Нагибина Н.И. УПРАВЛЕНИЕ ПРОИЗВОДИТЕЛЬНОСТЬЮ

!" 331.101.6
.!. "#$%$&"
!"#$%&' ()$*+,"$-.!//0' -!1/&2!$%&' */&.!"$&-!-
'()*+,- !- ().!/+.0!1-,2 .3124 1)'0*
5*5 .3 .+* 677-51!+ .8. '()*+,- !9 (-)3. *,.:
3,$$#,-"&.,4-$5 6")78!#0 ")$-, 6")&9.)+&-!8:/)$-& -"*+, . 3)$$&&. 3,$%"0.,4-$5
6"&2&/0 )-$-,.,/&5 ")$$&'$%)' ;%)/)#&%& 6) +,//)#* 6)%,9,-!84 %,% /, *")./! ()$*+,"$-.,,
-,% & )-+!8:/)() 6"!+6"&5-&5. "!+8)<!/ 6)+1)+ % =)"#&").,/&4 $)."!#!//)' #)+!8& *6",.8!/&5 ;==!%-&./)$-:4 6!"$)/,8, /, )$/).! 6")&9.)+&-!8:/)$-& -"*+,.
!!"#$%&'()$* $+,-., /+(%0&(-%$"1*'()$* $+,-., /(#.0.$"1% 2!!"#$%&'()$%
,/+.&1"'%3 /"+)('.1(4.
#$%&'()* +,-.%/ 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 1 8%55,, , (( 1',9+,( +7
$%53 ::#, ;7$7.3($+*( 2'9 5%1$()(++%<% 5%53%9+,9 $%55,/5.%/ =.%+%),.,,
%51(>7',54 +7 5-) =.%+%),?(5.%) @%$6)( «A($$,3%$,9 .%+.6$(+3+%<% $7-1,3,9», 0$%;%2,1B() 1 <. #($), 11–12 5(+39&$9 2009 <. : 1*5360'(+,9; %3)(?7'%54, ?3% 5 1998 <%27 (C(<%2+*/ $%53 ::# +7 7 % %&(50(?,' 0($(;%2
+7B(/ 53$7+* 0% 6$%1+D &'7<%5%53%9+,9 5 72-<% +7 53-( )(53% 1 ),$(, , 2'9
3%<% ?3%&* 27++79 3(+2(+E,9 5%;$7+9'754, $%53 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627
2%'C(+ %0($(C734 $%53 17'%1%<% 1+63$(++(<% 0$%26.37, ?(<% 1 ,53%$,, $%55,/5.%/ =.%+%),., +,.%<27 +( &*'%.
F7$6&(C+*( , %3(?(531(++*( 6?(+*( , 0$7.3,., 1*2('9D3 2%5373%?+%
)+%<% 0$,?,+, )(B7D>,; 0%1*B(+,D 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 1 8%55,,.
A7., :.G. H76, $(.3%$ G.72(),, +7$%2+%<% ;%-9/5317 0$, #$71,3('4531(
8%55,/5.%/ I(2($7E,,, 1*536079 +7 5-) =.%+%),?(5.%) @%$6)(, 0$%;%2,1B() 1 <. #($), [3], %3)(?7' ,)(D>,/59 .%+@',.3 )(C26 )(+(2C($7),
, 5%&531(++,.7), 1 <%+.( -7 .70,37',-7E,(/ , %3.7-( %3 0%1*B(+,9 0$, =3%)
0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627. !$6<6D 0$,?,+6 1 51%() 2%.'72( «87-1,3,( 8%55,, 1 &',C7/B(/ 0($50(.3,1(», 0$%-16?71B() 37) C( [8], +7-17' J.K. L5,+:
«…=3% 37. +7-*17()*( ,+53,363*, .6'436$7, ,-)(+(+,( 0$71,' C,-+,, 0$71,' ,<$*, .%3%$*( +( 3%'4.% @,.5,$6D359 1 -7.%+(, =3% 1+(2$(+,( 1 ?('%1(?(5.%( 5%-+7+,(, )(+37',3(3, 5,53()6 E(++%53(/ %0$(2('(++*; 6537+%1%.,
%0$(2('(++*; 0$(25371'(+,/, .%3%$*( )(+9D3 0%1(2(+,( 'D2(/...». :%-)%C+%, $(?4 ,2(3 %& %5%&(++%539; .6'436$* +7E,, – %3563531,, .6'436$*
&($(C',1%53, , =@@(.3,1+%53,, ,+,E,73,1* , $7E,%+7'4+*; 0$(2'%C(+,/,
2%'<%3($0(+,,, .%3%$*) 37. 5'719359 $655.,( [6, 22]. :)(53( 5 3() =3, 0$,46
?,+* +%593 <'%&7'4+*/ ;7$7.3($. A7., ,-1(53+*/ 7)($,.7+5.,/ 6?(+*/ M%$(+5 N7$,5%+, 2,$(.3%$ O+53,3637 .6'436$+*; ,-)(+(+,/ 0$, O+53,363(
A7@37, $7-$7&%37' 0$%<$7))6 ,-)(+(+,9 .6'436$+*; %5+%1, 5%5371'9D>,;
@6+27)(+3 =@@(.3,1+%/ =.%+%),.,. P37 0$%<$7))7 0$(20%'7<7(3 .%)0'(.5
,-)(+(+,/ – 1 B.%'(, 1 5()4(, 1 5$(25317; )755%1*; .%))6+,.7E,/, $7-1'(?(+,/ , 0$.
G ?3% +7 6$%1+( 0$(20$,93,/? "3% ,', ?3% )(B7(3 5%&531(++,.7) &,-+(57 1 0$,+93,, $(B(+,/, =@@(.3,1+%534 .%3%$*; &7-,$6(359 +7 $%53( 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627?
: %&'753, ?('%1(?(5.,; $(56$5%1 <'71+*), 65'%1,9), $%537 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 91'9D359 %03,)7'4+%534 ?,5'(++%53, 0($5%+7'7 %$<7+,-7E,, 5 3%?., -$(+,9 0$%,-1(2(++*; 3$62%-73$73 , $75;%2%1 +7 5%2($C7+,(
$7&%?(/ 5,'*. 875;%2* +7 0($5%+7' 1 %&>,; $75;%27; .%)07+,, -7+,)7D3
0%$%/ 2% 30 % 1 -71,5,)%53, %3 5@($* 2(93('4+%53,, +% =3, 0%.7-73(', +,C(,
?() 1 $7-1,3*; 53$7+7;. A7. 5%<'75+% ,55'(2%17+,D =@@(.3,1+%53, 5,53()*
60$71'(+,9 0($5%+7'%), 0$%1(2(++%)6 1 2007 <%26 PricewaterhouseCoopers
(PwC) [2], +7 .7C2*/ $1, ,+1(53,$%17++*/ -7072+*), .%)07+,9), 1 $%55,/5.,/ 0($5%+7' 1 1,2( 1%-+7<$7C2(+,9, .%)07+,, 0%'6?,', $2,3 0$,&*',.
P3%3 0%.7-73('4 0$(1*B7(3 1 217 $7-7 7+7'%<,?+*/ 0%.7-73('4 1 F7072+%/
J1$%0(, <2( 5%%3+%B(+,( – 1,16. Q373,53,?(5.,( 27++*( 0% $%55,/5.,) .%)07+,9) %35635316D3 – %$<7+,-7E,, +( ;%393 2(',3459 37.%/ ,+@%$)7E,(/
5 .%+.6$(+37),, 7 ?7>( 0$%53% +( ,50%'4-6D3 0%.7-73('4 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 2'9 %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53, 5,53()* 60$71'(+,9 0($5%+7'%).
: 5%1(35.%( 1$()9 60$71'(+,( 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534D 3$627 91'9'%54
%2+%/ ,- %5+%1+*; -727? $6.%1%2,3('9 +7 0$%)*B'(++*; , 0$%,-1%2531(++*; 0$(20$,93,9;. F+734 37.,( 5373,53,?(5.,( 0%.7-73(',, .7. 0%3($,
$7&%?(<% 1$()(+, %3 0$%53%9 %&%$62%17+,9 ,', 0% 0$,?,+( +7$6B(+,9 3$62%1%/ 2,5E,0',+* 5%3$62+,.7),, .%+3$%',$%1734 ,; %3.'%+(+,( %3 +%$)73,1+*;, 0'7+,$%1734 +7 5'(26D>,/ 0($,%2 – &*'7 %2+7 ,- <'71+*; -727?
$6.%1%2,3('9 .72$%1%/ 5'6C&*. G )+%<% ', )(+(2C($%1 0% 0($5%+7'6 1 5%1$()(++*; %$<7+,-7E,9; 5?,37(3 17C+*) -7+,)73459 0%25?(3%) , 7+7',-%)
37.%<% 0%.7-73('9 3$62%1%/ 2(93('4+%53,, .7. .%=@@,E,(+3 7&5(+3(,-)7?
R32('* , '7&%$73%$,, +76?+%/ %$<7+,-7E,, 3$627 %&(50(?,17', %&S(.3,1+%( +%$),$%17+,( $7&%3, ?3%, 1 51%D %?($(24, 0%-1%'9'% 60$71'934 ?,5'(++%534D 0($5%+7'7 0$(20$,93,9, ,; $7&%?,) 1$()(+(), 7 =3% %-+7?7(3 , =@@(.3,1+%( 60$71'(+,( @,+7+5%1*), $(56$57),. R3$75'(1*( ,+53,363*,
$7-$7&73*171B,( 15(1%-)%C+*( +%$)73,1* ?,5'(++%53, 0($5%+7'7, 1$()(+, %&5'6C,17+,9 %&%$62%17+,9 , 0$%?,( 0$(.$73,', 51%D 2(93('4+%534, 27
, 0$(20$,93,9 0$, 0($(%5+7>(+,, ,50%'4-6D3 +%1%( ,)0%$3+%( %&%$62%17+,(, 2'9 .%3%$%<% 56>(5316D>79 +%$)73,1+79 &7-7 +( <%2,359.
47
A7.,) %&$7-%), 0$,)(+91B7959 0$, 0'7+%1%/ =.%+%),.( )%2('4
60$71'(+,9 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534D 3$627 [4, 49] +7 5%1$()(++%) =370( 6C( +(
,50%'4-6(359, 7 7.367'4+79 2'9 $*+%?+%/ =.%+%),., )%2('4 (>( +( 1*$7&%37+7, ?3% , %&65'71',17(3 %353717+,( 1 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 %3 $7-1,3*; 53$7+.
31($C2(+,( % 3%), ?3% =@@(.3,1+%534 5,53()* 60$71'(+,9 0($5%+7'%) %&(50(?,17(3 =@@(.3,1+%534 .%)07+,,, 0%231($C2(+% , 3(%$(3,?(5.,) ,
0$7.3,?(5.,) %0*3%). T3% %-+7?7(3 =@@(.3,1+%( 60$71'(+,( ?('%1(?(5.,),
$(56$57),? #$(C2( 15(<% =3% .%+.6$(+3+%( 0$(,)6>(531% .%)07+,,, .%3%$%( 3$62+(( 15(<% 5.%0,$%1734. P3% 2%53,C(+,( %$<7+,-7E,%++%/ E(', 0$,
%03,)7'4+*; -73$737;. T,5'(++%534 0($5%+7'7 %$<7+,-7E,,, $75;%2* +7 (<%
5%2($C7+,( , $7&%?(( 1$()9 – 1%3 5%5371'9D>,( .'D?(1%<% 0%.7-73('9 =@@(.3,1+%53, ?('%1(?(5.,; $(56$5%1 , .70,37'7 – 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627.
:+(2$(+,( +7 6$%1+( %$<7+,-7E,, =@@(.3,1+%<% 60$71'(+,9 ?('%1(?(5.,),
$(56$57), , 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534D 3$627 0%-1%'9(3 .%)07+,, ,23, 0% 063,
$7-1,3,9 , 1 65'%1,9; =.%+%),?(5.%<% .$,-,57 , %&(50(?,34 5(&( 0$(,)6>(531% 0($(2 .%+.6$(+37),, +( ,50%'4-6D>,), 37.,( 3(;+%'%<,, ',&% +( %.7-*17D>,), ,; 1+(2$(+,D 2%'C+%<% 1+,)7+,9.
Q%-27+,( .%+.6$(+3+%<% 0$(,)6>(5317 .%)07+,, -7 5?(3 5%.$7>(+,9 ,-2($C(. , 0%1*B(+,9 %327?, %3 5%3$62+,.%1 – .'D?(179 .%)0(3(+E,9 )(+(2C($%1, %31(3531(++*; -7 =@@(.3,1+%( 60$71'(+,( 0($5%+7'%).
Q%%31(3531(++%, 2'9 %E(+., )(+(2C($%1, %31(3531(++*; -7 =@@(.3,1+%534
60$71'(+,9 0($5%+7'%), 1 +753%9>(( 1$()9 17C+7 +( 53%'4.% =@@(.3,1+%534 $(.$63,+<7 , $7-1,3,9 0($5%+7'7, 5.%'4.% 1'72(+,( 3(;+%'%<,9),
60$71'(+,9 ,-)(+(+,9),, 0%+,)7+,( -+7?,)%53, , 6)(+,( 60$71'934 =@@(.3,1+%534D 3$627.
: 519-, 5 1*B(%&%-+7?(++*), 0$%&'()7), 1%-+,.7(3 +(%&;%2,)%534
695+(+,9 ,', &%'(( 3%?+%/ ,+3($0$(37E,, 57)%<% 0%+93,9 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627. F2(54 )%C+% 1*2(',34 217 %5+%1+*; +70$71'(+,9 1 $75.$*3,,
56>+%53, 27++%/ .73(<%$,,: 7) .7. 0%.7-73('9 1 5,53()( 5373,53,?(5.%<%
7+7',-7, , &) .7. ;7$7.3($,53,., =@@(.3,1+%53, ,50%'4-%17+,9 3$62%1*;
$(56$5%1.
U7 6$%1+( =.%+%),., 53$7+* 0$, $75?(3( 0%.7-73('9 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 0$,)(+9D359 27++*( % 17'%1%) 1+63$(++() 0$%26.3( (::#) ,
17'%1%) +7E,%+7'4+%) 0$%26.3( (:U#), .%3%$*( $7-$7&%37+* +7 %5+%1(
(2,+%/ 5,53()* +7E,%+7'4+*; 5?(3%1 (QUQ) 5373,53,?(5.%/ .%),55,(/
RRU (37&'. 1).
48
A7&',E7 1
!"#$%"$&$'()*+"(* ,$"!-!.*/( ,#$(-0$1(.*/2&$+.( .#31!
#%.7-73('4
:7'%1*/ 1+63$(++,/ 0$%26.3
+7 26B6 +75('(+,9
N7$7.3($,53,.7
L1'9(359 )($,'%) +7E,%+7'4+%<% &%<735317 15(/
53$7+*, 7 +( 3%'4.% %2+%/ 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53,
3$627 .7. 37.%1%/, 0%3%)6 ?3% ::# %3+%5,359 +7
%&>6D ?,5'(++%534 +75('(+,9, 7 +( +7 .%',?(531%
$7&%3+,.%1
R&S() 17'%1%<% #%.7-73('4 &%'(( 3%?(+ 1 ,-)($(+,, 0$%,-1%2,1+63$(++(<%
3('4+%53, 3$627, +% +( 6?,3*17(3 56>(5316D>,;
0$%26.37 +7 %2- 1 $7-+*; 53$7+7; $7-',?,/ 1 0$%2%'C,3('4+%53,
+%<% $7&%37D>(- $7&%?(<% 2+9
<%
R&S() 1+63$(+- !7++*/ 0%.7-73('4 5?,37(359 +7,'6?B,) ,-)($,+(<% 17'%1%<%
3('() 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627, %2+7.% (<%
0$%26.37 +7 1
3$62+% ,50%'4-%1734 0$, )(C26+7$%2+*; 5%0%5%3$7&%37++*/ ?75 371'(+,9; 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627
H(3%2,.7
$75?(37
R3+%B(+,( %&S()7
::# . ?,5'6 C,3('(/ 53$7+*
R3+%B(+,( %&S()7
::# . ?,5'6 -7+93*;
R3+%B(+,( %&S()7
::# . 1 %3$7&%37++%)6 ,', %0'7?(++%)6 ?756
!7++*( 0%.7-73(', 5'6C73 2'9 %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53, 3$62%-73$73,
0$%,-1(2(++*; 1 +7$%2+%) ;%-9/531( ,', %32('4+*; (<% %3$75'9; 0$, 56>(5316D>() 6$%1+( $7-1,3,9 =.%+%),., 1 %0$(2('(++*/ 0($,%2 1$()(+,. A7.,) %&$7-%), .7. %&S(.3 5373,53,?(5.%<% 7+7',-7, 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534 3$627
1*53607(3 %&%&>7D>(/ ;7$7.3($,53,.%/ .7?(531(++*; 521,<%1 1 %&>(531(++%) 0$%,-1%2531(.
R@,E,7'4+*( 27++*( I(2($7'4+%/ 5'6C&* <%5627$531(++%/ 5373,53,., «R 0$%,-1%2531( , ,50%'4-%17+,, 17'%1%<% 1+63$(++(<% 0$%26.37 (::#)
-7 2009 <%2» 0%.7-*17D3, ?3% %&S() ::# 8%55,, -7 2009 <., 0% 0$(217$,3('4+%/ %E(+.(, 5%5371,' 1 3(.6>,; E(+7; 39016,1 )'$2 $6&'(/. J<% $(7'4+*/
%&S() %3+%5,3('4+% 2008 <. 5%5371,' 92,1 %. O+2(.5-2(@'93%$ ::# -7 2009 <.
0% %3+%B(+,D . E(+7) 2008 <. 5%5371,' 102,7 % [9] (37&'. 2).
R2+7.% 27++*( %@,E,7'4+%/ 5373,53,., +( 27D3 27 , +( )%<63 0$(2%5371'934 ,+@%$)7E,D % 0$,?,+7; %3563531,9 0%'%C,3('4+%/ 2,+7),., 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627 1 0%5'(2+,( <%2*, ?3% 56>(531(++% %5'%C+9(3 ,55'(2%17+,9 , 0$(0935316(3 1*$7&%3.( 0$7.3,?(5., -+7?,)*; $(B(+,/ 1 %&'753,
0%1*B(+,9 =@@(.3,1+%53, 0$%,-1%25317. #% +7B()6 )+(+,D, 17C+(/B(/
-727?(/ 1 27++%) .%+3(.53( 91'9(359 @%$),$%17+,( 5%1$()(++%/ )%2(',
60$71'(+,9 =@@(.3,1+%534D 0($5%+7'7 +7 %5+%1( 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627,
<2( .'D?(1%( )(53% 2%'C+7 -7+934 5,53()7 0%.7-73('(/ %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53, 3$627.
49
A7&',E7 2
4&1*"+ #*!/2&$5$ $67*'! 889 ( 0!/$0$: 1$6!0/*&&$: +.$('$+.(
,$ 0(1!' %"$&$'()*+"$: 1*;.*/2&$+.( 0 ,$+.$;&&<= >*&!=, 0 %,
" ,#*1<13?*'3 5$13
92,1
Q0$71%?+%
2008<.
105,6
98,3
98,4
98,1
86,1
94,0
83,6
107,4
94,4
100,1
100,2
100,9
111,9
91,7
84,6
97,7
94,3
109,5
110,7
106,3
104,0
94,7
113,6
103,2
98,7
100,6
103,0
100,0
100,0
81,7
95,4
87,1
97,8
106,7
106,8
2009<.
8!/$0$: 0&3.#*&&(: ,#$13". 0 #<&$)&<= >*&!=
: 3%) ?,5'(:
5('45.%( ;%-9/531%, %;%37 , '(5+%( ;%-9/531%
$*&%'%1531%, $*&%1%2531%
2%&*?7 0%'(-+*; ,5.%07()*;
%&$7&73*17D>,( 0$%,-1%25317
0$%,-1%2531% , $750$(2('(+,( ='(.3$%=+($<,,, <7-7 , 1%2*
53$%,3('4531%
%03%179 , $%-+,?+79 3%$<%1'9; $()%+3 713%3$7+50%$3+*;
5$(2531, )%3%E,.'%1, &*3%1*; ,-2(',/ , 0$(2)(3%1 ',?+%<%
0%'4-%17+,9
<%53,+,E* , $(53%$7+*
3$7+50%$3 , 519-4
@,+7+5%179 2(93('4+%534
%0($7E,, 5 +(21,C,)*) ,)6>(531%), 7$(+27 , 0$(2%5371'(+,(
65'6<
<%5627$531(++%( 60$71'(+,( , %&(50(?(+,( 1%(++%/ &(-%075+%53,; %&9-73('4+%( 5%E,7'4+%( %&(50(?(+,(
%&$7-%17+,(
-2$71%%;$7+(+,( , 0$(2%5371'(+,( 5%E,7'4+*; 65'6<
0$(2%5371'(+,( 0$%?,; .%))6+7'4+*;, 5%E,7'4+*; , 0($5%+7'4+*; 65'6<
@$+0*&&$ (-'*#;*'<* 3+/35( A(&!&+$0$5$ ,$+#*1&()*+.0! (-)
B(+.<* &!/$5( &! ,#$13".<
!'9 %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53, 3$627 +7 0$(20$,93,, +7,&%'(( ?753% 0$,)(+9D3 0%.7-73('4 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, 3$627, $755?,3*17()*/ .7. %3+%B(+,( %&S()7 0$%,-1(2(++%<% 0$%26.37 (3%17$%1 ,', 65'6<) . -73$737) 3$627.
: 27++%) 5'6?7( 0%.7-73('9), 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53, )%<63 1*5360734 %&S()
0$%26.E,, +7 %2,+ %3$7&%37++*/ ,', %0'7?(++*/ ?75, %&S() 0$%26.E,, +7
%2+%<% 5%3$62+,.7 , 3.2. !'9 %&S(.3,1+%53, , .%$$(.3+%53, $75?(3%1 0$,
0$%1(2(+,, 7+7',-7 1 .7C2%) 5'6?7( +(%&;%2,)% %0$(2('934 [1, 238]:
1) 1 .7.%), +736$7'4+%) ,', 53%,)%53+%) ,-)($(+,, $755?,3*17()
0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534 3$627;
2) 1 7&5%'D3+%) ,', %3+%5,3('4+%) 1*$7C(+,,;
3) ?3% 0%+,)734 0%2 %&S()%) 0$%26.E,,: 0$,&*'4, 2%;%2, 2%&71'(++79
53%,)%534, 3%17$%%&%$%3, %&S() 0$%,-1%25317 ,', %.7-7++%/ 5'6<,;
50
4) ?3% 0%+,)734 0%2 -73$737), 3$627: 7) ?,5'(++%534 0($5%+7'7 (1 ?('%1(., 5$(2+(50,5%?+79 ?,5'(++%534), &) $75;%2* +7 5%2($C7+,( 0($5%+7'7
(15( $75;%2*, @%+2 %0'73* 3$627), 1) @%+2 $7&%?(<% 1$()(+, (?75, 2(+4, )(59E, .17$37').
:%-)%C+*), 0%.7-73('9),, 0$,)(+9()*), 2'9 %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53,
3$627 +7 6$%1+( %$<7+,-7E,,, )%<63 &*34 [5, 160; 7, 304]:
! 3%17$%%&%$%3, 0$,&*'4, 2%;%2, 2%&71'(++79 53%,)%534, %&S() 0$%,-1(2(++%/ 0$%26.E,, ,', %.7-7++%/ 65'6<, +7 1 $7&%3+,.7, ,-)($9()*/ 1 +736$7'4+%) , 53%,)%53+%) 1*$7C(+,,;
! ?,5'(++%534 0($5%+7'7 5 0%-,E,, %03,)7'4+%53, %&S()%1 3$62%-73$73, %0$(2('9()%/ +7 %5+%1( +%$),$%17+,9 1$()(+, , $(-6'4373%1 2'9 15(;
1,2%1 $7&%3 1 %$<7+,-7E,,;
! @%+2 %0'73* 3$627, 15( $75;%2* +7 5%2($C7+,( 0($5%+7'7 1 0$%E(+37; %3 %&>,; -73$73 .%)07+,,;
! %&S() 0$%,-1(2(++%/ 0$%26.E,, ,', %.7-7++%/ 65'6<,, 0$,&*'4,
2%;%2, 2%&71'(++79 53%,)%534, 3%17$%%&%$%3 +7 1 $6&'4, -73$7?(++*/ +7 0($5%+7' ,', +7 1 $6&'4 -7$7&%3+%/ 0'73*;
! %&S() 0$%,-1(2(++%/ 0$%26.E,, ,', %.7-7++%/ 65'6<, 1 +736$7'4+%) ,', 53%,)%53+%) 1*$7C(+,, -7 1 ?75 3$627;
! ?,5'% ?75%1, -73$7?(++*; +7 0$%,-1%2531% (2,+,E* 0$%26.E,, ,',
%.7-7++%/ 65'6<,;
! 0%3($9++79 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534 – 2%&71'(++79 53%,)%534 -7 1 ?75
0$%,-1%2,3('4+%<% 3$627, 6)+%C(++79 +7 ?,5'% 0%3($9++*; ?75%1 (-70'7+,$%17++*; , +(-70'7+,$%17++*;).
: -7072+*; 53$7+7;, 1 ?753+%53, 1 L0%+,,, 0$,)(+9(359 0%.7-73('4
(&%'(( 3%<%, =3%3 0%.7-73('4 0'7+,$6(359 , -7.$(0'9(359 -7 5%3$62+,.%) .7.
%2,+ ,- .'D?(1*;), %3$7C7D>,/ .%',?(531% ,++%17E,%++*; $(B(+,/, 0$(2'%C(++*; 5%3$62+,.%) +7 $7&%?() )(53( , 0%-1%'9D>,; 65%1($B(+531%1734
$7&%?,/ 0$%E(55.
:*&%$ .%+.$(3+*; 0%.7-73('(/ %E(+., =@@(.3,1+%53, 3$627 E('(5%%&$7-+% 0$%1%2,34 1 -71,5,)%53, %3 50(E,@,?(5.,; 65'%1,/ 2(93('4+%53,
%$<7+,-7E,,, 7 37. C( -727? 7+7',-7 %$<7+,-7E,%++*; 0$%&'(). #($50(.3,1*
1+(2$(+,9 5,53()* )%+,3%$,+<7 1 27++%/ %&'753, 0$(25371'9D359 1(54)7
-+7?,)*), .7. 1 .%+3(.53( 53$73(<,?(5.%<% 60$71'(+,9, 37. , 0$, $(B(+,,
3(.6>,; -727? 0$(20$,93,9. #$, =3%) +(%&;%2,)% @%$),$%17+,( .%)0'(.57
,-)($,3('(/ =@@(.3,1+%53, 3$627, 0$,)(+9()*; +7 )7.$%6$%1+( =.%+%),.,
53$7+*, )(-%6$%1+( – =.%+%),., $(<,%+7, ),.$%6$%1+( – 0$(20$,93,9 .7.
%5+%1+%/ ;%-9/531(++%/ (2,+,E* %&>(531(++%<% 0$%,-1%25317.
51
C,(+$" /(.*#!.3#<
1. "%.,+ V.#., W'(+2($ #.P. P.%+%),.7 3$627: 6?(&+,.. – H.: H7<,53$, 2008.
2. H7'*;,+ H. 8753,34 =@@(.3,1+%534. :(2%)%53, 07.10.2008. – URL:
http://www.vedomosti.ru/newspaper/article/2008/10/07/163772
3. H76 :.G. K%5627$531% , =.%+%),?(5.%( $7-1,3,(: 5.1%-4 .$,-,5* ,
$(@%$)* // 5-/ =.%+%),?(5.,/ @%$6) «A($$,3%$,9 .%+.6$(+3+%<% $7-1,3,9». – URL: http://ecforum.perm.ru/forum091-a.html#VI
4. Q,+. !.Q. 0$71'(+,( 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%534D: 0'7+,$%17+,(, ,-)($(+,(
, %E(+.7, .%+3$%'4 , 0%1*B(+,( [0($. 5 7+<'.]. – H.: #$%<$(55, 1989. – Q. 29.
5. '4$,; !=/1, X$%.&=+. =/+. HR 1 &%$4&( -7 .%+.6$(+3+%( 0$(,)6>(531% [0($. 5 7+<'.] / !=/1 ., =/+ X. – H.: #$(3(.53, 2010.
6. I,'%+%1,? Q. R 3($0(+,, , … 0$%,-1%2,3('4+%53,. – Harvard Business Review – 8%55,9. Q(+39&$4 2009. – URL: http://www.hbr-russia.ru/issue/
51/958/
7. I,3E-(+E L.. 8(+37&('4+%534 ,+1(53,E,/ 1 0($5%+7': ,-)($(+,(
=.%+%),?(5.%/ E(++%53, 0($5%+7'7 [0($. 5 7+<'.]. – H.: :($B,+7, 2006.
8. L5,+ J.K. 87-1,3,( 8%55,, 1 &',C7/B(/ 0($50(.3,1( // 5-/ =.%+%),?(5.,/ @%$6) «A($$,3%$,9 .%+.6$(+3+%<% $7-1,3,9». – URL:
http://ecforum.perm.ru/forum091-a.html#VI
9. http://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b09_01/IssWWW.exe/Stg/d12/1–0.htm
#%'6?(+% 10.02.2010
52