МЕХАНИЗМЫ РОТАЦИИ ПОЛИТИЧЕСКИХ ЭЛИТ В УСЛОВИЯХ

"#$%&"'()&%*+,+-'*)'(.)*'/).+0-%#$0")1)234567)8)+9957):):;8<
=>?@A)B>A>CDEFA)
!"#$%& '()*+#,%%(
-*.%+%/!01%"(2.%+(3(40.*3%5"(
6! *1)#+%/!01*7*(*89!0+3#(
!"#$%&'()"#'*#+",-&"+#&-#&!"#.%-/)"0#-1#.-)'&'($)#&!"-%2#$3+#.%$(&'("#4#&!"#
*&5+2#-1#0"(!$3'*0*#-1#%-&$&'-3#-1#.-)'&'($)#")'&"*#'3#$#+"0-(%$&'(#*-('"&26# !"#
*."('1'('&2#-1#&!"#1-%0$&'-3#-1#.-)'&'($)#")'&"*#$&#+'11"%"3&#*&$7"*#-1#!'*&-%'($)#
+",")-.0"3&6# 8&# '*# 3-&"+# &!$&# $&# .%"*"3&# &!"# 0"(!$3'*0*# -1# %-&$&'-3# -1#
.-)'&'($)#")'&"*#*&'.5)$&"+#&!"#1-%0$&'-3#-1#.-*&0-+"%3#9'31-%0$&'-3:#*-('"&2#
0"+'$&';$&'-3# -1# .-)'&'(*<# &!"# &%$3*'&'-3# 1%-0# $5&!-%'&$%'$3# &-# +"0-(%$&'(#
.-)'&'($)# %"7'0"6# =3$)2;"+# &!"# (!$%$(&"%'*&'(*# -1# '3&"%$(&'-3# ")'&"*# '3# $#
+"0-(%$&'(#&%$3*'&6
!"#$%&'()"!&*!"+',*-(.))%/0*+,12(&%2',*3&"+(!"0'4**(5"6
$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+18095'%0(":,";(*3('/09'$<,12(:$-(5"$*0*7%8/";(
0%"!**(*(5!'/0*/*(:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(5"$*0*7%8/*2(5!%"#!'3"+',*;=(
>"$<(.$*0(+(8"+!%&%,,12(:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(80!','2(0!9:,"(5%!%"4%6
,*0<?(",*(+15"$,-@0(+'A,1%()9,/4**(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(95!'+$%,*-C(
'B!%B'4**( *( 5!%:80'+*0%$<80+'( B!955"+12( *,0%!%8"+C( *:%"$"B*3'6
4**(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(5!"80!',80+'C("5!%:%$%,*-("#D%80+%,,"B"(*,6
0%!%8'(E*,0%B!'0*+,9@FC(/"&&9,*/'0*+,9@(*(:!=(
G(*88$%:"+',*-2(+3'*&":%;80+*-(.$*0(+"3,*/'%0(,%"#2":*&"80<(
97*01+'0<( )"!&*!"+',*%( /"&&9,*/'0*+,12( &%2',*3&"+( +3'*&"6
:%;80+*-(+$'80*(*("#D%80+'C(.$*0,12(B!955C(5!%:80'+*0%$%;(&'886
&%:*'(5":(+$*-,*%&(5!"4%88"+(&%:*'0*3'4**(5"$*0*/*C(5$@!'$*6
3'4**( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"( 5!"80!',80+'C( :%&"/!'0*3'4**( 8"4*'$<,12(
"0,"H%,*;C('(0'/A%("#I%/0*+,"("4%,*0<(0'/"%(,%B'0*+,"%(-+$%,*%C(
/'/( #%3"0+%080+%,,"80<( .$*0C( /"0"!'-( 5!%5-080+9%0( !%'$*3'4**(
5!*,4*5"+(:%&"/!'0*7%8/";(5"$*0*7%8/";(:%-0%$<,"80*=
J88$%:"+',*%( )%,"&%,'( 5"$*0*7%8/";( .$*01( 5!*"#!%0'%0( "8"6
#9@('/09'$<,"80<(+(5%!%2":,1%(5%!*":1C(/"0"!1%(8"5!"+"A:'@08-(
/!*3*8"&( :"+%!*-( &%A:9( "#D%80+"&( *( +$'80<@C( ,%"#2":*&"80<@(
5"*8/'(&%2',*3&"+(5"+1H%,*-(.))%/0*+,"80*(:%-0%$<,"80*(.$*0C(
:%&"/!'0*3'4*%;( 5!"4%88'( 5!*,-0*-( *( !%'$*3'4**( 5"$*0*7%8/*2(
!%H%,*;=
"$*0*7%8/'-( .$*0'( +( ,'97,"&( :*8/9!8%( *,0%!5!%0*!9%08-( +(
.0*7%8/*( ,%;0!'$<,"&( 3,'7%,**C( 70"( "#98$"+$%,"( *80"!*7%8/*( *(
&%0":"$"B*7%8/*=(G"65%!+12C(5"$*0*7%8/'-(.$*0'(2'!'/0%!*39%08-(
3,'7*0%$<,1&(+$*-,*%&(,'(+$'80<(*(95!'+$%,*%C(/",/9!%,4*%@(3'(
:"8095(/(+$'80,1&(!%89!8'&C(:*,'&*3&"&C(*%!'!2*%;=(G"6+0"!12C(
!
"2$%&0GH)&%*+,+-GH)')&$I2(J).+0G#$K
5"(8+"%;(890*C(5"$*0*7%8/'-(.$*0'(K(.0"(,%(0"$</"(0%C(/0"(3',*&'%0(
8""0+%080+9@D*%(:"$A,"80*(E.$*0'(5"()"!&'$<,1&(5!*3,'/'&FC(,"(
*(0%C(/0"(,'(!'3,12(.0'5'2(*B!'%0(+'A,9@(!"$<(+(5!*,-0**(5"$*0*6
7%8/*2(!%H%,*;C(!%'$*3'4**(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(/9!8'C(0"(%80<(K(89#I%/6
01(5"$*0*7%8/";(:%-0%$<,"80*=
L"+!%&%,,'-( 5"$*0*7%8/'-( 0%"!*-( 2'!'/0%!*39%08-( 5"80"6
-,,1&( +,*&',*%&( /( 5!"#$%&%( !"0'4**( 5"$*0*7%8/*2( .$*0C( %%(
/",80*094*",,"65!'+"+12C(*,80*094*",'$<,12C(/"&&9,*/'0*+,12(
*( 5!"4%889'$<,12( "8,"+',*;=( L!%:*( 3'!9#%A,12( '+0"!"+C( *88$%6
:9@D*2( 0%"!%0*7%8/*%( *( 5!'/0*7%8/*%( *3&%!%,*-( :%-0%$<,"80*(
5"$*0*7%8/*2( .$*0( *( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"( /$'88'( +( 98$"+*-2( :%&"/!'6
0**(8$%:9%0("0&%0*0<(M=(N"00"&"!'C(>=(O'!%,:"!)'C(P=(Q%;52'!:'C(
R=(S9&5%0%!'C(>=(O'$-C(T=(U'#%!&'8'C(O=(>'80"9(*(:!=(
V%8&"0!-(,'("8"#%,,"80*(5"$*0*7%8/";(8*80%&1(/'A:";(:%&"6
/!'0*7%8/";( 80!',1( *( !'3$*7*-( +( &%2',*3&'2( !"0'4**( 5"$*0*7%6
8/*2(.$*0C(/"0"!1%(8)"!&*!"+'$*8<(*80"!*7%8/*C(5!"4%88(!"0'4**(
5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(K(.0"(+'A,1;(5!*3,'/(:%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"(5"$*6
0*7%8/"B"(!%A*&'C(%B"("0$*7*0%$<,'-(7%!0'C(5"(8!'+,%,*@(8(0"0'$*6
0'!*3&"&(*('+0"!*0'!*3&"&=
J88$%:"+',*@(!"$*(*()9,/4*;(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+(9/!'*,8/"&(
"#D%80+%(5"8+-D%,1(!'#"01(G=(N%#*/'C(W=(N180!*4/"B"C(X=(Y"$"+'6
0"B"C(G=(Y"!#'0%,/"C(N=(Z9201C(L=(X'/%%+'C(X=(X*2'$<7%,/"C(L=(V'6
9&/*,";C(X=([#9H,"B"C(P=( '2'!%+'C(T=(S';B"!":8/"B"C(T=(S+%6
:1C(O=(\/"+$%+'(*(:!=(
G( 0"( A%( +!%&-C( 5!"#$%&'( /",80!9*!"+',*-( "50*&'$<,"B"( *( .)6
)%/0*+,"B"( &%2',*3&'( !"0'4**( 5"$*0*7%8/*2( .$*0( +( ]/!'*,%( 8(
97%0"&(85%4*)*/*(&%2',*3&"+(*(5!*,4*5"+(!"0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(
.$*0( +( !'3$*7,12( &":%$-2( :%&"/!'0**( *( "510'( :%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(
5!%"#!'3"+',*;(5"8$%:,*2($%0(0!%#9%0(:'$<,%;H*2(*88$%:"+',*;=
^%$<( :',,";( ,'97,";( 80'0<*( 3'/$@7'%08-( +( 5"$*0"$"B*7%8/"&(
','$*3%(&%2',*3&"+(!"0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+(98$"+*-2(:%&"6
/!'0*7%8/"B"("#D%80+'=(M%"!*-(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+(8"+!%&%,,"&(
5"3,',**( +18095'%0( +( /'7%80+%( ":,";( *3( +'A,12( "#I-8,*0%$<,12(
82%&C(%%(.$%&%,01(5!*89080+9@0(+(*:%"$"B*7%8/*2(:"/0!*,'2(K("0(
$*#%!'$*3&'(:"(/"&&9,*3&'=
J80"7,*/*(.$*0'!,"B"(5":2":'(/(5"$*0*/%(*(*8/9880+9(95!'+$%6
,*-( B"89:'!80+%,,1&*( :%$'&*( &"A,"( ,';0*( +( !'#"0'2( Z",)94*-C(
$'0",'C( P!*80"0%$-=( [,*( 87*0'$*C( 70"( B"85":80+"+'0<( +( 8""#D%6
80+%(:"$A,1($97H*%?(8"+%!H%,,1%(&"!'$<,1%(5!'+*0%$*(9(Z",)96
4*-C( &9:!1%( E)*$"8")1F( 9( $'0",'C( _8!%:,*%`( +( _5"$*0**`( P!*6
80"0%$-=
"#$%&"'()&%*+,+-'*)'(.)*'/).+0-%#$0")1)234567)8)+9957):):;8<
G(0%"$"B*7%8/*2(:"/0!*,'2(L!%:,%+%/"+<-(5"-+$-%08-()%,"&%,(
_4%3'!%5'5*3&'`C(/'/(8"7%0',*-(+$'80*(8+%08/";(*(4%!/"+,";(+($*4%(
*&5%!'0"!'(*(*:%-("(_:+92(&%7'2`(+$'80*(E'+0"!"&(/"0"!";(-+$-%08-(
Y%$'8*;FC(/"0"!1%(,'2":-08-(+(!9/'2( '51(>*&8/"B"=
V'( 8$%:9@D%&( *80"!*7%8/"&( "0!%3/%( !'3+*0*-( .$*0'!*3&'(
V=( (X'/*'+%$$*C( /'/( 5%!+1;( 8"+!%&%,,1;( 5"$*0*7%8/*;( 0%"!%0*/(
:'$(8"+%01(5"(_0%2,*/%(5"$97%,*-(*(9:%!A',*-(+$'80*(B!955%(B"896
:'!80+%,,12(&9A%;C(/"0"!'-("0"!+'$'8<("0(8!%:,%+%/"+12()%":'$<6
,12(*(!%$*B*"3,12(/$*/`C(",(*82":*$(*3(,%"#2":*&"80*(5!*&%,%6
,*-(,'8*$*-(:$-(!'3!%H%,*-(/",)$*/0"+=a([#!'D'-8<(/(5!'+*0%$-&C(
V=(X'/*'+%$$*(8"+%0"+'$(*&(#10<(":,"+!%&%,,"($<+'&*(*($*8'&*C(
%8$*(,%(9:'%08-(!'3!%H*0<(/",)$*/0(#$'B":'!-(5!'+9=
J:%-(!'3:%$%,*-(+$'80%;(*(!"0'4**(:"$A,"80,12($*4(80',"+*06
8-( "#D*&( 3,'&%,'0%$%&( 5"$*0*7%8/*2( :"/0!*,( V"+"B"( +!%&%,*( *(
+1!'A'%08-( +( 5!"*3+%:%,*-2( Y9B"( Y!"4*-C( OA%;&8'( Y'!*,B0",'C(
M"&'8'(Y"##8'C(OA",'(Q"//'C(b',6b'/'(>988"C(S'!$-(Q9*(:%(X",6
0%8/<%(*(:!=(
G( 7'80,"80*C( OA=( Y'!*,B0",C( 5!%:80'+$-+H*;( !%859#$*/',8/*%(
+3B$-:1( ,'( B"89:'!80+%,,"%( 980!";80+"C( 8!'+,*+'$( !"0'4*@( B"896
:'!80+%,,12( 8$9A'D*2( 8( /!"+""#!'D%,*%&=( [,( 5":7%!/*+'$( ,%6
"#2":*&"80<( !"0'4**C( 0';,"B"( B"$"8"+',*-C( !'3:%$%,*-( +$'80%;( *(
87*0'$C(70"(_L9:<*(:"$A,1(*3#*!'0<8-(,'(/"!"0/*%(8!"/*C("#17,"(
,'( B":( *( :"$A,1( #10<( $*H%,1( 5!'+'( +,"+<( *3#*!'0<8-( 8!'39( 5"6
8$%("/",7',*-(8!"/'(5"$,"&"7*;===(L5!'+%:$*+'-(!%859#$*/'===(.0"(
95!'+$%,*%C( /"0"!"%( "8,"+1+'%08-( ,'( !'+,12( 3'/",'2( *( +"5$"D'6
%08-(+(,':80!";/%(*$*(+(0!%2("#D%80+%,,12(B!955'2(?(+(8%,'0%C(70"(
+%:%0(85"!1(*(+1,"8*0(5!%:$"A%,*-C(+(*3#*!'0%$-2C(!%H'@D*2(B"6
$"8"+',*%&C(*(+(B"89:'!80+%,,12(7*,"+,*/'2C(/"0"!1%()"!&*!9@06
8-(,'("8,"+%(!'+,"5!'+,"B"(!"0'4**(7%!%3(B"$"8"+',*%(*3#*!'0%$%;(
,'("8,"+%(#'$$"0*!"+',*-`=c
Z$'88*7%8/*%( 0%"!**( .$*0( Y=( X"8/'C( G=( '!%0"( *( >=( X*2%$<6
8'( "#I%:*,-@0( *:%*( !'3:%$%,*-( "#D%80+%,,12( B!955( ,'( .$*01( *(
,%6.$*01=(d0*('+0"!1(*82":*$*(*3(%80%80+%,,"80*(8"5%!,*7%80+'C(
/",)$*/0"+(*(89D%80+%,,12(!'82"A:%,*;C(/"0"!1%(5"80"-,,"(+"36
,*/'@0(+,90!*(.$*0=(O$-(8"2!',%,*-(+$'80*(.$*01(5!*#%B'@0(/(,'6
8*$*@( *( *!!'4*",'$*3&9C( ,'+-31+'-( &'88'&( "0/!"+%,,"( $"A,9@(
/'!0*,9(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(&*!'=
( N';&%C(Z=(EceefF=( !"#$%&'#($)!*#+(,-&.,'!,$#=(Z*g+?(L0*$"8C(hie=
( L%#';,C( OA=( Y=C( M"!8",C( M=( Q=( EajjkF=( /,$!*#0( 1!"#$%&'!+( 2-34%=( Z*g+?(
[8,"+*C(lie=
a
c
L
"2$%&0GH)&%*+,+-GH)')&$I2(J).+0G#$K
M'/C( Y=( X"8/'( !'3$*7'$( $*#%!'$<,1;( *( '+0"/!'0*7%8/*;( !%A*&(
*&%,,"( 5"( &%2',*3&9( !%/!90*!"+',*-( .$*0?( _W8$*( +$'80<( 5%!%:'6
%08-( 8+%!29( +,*3( 0'/C( 70"( ,*3H%B"( )9,/4*",%!'( +1#*!'%0( +1H%C(
0"( !%7<( *:%0( "( '+0"/!'0*7%8/*;( !%A*&=( W8$*( A%( +$'80<( :%$%B*!96
%08-( 8,*39C( 0"( !%A*&( 8$%:9%0( ,'31+'0<( $*#%!'$<,1&=( P+0"/!'0*6
7%8/*;( !%A*&( :"598/'%0( 89D%80+"+',*%( '+0"/!'0'C( 0=%=( $*7,"80*C(
"$*4%0+"!-@D%;(*,80*090(+$'80*=(Q*#%!'$<,1;(!%A*&C(,'"#"!"0C(
)9,/4*",*!9%0(,'("8,"+%(,':$%A'D%;("!B',*3'4**(*3#*!'0%$<,";(
8*80%&1`a(
Y=(X"8/'(87*0'$C(70"(":,*&(*3(B$'+,12(98$"+*;(89D%80+"+',*-(
:%&"/!'0*7%8/";(&":%$*(-+$-%08-("#,"+$%,*%(.$*0(590%&(!"0'4**(
7%!%3( &%2',*3&( :%&"/!'0*7%8/*2( +1#"!"+=( >=( X*2%$<8( 8)"!&9$*6
!"+'$(_A%$%3,1;(3'/",("$*B'!2**`C(/"0"!1;("0!'A'%0(5!"4%88("06
79A:%,*-(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0=
J397'-( !'#"01( G=( '!%0"C( Y=(X"8/*C( >=(X*2%$<8'( 8$%:9%0( "#!'6
0*0<(+,*&',*%(,'(8$%:9@D*%(5"$"A%,*-?
K(( "5!%:%$%,*%(!"$*(5!'+-D*2(*(,%65!'+-D*2(.$*0(+(5"$*0*7%6
8/";(:%-0%$<,"80*C(!%+"$@4**C(/'/(8!%:80+'(98/"!%,,";(!"6
0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(*(4*!/9$-4**(.$*0(EG=( '!%0"Fm
K(( "#"8,"+',*%( )9,/4*;( 5!'+-D%B"( /$'88'( *( B"89:'!80+%,,";(
#@!"/!'0**(+(5"$*0*7%8/"&(5!"4%88%(EY=(X"8/'Fm
K(( "$*B'!2*3'4*-( /'/( ,%*3#%A,'-( )"!&'( "!B',*3'4**( 5'!0*;6
,12(80!9/09!(E>=(X*2%$<8F=
O$-(*88$%:"+',*-(&%2',*3&"+(!"0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+'A6
,"(&,%,*%(X=(G%#%!'("($%B*0*&,"80*(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(B"85":80+'C(/"6
0"!"%("#"8,"+1+'%08-(0!':*4*",,1&(590%&C(2'!*3&";($*:%!'C(*$*(
!'4*",'$<,"6$%B'$<,1&*(8!%:80+'&*(5"$*0*7%8/";(/",/9!%,4**=
V'( "5'8,"80*( 3'/!10"80*( .$*0C( 3'&/,90"80*( '!*80"/!'0*7%8/"6
B"( /!9B'C( ,%8&"0!-( ,'( +%:9D9@( :92"+,9@( &*88*@( '!*80"/!'0**C(
5":7%!/*+'$( V=( N%!:-%+=( !%":"$%,*@( #@!"/!'0*3'4**( 5'!0*;6
,";( 8*80%&1( :"$A,1( 85"8"#80+"+'0<( &%2',*3&1C( 5!%:$"A%,,1%(
X=([80!"B"!8/*&?(K(+15"$,%,*%(5'!0*-&*()9,/4*;(5!%3%,0'4**(*(
'!0*/9$-4**( 8"4*'$<,12( *,0%!%8"+C( '( ,%( 5"$97%,*%( 5!%)%!%,4*;(
:$-(5'!0*;,";(.$*01m(K(*,:*+*:9'$<,'-(5"$*0*7%8/'-("0+%080+%,6
,"80<C('(,%(/"$$%/0*+,'-(5'!0*;,'-=
"(&,%,*@(Z=(N';&%C(_*80"!*7%8/*(8"+8%&(,%(8$97';,"C(70"(0%"6
!*-(.$*0(#1$'(8)"!&9$*!"+','(8,'7'$'(+(0'/*2(80!','2C(/'/(J0'6
$*-( *( Y%!&',*-C( /"0"!1%( !'3+*+'$*8<( "0,"8*0%$<,"( :*85'!*0%0,"(
a( (
S+%:'C(T=(>=(EceaeF=(5%6!*%($.(7%6!*&#(,%,$)3%8(97*!1):,;4#(,$.'2.*$%($.(
2!,7#2(2"0(-$7)*2<)''0(2)3!4*.$#+(7(=4*.+'#=(Q<+n+C(ceae=
M
"#$%&"'()&%*+,+-'*)'(.)*'/).+0-%#$0")1)234567)8)+9957):):;8<
*(*&%$*(#"$<H*%(0!9:,"80*(8(5'!$'&%,08/";()"!&";(5!'+$%,*-===(
J&%,,"(_3'5"3:'$1%(,'4**`( %D%(8%B":,-(*&%@0("8"#%,,"(5$"2"%(
"0,"H%,*%(/(5!*&%,%,*@(5",-0*-(_.$*0'`C(*(&,"B*%(*88$%:"+'0%$*(
510'@08-( K( 5"8$%( ,%5!'+*$<,"B"( *85"$<3"+',*-C( /"0"!"%( 95"0!%6
#$-$*(/(0"&9(A%(+()'H*808/*2(8*80%&'2(K(*3#%B'0<(8$"+'(_.$*0'`=a
G( 8"+!%&%,,12( 0%"!*-2( .$*09( 5!%*&9D%80+%,,"( 5!"0*+"5"6
80'+$-$*(5",-0*@(&'881(*(5!%5":,"8*$*(*:%@(.$*01(/'/(85'8%,*%(
"0(+1!"A:%,*-(&'88"+"B"("#D%80+'=(O'$<,%;H%%(!'3+*0*%(0%"!**(
5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(8+-31+'%08-(8($*#%!'$<,";(:"/0!*,";C(/"0"!'-(
8)"!&*!"+'$'( 8"#80+%,,"%( "0,"H%,*%( /( !"0'4**( .$*0( +( #"!<#%( 8(
*:%"$"B*7%8/*&*( :"/0!*,'&*( /"&&9,*3&'C( )'H*3&'( *( ,'4*",'$6
8"4*'$*3&'=( "8$%:,*%("0+%!B'$*(5!'/0*/9($*#%!'$<,";(5"$*0*/*(
*(5!%0%,:"+'$*(,'()"!&9$*!"+',*%(,"+12()*$"8")8/*2C(5"$*0*7%6
8/*2(*(*:%"$"B*7%8/*2(5!*,4*5"+(+3'*&":%;80+*-(.$*01(*(,'!":'(
E&'881F=
!%:80'+$--( 8%#-( /'/( _5!'+:*+1%`( :%&"/!'0**C( /"&&9,*3&( *(
)'H*3&( /$%;&*$*( $*#%!'$*3&( /'/( 58%+:":%&"/!'0*@=( !*( .0"&(
0"0'$*0'!,1%(!%A*&1(9,*70"A*$*(B!'A:',8/*%(8+"#":1(*(5!'+'C(
:$-( 3'D*01( /"0"!12( *( 8"3:'+'$*8<( :%&"/!'0*7%8/*%( /",(80*094**(
8(5!*,4*5'&*(5'!*0%0'(*(!'85!%:%$%,*-(+$'80*=(G("8,"+%(:"/0!*,(
/"&&9,*3&'(*()'H*3&'(,'2":*$'8<(*:%-(/"$$%/0*+*3&'=([,*(_"06
!*4'$*C(70"(5%!+""7%!%:,";(4%$<@(5!'+*0%$<80+'(-+$-%08-(3'D*0'(
5!'+(*(8+"#":C(*(0'/A%C(70"(*,:*+*:9'$<,'-(7%$"+%7%8/"%(89D%80+"(
-+$-%08-(/"&5%0%,0,1&(89:<%;(/'/(8+"*2(8"#80+%,,12(5%!+""7%!%:6
,12(*,0%!%8"+C(0'/(*(80!'0%B*;(*(5!'/0*/C(/"0"!1%(:"$A%,(8"#$@6
:'0<(5!'+*0%$<80+"C(70"#1(3'D*0*0<("#D*%(*$*(8"4*'$<,1%(*,0%6
!%81=([#'(++%$*(/"$$%/0*+,9@(89D,"80<(K(!'89(+(8$97'%()'H*3&'(*(
"#D%80+"(+(8$97'%(8"4*'$*3&'(K(/'/("#$':'0%$-(80"*&"80*(+18H%;(
7%&(*,:*+*:1C(*(*3"#!'A'$*(7%$"+%7%8/*%(89D%80+'(/'/()'/0"!1(
*$*("!B',1(/"$$%/0*+'=([#'(0'/A%(*3"#!'A'$*(5"$*0*/9(/'/(0';,9(
8+%!2"#17,";(7%$"+%7%8/";(5",-0$*+"80*(*(5",*&'$*(%%(/'/()9,/6
4*@( .$*01C( ,':%$%,,";( "8"#1&*( 85"8"#,"80<@( *( 0'$',0"&=( o'6
H*3&(5!%:80'+$-$(.09(85"8"#,"80<(/'/(*,80*,/0(*$*(B%,*'$<,"80<=(
P(/"&&9,*3&(5!%:80'+$-$(.0"(/'/(+18H*;(0*5(,'9/*(*(5".0"&9(5!%6
!"B'0*+9(./85%!0"+C("#97%,,12(!'85"3,'+'0<(,%"#2":*&1;(/9!8(5"(
/"0"!"&9(:"$A%,(*:0*(*80"!*7%8/*;(5!"B!%88`c=
G( "0$*7*%( "0( 0"0'$*0'!,12( *:%"$"B*;C( /"0"!1%( +"85!*,*6
&'$*( 5"$*0*/9( /'/( 8)%!9( :%-0%$<,"80*( .$*0C( B%,*%+( *( +"A:%;C(
a
( N';&%C(Z=(EceefF=( !"#$%&'#($)!*#+(,-&.,'!,$#=(Z*g+?(L0*$"8C(hlj=
L%#';,C(OA=(Y=C(M"!8",C(M=(Q=(EajjkF=(/,$!*#0(1!"#$%&'!+(2-34%8(Z*g+?([8,"+*C(pll=
c( (
N
"2$%&0GH)&%*+,+-GH)')&$I2(J).+0G#$K
:%&"/!'0*7%8/*;(5"$*0*7%8/*;(!%A*&(80!"*08-(,'(0%3*8%($*#%!'6
$*3&'(*(5!*3+',(!%H'0<(5!"#$%&1C(/"0"!1%(+"3,*/'@0(+(5"$*0*7%6
8/*2(*(8"4*'$<,12("0,"H%,*-2(&%A:9($@:<&*=
!%0%,3**()'H*808/"B"(*$*(/"&&9,*80*7%8/"B"($*:%!'(,'(+186
H*%(/'7%80+'(+(5",*&',**(5"$*0*/*(*(*,0%!%8"+(,'!":'(80'+-08-(
5":( 8"&,%,*%( 8( 0"7/*( 3!%,*-( $*#%!'$<,"B"( 5":2":'( /( 5"$*0*/%C(
/'/( 8)%!1( B"85":80+'( !'4*",'$*3&'( *( &"!'$*=( !*( .0"&( _/"&&96
,*80*7%8/*%( 5!%0%,3**( ,'( +18H9@( )"!&9( ,'97,"B"( 3,',*-( #1$*(
5"( )"!&%( !'4*",'$<,1&*C( ,"( ,'!9H'$*( )9,:'&%,0'$<,1;( 5!*,6
4*5( $*#%!'$*3&'( K( 70"( 8"4*'$<,1%( "0,"H%,*-( -+$-@08-( 5"( 890*(
&"!'$<,1&*("0,"H%,*-&*===($*#%!'$<,'-(5"$*0*/'(+8%B:'(87*0'$'(
5"$*0*7%8/"B"(./85%!0'(5"(8"3:'0%$-(5"$*0*/*C(7<%("/",7'0%$<,"%(
!%H%,*%(#1$"(,%(5!"80"("4%,/";(5!*7*,(*$*(5":87%0"&(H',8"+C('(
89A:%,*%&( 7%80,";( *B!1C( *$*( 85!'+%:$*+"80*C( *$*( :"$B"8!"7,1%(
*,0%!%8"+C( *$*( "#D%B"( #$'B"8"80"-,*-C( K( 3,'7*0C( +( 5"8$%:,%;( *,6
80',4**(.0*7%8/*&(89A:%,*%&("(0"&C(70"(:"$A,"(#1$"(#1(5!"*3";6
0*C(8/"!%%(7%&()'/0*7%8/*&(89A:%,*%&("(0"&C(70"(5!"*3";:%0`=a
V'4*",'$( K( 8"4*'$*80*7%8/'-( *:%"$"B*-( 5!%:$'B'$'( 8"#80+%,6
,9@(0!'/0"+/9("0,"H%,*;(,'!":'C(.$*01(*(+"A:-C(/"0"!'-(*82":*$'(
*3(0"B"C(70"($@:*(,%(!'+,1("0(5!*!":1(E3:%8<(&"A,"(+85"&,*0<(*(0=(
,=(_>'8"+9@(0%"!*@`(,'4*3&'FC('(8"3:'@0(*%!'!2*@(!9/"+":*0%$%;(
*( 5":7*,%,,12=( "$*0*7%8/*%( *,80*0901( :"$A,1( !'3$*7'0<( .09(
*,:*+*:9'$<,9@( 80"*&"80<( ?( +( 4%,0!%( 8*80%&1( ,'2":*08-( +"A:<C(
%B"("/!9A'@0(#$*A';H*%(5"8$%:"+'0%$*(E5!'+-D*;(/$'88(*$*(.$*6
0'F=(X'88'&(5!"0*+"5"80'+$-$'8<(%80%80+%,,'-('!*80"/!'0*-C(.$*6
0'C(/"0"!'-(+1!'A'%0(+"$@(,'!":'C("#%85%7*+'%0(:92"+,"%(*(*,0%$6
$%/09'$<,"%( !9/"+":80+"C( '( %%( "0#"!( K( .0"( %80%80+%,,1;( 5!"4%88C(
/"0"!1;( 5!"0*+"5"80'+$-%08-( &%2',*7%8/"&9( 5":87%09( B"$"8"+( +(
98$"+*-2(:%&"/!'0*7%8/";(5!"4%:9!1(+1#"!"+(*(B"$"8"+',*-=
G(8%!%:*,%(UU(+%/'C(+(5!%:%$'2(:%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(
:*8/9!8'C(8)"!&*!"+'$*8<(:+%("8,"+,1%(H/"$1(*88$%:"+',*-(.$*0?(
_&'/*'+%$$*808/'-`(*(_.$*0,"B"(5$@!'$*3&'`=([8,"+,1&(&%2',*36
&"&($%B*0*&'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+(98$"+*-2(:%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"(
5"$*0*7%8/"B"(!%A*&'(+18095'%0(!'4*",'$<,1;("0#"!(*(!%/!90*6
!"+',*%(95!'+$%,4%+C(,'7*,'-(8(8*80%&1("#!'3"+',*-(*(3'/',7*+'-(
+1#"!'&*=([:,'/"C(5"(&,%,*@(Z=((X',B%;&'C(0!*(85"8"#'(8%$%/4**(
*(!"0'4**(.$*0(K(/!"+<C(8"#80+%,,"80<(*(:"80*A%,*-C(/"&#*,*!96
@08-(*(8"7%0'@08-(+(:%&"/!'0**=M%"!*-(5$@!'$*3&'(.$*0(*82":*0(
*3(,'$*7*-(+("#D%80+%(!'3+%0+$%,,";(8*80%&1(8"4*'$<,12(B!955C(
( L%#';,C(OA=(Y=C(M"!8",C(M=(Q=(EajjkF=(/,$!*#0(1!"#$%&'!+(2-34%8(Z*g+?([8,"+*C(pli=
a
L;
"#$%&"'()&%*+,+-'*)'(.)*'/).+0-%#$0")1)234567)8)+9957):):;8<
/"0"!1%( 3'D*D'@0( 8"#80+%,,1%( 85%4*)*7%8/*%( *,0%!%81C( 8:%!6
A*+'%0(+"3&"A,"80<(&","5"$<,"B"(8"8!%:"0"7%,*-(+$'80*(+(!9/'2(
":,";(B!9551(.$*0=
G( 0%"!*-2( R=( S9&5%0%!'( E0%"!*-( :%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"( .$*0*3&'FC(
P=( (Q%;5B'!0'( E0%"!*-( :%&"/!'0**( +( 5$@!'$<,12( "#D%80+'2F( *(
>=( (O'$-( E0%"!*-( 5"$*'!2**F( +1:%$-%08-( ":,'( *3( B$'+,12( 5!"#$%&(
5"$*0*7%8/"B"(95!'+$%,*-(+(98$"+*-2(:%&"/!'0**?(&","5"$*3'4*-(
5"$*0*7%8/"B"(!1,/'(8"(80"!",1(.$*0,12(B!955C(.$*&*,*!"+',*-(
:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2( 5!*,4*5"+( !"0'4**( .$*0( *C( /'/( 8$%:80+*%C( "#"6
80!%,*%(/",)$*/0"+(&%A:9(+$'80<@(*("#D%80+"&=
G( "0+%0( ,'( .0*( +13"+1( R=( S9&5%0%!( 5!%:$'B'%0( 8+"#":,"%( 8"6
!%+,"+',*%(&%A:9(5!%:80'+*0%$-&*(/",/9!*!9@D*2(.$*0(3'(B"$"8'(
*3#*!'0%$%;C(P=(Q%;5B'!0(5":7%!/*+'%0(,%"#2":*&"80<(5$@!'$*36
&'( .$*0( +( :%&"/!'0**( 8"4*'$<,"B"( 8"B$'8*-C( '( >=( O'$<( 5!%:$'B'%0(
&":%$<(5"$*'!2**C('(#"!<#'(3'(:"$A,"80*(&%A:9(5"$*0*7%8/*('/6
0*+,1&*(B!'A:','&*=(O$-(&":%$*(5"$*'!2**("5!%:%$-@D*&*(80'6
,"+-08-(,%(0"$</"(+1#"!1C('(*,80*094*",'$<,1%(B'!',0**(:%&"/!'6
0**C(/"0"!1%(+/$@7'@0(8+"#":9('88"4*'4*;C(8+"#":9(8$"+'C(5!'+"(
*3#*!'0<( *( #10<( *3#!',,1&C( 5!'+"( ,'( '$<0%!,'0*+,1%( *80"7,*/*(
*,)"!&'4**=
[:,";(*3("8,"+,12(5!"#$%&(+(5!"4%88%(:%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"(0!',6
3*0'( 9/!'*,8/"B"( "#D%80+'( +18095'%0( 5"*8/( "50*&'$<,";( &":%$*(
!"0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0=(d0"("#98$"+$%,"("8"#%,,"80<@(0!',6
3*0'C(/'8'@D%B"8-(":,"+!%&%,,"(+8%2(8)%!("#D%80+%,,";(A*3,*(K(
"0(5"$*0*/*(*(./","&*/*(:"(/9$<09!1(*("#!'3"+',*-=(
J( %8$*( ,'( 5%!+"&( .0'5%( 0!',3*0'( '+0"!*0'!,1%( .$*01( &"B90(
+15"$,-0<(5"3*0*+,9@(!"$<(*,*4**!"+',*-(:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(!%6
)"!&C("#%85%7%,*-(80'#*$<,"80*(+("#D%80+%(*(5!%:80'+*0%$<80+'(
*,0%!%8"+C( 0"( "/",7'0%$<,1;( :%&"/!'0*7%8/*;( 0!',3*0( ,%+"3&"6
A%,( #%3( 5!%":"$%,*-( '+0"!*0'!,12( 0%,:%,4*;( 5!*( 8"2!',%,**(
5$@!'$*3&'(B!955(*(#'$',8'C(5'!*0%0'(!'3$*7,12(/",)%88*",'$<6
,12C( .0,*7%8/*2C( /9$<09!,12( *( B%,:%!,12( B!955=( G( 0'/*2( 98$"6
+*-2( 5!"#$%&1( &*!"+"33!%,7%8/*2( "!*%,0'4*;( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"(
/$'88'C( 5"+1H%,*%( 9!"+,-( 5"$*0*7%8/";( /9$<09!1( .$*0( *( 5"$*6
0*7%8/";('/0*+,"80*(B!'A:',C("8"3,',*-(&%80'(*(!"$*(5"$*0*7%6
8/";(+$'80*C("0+%080+%,,"80*(3'(8+";(!'4*",'$<,1;(+1#"!()"!&(
*(,'5!'+$%,*;(:%-0%$<,"80*(8"(80"!",1(.$*0(80',"+-08-(":,*&*(
*3(B$'+,12=(G3'*&":%;80+*%(.$*0(5!%+!'D'%08-(+(8*$"+"%(5"$%(5"6
$*0*7%8/";(:%-0%$<,"80*C(+(/"0"!1;(5"80%5%,,"(+0-B*+'@08-(+8%(
"#D%80+%,,1%(5!"#$%&1(E"0(-31/'(*(*80"!**(/()*,',8'&(*(8"#6
80+%,,"80*F=(J&%,,"("0(9!"+,-(+3'*&":%;80+*-(.$*0(+(9/!'*,8/"&(
L8
"2$%&0GH)&%*+,+-GH)')&$I2(J).+0G#$K
"#D%80+%(+("5!%:%$%,,";(80%5%,*(3'+*8*0(985%2(:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(
5!%"#!'3"+',*;=
V'(5"+%80/%(:,-()"!&*!"+',*%(.))%/0*+,12(&%2',*3&"+(!"0'6
4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(+(98$"+*-2(:%&"/!'0*7%8/"B"("#D%80+'(,'6
2":-08-?
K(( 5"+1H%,*%( 9!"+,-( 5"$*0*7%8/";( /9$<09!1( +$'80*( *( "#D%6
80+'(8(5"&"D<@("#!'3"+'0%$<,12(5!"B!'&&(*(&%!"5!*-0*;C(
,'5!'+$%,,12(,'(/"&&9,*/'0*+,"%(+3'*&":%;80+*%(5!%:80'6
+*0%$%;( !'3$*7,12( ,'4*",'$<,12C( /9$<09!,12C( /",)%88*"6
,'$<,12(B!955C("#%85%7%,*-(B%,:%!,"B"(!'+%,80+'(*(5'!*0%06
,"B"(5!%:80'+*0%$<80+'(+("!B','2(+$'80*m
K(( 5!%":"$%,*%(9B!"31(&","5"$*3'4**(+$'80*(8"(80"!",1(.$*06
,12(B!955(7%!%3(&%2',*3&1(5"+1H%,*-(B!'A:',8/";('/0*+6
,"80*( *( 5!*+$%7%,*-( *,80*090"+( B!'A:',8/"B"( "#D%80+'( /(
5!"4%889(5!*,-0*-(5"$*0*7%8/*2(!%H%,*;m
K(( +"880',"+$%,*%(:"+%!*-(+("0,"H%,*-2(_+$'80<(K("#D%80+"`m
K(( +,%:!%,*%( &":%$*( +1#"!"+C( /"0"!'-( #1( B'!',0*!"+'$'( &'/6
8*&'$<,"( H*!"/9@( 5!%3%,0'4*@( *,0%!%8"+( "#D%80+%,,12(
B!955(E,'4*",'$<,12C(/",)%88*",'$<,12C(B%,:%!,12Fm
G(UU(+%/%(+(*88$%:"+',*-2(+3'*&":%;80+*-(.$*0('/09'$*3*!9@06
8-(8$%:9@D*%(5!"#$%&1?
K(( &","5"$*3'4*-( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"( !1,/'( 8"( 80"!",1( .$*0,12(
B!955(ER=(S9&5%0%!Fm
K(( .$*&*,*!"+',*-( *3( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"( 5!"80!',80+'( :%&"/!'0*6
7%8/*2(5!*,4*5"+(!"0'4**(.$*0(E>=(O'$<Fm
K(( "#"80!%,*%( /",)$*/0"+( &%A:9( +$'80<@( *( "#D%80+"&(
EP=(Q%;52'!:Fm
K(98*$%,*%(/",/9!%,4**(.$*0(EX=([$8",F=
O$-("#%85%7%,*-(:%&"/!'0*7%8/*2(&%2',*3&"+(!"0'4**(5"$*0*6
7%8/*2(.$*0(+(98$"+*-2(5'!*0%0,";(:%&"/!'0**(+'A,1&*()'/0"!'6
&*(80',"+-08-(0'/A%(/",0!"$<(5'!$'&%,0'(,':(*85"$,*0%$<,";(+$'6
80<@C(+%!2"+%,80+"(5!'+'C("#%85%7%,*%(8+"#":1(8$"+'(*(8"#!',*;C(
"089080+*%(4%,39!1C(3'D*0'(5!'+(&%,<H*,80+=
G(8"+!%&%,,12(98$"+*-2(!"0'4*-(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0("#98$"+$%6
,'(8$%:9@D*&*(8"4*'$<,1&*()'/0"!'&*?
K(( 80',"+$%,*%( *,)"!&'4*",,"B"( "#D%80+'=( [:*,( *3( B$'+,12(
+13"+"+( 8"+!%&%,,"80*( 3'/$@7'%08-( +( 0"&C( 70"( 8"4*'$<,'-(
"8,"+'( 5"$*0*7%8/";( +$'80*( 5"80%5%,,"( 0!',8)"!&*!9%08-(
*( 3'&%D'%08-( *$*( "5"8!%:9%08-( &'88"+1&*( /"&&9,*/'0*+6
,1&*(5!"4%88'&*(*("#98$"+$*+'%0(8""0+%080+9@D*;()"!&'0(
59#$*7,";(*,0%!'/4**(.$*0C(+$*-%0(,'(!"0'4*@(.$*0m
L:
"#$%&"'()&%*+,+-'*)'(.)*'/).+0-%#$0")1)234567)8)+9957):):;8<
K(( "0/'3("0('+0"!*0'!,"B"(80*$-(5!'+$%,*-(+(5"$<39(&%2',*3&"+(
"89D%80+$%,*-( +$'80*( :%&"/!'0*7%8/*&( 590%&=( [8"3,',*%(
!'809D%;( ,%"#2":*&"80*( 5"$*0*7%8/"B"( 97'80*-( *,:*+*:"+(
+( :%&"/!'0*7%8/"&( 5!"4%88%( 5!*+":*0( /( &*)"$"B*3'4**( *(
B*5%!#"$*3'4**(80%5%,*(*2(97'80*-(+(5!"4%88%(5!*,-0**(5"6
$*0*7%8/*2(!%H%,*;(*,)"!&'4*",,";(.5"2*C(98*$*+'%0(5"6
$*0*7%8/9@("0+%080+%,,"80<(.$*0=(
P,'$*3( 5!"4%88'( !"0'4**( .$*0( "0/!1+'%0( ,"+1%( +"3&"A,"80*(
:$-( !'4*",'$<,"B"C( #"$%%( ':%/+'0,"B"( 5",*&',*-( "0,"H%,*;C( /"6
0"!1%()"!&*!9@08-(+(,%80'#*$<,12("#D%80+'2(8(5"$*0*7%8/*&*(*(
B"89:'!80+%,,1&*(*,80*090'&*C(*3&%,-@08-=(
G(8"+!%&%,,12(98$"+*-2(!"0'4*-(.$*0("#98$"+$%,'(/"&&9,*/'6
0*+,1&*( )'/0"!'&*?( 5"$*0*7%8/'-( :%-0%$<,"80<( .$*0( ,'7*,'%08-(
8( 5!"4%88'( *,0%!5!%0'4**( *,)"!&'4**C( +3'*&":%;80+*%( .$*0( !'36
+"!'7*+'%08-( +( 85%4*)*7%8/"&( /"&&9,*/'0*+,"&( 5!"80!',80+%C(
80!9/09!'(*(5!'+*$'(/"0"!"B"()"!&*!9@08-(5":(+$*-,*%&(LXJ=(
M'/*&("#!'3"&C(,%8&"0!-(,'("8"#%,,"80*(5"$*0*7%8/";(8*80%&1(
/'A:";(:%&"/!'0*7%8/";(80!',1(*(!'3$*7*-(+(&%2',*3&'2(!"0'4**(
5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0C(/"0"!1%(8)"!&*!"+'$*8<(*80"!*7%8/*C(5!"4%88(
!"0'4**(5"$*0*7%8/*2(.$*0(K(.0"(+'A,'-(2'!'/0%!*80*/'(:%&"/!'6
0*7%8/"B"(5"$*0*7%8/"B"(!%A*&'C(%B"("0$*7*0%$<,'-(7%!0'C(5"(8!'+6
,%,*@(8(0"0'$*0'!*3&"&(*('+0"!*0'!*3&"&=(
PEQRSAQTSAU
a=( N';&%C(Z=(EceefF=( !"#$%&'#($)!*#+(,-&.,'!,$#=(Z*g+?(L0*$"8=
c=( L%#';,C(OA=(Y=C(M"!8",C(M=(Q=(EajjkF=(/,$!*#0(1!"#$%&'!+(2-34%8(Z*g+?([8,"+*=
h=( S+%:'C(T=(>=(EceaeF=(5%6!*%($.(7%6!*&#(,%,$)3%8(97*!1):,;4#(,$.'2.*$%($.(
2!,7#2(2"0(-$7)*2<)''0(2)3!4*.$#+(7(=4*.+'#=(Q<+n+C(ceae=
LO