ПОЛИЦИЯ И ОБЩЕСТВО В РОССИЙСКОЙ ИМПЕРИИ НАЧАЛА

./0 351.741
%123435 3 1678 9:1 : ;1
>?@?2? XX :80?
. !. "#$%&',
!. (. )#'*$&',
3< 01< 3=%8;33
!"#!$ %$& &'()"&* +,-", .$!/())!$, 0,1( -%2&3 ",/( $!3 #(!$&& & &)#!$&& 4!)- ,$)#1, & .$,1, 56$76
.$(.! ,1,#(89 ",/( $: , ;&+&)#$,#&1+!4! .$,1, <-$4,+)"!4!
.!4$,+&'+!4! &+)#&#-#, =>? @!))&&
!""#!$%&'!($") *+",-!%"$'.//!) 0+1&$&2! +""&3"2+3 4#0.%&& ' "5.%. +6%!/7 +89."$'.//+*+ 0+%)-2!, ':!&#++$/+;./&)
0+1&<&& & +89."$'!, +$/+;./&. /!".1./&) 2 +%*!/!# +89.3 & 0+1&$&=."2+3 0+1&<&&.
!"#$%&$ '!(%): *'+(,*- .(!*/**, .(!*/*- * (01$'+%( % 2)#)!$ 33 %$4).
!"!#$ %% &'(! & )$**++ ,!-!(.'-+/$&!#$*0 1$#+.+"'*($2 + *$3+!#04$2 4'*.!5+#04$*.06, & *&7/+ * "'8 &$1-$*9 $5'*1'"'4+7 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(!, 5'/$1!*4$*.+
&#!*.+ + 4!*'#'4+7 7&#7#+*0 1'-&$$"'-'<498+. = .$ >' &-'87 1$4+8!4+' ;$*?<!-*.&'44$2 &#!*.06 *$<'->!4+7 $5:'*.&'44$;$
1$-7<(!, 4'$5,$<+89, @$-8 + 8'.$<$& ';$
$5'*1'"'4+7 4'*($#0($ $.#+"!#$*0 $. *$&-'8'44$;$, 1$A.$8? 1-'<*.!&#7'.*7 &!>498 $1-'<'#+.0 1$4+8!4+' /4!"'4+7 + *$<'->!4+7 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! & -!**8!.-+&!'892 +*.$-+"'*(+2 1'-+$<, ! .!(>' ';$ *$$.4$B'4+7 * 1-!&$1$-7<($8, $5:'*.&'44$2 5'/$1!*4$*.06.
C,-!4! $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! 7&#7'.*7 &!>4$2 + 4'$5,$<+8$2 @?4(3+'2 #65$;$
;$*?<!-*.&!, &9.'(!6:'2 +/ 1$.-'54$*.'2
$5:'*.&!. !#+"+' A@@'(.+&4$2 *+*.'89
$,-!49 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! &$ 84$;$8
,!-!(.'-+/?'. /!:+:'44$*.0 4!*'#'4+7 $.
1$*7;!.'#0*.& 4! &!>4'2B+', $,-!47'89'
;$*?<!-*.&$8 $5:'*.&'449' $.4$B'4+7, !
.!(>' 5'/$1!*4$*.0 *!8$2 ;$*?<!-*.&'44$2
&#!*.+. C. 1$4+8!4+7 $5:'*.&$8 + ;$*?<!-*.&$8 *$<'->!4+7 .'-8+4! «$5:'*.&'4492
1$-7<$(» /!&+*7. + ';$ -'!#+/!3+7 & 1$&*'<4'&4$2 >+/4+, *+*.'8! $-;!4$& + 8'.$<$&
';$ $5'*1'"'4+7.
C5:'*.&'44$' 84'4+' & *@'-' 5$-059 *
1-'*.?14$*.06 &9*.?1!'. 4'$5,$<+8$2
1-'<1$*9#($2 1-!&$&$2 !(.+&4$*.+ 4!*'#'4+7. D'8 &9B' $3'4(! 4!*'#'4+'8 <'7.'#04$*.+ $-;!4$& $,-!49 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(!, .'8 &9B' *.'1'40 <$&'-+7 ( 4+8, !
.!(>' ;$.$&4$*.0 $(!/9&!.0 +8 *$<'2*.&+'.
E-'<+ @!(.$-$&, &#+76:+, 4! !(.+&4$*.0 4!*'#'4+7 & *@'-' $,-!49 $5:'*.&'4!"#$ «%"&'(», ')*+,- 28
4$;$ 1$-7<(!, &9<'#76. $.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( 1-!&$$,-!4+.'#0498 $-;!4!8; $.4$B'4+' ( 1-'*.?14$*.+, 1-'*.?1#'4+6, 1-'*.?14+(? + 1$.'-1'&B'8?1.
F-+ !4!#+/' &/!+8$$.4$B'4+2 4!*'#'4+7 + 1$#+3++ *#'<?'. ?"+.9&!.0 -7< @!(.$-$&. =$-1'-&9,, 4'$<4$-$<4$*.0 *!8$;$
4!*'#'4+7. G!(, & 4!"!#' %% &'(! 4!-7<? *
.-!<+3+$44$2 <+@@'-'43+!3+'2 *$3+!#049, ;-?11 1$ +8?:'*.&'44$8?, $5-!/$&!.'#04$8?, 1-$@'**+$4!#04$8? 1-+/4!(!8
5$#0B$' /4!"'4+' +8'#+ ;'$;-!@+"'*(+',
4!3+$4!#049' + *$*#$&49' 1-+/4!(+. = /!&+*+8$*.+ $. 1-+4!<#'>4$*.+ *?5H'(.! (
.$2 +#+ +4$2 *$3+!#04$2 ;-?11' @$-8+-$&!#$*0 + ';$ $.4$B'4+' ( 1-!&$$,-!4+.'#0498 $-;!4!8. =$-&.$-9,, 4'$5,$<+8$ -!/#+"!.0 $.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( $5:'2 + 1$#+.+"'*($2 1$#+3++ & *&7/+ * .'8, ".$ /4!"+.'#04$ -!/#+"!#$*0 +, 1-!&$&$' 1$#$>'4+', 8!.'-+!#04$' $5'*1'"'4+' + 3'#+ <'7.'#04$*.+. =-.-'.0+,, &!>4$ ?"+.9&!.0, ".$
*!8+ 1$#+3'2*(+' "+49 .!(>' 7&#7#+*0 "!*.06 4!*'#'4+72.
F-'<*.!&#7'.*7, ".$ $<4+8 +/ $*4$&49,
(-+.'-+'& 1-+ @$-8+-$&!4++ $.4$B'4+7
4!*'#'4+7 ( .'8 +#+ +498 ;$*?<!-*.&'4498
$-;!4!8 7&#7'.*7 A@@'(.+&4$*.0 &91$#4'4+7 +8+ *$3+!#04$ /4!"+89, @?4(3+2. =
A.$2 *&7/+ 1-'+8?:'*.&'44$ 4';!.+&4!7
$3'4(! <'7.'#04$*.+ $5:'2 1$#+3++ 4!*'#'4+'8 & 4!"!#' %% &'(! 7&#7'.*7 /!($4$8'-4$2 + $5?*#$&#'4! -$*.$8 1-'*.?14$*.+.
= "!*.4$*.+, E. E. C*.-$?8$& 1-+&$<+. *#'<?6:+' *&'<'4+7 $.4$*+.'#04$ <+4!8+(+
«4!+5$#'' *'-0'/49,» 1-'*.?1#'4+2, 1$<*?<49, $(-?>4$8? *?<? +#+ *?<'54$2 1!#!.': & 3'#$8 ($#+"'*.&$ 1-'*.?1#'4+2 * 1899
21
%"(AB!C) # '(*"(,) D!("## # #,D("## E(,+F&",D'& # *"&'&
1$ 1908 ;;. &9-$*#$ * 266 710 <$ 385 039,
1-+ A.$8 ($#+"'*.&$ 1-'*.?1#'4+2 1-$.+&
1$-7<(! ?1-!&#'4+7 &9-$*#$ * 8 048 & 1899
;$<? <$ 8 729 & 1908 ;$<? (1-+ A.$8 *#'<?'.
$.8'.+.0 /4!"+.'#0492 -$*. 1$#+.+"'*(+,
1-'*.?1#'4+2 & 1905 ;$<? – <$ 16240, & 1906
;$<? – <$ 19 733, & 1907 – *4+>'4+' <$
10 917); ($#+"'*.&$ 1-'*.?1#'4+2 1-$.+&
>+/4+ &9-$*#$ * 16 293 <$ 33 053; ($#+"'*.&$ 4!*+#0*.&'449, 1$,+:'4+2 +8?:'*.&!
&9-$*#$ * 20 322 <$ 47 107; ($#+"'*.&$
(-!> &9-$*#$ * 63 328 <$ 108 5073. G!($2
-$*. 1-'*.?14$*.+ & 4!"!#' %% &'(!, 1$
84'4+6 E. E. C*.-$?8$&!, 59# &9/&!4
?,?<B'4+'8 1$#$>'4+7 4!-$<49, 8!**, $54+:!4+'8 4!*'#'4+7, $5$*.-'4+'8 *$3+!#049, + 1$#+.+"'*(+, 1-$.+&$-'"+2. = >?-4!#' «='*.4+( 1$#+3++» & 4!"!#' %% &'(!
4'$<4$(-!.4$ 1?5#+($&!#+*0 *.!.0+, *$<'->!:+' *&'<'4+7 $ -!*1-$*.-!4'4++ ,?#+;!4*.&! + 5'*1$-7<($& & *'#0*($2 8'*.4$*.+4.
I4!#+/ !-,+&49, 8!.'-+!#$& $ 1-'*.?14$*.+ & F'-8*($2 ;?5'-4++ /! 1911–
1913 ;;. 1$(!/9&!'., ".$ 4!+5$#'' -!*1-$*.-!4'4498+ 1-'*.?1#'4+78+ & A.$. 1'-+$<
59#+ ,?#+;!4*.&$ (5?2*.&$ * 4!4'*'4+'8
-!4), (-!>+, <-!(+5. F-+ A.$8 * 1911 1$
1913 ;;. ($#+"'*.&$ /!@+(*+-$&!449, 1-!&$4!-?B'4+2 ?&'#+"+#$*0. C<4!($ &#!*.0 &
1'-&?6 $"'-'<0 59#! $/!5$"'4! $5'*1'"'4+'8 *$5*.&'44$2 5'/$1!*4$*.+ + 1-'<$.&-!:'4+'8 ?;-$/ <#7 4'' *$ *.$-$49 4!*'#'4+7.
J-?;+8 &!>498 @!(.$-$8, &#+7&B+8 4!
@$-8+-$&!4+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 84'4+7 & $.4$B'4++ 1$#+3++, 7&#7#$*0 +*.$-+"'*($'
&$*1-+7.+' 1$#+3'2*(+, $-;!4$& 4!*'#'4+'8. G!(, K. I. )''4. ?(!/9&!'., ".$ 4!*.$-$>'44$' $.4$B'4+' ( 1-'<*.!&+.'#78 1$#+3'2*($2 &#!*.+, & 1'-&?6 $"'-'<0 +/ "+*#! 4+/$&$;$ '' /&'4!, +/<!&4! &$*1+.9&!#!*0
& B+-$(+, 4!-$<49, 8!**!, * 8!#$;$ &$/-!*.!. F#!"?:';$ +#+ 4'*#?B!6:';$*7 -'5'4(! .-!<+3+$44$ 1?;!#+ .'8, ".$ $.<!<?.
';$ ;$-$<$&$8?. E$$.&'.*.&'44$ <'.*(+'
&1'"!.#'4+7 1$<*$/4!.'#04$ 1'-'4$*+#+*0
4! 89*#+ + <'2*.&+7 /-'#$;$ "'#$&'(!6.
L-$8' .$;$, 4';!.+&4$' $.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( 1$#+3++ & )$**++ @$-8+-$&!#$*0
*$ *-'<4+, &'($&, ($;<! «1$#+3'2*(!7
&#!*.0 .$;$ &-'8'4+ 1$/&$#7#! *'5' ;-?5$
&.$-;!.0*7 & "!*.4?6 >+/40 #6<'2 + 4'
*.$#0($ & 3'#7, 4!*!><'4+7 1$-7<(!, *($#0($ & &+<!, 1$<!&#'4+7 &*7($;$ 1-$7&#'4+7
22
*&$5$<4$2 &$#+». C.*6<! – 4!"!#$ &-!><'54$;$ $.4$B'4+7 4!*'#'4+7 ( 1$#+3++7.
'8!#$&!>498 $5*.$7.'#0*.&$8 & ?*#$&+7, 5?->?!/4$;$ $5:'*.&!, $1-'<'#7&B+8
*.+#0 >+/4+ "'#$&'(! + &$ 84$;$8 &$*1-+7.+' $(-?>!6:+,, 7&#7#*7 ?-$&'40 ';$ <$*.!.(!. )!5$.!, 4' $5'*1'"+&!&B!7 ,$-$B';$
<$,$<!, @$-8+-$&!#! $.-+3!.'#04$' $.4$B'4+' ( #6<78, &94?><'4498 '' +*1$#47.0. =8'*.' * .'8 "+49 $5:'2 1$#+3++, &
$*$5'44$*.+ 4+>4+', 1$ ?-$&46 >+/4+ 8$;#+ 59.0 (&!#+@+3+-$&!49 .$#0($ (!( 4+:+'8.
M(!/!449' &9B' 1-+"+49 1$-$><!#+
1-$5#'89, *&7/!449' * ($81#'(.$&!4+'8
1$#+3'2*(+, *.-?(.?- <$*.$2498 (!<-$&98
*$*.!&$8. F$A.$8? *#'<?'. 1-+/4!.0 4$-8$2, ".$ 1-+ 4'<$*.!.$"4$8 8!.'-+!#04$8
$5'*1'"'4++ + .7>'#9, ?*#$&+7, *#?>59,
*$"'.!&B+,*7 * 4';!.+&498 $5:'*.&'4498
84'4+'8, 1$#+3'2*(+' 1$<-!/<'#'4+7 4'
8$;#+ 59.0 & 4'$5,$<+8$2 8'-' $5'*1'"'49
1-$@'**+$4!#0498+ *1'3+!#+*.!8+.
E?:'*.&'44$' /4!"'4+' &$ &/!+8$$.4$B'4+7, 4!*'#'4+7 * "+4!8+ 1$#+3++ +8'#+
#+"4$*.49' ,!-!(.'-+*.+(+ 1$#+3'2*(+,.
F$#$>+.'#049' 1-+8'-9 1$*.!4$&(+ 1$#+3'2*($;$ <'#! + A@@'(.+&4$;$ &/!+8$<'2*.&+7 * 4!*'#'4+'8 &*.-'"!6.*7 & -!/#+"49,
?'/<!, -';+$4!9.
= 3'#$8 4!*'#'4+' 1$4+8!#$, ".$ 4'<$*.!.$( 1$#+3++ 8$>'. 4';!.+&4$ *(!/!.0*7 + 4! +, >+/4+. '*8$.-7 4! (-+.+(? 1$#+3++ 4! *.-!4+3!, ;!/'., $5:'*.&'44$*.0
"'.($ $5$/4!"+#! *&$6 1$/+3+6, ($;<! *.!#$ +/&'*.4$, ".$ 4! 8#!<B+, "+4$& 1$#+3++
4!#!;!#+*0 &9"'.9 «+/ 5'/ .$;$ 4+".$>4$;$
>!#$&!4+7», ".$ &#'(#$ /! *$5$2 ?,$< #?"B+, *$.-?<4+($&. F-+ A.$8 <!&!#*7 1-!(.+"'*(+2 *$&'.: «D.$5 1?5#+(! 4' *8$.-'#!
1-'/-+.'#04$ 4! 4!B+, 1$#+3'2*(+, "+4$&4+($&, 4!<$ 1-'><' &*';$ ?&'#+"+.0 +8 >!#$&!4+'»10.
E#'<?'. $.8'.+.0, ".$ $.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( 1$#+3++ & 4!"!#' %% &'(! ,!-!(.'-+/$&!#$*0 7&498+ ($4.-!*.!8+. = $1-'<'#'449, *#?"!7, &*'4!-$<4$ 1-+/4!&!#+*0
+, 4'$5,$<+8$*.0 + 1$#'/4$*.0 <#7 $5:'*.&!. = .$ >' &-'87 4'-'<(+8+ 59#+ + *+.?!3++, ($;<! $.4$B'4+' ( 1$#+3++ + $3'4(' ''
<'7.'#04$*.+ *'-0'/4$ &+<$+/8'47#+*0.
'*($#0($ +4!"' 1-$7&#7#$*0 $.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( *$.-?<4+(!8 1$#+.+"'*($2
1$#+3++. =4'B4' /<'*0 1-$7&#7#$*0 ?&!>'4+' ( '' "+4!8, 4! *!8$8 >' <'#' A.$ «?&!:!,DG#- H."I., J 40, 2011
"#$%&'
. !., )#'*$&' !. (.
>'4+'» 59#$ 1-$<+(.$&!4$ $59"498 *.-!,$8. = $5:'*.&' 1$4+8!#+, ".$ /! 1$<"'-(4?.$ 5'/?1-'"498 1$&'<'4+'8 >!4<!-8*(+,
$@+3'-$& "!*.$ *(-9&!#+*0 >'*.$($*.0 +
5'/-!/#+"+' ( *?<05!8 /!&+*+89, $. 4+,
#6<'2. G!(+' @$-89 +, -!5$.9, (!( 1$$:-'4+' <$4$*+.'#0*.&!, 1-$&$(!3+7, 4';!.+&4$ &$*1-+4+8!#+*0 5$#0B+4*.&$8 4!*'#'4+711.
=!>498 !*1'(.$8 &/!+8$$.4$B'4+2
$5:'*.&! + ;$*?<!-*.&! & 1-!&$$,-!4+.'#04$2 *@'-' 7&#7'.*7 $.4$B'4+' 1$#+3++ (
4!*'#'4+6. K. I. )''4. *1-!&'<#+&$, 4!
4!B &/;#7<, ?(!/9&!'. 4! 4'$5,$<+8$*.0
-!**8$.-'4+7 $.4$B'4+7 1$#+3++ ( 4!*'#'4+6 & <&?, !*1'(.!,. E $<4$2 *.$-$49, $1-'<'#'44$' &4+8!4+' &/!+8$<'2*.&+6 1$#+3++ * 4!*'#'4+'8 ?<'#7#$*0 & 4$-8!.+&49, !(.!, + +4*.-?(3+7, 1$#+3'2*(+8 "+4!8 (@$-8!#04!7 *.$-$4!). E <-?;$2 *.$-$49, <$#>4$ 59.0 -!**8$.-'4$ + @!(.+"'*($' $.4$B'4+' 1$#+3++ ( $5:'*.&'44$*.+12.
L!( & 3'4.-', .!( + 4! 8'.!, /4!"+.'#04$' &4+8!4+' ?<'#7#$*0 -!/-!5$.(' + /!($4$<!.'#04$8? /!(-'1#'4+6 1-!&+# &/!+8$$.4$B'4+7 "+4$& 1$#+3++ * 4!*'#'4+'8.
E$.-?<4+(+ 1$#+3++ $57/9&!#+*0 «$.4$*+.0*7 ( /!1$<$/-'4498 + ($ &*'8 &$$5:'
#+3!8… *1$($24$, &'>#+&$ + .'-1'#+&$,
$.46<0 4' 1$/&$#77 *'5'… 1-+5';!.0 ( (!(+8-#+5$ 4!*+#0*.&'4498 <'2*.&+78 +#+
?;-$/!8 <#7 1$#?"'4+7 *$/4!4+7 +#+ 4?>49, *&'<'4+2»13.
= +/<!&!'89, +4*.-?(3+7, /!(-'1#7#$*0, ".$ 1$#+3'2*(+2 "+4 «& 1?5#+"49,
8'*.!,, & 4!-7<!, + ..1. <$#>'4 59.0 *$
&*'8+ &'>#+&, *'-0'/'4 + *<'->!4. E?'.#+&$*.0, $*($-5+.'#04$' $5-!:'4+' + -'/($*.0 & *#$&!, +#+ & <'2*.&+7, &-'<7. <'#?
+ ?4+".$>!6. ';$ <$*.$+4*.&$»14.
'$5,$<+8$*.0 @$-8+-$&!4+7 1$#$>+.'#04$;$ $.4$B'4+7 4!*'#'4+7 ( 1$#+3++
$*$/4!&!#!*0 *$.-?<4+(!8+ 1$#+3++, + *$$.&'.*.&?6:+' &$1-$*9 4'$<4$(-!.4$ 1$<4+8!#+*0 4! *.-!4+3!, 1'-+$<+"'*(+, +/<!4+2.
= 1909 ;$<? & >?-4!#' «='*.4+( 1$#+3++» 59#! $1?5#+($&!4! *.!.07 «N!&$'&!4+'
$5:'*.&!», & ($.$-$2 !&.$- ?(!/9&!#: «E$&'-B'44$ 1$47.4! 1$.$8? ;-$8!<4!7 -$#0
4$-8!#049, <-?>'#6549, +#+, 1$ (-!24'2
8'-', <$&'-"+&9, $.4$B'4+2 8'><? 1$#+3+'2 + $5:'*.&$8. I $4+, A.+ $.4$B'4+7,
?&9, /!*.!&#76. ? 4!* >'#!.0 ':' $"'40 +
!"#$ «%"&'(», ')*+,- 28
"&+,-,* , &./#0$'&
' 1&00,203&2 456#%,, 7898+8 XX '#38
$"'40 84$;$;$. O 1$(! $4+ .!($&9, 84$;$1$#'/4!7 <'7.'#04$*.0 4!B'2 1-$&+43+!#04$2 !<8+4+*.-!3++, .$ '*.0 1$#+3++, 4! (!><$8 B!;? .$-8$/+.*7 + /!.-?<47'.*7 4'<$&'-"+&$*.06 + 1$<$/-+.'#04$*.06 $5:'*.&!»15. = (!"'*.&' 8'- 1$ ?#?"B'4+6 &/!+8$$.4$B'4+2 8'><? 1$#+3+'2 + $5:'*.&$8
1-'<#!;!#+*0, & "!*.4$*.+, .!(+', (!( ($--'(.4$' $.4$B'4+' ( 4!*'#'4+6 & 1$&*'<4'&4$2 -!5$.', $.(-9.$*.0 1$#+3++, +4@$-8+-$&!4+' $ '' <'7.'#04$*.+ 4!*'#'4+7
+ ..<.16 C<4!($ &1#$.0 <$ P'&-!#0*($2 -'&$#63++ 1917 ;$<! *'-0'/49, +/8'4'4+2 &$
&/!+8$$.4$B'4+7, 1$#+3++ + $5:'*.&! 4'
1-$+/$B#$.
= 1915 ;$<? & «='*.4+(' 1$#+3++» ?(!/9&!#$*0, ".$ «"+4!8 1$#+3++ $*$5#+&$
*#'<?'. 1$84+.0, ".$ &*';<! + &*6<? $*4$&$2 +, <'7.'#04$*.+ <$#>4! 7&#7.0*7 & +4.'-'*!, ;$*?<!-*.&! + +, *!8+, *.-$;!7 /!($44$*.0… E$"'.!4+' "?&*.&! /!($44$*.+ *
"?&*.&$8 .!(.! – A.$ 7&#7'.*7… +<'!#$8
!;'4.! &#!*.+…»17. C<4$&-'8'44$ 1-+&$<+#*7 1-+8'- 4!-?B'4+2 & $*?:'*.&#'4++
+8+ *#?>'549, $57/!44$*.'2.
=/!+8$$.4$B'4+' 1$#+3++ + 4!*'#'4+7
& $1-'<'#'44$2 *.'1'4+ $5?*#$&+#$ + $.4$B'4+7 4!*'#'4+7 ( *!8+8 1-'*.?14+(!8 +
1-'*.?1#'4+78. F-+ A.$8 & "!*.+, (!*!6:'2*7 *$5*.&'449, +4.'-'*$& $59&!.'#'2,
$.4$B'4+' ( 1-'*.?1#'4+78 59#$ (-!24'
4';!.+&498. = .$ >' &-'87, '*#+ 1-'*.?14+(+ 1$*7;!#+ 4! +4.'-'*9 &#!<'#03'& +8'4+2 +#+ /!&$<$&, $. ($.$-9, /!&+*'#+ $59&!.'#+, $.4$B'4+' ( 1-!&$4!-?B+.'#78 +
*!8+8 1-!&$4!-?B'4+78 8'47#$*0 4! 4'2.-!#04$' +#+ 1$#$>+.'#04$'.
= 4!"!#' %% &'(! 1$4+8!4+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! & )$**++ 59#$ $5?*#$&#'4$
A($4$8+"'*($2, *$3+!#04$2 + 1$#+.+"'*($2
$5*.!4$&($2 & *.-!4', ! .!(>' +4.'-'*!8+
*!8$<'->!&+7. = *#$>+&B'2*7 *+.?!3++
$*4$&498 1-+$-+.'.$8 ;$*?<!-*.&! 7&#7#$*0 $5'*1'"'4+' 5'/$1!*4$*.+ &#!*.+ $.
&4?.-'44+, ?;-$/, ".$ + 1-'<$1-'<'#+#$
*$<'->!4+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(!, $5'*1'"'4+' ($.$-$;$ /!(-'1#7#$*0 & <'2*.&$&!&B+, 4$-8!.+&4$-1-!&$&9, !(.!,, ! .!(>'
-'!#+/$&9&!#$*0 & <'7.'#04$*.+ ;$*?<!-*.&'449, $-;!4$&. F-+ A.$8 4';!.+&4$' &$/<'2*.&+' 4! *$*.$74+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! $(!/9&!#$ &/!+8$$.4$B'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 + $-;!4$& $,-!49 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(!.
23
%"(AB!C) # '(*"(,) D!("## # #,D("## E(,+F&",D'& # *"&'&
= *&$6 $"'-'<0 &(#!<9&!'8$' ;$*?<!-*.&$8 & 1$47.+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! *$<'->!4+', 1$4+8!4+' 3'#'2 + *-'<*.& $5'*1'"'4+7 $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(!, &/!+8$$.4$B'4+' $5:'*.&! + ;$*?<!-*.&! & 1-!&$$,-!4+.'#04$2 *@'-' 1-'<$1-'<'#+#+ *+*.'8?, 8!.'-+!#04$' + +4$' $5'*1'"'4+', !
.!(>' @?4(3++ $-;!4$&, $5'*1'"+&!&B+, &
4!"!#' %% &'(! $5:'*.&'4492 1$-7<$( &
;$*?<!-*.&', @$-89 ?"!*.+7 4!*'#'4+7 &
A.$8 1-$3'**', !, & ($4'"4$8 *"'.', + *$*.$74+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! & ;$*?<!-*.&'.
! -';+$4!#04$8 ?-$&4', & "!*.4$*.+ 4!
M-!#', 1$4+8!4+' + *$<'->!4+' $5:'*.&'44$;$ 1$-7<(! *?:'*.&'44$ 4' $.#+"!#+*0 $.
$5:';$*?<!-*.&'449,. C*$5'44$*.+ & A.$2
*@'-' 59#+ $5?*#$&#'49 *.-?(.?-$2 4!*'#'4+7 + ';$ 1$#+.+/+-$&!44$*.06, /4!"+.'#0498 ($#+"'*.&$8 1-$89B#'449, 1-'<1-+7.+2, ?<!#'44$*.06 $. 3'4.-!.
1
Q!&-+#$& I. R. F-+&#'"'4+' 4!*'#'4+7 ( ?"!*.+6 &
5$-05' * 1-'*.?14$*.06: <+*. … (!4<. 6-+<. 4!?(.
E!-!.$&, 2004. E. 76.
2
E8.: )''4. K. I. C5:!7 + 1$#+.+"'*(!7 1$#+3+7
)$**++ (1900–1917 ;;.): 8$4$;-!@+7. )7/!40, 2001.
E. 223–230.
3
C*.-$?8$& E. E. F-'*.?14$*.0 + '' 1-+"+49 & <$-'&$#63+$44$2 )$**++. R., 1980. E. 64–65.
4
E8., 4!1-+8'-: R9*#+ 1$#+3'2*($;$ "+4$&4+(! 1$
1$&$<? (-'*.074*(+, 5'*1$-7<($& // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1910. S 1, 2; C ,?#+;!4*.&' // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++.
1910. S 3; %?#+;!4*.&$ // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1910.
S 7.
5
QIFC. P. 36. C. 6. J. 10. T. 28–67.
6
)''4. K. I. M(!/. *$". E. 225.
7
F$#+3+7 + 1?5#+(! // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1910. S 38.
E. 921.
8
E8.: F$#+3+7 + ,?#+;!4*.&$ // Q$#$* E'&'-!. I-,!4;'#0*(, 1906. 20 *'4..
9
E8., 4!1-+8'-: R?*+,+4 =. U. J'7.'#04$*.0 =7.*($2 1$#+3++ & 4!"!#' %% &. // O/ +*.$-++ =7.*(+,
*1'3*#?>5 + 1$#+3++: 8!.'-+!#9 <$(#!<$& + <$(?8'4.$& 4!?"4$-1-!(.+"'*($2 ($4@'-'43++. L+-$&,
1997. E. 43–51.
10
L!-!?#! Q$-$<$&$2 // )?**($' /4!87. EF5., 1906.
10 $(..
11
E'8+( I. I. E$3+!#04$-1*+,$#$;+"'*(+' ,!-!(.'-+*.+(+ $5#+(! -$**+2*($;$ 1$#+3'2*($;$ + *$&'.*($;$ 8+#+3+$4'-! (($4'3 XIX–%% &'(!). L$*.-$8!;
L-!*4$<!-. 2003. E. 227.
12
E8.: )''4. K. I. M(!/. *$". E. 231.
13
O4*.-?(3+7 "+4!8 1$#+3++ =!-B!&*($;$ *?<'54$;$ $(-?;!. =!-B!&!, 1908. E. 3.
14
O4*.-?(3+7 "+4!8 *9*(49, $.<'#'4+2. EF5., 1910.
E. 8.
15
='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1909. S 20. E. 487.
16
E8., 4!1-+8'-: F$-! -!/$5-!.0*7 // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1913. S 28. E. 498; N!&$'&!4+' $5:'*.&! // ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1909. S 20. E. 487; F$#+3+7 + 1?5#+(!
// ='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1910. S 38. E. 932.
17
='*.4+( 1$#+3++. 1915. S 51. E. 952.
!"!#$ %&'!(%)*" + ,-."/0)1 18 &/!$2,$ 2011 3.
24
:!,DG#- H."I., J 40, 2011