Ремонт выборки А.А.Давыдов, А.О. Крыштановский Первая

!"#$%& '()$*+,
-.-../'(0$', -.1. 2*(3&/%$'4+,5
!"#$%& '()*+,%-+& ./%/0+: 12341. 1989. 5 5. 1. 100—105.
6*/+&,+/ 7*$'"0"%,8 4$9,$:$;,<"4+,= ,44:"0$'/%,5 7$+/>('/"&, <&$, +/+ )(
&?/&":@%$ %, )(: 47:/%,*$'/% 7$:"'$5 A&/7 4)$*/ ,%B$*#/9,,, '4";0/ ,#"C& #"4&$
4#"?"%,8 '()$*$+ 7$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,# =/*/+&"*,4&,+/#, 7*$7D?"%%("
$&'"&( ' /%+"&/= , %"+$&$*(" 0*D;," #$#"%&(, 4%,E/C?," +/<"4&'$ 4$9,$:$;,<"4+$5
,%B$*#/9,,.
.:8 &$;$ <&$)( 4'"4&, + #,%,#D#D ':,8%," A&,= %"E":/&":@%(= B/+&$*$', '
#"&$0,<"4+$5 :,&"*/&D*" [1—3] *"+$#"%0D"&48 7*$'$0,&@ *"#$%& '()$*+,. 10%/+$ D
)$:@3,%4&'/ 4$9,$:$;$' %"& 84%$;$ 7*"04&/':"%,8 $ 7*/+&,<"4+$5 *"/:,>/9,, A&$;$
%"$)=$0,#$;$ A&/7/ 4$9,$:$;,<"4+$;$ ,44:"0$'/%,8. F/+, 4*"0, 300 ,44:"0$'/%,5,
4$0"*E/?,=48 '$ G4"4$C>%$# )/%+" 4$9,$:$;,<"4+,= 0/%%(= HI -J III!, :,3@ '
0"48&, $4D?"4&':8:48 *"#$%& '()$*+,. .:8 4*/'%"%,8 $&#"&,#, <&$ >/ *D)"E$# *"#$%&
'()$*+, DE" 0/'%$ 4&/: */47*$4&*/%"%%(# #"&$0$# 7$'(3"%,8 +/<"4&'/
4$9,$:$;,<"4+$5 ,%B$*#/9,,.
6*,<,%( %/3";$ $&4&/'/%,8 ' 7*,#"%"%,, *"#$%&/ '()$*+, $<"',0%(:
$&4D&4&'," '(<,4:,&":@%$5 &"=%,+,, 47"9,/:,>,*$'/%%$;$ 7*$;*/##%$;$ $)"47"<"%,8,
#"&$0,<"4+,= 7$4$),5, %"0$4&/&$<%/8 +'/:,B,+/9,8 ,44:"0$'/&":"5 , *80 0*D;,=
B/+&$*$'. G %/4&$8?"" '*"#8 7$:$E"%," #"%8"&48 ' :D<3DC 4&$*$%D, 7$A&$#D #(
4<,&/"# */>;$'$* $ *"#$%&" '()$*+, /+&D/:@%(#.
K&$ E" &/+$" *"#$%& '()$*+,? G D>+$# 4#(4:" — A&$ D*/'%,'/%," '()$*$<%(= ,
;"%"*/:@%(= */47*"0":"%,5 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,= =/*/+&"*,4&,+ *"47$%0"%&$'. G
3,*$+$# — 7"*',<%/8 4&/&,4&,<"4+/8 $)*/)$&+/ 0/%%(=, '+:C</C?/8 +$**"+9,C:
! 4#"?"%,8 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,= =/*/+&"*,4&,+ *"47$%0"%&$';
! %"$0%$*$0%$4&, #/44,'$' 0/%%(=;
! *">+$ '(0":8C?,=48 , '$44&/%$':"%," 7*$7D?"%%(= $&'"&$'.
F/+,# $)*/>$#, 9":@ *"#$%&/ '()$*+, — 7$'(3"%," +/<"4&'/ DE" 4$)*/%%$5
,%B$*#/9,,. .$),&@48 A&$5 9":, #$E%$, "4:, ,47$:@>$'/&@ ,>)(&$<%DC ,%B$*#/9,C,
+$&$*/8 4$0"*E,&48 ' 4$)*/%%(= 0/%%(=. L&$ '/E%"53"" 7$:$E"%,", + 4$E/:"%,C, *"0+$
D<,&('/C& 4$9,$:$;,.
!/44#$&*,# $)?," #"&$0$:$;,<"4+," 7*,%9,7(, %/ +$&$*(= )/>,*D"&48 :$;,+/
*"#$%&/ '()$*+,. 6"*'(5 — 0$#,%,*$'/%," %"B$*#/:@%(= 7*$9"0D* 7*,%8&,8 *"3"%,5.
M47"= 7*, *"#$%&" '()$*+, 0$4&,;/"&48 ):/;$0/*8 ;:D)$+$#D >%/%,C ,>D</"#$5
7*$):"#(, 7*$9"0D*( '()$*$<%$;$ ,44:"0$'/%,8, 4,&D/9,, $7*$4/ *"47$%0"%&$' , &.0., /
4$)4&'"%%$ #/&"#/&,<"4+," 7*$9"0D*( ,;*/C& 7$0<,%"%%DC *$:@. F/+$5 7$0=$0 ' +$*%"
7*$&,'$7$:$E"% #%"%,C, 4$;:/4%$ +$&$*$#D *"#$%& '()$*+, — A&$ %"0$4&$5%("
4"*@">%$;$ 4$9,$:$;/ #/&"#/&,<"4+," #/%,7D:89,,, D'$08?," ' 4&$*$%D $& 7$>%/%,8
4$9,/:@%$5 *"/:@%$4&,.
G&$*$5 7*,%9,7 — $7&,#,>/9,8. 6$'(3"%," +/<"4&'/ 4$)*/%%$5 ,%B$*#/9,,
$4D?"4&':8"&48 ):/;$0/*8 #/+4,#/:@%$#D D#"%@3"%,C ':,8%,8 %"E":/&":@%(= B/+&$*$'
7*, #,%,#/:@%$# ,4+/E"%,,, '%$4,#$# *"#$%&$# '()$*+,. 6$84%,# A&$ 7$:$E"%,"
7*,#"*$#. .$7D4&,#, #( $7*$4,:, #DE<,% )$:@3", <"# &*")$'/:$4@, , &"7"*@ D#"%@3/"#
,= +$:,<"4&'$ 0$ &*")D"#$5 +'$&(. G *">D:@&/&" $)N"# '()$*+, #$E"& $+/>/&@48
%"0$4&/&$<%(# 0:8 *"3"%,8 7$4&/':"%%(= >/0/<. O%/<,&, 4$+*/?/&@ $)N"# #$E%$ &$:@+$
0$ %" +$&$*$;$ $7&,#D#/. 6*, A&$# %/0$ 7$#%,&@, <&$ *"#$%& %" >/#"%8"& */4<"&/
'()$*+, , +/<"4&'"%%$5 */)$&( /%+"&"*$'. 1% :,3@ $):";</"& D4,:,8 7$ "" */4<"&D ,
*"/:,>/9,,.
!/44#$&*,# 7*$9"0D*( *"#$%&/ '()$*+, 4 &$;$ #$#"%&/, +$;0/ 0/%%(" ''"0"%( '
+$#7@C&"* , «$<,?"%(» $& $3,)$+ 7"*B$*/9,,.
!"##$%&'( )$"*)"#"*)"+,' +-"#. *.))/0. J"$0%$*$0%$4&@ 4)$*/ 0/%%(=
'$>%,+/"& 7$ 0'D# 7*,<,%/#. G$-7"*'(=, %/ 7$:"'$5 4&/0,, ,44:"0$'/%,8 7*/+&,<"4+,
'4";0/ 4)$* ,%B$*#/9,, $4D?"4&':8C& %"4+$:@+$ /%+"&"*$', */>:,</C?,=48 4&"7"%@C
7$0;$&$'+,, 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,#, , :,<%$4&%(#, =/*/+&"*,4&,+/#,. 2*$#" &$;$,
/%+"&"*( %" '4";0/ 7*$'$08& $7*$4 ' $0,%/+$'(= D4:$',8=. G4" A&$ $+/>('/"&
'$>0"54&'," %/ $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$', 7*,<"# 0$4&/&$<%$ 4,:@%$" [4].
G$-'&$*(=, 7*, 7*$'"0"%,, 7$<&$'$;$ $7*$4/ 4)$* ,%B$*#/9,, */4&8;,'/"&48
,%$;0/ %/ %"4+$:@+$ %"0":@, , 0/%%(", 7$4&D7,'3," ' */>%(" 7"*,$0( 7$:"'$;$ A&/7/,
#$;D& $&*/E/&@ '*"#"%%(" ,>#"%"%,8 ,>D</"#$;$ 8':"%,8 ,:, */>%(" ;*D77(
*"47$%0"%&$'.
6"*"0 ,44:"0$'/&":"# '$>%,+/"& '$7*$4: 7*/'$#"*%$ :, $)N"0,%8&@ A&, 0/%%(" '
$0,% $)?,5 #/44,', "4:, /%/:,>,*$'/&@ ,= '#"4&" %":@>8, 7$4+$:@+D ' A&$# 4:D</" #(
7$:D<,# 4D?"4&'"%%(" ,4+/E"%,8? P$E%$ :, */44#/&*,'/&@ %"4+$:@+$ 4$'$+D7%$4&"5
0/%%(= ' +/<"4&'" */>:,<%(= '()$*$+, 7$:D<"%%(= ,> $0%$5 , &$5 E" ;"%"*/:@%$5
4$'$+D7%$4&, [5]. G 4:D</", +$;0/ ;*D77( 0/%%(= $+/>/:,4@ %"$0%$*$0%(#,, 7"*"0
,44:"0$'/&":"# '$>%,+/C& 7*$):"#( +$**"+9,,.
Q4:, */>:,<,8 ' #/44,'/= 0/%%(= $)D4:$':"%( ':,8%,"# /%+"&"*/ ,:, D4:$',8#,
$7*$4/, 4:"0$'/:$ )( 7*$'"4&, 7$'&$*%(5 $7*$4 ' 0/%%$5 '()$*$<%$5 4$'$+D7%$4&, 4
7$#$?@C 0*D;$;$ /%+"&"*/ ,:, /%+"&"*$'. J$ A&$ ' ,0"/:", / %/ 7*/+&,+" — 0"B,9,&
'*"#"%,, #/&"*,/:@%(= , :C04+,= *"4D*4$'. 2*$#" &$;$, #$;D& 7*$,>$5&, 4D?"4&'"%%("
,>#"%"%,8 ' $)?"4&'"%%$5 E,>%,, , %"84%$, <&$ #( 7$:D<,#: ,%B$*#/9,C, +$&$*/8
$&*/E/"& 7*"0(0D?,5 7"*,$0, ,:, *">D:@&/&( ,>#"%"%,5 ' $)?"4&'"%%$5 E,>%,. I:"0D"&
&/+ E" D<,&('/&@, <&$ 7$'&$*%(5 $7*$4 $0%,= , &"= E" :C0"5 '"0"& + ,4+/E"%,8#,
$)D4:$':"%%(# 74,=$:$;,<"4+,#, $4$)"%%$4&8#,, / "4:, $7*/3,'/&@ 0*D;,=
*"47$%0"%&$' 4$ 4=$E,#, 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,#, =/*/+&"*,4&,+/#,, ,>#"%"%,8 '
$9"%+/= #$;D& )(&@ $)D4:$':"%( %$'(# $)N"+&$#.
G A&$5 4,&D/9,, %/ 7$#$?@ #$E"& 7*,5&, $0%/ ,> $4%$'%(= 7*$9"0D* *"#$%&/
'()$*+, — 7"*"'>'"3,'/%," 0/%%(=. ID&@ "" 4$4&$,& ' 4:"0DC?"#:
4 7$#$?@C A#7,*,<"4+, %/50"%%(= '"4$' &/+ 4+$**"+&,*$'/&@ 0/%%(", <&$)( ':,8%,"
4#"?"%,5 4%,>,&@ 0$ $7&,#/:@%(= 7*"0":$'. G":,<,%/ 4#"?"%,8 %/=$0,&48 :,)$ 4
7$#$?@C A+47"*&%$;$ $7*$4/, :,)$ +/+ $&+:$%"%," 4*"0%,= >%/<"%,5 ' 7$0'()$*+/= $&
4*"0%";$ >%/<"%,8 7$ '4"#D #/44,'D.
6*, 7"*"'>'"3,'/%,, 0/%%(= '$>%,+/"& 7*$):"#/ 7*/',:@%$;$ '()$*/ A&/:$%/, 7$
$&%$3"%,C + +$&$*$#D )D0"& $4D?"4&':8&@48 +$**"+9,8 %"$0%$*$0%$4&,. L&/:$% #$E%$
'()*/&@ ,4=$08 ,> 4$0"*E/&":@%(= 4$$)*/E"%,5 :,)$ +$%4&*D,*$'/&@ ";$ +/+ %"<&$
4*"0%"" ,> &"= 7$0'()$*$+, +$&$*(" ,#"C&48 ' %/:,<,,. 10%,# ,> &/+,= A&/:$%$' #$E"&
'(4&D7/&@ 4*"0%"'>'"3"%%/8 '":,<,%/ 4#"?"%,8 7$ '4"#D #/44,'D. G &/):. 1
7*"04&/':"%( A&/7( 7$0$)%$5 +$**"+9,,.
1.-2'&. 1. 2$**"+9,8 %"$0%$*$0%$4&, 0/%%(=*
3"4$# .)%$,$#.
H4=$0%$" +$:,<"4&'$ /%+"&
R/:: 4#"?"%,8
I*"0%"'>'"3"%%/8 '":,<,%/
4#"?"%,8
6*$9"0D*/ */4<"&/ '"4/
2$**"+9,8 +$:,<"4&'/ /%+"&
1
80
2
2
54
1
3
101
3
(80 = 2 + 54 = 1 + 101 = 3) : 235 S 2,2
2,2 : 2 = 1,1
80=1,1=88
2,2 : 1 = 2,2
54=2,2=119
2,2 : 3 S0,73
101=0,73=74
* 6*,#"</%,". L+47"*&( $9"%,'/:, 4#"?"%," 4 7$#$?@C 3-)/::@%$5 3+/:(, ;0"
1 )/:: — 4#"?"%," %">%/<,&":@%$", / 3 )/::/ — 4#"?"%," $<"%@ >%/<,&":@%$".
G *">D:@&/&" +$**"+9,, $)N"# #/44,'/ D'":,<,:48 %/ 46 /%+"& (%/ 20%
7"*'$%/</:@%$;$ $)N"#/). Q4:, )( ' +/<"4&'" A&/:$%/ )(:/ '()*/%/ %" 4*"0%"'>'"3"%%/8
'":,<,%/ 4#"?"%,8, +/+ ' &/):. 1, / #,%,#/:@%$" 4#"?"%," (1 )/::), $)N"#
4+$**"+&,*$'/%%$;$ #/44,'/ 4$+*/&,:48 )( %/ 108 /%+"& (46% %/</:@%$;$ $)N"#/).
F/+,# $)*/>$#, 4&*"#:"%," + #/+4,#/:@%$#D D#"%@3"%,C 4#"?"%,8 7*,'":$ +
4$+*/?"%,C ,4=$0%$;$ #/44,'/ 7$<&, '0'$". G &$ E" '*"#8 ,47$:@>$'/%,"
4*"0%"'>'"3"%%$5 '":,<,%( 4#"?"%,8 ' +/<"4&'" A&/:$%/ >/4&/',:$ 7*$0D):,*$'/&@
+/E0DC /%+"&D '&$*$;$ /%+"&"*/. H =$&8 ' #"&$0,<"4+$5 :,&"*/&D*" '(4+/>('/"&48
#%"%,", <&$ %":@>8 $0%D , &D E" /%+"&D '+:C</&@ ' #/3,%%DC $)*/)$&+D )$:"" 10—11 */>
[2], '4" E" 0D):,*$'/%," /%+"& D'":,<,'/"& ':,8%," ,%0,',0D/:@%(= $4$)"%%$4&"5
$7*/3,'/"#(=, +$&$*$" ' +/E0$# +$%+*"&%$# ,44:"0$'/%,, */>:,<%$. 6$A&$#D ' $0%$#
,44:"0$'/%,, 7*/'$#"*%$ D'":,<,&@ 7$0#/44,' '0'$", / ' 0*D;$# — %"&. 6*$):"#/
'"*=%,= ;*/%,9 0D):,*$'/%,8 $4&/"&48 $&+*(&$5, 7$A&$#D >%/%," 7*$):"#( , >0*/'(5
4#(4: — $4%$'%(" +*,&"*,, 7*,%8&,8 7*/',:@%$;$ *"3"%,8. P( */44#$&*":,
+$**"+9,C 4#"?"%,5, '(>'/%%(= ':,8%,"# /%+"&"*/.
-%/:$;,<%$ 7*$'$0,&48 +$**"+9,8 4#"?"%,5, $)D4:$':"%%(= */>:,<,"# #/44,'$'
0/%%(= '$ '*"#"%,.
6$4:" &$;$ +/+ '"4/ %/50"%( , #/44,' 4+$**"+&,*$'/%', 4 7$#$?@C 4&/&,4&,<"4+,=
+*,&"*,"' 4:"0D"& "?" */> 7*$'"4&, 7*$'"*+D %/ $0%$*$0%$4&@. G 4:D</", "4:,
7$0#/44,'( 4%$'/ $+/>/:,4@ %"$0%$*$0%(#,, &*")D"&48 %$'$" 7"*"'>'"3,'/%,", %$ DE" 4
0*D;,#, '"4/#,, , >/&"# 7*$'"*+D %/0$ 7$'&$*,&@. Q4:, 4+$**"+&,*$'/%%(" 7$0#/44,'(
$78&@ $+/ED&48 %"$0%$*$0%(#,, ,= 4:"0D"& $)*/)/&('/&@ $&0":@%$.
!"##$%&'( #.+5#$*$2$)'6 +"&'.27)"-*$4"8#.9':$+%'0 0.#.%,$#'+,'%
#$+5")*$),";. 6$4:" 4)$*/ ,%B$*#/9,, 7*/+&,<"4+, '4";0/ %/):C0/"&48 4#"?"%,"
4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,= =/*/+&"*,4&,+ $7*$3"%%(=, 7$ 4*/'%"%,C 4 ;"%"*/:@%$5
4$'$+D7%$4&@C. 6*"E0" <"# 7*,4&D7/&@ + +$**"+9,,, 7$:">%$ '(8',&@ ':,8%,"
4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,= 7*,>%/+$' %/ $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$'. L&$& /%/:,> #$E"& )(&@
$4D?"4&':"% 4 7$#$?@C 0'D#"*%(= &/):,9 4$7*8E"%%$4&, ,:, #%$E"4&'"%%$;$
%$#,%/:@%$;$ /%/:,>/.
J/7*,#"*, %/#, D4&/%$':"%$, <&$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+," 7*,>%/+, 4:/)$
4'8>/%( 4 $&'"&/#, $) D0$':"&'$*"%%$4&, */)$&$5 , E,>%@C, $9"%+$5 &"#7$'
7"*"4&*$5+,,
$0$)*"%,"#
0"8&":@%$4&,
7$:,&,<"4+,=
:,0"*$',
$9"%+$5
'%"3%"7$:,&,<"4+,= 4$)(&,5 , 0*. .:8 A&,= ,%0,+/&$*$' 7"*"'>'"3,'/%," 7$
4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,# =/*/+&"*,4&,+/# %" %DE%$.
G$>#$E%( &*, 4,&D/9,,. 6"*'/8 — $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$' %" 4'8>/%( 4 4$9,/:@%$0"#$;*/B,<"4+,#, =/*/+&"*,4&,+/#,, ' A&$# 4:D</" +$**"+9,8 %" 7*$'$0,&48. G&$*/8
4,&D/9,8 — +/+/8-&$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+/8 =/*/+&"*,4&,+/, %/7*,#"* 7$:, &"4%$
4'8>/%/ 4$ '4"#, 4$0"*E/&":@%(#, '$7*$4/#,, ,:, &*"&@8 — */>%(" '$7*$4( #$;D& )(&@
4'8>/%( 4 */>:,<%(#, =/*/+&"*,4&,+/#,. G A&$# 4:D</" +$**"+9,8 7*$'$0,&48 7$ 4="#",
$7,4/%%$5 ' [O].
H> &/):. 2 4:"0D"&, <&$ ' *">D:@&/&" +$**"+9,, +$:,<"4&'$ #DE<,% D#"%@3,:$4@ %/
28 <":$'"+, , %/ 4&$:@+$ E" D'":,<,:$4@ <,4:$ E"%?,%. .D):,*$'/%," /%+"& E"%?,%
$4%$'('/"&48 %/ )/>$'$# 7*,%9,7" '()$*$<%$;$ #"&$0/ [)], 4$;:/4%$ +$&$*$#D +/E0(5
,%0,',0 %"4"& '4C ,%B$*#/9,C, 7*"04&/':"%%DC ' ";$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+$5
;*D77". G &/):. 2 7*,'"0"% 7*,#"*, +$;0/ %/ $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$' $+/>('/"& ':,8%,"
&$:@+$ $0%/ =/*/+&"*,4&,+/ — 7$:. 6*/+&,+/ 7$+/>('/"&, <&$ &/+ )('/"& 0/:"+$ %"
'4";0/. O%/<,&":@%$ </?" '4&*"</"&48 4,&D/9,8, +$;0/ %/ $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$' $+/>('/C&
':,8%," 0'", %/7*,#"* '$>*/4& , $)*/>$'/%,", ,:, &*, , )$:"" 4$9,/:@%$0"#$;*/B,<"4+," =/*/+&"*,4&,+,. .:8 A&$;$ 4:D</8 $0%,# ,> /'&$*$' 4&/&@, */>*/)$&/%(
#"&$0 , 4$$&'"&4&'DC?," 7*$;*/##( 0:8 LGP, */44<,&('/C?," '"4/ 0:8 %"4+$:@+,=
7*,>%/+$' $0%$'*"#"%%$ [7]. O0"4@ $&#"&,# 4:"0DC?"": ,47$:@>$'/%," 0/%%(= 7*$;*/##
' HI -J III! 7$+/>/:$ ,= '(4$+DC A+47:D/&/9,$%%DC %/0"E%$4&@, / ;:/'%$" —
7*$4&$&D ' $)*/?"%,,.
1.-2'&. 2. 2$**"+9,8 7$ $0%$5 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+$5 =/*/+&"*,4&,+".
?"2
PDE<,%(
T"%?,%(
</-"#":).(
+";"%=5)"+,7
:'+2$))"+,7
%
100
66,6
50
33,4
@$)$#.27).(
A.+:B, ;$+. >%"##$%,'#";.)).
+";"%=5)"+,7,
( +";"%=5)"+,7
%
:'+2$))"+,7
%
48
48 : 66,6=0,72 100x0,72=72
48
52
52 : 33,4-1,56
50x1,56=78
52
6$4:" +$**"+9,, '()$*$<%(= */47*"0":"%,5 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,=
7*,>%/+$' #$E%$ 7*,4&D7/&@ + 4:"0DC?"#D A&/7D *"#$%&/ '()$*+, — +$**"+9,, *">+$
'(0":8C?,=48 , '$44&/%$':"%,C 7*$7D?"%%(= $&'"&$'.
!"##$%&'( #$C%" ;/*$2(DE'0+( ",;$,"; #$+5")*$),";. G 7*/+&,+" $7*$4$'
$)?"4&'"%%$;$ #%"%,8 '4&*"</C&48 $&'"&( *"47$%0"%&$', +$&$*(" 4,:@%$ $&:,</C&48 $&
$4%$'%$5 #/44( $&'"&$'. L&$ #$E"& )(&@ $)D4:$':"%$ $3,)+$5 4/#$;$ *"47$%0"%&/ ,:,
$3,)+$5 *";,4&*/9,, $&'"&/ ,%&"*'@C"*$#, ,%$;0/—$4$)"%%(# #%"%,"# *"47$%0"%&/
,:, *">+,# ,>#"%"%,"# D4:$',5 $7*$4/. M4&/%$',&@ ,4&,%%DC 7*,<,%D $&+:$%"%,8
7*/+&,<"4+, %"'$>#$E%$. !">+$ '(0":8C?,"48 $&'"&( >/&*D0%8C& /%/:,> 0/%%(=
7$A&$#D '7$:%" "4&"4&'"%%$ 4&*"#:"%," ,= +/+-&$ %/5&, , 4+$**"+&,*$'/&@
G(8':"%,C *">+$ '(0":8C?,=48 %/):C0"%,5 7$4'8?"%$ )$:@3$" +$:,<"4&'$
%/D<%(= 7D):,+/9,5 (%/7*,#"*, [5]), 7$A&$#D #( %" )D0"# 7$0*$)%$ $4&/%/':,'/&@48 %/
A&$5 >/0/<", , */44#$&*,# 7*$):"#D +$**"+9,, 7$0$)%(= %/):C0"%,5. I/#(5 7*$4&$5
47$4$) — D0/:,&@ 0/%%(5 $&'"& ,:, '4C /%+"&D , 0/:@%"53";$ /%/:,>/. L&/ '$>#$E%$4&@
7*"0D4#$&*"%/ ' 7/+"&/= «I$9,$:$;» GPD!-79, S!SS , *80" 0*D;,=. 10%/+$ +$;0/ $)N"#
'()$*+, %"'":,+, A&$ $)=$0,&48 4:,3+$# 0$*$;$, $4$)"%%$ "4:, *">+$ '(0":8C?,=48
$&'"&$' #%$;$.
G&$*$5 47$4$) — $&%"4"%," *">+$ '(0":8C?,=48 $&'"&$' + ;*/0/9,, «0*D;$"».
L&$& 7*,"# 7*,#"%8"&48 7*, +$0,*$'+" $&+*(&(= '$7*$4$' , 4 D47"=$# #$E"& )(&@
,47$:@>$'/% 7*, +$**"+9,, *">+$ '(0":8C?,=48 $&'"&$', 7$4+$:@+D «$&%"4"%,"» &/+,=
$&'"&$' ' $0%D ;*/0/9,C $)"47"<,'/"& %/7$:%"%," , 0":/"& '$>#$E%(# 0/:@%"53,5
/%/:,>.
F*"&,5 47$4$)—D#"%@3"%," 0*$)%$4&, 3+/:(. J/7*,#"*, U.H. I/;/%"%+$
$&#"</"&, <&$ 3+/:D ' 78&@-4"#@-0"'8&@ ;*/0/9,5 7$<&, '4";0/ 7*,=$0,&48 4'$0,&@ +
&*"#-<"&(*"# [)]. L&D >/0/<D #$E%$ *"3,&@ 4 7$#$?@C» 4&/&,4&,<"4+,= +*,&"*,"',
%/7*,#"* +*,&"*,8 V,3"*/, +$&$*(5 7$+/>('/"&, >%/<,#$ :, */>:,</C&48 0$:, $&'"&$'
*"47$%0"%&$'. J/3 $7(& 4',0"&":@4&'D"&, <&$ D#"%@3"%," 0*$)%$4&, 3+/:( 7$>'$:8"&
ABB"+&,'%$ )$*$&@48 4 *">+$ '(0":8C?,#,48 $&'"&/#,.
!"##$%&'( 5#"5=E$))/0 ",;$,";. ./%%(5 ',0 4#"?"%,5 '$>%,+/"& </?" '4";$ '
$&+*(&(= '$7*$4/= , '$7*$4/= &/):,<%$;$ &,7/. I/#(5 7*$4&$5 47$4$) +$**"+9,, —
,4+:C<"%," ,> 0/:@%"53";$ /%/:,>/ 7*$7D?"%%(=» $&'"&$' ,:, '4"5 /%+"&(. Q4:, $)N"#
'()$*+, )$:@3$5, A&$ '"4@#/ */9,$%/:@%(5 7$0=$0. G D4:$',8= '()$*$+ #/:(= ,
4*"0%,= $)N"#$' */47*$4&*/%"%%(#, 47$4$)/#, +$**"+9,, 8':8C&48: $&%"4"%,"
7*$7D?"%%$;$ $&'"&/ + ;*/0/9,, «>/&*D0%8C4@ $&'"&,&@», >/#"%/ 7*$7D?"%%$;$ $&'"&/
+/+,#-:,)$ 4*"0%,# >%/<"%,"#, */44<,&/%%(# 7$ ,#"C?,#48 0/%%(#, ,:, >%/<"%,"#,
'(<,4:"%%(# 4 7$#$?@C *";*"44,,. J/>'/%%(" 7*$9"0D*( *"/:,>$'/%( ' 7/+"&/=
«I$9,$:$;», GPD!-79, S!SS , *80" 0*D;,=. G()$* &$;$ ,:, ,%$;$ 47$4$)/ +$**"+9,,
7*$7D?"%%(= $&'"&$' ' >%/<,&":@%$5 #"*" >/',4,& $& 7$4:"0DC?";$ /%/:,>/ 0/%%(=.
J/7*,#"*, 7*, */4<"&" $0%$#"*%$;$ </4&$&%$;$ */47*"0":"%,8 7*$7D?"%%(5 $&'"&
:$;,<%$ $&%"4&, + +/&";$*,, «>/&*D0%8C4@ $&'"&,&@». 10%/+$ "4:, 7*"07$:/;/"&48
B/+&$*%(5 /%/:,>, &/+$5 7$0=$0 %"7*,"#:"#, 7$4+$:@+D A&/ +/&";$*,8 ,4+:C</"&48 ,>
$)*/)$&+,.
6*, 7:/%,*$'/%,, B/+&$*%$;$ /%/:,>/ )$:"" "4&"4&'"%%$ >/7$:%"%," 7*$7D4+$'
#$0/:@%(#, #"0,/%%(# ,:, 4*"0%"/*,B#"&,<"4+,# >%/<"%,"#, '(<,4:"%%(# 7$ '4"#D
#/44,'D ,:, ' 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+$5 ;*D77" &$;$ *"47$%0"%&/, +$&$*(5 %" $&'"&,:
%/ '$7*$4. 6*"07$:/;/"&48, <&$ #$0/, #"0,/%/ ,:, 4*"0%"/*,B#"&,<"4+$" >%/<"%,"
$&*/E/C& $)?DC &"%0"%9,C, / 0*D;," $&'"&(, $&+:$%8C?,"48 $& A&,= >%/<"%,5,
$)D4:$':"%( ':,8%,"# :,<%$4&%(= $4$)"%%$4&"5 *"47$%0"%&$', */>:,<,8#, ' 4,&D/9,,
$7*$4/ , 0*D;,#, 4:D</5%(#, B/+&$*/#,.
6*, 7:/%,*$'/%,, :$;:,%"5%$;$ /%/:,>/ +$**"+9,8 7*$7D?"%%(= $&'"&$'
$4D?"4&':8"&48 0*D;,# 47$4$)$#. J/7$#%,#, <&$ ' :$;:,%"5%$# /%/:,>" $& </4&$&( '
+/E0$5 8<"5+" &/):,9( 4$7*8E"%%$4&, )"*"&48 :$;/*,B#, ,, "4:, &/# %"& %/):C0"%,5,
&$, 4&*$;$ ;$'$*8, 0/%%(5 /%/:,> %"'$>#$E"%. 6$A&$#D ' 4&/&,4&,<"4+$5 :,&"*/&D*"
*"+$#"%0DC& 7"*"0 7*$'"0"%,"# :$;:,%"5%$;$ /%/:,>/ ' +/E0DC 8<"5+D &/):,9(
4$7*8E"%%$4&, 0$)/',&@ %"+$&$*$" %")$:@3$" <,4:$, +/+ 7*/',:$, ' ,%&"*'/:" $& 0,25 0$
1,00 [8], <&$ 7$>'$:8"& '(<,4:,&@ :$;/*,B# 7*, $&4D&4&',, $&'"&/. .$+/>/%$, <&$
7$0$)%/8 «0$)/'+/» %" 4+/>('/"&48 %/ +/<"4&'" *">D:@&/&/ [9]. (./%%/8 7*$9"0D*/
*"/:,>$'/%/ ' 7*$;*/##" :$;:,%"5%$;$ /%/:,>/ 7/+"&/ GPD!-79, ;0" ' +/E0DC 8<"5+D
&/):,9( 4$7*8E"%%$4&, 0$)/':8"&48 <,4:$ 0,5.)
.$ 4,= 7$* #( */44#/&*,'/:, 4,&D/9,,, +$;0/ 7*$7D?"% 4$0"*E/&":@%(5 $&'"&. <&$ 0":/&@, "4:, $&4D&4&'D"& +/+/8-:,)$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+/8 =/*/+&"*,4&,+/? G
A&$# 4:D</" #$E%$ 7$4&D7,&@ &/+: "4:, 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+," =/*/+&"*,4&,+, %"
4'8>/%( 4 4$0"*E/&":@%(#, $&'"&/#,, &$ /%+"&" 4 7*$7D?"%%(#, >%/<"%,8#, 4:"0D"&
7*,4'$,&@ %/,)$:"" </4&$ '4&*"</C?,"48 ' '()$*+" 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,"
=/*/+&"*,4&,+,, :,)$ $7*"0":,&@ ,= 4:D</5%(# $)*/>$# ,:, 7*$7$*9,$%/:@%$ ("4:,
&/+,= /%+"& #%$;$). Q4:, E" 4'8>@ "4&@, 4:"0D"& $7*"0":,&@, + $&'"&/# +/+$5 ;*D77(
(%/7*,#"*, #DE<,% ,:, E"%?,%) ):,E" $&'"&( ' /%+"&", ;0" ;*/B/ «7$:» %" D+/>/%/, ,
'%"4&, A&$& 7*,>%/+.
H&/+, #( $4D?"4&',:, *"#$%& '()$*+,, , &"7"*@ 4:"0D"& $9"%,&@ 4#"?"%,8,
'%$4,#(" 4/#,# *"#$%&$#. .:8 A&$5 9":, %DE%$ %/5&, A&/:$%, 7$ $&%$3"%,C + +$&$*$#D
)D0"& */44<,&('/&@48 4#"?"%,". G$>#$E%( 0'/ A&/:$%/— '%D&*"%%,5 , '%"3%,5.
6*$9"0D*/ 7$4&*$"%,8 '%D&*"%%";$ A&/:$%/ #$E"& )(&@ 4:"0DC?"5: ,> '()$*$<%$5
4$'$+D7%$4&, B$*#,*D"&48 %")$:@3/8 7$0'()$*+/, ' +$&$*$5 7*/+&,<"4+, $&4D&4&'DC&
4#"?"%,8 7$ 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,# 7*,>%/+/#, *">+$ '(0":8C?,"48 ,
7*$7D?"%%(" $&'"&(. 6$ 0/%%$5 7$0'()$*+" */44<,&('/C&48 7*$9"%&%("
*/47*"0":"%,8, 4'8>, , &.0., / >/&"# 4*/'%,'/C&48 4 0/%%(#,, 7$:D<"%%(#, 7$4:"
*"#$%&/.
P"*/ $&+:$%"%,8 $& *">D:@&/&$' A&/:$%%$5 7$0'()$*+, , )D0"& '(4&D7/&@
7$+/>/&":"# 4#"?"%,8, '%$4,#$;$ *"#$%&$#. .$7D4&,#$4&@ 4#"?"%,5 :";+$ '(8':8"&48 4
7$#$?@C 4&/&,4&,<"4+,= 7$+/>/&":"5, %/7*,#"*, %2 */47*"0":"%,8. 6*$9"0D*/
7$4&*$"%,8 '%"3%";$ A&/:$%/ %"4+$:@+$ ,%/8. G$ '*"#8 7$:"'$;$ A&/7/ 0/%%("
4$),*/C&48 7$ 0'D# '()$*$<%(# 7:/%/#. 10,% — $4%$'%$5, 7$ +$&$*$#D )D0"&
$4D?"4&':8&@48 *"#$%& '()$*+, , 0/:@%"53,5 /%/:,>, / '&$*$5 — 0:8 4$>0/%,8 A&/:$%/.
6$0*/>D#"'/"&48, <&$ A&/:$%%/8 7$0'()$*+/ %" D</4&'D"& ' $)?"#, /%/:,>", 4$),*/"&48
$4$)"%%$ &?/&":@%$, / */47*"0":"%,8 4$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+,= =/*/+&"*,4&,+ &$<%$
4$$&'"&4&'DC& */47*"0":"%,C ' ;"%"*/:@%$5 4$'$+D7%$4&,.
I %/3"5 &$<+, >*"%,8, 7*"07$<&"%," 4:"0D"& $&0/'/&@ '%"3%"#D A&/:$%D,
7$4+$:@+D 7*, 7$4&*$"%,, '%D&*"%%";$ #$;D& '$>%,+/&@ 4:$E%$4&,, $)D4:$':"%%("
$;*/%,<"%%(# $)N"#$# '()$*+, [)].
G >/+:C<"%," $&#"&,# "?" $0%$ 7*,%9,7,/:@%$" 7$:$E"%,". Q4:, 0/%%(= #%$;$,
*"#$%& '()$*+, #$E"& $4D?"4&':8&@48 >/ 4<"& 4$+*/?"%,8 '()$*$<%$5 4$'$+D7%$4&,.
L&$ %/,)$:"" */9,$%/:@%(5 7$0=$0 + *"#$%&D '()$*+,, 7$4+$:@+D 0/%%/8 4&*/&";,8 %"
$7,*/"&48 %, %/ +/+," 0$7$:%,&":@%(" 0$7D?"%,8. Q4:, $)N"# '()$*+, %">%/<,&":"%,
0:8 "" *"#$%&/ %DE%$ 7*,%,#/&@ *80 0$7$:%,&":@%(= 0$7D?"%,5, +$&$*(" %" 4:"0DC& ,>
4$)*/%%$;$ #/&"*,/:/ , ,4&,%%$4&@ +$&$*(= &*D0%$ 7*$'"*,&@. F/+,# $)*/>$#, '$>%,+/"&
0,:"##/: $7*/3,'/&@ )$:@3$" +$:,<"4&'$ *"47$%0"%&$', %" ; )"47$+$84@ $ +/<"4&'", '
%/0"E0" %/ «+/7,&/:@%(5» *"#$%& '()$*+,, ,:, $7*/3,'/&@ >%/<,&":@%$ #"%@3""
+$:,<"4&'$ *"47$%0"%&$', %$ 4 '(4$+,# +/<"4&'$#, 7*"07$:/;/8 «+$4#"&,<"4+,5» *"#$%&.
1&'"& 4:"0D"& ,4+/&@ ' */>#"*" >/&*/& (#/&"*,/:@%(=, '*"#"%%(= , 0*.), '(&"+/C?,= ,>
+/E0$;$ *"3"%,8, ' $4$)"%%$4&8= ,>D</"#$5 7*$):"#(, 9":8= , >/0/</= ,44:"0$'/%,8 ,
*80" 0*D;,= B/+&$*$'.
F',$#.,=#.
1. .E"44"% !. P"&$0( 4&/&,4&,<"4+,= $)4:"0$'/%,5. P.: V,%/%4( ,
4&/&,4&,+/, 1985.
2. 6"&*"%+$ Q.I., W*$3"%+$ F.P. I$9,/:@%$-0"#$;*/B,<"4+," 7$+/>/&":, '
4$9,$:$;,<"4+,= ,44:"0$'/%,8=. P.: I&/&,4&,+/, 1979.
3. 6*$9"44 $)*/)$&+, 0/%%(= /%+"&%(= $7*$4$' %/ LGP. P.: HI -J III!, 1985.
4. 6$;$48% U-. P"&$0 ,%&"*'@C , 0$4&$'"*%$4&@ 4$9,$:$;,<"4+$5 ,%B$*#/9,,. Q*"'/%:
H>0-'$ -J -*#8%4+$5 III!, 1985.
5. -5'/>8% I.-., Q%C+$' H.I., P"3/:+,% X... 6*,+:/0%/8 4&/&,4&,+/:
$4%$'( #$0":,*$'/%,8 , 7"*',<%/8 $)*/)$&+/ 0/%%(=. P.: V,%/%4( , 4&/&,4&,+/, 1983.
6. I/;/%"%+$ U.H. J/0"E%$4&@ *">D:@&/&$' 4$9,$:$;,<"4+$;$ ,44:"0$'/%,8. X.: J/D+/,
1983.
7. 2*(3&/%$'4+,5 -.1., 2D>%"9$' -.U. 6"*"'>'"3,'/%," '()$*+, //
2$#7:"+4%(5 7$0=$0 + /%/:,>D 0/%%(= ' 4$9,$:$;,,. P.:HI -J III!, 1988.
8. P$4&"::"* V., F@C+, .E. -%/:,> 0/%%(= , *";*"44,8. F. 1. P.: V,%/%4( , 4&/&,4&,+/,
1982.
9. -7&$% U. -%/:,> &/):,9 4$7*8E"%%$4&,. P.: B,%/%4( , 4&/&,4&,+/,
1983.