \RXU WRRWK /RRN DW LW $UH \RX DIUDLG QRZ" $2KQR'RFWRUWKDQN\RX '&RPHWRPHLQWKUHHGD\VDQG,¶OOSXW\RXDILOOLQJ*RRGE\H $7KDQN\RX'RFWRUJRRGE\H /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH ' H Q W L V W &DQ\RXRSHQ\RXUPRXWKDVZLGHDV lZdrbjhdhdZd \RXU H\HV" 7 h P ,KDYHDEDGWRRWKDFKH 1 L k N ,¶GKDYHLWWDNHQRXW Y[um^Zebeam[ LILWZDV PLQH 7 R P ,ILWZDV\RXUV,ZRXOGWRR 3 D W L H Q W 'R\RXH[WUDFWWHHWKSDLQOHVVO\" ' H Q W L V W 1RW DOZD\V WKH RWKHU GD\ , QHDUO\ GLVORFDWHG ihqlb \u\bogme P\ZULVW A:GYLB? MIJ:@G?GBY ,Hl\_lvl_gZ\hijhku 'R\RXKDYHKHDOWK\WHHWK"+RZRIWHQGR\RXYLVLWDGHQWLVW"'R \RXKDYHPDQ\WHHWKWKDWQHHGFXULQJ",VWKHSRO\FOLQLFIDURUQHDU\RXU KRXVH"$UH\RXDIUDLGRIJRLQJWRDGHQWLVW" ,,KdZ`bl_ihZg]ebckdb mf_gy[heblam[hldjhcl_jhlm\Zkbkihjq_ggucam[yaZiehf[bjmx \Zf am[ y ihklZ\ex \Zf iehf[m ijhihehsbl_ jhl ih`ZemcklZ l_ i_jv kiexgvl_ y ^he`_g m^Zeblv \Zf am[ g_ [hcl_kv y k^_eZx \Zf bgt_dpbx wlh \j_f_ggZy iehf[Z wlhlam[[hebl" ,,, =ey^y gZ jbkmghd Z gZah\b l_\k_qlh\ugZg_f\b^b l_ [ hibrbl_ jbkmghd \ khklZ\vl_ b jZau]jZcl_ ^bZeh] f_`^m \jZqhf [hev gufbk_kljhc ,9 I_j_\_^bl_ ^bZeh]b Z aZ l_fijhqlbl_bjZau]jZcl_bo \ebpZo 'LDORJXHV $W+RPH 0 R W K H U :HVKDOOJRWRWKHGHQWLVWZLWK\RXWRGD\ 2 O J D /HW VJRQH[WZHHN0XPP\7KHUH VQRWKLQJWKHPDWWHUZLWKP\ WHHWK 0 R W K H U 1HYHUSXWRIIWLOOWRPRUURZZKDW\RXFDQGRWRGD\ 2 O J D ,GRQ WOLNHWRJRWRGHQWLVWV, PDIUDLGRIWKHP 0 R W K H U 1RERG\OLNHVDQGDOPRVWHYHU\ERG\LVDIUDLG,W VPRUHSOHDVDQW WRJRWRWKHFLQHPDRIFRXUVHEXWVWLOOZHKDYHWRJRWRWKHSRO\FOLQLF/HW WKHGHQWLVWH[DPLQH\RXUWHHWK5LQVH\RXUPRXWKDQGEHUHDG\LQDPLQ XWH0RWKHUGUHVVHG2OJDDQGWKH\ZHQWWRWKHGHQWLVW 1HYHUSXWRIIWLOOWRPRUURZZKDW\RXFDQGRWRGD\Gbdh]^Zg_hldeZû\Zc gZaZ\ljZlhqlhlufh`_rvk^_eZlvk_]h^gy $WWKH'HQWLVW¶V ' R F W R U :KDW¶V\RXUQDPHJLUO" 2 O J D 0\QDPHLV2OJD ' R F W R U 'RQ¶WEHDIUDLGRIPH2OJD 2 O J D ,¶PQRWDIUDLGDWDOO ' R F W R U 7KDW VDEUDYHJLUO1RZRSHQ\RXUPRXWK,VHHDOO\RXUWHHWKDUH KHDOWK\EXW\RXGRQ¶WUHDFK\RXUODVWWHHWKZKHQ\RXEUXVKWKHPWKH\DUH DELWGLUW\1RZLW VDOORYHUDQG\RXFDQJRKRPH(DWPRUHFDUURWV fhj dh\v ±\RXUWHHWKUHTXLUHFKHZLQJ 2 O J D 7KDQN\RXGRFWRU*RRGE\H ' R F W R U *RRGE\H /DXJKWHULVWKH%HVW0HGLFLQH 7 R P PHHWLQJDIULHQG :K\WKHEURDGVPLOH" 1 L k N , YHMXVWFRPHIURQWP\GHQWLVW 7 R P ,VWKHUHDQ\WKLQJWRODXJKDERXW" 1 L k N <HVKHZDVQRWLQDQGZLOOQRWEHIRUWZRGD\V 1LFNZDVVL[+HKDGDYHU\EDGWRRWKDFKH+HFRXOGQRWHDWKHFRXOG QRWSOD\KHFRXOGQRWVOHHSDWQLJKW1LFN VIDWKHUWRRNKLPWRWKHGHQWLVW 7KHGHQWLVWSXOOHGRXW m^Zebe WKUHHRI1LFN VWHHWK $IWHUWKDW1LFNFULHGDQGVDLG2KKRZVKDOO,HDWQRZ"%XWWKHGHQWLVW VDLG'RQ WFU\OLWWOHER\<RXUWHHWKZLOOJURZ \ujZklml DJDLQ :LOOWKH\JURZIRUGLQQHU"DVNHG1LFNLQWHDUV \ke_aZo D H G L J H E V G U ?M I J : @ G ?G B Y ,<ijZ\hcdhehgd_gZc^bl_i_j_\h^dZ`^h]hZg]ebckdh]hkeh\Z jZ [hlm\uihegycl_gZi_jnhdZjl_ iehf[bjh\Zlv , WRRWKDFKH ihehkdZlv ,, WRILOO sbipu ,,, WRH[WUDFW ihklhyggu_am[u WRULQVH ,9 fhehqgu_am[u WRVSLWRXW 9 m^Zeylv MDZ 9, ihehklv SHUPDQHQWWHHWK 9,, 7HPSRUDU\ )RUFHSV GHFD\HG 9,,, ,; ; ;, ;,, ;,,, ;,9 ;9 am[fm^jhklb \j_f_gguc am[gZy[hev a_jdZeh bkihjq_gguc kiexgmlv rZlZ_lky q_exklv ,,<klZ\vl_^Zggu_gb`_keh\Z\gm`ghcihkfukemnhjf_ ,KDYHDEDG+HRIJRLQJWRDGHQWLVW6KHKDVLQWKLVWRRWK 7KHGRFWRUSXWLQP\WRRWK6KHH[WUDFWHGP\WHHWK SDLQOHVVO\EHDIUDLGDWHPSRUDU\ILOOLQJSDLQWRRWKDFKH ,,,I_j_\_^bl_gZZg]ebckdbcyaud^bZeh]f_`^mam[guf\jZ qhfbiZpb_glhfjZau]jZcl__]h\ebpZo A m [ g h c \ j Z q Qlhk\Zfb" I Z p b _ g l Mf_gykbevgh[heblam[ A m [ g h c \ j Z q KZ^bl_kvih`ZemcklZHldjhcl_jhl I Z p b _ g l Mf_gy[heblwlhlam[ A m [ g h c \ j Z q K_]h^gyyihklZ\ex\Zf\j_f_ggmxiehf[mIjboh ^bl_dhfg_q_j_aljb^gy ,9Ijb^mfZcl_jZkkdZabkihevamyke_^mxsb_keh\Zbkeh\h khq_lZgby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±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~µ]HLLN@QfhaZbdZ VHUYLFH>µV~YLV@Qkem`[Z IUHH>IUL@Da^[_kieZlguc PHGLFDOFDUHa^f_^bpbgkdh_h[ kem`b\Zgb_ LQVWLWXWLRQ>LQVWL¶WMX ~Q@Qmqj_`^_ gb_ WRIXQFWLRQ>µI¾N ~Q@Y^_ckl\h\Zlv nmgdpbhgbjh\Zlv FKROHUD>µNuO~U~@Qohe_jZ SODJXH>SOHLJ@QqmfZ VPDOOSR[>µVPuOSuNV@QhkiZ W\SKXV> WDLI~V@Qlbn WRFRQTXHU>µNu¾N~@Yih[_`^Zlv QXPEHU>µQPE~@Qdhebq_kl\h WRJURZ>JURX@Y JUHZJURZQ jZklb SRZHU>µjZX~@Q\eZklv WRLQFUHDVH>LQ NULV,Ym\_ebqb\Zlv EDVLV> EHLVLV@Qhkgh\Z SURSK\OD[LV>SUuIL OÙNVLV@Qijh nbeZdlbdZ WR SUDFWLVH > SUÙNWLV@ Y ijbf_gylv hkms_kl\eylv WRXQGHUJR>QG~ JRX@Yih^\_j ]Zlvky WXLWLRQ>WMX¶L ~Q@Qh[mq_gb_IUHH WXLWLRQ[_kieZlgh_h[mq_gb_ GHOLFDWH>µGHOOLNLW@Zojmidbc KHDOWK\>µKHOL@Dp_e_[guc SLFWXUHVTXH>SLNW ~ UHVN@D`b\h ibkguc SUHYHQWLRQ>SUL YHQ ~Q@Qij_^mij_ `^_gb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~ GMXV@Yijbqbgylv FXOWXUH> NOW ~@QdmevlmjZ VOLGH>VODLG@Qij_^f_lgh_kl_deh FRYHUVOLS>µNY~VOLS@Qihdjh\gh_ kl_deh MDU>!.@Q[ZgdZ WRPRLVWHQ>µPuLVQ@Ym\eZ`gylvkfZ qb\Zlv ODEHO>µOHLEO@Qyjeudwlbd_ldZ LQRFXODWLQJQHHGOH>L¶QuNMXOHLWL¾ QLGO@ijb\b\hqgZyb]eZ ieZlbgh\Zy b]eZêyihk_\Zfbdjhhj]Zgbafh\ WRKHDW>KLWOYgZ]j_\ZlvgZdZeb\Zlv IODPH>IOHLP@QieZfyh]hgv WHVWWXEH>µWHVWWMXE@Qijh[bjdZ UDFN>UÙN@Qa^rlZlb\ 6RPH5XOHVIRUWKH:RUNRID/DERUDWRU\$VVLVWDQW 7KHODERUDWRU\DVVLVWDQWPXVWZULWHGRZQDOOWKHZRUNFDUULHGRXWLQWKH ODERUDWRU\LQWRWKHODERUDWRU\UHSRUWERRN7KHQRWHVPXVWEHIXOO$OOWKH REVHUYDWLRQVGXULQJDQH[SHULPHQWPXVWEHZULWWHQGRZQLQWRWKHUHSRUW ERRN 7KHUHSRUWPXVWEHZULWWHQLQWKHIROORZLQJIRUP 7LWOHRIWKHH[SHULPHQWDQGWKHGDWH 7KHREMHFWRIWKHH[SHULPHQW 7KHGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHPHWKRGVXVHGDQGWKHQDPHVDQG GHVFULSWLRQVRIWKHRUJDQLVPV 7KHGHVFULSWLRQRIWKHUHVXOWV 7KHFRQFOXVLRQIURPWKHUHVXOWV UHSRUWERRN>UL¶SuW@Q^g_\gbd WLWOH>WDLWO@QgZa\Zgb_ REMHFW> uE!LNW@Qh[t_dlij_^f_l GHVFULSWLRQ>GLV¶NULS ~Q@QhibkZgb_ FRQFOXVLRQ>N~Q¶NOX~Q@iaZdexq_ gb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¶GHQWLN~O@Zh^bgZdh\uc WRUHDFW>ULÙNW@Yj_Z]bjh\Zlv RZQ>RXQ@Zkh[kl\_gguc WR EH XQGHU VSHFLDO FDUH [ulv ih^ ki_pbZevgufgZ[ex^_gb_f REVHUYDWLRQ>uE]~ YHL ~Q@QgZ[ex ^_gb_ UHVHDUFK>UL¶V~W @Dbkke_^h\Zl_ev kdbc WHDP>WLP@Q[jb]Z^Z $WWKH'RFWRU V ' R F W R U :KDW VWURXEOLQJ\RX" 3 D W L H Q W ,KDYHDVZROOHQWKXPEDQG,FRXOGQRWVOHHSDOOQLJKW '+P\RXKDYHDVSOLQWHUWKHUH,PXVWXVHWKHODQFHW WRJHWDWLW<RX VKRXOGQHYHUQHJOHFWDVSOLQWHU,WPD\FDXVHDQLQIHFWLRQDQGDQDEVFHVV 7KHGRFWRUUHPRYHGWKHVSOLQWHUSXWDSDGRIFRWWRQZRRODQGEDQGDJHGXS WKHWKXPE ''RQ¶WUHPRYHWKHEDQGDJH,I\RXUHPRYHLWGLUWZLOOJHWLQLWDQG\RXU WKXPEZLOOVZHOOXSDJDLQ$QGKHUHLVVRPHRLQWPHQWWRSXWRQWKHVZHOO LQJ ODQFHW>µO.QVLW@QeZgp_l WRQHJOHFW>QL¶JOHNW@Yij_g_[j_]Zlv SDGRIFRWWRQZRROlZfihg ,33DYORY±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uO~!L@ 0LOLWDU\$FDGHP\<h_ggZyZdZ^_fby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µQÙW ~U~OµVDL~QVL]@ _kl_kl\_ggu_gZmdb SK\VLRORJLVW>IL]L uO~!LVW@Qnbabheh] WRGLVFRYHU>GLV NY~@Yh[gZjm`b\Zlv WRPDUU\> PÙUL@Y`_gblvky \uoh^blvaZfm` PHPRU\>µPHP~UL@iiZfylv WRLQWHUUXSW>LQW~µUSW@Yij_ju\Zlv GLJHVWLYH>GDL¶!HVWLY@Zibs_\Zjb l_evguc FRQWULEXWLRQ>NuQWUL EMX ~Q@Q \deZ^ VSOHQGLG>µVSOHQGLG@Z\_ebdhe_iguc WRSDVVRQi_j_oh^blv WRKLGH>KDLG@YijylZlv NQRZOHGJH>µQuOL!@QagZgb_ PRGHVW\>µPuG~VWL@Qkdjhfghklv WRLPDJLQH>L¶PÙ!LQ@Y\hh[jZ`Zlv 7UXH )ULHQGVKLS 'XULQJ:RUOG:DU,,DQ$PHULFDQVROGLHUVDZWKDWKLVIULHQGKDGIDOOHQ QHDUWKHWUHQFK+HDVNHGWKHRIILFHU0D\,JRDQGEULQJP\IULHQGVLU" %XWWKHRIILFHUUHIXVHG KLP 'LVREH\LQJWKHRUGHUWKHVROGLHUZHQWWRVDYHKLVIULHQG+HJRWKLPRQ KLV VKRXOGHU DQG UHWXUQHG WR WKH WUHQFKHV EXW KH KLPVHOI ZDV PRUWDOO\ ZRXQGHGDQGKLVIULHQGVRRQGLHG 7KH RIILFHU ZDV DQJU\ , IROG \RX QRW WR JR 1RZ , KDYH ORVW ERWK RI \RX,WZDVQRWZRUWKRILW ,WZDVZRUWKRILWVLUVDLGWKHVROGLHUEH FDXVHZKHQ,JRWWRKLPKHVDLG -LP,NQHZ\RX GFRPH ,WUXH>WUX@Zbklbgguc WRUHIXVH>UL IMX]@YhldZau\Zlv WRGLVREH\>GLV~µEHL@Yg_ih\bgh\Zlvky WUHQFQ>WUHQW @Qhdhi BBBBBBBBBBBBBBB DFFRPSDQLPHQW>~µNPS~QLP~QW@ HQWKXVLDVP>LQ¶MXÙ]L]P@ PRUWDOO\>µPuW~OL@DGYkf_jl_evgh WRGLH>GDL@YmfbjZlv ,WZDVQRWZRUWKRILWg_baaZq_]h[ueh b^lb \RX G \RXZRXOG FRPHluijb^_rv .HHS<RXU+RXVH:HOO .HHS\RXUKRXVHZHOO/HWLWEHFOHDQ:KHQWKHWKLQJVLQ\RXUKRXVH DUHRXWRIRUGHUWKH\PD\FDXVHDFFLGHQWV'LVRUGHUVDOVRGHSUHVV WKHVSLU LWV 'LUWDWWUDFWVLQVHFWVDQGWKH\PD\FDUU\GLVHDVHJHUPV 'XVWPD\DOVR KDYHJHUPV<RXPXVWGDLO\GXVWRUZLSHRUZDVKPRVWRIWKHWKLQJVLQ\RXU KRXVH (YHU\ZHHN\RXPXVWFOHDQWKHUHIULJHUDWRU (DFKPHPEHURIDIDPLO\ PXVWKDYHKLVGXWLHVDWKRPH 'RQ WGLVFXVVZKHWKHU\RXUZRUNLVPHQ VZRUNRUZRPHQ VZRUN(YHQ VPDOOFKLOGUHQFDQGRWKHLUSDUW WRGHSUHVV>GL¶SUHV@Ym]g_lZlv LQVHFW>µLQVHNW@QgZk_dhfh_ JHUP>!~P@Qfbdjh[ UHIULJHUDWRU>ULIUL!~µUHLW~@Q[Reh^bevgbd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~µVMXWLVW@QnZj fZp_\l GHQWDOPHFKDQLF>µGHQWOPL¶NÙQLN@ am[ghcl_ogbd VWDII>VW.I@Qi_jkhgZerlZl WRFRQVLVW>N~Q¶VLVW@Ykhklhylv ba H[SHULHQFHG>LNV SL~UL~QVW@Zhiulguc agZxsbc ZHOOHTXLSSHG>L¶NZLSW@Zohjhrh h[hjm^h\Zgguc WRGLYLGH>GL¶YDLG@Y^_eblv PDLQ>PHLQ@Z]eZ\guchkgh\ghc LQGHSHQGHQW>LQGLSHQG~QW@ZkZfh klhyl_evgucg_aZ\bkbfuc GLUHFWLRQ>GL¶UHN ~Q@Qjmdh\h^kl\h VWDWH>VWHLW@Q]hkm^Zjkl\h Z]hkm^Zjkl\_gguc FRPSOHWH>NuP SOLW@Ziheguc HGXFDWLRQ>HGMX¶NHL ~Q@Qh[jZah\Z gb_ HLWKHU«RU>µDL~@beb«beb OLIHJLYHU^ZjmxsZy`bagv WRGLH>GDL@YmfbjZlv WRQHHG>QLG@Ygm`^Zlvky NLGQH\> NLGQG@QihqdZ WRRSHUDWH>µuS~UHLW@Y^_ckl\h\Zlv IUHHRIFKDUJH>W .!@[_kieZlgh WRGRQDWH>G~ QHLW@Yk^Z\Zlvdjh\v /LIH*LYHU %ORRGLVFDOOHGWKHOLIHJLYHU2IWHQSHRSOHGLH ZLWKRXWEORRGWUDQVIX VLRQ0RUHDQGPRUHEORRGLVQHHGHG WKHVHGD\V,WWDNHVOLWUHVRIEORRG IRUKHDUWRUNLGQH\RSHUDWLRQV $VSHFLDO%ORRG6HUYLFHRSHUDWHV LQ0RVFRZ7KRXVDQGVRISHRSOHJLYH WKHLUEORRGIUHHRIFKDUJH 'RQDWLQJEORRGLVSRSXODUZLWKVWXGHQWVHVSH FLDOO\LQWKHPHGLFDOVFKRROVDQGPHGLFDOLQVWLWXWHV/DUJH0RVFRZIDFWRULHV KDYH'RQRU'D\V 'LDORJXHV ±2K\RXUQRVHLVEOHHGLQJ:KDWKDYH\RXGRQHWRLW" ± 1RWKLQJ , DP VXEMHFW WRLO , WKLQN LW PXVW EH WKH KHDW 6RPHWLPHV LW VWDUWVEOHHGLQJZKLOH ,DPZDONLQJDORQJWKHVWUHHWDQGLWLVYHU\XQ SOHDVDQW ±$OLWWOHFROGZDWHURQWKHEDFNRI\RXUQHFNPD\VWRSLW%HFDUHIXORUWKH EORRGPD\GURSRQ\RXUGUHVV ± 2K LW V EOHHGLQJ SURIXVHO\ 0\ KDQGNHUFKLHI LV TXLWH VRDNHG ZLWK EORRG ±,WKLQNLWZLOOZDVKRXW%ORRGVWDLQV ZDVKRXWLIWKHEORRGLVQRWDOORZHG WRGU\<RXPXVWVHHDGRFWRU<RXFDQVWRSWKHV\PSWRPVEXW\RXGRQ W FXUHWKHFDXVHRIWKHP7KHLOOQHVVPD\EHFRPHVHULRXV WREHVXEMHFW>VE¶!HNW@[ulvih^\_j SURIXVHO\>SU~µIMXVOL@DGYh[bevgh KDQGNHUFKLHI> KÙ¾N~W LI@Qghkh\hc `_gguf ieZlhd KHDW>KLW@Q`ZjZ WRVRDN>VRXN@Yijhiblu\Zlv ZKLOH>ZDLO@FRQM\lh\j_fydZd XQSOHDVDQW>Q¶SOH]~QW@Zg_ijbylgucVWDLQ>VWHLQ@Qiylgh ± +DYH\RXVHHQWKHGRFWRU" ± <HV+HVD\VWKHUHLVQRWKLQJVHULRXVMXVWDFROG,PXVWNHHSLQEHGIRU DIHZGD\V ± $Q\PHGLFLQHWRWDNHIRULW" ± +HJDYHPHVRPHSRZGHUV,PXVWWDNHRQHDWQLJKWDQGDQRWKHULQWKH PRUQLQJ ± 'HDUPH,GRQ WOLNHWDNLQJSRZGHUV7KH\VWLFN WRP\WRQJXH,QHYHU SXWDSRZGHURQP\WRQJXH,SXWLWLQDJODVVRIZDWHUDQGGULQNLW,ILW IORDWV,PL[LWZLWKVRPHMDPDQGWDNHLW%XWLW VEHWWHUZKHQWKHSRZ GHUVDUHSXWXSLQFDSVXOHV7KHQ,KDYHQRSUREOHPV ,WRVWLFN VWXFN YaîjbebiZlv WRIORDW>IORXW@YieZ\Zlv WRPL[>PLNV@Ykf_rb\Zlv MDP>!ÑP@Q\Zj_gv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~Q@Qh`h] HOHFWULFILUH>IDL~@Qwe_dljbq_kdbc dZfbg WRFDWFKILUH>NÙW @aZ]hjZlvky VFUHDP>VNULP@Qdjbd IODPH>IOHLP@QieZfy FDUSHW> N. SLW@Qdh\_j WRJRRXWihlmoZlv SLHFH>SLV@Qdmkhd EXUQW>E~QW@Zkh``_gguc FORWKHV>NORXç]@QieZlv_h^_`^Z DPEXODQFH>µÙPEMXO~QV@QfDrbgZ kdhjhcihfhsb WRZUDS>UÙj@YaZ\_jlu\Zlv WDEOHFORWK>µWHLEONOu@QFdDl_jlv WRKHDO>KLO@YwZ`b\eylvbae_qb\Zlv Bkihevamykeh\Zb\ujZ`_gbybal_dklZ^Zcl_ihîbkbdjb kmgdZf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± DFDGHPLFLDQ , 3 3DYORY RQ WKH SODWHVRIPDQ\KRXVHVLQ0RVFRZ ,WRQDPHDIWHUgZa\ZlvQRbf_gb WREHVLWXDWHG[ulvjZkiheh`_gguf IDPRXV>µIHLP~V@ZwgZf_gblucba \_klguc SHGLDWULVW>SLGL ÙWULVW@Qi_^bZlj WRIDNHSDUWLQ WRRNWDNHQ ijbgb fZlvmqZklb_\ WRSHULVK> SHUL @Yih]b[Zlv WRDGGY^h[Z\eylvijb[Z\eylv E\VWUHHW> EDLVWULW@Qi_j_mehd WRUHPLQG>UL PDLQG@YgZihfbgZlv SODWH >SOHLW@ Q a^ f_fhjbZevgZy ^hkd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¶WSD\\RXDQ\WKLQJ:K\"DVNHGWKH ERRNVHOOHU ,ISHRSOHFRPHWRP\KRXVH,DVNWKHPWRSD\RQHSRXQGEXWZKHQ,JR WRWKHLUKRXVHV,WDNHWZRSRXQGV ,WRSD\>SHL@Y SDLG ieZlblv SRXQG>SDXQG@Qnmgl kl_jebg]h\ ERRNVHOOHU> EXNVHO~@Qijh^Z\_pdgb] &DOP/HDGHUVKLSLV,PSRUWDQW <RXNQRZWKHOLIHVDYLQJILUVWDLG,I\RXDUHILUVWRQWKHVFHQHRIDQDF FLGHQW \RX FDQ GHFLGH ZKDW PXVW EH GRQH EHIRUH WKH DUULYDO RI DQ DPEX ODQFHRUPHGLFDOSHUVRQQHO&DOPOHDGHUVKLSLVYHU\LPSRUWDQW 0DNHWKHRWKHUV :KHQ\RXWHOHSKRQHIRUDQDPEXODQFH\RXPXVW JLYHFOHDULQVWUXFWLRQVURDG±VWUHHW±SODFH WHOODERXWWKHW\SHRIDFFLGHQWFROOLVLRQ klhedgh\_gb_ FDURQILUH QXPEHURIYLFWLPV `_jl\ 6RPH:RUGVDERXW0HPRU\ 6RPH SHRSOH KDYH JRRG PHPRULHV DQG HDVLO\ OHDUQ ORQJ SRHPV E\ KHDUW %XW WKH\ RIWHQ IRUJHW WKHP YHU\ TXLFNO\ 2WKHU SHRSOH UHPHPEHU WKLQJVZKHQWKH\VD\WKHPRYHUDQGRYHU$JRRGPHPRU\LVDJUHDWK HOS 7KH EHVW ZD\ WR UHPHPEHU WKLQJV LV WR MRLQ WKHP LQ RXU PLQG ZLWK VRPHWKLQJZKLFKZHNQRZDOUHDG\ 7KHKXPDQPLQGLVOLNHDFDPHUDEXWLWWDNHVSKRWRJUDSKVQRWRQO\RIZKDW ZHVHHEXWRIZKDWZHIHHOKHDUVPHOO DQGWDVWH 0HPRU\LVWKHGLDU\WKDWZHDOOFDUU\DERXWZLWKXV PLQG>PDLQG@QaîZfylv WRVPHOO>VPHO@Yh[hgylvgxoZlv WRWDVWH>WHLVW@Yijh[h\Zlv GLDU\> GDL~UL@Q^g_\gbd ,PHPRU\>µPHP~UL@QiZfylv E\KHDUWgZbamklv WRIRUJHW>I~µJHW@YaZ[u\Zlv WRMRLQ>!uLQ@Ykh_^bgylv 63%RWNLQ 6 3 %RWNLQ ZDV ERUQ RQ 6HSWHPEHU $IWHU ILQLVKLQJ RQH RI 0RVFRZVFKRROVKHHQWHUHGWKH0HGLFDO)DFXOW\ RI0RVFRZ8QLYHUVLW\ %RWNLQ ZDV LQWHUHVWHG LQ PHGLFLQH YHU\ PXFK DQG VRRQ EHFDPH RQH RI WKHEHVWVWXGHQWV $IWHU JUDGXDWLQJ IURP WKH 0HGLFDO )DFXOW\ LQ %RWNLQ ZHQWWRWKH &ULPHDZKHUHKHZRUNHGDVDSK\VLFLDQDWWKH6LPIHURSRO0LOLWDU\+RVSL WDOXQGHUWKHGLUHFWLRQRIWKHZHOONQRZQ5XVVLDQVXUJHRQ3LURJRY ,Q %RWNLQ EHJDQ WR ZRUN DW WKH 0HGLFR6XUJLFDO $FDGHP\ LQ 3HWHUVEXUJ,QKHEHFDPHDSURIHVVRURIWKH7KHUDSHXWLF&OLQLFDWWKH $FDGHP\+HZRUNHGKDUG+HZDQWHGWRKDYHDPRGHO FOLQLFDWWKH$FDG HP\%RWNLQRUJDQL]HGDZHOOHTXLSSHGSK\VLRORJLFDOODERUDWRU\IRUFOLQL FDOH[SHULPHQWV%RWNLQZDVDEULOOLDQWWKHUDSHXWLVWDQGGLDJQRVWLFLDQ2QH RI KLV JUHDWHVW DFKLHYHPHQWV ZDV KLV WKHRU\ RI QHUYRVLVP ZKLFK LV WKH PRVWSURJUHVVLYHWKHRU\LQFOLQLFDOPHGLFLQH %RWNLQ ZDV QRW RQO\ D EULOOLDQW VFLHQWLVW EXW DQ H[FHOOHQW WHDFKHU WRR 0DQ\ RI KLV SXSLOV EHFDPH IDPRXV SK\VLFLDQV DQG ZRUNHG DW 5XVVLDQ XQLYHUVLWLHVDVSURIHVVRUV %RWNLQ ZDV DOVR RQH RI WKH IRXQGHUV RI PLOLWDU\ WKHUDSHXWLFV +H ZRUNHGDWWKHIURQWGXULQJWKH5XVVR7XUNLVKZDUJLYLQJPXFKRIKLVWLPH WRWKHRUJDQL]DWLRQRIPHGLFDODLG 'XULQJKLVZKROHOLIHKHQHYHUVWRSSHGZRUNLQJIRUWKHJRRGRIWKH5XV VLDQSHRSOH+LVQDPHLVRQHRIWKHPRVWIDPRXVQDPHVLQPHGLFLQHDQGLW ZLOOEHDOZD\VUHPHPEHUHGLQWKHKLVWRU\RI5XVVLDQVFLHQFH IDFXOW\>µIÙN~OWL@QnZdmevl_l &ULPHD>NUDL PL~@.Suf GLUHFWLRQ>GL¶UHN ~Q@Qjmdh\h ^kl\h PRGHO>µPuGO@Qh[jZa_p WRHTXLS>L NZLS@Yh[hjm^h\Zlv GLDJQRVWLFLDQ>GDL~JQuV¶WL ~Q@Q^bZ]ghkl DFKLHYHPHQW>~µW LYP~QW@Q^hklb`_gb_ VFLHQWLVW>µVDL~QWLVW@Qmq_guc H[FHOOHQW>µHNV~O~QW@Dij_\hkoh^guc WKHUDSHXWLFV>µHU~µSMXWLNV@Ql_jZiby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~QG@QXPlukyqZ WRSDLQW>SHLQW@YdjZkblvkyjm fygblvky DQFLHQW>µHLQ ~QW@Z^j_\gbc SRZGHUHG>µSDXG~G@Zihjhrdh h[jZaguc WRZKLWHQ>µZDLW~Q@Yh[_eblv FURZG>NUDXG@QlheiZ VODYH>VOHLY@QjZ[jZ[ugy IDFHSDFN >µIHLVSÙN@ Q iblZl_evgZy fZkdZ IORXU>IODX~@QfmdZ VPRRWK>VPXç@Z]eZ^dbc EULJKW>EUDLW@Zk\_leuc FXVWRP>µNVW~P@Qh[uqZc WDVWH>WHLVW@Q\dmk WRDFFHSW>~N¶VHSW@YijbgbfZlv <RX0XVW%H3URXG²<RX:LOO%HD1XUVH 7KH QXUVH LVSUHVHQWDWWKHWLPHRIELUWKDQGVKHLVVRPHWLPHVSUHVHQW ZKHQOLIHHQGV+HUZKROHOLIHLVGHYRWHG WRSHRSOH6KHLVUHVSRQVLEOH IRU ZKDWVKHGRHV6KHLVUHVSRQVLEOHIRUZKDWVKHDGYLVHVRWKHUVWRGR (YHU\QXUVHPXVWKDYHHQRXJKNQRZOHGJHRIKHUZRUN6KHPXVWUHDG PHGLFDOMRXUQDOV6KHPXVWKHOSKHUSDWLHQWVDWDQ\KRXURIWKHGD\RUQLJKW 6KHPXVWFDUHIRUWKHSDWLHQWHYHQLIWKHSDWLHQWKDVDPRUWDO LQIHFWLRXVGLV HDVH5HPHPEHUWKDWSDWLHQWVQHHG\RXUKHOSFDUHDQGSDWLHQFH (YHU\QXUVHIROORZVPRUDOUXOHVWKDWGLUHFWKHULQKHUZRUN ,ELUWK>E~@Qjh`^_gb_ WRGHYRWH>GL¶YRXW@Yihk\ysZlv UHVSRQVLEOH>ULV¶SuQV~EO@Zhl\_lkl\_gguc PRUWDO>µPuW~O@Zkf_jl_evguc WRGLUHFW>GL¶UHNW@Yjmdh\h^blv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µNOLQQLV@QqbklhlZ PLGGD\>µPLGGHL@Zihe^g_\gucih em^_gguc WRFKLOO>W LO@YhoeZ`^Zlvklm^blv GLVLQIHFWDQW>GLVLQ¶IHNW~QW@Q^_abg nbpbjmxs__kj_^kl\h G\VHQWHU\>GLV~QWUL@Q^ba_gl_jby +LSSRFUDWHV±WKH)DWKHURI0HGLFLQH ²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µELµVL@^hgZr_cwju WRGULYHRXW>GUDLY@Y GURYH ba]h gylv $WKHQV> ÙLQ]@:nbgu WROLJKW>ODLW@Y OLWOLJKWHG aZ`b]Zlv ILUH>µIDL~@Qdhkl_j FROOHFWLRQ>N~µOHN ~Q@Qkh[jZgb_ WRFRQVLVW RI >N~Q¶VLVW@Ykhklhylv ba PRGHUQ> PuG~Q@Zkh\j_f_gguc RDWK>RX@Qdeyl\Z SUDFWLWLRQHU>jUÙN¶WL Q~@QijZdlb dmxsbc\jZq WRFUHDWH>NUL¶HLW@Ykha^Z\Zlv H[SHULHQFH>LNV¶SL~UL~QV@Qhiul IUHH>IQ@Yhk\h[h`^Zlv VXSHUVWLWLRQ>VMXS~µVWL ~Q@Qkm_\_ jb_ SXQLVKPHQW> jQL P~QW@QgZdZaZgb_ J\PQDVWLFV>LP¶QÙVWLNV@Q]bfgZklb dZ PDVVDJH >µPÙV.@ Q fZkkZ` Y ^_ eZlvfZkkZ` WRVHW>VHW@Y VHW \ijZ\eylv WR WUHSKLQH >WUL¶ILQ@ Y ijhba\h^blv lj_iZgZpbx )URPWKH+LSSRFUDWLF2DWK ,ZLOOXVHWUHDWPHQWWRKHOSWKHVLFNSHRSOHEXWQHYHUWRLQMXUH>µLQ !~@ ih\j_^blv WKHP ,ZLOOHQWHUWRKHOSWKHVLFNDQG ZKDWVRHYHU,VKDOOVHHRUKHDULQWKH FRXUVHRIP\SURIHVVLRQ,ZLOOQHYHUGLYXOJH>GDLY O!@ jZa]eZrZlv ,ZLOO KROGVXFKWKLQJVLQVHFUHW« 3KDUPDFRJQRV\ 7KHWHUPRISKDUPDFRJQRV\FRPHVIURPWKH*UHHNZRUGV SKDUPDNRQ± GUXJDQGJQRVLV±NQRZOHGJHDQGPHDQVWKHWRWDONQRZOHGJHRIGUXJV 7KH VROXELOLW\ RI SODQW HOHPHQWV GHSHQGV RQ WKHLU FKHPLFDO VWUXFWXUH $PRQJ WKH FDUERK\GUDWHV WKH WUXH VXJDUV VXFK DV JOXFRVH VXFURVH DQG ODFWRVH DUH VROXEOH LQ ZDWHU DXGLR D OLPLWHG H[WHQW LQ DOFRKRO EXW DUH LQ VROXEOHLQFKORURIRUPDQGLQHWKHU 7KHPXFLODJHVDUHLQVROXEOHLQZDWHUDOFRKROFKORURIRUPDQGHWKHU 7KHJO\FRVLGHVDUHVROXEOHLQZDWHU7KHYRODWLOHRLOVDUHVOLJKWO\ VROXEOH LQZDWHU$OFRKROLVDQLGHDOVROYHQW IRUYRODWLOHRLOV ,NQRZOHGJH>µQuOL!@QagZgb_ VROXELOLW\>VuOMX¶ELOLWL@QjZkl\hjb fhklv WRGHSHQG>GL SHQG@YaZ\bk_lv WUXH>WUX@Da^qbkluc WRDOLPLWHGH[WHQW^hg_dhlhjhckl_ i_gb VOLJKWO\>µVODLWOL@DGYke_]dZ VROYHQW> VuOY~QW@QjZkl\hjbl_ev 620(0(',&,1(6$1'+2:7286(7+(0 ,QWDO ,QWDOLVSUHVFULEHGIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIEURQFKLDODVWKPD,QWDOGRHVQRW KHOSGXULQJDQDFXWHDWWDFNRIDVWKPDHVSHFLDOO\VWDWXVDVWKPDWLFXV ,QWDO FDSVXOHV PXVW EH XVHG RQO\ LQ WKH VSLQKDOHU bg]Zeylhj DQG QRW VZDOORZHG ]ehlZlv 7KHGRFWRUZLOOLQVWUXFW\RXKRZWRXVH,QWDOFDSVXOHV LQWKHVSLQKDOHU 7KH FDSVXOHV DUH XVHG DW UHJXODU LQWHUYDOV DV SUHVFULEHG E\ WKH GRFWRU 5HJXODUGRVDJHLVLPSRUWDQW²GRQRWVWRSWKHWUHDWPHQWVXGGHQO\DQGGR QRWH[FHHG ij_\urZlv WKHSUHVFULEHGGRVDJHZLWKRXWWKHGRFWRU VSHUPLV VLRQ jZaj_r_gb_ ,QWDOFDSVXOHVPXVWEHNHSWLQDFROGGU\SODFH $WURPLG6 $WURPLG6LVSUHVFULEHGIRUWKHWUHDWPHQWRIDWKHURVFOHURVLVSDUWLFXODUO\ FRURQDU\KHDUWGLVHDVH ' R V D J H 7KH GDLO\ GRVDJH PXVW EH GLYLGHG LQWR WZR RU PRUH GRVHV DQG WDNHQDIWHUIRRG & D X W L R Q 7DNH QRW PRUH WKDQ FDSVXOHV 7UHDWPHQW RI SDWLHQWV ZLWK UHQDO ihq_qghc GLVIXQFWLRQ UHTXLUHV lj_[m_l FDXWLRQ 'R QRW JLYH $WURPLG6WRSUHJQDQWSDWLHQWV &RPSODPLQ , Q G L F D W L R Q V 7KURPERVLV WKURPERSKOHELWLV P\RFDUGLDO LQIDUFWLRQ OXQJHPEROLVP K R Q W U D L Q G L F D W L R Q V &RPSODPLQLQMHFWLRQVDUHQRWLQGLFDWHGLQPL WUDO VWHQRVLV ZLWK ULJKWKHDUW IDLOXUH ijZ\h`_em^hqdh\Zy g_^hklZlhq ghklv ' R V D J H &RPSODPLQLVXVHGIRULQWUDYHQRXVDQGLQWUDPXVFXODULQMHFWLRQV %RWKPHWKRGVDUHHTXDOO\HIIHFWLYH,QWUDYHQRXVLQMHFWLRQVKRXOGEHFDUULHG RXWVORZO\7KHGRVDJHRI&RPSODPLQVKRXOG ^he`gZ EHDVKLJKDVSRVVL EOHDVKLJKDVFDQEHWROHUDWHG i_j_ghkbf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µVHQV~WLY@Dqm\kl\bl_evguc DPEHU>µÙPE~@Z`_eluc VROXEOH> VuOMXEO@ZjZkl\hjbfuc VOLJKWO\> VODLWOL@DGYkeZ[h SRLVRQRXV>µSuL]Q~V@Zy^h\bluc LQWUDYHQRXVO\>LQWU~µYLQ~VOL@\gmljb \_ggh 5KXEDUE 5KHXP 7KHUKL]RPHVRIUKXEDUEDUHFROOHFWHGIURPSODQWVHLJKWWRWHQ\HDUVROG 7KHQWKHUKL]RPHVDUHGULHGHLWKHULQWKHVXQRULQRYHQV $IWHUWKHGU\LQJ RSHUDWLRQWKHUKL]RPHVDUHSHHOHG 5KXEDUEZDVXVHGLQ&KLQDPRUHWKDQ \HDUVDJR,WZDVXVHGE\WKH*UHHNDQG5RPDQSK\VLFLDQVDQGZDV XVHGLQ(XURSHLQWKHPLGGOHDJHV5KXEDUELVXVHGIRULWVSXUJDWLYH DFWLRQ UKXEDUE> UXE.E@Qj_\_gv UKL]RPH>µUDL]~P@Qdhjg_\bs_ RYHQ>µRXYQ@Qi_qv WRSHHO>SLO@Ya^kgbfZlvdh`mjm SXUJDWLYH>µS~J~WLY@ZkeZ[bl_evguc $OWKDHD 7KHVHFRQG\HDUURRWV RIWKLVSODQWDUHFROOHFWHGGULHGDQGSHHOHG $IWHUSHHOLQJLWLVFXWLQWRVPDOOSLHFHV$OWKDHDLVXVHGDVDVHGDWLYHLQ WKHIRUPRIWKHPXFLODJH RULQWKHIRUPRIDOWKDHDV\UXS DOWKDHD>ÙO¶L~@QZel_c URRW>UXW@Qdhj_gv SLHFH>SLV@Qdmkhd PXFLODJH > PMXVLOL!@ jZklbl_evgZy kebav *HQGRQ *HQGRQ LV SUHSDUHG IURP WKH URRW RI 5DXZROILD VHUSHQWLQD DQ ,QGLDQ SODQW *HQGRQFDXVHVDORZHULQJ RIWKHEORRGSUHVVXUH6LGHHIIHFWVDUHSUDFWL FDOO\DEVHQW ' R V D J H 7KHLQLWLDOGRVDJHLVWDEOHWV PJ GDLO\,QGD\VWKHEORRG SUHVVXUHWHQGVWRGURS3DWLHQWVZLWKK\SHUWHQVLRQPD\WDNHOHVVGXULQJWKH ILUVWGD\V,QVRPHFDVHVLWPD\EHQHFHVVDU\WRLQFUHDVHWKHGRVHWRWDE OHWV $PDLQWHQDQFHGRVHFRQVLVWVRI,WDEOHWV ,PJ GDLO\ 7DNHWKHWDEOHWVDIWHUPHDOVZLWKRXWFKHZLQJ $V*HQGRQKDVDVHGDWLYHHIIHFWWDNHLWDWILUVWLQWKHHYHQLQJ ,WRSUHSDUH>SUL¶S0~@Y]hlh\blv ORZHULQJ>µORX~UL¾@Qihgb`_gb_ LQLWLDO>L QL ~O@ZgZqZevguc WRWHQG>WHQG@Ybf_lvl_g^_gpbx\_klb d q_fme WRGURS>GUuS@YiZ^Zlv PDLQWHQDQFH>µPHLQWLQ~QV@Qih^^_j`Zgb_ *OLPLG 7DEOHWV , Q G L F D W L R Q V *OLPLGLVYDOXDEOH LQWUHDWLQJLQVRPQLD DQGQHUYRXVWHQ VLRQ,WLVDOVRXVHGDVDSUHPHGLFDWLRQ LQVXUJLFDOSURFHGXUHV 6 L G H H I I H F W V RI*OLPLGDUHRIOLWWOHVLJQLILFDQFH ,QVRPHFDVHVYRPLW LQJDQGVNLQUDVKPD\DSSHDU ' R V D J H ,QFDVHRILQVRPQLDDVLQJOHRUDOGRVHRIJIRUDGXOWVVKRXOG EH JLYHQ WKLUW\ PLQXWHV EHIRUH UHVW 1H[W GRVH FDQ EH UHSHDWHG GXULQJ WKH QLJKWEXWQRWODWHUWKDQIRXUKRXUVEHIRUHDZDNHQLQJ $VDVHGDWLYHGUXJJRI*OLPLGLVJLYHQWLPHVGDLO\ YDOXDEOH>µYÙOMXE~O@Zp_gguc LQVRPQLD>LQ VuPQL~@Q[_kkhggbpZ WHQVLRQ>µWHQ Q@QgZijy`_gb_ SUHPHGLFDWLRQ>SULPHGL¶NHL Q@Q ij_^\Zjbl_evgh_e_q_gb_ VLJQLILFDQFH>VLJµQLILN~QV@QagZq_gb_ VLQJOH>µVL¾JO@Qh^gb DZDNHQLQJ>~µZHLN~QL¾@Qijh[m`^_ gb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µLQ~@Z\gmlj_ggbc WULPHVWHU>WUDL¶PHVW~@Qlj_of_kyqguc kjhd SUHJQDQF\>µSUHJQ~QVL@Q[_j_f_gghklv EDVH>EHLVMQhkgh\Z XQFKHZHD>Q¶W XG@SDUWg_i_j_`_ \Zgguc P\RFDUGLDOLQIDUFWLRQ >PDLR¶N.GL~O@bgnZjdlfbhdZj^Z LQWUDYHQRXV>LQWU~ YLQ~V@Z\gml jb\_gguc WRLUULWDWH>µLULWHLW@YjZa^jZ`Zlv \uau\ZlvjZa^jZ`_gb_ (OL[RSK\OOLQ 7KHRSK\OOLQH(OL[LU , Q G L F D W L R Q )RU V\PSWRPDWLF UHOLHI RI EURQFKLDO DVWKPD SXOPRQDU\ HPSK\VHPDDQGRWKHUSXOPRQDU\GLVHDVHVZLWKEURQFKRVSDVP (OL[RSK\OOLQ KHOSV SDWLHQWV ZLWK HPSK\VHPD DQG FKURQLF EURQFKLDO DVWKPDWREUHDWKHFRPIRUWDEO\ (OL[RSK\OOLQ LV HVSHFLDOO\ XVHIXO LQ ORQJWHUP WKHUDS\ ZLWK ROGHU SD WLHQWV 3 U H F D X W L R Q 'R QRW XVH (OL[RSK\OOLQ WRJHWKHU ZLWK RWKHU WKHRSK\OOLQH SUHSDUDWLRQV UHOLHI>U~µOLI@Qh[e_]q_gb_ 0HOODULO 7KLRULGD]LQH+\GURFKORULGH , Q G L F D W L R Q )RUQHUYRXVDJHGSDWLHQWVZLWK klZjq_kdbc SV\FKRVLV )RU SDWLHQWV ZLWK GLVRUGHUO\ EHKDYLRXU VXGGHQ FKDQJHV LQ PRRG gZ kljh_gb_ 0HOODULOKHOSVWRFDOPQHUYRXVSDWLHQWV,WUHGXFHV kgb`Z_l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¶YLOM~Q@QrlZlkdbc a^\hj\Zlvky ERPEDUGPHQW>EuPE.GP~QW@Q[hf EDVHPHQW>µEHLVP~QW@Qih^\Ze [Zj^bjh\dZ WRKLGH>KDLG@ KLGKLGGHQ YijylZlv PLOLWDU\>PLOLW~UL@Z\h_gguc VDIH>VHLI@Z[_ahiZkguc GHFRUDWLRQ>GHN~µUHL ~Q@Qhj^_g /HQD3HWURYD $W WKH EHJLQQLQJ RI WKH ZDU /HQD YROXQWHHUHG IRU DUP\ VHUYLFH 6KH ZDVQLQHWHHQ\HDUVROG6KHZDVVPDOOEXWVWURQJDQGORRNHGOLNHDER\ZLWK KHUKDLUFXWVKRUW $W ILUVW VKH ZDV D QXUVH 6KH WRRN SDUW LQ PDQ\ KRW EDWWOHV DQG ZDV ZRXQGHGDQGWZLFHFRQWXVHG/HQDORVWKHUEHVWJLUOIULHQGDQGLWZDVWKHQ WKDWVKHGHFLGHGWRWDNHXSWKHULIOHLQVWHDGRIKHUQXUVHV VEDJ 6KHVZRUHWRWLJKWWKHHQHP\XQWLOKHUKHDUWFRXOGEHDWKHUH\HVFRXOG VHHDQGKHUKDQGFRXOGPRYH /HQDZDVDEUDYHJLUO6KHZDVDZDUGHGWKHRUGHURIWKH5HG6WDU$IWHU WKHZDUVKHEHFDPHDQXUVHDJDLQ WR YROXQWHHU >YuO~Q¶WLD@ Y ihklmiZlv ^h[jh\hevp_f DUP\VHUYLFH>µV~YLV@\h_ggZykem`[Z EDWWOH>µEÙWO@QkjZ`_gb_ WRGHFLGH>GL VDLG@Yj_rZlv ULIOH> UDLIO@Q\bglh\dZ WRVZHDU>VZ0~@Ydeyklvky HQHP\>µHQLPL@Qg_ijbyl_ev 1HDU'XERVHNRYR 7KH\ZHUHGLIILFXOW GD\V7KHIDVFLVWDUP\ZDVQHDU0RVFRZ7ZHQW\QLQH JXDUGV IURP WKH JHQHUDO 3DQILORY GLYLVLRQ IRXJKW KHURLFDOO\ :LWK WKHLU DQWLWDQN JXQV WKH\ GHVWUR\HG RQH DIWHU DQRWKHU WKH WDQNV DGYDQFLQJ RQ WKHP 7KHLU EDWWOH ODVWHG IRU IRXU KRXUV 7KH HQHP\ FRXOG QRW VKDNH WKH JXDUGV %XWDWODVWWKHUHZHUHQRPRUHDQWLWDQNJXQVKHOOVQRPRUHJUHQDGHV« 7KHRQO\JXDUGVPDQZKRZDVIRXQGDOLYH WROGWKLVVWRU\RQKLVGHDWK EHG+HSDVVHGRQWKHODVWZRUGVRIKLVFRPUDGHV'RQRWVKHG WHDUVIRU RXU GHDG ERGLHV :H GLG RXU VROGLHUV GXW\ :H FORVHG WKH ZD\ WR WKH HQ HP\:HNQRZZKDWZHZHUHG\LQJIRU)LJKWWKHIDVFLVWVDQGUHPHPEHU YLFWRU\RUGHDWK:HGLHGEXWZHZRQW GLIILFXOW>µGLILN~OW@Zljm^guc JXDUG>J.G@Q]\Zj^__p JXQ>JQ@Qhjm^b_ DGYDQFLQJ>~G Y.QVL¾@gZklmiZ\rb_ VKHOO> HO@QkgZjy^ DOLYH>~µODLY@Z`b\hc GHDWK>GH@Qkf_jlv WRVKHG> HG@ VKHG Yijheb\Zlv YLFWRU\>µYLNW~UL@Qih[_^Z )5207+(+,6725<2)0(',&,1( 7KH&RQTXHVWRI6PDOOSR[ ,Q WKH WK FHQWXU\ VPDOOSR[ ZDV RQH RI WKH PDLQ FDXVHV RI GHDWK <RXQJ DQG ROG FDXJKW WKLV GLVHDVH &KLOGUHQ RI SRRU SDUHQWV GLHG EHIRUH WKH\ZHUHILYH\HDUVROG (GZDUG-HQQHU>HGZ.G¶!HQ~@ZDVDQ(QJOLVKSK\VLFLDQ +HZDVERUQ LQ(QJODQGLQ-HQQHUVWXGLHGPHGLFLQHLQ/RQGRQDQGLQKHUH WXUQHGWRKLVQDWLYHWRZQ ,QWKRVHGD\VWKHZKROHZRUOGZDVDIUDLGRIVPDOOSR[(YHU\ILIWKSHUVRQ LQ/RQGRQKDGWKHPDUNV RIWKHGLVHDVHRQKLVIDFH 2QFH D PLONPDLG VDLG WR -HQQHU , VKDQ W FDWFK VPDOOSR[ DV , KDYH DO UHDG\KDGFRZSR[ -HQQHU DVNHG WKH FRXQWU\ SHRSOH DERXW FRZSR[ DQG IRXQG WKDW PDQ\ PHQDQGZRPHQWKRXJKWDERXWLWOLNHWKDWPLONPDLG )RU PRUH WKDQ \HDUV -HQQHU VWXGLHG FRZSR[ DQG H[SHULPHQWHG RQ DQLPDOV ,QD\RXQJZRPDQFDPHWR-HQQHU:KDW¶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kieZlgh DQ\RQHZKRFDPHWRKLP+HGLHGDW%HUNHOH\,Q 7KHUHLVDPRQXPHQWLQ/RQGRQZKLFKVKRZV-HQQHUYDFFLQDWLQJDFKLOG 1RZDGD\VPRVWEDELHVDUHYDFFLQDWHG7KHO\PSKLVSUHSDUHGLQODERUDW R ULHV7KHYDFFLQHLVHIIHFWLYHIRUDERXWVHYHQ\HDUV FRQTXHVW> Nu¾NZHVW@Qih[_^Z VPDOOSR[>µVPuOSuNV@ihkiZ PDLQ>PHLQ@Zhkgh\ghc GHDWK>GH@ikf_jlv SK\VLFLDQ>IL¶]L ~Q@Q\jZq QDWLYH> QHLWLY@Zjh^ghc PDUN>P.N@ike_^ PLONPDLG>µPLONPHLG@i^hyjdZ FRZSR[> NDXSuNV@idhjh\vyhkiZ VRUH>Vu@i[heyqdZjZgZ PDWWHU>µPÙW~@Q\_s_kl\h WRLQRFXODWH>L¶QuNMXOHLW@Y^_eZlv ijb\b\dm WRVXIIHU>µVI~@YkljZ^Zlv WHUULEOH>µWHULEO@Zm`Zkguc YDFFLQDWLRQ>YÙNVL¶QHL ~Q@i\Zdpb gZpby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µPuQMXP~QW@QiZfylgbd H[SHULPHQW>LNV¶SHULP~QW@Qhiul WRWKDQN>Ù¾N@Y[eZ]h^Zjblv LQWKHQDPHRIhlbf_gb VFLHQFH>µVDL~QV@QgZmdZ KXPDQLW\>KMX¶PÙQLWL@Qq_eh\_q_kl \h KRQRUDU\GHJUHH>µuQU~ULGL¶JUL@ ihq_lgZykl_i_gv WRSUHVHQW>SUL ]HQW@Yih^jblv JUDQGVRQ>µJUÙQVQ@Q\gmd PRQNH\>µP¾NL@Qh[_avygZ WXUQ>W~Q@Qhq_j_^v VORZO\>µVORXOL@DGYf_ê_ggh WRGURSY[jhkZlv WRPHDQ>PLQ@Y PHDQW>PHQW@ a^ bf_lv\\b^m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ÙNVL¶GHQWO@ZkemqZcguc H[SORVLRQ>LNV¶SORX~Q@Q\aju\ KROH>KRXO@QûjZhl\_jklb_ WRH[WUXGH>HNV¶WLXG@Y\uklmiZlv\u ibjZlv WRODFHUDWH>µOÙV~UHLW@YjZaju\ZlvjZa ^bjZlv LQMXU\>µLQ!~UL@Qih\j_`^_gb_jZgZ VXSHUILFLDO>VMXK~ IL ~@Zih\_joghkl guc WRUHGUHVV>UL¶GUHV@Yih\lhjghi_j_\y aZlvjZgm QDNHG RSHQLQJ >µQHLNLG µRXSQL¾@ hldjulh_hl\_jklb_ûjZ XQFORVHG>Q¶NORX]G@Zhldjuluc YDOYH>YÙOY@QdeZiZg GLJHVWLRQ>GL¶!HVW ~Q@Qibs_\Z j_gb_ WRVROYH>VuOY@Yj_rZlvjZaj_ rZlv WRUHIXVH>UL¶IMX]@YhldZau\Zlv WRRIIHU>µuI~@Yij_êZ]Zlv WREXU\>µEHUL@Yohjhgblv ³7\SKRLG 0DU\´ 7\SKRLG0DU\ZDVDQ$PHULFDQZRPDQZKRZDVWKHW\SKRLGFDUULHU 6KHZDVDFRRN ih\Zj WRPDQ\IDPLOLHVLQDQGDURXQG1HZ<RUNDQGSUR GXFHGRQHW\SKRLGHSLGHPLF DIWHUDQRWKHUXQWLOLQWKHFDXVHZDVGLV FRYHUHG 6KHIRXJKWDJDLQVWIRXUSROLFHPHQZKRZDQWHGWREULQJKHUWRWKHKRV SLWDO )RU\HDUVVKHZDVNHSWXQGHUVXSHUYLVLRQ 6KHSURPLVHGWRJLYHXS KHUSURIHVVLRQ%XWVKHEURNHKHUSURPLVHFKDQJHGKHUQDPHDQGZRUNHG DJDLQDVDFRRNLQKRWHOVDQGUHVWDXUDQWV>µUHVW~Uu¾V@$WODVWVKHZDVIRXQG DQGLVRODWHG6KHZDVJLYHQZRUNLQWKHODERUDWRU\RIDKRVSLWDODQGWKHUH VKHOLYHGXQWLOKHUGHDWKLQ6KHKDGEHHQWKHGLUHFWFDXVHRIILIW\WKUHH FDVHVRIW\SKRLG W\SKRLG>µWDLIuLG@Q[jxrghclbn Zlbnhaguc FDUULHU>µNÙUL~@Q[Zpbeehghkbl_ev HSLGHPLF>HSL¶GHPLN@Qwib^_fby FDXVH>Nu]@QijbqbgZ WRILJKW>IDLW@Y IRXJKW>IuW@ [hjhlvky VXSHUYLVLRQ>VMXS~µYL!~Q@QgZâhj WRSURPLVH>µSUuPLV@Yh[_sZlv :G=EHJMKKDB?L?F:LBQ?KDB? <UJ:@?GBYBJ:A=H<HJGBD ,Q:KLBL?E:Q?EH<?D: <ujZ`_gby WKHIRUHKHDGLVKRWeh[]hjyqbc WKHOLSVDUHKRWDQGGU\]m[u]hjyqb_bkmob_ WKHMRLQWVDUHSDLQIXOkmklZ\u[heyl ,,HKGH<G:YF?>BPBGKD:YL?JFBGHEH=BY :<ujZ`_gby WREHH[DPLQHGE\DGRFWRUijhclbhkfhljm\jZqZ WREHVLFNbkiulu\Zlvlhrghlm Zg]e [ulv[hevguf Zf_j WREHWUHDWHGE\DGRFWRU[ulvih^gZ[ex^_gb_f e_qblvkym\jZqZ WREHZHOOqm\kl\h\Zlvk_[yohjhrh WREH;UD\HGk^_eZlvj_gl]_ghkdhibx WRFDOO LQ DGRFWRU\ua\Zlv\jZqZ WRFRPHWRijbclb\k_[y WRIDOOLOO WREHWDNHQLOO aZ[he_lv WRIHHOEDG ZHOO qm\kl\h\Zlvk_[yiehoh ohjhrh WRIHHOEHWWHUqm\kl\h\Zlvk_[yemqr_ WRIROORZWKHGRFWRU VRUGHUV\uihegylvmdZaZgby\jZqZ WRJRIRUDSK\VLFLDQihclbaZ\jZqhf WRNHHS VWD\ LQEHGe_`Zlv hklZ\Zlvky \ihkl_eb WRORRNWLUHG\u]ey^_lvmklZeuf WRUXQDVSOLQWHU LQWRWKHKDQGHWF aZghablv jmdmbl^ WRVHH FRQVXOW DGRFWRUh[jZlblvkyd\jZqm WRVHQGIRUDSK\VLFLDQihkeZlvaZ\jZqhf ;JZa]h\hjgbd KZi,GRDQ\WKLQJIRU\RX"Fh]myk^_eZlvqlhgb[m^vêy\Zk" ,WLVQRWJRRGIRU\RXUKHDOWKWlh\j_^ghêy\Zr_]ha^hjh\vy 1RUHDGLQJLQEHG<ihkl_ebg_qblZcl_ 3XOO\RXUVHOIWRJHWKHU<havfbl_k_[y\jmdb 7KHSDWLHQWLVIHYHULVKM[hevgh]h`Zj 7KHSDWLHQWLVWKLUVW\;hevghcohq_liblv <RXDUHRYHUWLUHG<ui_j_mlhfe_gu <RXGRQ WORRNZHOO<uiehoh\u]ey^bl_ <RXORRNSDOH<u[e_^gu <RXORRNZHOO<uohjhrh\u]ey^bl_ <RXZLOOKDYH\RXUFKHVW;UD\HGDQG\RXUEORRGH[DPLQHG<Zfk^_eZxlj_gl]_ghkdh ibx]jm^ghcde_ldbbZgZebadjh\b :KDWLVWKHPDWWHUZLWK\RX" Qlhk\Zfb" :KDWLVWKHWURXEOH" :KDWLVWURXEOLQJ\RX" Qlh\Zk[_kihdhbl" :KDWWURXEOHV\RX" :KDWGR\RXFRPSODLQRI"GZqlh\u`Zem_l_kv" :HOOZHOO Gmgmmkihdhcl_kv 1RZQRZ 7KHUHWKHUH } } } &KHHUXS+Hmgu\Zcl_ .HHS\RXUVSLULWV+HiZ^Zcl_^mohf 7KLQJVZLOOFRPHULJKW<k_h[hc^_lky 7KHUHLVQRKDUPGRQHGbq_]hiehoh]hg_kemqbehkv 'RQ WWDNHLWVRPXFKWRKHDUW+HijbgbfZcl_wlh[ebadhdk_j^pm +DUG EDG OXFN<Zfg_ih\_aeh /HW VKRSHIRUWKHEHVW;m^_fgZ^_ylvkygZemqr__ 1HYHUPLQGGbq_]h ,W OOEHDOOULJKW<k_[m^_l\ihjy^d_ 2QHkZiQHYHUEHWRRFDUHIXOHklhjh`ghklvgbdh]^Zg_ihf_rZ_l ,,,;HE?AGB :<ujZ`_gby DEXQGOHRIQHUYHVdhfhdg_j\h\ WREHRSHUDWHGXSRQk^_eZlvhi_jZpbx WREHUXQQLQJDWHPSHUDWXUHbf_lvih\ur_ggmxl_fi_jZlmjm WKHGDQJHULVRYHUhiZkghklvfbgh\ZeZ WKHIHYHULVRYHUebohjZ^dZijhiZeZ `ZjkiZe WRFDWFK KDYH D FROGijhklm^blvky WRKDYHDUXQQLQJQRVHbf_lvkbevgucgZkfhjd WRVXIIHU IURP kljZ^Zlv hl WRVXIIHUIURPVOHHSOHVVQHVVkljZ^Zlvhl[_kkhggbpu ;JZa]h\hjgbd ,DPIHYHULVKF_gyebohjZ^bl ,DPUXQQLQJDWHPSHUDWXUHMf_gyih\ur_ggZyl_fi_jZlmjZ ,DPXQZHOOYk_[yiehohqm\kl\mx ,KDYHDEDGFROGYkbevghijhklm`_g Z ,KDYHDVOLJKWFROGYke_]dZijhklm`_g Z ,KDYHDVRUHWKURDWMf_gy[hebl]hjeh ,KDYHD VSOLWWLQJ KHDGDFKHMf_gy kbevgZy ]heh\gZy[hev ,KDYHSDLQ LQ Mf_gy[hebl« ,IHHOIDLQWFg_^mjgh 0mIRRWLVRXWRIMRLQWMf_gy\u\bogmlZgh]Z 0\KHDGVZLPVMf_gydjm`blky]heh\Z <RXKDYHIXOO\UHFRYHUHG<uiheghklvx\ua^hjh\_eb <RXKDYHDVOLJKWDWWDFNRIJULSSHM\Zkg_[hevrhc]jbii <RX YHGLVORFDWHG\RXUDQNOHM\Zk\u\bogmlZehû`dZ <RX YHVWUDLQHGDPXVFOH<ujZklygmebfurpm 7KHUHLVQRWKLQJVHULRXVZLWK\RXM\Zkg_lgbq_]hk_jv_agh]h 7DNHFDUHRI\RXUKHDOWK<u^he`guaZ[hlblvkyhk\h_fa^hjh\v_ ,9MIHKL?EB;HEVGH=H :<ujZ`_gby EHGVLGHmihkl_eb[hevgh]h EHGVLGHPDQQHUmf_gb_h[jZsZlvkyk[hevgufihôh^d[hevghfm WRIHHOVPE¶VSXOVHsmiZlvimevk WRJDUJOH ZLWK ihehkdZlv ]hjeh WRJLYHVPEDQLQMHFWLRQk^_eZlv dhfmeb[h bgt_dpbx WRKDYHDKLJK ORZQRUPDO WHPSHUDWXUHbf_lv\ukhdmx gbadmxghjfZevgmx l_fi_ jZlmjm WKHWHPSHUDWXUHULVHVl_fi_jZlmjZih\urZ_lky WKHWHPSHUDWXUHIDOOVl_fi_jZlmjZihgb`Z_lky WROLVWHQWRVPE VKHDUWOXQJVHWFijhkemrb\Zlvk_j^p_e_]db_bl^ WRORRNDIWHUijbkfZljb\Zlv aZ WRSXWDGUHVVLQJgZeh`blvih\yadmk^_eZlvi_j_\yadm WRWDNHFDUHRIijbkfZljb\Zlv aZ WRWDNHRQH VWHPSHUDWXUHbaf_jylvl_fi_jZlmjm ;JZa]h\hjgbd %UHDWKHGHHSO\SOHDVH>urbl_]em[`_ih`ZemcklZ ,PXVWFKHFN\RXUEORRGSUHVVXUHY^he`gZbaf_jblv\Zr_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ 2SHQ\RXUPRXWKDQGVD\$KHldjhcl_jhlbkdZ`bl_©:ª 6KRZPH\RXUWRQJXHIhdZ`bl_yaud 6WRSEUHDWKLQJIRUDPRPHQWSOHDVH+Hûrbl_fbgmldmih`ZemcklZ 3OHDVHVWULSWRWKHZDLVWIh`ZemcklZjZa^_gvl_kv^hihykZ <RXPXVWNHHS VWD\ LQEHG<Zfke_^m_le_`Zlv\ihkl_eb M\Zkihkl_evgucj_`bf 9IJB?FE?D:JKL< :<ujZ`_gby DIWHUPHDOihke__û EHIRUHPHDOi_j_^_^hc IRUH[WHUQDO LQWHUQDO XVHRQO\lhevdhêygZjm`gh]h \gmlj_gg_]h mihlj_[e_gby RQFHDGD\ DZHHN HWFh^bgjZa\^_gv \g_^_ex bl^ WZLFHDGD\^\ZjZaZ\^_gv WKUHHWLPHVDGD\ljbjZaZ\^_gv WRWDNHDPHGLFLQHijbgbfZlve_dZjkl\h ;JZa]h\hjgbd 6KDNHWKHERWWOHZHOOEHIRUHXVLQJI_j_^mihlj_[e_gb_f\a[Zelu\Zlv 7DNHWKLVGRVHHYHU\WKUHHKRXUVIjbgbfZcl_wlm^hamq_j_adZ`û_ljbqZkZ 7DNHWKLVPHGLFLQHSOHDVHIh`ZemcklZijbfbl_wlhe_dZjkl\h 7KDWPXVWEHWDNHQRQDQHPSW\VWRPDFKWlhke_^m_lijbgbfZlvgZ]heh^guc`_em^hd gZlhsZd^h_û :KDW GR \RX WDNH IRU D KHDGDFKH FROG FRXJK HWF " Qlh \u ijbgbfZ_l_ hl ]heh\ghc [heb ijhklmûdZreybl^ " 7KLVLVDIRRGPHGLFLQHIRUFROGVWlhohjhr__e_dZjkl\hhlijhklmû 9,MAM;GH=H<J:Q: JZa]h\hjgbd ,KDYHDWRRWKDFKHMf_gy[heblam[ <RXUWRRWKLVZRUNLQJORRVH<Zram[rZlZ_lky <RXKDYHDGHFD\HGWRRWKM\Zkbkihjq_ggucam[ 5LQVH\RXUPRXWKSOHDVHIjhihehsbl_jhlih`ZemcklZ 6SLWRXWKiexgvl_ JMKKDH:G=EBCKDBC L?F:LBQ?KDBCKEH<:JV ,Q:KLBL?E:Q?EH<?D: $ Zjl_jbyDUWHU\ ; [_^jhKLS WKLJK [hdVLGH [jh\vH\HEURZ [jxrgZyihehklvDEGRPHQ < \_dhH\HOLG \_gZYHLQ \bkhdWHPSOH \hehkuKDLU = ]eZaH\H ]eZagh_y[ehdhH\HEDOO ]he_gvVKLQ ]heh\ZKHDG ]hjeh]ehldZWKURDW ]jm^gZyde_ldZFKHVW ]jm^vEUHDVW ]m[ZOLS \_jogyy]m[ZXSSHUOLS gb`gyy]m[ZORZHUOLS > ^_kgZJXP @ `_em^hdVWRPDFK `b\hlDEGRPHQ A aZ^gbcijhoh^DQXV aZiyklv_ZULVW aZluehdEDFNRIWKHKHDG ajZqhdSXSLO SXSLORIWKHH\H am[ u WRRWK WHHWK B bdjZ gh]b FDOI D dbr_qgbd dbrdb LQWHVWLQH V dh`ZVNLQ dhe_ggZyqZrdZNQHHFDS NQHHSDQ dhe_ghNQHH dhg_qghklbOLPEV \_jogb_dhg_qghklbXSSHUOLPEV gb`gb_dhg_qghklbORZHUOLPEV dhklvERQH E eZ^hgvSDOP e_]db_OXQJV ebphIDFH eh[IRUHKHDG ehû`dZDQNOH ehdhlvHOERZ ehiZldZEODGH 0 fbg^ZebgZWRQVLO fha]EUDLQ furpZfmkdmePXVFOH G g_j\QHUYH gh]ZOHJ ih^t_f gh]b LQVWHS gh]hlvQDLO ghkQRVH I iZe_p gh]b WRH iZe_p jmdb ILQJHU [hevrhciZe_p jmdb WKXPE i_q_gvOLYHU ie_qhVKRZHU ih^[hjh^hdFKLQ ih^furdZDUPSLW ih^hr\ZVROH ihqdZNLGQH\ ijyfZydbrdZUHFWXP iyldZKHHO 3 j_[jhULE j_kgbpZH\HODVK jhlPRXWK jmdZDUP jmdZ dbklv KDQG K k_j^p_KHDUW kdmeZFKHHNERQH kibgZEDFN klhiZ u IRRW IHHW kmklZ\MRLQW kmklZ\iZevpZNQXFNOH L lZebyZDLVW l_ehWKHERG\ l_fyWRSRIWKHKHDG lmeh\bs_WUXQN M m]hejlZFRPHURIWKHPRXWK mohHDU R r_yQHFN S s_dZFKHHN Y yaudWRQJXH ,,HKGH<G:YF?>BPBGKD:YL?JFBGHEH=BY $ Zdlb\guchlûoDFWLYHUHVW Zii_lblDSSHWLWH Zk_ilbdZbZglbk_ilbdZDVHSVLVDQG DQWLVHSVLV ; [_j_f_ggZySUHJQDQW [_j_f_gghklvSUHJQDQF\ [he_ag_ggucSDLQIXO [he_agvaZ[he_\Zgb_LOOQHVVFRP SODLQW [hevDFKHSDLQ [hevghcSDWLHQW [hevgu_WKHVLFN e_`Zqbc[hevghcEHGSDWLHQW [hevghcdhlhjhfmfh`ghkb^_lv VLWWLQJSDWLHQW oh^yqbc[hevghcXSSDWLHQW klZpbhgZjguc[hevghcLQSDWLHQW Zf[meZlhjguc[hevghcRXWSDWLHQW [xee_l_gvVLFNOHDYHVLFNOLVW < \_jomrdZDSH[ \_kZHLJKW \hajZklDJH \hkiZe_ggh_]hjehVRUHWKURDW \jZq_[gucPHGLFDO \jZq_[gucijb_fGRFWRU VRIILFH KRXUV \u\boOX[DWLRQ \ua^hjh\e_gb_UHFRYHU\ \ua^hjZ\eb\ZlvWRUHFRYHU \ue_qb\ZlvWRFXUH \uibkdZ ba[hevgbpu GLVFKDUJH \ukemrb\ZlvWRVRXQG = ]b]b_gZK\JLHQH ]b]b_gbq_kdbca^hjh\ucK\JLHQLF ]bfgZklbdZH[HUFLVHV SK\VLFDO H[HUFLVHV ]bikh\Zyih\yadZSODVWHUFDVW ]emohcGHDI ]emohg_fhcGHDIDQGGXPE > ^bZ]ghaGLDJQRVLV klZ\blv^bZ]ghaWRGLDJQRVH ^b_lZGLHW ^haZdhebq_kl\he_dZjkl\ZgZ ijb_fGRVH ^mrVKRZHU @ `Zeh\Zlvky gZ[hev[he_agv WRFRPSODLQ `bag_ggu_\hijhkuYLWDOSUREOHPV A aZghaZVSOLQWHU aZjZ`_gb_bgn_dpbyLQIHFWLRQ aZjZablvkyWRFDWFK aZjZagucFDWFKLQJ a^hjh\v_KHDOWK a^jZ\hhojZg_gb_SXEOLFKHDOWK aj_gb_H\HVLJKW B baheylhjLVRODWHGZDUG bg]ZeypbyLQKDODWLRQ bkke_^h\Zgb_fhqbXULQRVFRS\ bklhjby[he_agbFDVHKLVWRU\FDVH UHFRUG D dZeH[FUHPHQW dZj^bh]jZffZFDUGLRJUDP RIRQH V KHDUW dZreylvWRFRXJK dbkehlghklvDFLGLW\ dhgqbd yaudZ WLS RIWKHWRQJXH djh\vEORRG ZgZebadjh\bEORRGWHVW FRXQW aZjZ`_gb_djh\bEORRGSRLVRQLQJ baf_j_gb_djh\ygh]h^Z\e_gby EORRGSUHVVXUHWHVW i_j_eb\Zgb_djh\bEORRGWUDQVIX VLRQ djh\_ghkguckhkmÊORRGYHVVHO djh\hh[jZs_gb_EORRGFLUFXODWLRQ djh\hlhqblvWREOHHG dmjke_q_gbyFRXUVHRIPHGLFDO WUHDWPHQW dmr_ldZêyhkfhljZ[hevgh]h H[ZPLQDWLRQFRXFK E eZ[hjZlhjgu_bkke_^h\Zgby ODERUDWRU\WHVWV e_]dh_aZ[he_\Zgb_VOLJKWLOOQHVV e_dZjkl\hPHGLFLQH e_q_gb_WUHDWPHQWFXUH e_q_gb_\[hevgbp_ klZpbhgZj_ KRVSLWDOWUHDWPHQW e_q_gb_^hfZKRPHWUHDWPHQW e_q_gb_hlûohfUHVWFXUH e_q_gb_k\_lhfOLJKWWUHDWPHQW e_q_gb_khegp_fVXQFXUH F fZrbgZkdhjhcihfhsbDPEXODQFH f_^bpbgkdZydZjlZ bklhjby[h e_agb PHGLFDOFDUG SDWLHQW V ILOH f_^bpbgkdZyihfhsvPHGLFDODLG f_^bpbgkdbcPHGLFDO f_^bpbgkdbchkfhljPHGLFDOH[ DPLQDWLRQ f_^bpbgkdh_h[hjm^h\Zgb_ PHGLFDOHTXLSPHQW f_^bpbgkdh_h[ke_^h\Zgb_FKHFN XS ihegh_f_^bpbgkdh_h[ke_^h\Zgb_ FRPSOHWHFKHFNXS f_^bpbgkdZyihfhsvgZk_e_gbx PHGLFDODLG VHUYLFH f_klgucgZjdhaORFDODQDHVWKHWLF + g_fhcGXPE g_hleh`gZyf_^bpbgkdZyihfhsv HPHUJHQF\VHUYLFH g_j\gZykbkl_fZQHUYRXVV\VWHP g_j\gucp_gljQHUYRXVFHQWUH g_kqZklguckemqZcZ\ZjbydZlZ kljhnZDFFLGHQW gh`gZy\ZggZIRRWEDWK ghjfZevgucQRUPDO H h[oh^\jZqZURXQG h[ohîZeZlZDUGURXQG h[s__khklhygb_JHQHUDOFRQGLWLRQ hdZaZgb_i_j\hcihfhsbILUVW DLGSURFHGXUHV hi_jZpbyRSHUDWLRQ ij_^hi_jZpbhggucSUHRSHUDWLYH ihke_hi_jZpbhggucSRVWRSHUDWLYH himohevVZHOOLQJ himorbcVZROOHQ himorb_`_e_auVZROOHQJODQGV hj]ZgbafRUJDQLVPERG\ hkfZljb\ZlvWRH[DPLQH hkihijb\b\Zgb_YDFFLQDWLRQ hkljZy[hevDFXWHSDLQ I iZeZlZZDUG i_j\ZyihfhsvILUVWDLG i_j_\yadZdjh\_ghkguokhkm^h\ OLJDWLRQRIEORRGYHVVHOV i_jkhgZeSHUVRQQHO ih^dh`gucK\SRGHUPLF ihehklvdZ\_jgZFDYLW\ ihj_aFXW ihke_hi_jZpbhggu_hkeh`g_gby SRVWRSHUDWLYHFRPSOLFDWLRQV ij_^hojZgbl_evgu_f_ju SUHYHQWLYHPHDVXUHV ij_^mij_`^_gb_ijhnbeZdlbdZ SUHYHQWLRQ ijb\b\dZLQRFXODWLRQ ijb_fgZy\jZqZFRQVXOWLQJURRP VXUJHU\ ijb_fgucihdhcUHFHSWLRQZDUG ijbagZdkbfilhfV\PSWRP ijhnbeZdlbq_kdZyijb\b\dZ LPPXQL]DWLRQ ijhnbeZdlbq_kdbcSURSK\ODFWLF ijhp_^mjZSURFHGXUH 3 jZgZZRXQG jZg_gucZRXQGHG jZkly`_gb_k\yahdVSUDLQ j_]bkljZlmjZUHJLVWU\ UHFHSWLRQ RIILFH j_gl]_gh\kdbckgbfhd;UD\ SODWH SKRWRJUDSKSLFWXUH j_gl]_ghkdhiby;UD\J ;UD\ H[DPLQDWLRQ j_p_ilSUHVFULSWLRQ \uibku\Zlvj_p_ilWRSUHVFULEH jh^bevgZyiZeZlZPDWHUQLW\ZDUG jhklKHLJKW K kZgblZjgucVDQLWDU\ kZgblZjgu_mkeh\byVDQLWDU\ FRQGLWLRQV k_jv_agucVHULRXV kbevgZynhjfZVHYHUHIRUP kbevguchj]ZgbafVWURQJFRQVWLWXWLRQ kdhev`_gb_k^\b]VOLS kdhjZyihfhsvDPEXODQFH VHUYLFH keZ[uchj]ZgbafZHDN SRRU FRQVWL WXWLRQ ke_ihcEOLQG kemqZc aZ[he_\Zgb_ FDVH kheg_qgZy\ZggZVXQEDWK khgVOHHS khkm^YHVVHO 7 l_ehkeh`_gb_SK\VLTXH l_jZibyWKHUDS\PHGLFLQH l_jZi_\lbq_kdbcPHGLFDO M mdZaZgby\jZqZGRFWRU VRUGHUV LQVWUXFWLRQV mdhebgt_dpbyLQMHFWLRQk ^_eZlvdhfmemdhe q_]he WRJLYH VPEDQLQMHFWLRQ RI mfjZamfPLQG mfkl\_ggZyjZ[hlZPHQWDOZRUN miZklv\h[fhjhdWRIDLQW mkeh\b_khklhygb_FRQGLWLRQ mlj_ggyyaZjy^dZPRUQLQJH[HUFLVHV ; objmj]byVXUJHU\ oZeZl f_^bpbgkdbc JRZQVXUJHRQ V FRDW objmj]bq_kdbckemqZcRSHUDWLRQ FDVH oheh^gh_h[lbjZgb_FROGUXEGRZQ ojhgbq_kdbcFKURQLF P p\_lebpZFRPSOH[LRQ R r_emrblvkyWRSHHO rjZfVFDU W wib^_fbyHSLGHPLF ,,,;HE?AGB : Zg]bgZTXLQV\ Zii_g^bpblDSSHQGLFLWLV ZklfZDVWKPD ; [he_agvGLVHDVHLOOQHVV [hev\`b\hl_VWRPDFKDFKH [hev\k_j^p_KHDUWDFKH < \hkiZe_gb_LQIODPPDWLRQ \hkiZe_gb_e_]dboSQHXPRQLD \hkiZe_ggh_]hjehVRUHWKURDW = ]heh\gZy[hevKHDGDFKH ]jbiiIOXI H LQIOXHQ]D JULSSH @ `ZjebohjZ^dZIHYHU aZ[he_\Zgb_e_]dboOXQJWURXEOH aZ[he_\Zgb_i_q_gbOLYHUWURXEOH aZ[he_\Zgb_k_j^pZKHDUWGLVHDVH WURXEOH aZihjFRQVWLSDWLRQ am[gZy[hevWRRWKDFKH B ba`h]ZKHDUWEXUQ bae_qbfZy[he_agvFXUDEOHGLVHDVH g_bae_qbfZy[he_agvLQFXUDEOH GLVHDVH bgnZjdlLQIDUFWLRQ bgn_dpbhggZy[he_agvLQIHFWLRXV GLVHDVH D dZr_evFRXJK dhjvPHDVOHV djh\hbaebygb_KDHPRUUKDJH djh\hbaebygb_\fha]DSRSOH[\ djh\hl_q_gb_EOHHGLQJ djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_EORRGSUHVVXUH \ukhdh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ ]b i_jlhgby KLJKEORRGSUHVVXUH K\ SHUWHQVLRQ E e_]dZyijhklm^ZFKLOO + gZjmr_gb_ibs_\Zj_gbyGLJHVWLRQ WURXEOH gZju\DEVFHVV gZkfhjdFROGLQWKHKHDG g_^hfh]Zgb_LQGLVSRVLWLRQ H h[fhjh`_gb_IURVWELWH himohevWXPRU JURZWK hkeh`g_gbyFRPSOLFDWLRQVDIWHUHI IHFWV RIDGLVHDVH I i_j_ehflj_sbgZdhklbljZ\fZ IUDFWXUH ih[hqgu_y\e_gbyVLGHHIIHFWV ihghkGLDUUKRHD ijhklm^ZFROG 3 jZdFDQFHU j_\fZlbafUKHXPDWLVP K k_j^_qghkhkm^bklu_aZ[he_\Zgby FDUGLRYDVFXODUGLVHDVHV kdZjeZlbgZVFDUOHWIHYHU kheg_qgucm^ZjVXQVWURNH khljyk_gb_fha]ZFRQFXVVLRQRIWKH EUDLQ km^hjh]ZkiZafFUDPS kuivUDVK 7 l_ieh\hcm^ZjKHDWVWURNH ljZ\fZLQMXU\ lm[_jdme_aWXEHUFXORVLV L< lm[_jdme_ae_]dboFRQVXPSWLRQ 7%& M mrgZy[hevHDUDFKH nmjmgdmegZju\ERLO O ojbiu\e_]dboFUHSLWDWLRQLQWKH OXQJV Q q_khldZam^LWFK R rmf\k_j^p_UQXUPXURIWKHKHDUW Y ya\ZXOFHU ,9IJ?>F?LUMOH>:A:;HEVGUFBF?>BPBGKDB? BGKLJMF?GLUBIJ?>F?LUK:GBL:JBBB=B=B?GU ; [ZgdbFXSV klZ\blv[ZgdbWRSXWFXSV [bglEDQGDJH < \ZlZFRWWRQZRRO = ]hjqbqgbdPXVWDUGSODVWHU ]jZ^mkgbdWKHUPRPHWHU ]j_edZKRWZDWHUERWWOH EDJ ]m[dZVSRQJH > ^_j_\ygguckl_lhkdhiZRRGHQ VWHWKRVFRSH am[gZyiZklZWRRWKSDVWH am[gZys_ldZWRRWKEUXVK B b]eZêyih^dh`gh]h\\_^_gby K\SRGHUPLFQHHGOH bg]ZeylhjVWHDPNHWWOH LQKDOHU bg^b\b^mZevguciZd_lSRFNHW EDQGDJH D dZi_evgbpZGURSSLQJERWWOH dZjlZ[hevgh]h gZdjh\Zlb SD WLHQW VFKDUWDQGSURJUHVVLYHFKDUW dZlZedZZKHHOHGEHG KRVSLWDOEHG ZKHHOHGFKDLUZKHHOHGVWUHWFKHU debafZHQHPD dhfij_kkFRPSUHVV E eZgp_lODQFHW e_cdhieZklujvVWLFNLQJSODVWHU 0 fZjeyJDX]H f_jgucklZdZgPHDVXULQJJODVV fhehlhq_dêy\uklmdb\Zgby SHUFXVVLRQKDPPHU fuehVRDS + gZ^m\ghcdjm]DLUULQJ gh`gbpuVFLVVRUV ghkbedbVWUHWFKHU I i_j_\yahqgucfZl_jbZeGUHVVLQJ ibi_ldZPHGLFLQHGURSSHU SLSHWWH ih\yadZEDQGDJH ihbevgbdIHHGLQJFXS imaujvêyev^ZLFHEDJ K kdZevi_evVFDOSHO km^ghEHGSDQ L lZaEDVLQ lZfihgSDG M moZ`b\ZlvaZ[hevgufWRQXUVH N nhg_g^hkdhiSKRQHQGRVFRSH VWHWKR VFRSH O oheh^gucdhfij_kkFROGSODVWHU R rijbpV\ULQJH rijbpêyih^dh`gh]h\\_^_gby K\SRGHUPLFV\ULQJH 9E?D:JKL<?GGU?NHJFU : ZfimeZDPSRXOHDPSXOH Zg_kl_abjmxs__ h[_a[heb\Zx s__ kj_^kl\hDQDHVWKHWLF Zglb[bhlbdbDQWLELRWLFV Zglbk_ilbq_kdh_ ^_abgnbpb jmxs__ kj_^kl\hDQWLVHSWLF ZkibjbgDVSLULQ ; [he_mlheyxsb_lZ[e_ldbVRRWKLQJ SLOOV [hjgZydbkehlZERULFDFLG [jhfEURPLQH = ]bikSODVWHURI3DULV C ch^LRGLQH D dZiebGURSV dZieb\ghkQDVDOGURSV E e_cdhieZklujvVWLFNLQJSODVWHU DGKHVLYHSODVWHU e_dZjkl\hPHGLFLQHPHGLFDPHQW UHPHG\GUXJ e_dZjkl\hkeZ[h_ [_a\j_^gh_ LQRI IHQVLYHGUXJ 0 fZavRLQWPHQW fbdklmjZPL[WXUH fbdklmjZhldZreyFRXJKPL[WXUH f_^bdZf_gle_dZjkl\hkj_^kl\h GUXJ G gZklhcLQIXVLRQ gZklhcdZ \Ze_jbZgubl^ WLQFWXUH gbljh]ebp_jbgQLWURJO\FHULQH H hl\ZjGHFRFWLRQ I iZklZSDVWH i_gbpbeebgSHQLFLOOLQ ibexebSLOOV ihjhrhdSRZGHU ihjhrhdhl]heh\ghc[hebKHDG DFKHSRZGHU ij_iZjZle_dZjkl\hSUHSDUDWLRQ J jZkl\hjVROXWLRQ j_p_ilSUHVFULSWLRQ K k\_qZVXSSRVLWRU\ k_j^_qgu_dZiebKHDUWGURSV keZ[bl_evgh_OD[DWLYH kghl\hjgh_VOHHSLQJGUDXJKW kh^Z ELFDUERQDWH VRGD klbfmebjmxs__WRQLF klheh\Zyeh`dZ q_]he WDEOH VSRRQIXO RI L lZ[e_ldZ hl WDEOHW IRU M mkihdZb\Zxs__VHGDWLYH ; oehjhnhjfFKORURIRUP Q qZcgZyeh`dZ q_]he WHDVSRRQIXO RI R rZjbdJOREXOH 9,AM;H<J:Q?;GU?L?JFBGU [hjGULOO 0 f_^k_kljZ\am[ghfdZ[bg_l_GHQ WDOQXUVH I ibgp_lSLQFHWWH iehf[ZILOOLQJ ih^]heh\gbdmdj_keZKHDGUHVW ihehklv^miehFDYLW\ M m^ZeblvWRH[WUDFW m^Zeblvam[WRKDYHDWRRWKH[WUDFWHG SXOOHGRXW ; objmj]bq_kdb_sbipuGHQWDOIRU FHSV Q q_exklvMDZ R r_cdZ am[Z QHFN RIWKHWRRWK rijbpêy\hûZDWHUV\ULQJH ; < \j_f_ggZyiehf[ZWHPSRUDU\ILOOLQJ \klZ\ghcam[IDOVHWRRWK > ^_kgZJXP A aZiehf[bjh\Zlvam[WRILOO WRVWRS WRSXWLQDILOOLQJWRVWRSDWRRWKWR KDYHDWRRWKILOOHG ahg^SUREH am[ghcGHQWDO am[gh_a_jdZehGHQWDOPLUURU am[ghcijhl_aDVHWRIIDOVH DUWLIL FLDO WHHWK D dhj_gv am[Z URRW RIWKHWRRWK dhjhgdZ am[Z FURZQ RIWKHWRRWK dhjhgdZahehlZy f_lZeebq_kdZy ieZklfZkkh\Zy JROG PHWDOSODVWLF FURZQ 9,,F?>BPBGKDB?MQJ?@>?GBY : Zf[meZlhjbyRXWSDWLHQWFOLQLF Zil_dZFKHPLVW VVKRSSKDUPDF\ $PGUXJVWRUH Zil_dZijb[hevgbp_GLVSHQVDU\ ; [hevgbpZKRVSLWDO = ]eZagZy[hevgbpZH\H RSKWKDO PDWLF KRVSLWDO > ^_lkdZy[hevgbpZFKLOGUHQ VKRVSLWDO ^_lkdZydhgkmevlZpbyLQIDQWZHO IDUHFOLQLF %U FKLOGKHDOWKFHQWHU $P QXUVLQJFHQWUH ^bkiZgk_jGLVSHQVDU\ @ `_gkdZydhgkmevlZpbyZRPHQ V GHSDUWPHQWZRPHQ VFRQVXOWDWLRQ FHQWUHDQWHQDWDODQGSRVWQDWDOFOLQLF B bgn_dpbhggZy[hevgbpZLVRODWLRQ KRVSLWDO D dmjhjlKHDOWKUHVRUW 0 f_^bpbgkdbcp_gljPHGLFDOFHQWUH I ihebdebgbdZSRO\FOLQLF ijhnbeZdlbq_kdb_mqj_`^_gby SURSK\ODFWLFLQVWLWXWLRQV ikbobZljbq_kdZy[hevgbpZPHQ WDOKRVSLWDO 3 jh^bevguc^hfPDWHUQLW\KRPH KRVSLWDO K kZgZlhjbc \ :g]ebb \b^ ]hkiblZ ey VDQDWRULXP 9,,F?>BPBGKDB?KI?PB:EVGHKLB : Zdmr_j\jZq ]bg_dheh] REVWHWUL FLDQ Zdmr_jdZPLGZLIH Zil_dZjvFKHPLVW %U GUXJJLVW $P f_^k_kljZjZ[hlZxsZyghqvx QLJKWQXUVH hiulgZyk_kljZWUDLQHGQXUVHiZ eZlgZyk_kljZZDUGQXUVHd\Zeb nbpbjh\ZggZyk_kljZTXDOLILHG QXUVH G < \h_gguc\jZqPHGLFDORIILFHU \jZqGRFWRUSK\VLFLDQ gH\SReh]QHXURORJLVW g_\jhiZlheh]QHXURSDWKLVW H = ]bg_dheh]J\QHFRORJLVW > ^_jfZlheh]GHUPDWRORJLVW A am[ghc\jZqGHQWLVW E e_qZsbc\jZqjZ[hlZxsbcdZd l_jZi_\lbobjmj]JHQHUDOSUDFWLWLR QHU F f_^bpbgkdZyk_kljZQXUVH f_^k_kljZjZ[hlZxsZy\am[ghf dZ[bg_l_GHQWDOQXUVH f_^k_kljZjZ[hlZxsZy^g_fGD\ QXUVH hdmebklRFXOLVWRSKWKDOPRORJLVW hgdheh]RQFRORJLVW I ikbobZljSV\FKLDWULVW 3 jZchgguc\jZqGLVWULFWGRFWRU K kZgblZjPDQQXUVH kZgblZjguc\jZqKHDOWKRIILFHU LQVSHFWRU N nZjfZp_\lSKDUPDFHXWLVW ; objmj]VXUJHRQ :G=EHJMKKDBCKEH<:JV :g]ebckdbcZenZ\bl :Z<VKk'G?_)I*J+KOL-M.N/O0P 1Q2R3S4T5U6V7W8X9Y:Z;[<\=] KhdjZs_gby DDGMHFWLYH²ijbeZ]Zl_evgh_ DGYDGYHUE±gZj_qb_ QQRXQ±kms_kl\bl_evgh_ SDUW,,±ijbqZklb_ijhr_^r_]h \j_f_gb SUHGLF±ij_^bdZlb\gh_mihl j_[e_gb_ SURQSURQRXQ±f_klhbf_gb_ SUHSSUHSRVLWLRQ±ij_êh] YYHUE]eZ]he $ DEGRPHQ>µÙEG~P~@Q[jxrgZy ihehklv`b\hl DERYH>µ~EY@SUHSgZ^\ur_ DEVHQFH>µÙEV~QV@Qhlkmlkl\b_ DFFHSW>ÙN VHSW@YijbgbfZlv DFFLGHQWDO>ÙNVL¶GHQWO@ZkemqZc guc DFFRUGLQJ>~µNuGL¾@SUHSkh]eZkgh \khhl\_lkl\bb DFKH>HLN@Q[hev lmiZyijh^he `bl_evgZy DFKLHYHPHQW>~µW LYP~QW@Q^hk lb`_gb_ DFW>ÙNW@Y^_ckl\h\ZlvihklmiZlv Qihklmihd^_ckl\b_ DGG>ÙG@Y^h[Z\blvijb[Z\blv DGKHVLYHSODVWHU>~G¶KLVLY SO.VW~@ e_cdhieZklujv DGPLW>~G PLW@YijbgbfZlv DGXOW>µ~GOW@Z\ajhkeuc DGYLFH >~G¶YDLV@ Q kh\_l WR DVN VPE VDGYLVHkijZrb\Zlvkh\_l DGYLVH>~G¶YDL]@Ykh\_lh\Zlv DIUDLG >~ IUHLG@ D SUHGLF bkim]Zg gucWREHDIUDLG RI [hylvky DJDLQ>~µJHLQ@DGYkgh\Zhiylv DJH>HL!@Q\hajZkl DJHG>HL!LG@Daîh`behc DJUHH>~µJUL@Ykh]eZrZlvky DLG>HLG@Yihfh]ZlvQihfhsv DLU>0~@Yijh\_ljb\Zlv DLUULQJ>0~UL¾@QgZ^m\ghcdjm] DOOHUJLF>~µO~!LN@ZZee_j]bq_kdbc DOORZ>~µODX@Yiha\heylv DOZD\V>µuOZHL]@DGY\k_]^Z DPEXODQFH >µÙPEMXO~QV@ Q fZrbgZ kdhjhcihfhsbWRFDOODQDPEX ODQFH\ua\Zlvkdhjmxihfhsv DPSXOH>µÙPSMXO@QZfimeZ DQDHPLD >~µQLPL~@ Q Zg_fby fZ ehdjh\b_ DQDHVWKHVLD>ÙQLV¶L]M~@QZg_kl_ abyWRJLYHDQDHVWKHVLD^Z\Zlv gZjdhaORFDODQDHVWKHVLDf_kl gucgZjdha DQDWRP\>~µQÙW~PL@QZgZlhfby DQFLHQW>µHLQ ~QW@Z^j_\gbc DQJU\>µÙ¾JUL@Zk_j^blucjZa ^jZ`_ggucWREHDQJU\jZkk_j ^blvky DQWLELRWLF>~QWLEDL¶uWLN@QZglb[bh lbd DSSHDU>~µSL~@Yihy\eylvkyihdZ au\Zlvky DSSHQGLFLWLV>~SHQGL¶VDLWLV@QZi i_g^bpbl DSSHWLWH>µÙSLWDLW@QZii_lbl DUP>.P@QjmdZ DUVHQLF>µ.VQLN@Qfurvyd DUWHU\>µ.W~UL@QZjl_jby DV RIWHQ DVlZd qZklh dZd DVSK\[LD>ÙV¶ILNVL~@Qm^mrv_Zk nbdkby DWWHQWLRQ>~µWHQ ~Q@Q\gbfZgb_WR SD\DWWHQWLRQ WR h[jZlblv\gb fZgb_DWWHQWLYH>~µWHQWLY@D\gb fZl_evgucaZ[hleb\uc DYRLG>~µYuLG@Yba[_]Zlv DZDUG>~µZuG@YgZ]jZ`^Zlv % EDFN>EÙN@QkibgZDGYgZaZ^ EDQGDJH> EÙQGL!@Q[bglih\ya dZYi_j_\yau\Zlv EDVHPHQW>µEHLVP~QW@Qih^\Ze EDVLQ>µEHLVQ@QlZa EDVLV>µEHLVL@Qhkgh\Z EDWK>E.@Q\ZggZdmiZgb_ YfulvdmiZlv EHDQ>ELQ@Q[h[ EHDW>ELW@Y EHDWEHDWHQ m^Zjylv Qm^Zj EHDWLQJ> ELWL¾@Q[b_gb_ k_j^pZ imevkZpby EHFRPH>EL¶NP@Y EHFDPHEH FRPH klZgh\blvkykemqZlvky EHGSDQ >µEHGSÙQ@ Q ih^deZ^gh_ km^gh EHIRUHKDQG>EL¶IuKÙQG@DGYaZjZ g__ EHOLHI>EL¶OLI@Q\_jZ EHOO\>µEHOL@Q`b\hl ELQG>EDLQG@Y ERXQG>EDXQG@ i_ j_\yau\Zlvk\yau\Zlv ELRORJ\>EDL¶uO~!L@Z[bheh]by ELUWK>E~@Qjh`^_gb_ ELVFXLW>µELVNLW@Qkmoh_i_q_gv_ ELWH>EDLW@Y ELWELWWHQ>µELWQ@ dm kZlvQmdmk EODQNHW> EOÙ¾NLW@Qh^_yeh EOHHG>EOLG@Y EOHG>EOHG@ djh\h lhqblv EOHHGLQJ>µEOLGL¾@Qdjh\hl_q_gb_ EOLVWHU >µEOLVW~@ Q \h^yghc imaujv \heûjv EORRG>EOG@YimkdZlvdjh\vQ djh\vEORRGFLUFXODWLRQ >µV~NMX OHOHL ~Q@djh\hh[jZs_gb_ EORRGSUHVVXUH>µSUHVVXUH@Zjl_ jbZevgh_^Z\e_gb_EORRGWHVW ZgZebadjh\bEORRGWUDQVIXVLRQ >WUÙQV¶IMX~Q@i_j_eb\Zgb_djh \b EORZ>EORX@Y EOHZEORZQ>EOX EORXQ@ ^mlvQm^Zj ERG\>µEuGL@Ql_ehhj]Zgbaf ERQH>ERXQ@Qdhklv ERQ\>µERXQL@Zdhklguc ERRNVHOOHU>µEXNVHO~@Qijh^Z\_p dgb] ERWK>ERX@SURQh[ZERWK«DQG «dZd«lZdb ERWWOH>EuWO@Q[mluedZ EUDLQ>EUHLQ@Qfha] EUHDN >EUHLN@ Y EURNH EURNHQ >EURXNµEURXN~Q@ ehfZlvjZa[b \Zlv Q hl\_jklb_ lj_sbgZ EUHDN WQWR \hj\Zlvky EUHDN GRZQ>µEUHNGDXQ@ihegucmiZ^hd kbe QHUYRXV EUHDNGRZQ g_j\ gh_jZkkljhckl\h EUHDWK>EUH@QûoZgb_\^ho EUHDWKH >EULç@ Y ûrZlv EUHDWKH LQY\^hogmlv EULJKW>EUDLW@Dk\_leuc EURDG>EUuG@Zrbjhdbc EURNHQ> EIRXNQ@SDUW,,hlEUHDN kehfZgguc EURQFKXV>µEUu¾N~V@Q[jhgo fgq EURQFKL> E>µEUu¾NDL@ EUXLVH>EUX]@Zkbgyddhglmaby djh\hih^l_d EUXVK>EU @YqbklblvQs_ldZ EXU\>µEHUL@Yohjhgblv EXWWHU>µEW~@QfZkeh EX\>EDL@Y ERXJKW>EuW@ ihdm iZlvijbh[j_lZlv E\VWUHHW>µEDLVWULW@Qi_j_mehd & FDFDR>N~µN.RX@idZdZh FDOO>NuO@Y a\ZlvgZau\ZlvWRFDOO LQ DGRFWRU\uau\Zlv\jZqZ FDOP >N.P@ h mkihdZb\Zlv Z kih dhcguclbobc FDORULF >N~µOuULN@ Q l_iehlZ D l_i eh\hcdDehjbcguc FDQFHURXV>µNÙQV~U~V@ZjZdh\uc FDSLOODU\>N~µSLO~UL@QdZibeeyj FDUERK\GUDWH>µN.ERXµKDLGUHLW@Q m]e_jh^ FDUGLRJUDP>µN.GLRXJU~P@QdZj ^bh]jZffZ FDUH>N0~@Y[_j_qvaZ[hlblvkyQ aZ[hlZWRWDNHFDUHRIkfhlj_lv aZd_fe FDUHIXO>µN0~IXO@DaZ[hleb\ucklZ jZl_evguc FDUHIXOO\>N0~IXOL@DGYlsZl_evgh \gbfZl_evghZddmjZlgh FDUULHU>µNÙUL~@Q[Zpbeehghkbl_ev FDUU\>µNÙUL@Yg_klbFDUU\RXW \uihegylv FDVH>NHLV@QkemqZcaZ[he_\Zgb_ FDVHKLVWRU\bklhjby[he_agb FDWFK> NÙW @Y FDXJKW>NuW@ eh \blvaZjZablvkyWRFDWFK D FROGijhklm^blvky FDXVH>NR]@Yijbqbgylv\uau \ZlvQijbqbgZ FHOO>VHO@Qde_ldZ FHUWLILFDWH>V~µWLILNLW@Qk\b^_l_ev kl\h FKDQJH>W HLQ!@Yf_gylvQi_j_ f_gZbaf_g_gb_ FKDUW>W .W@QdZjlZ^bZ]jZffZ FKHHN>W LN@Qs_dZ FKHHVF>W L]@Qkuj FKHVW>W HVW@Q]jm^v FKHZ>W X@Y`_\Zlv FKLFNHQSR[>µW LNLQSuNV@Q\_ljy gZyhkiZ FKLOG>W DLOG@ fgqFKLOGUHQ Qj_ [_ghd FKLOGLVK>µW DLOGL @Z^_lkdbc FKLOO>W LO@YhoeZ`^Zlvklm^blvQ ijhklm^Zhagh[WRKDYHDEDG FKLOO[ulvkbevghijhklm`_gguf FKROHUD>µNuO~U~@Qohe_jZ FLUFXODWLRQ>V~NMX¶OHL ~Q@Qdjh\h h[jZs_gb_pbjdmeypby FLYLOLDQ>VL¶YLOM~Q@rlZlkdbc FOHDQQHVV>µNOLQQLV@QqbklhlZ FOLS>NOLS@QaZ`bfkdh[Zkdj_idZ FORVH>NORX]@YaZdju\Zlvky FORWK>NOu@QldZgv FORWKHV>NORXç]@Qh^_`^Z a^[_ ev_ EHGFORWKHVihkl_evgh_[_ ev_ FRDW>NRXW@Qib^`Zd FRGOLYHURLO>µNuG¶OLY~µuLO@ju[bc `bj FROG>NRXOG@Qijhklm^ZZoheh^ gucFROGLQWKHKHDGgZkfhjd FROOHFW>N~ OHNW@Ykh[bjZlvdhe e_dpbhgbjh\Zlv FROOHFWLRQ>N~µOHN ~Q@Qkh[jZgb_ FRORXULQJ>µNO~UL¾@Qp\_l ebpZ \hehkbl^ FRPH>NP@Y FDPHFRPH>NHLP NP@ ijboh^blvWRkhP_XS ihôh^blv FRPIRUWDEOH>µNPI~W~EO@Zm^h[ gucdhfnhjlZ[_evguc FRPPXQLFDEOH>N~µPMXQLN~EO@Z aZjZaguc FRPSODLQ>N~P¶SOHLQ@Y`Zeh\Zlvky gZ[hev FRPSOHWH>N~P¶SOLW@Ziheguc FRPSOLFDWLRQ>NuPSOL¶NHL ~Q@Qhk eh`g_gb_ FRPSRVH>N~P¶SRX]@YkhklZ\eylv FRPSRXQG> NuPSDXQG@Dkeh`guc khklZ\ghc aâZdjuluc Ykh klZ\eylv FRPSUHVV> NuPSUHV@Qdhfij_kk FRQFHDO>N~Q¶VLO@Ykdju\Zlv FRQFOXVLRQ>N~Q¶NOX~Q@QaZdex q_gb_ FRQGLWLRQ>N~Q¶GL ~Q@Qmkeh\b_ khklhygb_ FRQTXHU>µNu¾N~@Yih[_`^Zlv FRQTXHVW>µNu¾NZHVW@Qih[_^Z FRQVFLRXVQHVV>µNu¾ LVQLV@QkhagZ gb_WRORVHFRQVFLRXVQHVVihl_ jylvkhagZgb_ FRQVLVW RI >N~Q VLVW@Ykhklh ylv ba aZdexqZlvky FRQVWLSDWLRQ>NuQVWL¶SHL ~Q@QaZ ihj FRQVXOW>N~Q¶VOW@Ykh\_lh\Zlvky WRFRQVXOWDGRFWRUh[jZsZlvkyd \jZqm FRQWDLQ>N~Q¶WHLQ@Ykh^_j`Zlv\ k_[_\f_sZlv FRQWHQW> NuQW~QW@Qkh^_j`Zgb_ FRRN>NXN@YkljyiZlvijb]hlh\ eylvibsmQdmoZjdZih\Zj FRRO>NX@YhoeZ`^ZlvZijh oeZ^guc FRUUHFLO\>N~·]_NWOL@DGYijZ\bevgh FRXJK>NuI@YdZreylvQdZr_ev FRXQW>µNDXQW@YkqblZlvQkq_l FRYHU>µNY~@Yihdju\ZlvaZdju \Zlv gZdj\ZlvQdjurdZ FRYHUVOLS>µNY~VOLS@Qihdjh\gh_ kl_deh FUDFN>NUÙN@YdhehlvjZks_ieylv FUHDP>NULP@Qkeb\dbdj_f FUHDWH>NUL¶HLW@Ykha^Z\Zlv FURZG>NUDXG@QlheiZ FURZQ>NUDXQ@QdhjhgdZ FU\>NUDL@QieZqdjbdYieZdZlv FXFXPEHU>µNMXN~PE~@Qh]mj_p FXOWXUH>µNOW ~@Q[ZdldmevlmjZ FXSV>NSV@Q[Zgdb FXUH>NMX~@Y\ue_qb\ZlvQe_dZj kl\hkj_^kl\he_q_gb_\ua^h jh\e_gb_ FXVWRP> NVW~P@Qh[uqZc FXW>NW@Y FXW j_aZlvQihj_a ' GDLO\>µGHLOL@DGY_`_^g_\gh GDPDJH>µGÙPL!@Q\j_îh\j_` ^_gb_ GDPS>GÙPS@Z\eZ`guc GDQJHURXV> GHLQ!~U~V@ZhiZkguc GDUN>G.N@Dl_fguc GHDG>GHG@Zf_jl\uc GHFD\HG>GL¶NHLG@ZjZajmr_gguc bkihjq_gguc GHFRFWLRQ>GL¶NuN ~Q@Qhl\Zj GHFRUDWLRQ>GHN~µUHL ~Q@Qhj^_g agZdhlebqby GHHS>GLS@Z]em[hdbc GHJUHH>GL¶JUL@Qkl_i_gv GHOLFDWH>µGHOLNLW@Z^_ebdZlguc ojmidbc GHOLULXP>GL¶OLUL~P@Q[j_^[j_^h \h_khklhygb_ GHPDQG>GL¶P.QG@Ylj_[h\Zlv GHQWDO> GHQWO@Zam[ghcGHQWDOIRU FHSV>µGHQWOµIuVHSV@objmj]bq_ kdb_sbipuGHQWDOPLUURU >µGHQWOµPLU~@am[gh_a_jdZeh GHQWDOQXUVH>Q~V@f_^k_kljZ\ am[ghfdZ[bg_l_ GHQWLVW>µGHQWLVW@iam[ghc\jZq GHSHQG>GL¶SHQG@ RQXSRQ YaZ \bk_lv GHSUHVVHG>GL¶SUHVW@Zih^Z\e_g gucm]g_l_gguc GHVFULSWLRQ>GLV¶NULS ~Q@QhibkZ gb_ GHVWUR\>GLV¶WUuL@Ymgbqlh`blv jZajmrblv GHYHORS>GL¶YHO~S@YjZa\b\Zlvky lZd`_h[he_agb GHYRWH>GL¶YRXW@Yihk\ysZlv GLDJQRVH> GDL~JQRX]@YklZ\blv^b Z]gha GLDJQRVLV>GDL~J·QRXVLV@Q^bZ] ghahij_^_e_gb_[he_agb GLH>GDL@YmfbjZlv GLHW>µGDL~W@QibsZ^b_lZ GLIIHU>µGLI~@YjZaebqZlvkyhleb qZlvky GLIIHUHQW>µGLIU~QW@ZjZaebqguc GLJHVWLRQ>GL¶!HVW ~Q@Qibs_\Zj_ gb_ GLJHVWLYH>GL¶!HVWLY@Dibs_\Zjb l_evguc GLUHFW>GL¶UHNW@YgZijZ\eylvjmdh \h^blv GLUHFWLRQ>GL¶UHN ~Q@Qjmdh\h ^kl\hgZijZ\e_gb_ GLUHFWO\>GL¶UHNWOL@DGYijyfhg_ih kj_^kl\_ggh GLVFRYHU>GLV¶NY~@Yhldju\Zlv GLVFRYHU\>GLV¶NY~UL@Qhldjulb_ GLVHDVH>GL¶]L]@Q[he_agv GLVLQIHFWLRQ>GLVLQ¶IHNW~QW@Q^_ abgnbpbjmxsbcjZkl\hjkj_^ kl\h GLVOLNH>GLV¶ODLN@Qg_ijbyagvhl \jZs_gb_Yg_ex[bblviblZlv hl\jZs_gb_ GLVREH\>GLV~µEHL@YgHih\bgh \Zlvky GLVWULFW> GLVWULNW@ZjZchggucmqZ kldh\ucGLVWULFWGRFWRUjZchgguc mqZkldh\uc \jZq GLVWXUE>GLV¶W~E@Y[_kihdhblv f_rZlv GLYLGH>GL¶YDLG@Y^_eblv GR>GX@Y^_eZlvWRGRZORWfgh ]h^_eZlvWRGRJRRGijbghkblv ihevam GRVH>GRXV@Q^haZijb_f GUDXJKW>GU.IW@Q^haZ`b^dh]h e_dZjkl\Z GUHDP>GULP@Qf_qlZkhg GUHVVLQJ>µGUHVL¾@Qih\yadZ GULOO>GULO@Qk\_jehYk\_jeblv am[ GHQWDOGULOO[hjfZrbgZ GULQN>GUL¾N@Y GUDQNGUXQN >GUÙ¾N@ iblvQiblv_ GULYH>GUDLY@Y GURYHGULYHQ >GURXYGULYQ@ \h^blv\_klb GURS>GUuS@Y[jhkZlviZ^ZlvQ dZiey GURSSLQJERWWOH>µGUuSL¾µEuWO@dZ i_evgbpZ GUXJ>GUJ@Qe_dZjkl\hf_^bdZ f_glVLOIDGUXJVe_dZjkl\_ggu_ kmevnZfb^gu_ij_iZjZlu GU\>GUDL@Ykmrblv\ulbjZlvZ kmohcGU\FRXJKkmohcdZr_ev GXULQJ>µGMX~UL¾@SUHS\l_q_gb_ GXVW>GVW@Y\ulbjZlviuevQ iuev GXW\>µGMXWL@Qh[yaZgghklv G\VHQWHU\>µGLV~QWUL@Q^ba_gl_jby ( HDHK>LW @ZdZ`ûc HDU>WR@Qmoh HDUDFKH>L~UHLN@QmrgZy[hev HDUO\>µ~OL@DGYjZgh HDV\>µL]L@Ze_]dbc HDW>LW@Y DWHHDWHQ>HWµLWQ@ _klv HGXFDWLRQ>HGMX¶NHL ~Q@Qh[jZah \Zgb_ HLWKHU> DLç~@FRQMIeb[hbeb HLWKHU«RUbebbeb HOERZ>µHOERX@Qehdhlv HPEDOP>LP E.P@Y[ZevaZfbjh \Zlv HPEDOPHG>LP E.PG@Z[ZevaZfb jh\Zgguc HQHPD>µHQLP~@QdebafZ HPRWLRQ>L PRX ~Q@Q^mr_\gh_ \heg_gb_ HPSW\>µHPSWL@Yhihjh`gylv HQRXIIK>L¶QI@Z^hklZlhqgucDDY ^hklZlhqgh HQWHU>µHQW~@YihklmiZlv\mq_[gh_ aZ\_^_gb_\oh^blv HQY\> HLQYL@YaZ\b^h\ZlvQaZ \bklv HSLGHPLF>HSL¶GHPLN@Qwib^_fby HTXLS>L¶NZLS@YkgZjy`Zlvh[hjm ^h\Zlv HVSHFLDIO\>LV¶SH ~OL@DGYhkh[_ggh ]eZ\gufh[jZahf HYDFXDWH>L YÙNMXHLW@Yw\Zdmbjh \Zlv HYDFXDWLRQ>L YÙNMX¶HL ~Q@QbkijZ `b_gb_hqbs_gb_`_em^dZ HYHQ>µLY~Q@DGY^Z`_ _YLO>µLYO@Qaeh HYROXWLRQ>LY~µOX ~Q@QjZa\blb_ w\hexpby H[DPLQH>LJ ]ÙPLQ@YhkfZljb\Zlv H[FHOOHQW>µHNV~O~QW@Zij_\hkoh^ guc H[HUFLVH>µHNV~VDL]@YmijZ` gylv ky lj_gbjh\Zlv ky Qmi jZ`g_gb_lj_gbjh\dZ H[KDXVW>LJ ]uVW@YbklhrZlvba gmjylvbkq_jiu\Zlv H[KDXVWHG>LJ ]uVWLG@Zbklhs_g gucbagmj_ggucbafmq_gguc bkq_jiZgguc H[LOH>µHNVDLO@Y\ukueZlvkkueZlv H[SHULHQFH>LNV¶SL~UL~QV@Qhiul H[SHULHQFHG>LNV¶SL~UL~QVW@Zhiul gucagZxsbc H[SHUWHQHQW>LNV¶SHULP~QWQhiul wdki_jbf_gl H[SODLQ>LNV¶SOHLQ@Yh[tykgylv H[SORVLRQ>LNV¶SORX~Q@Q\aju\ H[WUD>µHNVWU~@DGMk\_jo\g_Z^h [Z\hqguc^hihegbl_evgucDGY hkh[_ggh H[WUDFW>LNV¶WUÙNW@Ym^Zeylv am[ H[WUXGH>LNV¶WUXG@Y\uklmiZlv \uibjZlv _m_>DL@Q]eZa H\HEDOO> DLEuO@Q]eZagh_y[ehdh ) IDFH>IHLV@Qebph IDLQW>IHLQW@YiZ^Zlv\h[fhjhdQ h[fhjhdZkeZ[uc\yeuc IDLQWLQJ> IHLQWL¾@Qh[fhjhd IDOO>IuO@Y IHOOIDOOHQ>IHOµIuO~Q@ iZ^ZlvQiZ^_gb_WRIDOOLOOaZ [he_lv IDPRXV>µIHLP~V@ZagZf_gbluc ba\_klguc IDUPHU>µI.P~@Qn_jf_j IDVW>I.VW@Z[ukljuc IDVWHQ>I.VQ@Yijbdj_ieylv IDW>IÙW@Q`bjZ`bjguc IDWLJXH>I~µWLJ@YmlhfeylvkyQmk lZehklv IHDU>IL~@QkljZo IHHG>ILG@Y IHG>IHG@ iblZlv ky IHHGLQLFXS>µILGL¾NS@Qihbevgbd IHHO>ILO@Y IHOW>IHWW@ qm\kl\h\Zlv WRIHHOGL]]\>µGL]L@qm\kl\h\Zlv ]heh\hdjm`_gg_WRIHHOJRRG EHWWHUEDG qm\kl\h\Zlvk_[y ohjhrh emqr_iehoh WRIHHO VPE VSXOVHsmiZlvimevk IHHOLQJ>µILOL¾@Qqm\kl\h IHYHU>µILY~@Q`ZjebohjZ^dZ IHYHULVK>µILY~UL @Z^bohjZ^hqguc ILJKW>IDLW@Y IRXJKW>IuW@ [hjhlv kyQ[hjv[Z ILOO>ILO@Yiehf[bjh\Zlv am[u ILOOLQJ>µILOL¾@Qiehf[ZWRSXWD ILOOLQJFlZ\blviehf[miehf[b jh\Zlv am[ ILQJHU>µIL¾J~@QiZe_p jmdb ILUH>µIDL~@Qdhkl_j ILUVWDLG>µI~VWµHLG@i_j\Zyih fhsv ILVK>IL @Qju[Z IODPH>IOHLP@QieZfyh]hgv IODW>IOÙW@Ziehkdbcjh\gucDGY iehkdh IORXU> IODX~@QfmdZihjhrhd IORZ>IORX@Yl_qv IOX>IOL@Q]jbii IOXLG> IOXLG@Q`b^dhklv`b^dZy kj_^ZZ`b^dbc IOXVK>IO @Yijbeb\Zlvdebpm h djh\b \ua\ZlvdjZkdmgZebp_ iijbeb\djh\bjmfyg_p IOXVKHGIDFHihdjZkg_\r__ebph IROORZ> IuORX@Yke_^h\Zlv IROORZHU> IuORX~@iihke_^h\Zl_ev IRUN>IuN@Q\bedZ IRRG>IXG@QibsZ IRRGVWXII> IXGVWI@Qibs_\hc ijh^mdlijh^mdliblZgby IRRW>IXW@ SOIHHW>ILW@ QklhiZ IODWIRRWiehkdhklhib_ IRRWSULQWQke_^ IRUFH>IuV@YaZklZ\eylvijbgm` ^ZlvQkbeZ IRUFHSV mihlj_[edZd_^qbfg q > IuVHSV@iibgp_lobjmj]b q_kdb_sbipu IRUHKHDG> IuULG@ieh[ IUDFWLRQ> IÙN ~Q@QbaehfjZaju\ IUDFWXUH> IUÙNW ~@Qi_j_ehflj_ sbgZ IUHH>IUL@Yhk\h[h`^Zlv IUHHGRP> IULG~P@Qk\h[h^Z IUHTXHQW> IULNZ~QW@ZqZkluc h[uqgucY>IUL NZ~QW@qZklhih k_sZlv IUHVK>IUH @Dk\_`bc IULJKW>IUDLW@Qbkim] IUXLW>IUXW@Qieh^ IXQQ\> IQL@Zkf_rghc * JDPH>JHLP@Qb]jZ JDUJOH> J.JO@Y ZLWK ihehkdZlv ]hjeh QihehkdZgb_ êy]hj eZ JDX]H>Ju]@ifZjey JHQHUDO> !HQ~U~O@Zh[sbcLQ JHQHUDO\hh[s_ JHW>JHW@Y JRW ihemqZlv^hklZ \Zlv JHWWLUHG> JHW WDL~G@Y JRW mklZ \ZlvklZgh\blvkymklZeuf JLYH>JLY@Y JDYHJLYHQ>JHLY JLYQ@ ^Z\Zlv JODQG>JO.QG@Q`_e_aZ JODVV>JO.V@Qkl_dehklZdZg JODVVHV> JO.VL]@Qhqdb JOREXOHV> JOuEMXO]@Qkmiihablh jbb rZjbdb JORYH>JOY@Qi_jqZldZ JR>JRX@Y ZHQWJRQH>ZHQWJuQ@ b^lboh^blvWRJRWREHGeh `blvkykiZlv JRRG>JXG@D EHWWHUEHVW ohjh rbc emqr_kZfucemqrbc ihe_agucPLONLVJRRGIRUFKLO GUHQfhehdhihe_agh^_lyf JRZQ>JDXQ@QoZeZl JUDGXDWH> JUÙGMXHLW@Yhdhgqblv mq_[gh_aZ\_^_gb_>JUÙGMXLW@Q hdhgqb\rbcmq_[gh_aZ\_^_gb_ JUDLQ>JUHLQ@Qa_jgh JULSSH>JULS@Q]jbii JURXS>JUXS@Q]jmiiZ JURZ>JURX@Y JUHZJURZQ>JUX URXQ@ jZklbklZgh\blvkyJURZ OHVVklZgh\blvkyf_gvr_JURZQ XS\ajhkeuc JXDUG>J.G@YaZsbsZlv JXP>JP@Q^_kgZ + KDELW> KÙELW@Qijb\uqdZ KDLU>K0~@Q\hehku KDOI>K.I@Qiheh\bgZ KDQG>KÙQG@Qdbklvjmdb KDSSHQ> KÙSQ@YkemqZlvky KDSS\> KÙSL@ZkqZkleb\uc KDUG>K.G@Dmk_j^guckbevguc DGYdj_idhgZklhcqb\h KDUGHQ> K.GQ@Y^_eZlvkyl\_j ûf KDUPIXO> K.PIXO@Z\j_^guc KDWH>KHLW@Yg_gZ\b^_lvQg_gZ \bklv KHDG>KHG@Q]heh\Z KHDGDFKH> KHGHLN@Q]heh\gZy[hev KHDOWK>KHO@Qa^hjh\v_a^jZ\h hojZg_gb_ KHDOWKIXO> KHOIXO@Dp_e_[guc KHDOWK\> KHOL@Za^hjh\uc KHDOWKRIILFHU> KHO uILV~@kZgb lZjguc\jZq KHDUW>K.W@Qk_j^p_ KHDUWDFKH> K.WHLN@Q[hev\k_j^ p_ KHDW>KLW@YgZ]j_\ZlvgZdZeb\Zlv Ql_iehKHDWWUHDWPHQWe_q_gb_ l_iehf KHDY\> KHYL@Zly`_euckbevguc KHOS>KHOS@Yihfh]Zlv KLJK>KDL@Z\ukhdbc KLJKO\> KDLOL@DGY\ukhdh KLNLQJ> KDLNL¾@Qi_r_oh^gZywdk dmjkby KRDUVH>KuV@Zojbieuchkbirbc KREE\> KuEL@Qex[bfh_aZgylb_ KROH>KRXO@QûjZhl\_jklb_ KRQRUDU\> uQ~U~UL@Zihq_lguc KRW>KuW@D]hjyqbc`ZjdbcKRW ZDWHUERWWOH EDJ > KuW ZuW~ EuWO@Q]j_edZ KXPDQ> KMXP~Q@Zq_eh\_q_kdbc KXPDQLW\>KMX PÙQLWL@Qq_eh\_q_ kl\h KXQJU\> K¾JUL@D]heh^guc KXUU\> KUL@Qlhjhieb\hklvY lhjhiblvky KXUW>K~W@Y KXUW ijbqbgylv [hevih\j_^blvmrb[blvh[b `Zlviih\j_`^_gb_[hevjZgZ K\JLHQH> KDL!LQ@i]b]b_gZ K\SHUWHQVLRQ>KDLS~ WHQ ~Q@Qih \ur_ggh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gb_ ]bi_jlhgby KXSHUWHQVLYH>KDLS~ WHQVLY@Zhl ghkysbckydih\ur_gghfm djh\yghfm^Z\e_gbx K\SRFKRQGULD>KDLS~ NuQGUL~@i m]g_l_ggh_khklhygb_^moZ K\SRWHQVLRQ>KDLS~ WHQ ~Q@iih gb`_ggh_djh\ygh_^Z\e_gbc K\SRWHQVLYH>KDLS~ WHQVLY@ZoZjZd l_jbamxsbckyihgb`_gguf djh\yguf^Z\e_gb_f , LFHEDJ> DLVE~J@iimaujvkh ev^hf LGHQWLFDO>DL GHQWLN~O@Zh^bgZdh \ucb^_glbqguc LOOQHVV> LOQLV@ig_a^hjh\v_[h e_agv LPDJLQH>L PÙ!LQ@Y\hh[jZ`Zlv ij_^klZ\eylv LPPHGLDWHO\>L PLGM~WOL@DGYg_ f_ê_ggh LPPXQLW\>L PMXQLWL@ig_\hkijb bfqb\hklvd[he_agyfbffmgb l_l LPSRUWDQFH>LP SuW~QV@i\Z` ghklvagZq_gb_ LPSRUWDQW>LP SuW~QW@Z\Z`guc agZqbl_evguc LPSRVVLEOH>LP SuVLEO@Zg_\hafh` gucg_\ughkbfuc LPSUHVVLRQ>LP SUH ~Q@i\i_qZle_ gb_ LPSURYH>LP SUXY@YmemqrZlv LQFOXGH>LQ NOXG@YaZdexqZlvkh ^_j`Zlv\k_[_ LQFUHDVH>LQ NULV@Ymkbeb\Zlv\ha jZklZlvm\_ebqb\Zlv ky LQFXUDEOH>LQ NMX~U~EO@Zg_bae_qb fuc LQGHSHQGHQW>LQGL SHQG~QW@DFDfh klhyl_evgucg_aZ\bkbfuc LQGLFDWLRQ>LQGL NHL ~Q@QihdZaZ gb_ LQGLJHVWLRQ>LQGL !HVW ~Q@QjZk kljhckl\h`_em^dZ LQIHFW>LQ IHNW@YaZjZ`Zlv LQIHFWLRQ>LQ IHN ~Q@QaZjZ`_gb_ LQIHFWLRXV>LQ IHN ~V@Zbgn_dpbhg gucaZjZaguc LQIOXHQ]D>LQIOX HQ]~@Qbgnexwg pZ]jbii\bjmkgucdZlZj\_jo gboûoZl_evguoiml_c LQIXVLRQ>LQ IMX~Q@igZklhc LQMHFWLRQ>LQ !HN ~Q@i\ijukdb\Z gb_bgt_dpbyWRJLYHVPEDQ LQMHFWLRQ^_eZlvbgt_dpbx LQMXU\> LQ!~UL@QjZgZih\j_`^_ gb_ LQRFXODWLQJQHHGOH> QLGO@ieZlb gh\Zyb]eZêyihk_\Zfbdjhhj ]Zgbafh\ LQRFXODWLRQ>LQuNMX OHL ~Q@Qijb \b\dZ LQSODFHRI>LQ SOHLV~Y@\f_klh LQVHFW> LQVHNW@QgZk_dhfh_ LQVWHDGRI>LQ VWHG~Y@DGY\f_klh LQVWLWXWLRQ>LQVWL WMX ~Q@Qmqj_` ^_gb_ LQVWUXFWLRQ>LQ VWUN ~HQ@QmdZaZ gb_ij_îbkZgb_ LQWHUHVW> LQWULVW@Ybgl_j_kh\Zlvky LQWHUUXSW>LQW~ USW@Yij_ju\Zlv LQWUDPXVFXODUO\>LQWU~ PVNMXO~L@ DGY\gmljbfur_qgh LRGLQH> DL~GLQ@Qch^ LURQ> DL~Q@Q`_e_ah LVRODWH> DLV~OHLW@Ybahebjh\Zlv LWFK>LW @Qq_khldZYq_kZlvkyam ^_lv LWFKLQJZam^ysbc - MDU>!D@Qdm\rbgdjm`dZ MDZ>!u@Qq_exklv MRLQW>!uLQW@QkmklZ\ MRX>!uL@QjZ^hklv . NHHQO\> NLQOL@DGYhkljhkbevgh NHHS>NLS@Y NHSW>NHSW@ ^_j`Zlv khojZgylvWRNHHSFOHDQ>NLS NOLQ@^_j`Zlv\qbklhl_ qbk luf WRNHHSIUHHRIh]jZ`^Zlv h[_j_]ZlvWRNHHSLQEHGgZoh ^blvky\ihkl_ebWRNHHSXS ih^^_j`b\Zlvijh^he`Zlv NLGQH\> NLGQL@QihqdZ NLQG>NDLQG@Qkhjl\b^Z^h[juc eZkdh\uc NLQGKHDUWHG> NDLQG K.WLG@D^h[ jhk_j^_qguc NQHH>QL@Qdhe_gh NQLIH>QDLI@Qgh` NQRZ>QRX@Y NQHZNQRZQ>QMX QRXQ@ agZlv NQRZOHGJH> QuOL!@QagZgb_ / ODEHO> OHLEO@Qyjeud ODFHUDWH> OÙV~UHLW@YjZaju\Zlv jZa^bjZlvdZe_qblv ODQFHW> O.QVLW@QeZgp_l ODUJH>O.!@Z[hevrhc ODVK>OÙ @Qj_kgbpZ ODVW>O.VW@Yijh^he`Zlvky ODWHU> OHLW~@ZkjZ\gblkl_ihl ODWH[he__iha^gbcDGEiha`_ ODXJK>O.I@Ykf_ylvky ODXJKWHU> O.IW~@Qkf_o OD[DWLYH>OÙNV~WLY@QkeZ[bl_evgh_ kj_^kl\h OD\>OHL@Y ODLG>OHLG@ deZklvih eh`blv OHDUQ>~Q@Y OHDUQW>O~QW@ magZ \Zlvmqblv OHFWXUH> OHNW ~@YqblZlve_dpbxQ e_dpby OHIW>OHIW@Ze_\uc OHJ>OHJ@Qgh]Z OHVLRQ> OL~Q@QihjZ`_gb_ OHVV>OHV@kjZ\gblkl_ihlOLWWOH f_gvrbc OHW>OHW@Y OHW imkdZlviha\heylv WhOHWLQ\imkdZlv OLH>ODL@Y OD\ODLQ>OHLOHLQ@ e_ `Zlv OLIH>ODLI@Q`bagvZKROHOLIH>KRXO@ \ky`bagv OLJKW>ODLW@Y OLWOLJKWHG>OLW ODLWLG@ aZ`b]Zlvhk\_sZlv OLJKW>ODLW@Qk\_lZk\_leuce_]dbc OLNH>ODLN@YgjZ\blvkyDGYih^h[ ghdZd OLPE>OLP@Qdhg_qghklv OLQHQ> OLQLQ@Q[_ev_ OLTXLG> OLNZLG@Q`b^dhklv OLVWHQ> OLVQ@YkemrZlvijhkemrb \ZlvWROLVWHQWROXQJVKHDUW ijhkemrb\Zlve_]db_k_j^p_ OLYHU> OLY~@Qi_q_gv OLYLQJ> OLYL¾@D`b\hc ORFDO> ORXN~@Zf_klguc ORRN>OXN@Ykfhlj_lv]ey^_lv\u ]ey^_lvWRORRNDIWHUmoZ`b\Zlv ijbkfZljb\ZlvWRORRNIRUbk dZlv ORRVH>OXV@Yhk\h[h`^ZlvjZa\y au\ZlvhkeZ[eylv ORVH>OX]@Y ORVW>OVW@ l_jylv ORVV>OuV@Qihl_jy ORZ>ORX@Zgbadbc ORZHU>ORX~@Zgb`gbc OXQFK>OQW @Q\lhjhcaZ\ljZdY aZ\ljZdZlv OXQJ>O¾@Qe_]dh_ 0 PDLQ>PHLQ@Q]eZ\gZyqZklvZ ]eZ\guchkgh\ghc PDLQOH> PHLQOL@DGY]eZ\gufh[jZ ahf[hevr_cqZklvx PDNH>PHLN@Y PDGH>PHLG@ ^_ eZlv PDQXVFULSW> PÙQMXVNULSW@Qjmdh ibkv PDVVDJH> PÙV.@YfZkkZ`bjh \ZlvQfZkkZ` PDWFK>PÙW @QfZlqkhklyaZgb_ PDWWHU> PÙW~@Ybf_lvagZq_gb_ Q\_s_kl\hQRPDWWHUg_\Z`gh g_bf__lagZq_gby LWGRVQ W PDWWHUg_bf__lagZq_gbyZKDWLV WKHPDWWHU"\q_f^_ehqlhk\Z fb" PHDO>PLO@YijbgbfZlvibsm _klviijbgylb_ibsb_^ZDI WHUPHDOihke__ûEHIRUHPHDO ^h_û PHDQ>PLQ@Y PHDQW>PHQW@ agZ qblvbf_lv\\b^mih^jZamf_ \Zlv PHDVOHV> PL]O]@Qdhjv PHDVXUH> PH~@if_jZf_jh ijbylb_ PHDW>PLW@Qfykh PHGLFLQH> PHGVLQ@Qf_^bpbgZ l_jZibye_dZjkl\h PHGLFLQHGURSSHU SLSHWWH >PHG VLQ GUuS~SL SHW@Qibi_ldZ PHPRU\> PHP~UL@QiZfylv PHQWDO> PHQWO@Zmfkl\_gguc PHUU\> PHUL@Z\_k_euc PHWKRG> PH~G@Qf_lh^ PLFUREH> PDLNURXE@Qfbdjh[ PLGGD\> PLGGHL@Zihe^_gv PLOG>PDLOG@ZkeZ[uc he_dZjkl \_ g_hkljucfy]dbc hq_eh\_ d_ PLOH>PDLO@Qfbey f PLOLWDU\> PLOLW~UL@Z\h_gguc PLUDFXORXV>PL UÙNMXO~V@Zqm^h l\hjguck\_jot_kl_kl\_gguc PLUURU> PLU~@Qa_jdZeh PLVWDNH>PLV WHLN@Qhrb[dZWREH PLVWDNHQhrb[Zlvky PL[>PLNV@Yf_rZlvkf_rb\Zlv PL[WXUH> PLNVW ~@QfbdklmjZ PRGHO> PuGO@Qh[jZa_pfh^_ev PRGHUQ> PuGQ@Zkh\j_f_gguc PRGHVW\> PuGLVWL@Qkdjhfghklv PRLVW>PuLVW@Z\eZ`guckujhc PRLVWHQ> PuLVQ@Ym\eZ`gylvkfZ qb\ZlvklZgh\blvkyfhdjuf kujuf PRQNH\> PQNL@Qh[_avygZ PRUWDOO\> PuW~L@DGYkf_jl_evgh PRXWK>PDX@Qjhl PRYH>PXY@Y^\b]Zlvkyi_j_^\b ]Zlvkyi_j__a`Zlv PRYHPHQW> PXYP~QW@Q^\b`_gb_ PXPSV>PPSV@Qk\bgdZiZjh lblwib^_fbq_kdbc PXVFXODU> PVNMXO~@Zfur_qguc PXVWDUGSODVWHU> PVW~G SO.VW~@ Q]hjqbqgbd 1 QDLO>QHLO@Qgh]hlv]\ha^v QDPH DIWHU >QHLP@gZa\Zlvih bf_gb QDVDO> QHL]~O@Qghkh\hcQDVDO GURSVdZieb\ghk QDWLYH> QHLWLY@Zjh^ghc QDXVHD> QuVM~@QlhrghlZ QHDWO\> QLWOL@DGYhijylghZddm jZlgh QHFHVVDU\> QHVLV~UL@Zg_h[oh^b fuc QHFN>QHN@Qr_yr_cdZ am[Z QHHG>QLG@Ygm`^ZlvkyQgZ^h[ ghklvgm`^Z QHUYH>Q~Y@Qg_j\ QHUYRXV> Q~Y~V@Dg_j\guc \a\hegh\ZggucQHUYRXVV\VWHP > VLVWLP@g_j\gZykbkl_fZ QHZERUQ> QMXEuQ@Zgh\hjh` ^_gguc QRLVH>QRL]@Qrmf QRUPDO> QuP~O@ZghjfZevguc h[udgh\_gguc QRVH>QRX]@QghkWRKDYHDUXQ QLQJQRVHbf_lvkbevgucgZ kfhjd QRWKLQJ> QL¾@SURQgbq_]h QRXULVK> QUL @YiblZlvdhjfblv QRXULVKLQJ> QUL L¾@ZiblZl_ev guc QRZ>QDX@DGYl_i_jvk_cqZk QXPEHU> QPE~@Qdhebq_kl\h QXUVH>Q~V@Qf_^k_kljZf_^[jZl YmoZ`b\Zlv aZ[hevguf QXUVLQJ> Q~VL¾@imoh^ QXW>QW@ihj_o H RDWK>RX@ideyl\Z REMHFW> uEM!LNW@Qij_^f_l REVHUYDWLRQ>uE]~ YHL ~Q@QgZ [ex^_gb_ REVHUYH>~E ]~Y@YgZ[ex^ZlvaZ f_qZlv RIIHU> uI~@Yij_êZ]Zlv RIILFH> uILV@Qkem`[ZdhglhjZ RLQWPHQW> uLQWPQW@QfZav RPLW>~ PLW@YimkdZlvg_\dex qZlvij_g_[j_]ZlvmimkdZlv RSHUDWH> uS~UHLW@Yhi_jbjh\Zlv ^_ckl\h\ZlvWRRSHUDWHRQVPE IRUVPWKhi_jbjh\Zlvdh]heih ih\h^mq_]heRSHUDWLQJURRP hi_jZpbhggZyRSHUDWLQJWDEOH hi_jZpbhggucklhe RSHUDWLRQ>uj~ UHL ~Q@ihi_jZpby SRVWRSHUDWLYHDihke_hi_jZpb hggucSUHRSHUDWLYHZ^hhi_jZ pbhgguc RUDOO\> uU~OL@DGYaîjb_f\gmljv RUGHU> uG~@Qij_îbkZgb_ihjy ^hd RUJDQL]H> uJ~QDL]@Yhj]Zgbah\u \ZlvmkljZb\Zlv RWKHU> è~@D^jm]hc RYHUFRPH>RXY~ NP@Y RYHUFDPH RYHUFRPH ih[hjhlvij_\hafhqv RYHUGRVDJH>RXY~ GRXVL!@Qi_j_ ^habjh\dZ RYHUGRVH>µRXY~GRXV@Qkebrdhf [hevrZy\j_^gZy^haZ J SDG>jÙG@Qfy]dZyijhdeZ^dZ SDLQ>SHLQ@Q[hev SDLQIXO>µSHLQIXO@Z[he_ag_gguc SDLU>S0~@QiZjZ SDOH>SHLO@Z[e_^guc SDQLF>µjÙQLN@QiZgbdZZiZgbq_ kdbcYim]Zlv SDS\UXV>S~¶SDL~U~V@QiZibjmk SDVV>S.V@Yijhoh^blvi_j_oh ^blv SDVVHUE\>µS.V~EDL@Qijhoh`bc SDWHQW>µSHLW~QW@DiZl_glh\Zgguc SDWLHQW> SHLW~QW@Q[hevghciZpb _glEHGSDWLHQWe_`Zqbc[hev ghcVLWWLQJSDWLHQWkb^yqbc [hevghcXSSDWLHQWoh^yqbc [hevghcLQSDWLHQWklZpbhgZj guc[hevghcRXWSDWLHQWZf[m eZlhjguc[hevghcZl_ji_eb \uc SD\>SHL@Y SDLG>SHLG@ ieZlblvWR SD\DWWHQWLRQ WR h[jZlblv\gb fZgb_ SHDVH>SL]@QURSR[ SHHOLQJ> SLOL¾@Qkemsb\Zgb_r_ emr_gb_kgylb_dh`mjudhjdZ dh`Zr_emoZ SHQLFLOOLQ>SHQL VLOLQ@Qi_gbpbe ebg SHUFHQW>j~ VHQW@Qijhp_gl SHULVK>SHUL @Yih]b[Zlv SHUPDQHQW>µS~P~Q~QW@Zdhj_g ghcihklhygguc SHUVRQDO>S~VQO@Zebqguc SKDUPDFRORJ\>I.P~µNuO!L@Q nZjfZdheh]by SK\VLFDO> IL]LN~O@Znbabq_kdbc SK\VLFLDQ>IL¶]L ~Q@Q\jZq SK\VLRORJLFDO>µIL]L~µOu!LN~O@Znb abheh]bq_kdbc SK\VLRORJLVW>>µIL]L~µOu!LVW@Qnb abheh] SLFWXUHVTXH>SLNW ~µUHVN@Z`b\h ibkguc SLOO>SLO@Qibexey SLOORZ> SLORX@Qih^mrdZ SLQFHWW>SÙ¾µVHW Qibgp_l SLQW>SDLQW@QibglZ ebljZ SODFH>SOHLWV@Qf_klhYihf_sZlv LQSODFHRI>LQ SOHLV~Y@\f_klh SODJXH>SOHLJ@QqmfZ SOHDVDQW>SOH]QW@Zijbylguc SOHDVXUH>µSOH~@Qm^h\hevkl\b_ SOHQW\> SOHQWL@Qbah[beb_fgh`_ kl\hSOHQW\ RI fgh`_kl\h SQHXPRQLD>QMX¶PRXQM~@Q\hkiZ e_gb_e_]dboig_\fhgby SRLVRQ>µjuL]Q@Qy^YhljZ\eylv SRLVRQLQJ>µjuL]QL¾@QhljZ\e_gb_ SRRU>SX0@Z[_^guciehohc SRSXODU>µSuSMXO~@Zihimeyjguc jZkijhkljZg_gguc SRVLWLRQ>S~µ]L ~Q@Qiheh`_gb_ f_klh SRVWXUH>µjuVW ~@QhkZgdZihaZ SRXQG>SDXQG@Qnmglkl_jebg]h\ SRZGHU>µSDXG~@Qihjhrhd SUDFWLFH>µSUÙNWLV@YaZgbfZlvky q_fe QijZdlbdZSUDFWLFH PHGLFLQHaZgbfZlvkyf_^bpbghc SUDFWLVH>µSUÙNWLV@Yijbf_gylv hkms_kl\eylv SUDFWLWLRQHU>SUÙN¶WL ~Q~@QijZd lbdmxsbc\jZq SUDLVH>SUHL]@Yo\Zeblv SUHFDXWLRQ>SUL¶Nu ~Q@Qhklhjh` ghklv SUHVFULEH>SULV¶NUDLE@Yijhibku \Zlv e_dZjkl\h SUHVFULSWLRQ>SULV¶NULS ~Q@Qij_^ ibkZgb_j_p_il SUHVHQW>jUL¶]HQW@Y^Zjblv SUHVHQW>µSUH]~QW@Dijbkmlkl\mx sbcWREHSUHVHQWijbkmlkl\h \Zlv SUHVV>SUHV@Y`ZlvgZ`bfZlvQ gZ^Z\eb\Zgb_ SUHYHQW>SUL¶YHQW@Yij_^hl\jZ sZlvij_^hojZgylvij_^mij_ `^Zlvf_rZlvij_iylklh\Zlv SUHYHQWLRQ>SUL¶YHQW ~Q@iij_^hl \jZs_gb_ij_^hojZg_gb_ij_ ^mij_`^_gb_ SUHYHQWLYH>SUL¶YHQWLY@Zij_^m ij_^cl_evguc ijhnbeZdlbq_ kdbc SUL]H>SUDL]@QgZ]jZ^ SUREH>jURXE@Qahg^ SURGXFH>SU~ GMXV@Y\uau\Zlv [ulvijbqbghcijhba\h^blv SURGXFW>µSUuG~NW@Qijh^mdlj_ amevlZl SURIHVVLRQ>jU~µIH ~Q@iijhn_kkby SURORQJ>SU~µOu¾@Yijhê_\Zlv ijh^he`Zlv SURPLVH>µSUuPLV@Yh[_sZlv SURPSW>SUuPSW@Z[ukljuc SURSHU>µjUuS~@ZgZê_`Zsbc SURSK\OD[LV>SURIL¶OÙNVLV@Qijh nbeZdlbdZ SURWHFW>SU~µWHNW@YaZsbsZlvij_ ^hojZgylv SURWHLQ>µSURXWLQ@Q[_ehd SURYHUE> SU~Y~E@ihkeh\bpZ SXOVH>SOV@QimevkWRWDNH IHHO VPE VSXOVHsmiZlvimevk SXPS>SPS@YgZdZqb\Zlv\udZ qb\ZlvQgZkhk SXVK>SX @YlhedZlvgZ`bfZlv SXW>SXW@Y SXW deZklvklZ\blv SXWDZD\m[bjZlvSXWRQgZ^_ \Zlv 4 TXDUDQWLQH>µNZuUHQWLQ@QdZjZg lbgWRSXWLQTXDUDQWLQHih^ \_j]ZlvdZjZglbgm TXLFN>NZLN@D[ukljucDGY[ukl jhTXLFNO\[ukljh TXLHWO\>NZDL~WOL@DGYkihdhcgh lboh 5 UDFH>UHLV@QSDFD UDFN>UÙN@QrlZlb\ UDGLDO>µUHLGL~O@Zemq_\hc UDGLVK>µUÙGL @Qj_^bkdZ UDLOZD\>µUHLOZHL@Q`_e_agh^h jh`gucimlv UDLVH>UHL]@Yih^gbfZlv UDSLG>µUÙSLG@Z[ukljucmqZ s_gguc UDVK>UÙ @Qkuiv\ukuiZgb_ UDWH>UHLW@QqZklhlZ UDWKHU>µU.ç~@DGYkdhj__^h \hevgh UDZ>Uu@Zkujhc UHDFW>UL ÙNW@Yj_Z]bjh\Zlva^ hkeh`g_gb_ UHDFWLRQ>UL ÙNW ~Q@Qj_Zdpby UHFLSH>µUHVLSL@Qj_p_il UHFRYHU>UL¶NY~@Y\ua^hjZ\eb \Zlv UHFRYHU\>UL¶NY~UL@Q\ua^hjh\e_ gb_ UHGUHVV>UL¶GUHV@Yih\lhjghi_j_ \yaZlvjZgm UHGXFH>UL GMXV@Yihgb`ZlvhkeZ[ eylvmf_gvrZlv UHIXVH>UL¶IMX]@YhldZau\Zlvkyhl \_j]ZlvQhl[jhku UHJLVWHU> UH!LVWH@Yj_]bkljbjh \Zlv UHJLVWU\>UHF!LVWUL@Qj_]bkljZpb hggZyaZibkv`mjgZeaZibk_c UHJXODULW\>UHJMX¶OÙULWL@iijZ \bevghklvj_]meyjghklv UHJXODUO\> UHJMXO~OL@DGYijZ\bev ghj_]meyjgh UHOLHYH>UL¶OLY@Yh[e_]qZlvhk\h [h`^Zlv UHPDLQ>UL PHLQ@YhklZ\Zlvky UHPHPEHU>UL PHPE~@Yihfgblv \kihfgblv UHPLQG>UL PDLQG@YgZihfbgZlv UHPRYH>UL¶PXY@YkgbfZlvi_j_ ^\b]Zlvm[bjZlv UHSHDW>UL¶SLW@Yih\lhjylv UHSODFH>UL¶SOHLV@YklZ\blvbeb deZklvh[jZlghgZf_klh UHSODFHPHQW>UL¶SOHLVP~QW@iaZf_ s_gb_aZf_gZ UHSRUWERRN>UL SuWEXN@i^g_\gbd UHTXLUH>UL¶NZDL~@Ylj_[h\Zlv UHVHDUFK>UL V~W @Qbkke_^h\Zgb_ bamq_gb_ UHVLVWDQFH>UL¶]LVW~QV@Qkhijhlb\ e_gb_ijhlb\h^_ckl\b_ UHVSHFW>ULV¶SHNW@Ym\Z`Zlv UHVW>UHVW@QhlûoYhlûoZlv UHVWOHVV>µUHVWOLV@Z[_kihdhcguc UHVWRUH>ULV Wu@Y\hkklZgZ\eb\Zlv \ha\jZsZlv gZij_`g__f_klh UHVXOW>UL¶]OW@ij_amevlZl UHWHOO>UL¶WHO@Yi_j_kdZaZlv UK\WKP>ULçP@Qjblf ULFK>ULW @Z[h]Zluc ULFNHWV> ULNLWV@QjZobl ULJKW>UDLW@Z\_jgucijZ\bevguc ijZ\uc \ijhlb\hiheh`ghklv e_\hfm ULQVH>ULQV@YihehkdZlvijhfu \ZlviihehkdZgb_ijhfu\Zgb_ ULVH>UDL]@Y URVHULVHQ>URX] UL]Q@ ih^gbfZlvkyQih^t_f URRW>UXLW@Qdhj_gv URXQG>UDXQG@Zdjm]euckmlmeuc URXQGEDFNkmlmeZykibgZ UXE>UE@Yl_j_lv UXGH>UXG@Z]jm[uc UXOH>UXO@QijZ\beh UXQGRZQ> UQGDXQ@ZmklZeuc bklhs_ggucEH IHHO UXQGRZQ [ulv qm\kl\h\Zlvk_[y mklZ euf UXQQLQJ>µUQL¾@il_q_gb_\u^_ e_gb_UXQQLQJQRVHh[bevgu_ \u^_e_gbybaghkZUXQQLQJZD WHU>µUQL¾µZuW~@kljmy\hû 6 VDIHJXDUG>µVHLIJ.G@QhojZgZ VDOW>VuOW@Qkhev VDQDWRULXP>V~Q~µWuUL~P@QkZgZlh jbc VDXVDJH>µVuVL!@Qdhe[ZkZ VDYH>VHLY@YkiZkZlv VFDOSHO>µVNÙOS~O@QkdZevi_ev VFDU>VN.@QrjZf VFDUOHW>µVN.OLW@ZZeucQZeuc p\_l VFDUOHWIHYHU>µVN.OLWµILY~@QkdZj eZlbgZ VFLHQFH>µVDL~QV@QgZmdZ VFHQWLVW>µVDL~QWLVW@Qmq_guc VFLVVRUV>µVL]~]@Qgh`gbpu VFUDWFK>VNUÙW @Yq_kZlv ky QpZ jZibgZ VFUHHQ>VNULQ@QwdjZgsbl VHDUFK>V~W @Yh[ukdb\ZlvQih bkd VHFXUH>VL¶NMX~@ZgZ^_`gucijhq guc VHGDWLYH> VHG~WLY@QmkihdZb\Zx s__kghl\hjgh_kj_^kl\h VHHP>VLP@YdZaZlvky VHPLVROLG> VHPLµVOLG@Ziheml\_j ûc VHQG>VHQG@Y VHQW ihkueZlvhl ijZ\eylv VHSDUDWH>µVHS~ULW@Zhl^_evguc VHULRXV>µVL~UL~V@Yk_jv_aguc VHUYH>V~Y@Ykem`blv VHUYLFH>µV~YLV@Qkem`[Z VHW>VHW@QgZ[hj VHYHUDO>µVHYU~O@Zg_kdhevdh VHYHUH>VL¶YL~@Zj_adbckbevguc `_klhdbcly`_euc VKDNH> HLN@Y VKRRNVKDNHQ> XN µ HLNQ@ \a[Zelu\Zlv VKDOORZ>µ ÙORX@Zih\_joghklguc VKHHW> LW@Qijhklugy VKLYHU>µ LY~@Y^jh`Zlvagh[blv KHVKLYHUHG_]hagh[beh VKRFN> uN@Qrhd VKRXOGHU>µ RXOG~@Qie_qh VKRZHU>µ DXH@Q^mr VLFN>VLN@Z[hevghcqm\kl\mxsbc lhrghlm,DPVLFNRIfg_gZ ^h_eh VLGH>VDLG@Q[hdklhjhgZ VLGHHIIHFW>µVDLGLµIHNW@Qih[hqgh_ y\e_gb_ih[hqgh_^_ckl\b_ VLJQ>VDLQ@QagZdijbagZd VLPSOH>µVLPSO@Zijhklhc VLWXDWHG> VLWMXHLWLG@ZjZkiheh`_g gucWREHVLWXDWHG[ulvjZkih eh`_gguf VL]H>VDL]@QjZaf_j VNLQ>VNLQ@Qdh`Zihdjh\ VODYH>VOHLY@QjZ[ VOLGH>VODLG@Qij_^f_lgh_kl_deh VOLJKW>VODLW@ZkeZ[uclhgdbc ojmidbc VORZ>VORX@Zf_ê_ggucVORZO\ > VORXOL@DGYf_ê_ggh VPDOOSR[>µVPuOS~NV@QhkiZ VPHOO>VPHO@QaZiZo VPLOH>VPDLO@Qmeu[dZYmeu[Zlv ky VPRNH>VPRXN@QûfYdmjblv VPRRWK>VPXç@Z]eZ^dbc VQHH]H>VQL]@YqboZlvQqboZgv_ VRDS>VRXS@QfuehYgZfueb\Zlv fueblv VRIW>VuIW@Zfy]dbc VROXEOH> V~OMXEO@ZjZkl\hjbfuc VROXWLRQ>V~µOMX ~Q@QjZkl\hjj_ r_gb_ VROYH>VuOY@Yj_rZlvjZaj_rZlv VRUH>Vu@Z[hevghc[he_ag_gguc \hkiZe_ggucQya\Z dh`b gZ ju\[heyqdZjZgZVRUHPRXWK klhfZlblVRUHWKURDW\hkiZe_gb_ fbg^ZebgZg]bgZlhgabeebl VRXO>VRXO@Q^mrZ VRXUFH>VuV@Qbklhdbklhqgbd VSHFLDO>µVSHV~O@Dki_pbZevguc hkh[_gguc VSLW>VSLW@Yie_\Zlvky WRVSLWRXW kiexgmlv VSOLQW>VSOLQW@QrbgZ VSRQJH>VSQ!@Q]m[dZ VSRRQ>VSXQ@Qeh`dZ VSRW>VSuW@QiylghdjZibgdZ VSUHDG>VSUHG@Y VSUHDG jZkijh kljZgylvkyQjZkijhkljZg_gb_ VSULQNOH>µVSUL¾NO@Y[jua]ZlvQ g_[hevrh_dhebq_kl\h RI VWDII>VW.I@Qi_jkhgZerlZl VWDJH>VWHL!@QwlZii_jbh^klZ ^by VWDPS>VWÙPS@QfZjdZ VWDQG>VWÙQG@Y VWRRG>VWXG@ klh ylv VWDWH>VWHLW@Qkhklhygb_Yknhjfm ebjh\Zlv VWD\>VWHL@YhklZ\ZlvkyQij_[u \Zgb_hihjZ VWHULOH> VWHUDLO@Zkl_jbevguc VWLFNLQJSODVWHU>µVWLNL¾µSO.VW~@Q e_cdhieZklujv ebidbcieZ klujv VWLWFK>VWLW @Qkl_`hdrh\ VWRPDFN>µVWP~N@i`_em^hd`b \hl VWRXW>VWDXW@Zlmqguc VWUHQJWK>VWUH¾@ikbeZ VWUHQJWKHQ>VWUH¾~Q@Ymkbeb \Zlvmdj_ieylv VWUHWFKHU>µVWUHW ~@ighkbedb VWULS>VWULS@YjZa^_\ZlvkgbfZlv VWULSWRWKHZDLVWjZa^_lvky^h ihykZ VWURQJ>VWUu¾@Zkbevgucdj_idbc a^hjh\uc VWUXFWXUH>µVWUNW ~@ikljmdlmjZ VXEMHFW> VE!LNW@iij_^f_l VXEVWLWXWH> VEVWLMXW@YaZf_gylv VXFFHVVIXO>V~N VHVIXO@Zm^Zqguc mki_rguc VXFK>VW @ZlZdhc VXIIHU>µVI~@YkljZ^Zlvi_j_`b \Zlv VXJDU>µ XJ~@ikZoZj VXOIDGUXJV>µVI~µGUJ]@kmevnZ fb^gu_ij_iZjZlu VXOIRQDPLGH>µVOI~Q~ PDLG@i kmevnZgbeZfb^gu_e_dZjkl\Z VXQVWURNH> VQVWURXN@ikheg_q gucm^Zj VXSHUILFLDO>VMXS~µIL ~O@Zih\_jo ghklguc VXSHUYLVLRQ>VMXS~µYL~Q@igZ [ex^_gb_gZâhj VXSSRVLWRU\>V~Su]LW~UL@ikmiihab lhjbc k\_qZ VXUH> X~@Z\_jgucWREHVXUH hl [ulvm\_j_gguf\ VXUIDFH> V~ILV@iih\_joghklv VXUJHU\> V~!~UL@Qobjmj]by ijb_fgZy\jZqZ dZ[bg_l VXUJHRQ> V~!~Q@Qobjmj] VXUJLFDO> V~!LNO@Zobjmj]bq_ kdbc VXUURXQG>V~ UDXQG@Yhdjm`Zlv VZDE>VZuE@ilZfihg VZDOORZ>µVZuORX@Y]ehlZlvijh ]eZlu\Zlvi]ehlhd VZHDW>VZHW@Yihl_lviihlbkiZ jbgZ iieZ\Zgb_VZLPPLQJSRRO>SXO@ [Zkk_cg VZROOHQ>µVZRXO~Q@SDUW,,hl VZHOOLQJ>µVZuOL¾@ihimohev VZHOOhimorbc VZLP>VZLP@Y VZDPVZXP >VZÙPVZXP@ ieZ\ZlvVZLP PLQJ V\PSWRP>µVLPSW~P@Qkbfilhf ijbagZd V\ULQJH>µVLULQ!@Qrijbp 7 WDEOHVSRRQIXO>µVSXQIXO@Qklheh \Zyeh`dZ WDEOHW> WÙEOLW@ilZ[e_ldZ WDNH>WHLN@Y WRRNWDNHQ>WXN µWHLNQ@ [jZlvWRWDNHRIIkgb fZlvWRWDNHFDUH>N0~@ RI aZ [hlblvkymoZ`b\Zlv WDON>WuN@YjZa]h\Zjb\Zlv WDOO>WuO@Z\ukhdbc WDVN>W.VN@iaZ^ZqZaZ^Zgb_ WDVWH>WHLVW@Q\d\F L<>µWLµEL@khdjZslm[_jdme_a WHDVSRRQIXOiqZcgZyeh`dZWR WDNHDWHDVSRRQIXORIPHGLFLQH ijbgbfZlve_dZjkl\hihqZcghc eh`d_ WHDP>WLP@ikihjlb\gZydhfZg^Z [jb]Z^Z WHHWK>WL@iam[u WHOO>WHO@Y WROG>WRXOG@kdZaZlv jZkkdZaZlv WHPSHUDWXUH>µWHPSULW ~@il_fi_ jZlmjZWRWDNHRQH V WKH WHP SHUDWXUHbaf_jylvl_fi_jZlmjm WHPSRUDU\>µWHPS~U~UL@Z\j_f_g guc WKDQN>Ù¾N@Y[eZ]h^Zjblv WKHUDSHXWLF>HU~¶SMXWLN@Zl_jZ i_\lbq_kdbc WKHUPRPHWHU>~¶PuPLW~@i]jZ ^mkgbd WKLQ>LQ@Zlhgdbcom^hsZ\uc WKLQN>L¾N@Y WKRXJKW>uW@ ^m fZlv WKRXVDQG>µDX]~QG@ibllukyqZ WKURDW>URXW@i]hjeh]hjlZgv ]ehldZ WKURXJK>UX@DGYq_j_aWREH WKURXJKihdhgqblvkq_fe WKXPE>P@i[hevrhciZe_p jmdb WLJKW>WDLW@DiehlgucDGYdj_idh WLJKWO\>µWDLWOL@dj_idh WLQFWXUH> WL¾N ~@QgZklhcdZlbgd lmjZ WLUH>µWDU~@Ymlhfeylv ky mklZ \ZlvWREHWLUHG[ulvmklZeuf WLWOH>µWDLWO@QaZ]eZ\b_gZa\Zgb_ WRH>WRX@iiZe_pgh]b WRLOHW> WuLOLW@Q Zf_j m[hjgZy lmZe_lh^_\Zgb_ WRPDWR>W~ P.WRX@Qihfb^hj WRQJXH>W¾@Qyaud WRQVLO> WuQVLO@Qfbg^Ze_\b^gZy `_e_aZWRKDYHWRQVLOVRXWm^Z eylvfbg^Zebgu WRRWK>WX@Qam[WRRWKDFKH > WXHLN@Qam[gZy[hev WRUWXUH> WuW~@YiulZlv WRXFK>WW @Y ijb dZkZlvkyljh ]Zlv WRZHO> WDX~O@Qihehl_gp_ WUHDW>WULW@Ye_qblvWUHDWPHQW > WULWP~QW@Qe_q_gb_moh^KRPH WUHDWPHQWe_q_gb_^hfZKRVSLWDO WUHDWPHQWe_q_gb_\[hevgbp_ WURXEOH> WUEO@Qih\j_`^_gb_ jZkkljhckl\hY[_kihdhblv :KDWWURXEOHV\RX"Qlh\Zk [_kihdhbl" WU\>WUDL@YiulZlvkyklZjZlvky WXLWLRQ>WMX L ~Q@Qh[mq_gb_ WXUQ>W~Q@Yih\hjZqb\Zlv ky ij_\jZsZlvkyQi_j_f_gZhq_ j_^v WZLFH>WZDLV@DGY^\Z`û\^\h_ W\SH>WDLS@Qlbi W\SKRLG> WDLIRLG@Q[jxrghclbn Zlbnhaguc W\SKXV> WDLI~V@Qkuighclbn 8 XQFRQVFLRXV>Q NuQ ~V@Z[_kkha gZl_evguc XQGHUJR>QG~ JRX@Y XQGHUZHQW XQGHUJRQH ih^\_j]gmlvkyi_ j_ghkblvWRXQGHUJRDQRSHUD WLRQih^\_j]gmlvkyhi_jZpbb XQGHUVWDQG>QG~ VWÙQG@Y XQGHU VWRRG>QG~ VWXG@ ihgbfZlv XQLIRUP> MXQLIuP@QnhjfZnhj f_ggZyh^_`^Z XQSOHDVDQW>Q SOH]~QW@Zg_ijbyl guc XQWLO>Q WLO@SUHS^h XQZHOO>Q ZHO@Dg_a^hjh\uc XQZLVH>Q ZDL]@Z]emiucg_[eZ ]hjZamfguc XSSHU> j~@Z\_jogbc XVH>MX]@Ymihlj_[eylv>MXV@ Qmihlj_[e_gb_ XVHIXO> MXVIXO@Dihe_aguc XVXDOO\> MXX~OL@DGYh[uqgh 9 YDOYH>YÙOY@QdeZiZg YDULHW\>Y~ UDL~WL@QjZaghh[jZab_ YDULRXV> Y0~UL~V@ZjZaebqguc YHLQ>YHLQ@Q\_gD YHJHWDEOH> YH!LW~EO@Qh\hsZ jZklbl_evguc YLUXV> YDL~U~V@Qnbevljmxsbcky \bjmk YRPLW> YuPLW@Yj\ZlvQj\hlZ YRPLWLQJ> YPLWL@j\hlZ YR\DJH>YuL!@Qiml_r_kl\b_ ih fhjx : ZDLVW>ZHLVW@QlZebyaîhyk ZDLW>ZHLW@Y`^Zlv ZDQW>ZuQW@bohl_lvZDQWRIIRRG ]heh^ ZDUG>ZuG@QiZeZlZZDUGQXUVH iZeZlgZyk_kljZZDUGURXQG h[ohîZeZl ZDWFK>ZuW @YgZ[ex^Zlv ZDWHU> ZuW~@Q\h^ZYfhqblv kfZqb\Zlv ZD\>ZHL@Qimlv^hjh]ZLQVXFKD ZD\lZdbfh[jZahf ZHDN>ZLN@ZkeZ[uc ZHDOWK>ZHO@Q[h]Zlkl\h ZHDU>Z0~@Y ZRUHZRUQ>Zu ZuQ@ ghkblv h^_`^m [ulv h^_luf \hqlhe ZHLJKW>ZHLW@Q\_k ZHOO>ZHO@DGY EHWWHUEHVW [RSRrhemqr_emqr_\k_]hZ a^hjh\uc,DPZHOOya^hjh\ :HOOLQWGm \ujZ`Z_lkh]eZ kb_h`b^Zgb_blQ :HOO QRZWHOOPHDERXWLWGml_i_jv jZkkdZ`b ZHOOHTXLSSHG>L NZLSW@Zohjhrh h[hjm^h\Zgguc ZHW>ZHW@YfhqblvkfZqb\ZlvZ fhdjuc ZKHHOHGEHG> ZLOG EHG@QdZlZedZ ZKLOH>ZDLO@Q\j_fyDGYihdZD ZKLOHg_fgh]h ZKLWWHQ> ZDLW~Q@Y[_eblv ZKRRSLQJFRXJK> KXSL¾ NuI@Q dhdexr ZLGHO\> ZDLGOL@DGYrbjhdh ZLQ>ZLQ@Y ZRQ>ZQ@ ih[_` ^Zlv ZLVH>ZDL]@Zfm^juc ZLWKRXW>ZL çDXW@SUHS[_a ZRQGHUIXO> ZQG~IXO@ZaZf_qZ l_evgucm^b\bl_evguc ZRUNRYHU>Z~N RXY~@Yi_j_jZ[Z lu\Zlv ZRUU\> ZUL@Y\hegh\ZlvkyQ \heg_gb_[_kihdhckl\h ZRXQG>ZXQG@QjZgZjZg_gb_Y jZgblv ZULWH>UDLW@Y ZURWHZULWWHQ>URXW ULWQ@ ibkZlv ZULWHGRZQ> UDLW GDXQ@YaZibku \Zlv ZURQJ>Uu¾@Zg_ijZ\bevguc hrb[hqguc;UD\Q h[uqgh\h fgq j_gl]_gh\kdb_emqbY ijhk\_qb\Zlvj_gl]_gh\kdbfb emqZfb ;UD\SODWHSLFWXUH SKRWRJUDSK j_gl]_gh\kdbckgbfhd < \HDVW>MLVW@Q^jh``b \RXWK>MX@Qxghklvfheh^hklv fheh^_`vxghrZ KH>?J@:GB? Ij_^bkeh\b_«««««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e,3DUWVRIWKH+XPDQ%RG\ AZgylb_0\)DPLO\«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_3DUWVRIWKH+XPDQ%RG\««««««««««««««« AZgylb_5XOHVRI*RRG+HDWK«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_0RXWK+DQGV««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_+DLU«««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_+HDUWDQG%ORRG««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_6NHOHWRQ«««««««««««««««««««« Dhgljhevgu_mijZ`g_gby««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e,,*HQHUDO0HGLFDO7HUPLQRORJ\ AZgylb_7KH'LHW«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_7KH'LHW FRQWLQXHG ««««««««««««««« AZgylb_9LWDPLQV««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_,,:DWHU«««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_)LUVW$LG%UXLVH«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_%OHHGLQJ«««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_)UDFWXUHV«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_)DLQWLQJ««««««««««««««««««« ^Zgylb_6KRFN3RLVRQLQJ«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_6XQVWURNH«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_MijZ`g_gby««««««««««««««««« Dhgljhevgu_mijZ`g_gby«««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e,,,'LVHDVHVDQG1XUVLQJ AZgylb_MijZ`g_gb_««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_,QD+RVSLWDO««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$6WXGHQW1XUVH««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_2XU%HVW:DUG1XUVH««««««««««««««« AZgylb_MijZ`g_gby«««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_+RZWR7DNHWKH3XOVH««««««««««««««« AZgylb_'LVHDVHV«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_%ORRG3UHVVXUH««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$WWKH'RFWRUV««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_)HYHU««««««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$9LVLWRID'RFWRU««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_3HWH&DXJKWD&ROG««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_3QHXPRQLD««««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_7UHDWPHQWDQG1XUVLQJ3DWLHQWVZLWK+HDUW'LVHDVHV««««««« AZgylb_,QIHFWLRXV'LVHDVHV«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_6FDUOHW)HYHU«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_0HDVOHV«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_,QIOXHQ]D«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_5LFNHWV«««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_,QWKH6XUJLFDO'HSDUWDPHQW«««««««««««««« Klj AZgylb_,QWKH2SHUDWLQJ5RRP««««««««««««««« AZgylb_7KH0DQ:KR'LVFRYHUHG&KORURIRUP1XUVH V:RUNDWWKH6XUJLFDO 'HSDUWDPHQW«««««««««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_)URPWKH+LVWRU\RI0HGLFLQH««««««««««««« AZgylb_+HDOWK,V$ERYH:HDOWK««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$ERXW0\8QFOH«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$ERXW([HUFLVHV««««««««««««««««««« Dhgljhevgu_mijZ`g_gby««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e,90HGLFLQH AZgylb_0HGLFLQH«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$WWKH&KHPLVW V«««««««««««««««« AZgylb_7KH6XOIRQDUULLGHV$ERXW$QWLELRWLFV«««««««««««« AZgylb_0HGLFDO3ODQWV«««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_0\)ULHQGV V,OOQHVV««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$YRLG6HOI7UHDWPHQW««««««««««««««« Dhgljhevgu_mijZ`g_gby««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e9'HQWDO7HUPLQRORJ\ AZgylb_7HHWK««««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_$WWKH'HQWLVW V««««««««««««««««« AZgylb_MijZ`g_gby'LDORJXHV«««««««««««««««« Dhgljhevgu_mijZ`g_gby«««««««««««««««««« JZa^_e9,0HGLFDO0RVDLF :g]ehjmkkdb_l_fZlbq_kdb_\ujZ`_gbybjZa]h\hjgbd««««««««« JmkkdhZg]ebckdbcl_fZlbq_kdbckeh\Zjv«««««««««««« :g]ehjmkkdbckeh\Zjv««««««««««««««««««« Hjb]bgZefZd_lba^Zgbyih^]hlh\e_gHHH:GFB Ebp_gabyB>hl] KZgblZjghwib^_fbheh]bq_kdh_aZdexq_gb_ >hl] =KI]Fhkd\ZJZofZgh\kdbci_j^ L_enZdk l_e Ba^Zl_evkl\h©:GFBª\uimkdZ_l mq_[gmxebl_jZlmjmêyklm^_glh\ f_^bpbgkdboh[jZah\Zl_evguo mqj_`^_gbcZlZd`_f_^bpbgkdmx ebl_jZlmjmêyki_pbZebklh\ jZaebqguoki_pbZevghkl_c DhglZdlgu_l_e_nhgu AZf_qZgby b ij_êh`_gby \hagbdrb_ ijbbamq_gbb^Zggh]hfZl_jbZeZijhkbf gZijZ\eylv \ Z^j_k ba^Zl_evkl\Z =KI ] Fhkd\Z JZofZgh\kdbc i_j^HHH©:GFBª

1str

Products

Support

1str

Add this document to collection(s)

Add this document to saved

Suggest us how to improve StudyLib